1. 2 yukon freshwater fisheries presentation to yfwmb april 2014 nathan millar senior fisheries...
TRANSCRIPT
1
2
3
Yukon Freshwater Fisheries
Presentation to YFWMB
April 2014Nathan Millar
Senior Fisheries Biologist
4
You asked
• 5.2 The Board further recommends the Department of Environment… determine what can be done to enhance populations over the long term;
• The Board has also requested a scientific presentation from the Department pertaining to the effects of harvesting fish species such as whitefish and burbot on the survival rates of young lake trout and lake trout eggs.
5
Today
• Impact of fishing: trends• Status of populations• What do anglers want?• Options
6
Impact of fishing
• We encourage angling & stewardship ( )• Number of anglers is steady ( )• Amount of fishing is steady ( )• Fewer fish are harvested ( )• Technology has changed – boats, gear ( )
7
Status of populationsHow many?• 45,000 lakes >1 ha. (9,000 km2)• 8,000 lakes >10 ha.• 850 lakes > 100 ha. (e.g., Coal, Lacelle)• 75 lakes > 100 ha. (e.g., Squanga)• 10 lakes > 1000 ha. (e.g, Frances)
We have surveyed 115. We focus on the ones that get heavily fished and visit them repeatedly.
Distribution of Angling Effort in Yukon
Hours
Hours / ha
Fishing effort / impact is not distributed equally across Yukon•Centred in Southern Lakes•Effort determined by access
9
Lake/FisheryLake Size
(ha) YearEstimated
Hours Hours/ha. Lake/FisheryLake Size
(ha) YearEstimated
Hours Hours/ha.Jackson 65 2011 757 11.65 Kusawa Lake 14200 2006 4325 0.30Twin (West) Lake 160 2013 1543 9.64 Simpson Lake 2030 2002 608 0.30Tarfu Lake 405 2010 3141 7.76 Dezadeash Lake 8250 2013 2429 0.29Snafu Lake 651 2010 3783 5.81 Quiet Lake 5441 2011 1204 0.22Caribou Lake 32 1996 115 3.61 Tagish Lake 35460 2003 6888 0.19Frenchman Lake 1441 2012 4564 3.17 Teslin Lake 35400 2008 6812 0.19Fox Lake 1660 2013 5009 3.02 Aishihik Lake 14500 2006 2456 0.17Pine Lake 548 2009 1185 2.16 Frances Lake 9941 2009 1592 0.16Watson Lake 1320 2002 2543 1.93 Bennett Lake 9680 2009 1020 0.11Fish Lake 1320 2010 2376 1.80 Kluane Lake 39275 2004 2024 0.05Tatchun Lake 654 2005 750 1.15 Tagish Bridge 2007 2420Little Atlin Lake 4033 2008 4175 1.04 Johnson's Crossing - Spring 2001 322Kathleen Lake 3376 2004 2265 0.67 Kathleen River 2004 3757Braeburn Lake 558 2001 299 0.54 Lubbock River - Spring 2010 454Ethel Lake 4610 2012 2271 0.49 McIntyre Creek 2004 3190Laberge Lake 20100 2007 6706 0.33 Nares River 2009 2041Marsh Lake 9630 2007 3174 0.33
33 fisheries where we have monitored harvest
Harvest is sustainable
Harvest is increasingly unsustainable? ? ?
Status of lake trout500 – 1000 lakes that contain lake troutPopulation assessments done on 115Angler harvest surveys on 35 Most heavily fished populations
11
Summary: status of populations• > 1,000 lakes with fishable populations• 115 have been surveyed• Most activity takes place on 30 – 60 (?) waters• We know the harvest at 33• In most cases: the harvest is sustainable• Where harvest is unsustainable: we work with
RRCs, you, and anglers to develop and implement solutions
12
What do anglers want?
When you go angling, what is important to you?
What do you think are the most important things to Yukoner anglers, as a whole?
13
Beauty of surroundings
Quality of water
Escape routine
Access to wilderness
Privacy (from other anglers)
Weather conditions
Angling for wild fish
Number of fish caught
Catch desired species
Size of fish caught
Catch as a source of food
0 5 10 15
Ranking of Responses1 Environment beauty, water quality, wilderness2 Fish related size, number, etc.)3 Fishing environment not crowded4 Getting there cost, ease of access5 Socio-cultural enjoyment, family, relax6 sport challenge, excitement
Rec. Fish Survey1985
What most contributes to your enjoyment of sport fishing in Yukon?
