1" I ...t LA'i"'i1ill'lUl'M1

I .... 1JYIYI 4

4.1 m111\UI1tJ"lle:h'ln1'lth·::dh-t~~Ln~ttmJ

4.2 nTnh::dhi.~~Ln~tftJl!-;J1nm1111h::'Yiuhni1u~u (Environmental Appraisal)

- n111J".i".itl1tl~7a'V-l'l'ltll.U1 (Descriptions)

- n111.h::Liiu (Evaluations)

- ~wn1£Jfi1'V-l (Aesthetics) • f/' VA ,

- tl1'llltll. fi11:1J1~n (Emot1on) 'll

- fiJ13HhflqJ (Meanings)

- fi11:1Jflmth (Concerns) •

4.3 m".ilh::Liiu~~Ln~tftJl!-;J1mfn'lfm::"llEJ\J~llTI-l.'ri (Environmental Assessment)

4.4 f\11l!LL~n~1\11::~i1\ln111h::LflU~\JLL1~ttEJ:IJ-;J1nfiJ1:1Jth::'YilJL-;J~1U~ULL~::-;J1nin'lfm:: .J

"llEJ~"mwn

~1'i~d1R'ru

1. 1um'l1h::L:Uu~~LL1~tra:wfl1".ithit~ii.:~u"'-;J,r£J 4 m.h~ fiEJ ~n'lfm::"lltJ\J~U1::Lii'l-t 'IJ

,-lJ LLlJlJ nT~-111 La-'1-tEJ~~ Ln~ ~EJ:w 1u LLuum,-1\t-;JU£.1 LL~::Ln rn't"i"m".iU'l::Lii'l-t 'IJ 'll

2. m".iu".i::Liiu~~LL1~iEJ:wLLtJnL~Li1'1-t 2 u1::Lfi'Yl fiEJ m,-lJ,-::Liiu~~Ln~tfEJ:W-;J1n .I "''I ' .I A ~ " ... .J .4 .I A :;

fn1l!u'l::'Yl1J L';J a"1U~ULL~::nTlu'l::LlJ'I-ta-~LL 1~~ eJ:IJ-;J1niiln'l!tru::"llv~ a-m 'I-t 'Yl "ll'~n1'lu'l::L:IJU'Yl\J 2

it LL~n~1~n1ni~\il~L u'l-t ~n'l!trn::"lla~~th::Lii'l-t LLiil::u,-:: 1t~"11ufflvifu • 'IJ

PC 266 71

3. m7tb·::Liiui-\ILL1~tftJ:JJ~1nm111tl7::rllJL~&bu~u (Environmental Appraisal)

th::nuui1v m11171mv m1th::Liiu m71ii.~ur.Jt"t11:JJ-\11:JJ tJ17:JJm t111:JJihti"ruLL~::mu.fi1 .. . '

"lltl-\1~-\ILLd~itJ:JJ

4. m7th::Liiui-\ILL1~itJ:JJ~1nfi'nlfm::"lltJ-\I~t11Wrl d]um7th·::Liiufi'nlfm::'Yl1-\l o """ .:. .I 1'1 .J J; IV ~ A .:1 .- .r

mwnv-4 ~1U1ULL~::~nlfm::"lltJ-\I~-\I'Ylm.Hu~mwnuu ~nlfnL::"lltl-\l~mum•nl~n,-,-:JJmn~"ll'!.-1. 'II

LLL'l::Ul"'H.I1n1f'IY11-\Ii-\lt"t:JJ L~rJL"lf TEAs LL~:: OBEA Lih~Lt"l~tJ-\IiitlLUfiT1ti1::LiiU

.r..... tl ...... .r lJYIU:JJ1~t1 7::R-\It"l ~-\1'1.-1. • ... , ......... "1 tl .. ..: " 1. L ~tl L~Ufif'lfilf1L"ll1 ";JLL~::R1:JJ'l7t11Jtlfit111:JJ'VI:JJ1tl"llEl-\ln11 1::L:JJ'U.R-\I LL1~~tl:JJ~1n

m1:JJtl7::ri'u1";JtnU~u LL~::~1nfi'nlfm::"lltl-\l"mutfti 2. L ~a 1 iun~m11 ~1:JJ11t1 t~nm r.~~i'a:JJr.~ni1a ~,..,m,.1.h::Liiu~.., Ln~ia:JJ';J1nm1:JJ

U7::'Yl""'uh~1'U.~ULLfi~::fi'nlfnL::~i

3. L .rf ElL iun~nlf1LU;tllJL fi r.tlJfi11:JJ LL~fi~1-\l"ll El-\ln11th::Liit.~.i-\l LL1~ia:JJ-;J1fit111:JJ 1.h::f1uh~1U~ULL~~::inlfnL::~.,)

... ,......... A A ... """~ tl "'..: ._, 4. L ~El L'VI\l.fif'lfilf1R1:JJ17tl"'l::lJLL~::mrlJ1r.JLt"l1£1-\I:JJEIYI L'lh\l.fiTl 7::L:JJ\l.R-\ILL1~~tJ:JJ';J1fi •

intim::"llEJ-\I~mwrfli

72 PC 266

, .J' I .4 d 0 ... ca,... 0 .._.'I ~ ... ~ 'IUJ'Ylu~:::n ~Tl mm:::u-:ru nTl'YlU fl fl Gl 'Y11fl11117~ nLLGI:::'Y11 fl1111 L 'll1 ~ ~ ~" LL 1 '11 ~a 11 'Y11-:J

~ \1

m F.J1l1"r'4~"r'4u L ~ u lwn11iltl7:::-;h1u u'Yl~LLa1 'lin~11fi.:~m-,fuii.:~ LL 1'1li a 11 ~" Li1un1:::u1um1 'II

..J "' 0 tl .... .... .. .,.,I .... "' ~ ..f ... 'Y1L71Ln1J~1 LL Gl-:1 ~'il7:::1J1J ~11 LL~:::7:::G~nfl113J7LnF.l"ln1J~1l1'r4LL11ilGIEl11 ~'1-tlJ'YlU~::LUU

\1

n7:::1J1Un17~1JflflGIL"15'tum7tl7:::dju~.:JLL11ilatl3J ilii~U~.:JLL1'il~El11 2 n7::U1Un17 fi£1 n17 '

lh:::dh.t~.:JLL11il~El11~1nf11111th::'Ylu'l~~1Uiil'l-t (Environmental appraisal) LL~::m11h::Liiu .: ., Q.,o .J ~.:JLL11i1L'Hl11~1nflnoam:::'lle:J.:J~mu't1 (Environmental avassessments)

4.1 Environmental Appraisal

... - tl .... t . . ... .... ..1 !'I 'VImmH m1117~n 7:::'Ylu ~~1Uii!Uiilfl~1lTrm11ilGIEl11 'VI7El~fl1U'Yl Luum:::u1um7 'IJ

tl ,. ::: L ii u fl m fi 1 ~ .:J LL 11il i El 11 ~ L tX u n 1 ,. Vi 1 f11111 L 'li 1 '1. ';I 1 u i 1U fl fl ~ ~ 1 u Environ mental 1 1

assessments 'VI111F.Jii.:J n17~1~Gin17th:::Liiu'JJEl.:J~i.:~Lnlii'VIfl1F.J ') flU 3Tmi1u~L~F.J1"151nJ'V11a \1 'II ~

~'ti~mu~~"'J mlillil~u~mu~ Luum7Lf171~fi7T;J~.:JLL11ili£J11'hiiflm1l1"r"''VIie:Jhi111nn11 'II '

..1 0 "''l ...... 'Yl';):::'Y11 m111 L ·.o1 ';)fl11117~n'JJ El.:JUflfl Gl 'IJ ~

'luu't1d'';)::nfh1ii.:J m7tl7::Liiu~.:JLL11il~tl3J';)1nf11111th:::'Yluh (Environmental

Appraisal) LLG~::m7tl7:::Liiu~.:JLL11ila£111';)1nanoam:::"llfl.:J~mu~ (Environmental assessments)

tJ,-:::w'Ylc;i1.:J 'J lilflfllii';)Utl .... ';)-;luc;i1.:J 'Jitii~G~c;iem17th:::LiiuL'VIa1d' "Limi flminoam:::~1UUflf1GI ' ' .

L"Iiu "1i1.:J1'u Uf'l~n1l1'r4 -r~un,--,11 '1 LLG~::flmanoam::"li8.:J~.:JLL11ili£J11 L"Iiu f11111'1lu'li~m ' '

7tlLL1JlJ~tntl .... liiF.Jn1711'1 'IJ

1 um1finoa1 L~8.:Jm7tl7:::LiiuR.:JLL 11il~ 811 ~" 81';) 8iu1 u'lii1 u LL" 1fi lilf11111 i11vi'mi

"118.:J Lfl7n (Craik, 1968) ~na1111 m7t.h:::Liiu~.:JLL11ilaB11ifum.inutl .... ';)-;luc;i1.:J 'J i.:Jd 'II

1. inoam:::"l.la-:~~11,-:::Liiu~.:Jiii.:JLLc;ir-l'iifl1111~11117nvhf'loa L"lfu ~m11itn un11.:J~.:J 'IJ 'II

Li:i El.:J ~Yi1.:J1U~1UEli.:J'VI1i11'YlfW rJ'j ~1 iL~ vn:::na11 fl1'n ~~.:Jtl1 u unfim~1 LLGI:::1Jflflfl~1 L11 'II 'II ~ 'II 'II ' '

11 o .4 ,.. :: • , 11 .1 .- ' ..1

2. 1 LLU1Jn17U1L~UEl IJ5.:J11'Yl\ln17U1L~U8~Wl 'JJEl\lu7:::~1Jn17nLiil'l.:J L"15U n17LF.J£.111 'II 'II

"1511n11L~u~hu n17'llu,-mhu 1l1'V'lF.JUflf 11I111'V'I 1l1"r"'L~nlili lmlilfl 'VIi£Ja1';)Lliiim,-'ll

iim ~"a 'l u ,-t] LL u u Llil 'J 'IJ

3. 1tJ LLUU n11ifi ';I Q F.J Ld El"1511 fi17~ 1 L~'UEl ~-:ILL 11il a El11 LLi1 ij fi1771 F.J\11 'Ufl113J 'II

tJ,-:::'Yluh 'luniLLuuc;i1.:J ') L"lfu U7'W1F.J l~i~ua~,-::; liiBULLUU~Tn';J71F.Jn17 tJ,-:::Liiu~h'lu 'II

LL1JU~81Jfl111 tJ7:::LiiUL1GITrt't"15't'Un17"1511 'lfl'l

4. Lnrnonfl1111fi7-:JL'Um7tl,-:::Lii" ii'VIG~1uan"am::: L"lfu. m,-1!ilflmam~m:::L~.:~tl,-U'u ~

PC 266 73

.d ''t ~ I I .Q ..... t ..:=1 I ~ A .r L1HlL 11 El ~ U.~fl1U'Yl~1\l ') ~::WU11L 7T;J::1Jfl1111~~n~ EJ~f11U.'YIL ~1111\l.U.Ln~"lJU. EJ1';J

"JHllJ~~EJ L3J"llau ~mu ~~u. ') 1 um11h:: Liiu.~1l11::LL 1~~ EJ11~1nfl1'111th::'Y\"u h &hu.~ u afn

~111£Jri" m1111h::'Yluh~1U1Jflfl1111u 6 trnlfm:: fiEJ , - m7U77EJ1EJ {description) n17W771UU.1'h~mu~~u.Li]u.mh\1'17 - m11.h::Liiu. (evaluation) 1h::Liiwh~mu.~~uLi]uEJ~1\I't7 ~L~11 1fEJUL~11 - m,-1il.~uEJm111\1111 Gudgments of beauty) 1.h::Liiu-.h~mu.~1fu.~1ti~~EJL3J - m7L~~EllJ'Yl1.:JEl1711rn (emotional reaction) th::Liiw:hLrlaEJ~1u.~mu.~~ULL~1

'IJ

Ln~m111finEJ~1\IL"I 'IJ

- m111i"lfiiy (meanings) ~\ILL1~~EJ11~uiim111i1fltyLoW£J\IL~ A I A II d f::t I ,oi A

- L';J~fl~~El~.:JLL1~~El11'V\7em17L~Uflrn.f11 (attitudes of concern) l..JflflfUJL";J~fl~ , , EJ~1-:JL1~El~.:JLL1~~El1.1,fuLL~::~.:~Ln~~El11~U.iim111~mti~Bm1un,ja" w~u.1 L~ti\IL~

..... 1 •• 1 .. ..r.1 .. .. ' " 't .,1 .. ' • .... .,1 nnnfl1~ (Gnilford, 1975) 15 ~L~U.11fl1111L"ll1 ~"llel.:l~flflf:I'Yl11~El fl1111~1flq)'Yl

.d~.a. X lao# .I A~ .., .I o.;'t' ~fl1U.'YIUU11~El~ULEl.:J "1JUnlJn17u7::L11U~\ILL1~~El11~1nf11111u7::'YllJ ~~1\l.~'!-1.

m111U1;;'Ylu'tnf.:~ 6 u7::L1l'Yld u1-:~~rf\liim111Lflm"liEJ\InuEJ~ L-rlu tl1L71rhtr"~u.1f11 'IJ .. 1 A A .... I ..... • .J .-d. A ~ ~ I A ~

fl1111 ~1 tl-:111.1"1! el-:1 L11 El-:1 ~ L11 El\IWI-1.\1 L 1111 n11 tl-:11'1-1. 11 L 711~n~'Yl El £J'YIL11 El.:IU U. 1~n11 L11 El\1'1-1. U. 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

d]udhJ\I~ii fl1111 i1 iru LL~::f117A1 LLrin17awrn,; 't u. 'Yl1\l ~,."nu."li111 fl1111 u1::'Ylu 1~ 1 u ~ q

trn1Ym::~1-:Jnu. 't3J-4i1LUU~fl\ILUU 'tu1 ufif'I'Yl1\IL~tJ1nU. L -rlu. ~fl1U.~~it\l ') EJT;) iifl1111 i1fl .... ty

i1wfuu1-:~flu. LL~fl1111i1irudLn~~1nu7::~um,-cl~'li1~w1"ntr1 111nni1wEJh L-rlu L"ll1 .. 'V\ trn 'V\:;mr1u J 1 L~ 11 a1~ iif11111 i1 iru i1~fu flU.U1\Ifl u L w11:: ~rud~t~u fl fl 111~fn 'tu't u

01 cu.., ..

