1 older adults and alcohol problems niaaa social work education module 10c (revised 3/04)
TRANSCRIPT
1
Older Adults and Alcohol Older Adults and Alcohol ProblemsProblems
NIAAA Social Work EducationNIAAA Social Work Education
Module 10CModule 10C
(revised 3/04)
2
OutlineOutline
Prevalence Drinking guidelines Issues unique to older adults Co-morbid medical and psychiatric
conditions Screening and detection Prevention, brief alcohol intervention
and treatment Summary and recommendations
3
Prevalence…Prevalence…
Depends on definition of at-risk or problem drinking: – 1-15% of older adults are
at-risk or problem drinkers Differs with sampling
approach Alcohol use problems are the
most common substance issues for older adults. Confounded by prescription, herbal, and over-the-counter medications
4
Prevalence Prevalence (continued)(continued)
Older adults with Older adults with alcohol use problems alcohol use problems are not recognized by are not recognized by many professionalsmany professionals
Few older adults with Few older adults with alcohol abuse or alcohol abuse or dependence seek dependence seek help in specialized help in specialized addiction treatment addiction treatment settingssettings
©2002 Microsoft Corporation
5
Drinking GuidelinesDrinking Guidelines No more than 1 standard No more than 1 standard
drink per daydrink per day No more than 2-3 drinks on No more than 2-3 drinks on
any drinking day (binge any drinking day (binge drinking)drinking)
Limits for older Limits for older women should women should be somewhat be somewhat less than for olderless than for oldermenmen
(Source: NIAAA, 1995; (Source: NIAAA, 1995;
Dufour & Fuller, 1995)Dufour & Fuller, 1995)
6
Drinking Guidelines Drinking Guidelines (continued)(continued)
Recommendations consistent with Recommendations consistent with data on benefits/risks of drinking in data on benefits/risks of drinking in this age groupthis age group
Lower limits for older adults because: Lower limits for older adults because: IIncreased alcohol sensitivity with agencreased alcohol sensitivity with ageGreater use of contraindicated Greater use of contraindicated
medicationsmedicationsLess efficient liver metabolismLess efficient liver metabolismLess body mass/fat increases circulating Less body mass/fat increases circulating
levelslevels
7
Defining Alcohol Use Defining Alcohol Use PatternsPatterns
AbstinenceAbstinence
Low riskLow risk
At-riskAt-risk
ProblemProblem
DependentDependent
No alcohol use for past yearNo alcohol use for past year
Alcohol use with no problemsAlcohol use with no problems
Alcohol use with increased Alcohol use with increased chance of problems/ chance of problems/ complicationscomplications
Experiencing adverse Experiencing adverse consequencesconsequences
Loss of control, drinking despite Loss of control, drinking despite problems, physiological problems, physiological symptoms (tolerance, withdrawal)symptoms (tolerance, withdrawal)
8
Alcohol Use Patterns Alcohol Use Patterns (continued)(continued)
9
Older Adults and Alcohol Older Adults and Alcohol UseUse
Increased risk of:Increased risk of:– Stroke (with overuse)Stroke (with overuse)– Impaired motor skills (e.g., Impaired motor skills (e.g.,
driving) at low level usedriving) at low level use– Injury (falls, accidents)Injury (falls, accidents)– Sleep disordersSleep disorders– SuicideSuicide– Interaction with dementia Interaction with dementia
symptomssymptoms ©2002 Microsoft Corporation
10
Older Adults and Use Older Adults and Use (continued)(continued)
Other effects:Other effects:– Higher blood alcohol Higher blood alcohol
concentrations (BAC) from doseconcentrations (BAC) from dose– More impairment from BACMore impairment from BAC– Medication effects:Medication effects:
Potential interactionsPotential interactions Increased side effects Increased side effects Compromised metabolizing Compromised metabolizing
(especially psychoactive medications, (especially psychoactive medications, benzodiazepines, barbiturates, benzodiazepines, barbiturates, antidepressants, digoxin, warfarin)antidepressants, digoxin, warfarin)
©2002 Microsoft Corporation
11
Social Work ScreeningSocial Work Screening
Who?Who?
What?What?
How?How?
– If aged 60 or overIf aged 60 or over– If physical signs are presentIf physical signs are present– If undergoing major life changesIf undergoing major life changes
– Screen for alcohol and Screen for alcohol and prescription drug use/abuseprescription drug use/abuse
– During any regular serviceDuring any regular service– Utilize brown bag approachUtilize brown bag approach– Ask direct questionsAsk direct questions– Avoid stigmatizing termsAvoid stigmatizing terms
12
General Issues for Older General Issues for Older AdultsAdults
Loss (status, people, Loss (status, people, vocation, health, etc.)vocation, health, etc.)
