sanhatisanhati.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/32_4_porichoy...~, .., ... ~~ta1~~t~~,~.~~~ \!il~~t;;~...
TRANSCRIPT
:: OCTOBER 1962
~tlf<frn
~'€~ li'tr¢ ~9j.{ C~~
~~ to~ ~O{~• ~~~ Pf~~~~~m t~1:l
<ifw~f~ tl:l¢ ~~'l~
~~ ¢I:l~ ff~Cff~'iT'it~~C'fi ¢I:l'l ~~m~~9ft~
~ '3(4r.t~ ~~ ¢..:;'tr fu;rctm"'If1-' c~ : <lt~C'fj«'~ ~'l~ ¢¢I:l W <l~t9ftlfJTI[
~ "Ff~ <lid ffiOi'l~~ ¢¢'tr <!l'<l ~~
¢~~ 5ll~g)M C"Ff<l'1
~ 'l~~ ~t;r 'e <tt~ ¢~I:l ~~~C'lO{
~<fl <'tftm! ¢~'I f9t;rt~to1 ~9ft~¢ 'I~ ~~~I~11\!)f
~"Ff:9\fil~ll Cliil
1f""lIIf~
c5ft<'ttO'f~tO'fm I 'i5fO'ftSQ'l151:~t<'ttlfJnr
(~ \3 ~rn ~~
~"'MI!1 'q1i(1!1f~f~~f5~ ~1)~t~~~t~~~~f~~
~~~r~if
,~~/~ 'It'l''tfui f,!joU't,f(.!It:) fQj:,~.I) ~lf~'1 w"W, "Qj~IW1-).~~ ~ 10';0 1{~1~ ~"'t ~. ~Qj~I~H ,~~ ~lfiorw I
~, ...
..,
~~ta1~~t~~,~.~~~
\!Il~~t;;~
'ajt~t('f~ iSl~
~~~
~ <it1ftOf
~~~~~~~~~ ~m ~~~ ~ ~'1 '5ti'fC~ • ~~~~ l:5{tiSf
~I DI'II
~ I ~~~ ~~ ~~ 'I"rt~ ~~ oflf'iffi:~~~~~ ~ Wt~ '5tm R~ "l'fi1" I
~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~0Wf C~ ~~ 'lH~~l~m~~ C<l'ttrn ~~ ~ ~ DrO'f on I ~~ f.fm~ j%~ ~ @~ ~~ f<r~j~~\'l<l:1fC01 ~<t1
f.\rll '5{tlT~1cm<t1 <t>~~, ~~ ~;rtC'"t~ ~<t> ~~1 ~ WfWl <i11~ 1i~ I 0! @\fnf ~<f~ ~'i~ iSfC']] 'e\1~rCftSl
cwrn ~lft~9 ~~ ~"1, Cll ~ ~~;frt%~~ ~ ~~ ~~, 0! ~-RQC'i'lf- ffit~~ ~~~*~f'1---'-,*"l' ~m m'1~(ffil"~ ~ '"'ITtm ~~I ~;sfR'1 ~ ~,~ ~ ~1~q~~I~tC1~ I
Irt~~ ~ ~~ 'Sf1f~~?z~~~-~ .£rc~ ~'1
~j~~ll~~-l 1 CftC"t~ iSf'Plt~~~ ~~ "iftf<ll ~mte 'fffi1ClfC"tiPl~1f ~ ~G[ ~~ 1:5{t~"1 \5\t~k~\'l ~~ ~ "t'i~ ~~.I ~~ @~~ ~ 'Olt'T1ml~~ ~ ClfC'"t~ ~'lf-1-
~~ ~ ~~~ ~r <t>~<l:1
\5ft~ '5ft'1f'lf~, <rt~ajwrc~ fxtID-~~T1i~1 ~1%~ ~"I'I.'f·~ 1 ~ ~ f~~ "t\5tf~ NID~ ~~'1~WC\f~"lf>nl ~~~ ~'1 ~ 1 ~1Rf
~~, ~1 ~~ p!f~ ~t"1, clf~~ <>tm ~ C\f"t-
~ ~ .•..~ <fij''1, .£r<fT<r~ ~ I
~ ~ ~~$"!,.£r<fTf«m~ ~ f<lm~ ~~~ I
Oflf-r ~, fxtID-#ft~~m\f~ ~?Z N~ f<l~~ ~,
'1f"\A1.f1'il ~~ "R~ ~ <lim ~<fi ~
1m ~ I ~~ ~j,~~ "R~ ~1 Of~
<rol ~ I ~ 'l'm fu;{m1 CIf~
~~~~~~I ~"I,~
~f ~nr ~-~ ~ ~~-"I~
"I,~ ~ ~~"11 m~(;~ m~ <m:I
'ft~~ ~ I ~ ~,~ ~~ f.ml ~~~~ ~~<fi ~~ 9f1flffa1~~~ m-"l1~<l.~t~~~ "R~~ I ~ ~W1f~~~~nr~~1
~ ~-~~ ~ R I ~ 'Stsl~
. ~Q 'lWt~ C"tP:l'l-"tPfr;(f<l'f<l~ CIf"t "J.\~
~lj~ ~O{, ~-~ ~~ '89f~ Dtf9(rl!
~ ;gt~~ ~ "tt~~9 ~"lt,~Q 9f~ ~ ~ R~, ~ \7~ ~q,~ ~(;~ ~m f<fC~
f<lm~ ~ 9ft(;~, "ttf'lZ~9 ~'Rru "ltl@!
"'I"ltl\~ ~ <fi~ c<l~ 9ftt~ I '5!tw ~'l m.\5lf~ W~~91 ~~O{<fi "t~ ~m-'l"l~ "tt~1..of'5lt"ltm'8 'fi"lT I ~ ~~~ m<tiiG1't.1 ~~
~~I
~<l't~O'J ~Pl~ ~~~I~f1~ \!l{"\.~~ ~?t1-\!l{tfi "'I"l~nr~ ~~9f~ <fi(;m~ <fi~ ~r<l~ ~Q ~ 1
~~~~~~~,~~'8~~~ "'I~J~~ ~
, <rol<l' "t~~ ~ ~~~ '8 c~flr<fi "'I,~ 9ft"tt"ltPr ~
~'l\ ~<fi ~~ <fi~~, ~~ "'I"l'%l ~ ~~~
~d~~lk<l'~ooo c~ )(too ~ 9f~ "R~~ 9Jt5 "t~ <i~~ I
~I<li.fl~l'5\~ ~~~9f f<ll:~ ~ 9fWl' ;rJ, ~Q ~
~ ~ W-~~1 ~~ ~~ ~<i, ~~ ~l\~
-~ f~ ~ I ~(;m~fm~ 9ff~ ~ ~~,~~ 1f'lf ~, ~ '8 m~j1<t~~I ~ f~ \!l{,"t
m m ~ ~ ~ '5!tW~~ ~<t> ~~9f ~ 9ft'8m m~~tr.T1 ~~ I
'If<1 ~ ~~~ "'I"l~~'1 ~ro ~~ I ~~ ~~<1lm~~~ ~'8 <fi~ ~ <fi~'8 ~~ ~~ I
f'l~ ~~ c<l~~ '8 ~~nr~ \!l{f~ lWr ~ ~(;9f
fu.trl~ ~~ I cQ m ~<fit,"t ~ ~<fit~ wYjJ~
-~ ~,"t-~'& I ~~m ~9ft~ ~(;~ lWr '€
~ 'lVf "'I,~ ~ ~~I ~~ ~~
~~, ~ ~ ~~~ ~-~9f ~<i:\ ~ ~ I
I!I~ ~~~ \!l{~~ fuO'J'I ~~9f ~~"lk~<Q ~
8""'"
'<\'1-bi~I'r{~ <!:!1r<\~~~ 3lt~Of~( f.rffi1U ~~~ I ~~ ~ ~'lID1" ~<liiU ~t\!>tf~
<mr I ~ ~ ~~ 0( ~~\!>"1~<\t~~1'8 ~~
~ '<1lr;~ lft~ '8 ~, \!5tt'Rl 'lr;~ ~
~9\\fI, ~, '8 ~tz~<li ~ 'm~ I
~ 'Of$flf<l'tsl ~ <fi\:Q~~1 ~ ~g1 ~
~'8~~~G><1'I~~ I
QJ1M (J. H. Hutton) ~tf~ \51<l~ ~l@i
( Mediterranean) 0J<l,r;"\Sl~ I m~,<!:!1M~~t(~ "fC'1J ~ fr~~~ ~"t\!51 ~ <rnl~t
~~ 'lTI'f ~\!5S! ~ 'Oft~ I \5lm-
"IC'1J~,i!l~ ~nrn'8 ~ll:~ I 'Ofm-~,~oiI'~Q ~'8
~"i1 VWl1 '5\~pl! fir\!> ~ I ~t~ ~,iIr~
1~ 'Of'l'1.9 I ~fu<li ~ Pr'{i ~1\!5J<t't\i OJ<l,iIr~~
~'1J <!,ifr~'8 '5\Wt1t~Oj 0MgJ G'\f~ ~~ I ~ROJ<!,ifrn~ ~\!5 ~ '1~J\!>tr;<t'~ <lim W'eimf<l~ f~ ~1\!5J'ft~ ~ \5ltilt'8 Tii:~~'~~ <fil~ I
ll-n'li?<'1
'l'"f.\!5 ~~~J ~, 3lt\!5J,m~, f,j«tlf, ~\it\!5 .~
~~ ~ I ~~ ·O{t~~fC'jQOJ<I,ifr~~~ <t>-rn\!5~ I
~'r{'.q>~ ~ 0( 'Oft~ "\C<ifQC"l'tr-r1 ~,ilr~
~ ~ ~f\!5 onl, 1\1"1li~~ \51<lt~~ <Ii ~,
~ fs~ m~'8 C<t>t~t'8ffi,~"'1 ~<ti ~Brc~ 'Of~CO'!c~~"'1 'O{Jtc1,~ ~,,\«'ll ~ ~ I
~.ful 0J<l,r;"t"i1~ -n~, 'OfJtc1,~ '8 ft-Il <!l~~
'1~-~9f f~ ~ ~O{ I <M'<!l~<qi~ ( Von~\i ~ OJ<!,4r~0MZJC'f ~fui!3'Oft~J1f~ I
Hooton) ffi ~Q OJ<!,ifr~ ~~ ~-
~ I i<l9(~I>~ ~ <!t5fMt, ~'$I$, ~
'5lJta!~ '1tsl~ ~9\0{ ~~ ~1t\!5"'11
"
~ ~'L~ ~ onl, ~C<\fir<f'.:!l1'\!>JS1t'8~m,~~ ~-~9\ ~<tJ ~ I '5f~I<\,~~ '3{iif '8 ~~
~ ~~ ~ ~I ~ ~'8 ~m~CO'! ~1~<!l<l' ~ ~ ~~ ~,~ ~~-cS1~ ~
~ ~~ Cfff~ ~ C<t>~I
~ ~1 m~ ~ ~,~'f <!1~~ C~ I
~"fC~ fu"\« ~o\<!ifr~ ~ t'f \5lIM~\!)~, ~~ mc;n~/~ ~<t' 'f1'>lr:t<f'\!>1-~ I ~ ~'8 ~~ I
~ ~ ~-C~~'8 ~~\!5 3lt\!5Hlir;9f<t>f~ ~ I
~ ~1 ~ 'Ofm-~O'j"'M cS1~ "f\!) c9f1<l'1 <I'm~
<fII. ~~ ~f% I
~~~~IS1 D?;~1t~ ~\!5 '8 ~i>fl-~~~ ~'1 ~(;r~ I f<!i~ ~~ ~ 1m, ~~ "fmcf)~ "f~~ ~
I ~,~ ~., '8 ~\!5S! cS1<t'<!'i'1~ ~?;$[~ Clf~i m t
~ ~o188 ]
~\ilrlJ ~ ~ 'Of~\!5t~ ~~ ~ ~ 0{1I ~
~, m.m ~ 1f~~Qi 0J<l'~~ f~~~fc1C'f ~ "f~lf1 fire
Iti! f.f Iil<l~Iilmnr ~tt'f"i1 'Offs"f\!5 ~9fm ;r~ I ~i '8 'l,~
~ ~ffi c<rt~~ ~ C0{'8ID'8'f<l~<t' I ~,~lciiSl ~'t\!51-~
~ ~ \5ltt<t'"\tm ~-~ ~ <t>~i <!CO'!,'Of~ ~
~ ~~ ~tN-'5fC~~ ~ I \5lt<!1~,~bi'(!jI'o1~ 3l~i
~-~~~~~ ~ ~~ ~t«I~t~ I '8~t~~ \5lWr-'5fC~~.
~ <:s1<l1<!J<!~ ~ I \51<11'8 ~,~ '5fC* ~ cS1'f c~
~ c~ ~<jJ1ft\!5 ~ I ~,m\!5<t' <!Jt9\tt$frofC'J<!'~9\fl"
~ "ffurt'1 f.tofu <Ai ~ onl, ~ 'f<l~~ ~",f\!5 ~ ~~
~ ~~ I [pp. 52-55, A stndy of history,bee, 1951 ]
n ~~-~c~-;r~ ~ '5(~i-~~ c~ <!1OJ<!,ilr~'1tsl"hf
'1~~ <!t'11-'l~ I ~, ~fcf>t, ~, f<t>~t\!5~~\!5 ~
~ ~~ ~~ I ~ ~ #ft"f 0( ~M c<t'TDl~ ~15<;>
..g fu~~ ~~ ~ <>ftfi 0\1 I f<t;~ ~ ~
'\5{~~ ~~ ~c~ ~ ~~~-<f~1
~~ <f~ ~1 m I ~"i1~ 'fIf'l "t'fi-~
~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~G"i1 ~~ ~<I, lftl!-lt1
~ ~9,(C"i1~ ~<t$ C<l'Tm ~'8 ~, ~"i1 ~~~"-~-'\5{~~ '\5{~G'f~~ ~~ I ..!I~ ~'1
~ ~<I, ~mt>TI "\<ml~~,<ltIf 9ft'8m m 1 ~ om.-.;rtm ~~ PI"! ~ fO{Q'<l<f<r.l, f<t>~ ~W;9 <rt'ft'8 ~
'\5{Q{~ ~ ~ c<l C<t>m~ ~<l'i ~ ~
~ "rc~ <fi~'Rr-~ r<1>S1j~~S1C<fttrrl ~ ~ ~
I '3\Q{~ ~oI81~8 J~"tQ{ 3lt>w:~ ~t"tf~-":llI( 0f<!-cffi ~, ~~'1
~"{, '3\tfilfum1" '\5{~~<ltf<t9ftG'f~f~ ~iSft~9, ~"tQ ~'l
4i"i1<l'~ ~r~ ~~ ~~"t<; ~m ~ ~~z~, m~~ ~~ ~(;<\~ "tQ{C<ftm ?
w~~ 0f~ "ttf~ ~~ W'Sl1l '<l~ <lTtflCctl
'Q{t<fm 'Sf<JJI ~i "~ ~~:" ~"i1(;~ "i"fil<l~ "~
'\5{"t~t<li~cm~ <f~, ~t, ~-<>\1f-<rt~ I ~ 'f1 ~'8~i ~
Dl~(;~ <ut<fi"i19"ti.f\ ~<lT-~~ ~9fVf"t ~r( 9j~~f"! I [ ~I
~~ ~ ~-~"t R~ ~ I ~i ~~ l\,~
<fQ{i<!(;~, <m~ ~i f<f,<!i '\5{~<f ~~ ~tQ <ror-fon~~"i11 f<f <m~ f<f,<!i ~rl1r '\5{(;~~ f<l',<!i ~'1'!l-~9f
~~ "tWA"? ~~~"i1 ~ ~ C~~, ~{3 "lt~nQ~~"if"i1 "l~<l'W;9 C<ft~i <!t~i 0f~f~ "Ii I
~?[(;<l' '5\tfu'nl-~"t ~<tT <f~~~ ~. f'Sf·~~~~~~f(
C"lO\'@~ ~<!, '5\'Rr'8 ~ I ~ I~~I'<.
"lW~ ~G'f'8 "l~lI(Ij"{'<l~ ~~ I C<lN<f~ c"t"lf~ 0/~~H\iC"t 9jf'l"fu~ ~ I [pp. 8~-90} Evolutton
Indian law, N C. Sen Gupta} 1953 J
~ ~~ ~~ CIf~ ml ~ ~<r.l~'8 '!l\1~<{>I
~-9f1f-<$T I If\''l '8 '\5{~ 9ftf<f.T 'f1 ~(;G'f ~<l'~
~ ~rn~ ~ '\5{~1 [~ <Ii ~ <!i-
.I~0<1" ] ..-/11; ~<1' ~ ~~ ~ 1ft"!<rofc<l'~~ <li~'T I ~ ~~
~<PII' , /' ~~~~, ~ ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ <!W'l' ~~ <f~~ I
~ <l9-~ ~<;~ ~-~ ~ ~, iSfJI-~ ~
Caste-C<1') om I ~-<[(;ofu M 11m! ~ '8 'ft~ ~<; ~.
I [ ~ <!<PT-~ ~1~~18; ~ lf~T'T ,~ ~, <fcf"{ ~<;-~ ~I·I"\. ' "
","81" ]'!{~ ~t"if '8 ~ '1Q{m~9~"i1 ~~ '3\t<Pt9 <l'~ f
~ ~~ ~"i1i ~-~"t fu<rf~ ~ I [~~: @'5
'Ift:-'!{~ 81~o18; ~ ~ @~ ~-81~ollr J'1.iI''l~~'€'~<rf.r1~9 ~ ~ CIf~ ~ c<l ~m ~~
~~@<;~~ ~I ~ ~ ~ "1~~ C"l~
~ ,~ ( slavery ) ~ ~~ m~I~~~f&~'1J~'5\~ 1ft"!~ C~, ~'8 C~ I '5\~ iSft~
~ ~~'8 <l'~~, '\5{ft<;, C~~ <fttiSf~ ~ m<R t
~~~~1C<l'~~~~~1 ["'I~"J~ ~$fi"i1 1ft"!<!i c~tG'ftm <fQ{i~ I [lr18 ~ <t J~<!i ~ C~ lft~9\ ~<tT ~ I ~ ~
,~~ ~~'8 ~<; ~ frll
~~ ~ ~ f<t> <f"Ii m c<l ~ '8 Ift"!-~ ~ ~<;~~
~ c~? C<rflr<fi ~ ~ c~~~fo1 C~ lJ~ 1JG>~t~
~ ~ <!t~ ~~, ~t, ~Qi ~ WI'! f<l',<!i~-
-~ I ~i C*'1I~"lS1<fI'S1<l'~ 'f1, ~ ~ 1ft"! <!i "l~!H~i(;9\~ Ofj I
I!l ~ ~ ~ ~m~<fQimc<l~f~~~
~, ~Q{i-~9, ~fum <!i ~ ~<!, ~ I 'O{~t('~S1t
~rcm WI ~ 'f~F~iC<i <.!l<1:'~~~ C<1:Clf~-~<i
~. ~. ~~~<!lQ ,~ <.!l~ Fr~~ ~~ I
Some aspects of ancient Indian culture, 1940 ]
~l\''{3if~
~t9t~ ~ ~ '8 if~ <.!l~ ~ ~sr ~<:.. <1te'tt~ #\,~ iftt#jQ"~~<i, if~T '8 'f,~ ~ 15\f<l<llC'f<.!l
~ ~~ c<fi~-P{tl:f I
~jC<1'(!SISiC~~-~ ~ttSi m ffi<p ~c~ <.!l~
~9f-T;~~-lfntr C<t>ttPl1"t\fi'-C1'TC~ ~<p I f~R ~~'<lh,<r1f~-~~ i:l<!,'f <l'SiCC1P{I ~~ ~tt<I' '<!t~ <rnO'\if4{~<p C~'-'~ I [~I~ ]
~Cm'8 Cif~ ~lf& ~ '?;{fu;<p l;rlfP{
~~ (Azhi) <.!l<j' C<lRM> '5l:~Si ~lfT C<llttP{1
[~ ~IHi)~ ]
~~ Clf~,~ ~tTP{ ~ ~~ ~ I Crr~,~C~
~~ ~~~ ~<:..9jif cm ~C~ mSi I
~t~~ ffi"fp{ 'IN ~<if~~ Pl1 ~, ~ ~C~ iftll 'eC<l~-c<fi~-QiC9f ~9J ~ <1:ti:fJ ~~ ~m1 I ~~ ~
( barbaros) ~t~Jts[ 'fC~ ~$ WI <1:1~ I '!i{-~
~Si-Qi:;9f <pM~ ~~, C~l;r ~ C*~ ~IC~tfI'll
<1:1if~T -QiC<i'!i\t~ ~c~ I
\5ftN C<fN<P 9fC~~ '!i{P{tc~Sii~<f~ Fr'1( @1~J<1'j<1I~~I~,
"lft'f '8 ~T f<lcxrrc'tSi G'j~T~C'[ ~ <itCSiI ~ ~m ~
'5fi~~'{3> <.!l~ <P~ CSftCSi~'fC~ <1:G1<fl"STc~ ~<1i~ I
"tJf-~'l~
~cm '!i{~~ <.!l<t>$'SrhT>tTIlift#\-~ \5{'<l~ cm~I ~
~ ~t'<lPl1 ~ ~ Sift! ~ lfP{I ~ ~~<i @fiIT~$ <.!l<l:~m ~f I m, ~'<lt<:', ~'f~ <.!l<f'~
~ '€ ~o1rt 8~~
~ ~ ~ <iWl,-~~c~~!1(1-n
;01 [~~I~~llr ]
(t1r~~-;fu <;5['<l ~P{ ~~~ ~ <1:i ~ I
~ ~~RHliC<i f<I~ ~ ~ <.!l<1:'c~
~I~~ if?I-~~ C~ ~<:,~ ~ <I'~ I lfP{~
~ lfPI-~Q .m~ ~ ~ I <.!l~ C5fi"1Wl~
~ ~ ~ I [ ~ ~ \:Jllrl(t ] .
