1 law offices of ronald a. marron, aplc ronald a....

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Johnson v. Triple Leaf Tea Inc., Case No. 3:14-cv-01570

SUPP. MARRON DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEY’S FEES, COSTS AND INCENTIVE AWARD

LAW OFFICES OF RONALD A. MARRON, APLC RONALD A. MARRON (SBN 175650)

[email protected]

SKYE RESENDES (SBN 278511)

[email protected]

ALEXIS M. WOOD (SBN 270200)

[email protected]

651 Arroyo Drive

San Diego, California 92103

Telephone: (619) 696-9006

Facsimile: (619) 546-6665

Class Counsel

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

EUNICE JOHNSON, individually, on behalf of

all others similarly situated, and the general

public,

Plaintiff,

v.

TRIPLE LEAF TEA INC.;

Defendant.

CASE NO.: 3:14-cv-01570 MMC

CLASS ACTION

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF

RONALD A. MARRON IN SUPPORT OF

PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR ATTORNEY’S

FEES, COSTS AND INCENTIVE AWARD

(HEARING DATE SET BY ORDER GRANTING

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION

SETTLEMENT [DKT. NO. 53])

Judge: Hon. Maxine M. Chesney

Courtroom: 7 (19th Floor)

Date: Nov. 13, 2015

Time: 9:00 a.m.

Case3:14-cv-01570-MMC Document58-1 Filed09/08/15 Page1 of 100

mailto:[email protected]

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1



I, Ronald A. Marron, declare:

1. I am a member in good standing of the State Bar of California, the Southern, Central,

Eastern and Northern Districts of California, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

2. I submit this supplemental declaration in support of Plaintiff’s Motion for Approval of

Attorney’s Fees, Costs, and an Incentive Award. I make this Declaration based on personal

knowledge and if called to testify, I could and would competently testify to the matters contained

herein.

3. The hours billed in this action by my firm are reasonable, reflect the intensity with

which issues were disputed in this case, and the amount of work necessary for this litigation to

culminate in the successful resolution of injunctive relief on behalf of the Class.

4. My firm keeps detailed contemporaneous time records for each timekeeper and

regularly records time records in the normal course of business. It is standard practice for my firm to

bill in one-tenth-of-an-hour increments for each task performed. During the course of this litigation,

my firm kept time records consistent with that practice. Attached hereto as Exhibit 1 is a true and

correct copy of my firm’s contemporaneous time records that were maintained throughout the course

of this litigation. I reviewed my firm’s time records and made my best effort to allocate the amount of

time spent on work relating to specific aspects of this litigation. Entries were carefully reviewed to

discard erroneous entries and duplicative time.

5. My firm contributed a total of 436.8 hours to this litigation, including 417.8 attorney

hours, .1 law clerk hours, and 18.9 legal assistant/paralegal hours as of August 17, 2015.

6. My firm will also perform additional work and incur additional costs not reflected

above. For example, due to the need to tabulate fees and costs in advance of drafting, editing and

briefing this Motion; drafting and editing the Motion for Final Approval and supporting declarations;

and ensuring the Notice Administrator complies with all portions of the Preliminary Approval Order

are not included in the actual hours spent. Moreover, after this application is filed, Counsel will have

other duties, minimally including attending the Final Approval Hearing, which will involve

additional travel costs and attorney time, and responding to objections, which will substantially

increase the time spent. To account for the known additional work and the possibility of more if


1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

2



there are objections or an appeal, I have estimated that my firm will spend 100 “post-application

hours,” based on their experience of how long it takes to draft final approval papers, respond to

objections, if any, and known travel costs and time to attend the final approval hearing. My firm

valued these additional hours at the reduced blended rate of $440 per hour, representing the

approximate average billing rate of all attorney timekeepers plus one non-attorney staff member,

which is also equivalent to the lowest attorney rate at Class Counsel’s office. I reviewed my firm’s

time records and made my best effort to allocate the amount of time spent on work relating to specific

aspects of this litigation.

7. Below is a summary chart that reflects the hours spent on each category of time in this

case, as of August 17, 2015.

Pre-filing investigation and drafting CLRA letter: 10.9

Preparing Complaint: 14.2

Settlement negotiations and mediation: 117.7

Discovery and due diligence document review: 63.5

Client communications and case management: 61.6

Motions: 141.1

Preparing for and attending hearings: 27.8

8. Based on a review of my firm’s contemporaneous time sheets and my good faith

estimate of how many post-application hours my firm will expend on this matter, I have calculated

Class Counsel’s total lodestar to equal $253,166.00.

9. Below is a summary of my firm’s lodestar calculation showing each time keeper, their

requested hourly rate, and their total hours expended:


1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

3



Timekeeper Position Rate Requested Total

Hours

Total Amount

Ron Marron Partner $745 49 $36,505.00

Skye Resendes Associate $475 170.9 $81,177.50

Alexis Wood Associate

$475 7 $3,325.00

Kas Gallucci Associate

$450 7 $3,150.00

William Richards Associate

$440 43.4 $19,096.00

Marshall Lurtz Associate $440

120.7 $53,108.00

Beth Goodman Associate $440

0.9 $396.00

Erin Minelli Associate $440

18.9 $8,316.00

Danielle Eisner Law Clerk/

Patent

Agent with

Clinical

Science

Background

$290

.1 $29.00

Support Staff Paralegals/

Legal

Assistants

$215 18.9 $4,064.00

Subtotal = $209,166.00

Post-Application Hours (Est.): 100 hours x $440 = $44,000.00

TOTAL = $253,166.00

10. My firm’s time sheets, which are attached hereto as Exhibit 1, show in more detail the

total time expended for each time keeper, a description of the service that was rendered, the date that

it was rendered on, and the duration of time that was billed in accordance with my firm’s standard

practice of billing in one-tenth-of-an-hour increments.

11. Class Counsel in this case use email as their preferred method of communication.

Internal memoranda regarding research, new legal authorities, case strategy, and assignments are

routinely distributed by my firm’s attorneys via email. It is not uncommon for myself, and other


1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

4



associates at my firm, to spend a great deal of time drafting lengthy emails to opposing counsel and

clients. Moreover, my firm’s telephone system also distributes voicemail messages and facsimiles to

attorneys at my firm via email. Thus, several entries in Class Counsel’s time sheets reflect time spent

on reviewing, analyzing, and drafting email communications and email attachments.

12. It is routine practice for my law firm to bill all time spent on emails at the minimal

one-tenth-of-an-hour increment even though many of these emails take much longer than six minutes

to draft, edit, and revise.

13. My firm made all efforts to avoid spending unnecessary and duplicative time on this

litigation. As the supervising attorney at the Law Offices of Ronald A. Marron, I exercised my best

professional judgment when staffing this case and assigning projects to my associate attorneys and

support staff.

14. Class Counsel has also incurred recoverable costs in the amount of $3,276.22. Below

is a summary of expenses that were incurred by my firm during the course of this litigation:

Expenses Recoverable Under Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 1033.5:

Description Amount

Court Filings $400.00

Service of Process Fees $302.75

Certified mail postage to all Defendant and their agents

for statutory notice required by CLRA $12.96

Total: $715.71

Additional Expenses Reasonably Necessary to Prosecute Action

Description Amount

Mediation No charge to the Class

Postage Overhead – no charge

to the Class

Flat rate charge for case deadline calculations $ 160.00


1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

5



Description Amount

(CompuLaw Deadlines on Demand software)

Flights to out of county hearings $1,366.20

PACER Overhead – no charge

to the Class

Mileage and transportation $105.70

Lodging for out of county hearings $570.94

Photocopies $308.25

Westlaw online research Overhead – no charge

to the Class

Meals for out of county travel $19.42

Parking $30.00

Total: $2,560.51

GRAND TOTAL:

$3,276.22

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is true

and correct.

Executed on this 8th day of September 2015 in San Diego, California.

/s/ Ronald A. Marron

RONALD A. MARRON

LAW OFFICES OF RONALD A. MARRON

651 Arroyo Drive

San Diego, CA 92103

Telephone:(619) 696-9006

Facsimile: (619) 564-6665


EXHIBIT 1


Law Offices of Ronald A. MarronTIME ACTIVITIES BY EMPLOYEE DETAIL

Activity: All Dates

ACTIVITY DATE PRODUCT/SERVICE MEMO/DESCRIPTION DURATION

Alexis Wood02/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 2/19/2014 4:43 PMregarding CLRA letter.

0:06

02/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 2/19/2014 4:41 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06


0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Thu 4/3/2014 9:15 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:04 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06


0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/4/2014 11:31 AM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06


0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 4/4/2014 11:06 AM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06

04/08/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/8/2014 11:52 AM regarding summonsissued.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 4/25/2014 12:46 PM regarding clerk'snotice.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/29/2014 2:16 PM regarding summonsreturned executed.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/29/2014 2:32 PM regardingconsent/declination to proceed before a USMagistrate Judge.

0:06

04/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 4/30/2014 1:06 PM regarding clerk'snotice.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 001


04/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 4/30/2014 2:06 PM regarding orderreassigning case.

0:06

05/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/1/2014 11:48 AM regarding casemanagement scheduling order.

0:06

05/07/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from C.Balot dated Wed 5/7/2014 3:12 PM regarding ESI.

0:06

05/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/15/2014 10:59 AM regardingcertificate of service.

0:06

05/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/16/2014 2:01 PM regarding motion todismiss.

0:06

05/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/16/2014 3:09 PM regarding proposedorder.

0:06

05/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 5/21/2014 1:12 PM regarding notice ofappearance.

0:06

05/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/23/2014 12:43 PM regarding certificateof interested entities.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 5/28/2014 3:04 PM regardingstipulation.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Wed 5/28/2014 3:39 PMregarding proposed order granting joint stipulationto extend briefing schedule.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Wed 5/28/2014 12:43 PM regardingfiling.

0:06

05/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/29/2014 11:57 AM regarding ordergranting joint stipulation to extend briefingschedule.

0:06

05/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/29/2014 12:05 PM regarding motion todismiss.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 6/18/2014 5:52 PM regardingopposition/response to motion.

0:06

06/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/27/2014 3:56 PM regardingopposition/response.

0:06

07/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 7/15/2014 11:04 AM regardingstipulation.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 4:32 PM regarding ordervacating hearing on defendant's motion to dismiss.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 1:01 PM regarding notice by E.Johnson of initial disclosures.

0:06


0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 002


dated Fri 7/18/2014 4:27 PM regarding ordervacating hearing on defendant's motion to dismissor strike.

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 2:33 PM regarding joint casemanagement statement.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 2:36 PM regarding ADRcertification.

0:06

08/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 8/15/2014 2:19 PM regarding stipulationwith proposed order.

0:06

09/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/2/2014 9:36 AM regarding order onstipulation.

0:06

09/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 9/4/2014 2:19 PM regarding joint casemanagement statement.

0:06

09/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/9/2014 10:54 AM regarding ordercontinuing case management conference.

0:06

09/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/23/2014 12:25 PM regarding order onmotion to dismiss.

0:06

10/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/2/2014 4:07 PM regardingpossible settlement.

0:06

10/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/3/2014 9:50 AM regardingpossible settlement.

0:06

10/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 10/15/2014 12:24 PM regardingstipulation with proposed order.

0:06


0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/24/2014 11:42 AM regardingstipulation with proposed order.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/24/2014 11:36 AM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

10/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 10/28/2014 3:51 PM regarding motion towithdraw.

0:06

10/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 10/28/2014 1:33 PM regarding notice ofappearance.

0:06

10/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 10/30/2014 10:37 AM regarding orderon stipulation.

0:06

10/31/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/31/2014 2:53 PM regarding casemanagement conference.

0:06


0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 11/21/2014 11:46 AM regardingstipulated protective order.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 003


03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 3/13/2015 3:51 PM regarding casemanagement statement.

0:06


0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 4/15/2015 2:34 PM regarding notice byE. Johnson.

0:06

05/07/2015 Review Review letter to client re: deposition. 0:0605/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 5/15/2015 4:57 PM regarding motion forsettlement.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/15/2015 4:17 PM regarding motion tofile under seal.

0:06

06/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 6/3/2015 3:50 PM regarding order onadministrative motion to file under seal.

0:06

06/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 6/19/2015 12:52 PM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Tue 6/23/2015 2:43 PM regardingmotion hearing.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 6/23/2015 1:59 PM regarding hearing.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 6/23/2015 2:36 PM regardingmotion hearing.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 6/25/2015 2:56 PM regardingsupplemental brief.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/26/2015 10:07 AM regardingdeclaration in support.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/26/2015 4:58 PM regarding preliminaryapproval.

0:06

Total for Alexis Wood 7:00Amanda Beamer

04/08/2014 Download & Save Download and Save ECF re: summons. 0:0604/08/2014 Download & Save Download and Save ECF re: order setting initial

case management conference.0:06

04/08/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF dkt. 4 proposedsummons

0:06

04/25/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF dkt. 7 0:0604/30/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF dkt. 10 notice of

impending reassignment to U.S. District judge0:06

09/02/2014 Download & Save Download and Save ECF 0:0609/02/2014 Admin. ECF #30

Order granting initial stipulation to appear at casemanagement conference.

0:06

09/03/2014 Edit Edit joint case management conference statement. 0:2409/04/2014 Admin. Redact joint case management conference

statement.0:18

09/24/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF # 33 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 004


10/16/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF # 35 0:0610/28/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes and M. Lurtz re case

management conference and strategy0:06

10/31/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF # 40 "Order reUncontested Mtn to Withdraw Jnt Stip for DefenseCounsel to Appear at the CMC by Phone"

0:06

Total for Amanda Beamer 1:48Beth Goodman

09/23/2014 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0610/14/2014 Review Reviewed stipulation and order to appear by

phone.0:12

10/22/2014 TelephoneConference

Telephone conference team meeting re status andstrategy

0:06

12/03/2014 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0601/07/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy 0:0601/23/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0602/11/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0603/05/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:06

Total for Beth Goodman 0:54Bill Richards

04/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/16/2015 11:39 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 4/20/2015 2:50 PMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/20/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0604/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Tue 4/21/2015 4:16 PM regardingnotice bid.

0:06

04/22/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: motion forpreliminary approval.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:34 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:32 AMregarding notice provider.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:48 PMregarding quote.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:56 AMregarding quote.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:53 PM regardingCAFA notice.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:27 PM regardingsettlement estimate.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 7:24 AM regardingCAFA advertising.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:31 PM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 005


04/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/24/2015 10:35 AM regardingmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/24/2015 1:16 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

04/30/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: Triple Leafassignments (Motion for preliminary approval,review of settlement, declarations, etc.).

0:12

05/01/2015 Review Finished reviewing, modifying, and editingsettlement agreements, researching similarsettlements as a basis for comparison/reference.

1:54

05/01/2015 Draft Began drafting motion for preliminary approval.Drafted notice of motion and factual backgroundsections.

0:48

05/01/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/1/20151:38 PM regarding settlement.

0:06

05/01/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/1/20152:14 PM regarding settlement.

0:06

05/01/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/1/2015 2:37 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06

05/01/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/1/20152:29 PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06


0:06

05/01/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/1/2015 2:40 PM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

05/01/2015 Review Continued reviewing settlement agreement andediting, researching similar settlements as a pointof reference/comparison.

1:00

05/01/2015 Review Began reviewing settlement agreement, finaljudgment and order re: settlement, and orderapproving preliminary settlement in preparation formotion for preliminary approval assignment.

0:54

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/4/2015 10:11 AMregarding notice.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon5/4/2015 10:05 AM regarding question.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 8:15 AM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 8:30 AM regarding finalapproval.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/4/2015 10:27 AMregarding notice.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 11:59 AM regardingclient.

0:06

05/04/2015 Edit Continued personalizing and editing motion forpreliminary approval and declaration of R. Marronin support thereof.

0:18

05/04/2015 Draft Drafted rough summary/template for federalbackground section to motion for preliminary

1:48

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 006


approval. Drafted rough summary/template forinjunctive relief section.

05/04/2015 Finalize Drafted, edited, and finished rough draft/template ofentire motion for preliminary approval.

2:00

05/04/2015 Draft Finished drafting summary of settlement section toplaintiff's motion for preliminary approval.

0:48

05/04/2015 Finalize Finished updating/editing. Federal backgroundsection of motion for preliminary approval.Continued drafting/editing declaration of R. Marron.

0:30

05/04/2015 Edit Began editing and inserting specific relevant factsinto factual background to motion for preliminaryapproval, looking to relevant pleadings. Beganediting declaration of R. Marron to coincide withmotion for preliminary approval.

1:18

05/05/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/5/2015 4:30 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/05/2015 Edit Updated/edited all documents/pleadings in supportof joint motion for preliminary approval of classaction settlement, adding support with declarations.

0:54

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted declaration of E. Johnson in support of jointmotion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement. Left message for Ms. Johnson to callme back re: her declaration.

0:18

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted declaration of R. Polk in support of jointmotion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement.

0:30

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted declaration of R. Marron in support of jointmotion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement.

0:24

05/05/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: motion forpreliminary approval.

0:18

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted declaration of [TL employee] in support ofjoint motion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement.

