#) g ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bvx\4[ ddbv j

33

Upload: others

Post on 04-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

������������� �������� ����������� � ����������! "�#�$��&%('���'*)+���,�� ��������-�-����/.

021436587896:<;�=?>A@CB8=D789 EGFIHJ7CKMLON58B8PQFI7SR�FIHT7

UVXWZY�[�\�]*[�^`_bac\6[edgfhVXiZV�[eWkj`lnm+VX\I^`VXW�oQapW*m+acYGqDrD^ZVsWutDjv_wVs\6j<VyxzU�{M|}t?jZl?dwapiZi*~�_bWZdb_b\D�clDa��pVX\��I|h���p�c�c�e�#tD[e\D�I^��*rD�prDiZ^`_w\S�6UVXW`Y [e\��

� �zY [e_wdz���sl6[�\D�I���cY ��� ��Vc�cYyr?VXlDdbVX\I�6Vs_w\4�*�pY �����IV

�yR��s����=6�e�

�+�<�c�< J¡£¢�¤c¥z¦¨§�¥Z©sªª*¡£�p§�¡£«�¬�¡£«z J¡£�p§�­e¡£«z®c�<¬�¯T¥z¦�ª°¦� z®p�<¥±�<²¨¦X³£­p J¡£¦��I©X¥z´M©v³£§�¦¨¥J¡£ z®cª«�¡£�y z®I©X �¡£ +­c«z�<«� z¥z�<��¥z�k¤p¥z�<«z�k�� Z©vµ J¡£¦¨�c«�¦X¯�²�©s¥J¡w©X¶e³£�#«J¡£·<�¡£�p«z z�X©X¬�¦s¯C³�¡£�p�X©X¥«z z¥J¡£�c§¨«*¦s¯8¸�¹��<¬G³£�<�c§¨ z®Dº#»�®c��¼��<¹¨¡£¶�³£��¥z�<¤c¥z�<«z�<�� Z©X J¡£¦¨�M«z¢`®c�<ª�¡£«*²¨�<¥z´¡£ª¤I¦�¥z Z©s�� �¶I�<¢X©X­p«z�y¡£ #©v³�³£¦X½�«� z®p�y­c�p¬c�<¥J³£´¨¡£�c§¾«z z¥z­c¢< z­c¥z�y¦s¯� z®c�y¬�©s Z©G z¦/¶I�y¬�¡£«z¢<¦X²¨�<¥z�<¬¿©X­p z¦�ª�©s J¡£¢v©v³�³£´¨ºÁÀ+�p�¤p¥J¡£ªÂ©s¥z´¾¬�¡�Ã�¢<­�³£ J´�Ä+®c¦X½8�<²¨�k¥<Ä8¡£«� z®�©s � z®p�y«z¦X³£­p J¡£¦��p«yªÂ©v´M§�¥z¦s½, z¦�¦�¶�¡£§M½Å¡£ z®c¦¨­c y©X��´�¡£ª¤p¥z¦X²��<ª�<�� y¦X¯� z®c�`¡£¥§¨�<�c�<¥Z©<³�¡£·X©s J¡£¦��M©s¶�¡�³�¡£ J´¨º�ÆQ�� z®�¡£«�¤I©X¤I�<¥+½C��¡£��²¨�k«z J¡£§�©s z�Ç z®p�+¯T­c�c¬I©Xª�<�� Z©v³�¥z�Z³w©s J¡£¦¨�c«z®�¡£¤�¶I�< Q½8�<�<�# z®p��¤I�k¥J¯T¦¨¥zª�©X�p¢k�©s�c¬�¢<¦�ª¤�³£�<¹¨¡£ J´/¦s¯� z®c���<²¨¦X³£²¨�<¬/«z z¥z­c¢< z­p¥z�k«<º�»�®c���<«z«z�<�c¢<�*¦s¯� z®c��¤I©X¥z«J¡£ª¦¨��´y¤c¥z¦¨¶�³£�<ª°¡£«±¬p�kª¦¨�c«z z¥Z©s z�<¬/�<ª¤�¡£¥J¡�µ¢X©v³�³£´�¶�´#©s��©v³£´�·Z¡£�p§#�<¥z¥z¦¨¥S³w©X�p¬c«z¢X©X¤I�<«+¦X¯�¤c¥z¦¨§�¥Z©sª«��<²�¦s³£²¨�k¬�¯T¦¨¥8�c�<­c¥Z©v³6�c�< J½8¦�¥zÈ«z´��� z®c�<«J¡£«<º�ÉG�±¢<¦¨�c«J¡£¬c�<¥+§��<�p�k J¡£¢¤p¥z¦�§¨¥Z©Xªª�¡£�c§/©s«*©2«z Z©X J¡£«z J¡£¢X©v³C¡£�e¯T�k¥z�<�p¢k�2¤c¥z¦¨¶�³£�<ªÊ©s�c¬�©X¤p¤�³£´� z®c��Ë8©<´¨�<«J¡w©X��ª¦�¬c�`³�µQ¢<¦¨ªÇ¤I©X¥J¡£«z¦¨�̯ͥZ©sª�<½C¦¨¥zÈy z¦¡£�� z¥z¦�¬p­c¢<��©�¢`³w©s«z«¦X¯8¸� z�p�<«z«*¯T­p�c¢< J¡£¦��p«½8¡£ z®��k¥z¥z¦¨¥Ç©s�c¬�¢<¦¨ªÇ¤e³£�<¹¨¡£ Q´M z�<¥zª«<ºyα��©X¬I©X¤p J¡£²���³£�X©s¥z��¡£�p§ ª�< z®c¦�¬G¡£« z®p�k��¤c¥z�<«z�<�� z�<¬# z®I©X +©X­p z¦�ª�©s J¡£¢v©v³�³£´/¶I©<³w©s�c¢<�<«� z®c�+ª¦�¬c�`³�µQ¢<¦¨ªÇ¤e³£�<¹¨¡w J´�¯Ï©s¢< z¦�¥� z¦Ç�<²¨¦X³£²¨��¤�©s¥z«J¡£ª¦��e¡£¦�­p«*¤p¥z¦�§¨¥Z©Xª«½8¡£ z®p¦�­p �³£¦�«J¡£�p§M z®c��¬�¡£²¨�<¥z«J¡£ Q´¾¦X¯+ z®c��¤�¦¨¤c­e³w©X J¡£¦¨�¿�p�<�k¬p�<¬M¯T¦¨¥Ç©s¢Z®�¡£�<²¨¡£�p§n z®p�#¬p�k«J¡£¥z�<¬¾ z¥Z©<¡£�e¡£�c§n©s¢<¢<­c¥Z©s¢k´¨ºM»�®p��`ÐD�<¢k J¡£²¨�<�c�<«z«�¦s¯6 z®�¡£«�©s¤c¤p¥z¦Ñ©s¢Z®2¡£«8�kª¤e¡£¥J¡£¢v©v³�³w´�«z®c¦s½���¦¨�� z®c�8¡£�p¬c­p¢k J¡£¦¨�y¦s¯g«J¡£§¨ª�©<µQ¤e¡6�c�<­p¥Z©<³6�p�< Q½8¦¨¥zÈ�«�¯T¦¨¥�«z¦s³£²¨¡£�c§©�¥z�X©<³�µJ½C¦¨¥J³£¬yª�<¬�¡£¢X©<³�¬e¡w©X§¨�c¦¨«J¡£«�¤c¥z¦¨¶�³£�<ª�©s«�½8�Z³�³�©s«�¶I�k�p¢Z®pªÂ©s¥zÈ� Z©X«zÈ�«<º

Ò�Ó�ÔDÕ�ÖI×XØ�Ù¨ÚuÛy©s¢Z®�¡£�p�³£�X©X¥z�e¡£�c§pÄ�»�¥z�k�h¡£�c¬p­c¢< J¡£¦��?ÄC�+�<�c�< J¡£¢¤c¥z¦¨§�¥Z©sªª�¡£�c§pÄ�Û2¡£�e¡£ª*­pª�¬c�<«z¢<¥J¡£¤c J¡£¦¨��³£�<�c§¨ z®/¤p¥J¡£��µ¢`¡£¤�³£�¨Ä6Ë8©<´¨�<«J¡w©X�GªÇ¦�¬p�`³g¢<¦¨ªÇ¤I©X¥J¡£«z¦¨�DÄ6Ü�²�¦s³£²¨¡£�c§y�p�<­c¥Z©v³g�p�k J½8¦�¥zÈ�«<º

ÝZÞIß�à<á�áIâZà<ã4ä�åÂæ�çvèvé ê¨ëbìÍè`ícî<ïzð�ñgè`ò�ó¨ê¨ëTî<ëbìÍè`í�ô�õDß<öT÷DøeôÑùSß�÷6ú¨ô�ú<ûXû�ü

.

Page 2: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

� � �#)��� G�¾� ��)+� "�

{M[pj`lD_b\DVdwV¨[�WZ\?_w\?�/l6[ei��6VXVs\ ["Y [��<apW±W`VXiZV¨[�Wkj`l [�W`V�[yi`_w\4j<V#^`lDV��D_bW`^ZlMaeo�[eWZ^`_���j<_T[�d�_b\I^ZVsdwdb_b�cVs\6j<V�[�i[y�I_biz�j<_bqDdb_b\DVGx tI^`VX_b\I�Dr6j`l�� .���D. tD[eYyrDVXdz� .��� � ]�_bdbiZi`ac\�� .��� � �� _b\DiZ^`ac\�� .�� �c�p}X�� �V�[�W`\D_b\D�M_bi�\Dap^Çap\Ddb�n[�\_b\6[edw_bVX\4[��DdbV�j<acYGq6ap\DVX\I^*aeo±lIrDY [e\M_b\I^ZVXdbdb_b�cVX\6jvVc�4�DrD^_b^Â[edbiZa/q?dÍ[¨�Ii[�\¾_wYGq6apWZ^<[�\I^�WZapdwV�_b\nj<ap\DiZ^`WZr6j<^`_b\D�lD_b�plI� q4VXW�oQacW`Y [�\4j<VÇ[eqDqDdb_TjX[�^`_wap\/i`��i`^ZVXYGi�xzm�[�WZ�4ac\?VXdbd � .����� }s��f�V�j<Vs\�^`db�����*ap��[y_b\I^ZW`aD�Ir6j<V��Ì[�\DV�� dbV�[�W`\I�_b\D��q6[�W<[c�I_b�cY¾��jX[�dbdbV��2�cVX\DVs^Z_Tj+qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_b\D�*x���ac��[?� .������ [c}s����l?_Íj`lyV��D^`VX\6�Ii�j<ac\I�pVX\I^Z_bac\6[edIVX�capdwr?^Z_bac\6[eWZ�[edw�pacW`_w^`lDY/ixz~��[pj`� [e\6�nt?jZl��+V<oQVXdz� .��� � UacdT�I�4VXWZ�4� .������ {��r?lDdbVX\I�6VX_b\�� .��� �p}*_b\¾^Zl6[e^^ZlDVGiZ^ZW`r6j<^`rDWZVXirD\4�IVXWZ�pac_b\D�¿[p�D[�qD^<[�^`_wap\ [�WZVÌlD_bVXWk[eWkj`lD_TjX[�dj<acYGqDrD^`VXW/qDW`ac�pWk[�YGi#_b\Di`^ZV�[p�Aa�o��D_b^`iZ^ZW`_b\D�ci¨�,UVX\DVs^Z_Tj�qDW`a���pWk[�YGYy_b\D�l6[�i��6VXVs\ni`r6jXj<VXi`izoQr?dwdb�M[�q?qDdb_wV¨�/^`aydbV�[�W`\nj<acYGqDrD^`VXW�qDWZap�cW<[�Y/i�oQapW*iZapdb��_b\D��Y [e\I�y_w\I^`VXWZVXi`^Z_b\D�qDW`ac�DdbVXYGi�_b\M[�WZ^`_��gj<_T[�d�_b\I^ZVXdbdb_b�cVX\4j<VÇ[e\6��[�WZ^`_��gj<_T[�d�db_ oQV�x���ac��[?� .����� [ �*ap��[D� .���� � ��_b\D\DV�[eW�� .���� ��[c}s���i ��_b^ZlMap^ZlDVsW�VX�capdbrD^Z_bac\4[�WZ�M[edw�pacW`_w^`lDY/i¨�D�pVX\DVX^`_Íj2qDW`ac�cW<[�YGY/_b\D��iZ^k[eWZ^`i ��_b^Zln[Gq4acqDrDdT[e^Z_bac\Maeo±Wk[e\I�

�IapY/db���cVX\DVsWk[�^`V���_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[edwi¨� � [cj`lM_b\6��_w�I_T�Ir6[ed6_bi*[�qDW`ac�pWk[�Y ^Zl4[�^��!��lDVX\MV"��V¨j<rD^ZV¨����_bi�^ZlDV�jX[�\6��_Í�?[�^ZVi`acdbrD^Z_bap\n^`an^`lDV/qDW`ac�DdbVXY¾�ntIVsdwV¨j<^Z_bac\A[�\6� j<WZapiZi`a��cVXWyapq6VXW<[�^`acWZiy[�W`V/rDi`V�� ^Za¾qDWZaD�Ir4j<V�_w\4j<WZV�[eiZ_b\D�pdw�#�6^q4acqDr?dÍ[e^Z_bac\?i�a�o�j<acYGqDrD^ZVsW#qDW`ac�pWk[�YGi�� � lD_bdwVGY/apiZ^�VX�pacdbrD^`_wap\6[�W`� [edb�cacW`_b^ZlDYGiÂ[eWZV��6[eiZV�� ac\ j`lDW`acY/ae�i`acY/Vsi�a�o$���DV���dbVX\D�p^Zl��?�cVX\?VX^Z_Tj2qDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D��r?iZVXilD_bVXW<[�Wkj`lD_TjX[ed�i`^ZWZr4j<^ZrDW`VXi��S_z� Vc�+^ZWZVsVXi�a�o��c[eWZ_T[��DdbV�iZ_b�XV[e\6� iZl6[eq6Vc�&%z\A^Zl?VMY/apiZ^y�cVs\DVXWk[edÇjX[eiZVc�h^ZlDVMq?WZac�pWk[eY/iyjX[�\ �4V' (%Zt�)�tp�zV��DqDWZVsiZiZ_bap\Di/W`VXqDWZVsiZVX\I^Z_b\D� [�I[�Y/Vv� qDdT[¨�I_b\D�iZ^`Wk[�^`VX�c�I��[yi`VX^a�o�qDWZaD�Ir4j<^Z_bac\ÌWZrDdbVXi¨�g[G�IV�j<_bi`_wap\M^ZW`VXVc��apWÇ[�\DVsrDWk[edC\?VX^��±apWZ���+*�lDV�iZ^`WZr6jk�^`rDWZV�� WZVXqDW`VXiZVs\�^<[�^`_wap\ ikj`lDVXYGV_wi�q6[�W`^Z_Tj<rDdT[eWZdb���+VXdbd�i`rD_b^ZV���^`a/qDW`ac�DdbVXYGi�_b\,��l?_Íj`lM^`lDV�W`VX�crDdT[eWZ_b^z�/aeo±^ZlDVrD\4�IVXWZdb�I_b\D��qDWZaDj<VXi`iYyrDiZ^+�6V��I_bi<j<a��cVXW`V��GoQW`acY�ap�DiZVsWZ�cV¨�M�D[�^<[D�-�\DVqDW`ac�DdbVXY.��_b^ZlG^ZlDV0/6V��D_b�DdbV*i`_w�sV*WZVsqDWZVXi`VX\I^k[e^Z_bac\M_b\y�pVX\DVX^`_ÍjhqDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_b\D�*_bi�^`l6[�^+^ZlDV�iZq6[pj<V�[�\6�

^`_wYGV�WZV�1prD_bW`VXY/VX\I^`i*a�o8^ZlDV2iZ^ZW`r6j<^`rDWZVXiY�[¨�#�4V�j<apY/V^ZaIay�cW`V�[�^¨�2 S[�WZ�pVXW�qDW`ac�cW<[�YGi±^<[��cVYGacWZV�V��DV�j<rD^`_bac\^`_wYGV�^Zl4[�\�iZY [edbdwVsW�ac\?VXi ��lDVs\/[�dbdI^ZlDV�VXdbVXY/VX\I^<[�WZ�2acq4VXWk[e^Z_bac\Di8^<[��cV�^`lDV�ik[eY/V+^Z_bY/Vp��^`lDV*^`ac^<[�dIV��DV�j<rD^`_bac\^`_wYGV�_bi�qDW`acq4acWZ^`_bac\6[ed�^ZaM^`lDV/i`_b�XV/aeou^`lDV/qDW`ac�pWk[�Y¾�3%z\ iZapY/Vy[�qDq?dw_TjX[e^Z_bac\?iÇi`r6j`l [ei�iZ�I\I^ZlDVsiZ_bi#aeoudbap�c_Tjj<_bW<j<rD_b^Zi�apW\DVXrDW<[�d+\DVX^��+acWZ�Ii¨��ap\DVyY [¨�4��_wi`l ^Za�_bY/qDdbVXYGVX\I^�^ZlDV5�4\6[�d8iZapdbrD^Z_bac\?iÇ_b\¾l6[�W<����[�WZVp��%z\¾^ZlD_bijX[eiZVc�pdT[�W`�cVXW8iZapdbrD^Z_bac\?iÅ[edbiZa*W`VXiZr?dw^�_w\�lD_b�cl?VXW8_wYGqDdbVXY/Vs\�^<[�^`_wap\Çj<apiZ^`i��$%z\y[c�D�I_b^`_wap\���[�i8^Zl?VX_bW�iZ_b�XV�_b\6j<W`V�[�i`VXi��^`lDV�qDWZap�cW<[�Y/iÅoQWZV�1prDVs\�^`db�#�4V�j<apY/V�lDapq6VXdbVXi`iZdb�yacq4[�1prDV�^Za�lIrDY [e\�rD\6��VXWZi`^k[�\4�I_b\D�/x���_w\?\DV�[�W¨� .��� �c}s�6-�\DV[eqDqDWZaI[cj`l�^Za/�IV¨[�db_b\D�3��_b^Zl�^ZlD_bi�qDWZap�DdbVXY _bi�^`a �IV��4\DV#[�\4�/W`VXrDi`V#i`rD�DY/aD�Ir?dwVsi��7��ac��[�i`rD�c�pVXiZ^`iÂ��V��6\D_b\D�q4ac^`VX\I^Z_T[�dbdb�#r?iZV<oQr?dCi`rD�DW`acrD^`_w\?VXiÇjX[edbdwV¨�98;:<>=;?@8A<CBED�8;FGF�H3I�JLKNMOJ�IQP�:�MOD"<�BE=RM�S�xQ�|UTWV ik}���rDWZ_b\D�/[�W`rD\¾xC��ac��[?�

.������ �6}X�yUVs\DVX^Z_Tj"qDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D�3��_b^Zl [�r?^ZacY�[�^`_ÍjÇoQrD\6j<^`_bac\ �IV��6\D_b^`_wap\ iZ_b�c\?_���jX[�\I^Zdb��WZV¨�Ir6j<VXiy^`lDV/[¨�cVsWz�

Page 3: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

[e�cVyiZ^`WZr6jv^ZrDW<[�dÇjvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z��a�o*^`lDV�iZapdwr?^Z_bac\Di�[�\6�¾^`lDVMj<acYGqDrD^k[e^Z_bac\4[�d8V���acWZ^y[�iyj<apY/q6[eWZV��¾^`aM�cVX\?VX^Z_TjqDW`ac�pWk[�YGY/_ \D�Q��_w^`lDacr?^u[erD^ZapY [�^`_Tj�oQrD\6j<^`_bac\M�IV��6\?_w^`_bac\Mx���ac��[?� .��� �p}X�� aR�±Vs�cVXW¨�±Vs�cVX\ ��_b^`l W`VXrDi<[��DdbVMi`rD�DY/aD�Ir?dwVsi#^`lDVMqDW`ac�cW<[�Y i`_b�XVMY [¨�¾iZ^`_bdwd��cW`aR� ��_b^ZlDaprD^y�6aprD\6� _ o

^`lDV^ZWk[e_b\D_b\D�/�D[�^<[�_bi�\Dac_biZ�GacW�_b\6j<apY/qDdbVX^`Vc� � Y/qD_bWZ_TjX[ed6i`^Zr6��_wVsi*WZVsq6apWZ^^Zl6[e^��!��lDVX\M^`lDVX_bW�^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�/[cjsj<rI�W<[cj<�G_wi�j<apY/q6[eWk[��?dwVp�ci`Y [�dbdbVXW+iZapdwr?^Z_bac\Di+rDi`r6[�dbdb�/�IVXYGac\Di`^ZWk[e^ZV�4VX^Z^`VXW*�pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\/q4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvVÇ^`l6[�\dT[�W`�cVXW2iZacdbrD^`_bac\Di¨� *�[cj`�cVs^Z^��SoJacW�_w\?iZ^k[e\6j<Vc��ac�Di`VXWZ�pVXiy_b\ lD_bi#q4[�^Z^`VXWZ\Aj<dT[�i`iZ_��gjX[e^Z_bac\ V��Dq6VXW`_bY/VX\I^Zi�^Zl4[�^#[lD_b�pl¿�IVX�cW`VXV�a�o�j<acW`WZVXdT[�^`_bac\¿V"��_bi`^Ziy�4VX^��±VsVX\A^ZWZVsVMiZ_b�XVM[�\4� q4VXWzoQapWZY�[�\6j<Vp���k[eY/ac\?� ^`lDV/i`VX^ya�o���qDWZVX^`^z��pa�aD��V4i`acdbrD^Z_bap\Di���^`lDVyiZY�[�dbdbVXiZ^+��_b^ZlD_b\¾^ZlDVyi`VX^�rDi`r6[�dbdb�n[cj`lD_bVX�pV��¾^Zl?VylD_b�clDVXi`^q6VXW�oQacW`Y [e\6j<V��¾xE*�[pjZ�pVX^Z^¨�

.���� �p}X� � V�[�dbiZaMap�DiZVsWZ�cV¨�¿^`l6[�^¨��[�i�^`lDV/i`_b�XV [e\6�¿j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��a�o*^`WZVXVXiy�pWZV�����[ q6ap_w\I^ ��[�i�VX�pVX\I^Zr6[edwdb�W`V�[cj`lDV��"_b\yY/aci`^8WZrD\DiW��lDVXW`V*q4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvVÇ�IW`acqDq4V���� � V*iZr?�c�cVsiZ^Zi+^Zl4[�^8oQapW±[�\yapq6Vs\I� Vs\6�IV��GV��DqDdbacW<[�^`_wap\aeo�qDWZap�DdbVXY�iZq4[cj<Vc�?q6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\I��Y [¨���4V�[�\G_wYGq6apWZ^<[�\I^So [cj<^`acW+\Dac^�oQapWu[eVXiZ^`lDVX^Z_Tj�WZV¨[�iZap\Di*apW±V¨[�iZVaeoC[�\6[ed£��IiZ_bi¨�6�?rD^�6V�js[�rDi`Vy^ZlDVXW`VyiZVXVsY/i*^`a/�4V�[G�4acrD\4��ac\M^`lDVy[�qDqDW`acqDW`_T[�^ZV�iZ_b�XV�a�o+iZacdbrD^`_bac\�^ZW`VXVXioQapW�[y�c_b�pVX\qDW`ac�DdbVXY¾�6��_b\D\DV�[eW�WZVXq4acW`^Zi*^`l6[�^*[ei�lD_bi±q?WZac�pWk[eY/i+�cWZV ���I_w^��4V�jX[eY/V�dwVsiZiÇ[e\6�ydbVXi`i�db_w�pVXdb��oQacW+^Zl?VXY ^`ay�6V�pVX\DVXW<[�d+xC��_b\D\DV�[eW�� .��� �p}X� � V@1prDVsiZ^Z_bap\Di���lDVs^ZlDVXW^`lDVXWZVy[�W`V�ac^`lDVXWqDW`ac�DdbVXYGi+oQacW7��lD_Tj`lM�pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\_bi+_w\I�pVXWZi`VXdb�/qDW`acq4acWZ^`_bac\6[ed�^Zay^Zl?VÇq?WZac�pWk[eY i`_w�sVc�%z\�^Zl?_wi8q6[eq6VsWN�±V+iZl?aR�¿^Zl4[�^�^`lDV±q?WZac�?dwVsY,a�o4q6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\��_bi8rD�D_G1prD_b^ZaprDi�_b\��cVX\DVs^Z_Tj+qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_£\D��oQW`acY

