046 signal traffic

Upload: khaled-abdelbaki

Post on 04-Jun-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    1/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 1 of 24

    INTRODUCTION TO TRAFFIC SIGNALS

    This Traffic Signal Design course provides an introduction to intersection control, with an emphasis

    on the use of traffic signals. Also included in this course is a discussion of MUTCD requirements

    and safety concerns relative to intersection control and traffic signal operation.

    The primary national reference document with respect to traffic signals is the Manual on Uniform

    Traffic Control Devices (commonly referred to as the "MUTCD"), which is published by the

    Federal Highway Administration. The first MUTCD was published in 1935 with updated manuals

    being produced on an intermittent basis at roughly ten year intervals. The most recent MUTCD has10"parts" (chapters) and was published in 2003.

    PART 1: GENERAL

    Part 1 of the MUTCD discusses the purpose of traffic control devices, outlines the responsibility for

    traffic control devices, and describes how the manual is updated. Definitions and standard

    abbreviations are also provided for words and phrases used in the manual.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    2/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 2 of 24

    The MUTCD states that the purpose of traffic control devices, including traffic signals, is to:

    "...promote highway safety and efficiency by providing for the orderly movement of all road users

    on streets and highways..." The key to ensuring "orderly and predictable movement" is the use of

    uniform traffic control devices, that is, standard devices that treat similar situations in the same way.

    For this reason, the use of unique or custom made devices is generally considered undesirable. It is

    important to understand that uniformity can also be lost if a standard device is used in a nonstandard

    location, such as would be the case if a traffic signal were inappropriately installed on a freeway

    mainline.

    Design, placement, operation, and maintenance of traffic control devices are the responsibilities ofthe agency having official jurisdiction over the area in question. In most cases this is the state,

    county, or city with federal agencies having little direct involvement. The major exception is on

    military bases where federal agencies do play a direct role. Responsibilities with respect to traffic

    control devices are typically spelled out in legislation and intergovernmental agreements; and it is

    common for areas of responsibility to be allocated amongst more than one agency. For example,

    state law might require that the state design and construct all traffic signals located on state

    highways with the local city or county being responsible for operation and maintenance of these

    signals. The MUTCD allows states to develop their own manual on traffic control devices.

    However, the MUTCD requires that the state manual be "in substantial conformance" to the federal

    MUTCD.

    The MUTCD makes it clear that, although the manual provides standards for the application and

    design of traffic control devices, it is not a substitute for sound engineering judgment. Qualified

    engineers are still needed to properly locate and design traffic control devices. This is especially

    true in the case of traffic signals where placement, design and timing involve relatively complex

    issues.

    The MUTCD uses the verbs "Shall", "Should", and "May" to denote the requirement for varying

    degrees of conformity with its directives. "Shall" is the most restrictive term, indicating a

    mandatory condition that must be met. Such mandatory conditions are referred to as Standards.

    An example standard is: A yellow signal indication shall be displayed following every circular

    green or green arrow signal indication. "May" is the least restrictive term, indicating a permissive

    condition that leaves the choice to the designer. Such permissive conditions are referred to as

    Options. An example option is: Pushbutton locator tones may be used with accessible pedestrian

    signals. It is left up to the discretion of the designer as to whether or not to use locator tones.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    3/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 3 of 24

    "Should" is an advisory condition which recommends that a certain action be taken, but does not

    require it. Such advisory conditions are considered Guidance. An example of such guidance is:

    Traffic control signals within 1/2 mile of one another along a major route or in a network of

    intersecting major routes should be coordinated. The indication is that this is a highly desirable

    thing to do; however, for one of many valid reasons, the designer may decide that it is best not to

    coordinate a given pair of signals.

    The MUTCD permits any person or organization to submit to the Federal Highway Administration

    (FHWA) a request for a change. This change might involve modification of an existing device, the

    use of a new device, or changes to the way in which a device is applied. Although many changes

    have been granted by the FHWA, in most past cases the requested change has been consideredunnecessary and has been rejected to preserve uniformity.

