Журнал "Центральная Азия и Кавказ" 2009, nr66, Выпуск 6
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
1/168
6(66), 2009
1
CA&CC Press
20096(66)
-
1998
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
2/168
6(66), 2009
2
/: (994 - 12) 497 12 22 E-mail: [email protected] /: (46) 920 62016 E-mail: [email protected] /: (994 - 12) 596 11 73 E-mail: [email protected] ()/: (+7 - 701) 531 61 46 E-mail: [email protected] ().: (+996 - 312) 65-48-33 E-mail: [email protected] ().: (992 - 917) 72 81 79 E-mail: [email protected] ().: (998 - 71) 125 43 22 E-mail: farkhad _ [email protected] (): (+994 50) 3006694 E-mail: [email protected] (): (374 - 1) 56 65 59 E-mail: [email protected] ().: (995 - 32) 96 85 87 E-mail: [email protected] ().: (972) 2 5882332 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (49 - 89) 3003132 E-mail:[email protected] ().: (86) 10-64039088 E-mail: [email protected] (). (7 - 495) 3163146 E-mail: [email protected] (, -).: (716) 880-2104 E-mail: [email protected] ().: (380-44) 524 79 13 E-mail: [email protected]
: 620720-0459
: 22 339
: M-770
CA&CC Press .
: 556699-5964
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
3/168
6(66), 2009
3
, , ()
, () ,
( ) , ,
() , , -
() ()
, ()
, , , ()
, , ,
. .. , ( )
, , ()
, () , ()
. ()
() ,
() , - ( )
, ()
, , ()
, , ( ) , , () , , - , () ,
. c () , ()
, ,
()
, ,
:CA&CC Press AB
Hubertusstigen 9. 97455 LuleSWEDEN
:www.ca-c.org , 2009 CA&CC Press, 2009
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
4/168
6(66), 2009
4
- 6(66) 2009 .
. . .......................... 7
. . ...... ..... 21
. . : ....................... 28
. . : . - ? ............. 38
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
5/168
6(66), 2009
5
. . : ....................................... .... 50
. , . .
.... ............................................. 59
. . - ...................................... 73
. . ..................... 91
. . - ................................................................... 106
. .
115
. . .... 123
. . ( - XXI . ). II .... .................................................. 135
. . : ..... 146
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
6/168
6(66), 2009
6
. . UTI POSSIDETIS JURIS ...................... 156
2009 . ..................................... 164
:
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
7/168
6(66), 2009
7
,
(, )
, - - .. -, - (-). , XXI - , , - 1.
- - -
: ,, , - - . - .
- , -
- , - -
-
1 : - / -, . (/59/565)[http://www.un.org/russian/secureworld/].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
8/168
6(66), 2009
8
-
. - 2 , , . - - . : - - .
, , -- -, : - .
. , 3. - ( 1990- .), - (), ( ), ., - .
. - , , - 4. - - 5. -
-- -
- -. - , ,
, -
- ; - - .
2 , , - .
3 [http://www.cis.minsk.by/webnpa/text.aspx?RN=N09100001].
4 , , - , . 49 .
5 - [http://www.cis.minsk.by/main.aspx?uid=178].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
9/168
6(66), 2009
9
, , - 6.
-, , - . - , , - , , VIII .
-. - - . - , - .
, n ;n , -
;n ;n - -
.
. , ; - , - .
- . -: , , , ; , , - , , . - , , - 7. - ,
6 .7 .: Bailes A.J.K., Cottey A . Regional Security Cooperation in the Early 21st Century [http://yearbook2006.
sipri.org/chap4];Job B.L. Alliances and Regional Security Developments: The Role of Regional Arrangements inthe United Nations Promotion of Peace and Stability. .: New Millennium, New Perspectives: The United Na-tions, and Governance / Ed. by R. Thakur, E. Newman. Tokyo, New York. Paris: United Nations University Press,2000 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
10/168
6(66), 2009
10
, - .
- - - . - - - .
, , , , . - ; , , .
, , -, . , - .
, : -, - ; -, , - . -- (), 2006 , (), ().
, - , . , , , - - , - . - (.. - ): - . , , - , .
- . , (, , , ), (, ). , - . (), () . - , - - .
, - . - -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
11/168
6(66), 2009
11
. - ( , ) -
.
. 1998 -- () - (, 2001 . - -
2002 .) . : , - ( , ), , .
, -:
n - ;
n -
, ;n ( -
, , );n -
;n ,
. .
2006 8, - ( 2004 . ), (2005 .), - (2006 .) . - , , . , - - () .
: - , . -
8 . 2008 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
12/168
6(66), 2009
12
, , , - 8 10 . 350 .
( 300 . 50 .)9
. - , , ( , ) - .
. , - , - , . - (1996 .) - (1997 .), - 10.
-: -, - ; -, - - . - - (1975 .). : , - , - .. .
, -
. - . - (14 2001 .). - - 2025 (2003 .) (2004 .); - , - .
. 12 - ; , , 600 -
. . , - 11.
9 .: Troubles Across Turkestan // Economist, 2009, 18 24 July. P. 58.10 - . 3 1998 [http://russian.china.
org.cn/russian/43089.htm].11 -
, - -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
13/168
6(66), 2009
13
, - ,
(). - - . - 974- - (1996 1999 .), - . , - 11- - (2006 2010 .)12.
, - - : - . - (; ), - (; );
()13
(). - 25 2001 . - , , . 2003 () ; 2004 - - .
- . 2005 , (- 2008 .).
2009 - , .4 2009 , , - . , , - , .
: - ; , ; -; 14.
- .
- . -
(.: . : ? // -, 2007, . 5, 3. . 82). , (.: -
. : // , 2007, 2. . 84).
12 .: , 5 2007 [http://newspaper.kz/print.asp?aid=93202].13 . --
1996 , - 1999 .14 .: . : , , -
() [http://www.mamf.ru/odkb_mamf/pr/kzv.php].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
14/168
6(66), 2009
14
. - , -
. , - , .
, -, : -- - . - - , , , 15.
-, . -, -
( . . .) 16, -. , -- ( ) .
( -), .
. .
, , 17.
, , - , , , , - ( ), , 18.
-, . 2005 , , - (); 2006 - - , .
15
.: -. .. 18 2009 [http://www.uzbekistan.pl/index.php?goto=985].
16 . : () // -, 29 2009.
17 .: - [http://mfa.uz/rus/pressa_I_media_servis/press reizi/180609u_7.mgr].
18 , , -- : - - (The Department of State Bulletin, 34/884 (4 June 1956) 925-26). .: Abass A. Regional Organisations and the Development of Collective Security. Oxford and Portland, Oregon:Hart Publishing, 2004. P. 38.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
15/168
6(66), 2009
15
2003 . -
19.-, -
- . - , , - , -. , , - 20. - : . 12 , , , , - ( ) -
. . , - - ; . , , - -: ( 1992 .) . - 21.
-, , -. , - , - ., - .
, - . , - - 22.
- . -, , , -
19 .: -. .: . ., 2008. 9. . 63.
20 .: O [http://uza.uz/ru/politics/7009/].
21 .: -. . 68.
22 [http://russian.china.org.cn/international/txt/2002-06/12/content_2033359.htm].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
16/168
6(66), 2009
16
51 . - -
23
. , , - - , . - - 24. 9 17 2007 -2007. ; 25.
11 2001 ( 90 . .) 26 : ,
, . 2003 () , 2001 , .
, , - , . -, , - . , , . - , , (2002 .). , 400 . 100 - 27.
2004 - . . .
- 28; . - - . , , , , - . -, , -- .
23 - -
, . [http://www.kisi.kz/site.html?id=3938].24 .: - () . 2007. 3 (18). : - . . 49.
25 6 500 80 - . : 34- . - () .
