1.10 expectant management of early onset of severe pre-eclampsia in durban, j.moodley, s.a.korant

5
 Expectant management o f early onset o f severe pre eclampsia i n  urban J MOODLEY, S. A. KORANTENG, C . ROUT Abstract Fifty patientswith severe pre-eciaInpsia wh o pre sented before 32 weeks' gestation were managed conservatively(sedation, bed rest, antihyperten sive therapy a n d intensive fetal an d maternal monitoring) until intervention w a s indicated. Twelve patientspresented before 26 weeks ofpreg nancy and ther were no fetal survivors in this group; 23 presented between 26 a n d 29 weeks a nd 8(34,8 ) o f th e babies in this group survived. The rate o f perinatal loss i n those presenting between 30 an d 32 weeks wa s 26,6 N = 4) . Patients wh o h a d a history o f a hypertensive disorder i n their previous pregnancy(ies) h ad a higher perinatal mortality rate; 23 such mothers experienced 16 perinatal losses compared with 27 mothers who h a d no such history a nd who had only 8 perinatal losses. There was 1 maternal death, there were 2 cases o f eclampsia, 3 of pulmonary oedema, 4 of abrup tioplacentae a nd 1 case o f renal failure; 2 patients h a d disseminatedintravascular coagulation. T h e localindigent and underprivileged black popula tion have a more aggressive form o f early onset o f severe pre-eclampsia thanthat reported for other population groups. T h e high maternal complica tion rate o f 30,8 a nd th e low fetal survival rate before 26 weeks indicate that there is no place i n o u r setting for expectant management o f severe pre-eclampsia i n patients presenting before 26 weeks. This applies particularly to those with a previoushistory o f hypertension in pregnancy. 5 At r  e J 1 9 93 ; 8 3 : 5 8 4- 5 87 . S evere pre-eclampsia that complicates chronic hypertension or renal disease occurring in mid trimester is a decision-making dilemma for th e obstetrician. On the one hand is th e knowledge thatthe ultimate cure is delivery of t he f et us and placenta, an d on the other is knowledge of the high perinatal mortality rate among babies delivered to o early. Most obstetri c ia ns c ho os e to manage these patients c o ns e rv a ti v ely, hoping to ac hie ve fe ta l l un g m at ur it y b ef or e d el iv er yY Sibai er al. however, highli ghted the high mater n a l r is ks an d the high numberof p e ri n at a l l os s es a s so ci a te d w i th conservative managementand concluded that t h er e w as no p la ce f or such an approach. Pattinson et  l have more recently advocated conservative management in patients presenting later than24 weeks based on a 38 sal vage rate in theirstudy. Th e presentstudywas under taken to assess the outcome o f severe pre-eclampsia before 32 weeks gestation in members of an indigent an d underprivil eged black community a t te n di n g a l ar ge tertiary urban hospital, viz. King EdwardVllI Hospital, an d to assess the value of expectant management. MR C PregnancyHypertensionResearch Unit,Departm.ent o f Obstetrics a n d Gynaecology, University of Natal, Durban J MOODLEY, M.B. CH.B., F.KCO.G., F.CO.G., MD S. A. KORANTENG, M.B. CR B C. ROUT, M.B. B.S., F.KC.A. Accepted  Sep 1992.  tients  n methods All p at ie nt s w it h s ev ere p re -e cl am ps ia d ef in ed as t wo recordings of d ia st ol ic b l oo d p re s su re g re at e r than 110 mmHg at least 6 hours apart with proteinuria) admitted to hos pi ta l between May an d August 1991 were includ ed in the s tu dy . Ge sta ti on al age was d et er mi ne d b y th e date of the last menstrual period an d confirmed by u lt ra so no gr ap hy . O nl y p at ie nt s w it h a live f et us of less than 32 weeks' gestational age were included in th e study. Patients were managed according to standard methods B ri ef ly t h es e c o mp r i se d an initial intramuscu la r injection of 20 0 mg sodiumphenobarbitone and a l o ad i ng d o se of 1 g a-methyldopa followed by 2 g every 24 h o ur s i n d iv id ed d os es . I n tr a ve n ou s c ry st al lo id i nf u sion w as a d m in i s te r e d to raise the intravascular volume. to 6 cm  O in those patients with a low central venous pressure  CVP reading. Intravenous fluids were no t infused  th e CV P reading was 6 cm H 2  or greater. Intravenous dihydralazine 6,25 mg was given if the blood pressure remained elevated at a d ia s to li c l ev el of 11 0 mmHg or more, 2 hours after sedation and the. loading dose of a-methyldopa. Where th e gestational age was 28 weeks or m or e, d ih yd ra la zi ne wa s a dm in i stered while the fetal heart rate was continuously moni tored by external cardiotocography in order to detect acute fetal distress due to any inadvenent rapid lowering of the high blood pressure an d subsequent decrease in uteroplacental circul ation. 5 A second drug, monohydralazine, 75 - 20 0 mg in 24 hours, was added to the treatment if th e high blood pressure wa s n o t lowered within 24 - 48 hours o f a-methyldopa therapy an d bed rest. I t a third antihyper t en si ve agent ha d to be added to the drug regimen, the patient was considered to have resistant hypertension, an d s er io us c on si de ra ti on w as g iv en to termination of pregnancy. laboratory included urine protein detection by means of a d ip s ti ck t e ch n iq u e, a s se s sm en t of urea an d electrolyte lev el s, blood u ri c a c id an d serum creatinine, blood count including platel et count an d measurement of haematocrit levels , l iv er function tes t s, a c oa gu la ti on p ro fil e, a full 24-hour urine protein an d creatinine clearance estimation an d urine microscopy to. detect underlying renal disease. All patients wh o were more than 28 weeks pregnant w er e g iv en dexametha zone 8 mg 8-hourly for 48 hours; this was repeated wee kl y with th e aim of achievi ng f et al l u n g m a tu r it y . Indications for delivery were divided into maternal factors an d fetal factors. Maternal indications were uncontrollable hypertension, imminent eclampsia, eclampsia, pulmonary oedema, renal failure, an impaired liver function test, coagulopathy an d abruptio placentae. Fetal indications for delivery were abnormal fetal heart rate patterns, intra-uterine growth retardation and severe oligohydr amni os. The mode of d el iv ery was i n di v id u al is e d. Caesarean s ec ti on w as d e ci de d upon  there was an obstetri c indi cation and not for prematurity  r se 6 In the post-deliv e ry p e ri o d, the patients were kept in a h ig h -c a re ward for 24 hours an d subsequently transferred to the post natal ward  their condition had stabilised. All infants d is ch ar ge d w er e c o ns id e re d t o h av e s ur vi ve d. Patients who presented with impending eclampsia an d eclampsia