~ ~ <.!l<\i$<mlffi ~~~ ~<i<fQ~ f~ I ~ ~
~-~<i <ifm~ ~c~ C<lN<I' #\$iSf, ~ C~'8
~ ~ I c5jtC1t~ ~ ~~ ~~ ffi ~tt~, ~ ~1
~~~I
'lll~"Ji!!t9Jiil~ ~W~i C~C<P ~1 m c'! ift~-~<1i ~'8m ~P{ ~
~~~I "~Pl ~~, ~~, ~ ~ ~1~ Ofl"-<.!l<p~ <p<f'lC<p<1:G1~ ~~ #\~ I [~~'1 ~~I\:J;
11 ~II/)I)]
R't~9Si 1<\~?i~~1 ~ c<t> ~~ ~? ~ ~~ c~tr c'1ftC1t~~W1 '!i\tSi c<P@ P{P{ I <.!l~Si @<iQ W& ~
~R3 <.!l<f~@<i~~ ~ I @<i<>rm ~m ~ fuC'fP{
~I
~'€ C<t>t~'8 '!i{mi ~~ '8 ~~ #jffi<:, ~ I ~
~.~ ~ m C~-QiC<i ~f~ ~ I ~R8 @<i1m
~I
"fu"t ~C~ <f<:..:fj<pN ~-~-QiC<i ~ ~ I ~~
~ ~, ~ ~'1 ~lftf~N ~ ~"3lN~-Qic<i ~<:..~
I '5(~, ~ <.!l<P<ftt~ #\~ I <.!l~ ~ m C'l f~
~ ~tf~ ~ c~, @<iffi~ ~ ~ <!lQ~ ~I~I~~I
<f<;~~ f~~t<IHliC9f 9ff<IT~ ~ I ~~
~;rn I ~~~ ~ ~ ~C~ ~.~-~, I
~~ ~'1 (~ ~ ~ ~ M wT'r-~,~'trI,"t:~H[9f, <f)~ <11 ~~-Q[9f <f<R1 ~ ~3[I ~,
'5I~'e ~, it (~ <ret' I ~ ~~ ~ m ,
<ffil I ~ i1cG'fi<ll <ffitr;fl ~ ($TIm ~~ ~,~~<rr~T~ I
~QW<rT~~~~~~~~
(~"h ~ <f)Q~ 'l1, ~ <f~ 'e <ff'lfO[~ ~~,
~ I lft~, ~ 'e '5l~~ <il~ ~~ mWlQ ~
~~ I <il~ ~~f~ <il~ m5Ol1 ~0'[ ~ ~
lm~ ~ I i1c~ ~ ~ f<lst~ ~~~ ~
~ I c<i'IT'!1<il<f)~ lft~ 'e ~ '51~ ~~
<il<f,~ (~IC'[I.(jc<t>'e~ <!lQ~ I r 9f ~ ~BI"'I"'; ~'<I:l~ ]
~~9f~ ~~i-Concubinage
~"fi'1-~i~C~JSl ~~ 'e ~~~Q1 ~ ~~ @<>f<>fit~
m~f~OT/
~ 'e '51~ (~~~~ 'l:fC~T~m~ ~ ~@9f<ft~-~m @<:..9fRl~C'f <fCC'['l:fC#f~ I
~~~ ~ m ~ ~ @9fCQ'e '5l~" 'Iffi~~, ~ @9f<NI-~Qjt~ Wlc~ '5It'l:[Q1'3Ff~ ~ortf9ftrnl
~ <fC'fC~-~, '51'4t<:..~'1, ~f~~'e '<1~ lf1i~
~ ~i~Hf(c9f ~'1 <fiSI~ ~ 'l1, ~ m~ ~~R~OT~ I [f~, '<"'I(t ] .
~ ~ ~ 0~ ~-~ <fQi 15M 'Ii I
'5lbr~ "£.<!f1-~~'l:['<lib, ~~ ~-~~ ~~~, '5l{t<1..,'~
~~ ~~ I [~, I:lIH, ~I:l,~9; ~I~(t(t ]
'(3 ~ m~ ~ '5fiif-Q[9f ~ ~ 9fWr, ~
~~ I3ltll ~c"1lc<l'~ ~,~ <w1 ~<:.."i:l~~ ~9T ~ ~-
[~ ) ol"'~ ] _
~ ~~ fS~.~~ ~m~OT '5["1"l1c1f~~OT, (~ ~~ ~
rgamy) cWr ~ ~~ ~, f<p~ ~ ( hypogamy )~ «f.tc'li ~'l:[{'l f'l:[O'j~ 'l1 / '5l~<:", ~~ ~ Pr~~~ ~~ 'lft~Q ~~, ~ <ilQf<l~~ ~f5 ~ R~ I
~ ~ '5ftif ~ 'e ~ -rrmQ ~~'l:[ ~~~,
~m ~ ~m-<flnr c~ ~~ ~ I
'lIlj~'1"{iC~@<>f~-~QjtQ ~])"1r1 ~C'f ~OT <f)~ <>tm-1 f<f)~
m~ f<p 9fRT'lTtC'1~C'f \5i ~ <!lQimr 'l1 / "£.<!f1~
~ ~ ~t~ ~ ~ <il<f)~~t~ISlC\!)'e ~~ ~m: t
~ \!I~ Iff"fj ~~C"ll~<i <f)Qc~;r, ~ ~~ 'l1/ ~-~
'JiI-~~ f~ ~OT ~ R<iTRT~ ~c~ ~~ RPM I
~ ~m ~<fC{ ;rQ-OTlif!Q'<l\i'l:[' ~ ~'&, ~'l:[<f9i 'Ttm~
mc<fu- ~ ~~ f;rfil~, f~~ ;fJ])<fC~ -rrm 'e ~<fCofu
~~WIi N~t])nf OT~f<p,(fi f~'e OT~I [~~..:lIBBI~'<, ~I:l;_
~,)~ ~; ~~ ~I~ ]
~ ~. 9fIf~~C'f (~~ "£.QfQ ~<:"9fRl m~ mc~ I
~ ~ ~'l:ftf%1~ ~ (<1ffl (~'e ~~ 9ffu;t~
~~lf ~ 'e ~ '1~~1~QC'1~ '51~ ~~ ~ I
~ ~fu ~~ I '5I~fIr ~{: <ff~fIr C"l1<!'f:-~
~ ~~ ~~ <icfomr '5fiif 'e ~ m~ ~~~ ~ ~~~~lfj ~ 'l11 [,~ ~ '<IBo(t ]
.~ ~'1 '51~ ~ ~ ~ (~:(fi~~<il<l'In:, I!ij~<;,~<f) ~ ~ ~I"lc~j ~ ~ (fi ~
~011 ~"t ~-~~ ~ (~ (~-$~ PMm,
8018
~, ~ -e MTIl C~~~<!l~~
T~~ '11<tI'-=lJ
~~~~~~~~ ~,.~ 1 \5{~ .rriSfQ m1 C~' "'Pf~
\5{~ ~f~f~ ;rtQ( -e ~Q ~ ~~ c~'~I [\5{~ 17'117'1~~; )'-=II<!'-=I'IJ
~ C5j'I.,I}fl~~c<t> ~ 'K~ ~ 9f1ft"fl,
,~ ~ttiSf ~ ~~1 'J1Qi9f~ ~ f
~ 1ft'$ ~~~~ ~ ~~ 1 [17'18)'-=I-S)¢]
c<lht~ ~Q ~~ ~-~fu iJRS" ~ 1 [~If ~ )
~ ~Q \5{<!nR-e ~ \5(f~ ~~,
~ <!l~\5{f~ ~Q(1WR R 1 '5(t9f~ C~~
~<tq ~<>fnR, c<1lft<!nR' \5{mR~ ~ 1) ~ I
\5{~<;,~n11~;r.T ~ ~ c<1lft'1"HI~,\5{mR;r.:r-Qi9f~
<M~ <Pi ~ 1 'M~~ <lii'f ~~ ~ ~ f<fiw; "lll:)I) I) I~ J
<!l~ ~ C~ ~ ~'€m m ~ ~~Q1 rotlfllltOl
~f~"J ~ ~ I ~-m '1Pim:~ ~~ (~~~-*9 ~ ~l:~1 I ~ -e ~ C<lC'!t~<!l~~ ~,
~~-<Pi ~ ~ ~m 0'f'V!\ ~m~ ~ ~~'efi'<i'$<t>\!>t-e~ ~11 ~~ C<lflr<t>~ ~Q @"lif
,c<ffi;fl AA ~ ~ <!lQi9f~tt'1g ~~ ~ 9f1ft ~ I
~ ~-'-=II<I)), ~ <ut~ ~~;qJJr- ~ Of!~~ <ll:"fJt9ft'1"OOQ~'€ ~ c~-9fim I 'f<.~1
:m9 ~ ~9 9.(c~jf~Y~'ll1~ ~ m~"T ~'1
{ p. 55) The Hz'ndu law of marrz'age and Strz'dhana, 1
~t"lll ~fl1'lltll
,~ ~ ~ ~ '1"rtl \5(f~ ~ ~i <!l~
5j~'llI~c\!>'llC~ m1 ~ ~~ ~~ C~ rrI <!lmct
SOlt
I ~~ WR ~ \5{~ ~-~
~ ~~ ~t~~ \5(f~ ~ ~ I ~~
~ ~ \5{~ ~ ~'"t *9 <li~ ~ -e ~,
tJ.1"', ~ ~ ~~ ~~ \5{~ cm~ <!l;q~<!l~
~ ~ ~ ~ I [pp. 4:-5, The religion and/If of the Atharvaveda) N. J. Shende) 1952]
~ ~ \5(f~ ~~'t'€ 9fM~1 m I ~9f~
~ ~~ ~9f ~, f~ ~ ~Q( ;q1
~9~, ~ ~ ~-Qil:9f mtlA ~~~, \5{M
~ I [~~ 81)1); 81<18, <t; pp. 4-5) Socz'al,eligiouslife in the Grz'hya Sub'as) V. M. Apte) 1954 ]
~ ~ ~ C~ 1J~<il'~ CIf~ <iTf~ 1 ~~~~ ~ ~ m~ ~~1 ~ <!l<t>Q(1f;r:~~ <fO'j1W'll
~ ~ ~Q ~ iT~ <t>~;qt'1"i ~ I
~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~-Qil:9f 9fR!~ C~ \5lt~t;q
I ~1~>1'llc\91~ ~'"t ~1;~C~9f <il;q~c5j~,~
~il ~~, ~ \5{~ cm~ ~ C<li~ ~~ <lCfI ~1
~ tm> ~ ~~ ~ -erifr!, ~ ~ ~-m ~ ~, \5{1~~'ltciSfQ9fR!f~ ~~ ~~ ~,
WO! '8 ~ ~ ~-e 'll~ ;qJt~ 9fR!~ ~ I
~~ 0T~ "Rf.I1~~~, ~~ ~tror \5{~9 ~Crj<t>~'ll
~ <!l~ ~ '€ \5{~ c~~"J Q~Q Cl)~t'€ ~ I,lr<I)8J
~~ R:~~ ~ iSf~m9, \5{~<;, "Tt'f<l>~~ mI~ ~ ~~ ~ ~,-Qil:9f <!l;q~~C!f f~ ~ ~~
~, '€ ~ <!l~<u1~ m m '5("'9f~~~, ~~~ ~
~ ~~ <P~ ~ ~~1 CIf~ f~ I
~C~Rm~~~,~ c~~-
~t'1~~~<ml~1 \5(~~
~ 'l~ I <>ttf<tf.r-~U!i~ ~~
~i I 9JtMf-T ~~ ~ ~m f;~,€,~~Pl~, \5(ft<:"~ CQ[C~ \5l<l~ ~'<fi ~9ht ~c<IT(f~ f~~ I m~ <Ii'l"l~ c~ ~ ~
AA is/1-\c\!)-\ I C"t~ @mQ"'1-~<i ~~
~~ ~<1 1 ~~U!i ~<!f-9\f<mml ~~ ~
[ <ii ~181) 0 ]
"'llt~ ~"C'1 ~ '8 ~ ~Fe~ ~t<:, ~i m'li I
'iWm 'l~ ~, r<\'!JJ, ~"1~ "'lif<ml'8 w~~'1 <!lQ"c~~ I [~I)~ ]
<ITi!;'i"<\'i!J~ c<!~~~~i ~~'8 fi~ '8 <\tf~ ~
~~I [)I)~oJ
f~'8 ~,-~~ ~fit$ltR I [~I~ ]~~<i ~'1 cfl cmt! m c<! ~-<iftfDnT C<fi~
\5('Ii~~ f<nrR 'l~, <ut~ ~m'1 ~-~ ~ ~~ ~~ <iM~Q" f~ ~~ \5(rT '8 \5(~
~~f~~;ftl
("llT'I J'f~fll-!l't
~ '8 ~ f~(f-~ <it"tt9JtN ~C"'l~ ~~
~ ~ ~~<ll 'f~~ '<ll"Cm~\5ft'l"C~ ~~ ~ ~
~T<1'f,~"C't~ ~5f ~2 ~ I ~<j>?l ~ ~
CQ[C~ ~ ~ it ~'1 ~Q""c~, ~ ~ 'fmt'f
\5('5t<!~ I ~Q.( ~<t>t?l ~~ "1~ ~<t>M ~ I 1%Ul~ ~Q.(t'8~ c<! ~c.,jC<l'~ 'f,~ ~
~ '8 f.lrn5f'~~ ~~ ~~ I [pp. 16-17, /J6.the ages, Jadunath Sarkar, 1928; p. 86, EpicVaidya, 1907 ]
~ <t>t~ol't~f~ ~ '8 15Rt~~-~ ~ ~
I ~ Pr"~ 15{~~~~ f<l:~~ff 9ftM~'1 -nT,
~9\fi~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~, ~_Jl~-<!>f~ pairing family <\1~~-9f~Q" ~~ I
~ ~9(~ ~sr f<g<\i <\~ fu~ m"fr;{ ~~~ C1f~ ~ I @if~sr<t~9f ~ '8 \5((~ ~ @rn~
~ I Jl~ ~9(:{ ~~ C~ ~<t>~ ~~ 9f~ ~9fi%
~ ~~ Jl~ ~"<fi~ C<!fflsr ~~ c<ire 9Jt"Csr!
~ ~-~ ~sr fffif ~~-f<!f~ ~ ~rn~ I ~~
'I'~c~ \5{'10O{t~ \5(rT5J"~'~J""i"C~~tOf C'ft'5 <t>sr~I \5(~C.,tC"1Q"
~~~sr ~c.,€ ~Q"f<l:9f~~ ~~C.,tt~sr 'f~fOf 'f~~.,'5T ~., 'Ii,
~RwI~sr ~ ~ Q""1m \5(Of~ ~. <2t"C<\"t<t>~ ~~ I
~'1-~ 1j1~~<tsr <j>t~~ f<l:<!t~sr 1Wi Of~, ~,
~ f.rf{~C<i f<l:m ~"C~9ft~ 'Ii I
'I'Mi ~~C"'lC~Of'!~Pr~C<tsr<t>"C~~~~t~;fT @"t~tr<i'3 <j>?l~ I
~) W'5tQ"~ ~mor \5(~'!t"C?!"tt~~ f<l:<!t~<t>~Of lft"t?l~-
1 C'3R3ffi ~'1 CQ.(C<t> iSftOf~ 9ftR! c<!'ft"C"tsriSf"if<r~~~
~ ~ 1 ~ iSfO'(t~ 'f~ 'ftM?! 'f"9(* <IT~ ~~, ~~m,
'l!l,~~ ~~ ~ I 'ft"t~~?l <J::~t~ \5(~ru "1tc~ ~
~, iii?!~~ <>R ~~ 9ft~ f~f-T C'S!"CO'(?l~ I \5("c'l"C~ <\"CC'fOfc<!
~ 'K,,*~?! \5(~~\g. o:r~I ~c"If1-~ttm~~ '5t~~~~ 'f~<!f'l! • ~ '
, ''I, qit'!i, f~7[, ~O{,@~ ( Camel ), Fr~~?! <!ts~ 'f'S!t~ ~
~li "Ii I "1tt~ 'f"C5f\5(tfiT-\5{~cfhr~~~ 'f~'ifi ~fiT
~lT,\5~C"'l'ft"t ~~tsr \5(rrt~c~C<lltt'l1'f"Cilf~Q.(tt~'Ii /
~rsnt~sr "tt~~ ~~Of '<ll"C>.t"Cif?!"t~~~ I f~R ~~~'l \5(0 ~<i~ I
~1f.. ~'1 ~'3T ~O'( <\0'(1SO'(~ <it"C?!c<!'<ll"C>.tfu\5(t"1"C~\5ft~ '8~ <'~Iof 'f'~~\ '1 ~~ ~rn~ 1 ["1~i )/)00189 81r ~o . )/)0' .i~ ' , , J ,
; ~ ) 0 ''O>Ir/ ~ . C~ 7li I 3, q I "8/):<'; pp. 06-307, Foundations
e, Gray; pp. 84-88, The Aryans, Gordon Childe ]) lfP.t-~~ i"\.
If <J I >i <J::~?ll\5f~t~ <i?lt"tC~ 'f"C5fc<IT'l~Of '<fd;~.,I'~<.!l~ "\5f1ir c5ft<!i-<1t~I ~'3i1t~ ~ C'l'8lii ~t~ c<! <im"hi
I
Siillr
e~ c<ffi;r1 ~ W 1fM-~Sl ~ ~
PlG'['T-'Si~ W~· Cv.i~ ~-~ ~ ~ I [
~~lrIBlr]
('if) ~~III.?I~~~ <rt"~ ~ c<! ~ Q~ ~
~~~I ~'T~~@i,~~~~~
C~Pl'T'1Sl ~'l ~ ~~ ~ ~<tQ <rf.r1 ~ ~
'Of~~ <rt<U I ~f.i<il<r,~i]j> <il<1>~ I <1>~ ~
<{,"tlfSll <il~ ~~ <il<ffi; ~ '>tC<tSl~ I '5\1i ~~'" ~
<tf<rf~ ~Ojl <r1 ~i]j> <il~ f<f; <1>'CSl? ~ ~
Sl~ I <ilSl 'CG1 Sl~ ~(;<tSl ~ ~f~~ I.!l~
~~~ wfu w.n ~,~ I 'Of~~
~ortSl f9t~ ~lftSl ~ eD(;~, ~ ~~Wl ~
Pl~ ~ '<l~~ I [~~I\;r~I"'~-"'~; ~ ~ol~"'I~ ; ••.~:
C\Sf~ ~I~~~ ; ~I~~<i ; ~~7J) ~<il~<i ]
('<l) ~ ~ ~'TPi "t'.f.'CSlSl'RIf{'T-~9f 'ifotJ ~.
f~lf1 ~ ~~WT <\lt~ I ~"L'1t ;rt?t-<t>~ I 'Ttt'll~ I ~ <rJt9fnrGl ~ ~~-<£l<f~
~ I 1t~ C<1>1m 'Oftm <1rr ~~ <t>Sl1'T1 ~,
<1>Sll'W1 c<! <il<l'W 'OfP{ c<fi~Sl CG'ft<f~G!'-8 ~'T ~~
~ ~~'T I ~ <il<1>Sl1Im ~r~~ ~ ~~fil<p'lll~
~~ 1 f~f.r ~t~'f11 ~tQ ~'ll"~t'T .-rr<t~, ~ft~, ~~ 9j
~~ ~1 Slt'1f-TI1 Slt'1f-TI ~ W ~~ ~Sf ~~ ~:{ ~ I [~)1~~81~\;r,~","8;
~~; ~I~<i<il~"-"'~; pp. 32-34,· Studies in Indt'an
H. C. Ray Chaudhuri, 1932 ]
('jjtm-\!it~<l't~ 'li{Olt~ '11~
c<ft~Sl ~~ e'if~ <il<l'W ~~<1>1 cfnf~ ~ I
~'T1 ~ ;rtm ~. f<l'\ftil <fiQ1 <t>rJ'll
~~CG1 ~ ~ <iWi I
~ ~ ~ S"~
~ <£l~ '"It~ ~ e~j I C~ ~,~_ ~~ <£l<fi~~~ e~ ~nT'tj ~ c<! ~~~ <£l<1>fU~-
0JPf1cf ~~ ~~~Q '"It~t1 1 ~nr'1r<l> 'Of'TP! e~-~<t,
~ ~'&~'&, c<P-R1 ~~ ~ 'Of~'l ~,fit~I ~~,~ ~ fWr ~~ <iWi 0111
orJ3l ~ ~-'OffLm:~ <£l<t>J1;1<ft~ I ~ ~<tSf
~ ~-~<t 'ifotJ ~~ <rul<1>fU ~ I ~~,~, <r~,~ ~ ..• I <£l~ ~~~ <r~Sft~ 1i1~ ~"f1-$~" <£lQ1 ~<t>CO'j~ frIT~ ~ 'Of~ I ~~,
~:'f) ~ ~ <T'iflf~ ~cfbrtf.1 ;
tI) ~, ~ ~ ~~ em"!' ~ ~~ ~iSfo1~ ~~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~C~ 'lTClfJ 'Oft,M<1'II.?1'C<l~~J M~ ~C~ I c<r~~I!l<fi~ f.!N~ 'if'~ ~G'[ I <£l~ 'if~nr ~~ ~Sf1 ~-~9f
~ ~ ~~~-~ I Q'lTt~ D<>T ~ft~ <il~9f 'Ut~~I
~~ ~~<f ~ ~~ ~~ ~/'& ~~'T ;rj I ~Q1'E ~ e~ <1>~ <H'T~ ~-~<t <1>f~ ~C~~ I "i~
'{Jf € ~F<l'¥~ ~Tt~ eQjc<1> ~~~ ~~ I
~- '€ ~ ~~~ ~Sf f~~ 'Of9f~ 1 ~ <il f<l<rm
I!l~, ~O'j I ~Sf $ <1>~'T~ ~ c<!C~ <tm-;rj I,
~ ~ ~ ~ c<! ~"'rn ~ (cult) t(1vRr ~9m~~~I ~mlfC1<r1 e~1 ~~~.
%'-1-1, \!j~ ~J-~<t ~~ <t~ I ~nT1 ~iSfo1-~.
~€ ~\3 ~<l, f~,<r1 ~~ ~ ~ I,c~~ ~~ e'ift~'@far ~m <t,~-~;~(~
~I ~ ,~ ~ e<fi ~ C<1> ~ ~1 f;r<fu ~,
~nr <il~ ~ ~/~ m~ 'T~ I <ilSf f~C'T ~-
00
'5\~~ <li~T"tO'j 1 [~~ ~I)<t; ~18).
-s1<t18; ~9jyt9 81)b-1) ; c<ITlfhR~~~-)I)I~I)8,'H
~1~JroI'l!
~M ~ C<! ~<liQ9 ~W ~O'j. \ffi ~C!
.~ ~ ~'IT I ~~f<l,"t ~9 ~ ~ ~,.
<ffiG'fl\;~Q ~ 61t~ ~ Joined group qj lfa[-~
~Q1 61~ <Ii~Q <li~<rrf~ c<l1f9f'ti~ on, ~
~f'€ ~9 ~ ~i, ~~ '8 @~~, ( ~~ ) mlft;\ ~ I
'5(~ ~ ~Qi ~i c~ ~ m I Dtf~.~"5f '5(t~ ~fir~ ~~ ~~f<l,><t6It"lir;~ 1 [~6Ii )~1)-8
'5(~~ ~~ ~~ <lit~ 61~ m-~ f.,~1I1l1re6It~-'Qi~ ~~~~ ~~<li ~9 ~m~, ~ ~ ~~"5tt~ '5(t~T5t9, ¥l~ m5t9, M, '5(fIrf~, ~,
:~~~ I ~tt<li ~~9 ~ ~~, 9jyt9, 5tt~ 'e
~~ ~r;01Q '5(~fu;~ @~ <rr'S' ~~ ~ i\"PJ
c<l"\'~m ~9 '5\t~ 61~~ ~ f~~ "iffi" I m0l6lt~T @~'lfi~, \ft{f;(<li ~~If ,~~ ~traItDr fu1
·)<tI)I),~; )<tI~I)-~; )11~1)),~0 ]
<>rfu~ «CO'R C<! ~ c<N '8 ~ ~ f~ Oft, ~
.ftr;O'j~ '5(~,l:'€i~ ~M ~~, f<li~ ~i ~ ,5tthfill
f~ I ';m ~ ~aR'r.l ~r;Wf @fm~ ~-~~-c5fiil1 ~~-<tf'~ 6I"li~, ~ ~9 m Pli, 'a{9f-~
~Q1 61~ ~t~ <li~ ~ 1 ~-f~ ~-~t~
'¥l,~f~ ~~tfir~ <liQm ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ IiSf'1J ~ ~ ~ ~ on ~'R <li~ ~ ~ Pli,cml
. 418~1~-r~~ ffir;~~ ~i I [~ )1)\:I°lb-; 111:)~11:),
A Survey of Indian history, K. M. Panikkar, 1954]l -:",r..'l
~"HI '!I~'f I 'l!~ <!~ C'f(JrFtfil(ll~ 1 '!It9\"f\§ "tt~ f.l~'l! ~ I
. ~i CDllI"il' c0{9f(otJqf(~il C~('5j~l1.i>1~9f'li"ilt"il"1'WC"1t"l1 ~(~ I
'm!; '<lO ~l11WlI clfol1~ll. COl1'11';sfjO{ta;t"if"j(l~ '5j~ ~ fIr('l' ~~
'l'(Jl iit~(ll 9\t~9f °n(~ 'l't"1 I ~1t~ ci>fa1C1l'to{C<!(;sf~AA~~"iI iir~tll I i1I(~ ..!l(}(ci>fa;~<rlO{i>l~o;j C"lll I
Yes, hm' hm'. No···no. Yes. What is it? I see.I see. No. No....
