2015-09-23 flores v usdoj - amended complaint (foia lawsuit) (blackline)(stamped)

7/23/2019 2015-09-23 Flores v USDOJ - Amended Complaint (FOIA Lawsuit) (Blackline)(Stamped)

1/35

!"#$% '(")*%

+,-. //01 20)**03 4"5 ,67

89:;%"< =*$>10%3 4*? @"); ..+/-

("#$%A(")*%B("#$%A(")*%5:"C

. D7,7E ,66F..7G

-+ 2*H0*CI*) -6.J

K@ LM'

="


2/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

1

!"#$%& ($)$%( ($*#+$ +,!*$

%)($%*" ($*#+$ ,- "%. /,*0

489:; 548

!"#$%&$''>

?@

9A:!=B ;!C!=; B=DC

F9;!:'=>

()')%*#%&@

)1%"&%&

+,123)#"$ -,*

#"4!"+$#5% *%3#%-

'#,+ AG@ H 12I'JI-K-LMMMMMMMMMMM

NG)@ MMMMMMMMMMMMMM3OP++,G)> F@63E#))>

2 9@;@'@ \ 22- 3U58:CV6> SG" Q)]T)$RQ?+ #)X GR(+" #YY"GY"Q#R+

"+PQ+S> ,++%Q)* R(+ QZZ+XQ#R+ Y"G$+,,Q)* #)X "+P+#,+ GS #*+)$^ "+$G"X, "+_T+,R+X W^

DP#Q)RQSS S"GZ B+S+)X#)R@

-@ DP#Q)RQSS #P,G ,++%, $GZYPQ#)$+ [QR( R(+ Z+ZG"#)XTZ X#R+X

F#)T#"^ -1> -``0> #)X #TR(G"+X #)X ,Q*)+X W^ 9)QR+X ;R#R+, D"+,QX+)R a#"#$%

8W#Z# 3R(+ UD"+,QX+)RV6> #SSQ"ZQ)* R(+ QZYG"R#)$+ GS # bY"GSGT)X )#RQG)#P

$GZZQRZ+)R RG +),T"Q)* #) GY+) OG?+")Z+)RV 3R(+ UD"+,QX+)Rc, 58:C

E+ZG"#)XTZV6@ +))a#"#$% 8W#Z#> ,)-./#%*0- .' 2#%0#/3 456 4778 9 :/))*.- .'

;%'./-#&$.% -``06> Ld 5+X@ (RRYH//[[[@]T,RQ$+@*G?/,QR+,/

X+S#TPR/SQP+,/GQY/P+*#$^/-`1d/`L/-./Y"+,QX+)RQ#PISGQ#@YXS@

Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 16 Filed 09/23/15 Page 2 of 35 PageID #: 169


3/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-

.7 89#:);:9H+"C P"7C ;(+) ;(+ G;;>")+N

Q+)+"#9 >< ;(+ R):;+H S;#;+, 3TO>9H+"U6C "+:;+"#;:)* ;(+ 8"+,:H+);V, $>??:;?+); ;>

(>)>":)* 5EFG 3;(+ TG;;>")+N Q+)+"#9V, 5EFG Q=:H+9:)+,U67 G$$>"H:)* ;> ;(+

G;;>")+N Q+)+"#9W, 5EFG Q=:H+9:)+,C O>9H+" A">;+C :) @#";C ;(#; TF A>=9H 9:%+ ;>

+?@(#,:X+ ;(#; "+,@>),:M:9:;N " + #) #*+)$NW, 5EFG ,;#=" @#"; ;> +),="+

>@+) *>K+")?+);7U !"" I":$ O>9H+"C P"7C #"$%&'()*$ ,%& -"'). %, /0"1*234"

5"6'&2$"(2. '() 78"(13".C E")+N Q+)+"#9 3B#"7 10C -DD06C

(;;@[//AAA7\=,;:$+7*>K/,:;+,/H+"*+U6C # @">,+$=;>" A:;( ;(+ R7S7 G;;>")+NW,

E: 3T4;7 '(>:U67 4;7 '(>: @">?:)+);9N

+J+";+H @>9:;:$#9 @"+,,="+ >) ;(+ R7S7 '>)*"+,, #)H >) ;(+ 8"+,:H+); ;> >K+";=") ;(+

R7S7 ?:9:;#"NW, "?+"9N H:,$":?:)#;>"N @>9:$N %)>A) #, Tc>)W; G,%C c>)W; !+997U !""

4:X O#99>"#)C 932: ;"6"'< =, >5%(>2 7.?@ 5%(>2 A": (#)H$==,+ @9+V,


4/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

.

