32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs ›...

46
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

Upload: others

Post on 06-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

!

!"##$#%&%'(!)#""*$+,!!

-."'!/$0"#'+"'12!32"!4"5#"22%$'!1$!67'%58971"!:9";1%$'2!!

!

!

!"#$#%!&'!()*+%,"-.,/0+!

12203#)/%!4,0*%220,!!

53600$!0*!7+/%,+)/#0+)$!8%$)/#0+2!)+9!4)3#*#3!5/.9#%2!

!:+#;%,2#/<!0*!=)$#*0,+#)>!5)+!?#%@0!

%6)*+%,A.329'%9.!

!

5.2)+!?'!(<9%!

122#2/)+/!4,0*%220,!

?%B),/"%+/!0*!40$#/#3)$!53#%+3%!

C)$%!:+#;%,2#/<!

2.2)+'6<9%A<)$%'%9.!!

!

8<)+!5'!D)E$0+2F#!

46?!=)+9#9)/%!

?%B),/"%+/!0*!40$#/#3)$!53#%+3%!

:+#;%,2#/<!0*!=)$#*0,+#)>!5)+!?#%@0!

,G)E$0+2F#A.329'%9.!

!

!

!

<8(821!=>?!=@A@!

!

<B21#7;1,!&02/!@0;%,+"%+/2!#+!/6%!H0,$9!+0H!60$9!%$%3/#0+2>!<%/!")+<!#+3."E%+/!$%)9%,2!.2%!%$%3/#0+2!

*0,!+0+"9%"03,)/#3!B.,B02%2>!2.36!)2!#+3,%)2#+@!/6%#,!60$9!0+!B0H%,!#+2/%)9!0*!)$$0H#+@!@%+.#+%!

B0$#/#3)$!30"B%/#/#0+!)+9!36)+@%'!I6#2!),/#3$%!%;)$.)/%2!/6%!30+9#/#0+2!.+9%,!H6#36!@0;%,+"%+/2!),%!

$#F%$<!/0!.2%!2/)/%"2B0+20,%9!B0$#/#3)$!,%B,%22#0+!!"!!#!$%$&'()!%!'!&'*&'!J%!),@.%!/6)/!@0;%,+"%+/2!),%!

"02/!$#F%$<!/0!#+3,%)2%!,%B,%22#0+!9.,#+@!K)+9!#""%9#)/%$<!2.,,0.+9#+@L!%$%3/#0+2!H6%+!/6%<!B%,3%#;%!

/6)/!B0$#/#3)$!0BB02#/#0+!/6,%)/%+2!/6%#,!60$9!0+!B0H%,!)+9!/6%!)E.2%!H#$$!$%)9!/0!*%H!+%@)/#;%!

30+2%M.%+3%2'!J%!/%2/!0.,!),@."%+/!H#/6!3,022!+)/#0+)$!%;#9%+3%!0+!%$%3/#0+2!)+9!,%B,%22#0+!*,0"!

NOPN!/0!QRRS'!

Page 2: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

!"

"

!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!&")!)'*$+

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

!! ,"!-&-$%.!/0$%1&!2&"!!+!&!*3(#!"-&%#4!)$*'5%&54.!6!#7!"$&%(4!8!8#4!-'(!#!5&(!-&%#!$+.!&")!-$%!')!5!

-%$+!)$"#!&(!&")!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!$($5#!'"+!+!"5$!#7$!5'3"#%4!%$9&!"$)!!")$-$")$"5$!8%'*!#7$!:';!$#!

<"!'"!!"!=>>=?!@$+-!#$!#7$!"'*!"&(!$A!+#$"5$!'8!)$*'5%&#!5!!"+#!#3#!'"+.!$($5#'%&(!8%&3)!!+!-$%;&+!;$.!&")!

#&5#!5+!'8!$($5#'%&(!*&"!-3(&#!'"!!"5(3)$!9';$%"*$"#!%$-%$++!'".!;!'($"5$.!&")!!"#!*!)&#!'"?!,--'+!#!'"!

+3--'%#$%+.!'--'+!#!'"!5&")!)&#$+.!&")!2'3%"&(!+#+!%!+B!#'%#3%$.!&%1!#%&%4!&%%$+#.!&")!-'(!#!5&(!

!*-%!+'"*$"#.!&((!+#%&#$9!$+!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!3+$+!#'!C6!"D!$($5#!'"+!E<?:?!@$-&%#*$"#!'8!:#&#$!FGGHI?!

J'%!$A&*-($.!!"!#7$!%3"!3-!#'!#7$!FGGK!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!$($5#!'"+!!"!/0$%1&!2&".!8&5!"9!#7$!-'++!1!(!#4!#7&#!

#7$!'--'+!#!'"!3"!#4!$A7!1!#$)!!"!#7$!C5'('%!%$;'(3#!'"+D!'8!L$'%9!&!&")!<B%&!"$!6'3()!+-%$&).!#7$!

9';$%"*$"#!%$-%$++$)!+-$$57!&")!8%$$)'*!'8!&++$*1(4.!&%%$+#$)!2'3%"&(!+#+.!&")!&##$*-#$)!#'!-%$;$"#!

#7$!'--'+!#!'"!8%'*!5&*-&!9"!"9?!M7$!-'(!5$!)$#&!"$)!';$%!&!#7'3+&")!&5#!;!+#+!1$8'%$!#7$!$($5#!'".!

7$()!73")%$)+!!"!53+#')4!8'%!+3+#&!"$)!-$%!')+!&")!7$()!73")%$)+!*'%$!!"!2&!(!8'%!+7'%#$%!-$%!')+!

6!#7'3#!5&3+$?=!!

/8#$%!#7$!$($5#!'".!&*!)!&553+&#!'"+!'8!8%&3).!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!&""'3"5$)!#7&#!#7$!%3(!"9!N$"!!

/0$%1&!2&"!O&%#4!6'"!&"!';$%67$(*!"9!*&2'%!#4.!6!#7!#7$!"$A#!(&%9$+#!'--'+!#!'"!5'&(!#!'"!6!""!"9!'"(4!

$!97#!'8!#7$!=FK!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!+$&#+?!M7$!$($5#!'"+!6$%$!5'")$*"$)!14!%$-3#&1($!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!

'1+$%;$%+.!67'!)'53*$"#$)!8%&3)!!"!*'%$!#7&"!PQR!'8!#7$!-%$5!"5#+!#7$4!'1+$%;$)?F!S**$)!&#$(4!

8'(('6!"9!#7$!$($5#!'"+.!'--'+!#!'"!+3--'%#$%+!1$9&"!#'!-%'#$+#!#7$!%$+3(#+.!!"5(3)!"9!&!5%'6)!'8!*'%$!

#7&"!T.GGG!-$'-($?!U!'#!-'(!5$!&")!*!(!#&%4!8'%5$+!)!+13%+$)!#7$!-%'#$+#$%+!3+!"9!5(31+!&")!6&#$%!

5&""'"+.!&")!+$;$%&(!'--'+!#!'"!($&)$%+!6$%$!1$&#$"!E<?:?!@$-&%#*$"#!'8!:#&#$!FGGHI?!S"!#7$!$").!

)$+-!#$ #!5!5%!#!5!+*!&")!-%'#$+#.!#7$!-%$+!)$"#!&")!%3(!"9!-&%#4!%$*&!"$)!!"!

"=!/")%$6!,+1'%"?!!CV$+#!M3%"+!&!W(!")!X4$!&+!/5#!;!+#+!Y%3+7$)!W$8'%$!/0$%1&!2&"!O'((.D!!"#!$%&#'#%&#%(!

EZ'")'"I.![';$*1$%!K.!FGGK?!

F!,%9&"!0&#!'"!8'%!:$53%!#4!&")!Y''-$%&#!'"!!"!X3%'-$\+!,88!5$!8'%!@$*'5%&#!5!S"+#!#3#!'"+!&")!]3*&"!

U!97#+.!)**+!,-./0-1#%(-.2!3/#4(05%6!0%!78#.9-0:-%;!!!

Page 3: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #

3#7'%!#&%!&"!+*!%&#7$%

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

-'6$%.!&")!#7$!9';$%"*$"#\+!;!'($"#!+#%&#$94!6&+!+355$++83(!&#!&(('6!"9!*3(#!"-&%#4!5'*-$#!#!'".!#73+!

*&!"#&!"!"9!#7$!8&5&)$!'8!*3(#!-&%#4!)$*'5%&54.!13#!*&"!-3(&#!"9!#7$!$($5#!'"!%$+3(#+!&")!+#4*!$!"9!

-'+#"$($5#!'"!-%'#$+#+!E^&(!4$;!FGGHI?!!!

M7$!9';$%"*$"#!'8!/0$%1&!2&"!!+!"'#!&('"$!!"!3+!"9!%$-%$++!'"!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!#&5#!5?!!/!9%'6!"9!

