SUGGESTED ANSWERS TO BAR EXAMINATIONIN

FORWARDThis work is not intended for sale or commerce. This work is freeware. It may be freely copied and distributed. It is primarily intended for all those who desire to have a deeper understanding of the issues touched by the Philippine Bar Examinations and its trend.

It is specially intended for law students from the provinces who, very often, are recipients of deliberately distorted notes from other

POLITICAL LAWARRANGED BY TOPIC

unscrupulous law schools and students. Share to others this work and you will be richly rewarded by God in heaven. It is also very We would like to seek the indulgence of the reader for some Bar good karma.

(1987 2006)Edited and Arranged by:

Questions which are improperly classified under a topic and for some topics which are improperly or ignorantly phrased, for the authors are just

reviewing for the Bar Exams under time constraints and within their

Atty. Janette LagguiIcao and have Alex Bar Reviewees whoAtty. prepared this (Silliman University College of Andrew P. 2005 Law)July 26, Icaoby: April 19, 2007

work while

Updated limited knowledge of the law. We would like to seek the readers

Romualdo L. Seeris II, LLB. indulgence for a lot of typographical errors in this work.The Authors

From the ANSWERS TO BAR EXAMINATION QUESTIONSin POLITICAL LAW by theUP LAW COMPLEX and PHILIPPINE ASSOCIATION OF LAW SCHOOLS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1987 CONSTITUTION OF THE PHILIPPINES ................................................................... 14 Phil Con 87; New Features (1991)..................................................................................... 14 Phil Con 87; People Power (1987)..................................................................................... 14 Phil Con 87; People Power (2000)..................................................................................... 15 Phil Con 87; People Power (2003)..................................................................................... 15 Nature of the Constitution: Constitutional Supremacy (2004) ....................................... 15 Government Presidential Form vs. Parliamentary Form (Q6-2006)............................. 15 ARTICLE I National Territory........................................................................................... 16 Archipelagic Doctrine (1989)............................................................................................... 16 Contiguous Zone vs. Exclusive Economic Zone (2004)................................................. 16 Exclusive Economic Zone; Rights of the Coastal State (1994)..................................... 16 Exclusive Economic Zone; Rights of the Coastal State (Q1-2005) .............................. 17 Flag State vs. Flag of Convenience (2004) ...................................................................... 17 Territory & Government (1996)........................................................................................... 17 Territorial Sea vs. Internal Waters (2004)......................................................................... 17 ARTICLE II Declaration of Principles and State Policies.......................................... 18 Armed Forces; Servant of the People (2003)................................................................... 18 Doctrine of Incorporation; Constitutional Law (1997)...................................................... 18 Doctrine of Incorporation; Pacta Sunt Servanda (2000)................................................. 18 Freedom from Nuclear Weapons; Foreign Military Bases (1988)................................. 18 Philippine Flag (Q42006).................................................................................................... 19 Principle of Civilian Supremacy (Q6-2006)....................................................................... 19 State Immunity from Suit (1991)......................................................................................... 19 State Immunity from Suit (1996)......................................................................................... 20 State Immunity from Suit (1989)........................................................................................ 20 State Immunity from Suit (1994)......................................................................................... 21 State Immunity from Suit (1992)......................................................................................... 21 State Immunity from Suit (1999)......................................................................................... 22 State Immunity from Suit (1999)......................................................................................... 22 State Immunity from Suit (1987)......................................................................................... 22 State Immunity vs. Waiver of Immunity (1997) ................................................................ 22 State Immunity from Suit (1993)......................................................................................... 23 State Principles & Policies (1994)...................................................................................... 23 Transparency; Matters of Public Interest (1989).............................................................. 24 Transparency; Matters of Public Interest (2000).............................................................. 25 ARTICLE III Bill of Rights ................................................................................................... 25 Bill of Attainder (1987).......................................................................................................... 25 Bill of Attainder (1990).......................................................................................................... 26 Custodial Investigation; Extrajudicial Confession (2001) ............................................... 26 Custodial Investigation; Extrajudicial Confession; Police Line-Up (1994) ................... 26 Custodial Investigation; Police Line-Up (1997)................................................................ 27 Custodial Investigation; Right to Counsel (1988) ............................................................ 27 Custodial Investigation; Right to Counsel (1993) ............................................................ 27 Custodial Investigation; Right to Counsel (2000) ............................................................ 28 Custodial Investigation; Right to Counsel; Receipt of Property Seized (2002)........... 28 Custodial Investigation; Rights (1990)............................................................................... 29 Custodial Investigation; Rights (1993)............................................................................... 29 Custodial Investigation; Rights (1996)............................................................................... 30

Double Jeopardy (1988) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (1993) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (1997) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (1999) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (1999) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (2000) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (2001) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy (2002) ...................................................................................................... Double Jeopardy; Requisites (1999) ................................................................................. Due Process; Absence of Denial (1999)........................................................................... Due Process; Deportation (1994)....................................................................................... Due Process; Forfeiture Proceedings (1993)................................................................... Due Process; Media Coverage during Hearing (1996)................................................... Due Process; Meeting vs. Hearing (1999)........................................................................ Due Process; Notice by Publication (1988)...................................................................... Due Process; Permit to Carry Firearm Outside Residence (Q6-2006)........................ Due Process; PPA-Pilots (2001) ........................................................................................ Due Process; Procedural vs. Substantive (1999)............................................................ Due Process; Provisional Order (1991) ............................................................................ Due Process; Public School Teachers (2002) ................................................................. Due Process; Radio Station (1987) ................................................................................... Due Process; Represented by a Non-Lawyer (1988) ..................................................... Due Process; Substantive (2003) ...................................................................................... Due Process; Suspension of Driver's License (1992)..................................................... Due Process; Urgent Public Need (1987)......................................................................... Eminent Domain; Garnishment (1994).............................................................................. Eminent Domain; Garnishment (1998).............................................................................. Eminent Domain; immunity from suit (2001) .................................................................... Eminent Domain; Indirect Public Benefit (1990).............................................................. Eminent Domain; Just Compensation (1988) .................................................................. Eminent Domain; Just Compensation (1989) .................................................................. Eminent Domain; Just Compensation (1998) .................................................................. Eminent Domain; Legal Interest (1993) ............................................................................ Eminent Domain; Non-observance of the policy of "all or none" (2000)...................... Eminent Domain; Power to Exercise (2005) .................................................................... Eminent Domain; Public Use (1987).................................................................................. Eminent Domain; Socialized Housing (1996)................................................................... Eminent Domain; Writ of Possession (1993).................................................................... Equal Protection; Alien Employment (1989)..................................................................... Equal Protection; Invidious Discrimination (1987)........................................................... Equal Protection; Invidious Discrimination (1987)........................................................... Equal Protection; Police Power (2000).............................................................................. Equal Protection; Right to Education (1994) .................................................................... Equal Protection; Subsidiary Imprisonment (1989)......................................................... Freedom of Expression; Censorship (2003)..................................................................... Freedom of Expression; Prior Restraint (1988) ............................................................... Freedom of Religion; Convicted Prisoners (1989) .......................................................... Freedom of Religion; Flag Salute (1997).......................................................................... Freedom of Religion; Flag Salute (2003).......................................................................... Freedom of Religion; Non-Establishment Clause (1988)............................................... Freedom of Religion; Non-Establishment Clause (1992)............................................... 48BAR Q&A (as arranged by Topics) POLITICAL LAW (1987-2006)

30 31 31 32 32 32 32 33 33 33 34 35 35 35 35 36 36 37 37 37 38 38 38 38 39 39 40 40 40 40 41 41 41 42 42 42 43 43 44 44 45 45 45 45 46 46 46 47 48 48