["^ZlDVXapWZVX^`_TjX[�d8q4ac_b\I^*a�o+��_bV����+%z\ntIV¨j<^Z_bac\ � ���+V�rDi`V#^`lDV#W`VXiZr?dw^`ioQW`acY ^ZlDV�iZ^<[�^Z_bi`^Z_Tj<idb_w^`VXWk[e^ZrDW`V#^`a/i`lDV��db_b�clI^�ac\�^Zl?V+oQrD\6�D[eY/VX\I^<[�dcW`VXdT[�^`_wap\DiZl?_wq2�6VX^��+VXVX\/[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�/[e\6�q6[eWZi`_wYGac\I�*_b\��cVX\?VX^Z_Tj+qDW`ac�cW<[�YGY/_£\?�6��%z\tIV¨j<^Z_bac\y�D�¨^`lDV±VsiZiZVs\6j<Va�o6^`lDV+qDWZap�DdbVXY _biÅ��VXY/ap\DiZ^`Wk[�^`V��2VXY/qD_bW`_Íjs[�dbdb�7��lDVX\5�±V�[�\6[edb���sV±VXW`WZapWCdT[e\6�Iikjs[�q4VXiaeoÇqDW`ac�cW<[�YGi#VX�pacdb�cV¨�¾oQapWy\DVXrDW<[�d*\?VX^��±apWZ� iZ�I\I^ZlDVXi`_bi��&%z\ tIV�j<^`_wap\A�6��[n~+[¨�cVsiZ_T[�\AY/aD�IVsd£�Zj<apY/q6[eWZ_biZap\YGVX^ZlDaD� _wiGrDiZV¨� ^`a¿�IVX�cVsdwapq�[ÌoQW<[�Y/V �±apWZ�¿_b\ ��lD_Tj`l�[ j<dT[�i`i/aeoU�4^Z\DVXi`i�Y/V�[eiZrDW`VXi/_bi/_b\I^ZW`aD�Ir6j<V�� oQacW�IV¨[�db_b\D�'��_b^`l¿qDW`ac�DdbVXYGiya�oÇq4[�WZi`_bY/ac\I�I� � V�^ZlDVs\��IVXi<j<WZ_b�4Vn[�\ [c�?[�qD^`_w�pV�^ZV�j`lD\D_G1prDV�oJacW�qDrD^Z^`_b\D� ^ZlD_bi�6^`\DVXi`i*oJrD\6j<^`_wap\�_w\I^`ayqDWk[pj<^Z_Tj<Vc�0%z^Ç[�r?^ZacY�[�^`_Íjs[�dbdb���6[�dT[e\6j<VXi�^ZlDV�W<[�^`_wayaeo�^ZWk[e_b\D_b\D�/[cjXjvrDWk[pj<�M^Zayi`acdbrD^`_wap\j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�Q��_b^ZlDaprD^�dbaci`_w\?�Ç^`lDV*q4acq?rDdT[�^Z_bap\��I_b�pVXWZi`_w^z��\DVXV¨�IV��G^Za#[pj`lD_bVX�cV[iZq4V�j<_��6V��G^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D��[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�I�*�lDV�V���V�j<^`_b�cVX\DVsiZiMaeoÂ^`lDVMYGVX^ZlDaD� _biyiZlDaR��\ _w\ tIV¨j<^Z_bac\ � �7��lDVXW`VMiZ_bYyrDdT[�^`_bac\ WZVsiZrDdb^Zi�[�W`VMqDWZVsiZVX\I^ZV¨��IVsY/ac\?iZ^ZW<[�^`_w\?��^ZlDV�_b\6�Ir6j<^`_bac\/aeoC\DVsrDWk[ed�\DVX^��+acWZ�Ii�rDi`_b\D�#\?ac_biZ��^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�y�D[�^<[D� %z\ tIV�jv^Z_bac\M� �±V�I_bikj<rDi`i^`lDV*W`VXdT[�^Z_bap\DiZlD_bqyaeo�^ZlD_biN�+acW`�3��_w^`lyac^`lDVXW+^ZWZVsV<� �4[�iZV¨�/Y�[cj`lD_b\DV�dbV�[eWZ\D_b\D��YGVX^Zl?a���i��8tIV�j<^`_wap\ � jvac\6j<dbr6��VXi�I�yiZr?Y/Y [eWZ_b�X_b\D�^Zl?VÇW`VXiZr?dw^`i�[�\6�"_wYGqDdb_TjX[�^`_wap\Di8a�o�^Zl?_wi7�+acW`���

Page 4: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

� %('2� '�)+��(�,�� ��#�����-�-�� � ��� �$)�� ' � ��2����� ���+���� �*' �,�� �� ��'��

{M[e\I�¿iZVsVXY/_b\D�pdw�¿��_ ��VXW`VX\I^ q?WZac�?dwVsY/iy_b\ [�WZ^`_��gj<_T[�d�_w\I^`VXdbdw_b�pVX\6j<VM[�\4� [�W`^Z_��gj<_T[�d�db_£oJV js[�\ �4VM�I_bV��±V¨� [�i^`lDVqDWZap�DdbVXY aeo±�I_bikj<a��pVXWZ_b\D�/[yj<apY/qDr?^ZVXW�qDW`ac�pWk[�Y ^Zl4[�^�qDW`a���r6j<VXiiZapY/V��IVXi`_bWZV���aprD^Zq?rD^+oQacW�q4[�WZ^`_Tj<rDdT[�W_b\DqDr?^Zi��$T?acW�_b\Di`^k[e\6j<Vc�p_b\��I_wi`r6[�d?q6[�^`^ZVXW`\I� W`V�j<ap�c\D_b^Z_bap\�[eqDqDdb_TjX[�^`_wap\Di�^`lDV+_w\?qDrD^8a�og[�qDW`ac�pWk[�YA_bi�[��pV�j<^ZapW

� a�o4oQV�[�^`rDWZVsi�oQW`acY,[i`VX�cYGVX\I^ZV��2_bY [e�cV±[e\6��V¨[cj`l/j<acYGq6ap\DVX\I^ ����a�o�^ZlDV�aprD^ZqDr?^��cV�jv^ZacW 1 Y�[¨�WZVXqDW`VXiZVs\�^^`lDVqDWZap�6[��D_bdb_b^z�#^`l6[�^�^`lDV�_bY [e�cV��4VXdbac\D�pi�^ZayjX[�^`VX�capWZ�����*�l?V�qDWZaDj<VsiZi�aeoÅi`acdb�I_b\D�y^ZlDVsiZV�qDWZap�DdbVXY/i*jX[e\M�4V�oQapWZYyrDdT[e^ZV��y[eiÇ[yi`V�[�W<j`lMoQapW*[ylD_b�plDdb�5�6^Çj<apY/qDr?^ZVXW

qDW`ac�pWk[�Y¾����������<�I_b\ ^`lDVQ��lDacdbViZq4[cj<V�aeoCq4aci`iZ_b�DdbV�j<acYGqDrD^ZVsW�qDWZap�cWk[eY/i�� �

������! �"��#�"%$&$'$)(*$ x . }

*�lDV�VX�pacdbrD^Z_bap\6[�W`�n[�qDq?WZa�[pj`l �I_ ��VXWZiÂoQWZapY Y/apiZ^�ac^Zl?VXW�iZV¨[�Wkj`l ^`V�j`lD\D_G1prDVXi�_w\¾^Zl4[�^_b^ÇY�[��pVXiÇ[Gq6[eWk[�dbdbVXdi`V�[�W<jZl�i`_wYyr?dw^<[�\DVsacrDi`dw�_b\I�capdw�I_b\D�lIrD\6�IW`V��Ii�apW±^`lDacrDi<[�\6��i�a�o�q4ac_b\I^Zi+_w\y^`lDViZV�[eWkj`l�iZq6[pj<Vc�+UVX\DVX^`_Tj�qDW`a���pWk[�YGYy_b\D�±i`^k[eWZ^Zi ��_w^`l�[e\�_b\D_b^Z_T[�dpq6apqDrDdT[�^`_bac\+� a�o�Wk[e\6�IacYGdb�*�cVs\DVXWk[e^ZV��yjvacY/q?rD^ZVXW8qDW`ac�pWk[�YGiCj<apY/q4aci`V��aeo6VXdbVXY/Vs\�^<[�W`�*oJrD\6j<^`_wap\Di�[�\6�2^ZVsWZY/_b\6[edbi�jZl?aciZVs\y���^`lDV*�IacY�[�_b\*V"��q4VXW`^��N*�l?V±VXdbVXYGVX\I^k[eWZ��oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\Di8Y�[¨��4V#[�W`_b^ZlDYGVX^Z_Tj�acq4VXWk[e^Z_bac\?i��Ddbap�c_TjX[�d�oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\Di¨�Di`^k[�\4�D[�W<��qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_b\D�acq4VXWk[e^Z_bac\Di¨�4acWÇ��acY [e_b\I� i`q6V¨j<_��gjoQr?\6j<^Z_bap\Di��%z\¾^Zl?V#i`��\I^`lDVXiZ_bia�o+iZ_b�cY�[¨�zqD_�\DVXrDW<[�d�\?VX^��±apWZ�Ii�x-,4l6[e\D� [e\6�¾{ �rDlDdbVX\I�4VX_b\�� .��� �I}X�IoJacW*_b\Di`^k[e\6j<Vc�S^ZlDV

^`VXWZYG_w\4[�d4iZVX^/.�j<ap\DiZ_biZ^`i*aeo10Ì_w\?qDrD^��c[�W`_T[��DdbVXi¨�

.2���43 "53 # "%6%6�6�"73�89( x � }

[e\6�y^`lDV�VXdbVXYGVX\I^k[�W`��oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\�iZVs^+: jvac\I^k[e_w\?i�iZ_b�cY�[�x-;8}*[e\6�yq?_�x-<2}�rD\?_w^`i��

:=���;>"7<?(@$ xz�c}

��\n_b\Di`^k[�\4j<Vya�o�^ZlDVyq?WZac�pWk[eY�j<ap\DiZ_biZ^`_b\D��a�o�^ZlDV/[e�6a��pV#VXdbVXYGVX\I^k[eWZ��oQr?\6j<^Z_bap\Di���_z� Vc�y[GiZ_b�cY�[¨�zqD_�\?VXrDWk[ed\DVs^��±apWZ����_bi�iZlDaR��\ _w\ TS_w�prDWZV . � *�l?_wiyq?WZac�pWk[eY jvac\Di`_wi`^ZiGa�o*^Zl?WZVXVA; rD\D_b^Ziy[�\4�¿^��+aA< rD\D_b^Ziy_b\¿[�\VXYy�4V��D��V��Gdw_bi`^±i`^ZWZr4j<^ZrDW`Vc�

� x�;B *x�;C#D39#E3GF�}ux-;9FD3�Hx-<BHD3C I3�FD39JX}Z} 3K �x-<>LE39#E3GHD39LX}`}M" xJ��}

��lDVsWZV�;9N�[�\6�O<�N�[eWZV�WZV�[edb_w�¨[�^Z_bap\Di�a�o�[Mi`_b�cY [�[e\6� qD_�r?\D_b^�[e^?PÏ^Zl \DaD�IVc�+WZVXi`q6V¨j<^Z_b�cVsdw�I�¿]hac^Z_Tj<V�^`l6[�^[edw^`lDacr?�cl/^`lDV\IrDYy�6VsW±aeoÅq?WZ_bY/_b^Z_b�pV�oQr?\6j<^Z_bap\Di*[�\6�G^`VXWZYG_w\4[�dbi±_biW�6\?_w^`Vc�D[�\I��[�WZ�?_w^`Wk[eWZ_bdb�ydÍ[eWZ�pV*qDW`ac�cW<[�YGijX[e\��6V�cVs\DVXWk[e^ZV�� ���GWZV�jvrDWZi`_w�pV�rDi`V�a�o8^ZlDVXY¾�

Page 5: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

x2

S3

w11

w12

w14

w13

w21 w31 w32

x6

w41 w43w42

x2

w51w52

w53

x3

w22

x5

x3x1

x4 x4

x1

P4

P5S2

S1

TS_b�crDW`V . � ��� J�J � J�� � J"S�J�M�< 8�<�BE=;M'=�P38 S"B��A?38����B2MOJ : � 8;F6MOJ"<�W= � � NB <��4S"B��@BGM��O:<ES38RMOI =;MOJ3=R:<��O:<���� 8D �:�M�B <�� 8AS 83F =�D�8RF � J D�J���<�B�RJ$K2J F I��� [cj`l/rD\?_w^¨�@; N apW < N �Il6[ei±_b^`i�aR��\/W`V�j<VXqD^`_b�cV+�6VXdT���2x�PQ}s�c^`lDViZVX^+a�o�_b\6j<apY/_b\D��j<ap\D\DV�j<^`_bac\Di+oQW`acY ac^`lDVXW

rD\?_w^`iyacW�oQW`acY V"��^`VXWZ\4[�d_b\DqDrD^`i�� # � [pjZlA_b\DqDr?^/j<ac\D\?V�j<^Z_bap\ _bi/[�iZi`aDj<_T[�^ZV¨� ��_b^Zl [ �±Vs_w�plI^#�c[edwr?Vc����N �I��IVs\Dac^`_w\?�/^Zl?V#i`^ZWZVs\D�c^`lnaeo±^ZlDVyj<ap\D\DV�j<^`_bac\ÌoQWZapY �/^`a P`��]�VXrDW`ac\¾^z�Iq6VXi��I_ ��VXW_b\ ^`lDVX_bW�j<acYGqDrD^<[�^Z_bap\ aeo[pj<^Z_b�c[�^`_bac\y�c[�dbrDVsi���tI_b�cY�[�rD\D_b^Zi¨� ;9N<�6j<apY/qDrD^`V*^`lDVQ�±VX_b�pl�^`V��GiZrDY a�o�^`lD_bi±_b\DqDr?^Zi

� N � ; N x � } �!"# "$&% . _ o(' ��)�*,+&N- ��N.��� �0/ �1 . ap^ZlDVsW ��_biZVc�

xz�c}

��lD_bdbV*q?_�rD\D_b^Zi¨� <BNZ�6jvacY/q?rD^ZV�^ZlDV�q?WZaD�Ir6j<^�aeo�^ZlDVX_bW7�+VX_b�clI^ZV¨�/_b\Dq?rD^Zi

�%N>�=<BNZx � } �!"# "$2% . _£o43 ��)�*,+&N- ��N ��� �5/ �1 . ac^Zl?VXW ��_biZVp�

x � }

*�l?V'1pr6[�db_b^z�naeo�V�[cj`l�j<apY/qDr?^ZVXW�qDWZap�cW<[�Y _w\A^`lDV�q6apqDrDdT[�^`_wap\¿_biyY/V¨[�iZr?WZV�� _b\A^ZVXW`Y/iya�olDaR� �±VXdbd_b^�q4VXWzoJacWZYGi�_b\ ^ZlDVGq6[�W`^Z_Tj<rDdT[eW�qDWZap�DdbVXY(VX\I�I_wW`ac\DYGVX\I^�� *�lD_bi�Y/V�[eiZrDW`Vy_bi#jX[�dbdbV�� ^ZlDV �6^Z\DVsiZiyY/V¨[�iZr?WZVc�*+�IqD_TjX[�dbdb���sV�[cj`l�j<acYGqDrD^ZVsWCq?WZac�pWk[eY,_b\#^`lDV*q4acq?rDdT[�^Z_bap\�_bi�WZrD\ya��pVXW±[�\IrDYy�4VXW8a�oC�I_ ��VXWZVX\I^�_b\Dq?rD^z�zacrD^`qDrD^jX[eiZVXi�i`a#^`l6[�^+_b^Zi$�4^Z\DVXi`i*_bi�YGV�[�i`rDWZV��G[�i�[�i`rDY�apW±[�\�[¨�cVXW<[��cV�a��cVXW+^Zl?VX_bW±VXW`WZapWZi�� *�lDV*i`VX^�a�o�i`r6j`lMjX[�i`VXi_bi�jX[�dbdbV��G^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D��iZVX^¨�76��

6 ���cx �,8 " 1 8 }5(:98�; xz�c}

��lDVsWZV � 8=< . [e\6� 1 8=<?> �7*�lDV��IacY�[�_b\ . [e\6��^`lDV�Wk[e\D�cV > [eWZV#�IV"�6\DV��Ì�I� ^`lDVy[�qDqDdb_TjX[e^Z_bac\��W*�lDV@ Þ�AcâCB�ä£àED4ß<ãGFA�ãzâHDIAcß<öKJML`à<å�B�âNFÏã â`àEFJâHJ�àED�à�O4âzäKP A�F7L`ß<å�åcâHLQFQâQJNFQß+àMDÏá�âHL�ä£à<ö�R�å�äKFSO�AcßEDJâ8àELHFÏäKT<àEFÏä£ß<åUT<à<ö.Rcâ4äKD�à<öKO4à V:D�ú¨÷Þ�A�RWDZôsä�åXFIAcâCYwß<ö�ö£ß O4ä�åWPMJ¨äKDZL�RWDZDTä£ßvå[O4âMLZßvåWDTäKJ�â�ã7FAcâCB�ä£àED�à\D^]RWDZF�à<åcßEFIAcâzãDä�å�á�RWF�FQß�FIAcâGR�å�äKF`÷

Page 6: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�2iZVX^�_wi*[eiZi`rDY/V��G^`a#�4V��cVs\DVXWk[e^ZV�� oQWZapY [�\�rD\D�I\DaR��\GWZVXdT[e^Z_bac\Di`lD_bq ���ik[e^Z_bizoQ�I_b\D�1 8 � ��Sx � 8 } $ x � }

%Jo ��G_bi8iZ^`a�j`l6[eiZ^`_Íje�c_b^8_bi�oJrDWZ^`lDVXW±[eiZiZr?Y/V��2^Zl6[e^�^Zl?V�WZVXdT[�^`_bac\ ��GjX[�\y�4V*�IVXi<j<WZ_b�4V��y�I�#[�qDW`ac�6[e�D_bdw_b^z���IVX\?iZ_b^z�oQr?\6j<^Z_bap\ �IV��4\DV���a��pVXW�^ZlDV2iZq6[pj<V+.�� > �

<��� x � " 1 }>� <��� x � } <��� x 1�� � }M" x � }

��lDVsWZV!<�� x � }���V��6\DVXi�^`lDVWZVX�p_bac\/aeo�_b\�^`VXWZVsiZ^�_b\/^`lDV_w\?qDrD^+iZq6[pj<Vc�6[e\6� <��� x 1� � }+�IVXi<j<WZ_b�4VXi*^`lDV*i`^k[�^`_biZ^Z_TjX[edW`VXdT[�^Z_bap\/�4VX^��±VsVX\M^Zl?V�_b\DqDrD^`i*[�\6�"^ZlDV�aprD^Zq?rD^Zi¨�UÂ_w�pVX\ ^Zl?_wi¨��^`lDV/�pa�[edCaeo*�cVX\?VX^Z_Tjyq?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_ \D�y_bioQapWZYyrDdT[�^`V��M[eiQ�6\6�I_b\D�M[�q?WZac�pWk[eY < � ^`l6[�^

j<apY/qDr?^ZVXiG^ZlDV¾�6VsiZ^M[�qDq?WZa��D_bY [�^`_bac\�� ��x � }/^`a �� �6[eiZV�� ac\ ^ZlDV¾^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D� iZVs^?6�� *�l?_wi�_bi [ ^z�IqD_TjX[�ddbV�[eWZ\D_b\D�e�QoQW`acY"� V��6[eYyqDd£VXiSqDWZap�DdbVXYn� %z\yacW<�IVXW+^Zayj`lDaIaciZV�^ZlDV��6VsiZ^*[¨�c[�_bdT[��?dwV+[�qDqDW`a��D_wY�[�^`_wap\����±V�YGV�[�i`rDWZV^`lDV/�I_bikj<W`VXq6[e\6j<�I��acW2dwapiZi¨����x 1 "�� ��x � }Z}2�4VX^��±VsVX\A^ZlDVy^<[�WZ�pVX^�WZVXi`q6ap\DiZV 1 ^Za [G�c_b�cVX\ _b\Dq?rD^ � [e\6�¾^ZlDV[pj<^Zr6[edDWZVsiZq4ac\Di`V�� ��x � }8qDWZa��I_T�IV��2�I�#^`lDV�qDW`ac�cW<[�Y¾��*�lDV�dbaci`i8oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\�Y/apiZ^�j<acYGY/ap\Dd£��rDiZV���_bi�^`lDV�iZr?YaeoCi 1pr6[eWZV�� VXWZW`acWZi¨�

��x 1 "�� � x � }`} � x 1 1 � � x � }Z} # $ x .�� }

]haR�A^Zl6[e^C^`lDV*i`_bY/_bdT[�WZ_b^z��a�o��cVX\DVs^Z_Tj+qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_b\D�*[�\6�2dbV�[�W`\D_b\D��oQWZapY,V��6[eY/qDdbVXi8l6[ei��6VsVX\/VXi`^k[e�Ddb_wi`lI�V����O�+VyjX[�\ [�\6[edb���sV�^ZlDV�qDW`a�jvVXiZi�a�o±�pVX\DVX^`_Tj�qDW`ac�pWk[�YGY/_ \D�#�I��Y/V¨[�\Di�a�o±^`lDV#^`V�j`lD\D_G1prDVXi��IVX�pVXdbacq4V��¾_b\i`^k[�^`_biZ^Z_TjX[ed�_b\IoQVXW`VX\6j<Vc� *�lDV*�pVX\DVX^`_Tj`� q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_b\D�q6[eWk[p�I_b�cY rDiZVsi*[�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D��iZVs^�a�o6�!��V¨�yiZ_b�XV^`a#VX�pacdb�cV^`lDV�qDW`ac�cW<[�YGi��I�DrD^^`lDV�VX�pVX\I^Zr6[edC�pa�[ed�_bi�^ZlDV�Y/_b\D_bYy_b��[e^Z_ba�\ya�o±^`lDV�VXW`WZapWÇa��pVXWÇ[edbd�q6apiZiZ_b�DdbVy�D[�^<[�_b\M^ZlDV�IapY [e_w\S�O%z\�ap^ZlDVXW+�±apWk�Ii¨���±V^`WZ��^Za�Y/_b\D_bY/_ �XV�^Zl?VÂ[¨�pVXWk[e�cVVXW`WZacW¨�

� x Ç}�� .� 9� 8�; ��x 1 8 "�� � x � 8 }Z}M" x .p. }

j<ap\DiZ^`WZr6jv^ZV��¾ap\ ^`lDV��6[�i`_wi�a�o�^Zl?V#^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�yi`VX^X6 a�o�iZ_b�XV � �!��lD_bdwV2^ZlDV�Vs�cVX\I^Zr4[�d8�caI[�d�aeo�dwV¨[�WZ\?_w\?�/_bi�^ZaYG_w\?_wYy_ �XV�^Zl?V�V��Dq6V¨j<^ZV��Ì�c[�dbrDV�a�o8^ZlDV�dbapiZi

�2x Ç}�������x 1 "�� �+x � }`}G<�� x � " 1 }�� � � 1 $ x .�� }

~�rD^�^`lDV �<ap_b\�^�qDWZap�6[��D_bdb_b^z���I_biZ^ZW`_b�DrD^Z_bap\ <�� x � " 1 } � <��� x 1� � } <��� x � }�_bi�r?\D�I\DaR��\��I[�\6��^`lDV*ap\Ddb�#[¨�c[�_bdT[��DdbV_b\IoQapWZY�[�^Z_bap\/_bi�j<ac\I^k[e_b\DV��¾_b\n^`lDVy^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�GiZVX^�6��3*�[��I_b\D����x 1 8 "�� � x � 8 }`}+� x 1 1 � � x � }Z} # �S^ZlDVyV �gV�jk�^`_w�pVX\DVXi`i�a�o��¿[ei#[GqDWZV¨�I_Tj<^ZapW�a�o 1 ���p_b�cVX\ 6([�\6� [Gq6[eWZ^Z_Tj<r?dÍ[eW � ��_biY/V�[eiZrDW`V��Ì���¾^Zl?VyY/V�[e\I� i�1pr6[�W`V��

Page 7: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

VXW`WZapW��

� � x 1 1 � ��x � 6y}`} # � � " 6�� $ x . �c}

��lDVsWZV � � 6 ��_wi^`lDVyV��Dq6V¨j<^k[e^Z_bac\ apq6VXW<[�^`acW�� � VXWZV4�±V�rDiZV¨�¾^ZlDVy\Dap^k[e^Z_bac\ � � x � 6y}*_b\Di`^ZV�[p�¾a�o� � x � }�^ZaV��DqDdb_Tj<_b^Zdb�n��VX\Dac^`V/^`lDV �IVsq6VX\4�IVX\6j<�Aaeo*^ZlDV"oQrD\6j<^`_bac\�� � acW2^ZlDVGqDWZap�cWk[eY �ac\ ^ZlDVG^ZWk[e_b\D_b\D�M�D[�^<[ 6��tIapY/V�Y�[�\D_bqDr?dÍ[e^Z_ba�\�a�o±^`lDV�oQapWZYyrDdT[�iZl?aR��iÇ^`l6[�^2^ZlD_bi�jX[�\¾�4V/�IV�j<apY/q4aciZV¨�¾_w\I^`a/^��+a ^`VXWZYGi�x ~�WZVX_bY [e\VX^*[edz�w� .��� � UVXY [e\yVX^*[�dz�b� .����� }s�

� � x 1 1 � ��x � 6y}Z} # � � " 6�� � � � x 1 1 � � 1�� � �Q} # � � " 6�� % x � � 1� � � 1 � �+x � 6y}Z}# $ x . ��}

� VXWZV � � x 1 1 � � 1 � � �Q} # � � " 6��±�IaIVXi�\Dap^Ç�IVsq6VX\4�¾ac\¾^ZlDVy�D[�^<[�6���\?acWac\M^`lDVyVXi`^Z_bY [e^ZacW��S� � VX\6j<VG^ZlDVi�1cr4[�WZV¨� �I_biZ^k[e\6j<Vy^`aM^ZlDVyW`VX�cW`VXiZi`_bac\ oJrD\6j<^`_wap\ � � 1�� � ���Åx � � 1� � � 1 � � x � 6y}Z} # "�YGV�[�i`rDWZVXi2_w\ [�\6[e^ZrDW<[�d��[¨�#^`lDV�V���V�j<^`_b�cVX\DVsiZia�o��M[�i*[2qDWZV¨�I_Tj<^ZapW�a�o 1 �$*�l?VÇYGV�[�\�� i�1cr4[�WZV¨�yVXW`WZacW�a�o��M[�i*[e\/VXi`^Z_bY [e^ZacW+a�o8^ZlDVW`VX�cW`VXiZi`_wap\M_bi

����� x � � 1�� � � 1 � �+x � 6y}`} #�� " x . �c}

��lDVsWZV � � W`VXqDWZVsiZVX\I^Zi2V��Dq6V�jv^k[�^`_bac\ ��_b^Zl�W`VXiZq4V�j<^^Zay^`lDV�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�yi`VX^X6��?^Zl6[e^�_bi��D^`lDV#[¨�pVXWk[e�cVa��cVXW�^ZlDVVX\?iZVXYy�DdbV�aeouq4aci`iZ_b�DdbV�6 xÏoQacW+���DV��Ìik[eY/qDdbV�i`_b�XV � }X�5*�lD_biVXW`WZacW�jX[�\ [��I[�_b\M�4V/�IV�j<apY/q4aciZV¨�M_b\I^Za�^��+a^`VXWZYGi��

��� x � � 1�� � � 1 � ��x � 6y}Z} # �� x ��� � � �+x � 6y}�� 1 � � 1� � �Q} # % ���� x � �+x � 6y} 1 �� � � �±x � 6y}��Q} #�� $ x .�� }