Upload: ana-liz-chavez-velasquez

Post on 14-Feb-2018

227 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

7/23/2019 1.10 Expectant Management of Early Onset of Severe Pre-eclampsia in Durban, j.moodley, s.a.korant

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/110-expectant-management-of-early-onset-of-severe-pre-eclampsia-in-durban 1/4

 

Expectant management

of early

onset of

severe

pre eclampsia

in   urban

J

MOODLEY, S.

A. KORANTENG,

C.

ROUT

Abstract Fifty patients with severe pre-eciaInpsia who pre

sented before 32 weeks ' g es ta tion were managed

conservatively (sedation, bed r es t,

antihyperten

sive therapy

and

intensive fetal

and

maternal

mon ito ri ng) un ti l i n te rvent ion was indicated.

Twelve patients presented

before

26

weeks

ofpreg

nancy

a nd t he re were n o fetal survivors in

this

group; 23 presented

between

26 and 29 weeks and

8(34,8 ) of th e babies in

this

group survived. The

rate of perinatal loss in

those

presenting

between

30 and 32

weeks

was 26,6 N =4). Patients

who

had

a

history

of

a

hypertensive

disorder

in

their

previous pregnancy( ies) had a higher perinatal

mor ta li ty ra te ;

23

such mothe rs experienced 16

perinatal

losses

compared with

27

mothers

who

had no

such

history and

who

had

only 8

perinatal

losses.

There

was 1

maternal death, there

were 2 cases

of eclampsia,

3 of

pulmonary oedema,

4

of abrup

t io placentae

and 1

case of

renal

failure;

2

patients

had disseminated intravascular

coagulation.

The

local indigen t

and

underprivileged

black popula

tion have a

more

aggressive form of

early

onset of

severe pre-eclampsia t han that reported

fo r

other

population

groups.

The

high maternal complica

t ion r at e of 30,8 and

th e

low fetal surviva l rate

before

26

weeks

indicate

that

there

is no

place

in

our

sett ing for

expectant management

of severe

pre-eclampsia in patients

presenting before

26

weeks. This

applies

par ticular ly to t ho se wi th a

previous history

of

hypertension in pregnancy.