"3*1$%!'8!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+!&")!%3(!"9!-&%#4!&9$"#+_(!B$!#7'+$!!"!/0$%1&!2&"_"'6!&(('6!*3(#!-&%#4!

$($5#!'"+!13#!$A-('!#!#7$*!8'%!"'"")$*'5%&#!5!-3%-'+$+.!!"5%$&+!"9!#7$!%!7'()!'"!-'6$%?Q!/#!#7$!

$A#%$*$.!($&)$%+!$*-('4!*3%)$%.!#'%#3%$.!)!+&--$&%&"5$+.!&")!-'(!#!5&(!!*-%!+'"*$"#!&9&!"+#!-'#$"#!&(!

;'#$%+!&")!-'(!#!5&(!'--'+!#!'"!#'!+3--%$++!$($5#'%&(!5'*-$#!#!'"!&")!!"#!*!)&#$!#7$!-31(!5!1$8'%$.!

)3%!"9.!&")!&8#$%!$($5#!'"+?!M7$4!3+$!#7$!1&(('#!1'A!)$5$-#!;$(4.!#'!-31(!5&((4!;&(!)&#$!&")!($9!#!*!0$!#7$!%!

9';$%"*$"#\+!7'()!'"!-'6$%!67!($!&#!#7$!+&*$!#!*$!;!'(&#!"9!#7$!%3($!'8!(&6!&")!73*&"!)!9"!#4!'8!#7$!

-$'-($!67'!C$($5#D!#7$*?!!

O'(!#!5&(!57&"9$!7&+!&(6&4+!1$$"!-(&93$)!14!;!'($"5$.!&")!*&"4!'8!#7$!*'+#!-%'*!"$"#!+57'(&%+!'8!

)$*'5%&#!0&#!'".!!"5(3)!"9!U'1$%#!@&7(.!:&*3$(!]3"#!"9#'".!&")!/)&*!O%0$6'%+B!.!7!97(!97#!#7$!

!"5%$&+$)!;!'($"5$!#7&#!8%$`3$"#(4!&55'*-&"!$+!-'(!#!5&(!#%&"+!#!'"+!E@&7(!=>T=a!]3"#!"9#'"!=>>=a!

O%0$6'%+B!!=>>=I?!!@$+-!#$!#7$!%$5'9"!#!'"!#7&#!#%&"+!#!'"+!&%$!'8#$"!;!'($"#.!#7$!+#%&#$9!5!3+$!'8!

$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"!14!!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#+!7&+!"'#!1$$"!#7$!8'53+!'8!#7$!)$*'5%&#!0&#!'"!

(!#$%&#3%$?!!U&#7$%.!#7&#!(!#$%&#3%$!7&+!8%$`3$"#(4!&++3*$)!#7&#!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!!+!&!+4*-#'*!'8!

& !#7&"!&!#''(!3+$)!+#%&#$9!5&((4!14!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+?!!

"Q!['#$!#7&#!#7$!#$%*!C!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+D!%$8$%+!#'!#7$!-%!"5!-&(!&5#'%!!"+#!9&#!"9!#7$!3+$!'8!+#&#$!

+-'"+'%$)!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!#&5#!5?!,#7$%!+57'(&%+!+'*$#!*$+!3+$!C%$9!*$+.D!

C9';$%"*$"#+.D!&")!C#7$!+#&#$D!#'!)$+5%!1$!+!*!(&%!&5#'%+?!S"!#7!+!-&-$%.!6$!3+$!#7$!#$%*!#'!%$8$%!#'!&((!

!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#!($&)$%+!&")!#7$!%!&9$"#+!67'!$"9&9$!!"!$($5#'%&((4!*'#!;&#$)!-'(!#!5&(!

%$-%$++!'"?!,--'+!#!'"!($&)$%+!*&4!$"9&9$!!"!#7$!+#%&#$9!5!3+$!'8!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'".!13#!#'!&;'!)!

5'"83+!'".!6$!%$8$%!#'!'--'+!#!'"!($&)$%+!$A-(!5!#(4?!!

Page 4: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $

! /+!$($5#!'"+!7&;$!+-%$&)

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

S"!&!%$(&#$)!13#!+$-&%&#$!(!#$%&#3%$!'"!73*&"!%!97#+.!+57'(&%+!7&;$!-%')35$)!&!+!0&1($!1')4!'8!

%$+$&%57!#7&#!$A-('%$+!7'6!)$*'5%&54!&")!'#7$%!8'%*+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!(!1$%&(!0&#!'"!!"8(3$"5$!#7$!+#&#$\+!

3+$!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'".!&")!7'6!+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"!!"8(3$"5$+!#7$!-%'1&1!(!#4!'8!-'(!#!5&(!

#%&"+!#!'"!&")!)$*'5%&#!0&#!'"!EO'$!&")!M&#$!=>>Pa!O'$.!M&#$.!&")!b$!#7!=>>>a!:"4)$%!FGGGa!@&;$"-'%#!

&")!/%*+#%'"9!FGGPa!@&;$"-'%#!FGGTI?!N$#!_!6!#7!&!8$6!"'#&1($!$A5$-#!'"+!E@&;$"-'%#!=>>T.!=>>Ha!

U!57&%)+!=>>>a!@&;$"-'%#!&")!/%*+#%'"9!FGGPa!Y!"9%&"$((!!&")!J!(!--';!FG=Ga!U'1!"+'"!&")!M'%;!B!

FGG>I!_!#7$%$!7&+!1$$"!(!##($!+4+#$*&#!5!%$+$&%57!'"!$($5#!'"+!&")!73*&"!%!97#+!;!'(&#!'"+?!!

<+!"9!&!"$6!)&#&+$#!'"!$($5#!'"+!&")!-'(!#!5&(!5'*-$#!#!'".!&+!6$((!&+!$A!+#!"9!)&#&!'"!+#&#$"

+-'"+'%$)!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+.!6$!-%$+$"#!&")!#$+#!&!#7$'%4!'8!67$"!($&)$%+!#7%'397'3#!#7$!

)$;$('-!"9!6'%()!&%$!(!B$(4!#'!$*-('4!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!#'!*&"!-3(&#$!$($5#!'"+.!&")!67!57!8&5#'%+!&%$!

(!B$(4!#'!)$5%$&+$!($&)$%+\!!"5$"#!;$+!#'!3+$!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"?!!

V$!&%93$!#7&#!!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#+!&%$!*'+#!(!B$(4!#'!3+$!%$-%$++!'"!-6!-%!#/#4(5.-/!(-4(04!67$"!

#7$4!-$%5$!;$!_!%!97#(4!'%!6%'"9(4!_!#7&#!$($5#!'"+!-'+$!&!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%!7'()!'"!-'6$%!&")!#7&#!#7$!

&13+$!6!((!9'!3"-3"!+7$)?!!

!"#$%&'%()!*+"%,-$./)!'.0!,1"!2-/"!$3!45++-6"&'+7!!"#$%&'%-"/!

M7$%$!!+!(!##($!)$1&#$!#7&#!$($5#!'"+.!(!B$!-%'#$5#!'"+!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+.!&%$!"$5$++&%4!8'%!

)$*'5%&#!5!9';$%"&"5$a!#7$4!&%$!C#7$!$++$"5$!'8!)$*'5%&54.!#7$!!"$+5&-&1($!+!"$!`3&!"'"D!E]3"#!"9#'"!

=>>=I.!&").!&+!+3**&%!0$)!14!V!((!&*!U!B$%.!C#7$!$++$"#!&(!)$*'5%&#!5!!"+#!#3#!'"!!+!#7$!1&(('#!1'A!&")!

&((!#7&#!9'$+!6!#7!!#D!E=>HK.!FKI?!/#!#7$!+&*$!#!*$.!+57'(&%+!'8!5'*-&%&#!;$!-'(!#!5+!9$"$%&((4!&9%$$!#7&#!

7'()!"9!$($5#!'"+!)'$+!"'#!*$&"!#7&#!&!5'3"#%4!!+!)$*'5%&#!5?!S"!8&5#.!($++!#7&"!7&(8!'8!#7$!9';$%"*$"#+!

#7&#!"'6!7'()!)!%$5#!$($5#!'"+!8'%!"&#!'"&(!'88!5$!)'!+'!6!#7!"!&!5'"#$A#!'8!5'"+'(!)&#$)!)$*'5%&#!5!

-'(!#!5&(!!"+#!#3#!'"+!&")!%$+-$5#!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+?P!!

!#'!*'+#!5'3"#%!$+!!"!#7$!6'%().!#7$!%!+$!'8!%$9!*$+!#7&#!&%$!"$!#7$%!83((4!

"P!/3#7'%+\!5&(53(&#!'"?!!