L'V\~m,-cl.rlt~wu1iflf\li1fl'ru Lrlmn~tiu.1ii 'tu.i1 w.f'I.254B Li]u~u. ' ~

''il.l.f 11"' "' .1 .. tJ ""'~ ~ tJ ~ El ~uu.~:: ~~ni1111fl\ln11u7::L1.1Ufl1111 1::'Ylu ~" 'Yl\1 6 1::L1l'Yl

4.2.1 n1'i1J'i"UI1ti'Vi~Elfl1'i'W"i'im'l41 (Description)

m1U17tl1 £J~:;EJ'rlnmu1a"1l11::Ln~~El11iimt-m~ a~~m~ J" 't u 7U"ll a.:~ Lfli11\l n111 au 'IJ

A.A I di ........ ....\1 ... .... A 'V\7EIU£J1tl L"JfU n11'ri77UI.U1LnEJ1nlJU1'1-t 1lL"ll1 ~U ~11 'Yl::Lfl L11El.:J 'V\'iflfln ~ LWEILL~~\Ifl1111

'IJ ,

tJ .... ~ ..1... ..1 , .f ,., ., "' ..ol "~ .. ~ ..!\'1.1..1 .. 1::'YllJ ~~'Yl11~El~fl1U'YIL 'V\~1'1-1. LL~m~ El·3n17f'ln'l.t1L 'riEIL "ll1 ~~fl1111fl~L ~U"lJEI\IlJ flfl111'Yl1 ~u'Yl11 ,

~El~\ILL1~~El111wii1~u7::,)11U fl17ii1~n1'lfln1f1~LL~n~1\I';J1n lflfl\1 n111EIU 'V\1Elil£J1£J ~111 LL U 1~~"1! e.J\1 Lmn £i1im7fln1f1 L ~fl\ln171J77Ll1 EJ'VI~El'W77UI. U 1 ~.:I LL1 ~ ~ EU.J 1~ £.1 1-iLL~ fl::lJ flfl ~ , L ;j£.JU1J17EJ1 £J1~ £.1~~7::~\1 L um::~11fL1..JGh indii~H'l~'VI ~1 £.1 mh\1 L "lfu 'Yh 1-i'Yl711Ji1LL~fl::1Jflflfl ,

......... ,, '~~" \'ltJ ,. ....... ..~ ";J::L"lltiUlJ17£J1[Jrl.:Jfln1ftu.:: L~mlU lJ77r.J1tJEJ:: L71J1\I fl::LfltiEJ:: L71J1\I LLfl!:B:: L7flEla-17!:~1flq)'Yl

-;,::~~-;nnm7'rl77ntU1"llfl\I~L;itJu ~111~ LL~ii"lia~.:J£J1n'V1~1m.h::m7 L"lfu U1\lfluntr1n7::~11f ~ ~

74 PC 266

Llhh L:lirrnu,-,::L-iit.JUU1'1'[.11£JEJ:::h U1\IE!th\ILUU~\I~flru LL~~U1'1'[.11FJEl1';1L:li~uh 3JB\Ii13J .. 'II

hl m1'U1'1'£J1FJ';J1nuflfl~~1\lnurh 1ir.nn~am7li.1mL111t.Jm fit.Junu ~1 mw;1~~~1\l 'J • • · .r • 1 ... .... .. .. ...... 1 ... ... ... ... 1. n

L~Gl1U 'Yl1 'VIUfl';JCI11'Ylt.J1~~1£JfiUYW1EJ1!1~111rn17 UflTlV'l~U1Lfi'I1'El\13Jtl'Yl';l::: "1f Ufl11

u1'1tntJ~1ElV'l11mu1i\ILn'll~Bllmim'll,.~1u J1mLr\m,-1'11LL~::Lu1EJuLfit.Ju ... .. \'1 ... ... ... .. ... 'l""

Lfi~L!Ifl1 {Kasmer, 1970) ~<i!V'lt.J1t.J1!1~11\1Lfi1'El\1!1El3J1'111!1U LV'leJ "lfLUn11'V'l1'1'ntU1

..: ... ..1 ."1 ..1 ..: 'l ... ' ... .. ... ..1 ... ~\I LLd'il~ eJ!I'YlLIJ UEl1fl11 ~rnu 'Yl L 1'3-1';11 n 'VIU flfi'l~n~!I'V\U\1 L "ll tiUlJ11£J1 FJ'VI El\I'Yl'ilU"lft:llJ 2 'VI t:l\1 • • LL~::iu\I~L:li"lfau 2 ifl-:~ L'llt1D~1':: ';l1flfl11.l11t.J1t.JL'VIlhULL~:::';l1nLEln~11~1\l ') L"ll1L~~;,_, fl1flnt~V'lrl~'il1\li111~U111 500 fl1 LL~:::U13Jlfl'ilL~Eln L~£Jfl1111.lflfl~~1-:l ') i1fl1flntfi"V'll'ffiL~

• 'II • • 'II

L 'V\3-11::~11 rf';l::U13Jl 1 ilJ1'1'£J1 EJ in~m:::"ll El-:1 nnu"'Cil tln1'1'11~1LU 'VI1El~\ILL 1~~ f) 1lfiihln~m::: Luvn:::<il1 ';lUn1::..f-:~'lurf~'llL~fi1flm~V'lrl~'il1'\li1113J1 66 ~ ~1Ufl1fiUI.flV'llfdfl11tn!l'luii~

• • 'II 'II •

1~U1\I,fU ii'V1~1t.JLLU1f1'11 un~~1'Yl£J11.l1\lt1UlJElni1 3 ii~ fiBii~~1UflnEJ111V'l (potency) n11'

u1:::Liiu (evaluation) LL~::n';ln1'1!1 {activity) iiL~t.J-:JV'leJ LL~un~'ll1'YltJ1'VI~1tlflUYW1tJ1!1~m~1

i1m1iifl1flnt~V'lrlmnni1 3 m1 Lv1BlJ11tJ1tJ~1111:::LL1'il~El!ILimEl1.lfl~3J L'riu LLfi~LL~::Lni'"lf • • LlJElfLnBf {Cass & Hershberger, 1973) L~3Jtli1fi11'U1'::Liiu'VIiEl'l~u·nmtJB~1\Itl:EltJ 10

1 .......... .t 3J umm ~-:~u

1. m1u1::Liiurt1lu

2. 117:::Liiutl71'nu,-::1EJ"ln!

3. 1h::LiiUt11111Gf1tl\11!1

4. n';ln1'11l ..f ..1,

5. WU'Y111\I

6. timm1V'l

7. fi113JLUU1::LuEJu

8. nTl-;l~nTltl ~1\1 Lilu 1::uu

9. tlnt~flii • 'II

.. <il-L~1

iiu1:: 1FJ"lf1!-'1.iu,.:: 1EJ"lf1!

~Lt'IH-~13Jru "

' ' ... ... fi~El" LLflfl1-L 1El mum.J

L~nflue:iu-n11\l 'l 'VI oJ . .. 'YlU'Yl1U-lJEllJlJ1\I

~::: e11 ~-~nu1n

LU u 'l::lJl.l-~\1 L ~ V\1 •

' .. ~11\1-!l<il

LW~'ilL V'l~U-i1fl1qj

Liluii'll-s-Li] uu1Jn1f

' , ' ... U1~UL';l-U1LlJEl

""' '&.' ;&l:lf; I

'D'U 'If El u-L ·wu \11 t.J

~1U<il1-~1r11m::

LUU 7::Lii FJlJ-~-:IL ~ti-:~ • Lilun';lanHm:::-~1LHl"

iflU-'VIU11

i1-lJ1

1111ili,fu'Yl~r.lfliiEJ1';1th:::nEJui1t.Jfi1tlmfl'wn: Ln1-1'VI3.i LLW\1-nn 1.~ni-L~n II ~ II ,_. cu

~u.L~u-Gf\lu -ililL';lu- tl~mfliB iiii11ilii11 -rh'liGf\llJ uG~Biilrlt.J- eiulil11t.J L~£.Ju~\lu - ~nfin •

PC 266 75

tllJ tl11-EI1n1flth £.IL rl •n-1 "1 rJ'I111i ~13J17t1Wl"li El EJ~l'ii11 Lott11TllJ77EJ1EJ,_,7EJVl71UUn ~1111:: 1

~n~~EJmfu. '111hrlii~ Lilu.L~EJ-1~1Xn~~imn~EJ'I1~n~1~EJLU 4.2.2 017U7::t3l,.. (Evaluation)

Lrl Elt1 13Jii'l1fi113JU1::rllJ hJ~ij~ El ~\ILL 1 ~tf El3J tiEl EJfl.f\lfilJflfl L'l3J .... nmh1ii-1fi113J'lfEllJ 1

"' 'II ' ..1 ..!: • I "' 1 "' .-AI .... .t " "' ,_,.,tl ~3J'lfEllJ~tnU.rlUU. nTlu1::L3JU. (Evaluation) ~::,.,3J1EJ113J3J U.rlt'IU.BU') ~'11U.~1EJ flflflnt q

-113Jfi113J~ flnt111Vl fi113J'lfBU LL~::thiu t;'i1LL,.,U\I "1L'l"1 'lu.nT'ii~;u.,.,7atl,-::L£iu.flrn\113J q q

"" .. ..1 , ..!: ."1 AI .,.. , .- ..1, '!"! m13J~ ,., 1EJ fJ ru111Vl"ll B\1 ~mwn~1\l 'JU.U. LuUL 'lEl\1"11 B\lfi113..1J~n111 EJ ~ u L n rn't'lrJ ~"6 ~ u.m1

LtliEJ1.JLfiEJU3J1~11lLL,.,~\1~1\I ')rlU. EJ1nLLfi111'lU1~t11U.~ 2 LL'Vi\13J1LUiEJ1.JLfiEJ1.JrlU. LL~n1'l i~ ~u.L1El\l"ll B\lfi113J"l1El1.J LLL'l::m·r;l~~1~ut;'i1 LL,., u,., LUU. m7LU7FJuL fi EJU~L ~ u. li-i~ L-;JU. 'l u.m7

_fir, ~ ,J 4 I ... I Ao ~ 1,.1

u\Hl t1Yl3J IIHt lA e:J 017u7::: L3J,..i."'\l U 'UI iiHUJ :

1. flrlWVlL'l~1U1.JflfiL'l : n17U7::L£iU.~\ILL1~ati3J,f._,rl1\llJ1nLLL'l::rl1\IL'l1.J,fU -lfumlnu q 'lJ

11 £i,., i'l1"1l El-\lU" fl L'l LL~:: Lit11u.~fu. iinTl~fl~1tl .... ~i'EJ "1 U.Ufl fl~~51~rJnVl L'l~ an11tl ,-:: Liiu. 'lJ q 1

~\ILL1~ifEl3J 1~£J'li~fiLflu.n~3Ji1Elrl1\I~LiL~~"llEl\Jf;j 2 fv lu.m3J1n1 -;J1nfu.'loitl,-::L£iu. v • \1 .. "'

fi113J'lftJufi ~u.ii~ tJfnf\1 2 Y-l u11 f1113J'lftl1J"ll B\IU flfl ~Li1m1mhu.1 £.1l~~1n11 £i,., i-\l"ll fl\1 L "111 ... • 'IJ

I "" I ..... .... A -.,.. ¥' 0,.0 ..J I I I ...

L 'lfU. tl1 £J L Y-lfl LLL'l::1~U.1i'l13J L 'lfU. f1U.EJ1EJU.tJEJ3Jn'lftJUrl1rlt'IU."llEJ\17vrl~U.ElEJmnn11~1-\l7v " • "' 'U .&$:

~ A.... ~ I ~~~. .. A A.... I .... A .... ~AI 3J n111~ £.1,., L'l1 EJ'lfU. Y-lU~ L'l LL~n ~1\lllU.fl El 1.J1'11 n171';1 EJY-l1.J11 flll.L 'l13Jll'lfEIU113Jrl flU. rl

'lJ

flU.Lfl E1 3J1nn-h LL~n11ii £.1 Bn,_, L'l1 t~i'u. Y-l tl"h fiU.L 71ai'n'lfEI1.J1l £i rl t'IU ~LliflULfl E1 3..11 nn11 q 'lJ q

~ ""' I .J.a A

(Canter and Thorne I 1972 LLL'l:: Nasar I 1984) Utln~1nu.u.EJ\IY-lU11 fiU.rl3JlJfl~n111Y-l • ~1\1 n U.';l ::'lftJU ~'11 LL 1~ a El3J ~1-1 nu.'i11 E1 Li1UL~l111 £j,., i-1 ~1\ltlU fi113J "11fl1.J l u. ~\ILL 1 ~a fl3J-;J::

q 'lJ

I .... f.... .... -1 .. ., .c::l I I I

fl flU."ll1\ILLu.'lf~fiU.L 113Jll'lfEl1.JLitl1U. rl ')3J t'lll~lli::n1EJ111Vl L 1EJ1.J\11 EJ3J111011 L 'll"U. fiU.-;J::

'lftJui EJ'I1~ii,.,1l'1~1-13J1nn-:hi a'l1m1iiiwll'1~h.,'lftJu i fl'11~ii'ltli1'11~L,., ~FJ 3Jmnn11 Li13J L,., ~ EJ3J 'lJ

"ll'tllJ i fl\1 rt ii L Vl ~~ u. Li-1 111 n n-;11 i EJ -1 t1 n ~ Nasar ( 1983) Y-l u 11 ~ tl £l fl1 tlEJ'lf flU tl1 fl17rt ii 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ

76 PC 266

LYi£hHJ£h\IL~£Jd L"JiU dJUEJ1fiT,~ElcieJ1tl£l Li1u~U 'II

Q..oo ,;. li ~- I -' l \J li ,4 "'

Gln~rn::"ll e:J\1 "" LL 1til ~ e:JllYill ~ ~~ Elfi113J~e:Ju ua m:nnYJn ~11"1.11\1 ~ u fl eJ fi113J G(EJ ~fl Gl e:J\1

(Congruity) 'VIimLtiln~1\lnu (Contrast} 11~1Gl~ (Wohlwill, 1987) l~LLG{tii\Jf11l'f;i1GlEJ\I"llEJ\Iflii 'II

rlf'l'l1"lla \1 EJ1fl1"rtf\l 1 uin~m::"lle:J\If11WLL~::LLUU-;i1~ EJ\1 (model) wu-:i1 ~ i\ILn~';l::hl~EJUflii 'II 'II

ri'f'l'l1 ~~ "" Ln ~ri au 'VI u1d~ti~ i{u 11 iiin~m::~1" 'J hl G{EJtilfl~a"nu'VIie:Jii m111 LLtil n~1"n" L "111 'II

't~~n~1~ e1 'tu11fi113J '1.aJ G{EJtilfi~EJ\I'VIit~fi113J LL~n~1\11::~u111n-tl'EJ m Yir.J\1 lti~rfrh 1 iflu~EJu mnn-:i1nu wu11U1\Imi:JJ~au m111 LL~n~1\l 1 u 1::<ilu n ~1\lmn n-:i1~n Gl3Jn ~unu LL~U1\In~3J • • nhJ"ll'EJU LL~::'W1Jl1~ i\1 Ln~~n LaJ~EJU ;\ILL 1til~ EJ3J~£iimfm::LLtiln~1\I'VIiEJLaJ G(EJtilfl~ EJ\InUEJ ci1\l

'II '

mn ii Gl LGl Erf ( Miller) Lti~1 ~~ i\1 Ln~,X\ILim 'W a~ltJ,-au ')"11'1 £J ~":, British Columbia LLGl::tn3J 1\J I I

fi113J"ll'ElU~£i~ Elfl iirlf'IU~1 r.J~':,fl L ~'1.1. wui1~i\l L ntil';l::~tl1J~1 rJ J:,~£iLL~"11'1 £1~':, m.h\1 L~ £11 "1i' El 'II 'II

li ~ Q.ol A -A 1 A ... rdd ..... ... fLoo I a,.. ! flU 'WlJ'!.l.G('!.l.lJ &{'1.1. ULL U 1fltilfl11fl'!.l.L 71"ll'El1Jf13JYif'IU YI:IJ fi113JSJ51JSJfeJU7::ti~UnGl1\13J1 nm17::tii1Jti11

• 'II

uEJn';l1mf UrJ\IW1Jl1 fi113JG(e:J~fl ~EJ\1 (Congruity) Li1uii~wd\l 1 um7U7:: Liium13J"ll'EJU

... ... "" <il\luu EJ1';1 &{7UL~11rl\lfl min ~m::"ll EJ\IU fl fl~ LL~::fl min ~m::"ll e:J\1 G{tl1U t1 Gf1uii .. ~ .. . A A J 1.44 -:1 ,::( 1 ...

