1 pittsburgh water & sewer authority: a public entity pwsa provides critical services to the...

11
1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has the resources to perform but with the least possible risk PWSA Board must pass on a healthier – both financially and operationally – Authority to our children If PWSA Board exposes Authority to excessive risk they undermine the health of the Authority today and down the road for our children

Upload: robert-gutierrez

Post on 27-Mar-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

1

Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority:

A Public Entity

• PWSA provides critical services to the public• PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the

Authority has the resources to perform but with the least possible risk

• PWSA Board must pass on a healthier – both financially and operationally – Authority to our children

• If PWSA Board exposes Authority to excessive risk they undermine the health of the Authority today and down the road for our children

Page 2: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

2

PWSA 2008 Revenue Bonds

Series A, B, C, D

Total Deal = $419 M$$$s for Capital Projects = $98 M

Page 3: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

3

Risk: Who owns it?

Fixed Rate Bonds

Bondholders

Variable Rate Demand Bonds

Rate Payers

Page 4: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

4

Losers

Pittsburgh Ratepayers:

Exposed to

Unconscionable Levels of Risk

Page 5: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

5

What are the Risks?

• Variable Rates

• Annual renewal of Liquidity Facility (June 2009)

• Failure could bankrupt PWSA

• SWAPs – Spreads between actual interest rates and index rate (Basis risk)

• Credit rating of the SWAP providers

• SWAP providers fail to pay (e.g., Lehman Brothers)

• Credit Rating of the Bond Insurer

Page 6: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

6

2008 Variable Rate Demand Bonds& SWAP Structure

PWSATax Exempt

Variable Rate Demand Bonds

Bondholders

SWAPProviders

JPMorganMerrill Lynch

Trustee

RemarketingAgents

JPMorganMerrill Lynch

Bank LiquidityFacility

JPMorganDexia Credit Local

$ 2.6 Million losses to date

Page 7: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

7

Ratepayer Share of Wall Street Indebtedness

$320M Principal amount*/83,322 PWSA Customers

=$ 3,840.52 per Customer

* Plus higher interest and related costs of fixed rate bonds in current credit market.

Page 8: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

8

Winners:Hand-Picked Firms

• JP Morgan

• Merrill Lynch

• Commonwealth Securities and Investments

• Dexia Credit Local

• No competitive bidding

Page 9: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

9

Churning for Fees?

Total bonds issued

1993 – 2005

(12 Years):

$688 Million

Total bonds issued

March 2007 – June 2008

(15 months):

$ 580 Million

Page 10: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

10

Initial Cost of 2008 Deal

• 2007 SWAP Termination -- $ 594,000*

• 2008 SWAP Termination -- 5,036,000*

• FSA Insurance Premium -- 7,801,917

• Surety Premium -- 2,249,610

• Professional Fees -- 2,095,491

• Underwriters Commission -- 1,269,462

TOTAL $19,046,480 or

5% of Total Deal

*Commissions on SWAPs are not included

Source: Schedule C to Closing Receipts of PWSA, dated June 12, 2008, “Settlement Account Reconciliation”, page D-1.

Page 11: 1 Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority: A Public Entity PWSA provides critical services to the public PWSA Board of Directors must ensure the Authority has

11

Call to Action

• An independent, credentialed third-party auditor must immediately determine:

–What exactly are the full terms of this deal?

–What exactly are all the risks?

–When exactly do these risks occur?

–How do we get out of this situation?

• Full public disclosure of the report and an honest and open discussion of our options