5 At r  e J 1993; 83: 584-587.

S

evere

pre-eclampsia that

complicates

chronic

hypertension

or r enal disease

occurring in

mid

trimester

is a

decision-making

dilemma for

the

obstetrician.

On t he one hand

is

the

knowledge

that the

ultimate cure

is

delivery

of

the fetus

and

placenta,

and

on

the

other

is knowledge of the high perinatal mortality

rate

among babies delivered

too

early. Most obstetri

c ia ns c ho os e to

manage

these patients conservatively,

hoping to

achieve fetal l ung mat ur it y bef or e del iver yY

Sibai er al. however, highlighted the high maternal risks

and

t he high

number of

perinatal losses associated with

conservative

management and

concluded

that

there was

no

place f or

such an approach.

Pattinson

et

  l have

more

recently

advocated

conservative

management

in

patients presenting later

t han 24

weeks based

on

a

38

salvage rate

in

their study.

The

present study was

under

taken

t o a ss es s

the outcome

of severe

pre-eclampsia

before

32

weeks gestation in

members

of

an

indigent

and

underprivileged black

community

attending a large

tertiary

urban

hospital,

viz.

King

Edward VllI

Hospital,

and

to assess the value of expectant management.

MRC Pregnancy Hypertension Research Unit, Departm.ent

of

Obstetrics and

Gynaecology, University

of

Natal,

Durban

J

MOODLEY,

M.B.

CH.B., F.KCO.G.,

F.CO.G., MD

S . A. KORANTENG, M.B.

CRB

C. ROUT,

M.B. B.S.,

F.KC.A.

Accepted

 

Sep 1992.

  tients

 n

methods

All pat ient s wit h severe pre-ecl ampsia def ined as t wo

recordings

of

diastolic blood pressure greater

than

110

mmHg at

l east 6 hours apart wit h proteinur ia) admit ted

to hospital

between

May

and

August 1991 were i nclud

ed

in the s tu dy . Ge sta ti on al age was d et er mi ne d b y

the

date of

the l as t

menstrual

period

and confirmed

by

ult rasonogr aphy. Onl y pat ient s wit h a live f et us of less

than 32

weeks'

gest at ional age

were

included

in

the

study.

Patients

were

managed according to

standard

methods

Briefly these comprised

an

initial intramuscu

lar

injection of

200

mg

sodium phenobarbitone and

a

loading dose of 1 g a -m et hy ld op a followed b y 2 g every

24

hours in divided doses. Intravenous crystalloid infu

sion was administered

to

raise

the

intravascular volume.

to 6 cm

  O

i n t hose pat ient s wit h a l ow centr al venous

pressure

 CVP reading.

Intravenous

fluids

were no t

infused  

the

CVP rea din g was 6

cm

H

2

  or

greater.

Intravenous dihydralazine 6,25 mg

wa s g iv en

if th e

blood pressure remained elevated

at

a diastolic level

of

110

mmHg or

more,

2

hours

after sedation

and

the.

loading

dose

of

a-methyldopa. Where

the

gestational

age was

28

weeks

or

mor e, dihydralazi ne was admini

stered while the fetal

heart

rate was continuously moni

tored

by external cardiotocography

in

order

to detect

acute fetal distr ess due t o any

inadvenent

rapid lowering

of

the high blood pressur e

and subsequent

decrease in

uteroplacental circulation.

5

A second drug, monohydralazi ne, 75 -

200 mg

in 24

hours,

was

added

to

the treatment if the high blood

pressure was

not

lowered

within 24 -

48

hours

of

a-methyldopa therapy and bed rest. It a

third

antihyper

tensive agent

had

to be

added to

the

drug

regimen, the

pat ient was consi dered

to

have resistant hypertension,

and

ser ious consi derati on was given to

termination of

pregnancy.

Initial

laboratory

screening

included urine protein

detection by means

of

a dipstick technique, assessment

of

urea

and

electrolyte levels,

blood

uric acid

and serum

creatinine, full blood

count

including platelet

count

and

measurement of haematocrit levels, liver function tests,

a coagulati on profil e, a

full 24-hour

urine

protein and

creatinine clearance estimation and urine microscopy to.

det ect under lying r enal disease. All pat ient s

who

were

more than 28

weeks

pregnant

wer e given

dexametha

zone 8 mg

8-hourly

for

48

hours;

t hi s wa s

repeated

weekly with

the aim of

achieving fetal lung maturity.