26 .: British orces in Afghanistan // Economist, 2009, 18 24 July. P. 26.27 [htpp://mfa.uz/rus/pressa_i_media_servis/news/040408r_5.mgr].28 Chung E . Multiple Regional Security rameworks for Central Asia. P. 292 [http://www.sejong.org/Pub_st/
PUB_ST_DATA/kst005-09.pdf].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
17/168
6(66), 2009
17
,
29
. , -. , - .
1992 - (). - , ( -), ( ), (), (), (-) () 30.
, . . -
. , ,
, , - . , - , . - - . , . , , - , , 31.
--
1991 *
( 11 **)
29 1993 , , - : (), 1951 , () (), 1957 .
30 2007 2013 2007 - (), .
31 The War in Afghanistan // Economist, 28 March 3 April 2009. P. 16.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
18/168
6(66), 2009
18
--
1992 2002 33
32( 7 )
1996
2001 ( 6 )
1975 1994
( 56 )
1993
( 27 )
1949 -
1994 (20 -)
1993
* - .
** .
32 2006 . - 74, - .
33 . , , 2009 ,
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
19/168
6(66), 2009
19
? 1994
; , 6+1 - 34.
1997 6+2 35.
() () , - .
, , -. , , - : , , . - . , - (-) .
-. , , -, ( , ); . - - . , -
, , - (1947 .) . - , , - , ., , , . - , . , - 2002 , - .
. 6+3 - . -
, - . - . , 2007 - - --2007.
34 . - 2004 .
35 2008 . - 6+2 6+3 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
20/168
6(66), 2009
20
, .
, - , , - .
- . - .
(), , -, , - 36.
6+3, -, (, ), - . - :
n -, , - ;
n -, - ;
n -, , .
, , - ( ) - 37.
, - , - . , , - .
, - - .
,
, : . -
.
36 . , 2009 - .
37 Nye J.S . International Regionalism. Boston: Little, Brown, Co. 1968. P. vii.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
21/168
6(66), 2009
21
, - , ,
.
, ,
(, )
- - . , . - friction (). ,friction : , . - , - 1.
- -
- , - -
. , -, ,
- .
1 .: . friction - // , 2009, 2 (62).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
22/168
6(66), 2009
22
, , - .
. : - , - , - - , - 2.
- , , - XIX XX 3, - : , ; -; , , -
. , (), , 4.
, - . , . , -, , , .
: - - - , - -, . , - , - . , , , . , -, , , , , -, .. , , -, . , , -, . , ,-, , -
2 . I : , . .: , 1997. . 20, 25.
3 , , - , . - .
4 .: Rubin B.R., Rashid A . rom Great Game to Grand Bargain // oreign Affairs, November/December2008. P. 33.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
23/168
6(66), 2009
23
, , ., .
- . - -, . - . - - . , - , , - ( - , ).
-
. , . - , (ISA ) (OE ). , , .. 63- 2008 . , -. , - . , , - - - , .
, - (-, - ---) - . - , - . , : , , .
, , , - , , -.
, . , 1999 75% 5; -
5 .: , -, 18 1999 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
24/168
6(66), 2009
24
90% (8 . )6. , - , -
. - . ,
, - . : , , ; , . - : - , , 7.
, - . ,
, , . - , .
. . , , , , - . - , , 8. -, - - .
- . , , . , , - .
, - .
2009 - 2010 . ( ) - - - , - . - . , , - , .
6 .: , -, 2008 .
7 . , (.: . . .).
8 Rubin B.R., Rashid A . Op. cit. P. 30.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
25/168
6(66), 2009
25
, , - ,
. , , - .4 2009 -, ,
. , . - 17 . , 5 ., 3 . , - , 9.
. . , - . , , .
- - . - , , -, . , - , . , . , , - , . , - , , - , - . - - , - ( , ), .
-, : . , , , , 10.
, . 2008 . - / 11. .
9 Summit Declaration on Afghanistan Issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meet-ing of the North Atlantic Council in Strasbourg / Kehl on 4 April 2009, Press Release: (2009) 045, NATO 04 Apr.2009 [http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/news_52836.htm?mode=pressrelease].
10 .: DeYoung K . Obama Outlines Afghan Strategy. He Pushes Stability and Regional Partnerships // TheWashington Post, Saturday, 28 March 2009. P. A01.
11 .: /, -, 4 2008 (. : . -. , 2008. . 240 244) [http://www.press-service.uz/ru/gsection.scm?groupId=4392&contentId=38285].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
26/168
6(66), 2009
26
, .
1. . - .
2. ( ). - , , , , ..
3. - , - .
1999 2001 6+2 , , - .
, .
, . , , , , - . , , , 12. .
. - , .
, --. , -
, - , -.
.
n -, , . , , , , - -. - .
n -, , , .
12 .: : - , , 17 18 2009 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
27/168
6(66), 2009
27
, - , . -
, , , . , -- .
n -, , , , , - .. - .
n -, . , - . - - , -, . , 13.
, - . - . , , , . , - .
13 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
28/168
6(66), 2009
28
:
-
(, . , )
1.
- - . - , - .
- -, -
- - -, . - - - .
- - , - , - , -
1 , , - /, , , , - ..
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
29/168
6(66), 2009
29
-
, - 2. - - ( , -, , .) , - (, -, .), - . - - -, . - , - ( - ), - . , - .
- -. 2003, - - , - -
, . - - -
-, -
-.
- : - - . -, - - .
- . - , -. - - - , -, - - . , - , , , - -, - , - - .
- -, , - . - / - , , - (, ) (, ) : -- -
2 - Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics.New York: Public Affairs, 2005.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
30/168
6(66), 2009
30
-. , , . , , - .
. - -, - 3. , ; - . , , . - , , - . , .
. , , - . , , , : , /, / . - , -, -, - , 4. , , , , , , .
, , , , - . - ( - -). , , , -
. , -
( ), ( ).
, - , .
3 .: Waltz K . Theory of International Politics. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1979.4 .: ukuyama . State-Building: Governance and World Order in the 21st Century. Ithaca, NY: Cornell
University Press, 2004.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
31/168
6(66), 2009
31
, - , , ,
, -; . , , - , : , .
, , - . - -. -, , - . , -- , -
, . - - - -; ; - -, 5. , - , , . - , -, , - , , 6.
, - . - - , - / , - , . , - , - 2007 7. - , - , , - , .
, . , -
5 .: Ettmayer W . Alte Staatenneue Welt: Stabilitt und Wandel in den internationalen Beziehungen. Linz:Trauner Verlag, 2008.
6 -, - . - , ; , , (, , ).
7 : ,- , - .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
32/168
6(66), 2009
32
, -, -
8
. , , ( ). , , , , - . - , , - . - -, .
XVII , -, 9. -
, -, , , . - , . - . - - 10. - . , , - .
, - . , , . - , , - . - - . - , -, ; . -
8 , 1995 , , , -, 2008 , - .
9 .: Gilpin R . War and Change in World Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981.10 , -
1990- , , , . , , (., : Clausewitz C . von. On War. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1976. Book I.Chapter 1 ).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
33/168
6(66), 2009
33
, , , - - 11.
. ,, , - ( ) , - 12. , 13 , - (, ) (, ). XVIII - :/, / /. - - , - .
-.
n -, , , , .
n -, , , . , - .
11 , World Oil [http://www.worldoil.com/] Oil & Gas Journal[http://www.ogj.com/], , [http://www.eia.doe.gov/], , - (.: The Oil Drum // World Oil Production orecast Update May 2009[http://www.theoildrum.com/node/5395]).
12 , , .:Tchantouridze L. The States of the Caucasus and their Neighbours. .: Coming Together or Falling Apart? Regional-ism in the Former Soviet Union / Ed. by S.N. MacFarlane. Kingston: QCIR, 1997; Breault Ya., Jolicoeur P., Lvesque J.La Russie et son ex-empire: reconfiguration gopolitique de lancien espace sovitique. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po,2003.