Freedom of Religion; Non-Establishment Clause (1997)............................................... 49 Freedom of Speech; Ban on Tobacco AD (1992) ........................................................... 49 Freedom of the Press; Actual Malice (2004).................................................................... 50 Freedom of the Press; Wartime Censorship (1987)........................................................ 50 Impairment Clause; Basic Human Rights (1992) ............................................................ 51 Involuntary Servitude (1993)............................................................................................... 51 Liberty of Abode; Limitations (1998).................................................................................. 51 Liberty of Abode; Temporary (1996).................................................................................. 52 Non-Imprisonment for Non-Payment of Debt (1993) ...................................................... 52 Police Power; Abatement of Nuisance (2004) ................................................................. 52 Police Power; Ban on Tobacco AD (1992) ....................................................................... 52 Police Power; Zoning Ordinance vs. Non-Impairment of Contracts (1989) ................ 53 Police Power; Zoning Ordinance vs. Non-Impairment of Contracts (2001) ................ 53 Privacy of Communication (2001)...................................................................................... 53 Privacy of Correspondence (1998) .................................................................................... 54 Privacy of Correspondence; Jail (1989)............................................................................ 54 Right to Assembly; Permit Application; Freedom Parks (Q2-2006).............................. 54 Right to Assembly; Permit Requirements (1992) ........................................................... 55 Right to Assembly; Public Teachers (2000) ..................................................................... 55 Right to Assembly; Public Teachers (2002) ..................................................................... 56 Right to Travel; Order of Arrest (1991).............................................................................. 56 Rights of the Accused; Counsel of his Choice (Q8-2005).............................................. 56 Rights of the Accused; Presumption of Innocence vs. Presumption of Theft (2004) 57 Rights of the Accused; Right to Bail (1993)...................................................................... 57 Rights of the Accused; Right to Bail; Capital Offense (Q4-2006) ................................. 58 Rights of the Accused; Right to Bail; Deportation Case (1989) .................................... 58 Rights of the Accused; Right to Bail; Matter of Right or a Matter of Discretion (Q72005)....................................................................................................................................... 58 Rights of the Accused; Right to Speedy Trial (2000)...................................................... 59 Rights of the Accused; Self-Incrimination (1988) ............................................................ 59 Rights of the Accused; Self-Incrimination (1990) ............................................................ 59 Rights of the Accused; Self-Incrimination (1992) ............................................................ 60 Rights of the Accused; Self-Incrimination (2000) ............................................................ 60 Rights of the Accused; Self-Incrimination (Q7-2006)...................................................... 61 Searches and Seizure; Private Individuals (Q8-2005)................................................... 61 Searches and Seizures; Aliens (2001).............................................................................. 61 Searches and Seizures; Breathalyzer Test (1992).......................................................... 62 Searches and Seizures; Immediate Control (1987) ........................................................ 62 Searches and Seizures; Incidental to Valid Search (1990) ........................................... 62 Searches and Seizures; Place of Search (2001)............................................................. 63 Searches and Seizures; search made by a private citizen (1993)................................ 63 Searches and Seizures; search made by a private citizen (2002)................................ 64 Searches and Seizures; Valid Warrantless Search (2000)............................................ 64 Searches and Seizures; Visual Search (1992) ................................................................ 65 Searches and Seizures; Waiver of Consent (1989)........................................................ 65 Searches and Seizures; Warrantless Arrests (1993)...................................................... 66 Searches and Seizures; Warrants of Arrest (1991) ........................................................ 66 ARTICLE IV Citizenship ..................................................................................................... 66 Action for Cancellation; Prescription & Effect of Death (1994)...................................... 66 Citizenship; Elected Official (1993).................................................................................... 67 Dual Allegiance vs. Dual Citizenship (1987) .................................................................... 67BAR Q&A (as arranged by Topics) POLITICAL LAW (1987-2006)

Dual Allegiance vs. Dual Citizenship (1988) .................................................................... 68 Dual Citizenship (1994)........................................................................................................ 68 Effect of Marriage; Filipino (1989)..................................................................................... 69 Effect of Oath of Allegiance (2004).................................................................................... 69 Effect of Repatriation (1999) ............................................................................................... 70 Effect of Repatriation (2002) ............................................................................................... 70 Effect of Repatriation (2003) ............................................................................................... 70 Effects of Marriages (1999)................................................................................................. 70 Effects of Philippine Bill of 1902 (2001) ............................................................................ 71 Elected Official (1992).......................................................................................................... 71 Electing Philippine Citizenship (Q8-2006) ........................................................................ 71 Electing Philippine Citizenship; When Proper (Q8-2006)............................................... 72 Natural Born Filipino (1989) ................................................................................................ 72 Natural Born Filipino (1998) ................................................................................................ 72 Natural-Born Filipino(1993) ................................................................................................. 73 Naturalization; Cancellation of Citizenship (1998)........................................................... 73 Residency Requirements; Elective Official (Q9-2005).................................................... 73 Status; Illegitimate Child (1990).......................................................................................... 74 Status; Illegitimate Child; Dual Citizenship (1996) .......................................................... 74 Status; Legitimate Child (2003) .......................................................................................... 74 Ways of Reacquiring Citizenship (2000)........................................................................... 75 ARTICLE VI Legislative Department .............................................................................. 75 Appropriation of Public Funds (1988)................................................................................ 75 Appropriation of Public Funds; Debt Servicing (1992).................................................... 75 Appropriation of Public Funds; Public Purposes (1988)................................................. 75 Commission on Appointments (2002) ............................................................................... 76 Delegation of Powers (2002) .............................................................................................. 76 Delegation of Powers; (Q6-2005)....................................................................................... 76 Delegation of Powers; Completeness Test; Sufficient Standard Test (Q6-2005) ...... 77 Discipline; Modes of Removal (1993)............................................................................... 77 Discipline; Suspension of a Member of the Congress (2002) ....................................... 77 Elected Official; De Facto Officer (2004) .......................................................................... 78 Electoral Tribunal; HRET Members Right & Responsibilities (2002) .......................... 78 Electoral Tribunal; Senate; Jurisdiction (1990) ................................................................ 79 Foreign Affairs; Role of House of Rep (1996).................................................................. 79 Foreign Affairs; Role of Senate (1994).............................................................................. 79 Investigations in Aid of Legislation (1992) ........................................................................ 79 Law Making; Process & Publication (1993)...................................................................... 80 LawMaking; Appropriation Bill (1996) .............................................................................. 80 LawMaking; Appropriation Law; Automatic Renewal & Power of Augmentation (1998)...................................................................................................................................... 80 LawMaking; Appropriation Law; Rider Provision (2001) ............................................... 81 LawMaking; Foreign Affairs; Treaties (1996).................................................................. 81 LawMaking; Overriding the Presidential Veto (1991) .................................................... 81 LawMaking; Passage of a Law (1988)............................................................................. 82 Legislative Power; Pres. Aquinos Time (1990) ............................................................... 82 Legislative Powers (1989) ................................................................................................... 82 Loans Extended to Members of Congress (1991)........................................................... 82 Multi-Party System (1999)................................................................................................... 83 Non-Legislative Powers (1988) .......................................................................................... 83 Non-Legislative Powers; Emergency Powers; Requisites (1997)................................. 83BAR Q&A (as arranged by Topics) POLITICAL LAW (1987-2006)