%z\yVsiZiZVs\6j<Vc�4^Zl?_wi�iZ^k[e^ZVXi+^Zl4[�^�^`lDVXWZV�[eWZV�^��+a#�I_ �gVsWZVX\I^+��_b\6��iCaeo�VXWZW`acW`i��2-�\DV�_bi�^`lDV*VsWZWZapWujs[�rDi`V��3��lDVs\��ap\�^ZlDV*[¨�pVXWk[e�cVc� � �±x � 6y}S_bi��I_ �gVsWZVX\I^8oQW`acY � � 1�� � �Z��*�l?_wiS^z�Iq6V�aeo6VXWZW`acW�_bi8jX[�dbdbV�����BE8AS�VXW`WZacW¨�$*�lDV+iZV�j<ap\6�^z�Iq4VÇaeoCVXW`WZapW��N�A8 � BE8;MOD�J+VXWZW`acW¨�6_bi�jX[�r?iZV��Ì_ o � �+x � 6y}+_bi�lD_b�clDdb�yiZVs\DiZ_b^Z_b�pV�^Zay^`lDV��D[�^<[y[�\6�"o [eW�oQW`acY ^ZlDVW`VX�cW`VXiZi`_wap\ � � 1�� � �+VX�cVX\���_b^Zl iZY�[�dbd8�D_T[�i�apW �� � � ��x � 6y}���� � � 1� � �Z��*�lIrDi�Vs_w^`lDVXW��D_T[�i�apW��c[�W`_T[�\6j<VjX[e\Mj<ac\I^ZW`_b�DrD^ZV^`ayq6aIacW�q4VXW�oQacW`Y [�\4j<Vc��tI_b\6j<V�j<acYGqDdbV���YGaD�IVXdbiujs[�\�WZV���r6j<V��D_T[�i�VXW`WZacW�Y/apWZV*V¨[�iZ_bdb��xQ_z� Vc�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�VXW`WZapW*jX[�\y�4V�cVXW`�#i`Y [�dbdT}S^Zl6[e\yiZ_bY/q?dwVsW�ac\DVsi±�Dr?^N��_bdwd4_b\y�cVX\?VXWk[ed6l6[¨�pV*dT[�W`�cV��c[eWZ_T[�\6jvVxQ_z� Vc�8^ZlDVW`VXiZrDdb^`_w\?�/Y/aD�IVsd�_wi��cVXW`�MiZq4V�j<_��gj2^ZaG^ZlDVy�D[e^k[/j`lDapiZVX\ÌoQapW*^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�I}X�D^`lDV�^ZlDVXapWZ��iZr?�c�cVsiZ^Zi2^Zl6[e^*iZY�[�dbdbVXWqDW`ac�pWk[�YGi�iZl?acrDdT�G�6V2qDWZV<oJVXWZW`V���^ZaydT[eWZ�cVsW�ac\DVXi¨�DW`VX��[eWk�IdbVXi`i*a�o±j<ap\6j<W`VX^ZV#��VXikj<W`_bqD^Z_bac\ oQacW`Y/i+rDiZV����N%z\�^ZlDV\DV"��^�i`V�j<^`_wap\ �+VÇVsY/qD_bWZ_TjX[edbdw�2iZ^Zr4�I�/^`lD_bi�qDlDVX\DapY/VX\?ac\��I�yV��6[�Y/_b\D_b\D�2^ZlDVVXW`WZacW�dT[�\6�Ii<jX[�q4Vc�

Page 8: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

� %('2� '����������)+� y���������� y� ��'��ÌX)��

%z\�[�\�[�^Z^`VXY/q?^�^Za*V"�?[eY/_b\DV8^Zl?V�WZVXdT[e^Z_bac\Di`lD_bq�6VX^��+VXVX\/[pjXj<rDW<[cj<��[�\6��iZ^`WZr6jv^ZrDW<[�d6j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�I���±V±[e\6[�db�I�XV��^`lDV±VsWZWZapW8dÍ[e\6�Ii<jX[�q4V±aeo6iZ_b�pY [¨�zqD_�\DVsrDWk[edD\DVX^��+acW`��i+x�,4l6[�\D�4� .��� �I}X�6 S[�\6�Ii<jX[�q4V*[�\4[�db�IiZ_bi�^ZV�j`lD\?_ 1prDVsi�l6[¨�cV[edwi`a/�4VXVX\ rDi`V��Ì^ZaMj`l6[�W<[cj<^`VXWZ_b�XVy^`lDV/�I_� j<rDdb^z�/aeou^`lDV�^k[�i`�IiÇ_b\M�pVX\DVX^`_Tjy[�db�capWZ_b^ZlDYGi*xz{M[�\4�IVXWZ_Tj`�¾VX^�[�dz�b�.����D. }±[e\6�y_b\��cVs\DVX^Z_Tjq?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_ \D��xC��_b\D\DV�[eW�� .���� �c�6}s� � V*rDi`V���^`lDV�q6[eWZ_b^z�yqDWZap�DdbVXY ��_w^`l�_w\?qDrD^+iZ_b�XV0 � �D� � V+�6W`iZ^��cVX\DVsWk[�^`V��¾[yj<dbV�[�\M�D[e^k[�iZVs^ �6 9 a�o�i`_w�sV � � ��� ���,\Dap_biZ�/^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?�#i`VX^X6 9 ��[�i�^`lDVX\qDW`aD�Ir6j<V�� oQWZapY �6 9 �I�5/6_bqDqD_b\D��^ZlDV�aprD^Zq?rD^��c[�dbrDV�a�oCV¨[cj`lMV��6[�YGqDdbV7��_b^ZlM��� q?WZac�4[��D_bdb_b^z�����qDqDW`a���_bY�[�^ZVsdw��� � ������� iZ_b�cY�[¨�zqD_D\DVX^��+acW`�Ii*a�o��I_ �gVsWZ_b\D�yiZ_b�XV ��_w^`l/�D_b\6[eWZ�p�z�c[�dbrDV�� �±VX_b�pl�^`i7�±VsWZV

W<[�\6�IapY/db���cVX\?VXWk[e^ZV���� � [cj`l¿\?VX^��±apWZ� N ��[�i�^ZlDVX\ ^ZW<[�_b\DV�� ac\ ^Zl?V \?ac_biZ� �D[�^<[ 6 9 rDiZ_b\D�M^`lDV/VsWZWZapWYGV�[�i`rDWZVc�

��x�6 9 � N } �9�8�; x�� 8 1 ��x � 8 N }Z}

# $ x . �c}

��lDVsWZV!� 8 [e\6� ��x �,8 DNJ}�[�WZV^`lDV��IVXiZ_bW`V���[�\6��[cjv^Zr6[ed�acrD^`qDrD^+�c[�dbrDV*aeoC^`lDV!PT^`l \?VX^��±apWZ�y�p_w�pVX\/^`lDV_b\DqDrD^q6[e^Z^`VXWZ\ �,8 �Q*�lDV#^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?����[�i*q4VXW�oQacW`Y/V��Ì�I� ["iZ_bY/q?dwVlD_bdbdTj<db_bYy�D_b\D��Y/Vs^ZlDaD��_b\ ��lD_Tj`ln[G\DV�� �±Vs_w�plI^j<ap\��6�prDWk[e^Z_bac\_bi��pVX\DVXW<[�^ZV¨���I�YyrD^k[e^Z_b\D�+^ZlDV�V��D_wi`^Z_b\D�j<ac\��4�crDW<[�^Z_bap\�����oJ^ZVXW8^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�4�X^Zl?V±�pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\q4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvV � x �6 9 � DNJ}�aeog^`lDV+\DVX^��+acWZ�5��[�i�YGV�[�i`rDWZV¨��ap\#^`lDV�^ZVXi`^�iZVs^ �6 9 a�o � j<dbV�[�\�V��6[�YGqDdbVXi�� *7�+a\DapWZY�[�db_b�XV���q4VXWzoQapWZY�[�\6j<VYGV�[�i`rDWZVXi7�+VXW`V�^ZlDVs\ q?WZaD�Ir6j<V¨�GoQacW�V¨[cj`l�\DVX^��+acWZ���

� x-PJ} � .� ��x�6 9 � N } " x .�� }

��x-PJ} � .� ��x �6 9 � /N } $ x .�� }

*�l?VÇ\IrDYy�4VXW�aeo �+VX_b�clI^Zi�_b\/V¨[cj`lM\DVX^��+acW`�/_bi+rDiZV��Ì[�i*[yj<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�#YGV�[�i`rDWZVp�

� N � � x DNz} ���+&N-� �*,+ �:-��� #��� " x �� }

��lDVsWZV�^ZlDV�_b\6��V�� �/WZrD\Di�a��cVXW[�dbd�^`lDV�rD\?_w^`i_w\ N ��[�\4���GWZrD\Dia��pVXW*^`lDV#_b\6jvacY/_b\D�2rD\D_b^Zi�^Za��D�Q)�VsWzoQapWz�Y�[�\6j<V2_wi��IVsqD_Tj<^ZV�� [�i�["oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\¾a�o±^`lDVy\DVX^��+acW`� jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z� � N<�3TDapWÂ��_ ��VXW`VX\I^#j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^Z_bVXi��*� �±Vj<apY/qDr?^ZV�^`lDV�oJacdbdbaR��_w\?�#�c[edwr?VXi���^`lDVy[¨�cVXW<[��cV2\�r?Yy�6VXW�a�o±^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?�/VXW`WZacW`i ��� x��±}X��^`lDV�[¨�pVXWk[e�cV�\IrDYy�6VsWaeoC�cVs\DVXWk[edb_w�¨[�^Z_bap\/VXW`WZacW`i ��� x��±}X�4[�\6�G^`lDVX_bW*�I_ �gVsWZVX\6jvV ���! "� x��±}X�

� � x��±} � [¨�I�*� � x-PJ} �#� N �$�D" P�� . "%6%6�65"%� (@" x �?. }

� � x��±} � [¨�I�*�&��x-PJ} �#� N �$�D" PB� . "�6%6�6�"'� (*" x �� }

Page 9: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 50 100 150 200 250

number of weights

ave

rag

e e

rro

r

training error (T)generalization error (G)

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 50 100 150 200 250

number of weights

err

or

diff

ere

nce

(G

- T

)

T�_b�prDWZV � ������J D"<�=�PQ<Z� J M�:�? ��J � =�P 2J B�����< S =RM ��J�M�J � 8RF�B�� 8A<CB =RM��� "� x��±} � ��� x��±} 1 ��� x��±}M$ x � �c}

*�lDVyW`VXiZr?dw^`_b\D� �4^Z\DVXi`i#dT[e\6�Iikjs[�q4V/_bi#�IVXq?_Íjv^ZV�� _b\ TS_w�prDWZV � � *�lDV/�pWk[eqDlDi#[eWZV ��Wk[���\¾oQapW�^ZlDV �8� q4ac_b\I^Zi��lDVsWZV�YGacWZV�^`l6[�\4�6�pV � N � _b\Di`^k[e\6j<VXi+�±VXW`VoQaprD\6�G_b\ j<apY/qDrD^`_b\D�yx �?. }�[e\6�Ìx ��� }X�t�_wYG_bdÍ[eWZdb�5�±V#jvacY/q?rD^ZV��G^`lDV�[¨�pVXWk[e�cV��pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_bac\�q6VsWzoQapWZY [e\6j<V#[eiÇ[�oQrD\6j<^`_bac\MaeoÅ^`lDV�\�r?Yy�6VXW�aeo

rD\?_w^`i���[�\6�"^ZlDV�\IrDYy�4VXW+a�o8dÍ[¨�pVXWZi��c�

: N � :�x N } " x � ��}

��� x��6} � [¨�I�*� � x-PJ} � :BN ��G" P�� . "%6�6%65"'� (*" x � �c}

� � x��6} � [¨�I�*� ��x�PQ} � : N ���" P�� . "%6�6%6 "%� (@" x �� }

� �! "� x��6} � � � x��6} 1 � � x��4}M$ x � �c}

� N � � x N }M" x �� }

� � x ��} � [¨�I�*� � x-PJ} � : N ��� " P�� . "%6%6�6�"'� (*" x �� }

��� x ��} � [¨�I�*�&��x-PJ} � :�N���� "IPC� . "%6�6%65"'� (*" x � � }

��� "� x ��} � ��� x���} 1 ��� x���}M$ x � . }

TS_b�crDW`VXi*�/[e\6�G�/�IVXqD_Tj<^�^ZlDV2�cVX\DVsWk[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\�VXW`WZacW[�i[2oQrD\6j<^`_bac\�a�o�^Zl?V�\IrDYy�6VsW�a�oCr?\D_b^ZiÇ[e\6�GdT[¨�cVXW`i*_b\^`lDV\DVX^��+acWZ���?WZVXi`q6V�jv^Z_b�cVXdb�I�

Page 10: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 10 20 30 40 50

number of units

ave

rag

e e

rro

r

training error (T)generalization error (G)

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 10 20 30 40 50

number of units

err

or

diff

ere

nce

(G

- T

)

T�_b�prDWZV��D������J D"<U=�P+<Z� J M�:�? ��J � =�P : M!B <ES =;M �;J MOJ � 8;F�B ��8�<�BE=;M

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

number of layers

ave

rag

e e

rro

r

training error (T)generalization error (G)

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

number of layers

err

or

diff

ere

nce

(G

- T

)

TS_b�cr?WZV�6��� ��J�D"<0=>PQ<Z� J M�:�? ��J � =�P F 8RH�J � S =;M ��J MOJ � 8RF�B ��8�<�BE=RM

.��

Page 11: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

number of layers

ave

rag

e e

rro

r

training error (T)generalization error (G)

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

number of layers

err

or

diff

ere

nce

(G

- T

)

TS_b�crDW`V��D� � ��J�D�<U=>P�<Z� J M�:�? � J � =>P F 8;H�J � S =;M �;J MOJ � 8;F�B ��8�<�BE=;M BGM���J � D�J��!< � =RM�S*�l?V�WZVXi`rDdb^Zi+_w\4�I_TjX[�^`V�^ZlDV�^ZVX\6��VX\6j<��oQapW�^Zl?V�WZVXdT[�^`_b�cV��cVs\DVXWk[edb_w�¨[�^Z_bap\#VXW`WZapW±^`aÇ_b\6jvWZV�[eiZV�[�i8^Zl?V*\DVX^��+acW`�

i`_w�sVÇ�pWZaR��i¨�NTDapW±^`lDVqDWZap�DdbVXY�iZ^`r6�I_bV��GlDVXW`V�^Zl?VÇYG_b\D_bY/[�dIiZ_b�cY�[¨�zqD_D\DVs^��±apWZ�yiZapdbrD^Z_bac\G_bi±�pVXWZ�GiZY [edbd6[�\6�^`l�r?i6�+V±ap�DiZVXW`�cV*[e\�_b\6j<WZV¨[�iZV�aeo � 1 � oQW`acY ^Zl?V±i`^k[�W`^���~�rD^8_b\��cVX\?VXWk[ed�^`lDV*j<rDW`�cVW��_bdwdI�IV�j<W`V�[�i`V7�6W`iZ^8rD\I^Z_bd^`lDV±YG_b\D_bY [¨d�iZapdbrD^Z_bac\�j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z��[e\6��^`lDVX\y_b\6j<W`V�[�i`V*[¨oQ^`VXW8^Zl6[e^��$*�lD_bi8qDlDVs\DacYGVX\Dac\2_wi8i`lDaR��\#_b\3TS_w�prDWZV� ��lD_Tj`l/WZVsiZrDdb^ZihoQWZapY [2iZ_bY/_bdT[�W±[e\6[�db�IiZ_bi8oJacW�^Zl?VÇq4VXW<j<VXqD^`WZac\ [�W<j`lD_b^ZV�j<^`rDWZVp�6_z� Vc�S^ZlDV\DVs^��±apWZ� jvac\Di`_wi`^Z_b\D�i`acdbVXdb��a�o�iZ_b�pY [�r?\D_b^Zi��$T?acW�^`lD_bi±[�W<jZl?_w^`V�j<^`rDWZVc�?^ZlDV�q4[�WZ_b^z��q?WZac�?dwVsY W`V�1prD_bWZVXi�[�^�dwV¨[�iZ^�^��±adT[¨�cVXW`i�a�o�iZ_b�pY [rD\?_w^`iÇ[e\6��^Zl?V��6VsiZ^��pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\�_wi�V��Dq6V¨j<^ZV��¾^`a/�4V�[pj`lD_bVX�cV�� ��_w^`ln[y^��+a��zdT[¨�cVXW�i`^ZW`r6j<^Zr?WZVc�2�,dT[�W`�cVXWapW±i`Y [�dbdbVXW+\DVX^��+acW`�/iZ_b�XV�[pjXj<acYGq6[�\?_wVsi�Y/acW`V��cVX\?VXWk[edw_b��[e^Z_bac\�VXW`WZapW��]hac^`Vc�DlDaR�+VX�pVXW��?^Zl6[e^±_ o �+V�j<acYGq6[�W`V*i`acY/V�q6[�W`^Z_T[�d�W`VX�c_bap\Di�a�o8^ZlDV�j<ap\��6�cr?Wk[�^`_bac\�iZq6[pj<Vc�?^ZlD_bi��cVs\DVXWk[ed

^`VX\6�IVX\4j<��Y [¨���6V��I_bacdT[e^ZV����$T?acW�_b\DiZ^<[�\6jvVc�D_b\,TS_b�cr?WZV � ^ZlDV�[¨�cVXW<[��cV�pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\/VXW`WZapW�oQapW�\DVX^��+acWZ�Ii��_b^Zl �� �+VX_b�clI^Zi�_bi+dT[�WZ�pVXW�^`l6[�\G^Zl6[e^�a�o�\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii7��_b^Zl � � � �+VX_b�clI^Zi¨�6%z^+_bi�\Dac^��I_� j<rDdb^8^Za�_bY [e�c_b\DV�^`l6[�^^`lDV*apqD^Z_bY [edDj<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z� ��_wdbd�[�dbiZa��I_ �gVXW+oJWZacY ap\DV*qDW`ac�DdbVXYO^Za#[e\Dac^`lDVXW�� � aR�±Vs�cVXW¨�D^Zl?V*a��cVsWk[�dbd�[�\6[edb��i`_bii`rD�c�pVXiZ^`i±^`l6[�^�i`Y [edwdI\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii�iZl?acrDdT���4V*qDW`V<oQVXW`WZV��G^Za2dÍ[eWZ�pVXW�ac\?VXi�_ o�\Da_b\IoQacW`Y [e^Z_bac\�_bi�[¨�c[�_bdT[��?dwV+[��4acrD^^`lDV/j<ac\ �6�crDW<[�^`_wap\ iZq6[pj<Vc��j<ap\��6W`Y/_b\D�/^`lDV/q?WZ_b\6j<_bqDdbV�a�oU-jXjX[eY'V i�f*[��sacWyxz~�dbrDYGVXWVX^#[�dz�b� .���� � ,4l4[�\D�[e\6�/{��r?lDdbVX\I�6VX_b\�� .��� �c[p}X�

.p.

Page 12: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

� � X)±��'Ç�8� � �M� ��)+� "� ���c ���� �y "� �M�� � ����������! "�M� "� � � �� #�������!�

*�lDV ~+[¨�cVXi`_Í[e\AoQW<[�Y/V �±apWZ�¿a �gVsWZiMap\DVn[�q?qDWZaI[cj`l�^`a¿^`lDV �D_T[�i�� �c[eWZ_T[�\6jvVMqDWZap�DdbVXY �I� oQacW`Y [�db_b�X_b\D�¾^ZlDV_b\I^ZrD_b^`_w�pV*_T�IV�[��4VXlD_b\6� -jXjX[eY'V i*f*[e�XacW¨�8�*i�IVXikjvWZ_b�6V¨�M_b\MtIV�j<^`_bac\ � �?^ZlDV�caI[�d�aeoÅ�pVX\DVX^`_TjqDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_£\D�_bi�^`a �6\4�/[2Y/aD�IVXdG&��lDapiZVVX�c[�dbr6[e^Z_bac\� ��x � }��4VXiZ^*[eqDqDW`a���_bY�[�^ZVsiC^`lDVrD\6�IVsWZdb�I_w\?��WZVXdT[e^Z_bac\ ��Sx 1 }��c_b�pVX\[e\/_b\DqDrD^ � �$*�l?VÇ�paIa���\DVXiZi�a�o8^ZlDV�q?WZac�pWk[eY oQacW�^`lDV��D[�^<[�i`VX^X6O_bi�rDiZr6[edbdw�yYGV�[�i`rDWZV¨�/�I�

� x�6 � Ç} � .� 9� 8�; x 1 8 1 � �+x �,8 }`}# $ x � � }

m+ap\DiZ_T�IVXW`_b\D�/^`lDVyqDWZap�cW<[�Y [�i�[�U�[erDiZi`_Í[e\nYGaD�IVXd�aeo±^Zl?V/�D[�^<[D��^`lDV#db_b�cVsdw_blDaIaD��aeo±^ZlDVy^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?� �D[e^k[y_bi�IVsikj<W`_w�4V����I�

<�x�6 � Ç} � .� x���}

��� + ��� �,- " x �p�c}

��lDVsWZV � x���}�_biÇ[�\?acWZY�[�db_b�X_b\D�#j<ap\DiZ^<[�\I^��S[�\6��� _bi[yq4aciZ_b^`_w�pV�j<ac\Di`^k[e\�^��IVs^ZVXW`Y/_b\D_b\D��^ZlDV�iZVX\?iZ_b^Z_b�I_b^z� aeo^`lDVqDWZap�6[��D_bdb_b^z�#^`ay^ZlDV2VXWZW`acW��c[�dbrDVp�~+[¨�cVsi�VDW`rDdbViZ^k[e^ZVXi�^Zl6[e^�^ZlDV2q6apiZ^ZVsWZ_bacW�qDW`ac�6[e�D_bdb_w^z�yaeoÅ[2Y/aD�IVXd�_bi¨�

<�x � 6y} � <�x�6 � Ç} <�x Ç}<�x�6y} x �e��}

��lDVsWZV�<�x Ç}�_bi�^ZlDVqDW`_wapW�qDWZap�6[��?_wdb_b^z��a�o�^ZlDVYGa���VXdbiu[e\6�

<�x�6y} � � <�x�6 � Ç}�<�x } � �$ x �p�c}

*�lDV�Y/apiZ^+qDdT[�rDi`_w�?dwV�YGaD�IVXd4�c_b�cVX\G^ZlDV��D[e^k[2_bi±^`lDVX\�_b\IoQVXW`WZV��G�I� j<apY/q6[eWZ_b\D�^Zl?VÇq4aci`^ZVXW`_bacW�qDW`ac�6[e�D_bdw_b^`_wVsiaeou[�dbd8Y/aD�IVXdbi¨��tI_b\6j<V <�x�6y}*_bi^Zl?Vyik[�YGVoQapWÇ[�dbd8Y/aD�IVsdwi¨�?oQacW^Zl?VyqDrDWZq4aci`VXi�aeouYGa���VXdCj<apY/q6[eWZ_biZap\����±V\DVsV��Gac\Ddb�/j<apY/qDrD^`V

<�x�6 � } <�x Ç}M$ x � � }

��jvacY/q?dwV"�#Y/aD�IVXd!��_w^`lyY [e\��2q6[�W<[�Y/Vs^ZVXW`iN��_bdwd?l6[¨�cV*[2�DWZaI[c�y�I_bi`^ZWZ_b�Dr?^Z_bac\yaeo�qDWZ_bacW`i��p_z� Vp�C[i`Y [edwdG<�x Ç}�c[edwr?Vc��[�\6�ÌlDVX\6jvV/[/i`Y [edwd><�x � 6y}*�c[edbrDVc��� i`_wYGqDdbVXW��4YGacWZV�j<ac\Di`^ZW<[�_b\DV��¾YGa���VXd$��_wdbdSl6[¨�cVy[GiZl6[eWZq4VXWqDW`_bacW�[�\6�G^ZlIrDi*[�dT[eWZ�cV!<�x � 6y}��c[�dbrDVc�NT?acW�^`lDVY/acW`VÇj<apY/qDdbV��/YGaD�IVXd4^Zay�4V*oz[¨�cacW`V��Ga��cVXW�^`lDViZ_bY/q?dwVsWap\DVc�4_b^ÇYyr?iZ^*[cj`lD_bVX�pV�[GYyr6j`l��4VX^Z^`VXW �4^Ç^`a/^`lDV��?[�^k[?� *�lIrDi�~+[¨�cVXi`_Í[e\MY/aD�IVsd£�Zj<apY/q6[eWZ_biZap\/^ZV¨jZl?\D_G1cr?VXij`lDaIaci`V*�4VX^��+VXVX\M[�db^ZVsWZ\6[e^Z_b�cV�Y/aD�IVXdbi��I�y^ZW<[c�I_b\D�2a �M^ZlD_bi+Y/V�[eiZrDW`V�a�o8^ZlDV�iZ_bY/qDdb_Tj<_b^z��aeoC[Y/aD�IVXd�[��I[�_b\Di`^

.��

Page 13: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

^`lDV��?[�^k["Y/_bi��4^��7*�lIrDi_b^*_biWZV�[eiZap\6[��DdbV�^Za��IV��6\DVy^`lDV�VX�capdwr?^Z_bac\6[eWZ�GqDWZaDj<VXi`i#aeo±�cVs\DVX^Z_Tj2qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_£\D�[ei�^ZlDVY [A�D_wYy_b��[e^Z_bac\2a�o�^ZlDVq4aci`^ZVXW`_wapW*qDW`ac�6[e�D_bdb_w^z���

��� � � ��[eWZ��Y�[��� � )�� �4<�x DN � 6y}5(D� [�WZ�2Y [��� � )�� ��<�x�6 � DNz} <�x DNJ}5(I$ x �p�c}

*�l?acrD�pl/^Zl?VÇ~+[¨�cVXi`_Í[e\/_b\IoQVsWZVX\6jvVÇ_bi+�cVXW`�yrDiZVvoQrDd�_b\y^`lDVXacW`���I_b^�_bi+\Dac^+�cVsWZ�/j<ap\��pVX\D_bVX\I^�^Za��IV�[�d���_b^`l/_b\qDW<[cj<^`_Tj<Vc����db^ZVXW`\6[�^`_w�pVXdb���!�±VyjX[e\nrDi`V#^`lDV�Y/aD�IVXd8j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z� [cjXj<apWk�I_b\D��^`a j<aD�I_b\D�G^ZlDVXapWZ� xzf�_biZi<[�\DVs\��

.���� �I}X��_£o�<�x � }�_biy�c_b�cVX\S�±^`lDVX\ _b^`i j<aD�IVMdbVX\?�c^ZlA_bi/�p_b�cVX\ [�i � x-<�x � }Z} � 1 dwap�Dx�<�x � }`}X� {M[��D_bY/_b�X_b\D�<�x�6 � Ç} <�x Ç}�_bi�^ZlIrDi�V�1prD_b�c[edwVs\�^+^ZayYG_b\D_bYy_w�s_w\?�Ç^`lDV^Zap^k[�d�jva���V�dbVX\D�c^`l��

� x � 6y} � � x-<�x�6 � Ç}�<�x }Z} � 1 dbap�Dx-<�x�6 � Ç}�<�x }Z}>� � x�6 � Ç} % � x Ç}M" x � � }