EJYilf'W ~til Elfi113J1G{n"ll'EJ1JYI1Jflfl ~3Jtil El G{f111::LL 1til ~ El:IJ 'II •

(Cognitive process) ~\liiluYJnfiU • ... A I ~d I .J I J; d

LLfi'W~U (Kaplans, 1982) L"11'El11 fi113J"ll'El1.J"lJEJ..1~flfi~'Yl3J~EJHtnUYim\l ') '1.1.'1.1. 3J

rhL Uti13J1';11n11il!U 1nT'~"ll el\1~1~viuil UEJ~ti~LL~::-;nnm1ufu~1~ EJG(f11'VHL1til~ El:IJ L -nut Un17 • 1i£J'VIii\lwU11 L~n ')"ll'EJU'Yi\I'VItU1 "::1'uu1 ('Yi\I'VI W1"l.IU1 till 'VI nlmll UL"llti~iau) 111nn'l1fl iiri'f'lu

• w , ., ., ~ \1

.... A .... ... .A .d • .... .d.A .., I " ....

~n ~m:: EJU El1~ G(EJ tilfl ~ EJ\In 1J fi113J L "ll'EJYI11"11'11tii::1Utiln3J119.1JU 1n173J1~'1nYI\I'VI lli1 H::1U '1.1. 1 . .. 1 "':..1"' .ol ' r d ..f • 1 ., "" • I ~ "" "" Utln1n1 L"ll1L~EJ113JWif£JL 71';l::'lfEJ1JG(tnUYI ') LEJEJ EJ1'!.1.1r.l 'VIL111J77~1tilflu7::&{\lfl mn11£l\l"ll''W • • • l~ L "liu Hmu ttu~ Btilnr.J H13J17fl'V11EJ1'V111L~LL~:: Li1u rfvrnYi" li ~" G(EJtilfl~ t~\lnu tm 1fitil"llEJ\I

nu iud'l rnnu affordance UeJm:nm.f U LLfi'W iUrJ\1 L ~Ell13JWlfU£ifi113JU'l1'lflU1 El ci1..1 LL 'l\ln~1 • .d ... ""~"" .., t.. ~ ... ~ Yl';l ::w £11 r.I13J'V\1 fi113J'V\3J 1 £1';)1 n Hf111:: LL1 til Gl EJ3J L 'VI U Ltil-;)1 nnTl&{11'1 LL~:: "ll'LL~ '1.1. Yl nT'nfl til

'II

. . ..: ... "" "'" .r "" ., 'l (cogmt1ve maps) fi1111'VI111 t.J"ll EJ'IH\1 LL1!111.'Hl3Jfl3J'!.l.tttl~ a\ln11U EJ1';1 L 'W Elfi113J!II tl-\ln11~ u • U;';IUU 'VIi Ell UEJU1flti~ril~ L "1.11 L~ Hi1\l~\lfi113J~ElUifu <i'ld •

PC 266 77

iiR113J'M3J1tl

Coherence

Legibility

. "' .... fl113J Lnti1'W"

Complexity

Mystery

- Coherence (l'i1 'l ~L n~fl113J\Ul1 tiL 'U.rlUYh1'U. L~) 'V\3..11 trii·:Jn1"rrt'Yi"~it£J1l1~~\l.~1£.1 LLfin11'';1 .... ~1'::UU'Yl1-\ln1''~"'ffi~ ~1tJLLfin11'i~tJi:::L1l'Yl -i~L';l\1.

'II

.g~""' ..I ... , ......... , "" ..1 ...~~ Complexity (111 ~'VI L n~nTnn £.11~\l. ~ U'Yl'U.'Yl'Yl\1. ~~) 'V\3..11 £Jrl.:t n11''Yl ~r11U'Yl'U.U

~m,-r~l'i1L iflu~1 ~::1u'VI1e:dua rlnui.:~ Ln~nfa11~'" L 'W1'1::~"lia3J~ 1 ~ tm hmn ~ 'II 'II

' .. 'l "" ..1..1 0 \'1 " - Legibility (fl1~1T;J::3Jfl"'J13J'VI3J~Itl UEJ'U.1fl<il) 'V\3J1t.Jri.:J ~rl1\l.'Yl'Yl~13J11'rl~1"l11il ~~

l~vhi'VIfl-\1 LW1'1::iim,-,J~11.:t'f1-i~L';J\l. ~~1£.l 'II

6'' ..1 &• ... 1 "" ..I ..I 0 1" -Mystery (m~m1'nt11';1::Lmnwwil1tl 'U.El'U.1fl<il) 'V13J1£Jrl.:t ~ri1WYl'Yl'Y11 'VIUflflL'I ~

~,m,.m7vwrl~mn'if'" rl'1Uflfla~unim~·ufnui.:~Ln~aa3Jmn'if'" 'VI~El~13J11'rlmauma.:J 'II ~ ;,)

t~'tu1um~~a~u ... 1 ~ !'I ... 1 ..1 ... ... A

a.:t~Jl.Ji::nmm.:J 4 Lu'U.El.:Jflui::nau Lmnnufl113J'7Hl1J ~1l1WLL"'l<iiL'Ifl3J<i113J LL'" 1 fl~"ll El-\1

ca..o lt_,o, A A ~tJ ~ '-'...,A LLfl~fl\1. ~'ll'fl111 Cognitive affordance L'Wilfl1iU1!.1£l.:Jfl 'l::ntlU'Yl-:1 4 "111-:J~'U. '15-\1

,J ~ ..... '-'A ... .. 'IJ A I ... ....A I; L mn"ll a.:~ nun 1::u1'U. n11'1'fl<il LLL'I::"ll a 3Jfl';J'1n ".:~ LL 1<iiL'I EJ3J L "111 L ".!Hn1 m fl nu~11 u ~"ll El.:t 'Yl.:t 4

'II 'II ~

EJ.:J~tJ,-::nau~.:~'if'" fl113J'li'EJU'f1ii~ a"n1'U.'f1~'" ')lii::L ~11-ff'" LL~ii"limhn~mh1~a ti1 Legibiliy 'II

~-\13J1nLnu ttl Mystery n-;J::UmHH ti'U.~arl~itt.J111~ ~fi113J-i<il L';J'U.3J1n l3.ll'i1L i'VI L'l-:1 'II

"llnt:: L~ £J1n'U.i.:t L 'VI ~1d l'i1l ~li"~itvn1w~'" ~1itb ~'" 1lil LYh~ fl11''VI7a Li1um,-mn~-;J::l'i1L i

78 PC 266

.d"' d " Q..l 0,...-;11 ~~,d. IV~ ~mt.~.'Y1U\.b ') 3J Coherence LLL'l:: Complexity ~ Wl::Y~u~~ LVrn::mmtJ1l1'Vi ~'i13Jf1113J'l5'1.J'1Hlt.~.

.. ' ... ~L'l1m'IL'l1tJ3J1nnmnLLnnT"I';JYI1'::uu

'I .. "" .J.... .J, J1 ... .., .... ~ \.b n11't'lfl 'l!t1 L 'lEI~ fl113J"lHl '1.J 'Y13J 'il e:J ~{11 WYI 'il1 ~ ') \.b '1.1. tLfl 'Vi~ \.b ~Yl L \I. \.b '1.J 'Y1 U1 'YI"ll e:J ~

.l .. ..II 'I ..,.J ~ ... • ... ' 'I f1113Jfl'I-!.Lfltl<il e:J~tn\1. 'YIY11tl L 'Vi1'1!:n11''Vi tl1 tl13J n1 ~ "'I'YIU\.b ') 3Jfl113J~ 3J1 tl ~1"111''1.J L 1'13J1nL 'Yl1 L'il . ... L":nn';l::f\uLfltJnu~Jumnifu LLiilti1fit.~.LfltJ3J1n ')e:J1-;) l1lmnm"li11tl1 u~Cl1U~"u L "liu L1ie:J t11n

• • .., .l ... .. "' "' .l ... ... .. Vl.l ~tJ L 'YI tl11'il"ll1.:1'1.J1\.b "111'e:JlJ1.:1~tl1U'YIL 1'1 e:J1';1-;):; tl.:I'Vi tl1 £J11.1~1fi113J"'I111 mL~:::tJ.:t El tl1nL"ll1 ~u

L~t11vfw~i1tl L"li\l. LfltJL1.JL ~tlTWfilitlW.'tfi'YitJ1fi1~Yif ~1WlUL~f1~~1 tlfli,LLtr1 LL<il ~.:le:Jtl1n1tJ an d1\l.c;iu

~A G.oo .. ,ct tf 4.2.3 f1171~\JQU~113J"13J\Ii7il~\U'17Uil1YCA1~fl"i (Aesthetlce} • LL~i1 L~El.:l"ll El·:ln11'iir;)Utlfl111.1 ~1tl~13JLi1UU1111i1'1'3J ifuEl tinUfl113Ji~n ~1Elfi113J

'I 'I

LL'i!n<il1.:t1':::~-h.:~uflflel LL9htn~'ili'YI mc;ie:J.:~m,.~n'l!t1i11 \l.f1113JL ~"~LL'iln<il1.:~n"U i1~ inm,. • 1Y~ffi iV1';111'W.1 L"" ii e:J\l.n\.bU1.:1 L 'Vi1'1:::fl \4~1\l. 1 ~nl1.J'l:::LiiU.L "'lii el\.bn\1. i11'1t'littlll1'Vi"ll e:J.:tllm:::~.:t

u ~

~1 tJni1'YlflittJ1l1'Vi"ll a.:tn El.:t"ll tJ:::~ ei em wn Li1u9iu i1iitJ'V'lui1m,.i\t';J,rtJfl113J~1 tJ.:t13J"ll El.:t • ~.o~ .r=~A • .... ~. 'I ~"' -='.., t .a

'Ylfl\l.tl111'Vi 3J L 1' e:J.:I"ll El-:11'::: tJ:::'Yl1.:1"111'Elf111'';1 Yl11.:1 ~.:IYI1'1 ') L \.b111'Vi\.b \.bL "ll1111 m tl1"ll D.:! Yl tlt'lfl'l!t1

';11n'Ylt'littJn1'Vi~fltr1 tJ "n" 6 n1'Vi LLiilL'l:::n1w';l:::i1am~w.:::"tr1 tJau11.1~ru111.:1 e:Jti1 "~1u""1t1 ) .. '1.1

"lle:J.:t1l1'Vi i1L ii.UL"ll1"ll\l.1YIL~nElti'il'l.:lf1~1.:1 LLL'l::LLU1i\l.L"ll1"lJU1YI1 "'lrufl tii1u~a.:t 1Y~ mh tJ1'tl1 \l. -u .., ,. 'U

,-::: tl:::~h .:1 ') nu LLtr11 ~ n ~ 3J ~1 tl ti1.:t V1';)11'W. 1 iY~ RUfl111.1 ~1 tl.:111l"ll fl.:lrlf1Utlll1 'Vi L ~ iihd' , ~ &lf111'iitJ'Vi1Ji1 fl111.1 a1 tl'I13JLL1.J1'~Wii13J1'::: r.J::Vh.:t"ll El'l u.:tfi'1.J,-::n ElU 1 U1l1'Vi LL~L11Lc;iLL1.J,-~\l.

1 CV ._, A .c:..-. """ 1 l: • IV ~ .... 11:11 1 d_" '" t.1 A, U&lfl'J:+lli::: L ~Wil1''1 ';l:::3Jf111'1U';l~tl111l1'ViU \4~1 r.JL3J e:J ~UL "ll1'il1U~ ~.:1111':::r.J::~1.:1'YI ~3J Lfl~"'I1'El

Ln ~ L nu l1.J Uelf1';)1fl,fU£1.:~.ffwu tinm.J7m W."ll El.:l El.:t~1.J'l::n flU lil1.:t ') 1 U1l1'Vi LLa:::m1'iYI11'1 'I

u.:tff1.J,-:::n fiU"ll fl.:tll1'Vi L "liu 'Viui1rl'1iim'li'il11.:t~wrf~L ii tJ1 l l'il1'.:tn ~1\1 ';l:::iim1fuii1a1 r.J '1.1

' ..,.., "" 3J1f1f11111.:t n m ~YiflU (Gifford, 1987)

Luufhnt (Berlyne, 1960) 19i'Yi1m,.~n'l!t1LL~:::,-:::ui1 i1flma1lu1hvlum1'Lnr.JUL~tl\l . , 4 in'I:+W.:::"llu\li.:t LL1Y!Lfu1.1 ~L 1'1U13J1LUi'tlUL fitJU'l::"'li1.:t~1l11::LL1Yttru11 1 Ufl~'ilnlJtl';J';IU\l. ~ El ,

1.fi113J"'IL'l1f1'VIfl1tl (Complexity) ~mrJii.:ttl~mm"lleJ\Ifl.:t~tl,-:::nuulil1.:t ') 1 u

~fl11::LL 1Yttr El3J

2. fl11mLtl&ln 1'VI1i (novelty) fl1';) Li1ui.:~ Li1~L 11 L11LfltJi.:tLn'i!L ~umriau 3. fl113J l11 ~flY~fli eJ.:tnu (incongruity) 'V\1.11 £Jii.:t~.:tL i1\u~n1w LL'l'iltr B1lif'i!L 'VIii flU

~

luc;l··wnu 111 L "li1n\l.'V17eJ l1ifli tl.:t';ltl.:tnu

4.fl113J'!-l1u'l:::~L'l1'il h (Surprisingness) ~3J1tJn.:t ~1l11::Ln'iltrn3Ji1i.:~Li1rh,-, llilc;im Y~~ 1.:ti1';l:::iitl11 nLJ tl ~

PC 266 79

Luerflrnl' mh1·h th ~.., LL 1'i1~ till Lliliimlurn~m::rf.., 4 1h::nT-x"li1.J~\~t~til,., , 'U

