· 1 structural geology, tectonics and geomechanics, rwth aachen university (de) * corresponding...
TRANSCRIPT
Radioactive Waste ManagementNEA/RWM/CLAYCLUB(2013)1May 2013www.oecd-nea.org
NEA CLAY CLUB Workshop ProceedingsKarlsruhe, Germany6-8 September 2011
Clay characterisation from nanoscopic to microscopic resolution
NEA
109
Qualitative and Quantitative Characterization of Porosity in a Low Porous and Low
Permeable Organic Rich Shale by Combining Broad Ion Beam and Scanning Electron
Microscopy (BIB-SEM)
Jop Klaver1*, Guillaume Desbois 1, Janos L. Urai1
1 Structural Geology, Tectonics and Geomechanics, RWTH Aachen University (DE)
* Corresponding author: [email protected]
Abstract
This contribution focuses on the characterization of porosity in low porous shale using a broad ion beam (BIB) polishing technique combined with a conventional scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Porosity was traced in certain representative elementary areas (REA) and pores detected are segmented from mosaics of secondary electron (SE) images. Traced pores could be classified into two major pore‐size classes. Relative large pores (> 0.5 μm2) were found in the organic matter and matrix. They contribute strongly to the overall porosity con-tent of the shale. Nevertheless the far majority of the pores traced have equivalent radius less than 400 nm. Including the latter pore class, the imaged porosity from both samples gives similar results in the order of < 1 %.
Introduction
This combined BIB-SEM technique of imaging and mapping of pores in shales enables to work on large areas and to actually see the pores and study the pore morphology. With the use of a BIB cross‐section polisher the area of the polished surface increased by a factor of sev-eral thousand compared to focused ion beam (FIB) techniques, enclosing an area of roughly 1-2 mm2 and allows working on REA. Conventional SEM imaging allows analysis of pores down to the nanometer scale. Two adjacent organic rich core samples from a shale interval (3.5 km depth) were investigated. From each sample one BIB polished cross-section was made and pores were segmented from several mosaics consisting of hundreds of images. Method and technique
Studied material was stored in foil at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and stored
in a tight plastic barrel. From the air-dried sample material, small pieces (~0.5 x 0.5 x 0.5
cm3) were cut off with a low speed diamond saw machine (Figure 1). After cutting, the sam-
110
ple was pre-polished using sandpaper reducing surface roughness down to 10 m. Pre-
polishing maximizes the quality of the cutting of the BIB cross-section. Eventual damage on
the surface of the shale sample created by the pre-polishing will be removed by the BIB. Sub-
samples were preserved in an exicator under low vacuum.
Figure 1. Picture of shale investigated (A). Electric low speed drill (B) used for sawing of the shale with diamond saw (pop-up). A polish tool (C) was used to create perpendicular edges with sandpaper (D). JEOL cross-section BIB polisher SM-09010 and sample setup and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) plot of a scanned BIB-polished surface (E).
The dry subsample was put in the BIB cross-section polisher for the argon polishing. On top
of the sample a mask is placed and argon ions mill into the sample that is not covered by the
mask. In 8 hours of milling under vacuum (1 x 10-3
-10-4
Pa), a 1 mm2 polished cross-section
was created with an amplitude less than 5 nanometers (Figure 1E). Here after the polished
cross-section was coated to prevent charging by the SEM. Imaging in the SEM was done un-
der high magnification with the back scatter electron (BSE) detector and the secondary elec-
tron detector (Inlens or SE2) with a pixel size of a few nanometers for the SE detectors. Minor
micro-scale cracks was interpreted as ex-situ damage and subtracted during analysis. REA
mosaics were created by stitching hundreds of images together with a bicubic interpolation
algorithm in Autopano 2 (http://www.kolor.com/image-stitching-software-autopano-
giga.html). Pores were traced manually in ArcGIS 10 from mosaics of SE images. After pore
segmentation, shapes were analysed in MATLAB with PolyLX (Lexa (2010)). Classification
and mapping of mineral phases were done using grey values from BSE images verified and
calibrated by a combination of energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDX) and bulk X-ray
diffraction (XRD) analyses. REA was determined with the box counting method applied on
the classified BSE mosaic and turned out to be 80 x 80 m2.
