13 – 14 october 2011, ess-lund, sweden · get the lowest budget possible by taking some risks...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Leading companies to
Cost-Effective & Sustainable Energy
STRATEGIC SOURCING IN A LIBERALIZED MARKET 13 – 14 October 2011, ESS-Lund, Sweden
2 Quick Facts
3
Summit Service Offering
Energy Management and Procurement Services (“EMPS”)
● Strategic sourcing ● Utility rates analysis/budgeting ● Risk management services ● Market intelligence reporting ● Data management services
Sustainability Services
● Environmental strategic development ● Energy efficiency workshops ● Environmental reporting ● Clean-tech services ● Metering/monitoring services
4
Different phases:
Ø UK and Norway: beginning 1990 – mature markets
Ø EU Directives
96/92/EC on electricity – date of effect 19/02/1997 98/30/EC on natural gas – date of effect 10/08/1998
Main obstacles :
• access of the network • different degrees of market opening between Member States
Ø Full market opening for all consumers: July 1st, 2007
• All markets are becoming more mature with spot markets and future markets
• Still markets in transition, mainly in Central and Eastern Europe
Liberalization of European power and natural gas markets
5
Calendar deregulation European electricity market
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 ≥ 2007Austria > 40 GWh > 20 GWh October- All
Belgium Federal law Flanders region Walloon region Brussels region
> 100 GWh > 40 GWh > 20 GWh> 20 GWh (11/08)
> 20 GWh (25/10)> 10 GWh
1 GWh> 10 GWh
> 56 kVA (01/01)all (01/07)10 GWh all HV clients
(31/12/2004)
All consumers
all
Denmark > 10 GWh(April) 1 GWh All
France > 100 GWh > 16 GWh 7 GWh(19/02/03)
All consumers(except domestic
sector)
Finland 100%
Germany All consumers
Greece 30% 35%
Ireland 4 GWh(30%)
1 GWh(40%)
Italy > 20 GWh(1 GWh)
> 9 GWh(1 GWh)
50 000 kWh
Luxembourg > 100 GWh > 20 GWh > 9 GWh > 1 GWh(2005)
Netherlands > 2 MW > 3 * 80 A All consumers
Portugal > 9 GWh
Spain > 1 GWh 1 kV All consumers
Sweden All consumers
United Kingdom All consumers
6
Exchange markets
Liberalization of European power and natural gas markets
PRAGUE ENERGY EXCHANGE ENERGETICKÁ BURZA PRAHA
7
Average power prices in industry (€/MWh)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
Standard customer 20 GWh/year – 4 MW demand Source: Eurostat – June 2011
8
Average natural gas prices in industry (€/MWh)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Standard customer : 5 GWh/year Source: Eurostat – June 2011
9
Cost optimization by a combination of Competences
ENERGY COSTS ENERGY MARKETS
ENERGY TECHNOLOGY - DEMAND RESPONSE
ENERGY LEGISLATION ENERGY REGULATION ENERGY INCENTIVES ENERGY TAXATION
10
Energy Cost Components
11
§ Price volatility of energy is significantly higher than other market exposures.