"X::'i1 ... un ~1..1 -.J Uflfl~"iJ::1U"iJur.rhnf'!itEJn1w,f u1.n £1..1111 "llm::~ t 1~1 ~Gf l:U L iu~1 mru u,., 1fifild' , l!i~ttl1L'I:huf mhTJ1LUm71ii."iJUr.tf11111~1£J..1111J~ ii~il1Ufl1111~~1n~~1r.t (Complexity} ii

m11nf'm•rt.urLi.JLiutff...., ~EJ fl17iim111~~1n~~1£JLw-x::lil"'un~1-' -.J LL<iiii~~1Ufi1111LL1l~nh11

(novelty) LL~::fl111lt.bl..h::~L'I1'i1 1u (Surprising ness) "iJ::iim11li1l~UtrLi.JLiU'i17..1 ~t1fl..1iiii~

J.., 2 ~1uU111n fl..:~~1r.t L-riuL~£11n1Jfi1111L1i~EJlilfi~El..:Jnu (incongruity) fl..:~ii~n111L:U ~Ellilfl~a..:~uEJ mrh Llilfl..:J~1r.t

Lu e:Jft~~ w m m11 t~!1J1r.tm111 im·r~lh::~11..:Jflm~111J1i L fir.JU Lfi £J..:Jn1Jwt']~m,-1lm7

Gfl1"1"il fffl11:: LL 1 ~a El11 L "111 LL£1 nw t'] ~ n7711 n17GfT'n';l LU~ m"Xa-171';) LL1J 1J LU W1:: L ';)1 ::"iJ..:J LLL'I::LL1J1J

t . ..:.rd ..... \1•• ~snn~ ~1 £1 lil £1n17~171"iJLLlJULU W1::L "iJ1::"iJ.J"iJ::L W11"1JUL11 El~fl11::LL 1lil ~El111lfl'1111 LllLL U,U,EJ~

.r \!•' ....... .,.. • ' ..d ff\l"lJU, L W71::fl'1111 L11LL U~tlU"iJ::n7::'i1U ~7m·n L ~1JflfiL'I~17'1';l El£11..1 L"iJ1::"iJ..:J L WEl~1~1L ~ lil"lJEl..:J 'U , • ,

... .. .. 'I ... t .. ..d \1 ' •'I nTH 71 fiUL 71';1 ::2Jfi1111W\I W tl L ';) ~[}1'1:: LL1lil ~ El11 U 7::'i1ULN ~lil L11 El fi112J L11Utl'U.EI £1 L U,

'U , 'U

"X:::iunL'!1..1 'J LLL'I::n11"Gtl71"iJLLlJU~L'I1n~ L'l1 mnli1ifUL~Elf11111L1iLLU u,au,mjL U7::iu~1 mh1fiEl 'U

rl'1fl m;n~m::: L l4 am "XL fi £11J Lfl £J..1"1J EJ..:J ;., LL '1'i1~ EJ11 a cit~ 1::~1J ~1 L 71"iJ::lifum7n7::~u, 1::iu~1 • 'U ,

f~mrla~u1 r.t ~1LilJflfiL'IW r.t1£113JflU~1~;tltf171"iJ~1111::LL1lii~EI11L ~aL~117::ilJn11"Lf1L ~ 'U ,

.r 111fi"1JU

L Un17~n~1L~tl.Jf11111 ~1£1..1111"1J tl.Jeffl1'1::LL '1lil~ tl3J,fu, un~lili'l'l £11WlJi1m71it"ilU£J

fi113J ~1 £1\1111"1J tJ.Jfliiflf'I~LUUn171J"HU1nTl u""iJ,)£1'1'l1..1;f11'1'l £11 -f~Uli7711 LLL'I::t.J""iJ,}£ltf1U 'U 'U

1 " .I .- .J ""' " "' "' lJflfiL'I Ulii1Uu7::~1Jn17tlUfir.t1filJf11111..1111L"1J'lfil'1£1fiU •

80 PC 266

A .. d mm,-,.11 rn'lL 1-rJ u. 'Yl 1

~.., L~11'h twria-.111\IL-i ~11u,.or 'II

1. Environmental Appraisal ~mtJn-.1 .................................................................... .

2. 1u.rn,.t.h::Lilu.i.:JLn~tfa11 m,-fhii.._,fi..,J~i'tJ 4 mh.:J i.:Jd

2.1 ........................................................................................... .

2.2 .......................................................................................... .

2.3 .......................................................................................... .

2.4 .......................................................................................... . Q.<f CLool ~.-:fA A 1 A • t.l AI ..... ..... "1: ... I

3. tJ~~ ti'Yl11El'YltrYHI~ ElnTnh::L11U.tf..1LL1il~ El1111 ......... U-;J~ tJ ~~ LLn .......................... .

tJ A ,J" 1 ~ "" CL.; .:11

4. f111 'l::L11U.fl1111"lftl1J'Yl111iltl&f..1LL1~~El11"1Jtl..1 LLfi~~U.3.1 ....................................... .

EJ\1 fftJ,-::n au ti EJ ..................................................................................... . AA ..... A ._, A !'VI ft .cl

5. f1111Wv'il.tlfl1111~1ti\1111"1Jel\1~..1LL1~'&Hl111il111LL'\.l.1fl~"lJEJ\I LlJEJ'l ~~U. 11 .............. .

EJ..1tftl,-:::nElu tiEJ .................................................................................................... .

4.2.4. e:J1"n.nl1-A11aJ~n (Emotions)

1~tJtJn~ ~mu.ffffuflfl~t.h::LiJU 11~ LL~::&f'"l t1..11112fn~1t iiin~EJ h LL~1J1\Iflf..1f111 , 'II

tl1:: Lilu.mu111~ n111it\1Utlfi1111\113J LL~::fl1111fin'Yl1..1 u1 n-;J::mu L fl t~1nu. LL~'1111 "li~\1 , 'II

.c=f. Q..- .... .r L~tJ1nU. L ~11::L ~lil~\1'\.l.

q

fl1111~ EJL";J~7Elfi113J L ~ ~~ L ~ ~U.LU U.fl1111i~n~1a tl1111 mL~ tJ'"Jft ;11-vru. fnun11 'II

tJ A .... 1 ._, .-..1 1 tJ A ._,

'l::L11U.fl1111 ~1 tl\1111 LL~::tl1111 tll.1111 U. 'Ylf'!U. 'Yllil1..1";11nf11,- 'l::L11U. LL~::fl1111 ~1 tl\1111 ~mitll.::

"lltl\1 tl1111 m~1U.Lf11:: ~fJ~n1111 LL~::n11ifi~ LL<iln~1\l eJ ci1-:tL ~U. L~'lflilrllJ &rn'Jjtll.::ff-:t 3 if 'II

..d CLool .... I ~ cv A A A .... .. LntJ1nUfl1111tf1r.J..1111 ~..1L"lfU. fi~L~tl"i (Kuller, 1980) u.n-;J<i11'Yltl1tf-:tLL1~~a11"lf11a1LiiiU

'II

aiu1 tlrJ1 el11\J mLUU.1l11::~'Jlu"Jl'EJU"lJ tl-.111'\.l.'Jjrf ~ 111 tl"i111n..1fl1111iin L "Jiu. fl1111 LFrf1 fl1111 q 'II

mr1 fl1111\i1Ln'l..1"1J111 fi1111L~tl~~1~ fl1111U"i::~~1~\, fi113.1Liimnu. nTntl~tiU.LLU~\I'Yl1..1 ~~,-::~1El'Yl1-:ti1..1f11 E.J LL~::LL'l..1~iniu.L UnT'HLtilil\l~fJ~n"i111~1..1 ')

L"ll1 i-.1 Lnlil11i..1LL1~~El11ff11wticl"riatii1..1;fu. (built environment) '111'1~-rh 'l iuflfl~ , q

Ln~m,11mfi113J~n L"liu. L~fllil~1~ ~7ail~fiu.~ ff,-u.LL,...,~;mnlila1,.11mnwrh1u.'llil LL~-;)::~1 'II q

L'iLnl1l~HHL1J1J~Eltl ')~::tf11LLfl::fl\ltl £iu.1u. i..1LL111l~El11ii~~Lhtlru~m'l1L u,,-::ti::EJ11L111 E.l~fiUL 11 'II v

3Jn La.lnu.i-:JLnlil L ~"i1::L3JL ~U.fl1111LU~ E.JU.LLU ~..1 L U.LL~~::-fu.

PC 266 81

Ail A A ~ A ..J L~ IS" ...._. .J,ICII 1 .Q t,l A

:IJLLU'dfl~ 2 LLU1fl~'Yltlli1J1£Jbn£l1n'I.Je.JTUJnl. fl111J'S'tfnmJ~e.Jtf\ILL1~fHI11 LLU'dfl'IILL'S'n \1

LUW'llel\1 1'1£'11~~ (Wohlwill, 1966) Gi'1UBnLLU'1fl'II'Wd\ILUW'llel\l el'iuflf'll LaJ'S'1LU£JULLL'I::L~aJLf ftfL'll£'1 (Albert Mehrabian and James Russell, 1974,1975)

A t A t( U~1fl~t10\l 'Jft'lftft

11£'11~~ n~1ThelT~1JtU"lJEh1flUL'S'1~~c;ieJi'I1LL1CIIamJ f:i~1'S'nl.1'i~1m.J7mmf1111J LL'IIn'ii1.:J'S'::'VI·h.:~,-::iun1'S'L f1 t uJ~~uunu1::ium,-tlfui1 {1::iunTn fTrh 'S'1flULfl tJ) L"ll1

~ . n~1T·h tf1l1l<ii!1Ultl1fi'.:~~L~tl {butterfly curve hypothesis) tf11JT'H1Yi1U1£Jf1111JH1l't~,u1hi.:~ uiu 1f1.,,-::'VI 11'11f1111lf~n'Y11'11'1.J1nnufl1111 LL'IIn'ii1.:~.J1" d] ue.~ ~~1nm,. L vi11'VI~El ~ C~Jm'S'n'S'::iu

\1 •

{'VI~mf1) ~1m::ium,-tlfui1

111'Vif11111LL'IInc;i1\1~1m::ium,-tlfuc;h [discrepancy from adaptation Level {AL) ]

n t:i11 fi t1 'I.Jflfl~aJ El.:!l1 n1'S'L vi aJ'VI~tl £'1CIIn1'S'L fTVI~Eln'S'::iU~1n'S'::i!u n1'S'tlfui1L U • • ,-::i!umn\1 'J LUUf111aJiin~"'V'l EJL~ LLa::m'S'LLC~Jnc;i1.:~ a r.i1..1111mf.:~ 2 i1u~::ije.~aofi1L iLn'll

\1

f1111lfiini1UL'I'I.J LLU1flC11UijtJ,-:: 1£J"lf,fl unTl"Yi1m111 L "li'1L~n1'S'lh::djutf1111::LL1CII~EI1l'ii1'11 ') \1

82 PC 266

"1J Eh1 bL~fl::Uflfl fl fl11ll LL'il n~1\17::'VI'h\11Jfl fl~ 1 u 7::1ilun171lfu lil1 LUU~~-;nnn17t~11'1t1 t1 £11 u ~ ~ 'II

~\ILnlil~ t~ll~~1\lnu rh 1 'il'lu111um7111::Lih~~.,L~rnnu U1\lfiUEJ1';)';J::l'lEJ hm.h\la..nn"llru.::~ anfiULnlilm1l!L3Jl'l El h El ci1\lll1nL~ L 'ltUfi'\.I.~L~1J 11i1L \.l.'1l'\.1.1J'Ylth-\!iil17::"lf1n1-;i1'\.1,1'\.l, UEI£.1 El1';) ...... I 0 l: ..... f 0 .... .... ... a I

1tm11 fl'\.1.';}1'\.1.1'\.1. 30,000 fl'\.1. '\.l,'\.l.ll1nli1£JLLElEl~ LLilR1'VI"HJfl'\.l.n1-\!L'Yll'ltj LL~1El1';!1Rn11 'II • 'II

~ ~ 0 .J "' I A I A I ~.... - .. 1 s' 30,000 fl'\.1.'\.1.'\.1, Lu\.1.';11'\.1.1'\.l.fi'\.I.'Yl\.l.Eltl LL~!''\.1.1LtJEl'VI'\.1.1tl 'If-\!fiU 2 n~li'\.1.~1'\.1.3Ju1!'Rt.ln11nt. • L~ tl1nt.lfl173.1 rn 'Yl1-\! ~1J L l'l71::Ln~m1ll LL'iln~1\1';!1n1::tii1Jm1UftJi1"1J El-\! L '!11 El ci1\13J1n LL3T';J:;ij

iifi'Yl1\1~~1\lnunlil1ll (Veitch and Askkelin , 1995)

- ~ ~ LL 14"lfl~'21 0\1 LaJ1'1 L 1J ll't4LLa::•nt t!fa

\11u1it1"1JEl\IL3J11LUti'\.I.LL~::faL'If~ (Mehrabian and Russell, 1974) 't'hL'iL"li1L';J ""' ..... f( I .... ..., ,.., ....... .... d I

fl113.1 R3Jl'lUli7::'V\11\11::~tJ"1J El\ln17L 11 n11n1::1il'\.l. LLL~::fi113J1Rn~1UtJ1n-~tJ 'Yllil Elt.l RUEl-\!lil El 1 'II

.... \1 ........ ..r A .A .... II "' " a...o ....... R1l11!'LL1~ ~ El3J L~'1l~L';J'U"1J'\.I. L l'l1'1::LLU 1fllil"1J tl\1 L3J11 Lt.l ti'\.I.LL~::7RL'If~ LLR'il\1 L 'VI L 'VI Ufi113J Rlll'l'\.l.li

1::'VIl1-\! i1 LLU1 L 'VI ~1d'nul'lq ~ n17ll 11il tl L "1J1 'tiih LR'\.1. ti3J 1 unf!"L ~ tl1n1Jn11U7::Liit.l."lit:J3J ~ 'II

(information rating) L ~ t1 t1nt.11 tl1::1ilum7L f1"1J tl-\! ~\I LL11il~ti3J n11U1::Liit.l."lit!llfl 'V13J1 r.~ii\1 'II

• I"' ..1 " ..1 • I "" ..., ' ' 1 "" r .f L ... "" u1ll1 nt.Liil~ tl'll tl\l'lltlll ~'Ylll1m·::'Y11J u1:: R1'Yl R3J~ Rlil fl'VI '\.1. 1m 1~1 3J '\.1. 'Ylflwt-Ltl1';! '1l'VI a..n tl11llt1\l 'II

mi~1\l ') "1Jfl\ln11Lf1'Yl1\I~\ILL1~~flll L"lfUfi113J'!ftJaieJU fl11l!LLU~nL'VIai fi113JL3-iafl~fi~El\l o .I 'l ~.... .... ,.d -., AA 1 ~.... ~ 1

fi113J '\.1. 1u1::'V\ ~11il ';) fi113J ~ ~U LL~:: n17';! ~1::1.1 1J'Y1'1l~ L ';JU L l'l11::3J Iii L 'VI ~1'\.1.~1 '\.1.3J t:-1 ~Iii e:J n17

l17::Liiu"lit~ll~"1l EJ-\!R1l11::LL 11il~ e:J3J~ iu Lll11 LU tiULL~::faLsn~ Lith LRU.Elt:-~~\11'\.1. 1ir.~'it\l LLa~\l 't i 'II