0:18

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted declaration of [TL employee] in support ofjoint motion to seal certain information indeclaration of [TL employee] filed in support of jointmotion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement.

0:18

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted proposed order re: joint motion to sealcertain information in declaration of [TL employee]filed in support of joint motion for preliminaryapproval of class action settlement.

0:18

05/05/2015 Edit Edited/reviewed all documents/pleadings re: jointmotion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement to ensure everything crafted.Reviewed/researched local rules. Meeting with S.Resendes re: progress.

0:30

05/05/2015 Edit Edited standard of review section to motion forpreliminary approval. Cite checked standard ofreview section. Fixed crossreference cites.Finished entire first draft of motion for preliminaryapproval.

2:54

05/05/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue 5/5/20154:28 PM regarding motion for preliminary approvalpleadings.

0:06

05/05/2015 Draft Drafted summary of client purchases. Called clientsfor additional information, and to follow up re:retainer agreements.

0:30

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 007


05/05/2015 Draft Drafted joint motion to seal certain information in[Triple Leaf employee] declaration in support ofjoint motion for preliminary approval of class actionsettlement.

0:42

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:06 PM regardingdraft settlement agreement.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed5/6/2015 12:44 PM regarding motion forpreliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:02 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/06/2015 Preparation Marked/prepared table of authorities for motion forpreliminary approval of settlement. Correctednumerous table of authorities mistakes/mismarks.

2:24

05/06/2015 Review Reviewed and compared draft final approval orderwith final approval order in Tadin. Implementededits and edited for spelling, grammar, andformatting

1:30

05/06/2015 Review Reviewed and compared memorandum ofunderstanding, proposed settlement agreement,draft preliminary approval order, and draft finalapproval order. Compared with orders in Tadin.Updated/edited proposed order grantingpreliminary approval.

1:30

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:17 PM regarding draftsettlement agreement.

0:06


Spoke with E. Johnson and went over theproposed settlement agreement and declaration insupport of joint motion for preliminary approval ofsettlement. Updated her declaration and sent to herfor signature.

0:36

05/07/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Thu 5/7/20152:51 PM regarding Johnson declaration ins supportof motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Johnson dated Thu 5/7/2015 3:11 PM regardingdeclaration.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 5/7/2015 2:47 PM regardingdeclaration.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email to Drafted email to E. Johnson sent on Thu 5/7/20152:59 PM regarding declaration.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Thu 5/7/20152:35 PM regarding Johnson declaration in supportof motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/8/2015 9:09 AM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/8/20158:37 AM regarding motion for preliminary approvalpleadings.

0:06


0:06

05/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to E. Johnson sent on Fri 5/8/20159:07 AM regarding E. Johnson declaration.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to E. Johnson declaration. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 008


05/08/2015 Preparation Prepared signature page for settlement agreementand sent to e. Johnson for signature. Saved hersigned declaration in support of motion forpreliminary approval of class settlement.

0:12

05/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/8/20153:47 PM regarding signature page.

0:06

05/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/11/2015 1:13 PMregarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Review Reviewed defendant's redlined joint motion forpreliminary approval of class settlement, anddeclaration of R. Polk in support of joint motion forpreliminary approval.

0:30

05/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed5/13/2015 11:46 AM regarding joint motion forpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Edit Updated settlement agreement, motion forpreliminary approval of class settlement,declaration of R. Polk, Lam declaration, andproposed order.

0:30

05/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 5/14/2015 2:49 PM regarding jointmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Meeting Meetings with S. Resendes re: Friday's motions. 0:2405/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Thu 5/14/2015 2:46 PM regardingjoint motion for preliminary approval.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 2:16 PM regardingdeclaration in support of motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:16 PM regarding motionfor preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 5/15/2015 2:17 PM regardingdeclaration in support of motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:54 PM regardingdeclaration in support of joint motion.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:47 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/15/20152:09 PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:46 PM regardingrevised document.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 5/15/2015 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 009


4:07 PM regarding proposed preliminary and finalapprovals.

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 4:21 PM regardingproposed order re: joint motion.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:49 PM regardingsignature pages.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 2:29 PM regardingjoint motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:49 PM regardingsignature page.

0:06

05/15/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: motion forpreliminary approal status and motion to sealinformation in declaration of V. Lam preparedsignature page for settlement agreement.

0:30

05/15/2015 Draft Created table of authorities for joint motion forpreliminary approval of class action settlement.

0:42

05/15/2015 Edit Updated joint motion for preliminary approvalremoved all highlights, made corrections. Updateddeclaration of R. Marron in support of motion forpreliminary approval. Created PDFs of attachedexhibits for R. Marron declaration.

1:24

05/15/2015 Edit Compiled and merged exhibits for settlementagreement and declaration of R. Marron in supportof joint motion for preliminary approval. Preparedall PDFs and pleadings in final form for filing. Filedall pleadings with S. Resendes (Motion,declarations, orders, exhibits, etc.).

1:48

05/15/2015 Draft Created table of contents and updated table ofauthorities in joint motion for preliminary approval,with S. Resendes' help re: creating tables ofcontents.

1:00

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:56 PM regardingsignatures.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 5/20/2015 11:52 AMregarding correspondence.

0:06

06/02/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0606/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Thu 6/4/2015 10:35 AM regardingmotion to file under seal.

0:06


0:06

06/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 6/22/2015 7:03 PM

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 010


regarding preliminary approval.06/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.

Ivie dated Mon 6/22/2015 7:23 PM regardinginformation.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:53 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:26 PM regardingrevised notice plan.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:16 PM regardingquestions.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:27 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Tue 6/23/2015 5:49 PM regarding notice.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/23/2015 2:42 PM regardingmotion hearing.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 2:47 PMregarding notice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 11:45 AMregarding notice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 12:07 PMregarding supplemental brief.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 6/24/2015 8:59 AM regardingsupplemental declaration.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 1:12 PMregarding inquiry.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 12:08 PMregarding notice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 8:57 AMregarding supplemental brief.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 11:21 AMregarding readership numbers.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 6/25/2015 10:57 AM regardingnegotiations.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/25/2015 2:18 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Thu 6/25/2015 6:56 AM regardingresponses.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/25/2015 10:51 AMregarding negotiations.

0:06

06/30/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0607/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S. 0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 011


Resendes dated Thu 7/2/2015 2:28 PM regardingadministration.

07/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 7/7/2015 12:00 PM regardingnotice documents.

0:06

07/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 7/7/2015 2:54 PM regardingnotice documents.

0:06


0:06

07/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Tue 7/7/2015 12:59 PMregarding notice documents.

0:06

07/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Tue 7/7/2015 11:57 AMregarding notice documents.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 7/8/2015 10:54 AMregarding media approval and notice plandocuments.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Wed 7/8/2015 11:30 AMregarding media approval and notice plandocuments.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 7/8/2015 3:45 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Wed 7/8/2015 8:45 AM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06


0:06


0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 7/8/2015 3:47 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Wed 7/8/2015 1:35 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06

07/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Thu 7/9/2015 11:20 AMregarding draft website.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Caramers dated Fri 7/10/2015 2:53 PM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 7/10/2015 2:43 PM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

07/24/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:06Total for Bill Richards 43:24Danielle Eisner


Call with E. Johnson re: retainer. 0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 012


Total for Danielle Eisner 0:06Erin Minelli

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/4/2014 11:37 AM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 4/4/2014 11:06 AM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/01/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 5/1/201412:00 PM regarding case management schedulingorder.

0:06

05/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 5/1/2014 11:59 AM regardingcase management scheduling order.

0:06

05/22/2014 Conference Conference with S. Resendes re: defendants'motion to dismiss complaint and plaintiff's responseto same.

0:30

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 5/22/2014 3:19 PM regardingproposed order.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/22/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 5/22/20144:13 PM regarding proposed order.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 5/22/2014 4:45 PM regardingmotion to strike.

0:06

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 5/22/2014 7:13 PM regardingmotion to strike.

0:06


0:06

05/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/23/2014 10:17 AM regardingdisclosure dates.

0:06

05/23/2014 Conference Conference with S. Resendes re: possibleamendments to complaint.

0:06

05/27/2014 Draft Draft proposed order in support of joint stipulationto extend briefing schedule for defendant's motionto dismiss plaintiff's complaint.

0:12

05/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 5/27/2014 8:27 AM regardingdisclosure dates.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 013


05/27/2014 Draft Draft joint stipulation to extend briefing schedule fordefendant's motion to dismiss plaintiff's complaint.

0:36

05/27/2014 Review Review and analysis of defendant's motion todismiss in preparation for meeting with defendant'scounsel to discuss plaintiffs' response todefendant's motion to dismiss.

0:36

05/27/2014 Conference Premeeting conference with S. Resendes todiscuss case status and strategy.

0:06

05/27/2014 Conference Conference with defendant's counsel re: briefingschedule for defendant's motion to dismiss.

0:12

05/27/2014 Review Review and analysis of local rules re: filing of jointstipulation in Northern District of California inpreparation for drafting same.

0:18

05/27/2014 Draft Draft declaration of S. Resendes in support of jointstipulation to extend briefing schedule fordefendant's motion to dismiss plaintiff's complaint.

0:12

05/27/2014 Review Review and analysis of complaint in preparation formeeting with defendant's counsel to discussplaintiffs' response to defendant's motion todismiss.

0:42

05/27/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 5/27/20145:58 PM regarding proposed order.

0:06

05/27/2014 Meeting Postconference meeting with S. Resendes todiscuss strategy for responding to defendant'smotion to dismiss.

0:12

05/27/2014 Conference Conference with S. Resendes re: case status andstrategy re: amendments to complaint.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/28/2014 10:30 AM regardingjoint stipulation.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and S. Resendes on Wed5/28/2014 9:56 AM regarding joint stipulation.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and S. Resendes on Wed5/28/2014 12:00 PM regarding motion to dismiss.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/28/2014 12:10 PM regardingproposed order.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Wed 5/28/2014 3:39 PMregarding proposed order.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and S. Resendes on Wed5/28/2014 12:11 PM regarding proposed order.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 5/28/2014 7:42 AMregarding proposed order.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/28/2014 10:41 AM regardingjoint stipulation.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer, N. Perez Lara, and P.Cruz on Wed 5/28/2014 12:43 PM regarding jointstipulation.

0:06

05/30/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 5/30/2014 1:47PM regarding meet and confer.

0:06

05/30/2014 Conference Conference with S. Resendes re: case status. 0:0605/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 5/30/2014 1:47 PM regardingmeet and confer.

0:06


0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 014



0:06

05/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resends dated Fri 5/30/2014 1:47 PM regardingmeet and confer.

0:06

05/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/30/2014 2:13 PM regardingmeet and confer.

0:06


0:06

06/17/2014 Edit Supplement argument section of plaintiff'sopposition to defendant's motion to dismiss withdistinguishing analysis of case law cited bydefendant in support of its breach of warrantyarguments.

0:54

06/17/2014 Draft Draft section of plaintiff's opposition to defendant'smotion to dismiss re: breach of warranty claims.

2:06

06/17/2014 Research Research and analysis of case law cited indefendant's motion to dismiss re: breach ofwarranty claims in preparation for draftingopposition to same.

0:42

06/17/2014 Finalize Finalize plaintiff's warranty argument in support ofopposition to defendant's motion to dismiss inpreparation for filing same.

0:36

06/17/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 6/17/20142:40 PM regarding breach of warranty arguments.

0:06


0:06

06/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/17/2014 4:59 PM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:23 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and A. Beamer onWed 6/18/2014 5:19 PM regarding proof of service.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:09 PM regardingmotion to dismiss.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:18 PMregarding proof of service.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:09 PMregarding motion to dismiss.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:20 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 6/18/2014 4:03 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 015


motion to dismiss.


0:06

06/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and A. Beamer onWed 6/18/2014 5:23 PM regarding proof of service.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:11 PM regardingmotion to dismiss.

0:06


0:06

06/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resends on Wed 6/18/20149:12 AM regarding breach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 6/18/20145:25 PM regarding meet and confer letter.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/18/2014 8:20 AMregarding breach of warranty arguments.

0:06


0:06

06/19/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 6/19/20148:48 AM regarding breach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/19/2014 7:56 AM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/19/2014 7:32 AM regardingdocument.

0:06

07/03/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: status and workloadassignments for Triple Leaf.

0:06

07/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 7/9/2014 9:55 AM regarding rule26 conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 7/10/2014 10:45 AM regarding26(f) conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and S. Resendes on Thu7/10/2014 12:39 PM regarding rule 26(f)conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 7/10/201410:26 AM regarding 26(f).

0:06

07/10/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 7/10/201410:28 AM regarding rule 26(f) conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 7/10/2014 10:27 AMregarding rule 26 conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and S. Resendes on Thu7/10/2014 10:43 AM regarding 26(f) conference.

0:06

07/11/2014 Draft Draft ESI protocol to comply with court's modelorder re: same.

0:18

07/11/2014 Draft Draft stipulated protective order to comply withcourt's model order re: same.

0:48


Participate in telephonic rule 26(f) conference callwith defense counsel.

0:30

07/11/2014 Draft Draft certificate of interested parties. 0:1207/11/2014 Draft Draft initial disclosures. 0:24

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 016


07/11/2014 Review Review and analysis of local rules re: filing ofcertificate of interested parties in preparation fordrafting same.

0:06

07/11/2014 Draft Draft plaintiff's first set of requests for productions todefendant.

0:48

07/11/2014 Review Review local rules and guidelines in preparationfor preparing draft stipulated protective order andESI protocol.

0:12

07/11/2014 Conference Conference with S. Resendes re: points discussedwith defense counsel during rule 26(f) conference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 7/14/2014 2:06 PM regarding jointcase management conference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 7/14/2014 11:18 AM regardingjoint case management conference.

0:06

07/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 7/17/2014 5:28 PM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

07/17/2014 Review Review and analysis of defendant's edits to jointcase management statement in preparation forfiling same.

0:12

07/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Fri 7/18/2014 11:13AM regarding proof of service.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 7/18/2014 9:54 AM regardingjoint case management statement.

0:06

Total for Erin Minelli 18:54Kas L. Gallucci

02/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/19/2014 4:43 PMregarding CLRA letter.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Thu 4/3/2014 9:15 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06


0:06

04/03/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara and R. Marron senton Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regarding CLRA letterdraft.

0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/4/2014 2:35 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 017


CLRA letter.


0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/4/2014 2:35 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from SARdated Fri 4/4/2014 2:33 PM regarding CLRA letter.

0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron sent on Fri 4/4/20149:40 AM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06


0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 4/4/2014 11:04 AM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 4/4/201411:34 AM regarding CLRA letter.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 4/4/2014 11:06 AM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06


0:06


0:06

04/07/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Mon 4/7/2014 10:15 AMregarding complaint.

0:06

04/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/16/2014 4:32 PMregarding case management scheduling order.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/6/2014 2:52 PM regardingprocess server.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 5/6/2014 2:28 PM regardingcase management conference order.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 5/6/2014 2:58 PM regardingprocess server.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/6/2014 2:59 PM regardingprocess server.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Wed 5/28/2014 12:43 PM regardingfiling.

0:06

06/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 018


Resendes dated Tue 6/17/2014 4:59 PM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/18/2014 11:07 AMregarding breach of warranty arguments.

0:06

07/01/2014 Email to Drafted email to P. Cruz sent on Tue 7/1/2014 1:38PM regarding expenses.

0:06

07/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 7/1/2014 10:11 AM regardingexpenses.

0:06

07/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Cruz dated Tue 7/1/2014 12:35 PM regardingexpenses.

0:06

07/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Cruz dated Tue 7/1/2014 9:53 AM regardingexpenses.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 7/14/2014 12:24 PMregarding case management conference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 7/14/2014 10:56 AMregarding case management conference.

0:06

09/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 9/9/2014 11:47 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

10/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/2/2014 4:07 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06

10/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/3/2014 9:50 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 11/26/2014 3:34 PMregarding mediator's fees.

0:06


0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 11/26/2014 3:32 PM regardingmediator's fees.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 11/26/2014 3:33 PM regardingmediator's fees.

0:06

01/28/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed1/28/2015 11:01 AM regarding delivery.

0:06

01/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 1/28/2015 11:10 AMregarding delivery.

0:06


0:06


0:06

01/28/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed1/28/2015 11:08 AM regarding delivery.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 4/8/2015 9:52 AMregarding initial draft.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 019


05/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/18/2015 2:23 PMregarding courtesy copies.

0:06

05/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon5/18/2015 2:25 PM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06

05/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated 05/18/2015 regarding courtesycopies.

0:06

05/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Vogel sent on Mon 5/25/20152:32 PM regarding delivery.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/26/2015 12:14 PMregarding delivery.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Tue 5/26/2015 10:40 AM regardingletter and documents.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 5/26/2015 11:03 AM regardingdelivery.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/26/2015 10:04 AMregarding delivery.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue5/26/2015 10:28 AM regarding delivery.

0:06

06/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/9/2015 1:37 PM regardingmotion to file under seal.

0:06

06/09/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue 6/9/20151:36 PM regarding motion to file under seal.