I ndicat ions for del ivery wer e divided i nt o

maternal

factors and f et al f actors.

Maternal indications

were

uncontrollable hypertension, imminent

eclampsia,

eclampsia, pulmonary

oedema,

renal f ai lu re , an

impaired liver function test, coagulopathy

and

abruptio

placentae. Fetal indications for delivery were abnormal

fetal

heart

rate patterns, intra-uterine growth retardation

and severe oligohydramnios.

The

mode

of delivery was individualised. Caesarean

section was decided

upon

  there was

an

obstetric indi

cation

and not

for prematurity

  r se

6

In the post-deliv

ery period,

the

pat ient s wer e kept

in

a high-care

ward

for 24

hours

and

subsequentl y t ransferr ed t o t he post

natal

ward  

their condition

had

stabilised. All infants

dischar ged wer e considered t o have sur vi ved. Pat ient s

who

presented

with

impending

eclampsia

and

eclampsia

7/23/2019 1.10 Expectant Management of Early Onset of Severe Pre-eclampsia in Durban, j.moodley, s.a.korant

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/110-expectant-management-of-early-onset-of-severe-pre-eclampsia-in-durban 2/4

  =

sults

were not included in t he srudy because

the standard

management of these patients was immediate delivery.

All results are

presented

as

means

and ranges.

Where

applicable,

Srudent s

[-test was applied

and

a P-value of

< 0,05 taken as significant.

Fifty patients who fulfilled the criteria for admission to

t he srudy were seen during a 4-month period. Their

clinical

data

are

shown

in Table

1.

None of the patients

was

under

17 years old; 19 were aged between 21

and

29 years

and

8 were more than 35 years

of

age. There

were 12 primigravidas ; 8 pat ients had 4 or more child

ren,

20 patients

had 2 or 3 children, and 10 were

secundigravidas.

The perinatal survival

rate

at varying gestational ages

is

shown

in Table IT. All pregnancies of 26 weeks gesta

tional age and less

resul ted in intra-uter ine deaths

(Table lIT). Of

the

2

neonatal

deaths in pregnancies

between

28 and 29 weeks gestation, 1 had multiple

congenital abnormalities

and

the o ther d ied

of

severe

sepsis. There

were

3 macerated stillbirths

between

30

and 32 weeks gestation.

In

the gesta tional age

group

27

- 32 weeks,

there

were 15 stillbirths (30 ); 3

of

these weighed less than

500 g; 7

weighed

between

500

g and I

000

g and 5

between 1 000 g and 1 500 g. Four

patients

with

abruptio

placentae delivered babies less

than

1

000

g in

weight.

Apart

from

a previous history of pre-eclampsia no

other factors,

viz.

age,

parity

or

proreinuria,

predicted

the outcome of

any

of

the pregnancies.

Twenty-three

(46 ) of t he 50 pat ient s had a history

of

pre-eclampsia

in their previous pregnancies. The fetal loss in these

23

pat ients was 16

(69,6 )

compared with a fetal loss of 8

(29,6 ) in those patients without a

history

of pre

eclampsia

 P < 0,01). The average number

of

days

gained by conservative management was 12,3 days. The

mean weight

of

all surviving babies was 1 300 g and that

of non-surviving babies 817 g. Tab le I II shows that

those patients admitted before they

reached 26

weeks

gestation

gained more

days

by expectant medical

management than those admitted later.

Maternal

complications are

shown

in Table IV. Two

patients developed

eclampsia

during

the s rudy

period.

One was a

21-year-old primigravida admi tted a t

26

weeks,

with

a blood

pressure

of

1501120 mrnHg. She

had her blood pressure

controlled with

a-methyldopa

but absconded after a 30-day s tay i n hospi ta l.

She

returned

a week later , having had a convulsion

at home.

A diagnosis of

eclampsia

was

made

on

readmission

(blood

pressure =160 110 mmHg;

proteinuria

++) and

a live

baby

weighing 1

500

g was delivered

by

caesarean

section. The

second patient

had

requested

a

weekend s

leave to

attend

to her domestic

problems

following a

3-week stay in hospital. She did

no r

rerum after

the

weekend

bu t was readmitted a week la te r

with eclamp

sia. Following caesarean section, she wen t into pu l

monary

oedema. Four

patients

developed

abruptio

placentae during expectant management.

