165 d ex parte shorten time re mpo - d decl

8/14/2019 165 D Ex Parte Shorten Time Re MPO - D Decl

1/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 1 of 67

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTEASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

Attorneys for Defendants County ofKern,Peter Bryan, Irwin Harris, Eugene Kercher,Jelmifer Abraham, Scott Ragland, Toni Smithand William Roy

Mark A. Wasser, CA SB #060160LAW OFFlCES OF MARK A. WASSER400 Capitol Mall, Suite 2640Sacramento, CA 95814Phone: (916) 444-6400Fax: (916) 444-6405E-mail: [email protected]

Case No.: 1:07-cv-00026-0WW-TAG

Bernard C. Barmann, Sr. CA SB #60508KERN COUNTY COUNSELMark Nations, ChiefDeputy CA SB #1018381115 Truxtun Avenue, Fourth FloorBakersfield, CA 93301Phone: (661) 868-3800Fax: (661) 868-3805E-mail: [email protected]

12345678910111213141516 DAVID F. JADWIN, D.O.17 Plaintiff,

19 COUNTY OF KERN, et aI.,18 vs.

202122232425262728

Defendants.

DECLARATION OFMARK A. WASSERIN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' EXPARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDERSHORTENING TIME ONMOTION FORPROTECTIVE ORDER RE: FURTHERDEPOSITIONS ANDINTERROGATORIES BY PLAINTIFF

Date:Time:Place: U.S. Bankruptcy Courthouse,Bakersfield Courtroom 8

Date Action Filed: January 6, 2007Trial Date: December 2, 2008

-1-DECLARATION OF MARK A. WASSER IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER

SHORTENING TIME FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER RE: FURTHERDEPOSITIONS AND INTERROGATORIES BY PLAINTIFF


2/67


1 I, Mark A. Wasser, declare as follows:2 1. I am counsel of record for Defendants and I am familiar with this proceeding. The3 facts in this declaration are true and correct ofmy own personal knowledge and I can testifY4 competently to them if called as a witness.5 2. The original scheduling order (filed June 6, 2007) was modified by stipulation of the6 patties and Order of this Court on June 3, 2008 ("Scheduling Order").7 3. Under the Scheduling Order as modified, expert witnesses were disclosed on June 16,8 2008, and supplemental experts are to be disclosed on July 16, 2008.9 4. Under the Scheduling Order as modified, discovery is set to close on August 18,

10 2008.11 5. Under the Scheduling Order, Defendants agreed to granting Plaintiff "relief' from the12 25-interrogatory limit in Rule 33 of the Federal Rules ofCivil Procedure and the 10-deposition13 limit in Rule 30 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.14 6. At the time Defendants agreed to grant Plaintiff the specified "relief," Defendants15 assumed, enoneously, that Plaintiffwould undettake discovery in a reasonable and judicious16 fashion.17 7. To date, Plaintiff has served 91 intenogatories to which Defendants have responded.18 Most of those interrogatories requested infonnation that is irrelevant to any issues in the19 complaint. On July 8, 2008, Plaintiff served another 7 interrogatories (in violation of an20 agreement between the parties). A copy of Plaintiffs third set of interrogatories is attached21 hereto as Exhibit A. Nothing in this case wanants 98 interrogatories.22 8. To date, Plaintiff has taken 16 depositions. In an e-mail dated June 30, 2008,23 Plaintiffs counsel communicated his desire to take an additional 17 depositions. A copy ofMr.24 Lee's e-mail isattachedheretoasExhibitB.OnJuly3.2008.Mr. Lee sent Defendant's counsel,25 by fax, 17 deposition subpoenas. Copies of those deposition subpoenas are attached to this26 declaration as Exhibit C. In e-mails exchanged between the patties during the last couple of27 weeks Plaintiffs counsel has also expressed the intent to depose Defendant's expert witnesses.28

-2-DECLARATIONOF MARK A. WASSER IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER

SHORTENING TIME FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER RE: FURTHER DEPOSITIONS AND INTERROGATORIES BY PLAINTIFF


3/67


I Copies of e-mail correspondence between counsel regarding the expert depositions is attached2 hereto as Exhibit D. This brings to over 20 the number of additional depositions Plaintiffhas3 either noticed or requested.4 9. Combined with the 16 depositions already taken, these additional depositions, not5 including depositions of supplemental experts that have not yet been disclosed, will bring the6 total number of depositions in this case to about 40 - 4 times the number authorized by Rule 30.7 Nothing about this case warrants that many depositions.8 10. The 16 depositions Plaintiffhas already taken have yielded virtually no evidence9 relevant to any of Plaintiffs claims. The same is true of Plaintiffs interrogatories. Discovery

10 has long since passed the point of diminishing returns.II II . The additional depositions Plaintiffhas noticed include the depositions of2 county12 supervisors - one incumbent supervisor and one former supervisor. Defendants are at a loss to13 understand what admissible evidence either supervisor can contribute.14 12. In an e-mail dated July 2, 2008, a copy of which is included in Exhibit D, PlaintiffsIS counsel wrote that Plaintiffwas taking these additional depositions, at least in part, because16 Defendants were not willing to stipulate to the authentication of documents. In 2 e-mails dated17 July 3, 2008, copies ofwhich are attached as Exhibit E, Defendant's counsel responded by18 offering to stipulate to the authentication of any documents that Plaintiff could identify with19 regard to any specific deponents if doing so would obviate the need for additional depositions.20 Plaintiff responded to that overture by serving 290 requests for admission. Those requests are21 not part of this motion because Defendants' counsel has not had an adequate opportunity to meet22 and confer with Plaintiffs counsel.23 13. Plaintiffs discovery is burdensome and abusive.24 14. Plaintiff has rejected Defendants' attempts to negotiate a reasonable limit to the25 number of interrogatories or depositions.26 IS. Defendants have met and conferred with Plaintiff without success in an attempt to27 resolve this issue.28


SHORTENING TIME FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER RE: FURTHER DEPOSITIONS AND INTERROGATORIES BY PLAINTIFF


4/67


I 16. Good cause exists for shortening time. The additional depositions are set to begin on2 July 15,2008. Supplemental expert disclosures are set for July 16,2008. Also, Plaintiffhas3 filed a motion to amend his complaint to add new theories against the County. That motion is set4 for hearing on September 8, 2008. It will not be possible to accommodate the additional5 discovery Plaintiffhas propounded and the new theories he is asserting against the County6 without modifying the Scheduling Order.7 17. The underlying motion for protective order is attached hereto as Exhibit F.8 18. The ex-parte application, this Declaration and supporting exhibits, and the Proposed9 Order were served on Plaintiffs counsel by facsimile on July 14, 2008, before 5:00 p.m.10 I certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.I I Executed this 14th day of July, 2008, in Sacramento, California.1213141516171819202122232425262728

By: /s/ Mark A. WasserMark A. Wasser


SHORTENING TIME FOR PROTECTIVE ORDERRE: FURTHERDEPOSITIONS AND INTERROGATORIES BY PLAINTIFF


5/67


EXHIBIT A


6/67


rru.: LCM u r r l ~ " VI UI:f 'i11t i L t iV

123456789101112

Eugene D. Lee SB# 236812LAW OFFICE OF EUGENE LEE555 West Fifth Street, Suite 3100Los Angeles, California 90013Telepbone: (213) 992-3299Facsimile: (213) 596-0487Email: [email protected] Herrington, SB# 178988BAY AREA EMPLOYMENT LAW OFFICE5032 Woodminster LaneOakland, CA 94602-2614Telepbone: (510) 530-4078Facsimile: (510) 530-4725Email: [email protected] Counsel to LAW OFFICE OF EUGENE LEEAttorneys for PlaintiffDAVID F. JADWIN, D.O.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTFOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

1314 DAVID F. JADWIN, D.O., Civil Action No. 1:07-cv-00026-0WW-TAG1516 v

Plaintiff, INTERROGATORIES FOR DEFENDANTCOUNTY OF KERN (SET THREE).17 COUNTY OF KERN; et al. Date Action Filed: January 6, 2007Date Se t for Trial: August, 2008181920212223

Defendants.

PROPOUNDING PARTY:RESPONDING PARTY:SET NO.:

Plaintiff DAVID F. JADWIN, D.O., F.C.A.P.Defendant COUNTY OF KERNThree

2425262728

Pursuant to Rule 33 oftbe Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Plaintiff David F. Jadwin requeststhat you serve written answers to tbe following interrogatories under oath witbin tbirty (30) days ofservice bereof.