0:06

06/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/9/2015 12:13 PM regardingmotion to file under seal.

0:06


0:06


0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 6/23/2015 2:36 PM regardingmotion hearing.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to firm sent on Tue 6/23/2015 2:43PM regarding motion hearing.

0:06


0:06

07/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron senton Mon 7/14/2014 11:37 AM regarding telephonicappearance.

0:06

08/13/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: strategy on feemotion.

0:06

Total for Kas L. Gallucci 7:00Katharine Scott

01/26/2015 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared mediation briefdeadline

0:06

02/10/2015 Admin. Administrative filing of billing records 0:0602/11/2015 Meeting Team meeting re status and strategy 0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 020


02/17/2015 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared extended datefor defense to response to all of discovery

0:06

03/05/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0603/12/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re courtesy copies. 0:0603/13/2015 Court Filing Filed joint case management conference and serve

of courtesy copies.1:12

03/19/2015 Download & Save Download and Save ECF Johnson's signature formemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/20/2015 Draft and Edit Drafted, reviewed and edited and sent letter todefense counsel re memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:54

03/20/2015 Revise Revise letter to defense counsel re memorandumof understanding and send.

1:30

03/23/2015 Download & Save Download and Save ECF 45, file and calendarrelated dates.

0:48

03/24/2015 Download & Save Download and Save fully executed Memorandumof Understanding on internal office database

0:06

03/30/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0604/08/2015 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared all

memorandum of understanding dates.0:24

04/15/2015 Download & Save Download and Save ECF #46 and 46.1, print andfile

0:12

04/15/2015 Correspondence Correspond with R. Polk re Marshall Lurtz'sleaving.

0:12

04/15/2015 Case Management /Filing

Prepare and file notice of withdrawal of M. Lurtz 0:48

04/15/2015 Meeting Meeting with Sr re: edits to settlement agreement. 0:0604/16/2015 Edit Insert edits using tack changes to draft settlement

agreement.1:42

04/20/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:06Total for Katharine Scott 8:48Marshall Lurtz

09/23/2014 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0610/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:02 PMregarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:06 PMregarding case management conference.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Goodman dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:10 PMregarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:07 PMregarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:04 PM regardingorder on stipulation.

0:06

10/15/2014 Review Review pleadings and discovery 3:0010/20/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Mon 10/20/2014 5:10 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

10/20/2014 Draft Draft discovery. Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatoriesto Defendant, Plaintiff's First Set of Requests forProduction of Documents to Defendant, andPlaintiff's First Set of Requests for Admission toDefendant.

3:48

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 021


10/20/2014 Draft Draft Discovery. Plaintiff's First Set ofInterrogatories to Defendant, Plaintiff's First Set ofRequests for Production of Documents toDefendant, and Plaintiff's First Set of Requests forAdmission to Defendant.

2:48

10/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 10/21/2014 2:49 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

10/22/2014 Email Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 10/22/20149:10 AM regarding discovery.

0:06


Telephone conference team meeting re status andstrategy

0:06

10/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 10/22/2014 10:26 AMregarding discovery.

0:06

10/22/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR re discovery. 0:0610/22/2014 Edit Make corrections and finalize discovery 1:0010/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resende dated Thu 10/23/2014 10:45 AMregarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/23/2014 2:12 PMregarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 10/23/20148:58 AM regarding case management conferencestatement.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/23/2014 10:18 AMregarding case management conference.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 10/23/2014 12:30 PM regardingjoint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy. 0:2410/23/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with SR re CaseManagement Conference Statement

0:06

10/23/2014 Draft Draft email to defendant's counsel with amendedcase management statement report

0:48

10/23/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR to discuss 0:1810/23/2014 Draft and Edit Review and correct Case Management

Conference Statement and 26(f) report0:30

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 10/23/2014 10:42 AM regardingconference call.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 10/23/20142:01 PM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Thu 10/23/2014 3:40PM regarding rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 10/23/20142:20 PM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Thu 10/23/2014 3:37PM regarding rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:48 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 10/24/201410:49 AM regarding case managementconference.

0:06



Resendes dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:54 AMregarding order.

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:37 AM regarding jointstipulation.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:45 AMregarding case management conference.

0:06


0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 10/24/201410:42 AM regarding joint stipulation.

0:06

10/24/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR re Case Management Conference 0:1210/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 10/24/2014 11:41 AMregarding case management statement.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:44 AMregarding proposed order.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 10/24/2014 9:07 AM regarding rule26(f) report.

0:06

10/28/2014 Meeting Meeting with AB and SR re Case ManagementConference and strategy.

0:06

10/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 10/28/2014 2:23 PMregarding notice of appearance.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


Telephone conference with Defendant's counsel rewithdraw stipulation

0:18

10/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 10/28/20142:18 PM regarding notice of appearance.

0:06


Telephone conference with SR re strategy. 0:06


0:06

10/30/2014 Finalize Finalize discovery to serve at hearing 3:3010/30/2014 Travel Travel to San Francisco for 10/31/14 Case

Management Conference.3:00

10/30/2014 Preparation Prepare for hearingMeet with SR re: strategy

1:48

10/30/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy 0:1210/31/2014 Travel Travel to Case Management Conference. 0:3010/31/2014 Hearing Court appearance for Triple Leaf Tea re: Case

Management Conference.0:48

10/31/2014 Preparation Prepare for hearing 2:3010/31/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 10/31/2014 2:53 PM regarding case0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 023


management conference.11/02/2014 Travel Travel from San Francisco Case Management

Conference back to San Diego3:00

11/03/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Mon 11/3/2014 8:05AM regarding case management conference.

0:06

11/03/2014 Draft Draft 26(a)(1) disclosures 2:4811/13/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR and RM re mediation 0:0611/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Tue 11/18/2014 9:51 AMregarding proposed mediators.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 11/18/2014 2:37 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 11/18/20148:51 AM regarding mediation and discovery.

0:06


0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 11/21/2014 10:28 AMregarding sales data.

0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 11/21/2014 11:46 AM regarding order onstipulation.

0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 11/21/2014 12:20 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 11/21/2014 8:24 AM regardingmediation.

0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 11/21/2014 11:02 AM regardingstatus conference.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Tue 11/25/2014 2:35PM regarding discovery requests.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 11/25/2014 10:36 AM regardingdiscovery requests.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 11/25/201411:30 AM regarding sales data.

0:06

11/25/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy. 0:0611/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 11/26/2014 3:34 PMregarding mediator's fees.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 11/26/2014 4:18 PMregarding mediation agreement.

0:06


0:06

11/26/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 11/26/20141:11 PM regarding mediator's fees.

0:06

12/03/2014 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0612/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Tue 12/9/2014 11:37 AM regardingselected discovery requests.

0:06

12/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Tue 12/23/2014 4:05 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 024


Fed Ex delivery.01/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Marron dated Sun 1/4/2015 10:25 AM regardingselected discovery requests.

0:06

01/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Sun 1/4/2015 4:27 AM regardingselected discovery requests.

0:06

01/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Sun 1/4/2015 10:25 AM regardingselected discovery requests.

0:06


0:06


0:06

01/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/6/2015 12:18 PM regardingmeet and confer.

0:06

01/07/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy 0:0601/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Marron dated Fri 1/9/2015 3:45 PM regarding meetand confer.

0:06

01/09/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy. 0:1201/09/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 1/9/2015 2:02

PM regarding meet and confer.0:06


0:06

01/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to T. Pham and S. Vogel on Mon1/12/2015 4:10 PM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/12/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re discovery. 0:0601/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Mon 1/12/2015 2:15 PMregarding interrogatories.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 1/12/2015 4:09 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Mon 1/12/20152:10 PM regarding interrogatories.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Vogel on Mon 1/12/2015 3:34PM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Mon 1/12/20152:16 PM regarding interrogatories.

0:06

01/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 1/13/2015 12:14 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML1 and SR re defense financials 0:2401/14/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy and documents

produced.0:30

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Wed 1/14/201510:48 AM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 1/14/2015 1:08 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 1/14/2015 9:00 AM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 1/14/2015 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 025


3:30 PM regarding draft to counsel.01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 1/14/2015 10:49 AMregarding discovery.

0:06


0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:48 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:31 PMregarding draft to counsel.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 1/14/201511:57 AM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Wed 1/14/2015 3:42PM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 1/14/20152:40 PM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron onWed 1/14/2015 3:27 PM regarding draft to counsel.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 1/14/201510:50 AM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 1/14/2015 12:05 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 1/14/2015 11:01 AMregarding discovery.

0:06


0:06

01/15/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re discovery. 0:0601/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Tue 1/20/2015 5:44 PM regardingdraft mediation brief.

0:06

01/21/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re mediation brief and strategy 0:2401/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 1/21/2015 10:38 AMregarding mediation.

0:06

01/21/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Wed 1/21/20158:34 AM regarding mediation brief.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:54 PMregarding memorandum of understandings.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Thu 1/22/2015 12:08PM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 1/22/2015 11:15 AMregarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Thu 1/22/2015 12:13PM regarding hearing.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 1/22/201512:55 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstandings.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:15 PMregarding mediation.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 026


01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 1/22/2015 3:10 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:09 PM regardinginformation.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron on Fri1/23/2015 2:54 PM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron on Fri1/23/2015 2:04 PM regarding mediation brief.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 1/23/2015 2:17 PM regardingmediation brief.

0:06

01/23/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0601/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 1/23/2015 2:57 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/25/2015 Draft Drafted, Edited, Revised Mediation Brief. 2:3001/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR and RM re labels, sales and

mediation strategy0:12

01/26/2015 Draft and Edit Drafted, reviewed and edited mediation brief. 8:3001/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy and mediation brief. 0:2401/27/2015 Finalize Finalize mediation brief, collected exhibits 2:0001/27/2015 Finalize Finalize mediation brief, collected exhibits and

send out1:30

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/27/2015 11:59 AMregarding documents.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Houchin dated Tue 1/27/2015 1:23 PM regardingtable of exhibits.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and S. Resendes onTue 1/27/2015 9:52 AM regarding data.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/27/2015 5:03 PM regardingdelivery.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/27/2015 10:34 AMregarding sales figures.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Houchin on Tue 1/27/2015 1:18PM regarding exhibits.

0:06

01/27/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR and RM re third party liability 0:0601/27/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re settlement strategy and sample

memorandum of understanding.0:30

01/27/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 1/27/201510:38 AM regarding documents.

0:06

01/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 1/28/2015 10:29 AMregarding deliveries.

0:06

01/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Wed 1/28/2015 9:51 AM regardingdeliveries.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Mon 2/2/20151:42 PM regarding mediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Mon 2/2/20152:13 PM regarding mediation/settlement.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Mon 2/2/2015 2:50 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 027


mediation.02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Mon 2/2/2015 2:36 PM

regarding mediation.0:06

02/02/2015 Meeting Premediation strategy meeting with SR 0:4802/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Mon 2/2/2015 2:16 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 2/2/2015 2:01 PM regardingmediation/settlement.

0:06

02/02/2015 Preparation Prepare for mediation: strategy, documents, reviewletter, exhibits.

0:30


3:00

02/02/2015 Travel Travel to San Francisco for mediation on 2/3/2015 3:1802/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Mon 2/2/2015 9:24 AM regardingstipulation.

0:06


2:18

02/03/2015 Travel Travel home from mediation 3:3002/03/2015 Travel Travel to mediation 0:1802/03/2015 Preparation Prepare for mediation 1:1802/03/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with SR re mediation status 0:12


Telephone conference with SR 0:06

02/03/2015 Mediation Mediation 6:0002/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.

Stouffer dated Tue 2/3/2015 12:04 PM regardingupdated lodestar.

0:06

02/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 2/3/2015 8:08 AM regardinglodestar.

0:06

02/04/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re outcome of mediation 0:1202/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.

Deang dated Fri 2/6/2015 9:48 AM regarding letterto Mr. Marron.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/6/2015 10:11 AM regardinglabel changes.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 2/6/2015 10:01 AM regardingcorrespondence.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 2/6/201510:07 AM regarding letter to Mr. Marron.

0:06

02/06/2015 Review Review defense settlement offer, reply and strategymeeting

1:00

02/11/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0602/11/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with defense counsel tablediscovery pending counter proposal coordination

0:18

02/13/2015 Review Review defense's counter settlement offer andemail to SR/RM re strategy

0:48

02/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron senton Fri 2/13/2015 9:32 AM regarding settlementoffer.

0:06



Resendes dated Fri 2/13/2015 1:07 PM regardingsettlement.

02/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 2/13/2015 8:01 AM regardingcorrespondence.

0:06

02/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/13/2015 10:57 AM regardingsettlement offer.

0:06

02/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 2/13/2015 11:36 AM regardingdamages release.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 2/16/2015 1:36 PMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 2/16/2015 8:35 AMregarding offer.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 2/16/2015 8:04 AMregarding offer.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Mon 2/16/2015 1:31 AM regardingattorney's fees.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon2/16/2015 8:38 AM regarding offer.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 2/16/2015 2:37 PMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 2/16/2015 1:50 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06

02/16/2015 Review Review latest offer/communicate counteroffer toopposing counsel

0:30

02/16/2015 Meeting Strategy meeting with SR 0:1802/16/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with SR re strategy 0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/18/2015 10:47 AMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Cominos dated Wed 2/18/2015 8:55 AM regardingsettlement communication.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron senton Wed 2/18/2015 11:01 AM regarding settlement.

0:06

02/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re memorandum of understandingterms

0:12

02/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 2/19/2015 10:27 AMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/19/2015 Draft Draft memorandum of understanding 2:3002/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 2/20/2015 3:10 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 2/20/2015 2:34 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 2/20/2015 8:05 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 029


02/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 2/20/201512:11 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding draft.

0:06


0:06

02/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 2/20/201512:45 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding draft.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/20/2015 12:07 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Polk and SR 0:12

02/20/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re memorandum ofunderstanding, discovery and strategy

0:18


Telephone conference with Defense's counsel re:settlement and discovery

0:30

02/20/2015 Draft Draft memorandum of understanding 4:0002/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron sent

on Fri 2/20/2015 12:04 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06


0:06


0:06

02/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed2/25/2015 11:42 AM regarding injunctive relief.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:42 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed2/25/2015 2:24 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

02/25/2015 Finalize Amend and finalize memorandum ofunderstanding for submission to Defense.

1:00

02/25/2015 Meeting Amend memorandum of understanding again afterstrategy meeting with SR for submission toDefense.

1:30

02/25/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re terms of memorandum ofunderstanding

0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:13 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re memorandum of understandingand upcoming hearing

0:12

02/26/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Thu 2/26/201510:32 AM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06


Telephone conference with opposing counsel meeting with SRSent email to Defense counsel with initial draft ofthe memorandum of understanding.

0:30

03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 3/4/2015 9:18 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 030


03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 3/4/2015 9:20 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 3/4/2015 3:52 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/05/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0603/10/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR 0:0603/10/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re timing and case management

conference and conversation with R. Polk0:18

03/11/2015 Review and Analysis Reviewed and analyzed the changes to thememorandum of understanding and make edits.

0:48

03/11/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:28 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06


0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 3/11/2015 12:20 PM regardingrevised memorandum.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:09 PM regardingnotice expense.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 3/11/2015 3:13 PMregarding waiver of damages.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed3/11/2015 1:03 PM regarding injunctive relief.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron sent on Wed 3/11/20151:22 PM regarding redlined edits.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed3/11/2015 3:17 PM regarding waiver.

0:06


0:06

03/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed3/11/2015 3:07 PM regarding settlement approval.

0:06


0:06

03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 3/12/2015 1:29 PM regardingdocuments.

0:06


0:06

03/12/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re case management conferenceand strategy

0:06

03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/12/2015 10:45 AM regardingredlines.

0:06

03/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and R. Marron senton Thu 3/12/2015 11:12 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/12/2015 Review Review memorandum of understanding and 1:30EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 031


changes thererto. Email to opposing counsel andphone call with opposing counsel re memorandumof understanding, hearing and case managementconference statement.

03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/12/2015 9:18 AM regarding edits.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 3/13/2015 9:57AM regarding joint case management conferencestatement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/13/2015 1:35 PM regardingcase management statement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Draft Draft joint case management settlement statementand file case management settlement statement.

3:30


Telephone conference with opposing counsel. 1:30

03/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott and S. Resendes sent onFri 3/13/2015 3:04 PM regarding joint casemanagement statement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 3/13/2015 2:05PM regarding joint rule 26(f).

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/13/2015 4:32 PM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06


0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 3/13/2015 9:58 AM regardinghearing.

0:06

03/13/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes to edit joint casemanagement conference statement.

0:18

03/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to Marshall Lurtz sent on Fri3/13/2015 1:12 PM regarding case managementstatement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/13/2015 4:44 PM regardingresponse.

0:06


0:06

03/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 3/13/20151:57 PM regarding joint 26(f).

0:06

03/16/2015 Research Case research concerning waiver of damages insettlement

1:00

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and S. Resendes senton Mon 3/16/2015 9:22 AM regarding notice plan.

