03 ecology of ecosystem services donaldsonbiodiversityadvisor.sanbi.org/wp-content/uploads/... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s Ecology of Ecosystem Services
John DonaldsonApplied Biodiversity Research, SANBI
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sECOLOGY IN CONTEXT
The concept of Ecosystem Services started as a useful metaphor to help us think about our attitude to nature
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sECOLOGY IN CONTEXT• Ecosystem Services is no longer just about
putting a value on nature
“Throw in some pollination services and I’ll take it”
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sECOLOGY IN CONTEXT
• The predominant view is of nature as a stock that provides a flow of particular services
• The assumption that we can manage and even optimize our interaction with nature to deliver services requires a profound understanding of ecological systems
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
DEFINITION
CHARACTERIZATION
VALUATION
MAPPING/ PLANNING
PAYMENTS (UNLOCKING BENEFITS)
SUSTAINABILITY E
colo
gica
l kn
owle
dge
ECOLOGY AS A BASE
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sDEFINITION
Ecosystem services are….
“the conditions and processes through which natural ecosystems, and the species that make them up, sustain and fulfillhuman life”. (Daily 1997)
..” the benefits people obtain from ecosystems”
(Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2004)
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sCHARACTERISATION
= A description of qualities or peculiarities
Supporting• Nutrient cycling• Soil formation• Primary production• ……
Provisioning• Food• Freshwater• Wood & Fiber• ……
Regulating• Climate regulation• Flood regulation• Disease regulation• ……
Cultural• Aesthetic• Spiritual• Educational• ……
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
The list of ecosystem services is long and varied, and most of them have not been characterised or quantified
= A description of qualities or peculiarities
CHARACTERISATION
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sPAYMENTS FOR E.S.An agreement between a buyer and a seller to exchange an asset or obtain a service for payment.
• What exactly is the asset?• What are the specs (how do I compare it to competitors)• Will it do what I want it to? • Will it last- does it come with a maintenance plan?
or
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sBEHIND THE SCENES
Yu-Hwa Chena, Fei-Yu Kuoa and Szu-Hua Wanga
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
ACTUAL QUESTIONS RELATING TO ACARBON SEQUESTRATION PROJECT
• Can you verify how much carbon is stored?
• Can you verify associated biodiversity benefits?
• What is the likelihood that these benefits will be maintained over time?
• Are there any impacts on the environment?
or
PAYMENTS FOR E.S.
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sBIG QUESTIONS
• What is the Link between Biological Diversity & ecosystem services
• Are there Trade-offs between ecosystem services (based on their ecology)
• Are there Critical Thresholds for delivery of ecosystem services
• Are there any unifying principles / theories
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sECOLOGY & SERVICES
Diaz et al (2006)
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sECOLOGY & SERVICES
Biodiversity (e.g. species richness)
Eco
syst
em S
ervi
ce
brittle
robust
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
From: Isbell et al. 2011.High plant diversity is needed to maintain ecosystem services. Nature, 2011
Species Diversity is Critical for Maintaining Multiple Ecosystem Services
• 17 of the largest and longest-running biodiversity experiments, combining data on 147 species
• In any one context, required a minimum of 27% of species
• In multiple contexts, 84% of species were necessary to maintain the same functions
BIODIVERITY & E.S.
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
From:Reich et al. 2012. Impacts of Biodiversity Loss Escalate Through Time as Redundancy Fades. Science 336
Diversity of Species is Key to Maintaining Ecosystem Services over Time
• every additional species in a plot contributed to a gradual increase in both soil fertility and biomass production over a 14-year period.
BIODIVERITY & E.S.
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sBIODIVERITY & E.S.
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
Cha
nge
in d
ecom
pois
ition
Cha
nge
in p
rodu
ctiv
ity
Hooper et al. 2012. A global synthesis reveals biodiversity loss as a major driver of ecosystem change. Nature, 2012
Accumulated Loss of Species Threatens Provision of Ecosystem Services
• Synthesis of 192 studies globally
• Moderate local species losses (21- 40%) reduce plant growth by up to 10 % (=climate warming and UV projections)
• Higher levels of local extinction (41 -60%) result in significant changes
BIODIVERITY & E.S.
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sTRADE-OFFSEcosystem Stocks
Carbon sequestration
Pollination services
Water provision
Flow of servicesB
EN
EFITS
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sTRADE-OFFS (pollination)
Pollination Water provision
Biodiversity
crops
gums
natural
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
Raudsepp-Hearnea et al. 2010. Ecosystem service bundles for analyzing tradeoffs in diverse landscapes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science
TRADE-OFFS
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
• Strong tradeoffs between ecosystem services, especially between provisioning services & regulating services
• Tradeoffs are not inescapable, could be managed
Raudsepp-Hearnea et al. 2010. Ecosystem service bundles for analyzing tradeoffs indiverse landscapes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science
TRADE-OFFS
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
• One of the challenges for Ecosystem Services is developing theories and frameworks that can address relationships so that it is possible to explain how a change in one variable will influence the other variables in the system.
• The multidimensional nature of ecosystem services means that any explanation of one component (ecological, economic or social) is dependent on relationships within and between other components
E.S. COMPLEXITY
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sE.S. COMPLEXITY
Strong species dependence
Functional groups/ structure
Site Level
Inputs to production PaymentsM
ulti stakeholder/C
omplex
Landowner/
simple
Social dynam
ics
Biodiversity link to Ecosystem Services
Economics
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sGENERAL
Site Level
Strong species dependence
Functional groups/ structure
Inputs to production Payments
Multi stakeholder/
Com
plexLandow
ner/ sim
ple
Social dynam
ics
Biodiversity link to Ecosystem Services
Economics
Managed bees pollination
Wild pollination
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
sCONCLUSIONS
• The development of ecosystem service applications must be supported by investment in an understanding of the ecology of the systems from which services are derived.
• Even if the complexity of ecosystems needs to be simplified to inform markets, we must not forget that we are dealing with ecological systems
• “Project-scale” ecosystem services analysis that assumes ecological and economic equilibrium will not result in the sustainable benefits we seek
• There is still considerable uncertainty regarding the characteristics and quantities of most ecosystem services, which presents a challenge for conservation planning
• Planning approaches
Eco
logy
of E
cosy
stem
Ser
vice
s
THANK YOU