III

INTERROGATORIES FOR DEFENDANT KERN COUNTY (SET TWO) 1


7/67


rn.,.: LCM urr Itll: ur t.1,lIJt:l1l:: Let:

DEFINITIONS12 A. The tenn "PERSON" as used herein includes, without limitation, any natural person,3 firm, entity, corporation, partnership, association, cooperative, governmental entity or agency, or any4 other entity.5 B. The term "PLAINTIFF" means plaintiffDavid F. Jadwin, D.O., F.C.A.P.6 C. The teon "DEFENDANT" means defendant County of Kern.7 D. The teon ''KMC" means Kern Medical Center, a hospital owned and operated by8 DEFENDANT.9 E. The teons "YOU" and "YOUR" as used herein include DEFENDANT and include10 without limitation each predecessor and successor-in-interest, as well as any officer, agent, employee,11 attorney, representative of DEFENDANT andlor any other PERSONS acting under the control of12 DEFENDANT or on behalf of DEFENDANT.13 F. The teon "DOCUMENT" or "DOCUMENTS" as used herein is broadly defined to14 include all media on which infonnation is recorded or stored, as well as all non-identical copies thereof15 including copies which bear any notes, notations or markings not found on the originals and all16 preliminary, inteonediate, final and revised drafts of such document. This includes but is not limited to17 any writings, drawings, graphs, charts, photographs, video or audio recordings, microfilm, data18 compilations, and electronically-stored information stored in any medium from which information can19 be obtained such as e-mails, internet browser bookmarks and history, voicemail messages, websites,20 electronic messages or bulletin boards. As used herein, the tenn "writings" shall include but is not21 limited to letters, memoranda, reports, and notes whether handwritten or otherwise recorded, whether22 internal or external to you. Electronically-stored infonnation should be printed for production.23 G. The phrase "RELATING TO" as used herein includes referring to, relating to, relates to,24 responding to, concerning, connected with, commenting on, in respect of, about, regarding, discussing,25 showing, describing, depicting, mentioning, reflecting, analyzing, comprising, constituting, evidencing,26 and pertaining to, whether in whole or in part.27 H. The term "PERSONNEL FILE" as used herein is broadly defined to include all28 DOCUMENTS RELATING TO an process improvement file; employee's credentials; medical staff file,



8/67


: narK wasser e ~ I b - q q q - b q ~ trOl: Lal un Ice Ot tugene Lee Pg 39/43 07/08/08 4:50 pi

2345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728

qualifications for employment, promotions, transfers, salary, raises, pension eligibility, discipline,separation or other employment action; as well as the "folder", "jacket" or other container of each suchfile and any attachments thereto and all files maintained by PERSONS employed by YOU.

r. The tenn "PATHOLOGY REPORT" as used herein is broadly defmed to include allDOCUMENTS RELATING TO the description of cells and tissues made by a pathologist based onmicroscopic evidence and lab testing and used to render a diagnosis of a disease, including but notlimited to the DOCUMENTS RELATING TO the following associated items: original requisitions andattached DOCUMENTS, HBO electronic documentation logs, peer reviewer comment sheets andattached DOCUMENTS, pathology specimens listed in the clinical history, subsequent pathologyspecimens, operative reports for pathology specimens, progress notes made by pathology, outsidepathologist reports, correspondence and contracts with outside reviewing pathologists, dictation logsfrom transcription, laboratory reports, surgical pathology reports, cytology reports, and bone marrowreports.

1. The tenn "IDENTIFY" when used in connection with natural PERSONS includes thename, address, phone number, the current or most recent position held with YOU if the PERSON is orwas employed with YOU as of the date these interrogatories are answered, and the last day of thePERSON's employment with YOU. When used in connection with DOCUMENTS, the term"IDENTIFY" includes the name(s) of the author(s), name(s) ofrecipient(s), date of creation, date ofmodification, date of delivery, date of execution, effective date, subject matter, bates numbers, pagenumbers, paragraph numbers, line numbers and/or section numbers.

K. The tenns "and" and "or" when used herein each mean "and/or".L. All references to the singular include the plural, and all references to the plural include

the singular. All references to the masculine gender include the feminine and neuter genders and vice-versa

INSTRUCTIONS

A. YOU are required to answer each interrogatory separately and fully in writing under oath.If YOU cannot answer an interrogatory in full, YOU must answer as fully as possible, specify the reasonfor YOUR inability to fully answer, and state any information YOU have concerning the unanswered



9/67


trOll: law un Ice or tugeJlC le e

I portion.2 B. In answering an interrogatory, YOU are required to furnish not only such information as3 is within YOUR own personal knowledge, but also any and all information which is in the possession of4 YOUR officers, agents, employees, attorneys, representatives and/or any other PERSONS acting under5 YOUR or their control or on YOUR or their behalf, or which is otherwise available to YOU.6 C. Whenever YOU refuse to answer any interrogatory based upon an objection, YOU are7 required to (1) fully answer the interrogatory to the extent it is not objectionable, (2) meaningfully state8 the nature ofYOUR objection, (b) meaningfully set forth each and every ground for YOUR objection,9 and (c) meaningfully describe the factual basis, if any, upon which YOU rely in making such objection.10 D. An answer to an interrogatory should be complete in and of itself and should not refer toII the pleadings, or to depositions or other documents, orto other interrogatories.12 E. YOU are under a duty to supplement and/or correct these responses upon learning that13 the earlier answers were in some material respect incomplete or incorrect when made or are no longer14 true, pursuant to Rule 26(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.15 INTERROGATORIES16 INTERROGATORY NO 92-17 Is your response to each request for admission (set one) served with these interrogatories an18 unqualified admission? \fnot, for each response that is not an unqualified admission:19 1I. State the number of the request;20 b. State all facts upon which you base YOUR response;21 c. IDENTIFY all PERSONS who have knowledge of those facts, including their names,22 addresses, and telephone numbers; and23 d. IDENTIFY all DOCUMENTS and other tangible things that support YOUR response24 and IDENTIFY all PERSONS who have each DOCUMENT or thing, including their25 names, addresses, and telephone numbers.26 INTERROGATORY NO n27 IDENTIFY all handwritten notes RELATING TO PLAINTIFF which were authored by Peter28 Bryan during his tenure at KMC, including but not limited to their current location.



10/67


rn.. : LdH Urrlloit:: ur UJljtiIIt:: Lt:t'

I INTERROGATORY NO. 94:2 IDENTIFY all handwritten notes RELATING TO PLAINTIFF which were authored by Marvin3 Kolb during his tenure at KMC, including but not limited to their current location.4 INTEMOGATORY NO. 95:5 IDENTIFY any and all DOCUMENTS contained in YOUR FRCP Rule 26 Initial Disclosures6 that YOU contend is not a "BUSINESS RECORD" (within the meaning of FRE 803(6; and state all7 facts on which you base your contention.8 INTERROGATORY NO 96:9 IDENTIFY any and all DOCUMENTS contained in PLAINTIFF'S FRCP Rule 26 Initial10 Disclosures that YOU contend is not a BUSINESS RECORD; and state all facts on which you base yourII contention.12 INTERROGATORY NO. 97:13 IDENTIFY any and all DOCUMENTS which YOU produced to PLAINTIFF in discovery or in14 supplemental disclosures [0001659 - 0028001] that YOU contend is not a BUSINESS RECORD; and15 state all facts on which you base your contention.16 INTERROGATORY NO. 98-17 Do YOU contend that YOU counseled PLAINTIFF at any time during his tenure at KMC? If so,18 for each occasion on which YOU counseled PLAINTIFF:19 8 . State the date(s) the counseling occurred;20 b. Describe the nature of the counseling, including what form it took and what was21 communicated;22 c. IDENTIFY all PERSONS who participated in counseling PLAINTIFF;23 d. IDENTIFY all PERSONS who have knowledge of those facts, including their names,24 addresses, and telephone numbers; and25 e. IDENTIFY all DOCUMENTS and other tangible things that support YOUR response26 and IDENTIFY all PERSONS who have each DOCUMENT or thing, including their27 names, addresses, and telephone numbers.28



11/67


rrv.: LdH u r r l ~ ~ ur L ~ l ~ L r " L J " ~ Uf fV \ l fUU , ..........

1 Date: July 8, 20082345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728



12/67


r,u-: LlM urr I\iU ur r . . ~ 1 t ' L r "hJl "hJ '" rI ' llU/1IO "t;.JfJ ....

2345678910I I1213141516171819202122232425262728

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICEI, the undersigned, hereby declare:I am a residentof Los Angeles in the State of California. I am overthe age of 18 and not a partyto the action described herein. I am employed in the County of Los Angeles, California. My businessaddress is LAW OFFICE OF EUGENE LEE, 555 West Fifth Street, Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA90013. On the date of execution of this DOCUMENT, I served the following:

PLAINTIFF'S INTERROGATORIES FOR DEFENDANT COUNTY OF KERN (SETTHREE)on the following parties in this action by and through their attorneys addressed as follows:Mark A. WasserLAW OFFICES OF MARK A. WASSER400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1100Sacramento, CA 95814Fax: (916) 444-6405Attorneys for Defendants County ofKern, PeterBryan, Irwin Harris, Eugene Kercher, JenniferAbraham, Scott Ragland, Toni Smith andWilliam Roy

[gJ BY FACSIMILE: I transmitted via facsimile the DOCUMENT(s) listed above to the faxnumber(s) set forth above on this date before or around 5:00 p.m. The outgoing facsimile machinetelephone number in this office is (213) 596-0487. The facsimile service used in this office creates atransmission report for each outgoing facsimile transmitted. A copy of the transmission report(s) for theservice of this DOCUMENT, 'properly issued by the facsimile service that transmitted this DOCUMENand showing that such transnussion was (transmissions were) completed without error, is attachedhereto.[gJ FEDERAL: I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States ofAmericathat the above is true and correct and that I took said actions at the direction of a licensed attorneyauthorized to practice before this Federal Court

Executed on July 8, 2008, at Los Angeles, California.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1


13/67


EXHIBITB


14/67


Page 1 of2

Mark WasserFrom: Eugene D. Lee [[email protected]]Sent: Monday, June 30, 20082:31 PMTo: [email protected]: Depositions