    If any agency desires to experiment with a new traffic control device, such as field deploying a new

    device for the purpose of testing it, they must file a request with the FHWA. The FHWA may or

    may not permit the requested experimentation.

    The FHWA also provides written interpretations as to the exact meaning of requirements contained

    within the MUTCD.

    PART 2: SIGNS

    Part 2 of the MUTCD discusses signing standards and is divided into ten sections:

    A. General Standards

    B. Regulatory Signs

    C. Warning Signs

    D. Guide Signs on Conventional Roads

    E. Guide Signs on Freeways and Expressways

    F. Specific Service Signs

    G. Tourist Oriented Directional Signs

    H. Recreational and Cultural Interest Area SignsI. Emergency Management Signing

    Unique colors and shapes are used to differentiate the various types of road signing. Signs (such as

    SIGNAL AHEAD or NO TURN ON RED) are often an integral part of a traffic signal

    installation and guidance is provided in this part of the MUTCD on the proper application of these

    signs.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    4/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 4 of 24

    PART 3: MARKINGS

    Part 3 of the MUTCD discusses pavement and curb marking standards. Included in this section are

    pavement marking standards for crosswalks, stop lines, and pavement arrows at signalized

    intersections. Sections are also provided that deal with the use of object markers, delineators,

    colored pavements, channelizing devices, and islands.

    PART 4: TRAFFIC SIGNALS

    Part 4 of the MUTCD discusses the operation of traffic signals and the eight traffic signal warrants

    that are used to evaluate the need for a traffic signal installation. Sections are also provided dealingwith pedestrian signals, emergence vehicle signals, signals at freeway entrance ramps, signals at

    moveable bridges, signals on one-lane roads, and lane use control signals. In addition, information

    is provided on the use of flashing beacons and in-roadway lights.

    PART 5: LOW-VOLUME ROADS

    Part 5 of the MUTCD discusses traffic control devices for Low-Volume Roads. A low volume road

    is defined as a facility lying outside of the built-up areas of cities, towns and communities and

    having a traffic volume of less than 400 vehicles per day.

    PART 6: TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL

    Part 6 of the MUTCD discusses measures for safely controlling traffic during construction,

    maintenance or utility work. Sections are included on pedestrian and worker safety, flagging, work

    zone signing, work zone barricades and pavement markings, lighting of the work zone for nighttime

    work, detours, and lane closures. A section is also provided which deals with the control of traffic

    through areas where a traffic incident (such as an accident or natural disaster) has occurred.

    PART 7: SCHOOL AREAS

    Part 7 of the MUTCD discusses traffic control measures for school zones, including special school

    zone signing and pavement marking. Sections are provided on the use of pedestrian crossing guards

    in school areas and the installation of grade-separated pedestrian crossings, such as a pedestrian

    overpass. The design and operation of traffic signals in school zones is also discussed.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    5/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 5 of 24

    PART 8: HIGHWAY-RAIL GRADE CROSSINGS

    Part 8 of the MUTCD discusses traffic control measures for highway-rail grade crossings, including

    railroad signs and markings and the operation of railroad crossing signals and gates. Requirements

    for traffic signal preemption at highway-rail grade crossings are also discussed.

    PART 9: BICYCLE FACILITIES

    Part 9 of the MUTCD discusses traffic control measures for bicycle facilities, including signs and

    pavement markings for bikes. Accommodating bicycles at signalized intersections is also

    addressed.

    PART 10: HIGHWAY-LIGHT RAIL TRANSIT GRADE CROSSINGS

    Part 10 of the MUTCD discusses traffic control measures for highway-light rail transit grade

    crossings, including signs, illumination and markings and the operation of light-rail transit grade

    crossing systems. Requirements for traffic signal preemption at highway-light rail transit grade

    crossings is also discussed.