--/78-9191---91:::;(; 7?I$ I)?C"=#U6J ,@A=I #)K


5/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

7

5"++89: 9; =, (>: =9 ;>A+ # A#B,C>= >) ;+8+"#A 8>,=">$= $9C"= >)

#$$9"8#)$+ B>=( 2 DEFE'E G 2--3#63763H6EI

JE 59" 9K+" =B9 L+#",MF>)$+ =(+)M )+>=(+" 9; =(+ DEFE ?==9")+LN, O;;>$+M

=(+ PODF?M =(+ O)+8 B(L "+,@9),>K+ "+$9"8, B+#"+ V+>)* B>=((+A8M

+#$( #) #$= 9; V#8 ;#>=(E *>)#A '9:@A#>)= >) =(>,

$#,+ =(#= =(+ PODF? @"9K>8+8M 9) V+(#A; 9; =(+ DEFE ?==9")+LN, O;;>$+ ;9" =(+ R>,=">$=

9; '9AC:V>#M # "+,@9),+ =9 =(+ W+XC+,= 3=(+ T5O


6/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

2

07 !(+ 8#9:;"+ ?@ $


7/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

7

189 :;# >?"=(+" ,++%, "+; >"@A B"@(


8/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

7

89,$"9:9)#;9?#9);9@@A, "9*(; ;< ,B+#% #C


9/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

7

!"#$%&'

189 :;# 5;?"+, ?" +FC#;?"G9 5;?"+, =(+ +O+$C=


10/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

0

789:*#;:7), II:$+ (#, 8++) "+G7";+= ;7 (#K+ +)*#*+= :) VK:)=:$;:K+ G"7,+$II:$+Q,

G"7,+$


11/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

17

!"#$ & '&()*8 9:;: !#): 1?8 -77.8 (@@AB//CCC:)D@


12/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

11

--7 !(+,+ "+89":, (#;+ # :(#: :(+ 8"9,+$=:?9) 9@ #$:?;?,:,

(#, A++) =)@#?"7 !(+ BCD/ECFG #$:?;?,:, (#> $(#?)+> :(+H,++" L"?$ '#):9" 3MND#76 :9 8"9:+,:O #H9)* 9:(+"

?,,=+,O $=:, :9 BCD/ECFG 8"9*"#H,7 !(+K P+"+ #""+,:+> 9) @+>+"#< $(#"*+,7 Q) :(+

,#H+ >#K #, :(+ BCD/ECFG #$:?;?,:, P+"+ #""+,:+>O R1 F?,:"?$: 9@ '9 9) '#8?:9< B?N8"9:+,:+",N:9N#88+#"N?)N$9=":NN_V1V.7(:H< T F+AA?+

G?+*+


13/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

1-

.2-.2078919#$:;9:D9W;))+

,D:#9#):;@#"9#$:;9DN9DP"9TP,:;$+9H+?#":M+):/J X)H ;) "+,?+$: DN 4:J '(D;G # M#*;,:"#:+ TPH*+

(#H NDP)H :(#: :(+"+ @#, ;)H;$#:;D) :(#: :(+ I+?#":M+): DN QP,:;$+ @#, ,;)*F;)* DP:

4:J '(D; ND" ^


14/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

1.

-711/78/.1/171--07/9:;


15/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

17

8)9:";# # ,


16/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

12

78)9 9:$;@+ =: 9+=+"@8$ 8, #@,: ;)#>@+ =: )*!&'#!&1/E !(+ R#,(8)*=:) Y:,=E 3Z#B 1.E -[1.6

(==D\//HHHJH#,(8)*=:)D:,=J$:


17/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

17

,89:;+)#,?$+


18/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

17

.89 !(+ :; ?+@A+,B C#, $DE=+F BD DGG=$=#>, #B HIJ $D>DC;AE +>+$B"D)=$ "+@A+,B=)* # "+,ED),+9

.-9 KL ME"=> 1PN -81.N )D "+,ED),+ C#, "+$+=O+FN ,D 5>D"+, GD"C#"F+F

B(+ :; ?+@A+,B BD # *+)+"#> EAQ>=$ #,,=,B#)$+ +>+$B"D)=$ #$$DA)B DG B(+ HIJN

#,%=)* GD" # "+,ED),+9 !(+ ME"=> 1PN -81.N +>+$B"D)=$ $=B+F B(+ MBBD")+L

R+)+"#>S, 5ITM RA=F+>=)+,9

..9 KL +>+$B"D)=$ F#B+F ME"=> 17N -81.N U=>>+" =),B"A$B+F 5>D"+, BD

,AQ>+"Y,

+>+$B"D)=$ DG ME"=> 17N -81.N 5>D"+, E"+E#"+F #)F ,AQ+BB+" F#B+F

ME"=> .8N -81.N # 5ITM ?+@A+,B ,++%=)* Z

#9 M>> "+$D"F, #)F =)GD"O+

DO+""+#$(N #)F C(=$( H+E#"B, #EE"DO+ DG ,A$( )#BA"+ #)F EA"ED,+ DG

E"D,+$AB=D) DG #$B=O=,B, [

3===6 >=F Q+ B#%+) =)BD $D),=F+"#B=D) Q+GD"+N

FA"=)*N #)F #GB+" B(+ E"D,+$AB=D) DG #$B=O=,B, BD


19/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

17

"8*(9,: ;9(+" ';),9898,9, B

38>6 $;),8@+"#98;) ;A ;9(+" $8"$


20/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

10

#""+,78)* #)9/:" ;":,+$


21/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-7

"+89+,:+;


22/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-1

7(+ 89:9 ;77


23/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

--

728 9) :;)+ 11.= 5?@"+, #*#A) ,B@%+ CAD( E@?# F;"A)* # D+?+B(@)+

$#??= #)F= @)$+ #*#A)= E@?# D"#),G+""+F 5?@"+, D@ H(AD#%+"I, J@A$+K#A?= C(+"+;B@)

5?@"+, ?+GD #)@D(+" J@A$+K#A? K+,,#*+ G@" H(AD#%+" #L@;D D(+ M+N;+,D8

7O8 P) ,;L,+N;+)D #DD+KBD, D@ "+#$( E@?# LQ D+?+B(@)+= 5?@"+, ,B@%+

CAD( E@?# @) :;?Q 0= ->1.= C(+"+;B@) E@?# A)G@"K+F 5?@"+, D(#D D(+ "+N;+,D G@" # G++

C#AJ+" C#, F+$?A)+F8 E@?# D@?F 5?@"+, D(#D D(+ B+",@) K#%A)* D(+ F+D+"KA)#DA@) R;,D

$(+$%, # L@S8 E@?# #FF+F D(#D D(+ $@KB;D+" ,(@C+F (AK D(#D D(+ M+N;+,D C#, )@D #

K#DD+" @G TCAF+,B"+#F #)F +S$+BDA@)#? A)D+"+,D8U E@?# ,#AF D(#D 5?@"+, K#Q "+$+AJ+ #

?+DD+" D@ D(A, +GG+$D V (@C+J+"= 5?@"+, )+J+" "+$+AJ+F ,;$( # ?+DD+"8 5;"D(+"K@"+=

5?@"+, #,%+F E@?# (@C ,(@;?F 5?@"+, *@ #L@;D D@ #BB+#? D(+ F+D+"KA)#DA@) D(#D

F+)A+F D(+ G++ C#AJ+"= #)F E@?# D@?F 5?@"+, D(#D E@?# FAF )@D (#J+ D(#D A)G@"K#DA@)8

WFFADA@)#??Q= E@?# D@?F 5?@"+, D(#D D(+ M+N;+,D C#, T;)F+" ,+#"$(=U #)F 5?@"+, #,%+F

E@?# AG 5?@"+, ,(@;?F C#AD D@ ,++ (@C K#)Q "+$@"F, C@;?F L+ B"@F;$+F L+G@"+

#FF"+,,A)* D(+ A,,;+ @G G++,8 E@?# ,#AF D(#D D(+ B@?A$Q @G D(+ X8E8 WDD@")+QI, 9GGA$+ A,

D@ )@D $(#"*+ G@" D(+ GA",D 1>> B#*+,= *+)+"#??Q= L;D= #GD+" 1>> B#*+,= D(+ $(#"*+ A, D+)

$+)D, B+" B#*+= #FFA)* D(#D D(+ )+SD ,D+B C@;?F L+ G@" 5?@"+, D@ "+$+AJ+ #) A)J@A$+=

C(A$( C@;?F D(+) A)G@"K 5?@"+, (@C K#)Q "+$@"F, C+"+ G@;)F8 !(+ A)J@A$+ C@;?F

#?,@ A)G@"K 5?@"+, (@C K;$( 5?@"+, C@;?F (#J+ D@ B#Q8 5?@"+, )+J+" "+$+AJ+F ,;$(

#) A)J@A$+8

7Y8 P) ,;L,+N;+)D #DD+KBD, D@ "+#$( E@?# LQ D+?+B(@)+= 5?@"+, ,B@%+

CAD( E@?# @) 9$D@L+" 1Y= ->1.= C(+"+;B@) 5?@"+, D@?F E@?# D(#D 5?@"+, (#F )+J+"

