2 52

86

5 5

2

7 7 8

.

(1)

2017 3

( (2))(3)

※(4)

(Fiduciary Relationship)

SEC

2006

2 ( )(2014 2 )(5)

(2015 6 )(6)

(2017 3 )(7)

‘comply or explain’

(1) 2018

4 (2)

FD

(3) ( )

(4) [2017a], 1 (5) [2014a] (6) [2015] (7) [2017a]

1-1-1

2

2. 7 7

‘Loop Hole’

(8)

(8) [2011], 7

3. 7 7 (1) (a)

2

300

2

(FSA)300

(9)

(9) Bando[2014], pp 80.

�����

1-1-2

2

1-1-3

(b) 17

1694(10)

’(11)

(1946 )(12)

’

(LLR=Lender of the Last Resort)(13)

(14)

(Club Governance)(15)

(Governor’s Eyebrow)

(10) Rawlings[2011], pp 17. (11) [1988], 59 (12) [2012a], 131 (13) Bagehot[1837], pp 187. (14) [2000], 2

(16) 20

LLR

(c)

1980

(17)

1986

(15) Rawlings, [2011], pp 17. (16) [2011b], 48 (17) [2002], 343

b b(1694 )

b b(1979 )

Securities and Investment Board

( )

cLLR( )c

c 1946 ( )

c 4 2

c 9

9 (Club Governance)

cBOEc

BOEc

b b(1987 )

ccBOE2c n

c

Dual-layer System

(1986 d )cBOE d

c (SIB)c

ccSIBc1989 d B10 [ b [

Financial Services Authority

(1997 5 ) (2010 5 )

b b

Financial Policy Committee

Prudential Regulation Authority

Financial Conduct Authority

(2012 d )cFSA

BOE (FPC/PRA)cFSA FCAcFCA

FSA [ b [(2013 d )c b b

(1997 d )c SIBcSIB FSAc

FSA(1998 b b )cBOE FSA(2000 d )cFSA ( )cccFSA Handbook( )c [ b [

ocSIB [ b [ 0

1 811

b d ( c : 300 ) (15 ) b d

b ]b c dd c ad

[ b [

�����

) ( )( ( ( ( )(

2

(SIB=Securities and Investment Board)

SIB

SIB

SIB(18)

1979

(19) 1987

(20)

LLR

(d)

1997300

SIB (21)

SIB (22) SIB(FSA=Financial Services Authority)

2000FSA

(23)

(e)

FSA2000

FSA

(18) Black[1997], pp 66 (19) [2003], 149 (20) [2004], 69 (21) [1999], 57 (22) [2003], 163 (23) Bando[2014], pp 76. (24) FSA[2000], pp 14.

FSA(Standards)

(Guides)(24)

198910 FSA

11

(25)

FSA

(26)

(f) FSA

2008130

RBS(27) FSA

FSA (28) FSA

2009

FSA(29) 2010

6 l FSA

l

l ’ LLR

(30)

FPC(Financial Policy Committee)PRA

(25) [2011c], 84 (26) [2008], 33 (27) Bando[2014], pp 77. (28) FSA[2009]. (29) Cameron[2009]. (30) HM Treasury[2010].

1-1-4

2

Prudential Regulation AuthorityFCA(Financial Conduct Authority) FSA

(31) 15

(32)

(33) (2) (a)

FSAFSA

3FSA

FSA FCA49

(31) [2011b], 45 (32) Ferran[2010], pp 10. (33) Taylor[2009], pp 88. (34) FCA[2015] , pp 4. (35) Principle 11

FCA

28

LIBOR 300(34)

FCA 11(35)

30

(b)

(36)

( 21d)

( 32 )

(37)

( 27 33 2734 172 10)

(38)

(36) 206

(37) (

52 1 6 ) 18(

[2016], 625 ) (38) [2017], 1015

(��3)

(��)FSA���FCA������ ���

1-1-5

2

4. (1)

※

(39) 4

(Fiduciary) l l l

(40)

(41)

(39) [2017a], 1 (40) Frankel[2011], pp 4 [2014](

) (41) [2011], 48 Bristol & West Building Society v. Mothew(1998)

(42)

(2) (a)

13

5

(43) 14

(44)

(42) Frankel[2011], pp 2, SEC v. Chenery Corp., 318 U.S. 80, 85-86(1942) (43) [2014], 4 (44) [2014], 10

(��4)

