1 6 - 2 0 ord 0 1...2016/10/25 · case 1:16-cr-20801-jal document 23 entered on flsd docket...
TRANSCRIPT
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
1 6 - 2 0 orD 0 1CASE NO.
18 U.S.C. j 371
18 U.S.C. j 659
18 U.S.C. j 981(a)(1)(C)
UNITED STATES OF AM ERICA
Vs.
YOAN PEREZ, K
LEONEL PADRON BELLO,
EMILIO HERREIWRICARDO GONZALEZ,
RASIEL PEREZ 'Z
ELOY GARCIA, l z
M ISAEL CABRERA RUIZ, and
RODOLFO URIW
Defendants.
/
F r 1 = 7)k ' qo : ' rh C.) 'ik - u'. v ts-zc . .
1.
22T 2 1 2216
STC-.k'EN :1 ;. LAR 4 h?k IOR ECtr R 'J b -S , '.I l r3 )- fr f-
.-S t.' ') o'f '.7 t-z-s u.r tbq 1 (% ..t1 1
INDICTM ENT
The Grand Jury charges that:
COUNT I
From on or about September 24, 2015, through on or about April 4, 2016, in M iami-Dade
County, in the Southern District of Flodda, and elsewhere, the defendants,
YOAN PEREZ and
LEONEL PADRON BELLO ,
did knowingly and willfully combine, conspire, confederate and agree with each other and with
others known and unknown to the Grand Jury to com mit any offense against the United States,
that is, to knowingly steal, unlawfully take, and carry away goods valued at $ 1,000 or more,
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 1 of 19
nam ely, Apple iphones, from an air cargo container, air terminal facility, and aip ort, with intent
to convert the goods to their own use, whieh goods were m oving as, and whieh were pm of, and
which constituted an interstate and foreign shipm ent of freight and property, in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 659.
PIJRPOSE OF THE CONSPIM CY
lt was the pupose of the conspiracy for the defendants and their co-conspirators to unjustly
emich them selves by stealing and taking possession of m erchandise, which constituted a foreign
shipm ent of freight and property, for resale and protit.
OVERT ACTS
ln furtherance of the conspiracy and to accomplish the object and purpose thereof, at least
one of the co-conspirators comm itted and caused to be comm itted, in the Southern District of
Florida, at least one of the following overt acts, am ong others:
On or about September 24, 2015, Joaquin Rivas, a/k/a 6fchino,'' m et with a
pup orted accomplice with the pup ose to obtain a tk titious Florida Driver's License in the nam e
of Raul Lagos.
On or about October 28, 2015, YOAN PEREZ, Joaquin Rivas, a/k/a Etchino,'' and
others, m et with the purported accom plice and discussed the use of fictitious identification
documents and shipping docum ents to steal a load of cargo from the M iam i International Airport.
On or about April 2, 2016, YOAN PEREZ, LEONEL PADRON BELLO,
Joaquin Rivas, a/k/a ûf hino,'' and others, outfitted a tractor and trailer outside of E.J. Trade &
Logistics, LLC, and m ade the tractor and trailer appear as if it were operated by Florida
lnternational Enterpdses, lnc., d/b/a Florida lnternational Cargo.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 2 of 19
4. On or about April 2, 2016, a co-conspirator drove the outfitted tractor and trailer to
LAN cargo, 6500 Nw 22nd street, M iam i, Florida, in the M iami International Airport, purported
to be a driver from Florida International Cargo nam ed Raul Lagos, and left the M iami lntem ational
Airport with approximately $6,791,636.81 of stolen goods, that is, approximately twenty-three
thousand (23,000) Apple iphones.
All in violation of Title l 8, United States Code, Section 371.
COUNT Z
On or about April 2, 201 6, in M iam i-Dade County, in the Southern District of Florida, and
elsewhere, the defendants,
YOAN PEREZ and
LEONEL PADRON BELLO,
did unlawfully, willfully and knowingly steal, unlawfully take, and carry away goods valued at
$1,000 or more, namely, Apple iphones, from an air cargo container, air terminal facility, and
airport, with intent to convert the goods to their own use, which goods were moving as, and which
were part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipm ent of freight and property, in
violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2.