Mark,I asked you for dates of availabil ity to depose your experts last Monday. One week later, I've receivedone date from you -- July 7 -- for Dr. Burchuk, and nothing more. After I explained I'm not available onJuly 7, I didn't back heard from you. It shouldn't take this long to give me dates of availabil ity for yourexperts. I will go ahead and notice their depositions today since my attempt to work the dates out withyou has failed.It is unfortunate that you are unwilling to cooperate with me on something as simple as schedulingexpert depos, but it comes as no surprise given your conduct in this action to date.I have heard back from Ms. Rizzardi. She is available to be deposed all of next week, from 7/7 to 7/11,and also on 7/14 to 7/16. At this point, I'm still trying to reach Dr. Weiss, who was traveling last I heard.I hope to hear back from him soon though. I've already supplied you dates for Dr. Reading and Ms.Levison but haven't heard back from you.Also, Plaintiff would like to depose:Supervisor Ray Watson (4 hours)Supervisor Barbara Patrick (4 hours)Peter Bryan (full day)David Culberson (4 hours)Irwin Harris (full day)Scott Ragland (4 hours)Jennifer Abraham (4 hours)Royce Johnson (4 hours)Joseph Mansour (4 hours)Maureen Martin (4 hours)Albert McBride (4 hours)Philip Dutt (full day)Savita Shertudke (4 hours)Sandra Chester (4 hours)Toni Smith (4 hours)Karen Barnes (full day)Arlene Ramos Aninion (4 hours)If it would ease scheduling conflicts for Defendants, Plaintiff is willing to waive the stipulation to havingdepos only on TlW/Th and is Willing to consider any day of the week.Please let me know no later than Wednesday where things stand regarding the foregoing. Time isrunning short and Plaintiff cannot wait a week for Defendants to come back to Plaintiff with nothingmore than a single date for a single deponent.Sincerely,Gene Lee

7/14/2008


15/67


EXHIBIT C


16/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 16 of 67(2131992-3299TELEPHONE LAWE U G

OFFICEENE L OFE EELEE@LOELCOM

EMAIL

(2131 596 -0487FACSIMILE

FAX555 WEST F IFTH STREET SUITE 3100Los ANGELES , CALIFORNIA 90013-1010 WWW.LOEL.COMWEBSITE

To:Fax Number: 2135960487

Pages: 11 (including cover page)Re: Jadwin/KC: Deposition SUbpoenas/Notices

Comments:Mark,

From: Law Office of Eugene LeeDate: 07/03/2008

Attached a re depo sUbpoenas fo r 17 non-exper t deponents - in four faxi n s t a l lmen t s .Please con t ac t me if you have ques t ions .Have a p l e a san t 4th o f JUly weekend .


17/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 17 of 67b.AQ88 (Bey 12/06) Subpoena in DCiyil OIse

Issued by theUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIADavid F. Jadwin, D.O., F.CAP.

V.County of Kern

TO: Royce Johnson, M.D.

SUBPOENA IN A CIVIL CASE

Case Number:! 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

D YOU ARE CO!l-1MANDED to appear in the United StatesDistrict cOUIi at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.

PLACE OF TESTIMONY COURTROOM

DATE AND TIME

[i f YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testifY at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661 )323-1900 DATE AND TIME7/24/20089:00 am

D YOU ARE CO!l-1MANDED to produce and pennit inspection and copying of the following documents or objects at theplace, date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):

PLACE I_D_A_TE_A_ND_TI_M_E _D YOU ARE COlvlMANDED to pennit inspection of the following premises al the date and time specified below.PREMISES I_D_A_TE_AND_I_ME _

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the person will testify. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 30(b)(6).I S S U l N P \ l E ~ : ' ! . : ~ I G N A T U R E AND TITLE ~ N D I C A T E IF ATTORNEYFORPLAlNTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATEet;kjrj0J 7/3/2008ISSUl'tJ OFFICER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene D. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St., Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013; (213) 992-3299

(see Rule 43, f'ederol Rules of dvl l Procedure, SubdivIsions (c), (d), and (e), on next page)

I If action is pending in district other than district of issuance, state dislriCl under case number.


18/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 18 of 670088 (Rev 1'/96) S!!bpQenp in aPrj! 9 e

PROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDSERVED ON (pRINTNAME)

DATE7/3/2008

PLACELaw Offices of Mark Wasser, 400 Capitol Mail, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814MANNER OF SERVICE

Royce Johnson, M.D., by an d through, Mark WasserSERVED BY (pRlNTNAME)Eugene D. Lee

Facsimile & U.S. Mail, First Class to Mark Wasser pe rstipulationTITLEPrincipal, Law Office of Eugene Lee

DECLARATION OF SERVERI declare under penalty o fpeljUly under the laws ofthe United States ofAmerica that the foregoing informationcontained

in the Proof of Service is true an d conect.

Executed on 7/3/2008DATE

ADDRESS OF SERVER555 W 5th St., Ste. 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013

Rule 45, Federal Rules o fCivil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December 1,2006:(c) PROTECTION Of PER-SONS SUBJLCTTO SUBPOENAS.

(1) Aparty or an attorney responsible for theissuance andservice of asubpoenashall takereasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden or expense on a person subje than 14 dil)'l: after I:ervi ce, llerveupon Ule party or attorney designated in the subpoena written o ~ e c t i o n loprodlcingany or allofllie des goatedmolerials or inspection oflliepremises - or to producing electronicaUystoredinfonnntioo in lheformorforms requested. I f o ection ismade, theparty selVingthesubpoenashall notbe entitledto illll'peCI. copy. tero1. or ll'llmple the ffillierials- or inspect the p e e m i ~ s - e x c e p tpursuant 10 an order ofllie court by whichthe subpoenawas issued If objection liaS been made,lIle party serving !he subpoena may, upon notice to !he person commanded to produce, moveat any time for an order to compel the production, inspection, copyiug, testing, or sampliug.Such all order to compelshall protectany person who isnot a party or an officer of aparty fromsignificalll expeuse resulting from Ihe illspectiOll, copying, testing, or sampling commanded.

(3) (A) On timely molion,thecourt by whicha subpoena was issuedmall quash ormodifythe SUbpoena if it

(i) fails to allow reasonable lime for compliance;(ii) requires a person who isnot a party or on officer ofa party to travel to a placemore lIUll! 100 milesfrom theplacewherethat personresides. is employedorregularly transactsbusinessinperson, exceplthot,subject to theprovisions of dause (c)(3)(B)(iii) oflhis rule, sucha personmll)' in order to al1end trial be commanded to travel from any such place wiUlin Ihestale in which !he !rial is held;

(iii) requires dsclosure ofprivileged or other protected matter and no exceptiono rwaiver applies; or(iv) subjects a person 10 undue burden.

(B) If a &.Ibpoena(i) requires di sclosure ofa tradesecret or other conti dential research, development,

or commercial irnonnation, or(Ii) requires disclo!>\lre of an unretained expert's opinion or information notdescribing specific eventsor ocrurrences in dispute lindresultingfrom lIle expert'sstudymadenot otthe request of any party, or(iii) requires II personwho isnot a party or an officer of a party !o incur substantial

expense to InIvel more Ihan tOO miles to attend trial, Ule court may, to pnxect a person subject

to or affected by the subpOellft, quash or modfy the subpoena or, iflhe party in whose behu.lfthe subpoena is issued shows a substantial need for the testimony or material that canllol beotherwise met without undue hardohip andassures that the person to whom the subpoena isaddressedwill be reasonably compensated, the court may order appearance or production onlyupon specified conditions.(d ) DUTIES IN RESPONDING TO SUBPOENA.

(t ) (A) A person responding to a subpoena to produce documents shall produce Ulem asthey are kepi in the u ~ u a l coune ofbl1l:inel:G or shall organize andlabetthem to correspond wilhlIle calegories in the demand(B) If asubpoena doesnot specifythefonn orforms forproducing eI ectronicallystoredillform3tion, a person responding to a subpoena must produce the infonnation in II fonn orform" in which the perwn ordinarily mwntlline it or in a form or forme thai lire reasonablyusab! e. (C) A person responding to II. subpoenaneednot produce the same electronically sloredinformatiOll in more Ulan one form.(D) A person responding to 11 subpoefla neednot provide dill'COvet)' of electronicl i l lystored information from sources that the person identifies as 1'101 reasOllably accessiblebecauseof undue burden or cost. On motion to compel discovery or to quash, the person from whomdiscovery is soughtmust show Ulotlhe infonnatiOll soughtis nol reasonablyaccessiblebecauseof undue burden or cosl. If Ulat showing is made, tIle cow1 mllY nonetheless order discoveryfrom suchsourcesjftherequeslingpllrty shows good cause, 1;000sidering Ule limitations ofRule26(b)(2)(C). The courtmil}' specify conditionsfor the discovery.(2) (A) When infonnation s u * c l t o a subpoena is withheldon a claim that it isprivilegeor subject to protection as trial-preparation materials. the claim shall be made expressly andshall be supported by a destription ofthe nature of the documents, communications, or thingnot produced thai is suffio;ient 10 enable the demanding party 10 coniest the claim.(B) If infonnation is produced in response to a subpoena that is subject to 0 claim oprivil ege or of prolection as!rial-preparationmateria!. the personmaking the claim maynotifyany party !hatreceived the infonnation of the claim andthe basis for it. After being notifieda party musl promptly return, sequester, or destroy the specifiedinformation and lllly copiesihas andmay not use or disclose the infonnalion until theclaim is resolved. A receiving partmay promptly present the infonnation to the court under seal for a determinatioo ofthe claimIf the receiving party disci osed the infonnation before being notified, il must take reasonablsteps to relrieveil. The person who prowced theinformation must preserve Ihe infonnatiountil theclaim is resolved.(e) CONTEMPT. Failureofany person williout adequate excuse10 obey a subpoenaservedupothat person m ay be deemed a (:Qntempt of lIle (:Qurt from which the SUbpoena issued Aadequate cause for failure to obey exists when a subpoena purports to require a nonparty tattend or produce ot a place not within the limits provided by clause 0i) of subparagrap(c)(3)(A).