13 , , (.: . . ( ) // - , 2007, 1 [http://www.gfsis.net/pub/geo/showpub.php?detail=1&id=156]; . : - // & , . 1 (1), 2006).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
34/168
6(66), 2009
34
n -, / , -
, . -
, (, , , , ..) ( , ). - - , - , 14.
, , - . , , , - , , , , . - - , -, , , - , - . , , - . : , , 2008 , , , 15.
, - , . - - , , , , -. , - ;
-, , - .
14 Ramsbotham O., Woodhouse T., Miall H . Contemporary Conflict Resolution. Cambridge, UK: PolityPress, 2009.
15 [http://www.ceiig.ch/Report.html]. , , , .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
35/168
6(66), 2009
35
-
, -, (). - , , - , . - , , , , . , , , -, - / , , , .
, -, , . , , . , , : - , . , - , : . , , , , . - . , - , , , - , , . - ( ). , , , - 16.
, . , , , , , , -
16 - - (.:Lantis J.S., Howlett D . Strategic Culture. .: Strategy in the Contemporary World / Ed. byJ. Baylis, J. Wirtz, C.S. Grey, E. Cohen. London: Oxford University Press, 2007).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
36/168
6(66), 2009
36
, , , - , . -
, , , - PR-, - , , , .. , , - , , , , . , .
, , - , - - , . , -
, . , - , . - , , ,- , .
, , , , . , - , , 17. -, , , ( -), , - - .
, - - . ( - ) , / - / , , , , - . , , , - , , - , - . - , - - , , ,
17 , , . , , (.: Luard E. Peace and Opinion. London:Oxford University Press, 1962).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
37/168
6(66), 2009
37
- - 18.
- , , , , , . , . , - , , , -, (, , -- ) . - , , - 1980- 1990- , - , - , -
.
:
, - - , . , - , - . - -- . /, - , - .
( , , - ) - ( , -, ..). , , - . - , - , , , .
18 , (.: Oskanian RejectsArmenian-Turkey Protocols // The Civilitas oundation, 22 September 2009 [http://www.civilitasfoundation.org/cf/discussions/227-oskanian-rejects-armenia-turkey-protocols.html]).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
38/168
6(66), 2009
38
- , , - , -
, . - - , , . - , , .
: 1
- ?
. (, )
I. 2008 , - - .
, , . - : , , , , - .
, , - , : , (POVPEACE).
1 , - ; , -, . .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
39/168
6(66), 2009
39
2008 -, , ,
. , - - - , 2008 , - .
: , -, , - - . , , -, , , - , - .
1990- - -- . - 2008 - - .
2006 , -- . - , , 2004 , - . - , . - , 2006 - - . - . , , - , - 2007 . . .
, - - . -, - , - - - .
, , - ( ) . , , 1990- , , . , - .
, 2008 . -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
40/168
6(66), 2009
40
, , ,
, , - .
- International Security. . : , -, , , - , , - 2. , - . , , , -, 3. , - -, , -. , . , - , - 4.
, - -
. - - . , - 1992 2004 , - 2008 .
II. 1991 1992
, , , -. , , , .
2 Stedman St.J. Spoiler Problems in Peace Processes // International Security, all 1997, Vol. 22, No. 2. P. 5.3 Newman E., Richmond O . The Impact of Spoilers on Peace Processes and Peacebuilding // Policy Brief,
United Nations University, 2006, No. 2.4 Ibidem.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
41/168
6(66), 2009
41
2008 70 000 . 20 30% 5
, , : , 6
, . , , , , , - - , .
- . 1990 , -. 1992 : 1 000 , 100 , , 7.
1992 , - - - , 8. 1992 . () , , - , -, 9.
- -, -. . , - -, , .
2004
1990- , ,
5 .: acts about South Ossetia // International Herald Tribune, 8 August 2008 [http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2008/08/08/news/Georgia-South-Ossetia-Glance.php].
6 . , ,
.7 1991 1992 .: Blood-shed in the Caucasus: Violations of Humanitarian Law and Human Rights in the Georgia-South Ossetia Conflict.Human Rights Watch, March 1992. - 1990- , , -- . 19921993 8 000 , 18 000 200 000 (.: Human Rights Watch/Helsinki. Georgia/Abkhazia: Violations of the Laws of War and Russia s Role in theConflict // Human Rights Watch Arms Project, March 1995, Vol. 7, No. 7).
8 .: - , 24 1992.9 .: . . 3.
.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
42/168
6(66), 2009
42
. , -
() . . , , 10.
, . , - - 11. , , , 12. , - -, - . , - .
2003 - - . , - -. - , . . - 13.
2003 . , - , 14. 2004 -
, - . - , - , , - 15.
2004 - , , , , , , -
10 , , (130 . ), (60,5 . ), (60 ), (23,2 ) (12 ) (.: Kukhianidze A., Kupatadze A., Gotsiridze R . Smuggling Through Abkhazia and Tskhinvali Region/
South Ossetia. Research Report for the American University s Transnational Crime and Corruption Center(TRACC), 2003).11 .: Darchiashvili D., Tevzadze G . Ethnic Conflicts and Breakaway Regions in Georgia // Building
Democracy in Georgia. Discussion Paper, May 2003, No. 9. P. 12 13.12 , -
, - (.: Areshidze M. Current Economic Causes of Conflict in Georgia. UnpublishedReport for UK Department for International Development (D ID), 2002).
13 Georgia: Avoiding War in South Ossetia. Crisis Group Europe Report No. 159, 26 November 2004.14 .: //
Civil Georgia, 29 2003.15 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
43/168
6(66), 2009
43
. - , , , -
16
. -, 2004 .
2004 , 2008 , -, , , , , 17.
2006 -
- 2006 - - 18. 2006 : - - , . 19. - , .
20, . , -
. - , 21. 22. , , 2004 , 1990- - 23.
16 .: South Ossetia Crisis Abates // Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR), Caucasus Reporting Serv-ice No. 236, 3 June 2004; South Ossetia Tensions Still High // IWPR, Caucasus Reporting Service No. 242, 14 July2004; South Ossetia Conflict Heats Up // IWPR, Caucasus Reporting Service No. 246, 12 August 2004.
17 .: // Civil Georgia, 1 2005; // Civil Georgia, 30 2005.
18 .: // Civil Georgia, 7 2006; - - // Civil Georgia, 14 2006. - (1996 2001).
19 .: // Civil Georgia, 12 2006.20 .: 4 // Civil Georgia , 8 -
2006; // CivilGeorgia, 25 2007.
21 .: // Civil Georgia , 1 2008.22 .: // Civil Georgia, 25 2008.23 .: - , 30 2004;
// Regnum, 20 2006 (. : Goble P.A . Russian Passportization // New York Times, 9 September 2008).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
44/168
6(66), 2009
44
III.
,
, - , . , , - . - - . - , , , .
2008 -. . - - . - 2008 , - . , . , - , - .
2006 - . 1999 , - . 2005 2006 . , , , . , , -, , .
, - . , - , , - 24.
24 .: Georgia s South Ossetia Conflict: Make Haste Slowly. International Crisis Group. Europe ReportNo. 183, 7 June 2007.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
45/168
6(66), 2009
45
2007 ( 3,5 .)
: , 25
. - . - 12 ( 7 .) 26. 30 - 27. - . - , - . , - , - 28.
,
- . , , -. . , , , , -, . , -. .
, , - , - . 2006 - 3 , -, . - , 2006 29.
- 1993 30 2000- 31. 1993 , 2000 .
25 .: 6 // Civil Georgia, 24 2007.
26
.: // Civil Georgia, 22 2007.27 , 2008 , . 2008 19 , 2007 13 (.:Defense Spending to Go Up by GEL 295 mln // Georgian Times, 24 June 2008).
28 Georgia s South Ossetia Conflict: Make Haste Slowly. P. 22.29 , , , -
, , (.:Georgia s South Ossetia Conflict: Make Haste Slowly. P. 23).
