2019 submission - royal commission into victoria's mental ... · administration in the us has...
TRANSCRIPT
2019 Submission - Royal Commission into Victoria's Mental Health System Organisation Name N/A
Name Mr Tim Fraser
What are your suggestions to improve the Victorian communitys understanding of mentalillness and reduce stigma and discrimination? "A documentary series along the lines of Employable Me for mental health conditions, educationthroughout high schools on a diverse range of mental health conditions, more workplace initiativesthat encourage open dialogue about mental health (something more in-depth and considered thanRUOK day), and more discussion of alcohol & drug dependency that acknowledges that drug useis frequently non-harmful and potentially beneficial to mental health (to develop a more nuancedunderstanding of why problematic use develops i.e. self-medication for trauma, social/economicconditions, etc)."
What is already working well and what can be done better to prevent mental illness and tosupport people to get early treatment and support? "Public dialogue has sufficiently shifted and it is much easier to talk about mental health.Workplaces need to be much more open however, as mental health significantly impacts onworkplace performance and seeking help can be complicated by work requirements and culture."
What is already working well and what can be done better to prevent suicide? Support lines and greater honesty about mental illness. What needs to improve is the provision ofintensive support during acute periods of illness.
What makes it hard for people to experience good mental health and what can be done toimprove this? This may include how people find, access and experience mental healthtreatment and support and how services link with each other. "Stigma, lack of understanding from health professionals, lack of dedicated resources to supportmental illness (e.g. adequate funding for treatment) and a lack of efficacious treatments. Thepublic conversation around mental health needs to continue and deepen. Health professionals,particularly GPs, need further training and mentorship, as well as an understanding of the range oftreatments available beyond prescription medicine. Greater funding for therapeutic options andworkplace support (i.e. EAPs). A willingness to explore, fund and recommend alternativetreatments (i.e. CBT/talk therapy not the default recommendation from GPs)."
What are the drivers behind some communities in Victoria experiencing poorer mentalhealth outcomes and what needs to be done to address this? Social justice issues that need to be acknowledged so that discussions of solutions broaden to atruly biopsychosocial model.
What are the needs of family members and carers and what can be done better to supportthem?
N/A
What can be done to attract, retain and better support the mental health workforce,including peer support workers? "More places for psychology training at universities. Further financial support for postgraduatemental health (i.e. psychology, social work, etc) students."
What are the opportunities in the Victorian community for people living with mental illnessto improve their social and economic participation, and what needs to be done to realisethese opportunities? Supported employment through specialised social enterprises and not-for-profits. Communitygroups tailoring to their needs. Greater funding and organisational support for all of these.
Thinking about what Victorias mental health system should ideally look like, tell us whatareas and reform ideas you would like the Royal Commission to prioritise for change? "Funding research into alternative treatments, as current treatment models are insufficientlyeffective."
What can be done now to prepare for changes to Victorias mental health system andsupport improvements to last? Funding. It's always going to be helped by more funding.
Is there anything else you would like to share with the Royal Commission? "One way or another, I would very much like to see the Royal Commission recommend exploringalternative and promising emerging treatments, particularly the potential of using psychedelics totreat mental health conditions. Having spent years in the mental health care system and working,speaking and commiserating with many others who work or are a patient within it, I have come tothe conclusion that talk therapy and antidepressants are highly ineffective for a large plurality - ifnot a majority - of people who engage with the mental health care system. Research from studiesin the US, UK and elsewhere have indicated that psychedelics such as psilocybin, ayahuasca andMDMA may have immense potential in treating a range of mental health conditions, includingmood, anxiety, and dependence disorders. Research is now beginning in Australia, with the StVincent's trial of psilocybin for end of life anxiety+depression now underway and further researchsoon to be announced. The data from overseas trials is so promising that the Food and DrugAdministration in the US has designated both psilocybin for anxiety+depression and MDMA forPTSD 'breakthrough therapy' status and trials are only a couple of years away from changing theirscheduled status to legal medicines. Australia has some of the poorest mental health in the world,with 45% of Australians experiencing a mental illness in their lifetime. While I can understand theterms of reference for this inquiry may limit the commission's ability to recommend action in thisarea, I would implore that the commission considers the evidence included in my and others'submissions, as well as initiating its own research into the topic, so that it may best consider how itcan use the power of its recommendations to influence change in this area. As an ongoingpatient, a carer, a mental health support worker, and an advocate, I deeply hope you will considerthis request and thank you for your efforts in doing so."