19/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 19 of 67~ A Q B 8 fRey J 2fQill Suhpoena in jl Cjyil pse



V.County of Kern

TO: Jennifer Abraham, MD.


Case Number: 1 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

D YO U AR E COMl'v1ANDED to appear in the United States District court at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.


DAlE AND TIME

51 YO U AR E COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testifY atthe taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DAlE AND TIME8/6/20082:00 pmD YO U AR E COMMANDED to produce and permit inspection and copying ofthe following documents or objects at the

place, date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):

PLACE I_D_A_lE-,-AND_I_ME--:--::----:-:--:- _D YO U ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection o f the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES ILD_A_lE_A_ND_TI_ME _

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the personwill testify. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 30(b)(6).ISSUING OFl')CP ' ' ' ' ~ N A T U R B AND TITLE ONDICAlE IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAlNTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATEfu, leu 7/3/2008ISSUING q F ~ I C E R ' S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene b. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St., Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013; (213) 992-3299

(See Rule 43, Federal Rules or a v l l Procedure, Subdivisions (e), (d), and ( e) ,on next page)

I If action is pending in district other than district of issuance, state district under case number.


20/67


AO (Rex 1219) !!!woena jn a9yH CpsePROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDDATE

7/312008PLACE

Law Offices of Mark Wasser, 400 Capitol Mail, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814

SERVED ON (pRINTNAME)Jennifer Abraham, M.D., by and through, MarkWasser

SERVED BY (pRlNT NAME)Eugene D. Lee

MANNER OF SERVICEFacsimile & U.S. Mail , First Class to Mark Wasser perstipuiationTITLEPrincipal, Law Office of Eugene Lee

DECLARATION OF SERVERI declare under penaltyofperjury under the laws oftheUnitedStatesofAmerica that the foregoing information contained

in the Proof of Service is true and correct.



Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December 1, 2006:(c) PROTECTION or PERSONS SUBJECTTO SUBPOENAS.

(1) A party or an attorney responsible for theissuance and service of a subpoena shall takereasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden or expense on a person SUbject 10 thatsubpoena. The court on behal fof whidl !he subpoena was issued shall enforce tlris duty andimpose upon the party or attomey in breach ofthie duty I l l l approprillle sllDction, which mayinclude, but is not limited to, lost earnings llJ1d a reasonable allomey's fee.

(2) (A) A person commllJlded to produce and permit inspection, copying, testing, orsampling ofdesignaled electronically storedinformation, books, papers,documents or langible(hing;, or in;pection of premiGe; need not appear in periion al ti le place of product ion orinspection un! ess commanded 10 appear for deposition, hearing or trial.

(B) Subject 10 paragraph (d)(2) oflhisrule, a peISOfi commanded 10 produce andpermilinspection, copying, (esting, or sampling may, wilhin 14 daysafter service ofille SlIbpoena orbefore the time ~ p e c i f i e d for compliance if l:Ilch time il: le.-l: Ihnn 14 daye aftl'!" eervice, l;\!rveupon the party Of altomey designatedin the subpoena written objection loproducing lIny or allof the designatedmateriolsor inspectionof Ihe premlses - o r to p ro du ci ng d el;lroniCally storedinformation in theform orformsrequested Ifobjection is mllde,lheparty servinglhesubpoenashall nol be entitled 10 i l l s p e c ~ copy,test, or sample the moll'riuls or inspectthe premiseS' exCl'ptpursuanlto an orderofUle court by which thesubpoenawasisSJed If objection has!>ten made,the party serving Ihe subpoena may, upon noticeto lhe person :inesll or shallorganize andlabel them to correspondwiththe categorles in the demand

(B) I fa subpoenadoesnot specify thefonn orformsfor producing d eclronicallystoredinformation, a person responding 10 a robpoenB must produce the infonnation in a fonn orforms in which the pereon ordinarily mai.nlaine il or in a form or forme thai are reaeonablyusable. (C) A person respondingto a subpoena neednot produce thesame electronically storedinformalion in more than oneform.

(D) A perl;On responding 10 DSlIbpoena need not provide discovery of electronicallystored infonnalion from sources that the pel'Son identifies asnot reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden or cost. On motion 10 compel ci.scovery or 10 quash, lhe person from whomdiscovery is soughtmust show tllaltheinformation sough! isnot reasonably accessiblebeCllUSCof undue burden or cosl, If Ihot showing is made, IIle court mil)' nOlleUleless order discoveryfrom &lch sources if the requestingparty showsgood cause, considering the Iimitatiolls ofRul e26(b)(2)(C). The court may specify conditionsfor Ihe discovery.

(2) (A)When information subjeetto Bsubpoena is withheld 011 a daim thai itis privilegedor SIIbject 10 prolection as trial-preparation materials. the claim shall be made expressly andshaJl be supported by a description of tbe nature oflhe documents, commilllications, or thingsnot producedthai is sufficienl to enable the demandlug party 10 contesllhe claim.

(B) I f information is produced in response 10 a subpoena that is SUbject 10 a daim ofprivilegeor ofprotecti on as trial-preparation material. thepersonmaking the d aim may notifyany party that received the information of !he claim andthe basisfor il . After being notified,apartymusl promptly return, sequester, or destroy the specified information and any copies itbas andmay nol use or disclose the information until Ule claim is resolved. A receiving partymay promptly presenl the information tothe court under seaJ f or a determination ofllie claimIf thereceiving plIrty disclosed the information beforebeing notified, it must take reasonabl esteps to retrieve it. n le person who produced Iheinformation must preserve the infoffilationuntil the claim is resolved.(e) CONTEMPT. Failureof any person without adequateexcuseto obey a subpoena served uponthai person may be deemed a con1erupl of the court from which the subpoena issued Anudequate cause for failure 10 obey exists when a subpoena purports to require a nonparty 10attend or prodUce at a phce no t within the limils provided by clause (ii) of SUbparagraph(c)(3)(A).


21/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 21 of 67~ A Q 8 B fR ey J1/(6) Subpoena in a Cjyj ! case


EASTERN DISTRICTOF CALIFORNIADavid F. Jadwin, D.O., F.CAP.

V.County of Kern

TO: Arlene Ramos Aninion


Case Number:' 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

D YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United States District court at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.


DATE AND TIME

!if YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testifY at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DATE AND TIME7/22/2008 1:00 pmD YOU ARE COMMANDED to produce and pennit inspection and copying ofthe following documents or objects at the


PLACE I_D_A_TE--,-AND_TI_ME--,--::--:-:--:- _D YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES I_D_A_TE_A_ND_TI_ME _

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the person will testify. FederalRules of Civil Procedure, 30(b)(6).ISSUING OF4 ' I . ~ ~ ~ U R E AND TITLE ONDICATE IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATErv'V(J \Jc..} 7/3/2008ISSUING O ~ E R ' S N A ~ I E . ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene D. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St., Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013: (213) 992-3299

(See Rule 4 ', Federal RuIes or avl l Procedure, SUbdivisions (c), (d), and (e), on next page)

1 If action is pending in district other than district of issuance, state district under case number.


22/67


988 tRey 12/961 n!moena ip PViri' easePROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDDATE

7/3/2008PLACELaw Offices of MarkWasser, 400 Capitol Mail, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814

SERVED ON(PRlNT NAME)Arlene Ramos Aninion, by and through Mark Wasser

SERVED BY (pRINT NAME)Eugene D, Lee

MANNER OF SERVICEFacsimiie & U,S, Mail, First Class to MarkWasser pe rstipulationTI1LEPrincipal, Law Office of Eugene Lee

DECLARA nON OF SERVERI declare underpenaltyofperjUlY under the laws of theUnited States ofAmerica that the foregoing information contained

in the Proof of Service is hue and correct.


Eugene D, LeeADDRESS OF SERVER555 W 5th St., Ste, 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013

Rule 45, Federal Rules ofCivil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December 1,2006:(c) PROTECTION or PERSONS SUBJECT TO SUBPOENAS.

(1) A party or an attorney responsible for theissuanceand service of II. subpoena shall takereasonable s teps to avo id imposing unc1le burden or expense on a person subject to thatsubpoena. TIle court on behalf ofwllitb the subpoena was issued shall enforce this duty andimpooe upon the pllrty or IIttorney in brellcb of this duty an approprill.te sanction, which mayinclUde, but is nollimitedto, losl earnings anda reasonable attorney's fee.

(2) (A) A person commanded to pro e ~ need not appear in penron at Ule place of production orinspection unless commanded 10 appearfor deposition, hearing or trial.