Their ages

Range

17 - 40

0 -7

140 - 250

110 - 160

0,63 - 8,7

175 (22,77)

122 (13,99)

3,6 (2,88)

TABLE

Clinical data on all patients

Age (yrs) 29 (6,39)

Parity 2,3 (2,06)

Blood presure  mmHg)

Systolic

Oiastolic

Proteinuria (g/24 h)

N

= 50 Mean

 SO)

TABLE  

Survival

rate

of babies at different gestational ages

Babies dead Early neonatal

Fetal

Gestational

No.

of

at birth death

salvage

age (wks) patients No.

 

No.

 

No.

 

<26

12

12

26 - 27

9 5

55,6 1

11,1

3

33,3

28 - 29

14

7 50

2 12,3

5

35,7

30 - 32

15

3

20,0 1 6,7

11 73,3

Total 50 27 52 4 8 19 40

• Stillbirths and abortions.

TABLE

Ill.

Pregnancies below 26weeks

gestation

Blood

Gestational

Fetal

Age Gestational

pressure

Interval age at weight

(yrs)

Parity

age

(wks)

 mmHg)

Proteinuria

Complication Outcome  d)

delivery g)

24 1 24

21 16 3+

i BP,

ascites

IUO

8

25 500

21

0

23

16 12

3+

Oligohydramnios IUD 12 25

400

35

2 22

21 16

2+

i BP IUD

2

22

400

22 0 24

2 14 3+

Imminent eclampsia Abortion

2

24

400

22

0

22

190/140

2+

DIC, i

BP,

i

urates

IUD

23 25

650

40 7 24

21 11

2+

i

BP FSB 4 25 600

30 3

11 23 12 4+

Maternal death Abortion

81 23

300

31

3

16

18 13

3+

Renal failure

IOL

45 22

250

20 1 20

25 16

3+

i BP

IOL

1 20

250

25 3 25

15 12

3+

i

Urates IOL,MSB

25 29

1000

33 6

22

15 11

3+

Abruptio Abortion

8

23

300

29

1 20

15 12

3+

i BP

IOL 21

23

500

i

BP- rising blood pressure values; DIC - disseminated intravascular coagulation; IUD - intra-uterine death; FSB - fresh stillbirth; IOL- induction of labour;

MSB - macerated stillbirth.

• Days gained: mean ± SO =32 7 ± 22 9; median =1

7/23/2019 1.10 Expectant Management of Early Onset of Severe Pre-eclampsia in Durban, j.moodley, s.a.korant

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/110-expectant-management-of-early-onset-of-severe-pre-eclampsia-in-durban 3/4

ranged from 29 to 35 years and parity f rom 3 to 8; 3 had

proteinuria with diastolic blood pressures ranging from

110

to

120 mmHg and 3

had

had hypertension in a pre

vious pregnancy. All 4 were less than 29 weeks pregnant

and

did

not have non-stress tests.

TABLE V.

  tern l complic tions

Uncontrollable hypertension 19

Abruptio placentae 4

Pulmonary oedema

3

Coagulopathy Iow platelet counts 3

Imminent eclampsia 9

Renal failure decreased UQ;

i

urea

1

Eclampsia 2

Maternal death 1

uo

=

urine output.

There

was

one

maternal death in a known hyperten

sive, aged

30

years. Her hypertension had required 5

different medications. This patient was lost to follow-up

and

then

presented at

11

weeks' gestation with a blood

pressure

of

230/120

mmHg and

4

+

albuminuria. She

had had 3 previous pregnancies which had resulted in

non-obstetric deaths and therefore refused termination

of

pregnancy

despite intensive

counselling.

She

col

lapsed suddenly at 21 weeks' gestation. Post-mortem

findings included nephrosclerosis, hypertensive cardiac

disease,

old

dissection of abdominal aor ta and right

sided cardiac failure, bu t

the exact cause

of

death was

not

established. Sections

of

the brain did

not

reveal any

intracerebral haemorrhage

nor

was there any evidence of

subendocardial ischaemia.

Three patients developed pulmonary oedema.

One

case of pulmonary oedema

occurred

in an eclamptic

described above, the other in a 29-year-old patient with

a

previous history

of eclampsia and stillbirth.

Sh e

was

admit ted a t

23 weeks

with

a

blood

pressure

of

150/120 mmHg

and

3 + proteinuria, and developed

pulmonary

oedema 2

hours

after admission. She had

had o y

200 ml

Ringer's lactate in this 2-hour period.