Vulnuwndk sm.‘ fiadev mmon W, x.”mmWmn!WWW”wW.MM.mm. mm“m“.M» w Wm ”Mm.
EnddM-Ann», mu Anxmym‘myk‘duhnm'“'"ET‘sl‘mt'fifélm 2'57 Mw-2132 $4333.27Mmamw. mum WWMMWM
“Ak-WAZ: :77. ‘5: ”m
SUB.0002.0032.0041
SUB.0002.0032.0035
The Universe of FDA Drug Approval
On July 28,2017, MAPS
and the FDA reached 078 /oof all the drugs make it
agreement on the Special
Protocol Assessment for through Phase, mPhase 2Phase 3 clinical trials.
20%of all the drugs are
accepted for Phase 3
12%of all the drugs
are approved for
the market
The chart depicts all studies
that have entered the FDAdrug approval process as
represented by stars Studies
are placed according to how
much of the approval
process they completed. This
means that all stars In theouter layer represent studies
that dld not advance after thePhase 1 trials. Stars In theInner layer represent drugs
that have been approved by
the FDA for the market,
Source: Wong CH, Shaw K., L0 A. (201 B] Estlmatlnn 0f cllnlcal trlal success rates and related parameters. Biostatlstics (ptepublished). Numbers1mm 2000 to 2015. with oncology excluded.
BREAKTHROUGH THERAPY DESIGNATION (BTD)
On August 15, 2017, the FDA The BTD program was launched in 2012. The chart belowshows the percentage of novel drugs designated as
grafited Ereakthroth Therapy Breakthrough Therapies for each year.
Desngnatton to MDMA—aSSIsted
psychotherapy for PTSD. 10°80
60approximately 30%
of the requests for 40
BTD are granted by
the FDA ”mli%2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Source: FDMW novel nmgs summaries for the years 2013-2017
SUB.0002.0032.0039
SUB.0002.0032.0040
SUB.0002.0032.0043
:2
V S
<me
because of it's uncanny ability to foster feelings of security and
well-being combined with acute focus creates an ideal state for exploring
traumatic events in the past. When the overarching feeling is 'safety',
the mind is comfortable to explore, repattern and heal trauma that may
be quarantined in the deep recesses of the brain.
Psilocybin diverts cognitive priority from fear and survival based
mechanisms to more conscious thought patterns, facilitating new ways
to look at problems and reprogram mental disease. It can be an incredibly
spiritual experience, often offering a different perspective on death
and the nature of life itself.
I IN 5 M000DISORDERSOne in five of us will
develop a mood disorder.
By 2020, depression will rank
second in morbidity among all
illnesses worldwide. Tragically,
suicide, often triggered by a
mood disorder, takes roughly
a million lives worldwide
every year.
40 MILLIONADDICTIONAddiction is America's
most neglected disease
According to a Columbia
University study, 40 million
Americans age 12 and over
meet the clinical criteria for
addiction involving nicotine
alcohol or other drugs."
That's more Americans than
those with heart disease,
diabetes or cancer.
PSILOCYBIN-ASSISTEDPSYCHOTHERAPY
1 SINGLE 003E CUREDFlexible dose of .3-1. mg per kg
80W
0F DEPRESSIUN AND ANXIETYIN THE PATIENTS STUDIED
,5HEB
PSILUCYBlN-FACILITATEDSMOK|N0 CESSATIUN
Flexible dose of .29mg-Jo3mg per kg
At six months, 30% oftheparticipants were still abstinent.
