0$$ the origin of species !#$%&'()*$+,$-#$.(--#/-0$

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

!

! ! ! ! ! """#$%&'()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

The Origin of Species

The Beak of the Finch

0123%45*6!78+%3!9:;<!

0,/*!;!&=!>!

?7$!@ABCDEFFG!DGHIFJG!E7JIAHG!

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

I,+"%(K4!=%(-5*4#!!.&670&2*+%91':5"+%&$"%&(&0#"(%#*%61;1'2%1'%5&@1#&#+%31#5%+#$141'26-%(199"$"'#%9**(%+*<$:"+A%+<:5%&+%#5"%:&:#<+%91':5%*'%#5"%6"9#%&'(%#5"%,"(1<,%2$*<'(%91':5%*'%#5"%$125#>%X5&'2"+%1'%@"&4%+5&0"+%*;"$%#1,"%5&;"%"'&@6"(%"&:5%91':5%+0":1"+%#*%91'(%&'(%,&'10<6&#"%#5"%9**(%#5&#%1+%,*+#%:*,,*'%1'%#5"1$%5&@1#&#>%C!5*#*+%:*<$#"+-%*9%Y*5'%Z&'%("%.$&&99>D%

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!9!&=!>!




MATERIALS [&:5%2$*<0%3166%<+"%#5"%9*66*31'2W%

• L%@*V%%• ?3*%#-0"+%*9%#**6+W%$"2<6&$%#3""G"$+%&'(%061"$+%C-*<$%T@"&4+UD%• \<@+#$&#"%C&+#$*#<$9D%%• ?3*%#-0"+%*9%+""(+%C$1:"A%@"&'+D%• ]%0&0"$%:<0+%9*$%+""(%:*66":#1*'%C^%9*$%"&:5%#**6D%• ?1,"$%%• ?&@6"+0**'+%&'(%,"&+<$1'2%:<0+%C+5&$"(%31#5%*#5"$%2$*<0+D%

%

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

L> ?&4"%&%9"3%+""(+%*9%"&:5%#-0"%&'(%#$-%#*%01:4%#5",%<0%31#5%"&:5%#**6>%?$-%#*%&6+*$.&7/"%#5"%6&$2"%+""(+>%^> \"#%<0%-*<$%@*V%"';1$*',"'#%@-%0<##1'2%#5"%&+#$*#<$9%*'%#5"%@*##*,%*9%-*<$%@*V>%%_> J&4"%:&$"9<6%&24*+.,)%&(4%*9%-*<$%#**6+%C*$%T@"&4+UDA%#5"%@*V%"';1$*',"'#A%&'(%#5"%+""(+>%F$1#"%(*3'%-*<$%

*@+"$;&#1*'+W%

1#23/0```````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````

````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

=)<'&*)>#)4$?@')40$A*)/'6#&$4"#$/7;/4&24#$2)6$"*B$'4$B'88$2++#.4$2..#//$4*$/##6/C0$``````````````````````````````````````%

````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````

````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

,##6/0```````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````

````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

]> B&+"(%*'%-*<$%*@+"$;&#1*'+A%,&4"%&%8+*6%-)%&(%&@*<#%"&:5%@"&4/+%&@161#-%#*%01:4%<0%"'*<25%9**(%1'%-*<$%"';1$*',"'#%<'("$%#5"%#5$""%(199"$"'#%9**(%:*'(1#1*'+%61+#"(%@"6*3>%%

$

D8#)4E$*+$;*4"$/>288$2)6$82&(#$/##6/0$

!

!

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!R!&=!>!




%)8E$2$+#B$/>288$/##6/$?@FG!0$,>288$/##6/$.2)$+288$')4*$/>288H$8#//$2..#//';8#$/-2.#/$B'4"')$4"#$2/4&*47&+C0$

!

!%)8E$2$+#B$82&(#$/##6/$?&#>#>;#&$4"24$4"#E$"2<#$4*$;#$.&7/"#6C0$

!

!