30 .: - , 14 1993.
31 .: - - , 23 2000.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
46/168
6(66), 2009
46
, - ,
. - . 2006 , , , 32.
-, , . - .
. , , - . , -
, - .
- 2004 , . 2004 - - , . ,
, , . 2005 2006
( , ) (- , ) 33. - 10 - 34. , - .
2006 , ,
10 35. , 2007 -32 .: Russia: Ossetia Pipeline Adds uel to the Georgia ire // R E/RL, 6 November 2006.33 .: Georgia s South Ossetia Conflict: Make Haste Slowly. P. 21.34 .: 49 () -
- , 11 13 2006.35 (2 ), (2 .),
(1 ), (1 ), (500 000 ), (500 000 ), - ( 250 000 ), (200 000 ) (200 000 ). 150 000 , , , , , , , , , (.: - 10 // Civil Georgia, 15 2006).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
47/168
6(66), 2009
47
50 000 , 250 000 36.
. , , 3 , -, 37.
- - , , , . - , , .
- , - - . - . , , 2008 .
IV.
. - 38. - . 39. , - , - 40.
36 .: Georgia Pledges More Aid to Promote South Ossetia s Reconstruction // Eurasia Insight, 5 November2007.
37
.: // Civil Georgia,17 2006.38 .: EU Calls for Calm After Clash in Georgia Rebel Region // Reuters, 4 July 2008 [http://uk.reuters.
com/article/homepageCrisis/idUKL04712416._CH_.242020080704].39 .: .
. , 501-16-04-2008,16 2008.
40 15 ; , , -2008 (.: U.S. Troops Start Training Exercise in Georgia // Reuters,15 July 2008; - --2008. - , 15 2008).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
48/168
6(66), 2009
48
. 29 41.
, - . 7 2008 , , - . . , - , 42. - , - , -, , 43. 10 44. 16 - , , - 45. -, .
, . 192 000 46, 20 000 - . - , . , , , . , - , 47.
26 48 - 7 600 49. - . - , - , - 50.
V. -
.
41 .: // Civil Georgia, 1 - 2008.
42
.: Up in lames: Humanitarian Law Violations and Civilian Victims in the Conflict over South Ossetia.Human Rights Watch Report, January 2009. P. 5.43 .: Russian Invasion of Georgia, acts and igures. Government of Georgia Update, 1 October 2008.44 .: A Two-Sided Descent into ull-Scale War // The Washington Post, 17 August 2008.45 .: // Civil Georgia, 16 2008.46 .: Revised igures Push Number of Georgia Displaced up to 192,000 // UNHCR website, 12 September
2008.47 or more, see: Up in lames: Humanitarian Law Violations and Civilian Victims in the Conflict over
South Ossetia.48.: , 26 2008.49.: Russia Plans 7,600 orce in Georgia Rebel Regions // Reuters, 9 September 2008.50 .: // Civil Georgia, 31 2008.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
49/168
6(66), 2009
49
, , , - -
. - , , , , , , - , -. , , - , - , - , 2008 .
, , 2006 . 1999 - ,
. 2005 2006 - . - , , . - . - - , , - , 2008 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
50/168
6(66), 2009
50
:
(, )
- , -
. - 1994, 2001 2007 . 2008- 6,8% - - 1. 2009- - 16,3% - 2. -
18,7%. , -, .
, - . - -. -, , - . , , - , - -.1 .: . -
. .: 2008.: CA&CC Press, 2009.
2 ( 2009 .
2008 .) [www.cisstat.com], 20 - 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
51/168
6(66), 2009
51
,
, , - , .
(, ,). - . , , , - . ,
. . , , 600 800 . (15 20% ). 60 . . -, . 2008 1 630 . , 10% 48% .
, , . - , . 80% - , - . , , , , .
, . 2008 .
2009 . -, 2008 ( - ) . ( ), - 34% ( 2009 .).
2008 - . - . : - ( ), - .
, - , . , 2008 . -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
52/168
6(66), 2009
52
. 2009 , 6
8%. - . - : , , . : 2008 - 14% .
, - - ( , 19 2008 .). 75 ., ( 800 ., 400 . 2009 .) 3, 500 . +3 15 4.
2 2009
, 5,0% 7,5% . 230 (640 .) 15%. - (940 ), , - .
. 85 ., 35 ., . 47 .; - (. ).
- . ( -), : .
2009 - , .
, ,
2009 81,5% . . 1, : -
. : - 6,1% -
3 .: [http://www.imf.org/external/np/sec/pr/2009/pr09228.htm/].4 , 2009 -
245 . . .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
53/168
6(66), 2009
53
16,3% , 18,5% ( , ). -
: - 18,4% 18,3% - . : , 15% .
, . 54, . , -: . 12%, . - - . 4,57 . - -, , . , , - 26,5% ., -, .
. (16% ) 2009 2 , , . : N2 ( -
0
5
10
15
20
, % 0
, 7
3
, 7
6
, 1
9
, 7
1 5
, 7
1 6
, 3
1 8
, 5
1 8
, 4
1 8
, 3
1
2009
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
54/168
6(66), 2009
54
), 15%, 23,85%, 30,74%. 41,6 54,09 (146 .). , -, .
, - 7,75% 5,00% ( ). (2 3%) - . , 60 . . 5.
, , 2008 , - -. , - , (, HSBC- -
HSBC). - , , , : -.
- . - 2009 -
2009
( 2008 .)
81,7
88,6
98,7
56,2
100,898,8
112
58,5
72,1
81,5
88,0
97,9
55,0
100,199,5
111,3
55,5
70,5
5 5%, . , - .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
55/168
6(66), 2009
55
12,9% , 14%. , , -
- 34%. , - - . , , . (. .), (118,1%), . .
.n ,
. 6 . , - ( ). - - 60 .; . .
n , - . -: , . , , : -, , -
, . - 44 30 (80 .).
n . , - 50 ., 1 . .
n -, , , 50%. 10 . -.
. (. .).
, -
,
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
56/168
6(66), 2009
56
. - 2008 . , , , , . -
305 . -, : - 60 ., 10 .
2008 2009- - 600 . ( ), 40 70% . , , - 2004 2006 6, .
3 2009 , , . 305 370 .
, -
360 380 . 2009 ( ) 7. -, ( ). Stand-by. , .
-
. ,
. , - , ( ). , , , 2009 , , .
: . - , - - - - . 400 ., .
-, , - 20% . , 2008 27% , 2002 6,6%. - .
6 .: . : . .: -: / . .. . : CA&CC Press , 2008.
7 2010 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
57/168
6(66), 2009
57
2009 2006 (. . 2) 8,
.
1988 , 7 . -. 70 (190 .) - . .
, - 90% . . 2009 . - (), .
87 (235 .), 150 . - 17 .
8 . , , - -.
2
2006 2007 2008 2009
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
58/168
6(66), 2009
58
, -.
,
, -. , . - , 2000- , - .
. , 2008 , - : , , - , - .
, - , - .
, . , , : - , .
, - .
1. .
2. - . 3 .
3. , - . , , , . , , - , . , , 2009 16% 11,5% 2008 . ,
. , .4. -
, , . - 2009 - . . -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
59/168
6(66), 2009
59
.
, - - . .
: , - , , ..
-
: - -
( ). ; - .
, , . .
(, )
, . .
(, )
. - -
-, , - , -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
60/168
6(66), 2009
60
-
( , , , -, ..). - . -. 50% .
1, - , , ; - , - . , . , -
. - -.
- . - , , , - . - - .
, , .
, - , - , , .
, , - .
; -.
. - - , - . - , -, - .
, -
-; - - . - - . .
1 .: ., ., ., . . 2- . (D. Rechmen, M. Meskon,K. Bouvi, D. Till,Modern Business , Textbook, in two volumes). .: , 1995.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
61/168
6(66), 2009
61
- , .
