2014 international military airworthiness certification ... · aw certification recognition system...
TRANSCRIPT
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Director, Certification Planning Division
Col. Baek, Heon Young
Maj. Jung, Soo Ho
2014 International Military Airworthiness Certification Conference
1
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Contents
Contents
AW Certification System & Status
AW Issues
AW Recognition Cases & Analysis
International Recognition System
Facilitation
2
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
• Passenger Safety
• Aircraft Safety
Civil
Unified
Safety System
Under
a Single Body,
ICAO
• Nat’l Security
• Military Power (Weapon,Tech Issues)
MIL
Separate
Development of
Restricted Safety
System
Expansion of Common Ground in
Flight Safety &
Economic Effectiveness
Expand Mil-AW Cooperation to Secure Flight Safety
The differences between Civil & Military AW Certification
AW Certification System & Status (1/9)
3
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
ROK Military AW System
Law
Criteria
Procedure
Organization
Law (11559)(13.3.19)
DAPA Notice (2011-1)(11.12.7)
MIL-HDBK-516B-Based
Standard AW Certification Criteria
DAPA Regulations (277) (14.4.4)
AW Certification System & Status (2/9)
4
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
AW Organizations
5
Advisory Board
AW Tech Working
Group
AW Deliberation
Board
Cooperation
Analysis, Test &
Evaluation
Bureau *Staff : 9
Program Mgmt Org
Su
pp
ort/C
oo
rdin
atio
n
Coordination, Control
Policy-making,
Decision-making,
Advisory
Military Services
Lead Org
(Air Force) *Staff : 4
Specialty Org
(ADD)
*Staff : 5
Specialty Org
(Air Force)
*Staff : 21
Specialty Org
(DTaQ)
*Staff : 10
Specialty Org
(Army)
*Staff : 16
IPT, Industry
Continuous Efforts to Improve Org & Personnel to Advanced Level
(Civil Aviation Authority)
AW Certification System & Status (3/9)
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
연구개발30%
구매 30%
수출 39%
구매사업 52%
US 57% (15B)
Europe13% (5.1B)
ROK 24% (3B)
S-America Asia10%(2.7B)
Total : 29 Billion $
Programs Subject to Airworthiness Certification((2014 – 53 projects)
- Budget Focused on US, EU
★ But Recent increase In Asia, S-America, Middle-EAST
AW – subject Program Statistics
AW Certification System & Status (4/9)
6
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Basic Trainer(KT-1) Turkey, Peru
KUH-1 France
Advanced Trainer (T-50)
Lighter Attacker (FA-50) Indonesia, Iraq, Philippine, U.S
AW - subject Program(R&D) : 19 Projects
AW Certification System & Status (5/9)
7
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
8
Tanker US, EU, Israel
Large Attack Helicopter US
Maritime Helicopter UK
AW Certification System & Status (6/9)
AW - subject Program(Purchase) : 17 Projects
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
KF-16 US
UH-60 US, Israel
C-130H Israel
AW Certification System & Status (7/9)
AW - subject Program (Improvement) : 11 Projects
9
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
KUH-1P ROK Police
KC-100 ROK Air Force T-50
US
AW Certification System & Status (8/9)
AW - subject Program (Sale – Domestic, Foreign) : 6 Projects
10
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
AW-subject Program Status
구매 30%
수출 39%
구매사업 52%
Upgrade45%
Purchase 18%
R&D 24%
Export 13%
Programs subject to Airworthiness Certification
★ Mainly Purchase & Upgrade Programs from Foreign Companies [63%)
Much Room for International Cooperation in the Field of AW Certification
Need for Identification of Differences among Nations and Search for an Effective Approach
AW Certification System & Status (9/9)
11
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
연구개발30%
수출 39% 연구개발36%
구매사업 52%
AW Issues (1/5)
AW Issues
Differences among nations lead to high costs & redundancy in work.
Case 1) Performance Improvement Program
* US : FMS-only Support by Government
* UK : Limited Support by Government
(provide original certificate)
* Israel : Civil Authority(CAAI)’s confirmation of
a private company’s validation reports
& provision of
‘Certificate of Airworthiness’
12
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
구매 30% 구매사업 52%
Effective AW system required
AW Issues
Differences among nations lead to high costs & redundancy in work.