O&+,/%(/!FP8*+%Q*()!

a> ?*%#"+#%-*<$%0$"(1:#1*'+A%-*<%3166%'*3%$<'%&%=&+,/%(/!*P8*+%Q*()%<'("$%9**(%:*'(1#1*'+%#5&#%+1,<6&#"%#5"%:*'(1#1*'+%;#+*&#%&'(%67&')($#5"%#3*%,&K*$%($*<25#+%#5&#%3"$"%("+:$1@"(%1'%#5"%,*;1">%?5"%:*'(1#1*'+%&$"W%%

R> !"#$%&'%()*#+,-%6*#+%*9%6&$2"%&'(%+,&66%+""(+%&$"%&;&16&@6"%C+1,<6&#"+%9**(%&;&16&@161#-%;#+*&#%#5"%($*<25#+D%%B> ./&012+%3-%*'6-%6&$2"%+""(+%&$"%&;&16&@6"%&'(%@1$(+%5&;"%#*%:*,0"#"%9*$%9**(%C+1,<6&#"+%9**(%&;&16&@161#-%

(<$1'2%#5"%91$+#%($*<25#%1'%LMNND%%%X> ./&012+%4-%*'6-%+,&66%+""(+%&$"%&;&16&@6"%&'(%@1$(+%5&;"%#*%:*,0"#"%9*$%9**(%C+1,<6&#"+%9**(%&;&16&@161#-%

(<$1'2%#5"%+":*'(%($*<25#%-"&$+%6&#"$D%

% ?*%$<'%#5"%"V0"$1,"'#A%9*66*3%#5"%+#"0+%@"6*3>%%5&#$6+6&#%7-%!"#$%&'%()*#+,%

b> R00*1'#%#3*%,",@"$+%*9%-*<$%2$*<0%#*%@"%91':5"+%&'(%#5"%$",&1'1'2%,",@"$C+D%#*%@"%#5"%*@+"$;"$C+D>%[&:5%91':5%:5**+"+%*'"%*9%#5"%#3*%#**6+%#*%@"%<+"(%&+%&%@"&4%&'(%#&4"+%#3*%*9%#5"%9*<$%:<0+>%

N> ?5"%*@+"$;"$C+D%+0$1'46"C+D%^c_%:<0%*9%6&$2"%+""(+%C@"&'+D%&'(%_%#@+0>%*9%+,&66%+""(+%C$1:"D%1'#*%#5"%@*V>%d> )<'%-*<$%=%+4)!)+%,3!*9!R:!4*-&(64>%)"&(%#5$*<25%+#"0+%&D%&'(%@D%@"9*$"%-*<%+#&$#W%

&D ?5"%*@+"$;"$C+D%+#&$#%#5"%#$1&6>%@D O1':5"+%01:4%<0%&+%,&'-%+""(+%&+%0*++1@6"%&'(%06&:"%#5",%1'%#5"1$%:<0+>%\,&66%&'(%6&$2"%+""(+%2*%1'%+"0&$&#"%

:<0+>%e&$2"%+""(+%5&;"%#*%@"%:$<+5"(f%E@+"$;"$+%:*<'#%"&:5%6&$2"%+""(%&+%#5"-%&$"%:$<+5"(>%\,&66%+""(+%:&'%@"%:*<'#"(%&#%#5"%"'(%*9%#5"%#$1&6>%%

:D R9#"$%_g%+":*'(+A%*@+"$;"$+%"'(%#5"%#$1&6%&'(%:*<'#%#5"%+,&66%+""(+%:*66":#"(%@-%"&:5%91':5>%%(D O*$%"&:5%@"&4%#-0"A%"'#"$%#5"%#*#&6%'<,@"$%*9%:*66":#"(%+""(+%C'*%,&##"$%35&#%+1G"D%1'%#5"%#&@6"%<'("$%Te&'(%

