document11

2
 DATE OF EFFECTIVITY NATIONAL ELECTRIFICATION ADMINISTRATION vs. VICTORIANO B. GONZAGA G.R. No. 158761 Deceme! "# $%%7 F&c's( On November 13, 2000, respondent Victoriano B. Gonzaga fled his ertifcate o! andidac" !or membership in the Board o! #irectors o! $amboanga #el %&r '' (lectric ooperative, 'nc., #istrict '' )$*+%-(O. /ater that da", the screening committee resolved to dis&ali!" respondent beca&se his spo&se as an inc&mbent member o! the %angg&niang Ba"an o! #iplahan, $amboanga del %&r. Based on the (lectric ooperative (lect ion ode )((, prom&lgated b" petitio ner National (lectrifc ation *dmini stration )N(*, a candidate hose spo&se occ&pies an elective government position higher than Baranga" apt ain is pr ohibited to r&n as director o! an electr ic cooperative. $*+%-(Os b"las, hoever, do not provide !or s&ch gro&nd !or dis&alifcation. -espondent averred that the (( as n&ll and void beca&se it had not been p&blished. N(*, on the other hand, !ailed to prove hether the (( as indeed p&blished in a ne spape r o! general ci rc&lati on as re&i red b" the Ne i vi l ode and the *dministrative ode o! 1456. Iss)e( 7he ther or not (lectr ic oop erative (lection ode as n&ll and void !or not compl"ing ith the p&blication re&irement. R)*+,-(  8he %&preme o&rt held that (lectric ooperative (lection ode as n&ll and void !or not compl "i ng i th the p&bli catio n re &ir ement. 't observed that hile $*+%-(O complied ith the re&irements o! fling the code ith the niversit" o! the 9hilippines /a enter, it o:ered no proo! o! p&blication neither in the O;cial Gazette nor in a nespaper o! general circ&lation. 7itho&t compliance ith the re&irement o! p&blication, the r&les and reg&lations contained in the (( cannot be en!orced and implemented. *rticle 2 o! the Ne ivil ode provides that las shall ta<e e:ect a!ter f!teen )1= da"s !olloing the completion o! their p&blication in the O;cial Gazette or in a nespaper o! general circ&lation in the 9hilippines, &nless it is otherise provided. overed b" this r&le are presidential decrees and e>ec&tive orders prom&lgated b" the 9resident in the e>ercise o! legislative poers henever the same are validl" delegated b" the legislat&re or, at present, directl" con!erred b" the onstit&tion. *dministrative r&les and reg&lations m&st also be p&blished i! their p&rpose is to en!orce or implement e> ist ing la p&rs&ant als o to a valid delegat ion. 8he (( applie s to all el ectric cooper ati ves in the co&n tr" . 't is not a mere int er nal memoran d&m, int erpre tati ve re g&la tion, or inst r&c tion to s&bordinat es. 8h&s , the (( sho&ld compl" it h the re&irements o! the ivil ode and the *dministrative ode o! 1456.

Upload: jhenjhen-ganda

Post on 02-Nov-2015

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

11

TRANSCRIPT

DATE OF EFFECTIVITY

NATIONAL ELECTRIFICATION ADMINISTRATION vs. VICTORIANO B. GONZAGAG.R. No. 158761 December 4, 2007Facts:On November 13, 2000, respondent Victoriano B. Gonzaga filed his Certificate of Candidacy for membership in the Board of Directors of Zamboanga Del Sur II Electric Cooperative, Inc., District II (ZAMSURECO). Later that day, the screening committee resolved to disqualify respondent because his spouse was an incumbent member of the Sangguniang Bayan of Diplahan, Zamboanga del Sur. Based on the Electric Cooperative Election Code (ECEC), promulgated by petitioner National Electrification Administration (NEA), a candidate whose spouse occupies an elective government position higher than Barangay Captain is prohibited to run as director of an electric cooperative. ZAMSURECOs by-laws, however, do not provide for such ground for disqualification. Respondent averred that the ECEC was null and void because it had not been published. NEA, on the other hand, failed to prove whether the ECEC was indeed published in a newspaper of general circulation as required by the New Civil Code and the Administrative Code of 1987. Issue:Whether or not Electric Cooperative Election Code was null and void for not complying with the publication requirement.Ruling: The Supreme Court held that Electric Cooperative Election Code was null and void for not complying with the publication requirement. It observed that while ZAMSURECO complied with the requirements of filing the code with the University of the Philippines Law Center, it offered no proof of publication neither in the Official Gazette nor in a newspaper of general circulation. Without compliance with the requirement of publication, the rules and regulations contained in the ECEC cannot be enforced and implemented. Article 2 of the New Civil Code provides that laws shall take effect after fifteen (15) days following the completion of their publication in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation in the Philippines, unless it is otherwise provided. Covered by this rule are presidential decrees and executive orders promulgated by the President in the exercise of legislative powers whenever the same are validly delegated by the legislature or, at present, directly conferred by the Constitution. Administrative rules and regulations must also be published if their purpose is to enforce or implement existing law pursuant also to a valid delegation. The ECEC applies to all electric cooperatives in the country. It is not a mere internal memorandum, interpretative regulation, or instruction to subordinates. Thus, the ECEC should comply with the requirements of the Civil Code and the Administrative Code of 1987.