[ Ci>fi;«l'IOlC"iI(~~-!l'li "11..!lf5tCllflj'Cil .£l(}( ci>fUl("ll't~'f(a; COlli]
Ayer! Ayer, see me at once.[ci>fa1C"lflo{ 'il(~ CDlltCll f'5j(ll ~t}( '1'd.·"'t'5j!lj9f(<J!:rr~ 'l'~(~ "tt('l' ..!l'li~t"il9111..!l'l'St ]
[ '}(c~i>tfil "ffirtll-..!lll ~(<!"f ]
"·Yes,( ffi~ ~ '5\1m-C<li Clfl:~)'8, 1i~ ~ ~~~m ~ <!Il:O'ji~ ~~'8 ?It is two o'clock. He should have come by now.
trCfll ~! ~'l" <m~<1' ~ -'5\i m5ti ~~ I
f<i~ ~ ~i <m'Sf ~ ~ 0fR mt~ I ~r;~
~ <Vt~~<1'"{~Jj~~ C~ <litwl> '8~ ~
~,~ ~5ti I
C\5j ~ wr;~~i <li"l~ ~,~ ~~'l"?
~~, ~ com:, CC'If<R ~ ~r;~ ~. ~ ~T~ 1i~)] ~ CIfi¥'1t~wr;~~ ~ ~~~~k~'Si~ ~ I
~I
~ AA ~ ~ 9fi'! ~ftT ~~ ~~iSi~, -s"Q '5t5tt fWmr ~
~,V[ ~, m~<\~~ <I'~ ~ ;rt! S~5tt? Now listen Ayer, .~~ i~ I Mr. Hammerton ~ay drop here
from Delhi. Ledger Account f~ Up-
Dt~ I Auditor~ <WI ~~ ~ ~ r~: ~I
<\"V[ ~ ~ <I'~ I
~ ~ c'51 ~ manage ~"Q ~ I
<I',V[ How? Indian Trading Corporation
~~ C<I'm m5!1? ~
~'l1?~tQ @ ~ ~ntf~ I
<gV[ ~ru~ C<f.~i~~ <mm5! ?
~ Auditor-COl -q'Pf ~ ~ ;qt~ ~ ; ~ ...
<{l,V[ I say bribe him by any means.
~ ~:r.l C'f~ i I<I',,,t ~f~\5<f C'f~~.? <ic~C"1C>1r~<I'~
you can well understand my position.
~ You see sir I too have made my posi .
precarious.<{l,V[ So what! Want to back-out noW?
moment?
~ NaSir.
<{l,V[ Then !...
... ~ ~~,\51 ?mtm: [~m ] ~<I' c-ri'~ I
[ <fl~O:It"l1 ~Ht~ fll~ f1lCI
(~) Look.
~I •( ~ ) ~ C<tl1~ Cli11
.rr 1fI<l1
So I finalise the deal.
Yes sir.
You can go ...[ 'bj 1~1~-<!l"il02j~t"l1S ~'lf"l"ill~!-~"il~w.t }
., ·Oh, Please come, please come, take your seat~
please take your seat.
:~~~~~~?: ~ ti, ~, C<@c~I
: ~iC'fC'fQ~~1
: ~~C'l~ I
: Income Tax office-~ ~ m~I
: ~'ltari ~1) ~i ?
: Cflj 'l'WTICfj~5tt! ~C'f<\ ~ ~ I ~'ltQ COl<I'~ f<js-
c~ '€iwl5!1 I @itt<[5!1~ ~ C<tl'lI "Qm'1 ~i I
".~ ~ mwr ~ ~ ~5!1 ~ <\t~ I
~~ onm- ~ mr c'51 <ffiW! ~ '1<1''51 ~~ ~ <11~t~cS[ !
: I.; C\!ii ~ ~ruI
: ~ ~'Pril ...~~ ~ '1.~ ~9f 'lW 'It'lf ~
~ ~ TIl ~ transaction-C<tl ~ C<tlm<1'; 'l<{l~ ~ t
~, ~, <\hl~c~!• ~'hT-h.: I'II ~ C<tli 'lt~~9ff<t> ~, ~~ ~ ?• ~ ~ mfi¥C~,~9f ~1~I~c~ I
<fi~"t ~~ <\1~1~,~ I
~~: ~TI\ ~ ~"'m~or~l
<fi~"t For fifty tons of Rayon Silk?
~~: 0!f<l''I Forward Business ~ ~ ~~c:, ~ ~ <It<J:~ I
~~"t Rayon Silk ~ f"1C~c~ C"t~ I Import_~
or5t1 ~'tt~i~, ~r~C'51 ~~~? ~India C"l sole monopoly m~ Rayon Silk
~~<nlt~: @ c~ ~ ~ ~t~ I"'C~ ~<t~ ~ ~Jt~, <Q<\>~1 <!'tQ<l'h1:~ ...
~"t : Make the amount round two and I closethe~~: ~~~,~~<lt~1,<!",,\, ~<tf<l> ~ ~ C'51final <fiQW~~,
~i ~ fo1~~~~<fiQ*ctl
"!~~: ~-~~?~"t m~1.~~:~!,<!,,"t -€Q <Q<\>~ ~ ~ruf<t>if you agree to pay
you will have to close the deal to-day by
~~ ~ <ltt'SiZ<\>'5(i'\fQ~'tt<l'i W"CstmClMI ~
~~t~: ~ <lt~<l'i ~? ~ru~! ~ ~<lt~~? ~<t C<fi~i~~ Reserve Bank <ncm'<!~~~~?
'<fi~"t C'51PrQ C<fimc~') I
~~~: c;Wz <lt~, @~ .~~, ~ ~ ~~
~m~C\fN~~1 "'Cfl<ri~[
Ayar, please gee me.
[ ~~lli '8 ll'l~I.'l9fJlRCIl 'l'J~ ~C!l ~ ~,"f I <!l"~ 9\C\l~ ~tlla'
.!tC~ ~1l I ~~}[cltr c~~cli'\'l~ ~'l't\l C."*lI C'l'Clli 'ec:r I
~t!lrll f'llF11!';1ll~<:j C'lll I l1C!)f'fC!Jff~~!l ~c~ '<lei ~t1I Cl:;tc~
iot]
yes ....( ~"t-c<f) Trunk call from Hom~ay officec
sir.Mustbe Mr. Hammerton.
Just a moment please.[ ",,·t-C'l' f'llf'f~1'l1(lfl!J
Yes Mr. Hammerton, speaking-hm'·· hm' .. ·hm'···
no)no, hm'-no, no sir-no further tenders and no,furtherbuying and selling of shares-sorry I mean,no no-by shares I meant··· Mr. Hammerton-listen
Mr.Hammerton-Hallo- Hallo···By jove, you talked of shares I c"im f<\> <lt~ '5\t'tt.{:
~'8 @-Jtm I
Did I! Mistake, A slip of tongue.A slip!A slip. Give me the phone. (c~ CO{~) Yes,.,
Hallo Hallo·· Hallo··· Hallo, no connection. (c<mr.UlC~ ml)
...But how could I talk of shares !Just a slip.
A slip and I go down. (<tI~ ~) You can go-Mr. Ayer.R.ightsir.
[ ~tl!1\l-.!l'll.!l'fI'l }
[ ~Tlfif'll-!fC?{"f J
Any news Anne ?
i!~.,~, <Q~R~<ll \!l\t~ ~ ~ ~ I ~
~~~I He issister.
But that's a mad house. Father •that slip of a girl Kalyani Oh h lWOn, ,ope ess.Only a gesture from Kalyani earns youlacks, honestly.
~ <fiauT9r'lf ~~ ~ ~~ terms ~ ?
~~I .
~ ~ C'f ~'lr<! ?How do I know that. 9Jtlf ~~, ~-~~ <l'CQ ~-e~, f<t' ~ ?i ,...('i5t~t\!i~ f~?;~~ ~ 1m ~ ~<t't5j<sfm <t'?;Q fl![ ~ ~~ ~ ~<l~ c~cif nrrn c<f nrrn ~:{ ~ '<lQ~-n1 ~~ cffi~ ~ ~~, ~<:, C'1 ~
~~1)[ <\>~ <t't"tl:~ ] What this smoke
<\>~ ~?~,'l11 ~<t'~r;91 document-~
c~~? <:sfJt~!
A glass of water please···[<f.~"t (5f~~?\"il \S<111 (,~t<fi ~~''lll1J11l ~
'SjOj ~t~ ~Jtf'! I W'llt<'r ~fl;f~~ 'Dlt" ~
.. ·horrible. What did you say.
When?
V:Jas it a fire.\
It is all over.
Help me. I must take some rest,
Come. Give me your hand.[ ~Jtf'!~'t' f'!ll! (~'&1l fill!! ,sC'f ~
'fi1'lf'S/ f~~t~ ·lt~<fi ]
["ilgfm~)
••.Jlt'li ~~ ~g"l0{~~ I ~ ~ ~ '5\l:~ ~
~~I
~~A'~.gt@ ~c<fr11 ~ ~ I~ ~ -Rt> ~~ ~ ;rtf<\> ifi1fi! clerks-~ ~~
~~Cif~1
011; '!If<Pl formally ~; 'i5r<! Qt~ ~ ~~ 1 ~
pressure ~! .. ,Home life «O"j?;\!5 ~ :ff<\ ~ ~
c~ I" ·~sr ~ field \••..ork--e ~ 1 ~ ~ c~~ <!t~ ~, @ ... ~ ~?;~ <\>~ ~~, ~
~ ~_~ <\>~~ ~, most normal ~ <Utm-
nothing is possible in my position. C'\t~ C'\t~~
responsibility, businees expand ~~ ~~/9 ~~
~ m~Q ~ ~ ~~ m-~<l'1 ,sr51l ~~ I 'O\t?:Q ~ Incorporated in India <fi'{t/U
W~~? ~Cifl
m~iR ~ ~t9(~ mQi9 solvent "Ift"if1!'WI ~ ~ f<I>? India Limited ~ ~ c~~ overdraft-~sr ~9(sr <t't~ ~, cash balance
~t.,I<t>I~1 ~ m~? ~f\rr;<l> <>tt@~ ~Wl~-~~ 5\'fK;t<VG1
~ fifty percent-~sr ~9(Q profit "5?;C'\~ ~ I
National economy, national wealth-~~ ~~
c<m;~ ?~ ~ <l~ ~ ~rtm 1 ~ ~ ~9(f.! C<l''l m~ ~j~l(.bI!(-i?
~~~"1~~1~ ~ ~ ~ I f~ <J?fC'f?;1T @~ 9(tm~CO{ ~
~'€~~,Cif~~ 1
Director's Board-~ c~ ~ ~~ I offer ~
~~~I
~
11tc'l ~ \!)~'51t~tC1 ~, ~ f-rr~G'fI'5? ~ ~ ~ f.mr ~ ~holder ~ ~ ~"11?
~~~I
~ ~ ?···By the by, ~~!C-nT te
~ ~ P1>'ili ~ <1i~ ~ ~ honestquote <1i~1f;r 1 ~ ~ c~ quota .
~. f;r~ ~ ~ commission-~ ~
~ <fCC'!'"
Leave that to us. '5lt<1f"1f<lil ~ -rl ~ !~ ~1 ~ <fCC'l1,P1>~ ~M~?
"11, '5lt'if;r c~ ~? ~C01 ~ ~f ~
m 1···By the by, ~t'i"'TTIf Studebaker Van,
~~ "11, ~-"lt'f '!>ffi~ m c~ order--tt
~~; mt~ro1~~1
~C'fc~!m1 <1C1~CC1O{ ~tm ~ ~"fC~ ~
~~ <fCC'!~ ~ c~<R"11 <l'~ 1 '€tI
September '5lt~ ~ ~C01CIf'€~ ~ I
'8! But why 14th?
~: !'8~! ~J ~~~ ~~ c~~~~1 ~i ~ i9f~~ <l'~ P1><l'~ "fCOl~
~~m'it~! ~!'itffi! ~ ~ lftIf1~m 'fR~ ~ I~"111 ~1<1~I~ c~? c~prt~ ~ '!ftlI11
~1C~'i~"111 $1~~-~'~~
~t~ 'itffi! lfiT ~O'f P1>~, ~
~?:'f~"111'5ltm ~ fuaf ~ ~ ~?:'f ~ orIl
~~ ¢o''iJ
~ <p~l ~ ~ ~ ~ fm ~fWi ~, ~fU<IS:
f.l?:~ ~ ~ ~"111 P1> ~, P1> \5~,
~_~~"1t~~"111 ~~~~~m~ ;rj? c<f.tm c~O'f ~? ~,~, ~!"
~ ~ \!)11~\!)~I ~ ~ ~~ \5t?:0'f1~ I ~
~~ rest-~ ~ ~~ 1
f<l;, ~~?;rj,~~~~; ···~~,~~~I·
[CDlItC"iI f'lftll ~~ I ~t"Si9\i!! ClfC~ I ~lltil ~~ ~ I llgfi{"
~~lfJ '9fc~j; (~<li ~<li~lt'lt (Dq; ~~ m ~ll CD~ f~cit' <li~"t.'*
~(lfll]
[ CR' CIRl] ~~ f~ lftIf1 I
f'f? ~'Gi '5ltm f<t>? (m~) ~g;"1 !~~ mm! '€1l1f<t>'ili'5lt'i~ persona t'€ I O'ft~ ~1 f;r~ ~ <fO'f«"111 Need I thank
you for th is !
'li, rnr.:il1 lfiT<l'TIf~! '5lt'if;r ~~ ~ ~ "11lft1f1,
Roy and Roy Company-~ Director's Board-~ ~
~~m~~~~~"11Really! I am really happy Ranjan. ~~ \5tC011<t>~ I
After all we need stout hearts for stout projects.
New blood must come in.[ <!>f~fOlell ~Jtfilil <!te<f"r ]
...~~ \!iUtfol, ~g;"1 ~m ~1l ~~ ~ 0~ ~C'51~'51l'
~C~I
Really, how we cherished it Kansha.
Happy news, very happy news.
15ft~ ~ '1ft~"1~-~ I ~ ~~ ml ~ ~ '"~ ~<1fe <t>?:~ 1 <\\S5~0'f1 ~ ~ I
i§1 ~ ~ ~ 1 ('~!~Qt~ ~ ~ COWl: ~~ I
I am really happy Ranjan.
~~.,'l~~~t~ :
~:
'l~~~Pl :
<t>,'"f
'l~~~l<!:
~
~, <fiO'lTt~ ~ Clf~ "11 ~nr I ~
f<r; 1!Jftfol, ~ ~ <t>~ ~., I ~
~~\SW1J I
~~ fu, ~ 1Vtt~ "11 I
<l"~'I1r~"1I"l,~ ~ I
Appointment fail ~ ffi ~ ~ I
~~~~"111
"11"11,appointment f<r;~ ~ "11 I
~, c<lTflfj ~ ~ ~ I She should ~by this time.
m m '5fi1T1 ~'hf ~~ I
mm?~ ~ 'iR, ffi "Q11I m I
C'! f<r;, \Sf~ <TI'€, C'lG'fPTC'F'!-'5(Jtf.! !
<fI<li ~it<; ![ }{~t~ 'l"Jl(g ~'!l 9(ciip I
W <\t\!l "11f~ ~G'fPT I
~.,~., I
CWrC1jit;r-~<jl~~ "11<fCC'!~ ~ ~~ I
~~9!~~ f<jl~9 m I ~<jl~ ~ f~ I
~ "11MI CD<1>-"i ~ ~~ ? .. ~! . f<li~ <Ut~
c<t ~~<fJ ~~ emergency develop
CD<1>~."
~ <lC'fC<R~m I
~, ~ CD<1>~to:ri ~ ~~ 15th-~~9f\1 <Utt'ons of d
~V"l '5tt7f1 ~ I c<R"11, for some reas~~ accou~t temporarily operate ~ Of!
15th c<t c<ffi;fj date, f<r;, ~<fCli ~ '?
~ <Ut"ftif ~ c<t...011,.£l<n manage <jl"CQ;rt'€, ~~! ~ ~m-~ "11~
.£l~~ f,rc~ ~G'fPT I (m ~"l") "Q~;rc<l' ~<mf
Director's B.oard-~ ~, ~~ ~ I
~ <l'~ ~ ~C'! ~~9 I
UI f.lnl~, ~:! (~Jl~~<l") What about that
dimple,Anne.Dimple you said!Yes, dimple on your cheeks when you smiled.
Oh Mr. Roy, now you will find only the depression.Why, you have not grown older as all that.Yes, but too old to have that dimple Mr. Roy.Is it so? ..So it is-hm' -hm' -hm' --churio
. everybody, good night, good night.[ ~~l~tll ~ ~~~ ~101~.2I~I~)
Everything seems conspiring.What has happened ?
~Rl ~ ~<jl~ ~~, ~~., ~<jl ~<1'C'ft~ ~
<il<jl~ Cs<!' f'fV"l., I f<r;~ ~9f~ ~: m ~"C'l ~
~1 withhold <jl~ <lV"l c~C'!.,-:-<Ut~ ~
~ ~~ '5ttC'fi arr~~"11 I
"f~m ~~"Q,€C'fi ~r:'l~ ~ ~ I ~ ~<jl ~
~~?<jlt?;~ <jl?f1~ f<r; <fC~C'!~ "f~~! ~ ~ I
Pr: Q11I ~ "l"~m <jl~ C~ ~ <t>?f1 C~
~~I
~ f<r; <jl?f1~ <>ftftT~ "l"~~~I"l~<l" !
C'l ~ \Sftr:;r1 f<r; ~ ~Pr ~ I
~ f<r; ~ ~ ~~ c<ttm<TI~ ~ PT: ~~ I ~ 9f'R!~ <qi I "1i f<r; PT: ~1"l1'l1(;-i'"
Why lose nerve darling rAnything may happen now, any time.But nothing must upset you.I am failing Anne.
No darling, no, Steady, please be steadv[ </t~~C'l1C'l' l;ff~ ~ ~;
... My Lord, oh God.
~1[0l ~~-\I ~~tll'C1[ 'l1~J '<ICllt~1 1[~,! </C~ I ~
1l~~1~ '5jt~~ I <'l~1.~t:lf IS ~Pi't1[~'lllIm ~ 1ltl(
~~ <>tCll~'1ft'! ("tll 'l'Cll @d \!i{1C:If'l'0lr1911
f<t>, ~~~~ ~ ~ R"lDt"t WI ~! ~'!.•_
$1 C'"\Ht~, ~~ appreciate <llrSl1! ~ ~
~ affi:5tR I~~ ~<;<l'lQ "1t5tf~ 0\1,f<l' <!C'1<l!~ <l'aut9T,~~~ 5tR<ro1I, ~~ ~~ ~<1'j~~I'<1~ f<rWr ~ $1 <ro1I, 0\1?~ <l'Q{l~ $1, <l'Q{1'~~<f' '5{~~ ~ ~
~C'fi <l'r;Q '5'ft'8m ~ 0\11 5tt'8ID'8 ~ 0\1 ~
~ affi:5t0{11<l'Q{l~ ~ C~ ~"t1, ~-~<l' ~~ ~~-f~ ~ ~~~~~~ ~ f<fi ~rrca'I~ ~~ W, ~~~ ~ ~ ~<1ti m Oft,
~~0\11 5'ft~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~'l, ~Q Wl~Sl ~~~~ ~<f' Ci$ ~I ~ ~ ~
Clf~~~~~ml ~~i\1t'f
"
~ ~J <li!<f1 ~ ~ \!iftm I ~~~~~,~~
~~'8 ~ ~~ <l'~ ~ Pmmf ~ ~~~,.~~ <>tf~1%~O{ ~ ~ ~~'l ~~ ~
cqt<f~ ~ ;r!. I
~1' ~ ~ <l'aut9T, c~ ~ C'lffR 5'ft~ 0\1,f<l>~ ,~1, ~ ~CO{~~ 0\1<l'Q{1'~~,.,
c~ <l'~ ~? ~9 '5WfQ ~TIml ?
~I
~?~'lQ ~ ~~'8 Ulro'R0{1 ~9T, ~ ~lJ ~ I
~~ ~tWI f<WTQ~ \!ift~ ?~~ ~"C'l ~O{ I 'l~Sl ~~ c~r;~I \!iftQUl<l'~0{1 ~
"Wlli
Q~O{! UlC'llUl"C'llI
~'<i\t~?~~, ~ f~ ~ If''tGll'<i\Q(D~ cWlMr( ~ ~ ~ ~~~~ f<R!<l:~ '5ff;qfu '<i\tPr'l, <l'Q\1~ I
~ ~ f~ I W!1 0{1" .. \!ift"1t9f<f'OO ~-
( ~C<l' ) Q~O{Qi1l, 'It"! ~CO{~ ~ I·~~I
~Mining Federation-UlQ Ul<l'iSM~~, Chamber
of CommerCe-UlQ Ul<f'SM~Sft '!~.,.
\5ftQ !
C<l'O{,~ ~ ~f~ ?0{1I ~ €Q ~ 'ft'8 I
~~Q~~C'!r(1
~ I '5ft<>tf~ ~ Nuclear Physics-UlQ '8"tQ Research
Scholarship f~ ~ ~ ?
~ :
.'
( 't>"1J19til <!j'{t"l ]
fi 'lli"lIlI!llf9l <lit'll"'t1ft!! ",CII 9f~ fll'lttcili; lIilt!! ]~
~~
~~? ~c~"l1?on <rf1r I '3ft<>tR ~~ «U[ ~ !
i,~~~!~I~~~~~m<fl
~~~0\11
~ c!l~~~~'l1 ~;r.T, f<l>~?
~'~~~~~I ~ ~ <!i ~ -.,il'
~Q<!tN1
C~~!c<R, ~ ~twlf1, <!'¥lfi,~~ C~ ~~ ~ I ~~'~ ~ business relation ~ ~<i"1nr ~ ~ 1
UJ, ~ business relation Qtm ~ Q~-" ~ <llWfj'
<rt~ ~ ~ 0\11 ~~ ~tPl, ~r<f' ~~"'1t<!tPl~ 1
~ ~i ~C'jft~ I ~Pl ~t<!~...
~ f~~ ~~ -.,i Qg)""1<!~I ~nr '(9~ 'fffil ~ «~,~ 1 c~t\¥lfi f<l>~ C<!TN C~ ~~ ~ ~ ~;
mlc<1l., ~t~ !'
~ ~ <li~ ~nr~<i-.,nr ~.nsr ~ ~ ~ ~tQ'
~<rt<!~tPl ~<i"1~ ~flf""1 ~~ 00 ~~~ I'5lt~ '(9~ ~ ~~i ~ ~1 ~m 'Ol~<t1 <l'Q~"c!l~~! '
~1~~1
~i ~1, ~~i ~'8m ~ <ql~ ~; ~?"~~~'111
~l
c<M 1 '€ ~<! <!'¥ <!'¥ <!Ttm f<t> ~ ~
~0\11 ~~~~I .
~<i.,nr ~Nt~~~ ~ mtm., ~'1f.:!'i~f<l>?
Atom Bomb.