The

central venous line was only inserted after the onset

of

pulmonary oedema. She refused termination

of

preg

nancy after she was resuscitated and subsequently suf

fered

an

intra-uterine death. She delivered a macerated

stillborn baby 3 weeks later.

The

third patient

was

admi tt ed a t 29

weeks wi th a

blood pressure of200/130 rnmHg and a previous histo

ry of pre-eclampsia. She was given a rapid-acting antihy

pertensive agent on admission with concomitant central

venous pressure recordings

and

electronic fetal heart

rate monitoring. The

blood

pressure was well controlled

and

she was transferred to the lying-in ward. She deve

loped pulmonary oedema

on

the third day post-admis

sion, had an intra-uterine fetal death and delivered a

1 200 g macerated stillborn baby.

This

patient did not

have an int ravenous line in

the

lying-in ward. Renal

failure

occurred

in a 31-year-old patient admit ted at

31 weeks' gestation with a blood pressure of 230/120

mmHg.

Antihypertensive

therapy

initially included

intravenous dihydralazine. This was followed by a

u

methyldopa and monohydralazine. She was given dexa

methazone 8 mg every 8 hours for 48 hours to achieve

fetal lung

maturity. Her

blood urea

and

electrolyte

values however started rising

and

creatinille clearance

fell to less

than

50 mllmin during expectant manage

ment. She was therefore delivered of a live 1 700 g baby

by emergency caesarean section

on

the

8th

day. She had

to have renal dialysis when her urine

ourput

failed to

improve

and

her serum potassium levels began rising

postoperatively.

Nine

patients who developed signs of

imminent

eclampsia while in hospital were delivered after stabilisa

tion of high blood pressure.

 is ussion

Pregnant women presenting at or before 28

weeks

gestation with severe pre-eclampsia are associated with

high maternal

and

perinatal mortality rates.

l

,2 This study

confirms the findings of previous workers

l

,2 that fetal

salvage rates before 26 weeks' gestation in severe pre

eclampsia are

poor.

There were no fetal

survivors

among the 12 patients presenting before

26

weeks

gestation.

The overall perinatal mortality rate in

the present

study was extremely high (620/1 000 deliveries). This is

much higher t han the figure quoted by Moodley

215/1 000 deliveries for all cases of hypertension and

proteinuria for

the

same

population

group. However,

the

present

study

was

performed

in

a very

high-risk

group from an indigent population in a developing com

munity with limited neonatal facilities.   only pregnan

cies of 30 weeks' gestation and

more

are included,

then

the perinatal mortality rate in this study falls to 80/1 000

deliveries. This is similar to that reported by Odendaal

et al

and D

avey

7 for gestational ages of

30

weeks and

more.

Sibai et a l also reported a high perinatal mortali ty

rate of 250/1 000 deliveries (despite intensive treatment

of severe hypertension in the mid-trimester). They

reviewed pregnancy outcome over a 7-year per iod in 60

patients with severe pre-eclampsia between 18 and 27

weeks' gestation. The perinatal outcome for these preg

nancies was extremely poor, 31

of

the

60 pregnancies

ended in fetal demise

and

21 in neonatal deaths, giving

a total perinatal mortality rate

of

87 . In addition, the

perinatal survival rate was 3 for those developing

severe disease before 25 weeks' gestation compared with

24

for those developing disease

at or

after 25 weeks'

gestation. The majority

of

pat ients (70 ) in this s tudy

were black and indigent.

Odendaal et al described

favourable results with

expectant management in 45 patients developing severe

hypertension before 28 weeks. Eleven were less than 24

weeks pregnant and all 11 suffered perinatal deaths. The

remaining 34 patients were between 24 and 28 weeks'

gestation

and

14

of

these (41 ) produced an infant that

survived.

Thus

all these studies

and

the present one

confirm the poor perinatal outcome in pregnancies of 24

weeks' gestation or below.

There were

only 12 (24 )

primigravidas

in this

study. This figure is lower than those reported in o ther

series of severe early pre-eclampsia where the proportion

of

primigravidas varied between 31 and

67 .8 10 This

might therefore explain the

poor

outcome in this study

compared with other studies which had a larger number

of primigravidas. Moodley

reported that

the perinatal

mortality rate in primigravidas with proteinuric hyper

tension was 117/1 000 deliveries while that of multi

gravidas with proteinuric hypertension in late pregnancy

was 215/1 000 in a population similar to that of the

pre

sent study. Explanation

of

the high incidence

of

multi

gravidas is difficult as follow-up of patients in a large

hospital is poor;

consequently

the

role

of essential

hypertension and renal

disease

is difficult

to

assess,.