Page 5: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" %

!&"!$")!#'!#4%&""4!&")!!"5%

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

)$*'5%&#!5!"'%!83((4!&3#'5%&#!5!7&;$!&##%&5#$)!*'%$!+57'(&%(4!&##$"#!'".!&")!#7$!(&1$(+!8'%!#7$+$!C741%!)!

%$9!*$+D!7&;$!-%'(!8$%&#$).!!"5(3)!"9!C!((!1$%&(!)$*'5%&54.D!C+$*!")$*'5%&54.D!C$($5#'%&(!

&3#7'%!#&%!&"!+*D!&")!C5'*-$#!#!;$!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!+*D!E@!&*'")!FGGFa!c&B&%!&!=>>Ta!d&!"6&%!"9.!

W%!"B+.!&")!O$%$0"Z!"&"!FGG=a!:57$)($%!FGGFa!Z$;!#+B4!&")!V&4!FGGFI?!/5%'++!&((!'8!#7$+$!%$9!*$+.!

$($5#!'"+!&%$!"'#!"$5$++&%!(4!&"!!"+#!#3#!'"!'8!)$*'5%&54.!13#!!"+#$&)!+$%;$!&+!*$&"+!8'%!!"53*1$"#+!#'!

+#&4!!"!-'6$%!EL&")7!!&")!Z3+#",B&%!FGG>a!Z3+#",B&%!FGGHI.!'8#$"!67!($!&##$*-#!"9!#'!*&!"#&!"!&!

C+$*1(&"5$!'8!)$*'5%&#!5!($9!#!*&54D!E:57$)($%!FGGFI?K!!

! M7$%$!&%$!*&"4!$A-(&"&#!'"+!8'%!#7$!9('1&(!)!883+!'"!'8!$($5#!'"+.!!"5(3)!"9!#7&#!#7$4!&%$!7$()!#'!

7$(-!!"53*1$"#+!&(('5&#$!-&#%'"&9$!&")!#'!)!;!)$!'%!5'"#%'(!#7$!'--'+!#!'"!EZ3+#",B&%!FGGHa!L&")7!!&")!

O%0$6'%+B!!FGG>a!d&9&('"!!FGGHI.!#'!8&5!(!#&#$!&!"'"";!'($"#!#%&"+8$%!'8!-'6$%!#'!&!57'+$"!+355$++'%!

EY'A!FGGeI.!&+!&!%$+-'"+$!#'!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!-%$++3%$!8'%!)$*'5%&54!E&3#7'%I.!'%!#'!C%$&-!#7$!8%3!#+!'8!

$($5#'%&(!($9!#!*&54!6!#7'3#!%3""!"9!#7$!%!+B+!'8!)$*'5%&#!5!3"5$%#&!"#4D!E:57$)($%!FGGF.!QTI?!M7$!

$A!+#!"9!(!#$%&#3%$!5($&%(4!)$*'"+#%&#$+!#7&#!&(#7'397!$($5#!'"+!&%$!"$5$++&%4!8'%!)$*'5%&54!#7$4!&%$!

"'#!+388!5!$"#.!&")!$($5#!'"+!*&4!+$%;$!&!;&%!$#4!'8!-3%-'+$+!'#7$%!#7&"!)$*'5%&54!'%!)$*'5%&#!0&#!'"?!!!

! @$+-!#$!#7$!9%'6!"9!$*-7&+!+!'"!$($5#!'"+!!"!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!%$9!*$+.!+57'(&%+!7&;$!4$#!#'!$A-(&!"!

67$"!&")!674!$($5#!'"+!&%$!(!B$(4!#'!-%';'B$!+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"?!!

8-.9-.:!*+"%,-$./!'.0!2";&"//-$.!!

! M7$!%$(&#!'"+7!-!1$#6$$"!)$*'5%&54!&")!73*&"!%!97#+!!+!$"+7%!"$)!!"!"3*$%'3+!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!

&9%$$*$"#+.!!"5(3)!"9!#7$!<%0=#.6-/!>#4/-.-(05%!5?!@A1-%!B0C"(6!&")!*&"4!<"!#$)![&#!'"+!#%$&#!$+?!

V$+#$%"!5'3"#%!$+.!!"5(3)!"9!#7$!<"!#$)!:#&#$+!&")!X3%'-$&"!5'3"#%!$+.!-%'*'#$!)$*'5%&54!!"!-&%#!

1$5&3+$!'8!#7$!!)$&!#7&#!83((!-%'#$5#!'"+!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+!%$`3!%$!)$*'5%&#!5!9';$%"*$"#f!)$*'5%&54!

1%!"9+ $&+$+!(!1$%#4.!8%$$)'*!&")!+$53%!#4!8'%!5!#!0$"+?!d'3"#&!"+!'8!$;!)$"5$!

"K!/)&*!O%0$6'%+B!!&(+'!"'#$+!#7&#!#7!+!#%$")!!+!"'#!"$6.!&")!$($5#'%&(!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!%$9!*$+!C6$%$!#7$!

-%$;&($"#!8'%*!'8!-'(!#!5&(!'%9&"!0&#!'"!#7%'397'3#!7!+#'%4D!EO%0$6'%+B!!FGG>.!HI?!!!

Page 6: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" &

+7'6!#7&#!+#&1($!(!1$%&(!)$*'5%&5!$+!&%$!*357!*'%$!(!B$(4!#7&"!'#7$%!#4-$+!'8!9';$%"*$"#+!#'!%$+-$5#!

73*&"!%!97#+!EO'$!&")!M&#$!=>>PI.!&(#7'397!-'(!#!5&(!#%&"+!#!'"+!'8#$"!!"5(3)$!7!97!($;$(+!'8!5'$%5!'"!&")!

)$*'5%&#!0!"9!9';$%"*$"#+!)'!"'#!&(6&4+!%$+-$5#!73*&"!%!97#+!EY'((!$%!FGG>a!@&;$"-'%#!FGGTa!:"4)$%!

FGGGI?!!

! N$#.!&+!$($5#!'"+!7&;$!+-%$&)!#'!"$&%(4!$;$%4!5'3"#%4!!"!#7$!6'%().!+'!7&;$!5'*-(&!"#+!&1'3#!#7$!

3+$!'8!%$-%$++!'"!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!#''(?!J&%$$)!c&B&%!&!E=>>TI!8&*'3+(4!&%93$)!#7&#!$($5#!'"+!!"5%$&+$!

-'(!#!5&(!-'(&%!0&#!'"!&")!-'#$"#!&((4!!"5%$&+$!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!!"!5'3"#%!$+!6!#7'3#!6$((")$;$('-$)!

%$+-$5#!8'%!#7$!%3($!'8!(&6?!g&*$+!U'1!"+'"!&")!U&9"&%!M'%;!B!EFGG>I!7&;$!)$;$('-$)!&!*')$(!+7'6!"9!

#7&#!;!'($"5$!!+!&"!&##%&5#!;$!'-#!'"!8'%!-'(!#!5!&"+!67'!*3+#!5'*-$#$!8'%!#7$!+3--'%#!'8!+6!"9!;'#$%+!'%!

$(!*!"&#$!#7$*!8%'*!#7$!9&*$?!W4!5'"#%&+#.!'#7$%+!7&;$!&%93$)!#7&#!$($5#!'"+!!"!!((!1$%&(!+#&#$+!

$;$"#3&((4!1%!"9!&1'3#!1%'&)$%!-'(!#!5&(!-&%#!5!-&#!'".!5!;!5!$"9&9$*$"#.!&")!-'(!#!5&(!&55'3"#&1!(!#4.!&((!

'8!67!57!6!((!!*-%';$!%$+-$5#!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+!';$%!#!*$!EZ$6!+"W$5B!=>>Ga!Z!-+$#!=>e=a!:$(!9+'"!&")!

W''#7!=>>Ka!:!+B!=>>KI?!!!

N$#!#7$!$+#&1(!+7$)!8&5#+!'"!73*&"!%!97#+!&")!$($5#!'"+!&%$!8$6!&")!*&!"(4!!"5'"5(3+!;$?!S"!

/8%!5&.!:#&88&"!Z!")1$%9!EFGGHI!+7'6$)!#7&#!$A-$%!$"5$!6!#7!$($5#!'"+h$;$"!&*'"9!#7'+$!%$9!*$+!#7&#!

&%$!3")$*'5%&#!5h!"5%$&+$+!#7$!-%'1&1!(!#4!'8!)$*'5%&#!0&#!'".!#7$%$14!!*-(4!"9!#7&#!#7$!$88$5#!'8!

7'()!"9!$($5#!'"+!';$%!#!*$!!+!#'!)$5%$&+$!%$-%$++!'"?!d&%5!]'6&%)!&")!O7!(!-!U'$++($%!+7'6$)!#7&#!