0:06

03/16/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re settlement terms and case lawon certification under various 23(b) classes.

0:12

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:16 AMregarding notice plan.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:34 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon3/16/2015 9:39 AM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06



Resendes dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:18 AMregarding notice plan.

03/16/2015 Review Review memorandum of understanding. 1:0003/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 3/18/2015

1:41 PM regarding memorandum of understanding.0:06

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Thu3/19/2015 11:35 AM regarding understanding.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 3/19/2015 11:47 AMregarding understanding.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Thu3/19/2015 2:46 PM regarding letter.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Thu3/19/2015 10:45 AM regarding settlement.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 3/19/2015 6:03 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06


0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:54 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re case management conferencestrategy phone call with client and scheduling.

0:12

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:44 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR and RM 0:0603/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:35 AM regardingmembers in class.

0:06


0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR 0:0603/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from T.

Pham dated Thu 3/19/2015 9:21 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re additional modifications tomemorandum of understanding.

0:12

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Thu3/19/2015 11:40 AM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06


0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:07 PM regarding coverletter.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:26 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:59 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 033


final letter.03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:00 PM regardingcover letter.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:04 PM regardingsignature pages.

0:06


0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 12:57 PM regardingcover letter.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 2:26 PM regarding coverletter and memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:39 PM regarding letterto counsel re: memorandum of understanding.

0:06


0:06


Telephone conference with SR re casemanagement conference hearing.

0:12


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:59 PM regardingcover letter.

0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:38 PM regardingcover letter.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

03/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 3/24/2015 9:43 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/25/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes RE: Status and Strategy. 0:0603/30/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0603/30/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from KS

dated Mon 3/30/2015 5:40 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/31/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Tue 3/31/20154:13 PM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06



Resendes dated Thu 4/2/2015 11:53 AM regardingnotice plan.

04/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Thu 4/2/2015 2:10 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding dates.

0:06

04/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/2/2015 2:12 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

04/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/2/2015 2:08 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding dates.

0:06

04/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Mon 4/6/201510:29 AM regarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/06/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re notice and strategy 0:1204/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 4/8/2015 9:42 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding dates.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed4/8/2015 9:45 AM regarding initial draft.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/8/2015 9:49 AM regardingmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott sent on Wed 4/8/20159:52 AM regarding initial draft.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/8/2015 9:32 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

04/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 4/14/2015 7:31 AM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

Total for Marshall Lurtz 120:42Noemi Perez Lara

04/03/2014 Preparation Prepare civil complaint form/download from courtwebsite

0:06

04/03/2014 Download & Save Download and save fillable Summons 0:0604/03/2014 Conference Confer with Kas re: filing of complaint and prepping

case initiating paperwork0:06

04/03/2014 Preparation Prepare Civil Case Cover Sheet 0:1204/03/2014 Email Email inhouse counsel Complaint draft for review 0:0604/03/2014 Preparation Prepare Summons 0:0604/04/2014 Telephone

ConferenceAttempted telephone conference with courtregarding the refiling of a proposed summons

0:06

04/04/2014 Court Filing Complaint; filing, finalizing, adding exhibits. 1:3004/07/2014 Email Email Kas with request to open file in Deadlines 0:0604/07/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF dkt 3 0:0604/07/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared / Open new

case with Kas's instruction0:06

04/07/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared filing date 0:0604/07/2014 Finalize Fill in Summons with Defendant's information and

finalize to pdf.0:12

04/07/2014 Court Filing File proposed summons 0:0604/07/2014 Download & Save Download and save ECF standing orders 0:1204/16/2014 Email Email Skye regarding how we are serving

summons and complaint0:06

04/16/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared dkt 5 withadditional information regarding order setting case

0:12

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 035


management conference and ADR details04/17/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared dkt. 5 order

setting case management conference and ADRdetails

0:18

04/17/2014 Draft and Edit Drafted, reviewed and edited email withinstructions from process server on how to serveTriple Leaf

0:12


Telephone conference with Tiffany regardingbilling for services

0:06

04/17/2014 Download & Save Download and save consent/declaration ofMagistrate Judge form, prepare form and email it toSkye and Ron for review

0:18


Telephone conference with process serverregarding service of complaint

0:12

04/18/2014 Correspondence Read and respond to email from Skye informingher of telephone conference with process server

0:06


Telephone conference with process serverregarding adding declaration of Magistrate Judgeregarding order for service

0:06

04/21/2014 Review and Analysis Reviewed and analyzed/responded to email fromprocess server attaching additional documents

0:06

04/21/2014 Email Email process server regarding additionaldocuments Magistrate consent/Declaration form

0:06

04/21/2014 Finalize Finalize Magistrate declaration form and changedate

0:06

04/25/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared dkt. 7 Notice ofDeadline to file notice of consent/Declaration ofMagistrate judge.

0:06


Telephone conference with process serverregarding an update on whether the summons wasserved

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Email Skye and Ron regarding Status of Proof ofService of Summons and Complaint

0:06

04/28/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared Service ofSummons

0:06

04/29/2014 Admin. Email Skye regarding whether to attach proof asattachment onto delineation form.

0:06

04/29/2014 Admin. File magistrate delineation form. 0:0604/29/2014 Preparation Prepare proof of service of summons face page. 0:2404/29/2014 Preparation Prepare courtesy copies of declaration with "JCS

Chambers Copy"0:12

04/29/2014 Research Research courtesy copies Magistrate's standingorder

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Email Skye regarding the Magistrate's standingorder on courtesy copies

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Email Amanda information for courtesy copies 0:0604/29/2014 Admin. File proof of service of summons. 0:0605/06/2014 Serve Send order regarding case management

conference0:06


Telephone conference with process server 0:06

05/06/2014 Mail Received and processed service of casemanagement conference order of Defendant's withSkye

0:06

05/13/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared / change time ofcase management conference (Dkt. 12)

0:06

05/15/2014 Preparation Prepare face page for proof of service of orders 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 036


05/15/2014 Finalize Finalize and combine and sanitize 0:0605/15/2014 Court Filing File with N.D. CAC 0:0605/19/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared dkt 15 order

granting defendant's Motion to Dismiss0:12

06/02/2014 Deadlines Calculated deadlines / calendared dkt. 19 ordergranting joint stipulation

0:12

06/04/2014 Admin. Add dial in for telephonic conference call 0:06Total for Noemi Perez Lara 7:54Ronald A. Marron

01/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 1/9/2014 2:05 PM regardingproduct.

0:06

01/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Hill dated Thu 1/9/2014 10:17 AM regarding TripleLeaf Product.

0:06

01/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to P. Hill on Fri 1/24/2014 7:42 AMregarding Triple Leaf Tea.

0:06

01/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Hill dated Fri 1/24/2014 7:31 AM regarding TripleLeaf Tea.

0:06

01/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 1/24/2014 8:11 AM regardingTriple Leaf Tea.

0:06

01/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Fri 1/24/2014 8:57 AM regardingTriple Leaf Tea.

0:06

01/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Hill dated Mon 1/27/2014 8:40 PM regarding TripleLeaf Tea.

0:06

01/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Tue 1/28/2014 11:42 AM regardingretainer.

0:06

01/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Tue 1/28/2014 11:32 AM regardingTriple Leaf Tea retainer.

0:06

01/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/28/2014 11:37 AMregarding retainer.

0:06

01/31/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisnr dated Fri 1/31/2014 10:53 AM regardingTriple Leaf Tea.

0:06

02/06/2014 Review Review defense settlement offer. 0:3002/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.

Eisnerr dated Mon 2/10/2014 10:13 AM regardingretainer agreement.

0:06

02/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Hill dated Mon 2/10/2014 8:47 PM regarding CLRAletter.

0:06

02/10/2014 Email to Drafted email to D. Eisner on Mon 2/10/2014 10:49AM regarding retainer agreement.

0:06

02/13/2014 Review Reviewed and analyzed defense's counter offer. 0:3002/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.

Eisner dated Fri 2/14/2014 9:24 AM regardinginformation.

0:06

02/16/2014 Review Review latest counter offer. 0:1202/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.

Hill dated Wed 2/19/2014 4:36 PM regarding CLRA0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 037


letter.02/19/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes, D. Eisner, K.

Gallucci, and A. Wood on Wed 2/19/2014 4:41 PMregarding CLRA letter.

0:06

02/19/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes, D. Eisner, K.Gallucci, and A. Wood on Wed 2/19/2014 4:41 PMregarding CLRA letter.

0:06


0:06

03/27/2014 Review Review letter from defendant's attorneys. 0:1204/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.

Hill dated Tue 4/1/2014 9:15 PM regarding CLRAletter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:12 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Thu 4/3/20143:37 AM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci on Thu 4/3/2014 9:15PM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06


0:06


Telephone conference with S. Resendes re:complaint.

0:06

04/04/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: edits to complaint. 0:1204/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 4/4/2014 11:04

AM regarding CLRA letter draft.0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 4/4/2014 4:46 PM regarding complaint.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 4/4/2014 4:51 PM regarding proposedsummons.

0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/4/2014 2:35 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Fri 4/4/2014 9:40 AM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 4/4/2014 11:06AM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06


0:06


0:06



Resendes dated Fri 4/4/2014 2:35 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

04/07/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Mon 4/7/2014 7:37 AM regarding caseassignment.

0:06

04/07/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Mon 4/7/2014 9:59 AM regarding proposedsummons.

0:06

04/08/2014 Review Review court orders filed today. 0:1804/08/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: magistrate judge. 0:0604/08/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Tue 4/8/2014 11:52 AM regarding summonsissued.

0:06

04/08/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/8/2014 11:47 AM regarding initial casemanagement scheduling order.

0:06

04/09/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: status and strategy. 0:0604/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 4/16/2014 4:32 PMregarding initial case management schedulingorder.

0:06

04/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/16/2014 12:41 PMregarding initial case management schedulingorder.

0:06

04/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Wed 4/16/2014 4:29 PMregarding initial case management schedulingorder.

0:06

04/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Thu 4/17/2014 12:30 PMregarding initial case management schedulingorder.

0:06

04/17/2014 Review Review declination of magistrate judge. 0:0604/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Thu 4/17/2014 3:41 PM regardingdeclination.

0:06

04/17/2014 Review Review all standing orders in case. 0:1204/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.

Perez Lara dated Thu 4/17/2014 4:38 PMregarding declination form.

0:06

04/17/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: strategy. 0:0604/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:49 PM regarding0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 039


proof of service.04/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Fri 4/18/2014 4:53 PM regardingdocument.

0:06

04/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:58 PM regardingdocument.

0:06

04/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:41 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

04/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:43 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

04/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:16 PM regardingnotice of appearance.

0:06

04/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Mon 4/21/2014 10:03 AMregarding documents.

0:06

04/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 4/21/2014 9:58 AMregarding additional document.

0:06


Telephone conference with S. Resendes re: statusand strategy.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Fri 4/25/2014 1:27 PM regardingclerk's notice.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Fri 4/25/2014 2:33 PM regardingservice on Triple Leaf.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 4/25/2014 12:46 PM regarding clerk'snotice re: consent or declination.

0:06


Telephone conference with S. Resendes. 0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/25/2014 4:17 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/25/2014 12:49 PM regardingclerk's notice re: consent or declination.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/29/2014 2:16 PM regarding summons.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/29/2014 2:32 PM regardingdeclination.

0:06


0:06

04/30/2014 Review Research regarding newly assigned JudgeChesney.

0:12


0:06

04/30/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: J. Chesney. 0:0604/30/2014 Review Review newly assigned Judge Chesney. 0:1205/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Thu 5/1/2014 11:48 AM regarding casemanagement scheduling order.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 040


05/07/2014 Review Review letter to client re: deposition. 0:0605/07/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from C.

Balot dated Wed 5/7/2014 3:12 PM regarding ESI.0:12

05/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/15/2014 10:59 AM regardingcertificate of service.

0:06

05/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/16/2014 3:09 PM regarding proposedorder.

0:06


0:06

05/16/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 5/16/2014 2:28PM regarding motion to dismiss.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Wed 5/28/2014 3:39 PMregarding proposed order.

0:06


0:06

05/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/29/2014 11:57 AM regarding ordergranting joint stipulation to extend briefingschedule.

0:06

05/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/29/2014 12:05 PM regarding hearings.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 6/18/2014 5:52 PM regarding responseto motion.

0:06

06/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/27/2014 3:56 PM regarding reply toopposition/response.

0:06


Telephone conference with S. Resendes re:strategy.

0:06


0:06

07/14/2014 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes, A. Wood, and K.Gallucci re: status and strategy.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 7/14/2014 1:59 PMregarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 7/14/2014 2:06 PM regarding jointcase management conference statement.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 7/14/2014 12:24 PMregarding telephonic appearance.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Mon 7/14/2014 11:37 AM regardingtelephonic appearance.

0:06

07/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 7/15/2014 11:04 AM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 041


stipulation.07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 7/18/2014 2:36 PM regarding ADRcertification.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 4:27 PM regarding ordervacating hearing.

0:06


0:06


0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Deang dated Fri 7/18/2014 4:03 PM regardinginitial disclosure.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 1:01 PM regarding notice.

0:06

07/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Mon 7/21/2014 11:00 AM regardinghearings.

0:06

08/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 8/15/2014 2:19 PM regarding stipulationwith proposed order.

0:06

09/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/2/2014 9:36 AM regarding ordergranting joint stipulation for plaintiff's counsel.

0:06


0:06

09/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/9/2014 10:54 AM regarding casemanagement conference.

0:06

09/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/23/2014 12:25 PM regarding order onmotion to dismiss.

0:06

09/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 9/24/2014 3:44 PMregarding order on motion to dismiss.

0:06

10/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/2/2014 4:07 PM regardingpossible settlement.

0:06

10/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Thu 10/2/2014 4:10 PM regardingpossible settlement.

0:06

10/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/3/2014 9:50 AM regardingpossible settlement.

0:06

10/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/3/2014 4:15 PM regardingconference call.

0:06

10/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 10/3/2014 5:29 PM regardingconference call.

0:06

10/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 10/6/2014 9:34 AMregarding conference call.

0:06

10/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 10/6/2014 10:03 AM

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 042


regarding conference call.10/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Tue 10/14/2014

5:54 PM regarding conference call.0:06


0:06

10/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 10/15/2014 1:16 PM regardingterminate hearings.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/23/2014 10:18 AMregarding case management conference.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 10/23/2014 10:42 AM regardingtelephonic appearance.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/23/2014 11:18 AMregarding protective order.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Thu 10/23/201412:27 PM regarding protective order.

0:06


0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 10/23/2014 9:18 AM regardingstipulated protective order.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 10/23/2014 12:33 PMregarding protective order.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:37 AM regarding jointstipulation to appear by telephone.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes on Fri 10/24/201411:04 AM regarding proposed order.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:48 AM regardingproposed order.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/24/2014 11:42 AM regardingstipulation.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:45 AMregarding proposed order.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/24/2014 11:36 AM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

10/27/2014 Meeting Meeting with SR re strategy 0:0610/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Tue 10/28/2014 3:51 PM regarding motion towithdraw.

0:06


0:06


0:06


Telephone conference with SR re strategy 0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 043



0:06


0:06

10/31/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Andrews dated Thu 11/13/2014 1:32 PM regardingdepositions.

0:06

11/13/2014 Meeting Meeting wit SR and M. Lurtz re mediation 0:0611/13/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes and Marshall Lurtz

sent on Thu 11/13/2014 2:03 PM regarding casestatus.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 11/18/2014 8:51 AMregarding mediation and discovery.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 11/18/2014 9:51 AMregarding proposed mediators.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue11/18/2014 2:37 PM regarding proposedmediation.

0:06


0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 11/21/2014 11:02 AM regardingstatus conference.

0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 11/21/2014 8:24 AM regardingmediation.

0:06

11/21/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 11/21/201412:20 PM regarding merits and sales.

0:06


0:06

11/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 11/21/2014 12:28 PM regardingJudge Sabraw.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 11/25/2014 10:48 AMregarding discovery requests.

0:06


0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 11/25/2014 2:35 PMregarding discovery requests.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 11/25/2014 11:30 AMregarding requests to defendant's counsel.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 11/25/2014 1:07 PMregarding edits.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from C.Johnson dated Tue 11/25/2014 3:08 PM regardingfee agreement.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 11/25/2014 12:17 PM

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 044


regarding questions regarding label.11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 11/26/2014 3:34 PMregarding mediator's fees.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 11/26/2014 4:18 PMregarding mediation agreement.

0:06




0:06


0:06

12/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Tue 12/23/2014 4:05 PM regardingFedex delivery.

0:06

12/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 12/23/2014 4:58 PMregarding Fedex delivery.

0:06

01/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Sun 1/4/201510:25 AM regarding discovery requests.

0:06

01/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Sun 1/4/2015 7:35 AM regardingdiscovery requests.

0:06

01/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Sun 1/4/2015 4:27AM regarding discovery requests.

0:06


0:06


0:06

01/05/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re documents produced andstrategy

0:18

01/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/6/2015 12:18 PM regardingmeet and confer.