��lDVsWZV � x�6 � }!� 1 dbac��<�x�6 � Ç}[e\6� � x }!� 1 dbac� <�x Ç}s� � VXWZV � x�6 � Ç}Â_wi2^ZlDV/j<aD�IVGdbVX\D�c^`lnaeo*^ZlDV�D[e^k[4��lDVX\¾VX\6jva���V�� rDi`_b\D��^ZlDVyYGa���VXd> [ei�[/q?WZV��I_Tj<^`acW2oQacW^`lDV/�D[�^<[ 6���[�\6� � x Ç}�_bi�^`lDVydbVX\D�c^`lnaeo^`lDVY/aD�IVXd�_b^Zi`VXd ok�N*�l?_wi�dbV�[p�Ii�^Zay^`lDV�YG_w\?_wY�rDY �IVXikjvWZ_bqD^Z_bap\MdbVX\D�c^`l¾x {M|Q �}+q?WZ_b\6j<_bqDdbVyxzf�_biZi<[�\DVX\S� .�����!T?ac�pVXdz� .����?. }+��lDVXW`V/^Zl?Vy�ca�[ed8_wi2^Za�ac�D^<[�_b\ [cjXj<r?Wk[�^`V [e\6�¾q6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\D_bacrDi�VsiZ^Z_bY�[�^ZVsi�a�o�^ZlDVyq?WZac�4[��D_bdb_b^z��I_bi`^ZWZ_b�Dr?^Z_bac\��W*�lDV�_T�IV�[�_bi*^`a/VXi`^Z_bY [e^ZV^Zl?V#i`_wYGqDdbVXiZ^*��VX\DiZ_b^z��^Zl4[�^*l4[�i*l?_w�plMdb_b�cVXdb_blDaIaD�y�I��Y/_b\D_bYy_£�X_b\D�^`lDV^Zac^<[�d�dbVX\D�p^Zl�a�o8^ZlDV��IVXikjvWZ_bqD^Z_bap\ aeo�^ZlDV��D[e^k[D�

��� � � � [�WZ��YG_w\� � )�� � � x /N � 6y}5(D� [�W`� YG_b\� � )�� � � x�6 � /NZ} % � x DNz}5(�$ x � � }

{ _w\?_wYyr?Y,j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z�2VXiZ^`_wY�[�^`acWZi+[�WZV�^ZW`V�[�^`V��G_w\y^`lD_bi±�pVX\DVXW<[�d4oQapWZY ^Zl4[�^�jX[�\y�4ViZq4V�j<_T[�db_b�XV��"^Za��c[�Wz�_bacr?i±jX[�i`VXi�� *�lDViZq4V�j<_T[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\/jX[e\/�4V��Iac\DV��I�/jZl?a�apiZ_b\D�y[iZVs^�a�oÅjs[�\6�I_T�D[e^ZV�qDWZap�6[��D_bdb_b^z�#�I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`_bac\Di[e\6������j`lDaIaci`_b\D�*[��IVXi<j<WZ_bqD^`_wap\#dbVX\?�c^Zl�oQapW�V�[pj`l�a�oD^Zl?VXiZV��I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`_wap\Di��¨i`rD���<V�j<^8^`a*_b\IoQapWZY [e^Z_bac\�� ^`lDVXacW`VX^Z_TjW`V�1prD_bWZVXYGVX\I^Zi��0%Jo �+V#[eiZiZr?Y/V^Zl6[e^*^`lDV#i�1pr6[�W`V���VXW`WZacW`i�oQacW�^ZlDV#�?[�^k["q6ap_b\�^`i*[�W`V#_b\6�IVsq6VX\4�IVX\I^�[�\6�G\DapWz�Y�[�dbdb�#�I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`V���[��4acrD^*[��XVsWZayY/V¨[�\��I^`lDVX\�^ZlDV��IVX\Di`_w^z�"oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\G_wi

<�x�6y} � �N�� 8 <8N ���

N�� 8.� ���

������� � " xQ� � }

��lDVsWZV�� 8N _wi2^ZlDV PÏ^Zl¿j<apY/q4ac\DVs\�^aeo*^ZlDVyi�1cr4[�WZV¨� VXW`WZacWÂoQacW�^`lDV��<^`l V��6[�Y/q?dwVp��[�\6� # _bi�^`lDVy�c[�W`_T[�\6j<Vaeou^`lDV U�[erDiZi`_T[�\¿�I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`_bac\��#*�lDV/j<aci`^ya�o*j<aD�I_b\D�¾rDiZ_b\D�M^`lD_bi#�I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`_bac\¿jX[e\¿�4V j<apY/qDrD^`V��ÌoQW`acY^`lDV�acqD^`_wY�[�d±jva���_w\?� ^ZlDVXapWZVXY¾� *�lDV�qDWZap�6[��?_wdb_b^z�¾Y [�i`i#aeo�� 8N jX[�\A�4Vn[�qDq?WZa��D_bY [�^`V�� [�iy^`lDV�qDWZaD�Ir4j<^aeo±_b\�^`VXWZ�c[ed��M[�W`acrD\6��� 8N [e\6�M^`lDVylDVX_b�pl�^+<�x�� 8N }�rD\6��VXW�^Zl?V/U�[�rDi`iZ_T[�\¾�IVX\Di`_w^z�ÌoQrD\4j<^Z_bac\ [�^�� 8N ��^`l6[�^_bi��

. �

Page 14: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

Y�[�iZisx�� 8N } � <�x � 8N } �?�N*�lDV�j<aD�IV2dwVs\D�c^`l _bi�^`lDVX\��1 � N�� 8 dbac��x�< 8N �p} �

!# $ �N�� 8

� 8N� # % ;�dbac�?x

� � � }� ��(% ;�dbac� �

xQ� . }

��lDVsWZV ; _bi^ZlDVyqDW`aD�Ir6j<^�a�o�^ZlDVy\IrDYy�4VXWa�o�acr?^ZqDrD^�j<acYGq6ap\DVX\I^Zi�[�\4� �D[�^<[/_b^`VXY/i¨� � V/js[�\¾iZVXdbV�j<^y[�\apqD^Z_bY [ed6�c[edbrDV�a�o+^ZlDV��c[�W`_Í[e\6j<V�aeo±^Zl?V�U�[erDiZi`_T[�\M�I��Y/_b\D_bYy_b�X_b\D��^`lDV�jva���V#dbVX\D�p^Zl ��_b^ZlMW`VXiZq4V�j<^�^Za # �]hac^ZV�^Zl6[e^D;�dbac��� WZVXq?WZVXi`VX\I^Zi^ZlDV�j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��^ZVXW`Y �IV�j<W`V�[�i`_w\?����_b\6j<W`V�[�i`VXi*^`lDVVX\6j<aD�I_b\D�/[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�I�^`l�r?i�_w\4j<WZV�[eiZ_b\D�y^`lDV�j<aD�IV#j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�����i±_bdbdbrDiZ^`Wk[e^ZV��y[e�6a��pVc��[e\/_bY/q?dwVsYyVX\I^k[�^`_bac\�aeo�{M|Q Ì^z�IqD_TjX[�dbdb��\DV�jvVXiZi`_w^<[�^`VXi*�I\DaR��_b\D�^Zl?V*^ZW`rDV*r?\6�IVXW��

db�I_b\D�yqDWZap�6[��?_wdb_b^z�M�I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`_wap\MacW�[e\n[�qDq?WZa��D_bY [�^`_bac\/aeou_b^¨�Q%z\n�pVX\DVXW<[�dz��l?aR�±VX�pVXW���^ZlDVy�I_biZ^`WZ_b�DrD^`_wap\naeorD\4�IVXWZdb�I_b\D�y�D[�^<[�iZ^ZW`r6j<^`rDWZVy_bi�rD\D�I\DaR��\�[�\6�G^`lDV�V��6[cjv^�oQapWZYyrDdT[�oQapW±^`lDVQ�6^`\DVXi`i*oJrD\6j<^`_wap\�_wi�_bYGq6apiZiZ_b�DdbV^`a�ac�D^<[�_b\�� *�lDV�cVX�yq4ac_b\I^�_bi+^Zl6[e^±�4ac^`l/^Zl?VÂ~+[¨�cVsiZ_T[�\GY/aD�IVXd6jvacY/q4[�WZ_bi`ac\/[�\4�/{M|Q ÌqDWZ_b\6j<_bqDdbV�W`V��Ir6j<V¨�^`a/^Zl?Vy�cVX\DVsWk[�d+j<WZ_b^ZVsWZ_bac\¿j<ap\DiZ_bi`^Z_b\D��a�ou[pjXj<rDW<[cj<� [�\4�Mq6[eWZi`_wYGac\I�MxJacW^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�GVXWZW`acW#[e\6�MYGaD�IVXd�j<acY"�qDdbV��D_b^z�D}�a�o�Y/aD�IVXdbi*^`l6[�^2iZlDaprDdT�M�4Vy�6[�dT[e\6j<V���� � V#qDW`acq4aci`V/^Za�YGV�[�i`rDWZVy^`lDV5�6^Z\?VXiZi�a�o*[GqDWZap�cWk[eY �p_w�pVX\ [�^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?��iZVX^ 6 _b\/_b^Zi�YGaciZ^+�cVs\DVXWk[ed�oQapWZY [ei

� x � 6y} � � � % � �A� � � x�6 � } %���� x }M" xQ� � }

��lDVsWZV/^`lDV/q4[�Wk[eY/VX^`VXWZi � [�\6� ��j<ac\I^`WZacd+^Zl?V/^ZW<[c�IVv� a �Á�4VX^��+VXVX\ j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z� � x Ç}�[�\6�#�6^`^Z_b\D�MVsWZWZapW� x�6 � Ç}�aeo±^Zl?V#qDW`ac�pWk[�Y¾�7%z\¾^ZlD_bi�oJWk[�YGV��+acWZ���?�cVX\DVs^Z_Tj�q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_b\D�2_wij<ac\?iZ_T�IVXW`V�� [�i�[yi`V�[�W<j`lMoQapWÇ[qDW`ac�pWk[�YO^Zl6[e^�Y/_b\D_bYy_b�XVXi � x � 6y}X�IapW

���� � � � [eWZ��Y/_b\� � ) � � � x N � 6y} (�� [�WZ��YG_w\� � )�� � � � x�6 � N } %��� x N } (I$ xQ�I�c}

*�lDV2oQapdwdbaR��_b\D�yi`V�j<^Z_bap\¿�IVXikjvWZ_b�6Vsi�[G�cVs\DVXWk[edu[p�D[�q?^Z_b�cV�^ZV�j`lD\?_ 1prDVy^`l6[�^�6[edT[�\6j<Vsi � [�\4� �A_b\MrD\D�I\DaR��\VX\I�I_bWZap\DY/VX\I^`i��

�(�M� �)+ ��' � ������� ����� ���(�*�� �����h� ��� � ����������! "�#�

��i*iZr?�c�cVsiZ^ZV¨�¾����^`lDV#i`^k[e^Z_biZ^`_Íjs[�d�^`lDVXapWZ�n[e\6��^Zl?V#�pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\n[�\4[�db�IiZ_bi��?^ZaIa/i`Y [�dbd�["qDWZap�cWk[eY dT[pjZ�Ii^`lDV�dbV�[�W`\D_b\D�/jX[eq6[��D_bdb_b^z�3��lD_bdbVÇ^`aIaydÍ[eWZ�pV#[�qDWZap�cW<[�Y Y [¨�y�cVs\DVXWk[edb_w�sV�q6aIapWZdb�/ap\ r?\DiZVXVs\ �D[e^k[?�±� �6\D_b^ZVi`VX^�a�o�i`V�[�W<jZlÌq6ap_w\I^`iu[e\6�y^`lDVY [��D_bY�rDY,�IVXqD^`l�a�oC^`WZVXVsiÇ[�W`VrDiZr6[edbdw��iZVs^*[�i�rDi`VXWz�Z�IV��6\?V���q6[eWk[�YGVX^ZVsWZi�_b\apWk�IVXW�^Za�j<ac\I^ZW`acd8^ZW`VXV�iZ_b�XVXi¨���DrD^[�\n[eqDqDWZapqDWZ_T[e^ZV#�IVsqD^Zl¾_bi*\Dap^*�I\DaR��\M�4V<oQapWZVXl6[e\6��� � l6[e^7�±V�\DVXV��Ì_b\

. �

Page 15: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

qDW<[cj<^`_Tj<V_wi�[2�cVX\DVsWk[�d�YGV�j`l6[�\?_wi`Y ^Zl6[e^ujX[e\3/6V"��_b�Ddb�/j<ap\I^ZWZapd�^ZlDVqDW`ac�pWk[�Y�j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��^`a �6\4�/^`lDV*YGaci`^q6[eWZi`_wYGac\D_baprDi8qDWZap�cWk[eY ��l?_wdbV�ik[�^`_bizoQ�I_b\D��^ZlDV#��VXiZ_bWk[e�DdbV^ZWk[e_b\D_b\D��[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�I�-�rDW�6[eiZ_Tj�[eqDqDWZaI[cj`l¾_wi�^Za ���M^ZlDV�VXWZW`acW�o [pj<^ZapWÇ[�^�V�[cj`l¾�cVX\?VXWk[e^Z_bac\n[e\6��^`a j`l6[e\D�cV2^ZlDVyj<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�

o [pj<^ZapW*[c�D[eqD^Z_b�pVXdb����_b^Zl�WZVsiZq4V�j<^�^`ay^ZlDV�VsWZWZapW��Q �VX^ � N x � }��IVX\Dap^ZV�^ZlDV�VsWZWZapWÇ�IV"�6\DV��Ì�I� i`acYGVÇj<W`_w^`VXWZ_bap\��_z� Vc�

� N�x � } � � x�6 � ��N }M$ xQ�p��}

*�lDV�^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D��iZVX^ 6O_biu[eiZiZr?Y/V��"^Za��6V+���DV��4��_b^ZlGiZ_b�XV � �Ir?WZ_b\D��VX�capdwr?^Z_bac\��$T?acW+dÍ[e^ZVXW�r?iZVQ�±V�pVXVXq�^ZlDVVXW`WZapW�a�o�^ZlDV�4VXiZ^�_b\6�I_b�I_Í��r6[�dbi�rDq�^`ay^ZlDV � ^Zl��cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\S�

� ��� � �zx � } � � N�� x � } xQ�I�c}

P�� � [eWZ��YG_b\N � � N x � }���PB� . "�6%6%6 "%� (@$ xQ� � }

� VXWZV � N`x � }�_bi�^ZlDV2^Zac^<[�d(�6^Z\DVsiZi�c[�dbrDVa�o�^`lDV�PÏ^ZlM_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[ed�[�^��cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\ � rDi`V��GoQapW�WZVXqDW`aD�Ir6j<^`_wap\naeo^`lDV\DV��D^�q6apqDrDdT[�^`_bac\�� �VX^ � N x � }��4V#^`lDV�jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�G�c[�dbrDV�aeo PT^`ln_b\6��_w�I_T�Ir6[ed�_b\ � ^`lnq4acqDr?dÍ[e^Z_bac\S��*�lDVyj<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�/aeo±^ZlDV

qDW`ac�pWk[�Y°Y [¨��4VÇ�IV��4\DV��y_b\yi`VX�cVXW<[�d���[¨�Ii��$TDapW�_b\DiZ^<[�\6j<Vp�c_b\/jX[eiZV*aeo�\DVXrDW<[�d �z\DVX^��+acWZ��iZ�I\I^Zl?VXiZ_bi��Ii`l6[�dbdbaR�\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii7��_b^ZlM[�iZY�[�dbd6\IrDYy�4VXW�aeoÅr?\D_b^Zi*[�\4���+VX_b�clI^`i�iZlDaprDdT�/�4V�qDW`V<oQVXW`WZV��Ì^Za/��VXVXq¾iZ^ZW`r6j<^`rDWZVXi ��_w^`l [dT[�W`�cV\IrDYy�4VXW�a�o8rD\D_b^Zi[�\6�4�+VX_b�clI^Zi¨�2*�l?V�^Zap^k[�d8j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�ya�o�^ZlDV2\DVX^��+acWZ��jX[�\Ì^ZlIrDi*�4V#�IV"�6\DV��¾[�i*[db_b\DV�[eW±i`rDYn�

� Nzx � } � � x ��N } � � x ��N } % :�x ��N } % � x ��N }M" xQ�I�c}

��lDVsWZV � x ��N }s�E:�x ��N }X��[�\4� � x ��N }��IVX\Dap^ZV�^ZlDVG\IrDYy�6VsW�a�o��+VX_b�clI^Zi¨��rD\?_w^`i���[e\6� dT[¨�cVsWZi�WZVXi`q6V�jv^Z_b�cVXdb�I�{�apWZV��cVs\DVXWk[edbdw�I�±jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�¾_bi/�IV��6\DV¨�A_b\¿^ZVsWZY/iyaeoÂ[¾\IrDYy�4VXW�a�o*oz[cj<^`acWZi��c�W��lD_Tj`lÁ[eWZV �+VX_b�clI^ZV��[pjXj<acW<�I_b\D��^Zay^Zl?V�WZV�1prD_bW`VXY/VX\I^`i�a�oC^`lDV#[eqDqDdb_TjX[�^`_wap\ F �

� N x � } � � �

� x ��N } $ xQ� � }

��^�^`lDV�VX\4�/aeoCV�[pj`lM�cVX\?VXWk[e^Z_bac\ � �+VÂ[edbiZa��cVXVXqÌ^ZlDV�j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�#aeo�^ZlDV�4VXiZ^�_w\4�I_b��_T�Ir4[�dz�

� �������`x � } � � N�� x � } xQ� � }

P � � [�W`�±YG_b\N � � Nzx � }��!PB� . "%6%6�65"%� (@$ x � � }

�� DGO4ä�ö�ö�B�âCLzö£âZàvã�ö£à\FQâ�ãkô FAcâSà<á�á�ö�äKLZà B�ä�ö�äKF VSß Y FIAcâ��*âHFIAcß�J8äKDDåcß\FDö�ä���äKFJâHJNB�VMFIAcâ,L`ß:J¨ä�åWPCD�LZAcâ��*âDåcß<ã�B�VMFAcâCLZß���á�ö£â��XäKFIVJ�â���å�äKFTä£ß<åD÷

. �

Page 16: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

~+[�i`V��Gac\ � ��� � � x � }X�D^`lDV�i`_w�sVÇaeo�^ZlDV�4VXiZ^�_w\4�I_b��_T�Ir4[�d�[�^�^Zl?VÇ\?V��D^*�cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\�_bi�VXi`^Z_bY [e^ZV��G[�i�� ������� x � % . } � � ������� x � } % � � ����� x � } " x � . }

��lDVsWZV�� � ����� x � }+_bi*[�YGa��I_w\?�Â[¨�pVXWk[e�cV�^Zl6[e^��cVXVXq?i�^ZWk[pj`�/a�o8^ZlDV��I_ ��VXWZVs\6j<V�_b\/^`lDV�j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�#�4VX^��+VXVX\^`lDV�6VXi`^*_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[ed6aeoCac\?VÇ�pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\M[�\6�G^Zl?V��6VsiZ^*_b\6��_w�I_T�Ir6[edDa�o�^`lDV\DV��D^��

� � ����� x � } � .�� � ������� x � } 1 � ��� � � x � 1 . } % � � ����� x � 1 . } ( x � � }

��_b^Zl�� � ����� x � }�� � �+��^�^ZlDV��4VX�p_w\?\D_b\D�/aeoÅ�pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\ � �?^ZlDV3-jXjX[eY o [cj<^`acW¨� � x � }X�4_bi*j<acYGqDrD^ZV¨�M[�i*[oQr?\6j<^Z_bap\ aeo�^ZlDV��6VsiZ^VXWZW`acW � ������� x � 1 . }ha�o�^Zl?V#dT[�i`^��cVX\?VXWk[e^Z_bac\n[e\6��^`lDV�VXi`^Z_bY [e^ZV����4VXi`^Çi`_b�XV �� ��� � � x � }aeoC^Zl?VÂjvrDWZW`VX\I^Ç�pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\��

� x � } �!"# "$

9 � ��� �� + � H-�� ��� �� + � - _ o � ������� x � 1 . } /�� 9 � ��� �� +

� H-�� �� ��� �� + � - ap^ZlDVXW ��_biZV*"

x �p�c}

��lDVsWZV � _wi�^`lDV�i`_w�sVÇaeoC^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D��iZVs^��N*�l?V -jXjX[�YOo [pj<^ZapW�_wi�^`lDVX\�rDi`V���_b\/^`lDVQ�6^`\DVXiZihoQrD\6jv^Z_bac\M[�i

� Nzx � } � � N`x � } %�� x � } � N`x � }M$ x �e��}

*�lD_bi+V�1pr6[�^`_bac\/_bi�[�W`V�[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\yaeoC^Zl?VÇ�pVX\DVXW<[�d4oQapWZY ��VXWZ_b�cV¨��oQW`acY�^`lDV�{M|Q n[eqDqDWZaI[cj`lMxJ� � }N��lDVsWZV �n_bi���DV���[e\6� � _wi�V"��q?WZVXi`iZV��¾[�i*[2oQr?\6j<^Z_bap\/a�o � �

��� . $ � [�\6� � � � x � } $ x �p�c}

]hac^ZV^`l6[�^ � x � }��IVXq4VX\6�Ii�ac\ � �������zx � 1 . }+[�\4� �� �������zx � }s�

*�l?VÇr?iZVXW����IV"�6\DV���q4[�Wk[eY/VX^`VXW��+_w\Ìx �p�c}�iZq4V�j<_��6VXi�^ZlDVY [A�D_wY�rDY ^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�2VXWZW`acW*[�dbdbaR�+V��2oQacW+^Zl?V��4\6[�di`acdbrD^Z_bap\�� � lDVs\ � ��� � � x � 1 . }�/���� � x � }+�IV�j<W`V�[�i`VXi�[�i+^ZlDV^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D��VsWZWZapW+o [�dbdbi�i`_w\4j<V � ��� � � x � 1 . }�� . _biYyrDdb^`_wq?dw_ V����W*�lD_bi*Vs\6j<acr?Wk[��pVXi�o [�i`^*VXW`WZapWÇW`V��Ir6jv^Z_bac\ [�^�^ZlDV�V�[�W`db� i`^k[e�cVXi�a�o±VX�pacdbrD^`_wap\��7%z\njvac\I^ZW<[�iZ^¨�?oQacW� ��� ��� x � 1 . }����¨��[�i � ��� � � x � }*[eqDqDWZaI[cj`lDVXi � ^`lDV#W`VXdT[�^`_w�pV_wYGq6apWZ^<[�\6j<Vaeouj<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�y_w\4j<WZV�[eiZVXi��Ir?V�^Za^`lDV#�I_b�I_biZ_bac\G���M[�i`Y [�dbd��c[edwr?V � ��� � � x � 1 . }�� . �W*�lD_bi*Vs\6j<acr?Wk[��pVXiiZ^`WZac\?�cVXW�j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�yWZV���r6j<^Z_bap\n[�^^`lDVQ�6\6[ed�i`^k[��pVXi^ZaGac�D^<[�_b\�q6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\D_bacrDi+iZapdwr?^Z_bac\Di¨�W%z\M�6ap^Zlnjs[�iZVsi���^`lDV�jvac\Di`^k[�\I^ho [cj<^`acW 9 � jX[�W`VXi�oQacW^`lDViZ^k[e�D_bdb_w^z�yaeoC^`lD_bi*j<ac\I^ZW`acdSY/VX^`lDaD���6*�l?VÇV"��q4VXW`_wYGVX\I^k[ed�WZVXi`rDdb^Zi*i`l6[�dbd��4V��c_b�pVX\/_b\�^ZlDV\DV"��^�i`V�j<^`_wap\��-�\A^Zl?VMac^`lDVXW/l4[�\6����^ZlDV -ÇjsjX[�Y o [cjv^ZacW � x � }/��V�j<WZV¨[�iZVsi [ei/j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�

�� ������� x � }�_b\6jvWZV�[eiZVXiGoQapW�[

���DV�� � ��� ����x � 1 . }s�IVX\6j<aprDWk[e�c_b\D��^Zl6[e^�ac\6j<V^`lDV�iZ_b�XVaeoC^Zl?V��6VsiZ^*q?WZac�pWk[eY��cW`aR��i��I^Zl?VÇ_b\6��_w�I_T�Ir6[edbi�l6[¨�cV_b\6j<W`V�[�i`_b\D�cdb��lD_b�plDVXW�j`l6[�\6jvV*a�o��cW`aR��^Zl�� *�lD_bi�_bi8_b\�^`VX\6�IV¨��^Za��p_w�pVujvacrD\I^ZVsW�V���V�j<^Zi�^`a^ZlDV�-jXjX[eY'V i�f*[e�XacW

.��

Page 17: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

^`a�VX\Di`rDWZV�cW`aR��_b\D�_£o�\?V�j<VXi`ik[�W`��� *�lD_bi�Y/Vs^ZlDaD��_bi±[�q?qDdb_Íjs[��DdbV+_w\4�IVXq4VX\6�IVX\I^�aeo�^ZlDVj<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z���IV��6\D_b^`_wap\i`_w\4j<V�^Zl?V@-jXjX[eY o [cjv^ZacW�_biÇj<ap\�^`WZapdwdbV�� ����^`lDV�Wk[e^Z_ba/aeo�^ZlDVyj<rDW`WZVX\I^�j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�y^Za/^`lDV�VXiZ^`_wY�[�^`V��G�6VXi`^j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�I��\Dac^+�I�/^`lDV#[��?iZacdbrD^`V�c[�dbrDVc�*8a�iZVXV�lDaR� ^`lDV�i`VXdbV�j<^Z_bap\ �±apWZ�Ii��6[eiZV���ap\�^ZlD_biW�6^`\DVXiZi�VX�c[�dbr6[e^Z_bac\Gikj`lDVXYGVc���+V�j<ac\?iZ_T�IVXW�^ZlDVQ�4^Z\DVXi`i

�I_ ��VXWZVs\6j<V�aeoÅ^��+a�_w\4�I_b��_T�Ir4[�dbi��*P�[�\4���D�poQapW � ��� � �zx � 1 . } ���¨�

� � Nzx � } 1 � �Ix � } � � � � NZx � } 1 � �px � } % � x � }<x � N`x � } 1 � �cx � }`} � $ x � � }