    The FHWA also publishes the Traffic Control Devices Handbook. This handbook expands upon

    the material contained in the MUTCD and provides guidelines for implementing the standardscontained in the MUTCD. The latest edition of this handbook was published in 2001.

    In designing, installing, and operating a traffic signal control system there are four basic goals that

    we want the system to meet. We want the system to be:

    1. SAFE

    2. EFFICIENT

    3. FAIR

    4. AFFORDABLE

    Of highest priority is to make the signal system safe for all users. Potentially dangerous situations

    should be avoided to the maximum extent possible.

    To make a traffic signal system efficient we usually want to minimize the number of stops a driver

    is required to make and the delay associated with those stops. A side benefit of the implementation

    of an efficient system is low fuel consumption and reduced vehicle emissions.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    6/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 6 of 24

    For a fair system to exist, one group cannot be unduly penalized for the benefit of another. For

    example, motor vehicle travel could be enhanced by completely eliminating pedestrian crossings.

    However, this would not be fair to all users of our roadway system.

    Probably the most difficult goal is the development of a system that is affordable. Almost anything

    can be accomplished if enough money is allocated to it. The trick is to have a safe, efficient, and

    fair system that can be constructed and operated at a reasonable price. Having a transportation

    system where all major roadways are connected by full interchanges and no one is forced to stop at

    a traffic signal might be operationally desirable, but it would be extremely costly.

    Two roads can cross each other in one of three basic ways:

    One of the roads can be built over the top of the other (an overpass),

    One of the roads can be built over the top of the other with the two roads connected via a

    series of on and off ramps (an interchange), or

    The two roads can intersect at-grade (an intersection)

    If the two roadways cross each other "at-grade" (they form an intersection) then some form of

    intersection control is required so that it is clear as to which driver has the right-of-way. There are

    six basic types of intersection control:

    1. No Control

    2. Two-Way Stop Control

    3. Yield Control

    4. Multi-Way Stop Control

    5. Roundabout Operation

    6. Traffic Signal Control

    At low volume intersections with adequate sight distance it is permissible to have no formalintersection control. In this case, drivers must revert to the "rules of the road" which state that the

    first driver to reach the intersection has the right-of-way and, if the two drivers arrive at the

    intersection at about the same time, the driver on the right has the right-of-way.

    When application of the standard right-of-way rule is unduly hazardous, such as when the major

    street is busy or a sight distance restriction exists, the use of two-way stop control may be

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    7/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 7 of 24

    appropriate. STOP signs are typically installed on the minor street, which is the street having either

    the lower traffic volume or the lower speed (or both).

    Where adequate sight distance exists, intersection control using yield signs instead of stop signs

    may be appropriate. As with stop signs, yield signs are typically installed on the minor street.

    When the traffic volume on the intersecting roads is about equal, multi-way stop control or the use

    of roundabouts becomes an attractive option. With multi-way stop control all motorists entering the

    intersection must come to a complete stop before making their desired movement, doing so in a

    first-come-first-served fashion.

    Under roundabout control, a round central island is installed in the middle of the intersection and a

    circulating roadway is constructed around the island.

    All entering traffic must yield to traffic already on the circulating roadway, entering only when a

    suitable gap in the traffic stream exists. A true roundabout differs from a traffic circle or a rotary in

    that it has certain design features which enhance its operation. For example, a true roundabout

    incorporates raised triangular splitter islands where the approaching street intersects the circulatingroadway. These splitter islands encourage approaching motorists to reduce their speed and ensure

    that the path of approaching vehicles deflects to the right of the central island.

    It should be noted that there are numerical warrants contained within the MUTCD for multi-way

    stop control and these warrants should be met before multi-way stop control is installed. There are

    no such numerical warrants for roundabouts in the MUTCD.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    8/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 8 of 24

    Stop and yield signs are used when traffic volume on the minor street is relatively low. When minor

    street traffic volumes are high, then a more sophisticated form of intersection control is needed,

    such as a traffic signal. At a traffic signal, the right-of-way is assigned through a relatively complex

    series of red, yellow, and green "arrow" and "ball" indications, each with its own meaning. In

    addition to assigning the right-of-way amongst vehicular traffic, modern traffic signals also provide

    right-of-way control for pedestrians so that they may safely cross the street; and some traffic signals

    are even designed to accommodate light rail transit vehicles.