Prohibitions and Inhibitions of Public Office (2004)......................................................... 83 Qualifications; Congressmen (1988) ................................................................................. 84 Qualifications; Congressmen; (1993) ................................................................................ 84 Qualifications; Congressmen; (1999) ................................................................................ 85 Separation of Powers (1988) .............................................................................................. 85 Separation of Powers (2003) .............................................................................................. 85 Three-Term Limit: Congressmen (1996)........................................................................... 86 Three-Term Limit; Congressmen (2001)........................................................................... 86 ARTICLE VII Executive Department ................................................................................ 86 Appointing Power; Acting vs. Permanent Appointment (2003) ..................................... 86 Appointing Power; ad interim appointments (1991) ........................................................ 86 Appointing Power; Ad Interim Appointments (1994) ....................................................... 87 Appointing Power; Appointments Requiring Confirmation; RA 6975-Unconstitutional (2002)...................................................................................................................................... 87 Appointing Power; Categories of Officials (1999)............................................................ 88 Appointing Power; Kinds of Appointments (1994)........................................................... 88 Appointing Power; Limitations on Presidential Appointments (1997)........................... 89 Appointing Powers; Ad Interim Appointments (Q4-2005) .............................................. 90 Cabinet Members; limitation on accepting additional duties (1996) ............................. 90 Calling-out Power; President (Q1-2006) ........................................................................... 91 Declaration; State of Calamity; Legal Effects (Q1-2005)................................................ 91 Declaration; State of National Emergency (Q1-2006) .................................................... 91 Enter into Contract or Guarantee Foreign Loans (1994)................................................ 91 Enter into Contract or Guarantee Foreign Loans (1999)................................................ 92 Enter into Executive Agreements (2003) .......................................................................... 92 Impose Tariff Rates, Import and Export Quotas (1999).................................................. 92 Martial Law & Suspension of Writ of Habeas Corpus (1987) ........................................ 92 Martial Law; Limitations (2000).......................................................................................... 93 Martial Law; Sufficiency of the Factual Basis (Q3-2006)................................................ 94 Pardoning Power; Amnesty (1993).................................................................................... 95 Pardoning Power; Amnesty (1995).................................................................................... 95 Pardoning Power; Breach of Condition; Revocation (Q5-2005).................................... 95 Pardoning Power; Exec Clemency; Pardon (1995)......................................................... 95 Pardoning Power; Executive Clemency (1997) ............................................................... 96 Pardoning Power; Executive Clemency (1999) ............................................................... 96 Pardoning Power; Kinds (1988).......................................................................................... 96 Pardoning Power; Pardon, Conditional (1997) ................................................................ 97 President; Participation; Legislative Process (1996)....................................................... 97 Presidential Immunity from Suit (1997) ............................................................................. 97 Prohibition Against Multiple Positions & Additional Compensation (2002) ................. 97 Prohibition against Multiple Positions by Govt Officials (1987) .................................... 98 Suspension of Writ of Habeas Corpus (1997).................................................................. 99 ARTICLE VIII Judicial Department .................................................................................... 99 Cases to be Heard En Banc; Supreme Court (1999)...................................................... 99 Contempt Powers (1996)..................................................................................................... 99 Finality of Void Judgments (1993)...................................................................................... 99 Fiscal Autonomy (1999)..................................................................................................... 100 Function; Continuing Constitutional Convention (2000) ............................................... 100 Issuance of Restraining Orders and Injunctions (1992) ............................................... 100 Judicial & Bar Council (1988)............................................................................................ 101 Judicial & Bar Council (1999)............................................................................................ 101BAR Q&A (as arranged by Topics) POLITICAL LAW (1987-2006)

Judicial Department; Writ of Amparo (1991) .................................................................. 101 Judicial Independence; Safeguard (2000)...................................................................... 101 Judicial Power (1989)......................................................................................................... 102 Judicial Power (1992)......................................................................................................... 102 Judicial Power (1998)......................................................................................................... 103 Judicial Power; Scope (1994) ........................................................................................... 103 Judicial Review; Locus Standi (1992).............................................................................. 104 Judicial Review; Requisites (1994).................................................................................. 104 Jurisdiction of HLURB (1993) ........................................................................................... 104 Mandatory Period For Deciding Cases (1989)............................................................... 105 Political Question (1995).................................................................................................... 105 Political Question Doctrine (1997).................................................................................... 105 Political Question: Separation of Powers (2004) ........................................................... 106 Political Question; To Settle Actual Controversies (2004) ........................................... 106 Political Questions (1988).................................................................................................. 106 Pro Hac Vice Cases (1999)............................................................................................... 107 Removal of Lower Court Judges (1993) ......................................................................... 107 Review Executive Acts (1996).......................................................................................... 107 Supervision; Courts & its Personnel (Q5-2005)............................................................. 108 Taxpayer's Suit; Locus Standi (1995).............................................................................. 108 Term of Office; Justices (1996) ........................................................................................ 108 Votes required for declaring a law unconstitutional (1996).......................................... 109 ARTICLE IX Constitutional Commissions .................................................................. 109 Rotational Scheme (1999)................................................................................................. 109 Constitutional Commissions & Council (Q7-2006) ........................................................ 109 ARTICLE IX Civil Service Commission........................................................................ 109 Career Service; Characteristics (1999) ........................................................................... 109 Civil Service Commission vs. COA (2004) ..................................................................... 109 Function of CSC (1994) ..................................................................................................... 110 GOCCs Without Original Charter vs. GOCCs With Original Charter (1998)............. 110 Jurisdiction over the GOCCs (1999)................................................................................ 111 Jurisdiction over the GOCCs (2003)................................................................................ 111 Modes of Removal from Office (1993) ............................................................................ 111 Receiving of Indirect Compensation (1997) ................................................................... 111 Security of Tenure (1988).................................................................................................. 112 Security of Tenure (Q52005) ........................................................................................... 112 Security of Tenure; Meaning (1999) ................................................................................ 113 ARTICLE IX COMELEC .................................................................................................... 113 Electoral Tribunal; Functions & Composition (Q5-2006).............................................. 113 Fair Election; Equal Space & Time in Media (1989) ..................................................... 113 Grant of Pardon in Election Offenses (1991) ................................................................. 114 Judicial Review of Decisions (2001)................................................................................ 114 Removal from Office; Commissioners (1998) ................................................................ 114 Right to Vote; Jurisdiction (2001) ..................................................................................... 114 Election Laws ........................................................................................................................ 114 2nd Placer Rule (2003)..................................................................................................... 114 2nd Placer Rule (1990)...................................................................................................... 115 2nd Placer Rule; in Quo Warranto Cases (1992).......................................................... 115 2nd Placer Rule; Rule of Succession (1996) ................................................................ 115 Appreciation of Ballots (1994)........................................................................................... 116 Disqualification; Grounds (1991)...................................................................................... 116