*9%!6"'#-U%&'(%T?$1&6%L>U%"D [,0#-%#5"%:<0+>%I*%'*#%$"06"'1+5%#5"%+""(%+<006-%1'%-*<$%"';1$*',"'#>%%9D )"0"&#%4)*84!,ST*S!)5+**!Q&+*!)%Q*4%#*%$<'%&%#*#&6%*9%=&1+!)+%,34%&'(%"'#"$%-*<$%'<,@"$+%<'("$%?$1&6+%^A%_A%&'(%

]>%e"#%+*,"*'"%"6+"%@"%#5"%*@+"$;"$%"&:5%#1,">%F5"'%1#/+%-*<$%+":*'(%#1,"%#*%@"%&%91':5A%<+"%&%(199"$"'#%#**6>%%2D R9#"$%#5"%9*<$#5%#$1&6A%&((%<0%#5"%#*#&6%+""(%:*<'#+%9*$%"&:5%@"&4%1'%-*<$%#&@6">%%5D B*Q&.*!,33!4**64%9$*,%-*<$%"';1$*',"'#%&'(%,*;"%*'%#*%#5"%'"V#%:*'(1#1*'>%

%5&#$6+6&#%8-%./&012+%3%

M> ?5"%*@+"$;"$+%+0$1'46"%Lc_%:<0%*9%6&$2"%+""(+%C@"&'+D%1'#*%#5"%@*V>%%Lg> )<'%-*<$%=%+4)!)+%,3!*9!R:!4*-&(64>%)"&(%#5$*<25%+#"0+%&D%&'(%@D%@"9*$"%-*<%+#&$#W%

&D ?5"%*@+"$;"$C+D%+#&$#%#5"%#$1&6>%@D O1':5"+%01:4%<0%&'(%:$<+5%&+%,&'-%6&$2"%+""(+%&+%0*++1@6">%!6&:"%#5"%:$<+5"(%$",&1'+%1'%&%:<0>%E@+"$;"$+%5&;"%

#*%4""0%:*<'#%&+%"&:5%6&$2"%+""(%1+%:$<+5"(>%%:D R9#"$%_g%+":*'(+A%*@+"$;"$+%"'(%#5"%#$1&6>%%(D O*$%"&:5%@"&4%#-0"A%"'#"$%#5"%#*#&6%'<,@"$%*9%:*66":#"(%+""(+%1'%#5"%#&@6"%<'("$%TI$*<25#%LU%&'(%T?$1&6%L>U%"D !$*:""(%&+%1'%X*'(1#1*'%RA%+#"0+%"DP5D>%%

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!<!&=!>!




5&#$6+6&#%5-%./&012+%4%

LL> ?5"%*@+"$;"$C+D%+0$1'46"C+D%L>a%#@+0>%*9%+,&66%+""(+%1'#*%#5"%@*V>$ %L^> )<'%-*<$%=%+4)!)+%,3%*9%R:!4*-&(64>%)"&(%#5$*<25%+#"0+%&D%&'(%@D%@"9*$"%-*<%+#&$#W%

&D ?5"%*@+"$;"$C+D%+#&$#%#5"%#$1&6>%@D O1':5"+%01:4%<0%&+%,&'-%+,&66%+""(+%&+%0*++1@6"%&'(%06&:"%#5",%1'%#5"1$%*3'%:<0>%%:D R9#"$%_g%+":*'(+A%*@+"$;"$+%"'(%#5"%#$1&6%&'(%:*<'#%#5"%+,&66%+""(+%1'%"&:5%:<0>%%(D O*$%"&:5%@"&4%#-0"A%"'#"$%#5"%#*#&6%'<,@"$%*9%:*66":#"(%+""(+%1'%#5"%#&@6"%<'("$%TI$*<25#%^U%&'(%T?$1&6%L>U%"D !$*:""(%&+%1'%X*'(1#1*'%RA%+#"0+%"DP2D>%%

%D%h%+,&66%@"&4%C#3""G"$+DQ%?%h%6&$2"%@"&4%C061"$+D%

%%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%

!"#$%&"'($)*(&

+##,&-#.,/*/#.&

)0.,&#+&%)'.*1& ,"#$!2*&3& ,"#$!2*&4&

*"/0)!56'078&*1%'& 56'078&*1%'& 56'078&*1%'&(& )& (& )& (& )&

3& ! ! ! ! ! !