§ Most companies are negatively correlated to energy prices (energy ↑ = margins ↓)
§ The price of oil, electricity and gas is an important driver for the value of many companies.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Euro / USD Euribor
1y S&P500 Brent IPE NBP
FY EEX FY
Annualised %
Price volatility of energy
12
25
35
45
55
65
75
85
95
105
30
50
70
90
110
130
150
01-2
006
03-2
006
05-2
006
07-2
006
09-2
006
11-2
006
01-2
007
03-2
007
05-2
007
07-2
007
09-2
007
11-2
007
01-2
008
03-2
008
05-2
008
07-2
008
09-2
008
11-2
008
01-2
009
03-2
009
05-2
009
07-2
009
09-2
009
11-2
009
01-2
010
03-2
010
05-2
010
07-2
010
09-2
010
11-2
010
01-2
011
03-2
011
05-2
011
07-2
011
09-2
011
11-2
011
EUR
/ bb
l
$ / b
bl
Brent ($/bbl and €/bbl)
Brent($/bbl)
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Update: 02/10/2011
13
25
35
45
55
65
75
85
95
105
01-2
008
02-2
008
03-2
008
04-2
008
05-2
008
06-2
008
07-2
008
08-2
008
09-2
008
10-2
008
11-2
008
12-2
008
01-2
009
02-2
009
03-2
009
04-2
009
05-2
009
06-2
009
07-2
009
08-2
009
09-2
009
10-2
009
11-2
009
12-2
009
01-2
010
02-2
010
03-2
010
04-2
010
05-2
010
06-2
010
07-2
010
08-2
010
09-2
010
10-2
010
11-2
010
12-2
010
01-2
011
02-2
011
03-2
011
04-2
011
05-2
011
06-2
011
07-2
011
08-2
011
09-2
011
10-2
011
11-2
011
12-2
011
EUR
/ M
Wh
European electricity : Year +1
Belgian Base Y+1 Dutch Base Y+1 French Base Y+1 German Base Y+1 Spain Base Y+1 NordPool Y+1
2008 2009 2010 2011
Update: 02/10/2011
14
European power markets
German power
Czech, Hungarian,
Slovakian power
Nordpool (Finland, Sweden, Denmark,
Norway)
French power
Belgian power
Dutch power
UK power
15
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
01-2
006
03-2
006
05-2
006
07-2
006
09-2
006
11-2
006
01-2
007
03-2
007
05-2
007
07-2
007
09-2
007
11-2
007
01-2
008
03-2
008
05-2
008
07-2
008
09-2
008
11-2
008
01-2
009
03-2
009
05-2
009
07-2
009
09-2
009
11-2
009
01-2
010
03-2
010
05-2
010
07-2
010
09-2
010
11-2
010
01-2
011
03-2
011
05-2
011
07-2
011
09-2
011
11-2
011
EUR
/ bb
l
EUR
/ M
Wh
NBP Month Ahead (€/MWh) and Brent (€/bbl)
NBP Month Ahead (€/MWh) Brent (€/bbl)
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Update: 04/10/2011
16
European gas
Brent Crude
GOL, HFO
Gas Demand
Oil-indexed Gas Arbitrage
Premium
Natural Gas NBP, Zee, TTF
• Domestic & Commercial • Electricity Generation • Energy Industry • Heat Generation • Iron & Steel
Gas Supply • Indigenous Production • Supplies To/From Stocks • LNG Inports
17
Strategic Sourcing
Risk profile Price Forecasts (Banks,IEA,…)
STRATEGIC ENERGY SOURCING PLAN
Risk management
18
Risk Profiler – Principle
AGRESSIVE
More on how to beat the market
MODERATE
More focus on how to get the lowest budget possible by taking some risks
CONSERVATIVE
More focus on achieving cost certainty (no risk)
Meeting budget is of utmost importance
Hig
h pr
iorit
y M
AR
KET
Lo
w p
riorit
y
High priority BUDGET Low priority
19 19
BRENT oil forecast
455565758595
105115125135145
okt jan apr jul okt jan apr jul okt jan apr jul okt
$/barrel
BRENT Fundamental LOW Fundamental HIGH AVERAGE FUNDAMENTAL
2010 2011 2012
20
The Risk Profiler combined with the price forecasts gives the following orientations :
1. the duration of the supply contract(s) 2. fixed price or flexible pricing 3. the price structure (spot,months, quarters, seasons,..;) and
the type of indexation 4. take profit and stop losses in case of flexible contracts 5. number of possible price fixations and volume 6. timing for price fixation
21
Strategic Sourcing Process
Strategic Tactical
Market Opinion created from constantly monitoring all relevant market dynamics & regulatory trends
Buying Recommendation created by identifying market opportunity and quantifying potential impact
Know supplier strengths & weaknesses
Utilize efficient & flexible RFP and bid tools