    If designed and installed properly, traffic signals have many advantages with respect to other forms

    of intersection control. Since traffic signals clearly inform each driver of the right-of-way situation,

    little driver judgment is needed. Simply put, the driver need only go when the signal is green andstop when it is red. Other forms of traffic control (stop signs and roundabouts) require the driver to

    make more complex decisions, such as gauging the availability of suitable gaps in the opposing

    traffic stream. Reducing the amount of driver judgment required is generally considered beneficial

    since the less judgment a driver is required to exercise the less chance there is that a mistake will be

    made.

    Traffic signals are capable of efficiently handling relatively high volumes of traffic, even at

    complex intersections. This is not the case with stop or yield controlled intersections where vehicle

    queues and associated vehicular delay can become excessive if traffic volumes at the unsignalized

    intersection grow large.

    The assignment of right-of-way at an intersection is more "fair" with a traffic signal than with other

    forms of intersection control. At stop signs or roundabouts, vehicles desiring to enter the main

    traffic stream must wait for a suitable gap. If under high volume conditions it takes an inordinate

    amount of time to find such a gap then the entering driver simply has to wait. However, with a

    traffic signal the driver is assured that he or she will eventually be "given their turn" to proceed thru

    the intersection. The time that the entering driver has to wait is also controllable with traffic signals

    whereas it is not with stop signs or roundabouts. One need only change the timings in the traffic

    signal controller to change the amount of time that the entering driver is required to wait. Modern

    signal controllers also allow this waiting time to vary by time-of-day and day-of-week.

    The installation of a traffic signal generally reduces the number of right-angle accidents and, if left

    turn phasing is provided, the number of left turn accidents. If the intersection is properly designed

    and pedestrian signals are provided, it is generally safer for pedestrians to cross busy streets at a

    signalized intersection than at an unsignalized one. When a non-correctable sight distance

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    9/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 9 of 24

    restriction exists, such as when a building is located too close to the corner of the intersection, a

    traffic signal may be the only safe method for assigning intersection right-of-way.

    SIGHT DISTANC E

    Although traffic signals offer many advantages, they also have certain disadvantages with respect to

    other forms of intersection control.

    The installation cost of a traffic signal is much greater than for stop sign control and, depending on

    the situation, may also be greater than the cost of installing a roundabout. A combined design,construction, and inspection cost of from $70,000 to over $200,000 is typical for modern traffic

    signal installations. This is much more expensive than a STOP sign installation, which usually costs

    less than $5000. Once a traffic signal is installed, money must also be spent to power the traffic

    signal and to maintain, repair, and periodically retime the signal. These costs, which are ongoing

    over the life of the signal installation, can amount to a substantial amount of money.

    When traffic volumes at an intersection are low the high degree of control offered by traffic signals

    results in a substantial increase in overall motorists delay in comparison to other forms of

    intersection control. Stop signs, yield signs, or roundabouts are usually better forms of intersection

    control under low volume conditions. If situated in the wrong location, new traffic signals can also

    disrupt coordinated traffic flow along an arterial. Large platoons of traffic using the arterial may be

    forced to stop at the new signal, which substantially increases system delay and frustrates drivers.

    When a traffic signal is installed, the number of rear-end accidents on the main street can be

    expected to increase. This is only logical since, with the installation of a traffic signal, main street

    traffic is now required to stop where previously it kept going. A counterbalancing factor is that

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    10/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 10 of 24

    rear-end accidents (which tend to increase with the installation of a signal) are generally not as

    severe as right-angle accidents (which tend to decrease with the installation of a signal).

    A traffic signal installation is also a rather complex apparatus and there are many things that can go

    wrong, from equipment failure to power outages. If this happens during a busy traffic period the

    negative effect on both safety and congestion can be substantial.