Disualifications (1999)........................................................................................................ 116 Effect of Filing of Certificate of Candidacy; Appointive Officer vs Elective Officer (2002).................................................................................................................................... 116 Effect of Filing of Certificate of Candidacy; Fair Election Act (2003).......................... 117 Election Offenses; Conspiracy to Bribe Voters (1991) ................................................. 117 Election Protest (1990) ...................................................................................................... 117 Election Protest vs. Quo Warranto (2001)...................................................................... 118 Election Protest vs. Quo Warranto (Q5-2006) ............................................................... 118 Election Protest; Jurisdiction (1996) ................................................................................ 118 Expiration of term bars service thereof (2000)............................................................... 118 Petition to Declare Failure of Elections; Requisites & Effects (1995)......................... 118 Pre-Proclamation Contest (1987)..................................................................................... 119 Pre-Proclamation Contest (1988)..................................................................................... 119 Pre-Proclamation Contest vs. Election Contests (1997) .............................................. 120 Pre-Proclamation Contest; Proper Issues (1996).......................................................... 121 Process; Illiterate Voters (1987) ....................................................................................... 121 Process; Principle of Idem Sonans (1994) ..................................................................... 121 Process; Stray Ballot (1994) ............................................................................................. 121 Recall (2002) ....................................................................................................................... 122 Three-Term Limit Rule (2001) .......................................................................................... 122 Three-Term Limit; from Municipality to Newly-Created City (Q9-2005).................... 122 Vacancy; Effect of Vice-Mayor Acting As Mayor (2002)............................................... 123 Vacancy; Rule of Succession (1995)............................................................................... 123 Vacancy; SB; Rule on Succession (2002)...................................................................... 124 ARTICLE IX Commission on Audit ............................................................................... 124 COA; Jurisdiction (2001).................................................................................................... 124 COA; Money Claims (1998) .............................................................................................. 124 ARTICLE X Local Government ..................................................................................... 125 Appointment of Budget Officer; control vs supervision (1999) .................................... 125 Boundary Dispute Resolution; LGU; RTCs Jurisdiction (Q10-2005)........................ 126 Boundary Dispute Settlement; Authority; Jurisdiction (1999) ...................................... 126 Creation of New Local Government Units; Plebiscite Requirement (2004) .............. 126 De Facto Public Corporations; Effect (2004).................................................................. 126 Devolution of Power (1999)............................................................................................... 126 Franchise; prior approval of LGU necessary (1988) ..................................................... 126 Law fixing the terms of local elective officials (Q4-2006) ............................................. 127 Ordinance; Use & Lease of Properties; Public Use (1997).......................................... 127 Ordinance; Validity; Closure or Lease of Properties for Public Use (2003) .............. 127 Ordinance; Validity; Compensation; Tortuous Act of an Employee (1994) ............... 127 Ordinance; Validity; Local Taxation vs. Special Assessment (1987) ......................... 128 Ordinance; Validity; Preventing Immorality (1987) ........................................................ 128 Ordinance; Validity; Utilization & Development; National Wealth (1991) .................. 128 Ordinances; Validity; Amending Natl Laws (1988) ....................................................... 128 Ordinances; Validity; Gambling Prohibition (1995)........................................................ 129 Ordinances; Validity; Limitation of Penalties (1991) ..................................................... 129 Ordinances; Veto Power (1996) ....................................................................................... 129 Police Power; LLDA (1995)............................................................................................... 130 Power to Issue Subpoena & Cite For Contempt (1993) ............................................... 130 Power; Eminent Domain; LGU; Right to Exercise (Q10-2005).................................... 131 Powers of Barangay Assembly (2003)............................................................................ 131 Powers; Liga ng mga Barangay (2003)........................................................................... 131BAR Q&A (as arranged by Topics) POLITICAL LAW (1987-2006)

Requisites; Contracts Involving LGU (1991) .................................................................. 131 Requisites; Contracts involving LGU (1995) .................................................................. 132 Taxation; GOCC Liability For Real Estate Tax (1999).................................................. 132 Taxation; Sources of Revenue (1999)............................................................................. 132 Withdrawal of Public Property from Public Use (1990)................................................. 132 ARTICLE XI Accountability of Public Officers........................................................... 133 Abandonment of Office (2000).......................................................................................... 133 Discipline; Clemency; Doctrine of Condonation (2000)................................................ 133 Discipline; Effect of Pardon Granted in Favor of Public Officers (1999).................... 134 Discipline; Preventive Suspension & Appeal; entitlement to salary pendente (2001) ............................................................................................................................................... 134 Discipline; Preventive Suspension (1990) ...................................................................... 134 Discipline; Preventive Suspension (2002) ...................................................................... 135 Elective and Appointive Officials: disciplinary authority (2004) ................................... 135 Elective Public Officer; De Facto Officer (2000) ............................................................ 135 Elective Public Officers; De Facto Officer; effects (2004) ............................................ 136 Graft and Corruption; Prescription of Crime (2002) ...................................................... 136 Impeachment; Cronyism (2000) ....................................................................................... 137 Impeachment; Grounds (1999)......................................................................................... 137 Impeachment; Nature; Grounds; PD 1606 (1988)......................................................... 137 Law of Public Officers; Next-in-Rank Rule (1994)......................................................... 137 Liability For Damages in Performance of Official Functions (1990) ........................... 138 Local Elective Officials; Limitations On Additional Duties (1995) ............................... 139 Ombudsman: Power to Suspend; Preventive Suspension (2004) ............................. 139 Ombudsman; Power to Investigate (2003) ..................................................................... 139 Ombudsman; Power to Suspend; Preventive Suspension (1996) ............................. 140 Power to Issue Subpoena; validity of delegation (1989) .............................................. 140 Prohibition On Elective Officer to Hold Public Office (2002)........................................ 140 Public Office; Public Trust (1998)..................................................................................... 140 Retirement Benefits (1996) ............................................................................................... 141 ARTICLE XII National Economy and Patrimony......................................................... 142 Acquisition and Lease of Public Lands (1998)............................................................... 142 Acquisition of Lands (1987)............................................................................................... 142 Acquisition of Lands (2000)............................................................................................... 143 Acquisition of Lands by Hereditary Succession (2002) ................................................ 143 Acquisition of Lands; Citizenship issue (1989) .............................................................. 143 Acquisition of Lands; Citizenship issue (1994) .............................................................. 144 Acquisition of Lands; Citizenship issue (1995) .............................................................. 144 Acquisition of Lands; Prohibition; acquisition of private lands by aliens (1994) ....... 145 Citizenship Requirement in Management of Advertising Industry (1989) ................. 145 Engagement in Business & Exercise of Profession (1987).......................................... 145 Exploration and Development of Minerals (1994) ......................................................... 146 Expropriation of Public Utilities (1992) ............................................................................ 146 Lease of Private Agricultural Lands (2001) .................................................................... 146 National Economy & Patrimony; Constitutional Prohibition (2004)............................. 147 National Patrimony; definition (1999) .............................................................................. 147 Nationalized Activities (1994)............................................................................................ 147 Ownership Requirement of Mass Media (1989) ............................................................ 148 Chinese citizens; engaging in retail trade (Q4-2006).................................................... 148 Exploration, development, and utilization of natural resources (Q4-2006) ............... 148 ARTICLE XIII Social Justice and Human Rights ......................................................... 148