*�lDVsWZVÇ[eWZV�\D_b\DV�q6apiZi`_w�?dwV�W`VXdT[�^`_wap\DiZl?_wq?i��6Vs^��±VXVs\ � Nzx � }+[�\6� � �px � }±[ei�db_biZ^ZV¨��_w\y^`lDV7�4WZiZ^�j<apdwr?Y/\�aeo6*Å[e�DdbV. �Ç~�V�jX[erDiZVy^`lDV#ap���<V�j<^`_b�cV�_wi�^ZaGY/_b\D_bYy_b�XV*^`lDV �4^Z\DVXi`i����+Vy[�WZV�_b\I^ZVXW`VXiZ^`V��¾_b\ ^`lDVyjX[�i`VXi�_b\ ��lD_Tj`l � NZx � }_bi�dbVXiZi^`l6[�\ � �px � }[�\6��P�_bi*i`VXdbV�j<^ZV¨� [���[e_b\DiZ^��D��*�l?VXWZV/[eWZVoQaprDW*aeo�^ZlDVXY [eiY [�W`�cV��"_b\M^ZlDV�WZ_b�pl�^`Y/apiZ^j<apdbrDY/\yaeoC^Zl?V�^k[e�DdbVc�

�m�[eiZV . � � NZx � } � � �px � }�[�\4� � N`x � }�� � �px � }X�$*�lD_bi�_bi*[2^ZWZ_b�I_T[�d�jX[�i`V _ o P8l6[�i�dbVXi`i�VXWZW`acW[�\6�GdbaR�±VsWjvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z��^Zl6[e\ ��� � N`x � }W��_bdwd4�4V�dbVXiZi�^`l6[�\ � �px � }s�

�m�[eiZV � � � N`x � } � � �px � }�[�\4� � N`x � }�� � �px � }X� � l?VX\ �6ap^Zl l6[¨�pV#^`lDVyik[eY/Vyj<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z���9P�YyrDi`^l4[¨�cVdbVXiZi�VXWZW`acW�^Zl4[�\ ��_b\GacWk��VXW�oQapW � N`x � }+^Zay�4VÇdbVXi`i*^`l6[�\ � �px � }s�

�m�[eiZV�D� � NZx � } � � �px � }�[�\4� � Nzx � } � � �px � }X� � lDVX\y^Zl?V*VXW`WZacW`i±aeog�4ac^`ly_b\6�I_b�I_Í��r6[�dbiC[eWZV�^`lDV�ik[eY/Vc�^`lDV#j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��a�o1PÅYyrDiZ^+�6V2dwaR�+VXW+^Zl6[e\�^Zl6[e^�a�o,�D�

�m�[eiZVy�4� � N`x � }0/ � �px � }�[�\4� � N`x � }�� � �cx � }s�/��dw^`lDacr?�cl¾_w\4�I_b��_T�Ir4[�d Phl6[�i2dÍ[eWZ�pVXWVXWZW`acW�^Zl6[e\ �D�^`lDVQ�6^`\DVXi`iÇaeo1P�js[�\M�4ViZY [edbdwVsW±^`l6[�\�^Zl4[�^�a�oN�#_ o8^ZlDV#jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z��a�oIP8_bi�Yyr6j`l/i`Y [edwdbVXW�^Zl6[e\M^ZlDVjvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z��a�oN�D�

*�l?V*dT[�i`^ujX[eiZV_biN�+acWZ^`lI�ya�o�Y/apWZV��I_bikj<r?iZiZ_bap\�� � VXWZVQ�+V*l6[¨�pV � N`x � }[/ � �cx � }+[�\6� � N`x � } � � �cx � }+[�\6���[�\I^+^ZayiZ^`r6�I�G^ZlDV#jvac\6�I_b^`_wap\yoQapW � N`x � } � � �px � }X�!��lD_TjZlMjX[e\��6VWZV ��WZ_b^Z^`VX\n[�i

� x � }vx � � x � } 1 � N x � }`} / � N x � } 1 � � x � }M$ x �p�c}

~��/i`rD�DiZ^`_b^ZrD^`_w\?��x �c�p}8oJacW � ������� x � 1 . } � �+_b\�^`a#^`lD_bi�_b\DV�1pr6[�db_b^z�I���+V�cVX^

� �px � } 1 � NZx � } / � # 6 � ��� � � x � 1 . }>6 �� ������� x � } 6¨x � N`x � } 1 � �Ix � }Z} $ x � � }

. �

Page 18: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

ä.Y FAcâ�å àEJ�J¨äKFÏä£ß<åcà<ö:L`ß<åWJ¨äKFÏä£ß<å ãzâ�Ywâ�ã â�åWLZâ����������� ������� �������������������� LZàEDJâ�ú

������������������� ������������� ������� �������������������� LZàEDJâ�������������� ������� ��������������������� ���������! "�#��������%$&�����'�(���(�����! )� ���������

��������������������� ���������! "�#�������*�+$&�����'�(���(�����! )� �������������������� ������� �������������������� LZàEDJâ8ø

��������������������� ������������� ������� ��������������������������������� ������� ���������������������

�������������������� �#�������, "�*�������*+$&�����'�(���(�����! )� ��������� LZàEDJâ�-����������� ������� ��������������������� �#�������, "�*��������%$&�����'�(���(�����! )� ���������

��������������������� �#�������, "�*�������*�+$&�����'�(���(�����! )� ����������������������������� ������������� ������� ���������������������

������������ ������� ���������������������

*�[e�DdbV . ������J D"<�=�P J �E� = � 8;MOI D =;? ��F J �AB <CH5< J � ? S =RM K$<�MOJ"S�S �A8;F�:�J"S �VX^ � ��� � � x � 1 . } � x � }/. � ����lDVXWZV � _wi+^Zl?VÇ\IrDYy�4VXW+a�o�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�2V��6[�Y/q?dwVsiu[e\6� x � }+_wi+^Zl?V*\IrDYy�4VXW±aeoYG_wi`Y [¨^<jZl?V���V��6[�YGqDdbVXi�oJacW�^Zl?VÇ�4VXi`^*_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[�d4_b\��cVX\DVsWk[�^`_bac\ � �$*�lDVs\,�+Vl6[¨�cV

� � x � } 1 � N x � } / x � } 6 � 6 �� ��� � �zx � } 6¨x � N x � } 1 � � x � }Z} $ x � � }

%z\MjX[eiZV�a�o � N`x � } 1 � �px � }E� . . � �D_z� Vc�EPÏ^Zl¾qDWZap�cWk[eYÊjvacWZW`V�j<^`dw�¾j<dT[�iZi`_��6VXi*ap\DV�YGacWZV��D[e^k["^Zl6[e\M^ZlDV �Ñ^`l��^`lDV�j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z��WZV¨�Ir6j<^`_wap\MYyrDi`^±i<[�^Z_bi�oQ�y^ZlDV2WZVXdT[�^`_bac\

� �px � } 1 � Nzx � } / x � } 6�� ��� ��� x � } $ x �� }

*�lD_bi�YGV�[�\Di�^`l6[�^*[yjvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�yW`V��Ir6j<^`_bac\Maeo�[e^�dbV�[�i`^ x � }�6�� ������� x � }h_bi�WZV�1prD_bWZV¨��^Za�j<acYGq6VX\?ik[�^`V�oQacW*[dbaci`i�a�o�ap\DV*YGacW`V�Y/_bikj<dT[eiZiZ_��gjs[�^Z_bap\���*�lDV�a��cVXW<[�dbdDV���V�j<^�_bi+^Za�_bY/q?WZa��cV+^Zl?VÇq?WZac�4[��D_bdb_b^z��a�o��pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\

[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�4��_w^`l/q4aci`iZ_b�DdbV*dbaci`i�a�o�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�2VXWZW`acWZi¨����lDVXWZV^`lDVVXWZW`acW�^ZapdbVXWk[e\6j<V_b\�^`VXWZ�c[ed�_bi±i`q6V�jv_��4V����I�y^ZlDVrDi`VXWz�Z�IV��4\DV��Ìq6[�W<[�Y/Vs^ZVXW��¨�

.��

Page 19: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

� � � ¾��+��*�����y)+� �¾�'�

����� �� �����������������������������

tI_bYyrDdT[e^Z_ba�\yl6[�i��6VsVX\ q6VsWzoQapWZY/V¨�/ap\M^Zl?V#i`��\I^`lDVXiZ_bia�o�i`_w�pY [Ñ� qD_4\DVXr?Wk[�d8\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii�[�iÇ��VXikj<W`_b�6V��¾_b\MtIV�jk�^`_wap\ � � � lD_bdbV#^`lDVX_bW�\DV�j<VXi`iZ_b^z� [e\6�¾rDi`V<oQrDdb\DVXi`i#l4[¨�cVy�4VXVX\¿W`V�j<ap�c\D_b�XV�� V�[eWZdb_bVXW�_b\ ^Zl?V/\DVXr?Wk[�d+\DVX^��+acW`�j<apY/YyrD\?_£^z�Mxz|�rDWZ�D_b\ [�\6�¾f�r?Y/VXdbl6[eWZ^�� .������! T?VXdT�IY [e\n[�\6�¾~+[�dbdT[�Wk��� .������ f�rDYGVXdbl6[�W`^*VX^#[edz�w� .������ }X�^`lDV#q?_£�zrD\D_b^`i�l6[¨�cV�\Dac^��6VsVX\ndbap\D�/rDi`V��Ì_w\ÌqDWk[pj<^Z_Tj<Vc�5-�\DV#Y�[�_b\/W`V�[�i`ac\ �u[ei*^`lDV���_ jvrDdb^z� aeo±^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�4�� l?_wdbV�i`acYGV�iZq4V�j<_T[�d+j<dT[�iZiaeou\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii�j<ac\Di`_biZ^Z_b\D��i`acdbVXdb��a�o�qD_8rD\D_b^Zi�jX[e\n�4Vy^ZW<[�_b\DV��Ì�I�M^ZlDV��cW<[c�I_bVX\I^YGVX^ZlDaD���?VX_b^ZlDVsW�^ZlDVy[�W<j`lD_b^ZV�j<^`rDWZVyi`lDacr?dÍ�Ì�4V#�pVXWZ�Mi`_bY/qDdbV�x U_bdbVXi[�\6�¾{M[����+VXdbdz� .��� �p}�acW^`lDV#i`acdbrD^`_wap\_b\I�capdw�pVXi�^`lDVY [�\?_wq?rDdT[�^Z_bap\#aeoCj<acYGqDdbV��I� �c[edwr?V���V��DqDWZVsiZiZ_bap\Di�xz|*r?WZ�D_b\ [e\6��f�rDYGVXdbl6[�W`^�� .����� }X�S�*\?ac^Zl?VXWqDW`ac�DdbVXY _b\�rDiZ_b\D��qD_DrD\?_w^`i8_wiS^ZlDV*jvacYy�D_b\6[e^ZacW`_T[�d�V��DqDdbaci`_bac\�aeo6^ZlDV�\IrDYy�4VXWSa�o6^`VXWZYGi±xJ�*Y�[�WZ_z� .���D. }X��*�lDV\IrDYy�4VXW8a�o�q6[eWk[eY/VX^`VXWZi+\DV�j<VsiZik[eWZ�"oQacW�i`q6V¨j<_ oQ�I_w\?�#[�\GacWk��VXW ��\?VXrDWZap\/_bi � � � ' �N ;� 8 � N ���lDVXW`V!0/_bi+^ZlDV^`ac^k[ed6\IrDYy�4VXW+a�o8_w\?qDrD^Zi�[�\4� 8 � � [�W`V^ZlDV�D_b\DapY/_T[�dDj<aIV% j<_bVX\I^`i�� � V�l6[¨�cV�rDiZV¨���cVX\?VX^Z_Tj�qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_£\D�^`a#j<ac\?iZ^ZW`r6j<^*[l?_w�plDVXW�� apWk�IVXW�\?VXrDWk[ed6\?VX^��±apWZ�3��lDapiZV�^Zacq4acdbap�c�I��iZ_b�XVc�D[e\6��\DaD�IV�^z��q4VÇ[eWZV[c�D[eqD^ZV��"^Za�^ZlDVq6[eWZ^`_ÍjvrDdT[�W8qDWZap�DdbVXYn�(*�lDV±q?WZVXdb_bY/_b\6[eWZ�WZVXi`rDdb^Zi�l4[¨�cV��4VXVX\yWZVsq6apWZ^ZV¨�y_b\/x�,4l6[�\?�#[�\6��{��rDl?dwVs\��4VX_b\�� .��� ��� ,4l6[e\D�/[�\4�M{ �rDlDdbVX\I�4VX_b\�� .��� ��}s�D_b\ ��lD_Tj`lM[yi`Y [�dbd �<j<ac\Di`^k[e\�^ �,-jXjX[eY o [cjv^ZacW+�u[ei*rDi`V��Ì_w\�^`lDV �4^Z\DVXi`ioQr?\6j<^Z_bap\��*7�+aM�D[�^<[GiZVX^`i�[eWZVyrDi`V��¾oQapW^ZlDVyV��Dq4VXWZ_bYGVX\I^Zi�� *�lDVyac\DVy_bi�[�\ [�W`^Z_��gj<_T[ed±�D[�^<[GiZVX^��cVX\?VXWk[e^ZV�� ��_b^Zl

\Dap_biZV2oQWZapY ^Zl?V#q6[eWZ_b^z��oQr?\6j<^Z_bap\��5*�lDVyac^`lDVXW�_biWZV�[ed �C�+acW`dÍ�¾�D[e^k[�j<ac\?iZ_biZ^`_w\?� aeohjvdw_b\D_TjX[ed8Y/V�[eiZrDW`VXY/VX\I^`ioQapW*���I�/�I_ ��VXWZVX\I^q4VXWZi`ac\Di¨�Q*�lDV��caI[�dSlDVXWZV�_bi*^`a �I_T[��p\Daci`V#[yq4[�^Z_bVX\I^����G^ZlDV��DdbaIaD��^ZVXi`^Y/V�[eiZrDW`VXY/VX\I^`i��lDVs^ZlDVXWyl?_wi�db_b�cVXW�_bi#_b\¿�I_biZapWk�IVsWyacW�\Dac^¨� � [cj`lA�D[�^<[M_b^ZVsY j<ac\?iZ^Z_b^`rD^ZVXiG^ZlDVGWZV�jvacWk�Áa�oÇ[ÌiZ_b\D�cdbVGY [�dbV_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[ed�[�\4�yj<ac\Di`_biZ^Zi�a�o�iZ_��#_b\Dq?rD^��c[�dbrDVsiÅ[ei�db_biZ^ZV¨��_w\5*�[��DdbV � � *�lDVW�6W`iZ^±��c[eWZ_T[��?dwVsiCaeog^`lDV�_b\DqDrD^+[�WZV[edwd4�DdbaIaD�/^`VXiZ^`i���lD_Tj`lM[�W`VÇ^`lDacr?�clI^�^Za��6V2iZVX\Di`_b^Z_b�cV^Zaydb_b�cVsWu�I_bi`acWk��VXWZi�^Zl6[e^�Y/_b�clI^±[eWZ_biZV�oQW`acY�V��6j<VsiZiZ_b�pV[edÍjvaclDapd�j<ac\Di`rDY/q?^Z_bac\��0*�lDV�iZ_��D^ZlÌ_w\?qDrD^*�c[eWZ_T[��?dwV_bi*^`lDV�\�r?Yy�6VXW�aeo±l6[ed£oÏ� qD_b\I^+V�1prD_b�c[�dbVX\I^Zi�a�o±[�dTj<aplDacdb_Tj�4VX�cVsWk[��pVXiÇ��WZrD\D�Gq6VsW*�D[¨��� *�lDV�apWZ_b�c_b\6[ed6�D[e^k[��c[�dbrDVsi*xz{�rDWZq?l���[�\6�G��l6[D� .���� �I}N�+VXW`V�\DacW`Y [edw_b�XV¨��_w\I^`a^`lDV_w\I^`VXWZ�c[ed � � . � . ���6VvoQacW`VÇ�4VX_b\D�yrDi`V���^`ay^ZWk[e_b\/^Zl?V�\DVX^��+acW`��i¨�

.��

Page 20: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

[�^`^ZW`_w�?rD^ZV \6[�YGV �IVXikjvWZ_bqD^Z_bap\3 Y�j<� Y/V�[e\ j<apWZqDrDi<j<rDdT[�W��capdwr?Y/V3 # [edb��q?lDaci [�db�c[�db_b\DV�qDlDapiZqDl?ac^k[eiZV3 F i`�cqD^ [�dT[�YG_w\?V*[�Y/_b\Dap^ZW<[�\Di�oQVXWk[eiZV3GH i`�cap^ [�iZq4[�WZ^<[�^`V#[�YG_w\?ac^ZW<[�\Di�oQVXW<[�iZV3 L �I[�YGY [���^ ��[�YGY [Ñ� ��dbrD^<[�Y��IdD^`Wk[�\?iZq4VXqD^Z_T�D[eiZV3 J ��WZ_b\D�Ii [�dTj<acl?acdb_Tj��4VX�cVXW<[��pVXiÇ�IW`rD\D��q4VXW*�D[¨�

*�[��DdbV � ���+< < � B���:< JQBGM�P�= � ?38�<�BE=RM BGM � F =�=�I5< J�S�< S P�= � F�B�RJ � I;BE8��RMO=AS"B S

����� ��� ��� �

*�lDV[�db�capWZ_b^Zl?Y,_bi±i`rDY/Y�[�W`_w�sV���_b\�TS_b�crDW`V � �8��^±^`lDV*i`^k[�W`^��I^`lDV_w\?_w^`_T[�dDq4acqDr?dÍ[e^Z_bac\ �Gx � }�a�o � \DVX^��+acWZ�Ii_bi�j<WZV�[e^ZV��Ì[�^+Wk[�\4�IacY¾�6*�lDVW<[�\6�IapY�_b\D_b^Z_T[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\�_b\6jvdwr4�IVXi�^Zl?VÇ^z�Iq4V�[�\6�GWZV¨j<VXqD^`_w�pVQ�6VXdT�"a�oCr?\D_b^Zi��?^ZlDV�IVsqD^ZlMaeo�^ZlDV�\DVX^��+acW`�g�4[�\6� ^ZlDV �+VX_b�clI^��c[�dbrDVXi¨� T?acW�^ZlDV � ^ZlÌq6apqDrDdT[�^`_wap\��D^`lDVQ�6^`\DVXi`iÇaeo�V�[cj`l¾Y/VXYy�4VXW\DVs^��±apWZ��� � N x � }X�?_bi±VX�c[edbr6[�^`V��G���G^ZlDV�[p�D[�qD^`_b�cV+�6^Z\?VXiZihoQrD\6j<^`_bac\/_b\ � 1pr6[e^Z_bac\Ìx ���I}X�� [cj`lAY/VXYy�4VXWa�o^ZlDV�q4acqDrDdT[e^Z_bac\ rD\4�IVXWZ�paIVXi/[Ml?_wdbdTj<db_bYy�D_£\?�/iZV¨[�Wkj`l _b\���lD_TjZlA[ �!��V¨� \IrDYy�4VXW#aeo

dbaDjX[�dSiZV�[eWkj`l¾iZ^ZVsqDi#[�W`V�q4VXWzoQapWZYGV�� ��lD_bdbV�^Zl?V#i`^ZWZr4j<^ZrDW`Vy_bi7���DV���� � [pjZl¾dbaDjX[�dSiZV�[eWkj`l iZ^`VXq jvac\Di`_wi`^Zia�o±[W<[�\6�IapY Y/aD�I_��gjX[e^Z_bac\�aeou^`lDV3�±Vs_w�plI^Ç�c[edbrDVXi��goQacdbdbaR�±V¨���I�M_b^Zi+�6^Z\?VXiZi�VX�c[�dbr6[e^Z_bac\S�g[e\6�Ì^ZlDV/[pjXj<VXqD^<[�\6jvVapW#W`VE�<V�j<^`_bac\Aa�o\DV�� j<ac\��4�crDW<[�^Z_bap\�� *�lDV�\DV�� j<ap\��6�cr?Wk[�^`_bac\¿_biy[cjXjvVXqD^ZV¨��[ei#^`lDVMj<rDWZW`VX\I^/ap\DV�_£o^ZlDV\DV �,_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[�dS_biQ�6^Z^`VXW�^`l6[�\¾^ZlDV/jvrDWZW`VX\I^�ac\DVp��-�^ZlDVXW ��_biZVy^Zl?VyqDWZVX�I_bacr?i�ac\DV�_birDiZV�� [�i^Zl?V/j<rDWZW`VX\I^_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[ed � � _bdbdTj<db_wYy�?_£\D��^`rDWZ\?V���aprD^�^Za��6V�rDiZV<oJrDdpoQWZapY�aprDW�qDW`VX�I_bacrDiSac�Di`VXWZ�c[e^Z_bac\�^`l6[�^�ap\6j<V+^ZlDV+[¨�cVXW<[��cVi`_w�sVya�o±_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[edwi��cW`aR��i��S_w^�pVX^Zi�YGacW`V#�I_� j<rDdb^^Za4�6\6� [Gi`Y [�dbdbVXW�i`acdbrD^Z_bap\���[�db^`lDacrD�pln^`lDVyiZapdbrD^Z_bac\?iV��D_biZ^�_b\G^ZlDV�i`Y [edwdbVXW�iZrD�Di`q6[cjvVc�*�l?V/�4VXiZ^��"� aeo*^ZlDVGlD_bdbdÍjvdw_bY��6V¨��q6apqDrDdT[�^`_bac\¾a�o*�cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\ � [�WZVGiZVXdbV�jv^ZV�� _b\I^Za�^ZlDVGY [e^Z_b\D�/q4aIacd

�x � }s�$��lDVXWZV�� < x � " . �±_bi�^ZlDVG^ZWZr?\6jX[�^`_bac\ ^Zl?WZVXi`lDacdT�Axz{ �rDlDdbVX\I�4VX_b\ [e\6� tDj`lDdb_bVXWZ�c[eY/qI����aIaci`VX\�� .���� �p}X�*�lDV"x � % . }z^ZlÌ�cVX\DVsWk[�^`_bac\MaeoÅi`_b�XV � _bi*qDW`aD�Ir6j<V��Ì�I� [eqDqDdb�I_w\?��j<W`aci`iZa��cVsWÂ[e\6��YyrD^<[�^`_wap\/apq6VXW<[�^`acWZi�^Za^`lDV*q6[eWZVX\I^�\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii±_b\G^ZlDVY [e^Z_b\D��q6aIacd� hx � }s�±]hV�� q4acqDrDdT[e^Z_bac\Di+[�WZV�pVX\DVXW<[�^ZV¨�/r?\�^`_bd6^`lDV�c[�WZ_T[e\6j<V*aeo�6^`\DVXi`i*�c[�dbrDVsi�o [edbdwi+�4VXdbaR��^`lDViZq4V�j<_��6V��Ìdb_wYG_b^�� � N 8 apW�^ZlDV�cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\�\IrDYy�4VXW+WZV�[pjZl?VXi � ����� �*�l?VÇj<W`aciZi`a��cVXW�apq6VsWk[�^`acW+iZVXdbV�jv^Zi�^��+a#q6[eWZVX\I^`i����EN�[e\6���M��[�^�W<[�\6�IapYn�c[e\6��V��6j`l6[�\?�cVXi�^`lDVX_bW±i`rD�D^`WZVXVXi

��

Page 21: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

����������� ��� ~±U )ux � � ��� � � N 8 � � ���� }q6apqDrDdT[�^`_wap\yiZ_b�XVc���������^ZWZr?\6jX[�^`_bac\�Wk[e^ZVc� ������� ��6^Z\DVsiZi*�c[eWZ_T[�\4j<Vc� ������� � � N 8S����x � }�cVX\DVsWk[�^`_bac\�������� � ����6� ��6^Z\DVsiZi*�c[edbrDVXi�� ������� � Nq6apqDrDdT[�^`_wap\�� �������� � � x ! �"*�# "C$&$'$&" ��M}Y [�^`_b\D�q6aIacdz� �������� � x��+ �"��D# "�$&$&$&" � � � �M}

������� %z\D_b^Z_T[�db_b�XV�xz}X� � �c[edbr6[�^`V�x }s� � _bdbdÍjvdw_bYy��xz}X�ct�VXdbV�j<^Xxz}X�4{M[�^`V�x }

�"! �

�/x � } ! %z\D_b^Z_T[�db_b�XV�x � }

#%$ � � � x`x � � � ����� } � � x ��x � }[/ � � N 8 }`} ��� Nzx � } ! � �c[�dbr6[e^ZV�x DNzx � }Z} & P < � . "�$&$&$&"'��(/Nzx � } ! � _wdbdTj<db_bYy��x /NTx � }Z} & P < � . "%$&$'$&"%� ( hx � } ! tIVXdbV�j<^sx �/x � } " �?}�Gx � % . } ! {M[e^ZV�x �x � }M" � }%'��% ��� � � x � }5( VXdb_b^Z_bi`^

�(! � % .� � �#%$ � � �

� � )����������� ���

TS_b�cr?WZV � � � ��J+<>= �S� F JE�RJ�F(S�< � :�D"<C: � J =�PQ<Z� J58RF �;= � B <Z� ?

�?.

