11 participation2 slides

12
8/10/2019 11 Participation2 SLIDES http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/11-participation2-slides 1/12 I. FORMS OF POLITICAL PARTICIPATION I I.  WH Y P E O P LE P AR TI CI P AT E (O R DO N’ T) III. WH IC H ST AT ES HA VE HI GHE R TU RN OU T? IV . STATES AND ELECTIONS  V. DIRECT DEMOCRACY  VI . PROTEST AND PUBLIC OPINION Ch 5: Political Attitudes and Participation Part 2: Participation & Opinion History of Vote By Mail in Oregon  VBM adopted locally 1987; statewide used 1993 special election Practical concerns Measure 60 in 1998 Gronke, Paul and Peter Miller. 2012. “Voting by mail and turount in Oregon: Revisiting Southwell and Burchett”  American Politics Research 40: 976. Turnout in Oregon Source: Gronke, Paul and Peter Miller. 2012. “Voting by mail and turount in Oregon: Revisiting Southwell and Burchett” American Politics Research 40: 976.

Upload: timothy-huang

Post on 02-Jun-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

I F O R M S O F PO L I T I C A L PA R T I C I PA T I O N

I I WH Y P E O P LE P AR TI CI P AT E (O R DO Nrsquo T)

I I I WH IC H ST AT E S HA VE HI G HE R TU RN OU T

IV S T A T E S A ND E L E C T I O NS

V D I R E C T D E M O C R A C Y

VI PR O T E S T A ND PU BL I C O PI NI O N

Ch 5 Political Attitudes andParticipation

Part 2 Participation amp Opinion

History of Vote By Mail in Oregon

VBM adopted locally 1987 statewide used 1993special election

Practical concerns

Measure 60 in 1998

Gronke Paul and Peter Miller 2012ldquoVoting by mail and turount in OregonRevisiting Southwell and Burchettrdquo

American Politics Research 40 976

Turnout in Oregon

Source Gronke Paul and Peter Miller 2012 ldquoVoting by mail and turount inOregon Revisiting Southwell and Burchettrdquo American Politics Research 40 976

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

Turnout in Oregon

Source Gronke Paul and Peter Miller 2012 ldquoVoting by mail and turount inOregon Revisiting Southwell and Burchettrdquo American Politics Research 40 976

Turnout in Oregon

Source Gronke Paul and Peter Miller 2012 ldquoVoting by mail and turount inOregon Revisiting Southwell and Burchettrdquo American Politics Research 40 976

VBM amp Turnout in Oregon

So what

Limitation of the impact of BVM

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 312

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters tooE Voting laws can change outcomes

1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

Texas voting registration requirements

Must register to vote 30 days before the election

httpvotetexasgov

Automatically receive a new certificate every two

years if you havenrsquot moved

Texas voting requirements

Required

Texas Driverrsquos License

Texas ID card

US passport

Military id (with picture) US Citizenship certificate

(with photo)

Election identificationcertificate

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 412

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters too

E Voting laws can change outcomes1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

F Poll closing times matter

III Which states participate

F Why turnout rates matter

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 512

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

1 TEXAS ELECTION TURNOUT

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002

SMITH

BRISCOE

WHITE

RICHARDS

BUSH

BUSH

CLEMENTS

CLEMENTS PERRY

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter

1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 PARADOX OF THE TEXAS REPUBLICAN PARTY

30 is key Below 30 Republicans

have an advantage

Over 30 Democrats

have the advantage

WHY

DEMOCRATS

REPUBLICANS

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 612

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 Paradox of the Texas Republican Party

3 Turnout can determine partisan control

IV States and Elections

A T H E F E D E R A L G O V E R NM E NT

B S T A T E G O V E R NM E NT SC M U NI C I PA L G O V E R NM E NT S

D T H E L E A G U E O F W O M E N V O T E R S

E T H E F E D E R A L E L E C T O R A L T R I BU NA L

Who has primary responsibilityfor conducting elections

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 2: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

Turnout in Oregon

Source Gronke Paul and Peter Miller 2012 ldquoVoting by mail and turount inOregon Revisiting Southwell and Burchettrdquo American Politics Research 40 976

Turnout in Oregon

Source Gronke Paul and Peter Miller 2012 ldquoVoting by mail and turount inOregon Revisiting Southwell and Burchettrdquo American Politics Research 40 976

VBM amp Turnout in Oregon

So what

Limitation of the impact of BVM

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 312

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters tooE Voting laws can change outcomes