14
Lack of Pollutants in Fish
Lack of Angler Crowding
Absence of Other Recreationists
Presence of Wildlife
Size of Fish
Variety of Species Available
Cost
Catch Rate of Fish You Can Keep
Chance to Catch a Trophy Fish
Tourist Facility Quality
Access to Other Recreational Facilities
Availability of Handicapped Facilities
0 1 2 3 4 5Ranking of Responses
Rec. Fish Survey1990 and 1995
Factors that play a role in determining where to fish
15
To Enjoy Nature
To Get Away
Family Togetherness
For Companionship
For A Sense of Achievement
0 1 2 3 4 5
Ranking of Responses
Rec. Fish Survey1990 and 1995
Why anglers fish
16
Uncrowded sites
Lots of fish
Ease of access
Remoteness
Large fish
0 10 20 30 40
Ranking of ResponsesRec. Fish Survey2010
What is most important to your angling experience
17
Summary: what anglers want• The natural environment, the fishing environment, socio-cultural
aspects are the most important• Fish-related characteristics, logistics, and sport are less important to
most anglers• When it does comes to the fish:
– Wild fish (1)– Number of fish caught (2, 1)– The ‘right’ species (3, 1)– Size of fish / large / trophy (4, 2, 2, 2)– Catch a fish to eat (5, 1)– Variety (3)– Catch rate (4)
• The “Average” Angler doesn’t exist
18
The Nature Seeker-wants to get outside-some are good anglers, some aren’t-seeks appropriate setting
The Dinner Seeker-wants to catch a fish to eat-doesn’t practice live release unless required-high frequency-fish close to home where possible
The Experience/Sport Seeker-wants to catch a lot of fish-practices live release-typically an experienced angler
The Trophy Seeker-wants to catch large fish-typically an experienced angler-possible gear intensive
The Holiday Seeker-fishes as part of an outing or other activity-some are campground users
The Family Experience Seeker-fishes as part of an outing or activity to get the family together-practices live release and keeps some fish-amenities often important-some are campground users
Yukon Angler Psychographics
19
Questions
Given that anglers want different experiences when fishing, what kind of a fishery (or fisheries) best meets these interests?
Are some of these interests conflicting?
What makes fishing in Yukon different from fishing elsewhere?
20
What can we do?Wild Populations Enhanced Populations
Proactive regulations Yes Yes
Responsive Regulations Yes Yes
Stock Restoration Yes
Stock Enhancement Yes
Physical Habitat Restoration / Enhancement
Yes Yes
Chemical Habitat Restoration / Enhancement
? Yes
Manipulation of Other Species
? Yes
21
Question
Do you place a different value on a fish caught in a stocked lake and a wild caught fish?
22
Definitions
RestorationReturning a population (or habitat) to a natural level
EnhancementMoving a population (or habitat) beyond a natural level
23
Lake productivity
• Primary productivity – Production of organic matter – Primary – at the base
• All about energy flows• Root of all productivity: sun
– Photosynthesis
What are some of the environmental constraints to fish production that exist here?
24http://www.sage.wisc.edu/atlas/maps/npp/atl_npp.jpg
25
Productivity in lakes
• Temperature• Sunlight
– Effect of ice• Nutrients – phosphorus
and nitrogen• Geology
26
Experimental Lakes AreaLake 226
Phosphorus
Eutrophication
http://www.experimentallakesarea.ca/images/Eutrophication.pdf
27
Productivity across the landscape
Productivity is lowLimited by phosphorus and nitrogenOligotrophic and mesotrophic
28
Fish Habitat
Fish Passage & habitat fragmentation:culverts
Installed correctly
Flood scourspool
Repeated floods= barrier
Very expensiveto fix
Mike Sullivan
òÑ òÑ
Fragmentation
Athabasca River, near Hinton Craig Johnson (ACA)
95% of watershedlost
2 species above8 species below
Baseline Creek watershed
Mike Sullivan
32
Question
If you harvest a species it will help (or hinder) another species?
33
Fish Ecology
• Competition• Predation
Question:What do lake trout eat?
