00. ‘the origins of primitivism’ set (1977-1988) _ radicalarchives

8/11/2019 00. the Origins of Primitivism Set (1977-1988) _ Radicalarchives

1/3

Published September 6, 2010Anarchism , Marxism , Primitivism , Situationist , Technology ,

Theory 2 Comments

RADICAL ARCHIVESis happy to finally present our Origins of Primitivism set. It

consists of 16 documents related to the development of contemporary

primitivist thought, which were first printed in Fifth Estate between 1977 and

1988. All of these documents (listed at bottom) are available online for the first

time.

Additionally, David Watson has contributed a short introduction and reflection on

these texts for the occasion of putting them online; it is available here.

(If you are new to Radical Archives, we recommend you look at the indexof texts

posted, and the aboutstatement, which describes the sites topic interests.)

The most important of the these texts is David Watsons Against the

Megamachine(originally published in 1981), which outlines his distinct version of

primitivism. Watson renounced ideological primitivism with 1997sSwamp Fever,

Primitivism and the Ideological Vortex': Farewell to All That, two years before the

demonstrations in Seattle against the WTO. Partly because of Watsons exit from

the discourse, Zerzans version (which actually had been developed later) became

synonymous with the concept anarcho-primitivism.

Watsons essay is the only document of this set which was previously in print; it is

available as the title essay of the Autonomedia book Against the Megamachine:

Essays on Empire and Its Discontents. Prior to this, the other texts were only

accessible in specialized archival holdings.

Also of importance isConfronting the Enemy: A Response on Time, which is a

long critique of Zerzans article Beginning of Time, End of Time (which was the

first of his five origins essays). Written under Watsons pen name George

Bradford, this much-overlooked critique summarizes what are the basic objections

to Zerzans view from a sympathetic perspective: that the notion of purely

unalienated being (and along with it, the abolition of agriculture) is a misguided

and impossible approach to these issues. Paralleling many discussions within

the Western Marxist and Existentialist milieu (especially regarding Georg Lukcss

early work on reification), Watson argues that separation is something intrinsic to

human nature, and cannot be seen as outside of our own human existence. To

abolish separation is to return to the womb or ascend into heaven.

The third essay of special importance is Bob Brubakers Community, Society and

the State. Brubaker was a Fifth Estate writer who was involved in the magazines

dialogue as primitivism was developed. Brubakers work has been largely

forgotten.

The fourth essay of special importance is Fifth Estates 1977 review of Gary

Snyders The Old Ways, Six Essays. Steve Millett has identified this as the first

complete statement of a primitivist perspective to appear in Fifth Estate.

Last, a letter from Marcus Graham, who had edited the anarchist magazine MAN!

in the 1930s, shows the issues Fifth Estatewas grappling with around technology,organization, etc. had been long-standing discussions in the anarchist milieu, well

back into the classical era.

By making these documents available online, hopefully a richer understanding of

e Origins of Primitivism set (1977-1988) | radicalarchives http://radicalarchives.org/2010/09/06/primitivist-set/

3 12-Sep-14 02:52


2/3

the different strains of primitivism will result, as well as a constructive and critical

dialogue regarding this intellectual and political current. Important questions were

asked by the founders of primitivism, including: critiques of political organization,

spontaneity and resistance; the role of technology and the question of its

autonomy; and basic ontological questions about civilization, alienation and

environmental domination. With the partial exception of insurrectionism, these

questions have largely been shelved by the post-Seattle anglophone

anti-authoritarian milieu.

While Radical Archives is neither primitivist nor anti-civ, our position is that

these questions have not been answered by Murray Bookchins brand of social

ecology, John Zerzans version of primitivism, or any version of green

syndicalism.

It is partly for this reason, and partly out of interest in anarchist intellectual

history, that we are returning to the time in which these questions were being

actively grappled with in the anti-authoritarian milieu.

Radical Archiveswould like to thank Steve Millet for pointing out many of these

works in his dissertation, as well as to David Watson and Peter Werbe for their

help in identifying who wrote many of these articles. We would also like to

give special thanks to Dylan Smith for the many hours he spent transcribing all of

these works; without his labor, none of this would be possible.

We hope in the near future to make available a number of related works, including

works by primitivist John Moore, Sam Dolgoffs essay on technology, as well

as other works of Bob Brubaker.

THE ORIGINS OF PRIMITIVISM SET

Introduction to The Origins of Primitivism Set by David Watson (2010)

The First Primitivist Essay: Gary Snyder Asks: Poetry or Machines? Back to the

Stone Age (1977)

Technology & the State: An Introduction (1978)

FE Criticized and Our Response (1978)

On Having Nothing to Say (1979)

Searching for the Culprit (1979)

Against Civilization: Introduction to Russell Means (1980)

Introduction to Fifth Estate #306 (1981)

Against the Megamachine by David Watson (1981-1985/1997)

Marxism, Anarchism and the Roots of the New Totalitarianism by George

Bradford (1981)

Community, Primitive Society and the State by Bob Brubaker (1981)

Defeated Spirit?, letter from John Zerzan to Fifth Estate (1981)

Marcus Graham on Fifth Estate, Anarchism, Technology & Bookchin (1981)

More Debate on Technology: Does FE View Mean War or Big Brother?, letter

from Chris Dugan and reply from John Zerzan (1982)

Confronting the Enemy: A Response on Time by George Bradford (1983)


3 12-Sep-14 02:52


3/3

Language: John Zerzan on George Bradford on John Zerzan (1984)

Introduction to John Zerzans Agriculture essay, by E.B. Maple (1988)

One blogger likes this.

Related

David Watson:

Introduction to the

Origins of

Primitivism Set

(2010)

Top Posts at

www.radicalarchive

Introduction to 'Fifth

Estate' #306 (1981)

Trackback on September 9, 2010 at 9:04 am

Trackback on November 20, 2011 at 10:12 pm

Neues aus den Archiven der radikalen (und nicht so

radikalen) Linken Entdinglichung

Top Posts at www.radicalarchives.org radicalarchives


3 12-Sep-14 02:52

00. ‘the origins of primitivism’ set (1977-1988) _ radicalarchives

Documents