(B) Subject 10 paragraph (d)(2) ofthisrule,a person commanded10 produce andpennilinspection, copying,Iesting, or !;8mplingmay, within 14 days after service of the !lllbpoena orbefore the lime ~ p e c i f i e d for compliance if well lime i l e I 1 ~ than 14 d a y ~ lifter Ilervice, l.:i!rveupon Iheparty or attorney designatedin the subpoenawritten objection 10 prorncing any or alloHile deloignaledmaterialsorinspectionof the premises- orto producing electronicallystoredinformation in theform orforms requested. I fobj ection is made, the party servingthe subpoena>:halt notbe entitledto inspect,copy, lest, or ~ a m p l e the materialsor inspect the premises exceptpursuant 10 llI1 orderof the court by which thesubpoenawas issued If objection has beenmade,Ule party serving the subpoena moy, upon notice 10 the person commanded to protilce. moveat any t ime for an order to compel the production, inspection, copying, te!;1ing, or sampling.Such an order tol:ompel shall protel:t any personWho isnot a party oran officerof apartyfromsignificant expense resull1ng from the inspection, copying,testing, or sampling commanded.

(3)(Al On timelymotion,the courtbywhicha subpoenawasisroed shall quash ormolifythe SUbpoena if it

(i) fails to allow reasonable time for compliance;(ii) requires a person who isnol a party or an officer of a party to Iravel to a placemore than 100 miles from the place wherelhlltpersonresides,is employedor regUlarly transactsbusinessin persOll,except that,subject to theprovisions ofdause (c)(3)(B)(iii) of this rule,sucha person may in order to attend trial be commanded to travel f rom any such place within theslatein which the trial is held;

(ii i) requires lisclorore of privileged or other protectedmatter and no exception orwaiver applies; or

(iv) subjects a person to undueburden.(8) I f a subpoena(I) requires disclosure of atrade secret or other confidential research, development,or commercial information, or

(ii) requires lisclosure of an unretained exper t 's ol inion or information notdesqibing specific events or occurrencesin lispute nnd resulting from the expert's study madenot a t the requesl of any party. or

(iii) requires a personwho is nola party or an officerof aparty to incur subslantialexpense to travel more th1m 100 mileslo attendtrial, the courtmay, to protect a person subject

to or Ilffected by the subpoena, quash or moaly the suhpoeno. Or, ifthe party in whose beholfthe subpoena is issued shows a substantial need for the testimony or material thaI cannot beotherwise met without undue hard'ihip and assures that the person to whom the subpoena isaddressedwill be reasonably compensated, the court may order appearance or production onlyupon specified conditions.(d) DUTIES IN RESPONDING TO SUBPOENA.(1) (A) A person responding to II Subpoena to produce documents shall produce them asthey ere kept in the umJal cOUl"Ge ofbuilinecc or choll organize andhbel them to cOlTcspondwith!he categories in the demand

(B) If a subpoena does not specify the fonn orformsfor producing el ectronicallystoredinformation, a person responding 10 8 subpoena must produce Ule infotlllation in a fonn orforrru: in which the perron ordin:lIily maintainf] it Of in 9 form oc f o r m ~ thai are r e a ~ o n a b l yusable. (C) A person responding toa subpoenaneednol producethe same electronicallysloredinformation in more than oneform

(D) A person responding 10 8. !lIlbpoenQ need nol provide discovery of electronicoll;ystored information from sources that the person identifies asnot reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden or cost. On motion to compel dscovery or to quash, the person from whomdiscovery is sought must show thatthe information soughtisnot reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden or cost. I f Ulal showing is made, the cow1 may nonetheless order dis,"'Ovl:!)'from such sources iflhe requesting party showsgood cause.considering the limitations ofRule26(b)(2)(C). The courL may specify conrilions for the discovery.(2) (A) When information !lllbj ecl to a sUhpoena is withheld Of! a claim that it is pnvilegedor subject 10 protection as trial-preparation materials, the claim shall be made expressly andshall be supported by a description of the nalure of Ule documents, communications, or thingsnot produced thatis sufficienl to enable the demanding party 10 contest the claim.

(B) I f infolTllation is produced in respoose to a subpoena that is subject to a claim ofprivilege or of protection as triat-preparationmaterial, thepersonmaking the claim mll)' notifyany party that received the infonnation of the claim andthe basisfor it. After being notified,a party must promptly return, sequester, or destroy the specifiedinformalion and any copies ithas andmoy not use or disclose the infonnation unlit the claim is resolved. A receivingpartymay promptly present the infonnation 10 the court under seal for a determinatiOlI of the claim.If Ule receiving party disclosed the infolTllulion before being notified, it must take reasonabtesteps toretrieve il Th e person who produced Ute information mus! preserve the infonnationuntil the claim is resolved(e) CONTE;MPT. Failure ofarey person without adequateexcuse10 obey a subpoena served uponthat person may be deemed a contempt of the court from which the subpoena issued Anadequate CUllse for failure to obey exists when a subpoena purports 10 require a nonparty 10attend or produce al a phce no t within the limits provided by clause (ii) of snbpal1lgraph)(3)(A),


23/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 23 of 67:s.AQ88 (Bey p!Ofj) SUbpoena in a Cjyil Gase


EASTERN DISTRlCTOF CALIFORNIADavid F. Jadwin, D.O., F.CAP.

V.County of Kern

TO: Peter Bryan


Case Number: l 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United States District COUlt at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.


DAlli AND TIME

[ i YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testifY at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACEOFDEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DAl li AND TIME7/17/20089:00 arn

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to produce and pelmit inspection and copying of the following documents or objects at theplace, date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):

PLACE rAll iANDTIME

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES I_D_A_lli_A_ND_I_ME _

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the person will testify. Federal Rules ofCivil Procedure, 30(b)(6).AND TITLE ONDICAlli IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAlNTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATE

7/3/2008[SSUINGOFFICER' "ME . ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene D. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St., Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013; (213) 992-3299

(See Rule 4j , Feclernl Rules of dvlI Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), 0fI nexl page)



24/67


A98 tRey J2/96) Subpoega in 3 Civjl CasePROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDSERVED ON (PRlNTNAME)

DATE7/3/2008

PLACELawOffices of MarkWasser, 400 Capitol Mall, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814MANNER OF SERVICE

Peter Bryan, by and through, Mark WasserSERVED BY (pRINTNAME)Eugene D. Lee

Facsimile & U.S. Mail, First Class to MarkWasser perstipulationTITLEPrincipal, Law Office of Eugene Lee

DECLARAnON OF SERVERI declare underpenalty of peljury under the laws oftheUnited States ofAmerica that the foregoing infonnationcontained

in the Proof of Service is true and con-ect.


Eugene D. LeeADDRESS OF SERVER555 W 5th St., Ste. 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013

Rille 451Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (C)l (d), and (e), as amended on December 112006:(.c) PROTECTION OFPERSONS SUBJECT TO SUBPOENAS.(1) A party or an allomey responsible forUleissuance and service of asubpoena shall takereasollable Sleps 10 IIvoid imposing oolite burden or expense on a per son sub je ct to tnatsubpoena. The court on behalf of which the lrnbpoena wasislrned shaU enforce this duty andimpooe upon the parI) ' or attorney in breach of this duty on appropriatea8fiction, which meyinclude,but is nollimiled to, lost earnings and II reaSOll3b1e aUomey' s fee.

(2) CA) A person commanded to produce and pennit inspection, copying, testing, orsampling of designatedelectronically storedinfonnation, books, papers,documents or langiblet h i n g ~ , or inspection of p r e m i ~ e ~ need not appea r in p e r ~ o n at the place of production orinspection unless commlltldedto appear for deposition.hearing or trial.

(B) Subject toparagraph (d)(2) oHhisrule, a person commlltldedlo prowce and permitinspection, copying, lesting, or sampling may, within 14 days after service of the subpoena orbeforethe lime specifiw for compli:mce if I>'Uch lime is less than 14 d l l Y ~ after ~ I ! r v i c e . serveupon Ule Pllfty or attomey designated inthe subpoenawritten oqjection to prochJdng anyor allof the desi gnBled materialsor in;veclion of thepremises- orto producing el ectronicnllystoredinformati on in t.heform orforms requested. If oqjectien ismade,the party servingthe subpoenamall notbe entitled toinspect,copy, led, or S'ample the malerial';! or inllpect the pcemises exceptpurSU1lllt to an order of thecourt by which thesubpoena was iS9.led Ii objection hasbeen made,the party serving the subpoenamay, upon notice to fbeperson commanded to produce, moveal a ny t ime fo r an o rder to compellhe production, inspection, copying, testing, or SlImpling.Such all order to compel shull proteclany personwhoisllOt apartyor nn officer of a party fromsignificant expense resulting from the illlopection, copying, testing, or sampling commanded(3) (A) On timelymotion, thecOllrtbywhicha subpoenawasis9.led !ttall quash ormodifythe sUbpoena ifil

0) fails to allow reasonablelime for compliance;Oi) requires a person who i snot a par ty or an officer of a party to trnvello a plncemorethan 100milesfrom Iheplace wherelhatperson resides,is employedor regularly !fallsactsbusinessin person,excepl that, SUbject to Uleprovisionsof diluse (c)(3)(B)(iii) ofUlis rlJl e, sucha person may in order to attend trial be commanded to t rave l f rom any such p111ce within lhes ta te in whirl l the t rial i s held; .