. -, , , , , , , ( , - ), , , , - , .
, .
-
. XIX ,
1990- . - .
1990- , , - ( ); , - , .
, - . - . .
- , . , , , .. , - . - , - .
, - , . 1993 98,4% .
, , , . - .
1993 , .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
62/168
6(66), 2009
62
(1991 .) -
(1992 .), (1992 .), - (1993 .) - (1993 .).
, 1999 .
, 1999 , - . , , 50 .; 35 .; 30 .; 20 .; 20 .
23 1999 , -
-, , . - 40 - 500 . ; 20 300 . ; - 20 200 . ; 20 - 150 . ; 10 50 . ; , 25 60 . ; - 15 100 . 2.
, , 20 ., 500 . .
, - : . , - : 3 4 40 50 . . , -. .
( , ) . , 2007 42,9% -, , , - (28,7%).
. , . 2005 2007 , 2% ; 1,6%; , 0,6%. 2007 52,2% 3.
2007 5 6% .
2 .: // , 2006, 37 38, .3 .: . -
, 2008.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
63/168
6(66), 2009
63
- .
23 1999 . , . , - . , , - . , 13 : , , , -, , , , . .
, .
, , , . 2002 ; - . .
2006 ( -), . . , , , , .
-
. . - - . , - .
. - , , , . , - , -; - .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
64/168
6(66), 2009
64
-: -
. : , , -, .
, - . - , - . - -.
: ; () ; , ; -
; ; ; ; (. 1). -
, .
, -, .
, , , - , .
. ,, , , . - , , ,, , , , , - , , , , , , , , -, -, . - , -.
. - , , , .
. - , -, - .
- . - .
-
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
65/168
6 5
-
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
66/168
6(66), 2009
66
, .
, . -
, : () - , , .
, - , -. , - - .
,
- .
,
: -, , -
, - . , -
, -- , , , , , , .
, - . , - - , - .
, - , -, , , 1 000 , - ( , ).
-, . , . , ,
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
67/168
6(66), 2009
67
, , .
, -, , 10 ., - 150 . .
- . - , ( - , , ..). - .
- , : -, - , , . - .
, -, .
() - , . , , , , - .
() - .
- . - .
- . , , , . ( , , - .), , , .
, - ; . - , , , .
- . - , , , .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
68/168
6(66), 2009
68
, , -
, , , -, . ,
, - . - - . .
, - . , . - . , - . - , , -, .
.
- . : ; ; - -
; , ; ; - ; ; ( -) ; .
. , , -
, .
1) - ;
2) ;
3) ;4) -
- , .
. (. 2).
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
69/168
6 9
-
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
70/168
6(66), 2009
70
: - ; -
, , .
- ; - - ; - ; - ; - ; - ; (, , ,, ) - .
- - ( -); ; - - .
, , - .; , (, - , - , - ..); - ( ), .
-, ; - ; , ; , - ; . - .
- - , - , , , - .
- : - - ; , - ; , - ( - ); , - .
- -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
71/168
6(66), 2009
71
(, , ); ; -
, , . -
; , . - . - .
- , , , World Vision ( ) - ().
- 2006 2008 , . , -
. -
, - , , , , , - , , - , , -, -, , -, , , .. - ( - ); ; ; - .
, .
- .
-, , (- ), ( ), , ( ).
, - , - .
- .
, , .
, -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
72/168
6(66), 2009
72
, , . - -
. , . -. - - . - , (2006 .). ; - . , - . , - , -, -, , -,, ; -
, , , . , , - , ; - .
- .
. - . - .
- .
, - , - . , - . 50% , . - , - .
, -. -.
- , , ; . , .
, -
. , ,
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
73/168
6(66), 2009
73
, : , ,
..
-
(, )
, , - , 1.
2006 2 - ( -), , 3. - , -, . ; , - 4, , 5.
1 [http://www.ipd.kz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=278%3A2008-11-01-07-20-06&catid=80%3A2008-09-06-10-05-09&Itemid=31&lang=ru], 15 2009.
2
[http://akmolinka.narod.ru/n161_16_12/actual.htm], 15 2009.3 2000- -, . -, 2003 , . 20062007 , , - . - , -, (.: [http://www.utro.ru/articles/2009/02/09/796535.shtml], 25 2009).
4 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Jakupova.doc], 15 2009.5 [http://bb.f2.kz/ru/economic/vliyanie-mirovogo-krizisa-sentyabrya-2008-na-kazahstan-t408.html], 15
2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
74/168
6(66), 2009
74
- 2008 ( 1991 ) 6.
2008 - 20 ., 7. , ,
, :
1) , ;2) , ( -
: 64 65 ., , , 500 . 8); ( ), ;
3) ;4) (
1/2 );5)
;6) : () -
- , , (- , , - .);
7) - ; -
, - - 9.
. - - (1980- .) 10. : - . . .
. ,
, . -, ( ) . ,
6 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Seytkasimov.doc], 29 2009.7 .8 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.9 [http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/10/09/AR2008100903425.html], 16 2009.10 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Essentugelov.doc], 16 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
75/168
6(66), 2009
75
, ( - ). ,
; , -.
, , - .
- , , , . (90% , 80% , 70 80% ) 11 - . - . . , , . -
, , . , -- . - -, .
-, , . . - , . , .
- , - . . - , , - .
(-) - ; , .
. . 12, - XXI , , , . - , - .
1970- . - , . - , , - -
11 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Essentugelov.doc], 16 2009.12 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
76/168
6(66), 2009
76
. .
, XXI , . - .
- () , : () ; - .
. , () .
.
13.
-, . - 14. , - , .
- 2008 15, , 16. - ,
17
. - - , - (, -)18.
2007 , 19. , , , , - . , - 20, - , - ; 21.
13 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Jakupova.doc], 15 2009.14 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.15 [http://www.ipd.kz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=278%3A2008-11-01-07-20-06&catid=80%
3A2008-09-06-10-05-09&Itemid=31&lang=ru], 24 2009.16 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Seytkasimov.doc], 29 2009.17 [http://akmolinka.narod.ru/n161_16_12/actual.htm], 15 2009.18 [http://economyclub.info/upload/ am%20Ti%20Chan.doc], 24 2009.19 .20 [http://www.kazpravda.kz/index.php?uin=1151984397&act=archive_date&day=26&month=8&year=2008], 26
2009.21 [http://akmolinka.narod.ru/n161_16_12/actual.htm], 15 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
77/168
6(66), 2009
77
40 . 22 , -
. - - ; - .
23 - 24. , - , .
, - .
1. , , , - , 25. - 26. 27 , . 28, ..
2. , - (- ). - , 2008 29.
3. . , . , 2009 , , 2008 30.
4. - : 2008 2,3%, 7,7%. , - - ( 2008 50%), .
22 [http://economyclub.info/upload/ am%20Ti%20Chan.doc], 24 2009.23 [http://www.polit.nnov.ru/2008/03/12/crisisdate/], 24 2009.24 [http://ru.government.kz/documents/govprog/27], 24 2009.25 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Seytkasimov.doc], 29 2009.26 .27 .. 2009 . [http://www.
akorda.kz/www/www_akorda_kz.nsf/sections?Open orm&id_doc=73738D165C03D67D062575710070A04&lang=ru&L1=L2&L2=L2-22].
28 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Alpyspaeva.doc], 24 2009.29 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Iskakova.doc], 29 2009.30 [http://souz-atameken.kz/rus/pressfile/?cid=30&rid=6590], 29 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
78/168
6(66), 2009
78
, ( 5%) - 12 15% 31.
, - 32.5. , 2007 , -
96,4 . ( 2001 2007 . ), 100 . 33 2008 - , 105 .; 45 . 34. 8 21,7 , 21,8 35. 2009 - 11 ., 36. , - - - .
6. 3, - , - .
7. - , -; , - 37.