500.000VETERANSANDFmSTRESPONDERSwho served in Iraq
or Afg hanistan suffer
from PTSD
8 3 MILL|0NPSYCHOLOGICALDISTRESSAmerican adults 7
about 3.4 percent of
the U 5 population
suffer from serious
psychological distress,
an evaluation of federal
health data concluded.
70% 0F”.3. ADULTSTRAUMATIC EVENTat least once in their
lives. This equates to
approximately
223.4 MILLION PEOPLE MDMA-ASSISTEDPSYCHOTHERAPY
3 SESSIUNS BURED PTSDFlexible dose of 75-1875 mg
AND 00NTINUEO T0 REDUCE ITFOR YEARS LATER
@SUBVEYED 100 AUTISTID ADULTSWHO HAO EXPERIENCED MDMA
72% of MDMAexperienced individuals
reported being "more
comfortable in social
settings".
12% indicated that
these effects lasted for
TWO OR MORE YEARS EO0NOMICIMPAOT
Aéo‘s
t_AANXIETY DISORDERS ALONE HAVE AN ANNUAL COST OF
693% E? L?)$94141“ U Q»); @HLLH ® WI] PTSD IS THE MOST COSTLY
By enabling veterans to get off disability and return to work,
this treatmentcould reduce the need for VA services. improve
wait times, and reducereliance on Social Security.
THE SUBJECTIVEEFFECTS OF PSILOCYBINPsllocybin is a molecule that fits
into the serotonin receptors in the
brain, and diverts cognitive priority
to areas associated with higher
thought processes.
MDMA affects the brain by
increasing activity levels of three
different neurotransmitters: dopamine,
novepinephvine (noradrenaline),
and serotonin.
New perspective on 0 Increased empathy
emotional experiences and compassion
- Increased introspection 0 Enhanced communication
, Synaesthesia and introspection
(mixing sensory modalities) 0 Reduced feelings of fear
- Altered sense of time 0 Increased feelings of well-being
- Heightened feelings 0 Increased interpersonal trust
Of connectedness 0 Alert state of consciousness
SUPPORTING PSVCHEDELIC MEDICINEIS SUPPORTING FULL LECALlZATlONAll ofthe current clinical trials are testing psychedelic
medicine in controlled settings, with skilled practitioners
present Should psilocybin or MDMA become legal for
medicinal use it will remain under these controlled conditions
SHROOMS ARE PQlSONQUS
It's important to differentiate
mushroom poisoning from
nonvhallucinogenic species and
“intoxication" with hallucinogenic
species. 'Magic' mushrooms and
the active ingredient psilocybin is
not toxic and cause no known
major adverse effects.
Substances sold on the street under
these names may contain MDMA,
but frequently also contain unknown
and/or dangerous adulterants. These
adulterants and substitute chemicals can
be dangerous and as such, recreational
use of "MDMA" contains inherent risk.
SHROGMS MAKE ‘I’QU
GO ENSAN E
There is no conclusive evidence
suggesting that latent mental health
problems can be exacerbated by
psychedelic use in a controlled setting.
However people with mental health
problems should refrain from
recreational psychedelic use in the
absence ofa skilled medical practitioner.