4& ! ! ! ! ! !

9& ! ! ! ! ! !

:& ! ! ! ! ! !

*#*0)& ! ! ! ! ! !

!

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!U!&=!>!




i+"%#5"%#&@6"%@"6*3%&'(%C19%&0061:&@6"D%#5"%0$*;1("(%[V:"6%+0$"&(+5""#%#*%"'#"$%#5"%:6&++%$"+<6#+>%%

%%%7=)*+!)5*!FP8*+%Q*()!L_> ?5"%#"&:5"$%3166%"1#5"$%:*66":#%"&:5%2$*<0/+%$"+<6#+%1'%#5"%[V:"6%+0$"&(+5""#%0$*;1("(%*$%3$1#"%#5",%*'%#5"%@*&$(>%8'%

"1#5"$%:&+"A%:*0-%&66%2$*<0%$"+<6#+%1'#*%-*<$%TX6&++U%#&@6"%&@*;">%%L]> ['#"$%#5"%:6&++%,"&'%C&;"$&2"D%1'%#5"%#&@6"%<'("$%"&:5%:*'(1#1*'%&'(%@"&4%#-0">%S*<%3166%5&;"%#*%:&6:<6&#"%#5"%,"&'%

-*<$+"69%19%-*<%&$"%'*#%<+1'2%#5"%+0$"&(+5""#>%%La> X&6:<6&#"%35"#5"$%#5"%91':5"+%3"$"%&@6"%#*%+<$;1;"%#5"%#3*%+1,<6&#"(%($*<25#%:*'(1#1*'+W%?5"%)&),3!(1Q2*+!&=!4**64%

"&:5%91':5%:*66":#"(%(<$1'2%X*'(1#1*'%R%Ce&'(%*9%!6"'#-D%&$"%#5"%9$""P9""(1'2%&,*<'#+%#5&#%1#%3*<6(%"&#%#*%@"%9<66-%+&#1&#"(>%O*$%&%@1$(%#*%+<$;1;"A%1#%'""(+%#*%*@#&1'%&#%6"&+#%*'%&;"$&2"%dgj%*9%1#+%9$""P9""(1'2%&,*<'#>%O*66*3%#5"+"%+#"0+W%

&D O**(%61,1#%9*$%+,&66P@"&4"(%91':5"+W%i+"%#5"%:6&++%,"&'%9*$%@"&4%#-0"%T\U%<'("$%X*'(1#1*'%R%Ce&'(%*9%!6"'#-D%&'(%:&6:<6&#"%#5"%dgj%61,1#>%%

!"#$$%&'$(")$%

*++,%!+-,.).+-%

"#-,%+*%/"'-)0% ,&+(12)%3% ,&+(12)%4%

1&+(/%)+)#"$!

56'#78%)0/'% 56'#78%)0/'% 56'#78%)0/'%$% "% $% "% $% "%

19:;<%3% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%4% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%=% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%>% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%?% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%@% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%A% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%B% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%C% ! ! ! ! ! !

19:;<%3D% ! ! ! ! ! !

)+)#"%% ! ! ! ! ! !

E'#-% ! ! ! ! ! !

!

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!V!&=!>!




@D O**(%61,1#%9*$%6&$2"P@"&4"(%91':5"+W%i+"%#5"%:6&++%,"&'%9*$%@"&4%#-0"%TeU%<'("$%X*'(1#1*'%R%Ce&'(%*9%!6"'#-D%&'(%:&6:<6&#"%#5"%dgj%61,1#>%%