Agrarian Reform Law; Coverage (1992) ......................................................................... 148 Commission on Human Rights; Power to investigate (1992) ...................................... 149 Commission on Human Rights; Power to issue TRO (1997) ...................................... 149 Commission on Human Rights; Power to issue TRO (2001) ...................................... 149 Commission on Human Rights; Power; Limitations (Q4-2005)................................... 150 Labor; Right to Self-Organization (1988) ........................................................................ 151 Labor; Right to Strike (1988)............................................................................................. 151 Labor; Right to Strike (1993)............................................................................................. 151 Social Justice under the Present Constitution (1995)................................................... 152 Women (2000)..................................................................................................................... 152 ARTICLE XIV Education, Science and Technology, Arts ......................................... 153 Education; Academic Freedom (1987)............................................................................ 153 Education; Academic Freedom (1989)............................................................................ 153 Education; Academic Freedom (1993)............................................................................ 153 Education; Academic Freedom; Extent (1999) .............................................................. 154 Education; Alien Enrollees & Donors (1999).................................................................. 154 Education; Duties of State in Re Education (1999)....................................................... 154 Education; Flag Salute (1987) .......................................................................................... 155 Education; Right to Choose Profession (2000).............................................................. 155 Education; Right to Quality Education (2003) ................................................................ 156 Education; Teaching of Religion (1999).......................................................................... 156 Education; Validity of Academic Requirements (1994) ................................................ 156 ARTICLE XVI General Provisions .................................................................................. 156 General Provisions; Local Dialect (1987)........................................................................ 156 AFP; limitation on accepting additional duties (1996)................................................... 157 ARTICLE XVII Amendments or Revisions .................................................................... 157 Peoples Initiative (2004) ................................................................................................... 157 Amendments and Revisions; Modes (1997) .................................................................. 157 REFERENDUM vs. INITIATIVE (Q1-2005).................................................................... 157 ARTICLE XVIII Transitory Provisions.............................................................................. 158 Transitory Provisions; Foreign Military Bases (1996) ................................................... 158 Transitory Provisions; Foreign Military Bases (1988) ................................................... 158 PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW ........................................................................................ 158 Basic Principles in Public Intl Law (1991) ...................................................................... 158 Constitutive Theory vs. Declaratory Theory (2004)....................................................... 160 Contiguous Zone vs. Exclusive Economic Zone (2004).............................................. 160 Diplomatic Immunity (2000) .............................................................................................. 160 Diplomatic Immunity (2001) .............................................................................................. 160 Diplomatic Immunity (2003) .............................................................................................. 161 Diplomatic Immunity (2004) .............................................................................................. 161 Diplomatic Immunity; Ambassador (Q3-2005) ............................................................... 162 Diplomatic Immunity; Ambassadors (1990).................................................................... 162 Diplomatic Immunity; Coverage (Q3-2005) .................................................................... 163 Diplomatic Immunity; Diplomatic Envoy and Consular Officers (1995)...................... 164 Diplomatic Immunity; Diplomatic Envoy and Consular Officers (1997)...................... 165 Exclusive Economic Zone (2000)..................................................................................... 165 Executive Agreements; Binding Effect (2003)................................................................ 165 Extradition vs. Deportation (1993).................................................................................... 166 Extradition; Doctrine of Specialty (1993)......................................................................... 166 Extradition; Effectivity of treaty (1996)............................................................................. 166 Extradition; Grounds (2002).............................................................................................. 167

Extradition; Retroactive Application (Q2-2005).............................................................. 167 Flag State vs. Flag of Convenience (2004).................................................................. 168 Genocide (1988) ................................................................................................................. 168 Human Rights (1999) ......................................................................................................... 168 Human Rights; Civil and Political Rights (1992) ............................................................ 168 Human Rights; Civil and Political Rights (1996) ............................................................ 169 Intl Court of Justice; Jurisdiction Over States................................................................ 170 Intl Court of Justice; Jurisdiction Over States (1994)................................................... 170 Intl Court of Justice; Limitations On Jurisdiction (1999) .............................................. 170 Intl Court of Justice; Parties; Pleadings and Oral Argument (1994).......................... 170 International Convention; Law of the Sea (2004) .......................................................... 171 International Court of Justice (Q9-2006)......................................................................... 171 International Law vs. Municipal Law; Territorial Principle; International Crimes (Q22005)..................................................................................................................................... 171 Mandates and Trust Territories (2003)............................................................................ 172 Municipal Law vs. International Law (2003) ................................................................... 173 Neutrality of States (1988)................................................................................................. 173 Outer Space; Jurisdiction (2003)...................................................................................... 174 Principle of Auto-Limitation (Q10-2006).......................................................................... 174 Reciprocity v. Principle of Auto-Limitation (Q10-2006)................................................. 174 Recognition of States; De Facto vs. De Jure Recognition (1998) .............................. 174 Reparations Agreement; Validity (1992) ......................................................................... 175 Right to Innocent Passage (1999).................................................................................... 175 Right to Transit and Innocent Passage (2004) .............................................................. 176 Rights and Obligation under UN Charter (1991)............................................................ 176 Sources of International Law; Primary & Subsidiary Sources (2003) ........................ 177 Sovereign Immunity of States; Absolute vs. Restrictive (1998) .................................. 177 Sovereignty of States; Natural Use of Territory (1989)................................................. 178 Sovereignty; Definition; Nature (Q10-2006) ................................................................... 178 State Liabilities (1995)........................................................................................................ 179 State Sovereignty; Effective Occupation; Terra Nullius (2000) ................................... 179 Stateless Persons; Effects; Status; Rights (1995)......................................................... 179 Territorial Sea vs. Internal Waters (2004)....................................................................... 180 Use of Force; Exceptions (2003)...................................................................................... 180 Use of Force; Principle of Non-Intervention (1994)....................................................... 181 Use of Force; Right of Self-defense (2002).................................................................... 182 Use of Force; Self-Defense; Waging War (1998).......................................................... 182 Use of Force; When allowed (1988) ................................................................................ 183 War; Combatants/ Prisoners of War vs. Mercenaries (1993)...................................... 183 Wilson doctrine vs. Estrada doctrine (2004)................................................................... 184 ADMINISTRATIVE LAW....................................................................................................... 184 Admin Law; Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies (1991)....................................... 184 Admin Law; Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies (2000)....................................... 184 Admin Law; Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies vs Doctrine of Primary Jurisdiction (1996) .............................................................................................................. 185 Admin Law; Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies; Exceptions (1991) ................. 185 Admin Law; Judicial Review of Administrative Action (2001)...................................... 186 Admin Law; Judicial Review of Administrative Decisions (1988)................................ 186 Admin Law; Meaning of Government of the Philippines (1997) ............................... 187 Admin Law; Power of the President to Reorganize Administrative Structure (2003) ............................................................................................................................................... 187BAR Q&A (as arranged by Topics) POLITICAL LAW (1987-2006)

Admin Law; Rules and Regulations; Due Process (2000) ........................................... 187 Government Agency vs. Government Instrumentality (Q7-2005)............................... 188 Quasi-Judicial Body or Agency (Q5-2006) ..................................................................... 188

1987 CONSTITUTION OF THE PHILIPPINES Phil Con 87; NewFeatures (1991)

7. The Supreme Court is empowered to adopt rules for the protection and enforcement of constitutional rights.

No 1: How is the Bill of Rights strengthened in 8. Art. II. Sec. 11 commits the State to a the 1987 Constitution? policy which places value on the dignity of every SUGGESTED ANSWER: human person and guarantees full respect for human rights. There are several ways in which the Bill of Rights is strengthened in the 1987 Constitution. 9. A Commission on Human Rights is created. 1New rights are given explicit recognition such as, the 10. Under Article XVI. Sec. 5(2) the State is prohibition against detention by reason of politicalmandated to promote respect for the people's beliefs and aspirations. The waiver of Miranda rights is among the members of the military in the rights now required to be made in writing with the assistance performance of their duty. of counsel. The use of solitary, incommunicado and secret detention places is prohibited, while the existence of substandard and inadequate penal facilities is made the concern of legislation. There is also recognition of the right of expression, an express prohibition against the use of torture, a mandate to the State to provide compensation and rehabilitation for victims of torture and their families. Some rights have been expanded. For instance, free access to courts now includes access to quasi-judicial bodies and to adequate legal assistance. The requirements for interfering with some rights have been made more strict. For instance, only judges can now issue search warrants or warrants of arrest. There must be a law authorizing the Executive Department to interfere with the privacy of communication, the liberty of abode, and the right to travel before these rights may be impaired or curtailed. The Constitution now provides that the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus does not suspend the right to bail, thus resolving a doctrinal dispute of long standing. The suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus and the proclamation of martial law have been limited to sixty (60) days and are now subject to the power of Congress to revoke. In addition, the Supreme Court is given the jurisdiction, upon the petition of any citizen to determine the sufficiency of the factual basis of the suspension of the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus and the proclamation of martial law.

establishment of adequate mechanism for this purpose. (Id., sec, 16)

Article XIII, Section 16 of the 1987 Constitution provides that the right of the people and their organizations to participate at all levels of social, political, and economic decision-making shall not Phil Con 87; People Power (2000) be abridged and that the State shall, by law, No IX. Is the concept of People Power recognizedfacilitate the establishment of adequate in the Constitution? Discuss briefly. (3%) consultation mechanisms.