1'#7!3"!#$)!5'&(!#!'"+!'8!'--'+!#!'"!-'(!#!5&(!-&%#!$+!&")!'--'+!#!'"!-&%#4!*'1!(!0&#!'"!!"5%$&+$)!#7$!

57&"5$!'8!&!+!9"!8!5&"#!$-!+')$!'8!(!1$%&(!0!"9!-'(!#!5&(!57&"9$!6!#7!"!5'*-$#!#!;$!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!%$9!*$+.!

($&)!"9!#'!9%$&#$%!%$+-$5#!8'%!5!;!(!&")!-'(!#!5&(!%!97#+!EU'$++($%!&")!]'6&%)!FGG>a!]'6&%)!&")!U'$++($%!

FGGHI?!:#$;$"!V!(B!"+'"!EFGGHI!$A-('%$)!#7$!%$9!'"&(!S")!&"!9';$%"*$"#\+!3+$!'8!;'#$%"!"!#!&#$)!$#7"!5!

%!'#+!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!#&5#!5?!M7'397!&1($!#'!+3--%$++!+357!%!'#+.!#7$!S")!&"!+#&#$!9';$%"*$"#+!&(('6$)!

#7$*!#'!$+5&(&#$!67$"!!#!6&+!!"!#7$!%!+7'%#"#$%*!$($5#'%&(!!"#$%$+#.!#7$%$8'%$!1$"$8!##!"9!8%'*!#7$!

$88$5#+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!;!'($"5$!6!#7'3#!$"9&9!"9!!"!!#!)!%$5#(4?!!

Page 7: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" '

M7$%$!&%$!'"(4!&!8$6!5%'++""&#!'"&(!+#&#!+#!5&(!+#3)!$+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!&")!$($5#!'"+!&")!#7$+$!&%$!

!"5'"5(3+!;$?!S"!7!+!-&#7!1%$&B!"9!+#3)4!'8!P>!5'3"#%!$+!8%'*!=>Pe!#'!=>eF.!Y7%!+#!&"!@&;$"-'%#!E=>>TI!

8'3")!#7&#!"'"")$*'5%&#!5!9';$%"*$"#+!6$%$!+#&#!+#!5&((4!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!&13+$!-'(!#!5&(!%!97#+!)3%!"9!

"&#!'"&(!$($5#!'"+?!@&;!)!U!57&%)+!E=>>>I.!7'6$;$%.!+#3)!$)!$($5#!'"+!!"!TP!5'3"#%!$+!8%'*!=>e=!#'!=>eT!

&")!8'3")!#7&#!#7$!-%$+$"5$!'8!"&#!'"&(!$($5#!'"+!7&)!"'!$88$5#!'"!9';$%"*$"#!%$+-$5#!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+!

'"$!6&4!'%!#7$!'#7$%?!J'53+!"9!'"!)$*'5%&5!$+.!@&;!)!Y!"9%&"$((!!&")!d!B7&!(!J!(!--';!EFG=GI!&%93$)!

#7&#!1'#7!!"53*1$"#+!&")!'--'+!#!'"!($&)$%+!*&4!+#%&#$9!5&((4!57''+$!#'!$"9&9$!!"!'%!!9"'%$!-''%!

73*&"!%!97#+!-%&5#!5$+!!"!#7$!&1+$"5$!'8!-%'-$%!$($5#'%&(!!"5$"#!;$+?!M7$!%!+#3)4!)$*'"+#%&#$+!#7&#.!

&*'"9!)$*'5%&5!$+.!5$%#&!"!$($5#'%&(!%3($+!_!+357!&+!#7$!$($5#!'"!'8!*$*1$%+!'8!-&%(!&*$"#!#7%'397!('6!

*&9"!#3)$!-%'-'%#!'"&(!%$-%$+$"#&#!'"!)!+#%!5#+!_!&%$!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!1$##$%!-%'#$5#!'"+!8'%!73*&"!

%!97#+?!V7&#!!+!5($&%!8%'*!#7!+!%$+$&%57!!+!#7&#!#7$%$!!+!&!+#%'"9!5'""$5#!'"!1$#6$$"!+#&1($!(!1$%&(!

)$*'5%&54!&")!9';$%"*$"#!-%'#$5#!'"!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+.!13#!#7&#!&!9%'6!"9!"3*1$%!'8!$($5#!'"+!&%$!

#&B!"9!-(&5$!!"!;$%4!!((!1$%&(!-(&5$+!67$%$!)$*'5%&54!7&+!4$#!#'!1$!5'"+'(!)&#$)?!M7$!"&#3%$!'8!#7$!

%$(&#!'"+7!-!1$#6$$"!$($5#!'"+!&")!9';$%"*$"#!+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"!%$*&!"+!-''%(4!3")$%+#'')?!!

<&:=#".,!'.0!*>;"%,',-$./!

V$!&%93$!#7&#!$($5#!'"+!&%$!(!B$(4!#'!1%!"9!&1'3#!&"!!"5%$&+$!!"!+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"!

67$"!#7$!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+7!-!1$(!$;$+!#7&#!!#!8&5$+!&!#7%$&#!#'!!#+!7'()!'"!-'6$%!&")!#7$!(!B$(4!

5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'"!&%$!*!"!*&(?!,3%!&%93*$"#!!+!1&+$)!'"!#6'!&++3*-#!'"+f!#7&#!!"53*1$"#!

($&)$%+!&")!#7$!%!-'(!#!5&(!-&%#!$+!-%$8$%!#'!+#&4!!"!-'6$%a!&")!#7&#!%$-%$++!'"!!+!5'+#(4.!$;$"!8'%!

&3#'5%&#!5!($&)$%+.!$+-$5!&((4!67$"!5%$)!1($!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!$"9&9!"9!!"!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!$A!+#?!!!

X($5#!'"+!-3#!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!($&)$%+!!"!&!1!")f!#7$4!5&"!1%!"9!&!"3*1$%!'8!&);&"#&9$+.!!"5(3)!"9!

&"!'--'%#3"!#4!8'%!&"!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%!#'!;&(!)&#$!7!+!7'()!'"!-'6$%.!13#!#7$+$!5'"#$+#+!&(+'!!"#%')35$!

3"5$%#&!"#4!&1'3#!67$#7$%!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!6!((!+3%;!;$!#7$!$($5#!'"!EZ$;!#+B4!&")!V&4!FG=G.!FGGFa!

Page 8: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" (

-#!'"+!'8!$($5#!'"!8%&3).!'%

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

W%'6"($$!FGG>I?H!S#!!+!6$((!$+#&1(!+7$)!!"!#7$!73*&"!%!97#+!(!#$%&#3%$!#7&#!#7%$&#+!#'!-'6$%!'8#$"!-%'*-#!

9';$%"*$"#+!#'!%$+-'")!6!#7!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!E@&;$"-'%#!=>>Ka!O'$!$#!&(?!FGGGI?!W3!()!"9!'"!#7$+$!

8!")!"9+.!6$!&%93$!#7&#!($&)$%+!7&;$!!"5$"#!;$+!#'!3+$!$($5#'%&((4"*'#!;&#$)!%$-%$++!'"!67$"!$($5#!'"+!

-'+$!&!%$&(!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%!7'()!'"!-'6$%!Eb$!#7!&")!O'$!FGGPI?!W$5&3+$!%$-%$++!'"!'8#$"!5&%%!$+!

"$9&#!;$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!-$%-$#%&#'%+.!!"53*1$"#+!+7'3()!'"(4!3+$!%$-%$++!'"!-6!-%!#/#4(5.-/!(-4(04!

67$"!#7$4!-$%5$!;$!&!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%!-'6$%?!!S8!#7$4!1$(!$;$!#7$4!&%$!-'-3(&%!$"'397!#'!6!"!#7$!$($5#!'"!

'3#%!97#.!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"!+7'3()!1$!3""$5$++&%4!E&(#7'397!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!*&4!3+$!%$-%$++!'"!8'%!

'#7$%!%$&+'"+I?T!

M73+.!'3%!8!%+#!74-'#7$+!+!!+!#7&#!!8!($&)$%+!&"#!5!-&#$!&"!$($5#'%&((4"!")35$)!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%!7'()!

'"!-'6$%.!#7$4!+7'3()!1$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!!"5%$&+$!%$-%$++!'"!&%'3")!$($5#!'"+?!X*-!%!5&((4.!#7!+!+7'3()!1$!

%$8($5#$)!!"!#6'!6&4+f!5'*-&%$)!6!#7!($&)$%+!67'!8&5$!8$6$%!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%!7'()!'"!-'6$%.!

#7%$&#$"$)!($&)$%+!+7'3()!3+$!E&I!7!97$%!($;$(+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!!"!#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'"!&")!E1I!