(��)Frankel[2011]������

D D

F DD

F D

) )(

(��5)

(��)Frankel[2010]��[2014]��� ����

1-1-6

2

17Trust (45)

(b) 2006

(46)

21 2006

(47)

(2006 170) ( 171 )

( 172 ) ( 173 ) (174 ) ( 175 )

( 176 )(48)( 177 )

2006

(49)( 178 2 )

(50)

(45) [2014], 13 (46) FSA (Principles for Businesses) (Principle 6)

(Principle 7) (Principle 8)(Principle 9) (Principle 10)

(47) [2007], 2[2003], 93 (48) [2017], 120−125 (49) [2008], 206 (50) [2011], 46 (51) The Law Commission [2014], pp 39

l No Conflict Rule

l No Profit Rule

(51)

2 (52)

(c)

BIS(53)

2012 7(54)

(55) BIS 11

(56)

FRC(2012 9 )

(57) ’fiduciary’

’fiduciary’

l l

[2011], 51 (52) Frankel[2011], pp.106 [2017], 107-235 (53) (Department for Business, Innovation and Skill)

BEIS(Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy) (54) BIS[2012a]. (55) [2013], 109 (56) BIS[2012b]. (57) Ibid, pp 6.

1-1-7

2

l (58)

2014 7 (59)

BIS

DWP(60)

(61)

(62)

(d) Stewardship Fiduciary Duty

(63)

(58) Ibid, pp 9. (59) Law Commission[2014]. (60) (Department for Work and Pensions) (61) DWP[2015a], BIS[2014]. (62) DWP[2015b]. (63) FCA[2016], pp 1. “The responsibilities of the board include setting the company’s strategic aims, providing the leadership to

5. (1) (a)

(ERISA:Employee Retirement Income Security Act)

(b)

( )(Named Fiduciary:402 a(1))

(Trustee:403 a) (64)(3 38)

l

l l

l

put them into effect, supervising the management of the business and reporting to shareholders on their stewardship.” (64)

1-1-8

2

(3 (21))(65)

‘

IRA(66)

5

l (403 ) l ( 404 ) l l l

406( ’

) (

) (67) (2) (a)

SEC

(68) 2015 4

(69) IRA

(65) [2016], 504 (66) (Individual Retirement Account) (67) [2016], 4 (68) [2016], 5 (69) Federal Register[2015]. (70) [2016], 6 (71) [2016], 10

l ‘

IRA

l

(70)

(71) 2016 42017 4

(72) (b) SEC

SEC (913 )

2011 1 SEC(73) 2013 3

(74) 11 SEC

(75)

SEC (76)

SEC

(72) Federal Register[2016]. (73) SEC[2011]. (74) SEC[2013a]. (75) SEC[2013b]. (76) [2011a], 130

1-1-9

2

SEC Turf War( )SEC

(3) (a)

2017 12

(77) l

l

l

3

2017 4

60 (78)

2017 6 9 (79)

2018 12017 11 180(80)

2018 7

(b)

Financial CHOICE Act (81)

( 901 )( 482 )

(841 )

6.

(1)

(82)

(77) White House[2017]. (78) Federal Register[2017]. (79) Impartial Conduct Standards(1)

(2) (3)

3 (80) DOL[2017]. (81) Congress[2017]. (82) [2016], 11

16 94

2 9 9)73

)))

)) (

0 )0

) () () () (

(��6)

1-1-10

2

2006

( 29 1 ) (30 )(34 ) 3 (83)

(84)

6

( )

GPIF( )

( 222 )

( 44 3 3 )

(85)

(2)

(83) [2001], 99 (84) [2016], 9 (85)

(86)

[2014], 35 (87) [2017b], 16

( )

(86)

2017 5

6

(87)

complyFinancial

CHOICE Act

(88) (3) (a)

2015

(89)

(90)

(91)

2

(88) [2017], 852 (89)

(90) [2016], 32 (91) [2017], 22 [2016], 255

1-1-11

2

(92)

( 4-5)( 330 )

( 644 )( 355

)

(93)

(94)

(95) (b)

‘Stewardship’

( )

‘Stewardship aims to promote the long term success of companies in such a way that the ultimate providers of capital also prosper. Effective stewardship benefits companies, investors and the economy as a whole.’

The UK Stewardship Code (96)

(92) [2017], 10 (93) [2017], 7 (94) [2017], 7 (95)

[2016] [2016] [2015]

‘The responsibilities of the board include setting the company’s strategic aims, providing the leadership to put them into effect, supervising the management of the business and reporting to shareholders on their stewardship. The board’s actions are subject to laws, regulations and the shareholders in general meeting.’