Analyze and determine most strategic solution
Validate pricing, negotiate and execute deal
Define pricing benchmarks and product structures
Analyze bids against sourcing & risk strategy
Secure refreshed pricing from preferred supplier
22
Interval Data Analysis
How you use power is more important than how much you use
ATC block On-peak block Hourly usage
23
Importance of good data
How you use power is more important than how much you use
ATC block On-peak block Hourly usage
• The more detailed the load profile, the better offered prices
• Better analysis of suppliers proposals
• e.g.: Germany – it is possible that a new tax is introduced if no EMS
24
Risk Monitoring : Value at Risk Report
25
Negotiations Aggressively advocate for best option
Timing Be prepared to act when the time is right
Suppliers Choose the most competitive and reliable supplier
Reductions Leverage programs to spend and use less
Capture Opportunity
Negotiations Aggressively advocate for best option
Timing Strategically procure energy versus tactically
Regulations Identify market shifts and eliminate surprises
Suppliers Choose the most competitive and reliable supplier
Other Options:
26
Cost optimization by a combination of Competences
ENERGY COSTS ENERGY MARKETS
DEMAND RESPONSE/
INTERRUPTIBILITY ENERGY LEGISLATION ENERGY REGULATION ENERGY INCENTIVES ENERGY TAXATION
27
Optimization of transport / distribution contracts
* Optimal power demand subscription or hourly/daily capacity for natural gas subscription in the different rate periods
P1 - …. – P6 for Spain F1 - … - F3 for Italy P1 - … - P5 for France Peak/ Off peak for some other countries
Winter/ Summer for natural gas * Load shedding or switching to an alternative fuel
* Peak shaving by partial own generation at moments of high demand
Transport/Distribution costs
28
v Electrical storage remaining a technological and economical challenge, grid operators have to balance supply with demand at any moment
v Demand Response enables electricity users to actively help the grid operators to
- meet peak demand - limit peak demand to allow generators to operate the most efficient power stations
v Participating customers are compensated in function of
- importance of interruptible load, - Maximum allowed duration of the interruption - notice to give to the consumer
v Possible savings: 3 to 5 % of electricity costs
Demand Response
29
Cost optimization by a combination of Competences
ENERGY COSTS ENERGY MARKETS
ENERGY TECHNOLOGY -
DEMAND RESPONSE
ENERGY LEGISLATION ENERGY REGULATION ENERGY INCENTIVES ENERGY TAXATION
30
Sustainability Pressures
Societal / Citizenship Customer / Competitive Market
Regulatory Investor / Shareholder
31
Supplier Sustainability Assessment
" On-line survey to assess performance of suppliers on sustainability initiatives
" CO2 emissions factor for the supplied power – CO2 footprint
" Supplier support for energy reduction initiatives
32
SUSTAINABILITY WATCH tracking of opportunities and threats in both European and National energy and climate policies standards / regulation / finance
20 % 13 % 14 % 18 % 23 %
33
Green Energy
v Suppliers offers renewable energy as a selling point
v Prices: 0 to 8 €/MWh
v Germany: 1 to 2 €/MWh
v Sweden: 0 to 1 €/MWh (Bra Miljoval – good Energy) – Very prestigous
v France: different options – RECS are delivered by the Observer – part of the premium is often transferred to the Nature Option Energy fundation.
34
v Climate Change Levy in UK
Climate change Agreements give energy intensive business a discount on the CCL as long as they meet specific energy efficiency or carbon savings
v Renewable obligation in UK v EEG in Germany v Federal taxes in Belgium (audit convenants) v Certificates of origin in Belgium
v Czech Republic: green energy is free of energy tax (1.32 €/MWh)
Tax reductions for sustainable efforts