1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

Texas voting registration requirements

Must register to vote 30 days before the election

httpvotetexasgov

Automatically receive a new certificate every two

years if you havenrsquot moved

Texas voting requirements

Required

Texas Driverrsquos License

Texas ID card

US passport

Military id (with picture) US Citizenship certificate

(with photo)

Election identificationcertificate

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 412

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters too

E Voting laws can change outcomes1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

F Poll closing times matter

III Which states participate

F Why turnout rates matter

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 512

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

1 TEXAS ELECTION TURNOUT

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002

SMITH

BRISCOE

WHITE

RICHARDS

BUSH

BUSH

CLEMENTS

CLEMENTS PERRY

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter

1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 PARADOX OF THE TEXAS REPUBLICAN PARTY

30 is key Below 30 Republicans

have an advantage

Over 30 Democrats

have the advantage

WHY

DEMOCRATS

REPUBLICANS

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 612

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 Paradox of the Texas Republican Party

3 Turnout can determine partisan control

IV States and Elections

A T H E F E D E R A L G O V E R NM E NT

B S T A T E G O V E R NM E NT SC M U NI C I PA L G O V E R NM E NT S

D T H E L E A G U E O F W O M E N V O T E R S

E T H E F E D E R A L E L E C T O R A L T R I BU NA L

Who has primary responsibilityfor conducting elections

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 3: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 312

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters tooE Voting laws can change outcomes

1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

Texas voting registration requirements

Must register to vote 30 days before the election

httpvotetexasgov

Automatically receive a new certificate every two

years if you havenrsquot moved

Texas voting requirements

Required

Texas Driverrsquos License

Texas ID card

US passport

Military id (with picture) US Citizenship certificate

(with photo)

Election identificationcertificate

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 412

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters too

E Voting laws can change outcomes1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

F Poll closing times matter

III Which states participate

F Why turnout rates matter

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 512

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

1 TEXAS ELECTION TURNOUT

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002

SMITH

BRISCOE

WHITE

RICHARDS

BUSH

BUSH

CLEMENTS

CLEMENTS PERRY

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter

1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 PARADOX OF THE TEXAS REPUBLICAN PARTY

30 is key Below 30 Republicans

have an advantage

Over 30 Democrats

have the advantage

WHY

DEMOCRATS

REPUBLICANS

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 612

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 Paradox of the Texas Republican Party

3 Turnout can determine partisan control

IV States and Elections

A T H E F E D E R A L G O V E R NM E NT

B S T A T E G O V E R NM E NT SC M U NI C I PA L G O V E R NM E NT S

D T H E L E A G U E O F W O M E N V O T E R S

E T H E F E D E R A L E L E C T O R A L T R I BU NA L

Who has primary responsibilityfor conducting elections

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 4: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 412

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate (cont)

C The type of election can influence turnout

D How competitive the election is matters too

E Voting laws can change outcomes1 Elections by Mail

2 Registration requirements

3 ldquoMotor Voterrdquo Laws

a Why is 1993 Voter Registration Act a big deal

F Poll closing times matter

III Which states participate

F Why turnout rates matter

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 512

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

1 TEXAS ELECTION TURNOUT

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002

SMITH

BRISCOE

WHITE

RICHARDS

BUSH

BUSH

CLEMENTS

CLEMENTS PERRY

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter

1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 PARADOX OF THE TEXAS REPUBLICAN PARTY

30 is key Below 30 Republicans

have an advantage

Over 30 Democrats

have the advantage

WHY

DEMOCRATS

REPUBLICANS

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 612

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 Paradox of the Texas Republican Party

3 Turnout can determine partisan control

IV States and Elections

A T H E F E D E R A L G O V E R NM E NT

B S T A T E G O V E R NM E NT SC M U NI C I PA L G O V E R NM E NT S

D T H E L E A G U E O F W O M E N V O T E R S

E T H E F E D E R A L E L E C T O R A L T R I BU NA L

Who has primary responsibilityfor conducting elections

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 5: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 512

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

1 TEXAS ELECTION TURNOUT

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002

SMITH

BRISCOE

WHITE

RICHARDS

BUSH

BUSH

CLEMENTS

CLEMENTS PERRY

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter

1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 PARADOX OF THE TEXAS REPUBLICAN PARTY

30 is key Below 30 Republicans

have an advantage

Over 30 Democrats

have the advantage

WHY

DEMOCRATS

REPUBLICANS

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 612

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 Paradox of the Texas Republican Party