8. , , 38.
9. ; -, 39.
, 1) -
, - ; 40;
2) , - - ; 41; -
31 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Seytkasimov.doc], 29 2009.32
.33 .34 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.35 .36 .37 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Seytkasimov.doc], 29 2009.38 [http://www.zakon.kz/our/news/news.asp?id=30081515; http://www.akorda.kz/www/www_akorda_kz.nsf/
sections?Open orm&id_doc=5995684C07768CD1462572340019E67 &lang=ru; http://www.nomad.su/?a=4-200605060004], 24 2009.
39 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Seytkasimov.doc], 29 2009.40 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.41 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
79/168
6(66), 2009
79
, 42;
3) ; - ;4) ;
; ;
5) ( ) - ; , , -. -, , , - , . , -
;6) . - , - ; .
, 43 (. . 1).
1
(, , 44), , ( , , )
, , .. Arcelor Mittal , , ,
, . .
42 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.43 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Alpyspaeva.doc], 24 2009.44 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
80/168
6(66), 2009
80
1
.
, .
,, , . (60 . ). , , . 45, . - , . . , .
.
, ,
45 [http://www.ipd.kz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=278%3A2008-11-01-07-20-06&catid=80%3A2008-09-06-10-05-09&Itemid=31&lang=ru], 25 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
81/168
6(66), 2009
81
1
. Libor , Libor
, Libor.
, , , 46.
.n -, -
, - (, , , ).
n -, - , , .
n -, , .
( ). , , -.
. - ( - ). , , .
: - , , - .
- . -
2008 : - -. , . , , - . -
46 [http://www.dialog.kz/site.php?lan=ru&id=92&pub=1467], 25 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
82/168
6(66), 2009
82
, - .
- 47. ,
, ( ) - : - , 48. , -.
, 2009 2010 . 15 .(10 . , 5 . -), 20% 49.
:n 4 .;n 5 .;n 1 .;n 1 .;n , , -
4 .
- . - .
, - , - , . -. 2 1,5% - 3 2,5% 50.
3 :1) ;2) -
;3) 51. : ;
47 [http://akmolinka.narod.ru/n161_16_12/actual.htm], 26 2009.48 .49 [http://news.kkb.kz/news/show.asp?no=1165776], 26 2009.50 [http://www.aktau-business.com/2009/03/04/nacionalnyjj-bank-kazakhstana-snizil-normativy.html], 26
2009.51 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Nesternko.doc], 29 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
83/168
6(66), 2009
83
( 5 );
, - ( ); , , ;
, - ;
- , , , -, , ;
; -
- ;
( -) - - .
. - , 120 . .
15 10,512,5% . -
. - .
- - -, 265 . . -. -, , - 4% .
, , - . - .
. - , . - ; - 14%.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
84/168
6(66), 2009
84
- .
. - - .
- , . - , ; - , - . , - , .
, 1 2009, , -
52
. 30 15%, 12% 53; 54. -
- . , - . , ; -, - , , - , - , .
. - , - , 55. , - . , . 30 .
- 7 , . , - .
. - , 56.
52 [http://bb.f2.kz/ru/zakon/skachat-nalogovyj-kodeks-respubliki-kazahstan-2009-goda-t639.html], 29 2009.
53 .54 [http://www.minplan.kz/economyabout/247/5898/], 30 2009.55 [http://akmolinka.narod.ru/n161_16_12/actual.htm], 15 2009.56 [http://www.samruk-kazyna.kz/page.php?page_id=19&lang=1&article_id=235&parent_id=15], 29
2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
85/168
6(66), 2009
85
19 - (8 , 5 , 3
.), , , - 57. . ;
45 (28 17 -) 54 . 58
- , - 2010 2020 . - 7 , : - , , -, , , , - ; . 1 2009 59 2010 60.
, 2009 , - 61. , - , 30 , 62.
63:1) ;2) ;3) , ;
4) - -, , () ;5) ;6) -
;7) . 3 -
18 50 -, . -, , , , , . - 50 .
.
57 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.58 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Nurmaganbetov.doc], 29 2009.59 [http://www.kazakstan.kz/rus/news/economy/2009_06_02_19_30_00], 30 2009.60 [http://v.zakon.kz/140325-gotovimsja-k-industrializacii.html], 30 2009.61 [http://mirtv.ru/content/view/66468/86/], 30 2009.62 [http://www.khabar.kz/index.cfm?id=76139], 30 2009.63 [http://dorkarta.enbek.gov.kz/], 30 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
86/168
6(66), 2009
86
, , - .
- -- ( , -); , .; , - ; , , (), 64.
, , 6 ( - 15 000 ), 65.
2030.
- - -
2020 , 66.
, ( 2008 . 3 3,0%) 67.
2009 1 3% 68, 2009 2010 8,0%, 2009 11,0% 69.
, , 2009 2010 - 25%, 2011 30% 70. , - 2011 71.
2009 2%, IV - 2008 72.
2009 ( - ) 100,7%. , 2009 2008 3,5%, 1,0 , (4,5%).
2009 - 8,7% 19,0% 2008 (. . 1).
64 [http://209.85.129.132/search?q=cache:kpA 7qKvc98J:www.yujanka.kz/economics.php%3 subaction%3Dshowfull%26id%3D1241417811%26archive%3D%26start_from%3D%26ucat%3D2%26+%D0%93%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%B %D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B3%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%BC%D0%B0+%C2%AB%D0%94%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B6%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%8 +%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%82%D0%B0%C2%BB+%D0%B2+%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%B7%D0%B0%D1%85%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B5&cd=3&hl=ru&ct=clnk&gl=ru], 30 2009.
65 .66 [http://eng.minplan.kz/2020/], 30 2009.67 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.68 [http://ru.government.kz/documents/govprog/27], 30 2009.69 [http://economyclub.info/upload/Kuchukova.doc], 29 2009.70 [http://www.ipd.kz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=278%3A2008-11-01-07-20-06&catid=
80%3A2008-09-06-10-05-09&Itemid=31&lang=ru&limitstart=3], 29 2009.71 [http://www.automan.kz/57443-raskhody-gosudarstva-na-vyplatu-pensijj-i.html], 30 2009.72 [http://www.inform.kz/ShowArticle?id=234389], 30 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
87/168
6(66), 2009
87
, - I 2009 6,9%.
, . 30 2009 43 . (. . 2 3), , , .
73, 2009 1%; 2010 3,0%; 2013 4,3%. - - 11% ( 2009 .) 5,5 7,5% 2013 . 74
, 2010 2013 4,4 5,3%, , - . 2010 2013
1
2008 2009 ( % )
1,5
1,2
0,9
0,6
0,3
0
: .
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
73 [http://www.minplan.kz/economyabout/247/5898/], 30 2009.74 .75 .
0,9
1,1
0,80,6
0,91,0
1,2
0,8
0,6 0,6
0,4
0,20,3
0,8 0,8 0,80,7
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
88/168
6(66), 2009
88
2,7 3,5% (. . 2), 75.
, 7,4% 2009 6,8% 2013 76.
, ; , , - . , , - .
, 2009 2010 ; 2010 2013 , 77.
2
( .)
32
24
16
8
0
: C .
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2628
26,6 27,6 26,3 26,8 27,3
22,3 22 22,5 23,1
75 [http://www.minplan.kz/economyabout/247/5898/], 30 2009.76 .77 [http://www.ipd.kz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=278%3A2008-11-01-07-20-06&catid=
80%3A2008-09-06-10-05-09&Itemid=31&lang=ru], 15 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
89/168
6(66), 2009
89
3
( .)
2
2009 2013 ( % )78
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
0,3 2,7 3,1 3,3 3,5
: 0,2 2,2 2,5 2,7 3,0
3,0 4,4 5,0 5,2 5,3 0,0 4,2 4,6 5,1 5,3
2,0 3,1 2,0 2,3 3,2
0,4 3,7 1,1 1,5 2,7
: C
.