0:06


0:06


Telephone conference with SR re strategy. 0:06

01/09/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 1/9/20153:45 PM regarding meet and confer.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 1/12/2015 2:10 PMregarding request(s) for interrogatorie(s).

0:06

01/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 1/12/2015 4:09 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 1/12/2015 2:15 PMregarding request(s) for interrogatorie(s).

0:06


0:06



Resendes dated Wed 1/14/2015 1:08 PMregarding discovery.

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to Marshall Lurtz sent on Wed1/14/2015 9:00 AM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:42 PMregarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:27 PMregarding draft to counsel.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to Marshall Lurtz sent on Wed1/14/2015 3:48 PM regarding discovery.

0:06


0:06

01/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/20/2015 9:22 AM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Peterson dated Tue 1/20/2015 5:18 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/20/2015 5:44 PM regardingmediation brief.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 1/22/2015 11:15 AMregarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:07 PMregarding documents.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:08 PMregarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:09 PM regardingdocuments.

0:06


0:06

01/22/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re mediation 0:0601/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.

Peterson dated Thu 1/22/2015 5:02 PM regardingmediation.

0:06


0:06

01/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Fri 1/23/2015 2:04 PMregarding mediation brief.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Fri 1/23/2015 2:54 PMregarding mediation.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 1/23/2015 2:57 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 1/23/2015 2:17 PM regardingmediation brief.

0:06

01/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with Sr re mediation 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 046


01/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR and M. Lurtz re labels, sales andmediation strategy

0:12

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 1/27/2015 10:34 AMregarding labeling.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 1/27/2015 9:52 AMregarding data and request(s) for interrogatorie(s).

0:06

01/27/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR and M. Lurtz re third party liability 0:0601/28/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re mediation 0:1202/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Mon 2/2/2015 9:24 AM regardingagreements.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Stouffer dated Mon 2/2/2015 8:43 PM regardinglodestar.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Stouffer sent on Mon 2/2/20159:06 PM regarding lodestar.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Mon 2/2/2015 2:50 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re loadstar 0:0602/02/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re settlement strategy 0:0602/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.

Stouffer dated Tue 2/3/2015 12:04 PM regardingupdated lodestar and expenses.

0:06




Telephone conference with SR re mediation status 0:12

02/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Cominos dated Fri 2/6/2015 12:07 PM regardingcounter proposal.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/6/2015 10:11 AM regardingoffer.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Deang dated Fri 2/6/2015 9:48 AM regardingcorrespondence.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Deang sent on Fri 2/6/201510:01 AM regarding correspondence.

0:06

02/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to D. Cominos sent on Sun 2/8/20156:50 PM regarding settlement.

0:06



0:06

02/13/2015 Review Review letter from defense. 0:0602/13/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with SR re strategy 0:12

02/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 2/13/201511:36 AM regarding damages.

0:06

02/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/13/2015 10:57 AM regardingsettlement offer.

0:06

02/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/13/2015 1:07 PM regardingdamages release.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 2/16/2015 8:35 AM

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 047


regarding attorney's fees.


0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 2/16/2015 8:04 AMregarding attorney's fees.

0:06


0:06

02/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon2/16/2015 1:31 AM regarding fees and costs.

0:06

02/17/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue2/17/2015 4:55 PM regarding release of damages.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/18/2015 4:17 PMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 2/18/2015 11:01 AMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed2/18/2015 3:49 PM regarding release of damages.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Cominos dated Wed 2/18/2015 8:55 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/18/2015 10:47 AMregarding settlement.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/18/2015 12:10 PMregarding settlement.

0:06


0:06

02/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Fri 2/20/20152:34 PM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Fri 2/20/2015 12:04 PMregarding memorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/20/2015 12:37 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06


0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 2/20/2015 8:05 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06


0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 2/20/2015 12:07 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Fri 2/20/2015 12:11 PMregarding memorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

02/24/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR 0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 048


02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:42 AMregarding injunctive relief.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:13 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:42 AMregarding injunctive relief.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 2/25/2015 2:24 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/26/2015 Review Review edited memorandum of understanding. 0:1202/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from

Marshall Lurtz dated Thu 2/26/2015 10:32 AMregarding memorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 3/4/2015 9:18 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 3/4/2015 9:20 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 3/4/2015 3:52 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding revised.

0:06

03/11/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR re memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:12


0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:22 PMregarding notice expense.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:03 PMregarding injunctive relief.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 3:17 PMregarding waiver of damages.

0:06


0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 3/11/2015 12:20 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to Marshall Lurtz sent on Wed3/11/2015 1:09 PM regarding notice expense.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 3:07 PMregarding settlement approval.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 049


03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/12/2015 9:18 AM regarding edits.

0:06

03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Thu 3/12/2015 11:12 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06


0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 2:05 PMregarding joint case management statement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from MLdated Fri 3/13/2015 9:57 AM regarding hearing.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 3:04 PMregarding joint case management statement.

0:06


0:06

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:34 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:16 AMregarding notice plan.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:22 AMregarding case status.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon3/16/2015 9:20 AM regarding notice plan

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue4/21/2015 4:23 PM regarding quote.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR and M. Lurtz 0:0603/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from r.

pOLK dated Thu 3/19/2015 9:21 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06


0:06


0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:47 AMregarding injunctive relief.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:22 AM

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 050


regarding settlement.

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:59 PM regardingfinal letter.

0:06


0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 2:26 PM regarding letterto counsel.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:59 PM regardingletter.

0:06

03/20/2015 Review Review revised letter to defense. 0:0603/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Tue 3/24/2015 9:43 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/24/2015 Meeting Meeting with SR 0:0603/31/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from

Marshall Lurtz dated Tue 3/31/2015 4:13 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

04/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 4/6/2015 10:29 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 4/14/2015 7:31 AM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/15/2015 2:51 PMregarding edits.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 4/15/2015 3:02 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 4/15/2015 2:34 PM regarding notice.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Wed 4/15/2015 3:00 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

04/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/16/2015 11:39 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/16/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: settlementagreement.

0:06

04/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 4/20/2015 2:50 PMregarding short form notice.

0:06

04/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 4/21/2015 4:23 PM regardingquote.

0:06


0:06

04/21/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue4/21/2015 7:37 PM regarding quote.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 051


Polk dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:33 AM regardingquote.

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:56 AMregarding quote.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:34 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:48 PMregarding quote.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:32 AMregarding notice provider.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:27 PM regardingsettlement estimate.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 7:24 AM regardingCAFA advertising.

0:06

04/23/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: notice. 0:0604/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:31 PM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

04/23/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: status of finalsettlement agreement.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:53 PM regardingCAFA notice.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 4/24/2015 1:16 PM regardingquote.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 4/24/2015 1:09 PM regardingproposal.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 4/24/2015 9:00 AM regarding finaldrafts.

0:06

04/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 4/27/2015 9:14 AM regardingproposal.

0:06

04/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 4/27/2015 11:15 AMregarding quote.

0:06

05/01/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/1/2015 2:40 PM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 8:15 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 11:59 AM regardingclient.

0:06


0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/4/2015 10:27 AMregarding notice provider.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 052


05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/4/2015 10:11 AMregarding final approval.

0:06

05/05/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/5/2015 4:30 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/05/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Tue 5/5/2015 4:28 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval hearings.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:02 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Wed 5/6/2015 12:44 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/06/2015 Review Review edits to settlement agreement. 0:1205/06/2015 Review Review draft of final approval order. 0:3605/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:17 PM regarding draftsettlement agreement.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:06 PM regardingdraft settlement agreement.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/8/2015 3:47 PM regardingproposed settlement agreement.

0:06


0:06

05/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/11/2015 1:13 PMregarding joint motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 5/12/2015 8:10 AM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 5/12/2015 7:59 AM regardingredlined edits.

0:06

05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 5/12/2015 8:35 AM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/12/2015 10:36 AMregarding proposed order.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/13/2015 9:17 AM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/13/2015 2:19 PM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R>Polk dated Wed 5/13/2015 10:18 AM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 5/14/2015 2:46 PM regardingjoint motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R>Polk dated Thu 5/14/2015 2:49 PM regarding jointmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 053


05/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 5/14/2015 2:45 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/15/2015 4:57 PM regarding motion forsettlement approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:37 PM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:46 PM regardingrevised document.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 4:21 PM regardingproposed order re: joint motion to file under seal.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:54 PM regardingdeclaration.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/15/2015 4:17 PM regarding motion tofile under seal.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:56 PM regardingsignatures.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Field dated Mon 5/18/2015 12:37 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 054


settlement.05/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Wed 5/20/2015 11:52 AMregarding CAFA notice.

0:06

05/20/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: press articles andsettlement agreement.

0:12

05/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/26/2015 10:04 AMregarding package.

0:06

05/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Mon 5/25/2015 2:32 PM regardingpackage.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Tue5/26/2015 11:03 AM regarding notice.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Tue 5/26/2015 10:40 AM regardingdocuments.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 5/26/2015 12:14 PMregarding notice.

0:06

06/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 6/3/2015 3:50 PM regarding ordergranting joint ex parte motion.

0:06

06/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/4/2015 10:35 AM regardingadministrative motion to file under seal.

0:06

06/09/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: strategy. 0:0606/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Thu 6/18/2015 1:44 PM regardingconference call.

0:06

06/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 6/18/2015 1:31 PM regardingconference call.

0:06


0:06

06/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Mon 6/22/2015 7:23 PM regardinginformation.

0:06

06/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 6/22/2015 7:03 PMregarding preliminary approval hearing.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Marron re: strategy. 0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:16 PM regardingquestions.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/23/2015 1:30 PM regardingpreliminary approval motion.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 6/23/2015 1:59 PM regarding motionhearing.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:53 PM regardingnotice.

0:06


0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 055



0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 8:57 AMregarding supplemental brief.

0:06


0:06


0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 1:18 PMregarding preliminary approval.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 1:12 PMregarding inquiry.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 10:07 AMregarding transcript.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 12:07 PMregarding preliminary approval.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 12:08 PMregarding final question.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed6/24/2015 12:49 PM regarding settlement.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 6/24/2015 2:47 PMregarding short notice.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/25/2015 2:18 PM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06


0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 6/25/2015 10:51 AMregarding notice.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 6/25/2015 10:57 AM regardingnotice.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Thu 6/25/2015 6:56 AM regarding notice.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/26/2015 4:58 PM regarding preliminaryapproval.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/26/2015 10:07 AM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 056


declaration.06/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Sun 6/28/2015 8:28 AM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

06/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Sun 6/28/2015 8:54 AM regarding noticeplan.

0:06

06/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Sun 6/28/2015 8:58 AM regardingnotices.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 6/29/2015 10:01 AMregarding revised notices.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Mon6/29/2015 10:55 AM regarding settlement.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Dye dated Mon 6/29/2015 9:01 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Resendes sent on Wed7/8/2015 2:05 PM regarding media approval andnotice plan documents.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 6/29/2015 10:56 AMregarding settlement.

0:06

07/01/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Cooper dated Wed 7/1/2015 4:45 PM regardingadministration.

0:06

07/02/2015 Review Review notice plan. 0:1207/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Resendes dated Thu 7/2/2015 2:28 PM regardingadministration.

0:06

07/02/2015 Review Review CAFA notice. 0:1207/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.

Carameros dated Tue 7/7/2015 12:59 PMregarding notice documents.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Wed 7/8/2015 11:30 AMregarding notice plan.

0:06


0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 7/8/2015 3:47 PM regardingnotice plan.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 7/8/2015 10:54 AMregarding media approval and notice plan

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 057


documents.07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.

Carameros dated Wed 7/8/2015 1:35 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06


0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Wed 7/8/2015 3:45 PM regardingnotice plan.

0:06


0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Fri 7/10/2015 2:43 PM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Fri 7/10/2015 2:53 PM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

08/14/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Resendes re: ex parte. 0:06Total for Ronald A. Marron 49:00Skye Resendes

01/09/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and P. Hill on Thu1/9/2014 2:04 PM regarding product pictures.

0:06

01/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Fri 1/24/2014 8:57 AM regardingproduct packaging.

0:06

01/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Tue 1/28/2014 11:32 AM regarding E.Johnson retainer agreement.

0:06

01/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to D. Eisner, A. Beamer, and N.Perez Lara on Tue 1/28/2014 11:37 AM regardingE. Johnson retainer agreement.

0:06

01/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Hill dated Thu 1/30/2014 1:53 PM regardingproduct packaging.

0:06

02/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Mon 2/10/2014 10:13 AM regardingretainer agreement.

0:06

02/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Hill dated Mon 2/10/2014 8:47 PM regarding CLRAletter.

0:06

02/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Mon 2/10/2014 10:49 AM regardingretainer agreement.

0:06

02/19/2014 Email to Drafted email to D. Eisner on Wed 2/19/2014 5:05PM regarding CLRA letter.

0:06

02/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Eisner dated Wed 2/19/2014 5:10 PM regardingCLRA letter.

0:06



0:06



02/21/2014 Review Review packaging claims. 0:1202/21/2014 Draft Draft CLRA letter. 0:4802/21/2014 Research Research re: Triple Leaf potential sales. 0:12EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 058


02/21/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer and N. Perez Lara onFri 2/21/2014 1:10 PM regarding CLRA letter.

0:06

02/21/2014 Edit Edit CLRA letter. 0:1203/27/2014 Review Review letter from defendant;s attorneys. 0:1204/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.

Hill dated Tue 4/1/2014 9:15 PM regarding CLRAletter.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Thu 4/3/2014 4:08 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/03/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Thu 4/3/2014 9:15 PM regardingCLRA letter draft.

0:06


0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Fri 4/4/2014 11:42AM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Fri 4/4/2014 2:33PM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Fri 4/4/2014 2:18PM regarding summons and civil cover sheet.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara and R. Marron onFri 4/4/2014 2:35 PM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara and R. Marron onFri 4/4/2014 2:35 PM regarding summons and civilcover sheet.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Fri 4/4/2014 11:37AM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/04/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: edits to complaint. 0:1204/04/2014 Edit Edit complaint. 2:4204/04/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with R. Marron re:complaint.

0:06

04/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci on Fri 4/4/2014 11:38AM regarding CLRA letter draft.

0:06

04/08/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/8/2014 11:47 AM regarding initial casemanagement scheduling order.

0:06

04/08/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/8/2014 11:52 AM regarding summons.

0:06

04/08/2014 Review Review court orders filed today. 0:1804/08/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: magistrate judge. 0:0604/09/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: status and strategy. 0:0604/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.

Perez Lara on Wed 4/16/2014 11:36 AM regardinginitial case management scheduling order withADR deadlines.

0:06

04/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Wed 4/16/2014 4:29 PMregarding case management scheduling order withADR deadlines.

0:06

04/17/2014 Review Review all standing orders in case. 0:1204/17/2014 Review Review declination of magistrate judge. 0:0604/17/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Thu 4/17/2014

3:41 PM regarding magistrate judge jurisdiction.0:06

04/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Thu 4/17/2014 12:30 PM

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 059


regarding initial case management schedulingorder with ADR deadlines.

04/17/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: strategy. 0:0604/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.

Perez Lara dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:41 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

04/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Fri 4/18/2014 3:58 PM regardingproof of service.

0:06

04/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Fri 4/18/20144:53 PM regarding proof of service.

0:06


0:06

04/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Fri 4/18/20143:16 PM regarding notice of appearance.

0:06


0:06

04/21/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Mon 4/21/20149:58 AM regarding additional document for service.

0:06

04/21/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Mon 4/21/2014 10:03 AMregarding documents for service.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Marron re: statusand strategy.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Fri 4/25/20141:56 PM regarding service of complaint.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Marron. 0:06

04/25/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Fri 4/25/201412:49 PM regarding clerk's notice re: consent ordeclination.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Fri 4/25/2014 1:27 PM regardingclerk's notice re: consent or declination.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 4/25/2014 12:46 PM regarding clerk'snotice re: consent or declination.

0:06

04/25/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara and R. Marron onFri 4/25/2014 4:17 PM regarding proof of service.

0:06

04/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Mon 4/28/201412:57 PM regarding proof of service of summons.

0:06

04/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Mon 4/28/2014 5:39 PMregarding proof of service.

0:06

04/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Mon 4/28/20145:44 PM regarding proof of service.

0:06

04/28/2014 Review Review proof of service to confirm accuracy. 0:0604/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.

Perez Lara dated Tue 4/29/2014 5:07 PMregarding proof of service.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 4/29/2014 4:48 PMregarding courtesy copies.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Tue 4/29/20144:25 PM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Tue 4/29/20144:29 PM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Tue 4/29/2014 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 060


2:27 PM regarding proof of service.04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Tue 4/29/2014 2:32 PM regardingconsent/declination to proceed before a USMagistrate Judge.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 4/29/2014 2:16 PM regarding summons.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 4/29/2014 2:25 PMregarding proof of service of summons.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Tue 4/29/20145:06 PM regarding proof of service.

0:06

04/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 4/29/2014 3:49 PMregarding courtesy copies.

0:06


0:06

04/30/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: Judge Chesney. 0:0604/30/2014 Review Review newly assigned Judge Chesney. 0:1205/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Thu 5/1/2014 11:48 AM regarding casemanagement scheduling order.