COUNT 3
From on or about April 2, 2016, through on or about Septem ber 30, 2016, in M iami-Dade
County, in the Southern District of Florida, the defendants,
YOAN PEREZ,
LEONEL PADRO N BELLO,
EM ILIO HERREIWRICARDO GONZALEZ,
RASIEL PEREZ,
ELOY GARCIA,
M ISAEL CABREM RUIZ, and
RODOLFO URM ,
3
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 3 of 19
did knowingly and willfully combine, conspire, confederate, and agree with other persons known
and unknown to the Grand Jury to comm it an offense against the United States, that is, to
knowingly receive and have in their possession goods, valued at more than $1,000, that is, Apple
iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and canied away from an air cargo container,
air terminal facility, and airport, which goods were moving as, and were a part of, and which
constituted an interstate and foreign shipment of freight and other property, knowing the same to
have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 659.
PURPOSE OF TH E CONSPIM CY
It was the purpose of the conspiracy for the defendants and their co-conspirators to unjustly
enrich them selves by receiving and taking possession of stolen m erchandise, which constituted a
foreign shipment of freight and property, for resale and profit.
OVERT ACTS
In furtherance of the conspiracy and to accomplish the object and pupose thereof, at least
one of the co-conspirators committed and caused to be com mitted, in the Southern District of
Florida, at least one of the following overt acts, am ong others:
On or about April 4, 2016, RODOLFO URIG assisted in the rental of a storage
unit for the purpose of storing and concealing stolen Apple iphones.
On or about April 4, 2016, RICARDO G ONZALEZ assisted in the rental of an
additional storage unit for the pup ose of storing and concealing stolen Apple iphones.
On or about M ay 25, 2016, R ASIEL PEREZ, M ISAEL CABRERA RUIZ, and
RODOLFO URR A, anunged for the transfer and sale of l00 Apple iphone 5S cellular telephones
to a purported buyer for $12,500, and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
4
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 4 of 19
On or about July 26, 2016, RASIEL PEREZ and ELOY GARCIA arranged for
the transfer and sale of 80 Apple iphone 5S cellular telephones to a purported buyer for $9,800,
and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
On or about August 4, 2016, M SIEL PEREZ and ELO Y GARCIA anunged for
the transfer and sale of 90 Apple iphone 5S cellular telephones to a purported buyer for $12,600,
and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
On or about August 9, 2016, M SIEL PEREZ and ELOY GARCIA arranged for
the transfer and sale of 50 Apple iphone 5S cellular telephones to a purported buyer for $7,000,
and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
On or about Septem ber 1, 2016, EM ILIO HERRER A and RICARDO
GONZALEZ arranged for the transfer and sale of 100 Apple iphone 5S cellular telephones to a
purported buyer for $9,500, and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
8. On or about September 9, 2016, EM ILIO HERREI'A LEONEL PADRON
BELLO , and YOAN PEREZ, arranged for the transfer and sale of 40 Apple iphone 6S cellular
telephones to a pup orted buyer for $ 10,000, and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
9. On or about September 23, 2016, EM ILIO HERRERA and LEO NEL PADRO N
BELLO arranged for the transfer and sale of 40 Apple iphone 6S cellular telephones to a purported
buyer for $10,000, and did sell the Apple iphones to the buyer.
On or about Septem ber 30, 2016, EM ILIO H ERRERA, RICARDO
GO NZALEZ, and LEONEL PADRON BELLO attempted to arrange for the transfer and sale
of 100 Apple iphone 6S cellular telephones to a purported buyer.