Article XVII, Section 2 of the 1987 Constitution SUGGESTED ANSWER: provides that subject to the enactment of an Yes, the concept of People Power is recognized in implementing law, the people may directly the Constitution. Under Section 32. Article VI of the propose amendments to the Constitution through Constitution, through initiative and referendum, the initiative. people can directly propose and enact laws or approve or reject any act or law or part thereof Nature of the Constitution: Constitutional passed by the Congress or local legislative body Phil Con 87; People Power (1987) Supremacy (2004) after the registration of a petition therefor signed by (10-a) BNN Republic has a defense treaty with No. XVIII: The framers of the 1987 Constitution at least ten per centum of the total number of EVA Federation. According to the Republic's and the people who ratified it made sure that registered voters, of which every legislative district Secretary of Defense, the treaty allows temporary must be represented by at least three per centum provisions institutionalizing people power were basing of friendly foreign troops in case of training of the registered voters thereof. Under Section 16,incorporated in the fundamental law, Briefly exercises for the war on terrorism. The Majority discuss at least two such provisions. Article XIII of the Constitution, the right of the Leader of the Senate contends that whether people and their organizations to effective and SUGGESTED ANSWER: temporary or not, the basing of foreign troops reasonable participation at all levels of social, however friendly is prohibited by the Constitution Art. political and economic decision-making shall not be VI, Sec. 1, while vesting in Congress the of BNN which provides that, "No foreign military legislative power, nonetheless states that such abridged. The State shall, by law facilitate the bases shall be allowed in BNN territory." In case conferment of power shall be subject to the establishment of adequate consultation there is indeed an irreconcilable conflict between mechanisms. Under Section 2. Article XVII of the reservation made in favor of the people by a provision of the treaty and a provision of the provisions on initiatives and referendum. For this Constitution, the people may directly propose Constitution, in a jurisdiction and legal system like amendments to the Constitution through initiative purpose, Congress is required, as early as ours, which should prevail: the provision of the possible, to provide for a system of initiative of upon a petition of at least twelve per centum of the treaty or of the Constitution? Why? Explain with total number of registered voters, of which every referendum whereby the people can directly reasons, briefly. (5%) SUGGESTED ANSWER: In legislative district must be represented by at leastpropose and enact laws or approve or reject an case of conflict between a provision of a treaty three per centum of the registered voters therein. act or law or part thereof passed by the Congress and a provision of the Constitution, the provision or the legislative bodies after the registration of a of the Constitution should prevail. Section 5(2)(a), petition therefor, signed by at least 10% of the Article VIII of the 1987 Constitution authorizes the total number of registered voters, of which every nullification of a treaty when it conflicts with the legislative district must be represented by at least Constitution. (Gonzales v. Hechanova, 9 SCRA 3% of the registered voters. (Id., sec. 32) The 230 [1963]). Phil Con 87; People Power (2003) Constitution also provides that through initiative, No I -Is "people power" recognized by the 1987 upon a petition of at least 12% of the total numbers of registered voters, of which every Constitution? Explain fully. legislative district must be represented by at least SUGGESTED ANSWER: 3% of the registered voters therein,vs. ParliaGovernment Presidential Form amendments tomentary Form (Q6-2006) directly proposed by the Constitution may be "People power" is recognized in the Constitution. the people. is the principal identifying feature of 1. a) What a presidential form of government? Explain. Article III, Section 4 of the 1987 Constitution (2.5%) Art, XIII, sec. 15 states that the state shall respect guarantees the right of the people peaceable to SUGGESTED ANSWER: the role of independent people's organization to assemble and petition the government for redress The principal to pursue and protect, within the enable them identifying feature of a presidential of grievances. form of government is embodied in the separation democratic framework, their legitimate and Article VI, Section 32 of the 1987 Constitution of powers interests and aspirations through collective doctrine. Each department of requires Congress to pass a law allowing the government exercises powers granted to it by the peaceful lawful means. For this purpose, the people to directly propose and enact laws Constitution and may notto such organizations the Constitution guarantees control, interfere with or through initiative and to approve or reject any act encroach upon the at all done within the political right to participate acts levels of social, or law or part of it passed by Congress or a local constitutional competence of theand the state is and economic decision-making others. However, legislative body. the Constitution alsothe required to validate gives each department certain powers by which it

may definitely restrain the others from improvident prevent infringement of its customs, fiscal, action, thereby maintaining a system of checks immigration or sanitary laws and regulations and balances among them, thus, preserving the within its territory or territorial sea. (Article 33 of will of the sovereign expressed in the Constitution. Convention on the Law of the Sea.) the

The EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE is a zone b) What are the essential characteristics of aextending up to 200 nautical miles from the parliamentary form of government? (2.5%) baselines of a state over which the coastal state SUGGESTED ANSWER: has sovereign rights for the purpose of exploring The essential characteristics of a parliamentary exploiting, conserving and managing the and form of government are: the fusion of the legislative natural resources, whether living or nonliving, of and executive branches in parliament; the prime waters superjacent to the seabed and of the the minister, who is the head of government, and the seabed and subsoil, and with regard to other members of the cabinet, are chosen from among activities for the economic exploitation and the members of parliament and as such are exploration of the zone. (Articles 56 and 57 of the accountable to the latter; and the prime minister Convention on the Law of the Sea.) may be removed from office by a vote of loss of confidence of parliament. There may be a head of Exclusive Economic Zone; Rights of the state who may or may not be elected. Coastal State (1994)

No. 11: In the desire to improve the fishing methods of the fishermen, the Bureau of Fisheries, with the approval of the President, No. 20: What do you understand by the entered into a memorandum of agreement to archipelagic doctrine? Is this reflected in the 1987 allow Thai fishermen to fish within 200 miles from Constitution? the Philippine sea coasts on the condition that SUGGESTED ANSWER: Filipino fishermen be allowed to use Thai fishing The ARCHIPELAGIC DOCTRINE emphasizes equipment and vessels, and to learn modern the unity of land and waters by defining an technology in fishing and canning. archipelago either as a group of islands 1) Is the agreement valid? surrounded by waters or a body of waters studded with islands. For this purpose, it requires SUGGESTED ANSWER: that baselines be drawn by connecting the No. the President cannot authorize the Bureau 1) appropriate points of the "outermost islands to Fisheries to enter into a memorandum of of encircle the islands within the archipelago. The agreement allowing Thai fishermen to fish within waters on the landward side of the baselines exclusive economic zone of the Philippines, the regardless of breadth or dimensions are merely because the Constitution reserves to Filipino internal waters. citizens the use and enjoyment of the exclusive economic zone of the Philippines. Yes, the archipelagic doctrine is reflected in the 1987 Constitution. Article I, Section 1 provides Section 2. Article XII of the Constitution provides: that the national territory of the Philippines The State shall protect the nation's marine part in includes the Philippine archipelago, with all the its archipelagic waters, territorial sea, and islands and waters embraced therein; and the exclusive economic zone, and reserve its use and waters around, between, and connecting the enjoyment to Filipino citizens." islands of the archipelago, regardless of their breadth and dimensions, form part of the internal Section 7, Article XIII of the Constitution provides: waters of the Philippines. "The State shall protect the rights of subsistence fishermen, especially of local communities, to the Contiguous Zone vs. Exclusive Economic preferential use of the communal marine and Zone (2004) fishing resources, both inland and offshore. It shall (2-a-2) Distinguish: The contiguous zone and the provide support to such fishermen through exclusive economic zone. SUGGESTED appropriate technology and research, adequate ANSWER: CONTIGUOUS ZONE is a zone financial, production, and marketing assistance, contiguous to the territorial sea and extends up and other services. The State shall also protect, to 12 nautical miles from the territorial sea and develop, and conserve such resources. The over which the coastal state may exercise protection shall extend to offshore fishing grounds control necessary to of