"+$+AJ+F #)Q C"ADD+) $@)GA"K#DA@) D(#D D(+ Z9: (#F "+$+AJ+F D(+ M+N;+,D8 E@?# D(+)

#,%+F 5?@"+, AG 5?@"+, (#F "+$+AJ+F D(+ )@DAGA$#DA@) G"@K T9[WU D(#D D(+ "+N;+,D G@"



24/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-.

+78+9:;+9 8":)+9? ;< @(:$( 5>+$;"A 5>:)+9? ;(+ I+GH+,; @#, * 8" ,H=J+$; E? 4;A '(:+9 ;(#;

B#N, "+ :) "+,8+$;


25/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-7

708 9(+) ): "+,;:),, ?+"+ ;":>@$+>A 5B:"+, #;;":#$(+> C(+

:DD C(#C C(+ :DD+", C: ;"+,,@"+ C(+ #*+)$J C: $:U;BJ ?#C+5:" :=+" C?: J+#",A C(+ MNEFO (#, )+

"+,;:),, ):" +Y;B# A :) Q+(#BD :D C(+ E8F8 OCC:")+JP, NDD C:

C(+ H+R@+,C :C(+" C(#) C: C+BB ]"8 5B:"+, C(#CA >@+ C: C(+ #*+)$JP, :?)


26/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-2

7898:#:8;), ;) "+,;: M8:( :(+ 89B"+,,8;) :(#: :(+ GCH 8,

:#%8)* #) ;"+ >8$+ >;" :(+ G8,:"8$: ;> ';7> #77+*+, P#= >#8:( ;) P+(#7> ;> :(+ CD[

>;" =+78P+"#:+7A );: P+8)* 8) $;9B78#)$+ M8:( 5CDEV



27/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-7

!(+ 8+9#":;+): ?,:@$+

2AB C) D+9:B 1EF -G1AF 5H


28/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-7

#89:; ,9$ 49:


29/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-7

8#)*+" 9: 9(+ 5;",9 9(+ *:?+")=+)9 @"+$AB8+, 9(+ CBAA +D+"$;,+ :C

$:=@A+9+ ,@++$( EF "+,9";$9;)* 9(+ @BEA;$ 9: +)*#*+ ;) ,@++$( 9(#9 A#$%, ;)C:"=#9;:)

;) 9(+ "+$:"8, ,:B*(9 EF 9(+ G+HB+,9 C;A+8 EF IA#;)9;CC B)8+" 5JK P:B!BE+ 3J$9L 12> -U1.6> (99@,V//F:B9BLE+/

WCHW75)$K0X Y #,9:";#-2> 54"" !@""A( 6B@C>A2.>+,3 +D /01 /",)>,& 5067 8"9:"3. +, "C =(+>> P:B!BE+ 3M+$L Z> -U1.6> (99@,V//F:B9BLE+/#DD@[#E1\]X Y 4:B;, 5A:"+,>

E4+."3. 2&2>,3. F4>A G+CH"4 2. IJK 4"L 5067 4"9:"3. 2;+:. &+M"4,B",. @4+3"A:.>+, +D

2A.>M>3.3> P:B!BE+ 3T+@9L 1^> -U1Z6> (99@,V//F:B9BLE+/.SX__:G@=`7L

aUL !(+ #E;A;9F 9: +)*#*+ ;) $:=@A+9+ ,@++$( $:)$+");)* 9(+ )#9B"+

#)8 +D9+)9 :C 9(+ *:?+")=+)9N, $:)8B$9 ;, $";9;$#A 9: +#$( :C IA#;)9;CC> "+#8+", :C

IA#;)9;CCN, b+E ,;9+,> 9(+ @BEA;$> #)8 #$9;?;,9,> O(: #"+ ):9 @#"9F 9: 9(+ G+HB+,9L

a1L 3#6L

9(+ *:?+")=+)9 ;, ?;:A#9;)* 9(+ 5;",9 "+,@+$9;?+AFL 3E6L R+C:"+ #),O+";)* 9(+ G+HB+,9> 9(+

*:?+")=+)9 =;,"+@"+,+)9+8 E+C:"+ 9(;, ':B"9 9(#9 9(+ *:?+")=+)9 (#8 ): $:@F :C

9(+ G+HB+,9> +?+) 9(:B*( 9(+ *:?+")=+)9 #8=;99+8 ;) ;9,


30/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

-0

'789:#;)< ;) +) A:#;) $7)$:F>;)*J ;) 9#";+, #)> 3;;6 , 7@

"+$7">, A:#;) K++) ,++%;)* KF< B+"+ >+);+> A:#;) P+@+)>#);)* "+*F:#


31/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

.7

8.9 :+;+), ;#?@A"+ =B C"BDC=@E D#%+ #F#?@#G@+ =(+ "+$B"