There is no clinical evidence that
moderate use of MDMA can cause
damage to your brain. Frequent, high
dose use can cause heart problems
and memory problems. Early studies
to the contrary have subsequently been
retracted, as MDMA was accidentally
mislabeled as the amphetamine testedt
M. Thompson, Unlocking the secrets of PTSD," Time, val, 155, no. 12, pp. 1.073, Apr, 2015,
Natlmnal Center on Adtilctltm and Substance Abuse at leumbla umversrty, 'Addlctlon: A Preventable and Treatallle Dlsease,‘New van New Vork, USA, 2013,
3. Welssman, o, ssell, M,Jay,1. M, Beasley, o. Malasplna, and c Peg ‘Dlsparltles in Health Care Utlllmtlon and FuncunnaiUmltatlons Among Adults vwm Serlous Psycholaglcal Dlsuess, 200572014, sychlatv, sew, p. appv,ps.2oisaoz, 2017,
Staniord Mood Dlsnrders Center, 'Dloneerlng Sulutltms for Depression and Elpmlar Dlsorder,‘ 2m 7. [Onllne]. Avallable:http://med.stanford.edu/muoddlsavdershtml,
Wovltl Health Organlzatlon, 'Sulclde Data,‘ Am 7. [Onllne]. Avallable http://www,who.lnt/memalihealth/preventlon/sulclde/sulcldeprevent/en/
a. Buvge, ‘PRESS RELEASE: FDA Grams Breakthmugh Therapy Deslgnatlon luv MDMA“; ed Psychotherapy for PTSD,Agree "SpecialDmtocolAssessmentlmphaseSTvlals'Ma 2017. [Onllne]. Avallal ttp://www,map rg/news )erdlg/smepressrveleas largran breakthroughrtherapy eslgnatlnnrinrrmdmarasslste p.ycmmerapy ertsd,ragree‘ speclalrpmtucu ssessmentrfnrrphaseVSVtrlals.
A Daniunh nmage, Cmnnectlon,And Clar .Autism: Adu , Sofia University, 2013.
ML, drMethmds Callectlvercase Study of Mdma (Ecstasy) experiences of
n. u. Crlfl‘lths et a<.,-psnocybm produces substantlal anti sustalned tlecreas m depresslan and amtlety In patlents withllfeihreatenlng Cancer:A randomlzed dmublerbllnd trial, .Dsychopharmaco ,an 3 ,no. 12, pp. 1 1514 ‘7, Dec, 2015
.M. w. Johnson, A Gavclarnomeu, M, p, Coslmann, and a, Grlrflth Dllot study of the 57m ZA 9. agonlst psllocybln ln thetreatment of tobacco addlctlon,‘ 3. Psychopharmacok vol. 25, no] 1, pp. 534392, Nov. 2m 1.,
PTSD Unlted, ‘PTSD Statlstlcs,‘ 2m 3. [Onllne]. Available: http://www,ptsdunltednvg/ptsdrstatls
SUB.0002.0032.0042
Depression
severity
(BDI
)50—
Sevele depression (230)
33-7 (7-1)
Mild or moderate
depression (>9 to >30)
2°- 15-2 ('11)9=2
10— ---------------------------------------- - - - - - -------------------------------
No depression (59) 42%0—! / IBaseline ‘ 1 week 3 months
High dose (Carhart—Harris et al, 2016, modified)
SUB.0002.0032.0037
TREATING PTSDWITH MDMA-ASSISTED PSYCHOTHERAPY
Posttraumatlc Stress Dwsorder (PTSD) \S a wwdespread and devastamg wness for Whlch we urgermyneed more eflectwe Ireatments. Could non-profit research offer hope? The COHIIOI‘ed Use ofMDMA wn a psychotherapeutwc semng IS an Important step m the treatment 01 PTSD
What is PTSD?
Posllraumahc Shess stovder (PTSD) can PTSD Involves Changes m we Dram
be a CNOWC, devasmhng mness lhat severe‘y Palvenls have decreased aClMly m the
Impacts quamy 01 Me Sultevers onen stmgg‘e hippocampus and prelrontal cortexto mamlam healthy hves and Velailonsmps {aveas assocwated Wlm VWSVWOW and
\eammg) and Increased achv‘ly m the
amygdala (assocwaled w‘m tear).
t
. . 0 C 0 0 ° ' ' I in 7 u s semen membersII\ 1 ll‘ Ifl\ [mTT vatummg Worn \an and
Nghamslan suflms (mm PTSD.