Page 22: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

BiBjBi

,

Bj

,

q4[�WZVs\�^`i

a ��iZqDW`_w\?�

TS_b�crDW`V��D� � � D � B < J�D�<�: � J 8I�8 �!<>8A<CB =RM ��H�D � =AS S�=��AJ �^`a j<W`V�[�^`Vy^��±aya �gi`qDWZ_b\D��� �N [�\4� � �� xQi`VXV@TS_b�cr?WZVy�c}X�+%z\¾^ZlD_bi���[¨�I�D^Zl?V#i`_w�sVc���IVXq?^Zl [�\6��W`V�j<VXq?^Z_b�cV5�6VsdÍ�i`l6[�q4V#aeo±^Zl?V#\DVs^��±apWZ�n[eWkj`lD_b^ZV�jv^ZrDW`V/[�WZVy[c�?[�qD^`V����Q%z\'TS_b�crDW`V��?�?oQacW�V��6[�Y/q?dwVp�D^Zl?V#\IrDYy�4VXW*aeo±rD\D_b^`iÇaeoq6[eWZVX\I^��EN�l4[�i8_b\6j<WZV¨[�iZV¨�����2WZVXqDdT[pj<_b\D�*ap\DV�a�o6_b^`iCq?_£�ziZr?�D^ZW`VXV7��_b^Zl�^`lDV�iZ_b�cY�[¨�ziZ_b�cY/[Ñ�QqD_ �ziZrD�D^`WZVXV8aeogq6[eWZVX\I^� Nk�$*�lDVQ�+VX_b�clI^Zi�[�W`V#[c�?[�qD^`V��y�I�/W`VXq4V�[�^`V��Idb�M[�qDqDdb�I_b\D�#[2YyrD^k[e^Z_bac\yapq6VsWk[�^`acW�^`ayV�[cj`l�_b\6�I_b�I_Í��r6[�dz��*�lDVYyrD^<[�^`_wap\/apq6VXW<[�^`acWÇ[edbiZa j`l6[e\D�cVsiÇ^`lDV�_b\6�IV"� oJacW*^`lDV�_w\?qDrD^*r?\D_b^ZiÇ[e\6��^`lDV#\?VXrDWZap\n^z�Iq4Vc�QTDapW*_b\DiZ^<[�\6jvVc�["iZ_b�cY�[�rD\?_w^_bi*Yyr?^k[�^`V���^`a [yq?_�rD\D_b^Ç[e\6���I_Tj<V��cVXW`ik[D� *�lD_bi7/6V"��_b�D_bdb_b^z�/�p_w�pVXi^ZlDVyj`l6[�\4j<V#aeo±VX�pacdb�I_w\?�j<ap\I�cVX\I^Z_bap\6[�d8\DVXr?Wk[�d+\DVX^��+acW`�¿[�W<jZl?_w^`V�j<^`rDWZVXi/[ei �+VXdbd±[�i�\?VX^��±apWZ�Ii#j<ap\DiZ_bi`^Z_b\D�MaeoÇ[�\I�nj<apYy�D_b\6[�^`_wap\Di*aeoi`_w�pY [[�\4�/q?_�rD\D_b^`i��

����� � ����� ��������� ��� ����� � ���

*�lDV+q4VXWzoQapWZY�[�\6j<V�a�o6^`lDV±YGVX^Zl?a��ÇoQacWSiZacdb�I_b\D��^Zl?V±q6[eWZ_b^z�qDWZap�DdbVXY,aeo6�*_b\Dq?rD^ZiS_wi8i`lDaR��\�_b\ TS_b�crDW`V � �6*�lDV^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�yi`VX^�j<ac\?iZ_biZ^`i�a�o � �/V��6[eY/qDdbVXi7��lD_Tj`l �+VXWZV/j`lDapiZVX\¾Wk[e\6�IapY/db�yoQW`acY ��� � .��� �D[e^k[yq4ac_b\I^Zi[�\6�_b\Di`VXWZ^`V���\Dap_wi`V����j`l6[�\D�p_b\D�#^`lDVacrD^`qDrD^��c[edwr?VU��_b^`l ��� qDWZap�6[��D_bdb_b^z��� *�lDV�cVs\DVXWk[edb_w�¨[�^Z_bap\/q4VXWzoQapWZY�[�\6j<V

��

Page 23: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

aeou^`lDV/�4VXiZ^yi`acdbrD^`_wap\ _b\ V�[cj`l¿�pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\ �u[ei#YGV�[�i`rDWZV¨�¾���¾^Zl?V j<apY/qDdbVX^`V/�D[�^<[�iZVX^yaeo .��� \?ac_biZVXdbVXi`iV��6[eY/qDdbVXi¨�N*�lDV�q6apqDrDdT[�^`_bac\���[�i�_b\D_b^Z_T[�db_b�XV���oQacW�VX�cVXW`��_w\4�I_b��_T�Ir4[�d�^Za�j<ac\I^<[�_b\�iZ_b�cY�[#[e\6�GqD_8rD\D_b^Zi7��_b^Zl� � �°qDWZap�6[��?_wdb_b^z�yV�[pjZlS�$*�lDV��IVXqD^`lMa�o8_w\?_w^`_T[�db_b�XV���\DVX^��+acW`����[�i�db_bY/_b^ZV¨��^`a/�D�$*�lDV^ZW`rD\6jX[e^Z_bac\�W<[�^ZVQ��[�i� � ��� *�lDV�q4acqDrDdT[e^Z_bac\GiZ_b�XV#[e\6�G^ZlDVY [A�D_wYyr?Y �cVX\DVsWk[�^`_bac\Mdb_bY/_b^$�±VsWZV � � � � [�\4� � ����?� .��� �$*�lDVq6[eWk[eY/VX^`VXW �+�u[ei*iZVs^*^Za � � . �?WZV�1prD_bW`_w\?�y^ZlDV�^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�yVXW`WZacW�iZlDaprDdT���4V�[e^�Y/aci`^ � � . acW¨�D_b\Map^ZlDVXW+�±apWk�Ii¨�[e^±dbV�[eiZ^ ��� � a�o�^`lDV^ZWk[e_b\D_b\D�#V"�?[eY/qDdbVXi�[�W`V��IVXiZ_bW`V���^Zay�4V�dbV�[eWZ\DV���j<apWZW`V�j<^Zdb�I�

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50

generation

fitness

training errorgeneralization error

0

50

100

150

200

250

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50

generation

netw

ork

siz

e

weightsunitslayers

TS_b�cr?WZV � ���U�R=RF�:<CBE=;M'=�P K$<CM�J�S�S �A8;F�:�J58RMOI4MOJ"<�W= � � S�B ��J5=�PQ<Z� J ��J�S�<7BGMOI;B��B IR:�8RF STS_b�cr?WZV � xJdbV<oQ^k}�i`lDaR��i^ZlDVyq4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvV�VX�capdbrD^Z_bac\Ìa�o�^ZlDV��6VsiZ^�_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[edwi�_b\MV�[cj`l¾�cVX\?VXWk[e^Z_bac\��S_b\

^`VXWZYGi�a�o�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D��[e\6���cVX\?VXWk[edw_b��[e^Z_bac\yVsWZWZapWZi¨�N*�lDV�iZ^k[e�D_bdb_w^z�2a�o�^Zl?VÇ[cjsj<rDWk[pj<�p� q4[�WZi`_bY/ac\I���6[�dT[e\6j<_b\D��jX[�\�4V�iZVsVX\M�I�M[�\6[edw�I�X_b\D��^Zl?V�VXWZW`acWq4acWZ^`_bac\�a�o�^Zl?V�^Zap^k[�d(�6^Z\?VXiZi��IVXq?_Íjv^ZV���_b\ TS_b�crDW`V � � *�lDV��cW<[�qDlÌiZlDaR��i^`l6[�^�rD\I^Z_bd+^ZlDV�VXW`WZacW�oz[�dbdbi��6VsdwaR� � � � $ . [e^#�pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\ �� �8^Zl?V VsWZWZapWy^ZVXW`Y ��acY/_b\6[e^ZVXi^`lDV4�6^Z\DVsiZi����lD_bdbV*[¨oJ^ZVXW+^Zl6[e^�q6ap_b\�^�^ZlDVWZVsdÍ[e^Z_b�cV�IacYG_b\6[�^`_wap\�a�o8VXWZW`acW�^`VXWZY��paIVXi*�IaR��\/r?\6�IVXW . � � ^Za�Y [��pV±i`^ZW`ac\D�pVXWj<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��WZV��Ir4j<^Z_bac\S�D^Zl?acrD�pl�����_b^ZlDaprD^±W`_biZ�I_b\D�y^ZaIa�Yyr6j`l/VXW`WZacW�_b\6j<WZV¨[�iZVp�*�l?Vnj<acYGq6[�W`_biZac\AaeoÂ^`lDV �6^`\DVXi`i [e\6�A\DVs^��±apWZ�AiZ_b�XVnjvac\��6W`Y/iG^Zl6[e^y^ZlDV¾\DVX^��+acW`� i`_b�XVnj`l6[�\?�cVc��_z� Vc�

�pWZaR��_b\D��acW*q?WZrD\D_b\D�4�Dl6[eiÇ[��pVXWZ�njvdwapiZV�W`VXdT[�^`_wap\DiZl?_wq ��_b^Zl�^`lDV#^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?�yVXWZW`acW*W`V��Ir6jv^Z_bac\��+TDapW*_b\DiZ^<[�\6jvVc�oQW`acY �cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\ � ^Zay���IrDWZ_b\D�5��lD_Tj`ly^ZlDV^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�2VXWZW`acW7��[�i+WZV��Ir4j<V��"oQWZapY � ��� . ^`a � � ��� �e^ZlDV\DVX^��+acW`�i`_w�sV/_b\6j<W`V�[�i`V��¾oQW`acY �¨� .�� � .�� �ÌxQdT[¨�pVXWZi�� rD\?_w^`iz���±Vs_w�plI^Zik}Â^ZaM�e� �?. � .���� �,-�^`lDVXWyV��6[�YGqDdbVXia�o*�pWZaR��_b\D�M[�\6�qDW`rD\D_b\D�y[�W`VÇdb_biZ^`V��G_b\,*�[e�DdbVÇ�D�

� �

Page 24: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

1.1

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50

generation

E_best

(g)

/ F

_best

(g)

T�_b�prDWZV � ��� �E� = � ��= � <�BE=RM =�PQ<Z� J <>=A<>8;FRK$<�MOJ�S�S@=��AJ � �;J MOJ � 8A<CBE=;M�S

�±[�dbrDVXi�[�^��pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\ � �±[�dbrDVsiu[e^��cVX\DVsWk[�^`_bac\ � % . m+acYGY/VX\I^`i� � �������zx � } � �������`x � } � ��� ����x � % . } � ��� ���`x � % . }� � � � . �¨� .�� � .�� � � � ��� �e� �?. � .��� �cW`aR��_b\D�

.�� � � �� ��� �D. � .���� � � � � �� .�� � � � q?WZrD\D_b\D�

. � � � � � �� .�� � � � � � ��� �� .�� � � � q?WZrD\D_b\D�

�?. � � �� �Ñ� .�� � � � � � .c. �Ñ� . �¨� � � �cW`aR��_b\D�

� � � � .p. �Ñ� . �¨� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � . �cW`aR��_b\D�� � � � �� � �Z�c�Ñ� �� � � � � � �Ñ��� . � . �e� q?WZrD\D_b\D�

*�[e�DdbV�D��� �E� = � :���I�8A<>J0�AJ � S�:S D =;? ��F J �AB <CH�D � 8;M^�;J

� �

Page 25: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

0.10

0.20

0.30

0.40

0.50

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

generation

fitness

population averagetraining error

0

100

200

300

400

500

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

generation

netw

ork

siz

e

weightsunitslayers

T�_b�prDWZV .�� �M� �E� = � 8;MOI�D�=;? ��F J �AB <�H�J\�A=;F�:<CB =RM'=>PQ<���J ��J"S�< BGM�IRB��BEIR:�8;F SNP�= � <Z� J ?@J�I;BED�8RF I8�< 8*�l?V/j<dbaciZV�WZVsdÍ[e^Z_bac\?iZlD_bq¾�6VX^��+VXVX\¿jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z��[�\6�Ìq6VsWzoQapWZY [e\6j<V�a�o±^`lDVy\DVX^��+acW`�Ml6[eiÂ[edbiZa/�4VXVX\ ac�I�

i`VXWZ�pV��GoQapW±^`lDVY/V��I_TjX[ed��D[�^<[D�D[ei±i`lDaR��\�_w\ TS_b�crDW`V .�� �N-�\DV��I_ �gVsWZVX\6jvV ��[�i�^`lDV�o [cj<^�^`l6[�^�l?VXWZV#[2dT[�W`�cVXW\DVs^��±apWZ�3��[�i�WZV�1cr?_wW`V��G^Zl6[e\GoQacW+iZapdw�I_b\D��^ZlDVq6[eWZ_b^z�yqDW`ac�DdbVXY¾����dwi`a#i`lDaR��\�_b\/^Zl?V��4�crDW`VÇ_bi�^`lDV�[¨�cVXW<[��cV�6^`\DVXi`iÇa��pVXW*^`lDV�q6apqDrDdT[�^`_wap\��W*�lDVy[¨�cVXW<[��cV �6^Z\DVsiZiQ�u[ei*YGV�[�i`rDWZV�� ^��±aG^Z_bY/VXi+oJacW*V¨[cj`lM�cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\S�6_z� Vc��4V<oQapWZVy[�\6�M[ÑoQ^ZVsWÇl?_wdbdTj<db_bYy�D_£\?�6�W*�lIrDi^ZlDV�V���V�j<^�aeo±lD_bdbdÍjvdw_bYy�D_ \D�yjX[�\¾�6V�ac�?iZVXW`�cV��Ì_b\n^`lDV#�pWk[eqDl�� � _bdbd �j<db_bYy�D_b\D�N��[�i�VsiZq4V�j<_T[�dbdb�lDVXdbqIoQrDdI^`aW�6\6��pa�aD�Q�+VX_b�clI^�j<apYy�D_b\6[�^`_bac\Di���lDVX\�^`lDV+\DVX^��+acWZ��[eWkj`lD_b^ZV�jv^ZrDW`V2��[�ii`rD_b^k[��?dwVp� T?acW+^ZlD_bi+WZV�[ed � db_ oQV*�D[e^k[D�I^`lDV*^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?��q6VsWzoQapWZY [e\6j<V[¨oQ^`VXW .��� �cVX\?VXWk[e^Z_bac\Di7��[�i�[�q?qDWZa��D_bY [e^ZVXdb�

� ��� [�\6��^`lDV�cVX\?VXWk[edw_b��[e^Z_bac\/[pjXj<rDW<[cj<� ��[�i±[e�6aprD^ .�� �°dbVXi`i�^Zl6[e\/^Zl?_wi+�c[�dbrDVp�6*�lDVq4acqDr?dÍ[e^Z_bac\�iZ_b�XVQ��[�i

.���� �0*�lDacrD�pl�^ZlD_bi*q4VXW�oQacW`Y [�\4j<V�_bi*\Dap^Ç[eqDqDWZapqDWZ_T[e^ZV2oQacW�W`V�[�d�[�q?qDdb_Íjs[�^Z_bap\��D^`lDVXWZV�_bi*i`^Z_bdbdCq4aci`iZ_b�D_bdb_b^z��oQacWoQr?WZ^Zl?VXW±_bYGqDWZa��pVXY/VX\I^�[ei±^`lDV��cVX\?VXWk[e^Z_bac\G�caIVXi+ac\�� � i`_w\?��^ZlDV��cVX\?VX^Z_Tj�q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_ \D�*q4[�Wk[p�I_b�cY ��_w^`lDacr?^l6[¨�I_b\D��[�j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z��o [pj<^ZapW2��[�i�[�dbYGaciZ^S_bY/q4aciZi`_b�DdbV+oQacW�^`lD_biu�?[�^k[?�c�4V�jX[erDiZVaeo�^ZlDVWk[eqD_T���cW`aR��^Zlya�o8^ZlDVi`acdbrD^Z_bap\/iZ_b�XVp�$*�lD_bi�_w\4�I_TjX[�^`VXi*[�\Dap^ZlDVsW*qDW<[cj<^`_Íjs[�d�WZV¨[�iZap\�oQapW±q6[eWZi`_wYGac\D_baprDi�iZapdbrD^Z_bac\?i��*�l?V#V���V�j<^�a�o7-ÇjsjX[�Y V i�f�[��XapW���[�iiZ^`r6�I_bV��¾�I�Mj<acYGq6[�W`_w\?�y^ZlDVyq4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvV#aeo±^ZlDV�WZr?\Di ��_b^Zl¾^ZlDV

[p�D[�qD^`_b�cVN-jXjX[�Y YGVX^Zl?a��2xz����}(��_b^Zl^ZlDapiZV+a�oD^Zl?V��6[�i`VXdb_b\DV$�6^`\DVXiZiÅoQrD\6j<^`_bac\ � N x � } � � N x � } � � x�6 9 � N }X�~�ac^`lnYGVX^ZlDaD�Ii�rDiZV¨�¾^ZlDVyi<[�Y/V2q6[�W`_w^z�¾�D[�^<[/[�i�4V<oQapWZVc��T?acW�V�[cj`l YGVX^ZlDaD��� �� W`rD\DiQ�+VXWZVyV��DV�jvrD^ZV�� ^Zaap�DiZVXW`�cV^Zl?V#j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z�#aeoC^Zl?V��6VsiZ^*i`acdbrD^`_wap\ [e\6�G_w^`i±^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?��[e\6�G�cVX\DVsWk[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\Gq6VXW�oQacW`Y [e\6j<Vc�*�l?V �6WZi`^/^`lDWZVXV¾�6[eWy�cWk[eqDlDiG_w\ TS_w�prDWZV .c. j<apY/q6[eWZV/^`lDVn[¨�pVXWk[e�cV�\DVX^��+acW`� i`_b�XVMY/V¨[�iZr?WZV��A[�^G^ZlDV

� ���� ^`lM�cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\S�Q*�lDV#j<apWZWZVsiZq4ac\6�I_b\D�ÌdwV¨[�WZ\?_w\?�/[�\6�Ì�cVX\?VXWk[edw_b��[e^Z_bac\�q4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvV�a�o±�4ac^`lnYGVX^Zl?a���i

� �

Page 26: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

0.0

50.0

100.0

150.0

200.0

250.0

nu

mb

er

of w

eig

hts

198.3

22.5

F = F_D

F = F_D + F_A

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

nu

mb

er

of u

nits

32.7

4.5

F = F_D

F = F_D + F_A

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

nu

mb

er

of la

ye

rs

4.7

2.1

F = F_D

F = F_D + F_A

85.0

90.0

95.0

100.0

genera

lization a

ccu

racy (

%)

92.5

99.6F = F_D

F = F_D + F_A

85.0

90.0

95.0

100.0tr

ain

ing a

ccura

cy (

%)

93.7

96.9

F = F_D

F = F_D + F_A

0.0

200.0

400.0

600.0

800.0

learn

ing t

ime (

Me

ga

eva

ls) 672.1

193.1

F = F_D

F = F_D + F_A

½8�`¡£§¨®� z« ­c��¡£ z« ³w©v´��<¥z«

§¨�<�c�<¥Z©v³�¡£·v©s J¡£¦��  z¥Z©<¡£�e¡£�c§ ³£�X©X¥z�e¡£�c§y J¡£ª�

T�_b�prDWZV .c. ���2=;? ��8 � B S�=RM'=>P�� J � P�= � ?38RMOD�J NB <�� 8RMOI NB <Z� =R:<�D�=R?=�OF J �RB <CH ��J MO8RF <CH[eWZVy[�dbiZaMj<apY/q6[eWZV��Ì_b\n^`lDVy\DV��D^�^��+a��cWk[eqDlDi¨�3*�lDVyWZVsiZrDdb^Zi�iZl?aR�,^Zl4[�^#[eqDqDdb�I_w\?�/^Zl?V/[c�D[eqD^Z_b�cV3-jXjX[eYYGVX^ZlDaD�[cj`lD_bVX�pVXi8iZ_b�c\?_���jX[�\I^Zdb��4VX^Z^`VXW��cVs\DVXWk[edb_w�¨[�^Z_bap\�q6VsWzoQapWZY [e\6j<Vc�p[�i$�u[ei�V��Dq4V�j<^`V��y�I�^ZlDV+^Zl?VXacW`�#[�\6�dT[�\4�IikjX[eq6V/[e\6[�db�IiZ_bi¨� � l?VXWZV�[ei#^`lDVyiZapdbrD^Z_bac\¾iZ_b�XVG_b\ ^ZlDVy�6[eiZVXdb_b\DVyYGVX^ZlDaD�¾_b\6j<W`V�[�i`V�� ��_b^`lDacrD^2�6aprD\6���j<ap\I^ZWZapdbdw_b\D�2^ZlDVQ-ÇjsjX[�YOo [cjv^ZacW*[eiu��VXikj<W`_b�6V�� _w\G^ZlDVdT[�i`^±i`V�j<^`_wap\Mj<acrDdT�GqDW`rD\DV_b\DVXiZi`VX\I^Z_T[�d�i`rD�Di`^ZWZr4j<^ZrDW`VXi^`aÇ�pVX^+q6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\D_bacrDiSiZacdbrD^`_bac\Di8�DrD^W��_b^ZlDaprD^8dbaciZ_b\D�^`lDV*^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�q4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvVc�6%z^�_wi�_w\I^`VXWZVXi`^Z_b\D��^Za�\?ac^ZV^`l6[�^8^Zl?V�VX�capdwr?^Z_bac\5��_b^Zl3-ÇjsjX[�Y V i�f�[��XapWÅ[pj`lD_bVX�cV����4VX^`^ZVXW+dbV�[�W`\D_b\D�q6VXW�oQacW`Y [e\6j<V�^Zl4[�\5��_w^`lDacr?^C_b^¨�6*�lD_bi_bi�6V¨jX[�rDi`V/^`lDV/i`V�[�W<jZl ��_b^`l¿j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z�Gq6Vs\6[�db^z�ÌoQaDj<rDiZVsi#YGacWZV2ac\¿[GiZY�[�dbdbVXW*i`V�[�W<jZl iZq6[pj<V3��lD_bdbVy^ZlDVi`V�[�W<jZl4��_b^ZlDaprD^�_b^±Y�[¨�V��DqDdbacWZV�^ZaIa�dÍ[eWZ�pV*[iZq6[pj<V^Za��4V*q?Wk[cjv^Z_TjX[�dz��tI_b\6jvV*^Zl?V*VX�pacdbrD^Z_bap\y^Z_bY/V+_bi�db_wYG_b^ZV��^`a�^ZlDV�Y [A��_bY�rDY a�o � ���� �cVs\DVXWk[e^Z_bac\?i��IrDi`_w\?� -jXjX[�Y V i±f*[e�XacW±js[�\5�6\6�G[iZapdbrD^Z_bac\2o [eiZ^ZVsW±^`l6[�\4��_w^`lDacr?^_b^��

� V�[edwi`ayY/V�[eiZrDW`V���^`lDV#j<ap\��pVXWZ�pVX\6j<V�^Z_bYGVÇ^`aydba�js[�d�YG_b\D_bY/[*r?qM^Za � ���� �pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\Di��4_z� Vc�+^ZlDV2^Zac^<[�ddbV�[eWZ\D_b\D�^Z_bYGV�rD\I^Z_bdD^`lDV*�pVX\DVXW<[�^Z_bap\�oQWZapY ��lD_Tj`ly^ZlDVsWZV*_bi�\?a�_bY/qDW`a��cVXYGVX\I^�_w\�^Zl?V*iZ_b�XV[�\6�2q4VXWzoQapWZY�[�\6j<V

��

Page 27: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

aeo6^ZlDV��4VXi`^±_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[ed ��TS_b�crDW`V .p. iZlDaR��i�^`lDV*j<ap\��pVXWZ�pVX\6j<V�^Z_bY/V+[�i8Y/V�[eiZrDW`V��2_w\�Y/_bdbdb_bac\Di4a�o�VX�c[�dbr6[e^Z_bac\?iaeou[�W`_w^`lDY/Vs^Z_Tj�acq4VXWk[e^Z_bac\Di�[eiZiZaDj<_T[e^ZV��#��_b^ZlnjX[edTj<rDdT[�^`_w\?� [cjv^Z_b�c[�^`_wap\��c[�dbrDVXi�a�o±\DVsrDWk[ed�rD\D_b^Zi¨��m+acYGq6[�W`V����_b^ZlÌ^ZlDVyi`^k[�\4�D[�W<�¾Y/VX^`lDaD���4^ZlDV/[p�D[�qD^`_b�cV -jXjX[eY(Y/VX^`lDaD�Mj<ac\I�pVXWZ�pV��¾Y/apWZV�^`l6[�\¾^ZlDW`VXVy^Z_bYGVXi�o [�i`^ZVXWoQapW±^`lD_bi�qDWZap�DdbVXYn�

� � ��C�� �8��� y�

*�lDVyYG_b\D_bY#rDY �IVXikjvWZ_bqD^Z_bap\¿dbVX\D�p^Zl qDW`_w\4j<_bqDdbV#l6[ei#[�dbi`a �4VXVX\ rDiZV¨� _b\nap^ZlDVsW#^`WZVXV<�z�6[eiZV�� dwV¨[�WZ\?_w\?�n[�db�cae�W`_w^`lDY/i�i`r6j`l�[eiCm+�f$*¿xz~�W`VX_bY [e\�VX^�[�dz�b� .���� �I}�[�\6� %Z|Ç�Âx���rD_b\DdT[�\�[�\6��fh_b�cVXi`^�� .����� }s�6T?acW�^`lDV+_w\4�Ir6j<^`_wap\aeoCq6[eWZiZ_bYGac\D_bacr?i±�IV�j<_bi`_wap\�^ZWZVsVXi��4�4ac^ZlMm+�f$*�[�\4��%Z|�2rDiZV�[�^��±a�iZ^`VXqMqDW`a�jvVXiZi¨�2%z\�^`lDVQ�6W`iZ^�iZ^`VXq��4^ZW`VXVi`_w�sV/ac\?dw�¾�cW`aR��i#�I�¾iZ^<[�WZ^`_b\D�'��_b^`l¿[Mi`_w\?�cdbVydbV�[¨o*\DaD�IVM[e\6�¾V��Dq6[�\4�I_b\D�n^`lDV/dbV�[Ño*\DaD�IVXiyrD\I^`_wd+^Zl?V/^ZW`VXVq4VXWzoJV�j<^Zdb��j<dT[�iZi`_��6VXi�^Zl?V��c_b�cVs\/^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D��i`VX^*apW±r?\�^`_bd4oQrDWZ^`lDVXW��pWZaR��_b\D��_bi�_bY/q4aci`iZ_b�DdbVc��|�rDW`_w\?�#^`lDViZV�j<ap\6�i`^ZVXq��p^Zl?V�^ZWZVsV�_wi�WZVXq4V�[�^`V��Idb��qDWZrD\?V����6[cj`���I��WZVXq?dÍ[pj<_b\D���IV�j<_bi`_wap\/xJ\Dac\I^`VXWZYG_w\4[�dT}�\DaD�IVsi��I��dbV�[¨�cVXi¨����l?VX\I�VX�pVXW*^`lDV�^`ac^k[ed��IVXi<j<WZ_bqD^`_wap\MdbVX\D�p^ZlM_bi�WZV¨�Ir6j<V����7*�lDV�^`ac^k[edC�IVsikj<W`_wq?^Z_bac\MdbVX\?�c^Zl�_bi*�IV��4\DV��¾[�i�^Zl?V�iZrDY aeo^`lDV#^`WZVXVyj<aD�I_b\D��dbVX\D�p^Zln[e\6��^Zl?V#VXW`WZapW#j<aD�I_b\D�/dbVX\?�c^Zl¾_b\M�D_b^Zi¨�Ç]hac^`V#^`l6[�^_b\M^Zl?_wi^��+a/i`^ZVXq¾_b\6�Ir6j<^`_bac\��^`lDVy^ZW`VXV j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��_biÂjvac\Di`_Í��VXWZV�� ac\Ddb�M_b\¾^ZlDVGqDWZr?\D_b\D��qDl6[�i`Vc�4*�lD_bi�_biÇV�1cr?_w�c[edbVX\I^Ç^`an[GiZ^`Wk[�^`VX�c� aeo�6W`iZ^�W`V��Ir6j<_b\D�G^ZlDVVXW`WZapWÇ[�\4�/^`lDVX\�WZV¨�Ir6j<_b\D�G^ZlDV�j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z���-�\DV+oJrD\6�D[eY/VX\I^k[ed��I_ ��VXWZVs\6j<V�6Vs^��±VXVs\y^ZlDV��pVX\DVX^`_Íj+q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_b\D��[�q?qDWZaI[cj`l/xJ_b\6j<dbr6�I_b\D�acr?WCYGVX^Zl?a��?}