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 9
21
18,3
21,7 22 2119,1 19,4 19,7 18,9 19,5
19,9
25
20
15
10
5
0
78 [http://www.minplan.kz/economyabout/247/5898/], 30 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
90/168
6(66), 2009
90
, , , 2010 79. , -
. 80, 2009 16 ,
, 4,2%. - 2010 , 0,4%.
2009 - 4,9%, 2010 0,7%. - , 2009 3% 81.
. 82 2009 . , .
- ; .
10% 83. 5,7%, -
2009 21,6% 2008.
26,4% ( ); - .
2008 2009 84. : G-20 (, , 15 2008 .), - , , (-, , 8 9 2009 .), (, -
, 28 1 2009 .), II (, -, 11 12 2009 .) .
. , .
79 [http://www.kazks.kz/article/163.html], 15 2009.80 .81 [http://www.kabmir.org/news/1324-svobodnoe-padenie-mirovoy-ekonomiki-prodoljaetsya.html], 30
2009.82 [http://www.kazks.kz/article/163.html], 15 2009.83 [http://www.kabmir.org/news/1324-svobodnoe-padenie-mirovoy-ekonomiki-prodoljaetsya.html], 30
2009.84 [http://www.economyclub.info/], 30 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
91/168
6(66), 2009
91
- (-, )
XX , - , . (- ) ( - ). - - - , - -. , -, - - , . , - , - - , - .
2009 20 . -, . - . .
- - , -
. , : ( ) .
, - - . , -, , , . - , - , : - 2007 .
-- , -, - , . -, - . , - , , , - .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
92/168
6(66), 2009
92
( )
- . (2000 2006 .) () 9%. - 10% ( 2001 . 13,5%, 2006 . 10,7%). , , - 99,0%, , 1. 2005 56,8 ., (, , -, , , ), 2.
2006 81 ., 2007- 100 . (104,85 .).
2000 1 229 ., 2007- , 6 772 . 3
: 2000- - 15,5% , 2001- 13,8%, 2002 10,5%, 2003- 9,1%, 2004- 10,4%.
-, 5 7% 4.
, - .
. , , , : - - .
- ( - ) , - .
2009 - -
-
, ,, -
.
1 .: (1991 2007). : , 2008. . 75 76.
2 .: . // , 2006, 4 (46). . 57., , , ., (1991 2007) 57,1 .
3 .: (1991 2007). . 74.4 .: . . 10.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
93/168
6(66), 2009
93
2005 , - , ,
, - 5. ,
, - .
1995 . , 1995 20,6 , 2000- 35,3 , 5 71%.
, 2000 39,9%, 2/5 6.
-; . 2007 67,5 , 2008 70 ,
1,8% . 90% ., 2007 67,5 60,8 . 1999 2,57 .
. 2000 2007 8,9 29,2 . , 3,3 7.
2006 14,7%, - 66,3%.
, , - , 8.
- ., 2007 15,2 . 648,2 . 60 28,13 . , 1999 - 2,57 , 13,59 , 9.
- . 2003 12,9 ., 2004 20,1 ., 2007 47,8 ., 2008 71,2 . 10
, , . ( 2005 . 10,5 ., 2006 . 14,6 ., 2007 . 15,0 .).
- 2000 ,
5 , 11 2005.6 .: , 27 2000 16 2001. . 19.7 [http://www.rusoil.ru/opinions/o06-58.html].8 .9 : . . . . 53, 55 [http://lider-invest.com.ua/news/2008-02-14-1961].10 .: 2008 . : , 2009. . 12.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
94/168
6(66), 2009
94
, - .
, - - , - .
: (, ). , , , .
2001 , 2006- 14 039,1 . 21 045,5 ., 2008- 27 334,2 ., 1,5 2008 (19 396,2 .) 11.
. , , -
.. , 2004 12 817 ( ), 2005- 15 787 , 2006- 19 152 , 2007 25 226 , 2008- 30 509 12. 2004 28 329 , 2006- 40 790 , 2008 60 734 (526 .) 13.
2004 2008 1 323,8 3 394,1 , 2,5 .
2,6 6,8 . 14.
2007 -- 2008 2010 . , - 2008 2010 15. - - .
, , - 2007 . , , - .
11 .: z, 16 2008, 38 [http://news.finance.ua/ru/-/2/0/all/2009/02/05150897/printable].12 .: - 2008 . ( ). :
, 2009. . 7.13 .: .14 .: . . 8.15 - 2008 2010
// , 2007, 32. . 354.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
95/168
6(66), 2009
95
, . -
., , 2006 , (52%) - . , 2004 38%, - 1/3 16.
, -, , - : , , .
, -, - - . (, + Standard&Poor s).
, , - , . , . - .
, , - 45 ., 2007 . - .
2007 ( - ) , - . , 2 48,5 101,7%. , 17.
- , (- , ). , - 1/10 .
, - 1993 2008 166 . 18, -
, , , , - .
16 .: . : ( ) [http://www.klerk.ru/columnists/skvortsov/?130694].
17 .: . // , 6 2009.
18 .: - - . - [http://kbcc.org.uk/ru/business-info/kazakhstan-economy-outlook/].
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
96/168
6(66), 2009
96
, ( ) ( 80% -
)19
, , - - . , ( , ) ; .
. 2001 : , , , - . - . , , -, 20.
, 8 ., , 2009 - , , -, . , - .
: - , - , - 21.
, , , , , - .
, 5 , - 70% , 2,5 ( 2004 - 2007 .) 1,6 10,4 . 22 , ( ), 30% 23.
, - ( ) 2007 - 28 . - . .
: - : -
.19 .: . [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=
1234569780].20 . : // -
, 2001, 3 (15). . 57.21 . [http://www.dn.kz/main/bank01.htm].22 .:
[http://www.kazakhstan.socializm.ru/ideology/program/antikrizis_econ_program_ 2009].
23 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
97/168
6(66), 2009
97
, , -
, - . 2000 2007 1 780% 775% . 4 24.
2007 -: , - ; . - . , - , . - .
. 2005 - ( 4,97 .).
2006 2007 (, 8,49 10,95 .) 25. . -
, , . , 1 2008 , 1,4 , 2 26.
, , , , .
, , , , , -, : , 2005 7,7%; 2006- 8,4%; 2007- 18,8%.
- . : 2006 10,6%, 2007- 8,7% 27, 2008- 3,2%. . 2006 7,2%, 2007- 5,0%, 2008- 2,1%. - 2007 5,6%, : 2005 4,6%, 2006- 4,5%, 2007- 8,9% 28.
( -), : - . (-, ) . , 2006 37,3% , 2007 24,8%, 2008 49,1%.
2008 , - . -
24 [http://www.zakon.kz/our news/news_asp?id=30176764].25 .: . : ?
[http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1225058400].26 .: . // (), 14 2008.27 .: (1991 2007). . 11.28 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
98/168
6(66), 2009
98
, 2009- -. , 3 2009
2 ( 49,2%) 2008 8,02 . 15,8% 5,99 . , 2009 2,03 ., 4 , 2008 , 8,7 . 29
, - . . , (2004 2005) . 2005 43,4 ., 75% 30.
, , - 80% . 2006 : 74 . 90% (81 .). 2007 2008 : 2008 107,8 ., 81,5%31.
, - - .
- . 2007 46 ., 47,4% . 2008 14,1 ., ( 7,4 .). - 39,2 .
2008 . - - -. , - . .
(, , ) 2008 .
, .
( ) 2008 35 ., - 27,3 . 32
2008 -
, 11,2%, 107,8 . , 2008 , ,
,
29 .: - 2009 . : , 2009.
30 .: . // , 10 2009.31 .: .32 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
99/168
6(66), 2009
99
68 . 10,8 . 33
2008 ( - , - ) 31,3 . C - -, , . , , - , 2008 6 800 . .