Oii)requires cti.sdosureof privileged or oUter protected malter and no exception orwaiverapplies; or

( iv) subjecls a person to unci.Je burden.(B) If a subpoena(i) requires disclosure of II trade secret or other confidential research, development,

or commercial informalion, or(ij) requires disclosure of an unretained expert's opinion or information not

describing specificeve.nts or ocomencesin dispute and rerolting fromthe expert'S studymadenot at the request ohoy purty, or

(iii)requiresa person who is not aparty or an officerof a party 10 incur substanti alexpense to travel more than 100 milesto attend trial,Ute court may, to protect II person subject

to or affected by the subpoene., quash ormocti.fY the subpoena or, iflhe party in whose behlllfthe subpoena is issued shows II sub!>1nnlial need for the testimony or material that cannot beotJlerwise met without undue hardship and assures that the person to Whonl the subpoena isaddressed will bereasonably compellSaled, the court mayorderappearanceor production onlyupon .specified conalionll.(d) DUTIES IN RESPONDING TO SUBPOENA.

(1) (A) A person resp:lllcling!o a subpoena to produce documents shall produce thtm asthey I)fe kepi inIheusual coune ofbusinelilior lillall organize aud label them to colTwpondwiththecategories in the demand

(B) I f asubpoena does not specify Iheform or forms forproducing dectronically s10redinformalioll, a person respollding 10 a subpoena must produce the infOlmalioll in a Conn orforml: in which the perl:on ordinarily mainfainl: it or in a form or forml: thai He r e l l ~ o n l l b l yusable. (C) A personrelopondingto a &Ibpoena neednot produce the same electronicallystoredinforffiati orJ in more thon olle form.

(0 ) A p""soo respondioB to u subpoena nced not provide discovery of elcctronicallystoredinformation from sources that the person identifiesas not reasonably accessible becauseof undueburden or cost. On motion 10 compel cliscovery or to quaSh, theperson from whomdiscovel)' issouglltmustshow that theinformation sought is nol reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden or cost. I f thai showing is made, Ule court mil)' nonetheless order discoveryfrom such sources ifthe requestingparty showsgood cause, considering thelimitations ofRule26(b)(2)(C). The courtmay specify conditions for the discovery.(2) (A)Wlien information SUJ:!jecl to a SUbpoena is withheld on ndaim thaiil isprivilegedor subject to protection as trial-preparation materials, the daim shall be made expressly andshall besupported by a description of the nature of the documents, communications. or thingsnotproducedthat is sufficient to enable!hedemanding party to contest the claim.

(B) I f information is produced in response 10 a 9.lbpoena Ihal is sUbjec:' to a claim ofprivilege or of protection astrial-preparation malerial.the person making the claimmay notifyany party thatreceived the infonnation of the claim andlhe basis for it After beingnolified,a party must promptly return, sequester, or destroy the specifiedinformation and anycopiesithas andmay not use or disclose theinformation unlil the claim is resolved. A receiving partymil}' promplly present the infonnat.ion to the court underseal for a determination of the claim.If thereceiving party disclosed the informationbefore being notified, il musttake reasooablesteps 10 retrieve it The person who proooced the informationmusl. preserve theinformationuntil the claim is resolved.(e) CONTEMPT. Failure of any persoo withouladequate excuseto obey asubpoena selveduponthat person may be deemed a contempt of the rourt f rom which the subpoena is sued Anadequate cause for failure to obey exists when a subpoena purports to require a nonparty toat tend or p roduce at a p la ce not w il hi n t he limits provided by clause ~ i of 9.lbp.1ragraph(,)(3)(A).


25/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 25 of 67l::!.AQ88 (Rey 11m) Subpoena in aGjyjl [ase


EASTERN DISlRICTOF CALIFORNIADavid F. Jadwin, D.O., F.C.A.P.

v.County of Kern

TO: Sandra Chester


Case Number: ' 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

o YO U ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United StatesDishict coul1 at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.

PLACE OF TESTIMONY COUR1ROOM

DATE AND TIME

[i f YO U ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testify at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DATE AND TIME8/12/2008 9:00 am

o YO U ARE COMMANDED to produce and permit inspection and copying ofthe following documents or objects at theplace, date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):

PLACE I_D_A_TE_AND_I_ME _o YO U ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection o f the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES IDATE AND TIME

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one ormore officers,directors, ormanaging agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters onwhich the personwill testify. Federal Rules ofCivil Procedure, 30(b)(6).n ",ISSUING 9l'P11:iER'1it;!IQNATURE AND TITLE ONDlCATE IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAlNTlFF OR DEFENDANT) DATE, [ d\.)..) 7/3/2008

lSSUING\J: FleER'S NAME. ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene D. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St., Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA90013; (213) 992-3299

(See Rule < l ~ , F e d e r a l Rules of dvll Procedure, SubdiVisIons (c), (d), ami (e), on next page)



26/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 26 of 67988 fRey J1190) !!hpoeoa jn fI Ciyj! Case

PROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDDATE

7/3/2008PLACE

Law Offices of MarkWasser, 400 Capitol Mall, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814SERVED ON (pRlNTNAME)Sandra Chester, by and through Mark Wasser

SERVED BY (pRlNT NAME)Eugene D. Lee

MANNER OF SERVICEFacsimile & U.S. Mail, First Class to MarkWasser pe rstipulationTIlLEPrincipal, Law Office of Eugene Lee

DECLARAnON OF SERVERI declare under penalty ofperjUlY under the laws oftheUnited States ofAmerica that the foregoing information contained

in the Proof of Service .is bue and correct.



Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December 1,2006:(c) PROTECTiON OFPElI.SONS SUBJECTTOSUBPOENAS.

(1) A party or an allomey responsible forthe issuance andservice of a subpoena shall takereasonable steps to llvlid imposing llllwe burden or expense on a person subject lo lhatsubpoena. TIle court on behalf of which the subpoena was issued shall enforce this duly andimpose upon the parI)' or attorney in breach ofUlis duty an appropriate aanction, which mayinclude, bul is not limiledlo,losi earnings anda rellsonable atlonley's fee.

(2) (A) A person commanded to prodlce Illld permit inspection, copying, testing, orsamplingof designaledelectronicallys10red information,books, papers, documentsortangiblethinSs, or inspection of premises need nol nppear in penon at the place of production orinspection unless commanded to appear for deposition,hearing or trial.

(B) Subjectto paragraph(d)(2)oflhislUle, n personcommandedto prowce andpermitinspection, copying,tegling, or sampling may, within 14 days after service ofthe subpoena orbefore the time llpecified for compliance if I.'I.Idl time ill lellll than 14 duyll after lIervice, ~ l V eupon !hepnrty or attorney designated inthe subpoenawritten objection toproducingany or allof the desigoatedmaterialsor inspection of thepremi ses orto producing el e(;tronicallys toredinformati on in theform orforms requeg;ed. I f o ~ t ' ( ; t i o n ismade,Iheparty servingthesubpoenamoll not be entitled 10 inspect,copy,test, orsamplethe materials or il1lipeet the premises exceptpursuanlto anorderof the court by whichthe subpoena Wllsis&led If objection hasbeen made,the party selVing the subpoena may,upon nolice to the person commanded to produce, moveal any timefor ail order 10 compel the production, inspection, copying, lesting, or sampling.Such anorderto compel shall protectany personwhois not aparly oran officerof aparly fromsignificant expense resulting from the inspection, copying, testing, or sampling commanded.

(3) (A)On timelymotion,Ule courtby whicha subpoena was issued ~ . l I l 1 i quash ormodifythe subpoena if it

(i) fails to allow reasonable lime for compliance;0i) requires 8 personwho is not a party or an officerOfll party to lrave!lo a placemore lban100milesfrom theplace wherelhlll personresides, is employedorregularly transactsbusinessin persOfl, excepllhlll, subjecllo Uleprovisions of clause (c)(3)(B)(iii) ofUlisrule, sucha person may in order 10 attend trial be commanded to travel from any such place wiUlin thes1ale in whim Ule trial is held;

(iii) requires dsclosure of privileged or olher prolectedmatter Illld no exception orwaiverapplies; or(iv) wQi eels a person 10 undue burden.

(B) If a subpoena(I) requiresdisclosure ofa trode secret or other confidential research, development,

or commercial infonnation, or0i) requires disclosure of an unretained expert's opnion or infoffilation not

describing specifi c events or ocumences in dispute and rewlting from Ule expert's studymadeno! atlhe request oiany party, or

(iii)requires a personwho isnol aparty or on offi eer of 0 party 10 ineW" substantialeKpense 10 travel more than 10 0 mileslo atlendtrial, the collrtmay, to prol:ect a person subject

to or uffected by Ult subpoena, quosh or modify the subpoeno or, iflht party in whose behalftlte suopoena is issued silOWS a substanl:ial need for the testimony or material that cannot beotherwise met without undue hardship iIOd assures that the person 10 whom the subpoena isaddressedwill be reasonablycompensated, the court may order appearance or production oniyupon ~ p e c j f i e d conditions.(d) DUTIES IN RESPONDING TO SUBPOENA.

(1) (A) A personresponding 10 II subpoena 10 produce documents shall prowce Ihem asthey are kept inthe u ~ u a l course o f b u ~ i n e ~ ~ or ~ h a l l organize and label them to correlipondwiththe categories in the demand

(B) If asubpoena does notspecifythe fonnor formsfor producingeItronically storedinformation, a person responding to n subpoena must produce lite infOlmntion in a fonn orforfill in which lite perwn ordinnrily m:linl:linll il or in a form or forme thai \Ire re\llo':onablyusable.