'8! ~ f<l>~~~'1 D!~ ~ ~9t I
~ ~~ ~~, ~ <itfu f.f I
~ ~ ~ <!M ~<iR c<rt<l>I 1 0fC~ ~
~~ or~ I ~<iQ c<TIN, ~ST f~~ ~ ~ I
~Pl ~ @fJ ~tiSi ~~ 1 ~~ ~-~l ~
.,1 ~ <fto1 Laboratory-~ or~ ~ I
~9T:~1
Q~~ : ~tr;~ ~~ 0l ~! ~'>"ji'l «PI ~ ~!~Q<!, Prof Soong ~Pl .~~~., orfu ~fulf~ ~, ~~rt~." <iM~1:f~, ~fJ ~~ <mr ~orA ~~ C~C'jI ~Pli ~Pli, '~Qi ~e.. '8~ ~ I
Q~"! (~>Tfm;~) Q~m ~ c~ ~9f~? .
~ ~~fi!~ "1.« enterprising c~ 1 '8Q «t'1 ~~., «~
~_~~ ~~ m~; ~ '~Ko{~ f.,...rn: I
, Private Sector-~ 0l <fGl heavy industry ~
~~~~~~I ~~
~ <!Pli c~, 5tWl~ ~~ 1 ~Q1i~ I['ll~
~-n~ [ ~~ ] <!t:, ~ W'I ~, ~ ~<fi1
~~1!
I
~ 9f~ 0Ti'.~~ ~ 'Ii I
II(tif1 Indian Cons.titution-~ ultravires <\lCQfuO'j! ~9ftC1
~.,! ~ ~-c!:lQ c!:liSfO'!w[!
'(i ~ ~'" 'f<f I'" mr:~ f<l>~ ("j1f ~ 1
~ ~<f 0Ti1 ~ ~~ 'Ii I rrQ<l'tQ~ U. N. O.~ lli<f I
: ~~w.~, i! U. N. O. <l'r~.,!: ~~ crrr;~f;r'8 I Anne! Anne!
~~i¥i~tll f~ ~ \5(t~ ~ ,
'''<.!I~Cl1'"Ii, c!:lCI!i,n I
~if;rmmr "Ii! ~~! ...
~ el5l ~~ ; "~9 c!:l~~11 ?<.!I~f<!'~9 I
~ 'f<t;~M'8~f~<rr c!:l~ ~f\g \5ft~ 9(tCQiR 1
~<1'm \5ft'l<f! ""fu"t~%1 ~ ffl ~. iSJtDf 1lfti¥t'8, ~r;~ ~ 'It-r~ I
<.!I~ <!',"f-Q <ut9(tQ"f.ro51T~ ~~Il ?
~~~~I .
<.!I~f<l>m~~ !: ~-~O[ ~ ~-c!:lQ W;~ ~~ 9f"~ I
~ ~"f el5l ~~ c!:l"l'l~ 'WI 'e ~~"l ~ ~fif ~ I
• ~'( ~2it"l em, U. N. O. ~ ~~ I 9f"t*'1 'Ii"liQ[j ,"I1Qt"t !
: ~I.!l• '<f.! "li~ ~9JQ ~ ~r;~~ !· ~% .
~. ~ i$1 ~~ ~ ~~ <l'Q~ f~ e<l"l? ~<l'''tc <fi"9ftf.f ~ ~~ ~r;w ~ <PQC~~, @f.{'tc~ ~lfQ 'e9JQ e~1'f~ 1
c<tl Q~'1I"'c!:l~ Q~'1, ~i ~~ fuc1 on I 1mN'e, ~! __
c!:l~ m~l' ~fu~ ~ f<t; I, ~"l~.,l~~~l P1~ ~? (P1~ COIl
~ ~'Ii ~~-lf"t1~ ~O'j~~ I ~"1
9Jtm'li !'\5{t9f"~~ I·
[ <l'~"l q9f <liCl!,\"e'l 9feilp I -ll<1'g9fr.il~ VZlCll 9\t~ I lIM
"Ill C~C'" DC<'lllt~ I lI%!C'll! ;grt~'5j1~ '\"1l1'dlcJf ~ t'I-ll"'~<'l ~'l{j1 9f1l CDt~ CDell Clfc~-lIl:R C'l~ I ~tf~ttlii I CIfOicliiC'l ~1c'" , ]
QS)'11 (~~) ~ ~ c<ru;~~ I
~<fl c<tlt'4nr ~i ?
1t<fl, ~<fl ~<ttQ" ~ I
\5f~ c!:l<l'~<W!~ ~ I·" ~9f"Q" ~lfi !
f<l' ~lfi !c!:l~~-ffi!""O'j~1
'Ii, ell e~ Clf~ 9(tfu: I
~tQ9f"Q, ~ construction ~ ~ ?~~, f~~ ~ ~~ I ~ iSfO'jit~ ir.<ft\5~ ~w <l'"CQ?:~e~! c!:l~OT~1 ~W<rf~m"l11
m~ f~ contractor.
~Pf f<l>~~ ?",. ..-\5fiPf \5f1<liQ"f<l>~;q I 1't<l'nr <H~ I" ·l(t~~,
~I e~~~f<l>~~1
",,~~IBarrister ~Ql f<t; ;qCO'!? .
'Pt> \5ftQ" 1O'j?;1I ~~tQ c!:l<l'~tt:f1
flff~.1
~, \6{1~1~1f~~ MS! f<t; ~~ ?
~c<l'~~m~~~~tum;rt~~~! ~C;~
~ ~ at<f1 c~ ~ I <.!l~rej. '~ ~ ~~ C\f~~ ~ .. { ~~
'€a I <1Jwt ~ WI) ~, ~ 7-~ <DrQ"t~zJ; <1'~ ~ I'"
'51 1<1>S!tfuS!c<MI c~ ~~ 051 7... '¢It9(~ C<1'<1'~ ~rr? ~, ~ ~
~-~! ~ '€m;r mtf~~ ~f~'¢It~, ~"'I #f1<1'JM C;~ ~ ~
~ ~ I ~ '!iffi~,'¢ItPl ~ spot-
~?-~ ~?-~ ~?-~
~Gl ~~-( c<ft;r CS!C~m)~~ ! .
~ c~t~ f<1'~ ?
~ m~ <litiSf ~~ ~c;r 'lDwl, Concrete ~t
Dr?:"'! rr1 I <.!l<ftS!~ mfi;. I
~ C'l~m<.!l~ <1>'tt<li~ ; ~S! ~ I
Explanation 051 '¢Its!C'l ~ ~ I ~'\! C5t'1
~S!?:<lI Supervising Engineer! ~"'!1 <mI
~!~~Il
m$<:,~~W1C~! ~~~7c~ ,€9(Q f<t~~~fi¥j, '€Dr?:<1> ~ constrUdioQ
~ 'lj"~?:'5'ftaI~ I
<.!l~ c~<1' 15th ~<IT~~ If''t1~ ~ I
~mt9(ml~ <.!l~ <!l~ 'l<\ ~I ~ ~
~ ~~<tt'f I f<l>0l <1'S!ft'l ~ ~ !
~1~f<p~m
[ jP'}{~-<!lll ~C~"f ]
<t>~I~~-iI f<I> <utm f<I>? ~6bl~fb,
~7 .d ~ camp-<.!l#f1iSftf.1~tS! f<1''lj"~?:'5'ftaI~ I
Call1p-<.!l ?on011 camp-~ C<1';:r~ ~<q, Dam-il, Dam-<.!l I
~ <Wl1,<1t~-~I f<I>~ f<I><ffi;~?f.f C1R ~i¥ <f.?:S!f<t>'l<! <1'~<!?:~~ ~ ~~~ 9ft~
on-.<f.Qj'"j~ rr1 ~ <.!l<1'C~-~ ~ ~
c1/n! ~ 051? '51 c<1'tm ~m <1'tS!~'€m'"[mot ~ 'Set}
[Clfto{ ~ ] ~G'f1"'~G'f1"""[ c"9\c~r llIC<'It~.tll-<!lll "1~;Jf}{.,,(lft., ~C~'Sci )
91;;/1
~~~I~--.!lil<itl> ~il ~}{~ "lil I c'lj~~i>1 ~11'1 '"l1~. ~<'ltSj<'ll, f9f~"f t'"l~.,'S 'Gt f.lc~ COjt<t';sfiI ~ci>t~~ <t'ilC~ I ~C<1t~ H:lIll "tC~1 'lC!lf .
'f~ C<t'tQ(I'S~~~ C9\U1il lItf:i! 'li lll~<f "t~ C"tt'l1 111c~ I
C<'l1'l'llfC.,il~ '"lRtc5\t.,til 'iC~ @biD~il ~1<lli6t'l''S <t'tCiI~111c~ I
fl[~il1 'l't~ 'l'IlC~ c~~~t9f 'l'Cll I C<'It~til ~"<l'U11l~-~ '"11fife!;
lC"1 frtf~~ ~'lil;f'l f1[~ fllf<'l~-~ 'l't~ 'liilC~ c~f'l ~t~~ fifc~ CIf~~
lIllIl ll1l;Olil~, fil:Jl~il ~t'l'i6t'l'. c<'lt~1 c~f~ ~j~~il "lc~ ~~lt"Ifilc~"t ,
).,~: ~·I
~I
~~ f<t><1'S!~-m ~ ~~~ ~ I
~~I
[ 'il<f ~fgff.lll\Cilil ~ ~r;~"f ]
f<1;"l~ ~ ~~;rtm <1't~<tt~! ~~ C<1'tm '
~~t<1'~
~ ~~f.lmQ:~~~
'"'
C~! Unprecedented
C~!~m~~~ ~~water level exceed ~ c~~m~,~'~~~9fR -~~ C'"t~? SafelyConcrete set in ~ ~
Construction-~Q ~ 1%;{highest water level reach ~
<\"1r~"1t~···~ i!lfWJ flood lfffi11 ~ ~ I
~ ~, ~9f.ifi* c<Ii~ ?~, ~ ~~'€ C\5i ~CC'l0{Ofi~~'5l"\C\lt
[~9jll (~C'\'i 'l'~fi{l1~ f~l!l ~
Spillway BaY-Q
c5ft~ I
in, f<1'~O'j f<1'! ~Pf ~ ~ 7
Factor of safety Df~!
testing defective ~O'j, ~ ~ fofail <PQ~ I \!5i, <qa'fj <ffi<!<£l~llf1!e9f~ e~ C\5i<!~"tIf~fWf ~Unadaltrated ~ ~~
cement? <!~ e~ ~ <\lllf1
mfr e~<! ? '€ cement
certificate "Rlf.r Nm~O{, ~
Boss \5l<!Pf; 'l~ ~ I ~~~~~~g~l c5t9f~~ ~~ C\5i ~9fi ~
'lR'<ltf~~<!t~ ~ ~ r
• ~~. H~
-artt~Ft<fi Cffr<lc~~ I
,~ ~ eW{ c<lltC~<1'I
~, <orrm ~ <!'fr<l:I l!i:-~ ~ C<!~O{~•
~-~~ C<1'O{?
Jr q<rt~~~~iSf~ ~f.lm ~~O{ I ~,<£l~ ~ <P~-<1'tiSf Df~, ~ Df~ I
[~fg/fil~l"il '€ <1'~1<1'~ 9jfll~~ ~Cll"l ~fl-jj ~ ~c<l"ll
f<I> ~ ~, Df~ I <£l~ ~ ~i I \5{tCC'll
e<lltQ(ill ? ...[ :!1f~<!i1l1~IC<'l1~t~ i~l1l~~ <1'C"ilI (Ii'll ~t~ "m~ f~ "1'1\"
fifc~ 'll'lC"illl~C'll1"Si'-'l('8~Cll ~'l'CIilf<l~:! source (~~ ]
· ..~JtG1tm ~m ~ immediately pump out
<1'~ ~i <liU1 I Generator ~ ?
<£l~~m<T~1
~ m<T, ~ <P~ ~? <£l~'l ~ f<f
<1'~? ~ rn~, e~ ?-~'€, ~~ <liU1.
~'iS <liU1 I Pump house e~ pump~CC'li ~
~ I ern ~O'j ~ J'l<! 'itC<! OfiI ~~"lf~"1.
~-c<Ii ~, <Pt~ ![~~'l' Pl~ ~ .!lC<I"l}
Under sluice ~-~ opening collapse ~~ ~ I
~~~?~~I
f~~?~-Offil opening sir.
[~~1<l1i'111 ~tq("IC"l 'll"'~<l''5ff'llc~ ~O'\ f<lf~ fii;!f9j~ fiml 'llimf
l/C~1 g:C<l' ~Cll"l <1'~i'fil1l1, ~fg/f.lll\lI ~~f\olll' 'ltt~ '€ ~jj<!il1f
(lfs~tCO'\ COiCl!(11~(11'1~Cll ~f~ll 9j~ ~~1ft1'll~ '€~]
~~!~ ~'if.r ~1 ~ contract renew ~ t
~ bl<l'~b1 e~O{ C\5i?
I
1fOl~~~!'"
•... 1ff~~' ~. ~~ @~ ~ ~ G~1~lffG~ ~flf~ ~ ~ ~ ~ flf'S @f,{ ~"1~1~1~ ~ I ~~
f.ff~~~1: J~ ~m ~ cwn, ~ ~~~811
• ~ N'€.I ~1Q'?: f'fi ~1Sl? ~~ ~,~ 1'51:1 ?
~'1~~~Q' ~ ~~~ ~ 0i~ ~~i I ~
~~ c\!)i ~<fi~~ c~9J.ful <R~ cm;~ flfflf I ~
~~ ~tPT, ~~~ ~~, '!ll~<\; ~ ~i
~C<Itm~!
~1.~!\5i om C~ f<!l! ~<!l ~<!l ~ ~~ <fl~~ ~ <!l0'\Tt9T;~
~~~Olll
~! ~ C<!Tflr ~ ~ f<t> ~i ~~ ~
~ ~ ~,IlID1'?m?~ C<\TN\8CIlNOl ~~ ~~ <!l~~ ~"1~ I
f<f.~ ?
~~,'~ ~N ~ '\ftffi ~~~'Car\ ~t~~ accomodate <!l~~ ~ ~~ m would nothave withdrawn his mind from Kangsha. ~1~"l~Nj
~ ~<!l'llM ~~~ <{@ ~ f<t> ~ ~~ <!l~~1:"1i ~
~~1tft!on I
<!1~<rnr ~~ ~~ <\"1<\ 0tton M C~ I ~
1f!1rj~~~~~ ~I ~ 'Uc6~~<!l~~~ ~ CIj;p.T I
1j'f~~~'ll0'\ ~~-jl ~~t ~'l{ I ,~1"1 ,~i;'S!DCiijC~I 1\tll~
~~a; ~'r!.~C}{~t(~. ~~D 'tf'1"1ltllC~"11I ,~ll1 C6PCl!C~mjl'~ Dca;~t~ I (<iil"l '<!C'S!'(~C'S!,"IC'll'll\~
['11(11'1( ~1"\l\ C'f(ll
(
~, C<!ll ~m!...~ ~? f<l;~
~~~on~I"'ml ~ ~Sl~~
~ <>\1Qi ~ on I ~~~ <rrt9(tSl ~~~ <£1<1' ,~ ~ C'{t'ij'C~on ~m ~,~'lf I
~? ~ m ~ ~~~~~~, ~ \ (f~ cm;~ CIf~) I
9ffm
.~ ~ m~ ~~ DPffi~ ~ ~ <m1: Dam
~~~ on I ~~~~~~
~m; f<t;~? •
~~ <£I~ CIf~ Sir.~ CIf~ ~ f<t;, ~ C\f~ I
C'\f~, ~ ~t~ C\f~,
~ <1'~'S <1't~-~ W1 ?~9\f.{ ~ f<l"4<rt\ !\WI, ~ ~ ~~i, ~~i ~ ~~~arI, ;rtf<!l? ~-Q(i-~i-~' .. !l'l'.'iJ..••1<1iT;cll'll~l!~\f}{ll <f.a;CjlIC<,\~\jl ~~
~~C'l{tC<'l'll'l{M ~C'lI ~Cjl 9\0(1 '''IC'll~M ]
w~:l\9\1(1
~~: ~~~~~fW:t>~<fC01! \5{<!t<P~QCC1~ 01'5j~ !
""'5t ~ ~fir ~~ ~ 4ffir1 ~~ ,...~~<'T~~ ~, ~Ic~k<t>~ <r1 ~ ~
fWIfu<'T ~<'TJt~? ~ f~, '5Utf~ <!>~
lft'e, ~ m1 ~ ~ OTiSftf1 ~-.i~ 1if0ln! ~ ~ ~ fuQjJ ~~ ~Q~m ~~ ~ 'f(;~~ ~ f.mr ~~~~ ...
~~: c<ITnr! ~~ ~ ~r.(1~~1~klf'il
~~t"fm ~18 ~ ~ <rn1" f<i'~; ~fl~~1
~ ~,~~~~~"¥IJt~1<llc1Tt~: ~ c'5t ~~ ~ ~ ~ I ~
~!~I~If'il ~~ ~~ ~CG1l?
~ ~ 1C1r~C1t"f···
<llc1Tt~: on ~ ~ on I c~tcoi1
~ ~~ ~~ <ttlfJ 'l~ I
~ ~~ c'5t!
~am~:. U11"'I'5t c<r't,f~~ ~~t;1 ~~ ~ ~ c~"ft~ "'P(2 m
~<llam~'"
<llam~: ~"t"fnt c~t;t~ 'O\"'9f~ I "'9f~ <Wf ~ f<l>~ r~ ~<fC01~~~~~ ~ ~
~ I ~ ~~. ~ on C<lltt'ltffR ~ ~
<ll~~1 ~:!( <'\~t"il .!I'll'! '6
f<fUl <llam~! ~tl; ~ ~ ~ ~
<ll~~ ~11 ~, ~ <Wf '<!1~ <f~
~? ~~ m~-~Q ~ ~9f;
~~ <t~<r
')fol ~9f ~ ~ ~ c<TIm I ~ ~18-18 ~~
~ ~! <f'01Jt~!
0\1 ~ I~ 'l1 f<f.! 'it:, 'O\~ ~~ ...
• [ "il'l'l{~h.!l"il~(<f'1 \9 <ri<'\Jt~ ~'!!t'l]
~ ~Q f<f.~<11?
O\1,~~f~~!~, '~C~Jc<t>'il~m f<fi"%~ ~"'I ~ f<l><Wf "W1 f
. ~ ~ ~r<f, <rtm f<fi"%~~ 'l1 I ~ ~'lr<f c~.crr~ C<ll? ~18 ~ ~ ~ c~, ~18 f<!>w:
~l'f~~~I'"
~ ~ ~ f<l> f~~ C<f'l ~,~~ ~~.
~~~~I
UlI8 C~<l~ ~ ~~~; ~<1l~.~ m~-;rj 1 cwe; ~, ~~~~, ~ ~~~Q ~~'lI8 ~~ ~ ~~~m~ <t>t"l~~ 'l1 I
f<t>~ <l"1<l!'" ~~~ C<ll~'l C<f'l ~~"'I1 ~ <f~ I
~e; ~ ~ m ~ ,~~ ~ C5tt~,
~ I ~, ~~, c~nt' ma, ~ <l~, '<!Uf-
lJ~ ~ ~~ I·" C<lm~~~ ~'l~ ~1 ~ \5{~~-
~ ~ I f~<7fQ fu<l> ~ 4t18 ~1 ~~ m~. \!l~111I"'~ ~<lnt ~ ~,<rtl'f c~ ?
~, c<TIm~~~~~1 ~~~"'II\!i{~ ~~ Night plane-~ ~.,j~«,Slj ~~11!
sky master-~ C<fit~ ~~ C'l~ I
t1 ~ ~! ~peed, ~ speed, ~ speed,~speed.
'9t1ClJ1f ~
~'l'<'I~~-iI ~~~ ll'l{ 'f<lil<'l~11 ~~l~ ~lil ~<orlil Ojtf~Cil 'f'l'l<'I c~c~~ ~~
~lf~ ~'ft~\ ~~1'l'f~~ 'f~1>~f~lf, R~. >*~l~ ~
~fi:ll'l'til cwtd'!~ll'lil-~ 'ft~, <!1~"1 .• ~ I
~1['-'I ~~ .£I'li~ 9\rti{-~lt1[fil'l'ti{ C'l'i"'ttf.l;, f.~liit~tfoC<1iil~ciltil1[C~1 ~~ jl>Cl{<!1~"I 'l'Cil I ~ ~
<.!l'l' ~1~t&<:llil ~f'!!ci{~-i{t1[ lf19\~1[lil')I ~~
~~il1~. 9\1~\~, 1[1~~tm 'S 'tillftfol ~~1~~ }{~~ '0~l~ 'tt~c~ Clf~'lll1[<'f~~-iI nrc'll I
.~ ~ ~Wr1~Wr1 ~C'fI !mC'f~: ~ C~ ~~"1<1~!
~ ~~ I ... ~<ft~~C'fto1'?
~~ ~~I 'Olt9Jrl1~~~~~?.~ ~ajl
.~ 9Jt~i<f'r<r~: How do you do..~ Please sit down.
[f'!!c~jf C~iI C~C'l' <.!lf~c~ ~tC'f ~~~i{ 'l'~ n I
C'tlfl~f.f'lt~ ~<'11~.•~-~~ c't~~-'l\tf<'l <>t1I ]
~~O{!
~~ ~Ti, <!l~0{~ I ~ttQ Qi9f~' ..
~ 'OltQ 9ftfir C<f! ~~ ~ ~~ I ('Tffi ~ ) ~f;rQ ~ <RfiR ~ ~'Olt~ 'Olt)j?;<r-\~~O{ mJi'" I ~ ~ \;<t1 ••
.~ ~,~~~ I 'Olt~~~i~~fI1
m~~-: "Ti,~~~~"Ti~~1 ~~~C'f~~~~ttQ~~~,~ ~<u1'li ~ C'fi~ I ~ ~t<>(r-1 1l~
~ ...
~mPI~~?wtT;~ ~, ~0fCG'[cWt ~ ~ 'Olt9f~ ~
f<l> cSl<iil1 <l'Q{1 ~ !
~~ 'H'I
~~,~ Ofll ~~ ~ ~ f~,~~Ofll
~~Ofl~m?•f~ ~ -.em$! C'«<I' ~9f ~9f ~ 'Sf01~ I
~,,~w~~~,-.e~~ ~I
~9fQ'"
~9fQ ~ f<fi, -.em$! "Ti~~ ~lf;r.rtC'\Wf~
~ ; ~, ~-~-~ ~C1 ~ '!iffi'f ~ f<l> !
~~I
.~ ~~ ~ ~f;rxt I Retail-<!l ~ ~-.e
-.eQc<rM'fQ 'Olt9fR C~~ "TiI
~~~<fi~1[ ~<f ] \3ff9fCOlPNJ~ f~ <fCQr{; co{o{W'R I
'Ii 'Ii fS~ "Ti,~ wtT;~, <!l~<R wholesale ~~
~Q '!iffi5f ~i <ffil ~ I~Risk~~~1'f<1<Pf: ~? ~ if"! ~~Q ~~ c<ll~~ ~ 'Ii I
~ <fQ{1 f<l> iSitCO\O{,~J<\"'fi<l'Q~ $ ~ ~O{c<ffi;{iiSft~ <1) <1'1 t~Q ~9 "Ti 1 f~ <fJtot ~'C~
msir?f~ f'l"D~I·~~i c~ 5M ~tQ ~ I 'Olt~ ~ ~1
~~~?~~I
~-.e tf"l'ffir! <!l~'Olt~ ...