0:06

05/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 5/1/2014 12:00 PM regardingcase management scheduling order.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 5/6/2014 2:28 PM regardingcase management conference order.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara, A. Beamer, and P.Cruz on Tue 5/6/2014 2:52 PM regarding order forservice.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara, A. Beamer, and P.Cruz on Tue 5/6/2014 2:59 PM regarding order forservice.

0:06

05/06/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 5/6/2014 2:58 PM regardingorder for service.

0:06

05/13/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Tue 5/13/201410:21 AM regarding proof of service of orders.

0:06

05/13/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 5/13/2014 10:36 AMregarding proof of service of orders.

0:06

05/13/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Tue 5/13/2014 10:17 AMregarding proof of service of orders.

0:06

05/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Thu 5/15/2014 10:46 AMregarding proof of service of orders.

0:06

05/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Thu 5/15/2014 10:36 AMregarding proof of service of orders.

0:06

05/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/15/2014 10:59 AM regardingcertificate of service by E. Johnson re: casemanagement scheduling order.

0:06

05/15/2014 Email to Drafted email to N. Perez Lara on Thu 5/15/201410:42 AM regarding proof of service of orders.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 061


05/16/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/16/2014 3:09 PM regarding proposedorder re: motion to dismiss.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 5/22/2014 7:13 PM regarding dualmotion to dismiss and motion to strike.

0:06

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 5/22/2014 4:14 PM regardingopposition for motion to dismiss.

0:06

05/22/2014 Review Briefly review defendant's motion to dismiss. 0:2405/22/2014 Research Research local rules and standing order. 0:0605/22/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli on Thu 5/22/2014 4:10

PM regarding proposed order.0:06

05/22/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli on Thu 5/22/2014 3:19PM regarding proposed order.

0:06

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 5/22/2014 4:09 PM regardingproposed order.

0:06

05/22/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 5/22/2014 4:13 PM regardingproposed order.

0:06

05/22/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: strategy andcomplaint/motion to dismiss.

0:12

05/22/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: opposing defendant'smotion to dismiss.

0:30

05/22/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli on Thu 5/22/2014 4:14PM regarding proposed order.

0:06

05/22/2014 Email to Drafted email to D. Cominos and R. Polk on Thu5/22/2014 4:45 PM regarding dual motion tidismiss and motion to strike.

0:06


0:06

05/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Fri 5/23/2014 10:17 AMregarding dual motion to dismiss and motion tostrike.

0:06

05/23/2014 Meeting Meets with E. Minelli re: opposing motion todismiss.

0:06

05/27/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: complaint. 0:0605/27/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: strategy. 0:1205/27/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with defendant's attorney R.Polk and E. Minelli re: briefing schedule for motionto dismiss.

0:12

05/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Tue 5/27/2014 5:58 PM regardingjoint stipulation, declaration, and proposed order.

0:06

05/27/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: status conference. 0:0605/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.

Minelli dated Wed 5/28/2014 9:56 AM regardingjoint stipulation to extend briefing schedule fordefendant's motion to dismiss plaintiff's complaintand accompanying documents.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 062


05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Wed 5/28/2014 12:43 PM regardingjoint stipulation, declaration, and proposed order.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Wed 5/28/2014 12:00 PM regardingrevised draft of joint stipulation and S. Resendesdeclaration.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from N.Perez Lara dated Wed 5/28/2014 3:39 PMregarding proposed order granting joint stipulationto extend briefing schedule.

0:06

05/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 5/28/2014 3:04 PM regardingstipulation with proposed order to extend briefingschedule for defendant's motion to dismissplaintiff's complaint.

0:06

05/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/29/2014 11:57 AM regarding ordergranting joint stipulation to extend briefingschedule for defendant's motion to dismissplaintiff's complaint.

0:06

05/29/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Thu 5/29/2014 12:05 PM regarding motion todismiss.

0:06

05/30/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: status conference. 0:0605/30/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli on Fri 5/30/2014 1:47

PM regarding meet and confer.0:06

05/30/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Fri 5/30/2014 1:47 PM regardingmeet and confer.

0:06

06/09/2014 Draft Draft opposition to motion to dismiss. 2:1806/09/2014 Review Review defendant's motion to dismiss. 0:3606/09/2014 Draft Continue drafting opposition to motion to dismiss. 1:4206/09/2014 Research Research re: opposition to motion to dismiss. 1:1206/10/2014 Research Research for opposition to motion to dismiss. 1:2406/12/2014 Draft Continue drafting opposition to motion to dismiss. 2:4806/17/2014 Review Review E. Minelli's draft warranty arguments. 0:1206/17/2014 Research Research re: opposition to motion to dismiss. 1:4806/17/2014 Draft Draft opposition to motion to dismiss. 7:1206/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.

Minelli dated Tue 6/17/2014 7:08 PM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Tue 6/17/2014 5:03 PM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

0:06


0:06


0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 6/18/2014 4:03 PM regardingproof of service for opposition to motion to dismiss.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci on Wed 6/18/201411:07 AM regarding breach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/18/2014 Court Filing Efile opposition to motion to dismiss. 0:0606/18/2014 Review Review third draft of opposition to motion to 1:18EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 063


dismiss.06/18/2014 Edit Edit third draft of opposition to motion to dismiss. 3:0006/18/2014 Edit Edit second draft of opposition to motion to dismiss. 2:0006/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Wed 6/18/2014 5:52 PM regarding responsere: motion to dismiss.

0:06

06/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Wed 6/18/2014 9:12 AM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/19/2014 Other Instruct paralegal on courtesy copies and travelplans for July hearing.

0:06

06/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 6/19/2014 8:48 AM regardingbreach of warranty arguments.

0:06

06/24/2014 Meeting Meeting with A. Beamer re: travel to hearing. 0:0606/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 6/27/2014 3:56 PM regarding reply toopposition/response.

0:06

07/01/2014 Email to Drafted email to P. Cruz on Tue 7/1/2014 10:11 AMregarding expenses.

0:06

07/01/2014 Meeting Meeting with K. Gallucci re: case managementconference.

0:06

07/01/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Cruz dated Tue 7/1/2014 9:53 AM regardingexpenses.

0:06

07/03/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: status and workloadassignments.

0:06

07/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 7/9/2014 9:55 AM regarding rule26 conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 7/10/2014 10:45 AM regarding rule26(f) conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 7/10/2014 12:39 PM regardingrule 26(f) conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 7/10/2014 10:43 AM regardingrule 26(f) conference.

0:06

07/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Thu 7/10/2014 10:26 AM regardingrule 26 conference.

0:06


Telephone conference with E. Minelli re: discovery. 0:06



07/11/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: results of rule 26(f)conference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Edit Edit rule 26(f) report. 0:4807/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci and R. Marron on Mon

7/14/2014 12:24 PM regarding case managementconference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 7/14/2014 3:54 PM regarding casemanagement conference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 7/14/2014 11:17AM regarding motion to dismiss hearing and casemanagement conference.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 064


07/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Mon 7/14/2014 3:30PM regarding travel plans.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 7/14/2014 11:20 AM regardingmotion to dismiss hearing and case managementconference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Mon 7/14/2014 11:37 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Mon 7/14/2014 3:33 PM regardingtravel plans.

0:06


0:06

07/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 7/14/2014 3:27 PMregarding joint stipulation to appear telephonically.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 7/14/2014 11:24AM regarding case management conferencestatement.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 7/14/2014 11:18 AM regardingdraft of joint case management conferencestatement.

0:06


0:06

07/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and E. Minelli on Mon7/14/2014 1:59 PM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

07/14/2014 Review Review local rules and Judge Chesney standingorders.

0:06

07/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci and R. Marron on Mon7/14/2014 10:56 AM regarding case managementconference.

0:06

07/14/2014 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron, A. Wood, and K. Galluccire: status and strategy.

0:06


Telephone call with court clerk re: appearingtelephonically.

0:06

07/14/2014 Meeting Meeting with K. Gallucci re: strategy. 0:0607/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 7/14/2014 4:17 PM

regarding case management conference.0:06

07/14/2014 Draft Draft stipulation and order to appear telephonically. 0:1207/15/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Tue 7/15/2014 9:41 AM

regarding proposed order.0:06

07/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Tue 7/15/2014 10:21 AM regardingjoint stipulation to appear telephonically.

0:06

07/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 7/15/2014 11:04 AM regardingstipulation with proposed order.

0:06

07/15/2014 Review Review and edit final stipulation to appear byphone.

0:06

07/15/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Tue 7/15/2014 9:52AM regarding joint stipulation.

0:06

07/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Tue 7/15/2014 10:07 AM regardingproof of service.

0:06

07/17/2014 Review Review defendant's edits to 26(f) report. 0:0607/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.

Minelli dated Thu 7/17/2014 5:26 PM regarding0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 065


case management statement.07/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Thu 7/17/2014 11:19 AM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

07/17/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Thu 7/17/2014 9:54AM regarding stipulation to appear by telephone.

0:06

07/17/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk on Thu 7/17/2014 5:28 PM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from E.Minelli dated Fri 7/18/2014 11:13 AM regardingcertificate of noninterested parties.

0:06


0:06

07/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli and A. Beamer on Fri7/18/2014 11:20 AM regarding proof of service.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/18/2014 11:17 AM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 1:01 PM regarding notice by E.Johnson of initial disclosures.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli on Fri 7/18/2014 9:54AM regarding joint case management statement.

0:06

07/18/2014 Edit Edit 26(f) report. 0:0607/18/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone call with R. Polk. 0:06

07/18/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: initial disclosures. 0:0607/18/2014 Edit Edit rule 26(f) report. 0:0607/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 7/18/2014 2:36 PM regarding ADRcertification.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Fri 7/18/2014 9:49 AM regardingstipulation to appear by telephone.

0:06

07/18/2014 Meeting Meeting with E. Minelli re: initial disclosures, rule26(f) report.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to E. Minelli and A. Beamer on Fri7/18/2014 1:46 PM regarding initial disclosures.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 2:33 PM regarding joint casemanagement statement and rule 26(f) report.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and E. Minelli on Fri7/18/2014 11:14 AM regarding joint casemanagement statement.

0:06

07/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 7/18/2014 4:27 PM regarding ordervacating hearing on defendant's motion to dismissstrike.

0:06

08/15/2014 Meeting Meeting with A. Beamber re: courtesy copies. 0:0608/15/2014 Review Review forms prepared by A. Beamer re: case

management conference.0:06

09/03/2014 Review Review and edit joint rule 26(f) report. 0:1209/04/2014 Review Review defendant's edits to rule 26(f) report. 0:0609/04/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.

Beamer dated Thu 9/4/2014 1:48 PM regardingjoint rule 26(f).

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 066



0:06

09/04/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Thu 9/4/2014 1:49PM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

09/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 9/9/2014 10:54 AM regarding ordercontinuing case management conference.

0:06

09/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Tue 9/9/2014 11:13 AM regardingorder continuing case management conference.

0:06

09/10/2014 Meeting Meeting with A. Beamer. 0:0609/19/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from C.

Johnson dated Fri 9/19/2014 12:51 PM regardingexpert candidates.

0:12

09/23/2014 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0609/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Tue 9/23/2014 12:25 PM regarding order onmotion to dismiss.

0:06

09/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 9/24/2014 4:30 PM regardingorder on motion to dismiss.

0:06

09/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Wed 9/24/2014 5:02 PM regardingrequest for publication.

0:06

09/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Wed 9/24/2014 3:44PM regarding order on motion to dismiss.

0:06

09/24/2014 Review Review order denying motion to dismiss. 0:1209/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.

Beamer dated Wed 9/24/2014 4:52 PM regardingrequest for publication.

0:06

09/29/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Mon 9/29/2014 3:07PM regarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/02/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Thu 10/2/2014 4:07PM regarding possible settlement.

0:06

10/02/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Thu 10/2/2014 4:10 PM regardingpossible settlement.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Polk. 0:06

10/03/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Fri 10/3/2014 9:50AM regarding possible settlement.

0:06

10/03/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Fri 10/3/2014 4:15 PMregarding conference call.

0:06

10/06/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 10/6/2014 10:03AM regarding conference call.

0:06


Conference with R. Marron, R. Polk, and D.Cominos.

0:12

10/06/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Mon 10/6/2014 9:34AM regarding conference call.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Goodman dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:10 PMregarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Tue 10/14/20145:07 PM regarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.Beamer dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:04 PM regardingorder on stipulation.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 067


10/14/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 10/14/2014 5:54 PM regardingconference call.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Tue 10/14/20145:02 PM regarding order on stipulation.

0:06

10/14/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Tue 10/14/2014 5:06PM regarding case management conference.

0:06

10/15/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Wed 10/15/2014 1:16 PM regardinghearings.

0:06


0:06

10/20/2014 Email to Drafted email to A. Beamer on Mon 10/20/201410:07 AM regarding notice of errata.

0:06

10/20/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Mon 10/20/2014 4:40 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

10/21/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Tue 10/21/2014 2:49PM regarding discovery.

0:06

10/21/2014 Meeting Meeting with RM re status and strategy 0:0610/21/2014 Review Review and provide suggested edits to plaintiff's

RPDs, RFAs and Rogs to Defendant1:12

10/22/2014 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re discovery. 0:0610/22/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference team meeting re status andstrategy

0:06

10/22/2014 Email Email from ML3 re confirming that corrections hadbeen made to discovery as requested sent on10/22/2014 at 9:10am

0:06

10/22/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 10/22/2014 10:26AM regarding discovery.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Thu 10/23/201412:33 PM regarding protective order.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Thu 10/23/2014 11:18AM regarding protective order.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 10/23/2014 2:12PM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re strategy 0:2410/23/2014 Review Review proposed Protective order 0:3010/23/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with ML3 re casemanagement conference statement

0:06

10/23/2014 Edit Review and edit joint case managementconference statement

0:18

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Thu 10/23/2014 10:18AM regarding case management conference.

0:06


0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 10/23/2014 2:01 PM regardingjoint rul 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 10/23/2014 11:41 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 10/23/2014 10:45AM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 10/23/2014 10:42 AM regarding

0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 068


case management conference.10/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 10/23/2014 2:13

PM regarding joint rule 26(f) report.0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 10/23/2014 8:58 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Thu 10/23/2014 12:27 PM regardingprotective order.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 10/23/2014 9:18 AM regardingcase management conference statement.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 10/23/2014 3:37 PM regarding rule26(f) report.

0:06

10/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 10/23/2014 2:20 PM regardingjoint rule 26(f) report.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 10/24/2014 10:54AM regarding case management conference.

0:06


0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:42 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

10/24/2014 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re Case ManagementConference

0:12

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Fri 10/24/2014 11:04AM regarding case management conference.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and M. Lurtz on Fri10/24/2014 10:54 AM regarding case managementconference.

0:06

10/24/2014 Review Review stipulation to appear by phone and order 0:0610/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.

Lurtz dated Fri 10/24/2014 10:49 AM regardingcase management conference.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/24/2014 11:36 AM regarding casemanagement statement.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 10/24/2014 10:44AM regarding case management conference.

0:06

10/24/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and M. Lurtz on Fri10/24/2014 10:45 AM regarding case managementconference.

0:06


0:06

10/24/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 10/24/2014 11:42 AM regardingstipulation with proposed order.

0:06


0:06

10/27/2014 Meeting Meeting with RM re strategy 0:0610/27/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from A.

Beamer dated Mon 10/27/2014 12:14 PMregarding case management conference.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 069



Telephone conference with J. Chesney's clerk 0:06

10/28/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Tue 10/28/2014 2:18 PM regardingnotice of appearance.

0:06


0:06


0:06

10/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Tue 10/28/2014 2:23PM regarding notice to appearance.

0:06

10/28/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and M. Lurtz on Tue10/28/2014 1:40 PM regarding notice ofappearance.

0:06

10/28/2014 Meeting Meeting with AB and ML3 re Case ManagementConference and strategy

0:06


Telephone conference with M. Lurtz re strategy 0:06


Telephone conference with RM re strategy. 0:06


Telephone conference with Rm re strategy 0:06


0:06

10/30/2014 Meeting Meeting with ML re strategy. 0:1210/31/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 10/31/2014 2:53 PM regarding casemanagement conference.

0:06

11/13/2014 Meeting Meeting with RM and M. Lurtz re mediation 0:0611/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Marron dated Tue 11/18/2014 2:37 PM regardingproposed mediation.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Tue 11/18/2014 9:51AM regarding discovery.

0:06

11/18/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Tue 11/18/2014 8:51 AM regardingmediation and discovery.

0:06


0:06


0:06

11/21/2014 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 11/21/2014 10:28AM regarding sales data.

0:06

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Tue 11/25/2014 11:30 AM regardingsales data.

0:06

11/25/2014 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re strategy. 0:0611/25/2014 Review Review Plaintiff's discovery to Defense to confirm

ML3 selection of premediation items.0:18

11/25/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Tue 11/25/2014 12:17 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

11/26/2014 Review Review mediation agreement. 0:12EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 070


11/26/2014 Edit Edit mediation agreement. 0:0611/26/2014 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with RM 0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 11/26/2014 1:11 PM regardingmediator's fees.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email to Drafted email to J. Petenon on Wed 11/26/20144:18 PM regarding signed mediation agreement.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron, M. Lurtz, and K.Gallucci on Wed 11/26/2014 1:00 PM regardingmediator's fees.