34
What lake trout eat in Yukon
Unidentified Fish Non-Biting Midges CaddisfliesScuds, Sideswimmers Unidentified Inver-
tebratesLeast Cisco
Pond Snails Unknown Orb SnailsBeetles Unidentified Vegetation Clams, MusselsWater Mites Slimy Sculpin AntsRound Whitefish Water Fleas
1000 stomachs
35
round whitefishlake chub
burbot
lake trout
lake whitefish
sculpinGammarus (Amphipods / sideswimmer)
35
Snails (gastropod)
Copepod(planktonic)
Clams
Midges(Chironomids)
Water mites
Caddisfly(Tricopteran)
Dragonfly(Odonata)
Juvenilelake trout
Daphnia
36
What lake whitefish eat in YukonOrb SnailsCopepodsClams, MusselsNon-Biting MidgesSnailsScuds, SideswimmersUnknownPond SnailsUnidentified InvertebratesCaddisfliesLeechesWater MitesDragonflies, DamselfliesUnidentified Vegetation
400 stomachs
37
round whitefishlake chub
burbot
lake trout
lake whitefish
sculpinGammarus (Amphipods / sideswimmer)
37
Snails (gastropod)
Copepod(planktonic)
Clams
Midges(Chironomids)
Water mites
Caddisfly(Tricopteran)
Dragonfly(Odonata)
Juvenilelake trout
Daphnia
38
Fish eat different things are different times of their lives: ontogenetic shift
• Juvenile Lake Trout– Eat benthos– Suboptimal habitats
• Adult Lake Trout– Eat fish
39
1. Egg Predation
Eggs that don’t descendhave low survival anyway
No literature confirmation
1. Juvenile Predation
The frying pan or the fire
41
lake trout
lake whitefish
sculpinGammarus (Amphipods / sideswimmer)
41
Snails (gastropod)
Copepod(planktonic)
Clams
Midges(Chironomids)
Caddisfly(Tricopteran)
Dragonfly(Odonata)
Daphnia
3. Competition
N = 777
Small bodiedEat invertebratesNever get very bigTend to be in smaller lakesLakes don’t have lake whitefish
Large bodiedEat fishKeep growingTend to be in larger lakesLakes have lake whitefish
43
Others
• Burbot – predatory and opportunistic– Also a sport fish
• Round whitefish – opportunistic egg predators
Summary
Many northern fish are generalist feeders
CaveatsLimitations on diet analysis – ‘point in time’, variation between fish, some items more digestible.Other techniques – stable isotopes of carbon and nitrogen provide time averaged
45
Can you fish down predators and competitors
• Species interact but not in simple ways– Dietary overlaps (competition)– Predation– Interactions can be positive for juveniles and
negative for adults (for example)• There may be tradeoffs between
– Species– Size v. number
46
References• Lasenby, T.A., S.J. Kerr, and G.W. Hooper. 2001. Lake whitefish culture and stocking: an
annotated bibliography and literature review. Fish and Wildlife Branch, Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources. Peterborough, ON.
• Tolonen, A., J. Kjellman and J. Lappalainen. 1999. Diet overlap between burbot and whitefish in a subarctic lake. Ann. Zool. Fennici 36: 205-214.
• Beauchamp, D.A., M.W. Kershner, N.C. Overnman, J. Rhydderch, J. Lin, and L. Hauser. 2006. Trophic interactions of nonnative lake trout and lake whitefish in the flathead lake food web. Reportted to the Confederated Salish-Kootenai Tribes.
• Carl, L.M. 2008. Lake trout demographics in relation to burbot and coregonine populations in Algonquin Highlands, Ontario. Envrionmental Biology of Fish 83: 127-138.
• Fitzimons, J.D. 1996. The significant of man-made structures for lake trout spawning in the Great Lakes: are they a viable alternative to natural reefs?. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 53: 142-151 (Suppl).
• Hulsman, M.F. 2012. Influence of fish competitors on lake trout trophic ecology in sub-arctic lakes. M.Sc. Thesis. University of Alberta.
• Kerr, S.J. and T.A. Lasenby. 2001. Lake trout stocking in inland lakes: and annotated bibliography and literature review. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources.
47
Stocking
• Restoration / Enhancement• Divert Pressure• Yukon
– Pothole lakes – no outflow– No stocking of open systems– Limited supply of pothole lakes– Previously fishless lakes
Have you noticed differences in fishing in a lake that was stocked for the first time and that same lake a decade later?
48
20 Stocked Lakes8% of all fishing
49
Some issues with stocking open systems
• Genetics – do you stock the same species?• Competition • Disease • Cost – initial, ongoing, monitoring• Unintended consequences
50
A lake trout (mis)introduction
• Yellowstone Lake• 1994 – Lake trout were
first found– “bucket biology”
Native Cutthroat Trout
Netting out the lake trout
First 15 Years: 500,000 lake trout caught and eliminated 2011 and 2012: 525,000 lake trout caught and eliminated 2013: 172,000 in the first six weeks of the season
Solution – Lake trout suppressionActive netting