    Finally, although traffic signals can be designed with good aesthetics in mind, no matter how nicely

    you package them they are still rather ugly devices. Stop signs and roundabouts are considerably

    less obtrusive with respect to the surrounding visual environment.

    Contrary to what many citizens think, not every traffic problem is best corrected by installing a

    traffic signal. Sometimes geometric modifications or signing and striping changes are in order. A

    traffic signal is not a panacea for every traffic-related problem. The bottom line is that traffic

    signals should only be installed where the expected advantages outweigh the expected

    disadvantages. An engineering study is required to make the proper decision.

    In many instances, roundabouts designed with multiple circulating and entry lanes are capable of

    providing suitable traffic control at intersecting streets carrying substantial traffic volumes.

    MULTILANE ROUNDABOUT EXAMPLE

    OR

    OR

    Such multilane roundabouts represent a significantly more complex right-of-way assignment

    situation than single lane roundabouts. Vehicles in the center circulating roadway of a multilane

    roundabout are generally restricted in the movements that they can make from a given lane (i.e.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    11/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 11 of 24

    where they can exit the roundabout) whereas those in a single lane roundabout are not. The primary

    advantage of multilane roundabouts, if drivers know how to properly use them, is that they are

    capable of handling much higher volumes of traffic than single lane roundabouts. The primary

    disadvantage is that they require a high level of motorist familiarity with roundabout lane discipline;

    a level of familiarity that motorists in many other countries have mastered but that US motorists are

    still developing.

    In comparison to traffic signals, roundabouts have certain advantages and certain disadvantages.

    Advantages include:

    Lower motorist delay under moderate volume conditions No power cost and low maintenance & repair costs

    Not subject to power outages or equipment failures

    Attractive if properly landscaped

    Accidents are typically minor in nature, such as sideswipe accidents

    Disadvantages include:

    Potentially large right-of-way requirements

    Lack of driver familiarity in the US, especially with respect to multilane roundabouts

    Need for a higher level of driver judgment

    Adverse effect on signal coordination if situated within a progressed arterial

    Somewhat awkward accommodation of bicycle and pedestrian traffic

    Potentially "unfair" right-of-way assignment, especially if the approach to ones

    immediate left is a busy one.

    To avoid the extensive queuing and delay that can result from this last disadvantage, some

    roundabouts use traffic signals to assign the right-of-way at high volume entry points into the

    circulating roadway. However, such a design begins to challenge the definition of a true roundabout

    since true roundabouts do not utilize signal control.

    Traffic control at an intersection can also be accomplished through changes to the basic geometry of

    the intersection. An example of this is the installation of a raised island in the middle of the major

    street. The resulting directional median opening physically restricts left turns onto the major street

    or thru movements from one side street to the other.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    12/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 12 of 24

    Although traffic signals are most commonly used to control vehicular movements at the intersection

    of two roads, they are also used at:

    The intersection of freeway off-ramps and local streets,

    Mid-block pedestrian crossings,

    Mid-block fire stations,

    Moveable bridges,

    1-lane, 2-way work zones, and

    Freeway on-ramps (for ramp metering)

    Unless there is a good engineering reason, a traffic signal should not be installed at an intersection

    unless at least one of the 8 traffic signal "warrants" contained in Part 4 of the MUTCD is met.

    These 8 warrants are numerical and operational guidelines used to evaluate the need for a traffic

    signal. However, it should be understood that the satisfaction of a warrant is not in itself

    justification for the installation of a signal. Other measures, such as the construction of a

    roundabout or median modifications, may provide a better solution.

    Intersection controls, such as stop signs or traffic signals, should not be used for speed control.

    Placing unwarranted stop signs or traffic signals at an intersection in an attempt to reduce speeding

    breeds motorist disrespect for the entire traffic control system and tempts otherwise law-abiding

    citizens to break the law by disregarding the unwarranted device. Speed control should be obtained

    thru other acceptable measures such as traffic calming techniques (road narrowing, speed humps,

    raiser intersections, etc.) or increased speed enforcement.