The UK Corporate Governance Code (97)

ward(98)

(4)

2018 37

[2016] [2015][2015]

(96) [2013] (97) [2014b] (98) [2014], 30

1-1-12

2

1

35 3

(99)

’comply or explain’

’comply or explain’

(100)

(99) [2016], 39-40

67

.

(1)

300

(100) [2017a], 2

44

4

4

4

4 4

1-1-13

2

(101)

SEC FRB

(2) (a)

( )

(101) [2011a], 140−141

7

(b)

l (

‘ )

l

l

l ‘ ‘

l l

l l ( )

l

1.5 l

comply or

������

��(*�����"

l ����������!'��&l �������%���� ������

�+��)��������

������� $�#�

(��7)

1-1-14

2

explain(102)

(103)

(104)

(105)

(102) FRC

FCA

(market abuse)FCA

FRC(2017 9 ) FRC

17K03480

2006172

FRC FCA172

(103) [2010], 117−121 (104) [2017], 51−52 (105) [2010], 121

1-1-15

2

[2014], [ 4 ]2,

[2017], - -2,

[2003], , 2, 4

[2016], , “AoyamaAccounting Review”, Vol.3

[2017], , 2,33 ,

[2003], , 21 2,

[2016], , 2, 92 1

[2017], 2, [2014],

2 , 2, [2011],

, 2, 63 [2012a]. (1946 )

(1) , 2, 59 4 [2012b]. (1946 )

(2) , 2, 60 1 [2013],

, 2, 2013

[2007], , 2, 41 1

[2016], , 2,

[2011], , 2, 7 3

[2016], (1) , 2,67 3

[2015], , 2, 2068

[2016], - , 2, 6

[2017], , 2,

[2001], , 2,2001 3

[2013], ( ) ,(http://www.fsa.go.jp/singi/stewardship/ siryou/20131018/04.pdf)

[2014a], 2 , (http:// www.fsa.go.jp /news/25/singi/20140227- 2/04.pdf)

[2014b], ( ) 2014 , (http://www. fsa.go.jp/singi/corporategovernance/siryou/ 20140930/05.pdf

[2015], “Japan’s Corporate Governance Code [Final Proposal]”,(http://www.fsa.go.jp/en/refer/ councils/corporategovernance/20150306-1/01.pdf)

[2016], (http://www.fsa.go.jp/singi/singi_kinyu/ market_wg/siryou/20160706/02.pdf)

[2017a], , ( http://www.fsa.go.jp/news/28/20170330-1/02. pdf)

[2017b], 2 , (http: //www.fsa. go.jp/news/29/singi/20170529/01.pdf)

[2016], ( 7 )2, [2000],

, 2, 2000 11 [2004],

, 2, 42 3

[2017], ( ) , 2,

[1999], , 2, 381

[2014], - , 2,

[2016], 2, [2014],

2, [1988], :

1939 , 2, 35 3 [2002], -

1-1-16

2

, 2,50 1 2 [2017], ( )2,

[2015], , (http://www.jpx.co.jp/equities/listing /cg/tvdivq0000008jdy-att/code.pdf)

[2017], , 2, 68 1

= [2008], 2006 (2) , 2, 41 3

[2016], DC , 2, 2016

[2010], , 2,

[2011a], - , 2, 9 10

[2011b], , 2, 62 33

[2011c], , 2,

[2016], , 2,67 42

[2017], , 2,51 , 1 13

[2008] , (2) , 2, 1846

[2016], 2 , 2, 67 37

[2015], , 2, 2087

[2015], , 2, 67 7 Bando, Hiroyuki[2014], “Single Regulator or Twin Peaks – The Different Financial Regulatory Approaches by UK, Switzerland and Japan”, 150 Years Anniversary Yearbook, Swiss-Japan Chamber of Commerce Bagehot, Walter[1873], Lombard Street, Henry S. King &Co. BIS[2012a], The Kay Review of UK Equity Markets and

