1 an ecological psychology framework for customizing anchored instruction with real-time authentic...
TRANSCRIPT
1
An Ecological Psychology Framework An Ecological Psychology Framework for Customizing Anchored Instruction for Customizing Anchored Instruction
with Real-Time Authentic Datawith Real-Time Authentic Data
Michael F. Young,
Matthew S. Wlodarczyk, Neag School of Education, University of Connecticut
Thomas Torgersen,
Brett Branco, Marine Sciences, University of Connecticut
2
The Framework: The Framework: Ecological PsychologyEcological Psychology
• Education of Intention and Attention– Perception of real-time data driven by hypotheses– Students must detect patterns (processes) in data
• Detection of invariance– Patterns in real-time data represent invariant
structure
• Intentional Dynamics and Ontological Descent– Assume each student bring unique goals/intentions
that organize their interaction with the data.
3
Big Picture -- University of Big Picture -- University of Connecticut’s…Connecticut’s…
• Customization of Curriculum Group’s work.– “Vanilla Curriculum”– Design Protocol: Teacher Interview
• Customization of Assessment Group’s work.– Performance Assessment Rubric– Development of Cross Referenced Scientific
Problem Solving Taxonomy & SCALE Rubric
4
AbstractAbstractAnchored instruction scenarios were developed to invite high school and college students to understand authentic pond water quality data made available in near real time over the Internet. A framework based on Ecological Psychology was used to emphasize perception-action over memory-retrieval as the fundamental process of learning (see Young, Barab, and Garrett, 2001). Drawing on concepts of seamless assessment (e.g., Kulikowich and Young, 2000) and the full integration of situated learning with anchored assessment, we provided online teacher and student discussion and support materials to support customization of anchored instruction. Our methodology applied a combination of quantitative and qualitative techniques in the context of a design experiment focused on the development and refinement of an anchored problem-solving learning context through prototype development work with teachers, two undergraduate classrooms, and a high school classroom . Our poster will focus on the results of the design experiment related to the synergistic relationship with the SCALE group and its outcomes.
5
Geoscience Environmental Education-- Geoscience Environmental Education-- Web-accessible Instrumented Systems Web-accessible Instrumented Systems
(GEE – WIS)(GEE – WIS)• A joint project of the Department of Marine Sciences
and the Neag School of Education.• Established http://www.mypond.uconn.edu/ and
http://www.geewis.uconn.edu/. – MyPond is the data site.– GEE-WIS is the education site.
• Design experiment with undergraduate and high school science classrooms.– Real-time water quality data streamed via the Internet.– Anchored instruction scenarios featuring the Brown Family –
a young family living near a university campus.
7
Anchored Instruction ScenariosAnchored Instruction Scenarios• 2 “slideshow” scenarios
were developed.• The Brown Family (Peter,
Jeanette, and Ralph) are featured.
• They have recently moved into Peter’s late grandfather’s house near a university.
• Both scenarios develop a problem for students to solve, using the online data.
Illustration by Vadim Gershman
8
SCALE CollaborationSCALE Collaboration– Collaborated with SCALE to help support
customization of anchored instruction.– Participated in:
• SCALE Curriculum Group; and• SCALE Assessment Group.
– Participation in SCALE and implementation in undergraduate classrooms have informed design experiment.
• GEE-WIS based on SCALE “vanilla curriculum model.”• GEE-WIS rubrics are customizations of SCALE
assessment group products.• Anchored instruction scenarios have been refined over
several implementations.
9
SCALE CollaborationSCALE CollaborationSCALEGEE-WIS
1) Vanilla Curriculum
has informed
Curriculum Group
2) Design Protocol: Teacher Interview
has informed
10
SCALE CollaborationSCALE CollaborationSCALEGEE-WIS
• Performance Assessment Rubrichas informed
Assessment Group
Scie
ntifi
c Pr
oble
m S
olvi
ngTa
xono
my
has informed
Cross Referenced Scientific Problem Solving Taxonomy & SCALE Rubric
Cus
tom
ized
SC
ALE
Ass
essm
ent R
ubric
11
RefinementsRefinements• Participated in SCALE workshop in July of 2001.• Recognized political issues could attract focus from science content.
– Redesigned to lessen the politics and focus on science.• Implemented in a workshop for practicing teachers the late Summer
2001.– Reflection and Redesign…
• Integrated construction on campus into the scenarios.• Customized SCALE assessment rubric.• Customized the SCALE Design Protocol.
• Implemented in an undergraduate engineering course in the Fall of 2001.– Reflection and Redesign…
• Need for students to externalize the problem solving process online.• Designed a taxonomy for scientific problem solving (customization
of SCALE assessment).
12
RefinementsRefinementsSummer 2001Summer 2001
January 2002January 2002
Designed Anchor Designed Anchor Scenarios in PowerPointScenarios in PowerPoint
De-politicized Anchors:De-politicized Anchors:Focus on ScienceFocus on Science
July: SCALE July: SCALE WorkshopWorkshop @ NWU @ NWU
Implemented with Teachers in Summer WorkshopImplemented with Teachers in Summer Workshop
Integrated Construction on Campus into ScenariosIntegrated Construction on Campus into Scenarios
October: SCALE Workshop in SCOctober: SCALE Workshop in SC
Customized SCALE Design ProtocolCustomized SCALE Design Protocol
Implemented in Undergrad Engineering Course Implemented in Undergrad Engineering Course
Customized SCALE Performance Assessment RubricCustomized SCALE Performance Assessment Rubric
Need for Student Problem Solving Need for Student Problem Solving Process to be ExternalizedProcess to be Externalized
Use On-line Technologies toUse On-line Technologies toCapture More StudentCapture More Student
Problem SolvingProblem Solving
Italics indicates SCALE collaboration items.Italics indicates SCALE collaboration items.Green text across the arrow indicates significant events.Green text across the arrow indicates significant events.
13
Today…Today…• Implementing in an undergraduate marine sciences course.
– Reflection and Redesign…• Political issues still biasing scientific analysis.
• Redirecting students to focus on the scientific analysis of the data without trying to fit it to their “client” (either the Brown’s or the university).
• Applying SCALE customized assessment and scientific problem solving taxonomy to written student work.
• Implementing in a high school ecology course.– Reflection and Redesign…
• Need to simplify and scaffold the data for high school teachers and students.
• Students are currently presenting their solutions. No data collected as of April 1, 2002.
14
Refinements to Today…Refinements to Today…January 2002January 2002
April 2002April 2002
Designed Taxonomy for Designed Taxonomy for Scientific Problem SolvingScientific Problem Solving
Political Issues Still being RecognizedPolitical Issues Still being Recognized
Implementing in an Undergrad Marine Science CourseImplementing in an Undergrad Marine Science Course& High School Ecology Course& High School Ecology Course
Students Beginning to Present Preliminary Ideas/SolutionsStudents Beginning to Present Preliminary Ideas/Solutions
Need to Scaffold Data and Information Need to Scaffold Data and Information For Teachers & Students @ High SchoolsFor Teachers & Students @ High Schools
Redirecting Students to Focus on ScientificRedirecting Students to Focus on ScientificAnalysis without Fitting to ClientAnalysis without Fitting to Client
Applying SCALE Performance Assessment RubricApplying SCALE Performance Assessment Rubric& Taxonomy for Scientific Problem Solving& Taxonomy for Scientific Problem Solving
Italics indicates SCALE collaboration items.Italics indicates SCALE collaboration items.Green text across the arrow indicates significant events.Green text across the arrow indicates significant events.