#7!+!)!88$%$"5$!+7'3()!)$5%$&+$!67$"!$($5#!'"+!&%$!8&%#7$%!&6&4?!S"!'#7$%!6'%)+.!!8!&!($&)$%!8&5$+!&"!

$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#.!6$!$A-$5#!&!+-!B$!!"!;!'($"5$!&%'3")!$($5#!'"+!#'!1$!*'%$!(!B$(4?!!

M7%$&#+!#'!&"!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+7!-!5&"!+#$*!8%'*!&"4!8'%*!'8!$($5#'%&(!57&(($"9$.!&")!5&"!1$!

%$;$&($)!!"!#7$!-%$"$($5#'%&(!-$%!').!14!"$9&#!;$!-31(!5!'-!"!'"!'8!#7$!!"53*1$"#.!'%!!"!#7$!-'+#"

$($5#'%&(!-$%!').!14!$($5#!'"!%$+3(#+!#7&#!&%$!($++!8&;'%&1($!#7&"!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!&"#!5!-&#$).!6!)$+-%$&)!

-$%5$ !-31(!5!-%'#$+#?!/!9'')!!((3+#%&#!'"!!+!#7$!=>>Q!"&#!'"&(!$($5#!'"!!"!

"H!['#$!#7&#!*'+#!9';$%"*$"#+!!"!#7$!6'%()!"'6!7'()!%$93(&%!$($5#!'"+.!&")!&(#7'397!+'*$!+57'(&%+!

*')$(!#7$!)$5!+!'"!#'!7'()!$($5#!'"+!&+!&"!$")'9$"'3+!)$5!+!'"!*&)$!14!($&)$%+!$&57!#!*$!$($5#!'"+!&%$!

7$()!EY'A!FGGea!L&")7!!&")!O%0$6'%+B!!FGG>I.!6$!&++3*$!#7&#!$($5#!'"+!&%$!$A'9$"'3+.!&")!'3%!

&%93*$"#!&--(!$+!#'!5&+$+!!"!67!57!$($5#!'"+!&%$!7$()?!!

T!['#$!#7&#!#7$!*&%9!"!'8!;!5#'%4!&55$-#&1($!#'!*&"4!$($5#'%&(!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!($&)$%+!!+!*357!7!97$%!#7&"!

#7$!*&2'%!#4!%$`3!%$)!#'!+#&4!!"!-'6$%!E:!*-+$%!FGGKI?!

Page 9: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" )

!'6"!-'-3(&%!#4!!+!('6.!6$!$

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

Y&*1')!&?!S"!#7$!5'3"#%4\+!8!%+#!)$*'5%&#!5.!*3(#!"-&%#4!$($5#!'"+.!&)*!"!+#$%$)!14!#7$!<"!#$)![&#!'"+.!

#7$!%$!9"!"9!Y&*1')!&"!9';$%"*$"#!6&+!%$+-'"+!1($!8'%!';$%!TG!)'53*$"#$)!B!((!"9+!_!&")!*'%$!#7&"!

=GG!!"23%!$+!_!'8!*$*1$%+!'8!#7$!-'(!#!5&(!'--'+!#!'"!-%!'%!#'!#7$!$($5#!'"!E<?:?!@$-&%#*$"#!'8!:#&#$!

=>>PI?!M7$!-$%-$#%&#'%+!6$%$!&88!(!&#$)!6!#7!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!($&)$%+!&")!#7$!-'(!#!5&(!-&%#!$+!#7&#!6$%$!

*'+#!#7%$&#$"$)!14!)$*'5%&#!5!$($5#!'"+f!#7$!Y&*1')!&!O$'-($\+!O&%#4.!($)!14!O%!*$!d!"!+#$%!]3"!:$".!

&")!#7$!-&%#4!'8!#7$!Cb7*$%!U'39$D!E#7$!O&%#4!'8!@$*'5%&#!5!b&*-357$&I.!67!57!1'45'##$)!#7$!

$($5#!'"+!ES"#$%"O&%(!&*$"#&%4!<"!'"!=>>QI?!!!

N$#!#7$!#7%$&#+!-'+$)!#'!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!($&)$%+!14!$($5#!'"+!&%$!"'#!&(6&4+!5($&%.!&")!#7$!&1+$"5$!

'8!!"8'%*&#!'"!*&4!!#+$(8!-'+$!&!#7%$&#?!!/!)$8!"!"9!57&%&5#$%!+#!5!'8!*&"4!&3#7'%!#&%!&"!%$9!*$+!!+!#7&#!

#7$!8('6!'8!!"8'%*&#!'"!!+!%$+#%!5#$)!&")!8%$$!$A-%$++!'"!!+!(!*!#$)?!S"!#7$+$!%$9!*$+.!($&)$%+!5&""'#!

&(6&4+!1$!5'"8!)$"#!&1'3#!#7$!+#%$"9#7!'8!#7$!'--'+!#!'"!'%!67$#7$%!#7$4!&%$!8&5!"9!&!%$&(!$($5#'%&(!

#7%$&#?!U$(!&1($!-31(!5!'-!"!'"!-'((+!*&4!"'#!1$!&;&!(&1($.!'%!($&)$%+!*&4!3")$%"!'%!';$%$+#!*&#$!#7$!%!

&5#3&(!-'-3(&%!#4?!S"8'%*&#!'"!&1'3#!#7$!-'-3(&%!#4!'8!#7$!!"53*1$"#!*&4!1$!)!88!53(#!#'!'1#&!"!8'%!'#7$%!

%$&+'"+.!+357!&+!67$"!#7$!!"53*1$"#!!+!%$(&#!;$(4!"$6!!"!'88!5$?!!:#%!B!"9(4.!67$"!($&)$%+!&%$!3")$%!#7$!

!*-%$++!'"!#7&#!#7$4!5&"!6!"!&"!$($5#!'"!'3#%!97#.!$;$"!($&)$%+!67'!7&;$!#7$!&1!(!#4!#'!$"9&9$!!"!

$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"!'8#$"!57''+$!"'#!#'!$*-('4!!#!E#7'397!#7$4!*&4!3+$!%$-%$++!'"!8'%!'#7$%!-3%-'+$+I?!

J'%!$A&*-($.!!"!&);&"5$!'8!#7$!=>>G!$($5#!'"+!!"![!5&%&93&.!!"53*1$"#!-%$+!)$"#!&")!%$;'(3#!'"&%4!

($&)$%!@&"!$(!,%#$9&!5&*-&!9"$)!$"#73+!&+#!5&((4!&")!14!&((!&55'3"#+!6&+!3")$%!#7$!!*-%$++!'"!7$!

6'3()!6!"?!/+!&!%$+3(#.!7$!7&)!"'!"$$)!#'!3+$!;!'($"5$!&")!#7$!$($5#!'"+!#7&#!4$&%!6$%$!%$(&#!;$(4!

-$&5$83(?!<"1$B"'6"+#!#'!7!*!&")!#'!*'+#!'1+$%;$%+!'8![!5&%&93&"!-'(!#!5+.!-31(!5!'-!"!'"!-'((+!!"!#7$!

-'+#"5'"8(!5#!5'3"#%4!6$%$!6!()(4!!"&553%&#$.!&")!!"!&!+3%-%!+$!_!&")!-$&5$83(!_!'3#5'*$.!,%#$9&!('+#!#'!

^!'($#&!Y7&*'%%'?e!!V7$"!($&)$%+!7&;$!%$(!&1($!!"8'%*&#!'"!#7&#!#7$!%!5'*-$#!#!'"!!+!+#%'"9!'%!#7&#!

#7$!% A-$5#!#7$*!#'!7&;$!+#%'"9$%!!"5$"#!;$+!#'!3+$!%$-%$++!'"!#7&".!(!B$!

"e!DA-.&0-%!EF5%&5%G.!CJ%$$.!J&!%.!&")!&!M'#&(!:3%-%!+$.D!J$1%3&%4!FT.!=>>G?!

Page 10: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" *

!'--'+!#!'"!'%!#7$!%!+3--

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

,%#$9&!!"!=>>G.!67$"!#7$4!1$(!$;$!#7$4!&%$!-'-3(&%!&*'"9!;'#$%+?!!

N$#!*&"4!!"53*1$"#+!67'!8&5$!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#+!"$;$%!#3%"!#'!%$-%$++!'"!#'!+#&4!!"!-'6$%.!&+!

*'+#!$($5#!'"+!!"!5'"+'(!)&#$)!)$*'5%&5!$+!)$*'"+#%&#$?!S"!*&"4!5'3"#%!$+.!&"!!"53*1$"#\+!57'!5$!#'!

3+$!%$-%$++!'"!!+!$+-$5!&((4!5'"+#%&!"$)!14!#7$!&"#!5!-&#$)!5'"+$`3$"5$+!'8!$"9&9!"9!!"!&13+$?!S"!