Long-term Decision Making, (https://www.gov.uk/ government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment _data/file/253454/bis-12-917-kay-review-of-equity- markets-final-report.pdf) BIS[2012b], The Government Response to the Kay Review, (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/ system/uploads/attachment_data/file/253457/ bis-12-1188-equity-markets-support-growth- response-to-kay-review.pdf) BIS[2014], Implementation of the Kay Review: Progress Report, (https://www.gov.uk/government/ uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/ file/367070/bis-14-1157-implementation-of-the -kay-review-progress-report.pdf) Black, Julia[1997], Rules and Regulators, Clarendon Press Oxford Cameron, Rt Hon David[2009], “Bringing law and order to the financial markets”, March 24, 2009 Congress[2017], “H.R 10”, (https://www.congress.gov /115/bills/hr10/BILLS-115hr10rfs.pdf) DOL[2017], “U.S. Department of Labor extends Transition Period for Fiduciary Rule Exemptions”, (https://www. dol.gov/newsroom/releases/ebsa/ebsa20171127-0) DWP[2015a], Consultation on changes to the Investment Regulations following the Law Commission’s report ‘Fiduciary Duties of Investment Intermediaries’, (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/ system/uploads/attachment_data/file/407937/ Condoc_27_02_15_to_DWP.pdf) DWP[2015b], Better Workplace Pensions: Reducing regulatory burdens, minor regulation changes, and response to consultation on the investment regulations, (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/ system/uploads/attachment_data/file/476447/ reducing-regulatory-burdens-and-misc-regs-nov- 2015-consultation.pdf) Federal Register[2015], “Definition of the Term ‘‘Fiduciary’’ ; Conflict of Interest Rule—Retirement Investment Advice”, (https://www.gpo.gov /fdsys/pkg/FR-2015-04-20/pdf/2015-08831.pdf) Federal Register[2016], “Definition of the Term ‘‘Fiduciary’’; Conflict of Interest Rule—Retirement Investment Advice”, (https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2016-04-08/ pdf/2016-07924.pdf)

1-1-17

2

Federal Register[2017], “Final rule; extension of applicability date”, ( https://www.gpo.gov /fdsys/pkg/FR-2017-04-07/pdf/2017-06914.pdf) Ferran, Eilis[2010], “The Break-up of the Financial Services Authority”, Legal Studies Research Paper Series, 10/4 Frankel, Tamar[2011], Fiduciary Law, Oxford University Press FCA[2015],”Final Notice”, (https://www.fca.org.uk/ publication/final-notices/deutsche-bank-ag-2015. Pdf) FRC[2012],”The UK Stewardship Code”,( https://www. frc.org.uk/getattachment/d67933f9-ca38-4233-b603- 3d24b2f62c5f/UK-Stewardship-Code-(September- 2012).pdf) FRC[2016],”The UK Corporate Governance Code”, (https://www.frc.org.uk/getattachment/ca7e94c4- b9a9-49e2-a824-ad76a322873c/UK-Corporate- Governance-Code-April-2016.pdf) FSA[2000], “A new regulator for the new millennium, January 2000”, (http://www.fsa.gov.uk/static/pubs/ policy/p29.pdf) FSA[2009], “The Turner Review”, (http://www.fsa.gov. uk/pubs/other/turner_review.pdf) HM Treasury[2010],”Speech by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, RT Hon George Osborne MP, at Mansion House”, 16 June 2010 Keay, Andrew[2010b], “The Duty to promote the Success of the Compnay: Is it Fit for Purpose?”, University of

Leeds, Working Paper, (https://ssrn.com/ abstract= 1662411) Law Commission[2014], Fiduciary Duties of Investment Intermediaries, The Stationary Office Rawlings, Philip[2011], “All Changes: The Fall of the FSA and the Future Rise of the Bank of England”, Banking & Financial Services Policy Report, Vol. 30, No. 4 SEC[2011], “Study on Investment Advisers and Broker- Dealers”, (https://www.sec.gov/news/studies/ 2011/913studyfinal.pdf) SEC[2013a], ”Request for data and other information”, (https://www.sec.gov/rules/other/2013/34- 69013.pdf) SEC[2013b], “Recommendation of the Investor Advisory Committee Broker-Dealer Fiduciary Duty “,(https://

www.sec.gov/spotlight/investor-advisory- committee-2012/fiduciary-duty-recommendation- 2013.pdf) Taylor, Michael W.[2009], “The Road from ‘Twin Peaks’ and the Way Back”, Connecticut Insurance Law Journal, Vol. 16, Issue 1 White House[2017], “Presidential Memorandum on Fiduciary Duty Rule”, (https://www.whitehouse. gov/presidential-actions/presidential- memorandum-fiduciary-duty-rule/)

1-1-18