32/35

!"#$% '(#)*+, -./0/12 3456

.1

!"#$"%&"' !")*"+

789:95;:9< =>#?)@?AA "+,B+$@AC>>D "+EC+,@ @(#@ @(?, 'FC"@G

HI ;"J+" K+A+)J#)@ #)J ?@, $FLBF)+)@, @(+ MINI H@@F")+DO, ;AA?$+ AF"

@(+ K?,@"?$@ FA 'F>CLP?#< @(+ 9Q+$C@?R+ ;AA?$+ AF" M)?@+J N@#@+,

H@@F")+D,< #)J @(+ ;AA?$+ FA S)AF"L#@?F) =F>?$D @F ?LL+J?#@+>D

B"F$+,, @(+ :+EC+,@ #)J @F "+>+#,+ #)D "+,BF),?R+ "+$F"J, )F@

B"FB+">D T?@((F>J#P>+ C)J+" 5;SH U

VI 9)WF?) K+A+)J#)@ #)J ?@, $FLBF)+)@, A"FL $(#"*?)* =>#?)@?AA

,+#"$(< "+R?+T< F" JCB>?$#@?F) A++, AF" @(+ B"F$+,,?)* FA @(+

:+EC+,@ U

'I HT#"J =>#?)@?AA @(+?" $F,@, #)J "+#,F)#P>+ #@@F")+D,X A++, ?)$C""+J

?) @(?, #$@?F) U#)J

KI Y"#)@ ,C$( F@(+" "+>?+A #, @(+ 'FC"@ L#D J++L WC,@ #)J B"FB+"U #)JI

9I Y?R+) @(+ J+LF),@"#@?F), FA P#J A#?@( PD K+A+)J#)@ #)J @F R+"?AD

@(#@ @(+ K;Z $FLBF)+)@, "+>+#,+ #>> "+,BF),?R+ "+$F"J,< #BBF?)@ #

LF)?@F" @F $F)JC$@ F" R+"?AD @(+ ,+#"$( AF" "+,BF),?R+ "+$F"J,#@?F), FA 5;SHI

:+,B+$@AC>>D ,CPL?@@+J

()')%*#%&@

12G'HG-I-J 3FK63 U(R,+ #LL"+,, V, W $/R 9)VP+L ;P#P+, CPPR")+QX, 8SSV$+> =#,P+") BV,P"V$P RS A+U

YR"%> -J1 '#LZ#) DM#[# =#,P> JP( 5MRR"> \"RR%MQ)> A+U YR"% 11-]1 ^Q %3%+$*,"#+

1)#3 &%3#2%*/PR W "N%(,#)#(@,V)*(_N,LRT@*R?@

B#P+L W F#$%,R) +V*(P,> A+U YR"%

;+OP+Z^+" -.> -]12

4RNV, 5MR"+,

.aG-1 JJP( ;P"++P> COP@ a]I

F#$%,R) `+V*(P,> A+U YR"% 11.J-

D(R)+ W 3IaI6 a]]G11Ib

MRNV,SMR"+,_MRNV,SMR"+,@$RZ



35/35

/;IJK5 3JLJK3 5I3J!I?J ?M/!J

KL3JK!; 5I3J!I?J M* ;KN OM!P

!aPY2 '!aNL23

!/.0)(0++3

^5

P4YXLR 2XWXL2 RLSWNXOL4X a'

8P2XYML3

,&+&)-.)(5

.JFMcF-7-/ D8dEDN!OE

L**I!HLJIM;

M* 3K!@I?K

Y3 %M/I3 *%M!K33 Q*:(9)* #"^5

R90*Q V 89:;%"< =*$>10%3 4*? @");

2*H0*CI*) -+3 -6.J

!"#$% '(")*%

+,F-. //01 20)**03 WH05 ,67

89:;%"< =*$>10%3 4*? @"); ..+/-

S1"

2015-09-23 flores v usdoj - amended complaint (foia lawsuit) (blackline)(stamped)

Documents