Social isolation, Social isolation, lonelinessloneliness
Major financial Major financial problemsproblems
Housing changesHousing changes Family concernsFamily concerns Time management Time management
burdenburden
Complex medical Complex medical issuesissues
Multiple medicationsMultiple medications Sensory deficitsSensory deficits Reduced mobilityReduced mobility Cognitive Cognitive
impairmentsimpairments Impaired self-care, Impaired self-care,
loss of independenceloss of independence
13Signs of Potential Alcohol Signs of Potential Alcohol ProblemsProblems
Anxiety, depression, Anxiety, depression, excessive mood excessive mood swingsswings
Blackouts, dizziness, Blackouts, dizziness, idiopathic seizuresidiopathic seizures
DisorientationDisorientation Falls, bruises, burnsFalls, bruises, burns HeadachesHeadaches IncontinenceIncontinence Memory lossMemory loss Unusual response to Unusual response to
medicationsmedications
New difficulties in New difficulties in decision makingdecision making
Poor hygienePoor hygiene Poor nutritionPoor nutrition Sleep problemsSleep problems Family problemsFamily problems Financial problemsFinancial problems Legal difficultiesLegal difficulties Social isolationSocial isolation Increased alcohol Increased alcohol
tolerancetolerance
14
Special PopulationsSpecial Populations
Barriers to effective Barriers to effective identification exist for:identification exist for:– WomenWomen– Certain minority group Certain minority group
members/lack of members/lack of culturally competent culturally competent tools and interventionstools and interventions
– Individuals with physical Individuals with physical disabilities, comorbiditiesdisabilities, comorbidities
– HomeboundHomebound ©2002 Microsoft Corporation
15
Co-morbid ConditionsCo-morbid Conditions
Impaired Activities of Impaired Activities of Daily Living (ADL’s)Daily Living (ADL’s)
Psychiatric symptoms, Psychiatric symptoms, mental disordersmental disorders
Alzheimer’s diseaseAlzheimer’s disease Sleep disordersSleep disorders ©2002 Microsoft Corporation
Co-morbidity is a serious, common Co-morbidity is a serious, common concern among older adults using concern among older adults using alcohol:alcohol:
16
Screening for Alcohol Use Screening for Alcohol Use Problems in Older AdultsProblems in Older Adults
Goals
Identify Identify —at-risk drinkersat-risk drinkers—problem drinkersproblem drinkers—dependent dependent
drinkersdrinkers Determine the need Determine the need
for further diagnostic for further diagnostic assessment assessment
Rationale
Incidence is high Incidence is high enough to justify costsenough to justify costs
Adverse quality/ Adverse quality/ quantity of life effects quantity of life effects are significantare significant
Effective treatment Effective treatment existsexists
Valid and cost-Valid and cost-effective screening effective screening existsexists
17
Screening InstrumentsScreening Instruments
Short Michigan Alcohol Screening Short Michigan Alcohol Screening Test-Geriatric Version (SMAST-G)Test-Geriatric Version (SMAST-G)
Health Screening Survey Health Screening Survey (quantity/frequency and CAGE (quantity/frequency and CAGE questions embedded in a general questions embedded in a general health survey) health survey)
CAGE (Cut down, Annoyed by CAGE (Cut down, Annoyed by others, feel Guilty, need Eye others, feel Guilty, need Eye opener)opener)
18
S-MAST-GS-MAST-G
Yes or no answers to:Yes or no answers to:1. “When talking with others, do you 1. “When talking with others, do you
ever ever underestimate how much you underestimate how much you actually drink?”actually drink?”
2. “After a few drinks, have you 2. “After a few drinks, have you sometimes not sometimes not eaten or been able to skip eaten or been able to skip a meal because you a meal because you don’t feel hungry?”don’t feel hungry?”
3. “Does having a few drinks help 3. “Does having a few drinks help decrease decrease your your shakiness or tremors?”shakiness or tremors?”
19
S-MAST-G S-MAST-G (continued)(continued)
4. “Does alcohol sometimes make it hard 4. “Does alcohol sometimes make it hard for you to remember parts of the day or for you to remember parts of the day or night?”night?”
5. “Do you usually take a drink to relax or 5. “Do you usually take a drink to relax or calm your nerves?”calm your nerves?”
6. “Do you drink to take your mind off your 6. “Do you drink to take your mind off your problems?”problems?”
7. “Have you ever increased your drinking 7. “Have you ever increased your drinking after experiencing a loss in your life?”after experiencing a loss in your life?”
20
S-MAST-G S-MAST-G (continued)(continued)
8. “Has a doctor or nurse ever said they 8. “Has a doctor or nurse ever said they were worried or concerned about your were worried or concerned about your drinking?”drinking?”
9. “Have you ever made rules to manage 9. “Have you ever made rules to manage your drinking?”your drinking?”
10. “When you feel lonely, does having a 10. “When you feel lonely, does having a drink help?”drink help?”
2 or more positive responses = indicative of an alcohol abuse problem (range of scores of 0-10 possible)
21
Quantity/Frequency Quantity/Frequency ScreenScreen
1. “Do you drink alcohol?”1. “Do you drink alcohol?”
2. “On average, how many days a week do you 2. “On average, how many days a week do you drink?”drink?”
3. “On a day when you drink alcohol, how many 3. “On a day when you drink alcohol, how many drinks do you have?”drinks do you have?”
4. “What is the maximum number of drinks you 4. “What is the maximum number of drinks you consumed on any given occasion in the past consumed on any given occasion in the past month?”month?”