PTSD can be caused by'
O . ’
wav sexua‘ assauu cmldnoud abuse \onure accidents omer stresslwevents
What is MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy?A treatment that combines psychotherapy with the administration of MDMA, which
catalyzes the therapeutic process.
mm mu mummmmmmm mvIn1IvtvvIn11tmlmmmmmmnvvmuqm:nummmummuumntthmtttttmItHmmmmmmmnmnImtnmimmmmnmmmnvmuu«m:mummmmnmnmnttmltttttmIttmmmmmmmmmmmHnuHmImmmmmnmqvmuqcmnummmumnmnmnttIIIItttmmnmmmmmmmmvnmq«mumunnmmmmmmnqvmuqcmnummnmmnummnttImtttttmIttmmmmmmmmHmumnmummmmmmmmqvmuqcmnummmumnnmnmttImum!IIIttmmmmmmmmvnmunn:munnmmvmnmnmvvmuqm:nummmummuumnmummmmmmmmmmmmtvmmtmmmvmmnmmmmnmmmnmmnvmmmmmmmttImtttttmIttmmmmmmmm
MuMA Is not Ecstasy. SL' 5km No (1ng ‘5 wmwm {Ska MDMA ms MDMA ‘3 a synmeuu cumpumvdmm \anaw mm n n mmm , [man cmum 1 m mm! 750 human mm a fear and devensweness(mun (ka mm MDMAHH! sublects m chmcalstumeswun mm, mm t ytrustand empathysrm m Hw' )maH mmmn a(it“|eravv‘.\ mu), xe'u dvI—Me 8 am Hvakmg} u 01 pan L~ m be
covmoname between me exlvemes 01(mr and u m;
MDMA um >(}‘~\
n .my MDMA swgwhumuydecreases activny MDMAMUI mun apwh _ 1 humoxytocin and prolactm (Hummmzs in the left amygdala, usmmm mm tool lorthe therapistand patient.a ma wmv mm mm). «wand vnumuuc uwmry u HmymsoaHovmq panems um um Increase mterpevsanal trust wumulmv- t N(x..u\y limqun _ [u(muhmvsurS(msm
How does MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy work?MDMA can make it easier for people with chronic, treatment-resistant PTSD to
confront their traumatic memories.
Both FDA-approved PTSD treatments require patients to take drugs deny tor years or even the rest oftheir lives. But MDMA ‘5 only admlnlstered a vew Ilmes.
Even one sesslon can have prolound positive eflecls.
Current Results
In a study of the efficacy of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for treating PTSD:
..
XXx
~ ~sublem Wye give“ durmg 2 amour sessxows‘ a‘ong thh weekly
mm, MDMA or placebo 3-5 weeks apart nonrdvug psychotherapysesswons
””mmem”Even more importantly, a long-term lallow-up conducted a mean cl 3.5 years later showedthat the benefits were (on average) maintained over time.
Fercent of Subjects Severity of PTSD Symptoms
Qualifying for PTSD Diagnosis (CAPS Score)
‘0095 m
70
60
50
25% 75% 40
30
EU
H)
50%
. Beiore treatment 0 Belore treatment
. Psychotherapy alone 0 2 months afler \reatmem
Q MDMArAsswsted Psychotherapy O 3 8 yeavs alter treannem
MT MTAH subjects reported at Study Vound no negatwe Many pamcxpants sand the\east some pevswsmg eflects 0n cognmve umcuon "eamem gave mg,“ abenefit {row the study assocwated vmh MDMA use new Sm 0,, mg
The results show \ong‘aslmg chmcaHy meanmgm nenem and absence 0! harm «om just a vewMDMArAsswsted Psychothelapy sessions tor m SD,
Addmona‘ (:hmcal (He‘s 81C bomg manned Or conducted around "\C work}
For more information and to help make this treatment
available for people suffering from PTSD, visit:
MDMAPTSD.ORGThe Multxdlscxplmaw Assomamn tor Psychedehc Studwes (MAPS) \S a 501(c)(3) non»prollt research orgamzarhon wovkmg m develop MDMArAssusled Psychotherapy me an FDArapproved prescnphon trealmem
SUB.0002.0032.0034