(C) A person respondingto a subpoenaneednot producethe same tiectrQnicallysioredinformation in more Ulan one form.

(0 ) A person responding to a subpoena need not provide diS'covcry of electronicallystored information:from sOIIrces thal the person identifies as nol: reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden orcost. On motion 10 compet discovery or to quash, the person from whomdiscovery is sought mustshow that the informa.tion soughtis nol reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden or cost. IT Ullli showing is made, Ule courtmay nonetheless order discoveryfrom such sources iflhe requesting purty shows good cause,consideriugUle limitations ofRule26(b)(2)(C). The coW"l may speciJ cond lions for the discovery.(2) (A) 'Wllen infonnntion subject to a subpoena is withheld on a claim that it isprivilegedor subject 10 protection as trial-preparation materials, the claim shall be made expressly andshall be supported by a description oflhe nature of Ute documents, communications, or thingsnot producedthai is sufficient to enable the demanding party to rontest the claim.

(B) I f information is producedin response to a subpoena that is subject to a claim ofprivilege or of protection astrial-preparalionmaterial, the personmaking the claimmil)' nOlifyany party that received the infonnalioll of the claim andlhe basisfor it. After being notified,a party musl prompUy return, sequester, or deslroy the specified information and any copies ithas and may not use or disclose fue infonnation untillhe claim is resolved. A receiving partymay promptly presentthe infonnntion 10 Ihe court under seal for a determination of the claim.If the receiving parly disci osed the informationbefore being lIo1ified, it must take reasonablesteps 10 retrieve it The person who produced the informalion must preserve the infonnalionUntil the claim is resolved.(e) CONTEMPT. Failureofany person without adequate excuse to obey a subpoenaselVed uponthai person may be deemed a conlempl of !he oourt f rom which the subpoena issued Anadequate cause for failure to obey exists when a subpoena purports 10 require a nonparty 10atlend or produce al a p lace not wilhin the limits provided by clause (Ii) of subparagraph(c)(3)(A).


27/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 27 of 672131 992-3299

TELEPHONE LAWE U GOFFICEENE L

o FE E

[email protected]

(2131 596 - 0487FACSIMILE

FAX555 WEST FIFTH STREET SUITE 3 1 0 0L05 ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 900 1 3-1 a 1 a WWW.LOEL.GOMWEBSITE

To:Fax Number: 2135960487

Pages: 11 (including cover page)Re: Jadwin/KC: Deposition Subpoenas/Notices

Comments:Mark,More depo subpoenas.

From: Law Office of Eugene LeeDate: 07/03/2008


28/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 28 of 67~ A Q 8 8 (Rey ! 1(06) Spbpoena in 0Cjrjl ease


EASTERN DISTRICTOF CALIFORNIADavid F. Jadwin, D.O., F.CAP.

V.County of Kern

TO: David Culberson


Case Number: ' 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

D YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United StatesDistrict court at the place, date, and time specified below totestify in the above case.


DATE AND TIME

ri YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testify at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DATE AND TIME7/23/20089:00 amD YOU ARE COMMANDED to produce and pennit inspection and copying of the following documents or objects at the


PLACE I_D_A_TE_A_ND_I_ME _D YOU ARE COMMANDED to pennit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES I_D_A_TE_AND_I_ME _

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more omcers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the person will testify. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 30(b)(6).ISSUING [ J ' : + ~ ' ' ' I ~ M G N A T U R E AND TITLE ONDICATE IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAlNTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATE

L \,\fV' t1\,).J 7/3/2008ISSUINC\J HICER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene D. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St., Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013; (213) 992-3299

(See Rule


29/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 29 of 67A9 (Rey 11106) ubpoeoa in aCiyil eass

PROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDSERVED ON (pRlNT NAME)

DATE71312008

PLACELaw Offices of Mark Wasser, 400 Capitol Mall, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814MANNER OF SERVICE

David Culberson, by and through Mark WasserSERVED BY (pRINTNAME)Eugene D. Lee


DECLARATION OF SERVERI declare under penalty ofpeljUly under the laws of theUnited States ofAmerica that the foregoing infonnationcontained


Executed on 71312008DATE SIGNA OF SERVER


Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December I, 2006:(c) PROTECTION orPERsmlS SUBJCTTO SUBPOENAS.(1) A party or an attorney responsiblefor he issuanceand serviceof a subpoena sjlall takereasonable steps to avoid imposing unckJe burden or expense on a person subject to thatsubpoena. TIle wurt on behalf of which the subpoena was issued shall enforce this duty andimpose upon the purty or attorney in breach ofthis duty Il1l Ilpproprinte sllrlction, which mayinclude, butis not limited to, lost earnings and a reasooable attorney's fee.

(2) (A) A person commanded to produce and pennit inspection, copying. testing, Orsampling ofdesignated electronically storerlinformati on,books, paperS,documents Of tangiblethings;, or inllpection of premillell need not appear in penon at the place of production orinspedion unless commanded to appear for deposition,hearing or Irial.

(B) Subjed to paragraph (d)(l) ofthi smle, II person commanded to prodJce and permitinspection, copying,testing, or samplingmay, within 14 days afterservice oflhe !lUbpoena orbefore thl! time ~ p e c i f i e d for c o m p t i ~ n c e ifr.uch time i l e I : ~ Ihan 14 d 3 Y ~ after ~ e l V i c e , l;I!lVeupon theparty or attorney designated!n the subpoenawritten objection to producinganyor 1111ofthe designated mIIttrials or inspection of th epremis e s - or to producing el e('tronicallystoredinformation in thefO!m orforms requested. If o eclion ismade,the paTty selVingthe s u b p o e n ~shnll not be entitled to inspect,copy,test, orsample the mllterinls or inspect tlIeprernisesexceptpUf91ant to an orderof the court by whichthe subpoenuwaS issued If objection has beenmade,the party selVing the subpoena mil)'.upon notice to the person commanded to produce, moveat any time for lUI order to compel the production, inspection, copying, testing, or sampling.Suchan order \0 compd shall protectany perSonwho is nola paTly or all officerof a partyfromsignificanl expense resultingfrom the inspection, copying.testing, or sllffipling commanded.

(3) (A) On timely motion, thecourt by which a subpoena wasis91edmall quash OrmodifYthe subpoena if il

(i) fails to allow reasonable lime for compliance;(ii) reqUires a personwho i sno t a par ty or an offieer of a party to travel to D. placemore than 100 miles from theplace wllel'ethat personresides,isemployedonegularly transactsbusinessin person, except tMt, subject to the prOVisionsof clause (c)(3)(B)(iii) of this rule, sucha person may in order to attend hilll be commanded totravel from any such place within thestate in which thetrial is held;

(iii) requires disclosure of privileged or other prolected mailerand no exception orwaiver applies; or

(iv) sul:!i ects aperson to unwe burden.(B) If a subpoena(i) requires di sdosureof alrade secret or otherconfidential research, development,

or commercial infonnation, or(ii) requires disclosure of an unretlined expert 's opinion or infonnation nol

desaibing specificevents or OCOJlTences in eli spllte and resultingfrom the expert's studymadenot at the request of any party. or

(iii) requires a personwho is not a party oran offieel' of a party to incur substantialexpense to travet more than 100 milesto attend trial,the courtmay, to protect aperson subject

to or affected by the subpoena. q u a ~ h or modify the subpoena or, ifthe party in whose behalfthe subpoena is issued shows a substantial need for the testimony or material that cannot beotherwise met without undue hardship and assures that the person to whom the subpoena isaddressed will bereasonably ~ o m p e n s a t e d , the CQurt may orderappearance or productiononlyupon apedfie d condition!!.(d) DUTIES IN RESPONDINC TO SUBPOEHA.

(t ) (A) A personresponding 10 II subpoena !o produce documents shall produce them asthey lITe kept inthe usual course ofbul:inel:s or gllall organize andlabel them to corrcspondwiththecategories in the demand(B) If asubpoena does not specify llieforrn orformsfor producing d ectronica1lystoredinformation. II person responding to a SIIbpoena must produce the informalion ill a f onn orf o r m ~ in which the pen:on ordinarily maintainl: it or in a form or forml: that lire relll:onablyusuble. (C) A person respondingto a subpotllaneednot. produce!he sumt electronicully storedinformation in more than one form.

(D) A perlloll responding to II subpoena need not provide discovery of electronicallystored information from sources that the persOIi identi 6es as not reasonably accessible becauseofulldue burden Or cost. Onmotion to compel discovery or to quash, the person from whomdiscovery is soughlmustshow that the informalion soughtis 1101. reasonably IIccessibl e becauseof undue burden or cosl. I f tllnt showing is made. tile cow1 mll)' noneUltiess order discoveryfrom sudl Sourcesiftherequestingparty shows good cause,considering the limitations ofRul e26(b)(2)(C). Tbe court mil)' specifY concitions for Ihe discovery.