'Ii~~1
~~$Q, <I'~'C~t~<l't'CQ<f~, ~~'C"'f'iJt~ I
lQi9f~m ] <f~ Qi9f~, ~t"ftQ relief fund--ij
~ '5\tlfrn ~ O{t-.e<il~~ ~ ~-<!lQ ~ c~ I
~~ ~~, ~O{ 'OltC'ft9f<l'00~, ~t~kIfQ Qi9f~,
[ "'iPI(0\1~ <fi~1~t<i1~ ~ )
f<l> ~I ~ ~
( filf"~iI "1m 1ltc~]
(c~l~ c51~ill~.;gr"lm-mi ~~ o!tWl)
~ ~7f1 ~W11~ !•
~Q~, '8frr<\l<fits! ~~
deveiopment ~ ?Development ~~ elf Nit e~~ sanction "11 c9f?:o1~~letter of credit C~iT;1 ~~ ~ 0\1I ~ ~
~-Drn~ "l?:~ Nffl ~ I~ ~ 1 m ~~~~0{ '8 'Oft"tR ~ "11e~···Quota e'iru m 1 As a matter of fact (.(;fat('<fr,~
~ ~ Board of Trade-~Q ~~ ~~'8 ~ e~ I~~f<l>!
~~f<l> ~~ eager. 'Sftf.mr?:~ Agency ~ N~~ ~ 'Oft<>tfu~ 1tJ<ts-~; lunch-~ C1f~ ~ 1~! ...
( 'Sf<-!Clft"l ,~C~ 'Sct )Yes spcaking"'e~? '5ffiQ <\Jt"1t"fflr?-~~ ~~C"l1"''5lt"lts!!... ~, C~ ~'1~"'~ ~, ~ ...
'5lt~ elf ~~~O1' ..<\'1<\,<\'1~'" 'OftCQe"tt?:011,~~~t"11 5ftf$~ ~~ 'Oft\9f~ ~ ~~ ... ~ ~ro'l1 ~···O.k.
[ filflj~iI CifC~ 'Ill! )
. "(Qi9j~~I~G<!')W, e~~ 5ftf$Q <\J~tS1 ~~ e5f'11Oh Amal, you are very nice.
~ ~'8 '5filR!~'8· .. he at home··:( ~~)
~~ ~~9ftR, Qi"t~~~ (;<irNQ~ ~f~ PmT~~ ~! (Qi<>t~~I~G<!') you might haveknown him-Dancer Damarupani, ~ ~"'ll<f;tQ-who composed that famous ballet on LordKrishna.
"tfiml
~ '~IK~OT ~-~~ '~ ~
'~ ~'-~ m'1 ~ <rnfC~OTIct ct, C5Ol1CD01ja;tt5f 0{Of ,~~ "l1~~ I
~ ~~ <f¥ ~~~ ~~~ f.! ~~~I
~ ~, ~~! ~ <rnA clfR.f<l>~ ~Any sum-Prime Minister's famine relieffi
c-<M~1, .~ ~ I arrtt~ , ~, 0\1
01'801C'ft5f<l?
'1t5 'f"t f<p <f01~OT~ "l~! ~Prime Minister's relief fund!
e<\"'t~ <flG[OT!~ G<t>t~~tG~~~ O'ft~
c~ ~ 'Oft9j(;~ 'WI ~ 1 ~ f~ I'Oft9J.WT~~?:~ '5ltr.!-Qi~W, CO'l?:~~ 11( I
"1"1,0101I '<HIfffi ~ '5lts!~ 0\11 ~ 'IN~~7[ ~ I "1"1,"1"11~1 'Oft"tR <fj ~ro'l1 ~, <\i1l?:<\Oj1
<\t~ ~~ ~~ R ~I e~ ,'5l~ ~ m "l1 "If'11 ~~ ~fur1~~1~,~I
~ 1···0\1 Nc1 ~ "l1"lf~ 1 ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ Rml 31~ ~! 0\1, ~
~Q?~! ~<>t~,~m
~, "11 "If'1 1
~~. It.'''~
[ ~ ] Qg,I'if<It, ~ ,~ ;rt~ ~ U. K.
Q'8~~~!
~ ~ I ~9\"f.1 ~ ~ !~~ ...~ '~:t~ntf<t; !.~ m-R, <Ut9\"tQ \!iffi~I flff~ c=i =+ h-~·I"( "'I, 'l'I"'! I<l> ~Q'.
(;\5\5Q ~ elf ~ T;t~ I
'!i{'f&~I
'&<l, give me a date then to your conveniance.
~ 9ft~, on the 12th.
9ftW1 ?9ftW1 I
fJ<I; \!iffi~I (~~r;~ 2 ~ ~ ~~ 15th Q'8~1 ~l.
~ 1"'\5l'Rl C"\R, ~~ ~"'!! (~~~ m~)~. ~ tFt~~ C<!l~ ?[ ~~~ ] ~"l3 ~ I
~ ~, ~ lightly ~ ~'1 f~f~ Pl': ~~ I ~9\"f.1,
~ ~~ ~1,~Pl~'S ~Q ~Jt9fiQ, m~~ ~~ ~ \5ft~ ~~~~~~m~1C<f.t"9fif-\ \5ft9\"f.1 ~~"t~-~ fi~, 'Sd~t:\1Vl ~, <f1
"1ft ~ ff~; ~~ ~ ~~ ~, ~ \5ft~<!l
~~ <f.'l:Q~~ Pl': ~~ ~~~l:"1i ~~ C"1tt~
~, \5ft9\"f.1 ~ ~l:Q 9fir;Q~ Qru m:~QQ ~rn~ fiR I ~~ ~ \5ft9\"f.1~1~ ~1-~ fuar;r I
~<>tfo1 ~ ~~ ~ ~ \5ft9\"f.1 \5lt~ Ft~.~~!~ ~, '8 no piou~ platitudes, enough, enough of it
~:~~I ~~'8'l1 ~~ ~~ ~ ~I ~ .
~Cl{~~~~~~ ...
~~ ~ f<p~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~'11 This is,.
[ C<I'!ltillll(~ (~C'" ("\'1 ~C<'IQlI
...~ ~~, ~ ...f~~ ?-T;t<fiiQ?
~ m~1~~~ m~~~~'"
\5f"l''''! \5lIDl Q~~ m, ~9 ?Q~~ ~ ~r;oj'Q \5ll:9\"~'1 ~'1 CQr;~ \5ft~
~~ I you can go and look to others.
~ ~~~~ffi,~~f4>~~~~!Q~~ ~! ...
~~ ~! ~9\f~ composition ~ ~ CO(
f.P.n, ~<:., artistic ~ I
~1tf.f ~~m I ~ I( ~~ClfJ }j~1 f)]c"l'll19\fur'l'l~ 'elc9\'ll''lItoI~-"Si'l ~
f.Ic~ li:T>~Gl 'Sa ~f~("I~ <'lC'l1~ f4>,~?-(Qi~~)~~.
~ ~ COlr<l: ~~ I
)~ ~~: \5ft9\"f.1~ ~~ ~ I
~ ~~~!,·mc~,~~~~~~$ffi: Wonderful! \5(~<t angle.
( 1fJl"1~1~1l Df'l'1! ~<'lC'l' ~f~ CI!I<'l1~Cl! '4tC'l' ~f~ angle
9\(1
~<1'~ ~~ I ~1fi1l I Bouffet '41'1H }j,~ 9jt~c~~'S 'lW{\'l\'tJ'lI\-lJ 'elfl!Jf"1'llHtcl!J :zlcl! fiS"I f;lc~ "lI<11"il~'1r.liiil. 'lI~-
MCliiil l;iT><1\9\1f'l'(~ I ':((<1"1 C'-'\fiSBi"ill'S'ellClii'l,':(C'l-l
9\fi~1!J1 ~nl I flffl"l. :4;\"ilCIf"il~<f1<811'1f'i~'l 'ellc"'l~ 'll@iClii (otc"!'" (~C'l' I (ll'll" ~T."i1"il~lfl!J (l!J'lIfilirlcl!JllC~~
\'4. ~\fiI''ell~ <'IT\ll'-fi19\f:4;c'f'~ 'lI1g/1'lIHll t""ltillf<l 'lI151 cS'li~"t, <ftC'I"t, ~TIR, a'i'!>N 1j"l9\r~1!J 1l'!.!1'!Il ,"il~iI (ll'lc.
'l'C"lI .£l'l' 9\IC"t. .£l'l'T>1'{<!l9\f"\1c<I"I,'i\c~ @d(~ I '6l'll~ JlCl111
~\<I'1llf1"t~1
-~~<1
PI:~~~<1
~%~<1
not the time and placeyou all these nonsense.
But tell me where and when Mr. Gupta.
c'f~O{ ~: ~Wli, ~'8 f~ c~
c<l'Htf~~ ~~ '1~ ~ ~, ~t"\f.{~<11 ~~ C~ ~ ~ ~C1, ~ m...as a matter 0 f fact ~9fR ~ ~ on, Ialready resigned from the board of Directors.But that you can't do.
~ ~9fR ~ 9ftm <11PI: ~~ IResignation f~ft ~<t'~ 1C'f1DC"! 01"1 I
C<t'<1 ~ ?Because I being. one of your board, have
accepted that as yet.
'~7jt"f, ~~ ~ mOl" ~~
m"RILaw does not guarantee it.Hang you law. Legality! C<t'ttorl moral-~it 'I
~ C~~ C~~O{ '5(t1t~ ...
I have hanged Law long before you could .
of it Amal. And I need not remind yo'~ of
laws of an out law.Please don't shout Ranjan, I say.
(UI'I Crockery 'l'C1l~ 'I'[~il"ll C~~"li>1 @c<1i C~!j I ~ '1t'f"llgfilc<li~t'5j <t'C"ll~<t'O\t'll C~ ~·C~ 1l\Clll ,1['$llIC<'IC'lC1l
g<t'C"ll1~WC"ll1~Cll "lll"llI O\tiltf9(i\l"ll1ltqlqtCil Jl~ @~<;,fOl.!i"t1lil 'fi"llC~1lcl\'J\ '5j'~i'"llCQ(C'fi 9\t <l', ••C~ "'~C~ 'I'[1lCilJlC'l<'ICll ~f~Cll 9\c~ N<'IZj,~Ill i1i9\~1lt"ll11 1l11lC'l Jltll 'l{1ttf9\rC~"llf~fgfilill 'il~l d'Cil ~t~tll "l(cl\'"ll'5j~C"ll"5C<'111I11 ~9\flI
9\(1
8
ftjt\s?1t~?1 ~aJ?1Wi"~'ffi!r~ PT~~
fu7j ~ (.~~c~j~j"~'tHl ~~ ~9ff%~'ft~~~0I"
CC'[~~" <t~~IGl"~
~~ ~ c<nW,~fi>lc~ ~'ll'lf I
5tDrhfi fta1 ~~'5("tQ(~~
~9 C<1~ 1m ~ c~~~ 1ilRI"'
~ ~ <fI ~<i!~1McO{~~1
"rID <t'M, CsTI;~~, i<t'~~,9ff~ f<p~ ~ ~, 9fHht CO{t,m lSf"f,
~Dmr ~~ ~~ <{lO'[Jt~ ~~ ,
f<p~~ fta1 ?C1S0I"~ f~ iffilf ?~~<rt~~~?
'-!l ~ ~ ~~, ~'1 ~ ~t"ff~, ~tf~ ~ ;.0fIh ~<!i 'VSf 9fru ~I~~<!lf<l~ 'fC~ !
~~'~,~.Q"<fi~ ~
~ ~q I ~<fi ~ ~ 9ffWt
~2 ~q m 9ff"D"f N~ 111;"'1 ~ ;
~~~9f'f~~m~tf~m~
~~PlCS'I~~~~
~ "*11>1(01 ~"f ~f<j'Q~,
'l!~ 'iKS'I f~ ~'F~ ~
m"l"C~~'!l'€',~I,\!)~ ~~ 0t9fR I
,., .... "
'"~ ffi~ f~\5C$,"
'ff'l~'1~wt.
~ 'l!~ .Q"<fi~~ -{ fUoltfU<!f.r1'#t~'1~9j:f, "1'!lo11~\!)~ ~ m~I M<t>tm~ i"J~ ~t9f'f cimc~~m f~'1Cif~ ~, f"<fi,<!i'!..Q(m'1 i"J~ f<l~j,'!l'!l
~ ~5tW! ~11r~ ~C~, 9jtp ~
Cor:"f~ 'fC~5t ~: ~ f-1Ri ~~~ ~~ ~;r1, i"J'I.~ ~C~ ~<ffii~~ M<ti ~ I ~~ ~<lJI1<.~ ~ I
~-a, M<fitS'l~ ~f\5<fi "f~,T~S'l1
C<r'fi~ C~ ~ "<fi~'fJ ;rfm ~ I .
.Q<f(rf~tf1\\1t'8~9fo:{ ~~"liIT
'5ttiSi ~~mm9fCSinrr.n
\R;9f"ffil m<f151$'8-~~ ~ ~~ c<l~'ti I"~ffi"<fi ~9fC~S'I ~'&~
~~ '8~ ~t'ftC'f .m1ltC'ff<rart'l~of~ I
.•..•.
;rj ~~ ~ "<fit~ ~'~M1,S'I fS~~ .Q"<fi~~S'I mQ\i ~
~C'\ m: ou-" "<fitC'!,m"<fi
'~q ~~ ~tiSfl <tt~'-~Rr1;~ .Q~f<r'1r~'1, "<fitCb~ ".!¥'I
~NiSftC$'fl1
(.<t'tm ~ ~~"It9f !~tm ~-~~-~"f~ !
,~~~~~~I
<ml<fi ~ <mPl' ~ ~ I
~,CW1~~~~ (."'11~ ~ ~o;<tl ~ .
~ ~~<fi ~iS~ ~ ~Cb ~ <ltstif I
f'f(;~'8Clf~ ;rj ~ ~~,
~ mM<fit~ ~~ lft~o;<tll
,~~ '5\{brf~<l' ~f<l-"§~', <!l~ f-1(.~I~I'lt~· ~~
C<rott~ "~~i ~~ '<>\Rr~' <>tf~ ~~ ~
~~ ~ I <!l~~ cO'\~<l' ~ '5\{c~
~c* <Kll'~ ~~~<f <mt @~~ ~~ <l'~ f.{,R,~,~~I "'~ ~ ~, ~R ~ <f(MJ @~ ~
~{~ \!i{~ <!l~ ~w~~{ ~C<l' "'5\'$~" ~
. ~~ ~~'11 -
~~ ~'9' ~ ClT~<lJ @<>tf~ ~~'1 ~ ~
) I ~ If''t ~UT ~ '5\~~~~
~r;,,~ '8 ~"C~I <!l~ ~ "51(;{ ~~'ll '5{~ ~
~~'6l!i1
~ I ~~-'5{{~<l' <l't~t(;~~ ~~ ~~ 'S~
~ I ~~~ ~~ c<ffi;fj ~~ <!lr;lfC"t~.~,
~C~I
"I ~, mT ~~ 'Sf'{"C~~ ~ ~
~~~~Is I ~ If''f ~~ ~~~ ~ '5\~~ ~tf'~
~~I ~~lfr~~~~
~O'\<!l~<\ f~i ~ ~ I
• <t I if'ST~IGl<l' ,,~~i!l0'\~: @~~Q ~1t~
~ ~'1~<t~ ~ <J~ <>\t(;<\-~:<!lQ <!l~ ~
~f.{ I
<!l~ ~fl ~ ~~m'8~'l~ ~~1,~1[)~j ~ ~ I '~'5{~~ ~~', .!It
~<t~ ~~~~ '~~'~-rn~C1\: ~~~~~'8~~~'8~~ \b{l'<:1j[)~I~
~I ~~<!l~ ~'8 mm~~1,~tD>l1 ~~ ..
•~ ~ ~~. ~ f~ <!l~Pl~ ~<>\.~ ~ -C1\:,.
f'l ~ ~~ ~ c<!(~~,~, ~, ~~ ~ \5fIT~~ I ~ ~'ff ~ f~ ~'ff~~ ~ ~i-. .
~~~~I~ ~: "~{ '8 ~ ~w~~<f m<\~'1 ~r~lfrf<ffi ~
'!\tf'~ ~ ~ I ~~ 9fii~ <!l~i ~. ~
c<ltlf~ I . ~ -~ lft~9tC<flC'S'f<!lUT~ll;~ "51~
I£\~~i ~i ~~ Q{ '5\{~<!l ~ ~~ m-c~ ~_ c<!l~ ~'ff \5fC~ f~ ~ ~ C1f~ ~ I
dR_ ~~<\tw~" ( ~~ C~~, ~,,~~ ~; ~.).,,~-~ .\:l~ )
~ <\~ ~~ ~~ <!l~ <!lm~ ~<M "5Itm C<\tlf
~~,<!l~~~~'5\Wc<ffi;fj~ ~I ~ )'\~
~¢ ~~t, ~ '8 ~ ~<>\<J~ ~ <!l<\~~ '8 ~-
~ m~ <l'<:J<t'j~t~"'8'ft~ '5\f<Prl~~ <l'~ ~~ ~~
~fu~ ~r~:(;"1~C'S~ firnt CO'l~ -~ ~ c<M
~~~~C~I~ -
~ ~ C1l,~ ~9tC<l' C'S'f~ ~ ~~ ~
~ I f<t>~<\t~ <>\GR~~ <ft ".; ~ <\w~J '1~ ?~ ~~ ~ \5fIT~ ~ ~~~~Clf
~, ~tti ~ <!l~t~ ~~ ~ C<\tlf ~ I m~~~~ ~ <1l~ ~ 'ftf<l <!l~r;~ ~~'8 ~ 'Ii I <!l~r;~ ~
~ ~~f<M ~ ~'ff "5Itf~ ~~~~~1 ~ ~~ C<\tlfI
1{~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ <\R"l1 ~ ~ ~ C1f~
I .~<l'<fIcal ~ <l'tf~ <!l<!l~ <\O'Ii~ :
) Ol~o ~17', "II:))
)~~) ~~,17'01t
9jf~C'ftSl ~
~~ ~ G<tl~'1~~~ ~~ (.<1<tlI~(.IT~'l~~ :
.•
);;'It) It~,"oo
)0l~1t ),)<',000
);;,~) 1:),~I7',<';;')
~'e' ( ~~C'f1 ) f~ ~Sl fffi
~, ~,f;-I~I1lf\!,(.~[;'8 ~f.r.Tm~ ~'f~ ~?:<l'C'f ~~~ ~~) :
.-r ~ ~f.mm~ <fiQ{1C'<l~~, ltUo ~~
1fIf~<fi?:~~(."~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~;
m'8;r.1"V ?~~ ~.~ ~<$fi '1~~f\!> ~~
~ 9@l'l~~ ~ I ~ ~~~ W~ c<RJf-
~ ~ '!Plf<$fi fWi 9ft-em m Of'!, '\3ft~M<f; fWi 1t'8m
~'1, ~Sl ~~1 ~ ~ ,!:{~"f ~ ~~ ~ c<mH'
~ ~1~<tl1~'e' «i?;Qo{ I f~ ~~ ~\51 ~
~ ~~ ft:~ ~~ ~t~ ~~~ ~~ ~~tSl ~<fi~ ~~ ~m m I ~~ ~ C<fi~-
~?;lfSl ~~1 ~ '!:{~"f ~ ~ ~~ 'l~mr I
~ ~ fflt;1 ~ (.<tl~'1~('~ \!)1fa1<l'1~'e' C<f<fitSlm f~ :
'Ita'! C'I~ cllf~~~"f;! c~1'~\!tM"1~ C'l'l'lll
~;llto )<.,) 0,,-,1t17' '-','-'0, "181:)
~;lltlt ) It,17'8,0<' 8 ~,0l~,~1t17'
~;l~o <."I,1:)<',lt817' )~,0~,<'8<'
~ o~\:),olt,ltItl:)~ ~~~;r ~ e<fi;5(~~ ~~
~~~; '!:{*<:. ~1 )Ol~o ~ f~ ~ ~~lfaJ<1>t~'& <ll('~~G"1-1 ~ "f~~1 ))~ ~ ~,
I
t80
"~~ Jj<tl(."~~ ~ '!:{~ ~, ~~ ~nr ~~~~.~~~~~, lfflre~~~ ~~ ~'f~ '\3ft~ <rnrfl ~ ~ ~" (
~~<tlj(.~~ ~ lf~ <!'~ )~~<. ~ca1 ~'~ ~ ~~
)~~)' ~ 9Jf~<fj e~ ) I ~<fi~ ~ ~~ ~
~~~~~~~~I
~ ~, ~ ~~ 1%~ eC'f~<fi ~~ ~~~~
~~Jf<l'(3(.IT~'!:{TIQ/<P~C'fT ~~? ~~ i%R fa!~Of:-
"\ff~, ~~fu3 ~~~ ~~ (.<l<tll~(.~~ \ffC"~t1 ~
e~ I )~lto ~ ~C'f~ )~~o ~ ~<finft ~~
e~ I )~lto ~C'f ~ ~C'ff~ m~ 'fnm! 1f~'1 ~
C<l't$ ~<fj; ) ~~) ~C'f \51 )'17'<. ° e<!'tfU ~~ ~I~(.~(.~" (C<l-rt~, ) Ol~~ ; ~ ) 0'-'<, ) I
~ ~~ ~ '!:{~ Clff~ CC'fQ/<Pf<fi ~<j ~ ~
9ffimOf~1 ~m~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~I
~ <tl~bj~(.IT~ e<l~Of '8 '5m'8 ~~ 'f:n;~ '!:{~~/'{j I m, 1{
'!:{TIQ/<P~C'fT C<q?;~, '!:{Q{<f1,~~m ~~ C<f<fi~ ~
~~-~~ 1$IT<j ~~ 'Sf~ 'l~nft ~ ~ ~
Clf~ ~Q{~ 'f?:C'fR~ ~~ ~ Of'!I
c!l<!'Q{1'e\~'ll""I<tlI~C~ R~ If'"t?:<Il'lSl~ ~~fil e~ f~
C<q?;~ ~<l~ ~<fim ~filSl ~ffiSl<fi <{iC'ffu'l?:<l C<l-~<m?t
~1 ~ I f<l>~ ~~1 <l~ ~Q{~ Of~ I 'lRQ{ ~Q{ ~~
~, ~ mSl 'lSl~"1 ~<l~ C<f-'l~<fitSl"1~ ~, ~tSl ~
~<j c<Wt $ ~\fft~ ~~ ~rn~ ~'f~ <{ica1~~~ ~~lfl(."e~~Sl 'lt~<fi ~'f~ '\3ftc9jf~ ~N ~ I ~~ ~~
<!'~tSl '!:{'4'<ft~<fi ,!:{~<fitSl <fi~11 ~~~ ~~ c<1<l'I~(.~
~ ~ ~ ~1 ~Sl ~ e~ '!:{'4'~ ~~~
~Of 9(?;~ Of1I elf ~ ~ <fitSl"1lf~ '!:{~ 'l-elft~ ~
~'[;j <fi~~ ~ 'Sft0f?:~ 1tSl?:~ ~ f~ ~~, wt~~ 1t\~ 1t\~ ~Of~ ~ I ~~ em 9ff~C'f11f1f~
~ ~lft?!~ ~, ~a;1 ~Q"l'l('Q~ "l'~~j~(.lf'\'l~il"'o "]11,-'"
~ ~ '€ ~'€lft~ ~f<Wt1! "l'~~j~ClfQ ~j(.<lTt01o\,
~, <5{tfrtff-~lfJif~ ~(('<lTl«1o\ ~~Jj~~ ~'<l1 >1l~~
~ I ~~ ~ ';!;{1C"T101(.~~'i'C~ ~ ~ '€ ~t\!i1 ~Ri
¢'~ ~ if"! ~r:~, f~ ~ ~ ~ 9jG"l'$lo\~ '9jjD ~~
~~ <>t'lT~~ 'l.J"cOW!'5{~\5 ~~~ ~ 1fW'1,~~'h~~ "<:!i!~ "ltlfJ?;"l ~f@r\5 O'ft~ ~O'ft~T."t ~~ ~ C~ I ~
~ <f.~~ 'Oltf'ff ~~ft ~~ ~ .~i~~ "!r:$;f~~
~ m ~ c~, '5{ft~, ~W\5 '5ffi[ sFf c~. ~<l:~ ~
I ~, ~~"t?! "l,~ ~fui ~ ~iJJ'€ <t>ii~
~~*'1~~1 ~~r:o'l'5{~~f<l ~ ~<l:; m ~~~, ~lfJfU3 <l:'-i~j~Clf'\'l ~ ~o ~ "~'t,~"·1 ~~\!i1
~ ~ ~~, "l'01"l'f~t'\'l 0'ftC'j11fRl~:tl~ <!l<fiU ~'€ift~
~ ~ "t\5 <t>ii~"lt'fT ~~o 'SM ~ ~f~ I ~~ ~~o 'llf~
~~~'fT ~<to~ ~'t~ I
m-srm ~m~ f.f? <>ff"6"l<l:t~~ ~ ~~
~ ~"lft~ I <>ff~"11 ~~.~m ~"'!t~~~~ ~'1'i~
~ ~ I ~. DPf ""l\5~~ ~~ ~~ "ltPl~ '5ffi[ ~?;C'jJ <t 0 ~
",~I \Q~1 )~<t~ .~ ~ I )~~~ ~'€ ~~ ~~1
~'<llli'R I
~ ~<1' ~ ~ ~~~1 ~ C<l:\5~'€ ~?! ~ ~~r:"\t~~
llJ uc~ ~" Rrntc~ iftf<l ~ ~ i m ~~ ~~~~m~~'RI ~~, "l'~Dt~Clf'\'l f~ ~~ ~~ "~~~?!" <>tfit:~"~ <t>Prlu"Rrn5f ~ ~ 1
~ ~" m\5"l <t>~~ ~ ~ ~~. R~\5 ~
~~ ~~c<t>tCO{~~\5~RI ~~$~ ~ R{m-\5 ~ ~ ~ "l'-iDt~Clf'\'l ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ I "l'01"l'G51'€ ~iWl ~ "l'-i~j~ClfQ C"fU!i
~~~<!l<t>'~ml
~~,8t'1t-~oo
••
")~~~~tta1~~~ ~ ('''l'~''1~('~~ ~lO'Df '*(;<l"l'IQ(."l' <l'i'sf Clf'€m ~~; ~~~, ~ ~
~ ~'~'SM ~ ~~ C~tc1rT I
~~ ~ ~ ~j<l"1~~ COl'€m ~
~a;1 "1Q"l'I('QQ~~ $ ~~~~~ ~~ ~~ flr~, ~~~ ~-m~
~~"i~f.f<ru1 ~~ C~~ ~mOf1I
<!l~ "l'fTf<ro ~~ 'Oltf'ff ~~ ~
~ \!i~ ~~ ~ C1f'€~i ~ on C'Ff, '<fRi ~,
~1 ~~ 9JrQ'€ ~ "l'fTf<ro ~ f<l~ ~
lfiG(;<!!JQ"lClfJ <WI ~ I. ~~nft 9fftpj~~Jtt;r€ ~'"'
"l'fTf<ro 9JG<1IQ(.lfQ~ ~ ( ~~417-n)1f\f~~ ~Hlc'ift~ c~t~ •.tfil~ttnq
(~t~1 f~~(~) ( "t~t~"l f~)c~t~l~ <li"l .• t~
) ~ 0 0 '€ ~{ ),~~ ),17'1
. [ ~-.:.~ ~~~ c~ ~~~ ~~m~-~.~~ <>tfit:~~~ c~ C1f~ lftC<l:~, c<m~, ~t\!i1 ~~
"9jG<11Q~~~~Q~~ ~ ~n~·~, ~'1'84
;srr:"1?!m~ '!iffir ~<t ~ c'<lr:<t>~ 0 0 ~ "ltlfJ I JI.•••
~ WI c<!, ~~ ~ 9fftlm ~ ~~ ~fu<t>, ~4oo ~t<t>1 '€ ~lf'f/ m~ ~~, ~~ ~4fu~) ~, ~~?;"l ~~i ) '~~fU, ) '17'1fU ~~ )'
~C'ji WI ~, ~~ ~~ 9jfu<l:t~~ ~ ~ ~ I
<mt <t>~1m\5 <>fin!, \5iWI f.f "l'fTf<ro ~~
c~m ~~ f<li~' ~ I f<t;~ ~~r:~ ~
~m~ClMRI ~~~<l:~~~~~
~ "l'~~l~~lf'il, ~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~
'5\j~"T101o\ ~ ~ I ~~ ~ ~ 9fii~,
t88
~~ ~ \3(<r{1 '1~ ~ 1'~ ~.