0:06

11/26/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from C.Hughes dated Wed 11/26/2014 4:11 PM regardingsigned mediation agreement.

0:06

12/03/2014 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0612/09/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Tue 12/9/2014 11:37 AM regardingselected discovery requests.

0:06

12/10/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from T.Pham dated Wed 12/10/2014 9:53 AM regardingselected discovery requests.

0:06

12/23/2014 Email to Drafted email to S. Vogel and R. Marron on Tue12/23/2014 4:58 PM regarding Fed Ex delivery.

0:06

12/23/2014 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Tue 12/23/2014 4:05 PM regardingFed Ex delivery.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

01/05/2015 Review Document review 1:1801/05/2015 Meeting Meeting iwth RM re documents produced and

strategy0:18

01/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Tue 1/6/2015 12:18PM regarding meet and confer.

0:06

01/07/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy 0:0601/09/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with RM re strategy 0:06

01/09/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re strategy 0:1201/09/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 1/9/2015 1:58 PM

regarding meet and confer.0:06

01/09/2015 Email Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 1/9/2015 2:02 PMregarding meet and confer.

0:06

01/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 1/9/2015 3:45 PM regarding meetand confer.

0:06

01/12/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re discovery 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 071


01/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Mon 1/12/2015 2:16 PM regardinginterrogatories.

0:06


Telephone conference with ML3 re documentsproduced and new discovery.

0:12

01/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Mon 1/12/2015 2:10 PM regardinginterrogatories.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Mon 1/12/2015 4:09 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

01/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Mon 1/12/2015 2:15PM regarding interrogatories.

0:06


0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 11:57 AM regardingdiscovery.

0:06


0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:30 PM regarding draftto counsel.

0:06

01/14/2015 Meeting Meeting with Megan Lurtz and M. Lurtz re defensefinancials.

0:24

01/14/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re strategy and documentsproduced

0:30

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 1/14/2015 1:08PM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:48 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06


0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Wed1/14/2015 3:30 PM regarding draft to counsel.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Wed1/14/2015 10:49 AM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:42 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 1/14/2015 3:31PM regarding draft to counsel.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 3:27 PM regarding draftto counsel.

0:06


0:06


0:06

01/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 1/14/2015 2:40 PM regardingdiscovery.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 072


01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 1/14/2015 12:05PM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and M. Lurtz on Wed1/14/2015 11:01 AM regarding discovery.

0:06

01/15/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re discovery 0:0601/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Goodman on Thu 1/15/2015

3:01 PM regarding stipulation.0:06

01/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Goodman dated Thu 1/15/2015 2:12 PM regardingstipulation.

0:06

01/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Goodman on Thu 1/15/20153:18 PM regarding stipulation.

0:06

01/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Goodman dated Thu 1/15/2015 3:04 PM regardingstipulation.

0:06

01/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Tue 1/20/2015 9:22AM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and M. Lurtz on Tue1/20/2015 5:44 PM regarding mediation brief.

0:06

01/21/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 1/21/2015 10:38AM regarding hearing.

0:06

01/21/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM re strategy. 0:0601/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.

Lurtz dated Wed 1/21/2015 8:34 AM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/21/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Wed 1/21/2015 3:42PM regarding deadline.

0:06

01/21/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re mediation brief andstrategy.

0:24

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 1/22/2015 3:10PM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 1/22/2015 3:10PM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Thu 1/22/2015 12:15PM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from T.Pham dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:58 PM regardingcorrespondence.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Thu 1/22/2015 12:54PM regarding memorandum of understandings.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:09 PM regardinginformation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:55 PM regardingmemorandum of understandings.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Thu 1/22/2015 11:15AM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to T. Pham on Thu 1/22/2015 12:16PM regarding correspondence.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Thu 1/22/2015 11:16AM regarding correspondence.

0:06

01/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 1/22/2015 12:08 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Fri1/23/2015 2:17 PM regarding mediation brief.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 073


01/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Fri1/23/2015 2:17 PM regarding mediation brief.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 1/23/2015 2:50 PMregarding answers.

0:06

01/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Fri1/23/2015 2:57 PM regarding mediation.

0:06

01/23/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0601/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with Rm and ML3 re labels sales and

mediation strategy0:12

01/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM re mediation 0:0601/26/2015 Review Review draft mediation brief and suggest edits. 0:1801/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re strategy and mediation

brief.0:24

01/27/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Tue 1/27/2015 11:59AM regarding mediation brief.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Tue1/27/2015 10:34 AM regarding sales figures.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Tue 1/27/2015 10:38 AM regardingdocuments.

0:06

01/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Tue 1/27/2015 9:52 AM regardingsales figures.

0:06

01/27/2015 Review Review final mediation brief. 0:1201/27/2015 Meeting Meetings with M. Lurtz re settlement strategy and

sample memorandum of understanding.0:30

01/27/2015 Meeting Meeting with Rm and M. Lurtz re third party liability 0:0601/28/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM re mediation 0:1202/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.

Lurtz dated Mon 2/2/2015 2:13 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Mon 2/2/2015 1:42 PM regardingmediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Mon 2/2/2015 2:01 PMregarding mediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM re settlement strategy 0:0602/02/2015 Meeting Premediation strategy meeting with M. Lurtz 0:4802/02/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM re lodestar 0:0602/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron and M. Lurtz on Mon

2/2/2015 9:24 AM regarding settlement funds.0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Mon 2/2/2015 2:16 PMregarding mediation.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Mon 2/2/2015 9:06 PM regardinglodestar.

0:06


0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Stouffer on Mon 2/2/2015 4:21PM regarding lodestar.

0:06

02/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Mon 2/2/2015 2:48 PMregarding citation.

0:06


0:06

02/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 074


Stouffer dated Tue 2/3/2015 9:47 AM regardinglodestar.


Telephone conference with M. Lurtz 0:06

02/03/2015 Document Review /Index

Gather documents for RM and M. Lurtz 0:12


Telephone conference with RM and M. Lurtz remediation status

0:12


Telephone conference with RM 0:06

02/03/2015 Review Review packaging claims and draft injunctive relief 0:4802/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Marron dated Tue 2/3/2015 8:47 AM regardinglodestar.

0:06

02/03/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Tue 2/3/2015 12:08PM regarding lodestar.

0:06

02/03/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Stouffer, Meghaan Lurtz, and K.Scott on Tue 2/3/2015 10:15 AM regardinglodestar.

0:06

02/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Stouffer dated Tue 2/3/2015 12:04 PM regardinglodestar.

0:06

02/04/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML re outcome of mediation 0:1202/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.

Lurtz dated Fri 2/6/2015 10:07 AM regarding letterto R. Marron.

0:06

02/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 2/6/2015 10:11 AMregarding settlement offer.

0:06



02/11/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0602/13/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with RM re strategy 0:12

02/13/2015 Review Review letter from defense 0:0602/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Mon

2/16/2015 1:36 PM regarding confidentialsettlement communication.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 2/16/2015 1:50 PM regardingconfidential settlement communication.

0:06

02/16/2015 Meeting Meeting with Marshall Lurtz re: strategy. 0:1802/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Marron dated Mon 2/16/2015 1:31 AM regardingsettlement offer.

0:06

02/16/2015 Draft Draft settlement offer 0:1202/16/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with ML3 re strategy 0:06

02/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Mon 2/16/2015 8:38 AM regardingnotice plan.

0:06

02/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Mon 2/16/2015 2:37 PMregarding confidential settlement communication.

0:06

02/17/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 2/17/2015 4:55 PM regardingconfidential settlement of communication.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Wed 2/18/2015 4:17PM regarding confidential settlementcommunication.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 075


02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 2/18/2015 11:01 AM regardingconfidential settlement communication.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 2/18/2015 3:49 PM regardingconfidential settlement communication.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Wed 2/18/201510:47 AM regarding confidential settlementcommunication.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Wed 2/18/201512:10 PM regarding confidential settlementcommunication.

0:06

02/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from D.Caminos dated Wed 2/18/2015 8:55 AM regardingconfidential settlement communication.

0:06

02/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re memorandum terms 0:1202/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to D. Cominos and R. Polk on Thu

2/19/2015 10:27 AM regarding confidentialsettlement communication.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 2/20/2015 8:05 AM regardingconfidential settlement communication.

0:06

02/20/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re memorandum ofunderstanding, discovery and strategy

0:18

02/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Fri2/20/2015 12:07 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Fri 2/20/2015 12:45 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 2/20/2015 2:21 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/20/2015 Review Review defense deadline to respond to discovery 0:0602/20/2015 Review Review draft memorandum of understanding 0:2402/20/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with R. Polk and M. Lurtz 0:12

02/20/2015 Edit Edit draft of memorandum of understanding 0:4802/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 2/20/2015 12:37

PM regarding memorandum of understanding.0:06


0:06

02/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Fri2/20/2015 12:41 PM regarding confidentialsettlement communication.

0:06


0:06

02/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Fri 2/20/2015 2:34 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/24/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM 0:0602/25/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re terms of memorandum of

understanding0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:43 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 076


02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 2/25/2015 11:42 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 2/25/2015 11:42AM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Wed2/25/2015 11:13 AM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

02/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 2/25/2015 2:24 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

02/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 2/26/2015 10:32 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

02/26/2015 Review Review edited memorandum of understanding 0:1202/26/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re memorandum of

understanding and upcoming hearing0:12


Telephone conference with R. Polk re terms ofsettlement

0:12

03/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Wed 3/4/2015 3:52 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Polk on Wed3/4/2015 9:18 AM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

03/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 3/4/2015 9:20 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding draft.

0:06

03/04/2015 Edit Edit memorandum of understanding 0:0603/05/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0603/10/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with R. Polk rememorandum of understanding

0:06

03/10/2015 Meeting Meetings with ML3 re timing of case managementconference and conversation with R. Polk

0:18

03/10/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re: status and strategy. 0:0603/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and M. Lurtz on Wed

3/11/2015 5:02 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 3/11/2015 3:36PM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:03 PM regardinginjunctive relief.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 3/11/2015 12:20 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 3:07 PM regardingsettlement approval.

0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:09 PM regardingadditional notice expense.

0:06

03/11/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM re memorandum ofunderstanding

0:12

03/11/2015 Review Review defense's edits to memorandum ofunderstanding and draft analysis for RM and ML3

0:18


0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 077


Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 3:17 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

03/11/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re memorandum ofunderstanding

0:06

03/11/2015 Edit Edit memorandum of understanding. 0:1203/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Wed

3/11/2015 1:28 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06


0:06

03/11/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Wed 3/11/2015 1:22 PM regardingadditional notice expense.

0:06

03/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 3/12/2015 9:26AM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 3/12/2015 10:40 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Thu 3/12/2015 11:12 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06


0:06

03/12/2015 Meeting Meeting with KS re courtesy copies. 0:0603/12/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re case management conference

and strategy.0:06


0:06

03/13/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 to edit joint case managementconference statement.

0:18

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 2:05 PM regarding jointrule 26(f).

0:06

03/13/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Fri 3/13/2015 1:35 PMregarding case management statement.

0:06


0:06

03/13/2015 Review Review defense's edits to case managementstatement

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 9:57 AM regarding jointcase management conference statement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 3:04 PM regarding jointcase management statement.

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M.Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 1:57 PM regarding jointrule 26(f).

0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/13/2015 4:44 PM regardingresponse.

0:06


0:06

03/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from M. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 078


Lurtz dated Fri 3/13/2015 1:12 PM regarding casemanagement statement.

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:22 AMregarding notice plan.

0:06

03/16/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re settlement terms and case lawon certification under various 23(b) classes.

0:12

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Mon 3/16/2015 5:27 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Mon 3/16/2015 7:43 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 3/16/2015 9:39 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Mon 3/16/2015 9:34AM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Mon 3/16/2015 9:16AM regarding notice plan.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Mon3/16/2015 9:18 AM regarding notice plan.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Mon 3/16/2015 3:38PM regarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to P. Ivie on Mon 3/16/2015 9:17 AMregarding notice plan.

0:06


0:06


0:06

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and M. Lurtz on Thu3/19/2015 10:37 AM regarding settlement.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:35 AM regardingmembers in class.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Thu 3/19/2015 11:35 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:54 AM regardingclient's signatures.

0:06

03/19/2015 Review Review draft letter to client. 0:0603/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:44 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

03/19/2015 Review Review defense's new edits to memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

03/19/2015 Review Review old correspondence re memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz re: status and strategy. 0:0603/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and M. Lurtz on Thu

3/19/2015 10:22 AM regarding settlement.0:06

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and M. Lurtz on Thu3/19/2015 10:47 AM regarding injunctive relief.

0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM and M. Lurtz. 0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 079


Marshall Lurtz dated Thu 3/19/2015 11:55 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re additional modifications tomemorandum of understanding.

0:12

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Thu 3/19/2015 2:46 PMregarding email to Ms. Johnson.

0:06


0:06

03/19/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Thu 3/19/2015 10:45 AMregarding settlement.

0:06

03/19/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re case management conferencestrategy, phone call with client and scheduling.

0:12

03/19/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 3/19/2015 11:47AM regarding settlement agreement.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Fri 3/20/2015 1:31 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Fri 3/20/2015 1:07 PMregarding client information.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:48 PM regarding letterto counsel.

0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 1:07 PM regarding coverletter.

0:06


0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 12:57 PM regardingcover letter.

0:06


0:06

03/20/2015 Review and Edit Review and edit letter to defense re memorandumof understanding.

0:06

03/20/2015 Review Review revised letter to defense. 0:0603/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.

Scott dated Fri 3/20/2015 2:26 PM regarding letterto counsel re: memorandum of understanding.

0:06


Telephone conference with ML3 re casemanagement conference hearing.

0:12


0:06

03/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Fri 3/20/2015 1:04 PM 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 080


regarding memorandum of understanding.03/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Fri 3/20/2015 1:38 PM

regarding memorandum of understanding.0:06


0:06


0:06

03/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott and M. Lurtz on Mon3/23/2015 10:35 AM regarding case managementconference.

0:06

03/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Mon 3/23/2015 10:28 AMregarding case management conference.

0:06

03/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott on Tue 3/24/2015 9:49 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 3/24/2015 9:43 AM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/24/2015 Meeting Meeting with RM 0:0603/25/2015 Meeting Meeting with M. Lurtz. 0:0603/30/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0603/30/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.

Scott dated Mon 3/30/2015 5:40 PM regardingmemorandum of understanding.

0:06

03/31/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Tue 3/31/2015 4:13 PMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

04/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Scott and M. Lurtz on Thu4/2/2015 2:08 PM regarding memorandum ofunderstanding.

0:06

04/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Thu 4/2/2015 11:53AM regarding notice plan.

0:06

04/06/2015 Meeting Meeting with ML3 re notice and strategy 0:1204/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from

Marshall Lurtz dated Mon 4/6/2015 10:29 AMregarding class action settlement agreement.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 4/8/2015 9:49 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 4/8/2015 9:32 AMregarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz on Wed 4/8/2015 9:42 AMregarding memorandum of understanding.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 4/8/2015 9:45 AMregarding memorandum of understanding dates.

0:06

04/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email fromMarshall Lurtz dated Wed 4/8/2015 9:52 AMregarding initial draft.

0:06

04/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to M. Lurtz and R. Marron on Tue4/14/2015 12:36 PM regarding settlementagreement.

0:06

04/14/2015 Review Review and edit draft settlement agreement. 1:2404/14/2015 Review Review modified packaging for compliance with

settlement agreement.0:12

04/15/2015 Meeting Meeting with K. Scott re: edits to settlementagreement.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 081


dated Wed 4/15/2015 2:34 PM regarding notice.04/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Wed 4/15/2015 2:51

PM regarding withdrawal of M. Lurtz as counsel ofrecord.

0:06

04/15/2015 Edit Make additional edits to settlement agreement. 1:3004/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Wed 4/15/2015 2:44 PM regardingcorrespondence.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Wed 4/15/2015 3:00 PM regardingMarshall Lurtz.

0:06

04/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 4/15/2015 3:02 PM regardingMarshall Lurtz.

0:06

04/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Scott dated Thu 4/16/2015 11:31 AM regardingsettlement agreement edits.

0:06

04/16/2015 Review Review modified settlement agreement and makeadditional necessary edits.

1:30

04/16/2015 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: settlement agreement. 0:0604/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and R. Marron on Thu

4/16/2015 11:39 AM regarding settlementagreement.

0:06

04/20/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0604/20/2015 Review Review draft notices in other cases. 0:0604/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Mon

4/20/2015 2:50 PM regarding settlementagreement.

0:06

04/20/2015 Review Review draft labeling changes. 0:1804/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Marron dated Tue 4/21/2015 4:23 PM regardingquote.

0:06

04/21/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron on Tue 4/21/2015 4:23PM regarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 4/21/2015 4:16 PM regardingprocess of soliciting bids.