BIB-SEM technique has been applied recently on salt and clays too (Desbois et al. (2009),
Desbois et al. (2011), Hemes et al. (2010) and Houben et al.(2011)). Challenges that needs to
be overcome are serial cross-sectioning to get a better understanding of the 3D pore structure.
Sample
Mask
Polished cross-section
Ion beam irridation area
Ion Beam
BIB
Z (n
m)
X (nm) Y (nm) 0 0
600
1200 600
1200
-5
5
0
Sample
Sample-holder
A B C D
E
111
An appropriate automated pore detection algorithm has to be designed to deal with the huge
amount of pores in images covering REA.
Results Quantitative analyses
Traced pores in both samples resulted in a very low visible porosity in all the different mosa-
ics down to the different SEM resolutions. 99% of the pores are in the range of 20-400nm
equivalent radius (req, Figure 2A), and porosities are the same in this range for both samples.
However most of the pore space, 82% in cross-section 1 and 42% in cross-section 2 are in the
1% largest (≥400nm req) pore size range. These largest pores are predominantly found in the
clay rich matrix, and organic matter. Most pores (>6600) were found in the clay rich matrix,
and results in an average relative porosity of 0.12% at the magnifications used. Pores together
have a power law distribution in all the phases over three orders of magnitude of pore sizes
(Figure 2B) and this infers a fractal dimension (Mandelbrot (1982)).
Figure 2. A. Equivalent pore radius distributions of both cross-sections (CS 1 and 2) at different magnifications. B. Power law exponent (gradient of the fitted line, given in the boxes) of seg-mented pores in the clay rich matrix traced at different magnifications.
Qualitative investigation
Pores traced in the clay rich matrix are isolated and therefore not connected at the resolutions
used (Figure 3A). However intragranular pores in pyrite and rutile are clustered and are con-
nected (Figure 3B and C). Pore orientation of the organic matter is sub-parallel with the bed-
ding and most occurs at the interface of the organic matter and the surrounding phase (Figure
3D). A pore throat is seen in the clay-rich matrix (Figure 3E).
A 10kx B 78kx C 10kx 10kx E 200kx
~5nm
4 m 400nm 4 m 8 m 200nm
D
CS1
CS2
CS1
CS2
A B
112
Figure 3. A. Isolated relative small pores (arrows) in the clay-rich matrix. B. Intragranular pores in rutile and pores in pyrite framboids (C). D. Elongated pores along organic matter (BSE image). E. Pore throat between pores in clay rich matrix.
Summary and Conclusions
Porosity in both samples is very low (<1%) at resolutions used and are similar in the smaller
pore range (req < 400nm). The pore size distributions show similar power law exponents for
each phase and at different magnifications. Each phase has its own typical pore characteristics,
regardless of the sample. BIB-SEM is a very suitable technique for the study of porosity in
shale.
Acknowledgement
We would like to acknowledge U. Wollenberg for his help with the XRD analyses, BIB mill-
ing and SEM imaging and Dr. rer. nat. Anke Aretz for the AFM analyses.
References
Desbois, G., Urai, J. L., and Kukla, P. A. (2009). Morphology of the pore space in claystones – evidence from BIB/FIB ion beam sectioning and cryo-SEM observations. eEarth, 4, 15-22.
Hemes, S., Desbois, G., Urai, J. L., De Craen, M. and Honty, M. (2011). Comparative study on porosity in fine- and coarse-grained Boom Clay samples (Mol-Dessel reference site, Belgium).- Mol, Belgium: SCK•CEN, 2011.- 46 p.- (External Report of the Belgian Nuclear Research Centre; ER-157.
Houben, M.E., Desbois, G., Urai, J.L. (submit.). Pore morphology and distribution in the shaly facies of Opalinus Clay (Mont Terri, Switzerland): insights from representative 2D BIB-SEM investigations on the mm to nm scale. Applied Clay Science.
Lexa, O. (2010). PolyLX - the MATLAB™ toolbox for quantitative analysis of microstructures. Ondrej Lexa Website.
Mandelbrot, B. (1982). The Fractal Geometry of Nature, W. H. Freeman.