08: surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - john hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%a.j.%hart|%5%...

37
©2010 | A.J. Hart | 1 Nanomanufacturing University of Michigan ME599002 | Winter 2010 08: Surface energy, mel8ng, and we;ng February 8, 2010 John Hart [email protected] hEp://www.umich.edu/~ajohnh

Upload: others

Post on 25-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  1  

Nanomanufacturing  University  of  Michigan  ME599-­‐002  |  Winter  2010                                        

   

08:  Surface  energy,  mel8ng,    and  we;ng  

 February  8,  2010  

     

                       John  Hart  [email protected]  hEp://www.umich.edu/~ajohnh  

Page 2: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  2  

Announcements  § HW2  posted,  due  M  Feb/22  

Page 3: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  3  

Recap:  intermolecular  and  surface  forces  § ElectrostaMc/polarizaMon  interacMons  cause  intermolecular  forces,  at  length  scales  of  1-­‐100  nm  (short-­‐long  range)  

§ We  can  calculate  forces  between  solid  bodies  by  summing  pairwise  interacMon  potenMals,  e.g.,  for  van  der  Waals  forces  using  the  Lennard-­‐Jones  potenMal  

§ These  forces  pracMcally  govern  adhesion,  local  deformaMon,  and  assembly  of  nanostructures  

Hertel  et  al.,  Physical  Review  B  58(20):13870,  1998.  

Page 4: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  4  Israelachvili.  

VDW  energies  for  regular  geometries  

Page 5: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  5  

Adhesion  scaling  in  nature  

Artl  et  al.,  PNAS  100(19):10603-­‐10606,  2003.  

Page 6: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  6  

Synthe8c  gecko  adhesives  

Ge  et  al.,  PNAS  104(26):10792-­‐10795,  2007.  Zeng  et  al.,  Langmuir  25(13):7486–7495,  2009.  

Gecko  

CNTs  

Page 7: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  7  

Today’s  agenda  § DefiniMon  of  surface  energy  and  work  of  adhesion  § Thermodynamic  model  of  melMng  point  decrease  (suppression)  of  nanoparMcles  

§ GeneralizaMon  to  different  geometries  § Design  of  non-­‐wegng  surfaces  

Page 8: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  8  

Today’s  readings  Nominal:  (on  ctools)  § Couchman  and  Jesser,  “Thermodynamic  theory  of  size  dependence  of  melMng  temperature  in  metals”  

§ Goldstein  et  al.,  “MelMng  in  semiconductor  nanocrystals”  § Tuteja  et  al.,  “Design  parameters  for  superhydrophobicity  and  superoleophobicity”  

Page 9: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  9  Israelachvili.  

Surface  energy  (γ)  

Page 10: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  10  

Page 11: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  11  

Page 12: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  12  Nanda  et  al.,  Phys.  Rev.  B  66:013208,  2002.  

Surface  energy  across  the  periodic  table  

Page 13: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  13  

Model  of  nanopar8cle  mel8ng  

Assump8ons:    §   Spherical  parMcle  §   MelMng  begins  at  parMcle  surface,  with  uniform  liquid  layer  §   No  volume  or  density  changes  §   FloaMng  (no  surrounding/substrate  effects)  

Page 14: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  14  

Page 15: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  15  

Page 16: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  16  

Page 17: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  17  

Page 18: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  18  

Page 19: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  19  

Page 20: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  20  

Page 21: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  21  

Page 22: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  22  

Page 23: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  23  

Fit  of  thermodynamic  theory  to  data    (Indium)  

Couchman  et  al.,  Nature  269:481,  1977.  

Page 24: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  24  

Is  the  catalyst  solid  or  liquid?  

Moisala  et  al.,  J.  Phys.  Cond.  Ma..  15:S3011,  2003.  

Catalyst  (Ni) CNT

Page 25: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  25  

Watching  quantum  dots  melt  

Goldstein  et  al.,  Science  256:1425,  1992.  

Page 26: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  26  Goldstein  et  al.,  Science  256:1425,  1992.  

Page 27: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  27  

Magic  numbers  are  more  stable  (Na)  

Schmidt  et  al.,  Nature  393:238,  1998.  

Page 28: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  28  

Page 29: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  29  

Page 30: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  30  

Dimensionality  effect:  wires  vs.  spheres  

Gulseren  et  al.,  Phys.  Rev.  B.  51(11):7337,  1995.  

Page 31: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  31  

Hydrophilic  or  hydrophobic?  (see  videos)  

Courtesy  of  Hyungwoo  Lee,  MIT  

Page 32: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  32  

We;ng  § Wegng  is  the  ability  of  a  liquid  to  maintain  contact  with  a  solid  surface,  resulMng  from  intermolecular  interacMons  when  the  liquid  and  solid  are  brought  together  

§ Thus,  the  degree  of  wegng  is  determined  by  a  force  balance  between  adhesive  and  cohesive  forces  

 §  Liquids  more  frequently  wet  solids  having  high  surface  energy  (i.e.,  strongly  bonded  solids)  than  solids  with  low  surface  energy  (i.e.,  VDW  solids).    It’s  pracMcally  difficult  to  prevent  low  surface  energy  liquids  from  wegng  solids.  

Page 33: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  33  

Textured  surfaces:  Cassie  and  Wenzel  states  

   Droplet  condensa8on  and  growth  in  ESEM  

Advancing  and  receding  contact  angles  –mul8ple  stable  contact  angles  

Nosonovsky  and  Bhusan,  Nano  LeEers    7(9):2633-­‐2637,  2007.  

Page 34: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  34  

Superhydrophobicity:  petal  and  lotus  effects  § Rose  petals  and  lotus  leaves  are  both  superhydrophobic;  however,  droplets  roll  off  lotus  leaves  but  do  not  roll  off  rose  petals  

Feng  et  al.,  Langmuir  24(8):4114-­‐4119,  2008.  

Page 35: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  35  Feng  et  al.,  Langmuir  24(8):4114-­‐4119,  2008.  

Page 36: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  36  Lau  et  al.,  Nano  LeEers    3(12):1701-­‐1705,  2003.  

Texture  +  chemistry:  PTFE-­‐coated  CNT  forest  

Page 37: 08: Surfaceenergy,melng, andweng - John Hart · 2017. 7. 11. · ©2010%|%A.J.%Hart|%5% Adhesion-scaling-in-nature-Artl%etal.,%PNAS%100(19):10603210606,%2003.%

©2010  |  A.J.  Hart  |  37  

Apparent  contact  angle  of  microstructures  

Tuteja  et  al.,  MRS  BulleMn  33:752-­‐758,  2008.  Tuteja  et  al.,  PNAS  105(47):18200-­‐18205,  2008.