0:06

04/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 4/21/2015 7:37 PM regardingquote.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Wed4/22/2015 10:32 AM regarding approved noticeprovider.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:33 AM regardingnotice provider.

0:06

04/22/2015 Meeting Meeting with B. Richards re: motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:56 AMregarding notice bid.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnsaba dated Wed 4/22/2015 10:48 PMregarding notice bid.

0:06

04/22/2015 Email to Drafted email to G. Retnasaba on Wed 4/22/201510:34 AM regarding settlement agreement.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Thu4/23/2015 3:53 PM regarding CAFA notice.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 082


04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Thu 4/23/2015 7:43 AMregarding notice bid.

0:06

04/23/2015 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: notice. 0:0604/23/2015 Review Review Classaura's proposed notice plan. 0:0604/23/2015 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: status of final settlement

agreemen.0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:31 PM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos on Thu4/23/2015 3:27 PM regarding settlement estimate.

0:06

04/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from G.Retnasaba dated Thu 4/23/2015 3:17 PMregarding proposal.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 4/24/2015 9:00 AM regarding finaldrafts.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk on Fri 4/24/2015 1:16 PMregarding proposal from Rust Consulting.

0:06

04/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards on Fri 4/24/2015 10:35AM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

04/24/2015 Review Review Rust notice bid. 0:0604/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Fri 4/24/2015 1:09 PM regardingproposal.

0:06

04/27/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 4/27/2015 9:14 AMregarding proposal.

0:06

04/27/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Mon 4/27/201511:15 AM regarding updated proposal.

0:06

04/28/2015 Review Review final approval order and preliminaryapproval order.

0:48

04/30/2015 Meeting Meeting with B. Richards re: motion for preliminaryapproval and final approval order/final approvalorder and strategy.

0:12

05/01/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards sent on Fri 5/1/20152:12 PM regarding settlement.

0:06

05/01/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/1/2015 2:14 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/01/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/1/2015 2:40PM regarding settlement agreement.

0:06

05/01/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards sent on Fri 5/1/20152:37 PM regarding settlement.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Mon 5/4/2015 10:05 AM regardingsettlement agreement.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 8:15 AM regardingnotice.

0:06

05/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Mon 5/4/2015 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 083


10:11 AM regarding final approval.05/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Mon 5/4/2015 11:59 AM regarding finalapproval.

0:06


0:06

05/05/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Tue 5/5/2015 4:28 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/05/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards sent on Tue 5/5/20154:30 PM regarding motion for preliminary approvalpleadings.

0:06

05/05/2015 Meeting Meeting with B. Richards re: motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:18

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Wed 5/6/2015 12:44 PM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/06/2015 Review Reviewed and analyzed draft preliminary approvalorder.

0:36

05/06/2015 Review Review draft of final approval order. 0:3005/06/2015 Review Review edits to settlement agreement. 0:1205/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos sent on

Wed 5/6/2015 2:06 PM regarding settlementagreement.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/6/2015 2:17 PM regarding edits.

0:06

05/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards sent on Wed 5/6/20152:02 PM regarding motion for preliminary approvalpleadings.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Thu 5/7/2015 2:51 PM regardingJohnson declaration in support of motion forpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Thu 5/7/2015 2:35 PM regardingJohnson declaration in support of motion forpreliminary approval.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Thu 5/7/2015 2:59 PM regardingJohnson declaration.

0:06

05/07/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards sent on Thu 5/7/20152:47 PM regarding ex parte.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/8/2015 8:37 AM regardingmotion for preliminary approval pleadings.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/8/2015 9:07 AM regardingJohnson declaration.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/8/2015 9:06 AM regardingJohnson declaration.

0:06

05/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/8/2015 3:47 PM regardingJohnson declaration.

0:06

05/11/2015 Review Review draft motion to seal and draft motion forpreliminary approval papers and edit.

2:00

05/11/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos sent onMon 5/11/2015 1:13 PM regarding motion for

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 084


preliminary approval.05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Tue 5/12/2015 7:59 AM regardingredlined edits.

0:06

05/12/2015 Hours Review KCC notice bid. 0:0605/12/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Tue 5/12/2015

10:36 AM regarding motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 5/12/2015 8:10 AM regardingproposed order.

0:06

05/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Tue 5/12/2015 8:35 AM regardingdeclaration in support of motion to seal.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/13/2015 10:18 AM regardingjoint motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/13/2015 9:17 AM regardingdeclaration in support of preliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Wed 5/13/2015 11:46 AMregarding joint motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/13/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/13/2015 2:19 PM regardingdeclaration in support of motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Thu 5/14/20152:45 PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Meeting Meetings with B. Richards re: Friday's motions. 0:2405/14/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Thu 5/14/2015

2:46 PM regarding joint motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Review Review and edit motion for preliminary approval. 1:3005/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Fri 5/15/2015 1:16 PM regardingdeclaration in support of motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/14/2015 Review Review and edit seal motion. 0:3005/14/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Thu 5/14/2015 2:49 PM regarding jointmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Review Review and edit settlement agreement and motionfor preliminary approval papers.

1:48

05/15/2015 Meeting Meeting with B. Richards re: filings for today. 0:1805/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Fri 5/15/2015 4:57 PM regarding motion forsettlement.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 1:56PM regarding signature page.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 1:54PM regarding declaration in support of preliminaryapproval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 1:15 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 085


PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 1:47

PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/15/2015 2:09 PM regardingdeclaration in support of motion for preliminaryapproval.

0:06


0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to Judge Chesney sent on Fri5/15/2015 4:21 PM regarding proposed order re:joint motion.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to B. Richards sent on Fri 5/15/20152:16 PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Vogel and R. Drake sent on Fri5/15/2015 5:03 PM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 2:16PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 5/15/2015 2:34 PM regardingdeclarations.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 5/15/2015 4:17 PM regarding jointadministrative motion to file under seal.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from B.Richards dated Fri 5/15/2015 4:07 PM regardingproposed preliminary and final approvals.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 1:46PM regarding revised document.

0:06


0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to Judge Chesney sent on Fri5/15/2015 5:00 PM regarding order approvingpreliminary settlement.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 1:49PM regarding signature pages.

0:06

05/15/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 5/15/2015 2:27PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

05/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci sent on Mon 5/18/20152:35 PM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06

05/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Drake sent on Mon 5/18/201511:10 AM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06

05/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Resendes dated Mon 5/18/2015 2:25 PMregarding courtesy copies.

0:06

05/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Drake dated Mon 5/18/2015 11:11 AM regardingcourtesy copies.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 086


05/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci sent on Mon 5/18/20152:23 PM regarding courtesy copies.

0:06

05/20/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 5/20/2015 6:25 PM regardingCAFA mailing information.

0:06

05/20/2015 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: press articles andsettlement agreement.

0:12

05/20/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 5/20/201511:52 AM regarding CAFA notice.

0:06

05/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Chernila dated Thu 5/21/2015 4:19 PM regardingCAFA mailing information.

0:06

05/21/2015 Review Review and approve CAFA notice. 0:1805/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.

Chernila dated Thu 5/21/2015 8:27 AM regardingCAFA mailing information.

0:06

05/21/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 5/21/2015 7:49 AM regardingCAFA mailing information.

0:06

05/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Mon 5/25/2015 2:32 PM regardingpackage.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.Vogel dated Tue 5/26/2015 10:40 AM regardingletter and documents.

0:06

05/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Tue 5/26/2015 11:03 AM regardingletter/notice.

0:06

06/02/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0606/03/2015 Review Review order re: sealing. 0:0606/03/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECF

dated Wed 6/3/2015 3:50 PM regarding order onadministrative motion to file under seal.

0:06

06/04/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and D. Cominos sent onThu 6/4/2015 10:35 AM regarding order onadministrative motion to file under seal.

0:06

06/09/2015 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: strategy. 0:0606/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from S.

Ozomaro dated Tue 6/9/2015 12:05 PM regardingorder on administrative motion.

0:06

06/09/2015 Email to Drafted email to K. Gallucci sent on Tue 6/9/201512:13 PM regarding order on administrative motionto file under seal.

0:06

06/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from K.Gallucci dated Tue 6/9/2015 1:36 PM regardingorder on administrative motion to file under seal.

0:06

06/09/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Ozomaru sent on Tue 6/9/201512:00 PM regarding order on administrative motionto file under seal.

0:06

06/16/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Drake sent on Tue 6/16/20159:34 AM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

06/16/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Drake dated Tue 6/16/2015 8:59 AM regardingbinder.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Polk re: motion forpreliminary approval.

0:12

06/18/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 6/18/2015 1:31 PM regarding

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 087


conference call.06/18/2015 Hearing Hearing preparationmotion for preliminary

approval.1:00

06/18/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Thu 6/18/20151:44 PM regarding conference call.

0:06

06/19/2015 Hearing Attend motion for preliminary approval hearing. 2:3006/19/2015 Travel Travel to/from motion for preliminary approval

hearing.9:30

06/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Mon 6/22/2015 7:23 PM regardinginformation.

0:06

06/22/2015 Preparation Prepare supplement on notice. 0:1206/22/2015 Telephone

ConferenceTelephone conference with R. Marron re: strategy. 0:06

06/22/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Drake dated Mon 6/22/2015 9:49 AM regardingnotice.

0:06


0:06


0:06


0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Tue 6/23/2015 3:16 PM regarding ads.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Tue 6/23/20153:53 PM regarding additional notice.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Tue 6/23/2015 1:59 PM regarding motionhearing.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron sent on Tue 6/23/20151:30 PM regarding preliminary approval motion.

0:06

06/23/2015 Email to Drafted email to firm sent on Tue 6/23/2015 2:42PM regarding motion hearing.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 6/24/2015 1:16 PM regardingCAFA notice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 6/24/20151:12 PM regarding settlement.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 6/24/201512:08 PM regarding supplemental brief.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron sent on Wed 6/24/201512:50 PM regarding notice issues.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 6/24/2015 3:09 PM regardingsupplemental brief.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 6/24/20151:18 PM regarding preliminary approval.

0:06


Telephone conference with R. Polk. 0:18

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Wed 6/24/2015 2:40 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron sent on Wed 6/24/201510:07 AM regarding transcript of the hearing.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R. 0:06EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 088


Polk dated Wed 6/24/2015 3:35 PM regardingsupplemental brief.


0:06

06/24/2015 Draft Draft supplemental brief on notice. 2:0006/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 6/24/2015

3:34 PM regarding supplemental brief in support ofmotion for preliminary approval.

0:06

06/24/2015 Research Research re: supplemental brief on notice. 0:3006/24/2015 Edit Edit short ad long form notices. 0:1806/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to P. Ivie sent on Wed 6/24/2015

11:45 AM regarding ads.0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to P. Ivie and R. Polk sent on Wed6/24/2015 11:21 AM regarding readershipnumbers.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 6/24/2015 2:06 PM regardingnotice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 6/24/2015 1:31 PM regardingconference call.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 6/24/2015 12:49 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 6/24/20154:25 PM regarding motion for preliminary approval.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Wed 6/24/20152:47 PM regarding short notice.

0:06

06/24/2015 Email to Drafted email to P. Ivie and R. Polk sent on Wed6/24/2015 12:08 PM regarding ads.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Thu 6/25/201510:51 AM regarding ads.

0:06


0:06

06/25/2015 Email to Drafted email to S. Ozomaro sent on Thu 6/25/20152:18 PM regarding supplemental brief.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 6/25/2015 10:57 AM regardingnotice.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Thu 6/25/2015 6:56 AM regardingquestions.

0:06

06/25/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Ozomaru re: filing supplementalbrief.

0:06

06/25/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 6/25/2015 1:15 PM regardingsupplemental brief.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Fri 6/26/2015 8:51 AM regarding CLRArequirement.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/26/2015 10:07 AM regardingdeclaration in support of motion hearing.

0:06

06/26/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Fri 6/26/2015 4:58 PM regarding orderpreliminarily approving class action settlement.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 089


06/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from ECFdated Sun 6/28/2015 8:28 AM regardingpreliminary approval.

0:06

06/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Sun 6/28/2015 8:58 AM regarding jointsupplemental briefing.

0:06

06/28/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Ivie dated Sun 6/28/2015 8:54 AM regarding jointsupplemental briefing.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Marron sent on Mon 6/29/201510:56 AM regarding settlement.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Mon 6/29/2015 10:55 AM regardingsettlement.

0:06

06/29/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and P. Ivie sent on Mon6/29/2015 10:01 AM regarding revised notices.

0:06

06/30/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0607/01/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.

Cooper dated Wed 7/1/2015 4:45 PM regardingsettlement.

0:06

07/02/2015 Review Review notice plan and respond to noticeadministrator's questions.

0:12

07/02/2015 Email to Drafted email to P. Cooper, R. Polk, and R. Marronsent on Thu 7/2/2015 2:28 PM regarding notices.

0:06


0:06

07/07/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Carameros, R. Marron, B.Richards, and R. Polk sent on Tue 7/7/2015 2:54PM regarding notice documents.

0:06


0:06

07/07/2015 Review Review draft along and short notices and provideedits re: same.

0:18

07/07/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and J. Carameros sent onTue 7/7/2015 12:57 PM regarding noticedocuments.

0:06

07/07/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Tue 7/7/2015 12:59 PMregarding notice documents.

0:06


0:06

07/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Carameros, R. Marron, B.Richards, and R. Polk sent on Wed 7/8/2015 10:54AM regarding media approval and notice plandocuments.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Marron dated Wed 7/8/2015 2:05 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Wed 7/8/2015 1:35 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06

07/08/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Carameros, R. Marron, B.Richards, and R. Polk sent on Wed 7/8/2015 10:41AM regarding media approval and notice plandocuments.

0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 090



0:06


0:06


Telephone conference with R. Polk re: notice. 0:06

07/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 11:50 AM regardingbanner.

0:06

07/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Thu 7/9/2015 5:08 PM regardingupdated documents.

0:06


0:06

07/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 7/9/2015 5:07 PM regarding shortnotice.

0:06


0:06


0:06

07/09/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 7/9/2015 5:38 PM regarding mediaapproval and notice plan documents.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Sat 7/11/2015 10:04 AM regarding shortform notice.

0:06


0:06

07/10/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 7/10/201511:57 AM regarding edits to short notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:23 PM regarding finalnotices.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:04 PM regarding editsto short notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:05 PM regardingbanners.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:28 PMregarding media approval and notice plandocuments.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 11:51 AM regarding editsto short notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:26 PM regardingmedia approval and notice plan documents.

0:06


0:06

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 091


07/10/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk and J. Carameros sent onFri 7/10/2015 2:43 PM regarding short form notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:08 PMregarding update.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email to Drafted email to R. Polk sent on Fri 7/10/201511:56 AM regarding edits to short notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Carameros and R. Polk sent onFri 7/10/2015 12:17 PM regarding short formnotice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email to Drafted email to J. Carameros and R. Polk sent onFri 7/10/2015 12:22 PM regarding notice.

0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from J.Carameros dated Fri 7/10/2015 12:18 PMregarding update.

0:06


0:06

07/10/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Fri 7/10/2015 2:35 PM regarding shortform notice.

0:06

07/24/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0608/04/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.

Polk dated Tue 8/4/2015 2:23 PM regardingdevelopments.

0:06

08/05/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 8/5/2015 9:06 AM regardingdevelopments.

0:06

08/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 8/6/2015 9:56 AM regarding shortform notice.

0:06

08/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Cooper dated Thu 8/6/2015 11:12 AM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

08/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Thu 8/6/2015 10:24 AM regarding shortform notice.

0:06

08/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Cooper dated Thu 8/6/2015 11:00 AM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

08/06/2015 Email to Drafted email to P. Cooper and R. Polk sent on Thu8/6/2015 11:10 AM regarding short form notice.

0:06

08/06/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from P.Passarella dated Thu 8/6/2015 10:25 AM regardingshort form notice.

0:06

08/12/2015 Email Received, reviewed, and analyzed email from R.Polk dated Wed 8/12/2015 8:13 AM regardingattorney's fees.

0:06

08/13/2015 Review Review order granting preliminary approval andhearing notes.

0:12

08/13/2015 Meeting Meeting with K. Gallucci re: strategy on fee motion. 0:0608/14/2015 Meeting Meeting with R. Marron re: ex parte. 0:0608/14/2015 Draft Draft fee motion and accompanying documents. 8:0008/15/2015 Draft Draft fee motion and R. Marron declaration in

support of same.8:00

08/17/2015 Meeting Meetings with staff re: filings, attorney billing, andcourtesy copies with instructions on improper filing

0:12

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 092


of order on ex parte.Total for Skye Resendes 170:54Stephanie Ozomaro

06/02/2015 Meeting Team meeting to discuss status and strategy. 0:0606/25/2015 Meeting Meeting with S. Ozomaro re: filing supplemental

brief.0:06

06/30/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:0607/24/2015 Meeting Team meeting re: status and strategy. 0:06

Total for Stephanie Ozomaro 0:24

Wednesday, Sep 02, 2015 02:33:24 PM PDT GMT7

EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 093