L ~" 11m1m::ttiu'V11m f1 (arousal) iifi113J ill ~ufl~ tllil1-\!num1111::Liiu"lieJ3Jfl LLL'l::n11L f1 • 'II

.... #ill I I oiiM d,t I

1::1ilun ~1\l';l ::3J t:-1 ~Iii e.Jn11fl-\! t1 ti'VI 1EJ EJ t~n';J1n amu 'YIU u ') El tl1\la..nn 'II

Lli11LU ti'\.I.LL~::fRL'If~ LL Ud1fl11lli3J~WtYL oR-\! LiU 1fl'\11::Wl1-\!n11L "li1 Ln~LL~::n11Lf1

';J::L~r.~1"1ia.,nu,-::lilum1ll~.,~ eJ h~1 r.~ 1~ t1 Lu ~1::a£l·Hfl\ln1 di~fi113J~\l~ e:1 h 't u ,-::1iluu1u

n~1\l nTI~\ll'l El ha\l l'lq~n17lln11L"li1 'ln ~iiJ., L ~ll.;f'I.-LLL~::~~~" m~::n1fi113JW\ll'l eJ h~1 m1 'II

L 11';1::\h 'tu ~l'ltl ~m73Jn17'VI ~n'VI it 'II

faL'IftHL~::L3J11LUtiU L~fl111i11LLU1'Yl1\I~\JLL11il~El3J L'lf\-1. LLR-\1 e:Jnt.'VI1lii 'V11Elfi113JL11 • 'II

, a\l"li El3J ~~u fl fl~ 'tifu fi LLa::lil1 LLU1'Yl1\JUflann1l'l L "lfu n11LLR1\l'VI1 m1n1::iu 'VI1a 'tai 'II ~ ~ 1

LLR1\l'V11 "i iia'Ylnl'l~~El1::itJfl"l13Jl'l flL';JLL~::m7L f1~ii<iia R1l11::LL1~~Elll El11llrnfl11llfan 'II

L 'VIfhd'iia'Yln~~<ii Ell'ltl~n113JnT7L"li1 Lni 'VI1El'VI~n'VIU l'lq~n113Jn11Yl1\l1U LLfl::fl1';JU::1l1lf1

1uanT1::U1~iDll,fU') ~\JL"1J1L~ibLRUBRllll~~1'\.l.m13Jl'lBh-m1n1::~\-L (pleasure-arousal

hypothesis) ~n ~1111 Ufl fl~ Iii e:J\ln1"H "li1 'l n ~~\l LL 1~ ~ D3J'Y11\In1 FJ1l1l'l ~ii inlfnt.::<ii1\l';l1n • .... A .:~ ..., .::~ "" ...... I • L "'

flnt.~nlfnt.::au ')"11 El\l L '!11 3Jn17n1::1il u 'VI 1m 711::~tJu1Un ~1\l LLfl::3Jfi113Jl'l e:J ';!1::~u R\l fi113J ~ 1 'II

PC 266 83

""1..1..: ..¥ • "1" ..1:: "" ..,.J .d'YJ., Yh'lVHJ ';I 'I'lL Yl:JJ ~-\l"ll'!.l. ~1:JJT'Hl'Yl1'!.l.1£Jfi11:JJEH.J1nL"ll1 nGHUll'!.l.'Yl'!.l.'!.l. ';J1f17::~Uf1T'H71'Ylff-\l"ll'!.l. L~ ~ ~

~,-tJ1i11~:JJ :JJ ~~1'!.l.f111:JJYl EJL\1-f117f17::fiiuii ~,-::; Lhfi"'ru11 L 71\l:::~Wll':JJ i-\ILL 1~i el:JJ L ~:JJifutf1ii " "' 1 _,

m1:JJ'V'leJhi\ILL1~ieJ:JJJu lu,-:::~u~-\1 ~

fi.iL'lHl LL~::vl'Glrl hi1l1 Li.i'!.l.El~\ltJDn7m'Yl1\IEl17:JJrnftii'ii Eli \ILL 1~i eJ:JJftiim7L f1~1El " l .. ~ AA .=lA ..... .... ,:f

f117m::~ULLGl::fi11:JJYHl ';!Lu'!.l.3J~'Yltli.i7::';11f1f1'!.l. ~\1'\.l, ,

. ... "' ~'Ufl'Cl1

. ' "' 'U111Hl

, lSI J.Jl'll

ffUlf.l

G.l ... .... ~ 'VI .... I ~ d.a1 ... .... ........ \11 mJ\I"ll1\l ~ '!.l. \1::: L ~ U L~111.i 1111 ::LL1 ~ Gl v :JJ 'Yl:JJ f117f17::: ~ '!.l. 1::~ U i.i\1 'lJ fl f1 ~ ';! :::7U 711

1 ~ , ~

i" LL1~ i a11Ju u 1 Yl eJ L\1 (L 'iiu aU1:JJv-lq)'JJ t~G'Iftu1~uLiu) liL "ltuL~£.11nu i" Ln~i t1 :JJftii n11 , "' .... ~ 1 .clot""..,.. • A .Jl:, • f~td

m::~u,-::~'JJ~1 (L"Jl'U ~1Ui.i'11Jl'Hltr::'Yl'Yl1 ~7amHJufi~1£J) "11-\lfft11'!.l.'Yl'Yl\l 2 LL~\1 Lu'!.l.'Yl &J'Uflfl~ , ~ , ... 'II. I ' ... .... .... ..1 ... ..1 ..1 ..1'1 ' ' 1 :: ...~... ... l

el£.11f1L"ll1 LIJ L"Jl''!.l.L~£.11f1'!.l.f1U'Yl'Uflfi~Eltnf1~Glf1L~£.1\11.it11'!.l.'Yl 'Yl L3J'!.l.1'V'ltl \l'Yl-\I'Yl3Jf117f17::~U U, , , ,-::;~uff-\1 (L'iiu ieJ\INeJ'JJft·th1if~nn~~ni:JJ) LL~:::ftiim7m:::fiiw~::~'JJ~1 (L'iiu ~~:JJ~.j:,fi'V'lft'1'11

~ 'II , , ,

1........ .-: W~ffn7:::'Yl:JJ'Ylf1"ll) ~ ,

m,tJ,-::dJufi11:JJ'V'l t1 hifut~ [jnum,-i:JJt.JffnNm7L ~ "U:JJ1nw;hm,lifiu "ll m:::ft m1 ~

al A " 4 ".r , ..... ~ " \1t.IA ,f al 1Ci1o

u'l::: L3J'!.l.f117L 71~ 7tlf117m:::~U "ll'!.l.El £Jf1'JJ'Yl \lfi17L ~ 'ULL~::nTl' L~ EJ'!.l. '!.l.Elml1f1'!.l.f1Tlu'l::L3J U '1'11\1 , ~

D17:JJ n!ifuD~nu,-::iu"ll D\1 ~"L i'-rrh·ntJfu~1'ii1 £J ~1:JJ'Ylt'J'If~,.::~um,-tJfu~hmh111 ~ ~"';11n ..~ .., .... 1 .... .-:.J .... I ... n ... . .. t ..... 'Yl1Jflfl~ L~u7::Gi'Uf1'JJ~t11'!.l.f111tlt'Yl3Jf117u7::L:JJ'!.l.'Yl1\18173Jtlt '!.l.'l::qr'!Jf.i\1 L"Jl''!.l. Yl\IY-18 ';) ~7EIL71 , ~

L 'U 7:::~'JJ1.i\1~1a~1:JJ1f1 f117tl7::dJ'Uffll11:::LL1~i El:JJ 1 ~3J"ll8\l L "1J1';J::LU'U 1 'U fifi'Yl1\Jqr7\JrlWn1:JJ Lfla ~

LiJ1£J'JJ L ri£J1Jrl'JJ ~ftla.J Lfl £JiJ'l::i.i'JJ Gft11'Uf117m1117U7::L£iuti1'U8113Jtltr1 '!.l. 'l::qr"'u N\1 ~7fJ~1:JJ1f1 3J1 ~ ~

84 PC 266

rltl'\.l. L "J1'\.l. L~nrh~ r.~hJ~1'\.l.Lmn~~itrJLLfl'\.l.c;ffitJ,-::L 'Ylf'I~'V\'l~EIL3J1n1 111 LLcf1 [] El2JU1"::Lii'\.l.~1'\.l. q ~

~r.J13J'"hti.1YlEJL';J'!Zur.Jn-hL~nfihlL~r.Jttl~~itrftLfmc;f

4.2.5. A113JthAll! (Meaning)

mi'lJGhfiiy (Meaning) tn';liit1113J'V13J1r.J1!il'VI~1r.JEJ[j1...:J L'\.l.fiU 'V13J1r.Jii...:J m::U1'\.l.n11" ' <l::f I G..oo 1 A

'Yllil1...:Jn1-l. 3 EW1...:J ~El .... A lol\4 .. "I I A dl::

1. fl113J(:..lfi'rlU (Attachment) 'V\1"Elfl113J"l~nLuUGOU'VIU...:J"l.ltl...:J&H11U'Y1W"'J " " .d _. ~ ~ "' ..1

2. n11~El~1 (Communication) 'V13J1r.JtHin11"'Yl~fl1U'Yl'VI1EIEJ1m1~Elm13J'VI3J1r.J

1-i~Yl1JL~1-1.~11-1.3J turi'f'IU'Y11...:Jn11"Llitl...:J ~mtl"'lilr.Jm13J tlf"lf11J1 'VI~mi...:J~3J o; tl .. .. tl .. "' ~ ... ~ 3. 11ilt1 1::~\1~ (Purpose) 'V13J1r.Jrl...:J n11 1::L3J\.4'VIl41'Yl"l.IEI...:JEl1m1" 'VI1"El~fl1\.4'Y1

q

,f"'J Yii3J'rl ... wrinu,-tlmJu 'VI~an1-wimtm"lla...:Jmm,. "

A113J~m1'" (Attachment)

El1m1 ~t11l4fi~1...:J'"' ';l::ii~113J~1~imhwf1JL11 n1L11iiti1::~1Jn11mat.i~ti'\.l.LU't-4 J .. "

.. "'tl .. ~ .. "" • o; .. ... .. n ~1 u 11-1. 'VI 1m~ r.J 3J 1::~u nT"HU. 'Y111-l.LL 1...:1 anfl113J'VI3J1 r.J'VI l-4\1"1.1 El...:J~113J ~1~ru'VI1El~113J1~n q .. "

(:..lnv-i··"~ a~m"fi (place attachment) LU't-4n1::1.nu~~u-;i1't-4 1\.43J1n 1 imu.fi1a-1uu~~flLLfiU1\.4 " , q

~ .,I., ... d • ' ... ..... o; ' d .. ~ ... "1!3J"lfl4 LL~::~m1-l.'Y1 ~U'YllilEI...:Jr.J1tJ'Y1Elttmw 5"1 3J~113J1~n(:..ln'rl1-l.lilt:J~m"Yl';l::fl~fl...:J (:..jfl(:..l~lilmnlil

q " J " " .... A iQ.; I d A .... I 0 .... .d ....

';11 n ~ 113J1~ n (:..In Yl 't-41il a ~t11 "'Y1 ~a n11(:..j ~3J (:..1 ~11-1. n1-1. 1::'VI11...:J fi113J ~1 ~ ru"ll t:J...:J ~t11 '"'Y1 nu " " .. m13J~1fl'ru-na.:~ Blillil1 du~a taJ~1m1mLvmemin1frua-1utJflflfltltln';J1n~t11U~tfu t~ L 'liu .. , um7r.~ufiLL~~...:JiilU1~ttEl...:JLtln\fn1!trui'1LEl...:JntJ LEJn\fnttm"l.ltl...:J 1 1\IL7ttu ~1 tln11~~~a1 1...:JL7r.JU l)

m1(:..lnviunu~mu~eJ1-;J'Yh1-iufl~~ii"LLfim13Jiil1r.J1~ L'lium,-13.lva3J~::rf...:J~mu~ " q

'VI~mJ11-l."l.l El\lli!U LLaf-;1:: dj1-l.~L~ti...:J~ tln11Ln~nm~u1i~1...:J ') 13.111-;l::LU uJ 1'rl13J LLf..JU~U 1 'V\1

'VI~El'rl1 r.~i'1 mL ,...., i1t1...:J13.im.J3J t:JEln-;J1nU1U"l.l El..'llil1-l. q

n1'aiaiif1"i(Communlcatlon) o..... ""' ""' .. .d: 1 L- I"A d_

~113J ~1flt1)"11 El\1 ~1111:: LL 1~~ El3J~1Ufl11~El ~11 'VI 3J1 r.Jfl\1 3J U 'Ylf'IUL "lf...:JU 13Jii113J'Y1

~mU~'VIit\1 ') LL~~...:JElt:Jnn...:Jf1113J ~1~ .... 11J'VIia11i~fl11J lil13J~113J~\-;)"1.1El\l~f.l tlnLL1J1J L'liUB1~11 ~ ... 1 Q..o A .... .4 'I ""' I'S ..... Q..l I" ~ Q,.,o "" VJ I

'Y1~1"1...:J Iii r.J1~1J1~"1.1El...:Jelli!L~ tl1 ~El~11 L 'VIL 'VIU~llitlHin'lftu."l.IEl...:JU1'll" ~n'Jftu.::1J11-l."llf.l...:J~U L 'Y1 r.JLLiil ... .. .. fl::111~~1...:Jnu L ~umLLmiu an 1~11LUU"llB\1111flL 'VIUEJ Luu~u

PC 266 85

.J .J ., l .... r:t .I • A .......

n11'Yl El1fl11~fi1'\.L 'Yl ~ 3J11fi~::'Yl fl'\.L ~ L ~'\.Lfl113J u711fi'\.L1Wlfl ~\t~\t 1fi1"rn fl.:!~ ~11_, 'II

tf"" ~muil.na1~~ah LL~fi'\.L~1 ')1ua1~1li"Lrau L"li'tt LL'I41fi~l""m,~i1-:~a1fl17~i£Jl~li in

Li7U'Y17_,L1£JuJ1 £J ii1fi,-_,L ~~nLU'\.L7uiL ~~t13JLL~::m::~nLU'I.t.~im~iiau 6lfltt'Ylnfl1fl11 'ti1L ~ 'II 'II ) •

di91LL'\.L 1fl91L '\.Ln17~i1_,fl1fl17~L7£Jn'i1 postmodernism -if.:~Lfl"m7~i'1.:!fl1m11~£JlhLL tt1fi91

~1a ~ ""~ '141 n11'll a ~rn u if. n 3J1Li'i13JrlU LL tt1 fi ~'ll a.:~~a r.i a1 fltl aif.:~n1l ~a1 fl1,. LL '141 'II \1

postmodern ii fi113JLL~n~1..1n'l.t. LL~::Lfl"~il. £J3J3J1nn'i1 LL~~ a tia1fl£JU1..1fi'\.L fl1~ 1li"Lrau 'II 'II