    Traffic signal installations are composed of six major components:

    1. Signal supports

    2. Vehicular signal heads

    3. Pedestrian signal heads4. Pedestrian detection system

    5. Vehicle detection system

    6. The controller and cabinet

    Most traffic signals are either supported by a span wire strung between wooden, steel or concrete

    support poles, or are supported by a steel mast arm structure. Span wire installations are typically

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    13/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 13 of 24

    less expensive than mast arm installations and provide flexibility in signal head placement.

    However, traffic signal heads supported by mast arms with rigid support brackets are less

    susceptible to being turned or blown down by high winds. In most cases, mast arm installations are

    also considered more attractive than span wire installations.

    A signal head contains one or more signal faces and a signal face contains one or more signal

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    14/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 14 of 24

    indications. The MUTCD states that, except in pedestrian signals, each signal face shall have at

    least three but not more than five red, yellow or green signal indications.

    5 M A X IM U M

    3 M IN IM U M

    N U M B E R O F S IG N A L L E N S E S

    The MUTCD requires that signal indications be circular and either 8 inches or 12 inches in

    diameter. To maximize visibility, most modern traffic signal installations use 12 inch diameter

    indications.

    Signal indications consisting entirely of colored LED's (Light Emitting Diodes), instead of

    incandescent bulbs and lenses, are rapidly taking over as the preferred signal display technology.

    Although there initial cost is somewhat higher, these LED lamps have much lower power

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    15/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 15 of 24

    consumption than conventional bulbs and also have a much longer life. LED's are available in all of

    the required vehicular and pedestrian signal colors (red, yellow, green, white, and orange).

    A signal head with 4 faces is commonly referred to as a 4-way signal; a signal head with 3 faces is

    referred to as a 3-way signal, and so on.

    Many signal heads are made from aluminum, although polycarbonate signal heads ("plastic" heads)

    are also commonplace. The overall durability of aluminum heads is generally better than that of

    polycarbonate heads and aluminum heads have a lower susceptibility to deterioration caused by

    sun-induced ultraviolet (UV) radiation. However, polycarbonate heads weigh less than aluminum

    heads, are less susceptible to corrosion from ocean air (which is a problem for some seasidecommunities), and are usually less expensive than aluminum heads.

    For thru traffic, the MUTCD states that a minimum of 2 signal faces shall be provided. This

    requirement is made for obvious safety reasons since, if there were only one signal face and the red

    indication of this face burned out, approaching motorists would see no red indication at all.

    At signalized "T" intersections, the predominant turning movement on the stem of the "T" must also

    have at least 2 signal faces:

    S IG N A L F A C E S A T "T " I N T E R S E C T I O N S

    The MUTCD states that the 2 signal faces controlling a thru lane shall be horizontally separated by

    a minimum distance of 8 feet:

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    16/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 16 of 24

    H O R I Z O N T A L S E P A R A T I O N B E T W E E N H E A D S

    Providing sufficient horizontal separation reduces the chance that a large vehicle will

    simultaneously obstruct the view of both signal faces.

    For turn lanes, only 1 signal face is required by the MUTCD. Only 1 signal face is required since, if

    the red indication goes out in this face, motorists still have the adjacent thru lane signal faces to

    provide some indication as to right-of-way status. If there are dual turn lanes (either dual rights or

    dual lefts) then the MUTCD states that two signal faces should be provided.