Feeny has reported that change

of

partners may play a

role in multiparous women presenting with pre-eclamp

sia for the first time and as this is no t an uncommon fea

ture

in the local population, it

may be

a factor.

A history of hypertension in a previous pregnancy

was present in 23 (46 ) pat ients in this s tudy and these

patients had a greater fetal loss rate than those without a

7/23/2019 1.10 Expectant Management of Early Onset of Severe Pre-eclampsia in Durban, j.moodley, s.a.korant

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/110-expectant-management-of-early-onset-of-severe-pre-eclampsia-in-durban 4/4

history of previous

hypertension

- 16 (69 ,6 ) com

pared with 8 (29,6%). In a case con trol s tudv of severe

pre-eclampsia of early onset Moo re and Redman

'o

found that

a history of chronic hypertension or renal dis

ease was

no t

significantly associated with pre-eclampsia

bu t

that significantly more patients

had

had previous

pre-eclampsia.

The

policy

at

King

Edward

VIII Hospital at the t ime

of

the srudy was no t to deliver feruses before 28 weeks

or i f they

weighed

less than 1 000 g (unless specific

maternal

indications necessitated delivery) because the

perinatal

mortality

rate

in

this group

at the

hospital

is

100 .

Ten

of th e

15

stillbirths weighed

less

than

1 000 g.

It

is very likely

that

expectant management may

have converted these stillbirths to early neonatal deaths.

The

maternal complication rate

of

30 in the p re

sent study is s imilar to that reported by Sibai

et al

3 It is

difficult to explain the differing maternal complication

rates benveen the populat ion

groups studied

in Cape

Town

by Odendaal

et al

1,1

and tha t of

the

present

study.

Odendaal

'

 

studied

a

stable urban

populat ion and

reported a low maternal complication rate, whi le the

population srudied in

Durban

was black and indigent.

Many patients come from rural areas for maternity care

or

were transferred to K ing Edward VIII Hospital from

regional hospitals and

community

clincs. There is some

evidence from epidemiological srudies of

non-pregnant

patients in South Africa

l2

,13 that

the urban

black popula

tion

has a

higher

incidence of hypertension

than other

racial groups

and

that the highest incidence

of

hyperten

sion occurs

in

urban black women. The high incidence

may be due to stress caused by urban living on a popu

lation in transition from a rural to an

urban

setting.

Three

patients

developed

pulmonary oedema in

this

study. In only 2

patients,

however, could this be

ascribed

to

iatrogenic fluid overload. No patient

had

the

CVP

r ise to

greater

than 6

cm

H

2

 

It is possible

that

in

the 2 patients who developed pulmonary oedema, pul

monary capillary wedge pressure monitoring would have

demonstrated a higher value than CVP.

However

this

facility is no t available to us at present.

Intensive maternal monitoring might have prevented

some of the

complications found by

Odendaal et al.'

who

recommend frequent antenatal fetal

heart

rate

monitoring

to

detect

abruptio

placentae.

This

is cer

tainly of value in institutions with the appropriate neo

natal facilities to care for these very small bab ies . Sibai

et al

3

, 4 reported conflicting results on the

outcome

of

severe

pre-eclampsia in mid-trimester.

In

their second

srudy,'4 they noted

an improved outcome

because offre

quent fetal

monitoring

(non-stress tests

and

biophysical

profile). Their previous

protocol did

not institute fetal

monitoring until 27 weeks. They also note tha t the high

maternal

complication rate

of

their

earlier

stud

y

3 was

probably related

to management o f

these

cases

at

regional hospitals with referral t o the tertiary centre only

after the onset of maternal complications. The reduced

maternal complication rate is attributed

to

early

and

intensive

maternal and

fetal

monitoring

and suggests the

need for conservative management

beyond

24 weeks'

gestation.

Nevertheless

only 2 weeks were gained by

conservative management in patients between 24 weeks'

and

28 weeks gestation. Perinatal

and materna l out -

- -

S M

VOl83 AUG

1993

come

is dep ndent on

the

availability of sophisticated

neonatal facilities and

an

improved neonatal

outcome

is

normally

to be

expected

once

gestation of

more than 26

weeks has

been

achieved.

