11-May-2011

An overview of nuclear power, its current role and future directions

….in about one hour…

Note that mixture of fuels used → electricity production is very different in different countries

e.g. coal ~ 35% in UK, ~76% in China (where hydro ~ 18%)

Source: IEA WEO. 2008 IEA Key Statistics give 2.3% of ‘Other’ (2006 data)

Reactors Worldwide

• In 2007 the World Nuclear Industry Handbook listed 440 reactors producing ~16% of the world’s electricity

• In Feb 2010 57 reactors were under construction (20 in China, 9 Russia, 6 India, 6 S Korea)

Some history / facts

• UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) established 1954 to oversee UK nuclear energy programme.

• Calder Hall connected to the grid in August 1956.

Power Station      

Type        

Net MWe        

Construction started       

Connected to grid       

Commercial operation

      

Accounting closure date       

Oldbury Magnox 434 1962 1967 1968 2011

Wylfa Magnox 980 1963 1971 1972 2012

Dungeness B AGR 1110 1965 1983 1985 2018

Hinkley Point B AGR 1220 1967 1976 1976 2016

Hunterston B AGR 1190 1967 1976 1976 2016

Hartlepool AGR 1210 1968 1983 1989 2019

Heysham 1 AGR 1150 1970 1983 1989 2019

Heysham 2 AGR 1250 1980 1988 1989 2023

Torness AGR 1250 1980 1988 1988 2023

Sizewell B PWR 1188 1988 1995 1995 2035

Current UK nuclear power stations.

Asian Nuclear Reactors (~2010)

• Taiwan 4 x BWR, 2 x PWR, 2 ABWR in Build• Japan 54 reactors, mix of PWR and BWR• India 18 reactors, mainly PHWR, 1 BWR• South Korea 20 reactors, mainly PWR some

PHWR

– PWR = Pressurised Water Reactor– BWR = Boiling Water Reactors– PHWR = Pressurised Heavy Water Reactor

China….• Mainland China has 11 nuclear power reactors in

commercial operation, 20 under construction, and more about to start construction soon (2010 onwards).

• Plans to increase in nuclear capacity to at least 60 GWe or possibly more by 2020, and then a further substantial increase to 160 GWe by 2030.

• China is rapidly becoming self-sufficient in nuclear design and fuel cycle

Source WANO

Source of electricity in UK from 1990 - 2020

Note:- later numbers are estimates

Power Station        

Type        

Net MWe        

Construction started       

Connected to grid      

Commercial operation       

Closure        

Calder Hall Magnox 200 1953 1956 1959 2003

Chapelcross Magnox 240 1955 1959 1960 2004

Berkeley Magnox 276 1957 1962 1962 1989

Bradwell Magnox 246 1957 1962 1962 2002

Hunterston A Magnox 300 1957 1964 1964 1990

Hinkley Point A Magnox 470 1957 1965 1965 2000

Trawsfynydd Magnox 390 1959 1965 1965 1991

Dungeness A Magnox 450 1960 1965 1965 2006

Sizewell A Magnox 420 1961 1966 1966 2006

Former UK nuclear power stations.

Nuclear Power Production in the U.K.

Sizewell B

Elements of a nuclear reactor

Types of Reactors

Power reactors produce commercial electricity.

Research reactors are operated to produce high neutron fluxes for neutron-scattering experiments.

Heat production reactors supply heat in some cold countries.

Some reactors are designed to produce radioisotopes.

Several training reactors are located on college campuses.

Atoms – 10-8 m Z protons and Z electrons in neutral atom

Nuclei – 10-14 m Z protons and N neutrons

Nucleons – 10-15 m

Three quarks

Quarks

Should be Z = 39

A Nuclear Chain Reaction

Each neutron inducing fission results in the production of several other neutrons. Each of these neutrons is capable of initiating fission in another nucleus with the emission of another 2.5 neutrons on average.

The number of fissions and neutrons can increase very rapidly. This process is described as a chain reaction.

A chain reaction is characterised by the neutron multiplication factor k, which is defined as the ratio of the number of neutrons in one generation to the number in the preceding generation.

If k < 1 then the number of neutrons decreases with time and the process stops. In the context of a reactor it would be said to be sub-critical.