2007 , . , , , , . - , - .
, , , - . . -, -,
. . , 2007 - 40 . , - 4 . 34.
, , - , -. , 2008 , , , . , 2007 2008 35.
, - , . 2007 4 . , . . -
33 .: .34 .: (), 24 2008.35 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
100/168
6(66), 2009
100
, , -36.
2008 , - - , - . .
2008 - () - . 10 ., . 4 . 4 - ( , ( -), - ), .
3 .; 1 .
. , 1 . . 2008
, , -- ; , .
, , , , , -.
, - , - . - .
. , - , , , , . 37
2008 -. , 52 ., - . , , - . , . , , , - 3 ., , , 5 6 . ., , ,
, , . - 38. , -
; - 39.
36 .: (), 24 2008.37 .: (), 14 2008.38 . // , 25 2008.39 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
101/168
6(66), 2009
101
2008 , -
2009 2010 , . , , - .
. , - - ( -) .
- , . 2009 122 ( 1 .). -
. 2009 , 1 . - ; .
- . 1 2009 16,4%. : 2/3 - (55,2%), (7,2%) 40.
, 5 . ( -). - . - .
. 2009 1 . . 3 5 . 41
- , .
, , - (). - . . -, , - . , - 42.
2009 - , 1 - 122,3 144,0 ( 4 5 ). -
40 .: . [http://www.dn.kz/main/bank01.htm].41 [http://www.zakon.kz/our/news/news.asp?id=30369373].42 .: , 19 2008.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
102/168
6(66), 2009
102
; -
. - : 2008 4 2009 6 . 2009 2,7 . 43
, , , , - , .
. : , . , . , -, , -
. .
, , . -
- , -, ., .
- . 1 2 , , - .
, 2009 , - 2%. , - , 2009 , - 1%44.
2009 , 2009 2,2% 2008 45.
2009 4,6% 2008 . , -
, - . , -
,
43 [http://news.finance.ua/ru/-/2/0/all/2009/02/05/150897/printable].44 .: - , 16
2009.45 .: -
2009 . : , 2009.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
103/168
6(66), 2009
103
, - .
, - . - 19 ., 14% 46.
, , , 100 .
, 7,2% , 47.
(43 . 2009 .); .
, , .
4 2009 - 2008 9,3% 48, , - . , , .
2009 , - , 11%. 2009 (3,9%) 49 , . , , , - .
, ,
. - 2009 , ( 63,3% 2008 .), 27,4% 2008 50.
- 2009 , , , -, 2008 . , 2009 , -.
, ( 2 ., .), . , 1 2009 290 025 , 5,2% , . 5,5% , -, 50 . 51
46 [http://www.centrasia.ru/news/A.php?st=1244816640].47 .: [http://www.stat.kz/news/Pages.n2_01_07_2009.aspx].48 .: - 2009 . :
, 2009.49 .: .50 .: . .51 .: - 2009 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
104/168
6(66), 2009
104
2009 1/3 - 20%. 2011
15%. 12%52
. . -
. , -.
. 2 . - . , 2009 - 1,6 . 5 2009 ( ) 3,1% - 2008 .
Standard & Poor s , - , - .
90 . - ( 140 . ), - 2000 2,5 . , , , - , -, , .
, 2004 2005 - , - , .
, - . , 53. . .
, 2010 10- ( 5-), - .
-,
, , , , , 54.
52 .: 6 2009 .53 . 12 2009 [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA/
php?st=1244816640].54 .: .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
105/168
6(66), 2009
105
, , ( 2009 .) -
, .n -, -
, .n -,
.n -, -
.n -,
, ,
. , . - 6 2009 , , -, ; ( 2010 . 25%, 2011 . 30%).
, - , 11 . 40 . . 2009 - . , , 2009 - 64 730 . 2008 11,8%. - 2,8% 55.
, - .
* * *
, - . , .
, , .
- . , , - , -. , - - .
55 .: - 2009 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
106/168
6(66), 2009
106
. - . .
, - , - .
. - , - .
, , , , - . - , .
.
-
,
(, )
- , (,, ). ( ) .
2008 . - .
- -
-- , 2008 , -.
, - - , - (, 1847 1849 . - , 1929 . ). , -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
107/168
6(66), 2009
107
109,0
23,8
1,6
112,7
104,5
128,3
7,8
1 393,00
109,5
21,8
0,5
112,1
106,1
122,9
6,8
1 290,00
107,3
21,6
0,5
110,8
106,2
111,4
6,8
1 240,00
107,0
21,2
0,3
107,2
106,2
105,7
7,8
1 174,02
108,0
22,2
1,0
109,3
105,0
118,0
7-9
1 456,0
-
- . , -, - , - .
- : , , , , , - (. . 1).
1
( % )
2005 . 2006 . 2007 . 2008 . 2009 .()
( % )
/( % )
( )
/ ( )
: .
Transition Report 2007 , 7 5,4%, 2007 9,3%.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
108/168
6(66), 2009
108
, -
, 7% 1
(. . 1).
, 2001 2007 -: 6 1 600% 7,2% , 2005 2007 , 2001 2007 . , , 3 . , - , - ; , - - - .
, -- - 2009 . 2007 , - .
, ( ) . () , - ; .
: .
1
( .)
1 400 000 000,00
1 200 000 000,00
1 000 000 000,00
800 000 000,00
400 000 000,00
200 000 000,00
0,00
1 9 9 1
1 9 9 3
1 9 9 5
1 9 9 7
1 9 9 9
2 0 0 1
2 0 0 3
2 0 0 5
2 0 0 7
1 .: (), 10 2007.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
109/168
6(66), 2009
109
, -
, - . ( ), , . , .
- . , - : -1 (- ), ( ), ( - ), (---
- ), (- ), - - ( ), ( ); - , - .. 2
- , - . , . - , .
(. . 2) 3. - , , . 1 2009 13,3% 4. , , , , - , , -, . ( , , 50% , - 60%.)
- - . 3, - , .
2 .: ., . [http://www.ia-centr.ru/public_details.php?id=137].
3 .: . . - , . : , 2009. . 9.
4 . . 25 26.
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
110/168
6(66), 2009
110
: .
3
40,00
30,00
20,00
10,00
0,00
10,00
20,00
30,00 , % ( , %) ( %) ( , %)
1 9 9 1
1 9 9 2
1 9 9 3
1 9 9 4
1 9 9 5
1 9 9 6
1 9 9 7
1 9 9 8
1 9 9 9
2 0 0 0
2 0 0 1
2 0 0 2
2 0 0 3
2 0 0 4
2 0 0 5
2 0 0 6
2 0 0 7
2
( % )
120
100
80
40
20
0
91102
89 9080
85 83 81
110
64
81
60
76
: - ().
2005 2006 2007 2008
5145
36 37
2922
31
1713,3
34
92
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
111/168
6(66), 2009
111
- , -
., , - 1997, 1998 - , .
1993 1997 , . - 1997 , . - 1999 2008 , . - : -,, .
. , - .
- , - - .
- - , ( ).
- - ( , , , -, .). , , , . , , . 92% , .
- , , - , . - - 2009 2009 2012 . - .
n -, 2009 .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
112/168
6(66), 2009
112
n -, -, 2009 -
.n -, -
. , - - -.
n -, .
n -, 2009 - ; - .
- - . ; , - .
, -, , - .
, , - ( ), - . -
. , - .
n , .
n , - ; .
n , , , -, .
n - - .
n , - .
n . , - -, .
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
113/168
6(66), 2009
113
- , , -
, 30% . , , -
, -. , .
, ,
.
- . - ; - . .
- . , - , .
- . , , - , - .
, - . - , .
, - , , .
, -. ( ) ; - .
- . . -, . - -.
, , , - -. -
-
7/30/2019 " " 2009, nr66, 6
114/168
6(66), 2009
114
, - (-
). , -.