4.2.6. flm~h (Concern) • n171.h:: Lij\tfl nl.fl1 Lfl£J1'1ifl.:!rlUfiTl'f1Uflfl~3J fl.:!'i1~fi1Wrftt '14~7ai-.lLL 191 afl3J'Y11..1 • •

m£Jfl1~,f"~fi1fi11LLrim,-unila.:~ 'ti1fl113JL'li1hLLL'l::ufuu,..,l~~;f"" L'rl" ~a.:~'ri'n u1'1.t....rn • ..... .. A .ill ... ... I I ·' 'VI "" ..:. I 3... I 0 \1 A

tl1fl£.1 L3Jtl-.l ~7ElL~El'\.LU1'\.L 3Jflnl.fl1~ElL11tlu'H L7 fi1A.,'IL~~1\t3Jflnl.fl1 L71~::n7::'Y11tl:: L7 L~tl • • ' "" "'.I"" .1 .,I '.r., ~.:IL~73J~7tlu7Uu1"-.l ~fi1'\.L'YlL ~~1'\.LU1-.l •

L '\.L n 11f1 n'l~1 n17U1':: d.i '\.Lfl nLfl1'lJ EH i.:~ LL 1 ~a t:1 11tf '1-1. in U 1:: L ij "L ';') ~ fl ii ~ £i ~ El • ,d. .... d AI~ ~ ,k #t ., ~ A.d

~-.lLL1~HHl3J '11-.lL';'J~fl~~tlA-.lLL191L'lEl3J"~3J1£.1713Jfl.:l EHflU7::fit:JU'Yl-.l 3 'llfl-.lL';'J~fl~ fltl

86 PC 266

Eh1~tl1::n vlJ 'Yll-\ln11i'~~ f1111!i'amLfl ::n11n 1::'Yi1 v .:J~tl,-::n v1Jrt1..1 m1i'fi ~ (Cognitive 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

Component) 'VIm £Jii.:J f111:l.li''VIiEJm13Jfi~~1Jflf1 G~ijYin "1111:: LL1~~ mJ El1~ Llh!."li m -n~~7 .:J'VIia 'IJ ~

f1113Jfi~L ~uYiEJ~-\ILL1~~e:J3Jril.i El-\l~tl1::ntl1J'Yl1-\!f1113J'iin (Affective Component) 'V13J1 £Jii.:J 'IJ

r A ...,.. .cl• . .., tr. 1 ..., o

EI113J m 'VI 1 El f1113J 1 "n"ll EJ.:J 1J f1 f1 fl 'Yl3J ~ El "1111:: LL 1 ~ fl a :u LLG~:: a.:~ f1u1:: n au ~1 u n11n 1::n1 'IJ ~

(Conation Component) 'V13J1 £Jii.:JLLU11 'it3JL unT'nL"~.:IY-lt'J~n113JYi El"1l11::Ln~~a:u EJTn L~~ .c.d..:t, A a.dllld, d...,

fl~'Yl3J c;) Eln'l-:1 L 'YJy.j 3J'VI1Uf11Ci 'VI111 £J113J fl-\1 fl113J fl~'Yl3Jc;) e:Jfi1 .:1 L 'Yl'Y-1 (L n £J1n lJ"llU 1 c;) n11~11~1 ~ ~

1::i1J3Jfl1l11:: ~.:J~iEl.:Jn11LUc;)«i) fl113J~n~ijyjEJn1-\IL'Yly.j'i (L"Jiu fl113J~UL~U fl113Jrl-\11fl 'IJ 'IJ ~

fi113J ni1<1) LLG~::Y-1 q ~n113J'VIiEJm1n1::'Yi1~mCj)'"h~::n1::'Yi1L um.:~ L rt~ <1 (L "Jiu. 11-\ILL~m 'ttl ~

.cl ._.. ... .J.! A 1111 d ~ 1 1 'I(• L 'Yl £.111c;)y.j1:; LLn"l 11-\1 LL~U 'Yl~::U-\!1fl11.:J"lf3J L3J El-:1 'VI1El11-\l LL~U 'Yl';l::1-\1~1 U. Cj) E.1 ~3J LL1::fi1-\l L 'Yl'Y-1 '1

~

L~c;)fl~Yi El~-\ILL1c;)~EJ3J ElR1J1 £JL~~1 £J'Ylt'J1!t~'VIimL u1fi~"ll El-\ln11LiE.Juj' L "Jiu n1111-\l A~ A .,., 0 .A ....... A.d ....

L-\IEJU ~"llLL1JfiL'I1"~n n1111-\IL-\IEJU L"llLL1J1Jn11fi1::'Yl1 LLG!::n11L 1£JW'i';J1fin11~\JLnc;)'V\1Eln11L 1£JU1 'IJ • 'IJ

'Yl1.Ji.:Jf13J L1J1.LLLfl::fiL'IElf (Byme & Clore, 1970) L~"i'1\J The Byme-Ciore Reinforcement-d- .. VI A .. A A AI

affect model '15\1 3Jv1U3J1~1nn1111\J L.:J EJU ~"ll LL1J1J fl fl1 ""m ~ El Elll1J1 £J n11L fie;) L';Jc;) fie;) c;) EJ ... ~.:~ LL1c;)~EJ3J 1c;)mu ~1::m.h.Jfl\JEJ.:J~tl,-::nt~u'Yl1.:Jfl113Jiin 'VIimn13Jm i.,d li'1ttl~\JLi'1~ij~ G~

'1.1

Yi El El113J m ~ L i1 u. n Gl1.:J (Li£J n-h ~" L i'1 ~ ~ El" n1111\l L~ El "L "11) L "Jiu tl-\1"11 rJ:: n11El1m.i 1 ~ u • ~1un-:~1u.uvi" 1'VI:JJ 'J anL"li1~nu~" L i'1~'Yi11 'iLnc;)m,.Cj) au ~uEJ\J'Yl1\IEl113JmEJ ciLL~1 (Livni1 ;.:~

'IJ 'IJ

.... ~lll•"' A 'VI I ~ ~ A old .. A I~ .... ,:::! L11'Yl ~3Jc;)EJ\J11.:JL\IEJU ~"11) L"lf'U. nf!UL'V13Jtl. tllU'V11l3J~8L'VI3J1!:: L"£.1-\IElfi'Yln':f ';l::Y-11J11~\JL11Y!Lfl£.1

~ 'IJ

Li1unG~1\J ~::ij~ G~Yi Eln11c;)EJ1J""El-\IL 'VIllau~,n i'1ft'11i~El\111.:JL~EIU. L"ll i..:J.i1EJ ci1\J (Veitch and

Arkkelin , 1995)

PC 266 87

~\IL f1~1aJ~eH11..1 L~tlUL'lJ

L"JiU 0

A o<l

- fi~UL'VI:UU

- t~ru 'VIIliiVi m 'VI an:: • 'II

"' .. .. - L"ti..1EJn'Yln

..: .. ..1 "' .., ""L 11'Y111'11L'11EIU L"ll

{LUUfi~1'11TltlU11..1

L~tlUL"ll) L"JiU

.. - m7EJ11J~imiu •

..1. 0 t 0

- 'Yl'Y11'111ULL'V\..1 'VI:U

..1 m 1~ t11J "'~-Ul\1 'Yl n11~tl1J"Utl..1

1aJ~t~..111..1 \11fln11th·::LiiU

L~emL'll (11\IL~tlUL'll) _L'riu

.. L'riu

"' l .. ,. "~" " - laJ"lft~u

.. "1J1tl - "1fEJ1J ... ..

·• L "tl ":U11i - L\l.tl ')

L~iim1ii't1 L i4 m>i'f.lJU111h ... ~L\J~fl~~ii!iitli'I1U1~~tl:U L"JiU LL1J1J1~L\I~fl~iLi'l1ii.L 1111U

"lltl\1 m1~ L UEJLL~::flru:: (Maloney et.al., 1975) ii 4 :U1~7UEJtl L~LLTi tl11:UnL fl11:Ui ityty1

.... 0 .d .... .f .... .... .,tl ... .1 .. ~1tl11\11 LL~::nT~·m::'Yl1 'If\! 2 m~'l'VI~"""tl~fl~tl'l1fi1Jtl..1fl 'l::ntl1J~1Un17m::rn'lleh'lL\I~fl~

1~ t1 iruun ~1 tJ11\11 'VI 111 t~n-.1 n11fiu fl~t ~Vi ~i1\l::iiVi q~n,-,.:u n17tlu fn~1 uL~t~.:~l~u,.., "' ., ~ '\J q

.J...,. o A A ..., ... l"" r:t' .-=! d "llnt::'Yl "I1JI1J1'Yl1..1n17m::'Yl1 VIm tJfi.:Jn17LL"~.:JVi(l~n77:U mpn~mmm 'I'lL 'VIU :un1'l111n~1

fl11 :U LL~ n Iii 1n::'l'\ l1 \1 L Vi 111"1f1 tl LL~ ::'VI tU\IL U.L~ tl \1 L \1 ~ fl ~Iii El ~ \1 LL1 ~tf a :U Vi 1Ji1 ~'VI ru ..1 ~fl\1:: ii .. 'II "'

tl17:U rn'ii1u~ 1J!ii Eln17Vi1J L ~ UVi(l~fl7'l:Un17LaJ tlU fn,; ~fiVi~ L~tl\11.rn,'VI1i.:J LL 1~~ EJ:U LL~::ii • 'II ·~

m1 :ufLfl tJ1n"'m.rru'V11'1ltl..1i..,Ln~~mJ'!t'tltJrti1~"1f1 t1 (Gifford,Hay,and Borod, 1983) tl1\l Lflu 'II ... 'II

L Vi11::1::1J1J 1 7..1L7tmL Utl L:Uin1LaJL~tn.t'mmu L iL~fi~'VItU\I"Uh1'Yl tl11111 "~fLL~::~\ILL19l~tl:U • 'II "'

' ..1 L 'Yl1'Ylfl11

88 PC 266

m1~h1m~ r.nnlJ L~!jl t1~ ~a ~"Ln ~~mJ Li1u. 1 'VI niCi1 a.,m,-fim~n-)1 lJt'lt'l ~ ij'rlq~m111~ a ~ q

~"LLd!jl~ aaJ tie:J~t'l~e:J.,nlJ L~~t'l~~ii~ a~" LL1!j!~e:JaJ'VI7a l3J ~~m,-iiiJ'rllJ'h~~vi1" 1£J ~" LL "J!jl~ e:JaJ 'U

:J.Jn L "llT'i111ii~m,.aJ au.fmf'~LL~fm~1 ~" LL'1'11~ a11 LL~ a1~ l3Jlithnnii~n,.,.aJ rl'1fim~1 L Vi £.J"lJ1" q 'U q

A I Q.oo CLot 6" I A A .d.at I ._.. ~ .... ~ n~n113J e:J1';J'rllJ11fl113J ti3J'rl'U. 1i1::'V\11"L ';l'ilfl'il LL~::'rlrj'ilfi113J'Yl3J'il e:Jn11~ LL~1filf1ti" LL 1'11£1 eJ 3J 3J

fi113J im~"u.fl u. 1:: ilJ ~1 ~" t11 ,-fin lf1 'rl q ~ n1111 ~1" ') 1 u. 1" n1'1" ~:: 'rllJ11 tiel"~" d'ij Q.,o ca,... 6" ..... 'l Q,t .t

m1aJL1'3J'rlU.linu. L U.1::1ilmn•1Ju. 'U

A o .J ., ~"L~ an1.,mlil e:JlJ'Ylt'Jn!jl a"

'U

1. 11~i~Lf L~a-hi1LLth11ilij~GI~e:Jm13J~"'rle:J h 1 U.~"LL11il~e:J3JLfili1LrlanTnf1ar.J1 U.

PC 266

,-::i'lJ11il ' ... 0

(1) n~1"'J (2) ~.,'VI,.e:Jii11

2. ti3J3J~;j1U.t1113J'rl a h-m1n1::iu.n~1T:h lJt'lt'l~~::~·wnalJ ~\1 Ln~~aaJ 1~ .. q q

(1) iim,-n,-::Ci1u.,-::i'lJmnl] LLfl::'rla h,-::i'lJnfl1" q

(2) iim,-n,-::iu.,-::i'lJmn\1 LLfl::'rla 1';11::i'lJti" q 'IJ

(3) iim,-m::iu.,-::i'lJti" LL~::'rla L';l1::ilJnfl1" q 'U

( 4) ijm1n1::Ci1u. 1::i'1J ti" m~::'rl a h,-::ilJ ti" q 'U 'U

3. lJt1t1GlU1::Liiu.m1aJ~"'rl a h ~1niaJ~tiL!i1111nn-j1 q

'IJ

0 .... 4 I A

4. m13Jti1t'lty (Meaning) 'V13J1£Jt'l.,m::lJ1U.n11 3 e:J£.11\It'le:J .................................. .

o .... \ A ~ ., .:~ 5. fl113Jti1t'l!lj U.fiTltiEI~1"1.1El-.1ti"LL1'ilt1El3J 'V13J1£Jm .................................... .

1 • "' .I A d.c1 1

6. t'lmm"ll e:J.,ti., LL 1'ilfl EJ3Ju1::L3Jll.~1n ........................................................... 'Yl3J'il a • '

i"LL'1'il~El3J

89

al A .-:: lo' Q,; d 4.3 nT:iJJ,-:::LiiJ~Uh'IU'l~aoaJv1nan'ltm:::tiO\'I~fi1'WlYI (Environmental Assessment)

tfmtm::-,i1Lrn::"llfl·.1nTnh::dh~i>~LL1~~mJ';)1nflmLnJU~"lle:h'IRfl1'1.l.rf : Lmn (Craik, ~

1971) limhTJ1nTnh::Lii'l.l.Rm'l.l.ft D1,thli 5 in~m:: fit~ 1. -f~in~nt:::'Yl1\lnitl111~LL~::ii~i11ri''l.l.n L"1f'U.f1111JGI1~LerH'iiD\l~UL'il1 fi1111Gi\J"llfl\J

~ 'II

L~~1\lo ~1\lo1U1urfiiLLR\ILL~~ -,i1'1.l.1'1.l.ifi\IL'U.U1'1.l. li

2. 1~-,i1u 1Ufl1111v. G~1nv. ~1 t~"ll a" i.,th::~~fl 'l.l.R1111::LL 1~ ~fill L "lt'l.l.amtm::"ll a" .. L vJe:rfit L -,Hrfl 'U. i e:J\1 ,t., L ~ 'U. ;., ~1 'U. 1 tJ f1Tl11 Gi:: ~1 n L 'U.fh t~vf nLL 1"11 L fl ~ El \1 -;j n1 L 'U. h\1\11\l.

.... "" .J .J .I 0 Ail I .4 '1 1 A ..... l'.:i.... A

3. 1~an~m::"llfi\1Rtn'l.l.'Yl L·n'l.l. atl~l'l.l.'Yl'Yl1\11\l.L"llt~1".1Hl11W:ifl ~11 1111'Ylfll'l.l.11~n~m::L'l5ru ~ 'II ..