5'"#%&+#.!67$"!#7$%$!&%$!8$6!(!B$(4!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&"#!5!-&#$)!14!#7$!9';$%"*$"#.!&13+$!1$5'*$+!&!

*'%$!&--$&(!"9!$($5#'%&(!+#%&#$94?!M7$!+$;$%!#4!&")!5%$)!1!(!#4!'8!#7$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!)$-$")+!'"!#7$!

*$57&"!+*+!'8!&55'3"#&1!(!#4?!^!'($"#!+#%&#$9!$+!5&"!1$!$+-$5!&((4!%!+B4!8'%!($&)$%+.!&+!#7$4!5&"!($&)!#'!

($9&(!-%'+$53#!'"?!]3*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!_!+357!&+!*3%)$%!&")!#'%#3%$!_!&%$!!"!*'+#!5&+$+!!(($9&(!&")!

3"-'-3(&%!&*'"9!;'#$%+?!O$%-$#%&#'%+!'8!#7$+$!5%!*$+!%!+B!9$##!"9!5&397#!&")!-3"!+7$).!$!#7$%!67!($!

#7$4!&%$!!"!'88!5$.!'%!&8#$%!#7$4!+#$-!)'6".!$;$"!!"!$($5#'%&(!&3#'5%&5!$+?!!J'%!$A&*-($.!Y7&%($+!M&4('%.!

8'%*$%!E$($5#$)I!Z!1$%!&"!-%$+!)$"#!&")!+3+-$5#$)!6&%!5%!*!"&(.!7&+!1$$"!57&%9$)!14!#7$!S"#$%"&#!'"&(!

Y%!*!"&(!Y'3%#!8'%!#$%%'%!0!"9!#7$!5!;!(!&"!-'-3(&#!'".!&")!M&4('%!8&5$+!&!+$%!'3+!%!+B!'8!9'!"9!#'!2&!(?!

@'*$+#!5!5'3%#+!*&4!&(+'!-3"!+7!($&)$%+!8'%!&13+$+.!67!($!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!#%$&#4!1')!$+!&")!"'""

9';$%"*$"#&(!'%9&"!0&#!'"+!*&4!-%$++3%$!#7$!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!5'**3"!#4!#'!!"#$%;$"$?!J'%!$A&*-($.!

9('1&(!&##$"#!'"!#'!#7$!S%&"!&"!($&)$%+7!-\+!;!'($"#!5%&5B)'6"!'"!'--'+!#!'"!+3--'%#$%+!8'(('6!"9!#7$!

FGG>!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'"+!!"5%$&+$)!#7$!%$+'(;$!'8!'#7$%!9';$%"*$"#+!#'!!*-'+$!$5'"'*!5!+&"5#!'"+?>!

/")!&!<["1&5B$)!#%!13"&(!+$"#$"5$)!8'%*$%!b7*$%!U'39$!($&)$%.!b&!"9!L$57!X&;!EB"'6"!&+!@357I.!8'%!

5%!*$+!&9&!"+#!73*&"!#4!&")!6&%!5%!*$+.!!"5(3)!"9!7!+!%'($!!"!';$%+$$!"9!#7$!#'%#3%$!&")!)$&#7!'8!*'%$!

#7&"!#$"!#7'3+&")!-$'-($!!"!M3'(!:($"9!-%!+'"!!"!#7$!=>TG+!E]3*&"!U!97#+!V&#57!FG=GI!_!&!#!*$!!"!

67!57!@357!7&)!"'!%$&+'"!#'!1$(!$;$!7$!6'3()!'"$!)&4!1$!7$()!&55'3"#&1($?!

M73+.!6$!$A-$5#!#7&#!($&)$%+!&%$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!%$+-'")!#'!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%!-'6$%!14!%$-%$++!"9!

-'(!#!5&( '%#$%+!)3%!"9!E'%!!**$)!&#$(4!+3%%'3")!"9I!&"!$($5#!'"!67$"!#7$4!

">!:$$.!8'%!$A&*-($.!g3)4!@$*-+$4.!Cd$%B$(!:!9"&(+!:3--'%#!8'%!M'397$%!S%&"!:&"5#!'"+.D!H#I!J5.K!!01#6?!

:$-#$*1$%!F.!FGG>?!

Page 11: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !+

O%'2$5#!EFG=GI.!67!57!5')$+!9';

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

1$(!$;$!_!%!97#(4!'%!6%'"9(4!_!#7&#!#7$4!&%$!3"(!B$(4!#'!8&5$!5%$)!1($!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!5'**!##!"9!73*&"!

%!97#+!&13+$+.!$!#7$%!1$5&3+$!#7$4!6!((!"'#!1$!5&397#.!'%!1$5&3+$!$"8'%5$*$"#!*$57&"!+*+!&%$!6$&B?!

,3%!+$5'")!74-'#7$+!+!!+!#7&#!($&)$%+!67'!)'!"'#!&"#!5!-&#$!+$;$%$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!5'**!##!"9!

73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!&%$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!&13+$!73*&"!%!97#+!!"!#7$!$($5#!'""4$&%!#7&"!($&)$%+!67'!$A-$5#!

!*-3"!#4?!<"(!B$!#7%$&#+.!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!%$(&#!;$(4!#!*$!!";&%!&"#.!&")!'3%!#7$'%4!)'$+!"'#!-%$)!5#!

7'6!#7$!$88$5#!'8!5'"+$`3$"5$+!'"!%$-%$++!'"!+7'3()!57&"9$!&+!#!*$!#'!#7$!"$&%$+#!$($5#!'"!57&"9$+?!!

J!93%$!=!5'*1!"$+!#7$+$!74-'#7$+$+!&")!!((3+#%&#$+!'3%!#7!%)!74-'#7$+!+!#7&#!#7%$&#+!&")!

5'"+$`3$"5$+!!"#$%&5#?!Z$&)$%+!67'!)'!"'#!&"#!5!-&#$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'".!13#!)'!&"#!5!-&#$!&!

+#%'"9!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%!-'6$%.!+7'3()!1$!#7$!*'+#!(!B$(4!#'!!"5%$&+$!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!"$&%!

#7$!$($5#!'"?!Z$&)$%+!67'!&"#!5!-&#$!&!6$&B!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#!&")!+$%!'3+!E&")!5%$)!1($I!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!

&13+$!+7'3()!1$!#7$!($&+#!(!B$(4!#'!!"5%$&+$!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!#7$!$($5#!'"?!['#$!#7&#!6$!)'!"'#!&##$*-#!#'!

$A-(&!"!&!5'3"#%4\+!';$%&((!($;$(!'8!%$-%$++!'"!13#!%&#7$%!8'53+!'"!+-!B$+!!"!9';$%"*$"#"+-'"+'%$)!

%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!$($5#!'".!67!57!6$!&##%!13#$!#'!&!9';$%"*$"#\+!)$5!+!'"!#'!3+$!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!

#'!*&"!-3(&#$!$($5#!'"!'3#5'*$+?!S"!#7$!"$A#!+$5#!'"!6$!$;&(3&#$!$&57!'8!#7$+$!74-'#7$+$+!$*-!%!5&((4?!!

iJ!93%$!=!&1'3#!7$%$?j!

?&$//".',-$.'+!<.'+(/-/!

,3%!#7$'%4!-%$)!5#+!#7&#!!"53*1$"#+!6!((!$"9&9$!!"!$($5#!'""%$(&#$)!%$-%$++!'"!67$"!#7$4!

$A-$5#!#7&#!)'!"9!+'!%$)35$+!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%!+3%;!;&(!!"!'88!5$!&")!#7$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'"!&%$!

*!"!*&(?!,3%!)$-$")$"#!;&%!&1($!!+!#7$!&""3&(!($;$(!'8!9';$%"*$"#"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"!!"!$&57!

5'3"#%4.!&")!6$!$+#!*&#$!7'6!#7$+$!($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!;&%4!6!#7!#7$!#!*$!#'!&"!$($5#!'"!&")!

&"#!5!-&#$)!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#+!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'"?=G!!

M'!*$&+3%$!,5/0(04-/!B#'.#6605%.!6$!%$(4!'"!Y!"9%&"$((!!&")!U!57&%)+\!]3*&"!U!97#+!@&#&!

$%"*$"#"+-'"+'%$)!*3%)$%.!#'%#3%$.!8'%5$)!)!+&--$&%&"5$!&")!

"=G!M7$!3"!;$%+$!'8!5&+$+!$A5(3)$+!)$;$('-$)!)$*'5%&5!$+?!!!

Page 12: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !!

*1!"$)!$88$5#!'8!'3%!5$"#%&(!$A

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

-'(!#!5&(!!*-%!+'"*$"#!'"!&!"!"$"-'!"#!!")$A?!V$!!"5(3)$!#7$!%!83((!+&*-($!'8!5&+$+.!6!#7!#7$!$A5$-#!'"!