If k > 1 then the number of neutrons increases with time and the chain reaction diverges. A reactor would be said to be super-critical. ( a nuclear bomb!)

If k = 1 everything proceeds at a steady rate. A reactor in this state would be said to be critical.

A Nuclear Chain Reaction

The Energy released in Fission

Crude idea of a suitable configuration

The main elements of a reactor.1. Fuel – pellets of UO2 (1cm diam.by 1.5 cm long) arranged in tubes to form fuel rods. They are usually formed into fuel assemblies in the core. 2. Moderator – usually water but may be graphite or heavy water.

3.Control rods – Made with neutron absorbing material included so that inserting or withdrawing the rod controls or halts the rate of reaction. Note:-Secondary shutdown systems involve adding other absorbers of neutrons, usually in the primary cooling system.

4.Coolant- Liquid or gas circulating in the core to carry away heat. In light water reactors the coolant acts as moderator and coolant.

5.Pressure vessel – Usually a robust steel vessel containing the core and moderator/coolant but it may be a series of tubes holding the fuel and conveying the coolant through the moderator.

6.Steam generator – Part of cooling system where the reactor heat is used to make steam to drive the turbines.

7.Containment –Structure round core to protect it from intrusion and protect the outside from radiation in case of a major malfunction.

Energy Transfer Most common method is to pass hot water heated by the reactor through some form of heat exchanger. In boiling water reactors (BWRs) the moderating water turns into steam, which drives a turbine producing electricity. In pressurised water reactors (PWRs) the moderating water is under high pressure and circulates from the reactor to an external heat exchanger where it produces steam, which drives a turbine.

Boiling water reactors are inherently simpler than pressurized water reactors. However, the possibility that the steam driving the turbine may become radioactive is greater with the BWR.

The two-step process of the PWR helps to isolate the power generation system from possible radioactive contamination.

Boiling Water Reactor

Pressurised Water Reactor

Do we need reactors?

Source: ASPO

Oil Supply

Note:-Even if there is an unexpected source (unlikely) we will run out quite soon and we would have been better keeping it as a chemical feedstock

The amount of carbon dioxide released (Kg CO2/kWh) annually in the UK.

Nuclear Fuel

Where does the Uranium come from?

Uranium is relatively common – found in seawater and rocks.

Half the world’s production is in Canada and Australia in open pit or relatively shallow mines

It is then milled – the ore is crushed to form a fine slurry and it is leached with sulphuric acid to produce concentrated U3O8 – which is called yellowcake and generally has more than 80% U compared with the original 0.1%

Underground mines cause less disturbance but one needs very good ventilation to protect against airborne radiation exposure.

Tailings are radioactive with long-lived activities in low concentrations and also contain heavy metals. They have to be isolated.

Increasingly the mining industry uses in-situ leaching. Here oxygenated groundwater is circulated through the U deposit underground to dissolve the U and bring it to the surface.

Reserves Amount (M tonnes)

Total fuel provision time (years) based on current fleets' usage and fuel cycle strategies

Present known high-grade reserves

4 At least 60 years

Undiscovered conventional deposits

11 ~ 250

Unconventional resources

22 Uranium is only present at very low grades or recoverable as a minor by-product

Uranium separation from seawater

4,000 Breeder reactors, which also use uranium 50 times more efficiently than current reactors, could use such uranium separated by membrane techniques

Uranium deposits.

Source: Energy Visions 2030 for Finland, VTT Energy, Helsinki, 2003.

Canada11%

USA9%

Brazil7%

Namibia7%

Others12%

South Africa

9%

Kazakhstan22%

Australia23%

Source: Energy Visions 2030 for Finland, VTT Energy, Edita Prima Ltd, Helsinki, 2003.

Making Fuel rods

Most reactors use enriched fuel- enriched in mass 235.

The yellowcake is converted to UF6 – a gas- which is enriched either by gas diffusion or in a centrifuge. The former relies on the different diffusion rates of uranium isotopes with masses 235 (enriched) and 238 (depleted).

In the latter the gas passes through spinning cylinders and the centrifugal force causes the mass 238 move to the outside leaving a higher mass 235 concentration on the inside.

Uranium dioxide pellets are then made form the enriched material.