~9ft$:r~~~, ~ if"t ~~ \3(~~
~~ m~ ~<t, \3!t~ fu;{ ~9ft${ ~i ~~@:IT~'<l~ 'Ii ~, ~'8 ~ '<l~ ~~ C<tf-tI
~il'Qf~ ~ e"M,"f ~~ ~re '&i1'~~cfI
~ ~$ ~m ~~ ~<i f~~;r I
CO'!~ ~~ f~ C"1T~?;~ C~,i~~l' ~"\3($'i'ff~~ '1tN 'It?;~ \!l~~~ ~~?;'t~ ~:~~ ~ 9ft1-
~~ ~ '1~ ~'ltf~ ~ R I f~ ~~ 1'~ ~~~~
<!~~"l 'Ii, ~~~<Wl~ ~$ '9.( f\Sf<tift ~~1 '1"'P\~~
CO'!~ ~~ ~~~ '5lf;fIT~~ ~~ ~~fU, '5lt\Sf"l~ f<l,"I"I\5tfl
e~~ ;@p- \3('21~M~~ ?;~ I
~~~~~:
"~'1 m't1 .~~ If"l~tfill' <tm:t~ .~-<>tft!<rm
\!lf~ ~'ltm9 'ffu(!f c~ m(!f~ m ~i?;<t ~<t, C"\"lI~
'tl'~'1''5l'l~ ~ ~ ~~ C\!l~<t~~~~, ~ \3(~~
'fi1'9 ~~ RM<!9, ~ ~t~re ~'Q)~ ~<t I ~~r?;<t \3(~C~
'8 ~<;~"l~'@~ ~1fT ~ lfRl' '8 ~ '1,'<lm ~"f ~ I
"f<t;-~ ~-~~ pauperisation-~~ ~f<l~<; 'f-r.r ~
~ R'I (m'8 ~ <tt~~J ~tr\!> ~'I<tt'f f<l:~ ~C'ftCI
~ 'tl'Ul '11) I @:{~ If'l~<f. cif"t'@f~, ~~ f<l,~
C~l', ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ I lf~ C'f-f'S~
\5ffi1Ni '11 ~ C'f?;~ 'tl'N ~<$ If'l~1' ~mr<t> ~<fl'1?;!f
~ ~ ~~ C'Iilr;r <>ri~ pauperisation-~~ ~ -~f~ ~ ~~ I <fl~9 ~:{~ ~-I~IGl<l' cif"t'SMl
~~ c~ @! ,g~<fl \Sf*-~ ~~'111
~ ~ ~~ ~<\, ~~ ~~ \3(,~ ~
l:1-1~IGl<!>C'f"f'Sfo1~ ~~'8, f.l~~~I(Q ~<l'i~1-f -
c~ I ~ ~ if"t ~ ~~~t~ C'f?;~, ~
Clf?;"t'€ l:1.r:~lGl<l'<lJ<l"?{IQ~~ e~ f<mmr Cff'Sm ~
t.u
C(t<f, ~~ 'It~~ ~'1<l'i~t'i ~ 'Ii ~. ~
~ .£I~ ~$l~I~~~ ~~ ~'8 f<l:"I-m ~ ~ ~m
~ ~ 'S't~ <i~ :~~ ~~ c~" ( <ifmT-C<rott~,
. ?1 ~o\:)8-~O\:)¢.) I .
~ ~~~ ~ CO'!~~ t2t~ c~l' \3(t~ fum~~~I
~~ c$¥l c~' 'if'SRt?;~ l;~ m~ e~, i~~"f Rrn~ ~ ~i~1<ttlf \3(~~ ~ c~ ( ~~
~~, ~'l<tt'f~'~?;<t <ttf~ ~~ m '11 )-<i~~
orI ~'8 CO'!~ ~ ~1fT or;{ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ I
~ll'~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~1fT rofarl'~ fl'~ ~ I
a~'lstCcrn 'i~~" ~ \Sf~t;r ~~ m<l"l ~~t~ ~<t, ~~
-.m ~ ~ ~jQ~~~' ~ m~~ \3(lfJt<i<flc~~~,utff ;sr~, \3(lfJt<i<l>~ ~~ '5l~;ftl%f<fif~9 I \3!t\Sf f<l:~
4(~ CIf?;"Ii~~ ~~~ e<it"l~ ~~ <li~ ~ I
alf.lstCcrn 'i~" ~ fum~ \3!t?;~ <Q~ ~ f~~ I ~m-;r ~~ l!im ~~ ~~~~; elf ~ ~~ fl1
~ 'l1~, '{f;sr<lm l;f~ ~~ ~ m '11 I
~.~ .~"ft~'@f~ <tJ~~ ~'11, ~ 'Wf1~ C"ti<!9, i$Mf'(R <i'tJre m~ ~'8m, ~ '8 ~
~ "i~~~ ~ C<flOl~ \S ~fg;~ ~'8m, ~
il'IC~ ~. ~ ."ft\S~1--i f~~ ~~ '<lN~J'@M ~'l11
~ \3(~~ ~ ~9 <lim ~~t'€ "l~ f<t;-~ ~ I
\3(~<l1~;r<fl 'l~j~~311t?;1(~ \SfW C~~ ~ f<l:i1'?;~f<lf~
~ ~'ti <Q<t,~ \3(~ ~ ~"lt9 l'm ~~~1 ~
I f<f;~ ~ ~~~ -rt<f<tICI(Q, '~R<fl '1~~~CIlttlf ~ ~~ "R I
• ~ w<tJ ~~ ~~~, "lt~ '5l~ ~ ~,f~ ~ ~tm \3(~~m ''8 ~l%~ .£I<tit,"f
f~~\!)~\~~~1~ ~ ~O{ I ;~.~ l.!1~
~O\-'~ '~~ ~, ,-{~~ @<;~~~~
~~ iSM'ltC'tQ ~~'5\ f.1Qi<lr~:{ ~~ l.!1~' ~~~
'4t~, ~ l.!1~ ~ l.!1~ ~'&~ ~~ ~-~, ~
~ ~, ~ C~ @~t;{ ~ ~~ Oft,~flr I
~~ ~ l.!11>1~m \5(~oii~ ~ <ut~ ~
;p.\" I ~~ ~~O\ '5tt<l: m~~. \5(~. \5(~~
~~Oftl '&<l:~~~l.!1~<l:~~, ~
l.!1~~fi~" ~ ~ ~ <Ut~ ~ ~ ~ .,~ "lll
~, ~~ ~5'(C'tQ ~i ~ -{~'5tm~O{:@<;~~ l.!1<t>fU"1t<m1"'1~w1<1> f?z~ Off~O\ I ~
f.rQ~~ 5t~ l.!1<l:~~~ ~ ~~ ~. ~ ~ ~,
"It~ .~ fr! I l.!1~ "1t<m1"'1ci 1<1> ~ clWt l.!1~
Qf~, l.!1<{iQ\t'8~ ~'f.l", ~~~ '~~~ ~~ <\~'1r~~'1ot,
2!~ ,~~ c<WtFt~ ,-{f~fu; ~~otitraj ~:~"1tlft~'1 m~'(General Law of Capitalist A<;cumulation)
~Qf 1lt*., ~C~ : .
"$rtf~~.,»Y(lf 'B ~ i~9ff<ro'1 ~~ c<tfiOt ~ ~,~~ 'B lI\f~ ~~ ~ ~tt<t> l.!1<l:~~. ~~~~
'8 ~tm ~ @<;~~ ~ ~; ~ f>1l~ f.{rn~~~ .,~~Ji(Industrial reserve army) c<Wt ~ ~~ '~'1 i fiSf~ ~~ ~ ~<fM '<liS, ~ ~i~1~ ~ O'ft~. 9(tcQ l.!1'R ~'l"l~Q'B Pfft"l ~ ,
~m ro~~ (Potential energy j .,c~~ fitaIW ~Rr<l''1~~\5ltt1f'>'Pl' ~ 'l\TIlI f~ <Q~ ~ ~
~~~ .,,~rt~~,~~ ~~~ ~~ ~, ~ ~ ~,~ c"lti) <tnro'1 ~ ~~""j'fl~<l' ~ 'Bd ~-~~ l.!1m ~~ ~ ~ I~%q ~ ~ m~~Q ~ <Q<l:,f"1~ r-
~~~<\tf?z~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~Wf;~ ~'B ~
i~ .,~~ 1?1:@<;~ '5l~ "1t~9;
f.r.lDT~'6 ~ <l'1i!c~ ;rr.rrR~mro~ ffO{'
~ 9fic~N' [~t<1 ~: rn~; ~1l ~,_.~ 9f~~f~ <Q~ "1t~9 fonr~ <t'i~~"tl'~~ ~~
~ ~ m9fi)~ \5(i}J <Q<t>fU~~~~~'f ~\5 ~1~C1rEi~1.
I~~ ~ \5(nr-e ~~~ :
.~ ~ ~~ ~N<l> @<;~~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~·~~~I @<;9\11R.~ ~ @m~f~ @<;9ftIr~ @9f'it \5lif<f9fW ~ l.!1<!'
~9 ~~ @9finf met~ ~ <tCi¥; Jr~C011 ~
<.!l~~ ~~ ~~, C"10{1~"l"l1(!j ~ '<lM, C"1~,
~ ~ ~C~ <tC'S' 'B ~nt ~~ ~ \5lt~ti9 ~.
~ ~ f<t;~0{~ ~~ m <Q<l:,~ \5tQ ~ ~'tJ ~~.
~" i!fll:2l~"lTnT ~ i<l>ooI~~~l.!1~ ~~O{ ~ ~~ ~
fl1 ~ ~ \5(~~ ~Prr<l'Sl <tC~ ~'~~TIl ~ ~~
. <2Inlt~ <rt~ajT ~CQ ~; Jt~~ C'l\ \5«\~nt ~<lI .
~ <f.~ ~ ~ ~ ~"l'2j~~rn m. ~~ <Q'R
mwt~ "<f.~~~Q \5(~ ~ m, C"1 ~~~ \5tQ ~~ni lf~
~M"J'tJ~; ~~~~I9fI<\~~I"1~ ~ ~~ ~
~, ~ it, ~'B '1fiSffl mnt ~ m m 'l\~ I
~ ~ @<;9f~ ~~ ~ ~ l.!1~~"~ ~~<t~ •
$f~'€ "1~~ <Q«, .!r ~ ~f~ ~~ "1t<l~ @9\t~ I ~
~ ~1 c~ ~J:t<JI~~i'C<l: C<l:f<mr \5(Wf Clf '1~\!)IGl~~ '13:@<;9f~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~.'5t5'(J-
~ C<!flot ~, ~, ~1l c~~ Oft c<R-\5lf~~
~n!~ I ~ ~Q\I, C"1 ~~, \5ltt<tf"'l'<t'~I~<\
~ f<R<!i r~ f.rcm5'(~ "l'8J..'f<\I~~, JT<! ~ ~'fjQ9-
~ ~-\5(~1~ ~ ~ f;!~ ~ c5fc~ ~~.
-~ i!!lfil1"1' ~~ ~~ ~ c5fc~ ~;'SarffiOl <f'rc;<ll c~~ ~ ~C1r ~
-~ CW;~ ~ cfl'€ ~ I W ~.f~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~'t~~:~,~
.~~ ~~~ ~:~<1.,~ ~ ~ ~~
<Wm~ <TI~ 9fmR9 ~~ ~ ~~ ~
~ ~ \5{9fi'f ~~ ~I, ~ ~~
1!i11~~~\!)j, 9f~ll<\'<1.,~, ~ \5{~:9\~, ~
~<l'; ~~ ~ m"t ~ <rof ~ ~<:'9\~ ~
~ ~~i'f ~nf ~9 <rof ~I" [~~:
''1: ~lilt ]
~ \5{~ 9f~ I ~~ ~ \5{( ~
'~I ~ ~~'ti'f ~ ~N ~ 'i~\!)lll.qo~:~<1.,~ 'lt~9 ~ ~ I ~ f.!im~'€, ~~Ni ~ ~C9 '2I<l'nrt~i'f~ 9fttl,
~ fonl'l 9f~ ~ m on IC'T C'T ~9 ~~ 'lt~9 RwI~ ~<ffil~ ~
-~lfJ ~~ ~ ~9 ~ C~ ~~ ~t'<\fl.,~~~.~\f;~~,~~ ~ ~ '€ ~ ~ Q.!t~~ ~ ~ c<fiWf1 CIfC"t '!\tfff ~ ~
-<l'i'fC\59\1nf I 'Sti'f~ ~~ ~ -{~ ~
~I
"1~"1tc1t ~ ~~ ~~ <W'l ~
~ff \5{TIff<l>~ ~ ~( ~ I ffl ~ •
.~ ~ ~rt'lf~ ~-'St~'€ ~m:~ 'lt~I1I'1ct~ ~~ i!t'l '€ ffl~~ lf~ ~
.'ltcO'(i'f~~~ ~f<$l ~tfu~ c.,I<t'~~I~~ ~<l' ~
~fi:al :
I ~~t~ ~ ~ 'l~fu ~ ~~ 'St~ C<lC~~" I
~ 'll"~ C~<l' \5{M ~ ~~ ~1, ~~ cflJt~ "l,"I,
~ c<l"t f<li~ ;r~ ~'{[ C*,," (~~ <t>tif~9t-~ ~~o ) I ',~<t>tm 9ffpr~~ C~ Clf~ m C'T, ~~";l ~
).,a" 'ltCO'! ~~<l'm~ ~fu ~ ~ ~'St~ '$l[
fi:aj <.!l~ ~~a<1 'ltc~ 9fi'f C~ ~ f~~ m~~~~I
•~<l'~9ti'f ~~ ~fu ~ f~~[~~89=~.o]~~<1<1-)88.~
) ~<1~-)"8.~
~~<1l7'-)<'<1.~
)~<i~-H"~
~ffi~ ~~ <fii'<l' <$tfu~ "'5nfC\5i'f i!$l"
~, ~Cl~)" ] I .
'IW5t ~ ~ mc-n ~<flnft tWr<T ~ I f<l>~ ~~1 ~~. \!I~~~Cl~~ ~'€ ~ 'l~m~t~i'f ~~ \5{~ ~ I
~ f~, ~*~ \5{(~i'f fu"rf ~ ~ <TTt~Tj~<T,
~~ ~i'f 9ff.m~ ~ ~9-~~ ~-~i'f '€9fi'f
~ C01~ ~~ mtt~~ ~~ ~~;r C'T,~'R"fl ~ '!\tt~
~ farc~ f~~"'R ~ \5{t~~ 9ff<Tf~~'€ 'f~9 <$f~(
~ ~<:,9ft"ff;r<TJ1~hr !t~ ~~c'ti'f ~i'f 'Ii1lf~
~ ~~ ~ Wl"l f.r, f~ '!\tt~ (i1I~) ~m~f~1 \5{~<:', ~ ~ ~~ i'f~ ~ ~
~'€ 9ftti'f, f<l>~ ~ 'lW'€ '!\tt9f~ ~ ~
\.!11~ <n., ~ ~ C'll"C\59\1nf I '~i1I, $I '€ '1~''lft~f"IC~ :
tt.
"~\5 ~~ <.Q~ ff~ Q.\t<\lC\5<>\Wl,<.Q~O{~
f~ \5~ ~<>ff~ ~ ~ c<tt\5 <>\IDlI
COl'Sm m, ~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~C~ f<tr'?i~ ~ c<>\m~~ ~~ cQ<\l~~ ~,
~ <iWf ~ ~ cQ{C<\l~ "It* ~~ I 9£C~~
<!l~ ~~ ~ <>f91"~~~~~ ~~<.Q~~~
~ ~ <>f~9 <>f91"~ ~C\5 ~ <jd; f<P!i \5~,
~tsl ~ ~Q ~~ ~ c<>fm~I
. {f~<>f1%Q( m~ ~t~) ~t<fI <.Q<\lm~Nc
~ ~~<l' c~ ~Q f<l~ '!."Ir fIr~ \5t~ ~
~ ~ ~. ~~,€Q ~ '!.qr ~,;<>ftlf'l~~ ~
~m ~ {~ \3{,"f .~ I {~'8 ~ ~l{J
~ <j~0{ ~ ~ \3{'P\ ~m~ I q~<>f~~tt1~ ,m{f~<>f1% ~~ ~<>fQ~ <>f~~ '3{tR<i\5T~ ~ I
~9m '8<>fQ {~<>f~~9m ~1 ~~, ~~
~~Q ( social position) \3{<1:0{1%'«ffi~,~tC'fQ~,ft~'{~'8 <.Q<l'<rt<>f~ ~~ c~~" (~t*rr-<.Q~rr-~~
)~ '5'1Pf, ~ ~Y\I)~ ~<\l wt\5 ~~ ~ f<t;-\3{~M\5 ~ C~? OIl
~ ~\5 ~ {f~ ~f.nrt; ~ <.Q~i ~ ~
~ I ~~L!Wl ~ iSM*~ ~ ~<>f~
"lt~~<.Q~<.Q~<l'~~~ ®l~ @Cft~<>fif'{g~ f.r I
~:~ \3{tt<>ff"'f<\l~Nfs:\ ~:{ 0fc"f fs:\ ~:{ ~
0f~ W;~, f"fOO';~ ~ ~PI<\l-<R~m ~<>fT~-rc~ ~~ {f~~9m <m<>fJ\3{,"t ~; ~, i!t~
~ ~tsl ~<>ff~ '5{~0{1%~ I '5t~~ c~
~"'9fZI .
~ <t'tsl~ f~ ~c;~ -.fI5 ~i%f~ \3{,"f I
''IIi>~atH1"fI!1,"f f~'ll~~rlf~·",1(l)trrll~,"f ~f;sr9ff~ll~\"f
~;l¢ •~o'~ "",'8•
~jl¢¢¢¢') a 8'",
~;ldU- d 8'<' 8¢'o-
1fiI-~\5 rr~<l'tsl<tl~- ~<l'tfil\5 <. ",ff;<f.t~~tol1fitc~sr ~~~ ]
~~ Cif~ ~, ) "'¢ o-do- ~"1sr ~t~J ~c;<>ft'fCO{sr'l"1~ ~"1J
'1l'~Dls!1~<5j,"f "l~<f.~1 ~o'~ '5t~ CQ{C<f.<f.~~"l~~111 n '5t~
if; <Q<f.~'l"l~ if~<>ff%~lfsr''OJ,''f :'I\!i<f.sr1"",' 8 ~t~ C'<l~<pC<j~,¥
8¢'17' ''5t~~"'ll
~ <5{f<5j~~ <.Q~1 'l~ c~, i!tPl<P-<f.·s'fst~~\3{,"f f.r~<jf~:{ ~R5c\!)