    For maximum clarity, it is usually desirable to have a signal head aligned with the lane that it

    controls. However, this is by no means a requirement. The MUTCD also states that signal faces

    should be visible from the distance indicated in the following table:

    Note that the required minimum sight distance depends on the 85th percentile speed of the

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    17/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 17 of 24

    approaching traffic with higher speed traffic requiring more visibility distance. The minimum

    visibility table uses the 85th percentile speed, not the average speed or even the posted speed. The

    85th percentile speed, which is the speed exceeded by only 15% of the drivers, is typically

    determined through a traffic engineering speed study. In practice, engineers frequently use the

    posted speed as an approximation for the 85th percentile speed (since speed limits are typically set

    using the 85th percentile speed). However, there is no guarantee that the posted speed and the 85th

    percentile speed are the same. For this reason, a traffic engineering speed study is the most prudent

    method for determining the 85th percentile speed.

    When the minimum sight distance cannot be met on an intersection approach, then an advanced

    warning sign (such as the symbolic SIGNAL AHEAD sign) is required by the MUTCD.

    If so desired, this sign may be supplemented by a circular yellow Hazard Identification Beacon.

    When intersections are very closely spaced or when roads intersect at an angle, driver confusion can

    result if the signal faces for one approach are not shielded from the view of motorists on other

    approaches:

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    18/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 18 of 24

    U N S H I E L D E D S I G N A L F A C E S

    This shielding can be accomplished thru the use of long tunnel visors, louvers, or optically

    programmed signal heads. Optically programmed signal heads are special heads which are

    designed to present a narrow field of view to the motorist so that no ambiguity occurs as to which

    movement the head controls.

    A backplate is a thin strip of material (usually aluminum or plastic) that extends outward frombehind the signal face on all sides of the signal housing.

    Unlike those shown here, the MUTCD requires that the front surface of backplates have a dull black

    finish to minimize light reflection. Some agencies use backplates to enhance the target value of the

    signal face when viewed against a bright sky, or when viewed against potentially confusing

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    19/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 19 of 24

    background lighting. The primary disadvantage of backplates is that they have a high wind loading

    which may require the use of larger signal support poles.

    The MUTCD requires pedestrian signal heads to be rectangular in shape and consist of two

    indications:

    a white walking person , and

    an orange upraised hand

    As with signal heads, LED indications are quickly taking over as the preferred means of

    illumination for pedestrian indications.

    The MUTCD states that pedestrian signal heads shall be mounted at least 7 feet, but no more than

    10 feet, above the sidewalk. Pedestrian signal heads shall be positioned for maximum visibility at

    the beginning of the controlled crossing and the pedestrian indications should be visible from the

    beginning of the crossing to a point 10 feet or less from the end of the crossing.

    RECOMMENDED PEDESTRIAN VISIBILITY AREA

    The MUTCD requires pedestrian signal indications when one or more of the following conditions

    exist:

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    20/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 20 of 24

    A signal is installed under Warrant #4 (the Pedestrian Volume warrant) or Warrant #5 (the

    School Crossing warrant).

    An exclusive pedestrian phase is provided. (With an exclusive pedestrian phase, all vehicle

    movements are stopped to allow pedestrians to cross.)

    At established school crossings.

    The vehicular signal indications would tend to confuse pedestrians.

    The MUTCD states that pedestrian signal indications may be pertinent when one or more of the

    following conditions exist:

    Help is needed for pedestrians to safely cross the street. Pedestrians are required to cross a street in two movements, taking refuge on an intermediate

    island.

    The vehicular signal indications are not visible to pedestrians, such as on one-way streets or

    at "T" intersections.

    The most common type of pedestrian detector is a simple push button; which works much like an

    elevator button. When a pedestrian button is pushed a call for the pedestrian phase is "locked" into

    the traffic signal controller. Then, at the appropriate time, the WALKING PERSON (symbolic

    WALK) indication, followed by the flashing UPRAISED HAND (symbolic DON'T WALK)

    indication, are displayed.

    The WALK indication means that the pedestrian may enter the crosswalk in the direction of theindication. The flashing DONT WALK indication (which represents the pedestrian clearanceinterval) means that the pedestrian shall not begin crossing the roadway but, if he or she has alreadyentered the crosswalk, the crossing may be completed. The steady DONT WALK indicationmeans that the pedestrian crossing interval has ended and the green indication is about to be given toconflicting traffic. The length of the pedestrian clearance interval in seconds is based on a walkingspeed of 3.5 feet per second and is typically obtained by dividing the crossing distance in feet bythis speed.