:D X*,0&$"%"&:5%91':5/+%9**(%61,1#%31#5%#5"%&;"$&2"%C,"&'D%&,*<'#+%1#%*@#&1'"(%1'%X*'(1#1*'+%B%&'(%X%CI$*<25#+%L%&'(%^D>%89%#5"%&;"$&2"%1+%2$"&#"$%#5&'%*$%"=<&6%#*%#5"%61,1#A%#5"%91':5%+<$;1;"(Q%19%1#/+%6"++%#5&'%#5"%61,1#A%#5"%91':5%(1"(>%J&$4%#5*+"%#5&#%(1"(%31#5%&%:$*++>%

Lb> R'+3"$%#5"%=<"+#1*'+%@"6*3>%%

QUESTIONS L> X&$"9<66-%$";1"3%#5"%:6&++%$"+<6#+>%

&D X*,0&$"%#5"%,"&'+%1'%-*<$%:6&++%#&@6">%F51:5%@"&4%:*66":#"(%#5"%6&$2"+#%&;"$&2"%'<,@"$%*9%&66%+""(+k%8("'#19-%*'"%9*$%"&:5%9**(%:*'(1#1*'>%%

e&'(%*9%!6"'#-W%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

I$*<25#%LW%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

I$*<25#%^W%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

@D F51:5%@"&4%:*66":#"(%#5"%+,&66"+#%&;"$&2"%'<,@"$%*9%+""(+k%8("'#19-%*'"%9*$%"&:5%9**(%:*'(1#1*'>%

e&'(%*9%!6"'#-W%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

I$*<25#%LW%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

I$*<25#%^W%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

:D F51:5%@"&4%:*66":#"(%,*+#%*9%#5"%6&$2"%+""(+%1'%I$*<25#%L%&'(%,*+#%*9%#5"%+,&66%+""(+%1'%I$*<25#%^k%

e&$2"%+""(+W%``````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

\,&66%+""(+W%``````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

(D I1(%"1#5"$%*9%#5"%#3*%@"&4%#-0"+%:*'+1+#"'#6-%:*66":#%,*$"%+""(+%#5&'%#5"%*#5"$%<'("$%&66%:*'(1#1*'+k%89%+*A%351:5%*'"k%

!

!"D I1(%&'-%*9%#5"%91':5"+%:*66":#%6"++%9**(%#5&'%1#+%dgj%61,1#%(<$1'2%I$*<25#%L%*$%^%&'(%+#&$;"%#*%("&#5%&+%&%

:*'+"=<"':"k%e1+#%#5"%*'"+%#5&#%(1"(%(<$1'2%"&:5%($*<25#>%

I$*<25#%LW%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

I$*<25#%^W%````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````%

^> F&+%#5"$"%&'-%(199"$"':"%1'%#5"%#3*%@"&4+/%&@161#-%#*%01:4%<0%4Q,33%+""(+k%89%+*A%35&#%9"&#<$"+%,&("%*'"%@"&4%,*$"%+<::"++9<6%#5&'%#5"%*#5"$k%

!

!

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!W!&=!>!




_> F&+%#5"$"%&'-%(199"$"':"%1'%#5"%&@161#-%*9%#5"%#3*%@"&4+%#*%01:4%<0%2)6$:$<+5%3,+/*%+""(+k%89%+*A%35&#%9"&#<$"+%,&("%*'"%@"&4%,*$"%+<::"++9<6%#5&'%#5"%*#5"$k%

!

!]> I1(%-*<$%$"+<6#+%+<00*$#%-*<$%0$"(1:#1*'+k%[V06&1'%-*<$%&'+3"$>%

!

!

%

a> X*'+1("$%#5"%05-+1:&6%:5&$&:#"$1+#1:+%*9%#5"%+<@+#$&#"%C#5"%&+#$*#<$9D%1'%-*<$%,*("6%"';1$*',"'#%&'(%#5"%"99*$#%1#%#**4%#*%:*66":#%6&$2"%&'(%+,&66%+""(+%<'("$%&'-%*9%#5"%9**(%:*'(1#1*'+>%

&D F5&#%:5&$&:#"$1+#1:+%,&("%+""(+%6"++%&::"++1@6"A%&'(%351:5%+""(+%3"$"%,*+#%&99":#"(k%

!

!