'8!)$;$('-$)!)$*'5%&5!$+.!8%'*!=>e=!#'!FGGH?==!J'%!5'"+!+#$"54!6!#7!'3%!74-'#7$+$+.!#7$!!")$A!!+!

!";$%#$)!+'!#7&#!7!97$%!;&(3$+!!")!5&#$!7!97$%!($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"?!M'!;$%!84!#7&#!'3%!8!")!"9+!&%$!"'#!

+$"+!#!;$!#'!#7$!%!5')!"9!+57$*$.!&")!8'(('6!"9!'#7$%!+#3)!$+!!"!#7$!73*&"!%!97#+!(!#$%&#3%$.!6$!

%$-(!5&#$!'3%!$+#!*&#$+!3+!"9!#6'!&(#$%"&#!;$!8!;$"-'!"#!!")!5$+!'8!+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"!EL!1"$4.!

Y'%"$##.!&")!V'')!FG=GI?!

J'%!)&#&!'"!$($5#!'"!)&#$+!&")!57&%&5#$%!+#!5+.!6$!%$(4!'"!#7$![&#!'"&(!X($5#!'"+!&5%'++!

@$*'5%&54!&")!/3#'5%&54!E[XZ@/I!)&#&+$#!E]4)$!&")!d&%!"';!FGG>I?!!M7$+$!)&#&!5'"#&!"!!"8'%*&#!'"!

8'%!&((!!")$-$")$"#!5'3"#%!$+!6!#7!&!-'-3(&#!'"!';$%!7&(8!&!*!((!'"!8'%!67!57!&#!($&+#!'"$!$($5#!'"!

$;$"#!7&+!'553%%$)?!@$;$('-$)!)$*'5%&5!$+!&%$!$A5(3)$)?!X($5#!'"+!5&"!$!#7$%!1$!8'%!&!"&#!'"&(!

$A$53#!;$!8!93%$.!+357!&+!&!-%$+!)$"#.!'%!8'%!&!"&#!'"&(!($9!+(&#!;$!1')4.!+357!&+!&!-&%(!&*$"#?!S"!'%)$%!

8'%!&"!$($5#!'"!#'!1$!!"5(3)$).!)!%$5#!;'#!"9!*3+#!#&B$!-(&5$!8'%!"&#!'"&(!'88!5$?=F!M&1($!=!+3**&%!0$+!

#7$+$!;&%!&1($+?!!

iM&1($!=!/1'3#!]$%$f!:3**&%4!:#&#!+#!5+j!

S"!'%)$%!#'!$+#!*&#$!#7$!$88$5#!'8!#7$!"$&%"$++!'8!&"!$($5#!'".!6$!*$&+3%$!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!&+!#7$!

#!*$!1$#6$$"!$&57!'1+$%;&#!'"!&")!#7$!"$&%$+#!$($5#!'"?!V$!*$&+3%$!#7!+!;&%!&1($!14!#&B!"9!!"#'!

&55'3"#!1'#7!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!4$&%+!1$8'%$!&")!&8#$%!#7$!$($5#!'".!$A5$-#!67$"!'3%!+-$5!8!5!*$&+3%$+!'8!

#7%$&#+!'"(4!&--(4!#'!#7$!-%$!'%!-'+#"$($5#!'"!-$%!').!&+!)$+5%!1$)!1$('6?!V$!#7$"!$+#!*&#$!#7$!

5' -(&"&#'%4!;&%!&1($+!&")!#7$!"$&%"$++!'8!&"!$($5#!'"!14!!"#$%&5#!"9!

"==!['#$!#7&#!#7!+!!")$A!'"(4!5&-#3%$+!;!'($"5$!5'**!##$)!14!#7$!+#&#$.!&")!$A5(3)$+!;!'($"5$!-$%-$#%&#$)!

14!'#7$%!&5#'%+!+357!&+!'--'+!#!'"!9%'3-+?!

=F!M7!+!)'$+!"'#!!*-(4!&"4#7!"9!&1'3#!#7$!$A#$"#!'8!#7$!8%&"57!+$f!+'*$!%$9!*$+!*&4!5'"+#%3$!#7!+!#'!

*$&"!&!+*&((!-'%#!'"!'8!#7$!-'-3(&#!'"?!:$$!7##-fkk74)$?%$+$&%57?4&($?$)3k"$()&!8'%!&!)!+53++!'"!'8!

5')!"9!%3($+?!!

Page 13: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !#

J#-.6!53/#4(05%!6!#7!!")!5&#'%+!'8!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#+!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'"?!M7!+!%$+3(#+!!"!#7$!

8'(('6!"9!*')$(!"9!&--%'&57.!67$%$!,-.!!")!5&#$+!'"$!'8!#7$!;&%!&1($+!3+$)!#'!*$&+3%$!#7%$&#!'%!

+?5'"+$`3$"5$ !

/012033456-." 7 8 9 :;,-. 9 :<=,-. > ?0@23,5AB0CD456-.E 9 FG-. 9 H- 9 /012033456-.I; 9 J-.!

S"!'%)$%!#'!&55'3"#!8'%!#7$!8&5#!#7&#!&))!#!'"&(!;&%!&1($+!&88$5#!1'#7!%$-%$++!'"!&")!'3%!

#%$&#*$"#!;&%!&1($+.!6$!!"5(3)$!&!;$5#'%!'8!5';&%!&#$+.!G-.?!:!"5$!6$!7&;$!3"*$&+3%$)!7$#$%'9$"$!#4!

&")!%$+!)3&(!&3#'5'%%$(&#!'"!!"!'3%!*')$(.!6$!!"5(3)$!8!A$)!$88$5#+.!H-.!&")!&!(&99$)!)$-$")$"#!;&%!&1($!

EW$5B!&")!b&#0!FGGPI?!V$!&(+'!3+$!%'13+#!+#&")&%)!$%%'%+!#'!&))%$++!7$#$%'+5$)&+#!5!#4?!

M7!+!&--%'&57!7&+!#6'!*&2'%!&);&"#&9$+!';$%!$A!+#!"9!&##$*-#+!#'!$+#!*&#$!#7$!$88$5#!'8!

$($5#!'"+!'"!9';$%"*$"#!%$-%$++!'"?!J!%+#.!!#!&(('6+!3+!#'!$+#!*&#$!7'6!#7$!$88$5#!'8!&"!$($5#!'"!)!88$%+!

5'")!#!'"&(!'"!#7$!($;$(!'8!#7%$&#+!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!&!-&%#!53(&%!$($5#!'"?!:$5'").!14!

3+!"9!&!5'"#!"3'3+!*$&+3%$!'8!#7$!"$&%"$++!#'!&"!$($5#!'".!6$!5&"!$+#!*&#$!#7$!;!'($"5$!($&)!"9!3-!

#'.!&")!8'(('6!"9.!&"!$($5#!'".!%&#7$%!#7&"!'"(4!#7$!;!'($"5$!#7&#!'553%+!!"!#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'"?!/+!

#7$!/0$%1&!2&"!$A&*-($!!((3+#%&#$+.!&!+#%&#$9!5!!"53*1$"#!*&4!3+$!;!'($"5$!('"9!1$8'%$!&"!$($5#!'"!'%!

&8#$%!&"!$($5#!'"!!"!'%)$%!#'!`3$((!#7%$&#+!1$8'%$!#7$4!1$5'*$!;!&1($.!'%!&8#$%!#7$4!&%$!%$;$&($)?!

d$&+3%!"9!-%$"$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$!!+!-&%#!53(&%(4!!*-'%#&"#!67$"!&"!$($5#!'"!!+!$&%(4!'%!(&#$!!"!&!4$&%.!

+!"5$!6$!)'!"'#!$A-$5#!#7&#!;!'($"5$!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!#7$+$!$($5#!'"+!6!((!1$!(!*!#$)!#'!#7$!4$&%!'8!#7$!

$($5#!'"?!!

,3%!8!%+#!74-'#7$+!+!!+!#7&#!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+!67'!&"#!5!-&#$!&!+#%'"9!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%!

-'6$%!&%$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!!"5%$&+$!%$-%$++!'"!&%'3")!$($5#!'"+!#7&"!($&)$%+!67'!)'!"'#!8$$(!#7%$&#$"$)?!!

S8!#7!+!!+!#%3$.!#7$!)&#&!+7'3()!%$;$&(!#6'!#%$")+f!($&)$%+!8&5!"9!9%$&#$%!#7%$&#+!+7'3()!3+$!E&I!7!97$%!

($;$(+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!!"!$($5#!'"!4$&%+!#7&"!($&)$%+!8&5!"9!8$6$%!#7%$&#+!&")!E1I!('6$%!($;$(+!'8!