    An extremely popular extension of the typical pedestrian head is the use of countdown pedestrian

    signals. Countdown pedestrian signals include orange numbers next to the upraised orange hand

    that indicate the amount of time left in the pedestrian clearance interval.

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    21/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 21 of 24

    Although it is considered good engineering practice, the MUTCD does not require the use of

    marked crosswalks when pedestrian signals are used.

    Although signals may be placed in flashing operation when not needed, the MUTCD does not

    permit signals to be turned-off. When a traffic signal is placed into flashing operation, the MUTCD

    requires that the pedestrian heads be "dark"(that is, have no indication).

    If there are no pedestrian heads at a signalized intersection then pedestrians are required to cross

    with the appropriate green vehicular signal indication.

    The MUTCD states that a permanent sign explaining their purpose and use shall be installed near

    pedestrian buttons:

    When two crosswalks oriented in different directions end at or near the same location, the

    positioningof the pedestrian buttons and the associated signing should clearly indicate the button

    that pertains to each crossing. The MUTCD recommends a pedestrian button mounting height of

    approximately 3.5 feet from the sidewalk. This height is convenient for all users, including children

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    22/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 22 of 24

    and those in wheelchairs. In addition, the pedestrian button should be conveniently located near the

    end of the pedestrian crosswalk. Sidewalk access to the pedestrian button is highly desirable so that

    individuals in wheelchairs can reach it.

    A relatively new pedestrian feature that is finding increased use is a pilot light on pedestrian buttons.

    This light is activated when the button is pushed by a pedestrian and is extinguished when the

    pedestrian receives the WALK indication. The light gives pedestrians the assurance that their

    request for the WALK indication has been recognized by the traffic signal.

    The MUTCD permits the installation of mid-block school crossing signals where conditions warrant

    their use. Mid-block school crossings are free from the hazards of turning vehicles, and may offeradded convenience to students. However, they can surprise drivers who do not expect pedestrian

    crossings or signal control between intersections.

    Vehicular and pedestrian signal heads operate on 120 VAC current, the same type of current that is

    used for standard electrical outlets in a residential home. As with a home, this power is supplied to

    the intersection by the local electric company. The 120 VAC current passes through the traffic

    signal controller cabinet on its way to the vehicular and pedestrian signal heads.

    If, due to severe weather or some other unusual circumstance, a power outage occurs at a traffic

    signal, the traffic signal indications will go dark. Not having any indications at a traffic signal canbe very dangerous, especially at major intersections during periods of high traffic volume. To

    prevent this from happening, many jurisdictions are adding battery-powered uninterruptable power

    supply units to their traffic signal cabinets:

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    23/24

    Introduction to Traffic Signals by Jeffrey W. Buckholz, PhD, PE, PTOE

    A SunCam online continuing education course

    www.SunCam.com Copyright2010 Jeffrey W. Buckholz Page 23 of 24

    These units provide supplemental power to the traffic signal when power from the local electric

    company is absent.

    If the power outage is for an extended period of time, as might be the case after a hurricane or other

    severe storm has toppled electric lines, the battery reserve may eventually run dry. In these cases

    additional supplemental power can be provide by an external generator. Many jurisdictions have

    pre-installed the required electrical connections at the control cabinet in order to allow such

    generators to be quickly attached to the traffic signal installation.

    External sensors located either overhead or in the pavement are used to detect the presence of

    vehicles on the various approaches to a signalized intersection.

    This information is then communicated to the controller via 24 volt DC logic circuits. Pedestrian

    detection provided by pedestrian push buttons is also communicated to the controller via 24 volt DC

    logic circuits.

    The "brain" of the traffic signal is the traffic signal controller, which is housed inside a water-tight

  • 8/13/2019 046 Signal Traffic

    24/24