© t. m. whitmore today agriculture and rural development continued v: internal colonization of...

70
© T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia The issue of lowland tropical deforestation Mexican Agriculture- an example of a dual system Other examples of Commercial Agriculture in LA

Upload: jasmin-alexander

Post on 28-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

TODAY•Agriculture and rural development

continuedV: Internal Colonization of Tropical

Lowlands - AmazoniaThe issue of lowland tropical

deforestation

•Mexican Agriculture- an example of a dual system

•Other examples of Commercial Agriculture in LA

Page 2: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

LAST TIME- Questions?

•Agriculture and rural development continuedIV: Dual agricultural systems or

“The Productivity Paradox”V: Internal Colonization of Tropical

Lowlands

Page 3: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Agricultural and Rural Development V: Internal

Colonization of Tropical South American Lowlands•Example III from Amazonia

> 600 million haAmazonian environments

Terra firmeVárzaSavanna

Page 4: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Development history in Amazonia I

•Early extractive uses

•“Spontaneous” peasant agricultural colonization and Governmentally planned colonization in Brazilian AmazonAndean Amazon

Page 5: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Development in Amazonia II•Patterns of peasant colonization

Fishbone patternsScale & geography of changeCauses Cattle ranchingConsequences Ecuadorian “Oriente”

•Commercial expansion of modern agricultureExample of soy in Mato Groso

Page 6: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Amazonian deforestation•Wider consequences

In Brazilspeculation and abandoned lands

Loss of rare tropical rain forestDestruction of speciesDestruction of Indigenous people’s

traditional livelihoodConsequences for global warmingFails to solve land tenure problemLocal weather impacts

•Solutions?

Page 7: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 8: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Fordlândia

Jarí

Area of high density of rubber trees

Page 9: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 10: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore© Greenpeace / Felipe Goifman

Page 11: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Planned

Spontaneous

Amazonian colonization

Page 12: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 13: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

USGS

Page 14: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 15: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 16: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 17: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 18: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 19: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 20: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 21: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Source: NASA

Page 22: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 23: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Source: Frontiers in Ecology

Page 24: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 25: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Roger J. Harris, 2001

Page 26: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 27: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Roger J. Harris, 2001

Page 28: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 29: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 30: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Ecuadorian Oriente © Christine Erlien

Page 31: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Koeppe

Page 32: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Koeppe

Page 33: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Soy in S America

Page 34: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Koeppe

Page 35: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Koeppe

Page 36: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Tropical Deforestation•Deforestation rates•Causes

Agricultural clearingPasture clearingTimber harvestingOil exploration/extractionPopulation growth?Degradation of lands in source

areas of migrantsPoor land tenure equity in source

areas of migrantsUrban poverty

Page 37: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 38: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 39: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Mexican Agriculture-examples

•Dual system spatially and functionally

•Regions in Mexican agricultureNorthern irrigated oasesMesa Central and Bajío

Commercial, specialty, & small holder

Southern highland Mexico, lowlands near Gulf of Mexico, and Yucatan

Commercial & small holder

Page 40: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Bajío

Page 41: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Irrigated maize in Bajío

Page 42: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 43: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Tequila

Page 44: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Pulque

(like tequila & mezcal, pulque is from maguey, a species of agave) – not a cactus

Page 45: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Magueys in fallow field C. Mexico

Page 46: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. WhitmoreTraditional maize cob storage

Page 47: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Milpa (i.e., field – usually corn) in Chiapas

Page 48: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Commercial Agriculture in LA

•Argentina

•Chilean central valley

•Brazil

•Peru’s coastal oases

•Columbia’s coffee

•Specialty crops: coca, flowers, ferns

•Central America’s 3 Cs

Page 49: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Pam

pasW

ines

Page 50: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Argentine Soy(98% GMO)

Page 51: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

Navin Ramankutty, Nicholas J. Olejniczak, and Jonathan A. FoleyCenter for Sustainability and the Global Environmenthttp://www.sage.wisc.edu

Cultivation Intensity

Page 52: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Soy Citrus

Frui

t

Page 53: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 54: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© Chris Jochem 2006

North coastal Peruvian cane

Page 55: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 56: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 57: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 58: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical
Page 59: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. WhitmoreCut flower cultivation on ancient terraces; near Tarma, Peru

Page 60: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. WhitmoreCut flower cultivation on ancient terraces; near Tarma, Peru

Page 61: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Fern growth under meshIn cloud forest in theSierra de las Minas, Guatemala

Page 62: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 63: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

coffee

coffee

coffee

Tropical plantation crops

Cotton, sugar

Page 64: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 65: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 66: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 67: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 68: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 69: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore

Page 70: © T. M. Whitmore TODAY Agriculture and rural development continued  V: Internal Colonization of Tropical Lowlands - Amazonia  The issue of lowland tropical

© T. M. Whitmore