Al1 in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 5 of 19
CO UNT 4
On or about M ay 25, 2016, in M iami-Dade County, in the Southern District of Florida, and
elsewhere, the defendants,
RASIEL PEREZ,M ISAEL CABRERA RUIZ, and
RODOLFO URM ,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $ 1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and canied away from any air cargo
container, aircraft terminal facility, and airport, which goods were m oving as, and which were a
part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipm ent of freight and other property,
knowing the sam e to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
CO UNT S
On or about July 26, 2016, in M iami-Dade County, in the Southern District of Florida, and
elsewhere, the defendants,
M SIEL PEREZ and
ELOY GARCIA,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $ l ,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carlied away from any air cargo
container, aircraft tenninal facility, and airpol't, which goods were moving as, and which were a
pal4 of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipm ent of freight and other property,
knowing the sam e to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
6
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 6 of 19
COUNT 6
On or about August 4, 2016, in M iami-Dade County, in the Southem District of Florida,
and elsewhere, the defendants,
RASIEL PEREZ and
ELO Y GARCIA,
did knowingly l'eceive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carried away from any air cargo
eontainer, aircraft terminal facility, and aip ort, which goods were moving as, and which werc a
part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipm ent of freight and other property,
knowing the sam e to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
COUNT ;
On or about August 9, 2016, in M iam i-Dade County, in the Southern Distdct of Flodda,
and elsewhere, the defendants,
RASIEL PEREZ andELOY GARCIA,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carried away from any air cargo
container, aircraft term inal facility, and aip ort, which goods were m oving as, and which were a
part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipment of freight and other property,
knowing the sam e to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 7 of 19
CO UNT 8
On or about September 1, 20l 6, in M iami-Dade County, in the Southern Distlict of Florida,
and elsewhere, the defendants,
EM ILIO H ERREM and
RICARDO GONZALEZ,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carried away from any air cargo
container, aircraft terminal facility, and airport, which goods were m oving as, and which were a
part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipment of freight and other property,
knowing the same to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
COUNT 9
On or about September 9, 2016, in M iam i-Dade County, in the Southern District of Florida,
and elsewhere, the defendants,
YOAN PEREZ,
LEO NEL PADRON BELLO, and
EM ILIO H ERRER A,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $ 1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carried away from any air cargo
container, aircraft tenuinal facility, and airport, which goods were moving as, and which were a
pal't of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipm ent of freight and other property,
knowing the sam e to have been stolen, in violation of Title l 8, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 8 of 19
COUNT 10
On or about September 23, 2016, in M iami-Dade County, in the Southern District of
Florida, and elsewhere, the defendants,
LEO NEL PADRON BELLO and
EM ILIO HERRER A,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $ 1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carried away from any air cargo
container, aircraft terminal facility, and airport, which goods were m oving as, and which were a
part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipment of freight and other property,
knowing the sam e to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
COUNT 11
On or about September 30, 2016, in M iami-Dade County, in the Southern District of
Florida, and elsewhere, the defendants,
LEONEL PADRON BELLO,
EM ILIO HERREIW andRICARDO G ONZALEZ,
did knowingly receive and have in their possession goods valued at more than $1,000, that is,
Apple iphones, which had been stolen, unlawfully taken, and carried away from any air cargo
container, aircraft terminal facility, and airport, which goods were m oving as, and which were a
part of, and which constituted an interstate and foreign shipment of freight and other property,
knowing the same to have been stolen, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659
and 2.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 9 of 19
FORFEITURE ALLEG ATION S
The allegations in this lndictment are re-alleged and by this reference fully
incorporated herein for the purpose of alleging crim inal forfeiture to the United States of Am erica
of certain property in which any of the defendants, YOAN PEREZ, LEO NEL PADRON
BELLO , EM ILIO HERREM , RICARDO GO NZALEZ, M SIEL PEREZ, ELOY
GARCIA, M ISAEL CABREM RUIZ, and RODOLFO URM , has an interest.
Upon conviction of a violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 659, or a
conspiracy to comm it such violation, as alleged in this lndictm ent, the defendant so convicted shall
forfeit to the United States of Am erica, any property, real or personal, whieh constitutes or is
dedved from proceeds traceable to such violation, pursuant to Title 18, United States Code, Section
98 1(a)(1)(C).
All pursuant to Title 18, United States Code, Section 98 1(a)(1)(C), and the procedures set
forth in Title 2 1, United States Code, Section 853, which are m ade applicable by Title 28, United
States Code, Sedion 2461(c).
A TRUE BILL
FO/EFERSON
$ p t- tW IFREDO A.FERRER
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
MOVITZ 'CARY 0. AROASSISTANT UNITED STATES ATTORN EY
10
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 10 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
VS.
YOAN PEREZ, et aI.
Defendants./
Court Division: (Select One)
x Miami Ke WestIB FTpFTu w
New Defendantts)Num ber of New Defendants
Total number of counts
CASE NO.
CERTIFICATE OF TRIAL ATTO RNEY,
Superseding Case Information:
Yes No
1 do hereby certify that:
I have carefully considered the allegations of the indictmeq t the number of defendants, the numberof probable witnesses and the Iegal complexities of the Indlctment/lnformation attached hereto.
I am aware that th: information s pu plied oq this jtqtemeqt will be relied upon by the Judges of thisd schedullng crlmlnal trlals under the mandate of the Speedy TrialCourt in setting thelr cal:ndars an
Act, Title 28 U.S.C. Sectlon 3161.