The pellets are then encased in long metal tubes, usually made of zirconium alloy (zircalloy) or stainless steel to form fuel rods. The rods are sealed and assembled in clusters to form fuel assemblies for use in reactors.

Nuclear Fuel Production• 1. Uranium ore

• 3. Uranium hexafluoride

• 2. Yellow cake

• 4. Fuel pellets

Source: USDOE

A more advanced kind of reactor is the breeder reactor, which produces more fissionable fuel than it consumes.

The chain reaction is:

The plutonium is easily separated from uranium by chemical means.

Fast breeder reactors have been built that convert 238U to 239Pu.

Breeder reactors could provide an almost unlimited supply of fissionable material.

One of the downsides of such reactors is the production of plutonium and its possible use in unauthorised nuclear weapons.

Breeder Reactors

The Oklo reactor is interesting in itself but it is also highly relevant to the discussionof dealing with present day waste. Neither the fission fragments nor the Pu migrated from the site in 2 x 109 y.

Used Fuel

I. Uranium recovered can be used in MOX fuel or can be returned to conversion plant to be included in new fuel.

2. The Mixed Oxide (MOX) fuel is a blend of Pu and U. The Pu effectively substitutes for the U in new fuel.

3. Typically reactors use a one-third mixture of MOX and Uranium dioxide fuel assemblies although 100% MOX is possible.

Radioactive Waste ?

Used Fuel

A. Used fuel emits radiation and heat.

B. It is unloaded into a storage pond adjacent to the reactor to allow it to decay.

C. It can be stored there for long periods. It can also be stored in dry stores cooled by air.

D. Both kinds of store are intended to be temporary. It will be reprocessed or sent to final disposal. The longer it is stored the easier it is to handle.

E. Main options for long term – reprocessing to recover useful fuel - storage and final disposal

F. Reprocessing – separates U and Pu from waste products by chopping up rods and dissolving them in acid to separate the various materials.

G. Typically used fuel is 95% 238U, 1% 238U, 1% Pu and 3% fission products including other transuranics.

H. Reprocessing enables recycling of fuel and produces a significantly reduced waste volume.

Years

Radioactive Waste

A. Classification is different in different countries and may be based on different factors.

B High Level waste (HLW) – highly radioactive, generates a lot of heat. Mainly the liquid waste from reprocessed fuel after U and Pu extracted. In UK it is concentrated, mixed with molten glass and stored in 150 litre stainless steel drums.

C. Intermediate Level Waste (ILW) – less radioactive, much less heat. Mostly metal items such as fuel cladding reactor components, graphite from reactor cores, sludges from treatment of radioactive liquid effluents.It is stored in tanks,vaults and drums. It will be repackaged following immobilisation in cement-based materials in 500 l stainless steel drums.

D. Low Level Waste – largely consists of contaminated redundant equipment,protective clothing and packaging. It is sent to Drigg and compacted, packaged in large metal containers and placed in an engineered vault a few metres below the surface.

Note:- At present the large amount of stored Pu is not included in the waste category because it may yet be used in MOX fuel.

What to do with highly radioactive wastes?• Prevent dispersion• Shield

Present solution (“temporary”)

Stored in pools next to site

Long term

Store (bury) in deep stable geological formation

Treatment• Chemically processed• Vitrified• Packed in special canisters• Stored in disaffected mines (can be retrieved)• or specially constructed repository

Radioactive Waste and its Disposal

CORWM’s Long List - Options for radioactive Waste Disposal

1.Interim or Indefinite storage on or below the surface2.Near surface disposal – few metres to tens of metres down3.Deep disposal with surrounding geology as a barrier4.Phased deep disposal with storage and monitoring for a period5.Direct injection of liquid wastes into rock strata6.Disposal at sea7.sub-seabed disposal8.Disposal in ice sheets9.Disposal in subduction zones10.Disposal in space, into high orbit or propelled into Sun11.Dilution and dispersal of radioactivity in the environment12.Partitioning of wastes and transmutation of radionuclides13.Burning of Pu and U in reactors14.Incineration to reduce waste volumes15 melting of metals in furnaces to reduce waste volumes

CORWM’s short List - Options for radioactive Waste Disposal

1.Long term interim storage2.Deep geological disposal3.Phased deep geological disposal4.Near surface disposal of short-lived wastes

And the winner is

Deep geological disposal