'l51ULV.1l u1u~Lm-il"11111~7ahi m,-tl,-::Lii'l.l.an~m::L~~,dLL91n'ih-il,1nfl11111.h::nuhrfiiliia 'II

..I .4 !'I ..,.. • • I .. .... ..1 .... • I "' 1 "· I "' ..1 Rtn'l.l. 'Yl"ll" \1 Lu 'l.l.fi11111"Rn R1'1.l.U flfl ~ n11u1:: L11-u.an ~m::"ll e:J\1 Gitl1\lo 'Yl11 n u1:: L11'U. ~ m-1 u1:: L1l'U. 'Yl 'II q 'II

lifun11~n~'l.l.1111~mu~1:: ~~rtl~1i\lu1L~fl~fl111nn-hm1tl1"::Lii'l.l.i1Vfl111lf~n~1"~" 'II

• "' .... I ..... ..... ~.¥ ~ A ... A .... d ~ e:JT;Jn~11 ~~11n11"1~an~m::"1!El\lamu'Yl'l.l.L1..J'I.l.L'lfl\1"11El\ln11"1~~flan~n~m::'ilfl\lam'l.l.'Yl'l.l.'l.l.i.J

... .. .I .. .r t ...~~ ..I ' ..... 4. 1~~'J~n1"1"11'YlLn~"llmU~1:: 'U.t(tl1\l.'Yl'U.\lo') Gitl1WY1U1\ILL~\1Gi11111"tl11~t]'ilnl1"1J

~&nm·'\~1t!El~1\1Ln~if-u. L"li'U. ~1\l.Gi'l.l.n ii~q~n1"1"11nT'l"L~'U.Lfl~fl-1L~'U. v."1L1"1:: ~-1L~'U. i'El-ilLi li ~

LL'iiU1-1atn'l.l.ftii~q~n'l1"11L'ii'Lu ~1::U1"Elr.i1\IL fi11f'U. L"rl'U. a1u~aL:J iiowq~n'l'l11n11"L ~1::tl~n 'II

.. ..1 t + Lnmnm ~tlv ll

~

5. 1 ~U'l1"£J1 n1 fl'Y11-1 i-1 fl11"11 D\1 i., LL 1 ~ ~ El1l L "rlu n11n ~11 i1 h.,~ v1u1 a lll ii tJ,-::~'YlnnTri e:n,~muii" flm111~i1uR"11El\lo1livm.,mvn1~"11El\l h"~r.nu1~ L"rl" lllR::m~

~ ~

~7El fl1';)~ 111 rJn\1 an~m::m,-tl;; i11ri''l.l.n'l::V.i1\1Ufl fl1n1"rl'U.LEI\l 1"::~i1\1Ufl a1n1"rll.Jfl\lo L"li w ~ ~

.I A A ~ .r .. ~ ......... 1 ~ A !1 - ~ .J u1"::ami111~'YI\l 2 m111~ 111 £J'I.l.El1';111fl111l Lmn~ 'l.l.nu ~ va\1~ "" Lu'l.l.L v.~"ll El\1 on""~"" q

..I..: ., L ..1 ' ,.:. 1 .. .1..1 .I ..I ,.. 1 " o "llm::'Yla\ILL1~~fl11 'l.l.Gitl1'1.l.'Yl'il1\l i)'Yl""J an11n11"Lu~t~'l.l.LLu~\l'YlLn~,1n1111:: ~n1"El\lo 'YI1

t " .I ... .... ..!... 0.... A! !'I .r ~ m1"u1"::L1l'l.l.tm~m::'il El\1 am" 'Yl1lfl1111 Gi1flty LLa:: ~1 LJJ'I.l.1!1n'ilu

I I .,.J A .0: ~ ""' d._,. 4.4 A'l1 aJ LLIA n IA111";i:::\1111\l n11'JJ1'::: LaJ 'Wlt'fl1 u 1~ a o aJv1 n a n'itm:::tl o" ft1l1'WlYI nu n11'

u":i:::til'Wli\lu 1~ ft' oaJv1 nA11aJ111'::nu ~vft''J'WliA'Wl n11"1h::LiiU~Gi'El\lin~m::LL'iln'ii1-1rl'U. i-1d

1. m'l1im~£J1num1"1..h::Liiui.,LL1'il~Elmnnm111U1"::nuhnu'l.l.m1"Luwrii1uflflfl q

'I " t A.ct A ..,.4 .J.. I d 1 .._.

(person-centered) ';):: L ~fl1111 au ';)1trfl~ LLL'!::fl11111"«n"ll eJ\ll.JflfiG~'Yl11 'il El amu 'YI'il1\l ')1ElU'i11 'II ~

..1 A""' ..1 ... .I .. " .. , ..I !'I " ..1 "..lm::'Yim1"1';1 m n r.J1nun11u 1:: L11'1.l.~1U~n ~m::"ll El\1 Rtl1\lo 'Yl L JJ'I.l.n11"L" 'l.l.Rtl1 'l.l.'YI (place-

centered) ';)::L~fl111lR'I.l.hL~V1rlUflnl.111~"11El\IGi1111::LL1~~El11L\lo11111lfl\l"..leJ\IUflflfl L'U.n11'rl1 , . ~

90 PC 266

.... tr ... 1 - ~ - .... t'f\ILn~m7mVI~1£J ') fl'l.hJ7::L2J\UUl1U'YIL~ mm~

2. n1 71.11:: L ii ui \1 LL1 'It~ El m:n nfl 'J12J 111:: 'Yl .... lJ l;, ti1 u~ u ., :: L fl £J •"li t.l \1 nu i' n lfm::

1m\lt'fi1\I'Yl1\l~<il1'Yl£J1 L"lfu m111iin fi112Ji1fi'ru fi112JV12J1£J fi112J"lHllJ"i LL'iim71.h::Liiu 'II .,

in ~m::"ll e1 \1 t'ftl1U ft -,:: L uum7"W £11 £112Jl~fl mt'f2J u1i'Yl1\lm £J111'W"ll El\1 i\1 LL 1 'It i El2J ';J1m1mY:: ' ' .... o,... ~ • A t;

'111'\.l.n1771J7"ll El\llJ flfl~ L "li'\.l.fl n4111'W"ll el\1 t'f\1 LL1 ~~ EI2J "i 'II ' '

m71it-,U'£Jm12J"lH.JUft~uii'ii t~i\ILL 1'11it~2J (sit \I Luui-iiLL 1~Gi't~2J';J1f1fi112Jtl7::'t1u 1-,)

LL~::m71it-, ,r£Jfl mn1"W"ll a \I i-ii LL 1'11 ~ e111 (sit-ilL uu m11.l1:: Liiui\1 LL 1 '~~~a 2J';J1n inlYm::"ll a \I t'fm u ft '

tfu) iifi112JLL~n'ii1\lrl'\.I.LL~::81';J 1ahuu ttJt wn~'Yl1\1Lil£11rl'\.l. Hi-il Ln~ el1';JU1'::Liiuanlfm::'Yl1\l 'II

amtJ ... ~ £Jf1772J"lla\IEJ1fi17VItt\16li1 iiflm111Wt'f\l LL'iit1i"liellJTf1.i ) ' 'II

3. t-1 ~ f117l.h::Liiui\l LL1~ £i' El2J';J1f1 an lfm::"ll El\1 am '\.1. .yt aJn L "n1 '\.l.f117Uf1JU7\IVI1a '

Ltl~ tJULLll~"" 1£Ju1 £Ja1n-17m::2J1nni1m71.l7::Liiui\l LL1'11 i a11.,1nm111 1.1,-::'tfu h ti1u~u L -rlu

.I ... A.... .. "' • .I"' .I .... .. .... .. .J ' 1 u7::L1lli.1J1l'Yl~U"ll tl\1 t'f1Ut'f1fi17m:: L W tl'\.1.1t-l~ 2J1u71Ju1\l W~'\.1.1Wla El't7f11Yt'ft11Uflm\l ') L '\.1.

a1ua1n7m::

"' .I A ..: .. .... .J !'I .I A .J ., 4. L ua\I';J1f1n17u7::L11'\.I.t'f\l LL 1'11 ~a 2J';J1n~n1Ym::"llEJ\I amun Luun17u7::L2JU'YJLUU

• I "" .J, ._. '" 111 , '" .J , u7::L2J'\.I. r1 L"151fif117VI7Eln ~ Lf1~1\l ') V\7 afi112J L"li£11"151 qJLQ W1:: a tJ1\I (Technical based)

L7tJni1 Technical Environmental Assessments (TEAs) LU'\.I.n17Lifi112JiLii\11"151n17 VI1El 'II

Lfi~El-iliiflBllmrn 1unTl'Ei1uflm111"W"lla-ili\ILL1'~~£ia2J L"lfu 1iB1ln7m1'11flmn1wJ1 t1m111w ' ' , ' ,

Environmental Assessments (OBEAs)

OBEAs m~:: TEAs iitJ,-::1£J"l:f'tt'~i'w$uElcirllJl~tl1.l7::H\Ifl1um1'1.l7::Liiu L"liu TEAs 'II •

iithd£J"ntt1 um71.l7::Liiu 1::~ ... 1J"ll D\1 Eiu~11£Jftd1~';11n t'ft'f17 1 UEl1m~ J 1 Vl1a~u sit\12JU1YE.J11i ii '

fi112JH12J17tl';J::fuf\~&f1U OBEAs iitJ7:: 1£J"lf'lfl Uf117flf11Y1flfl.l.111'W"ll a\li\ILL'J'II~tl2Jff\li1U 'II •

PC 266 91

tl7:::Lu'lf1ltleh1 Observer-Based Environmental Assessments

OBEAs ijtJ7::1rJ"Jf11'VI;Erllilnlh:Li>Jt11u.nT-rLi ~\i ~

1. liL~mt17mHrirJum711ilflntf11"W'llfh1i-\ILL11iliEJ:JJ7:wi1>1:JJU.1!tJnunT-rli ~ ~

.I r .. d ""' \1 , .. 4 .. ... , Elun7nl.'VI1EJLmEJ-\I\ln"m~ Lnli\1-\1 ') 'VI78Lt17El-\13JEJL~V'n:'t11-\l tnt11"l..EI-\I TEAs LL~: OBEAs ~

LL!iln~1-\lnu.mn Luu.i.J~liL~U.m1:JJU1L~aiiB"llel-\l TEAs rl'1 TEAs 13-iLfirJ-\IIi\1-\1 ~:l~mm.,. tJfuu1-\lflUn7m'VI1fJLfl~fl-\li'J fl'VI;elfl"l1 ufL i-\11"ll"1nTlfiL i11ilfl nl.f11Wi.J LL 11ili el:JJ LL~ TEAs LL~:

q ~ 'II q

osEAs lli'\i1Luu.~B>11~~~fi~,-\lnu. m\ll~~~L'VIiiBu.nu. L-rlu. lu.m,-~n1!t1flntn1-w'lla.J\hlu. q

t1~ a>1 LLG{U.LLG{lJ llil r1 l i~ i>1 L n Iii tJ,-:dju. a·1~ 1~~ ~ L 'liu.L~ r11 n ... ufilia t1 n1m 'VI1mfl~EJ.J ii fl 'II q

t],-:dju.~

2. n11Li OBEAs L~mt1~Gl:JJ1W9l.IU.1flntf11~'t11-\ln1rlf11~"llfl-\li-\ILL11ilia:u L'liu. rl'1 1

~LitnU.ftria-\IL flm'VIt'11 mL ~-\lEI clL U.t1113Jii\LLPI"l..fl"L 'n LL~~£1-\In17W9l.IU.1L ~rl.,lJ1-\ILL~-\IrlEJU. El1'il 'II 'II

Q..t l d ... I .~ ... t d ~ 1 .... ,J 1 .... 1

m:JJU.n'Yl EJ-\1 L 't1 m LL~:~9l.IU.1LL 'VI ~.J'Ylu.n 'YlEJ-\1 L 't1 rJ1L 'VIU. 71:unu.mn't1 Lilil11t117~91JU.1mm 1

3. l11l 'VI1~"1ifl:u~ Lfl rJ1nut11: lrJ"ll"U"l..EJ.Ji" LL11il i a:u·;nn:u:u:JJ el-\l"llfl-\I:JJU.'ltJ~"a1\l 'II q ~

th Ltl~lt11"n11W9l.IU.1 tlfutl1-\li-\l LL11ili EUJ L 'liu. ~1nnT"rLifllJtn:JJ~1iJ1L U.LLlitl1Li1~7::rJ1 'II ~ 'II

'VI1a~'t iflL'Hl-\ILLLiU.LLLilJ 'Yi1L iL nlil lm-\ln17EJU. i'nHLLli1i1Li1~7:: rl1'VI1£1 lfl7-\ln171Ji'Ufl nl.f11W,i1 'II q, 1

LU.flt'IEJ-\ILLLiU.LLLilJ rl'1li TEAs fl1-;J~Ui1mttf11~tt1~;fu. LL~\11n OBEAs \l:-rh1i'Yl111Ji1 • q

tJ 7::"111 "lfll. 1 :JJ ~ ... ._, LLli tt 1 L i1~ 7: rl1 'VI1 EJ7:JJ t1 iii El" LLLiU. LLLilJ 113.1 J-\1 ~ iru \171 tJ :JJ1flJ i't111 :JJ 'II ., 'II

Ltl~ rJU.LLtl ~._,yt~;fu."ll a.J~LL~:n~u.'ll a-\ltl 111:JJii.Jt17::Lfl'Yl'll EJ-\11lt'11 LL~:ic;rftt 1~1-1 'l 1 U.LL 'VI &i-\IJ 1

,fu,'VI1al3.i

... 1 1 r..ol ... ... ..1 ... .I .. 4. OBEAs 3Ju7:: rJ"Jl'U.L:JJel<ilEJ-\In11-llEl:JJ~LnrJ1nlJ~iiln17u1:L:JJU.flnl.f11W"llfl-\l

'II ~

;-\ILL 11il i EJ:JJfiLLLilil-\1 L iL ~U.t111:JJ Lfl £.11 L ii fl-\J"llel-\ln17tJ~ i:JJWU.1f"l":::'VIi1-\I:JJ~1!tJnu ;-\ILL 1<illf EJ:JJ L oziu. "" 4, I ......... ,AI::.

n1711ilfl mn1~ L;.:{rJ-\1 (Sound) lil1-\l'il1nn1711il LLirJ-\1 Eln'Yln (Noise) L W'I1::fl mf11'WLLirJ-\IU.U. 1 •

...... tJ r A .. • .~~::~~ c~ A~ • • .J,J.., ..... ;.:{1 :JJ17t111illil1 £J a n7m LLiii::Lm a-1 :u EJ<il1-\l ') LL<il LLi£.1-\1 an'Yln LIJU.:JJiiiW'lt't11-\l LLi£.1-\I'YlL m.n'll a"nu

q

UflfliiiL u.~1U.fl11:JJ"ll"EllJ 1<ilntl,-:Li-\lfl1 u.mw~ ... " LLiil:n';ln,-,.:JJl U.Lif111::LL1<ilie:~:u si1"1liLi13J11n ~ q

92 PC 266

i'lli'l.n~1eYJ'il li~'1tJDtln1m'VI1mf1~a-,iia1'il 'J L ~11::LitJ..17::<iiuL~tJ'1nU.D1llJanrin t.hi1mru 1 J ~