3 Turnout can determine partisan control

IV States and Elections

A T H E F E D E R A L G O V E R NM E NT

B S T A T E G O V E R NM E NT SC M U NI C I PA L G O V E R NM E NT S

D T H E L E A G U E O F W O M E N V O T E R S

E T H E F E D E R A L E L E C T O R A L T R I BU NA L

Who has primary responsibilityfor conducting elections

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 6: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 612

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

III Which states participate

C Why turnout rates matter1 Texas Election Turnout patterns

2 Paradox of the Texas Republican Party

3 Turnout can determine partisan control

IV States and Elections

A T H E F E D E R A L G O V E R NM E NT

B S T A T E G O V E R NM E NT SC M U NI C I PA L G O V E R NM E NT S

D T H E L E A G U E O F W O M E N V O T E R S

E T H E F E D E R A L E L E C T O R A L T R I BU NA L

Who has primary responsibilityfor conducting elections

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 7: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 712

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

A US Constitution and voting1 ldquoThe electors in each state shall have the qualifications

requisite for electors for the most numerous branch of thestate legislaturerdquo

- Article 1 US Constitution

IV States and Elections (cont)

B States control elections through ballot regulation1 States impose different regulations on elections

2 Regulations reinforce political culture

3 This leads to 50 different election codes

IV States and Elections

C Control over elections meant control over who voted

1 Limited (restricted) suffrage

2 Restrictions registration rule still matter

Wersquoll come back toimplications for

parties

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 8: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 812

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

IV States and Elections

Consider how history might affect turnout today

D Regulating who votes in Texas A 1902 ndash 1964 (1966) Poll Tax

B 1923 ndash 1945 ldquoWhite Primaryrdquo

C Until 1970s Property requirements

IV States and Elections

D Regulating who votes in Texas (cont)D 1966 ndash 1971 Annual Registration System

E 1972 Progressive Permanent Registration System

F Presently requires registration 30 days before election

G Voter ID law (discussed above)

All these things successfully restricted voter registration which may be why turnout in Texas is lower thanelsewhere in the country

V Direct Democracy

ldquo PO PU L A R PA R T I C I PA T I O N I N G O V E R NM E NT

T H R O U G H D I R E C T V O T E R I NI T I A T I O N O FPO L I C Y A ND V O T E R A PPR O V A L O RR E J E C T I O N O F PO L I C Y D E C I S I O NS BYPO PU L A R V O T E rdquo

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 9: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 912

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy

A Direct Democracy vs Representative

Democracy1 Direct citizens decide on issues

2 Representative citizens elect leaders to decide for them

V Direct democracy (cont)

B Mechanisms1 Ballot initiatives

2 Referenda (Referendum)

3 Recall

4 Ballot initiative v legislative referendum

V Direct democracy (cont)

C Consequences (examples)1 Amendments to state constitutions to prohibit same sex

marriages

2 Voters have approved initiatives that make medical

marijuana legal3 Californiarsquos Prop 13 which rolled back property taxes

4 Californiarsquos Prop 87 which denied education and health benefits to illegal immigrants

D Limits1 Term Limits

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 10: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1012

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

V Direct Democracy (cont)

E Arguments for Direct Democracy 1 Increases government responsiveness

2 Allows representation of issues that are ignored

3 Stimulates public debate

4 Increases interest in elections and turnout

5 Can reduce citizen alienation

V Direct Democracy (cont)

F Arguments against Direct Democracy (or whyRepresentative Democracy is better)

1 Can promote tyranny of the majority

2 Can lead to the adoption of unsound policy

3 Voters may not be well informed

4 No provision for compromise or modification

V Direct Democracy (cont)

G Where

1 Progressive Era (1902 ndash 1918)

a 16 states adopted ballot initiative procedures

b Only 5 later

2 Many of the states that allow ballot initiates are WesternStates

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 11: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1112

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion

VI Protest and Public Opinion

A Public Opinion matters

1 In general politicians respond to public opinion

2 How do politicians know what citizens think

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

B Protest as Participation

1 Organized protests ndash marches demonstrations disruptionscivil disobedience ndash are all forms of political activity

2 Do they work It depends hellip

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge

Page 12: 11 Participation2 SLIDES

8102019 11 Participation2 SLIDES

httpslidepdfcomreaderfull11-participation2-slides 1212

983089983088983087983097983087983090983088

VI Protest and Public Opinion (cont)

C E-Democracy Fact or fiction1 Internet Votingblogstown halls

2 Marylandrsquos Red Bridge