~\5 ~sr <\lC~c~~~I ~-<.Q<\l<j~$! <.Qsrf.r"D~~ <1:Jf\!ii1ji~'«~~~~~ ~~~ I ~ 'lt~tsl9 C~~ t<f.W~~, i!tPl<l'~sr \3{,"f ~~
i~~ \3{,"f ~ fWt> I
~C1r~ "ltm~ ~c;SWR <.Q<j' ~~ 'lt~~~W'5 ~'8 <1:i~~;~<>f~ ~c;<>ftlf'l·c~ ~sr <j~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ;<RC1, ~W'5 ~~sr ~~ ~ ~~~ I
~ ~~ - ~1 <jtf\g~~, ~ttlfil ~<>fQ<Pt~~srDt<>f~~ <f.~
~lf,~~ ~ ~c;<>ftf\r\!i~; f<tr~ <.Q~@'t~'€~~"1~~~ 'lt~ilT ~,"f
~1ort~ I <.Q~~tt<1:<j~~~sr<>fQ<j~Q ~<t'~lfil @9fsrif~9ff\!i~~
~ ~ -~ ~I <.Q~€ ~~ ~<P ~
@~<>ftlf'l~tsl <.Q<l'ff;'ltm9 f.RP! ~ ~C\!iJ<t'Wf fiSf<l11fl~\2l~JI
~ fu~1 <l'~sr ~ '8 <l'-lij,~ ~~srsr ~~\!li~I.!j~ ~ (<.Q~ ~ ~(~ ~-<.Qsr '~~
1~'1\~ )"'~)'-<.Q ~"f\!i ~) ~ ~, ")~89
~ ~"'110-~ ~f-l<{>~If~"lt~ <1Pf~~<>ftlf'l~~ ~
tl) ~~, ~lfSi ~\5 ~ft! ~~'1 "f\!i<f.sr1<. 9 ~~ m
C"\tlfC<jQ ~. C;~ f~ f<l't., m~~~~c;~ I.!l~
i!tf-l~C1f~~W~ ~ RCSS1"f~ C;~~ ~ f<I>~'1?1\"!i{\Sf'1 ~ ~ - ®i~ ~ 9Jf~~ ~~
cmtl m I®il\'<!i ~tQ ~<K~ ~~ ~C.,C~'1 :"~ I.!\~ @ir;~pauperisation-I.!\~ 1f~ ~;prt~~
CS~~ ~m ~"ti ~t<f~ ~~f~'1, pauperisation-I.!l~•
\51 f<I>~9\Wl ~tf~ ~C<l"[ 9j"fm-''f'tt~, ) ~~~, ~ ) ·~t )
\"!i{tm ~ ~~ I.!\~ ~~ ~m~ m 1.!l~'2fi9 CD't1~~m 1.!\~'1 ~'1 ~~ ~~.~ f<I>~ C;~ I I.!\~
<!'Q{tS"l"<l"C~S~ \51 ~~-~t<Prrtffi1 "~Qi1 ~lfTVI
~ ~ ~~'1 'fI 1 ~t<f~<lt~ ~ ~~'1 0\1Cl{f5
f<l~"<l~l:~~ 1
.."...wr~Jfli'Itot~
~ ,,), ~~~ ~ '~' -I.!\' ~I<L~mWlN m~~~ <tt~"11-~ ~-.nfU 9\ti ~~ Cl{ ~' ~~fU ~Q{1~ ~ ~ ~~"M~ ~ ~ 'fI1 \5j~~~ ~ I.!\~~ \5It~
~~~~~"<ll
~~ ~~ ~1~"11At~ ~~9j"~ ~~ \5It~ '8~ ~ ~l:<f
~: "m"11 ~ "<l~ 'fI f~1 '8 ~ ~ ~~ ~~
~ ~ '8~ ~ c;~-\5j~f~ Cl{ \5jtvr.f ~'1
~ ~ ~ f'f1l~~ I" "iSft<'ltOl~~ ~ ~~ m~"~ ~m f<I> ~ CSl:~~, ~~ ~ '11 I ~, '8~~ 'C~~ ~ ~~ ~ iSftf.!, ~ ffi ~R,;-m~~~ ~1 '8 #!tf~nr \5j~ ~~ ~ 1 \5ItQ~ \5j~ f<l'QJ1'8
~ f.wf.T ~-"m~w c;~ I"· ~~ I.!\-~ C;~'8
~~ ~ ~ ~ R~~~j~~~~~ ft., '11 f~ 7~~ ~~~ ~lf<IlJ f<iffi ~ I.!\~ ~R~j~~~~~~~~I
~iS7!1-~ ~~<1~ ®i~ ~~ ~~ ~~~ ~~mc~: ""'~-~~<1f'l1~ Cl{ m ~~~<t't~
~~~"R ~ ffi~~~~~~"J{Ng,1ft9(;{ ~1~~I~I~~~'8 ~ 1.!\<tliSf'i~~ Gi!t~ ~ ~m
~ I" ®i~ I.!\~ \5ItQ l.!\<tlfUc;<tt~ (.~j~~~l' \5jjRI'(>I~
\5It9\"O\~l~~f~l~ I.!\~O\ ~~ Gi!t~ fitiI ~ I "~~
~" .~ ®i~ ~(Q{t~f<I>~ ~ ~ ~ <I<\tro;~I . ~V.-
:~.~ "'l1~1~~, (.(;"1~~lc'~"<l'l'1i&(.~~ ~ ~~W
~~ ~ 'fli&~(.l' ~f<1l'''1~j('<1~,~ ~"t ~~'11
us
f<f~ ~ ~~~m ~~,~ ~'~'~<fi~~ ~ ,1"1 ~~ ~-Anster, Hayward. .Shawcross ~ I ~ m "fC(fT ~ Macneice-~~~ ~lf <f~, \3f«~ m ~ ~ Q('ic<lll ~,
~<fi~'8~R,-~ 0T1 '€ ~ ~ I ~ ~
onT, ~~ <l'~1 c~ flfCC1'8l:j<\f.11l<$I C~C<ll~ I
traditori. .C~ ~<:, ~~ ~~f~~~~1 ~,
~~ <l'C~~ '<l"'l~, ~<lN ~ onT I ~ "m Wl~Plnl <fii<lPf''1'tm ~~ ~'8m~, ~~g ~~
"5(~~tif<li~ ~P!tm ~lftOl~ ~t<l$t~~ ~~ ~~~55"c~9M mitt ~~ ~<lN ~~~ ~~oi'I '~~ <l'€''U ~<flt"l ~~ (<.Q<l'~m'13m @ci'l~~~ ~ ~tt<! <.Q~ I "5(~<111t<l'MfU~m~f<v.n c~ ~~~ f<lc<l~ I Nec verbum verbo curabis
fidus inter pres (Horace; De Arte Poetica, 133)"5(~m ~N ~ ~ ~ ~~tf~ ~<VM 0119fhl, ~
9fR1<1~~'8 ~{;{ "5(~ Ol~I ~~" ~m '~~ ,~<.QC~ ~Q~~ <!t,O'fl~ ~~ ~ ~1f~ ~~ ~RQf<ll I ~'l~~, ~m~ C<!t~~ <!i~0'fl-'i'~~ '1n,-rtg'ffl ~
R I. ~5fi~~ ~MC"'lQ ~ f;r.!~Rt~~ 9ff~~~~ ~tc~rt~5t'1~~l:j<\R~~~
5ttcrrQ"~, ~tcm ~,~Q ~f9fC~ '5l"tf~ C<lC5t
f<lf~~ ~10l f<!'\t~'l'1 !
0fR<.Q-~~~~ <!~mOl,~N'8 c<!i~ 011~'<l~~nl"5(t%~!
<l~~~~
~~~~~~~! •
~~~~~~~,~'itf<p 1,m ~~ ~~~ ~~ ffl ~, ~ <.Q<l'<!i~0'fl-<.Q~~ ~
~~~~~~ mm '8 ~ 'lrrC<ll~~~ ~ I
Vierterach Burgdorf Kommt herauf : Gewiss dort findet ihr
Die Schoensten Maedchen und das beste Bier,Und Haendel von der ersten Sorte! .
~ ~! i!p CIf~,
~ ~l iWt CIf~"m f<R1 ro ~!'8~~, c~~ ~ ~ ~~ cm1 ~,~ <fi~ ~ "l'f ~ c<smltc"'liPlm,em ~<l' ~tc~ ~ <il~ ~ ~ !
( 9J. ~ ~ )Wagner.·· .
Doch gehen wir! Ergraut ist schon die welt,
Die Luft gekuehlt, der Nebel faellt !Am Abend Schaetzt man erst das Haus.-
i5t~ : ..... , .. , ..••. , •••
~~m,~~~~~~~,~ifr~,0lIDr <r.1 ~ c~ rc-, <t> I,
~ ~~"'li<fi ~~ ~fr1~ I. ( 9J. ~lr )
Anster ~ "Towgtrds ~ight we first have the true feel of•
~, Shawcross J11c~c<l~ 'when evening comes the charms
of home grow double" <f1Taylor ~ "At night,
house to prize" ~~~ m MacNeice-~ "It's in the ereally values home"-~~ ~ ~'Sft~ "~~.
~9f~" ~~ ~<tl ~~ '8 ~~ ~ ~
~ Taylor ~~ ~~ ~'<rui~ ~
~ 'Abend' ~ Th<1~~'Night' ~ ~'t~? ~<l:, ~ c~rt<fi ~~ <ut~ ~ ~
~~"~~IMephestopheles
Wie's wieder siedet, wieder glueht !Geh ein und troeste sie du Tor!
ro~i:~'t,<1:f~~ f<>tfu~,~., ~ ~,_'8ur 9ft~! 1>"~~;r, ~'8 ~~1 f9tm I
( '1. ~)) )
'f9t~' '8 'f~' "t~ rt{'~ <l:Tg);rj ~<;<tltfil~"l\j'i{~<l:Wf ~C'f ~ '8 ~1<1~1' ~"1\j~n:<l: ~ <tl?:Q~ I
~ ~~ ~ \~Hl~<1llfl'lc~~Q'8~ ~~ <tlQ(1~
Meine Ruh i~thi.n,. . .1Y.IeinHerz ..i~t.~c.4wer,Ich finde sie nimmer
Und nimmermehr
Taylor~<l::
My peace is gone,My heart is sore :I never find it,Ah nevermore !
~~:• "ItPt ~ fut~Rc1,
~~~,"t~ ~~ f~ ;rj C'i51,
f~ ~1 C'i51 '%i !
®1m:"ItPt ~~ c~ c~'
~~~~ftf~ c'ffU 9Jmi ;rj ~
9ftt<f1;rj ~ ~ft I
~I'(t{o'jnr "fwnr Rc1" ~<!, ~~R~ "c~ c~"-~ ~~t<fi ~<tl ;ro r
~~ "~ f;rc,"-~~'t' ~~ ~'t ~<l:,~Nt~NI ~~,
1m rom Taylor ~ ~~9 ~9fnr ~'€'~ ~ ~m9f,~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~?;~ I f<j)~,~'Sft~ ~~~ 9f,~-fuwr~ f.r I <!J"<ffU ~<fT ~''¥~?;9 ~ ~ rt{-fU ~~ 9ft'8~11f1':
Mein Busen draengtSich nach ihm hin,
Ach duerft' ich fassenUnd halten ihn !Und kuessen ihnSo wie ich wollt',
An Seinen KuessenVergehen sollt' !
( Goethe. Faust, P. 111 )
Bearbeiter Des BandesErnst Grumach
1954Academic-Verlag Berlin )
•
. :~
~~, ~j~C1m ~~ '~~''€ '1~ ~Mein schoos ! Gott! draengt
Sich nach ihm hin
Ach duerft' ich fassen.
Und halten ihn
Und kuessen ihn
So wie ich wollt
An seinen kussen
Vergehen sollt.
U rfaust, P. 45
Gesamtausgabe
1m lnsel-Verlag
1958 )
'it1 Cffq 'lil 'f<f~.~ ~'li', '~m 9]Q~ ~t9).{ ~',
~9'~-~ ~ ®l~ fM ~9/ftm 0ic1\5R ~<[,
~~ ~, ~ C'[ ~~ ~ ~ tf~ <['j "f,~~,~ 'T1[, ~ f;rf~ m<t1 ~-~ \5'f@i ~ ~~
'8 ~ m~ ~~ ~ ~ ffiORR~ ~~. I ~;rrt~ f<f "ltfu~<tS~ M~t,~t~ ®l~ ;ft~ C"fc;rn
~ ~>HI1{~' <['j 'C<tS<ff~ '5{t~' ~~ ~~ ~ft'T m~f.r? ~~ ®l"f~ <t>.fffi <1C"fJt<>tt~ ~<tS\S ~
~ 'f~ '5{t-1~ ~~t~' ~~ <rnr~~C'[~ ®l~l(Ttm ~"d~~ ~~ <tS~ f<fi ~R ~ C~? ~~
CJt1t ~ '0~ 'T1f! ~ ®l~ ~ M'1 ~ m c<R?. <PR1!l:~'1~<tS iE9fctflC(C'T'T<1rC'f?
~ 'R: ~ ~fr.!9 <W1~' ~ ~ ~ ~~ #j3f~ 9(t~J,
~.!r ~~fq ~~f9t f.TWti~ ~"'f CW;~ cm~-~i~ ~ ~'T 'li (~~ ~m ~9ft"'f <tS~ 'T1f, ~~~
~€ rrn-"lt~~<t>\!)~~ M"TI9(t~ ~ Mil ~, ~<tS~ ~
~) I ~ ~~~ ~"'f CW;~ ~Q('S ~ c~i'Sf (mood )-lUillm ~'8m "ftlMi })ft9J'lf--~ffi Tf'€ C}) })tlf~ "f<f-"'f~'T
~ ~ ~~ <tSm ~ f<p? ~ ~ "f~ ~~~'1
~ <fr&\!jft<tSm~ ~~~Ctf'T f.T I ~})<l 5ft;T ~9]Q
~ f.rn~~ ~lM 'Ii ~ C5j1T: C'[-})<l ~ f~ CWj
~ lJi!l~ ~~ <H~ I ~, '<[~ ~ ~ "fRQ)' f<!',<['j '~.
~ll' Ul<tS~ ~R~ tf'e C<fift'Tipercllrsion ~ <u<[~~~ <fi~
f.! l '~ <tSW9~~' ~f;r <fiC1<t>~ ~ C<fi~ CQ)~ C~,
~at C~ ~\!j '"f~~ iEc:,~ ~~ <tSd '<tS~ fuc1 <>too'
,~, ~ f~f;r ~~ ~~ ~, f<p~ <t>C1<t>!\!)j~
~ ~"'~'€ ~?:\S ~ 5ft;T ClC(~ ~- '<tS~ <[})~ C~'
~ ~ ~i'li', '''f1'G1 iSf'T"f ~',-~})<l ~ \!)<lC1r<l!~~
e C"1tor1~ 'li I ~"f'T f<p R~ ~~ 5ft;T '~~~'
~ ~ ~~ ~<tS~ ~~ ~~ ~,
I
"ltnzRc~~ fffi<m~ ®l~ ~ ~"'l1~ ~ 9j"f~ <l'~, f<t;~ ~ 5'Jtc~i{~'ltm ~
~ CORf.ll ~ WtQQf1lW1e<l'tm ? .
i{tt~ ~ ~ ~ f~ ~ "<>tt~J"
~f~~~ I f~ ~ <itffi C<{C<l'~1 ~~ f~
Cf>fi9rn-C<l'~~ ~1 ~ ~ or-T I ~'G1~ tJ<1><1>~~
m~ fttf~ 'creative' "111,(representational' <fI 'intef~ representation-~i{ 0'fi~<!I'8 9j"f~1ih ~
rn;9j" "!ti{1 <fI ~m ~ <lim ~~ ~ i!tt~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~fW1 P1<!1 ~~, <l'f9<f1 <w>m9!t
. ~R~<t>~~ -M~,2lt~, ~ m~ W~ .e~'8 ~fu;~ <it{<PJ O'f~~~, e~ 9j"t{<PJO'f~~ ~
"ltmlf<l ~ ~ ~fu;~, ~W<t> ~~ ~ ~~
'WIfJt<it'fJttmr "T(;'fJ'8I ~~0f4~TI1~ ~ ~~
<li~i{~<P'Sf01~<t> f.li\1Wff ~ 5(~i{ <lfto1 rot~, ~ ••
~<1'~~<1'~i{~~If5f~ ~~~ f~ ~~ "T(;~~ I .~
~~'f~ ~t'(gfir<l' ~m~f<l~~ ;rj ~ ~ ~
~~ f<l~~ ~? ~~~ ~,~~ "1.~ ~"ll <mOl
~<\i-~~ ~,m "111f<t>?
"I1~i{ <t>Q(~'1~ ~O'f ~<PfU fu"8( ~ <t>Q(1-'
~ ~~ ~<t>~~ e<t>I' ®l"l\<:5t<liM<l'1 ~Jt<itlfTh1
~~ ~ ~ ~m Sl:~ ~7[ e~ *~,®l~ ~~®l~ ~ ~ ~<\i~ ~ ~ *.~~-e~~ ~~9j" ~ I ~ ~ ~-fU ~~ ~'(g, ~~ Jl
~~-m ~ f~:fU ~ ~9j"O'f~ I ~~~'8 ~
~"l\ @~~ ~~ ~~ m~m~~ffl ~ ~ 1Mt'M'''l?:~J "l\fu~ ~~, em "ltnzfrl~<1'~-i e~~ ,~-~<l'tt~ ~~ ~-~ ~~ '~ ~ urc~M' ~ ~
~9j" ~) I '~9j"~ lIN ~~~' 5jir~ Jr ~ f.fI~~ mf<l'?
~ ~ m"l\t'f"9f!f or-T, ~~ ~ ~~~ ~'f<t>nft~lfJ ~fu<i> CffWli{ Qf~ <it'8ID'8 ~'1Wl "111I ~
~ <il<f.~ QIDNm ff~ ~~ <m9j"J~~,
t1f ~ c>rrf e'<tt<t> e<ffi;fj -M~ ~ ~~-e'l ~~
~ f.rc~ ~ ~<1'tV<u <li~ 'I'f~ "111I ~ ~~ <w't
~ ~Q~ ~~ 'f~ Qf'8m 'I'f~ 'f"l\~<t>i{
'!{~~ ~~ ~-f<t>~ e~ f~~ ~~~ ~<li~ ff~ '8
~ cW 'lm~ ~~mi{ 9j"firffirls ;roI
~~~ ~ ~'1~Q. ~ ~ I )\:I~~ '1ttC'lQc~'9fmll' "l\tPr<t' 9j"1%<t't"ll®lft~~ b<!P1~~ CO'f~ 'Q~~ffi~
'(ltS' 2f<l~ffl~ ~~ ~~~ ~C'ft"l\I ~Q ~m(9 ~
~<1\ fwt~ ~ fu~ ~~ c~ I f<li~. f~m« "iCW ~lJ:.
~~ ~ ~ C<{ "Q<Doi'l~~ ~ '8 ~"f~t~ Pr~ '1Wl~
11 'M~ ~~M eQ(~ ~m ®lQ~"l\"t~ ~<it~ffiT
~ '3fR~ '1"jk<1rb-i~ CO'f~~Q 'I.C'lW<U 1
~ W"t~ CO'f~Q ffitt'(gi{ PMff ~~ ~~
I ~~ m<t' ~ ~~, ®l~ ~9j"t'fJm ~~ ~~~
~ mfs~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ttC'ft~ m5t Pr~ ~~I
(!j~ f~~~(<[ 2i'<tt~ ~~'1 <t>~ ~
~ ,m f~ ~f4~-5tfft~~, i{~ ~~,
~ ~Jt<it'fJt"ll <il~~~~ '<!m~ ~m~~ ~~~~sr ~t9j"t~Q ~~t5tJ -M~ ~<!, ~ 'f~~
~<it~<t> I
~~ l.!j<rlf; ~ ~ ~ I ()~~.) '1="~ ~~i{
~~ ~ ~ C<1M ~5t '<!~ R I .i{~~
'f (~~H f<t> ~'8) ~~ ~~, e~t'f i{~~
.<\>~ ~tt<\l;i" I C01~C<\l?l~~ ~~T ~ft ~ ~~~<>tt<ot?:ml ~9(if $I 0tt~ ~~ ca'l~
~R ~;rrt~ ~mlf 'EiRtf~-~;rj ~~ ~*,@fr{ R"51l~ ~ mGl f;r~ ~OT «( 1~\!)1t:>1~ ~~
~~~ O\1I-~9(if, ~, c~ ~\5Ttnr f<\f~ 5'/t;r @f.!
9(Rl"r<1'"tOT<\lr?lt~ I
'~ lfnn ~~?:~ ~' 5'/tortU~ ®1~9(t~
~~ ~~~ ~M?l ~~ 5!tOTfU~t?:<\> 'i'f~ ~
'!{~ttlf I ~ ~m'bi ~'i.<\>'1<\l~ 0\11, <\>~
<l'?:"?l~; c~~m Rc"Pl ~?:"?lttlf ~~~ @fr{ ~ ~ C
'!{Qj""D~~f~~ f<1:'&~ <Vr?l I ~P\ <rl ~?:'Tf~ '3tt'3 '3m ~
~~~ '31 ~ ~~~ ~~~ ~ ~~Gl~ 1
.( H ~ ) '1:) '<1I"?l<1I"?l~Rl~ ~TIl ~t?l1 <\>~ ~
_ 12.l?:'3T<\>'., ... CWI'3'R ~~' -~ ~~ '!{t?l ~ 1\'3roC'f '~ ffi~' 5'/t?:'T"?l,~Qj"'lt~"t~ '~111~t'i'f"?l ~'
<\l~ ~Sl?:<\l 0t~tOT ~? ~ "?l<\l~ '!{ttSl1 ~ 'i1<11.!!("1"'.~?:~ 0t~ fl1 'ltr<1 OT11
( )~) '\ '1:) cC'f~ ~<ffU ~~T ~ ~'3~ ~-
~~ ~9f1f, c~, ~~1,<\>~ ~'3J'tN~ ~5f M~'e''flt~<\>1>1i!rtf~"-'!{tm ~'t1 «( "?l-{r&~~ ~Mg~ ~c~, ~~1~, <\l~~~lb7~'3rtf1r~ ~"?l 5f~ ~ ~
~~~I
( ) ~~~ '1: ) ~?lOT~ "?l-{r&~~ ~ ~ ~'" ~
• ~-""?l~ m?:~ ~if-f" #f'«~ ~ ~~ M~iSfR1 «('3 "~"'bi ~.?
CC'f~ ~'i.®1~9(t~ '!{tL!i'~'1 ~ ~ ~ f.{,~<\~ c5!t?:9(ffit~ ~ ~9T <\Tf'&?:<\>'8~ c~ ~~
(H~ '\ '1:) ®1~~" ®1~ "?l~~ lR3?:<\>~~'t ~'~'iOT ~fIf wtM?:C'{' ~ ~f~ ~ I ~ ~
'i'fto$ ~~ ~ I ®1~ if'ij ~ffi~'"t ~ ~
<>f~ <l'~-~ ~ ~ <\l~'8 'i'ft'T 'Til'
~ ~ ~ ~<\l ~~ <t>fJOT~ ~ Cif~
~ ~ r;.$i1 m I <\>~~~ ~-~~ ~<;, ~ d<\l1,
~~flf-~ 'i'ft'8m ~ ~, ~ ~ '!{~ '31
~~~~~ ~f'i'f'Gl ~ ~ <\l~ I ~<\>~
~ <1'?:Sl~~ <Vr?l ~ ~~ ~ ~f~ ~ <\l~
~ 'T1~'bi ~<tfu ~. <\Tf's>~ ~ I ~"?l <\'EiTIl CSl?:~
~ ~?:C'{ ~"?l C<\M~T ~~~~ ~Sj ~~ 'Tj, ~~ ~~ f<1:fxt'~
ctfq m ~ ~m ~<l' c~ m I "?l-{r&~~ ~OT '8 m~ ~ ~~g c«t~ ~ ~ I c«t~ f~ ~~ .~nWR I "?lttiSf~ crr\i ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~-orrltTtrn ~5fT1 MW1.. ~~ Cif~ ~'31 ~, ~,
f.ml ~~ ~M~T <\'EiTIl C"?l?:~'!{~ ~ '1;<R
~ fx1it ~ 9(t~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'Ti-~ OTt~ltf.rf.r I "?It?:\9fW ~ ~'i.<\t~"l1 ~ ~~ 0\11~~ f<1:~~-
* ~ <\t~C~C~--l I
~ ~ loS ~~"
~ '1~~TIl '9(ftm! ~<\>TIl' ®1,~ ~ t:><!l'<1~'i1"Sl<11'!!(1~C\!)