4.
5.
lqterpreter: (Yes qr No) YesLlst Ianguage and/or dlalect panlsh
This case will take 6-8 days for the parties to try.
Please check appropriate category and type of offense Iisted below:
lcheck only onel (Check only one)
I 0 to 5 days11 6 to 10 days11 I 1 1 to 20 daysIV 21 to 60 daysV 61 days and over X
6. Has this case been previously filed in this District Court? (Yes or No) NoIf yes:
Judge: Case No.(Attach copy Pf dispositive ?rdeç)Has a complalnt been filed In thls matter? (Yes or No) YesIf yej:Maglstrate Case No. 16-mj-03359-EGT
Related Miscqllaneous numbers:Defendantts) ln federal custody as ofDefendantls) In state custody as of
Rule 20 from the ls rIc o
ls this a potential death penaltycase? (Yes or No) MN
XpyttyM ! nOrM lsdem .Felony
Dpes this case or gi inate from a matter pending in the Northern Region of the U.S. Attorney's Office4- 2003:2 Yes x Noprlor to October 1 ,
Dges this case originate from a matter pending in the Central Region of the U.S. Attorney's Officeprlor to Septem ber 1, 2007:2 Yes x No
8.
/
CARY , AR VITZASSISTANT UNITED STATES ATTO RNEYFlorida Bar No. 86425
*penalty Sheetts) attached REV 4/8/08
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 11 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
PENALTY SHEET
Defendant's Nam e: YOAN PEREZ
Case No:
Count #: 1
Conspiracy to Steal Goods from an Interstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lm prisonment
Count #: 2
Theft from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' Im prisonment
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipment
Title 18, United States Code, Sedion 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' Im prisonment
Count #: 9
Possession of Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalt'y: 10 Years' Im prisonm ent
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 12 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT
SOUTH ERN DISTRICT OF FLO RIDA
PENALTY SHEET
Defendant's Nam e: LEONEL PADRON BELLO
Case No:
Count #: l
Conspiracy to Steal Goods from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lmprisonm ent
Count #: 2
Thcft from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' lm prisonm ent
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Stolen Goods from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipment
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lm plisonment
Counts #: 9- 1 1
Possession of Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sedions 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' lmprisonment
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 13 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTH ERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
PENALTY SHEET
Defendant's Name: EM ILIO HERRERA
Case No:
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Stolen Goods from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lmprisonm ent
Counts #: 8-1 1
Possession of Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' lmprisonment
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 14 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
PENALTY SH EET
Defendant's Nam e: RICARDO GONZALEZ
Case No:
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Goods Stolen from an Interstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lmprisonm ent
Counts #: 8 and 1 1
Possession of Goods Stolen from an Interstate or Foreign Shipment
Title 18, United States Code, Sedions 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' Im prisonm ent
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 15 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
PENALTY SH EET
Defendant's Nam e: RASIEL PEREZ
Case No:
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Goods Stolen from an Interstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' Im prisonm ent
Counts #: 4-7
Possession of Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipment
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' lm prisonm ent
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 16 of 19
UNITED STA TES DISTRICT COURTSOUTH ERN DISTRICT O F FLO RIDA
PENALTY SHEET
Defendant's Name: ELOY GARCIA
Case No:
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Goods Stolen from an Interstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lmprisonm ent
Counts #: 5-7
Possession of Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' lmprisonment
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 17 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT O F FLO RIDA
PENALTY SHEET
Defendant's Nam e: M ISAEL CABRER A RUIZ
Case No:
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lmprisonment
Count #: 4
Possession of Goods Stolen from an Interstate or Foreign Shipment
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' Imprisonment
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole terms, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 18 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
PENALTY SH EET
Defendant's Nam e: RODOLFO URR A
Case No:
Count #: 3
Conspiracy to Receive Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Section 371
*M ax. Penalty: 5 Years' lmprisonm ent
Count #: 4
Possession of Goods Stolen from an lnterstate or Foreign Shipm ent
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 659 and 2
*M ax. Penalty: 10 Years' Imprisonment
*Refers only to possible term of incarceration, does not include possible fines, restitution,
special assessm ents, parole term s, or forfeitures that m ay be applicable.
Case 1:16-cr-20801-JAL Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/24/2016 Page 19 of 19