ARTICLE I National TerritoryArchipelagic Doctrine (1989)

subsistence fishermen against foreign intrusion. Fishworkers shall receive a just share from their labor in the utilization of marine and fishing resources. Exclusive Economic Zone; Rights of the Coastal State (Q1-2005) (c) Enumerate the rights of the coastal state in the exclusive economic zone. (3%) ALTERNATIVE ANSWER: In the EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE, the coastal State has sovereign rights for the purpose of exploring and exploiting, conserving and managing the natural resources, whether living or non-living, of the waters superjacent to the seabed and of the seabed and its subsoil, and with regard to other activities for the economic exploitation and exploration of the zone, such as the production of energy from the water, currents and winds in an area not extending more than 200 nautical miles beyond the baseline from which the territorial sea is measured. Other rights include the production of energy from the water, currents and winds, the establishment and use of artificial islands, installations and structures, marine scientific research and the protection and preservation of the marine environment. (Art. 56, U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea) ALTERNATIVE ANSWER: SOVEREIGN RIGHTS for the purpose of exploring and exploiting, conserving and managing the natural resources, whether living or non-living, of the seabed and subsoil and the superjacent waters, and with regard to other activities such as the production of energy from the water, currents and winds in an area not extending more than 200 nautical miles beyond the baseline from which the territorial sea is measured. (See Art. 56, UNCLOS) Jurisdiction, inter alia, with regard to: (1) the establishment and use of artificial islands, installations and structures; (2) marine scientific research; (3) the protection and preservation of the and marine environment.

through the territorial sea. (Article 14 of the Convention on the Law of the Sea.)

such as What do you understand by or low No. 1; low or non-existent taxation the "Doctrine operating costs although the ship has no genuine of Incorporation" in Constitutional Law? SUGGESTED ANSWER: link with that state. (Harris, Cases and Materials DOCTRINE OF INCORPORATION Under Section 1, Article I of the 1987 Constitution, on International Law, 5th ed., 1998, p. 425.) means The the INTERNAL WATERS of the Philippines the rules of International law form part of the that Territory & and no legislative consist of the waters around, between and law of the landGovernment (1996) action is No. connecting the islands of the Philippine 8: A law make passedapplicablethe Philippines required to was them dividing to a country. into Philippines follows this doctrine, because Archipelago, regardless of their breadth and three regions (Luzon, Visayas, and Mindanao), The each constituting an of the Constitution states that dimensions, including the waters in bays, rivers Section 2. Article II independent state except on matters of foreign adopts thenational defense and and lakes. No right of innocent passage for the Philippines relations, generally accepted national taxation, which are vested inof the law of foreign vessels exists in the case of internal principles of international law as part the Central government. waters. (Harris, Cases and Materials on land. Is the law valid? Explain. the International Law, 5th ed., 1998, p. 407.) Internal SUGGESTED ANSWER: Doctrine of Incorporation; Pacta Sunt waters are the waters on the landward side of The law dividing the Philippines into three Servanda (2000) baselines from which the breadth of the territorial regions, each constituting an independent state No sea is calculated. (Brownlie, Principles of Public X. The Philippines has become a member of and vesting in a central government matters of the World Trade Organization (WTO) and International Law, 4th ed., 1990, p. 120.) foreign relations, resultantly agreednational it "shall and national that defense, ensure the taxation, conformityis unconstitutional. of its laws, regulations and administrative procedures with its obligations as ARTICLE II Declaration of First, it in the annexed Agreements." This is provided violates Article I, which guarantees the Principles and State Policies integrity the unconstitutional the Philippines assailed of as national territory of because this because it unduly limits, Philippinesand impairs into three undertaking divided the restricts Armed Forces; Servant of the People (2003) Philippine sovereignty and means among others states. No I - Article II. Section 3, of the 1987 that Congress could not pass legislation that will Constitution expresses, in part, that the "Armed goodit for our national interest andII general Second, violates Section 1, Article of the be Forces of the Philippines is the protector of the Constitution, which provides for the establishment welfare if such legislation will not conform with the people and (of) the State." Describe briefly what democratic and republicthis argument. (5%) it of WTO Agreements. Refute States by replacing this provision means. Is the Philippine National three States organized as a confederation. with Police covered by the same mandate? SUGGESTED ANSWER: FIRST ALTERNATIVE ANSWER: According to Tanada v. Angara, 272 SCRA 18 Article II, Section 3 of the 1987 Constitution Third, it the sovereignty of the Philippines the (1997), violates Section 22, Article II of is means that the Armed Forces of the Philippines Constitution, which, by its membership in and subject to restriction while recognizing the should not serve the interest of the President but promotingnations rights the limitations imposed of family of the and of indigenous cultural of the people and should not commit abuses communities, provides for 2. Article unity and treaty limitations. Section national II of the against the people. (Record of the Constitutional development. adopts the generally accepted Constitution Commission, Vol. V, p. 133.) This provision is principles of international law as part of the law of specifically addressed to the Armed Forces of the Fourth, it One of such principles is pacta sunt the land. violates Section 15, Article X of the Philippines and not to the Philippine National Constitution, which, provides for autonomous servanda. The Constitution did not envision a Police, because the latter is separate and distinct regions in Muslim Mindanao and infromCordilleras hermit-like isolation of the country the the rest of from the former. (Record of the Constitutional world. framework of national sovereignty as within the the Commission, Vol. V, p. 296; Manalo v. Sistoza. 312 well as territorial integrity of the Republic of the SCR A 239 [1999].) Philippines. from Nuclear Weapons; Foreign Freedom SECOND ALTERNATIVE ANSWER: Military Bases (1988) Article II, Section 3 of the 1987 Constitution can Fifth,The Secretary of Justice had recently ruled No. 22: it violates the sovereignty of the Republic be interpreted to mean that the Armed Forces thatof the Philippines. negotiate for a modification of the President may the Philippines can be a legitimate instrument for extension of military bases agreement with the or the overthrow of theof Convenience (2004) has Territorial Sea regardless of the "no Flag State vs. Flag civilian government if it United States vs. Internal Waters (2004) nukes" ceased Distinguish: The flag the people. (Bernas, (2-a-1) Distinguish: The territorial sea and the to be the servant of state and the flag provisions in the 1987 Constitution. The President (2-a-3) The 1987 Constitution of the Philippines: forthwith announced the Philippines. SUGGESTED A of convenience. SUGGESTED ANSWER: FLAG internal waters of that she finds the same opinion Commentary, 2003 ed., p. 66.) This provision does ANSWER:and will adopt it. Theis an adjacent the STATE means a ship has the nationality of the "acceptable" TERRITORIAL SEA Senators on not of the state the Philippine National aPolice, belt hand, with a breadth Senate President, are flag apply to it flies, but there must be other of sea led by the of 12 nautical miles because link between the state and the ship. the measured from the baselines of that noand over genuine it is separate and distinct from skeptical, and had even warned a state treaty or Armed Forces of the Philippines. (Record of the international state has sovereignty. (Articles 2without which the agreement may go into effect and 3 Constitutional Commission, Vol. V, p. 296, Manalo v. of the Convention on the Law of the Sea.) Ship of (Article 91 of the Convention on the Law of the Sea.) the concurrence of two-thirds of all members of the Sistoza. 312 SCRA 239 [1999].) all states enjoy the right of innocent passage Senate.FLAG OF CONVENIENCE refers to a state with which a Doctrine of Incorporation; Constitutional Law vessel is registered for various reasons