(2) (A)When infonnation suqectto 8 subpoena is withheld on a claim that itis privilegedor subject to protection as trial-preparalion materials, the claim shall be made expressly andshall be supported by a description of the nalure of the documents, eummunications, or thingsnol produ('edlha! is sufficient to enable the demanding party to contest tile claim,

(B) IfinfOlmation is produced in response to a >.l.IbpOetl8 Ihat is subject to 8 claim ofprivil ege or ofprolection as !rial-preparationmaterial, theperson makingthe claimmay notifyany party that reCeived tile information of theclaim andthe basisfor il. Afterbeing notified,a party must promptly return, sequester, or destroythe specified information and any copies ithas undmay not use or disclose llieinfonnation unlil the claim is resolved. A receivingpartymay promptly present the infonnation to the court under seal for ndetermination of tileclaim.If the receiving plIrty disdosed the infonnation before being notified, itmust take reasonablesteps 10 rdneve it. The person who proooced the information must preserve the infonnationuntil the claim is resolved.(e) CONTEMPT. Failure of any personwithout adequate excuseto obey a subpoenaserved uponthat person may be deemed a contempt of the court f rom which the subpoena iSSued AnadeqJate cause for failure to obey exists when a 9lbpoena purports to require II nonparty toattend or produce at Il place not within the limits provided by clause Oi) of subparagraph(c)(3)(A).


30/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 30 of 67t:r.AQ88 (Rey J1(06) SUhpoena jn aGjyHgse



V.County of Kern

TO: Phillip Dult, M.D.


Case Number:' 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United StatesDistrict cOUli at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.

PLACE OF TESTIMONY COUR1ROOM

DAlE AND TIME

@' YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testifY at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DATE AND TIME8/7/20089:00 am

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to produce and pelmit inspection and copying ofthe following documents or objects at theplace, date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):

PLACE I_D_A_TE_AND_I_ME _o YOU ARE COMMANDED to pelmit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES IDATE AND TIME

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the person will testify. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 30(b)(6).

" 0.,ISSUING (oqICfR:'1f:l\{',pATURE AND TITLE ONDICATE IF ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATERNd\..U 7/3/2008ISSUING i;)j;'FICER'S NAME. ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBEREugene D. Lee, Law Office of Eugene Lee, 555 West Fifth St, Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90013; (213) 992-3299

(See Rule 4"" Federal Rules of dvll Procedure, SubdivIsions (e), (d), and (e), on next page)

I If action is pending in district other than district of issuance, state district under case number.


31/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 31 of 67A9aR (Bey 12ffi6l llbpoepa in a Pri' Qpss

PROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDSERVED ON (pRlNTNAME)

DATE7/3/2008

PLACELaw Offices of MarkWasser, 400 Capitol Mall, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814MANNER OF SERVICE

Phillip Dull, M.D., by and through, Mark WasserSERVED BY (pRINT NAME)Eugene D. Lee


DECLARAnON OF SERVERI declare underpenalty ofperjury under the laws of the United StatesofAmerica that the foregoing infOimation contained




Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil P r o c e d u r e ~ Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December 1, 2006:(e) PR.OTECTION Of PERSONS SUBJECTTO SUllPOHIAS.(1) Aparty or lIJl attorney responsiblefor rhe is!,1Jance and service of a!,1Jbpoena shall takereasonable 5teps to avai d impolSing W1


32/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 32 of 67~ A Q S S CBey 1?ffi6) Subpoena jn a Cjyil Ose



V.County of Kern

TO: Irwin Harris, MD.


Case Number: l 1:07-cv-26-0WW-TAG

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United StatesDistrict court at the place, date, and time specified below totestifY in the above case.


DATE AND TIME

[i f YOUARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testifY at the taking of a depositionin the above case.

PLACE OF DEPOSITION Holiday Inn, 801 Truxton Ave, Bakersfield, CA 93301, (661) 323-1900 DATE AND TIME7/16/20089:00 amo YOU ARE COlvIl\IANDED to produce and permit inspection and copying ofthe following documents or objects at theplace, date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):

o YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit inspectionof the following premises at the date and time specified below.PREMISES ILD_A_TE_A_ND_TI_ME _

Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking ofa deposition shall designate one or more officers,directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, thematters on which the person will testify. Federal Rules ofCivil Procedure, 30(b)(6).ISSUING('Jr"'t ' \ r / ~ G N A T U R E AND TITLE GNDICATE IF ATTORNEY FORPLAINTIFF OR DEFENDANT) DATE

I ~ n r j \ . ) . ) 7/3/2008ISSUIN(J}


33/67

Case 1:07-cv-00026-OWW-TAG Document 165 Filed 07/14/2008 Page 33 of 67AO?? (Rey 12ffi6) Subpoepa in a CjYi! Cass

PROOF OF SERVICE

SERVEDSERVED ON (pRJNTNAME)

DATE7/3/2008

PLACELaw Offices of MarkWasser, 400 Capitol Mall, Ste2640, Sacramento, CA 95814MANNER OF SERVICE

Irwin Harris, M.D., by and through, MarkWasserSERVED BY (pRJNT NAME)Eugene D. Lee

Facsimiie & U.S. Mail, First Class to MarkWasserperstipulationTITLEPrincipal, Law Office of Eugene Lee

DECLARAnON OF SERVERI declare underpenaltyofperjury under the laws ofthe United StatesofAmerica that the foregoing infOlmationcontained

in the Proof of SelVice i s t rue and COlTect.



Rule 45, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), as amended on December 1,2006:(c) PROTECTION Of PERSONS SUBJOCTTO SUBPOENAS.

(1) A party or an auomey responsiblefor the is&lance and service ofa &lbpoenashall takereasonable steps to avoid imposng uncb.le burden or expense on a pe rson sub ject to tha tsubpoena. The court on behalfof which the subpoenawasissued shall enforce lhis duly andimpose upon t.he party or attorney in breach ofthifl duty IlII appropriate Bllficlion, which mayinclude, bUI is nollimiled 10,lo!>t earnings anda reasonable attorney's fee.

(2) (A) A person commanded to produce and pennit inspection, copying, lesting, orsampling of designaledelectronically storedinformation, books, papers,documentsor langiblethings,. or i n ~ p e c t i o n of p r e m i G ( ! ~ need not appeu i n per eon a t the ptace of produclion orinspection unless commaoded 10 appear for deposition, henring or trial.

(B) Subject 10 paragraph (d)(2) ofthisrule,a person commanded 10 prodlce andpermitinspection, copying, testing, or samplingmay, within 14 days afterservice of the gjbpoe.lla orbefore Ihe time epecified for compliance if wch lime ie Ieee than lA dayc after cervi ce, ;:eNeupon U\e party or attorney designaledin the sUbpoena written obj ection loprodudng any orallofUte designatedmaterialsor inspt(tion of Illepremises or to producingel ectronitallystoredinformation in theform orfonnsrequested. I f0l:!iecli on is made, thepllfty servingthe subpoenashnll not be entitled to inspect,copy, test, or sample the mllterilllsor inspect the premi .....sexceptpursuantto anorderof the court by which Ihesubpoena was issued If objection has beenmade,the p;lrty serving the subpoena may, upon notice to the person commanded 10 produce, moveat any limefor all order to compel the production, inspectioo, copying, testing, or sampling.Such anorder to compel shallprotect any perSOli whois IIOt aparty or anofficerof a Pllfty fromsignificant e),:pense resultingfrom the inspection, copying, lesling, or sampling commllllded.

(3)(A) On timelymotion, the court bywhich a subpoenaWIIS issued shall qlash ormodifythe subpoena if it

(i) fails to allow reasonable time for compliance;(Ii) requires a person whois not a party or an offi cer of a parly to t ravel toa pi acemore tflan 100 milesfrom theplace wherelhat personresides, is employedorregularly transactsbusinessin person, excepllhat, subjectto Iheprovisions of douse (c)(3)(B)(iii) oftJlis rule,sucha person may in order 10 attend tlial be commanded 10 travel from any such place within Ihe!>tale inwhich thetrial is held;

(iii) requires di sc10sure of privileged or other protected matter and no exception orwaiver applies; or

(iv) suttlects a person to unwe burden.(B) Ifa subpoena

(i)requires di sdosure of II tradesecret or other confidential research, development,or commercial infonnation, or

(ii) requires disclorore of an wtretained expert's opinion or information Dotdescribingspecificevents or occurrencesin dispute and reroltingfrom theexpert's ;,tudymadenot al the request of all)' party, or

(iii) requires a personwhois not a party or an officerof a party 10 incur sub,slanlialexpenseto travel more Ihan 100 milesloaltertd trial, the court may,to protect aperson SUbject

to or affected by the SLlbpOellR, quash or modify the subpoena or, ifthe ptlrty in whose behll1fthe subpoena is issued shows II robstanlial need for the testimony or material that carmot beotherwise melwithout undue hardship andassures that the person to whom the subpoena isaddressedwill be reasonablycompensated, the CO\1rt may order appearanceor production onlyupon specified condilions..(d) DUTIES IN RESPONDING TO SUBPOENA.

( 1) (A)A person responding to a subpoena to produce documenls shall produce them asthey are kept intheusual coune o f b U l i : i n e ~ s or shall organize and label them to cOlTe&pOndwiththe categories in the demand

(B) If a subpoenadoes nol specify thefonnorformsforproducingelectronically storedinforllllltion, a person responding 10 a subpoena must prodUce Ihe infonnation in a fonn orforms in which the perron ordinarily maintains it or in a form or forml;' !JIllt are real;'onablyusable.

(C) A person respondingto 0 subpoenaneednot produce the saffieelectronicallystoredinformation in more than oneform.

(D) A person respollding to 0 subpoena need not provide discovery of electronicallystored information from sources that Ihe person identifies asnot reasonably accessible becauseof undue burden or co!>t. On motion 10 compel discovery or to quash, the person

165 d ex parte shorten time re mpo - d decl

Documents