1 user rate adjustments june 30, 2008 financial analysis - karen spence
TRANSCRIPT
1
User Rate AdjustmentsJune 30, 2008
Financial Analysis -
Karen Spence
2
Water & Sewer FundExpenditure Categories
28%
24%
9%
14%
12% 3%
3%1%
6%
UOSA DebtUOSA MaintenanceSewer SalariesSewer OperationsWater Purchase
Water OperationsWater SalariesAdmin FeeWater Debt
Note: UOSA Debt and UOSA Maintenance are mandatory expenditures (52%) regardless of water/sewage usage. These mandatory expenditures represent approximately $50 - $60 per month per Manassas Park utility account.Manassas Park is mandated by Federal Court to utilize UOSA, our only source of sewage treatment.
3
Water & Sewer Enterprise Fund
The Water & Sewer fund is an Enterprise fund.
An enterprise fund is a self-sufficient fund. A self-sufficient fund is similar to a business in that revenues must at least equal expenditures. However, unlike a business an enterprise fund does not make a profit. Instead the enterprise fund’s goal is to have revenue equal expenditures.
4
$3.8
$4.9 $3.8
$5.3
$3.5
$5.0 $4.9 $4.9
$0
$2
$4
$6
$8
$10
(Mill
ions)
FY'06 FY'07 FY'08 FY'09
Revenue Expenditures
Current Water / Sewer FundRevenue vs. Expenditures
ProjectedWith Tiered-
Rate AdjustmentActual Actual
5
Customer Base– Average Total Number of Residential Accounts - 3,690– Average Total Number of Commercial Accounts - 295
Average Monthly Consumption:– Residential Accounts - 5,600 gallons/month– Commercial Accounts - 17,900 gallons/month
Average Monthly Bill– Residential Accounts - $57.40– Commercial Accounts - $194.11
Last assessment and adjustment to water and sewer rates– April 18, 1995
Current Status
6
Analysis Highlights
“The term "tiered" typically refers to a "block" type of rate structure where the unit price of water changes with each of several preset consumption blocks for each billing period. “ *
A five-tiered conservation approach is used for residential and a four-tiered approach for commercial accounts
Recommend rates be re-evaluated every other year even though this analysis is a 10-year projection (revenue, operational & debt) keeping the fund self-sufficient
* American Waterworks Association – www.awwa.org
7
Tiered Residential Rate Structure
Recommended
Option
Tiers in
gallons
Base
Fee
Cost/1000 gallons
UOSA Service Charge*
1 0-3,500 $0 $8.00 $26.00
2 3,501-7,000 $0 $8.25 $26.00
3 7,001- 10,000 $0 $9.50 $26.00
410,001- 14,000
$0 $10.25 $26.00
5 14,000+ $0 $12.25 $26.00
*UOSA Service Charge helps to defray the mandatory UOSA costs.
8
Monthly Utility Bill Comparison Recommended Option
Average 5,600 gal usage
Current Residential Bill
Base Fee $35.00
Consumption 22.40
Total $57.40
New Residential Bill – tiered $0 base
Base Fee $0.00
Consump-Tier1 28.00
Consump-Tier2 17.33
UOSA Srv Chrg 26.00
Total $71.33
Increase – $13.93 or 24%
9
Tiered Residential Rate Sample Bills
Gallons
Used
Current Bill
$35 base,
$4.00/1,000
Recommended Option
Utility BillIncrease / (Decrease)
1,000 $39 $34 (13%)
2,000 $43 $42 (2%)
3,000 $47 $50 6%
4,000 $51 $58.13 14%
5,000 $55 $66.38 21%
6,000 $59 $74.63 26%
7,000 $63 $82.88 32%
10
Tiered Residential Rate Sample Bills
Gallons
Used
Current Bill
$35 base,
$4.00/1,000
Recommended Option
Utility BillIncrease / (Decrease)
8,000 $67 $92.38 38%
9,000 $71 $101.88 43%
10,000 $75 $111.38 49%
11,000 $79 $121.63 54%
12,000 $83 $131.88 59%
13,000 $87 $142.13 63%
14,000 $91 $152.38 67%
15,000 $95 $164.63 73%
11
Surrounding Jurisdictions Comparison
Cost of W&S with use of 5,600 per month
Cost
1990
Increase/
Decrease
Cost
2000
Increase/
Decrease
Proj. 2009
Manassas Park 33.24 73% 57.40 24% 71.33
Manassas Na 32.15 64% 52.81
Fairfax Na 38.15 52% 58.13
PWCSA Na 39.85 45% 75.07 includes 17.42 peak
Average VA city 25.91 48% 38.23
Note: 1) All of the above jurisdictions except for Manassas Park have direct interlocal agreements with Fairfax County to purchase water.
PWCSA adds a peak charge of $3.11/1000 gallons over 7,000 gals OR 2,000 gals over winter aver OR 1.3 times winter consumption.
12
Cost Increases Over Time
Item - Cost 1970 1980 1990 2000 2008 Proj. 2009
Gasoline/gallon 0.36 2.05 1.30 1.50 4.06 * 3.00-6.00
Min wage 1.45 3.10 3.80 5.15 6.55 7.25
Milk/gallon 1.15 1.69 2.78 2.88 3.87 4.16 **
W&S Base Fee 14 11.75 17 35 35 0
Water /1000gallons6500
gallons included
4000 gals
included, 4001 + $4.25/ga
l
$.90 $1 $1 $2.88 – 1st tier
Sewer /1000gallons $2.00 $3 $3$5.12 – 1st tier
$26 UOSA Srv Chrg
Avg W&S bill
For 5,600 gal$14 $18.55 $33.24 $57.40 $57.40 $71.33
* National Average – AAA’s Fuel Gage Report 6/12/08
** Over next 5 yrs, food prices expected to increase at a 7.5% annual rate. – Adv Econ Solutions research firm.