[e\6�j<ac\I�cVs\�^`_bac\6[edc^ZW`VXV<�z_b\6�Ir6j<^`_bac\�Y/VX^`lDaD�Ii�_bi�^Zl4[�^C[hq6apqDrDdT[�^`_bac\*aeo6^ZW`VXVXi8_bi�rDi`V��2_w\?iZ^ZV¨[c�aeo?[hiZ_b\D�pdwV8^`WZVXVc�%z\ ^`lDV/�pVX\DVX^`_Íj"qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_£\D��[�qDq?WZa�[pj`l���q?WZrD\D_b\D�¾[�\6�¾�pWZaR��_b\D�n[eWZVy_b\I^ZVXW`dwV¨[¨�cV�� �IrDWZ_b\D�Ì^ZlDVGdwV¨[�WZ\?_w\?�qDW`aDj<VXiZi¨��*�l?_wi�_bi�qDWZ_bY [eWZ_bdb����ac\DV��I�G^ZlDVyj<WZapiZi`a��cVXWacq4VXW<[�^ZapW�����lD_Tj`l��cVX\DVsWk[�^`VXi\DV��°^ZWZVsVXi^Zl6[e^ÇjX[e\M�6VdT[�W`�cVXW+acW�i`Y [edwdbVXW+^Zl4[�\/^`lDVX_bW*q4[�WZVs\�^`i��%z�4[ J"< 8RFK� l6[¨�cVGrDiZV�� ^`lDV {M|Q qDWZ_b\6jv_wq?dwVG_b\ �cVX\DVs^Z_TjGqDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D�G^Za¾VX�capdw�pV/U�{M| � \DVX^��+acWZ�Ii

x %z�c[��IlD\DVX\?�ca6� .�� � . }�[e\6� �IV�j<_bi`_wap\¿^`WZVXVXiÌxE%z�6[ÌVX^y[�dz�b� .��� � %z�4[MVX^y[�dz�b� .��� �I}X�M��i#_b\�%Z|Ç�?�8^ZlDV�j<aD�IVdbVX\D�p^ZlÌx m7 �}+_bi*�IV"�6\DV��M[ei�^ZlDV2^Zac^<[�d�i`rDY aeoÅ�IVsikj<W`_wq?^Z_bac\�dbVX\D�p^ZlDi¨�

� � NZx � } � � x�6 � ��N } %�� x ��N }M" x �?. }

��lDVsWZV � x �N }*_bi^Zl?V/�IVXikjvWZ_bqD^Z_bap\ndbVX\D�p^ZlÌoQacW^`lDV#^`WZVXV �N [e\6� � x�6 � �N }�_bi^ZlDVyj<aD�I_b\D��dbVX\D�c^`lMoJacW^ZlDVj<dT[eiZiZ_��gjs[�^Z_bap\ VXWZW`acWya�o*^`lDV�^ZW`VXVGoQacW�^ZlDVG^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�Mi`VX^�6�� *�lDV��IVXikjvWZ_bqD^Z_bap\ dbVX\?�c^Zl?i�[eWZV ��V��6\DV�����_b^Zl

� �

Page 28: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

W`VXiZq4V�j<^�^Zan[Gi`q6V�jv_���jyVX\6jva���_w\?�Mikj`lDVXYGV/j`lDaci`VX\ �I�M^ZlDV�[�rD^`lDacW¨�/|�rDV�^ZaM^`lDVyrD\D�I\DaR��\¾Wk[e\D�cV H a�o�^ZlDV^`ac^k[ed±j<aD�I_b\D��dbVX\D�p^Zl��8[GikjX[edw_b\D� ��_b\6�IaR�°a�o�iZ_b�XV � � N

�� _bi�rDiZV¨�¾^Zan�IVs^ZVXW`Y/_b\DVy[�\DacW`Y [edw_b��[e^Z_bac\Go [pj<^ZapW��

� � ��� �Dx � }X� � � �����?x � }�_bi*�IV��6\?V��n[ei�^ZlDV2dÍ[eWZ�pVXiZ^j<aD�IV�dbVX\D�p^ZlM�IrDW`_w\?�y^ZlDV�dT[eiZ^ � � N � �*�pVX\DVXW<[�^`_wap\Di��W*�lDV�6^`\DVXi`i*�c[�dbrDV�a�o8^ZlDV�^`WZVXV2_wi�^`lDVX\M�IV��4\DV��M[ei

� N�x � } � � � ��� � x � } 1 � � NZx � }M$ x �� }

]hac^`_ÍjvV*^Zl4[�^+^ZlDV0�6^Z\DVsiZi�_biu��V��6\DV��"lDVXW`VÂ[ei±i`_bY/qDdb��^`lDV*i`rDY a�o�VXW`WZacW*[e\6�/jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z��j<apiZ^Zi¨�IoQapdbdwaR�+V���I�#[�\DapWZY [edb_w�¨[�^Z_bap\Çaeog^`lDV�^Zap^k[ed6j<aci`^Zi¨�$*�lDVXWZVvoQacW`Vc�I^ZlDV*jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z���c[�dbrDV � x ��N }�_bi±[ei8_wYGq6apWZ^<[�\I^C[ei�^ZlDVVXW`WZapW*�c[�dbrDV � x�6 � ��N }�_b\M�IVX^`VXWZYG_b\D_b\D�y^ZlDV2^Zac^<[�d �6^`\DVXiZi�c[edwr?VÇaeo±[�\M_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[ed � *�lD_bi7�±apWZ�Ii*q4VXW�oQV�j<^`dw���lDVs\/^Zl?VÇj<aD�I_b\D��ikj`lDVXYGV*V��6[pj<^Zdb�yWZV"/6V�j<^`i*^Zl?VÇ^`WZrDV�qDWZap�6[��?_wdb_b^z�y�I_biZ^ZW`_b�DrD^Z_bap\ya�o�^Zl?VÇVs\��I_bWZap\DY/Vs\�^¨�6-�\DVq4aci`iZ_b�DdbV*�IWk[����4[cj`�#_b\�^ZlD_bi+_bY/qDdbVXYyVX\I^<[�^Z_bap\Çaeo�^ZlDV*{Ì|U qDWZ_b\6j<_bqDdbV�_b\y�cVs\DVX^Z_TjhqDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D��_bi�^`lDV*dT[cj`�aeo2/6V"��_b�D_bdb_b^z�M_b\n�4[�dT[�\6jv_w\?� [pjXj<rDW<[cj<����_b^Zl¾q6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\��Ì_w\¾rD\D�I\DaR��\ Vs\��I_bWZap\DY/Vs\�^`i��4*�l6[�^2_wi¨�8^ZlDVsWZV/_bi[GWZ_bi`� ^Zl6[e^�^ZlDVG\DVX^��+acW`�ni`_w�sV/Y [¨���4V/q4VX\6[edw_b�XV¨�¾^ZaIaMYyr6j`l��SWZVXi`rDdb^Z_b\D�M_b\ qDW`VXY [e^ZrDW`V/j<ac\I�pVXWZ�pVX\6j<V�_b\i`qD_b^ZVya�o�ac^`lDVXWy�I_b�cVXW`iZ_b^z�p� _b\6jvWZV�[eiZ_b\D�MYGV�[�i`rDWZVXi¨�8iZr6j`l¿[ei#[�dT[�W`�cV/j<W`aciZi`a��cVXW�Wk[e^ZVc� %z\¾oz[cj<^¨��^`lDV [erD^ZlDapWZiW`VXY [eWZ��^Zl6[e^�^ZlD_bi+��_b\6�GaeoC{M|Q [�qDqDW`a�[pjZlGiZlDaprDdT�G�6VrDi`V���jX[�W`V<oQrDdbdb�3��lDVX\�VX�pacdb�I_w\?�#�pVX\DVXW<[�d�qDW`ac�cW<[�YGi��_b^ZlG�cVX\?VX^Z_TjqDW`ac�pWk[�YGY/_b\D�2xE%z�6[�VX^[�dz�b� .���� ��}X��]hac^`VÂ[edbiZa�^Zl6[e^�^ZlD_bi*i`^ZW<[�^ZVs�c�/_bi+o [eW+oQWZapY�^Zl?V�^��±a�iZ^`VXq[eqDqDWZaI[cj`l/aeoN%Z|Ç�?�c^<[��pVX\�^ZayVX\Di`rDWZV�q6[eWZiZ_bYGac\D_bacr?i�iZapdwr?^Z_bac\DiW��_b^ZlDaprD^�dbaci`_w\?���caIaD�Gq6VXW�oQacW`Y [e\6j<Vc�)ÅWZVXY�[�^Zr?WZVMj<ac\I�pVXWZ�pVX\6j<V¾_b\¿^Zl?V ��_wW`V�j<^�{M|Q [�qDqDW`a�[pjZlAjX[�\A�4Vn[¨�cap_T�IV�� �I� _b\I^ZW`a���r6j<_b\D�¿[ÌiZY [edbd

-jXjX[eY�oz[cj<^`acW � x � }X�� N x � } � � N x � } %�� x � } � N x � }M" x � �c}

��lDVsWZV � N�x � }2[�\6� � NZx � }[�W`Vy^ZlDVyVsWZWZapW#[�\4�nj<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�/�c[edbrDVXi\DacW`Y [edw_b�XV¨��iZVXq4[�Wk[e^ZVXdb�I��[�\4� � x � }�_wi�[j<ap\DiZ^<[�\I^�V��DqDW`VXiZi`V��/[ei±[hoQrD\6jv^Z_bac\�a�o�^ZlDV�^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?�Çi`VX^�i`_w�sV�x-,4l4[�\D��[�\4�y{ �rDlDdbVX\I�4VX_b\�� .��� �p[ ,4l6[e\D��[�\6�{��r?lDdbVX\I�6VX_b\�� .���� �e�6}X�0%z\M^ZlD_bi�{M|Q ¿[eqDqDW`a�[cj`l��4^`lDV�jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�/j<apiZ^_b\�/6rDVs\6j<VXi�^`lDV�i`VXdbV�j<^Z_bap\nqDW`aDj<VXiZiap\Ddb�'��lDVs\¿^Zl?V jX[e\6�I_T�D[�^`VXi�oQapW�iZVXdbV�jv^Z_bac\Al6[¨�pV j<apY/q6[eWk[��?dwV�q4VXWzoQapWZY�[�\6j<Vp�'*�l4[�^�_wi¨��[M^`WZVXV ��_b\Di�^ZlDVi`VXdbV�j<^Z_bap\¿ac\?dw�¾_ o*_b^Zi�VXWZW`acWy_bi�iZY�[�dbdbVXW^Zl6[e\¿^`l6[�^�a�o*_b^Ziyj<apY/q4VX^Z_b^ZapWZi¨�8acW�_w^`i#VsWZWZapW#_bi�^ZlDVGik[eY/V/[�i�_b^Zij<apY/q4VX^Z_b^`acWZi�Dr?^#_b^Zi2iZ_b�XV/_bi�iZY�[�dbdbVXW��/]hac^`V/^Zl4[�^�^`lD_bi#_bi#[e\ VX�capdwr?^Z_bac\6[eWZ�MV�1cr?_w�c[edbVX\I^�a�o�^ZlDVGiZ^`Wk[�^`VX�c�aeo2�6W`iZ^�WZV���r6j<_b\D�M^`lDV/VXW`WZapW�[e\6�¾^ZlDVs\ WZV��Ir4j<_b\D�n^`lDV/j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z��� � �Dq6VXW`_bY/VX\I^k[ed8VX�I_Í��VX\6j<V�iZl?aR��i�^ZlD_bi� Þ�AcâÅã à<åWPsâ�ß Y7FIAcâNLZß�J¨ä�åWP8ö£âzåWP\FA T<à<ãJä£âHD�Y ã ß�� �� FJß � J�RcâNFQß�FAcâ RWDQâ8ß YIö£ßEPXàvãQäKFIA � DIä�å LZà<öKL�R�ö£àEFÏä�åWP FIAcâSö£âzåWPEFIA�ä�åB�äKFZDZ÷

��

Page 29: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

YGVX^ZlDaD�_bi�W`ac�Dr?iZ^±[e\6��V���V�j<^Z_b�pV�oQapW±[+��_Í��V*j<dT[�iZi�a�o�^k[�i`�Ii�� � aR�+VX�pVXW��p^ZlD_bi��4[�dT[�\6jv_w\?�ÇYGV�j`l6[�\?_wi`Y _bi��cVXW`�j<ap\DiZVsWZ�c[�^`_b�cVÇ[e\6��jX[�\GiZ^`_wdbd��4ViZq4VXV��IV�� rDq����yY�[��I_b\D�^ZlDV�j<ap\I^ZWZapd�a�o8^ZlDV -jXjX[eY�o [pj<^ZapW±YGacW`V7/6V��D_b�DdbVc�*�l?Vu[p�D[�qD^`_b�cV7-ÇjsjX[�Y°Y/VX^`lDaD���IVXi<j<WZ_b�4V��y_b\�^`lDV�qDWZVsiZVX\I^�q6[eq6VsW�_bY/qDW`a��cVXi�^`lDVW���DV��5-ÇjsjX[�Y [�qDqDW`a�[pjZl

�I� j`l6[e\D�c_b\D�y^`lDV�Wk[�^`_baya�o�VXWZW`acW^Za/jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�y_b\M^`lDV#j<aprDWZi`V#aeoÅ^`lDV�WZrD\��0%z\MV�[�W`db�/iZ^<[��pVXia�o�dbV�[�W`\D_b\D�6�[�i`^ZWZap\D��_b\6j<WZV¨[�iZV�_b\�^ZWZVsV/j<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z�y_bi[�dbdbaR�±V��G�I�/�pVXVXqD_b\D�G^ZlDV3-jXjX[eY o [cj<^`acW�iZY [edbd ����l?_Íj`lMr?iZr6[edwdb�W`VXiZrDdb^`iÇ_b\�oz[�iZ^�VXWZW`acW�W`V��Ir6jv^Z_bac\��Q*�l?V#i`Y [�dbd6-jXjX[eY o [pj<^ZapW�[�dbiZayW`VXiZrDdb^`i�_b\MWZap�DrDiZ^�j<ap\I�cVXW`�cVX\6jvVy^Za�^ZlDV�IVsiZ_bWZV��¾^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?� [pjXj<rDW<[cj<�I�8iZ_b\6jvVyqDWZVXY�[�^`rDWZV/j<ap\I�cVXW`�cVX\6jvV/_bi#[¨�cap_T�IV��¾�IrDVy^Za�_b\6j<W`V�[�i`V��¿��_w�pVXWZi`_b^z���3%z\dT[�^`VXWiZ^<[��cVsi���_z� Vc�b��[¨oQ^`VXW^ZlDV/�IVsiZ_bWZV��¾dbVX�pVXd�aeo±^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�/q4VXW�oQacW`Y [�\4j<V#_bi[cj`lD_bVX�cV¨����^`lDVy[c�D[eqD^Z_b�cV3-jXjX[eY[eqDqDWZaI[cj`l¿Vs\IoQacW<j<VXi�[¾iZ^ZW`ac\D� j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�nq4VX\6[edb^z��� ��lD_TjZlAVX\4j<acrDW<[��pVXi/q6[eWZi`_wYGac\I�I�'-��cVXW<[�dbdz��^`lD_biyl6[�i^`lDV#V �gV�jv^#aeou_b\6j<W`V�[�i`_b\D���cVX\DVsWk[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\¾q6VsWzoQapWZY [e\6j<V5��_b^ZlDaprD^�cVX^`^Z_b\D��iZ^`r6j`�n_b\¾dwaDjX[ed8Y/_b\D_bY [��IrDV�^ZaqDW`VXY [e^ZrDW`V�jvac\I�cVXW`�cVX\4j<Vc�3*�lDVyj<ap\�^`WZapd�a�o�^ZlDV�qDl6[eiZVy^`Wk[�\?iZ_b^Z_bac\¾_bi*\Dap^��I_� j<rDdb^iZ_b\6j<Vy_b^*_bi��IV��4\DV��¾�I�^`lDV/�IVXi`_wW`V��¾^ZW<[�_b\D_b\D�M[cjsj<rDWk[pj<� ��lD_Tj`ln^`lDVyrDi`VXW#W`V�1prD_bWZVXi¨��*�l?acrD�pl ac^Zl?VXW#{M|Q 4�z�6[eiZV��¾^`WZVXVG_w\4�Ir6j<^`_wap\YGVX^ZlDaD�Ii*[edbiZayWZV �u[eWk�Ìq6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\��I�p^ZlDV#[p�D[�q?^Z_b�cV -jXjs[�Y [�q?qDWZaI[cj`lM_bi*�I_ �gVsWZVX\I^_b\M^Zl6[e^*_b^*�I�I\6[eY/_TjX[�dbdb��6[edT[�\6j<Vsi�VXWZW`acWÇ[e\6�/jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�yj<aci`^Zi¨�

� lD_bdwV�qDWZapq6apiZV��G_b\ [��I_ ��VXWZVX\I^*j<ap\I^ZV��D^��?^ZlDV�[p�D[�qD^`_b�cV7�4^Z\DVXi`i+oQrD\6jv^Z_bac\GqDWZVXi`VX\I^ZV��Ì_b\/^`lD_bi±q6[eq6VsW�l6[�ii`acY/V2iZ_bY/_bdT[�W`_w^z�y_b\Mi`qD_bWZ_b^^Za D�=R?=� J"<�B <CBI�AJ0K$<CM�J�S�S7P�:�MOD�<�BE=;M�S�xQ��\D�cVsdw_b\DV/[e\6� )SacdbdT[cj`��� .��� �c}s�#tI^<[�\6�?[�Wk��6^`\DVXi`ioQrD\6jv^Z_bac\Di2WZVX^`rDWZ\ ^ZlDVyi<[�Y/V �6^Z\DVsiZi2oQacW#[e\n_b\6��_w�I_T�Ir6[ed�W`VX��[eWk�IdbVXi`i#aeo ��l6[e^ac^Zl?VXW�Y/VsYy�6VXW`i�[�WZVqDW`VXiZVs\�^_b\M^`lDV�q4acqDrDdT[e^Z_bac\��4�IVXY�[�\6�I_b\D�y[�\¾[cjXj<r?Wk[�^`V�[e\6�Mj<ap\DiZ_bi`^ZVX\I^+�6^Z\?VXiZi�YGV�[�i`rDWZV2^ZlDW`acrD�plDacrD^�^ZlDVVX�pacdbrD^`_wap\6[�W`�/qDW`aDj<VXiZi¨� � lD_bdbV^ZlDV��cdbac�4[�d�[cjsj<rDWk[pj<�njX[e\n�4V�V�[eiZ_bdb�Mj<acYGqDrD^ZV¨����l?VX\nVs�cacdb�I_b\D�yiZapdbrD^Z_bac\?ioQapWY [�\I�GiZ_bY/qDdbV�q?WZac�?dwVsY/i���_w^_bi�aeoQ^ZVX\¾_bY/qDW<[cj<^`_TjX[�dSoQapWÇq?WZac�?dwVsY/i���_b^`ln�pWZV�[e^ZVXWyj<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z��� %z\ j<ap\I�^`Wk[�i`^��+j<acYGq6VX^`_b^Z_b�cV5�6^`\DVXi`i�oQrD\6j<^`_bac\Di�VX�c[�dbr6[e^ZVG^ZlDV �6^Z\DVsiZi/�c[edbrDVXi#�IVsq6VX\4�I_b\D� ac\ ^ZlDV�j<ac\Di`^Z_b^Zr?VX\I^Zi/aeo^`lDVq6apqDrDdT[�^`_wap\�����\D�cVXdb_b\DV[�WZ�prDVXi�^`l6[�^*j<apY/q4VX^Z_b^`_w�pVW�6^Z\?VXiZihoQrD\6j<^`_bac\Di+qDWZa��I_T�IV�[2Y/acW`V�WZap�DrDiZ^�^`Wk[e_w\?_w\?�VX\I�I_bWZap\DY/VX\I^�^`l6[�\�_b\6�IVsq6VX\4�IVX\I^7�6^`\DVXi`i*oJrD\6j<^`_wap\Di��� �6\6[�d+j<acYGY/VX\I^�_bi_w\¾acW<�IVXW�ac\¾^ZlDV/[eqDqDdb_TjX[��?_wdb_b^z�/aeou^`lD_bi#[�q?qDWZaI[cj`ln^`aM^Zl?VyY/acW`V��cVs\DVXWk[edujvdÍ[eiZi`VXi

aeo*qDWZap�cWk[eY/i^Zl4[�^yjX[�\ �6V��IVX�cVsdwapq6V¨� �I�n�pVX\DVX^`_Tj/q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_ \D�6� *�lDV��cVX\DVsWk[�d+Y/Vs^ZlDaD�¾a�o*�4[�dT[�\6jv_w\?�[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�n[e\6�Ìq6[�W`iZ_bY/ap\��/js[�\¾�6VyrDi`V�� oQacW^Zl?V#�pVX\DVX^`_Íj2_b\6�Ir6jv^Z_bac\Maeouap^ZlDVsWÂjvdÍ[eiZi`VXi�a�o+^ZWZVsV<� i`^ZW`r6j<^Zr?WZV��qDW`ac�pWk[�YGig[ei6�+VXdbdz��*�lD_bi�_bi��4V�jX[�r?iZV�^Zl?V�VXWZW`acW�[�\4��j<acYGqDdbV��D_b^z���c[�dbrDVXi�[eWZV�\DapWZY�[�db_b�XV���i`VXq6[eWk[�^`VXdb�#[�\4�^ZlDVi<[�Y/V[c�D[eqD^Z_b�pV*�6[edÍ[e\6j<_b\D��Y/V�j`l6[e\D_biZY�jX[e\ �4V�rDi`V��GoQapWu��_ ��VXW`VX\I^Ç�IV��4\D_b^Z_bac\Di�aeoCVXW`WZapWÇ[�\4� jvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�I�

��

Page 30: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

� �� "� ���� ��� y�

� VGl6[¨�cV�_b\I�cVXi`^Z_b��[e^ZV�� ^ZlDVM^`lDVXapWZVX^`_Íjs[�d*W`VXdT[�^`_wap\DiZl?_wqA�4VX^��+VXVX\ ^`lDVMj<acYGqDdbV��D_w^z�¾a�o#[ÌiZapdwr?^Z_bac\A[�\6� _b^Zi�pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\n[��?_wdb_b^z�/_b\M�pVX\DVX^`_Tj�qDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_w\?�D���*\ [�\6[edb��i`_biÇaeo±^Zl?V �6^`\DVXi`i#dT[�\4�IikjX[eq6V5��[�iY [p�IV�_b\^`lDVnj<ap\�^`V��D^/aeoÂ_b\IoJVXWZW`_w\?� iZ_b�cY�[¨�zqD_�\DVXr?Wk[�d\DVs^��±apWZ�IiyoQW`acY �D[�^<[D� *�lDVnj<apY/q6[eWZ_biZap\¿a�o�dbV�[eWZ\D_b\D� [�\6��pVX\DVXW<[�db_b��[�^`_wap\¿q4VXWzoJacWZY�[�\6jvV [ei�[ÌoJrD\6j<^`_wap\Aa�oÇ\?VX^��±apWZ� iZ_b�XV�iZrD�p�cVXi`^Zi�^Zl?V V �gV�jv^Z_b�cVX\?VXiZiMaeoÇYG_w\?_wY/[ed��j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�y[�qDqDW`a�[pjZl?VXi��

� Vyq?WZVXi`VX\I^ZV�� [�\¿[c�?[�qD^`_w�pV#YGVX^Zl?a��Ì^Zl4[�^�ap�D^k[e_w\?iÇq4[�WZi`_bY/ac\?_waprDi*i`acdbrD^`_wap\DiQ��lD_bdbVy�crDW<[�\I^ZVXVs_w\?�M^ZlDVi`q6V�jv_��4V�� YG_w\?_wY�[¨d�^`Wk[�_b\D_b\D�M[pjXj<rDW<[cj<� ��_b^Zl¿[ lD_b�cl qDW`ac�6[e�D_bdw_b^z�I�5*�lDV/YGVX^ZlDaD�Ì_bY/qDdbVXYGVX\I^ZiÇ[ ��_b\6�¾aeo�I�I\6[eY/_Tj2iZV�[eWkj`l ��lDVXW`V�^ZlDVGoQaDj<rDiyaeoÂ[e^Z^ZVs\�^`_bac\ ��VXq6Vs\6�Ii/ap\¿^`lDV�iZ^ZW`r6j<^`rDWZVMaeoÇ^`lDVMj<rDWZW`VX\I^ [e\6� q6[eiZ^�6^`\DVXi`i#dT[�\4�IikjX[eq6Vsi���_z� Vc�b�S^ZlDV/�I_bi`^ZWZ_b�Dr?^Z_bac\ aeo*VXWZW`acWy[�\6� j<apY/qDdbV��D_b^z�Maeou^`lDV/_b\6�I_b�I_T�Ir6[edwi_b\ ^Zl?V/WZV¨j<VX\I^q4acqDr?dÍ[e^Z_bac\?i�� � l?VXWZV�[ei�qDW`rD\D_b\D�/_bi[�d �u[¨�Ii�VX\6j<aprDWk[e�cV��Ì�I� ^`lDV�\Dac\I�z�XVXW`a -ÇjsjX[�Y o [cj<^`acW¨��^ZlDVy[c�?[�qD^`_w�pV�6^`\DVXi`i�oQrD\4j<^Z_bac\GiZ_bYyrDdb^k[e\DVXaprDiZdb��qDWZapY/ac^`VXi+�cWZaR��_b\D��_ oC_b^�_bi�\DV�j<VsiZik[eWZ�GoQapW�iZ_b�c\D_��gjs[�\I^±VsWZWZapW*W`V��Ir6j<^`_bac\��*�l?acrD�pl�acrDWSV��Dq6VsWZ_bY/VX\I^`i �+VXW`V±q4VXWzoJacWZYGV��_b\�^`lDV±j<ap\�^`V��D^8a�o6\DVsrDWk[ed�\?VX^��±apWZ��i`�I\�^`lDVXi`_wi¨��^Zl?V±rD\4�IVXWZdb�p�

_b\D��qDWZ_b\6j<_bqDdbV+a�o��6[�dT[e\6j<_b\D�Ç[pjXj<rDW<[cj<�3��_b^`l#q6[eWZi`_wYGac\I�Ç[eqDqDdb_bVXi8^Za�[�dbdI�cVs\DVX^Z_TjhqDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D��[�qDq?dw_TjX[e^Z_bac\?i_b\ ��lD_Tj`lM^`lDVyiZ^`WZr6j<^`rDWk[edujvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�I�D[�iQ�+VXdbdÅ[ei^ZlDV�iZ^`WZr6j<^`rDWZVsi#^`lDVXY/i`VXdb�cVXi¨��iZl?acrDdT�Ì�6V�acqD^`_bY/_b�XV��Gac\^`lDV�6[�i`_wi�aeoC\Dap_biZ�/apW�_b\6j<acYGqDdbVX^ZV*�?[�^k[?�

�(����� ��(��'�M��'�� '���)

*�lD_bi�W`VXiZV¨[�Wkj`l ��[�i�iZrDqDq4acW`^ZV�� _b\ q6[eWZ^����¾^Zl?V f�V¨[�d � � apWZdT�¾m+acY/q?rD^Z_b\D� )8WZap�cWk[eY(rD\6�IVXWy^`lDV/q?WZa��<V¨j<^t�% T -U�#� � V�^Zl6[e\D�n{M[eWZ�nfh_w\?�6�����rDWZ�pVX\¿~�Vs\6�I_bikj`l��8UVXW<� )C[p[��4�g[e\6�¾|*_bW`�ntDj`lDdb_bVXWZ�c[eY/qI����aIaci`VX\GoQacWlDVsdwq�oQrDd��I_bikjvrDiZi`_wap\Di��

' �c'��'2� ��'�

��Y [�W`_z�Ñt�� ��%X�?x .���D. }X��|�r6[�db_biZ^`_Íj+�pVXacYGVX^ZW`�#aeo�^ZlDVY�[�\D_ oQapdÍ�Âa�o�lD_b�cl?VXWz�zacW<�IVXW+\DVXrDW`ac\Di¨�� J�: � 8;F� J"<�W= � � SX��4� �c���� ��I� . �

��\D�cVXdb_b\DVc�$)8���4��[�\6� )SapdwdT[pjZ�����4��~���x .���� �c}s�/m+acYGq6VX^`_b^Z_b�cV�Vs\��I_bWZap\DY/Vs\�^`iVX�capdw�pVy�6Vs^Z^ZVsW#i`acdbrD^Z_bap\Di�oQacWjvacY/q?dwV"�n^k[eiZ�Ii�� %z\ T?acW`WZVXi`^��+t��b��V���_w^`acW¨��� � =�D�J�J�IRBGM^��S,=�P <���J��NB P�<Z��� M�< J � M�8�<�BE=RMO8;F��2=;M�P�J � J MOD�J =RM��J MOJ"<CBED �QF.��= � B <���? S���� ��� � �������e�?q6[��pVXi ��� �� � � � ��{ acWZ�I[�\ �Ç[erIoQY�[�\D\��ItD[e\ {M[e^ZVXa4�

� �

Page 31: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

~+�[cj`����*���[�\4� t?jZl��+V<oQVXdz� � � � )8�4x .���� �p}X�+�*\Ìa��cVXW`��_bV�� aeo�VX�capdwr?^Z_bac\6[eWZ��[�db�capWZ_b^ZlDYGi8oQapW�q6[�W<[�Y/Vs^ZVXW�acqD^`_£�YG_b��[�^`_wap\��C�U�R=RF�:<�BE=RM�8 � H �2=;? ��:�< 8�<�BE=;MD� . x . }s� . � �D�

~�dbrDY/VXW¨�D���w� � lDWZVs\IoQVXr6j`lI^��S�#�b� � [erDiZi`dbVXW���|��b��[�\6� � [�WZYyr?^Zl��4{ ���#�Sx .���� �c}s� -ÇjsjX[�Y V if*[e�XacW¨� ��M�P�= � �?38�<�BE=;M � � =�D�J�S�S�BGM^� � J"<E< J � SX� � �6���p�c� D� �� �

~�WZVX_bY�[�\��R ��b��T?WZ_bV���Y [�\S� �6� � �b��-�dbiZlDVX\S��f2�����b�c[�\6��tI^`ac\DVc�Im���4�Ix .���� �I}X� �NF 8�S�S�B K2D�8�<�BE=RM�8;MOI�� J�� � J�S�S�BE=RM��� J J"SX� � [c��i �+acWZ^`l %z\�^¨�DUWZaprDq��D~�VXdbY/ap\�^¨��m� ���

m�[eWZ�4ac\DVXdbdz� �6��Uy��x .������ }X�#%z\�^`WZaD�Ir6jv^Z_bac\�� )8[�W<[c�I_b�cYGi�oQacW�Y�[cj`lD_b\DVydbV�[eWZ\D_b\D�4� %z\��'8D ��BGMOJ � J�8 � M�BLM^����78 � 8IRB��R? S 8RM�I��'J"<���=�IASX�Dq6[e�cVXi . � �D{ %�* )8W`VXiZi¨��m�[�Yy�DW`_Í���cVc�

|�rDW`�D_b\��Df��D[e\6�/fhrDY/VXdbl6[eWZ^¨��|�� � ��x .����� }X�$)8WZaD�Ir6jv^*rD\D_b^`i��8�,j<apY/qDrD^<[�^`_wap\6[�dbdb��q4aR�±VsWzoQrDd�[e\6�G�D_bacdbac�e�_TjX[edbdw��qDdT[�r?iZ_b�DdbV*V��D^`VX\DiZ_bap\M^Zay�6[pj`��q?WZacq4[���[e^Z_bac\y\?VX^��±apWZ�Ii�� J : � 8RF �2=;? ��:<>8A<CBE=;MD� . � . �c�� . � � �

T?VXdT�IY [e\�� �6�4���g[e\6�M~+[�dbdT[�W<����|#� � ��x .����� }s�*m+ac\?\DV�j<^`_wap\D_biZ^Y/aD�IVsdwi*[e\6�Ì^ZlDVX_bWqDW`acq4VXWZ^`_wVsi�� �2= �RM�B <�B�AJ��D�BEJ MOD�Js� � � �� � � �e�6�

T?ac�pVXdz�D|#�4~*�Sx .����?. }s�±��\M_b\IoQapWZY [e^Z_bac\/jvWZ_b^ZVXW`_bac\�oQapW�acqD^`_bY [�d4\DVXr?Wk[�d8\DVs^��±apWZ��iZVXdbV�jv^Z_bac\�� � � �M� ��� 8RM�S �8D�<�BE=;M�S =RM J�: � 8;F� J"<�W= � � SX� � x �p}X� � �� I� � �?�

UVsY [�\S�±t��b�*~�_bVX\DVX\Di`^ZaDj`��� � �b�*[e\6� |�acr?WZik[e^��*f2��x .����� }s�,]�VXr?Wk[�d\DVs^��±apWZ�Ii [e\6�A^Zl?Vn�D_T[ei��c[eWZ_T[�\4j<V��_wdbVXYGY/[D� J : � 8;F �2=R?=�O:<>8A<CB =RMD�?�6� . D� � �

U_bdbVXi¨��m�� ��D[e\6�/{M[A���±VXdbdz�*��Dx .���� �c}s�6 �V�[eWZ\D_b\D�4�I_b\��c[eWZ_T[�\4j<Vc�I[�\6�"�cVX\DVsWk[�db_b��[e^Z_bac\y_b\/l?_w�plI�zacWk��VXW±\?VXrDWk[ed\?VX^��±apWZ�Ii���� �W��F�BEJ�I��N�!<CBED"SX� ��� x � �p}X� � � � � �� � � � �

UapdT�I�6VsWZ�6��|�� � �px .������ }X����J MOJ"<CBED �QF.��= � B <���? S2BLM � J�8 � D �����N�!<CBG?5B ��8�<�BE=;M����'8�D � BGMOJ � J�8 � M�BLM^��p��?�I_biZac\� VsiZdbVX�I�

%z�6[?� � �b�8�IV/U�[eWZ_bi�� � �b��[e\6� tD[�^`a6� *��8x .���� ��}X�GUVX\DVX^`_Tj�qDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D�yrDi`_b\D�n[GY/_b\D_bY�rDYÊ��VXikj<W`_bqD^Z_bac\dbVX\?�c^Zl�qDW`_w\4j<_bqDdbVc��%z\@��_b\D\DV�[eW������ � �b��V¨�I_b^ZacW¨� �QI��R8RM�D J"S�BGM �0J MOJ"<CB D�� � = � � 8R?5? BGM �Ñ��q4[��cVsi ��� � �� �4�{ %�* )8WZVsiZi���m�[eYy�DWZ_T�I�pVc��m�[eYy�DWZ_T�I�pVc�

%z�6[?� � �w�N��rDW`_b^k[D�W*��b���IVMU�[eWZ_bi�� � �b�±[e\6�¿tD[e^Za4�N*��+x .���� �c}X�AtI�IiZ^`VXY _Í��VX\I^Z_��gjX[e^Z_bac\ rDiZ_b\D�¾iZ^`WZr6j<^`rDWZV¨��pVX\DVX^`_Tj�[�db�capWZ_b^Zl?Y/i�� %z\ � � =�D�J�J�IRBGM^��S =>PN<Z� J �NB P�<Z� ��M�< J � MO8�<�BE=;MO8RF �2=RM P�J � J�M�D J7=;M ��J�MOJ"<�BED �QF.��= � B <���? S��� ��� � �������e�Iq4[��cVsi � � � ���� �I{�apWZ��[e\,�[�r�oQY [e\D\��

%z�c[e��l?\DVX\D�pa6�����cUy�Ix .�� � . }s�O)Sacdb�I\DacYG_T[�d�^Zl?VXacW`�ya�o�j<acYGqDdbV��#iZ�Ii`^ZVXYGi�� � �M�M� ��� 8;M�S�8�D"<CBE=;M�SU=RM��OH�S�<>J ? S��'8;M�� 8RM�I �NH ��J � MOJ"<CB D�SX� . xQ�I}X��� � �� D�c� � �

� .

Page 32: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

��_b\D\DV�[eW��W�#� � �+x .��� �p}X�¿UVs\DVXWk[edb_w^z� [�\4� ��_ jvrDdb^z�n_b\¿�pVX\DVX^`_Tj/q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_b\D�4� � �capdb��_b\D�¾[Mi`acWZ^¨� %z\T?acW`WZVXi`^��8t��b�4V��I_b^ZapW�� � � =�D�J J�I;BGM^��S@=�P5<Z� J � B P�<�� ��M�< J � MO8�<�BE=RM�8RF �2=;M�P�J � J MOD�J�=RM ��J MOJ"<CBED �QF.��= � B <���? S��� ��� � �������e�Iq4[��cVsi ��� �� �� �6�I{�apWZ��[e\,�[�r�oQY [e\D\��ItD[�\M{M[e^ZVXa4�

��_b\D\DV�[eW������ � �b�IV��I_b^`acWx .���� ��[c}s� �QI��R8RMOD�J"S BLM ��J MOJ"<CBED � � = � � 8;? ?5BGM^���C{ %�* )8WZVsiZi���m�[eYy�DWZ_T�I�pVc�cm�[�Y"��?WZ_T�I�cVp�

��_b\D\DV�[eW������ � �4x .��� �p�6}X�$TS_w^`\DVXi`i*dT[�\6��ikjX[eq6VXi*[e\6���I_� j<rDdb^z�y_b\/�pVX\DVX^`_ÍjÂqDWZap�cWk[eY/YG_£\D�4�O%z\ � � =�D�J�J I;BGM^��S=>P � �M�M� � M�<>J � MO8A<CB =RMO8;F �2=RM�P�J � J MOD�J =;M����A=;F�:<CB =RMO8 � H �2=R?=�O:< 8�<�BE=RM ��� �N���N��� � � ��� = � F I �2=RM^� � J"S�S=;M �2=R?=�O:< 8�<�BE=RM�8RF � M�< J�FGF�B���J�MOD�Js�Iq6[��pVXi . � � . �I�D�c]hV����±apWZ����% ����� m+acYGqDrD^`VXWut�a�jv_wVs^z�,)8W`VXiZi¨�

��ac�¨[D���6�+f���x .����� [p}X� ��J MOJ�<�BED�� � = � � 8R?5?5BGM^� � �7M <Z� J�� � = � � 8;? ?5BGM^�9=>P �2=R?=�O:< J � S � H �'J�8RM�S'=�P 8�<�: � 8RF ��J�F J D"<�BE=RMD��{ %�* )8W`VXiZi¨��m�[�Yy�DW`_Í���cVc�

��ac�¨[D� �6�¨f��¨x .����� �6}s� � _bVXW<[�Wkj`lD_TjX[ed�[erD^ZapY [�^`_Tj4oQrD\4j<^Z_bac\��IV"�6\D_b^Z_bac\_b\�cVX\?VX^Z_Tj8qDW`ac�pWk[�YGY/_b\D�4� %z\ � lD_b^ZdbVX�I�|��b�8V��I_b^`acW�� � � =�D�J�J J�I;BGM^��S,=�P��,= � � S ��= � =;M �6=R:�MOI�8A<CB =RM�S'=�P ��J�MOJ"<�BED �QF �;= � B <Z� ? S 8;MOI �NF 8�S�S�B K2J ���H�S < J ? SX�D{�apWZ��[e\ �Ç[erIoQY�[�\D\��

��ac�¨[D� �6�8f��8x .���� �c}s� tI_bYyrDdb^<[�\DVXaprDiÇ��_wi<j<a��cVsWZ� a�o�WZVsrDik[e�DdbV �IVX^`V�j<^`acWZi/[e\6�¾iZr?�DWZaprD^Z_b\DVXiyr?iZ_b\D���cVX\?VX^Z_Tjq?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_ \D�6� %z\ T?acWZW`VXiZ^¨��t��b��V��I_b^`acW���� � =�D�J�J�IRBGM ��S'=�P4<Z� J��NB P�<Z� ��M�< J � MO8�<�BE=RM�8RF �2=RM P�J � J�M�D J =RM��J MOJ"<CBED �QF.��= � B <���? SX�pq6[��pVXi ��� � D� ��� ��{ acWZ�I[�\ �Ç[erIoQY�[�\D\��

��ac�¨[D���4�Cf2��x .��� ��}s� �0J MOJ"<CB D � � = � � 8R?5? BGM � � � ���Q:<>=;?@8A<CBED��UB S�D�=��RJ � H =�P � J :S 8 ��F J � � = � � 8R? SX��{ %�*)ÅWZVXi`i���m�[�Yy�DW`_T�I�cVc�

{M[e\6�IVXW`_TjZ����~��w���IV � VX�cVXW¨��{ �b�g[e\6�MtIq?_wVsiZiZVs\Di��6)8�Sx .����?. }s�2*�l?V#�pVX\DVX^`_Íj�[�db�pacWZ_b^`lDY [�\4��^ZlDV�iZ^`WZr6jv^ZrDW`Vaeou^`lDV3�4^Z\DVXi`iydT[�\6�Ii<jX[�q4Vc� %z\ � � =�D�J�J�IRBGM ��S,=>P3<Z� J �(=;: � <�� ��M <>J � MO8A<CBE=;MO8RF �2=RM P�J � J�M�D J4=RM ��J�M�J�<�BED�QF �;= � B <Z� ? SX�cq6[e�cVXi . ���� . � � �I{�acW`��[e\,�[�rIoJY [�\?\��

{��r?lDdbVX\I�6VX_b\�� � �?x .���� �c}X� � �capdwr?^Z_bac\6[eWZ�#[edb�cacW`_b^ZlDYGi���*�lDVXapWZ�/[�\4�y[�qDqDdb_TjX[e^Z_bac\Di¨��%z\/�Ç[eWZ^`i�� � � � �� ��I[�\6� �VX\Di`^ZWk[?� �4�O���b�IV��I_b^ZapWZi�� � =�D�8RF � J�8 � D �,BGM �2=;? � BGMO8A<>= � BE8;F��N��<�BG?5B ��8�<�BE=RMD� � _bdbVX�I�

{��r?lDdbVX\I�6VX_b\�� � ��[e\6�¿tDj`lDdb_bVXW`�c[�Y/q�� ��aIapiZVX\��8|��+x .���� �p}X� )ÅWZV��I_Tj<^`_b�cV�Y/aD�IVXdbioJacW�^ZlDV��DW`VXV��IVXWG�cVX\?VX^Z_Tj[edb�cacW`_b^ZlDY.%X�Dm+ac\I^`_w\IrDaprDi+q6[�W<[�Y/Vs^ZVXW�apqD^Z_bY/_b��[e^Z_bac\S�,���A=;F�:<CB =RMO8 � H �2=R?=�O:< 8�<�BE=RMD� . x . }X� � � �� � �

{�r?WZqDlI�I��)8��{ �c[�\4����l6[D�I|�� � �cx .��� ��}s� � mW%�WZVsq6apiZ_b^ZapWZ��a�o�Y [cj`lD_b\DV�dwV¨[�WZ\?_w\?�Ç�D[e^k[��4[�iZVsi���|�VXq6[�W`^ZYGVX\I^aeo %z\IoJacWZY�[�^`_wap\�[e\6��m+acYGqDrD^ZVsWutDjv_wVs\6j<Vc� � \?_w�pVXWZi`_b^z�/a�o�m�[�db_ oQacW`\D_T[D�R%zW`�I_w\?Vc�6m� �#�

]h_wdbi`iZac\S�D]��4x .���� �c}X� � J 8 � M�BGM � �'8�D � BLMOJ�SX�+{MjXUW<[��+� � _wdbdz�I]�V����±acW`���

� �

Page 33: #) G ¾ )+ · 2015. 11. 24. · _b\6[edw_bVX\4[ DdbV j

��rD_b\DdT[�\S� �4��f���[e\6�Mf�_b�pVXiZ^¨��f��� ��Sx .����� }s� %z\IoQVsWZWZ_b\D�M�IV¨j<_biZ_bac\¾^ZW`VXVXi�rDiZ_b\D�G^ZlDVyYG_w\?_wY�rDY ��VXikj<W`_bqD^Z_bac\dbVX\?�c^ZlGqDWZ_b\6jv_wq?dwVp����M�P�= � ?38�<�BE=RM'8;MOI �2=R?=�O:< 8�<�BE=RMD� ��� � �� �� � � � �

fh_wi`ik[e\DVX\����4�Ix .���� ��}X� � \D_b�pVXWZi<[�d6j<aD�I_b\D�4��_b\IoQapWZY [e^Z_bac\S�XqDW`V��I_Tj<^Z_bap\���[e\6�2VXiZ^`_wY�[�^`_wap\�� � �M�M� ��� 8RM S 8D�<�BE=;M�S=;M ��M P�= � ?38�<�BE=;M � � J�= � H��D� � xJ��}s� ���� � � � �

fh_wi`ik[e\DVX\�� �4�4x .����� }X��tI^`aDjZl4[�iZ^`_TjÇjvacY/q?dwV"��_b^z�y[�\6�"Y/aD�IVXdb_b\D�4� � ��J�QM�MO8;F S =�P ��< 8�<�B S�<�BED�SX� . �6� .����� .c.���� �fhrDY/VXdbl6[eWZ^¨��|�� � �w� � _b\I^Zap\��DUy� � �w�4[�\6��{Mjsm+dwVsdwdT[e\6��� �4�O ���x .����� }X���,�pVX\DVXW<[�d�oJWk[�YGV��+acWZ��oJacW�q6[eWk[�dbdbVXd

��_wi`^ZW`_w�?rD^ZV��ÂqDWZaDj<VXi`iZ_b\D�4��%z\#f�rDYGVXdbl6[�W`^��¨|#� � ��[�\6�2{MjXm+dbVXdbdT[�\6��� �4�A ��b��V¨�I_b^ZacW`i�� � 8 � 8RFLF J F �QB S�< � B ��:< J�I� � =�D J"S�S�BGM^���I�cacdbrDYGV7%X�Iq6[��pVXi����� �� � �I{ %�* )ÅWZVXi`i���m�[�Yy�DW`_T�I�cVc�

tD[eYyrDVXdz�X���R ��px .���� �p}X�ItIacYGV�iZ^`r6�I_bVXi�_b\�Y�[cj`lD_b\DV8dbV�[�W`\D_b\D�rDiZ_b\D��^ZlDV+��[eY/V�aeogj`lDV�j`�cVsWZi���%z\ T?VX_b�cVs\��4[�rDY¾�� ��[e\6��T?VXdT�IY [e\�� �6�b�IV��I_b^`acWZi¨� �2=R?=�O:< J � SU8;MOI � ��=R: ����<z�Iq6[��pVXiu� . .�� �?�c{MjXUÂWk[��+� � _bdbd �p]�V����+acWZ���

tI^`VX_b\I�Dr6j`l�������x .����?. }s�C|�_bV �VXW`\DY [e^ZWZ_���� � H ��J � MOJ"<CB � � . x . }s��� � I���?�*�[cj`�pVX^Z^¨� � �D�#�Sx .���� �c}s�*UVX\DVs^Z_Tj�q?WZac�pWk[eY/Y/_ \D�oQapW�oQV¨[�^Zr?WZVy�I_bikj<a��pVXWZ�M[�\4��_bY [��pV��I_bikj<W`_wYG_b\6[�^`_wap\��N%z\

T?acW`WZVXi`^��8t��b�4V��I_b^ZapW�� � � =�D�J J�I;BGM^��S@=�P5<Z� J � B P�<�� ��M�< J � MO8�<�BE=RM�8RF �2=;M�P�J � J MOD�J�=RM ��J MOJ"<CBED �QF.��= � B <���? S��� ��� � �������e�Iq4[��cVsi*� � �� �� ��� �I{�apWZ��[e\,�[�r�oQY [e\D\��ItD[�\M{M[e^ZVXa4�

� _b\Di`^Zap\���)8��x .�� �c�p}X�. �V�[eWZ\D_b\D�Ai`^ZWZr4j<^ZrDW<[�d#��VXikj<W`_bqD^Z_bac\?i�oQWZapY V��6[�YGqDdbVXi�� %z\ )8�b� � �w�hV��I_b^ZapW�� � � J� S"H�D � =;F = �AH�=>P �2=R?=�O:< J ��� B S�BE=;MD�D{MjXUW<[��+� � _bdwdz�I]�V����±apWZ���

,4l6[e\D�6�4~*� ��*��Sx .��� �I}X� � ��V�j<^Zi2a�o2-jXjX[�Y V i*Wk[e�XacW�_b\MVX�capdb��_b\D��iZ_b�pY [¨�zqD_�\DVsrDWk[edC\?VX^��±apWZ�Ii��+%z\n|[¨�I_T�IacW¨��y�b��tDj`l �+V<oQVsd � � � � )8�w�8[�\4�¿f��b��{ �b��V��I_b^ZapWZi�� � J�D"<C: � J =�< J�S BGM �2=R?=�O:< J � � D�B J�MOD�J������ � � 8 � 8RFLF J F� � = � F J ? � =;FK��BGM^�7P � =;? 8A<C: � J��c�Iq6[e�cVXi�� ��� ��I� . �ptIqDWZ_b\D�pVXWz����VXW`dT[��6�� �ac\6��ac\��

,4l6[e\D�6�4~*� ��*���[�\6�M{��rDlDdbVX\I�6Vs_w\S� � �Sx .��� �p[c}X� � �capdw�I_b\D��acqD^`_bY [�d�\?VXrDWk[ed8\DVX^��+acWZ�IirDi`_w\?�/�cVs\DVX^Z_Tj�[�db�cae�W`_b^ZlDYGiN��_b^Zl -jXjX[�Y V i±W<[��XapW�� �2=;? ��F J � �OH�S�< J�? SX�6�Ixz�c}s� .���� ���� �

,4l6[e\D�6�8~�� ��*��8[�\6� {��r?lDdbVX\I�6VX_b\�� � ��x .���� �e�6}X�MUÂVX\DVX^`_Íj"qDWZap�cW<[�Y/YG_£\D�Ga�o�Y/_b\D_bY [¨dS\DVXrDW<[�d�\DVs^Zi�rDiZ_b\D�-jXjs[�Y'V iWk[e�XacW¨� %z\ TDapWZWZVsiZ^���t��w�8V¨�I_b^ZacW¨��� � =�D�J�J I;BGM^��S =>P4<���J �NB P"<�� � M�< J � M�8�<�BE=RMO8;F �2=RM�P�J � J�MOD�J =RM��J MOJ"<CBED �QF.��= � B <���? SX�pq6[��pVXi*��� � D��� � ��{ acWZ�I[�\ �Ç[erIoQY�[�\D\��ItD[e\ {Ì[�^ZVsa6�

,4l6[e\D�6�S~*� ��*���[�\6�¾{��rDl?dwVs\��4VX_b\�� � ��x .���� �I}X�ytI�I\I^ZlDVsiZ_bi�a�o�iZ_b�pY [¨�zqD_S\DVXrDW<[�d+\DVX^��+acWZ�Ii��I�M^`lDVy�DW`VXV��IVXW�pVX\DVX^`_Tj�qDW`ac�pWk[�YGY/_ \D�6��%z\ � � =�D�J�J�IRBGM ��S�=�P � �M� � ��M <>J � MO8A<CBE=;MO8RF �2=;M�P�J � J MOD�J�=RM5���A=;F�:<CB =RMO8 � H �2=R?0���:<>8A<CBE=;M � � �N���N��� � � � �,= � F I �2=;M^� � J�S�S'=RM �2=;? ��:�< 8�<�BE=;MO8RF���M�< J�FLF�B���J�M�D Js��q4[��cVsi/� .�� �� � �D�(% �����m+apY/qDr?^ZVXW�tIaDj<_bVX^z�,)ÅWZVXi`i���]�V����±apWZ���

�p