Only

1

of our patients how

ever

reached

a gestation

beyond 26

weeks

(IUD

at

29

weeks). I t is therefore totally inappropriate in our setting

to

anempt

prolongation of pregnancy in patients for

more than

26

weeks, particularly in view of the un

acceptable incidence of maternal morbidity and

mor

tality. Unless such neonatal facilities are available for

the

management of very small babies

and

their

long-term

outcome

established in developing

communities,

a

more

aggressive

approach to

the management

of

severe hyper

tension in patients below 26 weeks' gestation (particu

larly multigravidas with a his tory of hypertension in a

previous pregnancy) is

recommended. Such

patients

should be advised to termina te the ir

pregnancies.

In

pregnancies of

more

than 28 weeks'

duration

a conser

vative

approach

with

the

use of

dexamethazone

to

pro

mote lung

maturity is suggested. Intensive

maternal

and

fetal

monitoring (frequent non-stress

tests, biophysical

profiles, continuous

blood

pressure monitoring, correc

tion

of hypovolaemia

and

testing for coagulopathies)

should be performed in such

circumstances.

Patients

with severe hypertension should be referred to a tertiary

hospital at

an

early stage

rather

than at the onset of fetal

or matemal complications.

This research was performed under the auspices of the

South African Medical Research Council.

REFERENCES

1.

Partinson RC, Odendaal HJ,

Du

Toit

R. Conservative

management

of

severe proreinuric hypenension before 28 weeks' gestation. S Af r

Med] 1988;

 

517-51 .

2. Odendaal

HJ

Partinson RC,

Du

Toit R. Feral and neonatal Out

come

in patients severe pre-eclampsia before 34 weeks. S

Af r

Med]

19 7; 71: 555-558.

3. Sibai

BM,

Taslini M, Abdella TN ,

e'

al Maternal and perinatal

outcome

of conserv tive m n gement

of

severe preecl mpsi in

mid-trimester.  m

Obs,e, Gyneco11985;

152: 32-37.

4. MoodleyJ.

The

aetiology, clinical features

and management of

pre

eclampsia. S Afr Med] 1982; 8: 21-32.

5.

Vink GJ, Moodley J Philpott

RH.

Effect of hydralazine

on

the fetus

in the treatment of maternal hypenension. Obs,e, Gynecol 1980; 55:

519-522.

6. Kitchen

WH, Ford

G\V, Doyle LW. Caesarean section or vaginal

delivery t   4 8 weeks gest tion comparison of surviv l nd

neonatal

and

two-year morbidity. Obste' Gyllecol 1980; 66: 1079

1087.

7_Davey DA.

The

effect of maternal parity and age

on

perinatal

mor

ra ity in hypenensi e

disorders

in pregnancy. In : Rothberg A, ed.

Proceedings

of

,he 4,h Conft rertce on Priorities

of

Perinaeal Care ill Sollth

Africa. Johannesburg: Uni ersity of the \Vitwatersrand Press, 1984.

.

Manin

TR ,

Tupper

WRC. Th e management

of

severe toxemia

in patients less than

36

weeks gestation. Obs,e, Gynecol 1979; 54:

602-605.

9. Benedetti   Benederti

JK

Stenchever 'lA. Severe pre-eclampsia

- maternal and fetal outcome.

Cli

Exp

Hypercens

  B) 1982; 1:

(2-3): 401-406.

10.

Moore

MP, Redman

CWG.

Case control of severe pre-eclampsia

of early onset. BM ] 1983; 287: 580-583.

11.

Feeny

JG , Scon JS.

Preeclampsia and changed

paternity. Eur]

Obs,e, Gyllecol Reprod

Bid 1980; 11: 35-38.

12. Seedat YK, Seedat

 1A Hackland

DB. Biosocial factors

and

hyper

tension in rural

and urban

Zulus. ] Epidemiol   OIIIIIIHealth 1982;

36: 256-261.

13. Sever PS,

Gordon D,

Pean \VS, Beighton P. Blood-pressure

and

its correlates in urban and tribal Africa.

Lance'

1980;

1:

60-64.

14. Sibai BM,

AKL

S, Fairlie F, Morerti M. A protocol for managing

severe pre-eclampsia

in

the second trimester. Alii]

Obs,e, GYllecol

1990; 163: 733-738.

587