%

@D F*<6(%-*<%+&-%#5&#%#5"%&+#$*#<$9%,&("%1#%5&$(%9*$%+*,"%91':5"+%#*%91'(%"'*<25%9**(%#*%+<$;1;"k%89%+*A%351:5%91':5%5&(%#5"%2$"&#"+#%#$*<@6"k%S*<%,&-%2*%@&:4%#*%l<"+#1*'%L"D%%&'(%^%#*%5"60%31#5%-*<$%&'+3"$>%%

!

!

%

b> B&+"(%*'%-*<$%$"+<6#+A%35&#%C19%&'-#51'2D%:&'%-*<%:*':6<("%&@*<#%"&:5%@1$(/+%&@161#-%#*%:*66":#%9**(%&'(%+<$;1;"%1'%-*<$%,*("6%"';1$*',"'#%<'("$%#5"%#5$""%(199"$"'#%:*'(1#1*'+k%!$*0*+"%&'%&'+3"$%9*$%"&:5%:*'(1#1*'%+"0&$&#"6-%&'(%1':*$0*$&#"%#5"%"99":#%*9%-*<$%+<@+#$&#"%*'%9**(%&;&16&@161#->%

!

!

%

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

%

!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$!"#$%&'()*$+,$-"#$.(--#/-0$$

1&-23&4$5#4#6-(+)$&)7$87&9-&-(+)$ !

! !!!

?,2!@&+L45**)!

! ! ! ! ! """#2%&%()*+,-)%.*#&+/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 0,/*!>!&=!>!




N> 89%-*<%+&3%&%(199"$"':"%@"#3""'%&%@1$(/+%&@161#-%#*%*@#&1'%9**(%@&+"(%*'%@"&4%+5&0"A%"V06&1'%5*3%#51+%6"&(+%#*%";*6<#1*'%*;"$%#1,">%C)",",@"$%#5&#%#5"%(199"$"'#%@"&4%#-0"+%-*<%#"+#"(%1'%-*<$%"V0"$1,"'#%$"0$"+"'#%@1$(+%*9%#5"%+&,"%,"(1<,%2$*<'(%91':5%+0":1"+>%?5"-%,"$"6-%+5*3%;&$1&#1*'+%1'%@"&4%+1G">D%%"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!

d> ?51+%&:#1;1#-%+1,<6&#"+%&%;&$1"#-%*9%:*':"0#+%#5&#%06&-%&'%1,0*$#&'#%$*6"%1'%#5"%0$*:"++%*9%";*6<#1*'>%m&,"%&%+0":191:%"V&,06"%9$*,%#51+%&:#1;1#-%+1,<6&#1'2%"&:5%:*':"0#%@"6*3W%

• Z&$1&#1*'W%%

%

• R(&0#&#1*'%C1>">A%&%@"'"91:1&6%#$&1#%#5&#%1+%5"$1#&@6"DW%

!

%

• \"6":#1;"%0$"++<$"%*$%+"6":#1'2%&2"'#%C1>">A%35&#%+"6":#"(%9*$%*'"%@"&4%#-0"%;"$+<+%#5"%*#5"$kDW%

!

%

• O1#'"++%C1>">A%1':$"&+"(%614"615**(%#*%+<$;1;"%&'(%$"0$*(<:"DW%

!

%

%$

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

AUTHOR

F$1##"'%@-%Y&+*'%X$"&'A%JRA%J\A%e-*'+%?*3'+510%H125%\:5**6A%e&%.$&'2"A%8661'*1+%[(1#"(%@-%\&'($&%B6<,"'$&#5A%!5I%&'(%e&<$&%B*'"##&A%!5IA%HHJ8A%&'(%R''%B$*4&3A%)*:4-%)1;"$%H125%\:5**6A%E51*Q%:*0-"(1#"(%@-%e1'(&%O"6&:*%%\:1"'#191:%$";1"3%@-%Y*'&#5&'%e*+*+A%!5I%

0$$ the origin of species !#$%&'()*$+,$-#$.(--#/-0$

Documents