LhwiiJU1\Jf1U. LL~U1~..1'V'l D \';! Lhwi'UU1\Jfl1.1. l~

5. Li OBEAs Lvimuu.m1L'im1:1.l'lLLTif1m::'Yi1\11U.LU."111'1::Ln'ilam.n.fu.GJ L".!tU. 'U

~-;l'ilm1"'1"""n UflL'nn,-1wu1U.Wnf1W"1l'11 U71runfn,;iD.:J"3J'il "i El1llJfl'il"hlilu.iif111:JJ"i'l.u. 'U • • • 'U

L~El-,1 §-, 011.1.1 tlfl 1111 "::lil1 n~1..1 G) ~'II u.-;)'11;}'1.1. LL~::,)'il'YI n El ti1..1~'V'l'lEl1l LLa1 LL~ El1';1 l3J L 'V\111:: "11 • 'VI1a11ld]u.~~El\Jn11"lJEl..1~1iu7m,-nl~ L".!tu. ~1iia-,"3J'i'IEl1llJfl'll11 LLiH"i1\J m "'~~~'i'IU.,r\1

'U 'U • •

Ei1u.'VI1!-:~HmJ.:Jl3.ia-"h\J~a "llm::~u,.,-m1fn,;ti'ili1'ilu. L~'ll'il1\JL~l ia-11-:JL Vi tJ\J'V'l mLa1Til.~ ci\Jt.fwu t111~llJ1n OBEAs llJ::'Yi1L if1m::'Yi1\111.1.911111mi'llu1n11~1\J ')i1'1-L§\JLL11ili' El11L i

'U

REl~tfl a D\JrllJ fl1111 i D\J n11"ll El\J ~L "lfuim1 L 'I-Ln11U1:: Liiu.i\1 LL 11ili' 83.1 LLlJU OBEAs fl11thit-:~n\J 'U

~ ' \'ltl.r "\J'i'IEl ~ u. (Zube, 1984)

5.1 fl11LUU.~L~tJ1'1f1lliLU.n11U1::Lii'I-Lf1UL111~i\JLL1'ilaEJ11sit\1~1'1-Ln11~m.Ju. 'U ~ •

L1lvn::i1u. L".!tu. 1t'n1U.tl1Riilf 1!nai.:Jvni11'Yif~r.i "mtlitni1u.11iint1u 1t11n1"i 'U

AIJA • o .j t;-..

5.2 LL\1.1fl'il'i11Wll'iln1tJ111'V'l (Psychophysical Paradigm) LntJ1"lJEl\JnUn11

L~Elnf1UI."111J~ ~1-~ ')"ll El..'l "1111:: LL 1'ila El3Jt.fU.L fJ El'll1 ltll"lft 'I-Ln111itllJQ£lfl Ul.111~"ll El\1 i.:~LL 1'ila 811 1 ,

1'11m~a11~UI."3JlJ~"lJEl\Ji\1~1..1 ') L'I-LR1111::LL1'11iEl11LU'I-Li1nTV\'I-L'il 'VI1aii a1\1.1';1 l u.nT1'Yi1U.1 tJ

flUI.111'V'l"ll El\1 i\ILL1'ila El3Jmnn111Jflfl~ i-:~t.fu. L \1.1:: r.J::LL 1n El1';1~ El.J L ilJflfl~ L fJ ElL iLUU.~ii1'VIU.'il • , • 'U

11"m"3Ju~1'~~v.1aa::hi" Lnlila El3J~R1m,.r~l iLfl'1-Li1'Yi1u. 1£Jflm111'V'l1~ Ld El li"ma-11u'1i 1 , •

L'VI~1ilLLi11lliim13J-;l1LUU.~El"li~i.:JLnlil£in LWn::913.117nli'Lfl~El"3ja,br.~thu.1mL~ 'U

5.3 m::U1'1-Lm1ffllil (Cognitive Paradigm) lu.m7ti1::Lii'I-Li.JLL1'ili'El11LLtJU 'U

OBEAs t.fu. Uflfl ~":: 1 in7::U1U.m1'ffilil'VIa1n'VI a1 £1 Elth..1 1 u.m'l1itllJur.J"li El3J~U1\Jfl{,m,.,.13J • 'U 'U

A .... A ~ t-' ., ..... All 1 'lo' A

LL U. 1fl'il'i11\l.';l'iln1 £1111~ LL~::n1::1J1\I.n111fllilL"lJ1'111 tJn'I-L L 1tJfi11 'i11'1-L'V'lt']liln1"13J 'U

5.4 LLu.1fi'IILi.Jl17::"um7m'V11El3J'I-L1~HJittJ3J (Humanistic or experiential , ... ..! tl .. 1 ...... "'l"'tl ... . approach) -;J::L'I-L'I-L'Yin1'l 1::L3J'I-L 'ilti~R..'!Ln'il'YI '1f 1::"Un11UI.R1U.Iii'I-L (Phenomenological

'U

approach) L ".!tu. 1 itl,-::"um7mL'f1u.'il'!-L 'l u.m,-1it-;Ju£Jm13J\113J'V17Elfl113J'V1111 tJ'YI1\Ii1fl3J ~"~ 'U

U1::LiiU.lll::lifum1~n~'!-L3.11LUU.~LtlM .I .,. .,: " 1 ' .ol "' .ol U .. "" 5.4 nT'Ju1::L3J\1.9\ILL11ila El3J ~WlJflfl allJ::U.1L '15Elfl El L3.1El~fln11 1::L11'1-L3J • ..._ .... ...

flm"3JU'il 4 ~nMm:: f!El , iifl113JL ~ tJ\1 (Reliability) .. :JJf1113J'i11..1 (Validity) .. 11fl113Jfl1'Ell.Jfla3J (Generalizability) , ii El11mh:: 1v'1fu (Utility)

PC 266 93

fl113JL ff£J\I 'V\3J1£Jn\l n111U';JU£JfHll.111~i..1LL1Cilifi3J LL~~:fl~£im~ 1niLfl£J\Irlll. LL~~~ q

m11J1::Liill. .yffl._,.yfd:1,1i,)1Lflw;i B\lnni D-.1 fi1';Jt:i~~~1Cil li 'IJ

m13JCil1\l htm1111::Liiui.., LnCili aaJ 'VIm r.~fi..1 m1aJnn<il D..1Cil13J m1aJi t~\lm1 -i1..1f1113J 'IJ

.!'l .d "".1 ... "iJ .. ., ..1 ., .... ..: ., .d Cil'l\1 Lu'!.l.L 1fi\I'Yiu1:L3Jll.£J1n L ~71:~ 1:L3JWil El\I'YI111Jfl tll.111~'YI LL 'YI';J1..1"1J El-.1 "\ILL 1Cil~fi3J L ~ fl';)::

'IJ q

1J1::Liiu li11i\l LL1CiliD3J,fll.£iflmn1'WCil7..1L Vi r.J\11Cil q

fl113Jf11El1Jfl~3J 'V13J1r.Ji1\l ~~m7th:Liiui\l LL1Cil iaaJ,f '""13J111:1'1l 1 ~ ~ 1uu7::r.JnCil1 i1. u , , ..: ., "' At ....... ... ..,., ... 1"'"iJ ... • .I ... "..1 LL1Cil~ fi3J flU') 'V\1fl Cil tl~ "\ILnCilflUEI'!.l. ') L<il f:l1L 11 'VI~ 7::L3J'!.l. 'YI1n11u7:L3J'!.l."1\l."1tr11tll.::

'IJ 'IJ

LLv;\IL~ m ~ D3J 11i"1m7n'll1~~ tuu1:r.~ n~nu "1'1-l.Li1tr11m:~u ') 1c;i uan';J1n"1ll."1tr17tu.:'Yin q q

LL v; \1 iii n~m: L 'VI !i El '1-l. nu 'VIi au 7: L ii '"t <;} r.J 't ,r f1 un ~ 3JL ~ tl1 L "Jill. 1 ~L i1'VI "1 ff fl 'YI r.J1 "LUll.~ , , 'IJ

th::Liiuth t~vfn LL13J ~ ~.yftiaJ1 ~ El3J 11i "13J11f:l117:r.~n~ "1f"Linum7th::Liiu"ll El-:I~L "li1 'l -Ku~m1 , 'IJ

I .... A A ,¥ \1"' f11ti'WnLL13J L 'W11::';J::LnCilf1113J~Cil'W~1Cil"llll. L~

E111nl11:: 1t~"1fu 'VIm t~ii\l m1'1l 1~~m1u1::Liiu 1111 i1. '!.l.n'l711-:lll. ttJu1 r.~'VIiElm71Jiju1i

n11U1::Liill.i,m 1Cili fi3J fl1';)£ifl113JCil1\l fl~ au fl~3J LL~Lli £iu1dr.J"1fUnLi L '!iu OBEAs if i1 "1i't1 , 'VIi a 11i "eJCilfli fl\lnuth::L~" ~Li]-uu .... ru'V\1 ~tl".i:Lii-uril1i"1m1mt 1~ ~ 1111-tli

.. 'IJ

... ... ..1 n';Jm111n11L1£.Jll.'YI 3

';}\JL~aJth 1-u'!ia\!11..1

.I "" ..1 .... ' .... .t 1. Lf11n u1:L3Jll."tl1\l.'YI';J1n~n~tu.::Cil1\l ') Cil-3\l.

1.1 .................................................................................................. .

1.2 .................................................................................................. .

1.3 .................................................................................................. .

2. m11J1::Liiui.:~ LL 1Cil i El3J';J1ni n 1tm:: "m-u .yf~1\1';!1nnTlU1::Lii-u';J1nm13Jtl1::Yi'u L';J

1 ....................................................................................... ..

2 ........................................................................................ ..

3 ........................................................................................ ..

3. TEAs 'V\3J1tln\l ................................................................................... .

"""" ... - '.., 4. OBEAs 'YICilfl113Jfltll."3J1JCilfltl1..1 L1 ........................................................... . ,

94 PC 266

1. fl11th::Lilui\1Ln~ifa:u ii 2 tfn1!tm:: tia fl111h::Lilui\ILL1~ifm.l"il1flfl11:U th::l'lul;nhu~u (environmental appraisal) LL~::n111h::Liiui\ILL1Cilift~:u-;J1nan1!tm::"llfl\l ~rnw~ (environmental assessments)

2. fl111h::LiJUi\ILL1~ ift~:IJ-;J1flfl11:U1h::l'fu L-;J ~1U~U £i 6 afl1!tW.::ti u f1111J11EJ1 r.J

fl111.h::LilU fi111U-;JUtlfl11:U\11:U B11:U ru m1:u ilfl'ru LLa::flmfi1VI1t~-;J1nL-;J~fl~~ ai\ILL1 ~ifu:u "' .

fi111J11 tl1 t1 'VIi u fl1 1'W 11W.U 1 L U U fl11th:: d:h.ti\1 LL 1 ~a B :IJ 1~ ttL'lf

~1f!mi-wrffi~1\l"li1:u h~oil~~~" ') • 'IJ

fl11th:: Liiui\1 LL 1~ If a :IJ 3Jn dj Ufl111.h:: dJUfl'l1 :IJ"!fBlJ ~lJ flfl a ij~ B • i\1 LL 1~ If u :usS\ItJ-;J-;1 f.J~1UlJ flfl ~ LL~::tJ ... -;JitJYI1\I fl1 f.J1l1'W £i~YI iow~ L "'lJflfl ~ • • "1Hl1J~\ILL1~ifu:U~1-'!fl'U

m11it';Jur.Jm1:U\11:Utfuifuacinu fl11:U'V1~1fi'V1~1tJ m1:ULLtl~nl'VIaJ m1:u 'IJ

laJ~B~flifl\1 LLfl::fl11:U'\.i.lti1::VI~1~h"llB\Ifl\lf'ftJ1::flfl1J~h.,'J ') LU

~.cl I IS' .... A -... • -....

Yin ~mwn :u e-J ~ ~ mn1:um fl11:U1~n"ll B\IUfl fl ~ 1::C~~U'V11fl ~n1!tm::"ll fl \1 • 'IJ •

tr'd A .d"' I..... 1 "' ~ "' v11:u m 'Yl L fl<il"llUu vnu m1 :u-w u "LL!il::fl11!1nn1::~u "'n ~" LL 1~~ a:u

'IJ 'IJ •

;_, LL 1~ ia:u £ifl11 :U i1tfru~ ulJflfl f!L ui1Ufl11:1Je-Jfl ~'U fl11iB~11LLfl:: "' • 'IJ

1~ !1tl1::~\lfl • flW.fi1"ll fl\1 ~.,') LL 1~lf B :u~£i ~ BlJ fl fl ~~fl1!t1 li-;Jifl L ';)Cit fl~ ~ B ~.,') LL1<il i fl :IJ"ll tl\1 • • lJflfl~ •

3. fl11ti1::L iJui\1 LL1~ i u :IJ ';11 flafl1!tW.::"lJ fl\1 ~!11Wrf fl1';Jti1::LiJU-;J1fl an1!tW.::'Yl1.,'J

fi1Wl1'W Wli:IJVdinfiVIGlltl"lJEJ.,')i.,'J~I-1 ') LU~1l1'WLL1~ifu:u an1!tm::"lJEJ\I~mu~ -wq~fi11:1J~ A .ef Q..l td. "'

Lfl<il"ll'U LL~::U11tllfl1f'IYI1.,'J~\Ifl:IJ"ll fl\1~\1 LL1~~ fl:IJ

4. m1t11::Lilui\1Ln~aa:u";J1flfl11:Utl1::l'lul';l~1:u<ilu LL~::-;nntfn1!tm::~mu~iim1:u LL<ilfl~l\lfl'U LUii'U';l<ilLUU ~ti1::LiJU tl1::1tt"11l1~lifuLL~::Lfl~fl-'liit~fh"lf

• 'IJ

...~ .. dtn t1 ... ~ ... .... d.. · .. 5. Lfl1tl\1:1Jtl'Yl "!f Ufl11 1::L:IJ'U~\ILL1~~tl:IJ';J1fl~fl~nl.::"llfl\1Llt'l1'UYI :IJ 2 tltll\1 fltl

PC 266 95

. ... mmllm m.m

• ' 111 .l..t ';J-.1~Hl1Jflltl1ll~fl ~uu

1. n11U7::L~Ui-.1 LL 1~Lf flll';J1nm1llU7::nu h "1U~Wih-.1-;J1nn17U7::L~U~">1 LL1~m fill "' ..1 ' 111

-;nn~m~rn::'llfl-.1tnnu'Ylatn-.1 L,. 2. l ~U'l::L~ui-, LL 1~Lf flll'll fl">1 ll'Vnim.n;tl71llt11 LL'VI-.1';11nfl11llU'l::nu l';J "1U~U'llfi.J

... .. un~m~1

3. iiu"';J,r EJ 'l~u,..,fi ii ~ ~~ em1'lu7::Lijum1ll"ll"au~ a Rrnu ~'ll a.:~ u flfl~ ~

96 PC 266