8 or more drinks/week or 2 or more occasions of binge drinking in last month are indicative of alcohol use problems.
22
Screening ResultsScreening Results
23
Intervention with Older Intervention with Older AdultsAdults
1.1. Preventive education Preventive education for abstinent, low-risk for abstinent, low-risk drinkersdrinkers
2.2. Brief, preventive Brief, preventive intervention with intervention with at-risk and problem at-risk and problem drinkersdrinkers
3.3. Alcoholism treatment Alcoholism treatment for for abusing/dependent abusing/dependent drinkersdrinkers
©2002 Microsoft Corporation
24
Brief InterventionBrief Intervention
Time-limited (5 mins, up to 5 brief Time-limited (5 mins, up to 5 brief sessions)sessions)
Targeted at a specific behaviorTargeted at a specific behavior Goal directedGoal directed
– Reducing alcohol consumption, and/orReducing alcohol consumption, and/or– Facilitating entry into formal treatmentFacilitating entry into formal treatment
Relies on negotiated goalsRelies on negotiated goals Empirical support with younger drinkers Empirical support with younger drinkers
across multiple settingsacross multiple settings
25
Brief Intervention Brief Intervention (continued)(continued)
Project GOALProject GOAL (Guiding (Guiding Older Adult Lifestyles)Older Adult Lifestyles)
— Univ. of WisconsinUniv. of Wisconsin— Brief physician Brief physician
advice for at-risk advice for at-risk older drinkers older drinkers
— n=156n=156— Reduced Reduced
consumption at 12 consumption at 12 months by 35-40%months by 35-40%
Health Profile ProjectHealth Profile Project
— Univ. of MichiganUniv. of Michigan— Elder-specific Elder-specific
motivational motivational enhancement sessionenhancement session
— n=454n=454— Preliminary findings: Preliminary findings:
reduced at-risk reduced at-risk drinking at 12 monthsdrinking at 12 months
Empirical studies with older adults are limitedEmpirical studies with older adults are limited
26Brief Protocols with Older Brief Protocols with Older AdultsAdults
Brief intervention/motivational Brief intervention/motivational enhancement are effective enhancement are effective approachesapproaches
Accepted well by older adultsAccepted well by older adults Can be conducted at home or in clinicCan be conducted at home or in clinic Reduces alcohol useReduces alcohol use Reduces alcohol-related harmReduces alcohol-related harm Reduces health care utilizationReduces health care utilization
27
Brief Protocols Brief Protocols (continued)(continued)
Ten components:Ten components:1.1. Identify future goals (health, activities, Identify future goals (health, activities,
etc.)etc.)
2.2. Customize feedbackCustomize feedback
3.3. Define drinking patternsDefine drinking patterns
4.4. Discuss pros/cons of drinking (motivation Discuss pros/cons of drinking (motivation to change)to change)
5.5. Discuss consequences of heavier drinkingDiscuss consequences of heavier drinking
28
Brief Protocols Brief Protocols (continued)(continued)
Ten components:Ten components: 6.6. Identify reasons to cut down or quit Identify reasons to cut down or quit
drinkingdrinking7.7. Setting sensible limits, devising Setting sensible limits, devising
strategiesstrategies8.8. Develop a drinking agreementDevelop a drinking agreement9.9. Anticipate and plan for risky situationsAnticipate and plan for risky situations10.10. Summary of the brief sessionSummary of the brief session
29
Other Treatment Other Treatment ApproachesApproaches
Cognitive-Cognitive-behavioral therapybehavioral therapy
Group-based Group-based counselingcounseling
Individual Individual counselingcounseling
Medical/Medical/psychiatric psychiatric approachesapproaches
Marital and family Marital and family involvement/family involvement/family therapytherapy
Case management/ Case management/ community-linked community-linked services & outreachservices & outreach
Formalized Formalized substance abuse substance abuse treatmenttreatment
30
ConclusionsConclusions
Screening for alcohol use problems Screening for alcohol use problems among older adults is effectiveamong older adults is effective
Brief interventions are effectiveBrief interventions are effective Additional interventions complete a Additional interventions complete a
spectrum of effective approachesspectrum of effective approaches Treatment approach depends on client Treatment approach depends on client
background; assessment of needs, background; assessment of needs, goals, resources; and preferencesgoals, resources; and preferences
Intervention is availableIntervention is available
31
Conclusions Conclusions (continued)(continued)
Older adults benefit from Older adults benefit from screening, assessment, referral, screening, assessment, referral, prevention, and intervention prevention, and intervention delivered by social workers who delivered by social workers who are sensitive to elder issues:are sensitive to elder issues:– Non-judgmental approachNon-judgmental approach– MotivationalMotivational– Supportive approachSupportive approach
32
Recommendations Recommendations
Social workers in any setting with older Social workers in any setting with older adult clients should be prepared for:adult clients should be prepared for:Recognition and assessment of alcohol Recognition and assessment of alcohol
use problems (quantity and frequency; use problems (quantity and frequency; limits)limits)
Structured brief interventions when Structured brief interventions when appropriate appropriate
Initial management and referral for Initial management and referral for further assessment/treatment when further assessment/treatment when indicatedindicated