(j ~" ~ ~~ C<\"t~~ RGl ~O'[~ I f<t;~ ~OT<\t~
~Nt'€ '!{t~'1 ~<\~ '!{~ ~~ ~ ~ c9(~ OT1I
, ~~ ®1~~ ~9itlfTi1T lfl~~ <\Tf's>CIf'i1@m"?l~~9(
~ ~-~~\!)~'d'6TCl'~ '!{~ <\l~ rn~ I "?l?:~
., ~ ?l~~?:~ '3'R <T~ <\T~t"?l <\lr?lt~ I <\>~ f<t; 'Ifu ?'111 <\i1"?l'l"?lDM<tt, «( 5f~?:7f1 c'i'f'GlQj"tt<\l~,C#[~?:"l1~~-~-~. -Oftc~ $I I ~~ ~ m'Ttt~ $~"?l~lfT
'IT(~ ~ I 'i1~~--ljc~ $I ~~~, ~~?:O'[t"?l <\t9t
~ ~ ~'It.~l~ C~ ~9(m I 'i1~~1~C\!)'il ~~~~'ili
~9 ~t-l~ ~~, m~~f.f~c~~<f11r1~ ~fril" ~ ~, ~ ~<!, <!t~ ~1:<l' ~
~ ~1 m '•.-sft;r~onr <!t9t~~ ~<!, ~ ffi~~ I
.«. ~ ~~ m<fi1 ~f\;i \3W C<li1Bt'8 ~ 9ft€m""~~~~~~<KO'f~~, ~ill I ...,
tItt"f~ m ~1. ~ ~'T <ruR ~G'f ~~k~-i<11~~~ ~ '11 I f<p~ ~fu~<!J~~ ~ ~ ~~
ill, C'fPf-~I~-i';'r~-i N~'Ri1~ "fC~ ~~<fI ~ ~ I
~~ ~ ~~<:lJr.{) 1',-~~ ~ ~~ ~'@~ ~u~ ~~, ~ ~'T ~~ ~~ <l>$lim-~~ ~m~'l11 ~'~-i<1I~ ~'-i<1><1r$l<ft<!J~~'l,~S! cm:~ fiml $l<fl~-m~
~ m ~ \5{~~ ~~ ~tR<ffim:'T CmM, ~?;"T"f9ftlfTilr, ~'T I'M ~~ f~ c<r't <l>?;~<l>~ ~'~'~-i 1~~ f<f ~~. <~S! 'Ti <!O'fi<!t9ts! ~ ~~S!' '8~S!~ ~f9jn[ Nrn~? ~<!t~ m'Ti @1W, ~ ~~ <!t9t
~ \$f ~ @~t5li on! 0 ~'T C~ <l>?:S!\$f <lit <l>~iii I ~~ ~. ~ ~?:'Ti <l>~ <!O'f?:<!'T-~ c~1$ m ~'T I ~1Wf ~'8 ~, <!'t.T m ~
'1'1CI51 ~1 ~'T '11 C<!l'T? ~$i ~fif ~~ C~ ~
WI ~~,~ ~ \51Of <it])~~ '89fS! fuf& ~? ~'k~~<it~C1f~ ~~~ ~ <!t,O'fi~1 ~R1 \$f ~ ~~
~ 9f1nr 'Til m ~ ~~ ~'T cmM, ~
lfThr~~ fxt~ <!t,O'fi ~ ~~ iSMf~ ~?;O'fif<t;- <ffif?
~~ ~, ~<t>fUc~J~r ~'T fxt~$l'<l>t?:~c~, ~~'WfS!D1 ~~ \5{<t~jif ~ ~<!, ,~~?;~ ~ ~~
~, ~ $l'~-m~ ~~~ \$f <lit ~~ ~. ~~, \5{~;fT ~<!, "f~t~ ~~'l~1~S!1~ <m~
~ ~;"N1r~, ~<l>$l' ~<!, '!ilr-i<lTlft~<l>f~i' ~'~~<1j~~, ~~ ~ ~'8 ~t~ ~S! fu~ ~
I ~ ~ ~ '@W ~<1>I'"lI~-i c~ ~
~ roO'R C.<\SOT? \5{~ ~ ~ ~ ~
\5{~ ~ C~ ~, f!;~ c!l<q~"<Ii ~
~Q~~ ~;r\! ~R\ ~ ~.I1~
~~iWR?~C~'i~t1. c!l<li~m "~" ~ ~~ ~ I
OT~-"~" I c<l~;rT ~\!5 ~ ~ 9\"Q~ '« ~~ ~ "~ \!5tO{" ~ I "tm3: ~~~@<:.,m<1'; \5{\!5c!l<q~ m "~ ~5ti" \!ito!~
~ ~c<\ C~? ®1~ ~\!5i <qO'\r<H,'e<l'~ I ~O'\ ~ ~<q, m ~oftf\!5 ~t"lt~
Rabindranath Tagore, the greatest Indian poet of theage, was also in the old tradition when he composed
and set it to tune and sang i~himself.~~1. ~t~ ~<1'iSf~5f~ ~ '89\"Q ~~
~ <l'~1 fG'fC~ I f<l;'{Ji'~r~1&O!t~~<l'~ m5f
~' 5ffi;rT ~ c?ft~ ~ ~ c;qt~ ~t1.
"tt\!5i %0'\ m~ ~ I ~ c!l~ ~COT<l'm5f ~tt~, 1ftm
"l{~~~9 OT~I ~ '"!<q~ f~Q <2tm <l'~ ~
~9 ~ ~tt<l',-~ ~~ <l'~1 m5f ~ ~ ~~
~%1 ~~~ ~"t ~~ ~ "tttQ ;r\ I <1'tt~ ~~
~tt<HO'\c~ ~<1'FI~ m I c!l"C\5m ~C~'i~~
\!5tWl 141~'itt~ ~ '89\"Q C~?;<l' m5f-mfw ~ ~
~ 1 ~~ ~ f~ cm't~ ~<q~ '81;1 ~ c~~~ cw:5f I ~~;rt~'8 @fuf~ ~ ~ c~ ~
"tf?,?;"iC<\~<q C~ f~ ~~9 ~ m \!itOl ~ ~
~ 5ffiOl ~~ 0'!t5fc<\;~tQ ~~9 f~~ \!5t<T
,~ 5ffi;r'8 ~0'\1 O'\t~ oft I ~C~'i~t1. f4> ~
~ ~ <l'r;"QOl;r\ ?
~ '5IorI c~ m ~ ~<l' I \!5tQ~~ ~<fi ~t~ ~ ~~ ~'1<1S"~ I ~"t<fi~~ mc'9/J ~\!5~ ~ \!5~
~ ~ttiSf, C\!5~ ~ti c1ftnr, ~Q T;J.j m?;~,~ ~t"t 9jr;~, ~ ~ ~, ~9IfM, ~~m~ ~
WI, e<f.~-~ ~ \5tt<>tfu<l'CQOfj~'1 ~'1<1S"~Q<l'~~ ~~
_<f. I ~-9f\!5;"f, "t~<>ftN, 5ti"~<>fta'!1,9\!5t"lt\!5i,~-'fC'f '1<qf~
~ ~~WT ~ ~<l' ~ ~ 15m~<>f<l'~ iSf~ I ~~
~"f<fi?,(ts!iSf* ~<'I ~, \!5t?r ~~R Wn ~~ '1C~
~lfS! '3Tt~ I ~f\!5<l' Q~~ ~ ~~Q ~tOfl f<l"il~
<f.C~ '2f~. ~<>f<fi~tQiSf* ~. @r;~ I \!5tQ'iQ ~fOT<l'
. ~~~~ ~ '1r:~ ~~<l' ~~ ~;rf'1<l' ~~Q m~ 15CO'\?;~\!5\!5~ '"!~9 e~<l' ~ffi m \5tt~ ~'1<1S"m .
~ I <£I~<fitc;t~CQ~ <!ZO'\f~~ ~ c!l~~ @?jtf10!1,
0/(- ~S! @~'8 ~ <WlOfjffl f~'8 <l'~ I c!l~
, <£I~<ft.~ ~'1<1S"~ ~ ~~m ~ ~t;rf\i,r'(3<t>
I f<l~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '1f~~ ~ @~t'8
C~ e~ ~~CQ, ~<>f~ e~ ~t9"N, "t~tiSf ~~<f\!5
~ ~~<\!T~ ~ ~ ~-<q~S! ~5ti Rr:m~
~ ~Of' ~~ 'e~ ~fxJ.l' Clf\!5J, 'f1t0T<\,'?!t~, em'"!
~ ~~~, CQ~ ~\!5 ~ I #ft<ml<!\!J
'9 ~~mf:,r'8~ ~~ ~~-'1<q c~If.i<t> ~ '8 \!59,(J
~<t> ~5f\!5 ~~~1iT ~ ~ I ~ ~~
-8.-~ ~ ~<ffiR ~"tt\!5 ~<fiR~, ~~ ~'6~e''l'JIC\3 ~m~ ~<>f<>ffif~9,'~~!f.i<t> ~ ~ Ol~)
~ O:{~I f1~t--lt<ft~ <l'j~.{1~\!)~ ~tf.P~· ~
~ ~ ~ ~~'1i~1~~~O:{Ic<R1
<fi~~ f<fS~~~~'1i" ~j~l\'>f~\'l~<\1'!i{<l."t~~\!)t~~
~~ ,<\~I~<l' <l.1f~~'G€'1i" ~~ I5fhl ~
m:<rr ~,,1;1 C<l.1"<!'1inr~~~ I ~~ ~~
'&~, ~ ~ <\j«!l~\!)tC'1i~ '1i~ <j\!5f.{~~
~~ ~C'f "rc\!5 m~, '5\t9\t\!5<l.1~\!5tQ9(filwt
~~ ~ \!5\!5~~~ ~~1 ~f<t> ~ ~<\,
~~~ f1~f--lt~~ <fif$ '~J @9\tlft;l ~ro'!1 ~
\!5'4J '1\!5J '5\~ ~~ <\~9\tf\!5, \!5'4J, '1\!5R'1i"~~ '1i~ ~
,~~j~~\'l\'l m~, 12tthjf\!5~~ ~~ ~~9(tC'f1 f.!(.~ '"
~~ '8Q- I~R<t' ~$~~Q <Pro'!~<!~'1 ~<\ 'c1R~o:{ ~
'5\tf.r~t~~fC'fQ '1"C!f'9ffi1f5\!5~~, c<\~1~<1' \!5QjJ,~\!5Wli
Of"1i%:W'lQ~J ~~~ '1i~ '1i~Q ~'8 ft'
<\1,C'f1~tfu\!5J'8 ~Q <l.Jf\!5~ ~ I
12t<!to:{\!5f<l.(.~ \St"lli~ Mf~ <\~~ ~lfif m~'Itfu\!5nf 9('ti<fSQ1f<\~ti!\~ '1itf~'1Q ~"!f ~ 9(~~ .m~<\1,0'\1~~ '5\t~'1i\!5~ ~~ ~tt~ e~~ ~son ~ ..q
9((.i¥ "11,12tt~Co:{~~ \StC'fI <l.RC'f1~(.\!>~ f~t"1tr!1~
~~ 'Oft~'1i~ '1,~o:{ ~ ~"\ <l.~ CC'f~"~
~~<\" I ~ '5W\!5~'0M~J ~ ~ eC'f~<t'~ cm~
m(''l1 ~ ~~ '5\~ ~ I~ ~ ~~ '1itllf.r<1>~ I 12t~ 1f~ ~ JI~
iSiC'fWL,~9(tC'f1 ~9@t I ~Q ~~'1Q1 ~ "lW~ ~e'«<t' PlC'f'1i ~ ~ ~ ~'1i" ~ ~ I
~~?ftm f<t;~ '1,~ CC'ft<t'~~~ ~'1iffl~ ~~ m~('99: ~ ~ ~<l.' ~?Z f<r<f[S1(.<fQ ~~
<\,,,\~~ 9(~ ~~ m I ~~ 9ffi1~ <i'(.G1
~,"t~ ~<t\!5 ~ ~~ ~<\ e~ <l.1~9Tc\!5 I r;a\~
~-m~ t~O!-,
~ Ci1?:~ "~9f1" I ~9(m ~~ f<1<l't~"lS1m.,e, ~ ~ ~ ~<fiiSio:{~9(i ~~~~\!) R"t <l.~~
~ I ~<t' ~'8 ~~ ~m'1 ~<\1~ em~ I ~~ ~9t~ e9J"N ~i Q~~ I fuI'1i" ~
1f~t~, 'ltm'1 ~<l.t'Im ~9 f.!~'1
f.lWjj .~. I e~9t~\!5 m~"t ~~, m#\!5<fS ~9f'fu
~ ~ ~~I~ri\'l ~ ~~, Qt~~ '5\9(<l.J<l.~tQ
f1l@9ftm ~<!i ~ ~'8 I ~<ftQ9 ~<t'm1f~ ~-
fWM 'fll:~f~ '1'T~~ ~ "11 ~ ~~ R~ ~-m <l.J~ ~\!5 c~ "11 ~~ ~ Plarf' ~~ '1tm'1 '
~~ ~ ~ m9"\!5 ~~ ~~~:( l2tt~~
, Jfrlfj 'I'm '~i-e~t<fi~', C<IT<l.~'5\<fitC'f-<ft~ '5\<fi1{<j"J~,
j Wl<fi ~ 'I1"<ftQ9 ~f~ m9Jtm C"tt<\9-~,
~~C'f'1i ~~fC'f <jtt\!5f.1~<\j~fT~ <lCC'ff<l.'Wr ~
~ ~9(tQ1 c\!5fu ~ f~~DtfC'f\!5 futl> ~<fi <\t~ 'T~-
••~~~~*~~~ Dtf~ m ~ ~-clOfnr9'
11~ ~~~ ~ iSitfi!~ \!5tt1fQ<j\!5 <1t~ m<fRWt I '
~ lft~~ ~ro'!i ~9f1 I f~9Jtm m~M'\!5<fi f1ct~"'I--
~ ~~ ~~fi f~~ ~<f ~m9 <fQ~ 9Jt~ "111
llhlcC'fJ~<l'~ 'I1"<!t~9 ~~i <\t~<l' ~~ <\i <l.(.C'f
.~~ ~ Wli l{tfiI<fi ~~ ~ P1C'f(.~ ~~~, iSio:{~9-
~1W51I f~<l.t~ 'I<l. ~Q ~'Tt<fR <fi(.Q ~ ~<fi
I 1I'fC~ ~ ~~ ~i ~ ~, ~ ~ ~~ l{Gl~
~~~ ~ f.1~~~ I ~~"tt1f;\ M:il9, ~1 R(.~,~~ 9tftFI~~, <P~ C<fit'l ~<fim<fi ~~ ~i
~ ~ C1f~ ~~iSi '5\~'; f~mi <\im ~~ ~ ~J~f9 '~ ~ ~ ~~C<!l'l'~~I~--I\'lm<i''; ~9f1 \'lj'S!~~~~IT\'li
~ C1f1lI ~ ~ ~i ~9Jtt1f~ ~<fi 9Jt'8 ~(.~ ~\!5i
~ ~j~~~IT\'l1 ~~ f<I;-~ WI ~<\, ~~ f.!ffi"tQ~ 'T~ ~ ~ ~i <fl C\!5tC'fi~~ ~1~1~<1'~1~<l--
.~ I ~~ 'lfI ~ca;~~~tc1 ~ ~Ol "li ~ ~-~ m"lil ~~ ~~~ ~ Wf <fI ~~
f<fl"li<!l~~~~~"<fl ~ ~"<fl~
-4f1 I ~9fnrI ~~ ~~ ~~r ~ .m~ lft~1
<!l~1 '5(m urc~~., ~,"t 9f~"9r-m-~ I '5hl~ I!I~
~~ Dtf~ ~<FM ~tcOl<fl"CSl<!l<fl~0l$[tf"tm;{, I!I~
-<!l~ mt<R m:o;i f.mT ~~ ~<!'t"t ~~ I!Id
lfO'f i;m~~;.,~~ ~ I ~mi <!l~'5(~'1 ~
..~~ ~ ~~~~ ~~ ~~ m~~9ftf1
"<flmn ~ ;rj ~m ~<!> ~Q '5(f~'1C'R ~
~ ~ ~ f~ <!l"<fl~~ <lm:~ ~~"<flUT ~
.~ '5\t~9f~J ~ "<fl~, ~ ~~Q ~
i>ffi~i ~ I <!l~ ~ ~9fnrI '1f~'1 C~ '!fPri~ ~ C~ fitt~ ~ m ~~ ~ ~~t'15I"1~r~01"!aoj, ~t<l>t"t ~ ~aojO{tQ9f~ I ~~t"<flt"t ~ f~1
~ '5ffiM ~tQ ~ '5(f\S~ 'fG'!~ ~i <!>'\i'/Q~
conTI ~9fWfQ <!l~ ~ C"Pl' ~~ ~{~~ I ~, Oft
~ ~~tt~ roOlm '1N<fIQ ~"t ~~, '1f~
~~~j~ lf~ f<l>~ Qt~ ~~"lil ~tf~ ~~'\i ~
'5{~~ lfaoj~ ~J 1fM lfM~ ~ I ~~ ~ ~
'5(~'1 'fG'!$ '5(~<rt~ ~JQ ~~ C~C"<fl~C1fQ WlfI ~
i;~ ~ ~~$c"<fl ~1> '5('/Q UT~'e ~~ ~~
~~cf ~ flfCO'fOl,'It~'1 ~C1~1j~~If?l <fit~ ~9ftm
~~ Qt'SfCOlf%"<fl~OlQ "if~9fi;~ ~ ~ ~~9fWRi ~~ ~ fuaoR, ~~Q ~mro ~~~ ~ ~~ 'ltm'1 ~ ~tclf~ ~~fu ~"<fltc~ 9f~ ;erto{c~ mC'\ <!l~ ~Q ~
~~ ~ I ~,~<>f <!l~~'aoj'~"<fl ~ ~'~ 1iI
M9fWRi <flt~ ~, ~9fWRi ~~ '1f~ c(C'f
"'5(~ ~ ~,rn~<Ri~~ co;~ ~~ ~
~-9ffi~ <t '\~,
~~ ~.~ ~~<ttir ~aoj'e ~~'1cf~ <>finTR I
f1ff ~<fi ~~J '<lf6~ '5(~,~ <!l~, ~1~ '5(~ I
~~ PTG'f<f.~Q 1.~ '1f~ C~ ~"<fl ~~ ~
"l~ ~"t ~'SftQ ~aoj (.<fC~1>aojCaoj('1 ),,) '1M<fI ~
~lfJ ~<fi ~ c~;r ~~ f<!>~? "<flt~'1:<r%nr9\f1>"l~tQ
~~ S"fCaoj<!l<f.'5(tcC'lt"<fl<[~'5(~<; 9\t1>C'\'i'Ji~f"f ~t'SftQ '5\tH"t1
~ ( '1 ~o y '5(~ "<flQ~~ ~ ~C"ti ~C'€tQ ~ ~ m,~ ~~. '5(t~aoj ~Q ~ ;r1 '5(~ co;~"<flfm\f'
mlfP[ ~C<[ ~~'\i @c§~ '<[lC~Ol! <!l~ ~~ c~tf'1<!>
~ '5{~f~ '5\t'\i'e ~. <!l<!>~~ffi ~~ <>ft'em m<! I ~
$ ~9ff?l ~aoj'e'5(tt~ I
~ ~~ @~ ~'aoj ~ '<[lC'jJt'1I "ift~'1Clf~ ~~ 9(~
,l<1~<j,R~C;rQ ~tf%~t'\i ~lftC<! ~~Q '5(9f~~ ~t<r~
~ ~* m<!>C1f?lco;~<!> ~~Ol ~~ I ~tQ <!l~ ~~i
;; 0lt5/J I . "Pr~\ ~C~'\i ~~" -<!l'\i "fC~ ~~<; ~~<tm-~
€ ~~ortiJ, '3lt?l'e ~t4'<[l 'e '\iC'ltmcf f~ ~'1 '5f<rn
"'n~ '~·'3lt"fi <!>RrI ~ \Si<fj~t<!aoj~, ~<>fi, ~<f~, <!l~,
W WI, ~lft<[Q~'e ~"1~ ,
~~~'lr.,l~<fl~<!i" 'lIrr~'l'): C'fiti5I{3~1j{;5!tFS ~~~~iS I ~~~rl1: c~I'ilr"lt
f~·HI'I'l.I <2f'1'i"f'l': ~"l~illllmhl\) I ifi~: ~'SI'l'1 I
~~nt'\i~<!l~@9fm~ <i't~;(J ~ ~<!l<m 9ff~i ortm
~i~ ~,~m<!> '5(t~ "<flC'\iI iSf~ f<!f~ "Iffl"t
~ 2(f~~ Oltfu<t>i"tt&t~ <!l~ ~~of fWi @9f~Ttlf~C~ <>fMm
~ '\it'e, ~~ ~ m(!j~~ <flf~;(J~~ ~J '<[l~~ Tj
~ ~t<vcaoj'e,<!l'\ii ~ ~ ~mQ ~<!>~fc1 ~~ fu<fi~
~'tt~ -rt~ ~ <!l'<[l~~~-{j<l'1ii I
~mfU~ ~~Qt'e ~ ~~ M~~f~ I fft
.~ ~~ ~<iGfru~ ~ ~<\l ~ 001, ~ ~
Qft~ \!ftlff-l<\l~"11~1 I
~~~nr~i\f ;:r.! I f~~lf<it; $~~ ~J~~ ~J
~~1
~~~ C.!\C1{ll ~\ft-I"'I! ~fi\i9(t~ C~~~5"1' I
.!f~'M: 1{oe"l ''l' ~t~l\ I Ift'l{: '1i:' Vt~t I
·~~(.tt(."nl ~'1 ~J<\l'ltr;'t~ ~ ('~~~l>"('o{~ ~.,~
~9fWt'l '~: ~Q <rt~"I1~ ~ ~ I ,~
.9jft~ ~~ ~ '8 '~' ~ Gf"~ ''l~ ~ ,~~ ~<i~~ I lf~Q Gf~ C"P{ m ~ ~~'ltQ, ~ ~Jt~ <\l~ ~~~ I f<\l'{?i~~ WOl \!TIt,..<iR1'tf~ f~m~ I 1it~'1,~<u ~j~(.~~ <2tf'i3 ~.Qi<it~~ ~~ <Rt~ ~~Q ~W'1 ~~Q~~~
~~ '3\~ <£l~ f~~~'f~OOf '3\'1"[ ~~q~ ,~ fm1\!ft~ <\lCQI
~'i3 ~~ ~9fWt~ ,., '3\t<\lt['1<\lt~m '3\~0l~ "11, .-,
~j<\J~<l."1t~~ ~ ~ I
~ '8 ~i<i1~~ ~Ol ~ f<l~ ~N ~ ~.~~~~ro~~WI
••ARICHA YA :: NOVEMBER. 1~---_.1. i ••••••••.t .-Bi'm ~;mr..
~(Q WtIlt1"'lJ-. oA,f\ft..aoI. q •••.•• ~. ••• "" II " 'II'1,,~.~ ..,
••. _....iIt- •......•. •.••.