Case 2) Purchasing Program from Foreign Countries
* US : No AW Support for Commercial Purchase
* Turkey : Government-led AW support
* Israel : Civil Authority(CAAI)’s confirmation of
a private company’s validation reports
& provision of
‘Certificate of Airworthiness’
AW Issues (2/5)
13
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
International Military AW Cooperation Trends
Case 1) AW Cooperation between Export-Import Countries
US Army - Singapore Recognition Agreement(09.2)
CH-47, AH-64
USAF - Netherlands Recognition Agreement(12.2)
F-35, C-130, KC-10
AW Issues (3/5)
14
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
International Military AW Cooperation Trends
Case 2) AW Cooperation in International Joint Development Program
Recognition Agreement for Continued AW on A400M(13.3)
France-UK/France-Spain
Case 3) MOU between European Defense Agency (EDA) & European Aviation
Safety Agency (EASA) (13.6)
Diverse international cooperations are ongoing among nations (and also civil-
military) to overcome differences in AW systems!
AW Issues (4/5)
15
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
ROK Approach in International Trend
Limited in Application of a Common Certification Process
due to National Differences
Impractical to Apply Different AW Certification Criteria
for Different Countries
AW Certification Recognition System among Nations Is Needed!
AW Issues (5/5)
16
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
European Military Airworthiness Document – R (EMAD-R)
DEFINITION : European Military Airworthiness Document for
Recognition to promote recognition of other
countries’AW results
AW Recognition Cases & Analysis (1/3)
IMPLEMENTING STATUS
- 27 nations out of 28 EU nations are considering to implement.
- US DoD is also reviewing this document for implementation.
Example)
* UK-France mutual recognition agreement for the A400M AW
Certification
* US Army-UK in final signature stage
Activated Cooperation Is Expected Based on EMAD-R
17
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
European Military Airworthiness Document – R (EMAD-R)
AW Recognition Cases & Analysis (2/3)
1. Establish
common object
3. Mutual
Validation 2. Define scope of
recognition
4. Recognition
Agreement/ Sign
Procedure
★ Confirmation Method : Development, Consultation & Confirmation of MARQ
* MARQ : Military Airworthiness Recognition Question
Question AW Object Criteria Issue Action
1.4 AW Authority shall comply with the certification criteria & procedure.
Submit the Type Certificate and associate certificates
Substitute with Certificate of AW, or Risk Assessment
Apply
1.4.1 . . . .
AW Authority shall confirm & approve the Design Org. . .
Submit Design Org Approval & associated certificates . .
Too Different from the Export Nation’s AW System . .
Not Apply . . . .
18
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Pros & Cons of EMAD-R
Pros
- Reduction in additional AW activities
- Common Use of Aviation Infra according to the Agreement
Cons (in ROK perspective)
- Take a Long Time to Complete MARQ-related Procedures
- Need to Complement Applicable Methods by Case : Import/Export,
Mutual Flight Conducting, Joint Development, Upgrade...
AW Recognition Cases & Analysis (3/3)
19
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Identify common requirements through reviewing various AW issues
and make tailored AW recognition agreement
Proposal to Promote AW Recognition
International recognition system facilitation(1/3)
For example)
Certificate of Recognition-IE(Import and Export)
Certificate of Recognition-COB(Crew On Board)
Certificate of Recognition-JD(Joint Development)
Certificate of Recognition-Upgrade
20
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Certificate of Recognition-Upgrade (Sample)
Tailor Upgrade Area
(MARQ for Certificate of Recognition – Upgrade)
Q AW Safety Object Criteria Issue Action
1.4 AW Authority shall comply with the certification criteria & procedure.
Submit the Type Certificate and associate certificates
Substitute with Certificate of AW, or Risk Assessment
Apply
1.4.1 AW Authority shall confirm & approve the Design Org.
Submit Design Org Approval & associated certificates
Too Different from the Export Nation’s AW system .
Not Apply
1.4.3 … … … Apply
Current (EMAD-R)
1. AW Authority 2. AW Inspection 3. Production Ins 4. Aircraft Cert
After (COR-Upgrade )
4. Aircraft Cert
MARQ Area
Tailoring
+
Additional Q
(if applicable) • Rationale : Omitted sections
have little concern with
Import/Export.
* Others could be coordinated
between stakeholders.
International recognition system facilitation(2/3)
21
Military Airworthiness Certification Authority DAPA Military Airworthiness Certification Authority
Approved for Public Release; No sensitive material included. Reviewed by DAPA Service Management Team.
Development Direction Based on ROK AW Recognition Proposal
Conclusion
Facilitate Issue-Based Recognition System
among Potential Partners’ MAAs
Step 1
Set up International AW Recognition Process
Step 2
Facilitate International Military Airworthiness Recognition
Step 3
International recognition system facilitation(3/3)
22