(1997)

A former senator had said, "it is completely the flag must be recognized by law, it implies wrong, if not erroneous," and "is an amendment that certain aspects of the flag are subject to of the Constitution by misinterpretation." Some change through legislative action. members of the Lower House agree with Secretary Ordonez, while others lament the Principle of Civilian Supremacy (Q6-2006) latter's opinion as "questionable, unfortunate, and 2. What Constitutional provisions institutionalize the principle of civilian supremacy? (2.5%) without any basis at all." Do you or do you not SUGGESTED ANSWER: agree with the aforementioned ruling of the The following constitutional provisions Department of Justice? Why? institutionalize the principle of civilian supremacy: SUGGESTED ANSWER: No. The Constitution provides that if foreign Civilian authority is at all times supreme over the military bases, troops or facilities are to be military. [Article II, Section 3] allowed after the expiration of the present installation of the President, the highest The Philippine-American Military Bases Agreement civilian authority, as the Commander-in-Chief of in 1991, it must be "under a treaty duly concurred the military. [Article VII, Section 18] in The by the Senate and, when the Congress so requirement that members of the AFP swear to requires, ratified by a majority of the votes cast by uphold and defend the Constitution, which is the fundamental law of the civil government. [Article the people in a national referendum." (Art. XVIII, sec. 25) A mere agreement, therefore, not XVI, Section 5(1)] a treaty, without the concurrence of at least 2/3 The requirement that members of the AFP shall of have all the members of the Senate will not be valid respect for people's rights in the performance of (Art. VII, sec. 21, Art. XVIII, sec. 4). With respect their duty. [Article XVI, Section 5(2)] Professionalism in the armed forces. [Article XVI, to the provision allowing nuclear weapons within Section 5(3)] the bases, the Constitution appears to ban such Insulation of the AFP from partisan politics. [Article weapons from the Philippine territory. It declares XVI, as a state policy that "the Philippines, consistent Section 5(3)] with the national interest, adopts and pursues Prohibition against the appointment of an AFP a member in the active service to a civilian position. policy of freedom from nuclear weapons in its [Article XVI, Section 5(4)] territory." (Art, II, sec. 8) However, the Compulsory retirement of officers without deliberations of the Constitutional Commission extension of service. [Article XVI, Section 5(5)] would seem to indicate that this provision of the Requirement of proportional recruitment from all Constitution is "not something absolute nor 100 provinces and cities, so as to avoid any regional percent without exception." It may therefore be clique from forming within the AFP. [Article XVI, that circumstances may justify a provision on Section 5(7)] nuclear weapons. A 3-year limitation on the tour of duty of the Chief of Staff, which although extendible in case of Philippine Flag (Q4-2006) emergency by the President, depends on State whether or not the law is constitutional. Congressional declaration of emergency. [Article Explain briefly. XVI, Section 5(6)] 1. A law changing the design of the Philippine flag. (2%) ALTERNATIVE ANSWER: The law is invalid considering that under Article XVI, Section 1 of the 1987 Constitution, the flag of the Philippines shall be red, white, and blue, with a sun and three stars, as consecrated and honored by the people and recognized by law. Since the Constitution itself prescribes the design, it can only be changed by constitutional amendment. ALTERNATIVE ANSWER: The law is valid, provided that the new design does not change the elements and color scheme of the flag as stated in the Constitution, and the flag is consecrated and honored by the people. Since the Constitution itself states that

combat boots at U.S. $30 per pair delivered in Consent to the exercise of jurisdiction of a foreign Jakarta on or before 30 October 1990. The court does not include waiver of the separate contract was awarded by the Ministry of the Army immunity from execution. (Brownlie, Principles of to Marikina Shoe Corporation and was signed by Public International Law, 4th ed., p. 344.) Thus, in the parties in Jakarta. Marikina Shoe Corporation Dexter vs. Carpenter vs. Kunglig was able to deliver only 200,000 pairs of combat Jarnvagsstyrelsen, 43 Fed 705, it was held the boots in Jakarta by 30 October 1990 and it consent to be sued does not give consent to the received payment for 100,000 pairs or a total of attachment of the property of a sovereign U.S. $3,000,000.00. The Ministry of the Army government. promised to pay for the other 100,000 pairs State Immunity from Suit (1996) already delivered as soon as the remaining 300,000 pairs of combat boots are delivered, at No. 6; The Republic of the Balau (formerly Palau Islands) opened and operated in Manila an office which time the said 300,000 pairs will also be paid for. Marikina Shoe Corporation failed to deliver engaged in trading Balau products with Philippine products. In one transaction, the local buyer any more combat boots. complained that the Balau goods delivered to him On 1 June 1991, the Republic of Indonesia filed were substandard and he sued the Republic of Balau, before the Regional Trial Court of Pasig, an action before the Regional Trial Court of Pasig. for damages. a) How can the Republic of Balau Rizal, to compel Marikina Shoe Corporation to perform the balance of its obligations under the invoke its sovereign immunity? Explain. b) Will such defense of sovereign immunity prosper? contract and for damages. In its Answer, Marikina Shoe Corporation sets up a counterclaim for U.S. Explain. $3,000,000.00 representing the payment for the SUGGESTED ANSWER: 100,000 pairs of combat boots already delivered A) The Republic of Balau can invoke its but unpaid. Indonesia moved to dismiss the sovereign Immunity by filing a motion to dismiss counterclaim, asserting that it is entitled to in accordance with Section l(a), Rule 16 of the sovereign Immunity from suit. The trial court denied the motion to dismiss and issued two writsRules of Court on the ground that the court has no jurisdiction over its person. of garnishment upon Indonesian Government funds deposited in the Philippine National Bank According to the Holy See vs. Rosario, 238 SCRA and Far East Bank. Indonesia went to the Court of Appeals on a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 524, in Public International Law, when a State wishes to plead sovereign immunity in a foreign of the Rules of Court. How would the Court of court, it requests the Foreign Office of the State Appeals decide the case? where it is being sued to convey to the court that it is entitled to immunity. In the Philippines, the practice is for the foreign government to first SUGGESTED ANSWER: The Court of Appeals should dismiss the petition secure an executive endorsement of its claim of insofar as it seeks to annul the order denying the sovereign immunity. In some cases, the defense of motion of the Government of Indonesia to dismiss sovereign immunity is submitted directly to the the counterclaim. The counterclaim in this case islocal court by the foreign government through a compulsory counterclaim since it arises from counsel by filing a motion to dismiss on the the same contract involved in the complaint. As ground that the court has no Jurisdiction over its such it must be set up otherwise it will be barred. person. Above all, as held in Froilan vs. Pan Oriental Shipping Co., 95 Phil. 905, by filing a complaint,b) No, the defense of sovereign Immunity will not the state of Indonesia waived its immunity from prosper. The sale of Balau products is a contractnot The establishment of a police force that is involving a commercial activity. also under the local suit. It is not right that it can sue in the courts but only civilian in character but In United States vs. Ruiz, 136SCRA487 and United States vs. Guinto, it canno