%$-%$++!'"!67$"!&"!$($5#!'"!!+!8&%#7$%!&6&4!5'*-&%$)!#'!$($5#!'"+!#7&#!&%$!"$&%?!S"!'#7$%!6'%)+.!6$!

$A-$5#!&!+-!B$!!"!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!)3%!"9!&"!$($5#!'"!4$&%!!8!($&)$%+!-$%5$!;$!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%!7'()!'"!

Page 14: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !$

+-%$&)!5'"5$%"+!&1'3#!8%&3)

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

-'6$%?!

S"!'%)$%!#'!#$+#!#7$+$!#%$")+.!6$!8!%+#!*$&+3%$!#7$!#7%$&#!-'+$)!14!'#7$%!5&")!)&#$+!!"!#7$!

$($5#!'"?!V7$"!!"53*1$"#+!%3"!!"!$($5#!'"+!!"!67!57!#7$4!1$(!$;$!#7$4!&%$!"'#!(!B$(4!#'!6!"!'3#%!97#.!

#7$4!+7'3()!1$!*'%$!6!((!"9!#'!3+$!;!'($"5$!#'!`3$((!'--'+!#!'"!*$*1$%+!'%!5&")!)&#$+!#7&"!67$"!

#7$4!)'!"'#!8&5$!5'*-$#!#!;$!$($5#!'"+?!<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6!!")!5&#$+!67$#7$%!-31(!5!'-!"!'"!-'((+.!!8!#7$4!

$A!+#$).!6$%$!C3"8&;'%&1($!#'!#7$!!"53*1$"#?D=Q!J'%!$($5#!'"+!!"!67!57!#7$!!"53*1$"#!%&".!<%4#.(-0%!

L04(5.2!*$&+3%$+!67$#7$%!#7$!!"53*1$"#!6&+!"'#!C5'"8!)$"#!'8!;!5#'%4D!1$8'%$!#7$!$($5#!'"?=P!!W'#7!

;&%!&1($+!&%$!1!"&%4?!!

M7%$&#+!#'!&"!!"53*1$"#\+!-'6$%!5&"!&(+'!&%!+$!)!%$5#(4!8%'*!5!#!0$"+!#7$*+$(;$+?!/+!!"!#7$!C5'('%!

%$;'(3#!'"+D!'%!#7$!FGG>!S%&"!&"!$($5#!'"+.!5!#!0$"+!5&"!#7%$&#$"!&"!!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#!14!-%'#$+#!"9!

$($5#!'"+.!-%';'B!"9!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!#'!%$+-'")!6!#7!%$-%$++!'".!&")!-'#$"#!&((4!#%!99$%!"9!&!545($!'8!

-%'#$+#!&")!%$-%$++!'"!EY&%$4!FGGHI?!V$!*$&+3%$!#7!+!#4-$!'8!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!%$9!*$!6!#7!1!"&%4!!")!5&#'%+!

'8!3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(6!&")!3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&!&")!$A-$5#!1'#7!8%&3)!&")!-%'#$+#+!#'!!"5%$&+$!#7$!#7%$&#!#'!

!"53*1$"#!+3%;!;&(!&")!#7$%$8'%$!#'!!"5%$&+$!$($5#!'""%$(&#$)!%$-%$++!'"?=K!3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&!!"5(3)$+!

6!)$ !!"!#7$!-%$"!&")!-'+#"$($5#!'"!-$%!')+?!!3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(6!5')$+!'"(4!

"=Q!<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6!!+!5')$)!8%'*![XZ@/FH.!&+!=!!8![XZ@/=F!!+!5')$+!&+!C"'D!'%!C[/D?!M7!+!*')$(!

!"5(3)$+!'"(4!#7'+$!$($5#!'"+!!"!67!57!#7$!'88!5$!'8!#7$!!"53*1$"#!!+!5'"#$+#$)?!V7$"!6$!&"&(40$!#7!+!

*')$(!6$!'"(4!*$&+3%$!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!4$&%+!-%!'%!#'!&"!$($5#!'"!+!"5$!#7$!$A-$5#&#!'"!'8!;!5#'%4!+7'3()!

"'#!&88$5#!-'+#"$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$?!!

=P!<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2!!+!5')$)!8%'*![XZ@/=F.!&+!=!!8![XZ@/=F!!+!5')$)!&+!C"'D?![/+!&%$!$A5(3)$).!&")!

#7!+!*')$(!!"5(3)$+!'"(4!#7'+$!$($5#!'"+!!"!67!57!#7$!'88!5$!'8!#7$!!"53*1$"#!!+!5'"#$+#$)?!V7$"!6$!

&"&(40$!#7!+!*')$(!6$!'"(4!*$&+3%$!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!4$&%+!-%!'%!#'!&"!$($5#!'"!+!"5$!#7$!$A-$5#&#!'"!'8!

;!5#'%4!+7'3()!"'#!&88$5#!-'+#"$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$?!

=K!3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&!!+!5')$)!8%'*![XZ@/Fe?!3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(!!+!5')$)!8%'*![XZ@/F>?!

Page 15: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !%

!($++!-%'"$!#'!+#&#$!;!'($"5$

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

-'+#"$($5#!'"!-%'#$+#+.!67!57!+7'3()!'"(4!#7%$&#$"!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!&8#$%!&"!$($5#!'"!7&+!#&B$"!-(&5$?!!J'%!

#7$!*')$(+!!"5(3)!"9!3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(N!6$!#7$%$8'%$!5')$!J#-.6(53/#4(05%!&+!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!4$&%+!+!"5$!

#7$!*'+#!%$5$"#!$($5#!'"?!!!

M7%$&#+!-'+$)!#'!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+!14!$($5#!'"+!&%$!"'#!&(6&4+!5($&%.!&")!#7$!&1+$"5$!'8!

!"8'%*&#!'"!*&4!!#+$(8!-'+$!&!#7%$&#?!/!($&)$%!67'!7&+!1$$"!!"!-'6$%!8'%!&!('"9!-$%!')!'8!#!*$!+7'3()!

7&;$!*'%$!$A-$%!$"5$!3+!"9!#7$!%$!"+!'8!-'6$%!#'!$"+3%$!;!5#'%4.!&")!*'%$!!"8'%*&#!'"!&1'3#!7!+!'%!7$%!

-'-3(&%!#4?!/+!&!%$+3(#.!$A-$%!$"5$)!($&)$%+!+7'3()!1$!($++!(!B$(4!#7&"!!"$A-$%!$"5$)!($&)$%+!#'!%&*-!3-!

-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!1$8'%$.!)3%!"9!'%!&8#$%!#7$!$($5#!'"!-$%!')!&+!&!*$&"+!#'!*&"!-3(&#$!#7$!$($5#!'"?!M'!

*$&+3%$!F#-&#.!!#%A.#.!6$!%$(4!'"!#7$!/%57!9'+!)&#&+$#!'8!-'(!#!5&(!($&)$%+.!67!57!-%';!)$+!)&#&!'"!#7$!

"3*1$%!'8!)&4+!+!"5$!#7$!-%!*&%4!!"53*1$"#!#''B!-'6$%!EL'$*&"+.!L($)!#+57.!&")!Y7!'00&!FGG>I?!:!"5$!

6$!&%$!!"#$%$+#$)!!"!#7$!($"9#7!'8!#$"3%$!&#!#7$!#!*$!'8!&"!$($5#!'".!6$!%$5')$!#7$+$!)&#&!+'!#7&#!$&57!

'1+$%;&#!'"!5'"#&!"+!#7$!#$"3%$!!"!4$&%+!&#!#7$!#!*$!'8!#7$!"$&%$+#!$($5#!'"?=H!!!

M3%"!"9!#'!'3%!+$5'")!74-'#7$+!+.!6$!$A-$5#!#7&#!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%+!67'!&"#!5!-&#$!+$;$%$!

5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!5'**!##!"9!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!&%$!($++!(!B$(4!#'!&13+$!73*&"!%!97#+!!"!#7$!$($5#!'""

4$&%!#7&"!($&)$%+!67'!$A-$5#!!*-3"!#4?!!S"!'#7$%!6'%)+.!67$"!($&)$%+!7&;$!%$&+'"!#'!1$(!$;$!#7&#!

5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!(!B$(4.!6$!$A-$5#!('6$%!($;$(+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!!"!#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'"!

5'*-&%$)!#'!5&+$+!!"!67!57!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!3"(!B$(4?!!!

S"!'%)$%!#'!*$&+3%$!#7$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$.!6$!8!%+#!$A&*!"$!!"+#!#3#!'"&(!

5'"+#%&!"#+!'"!#7$!$A$53#!;$?!X($5#'%&(!+4+#$*+!)!88$%!!"!#7$!$A#$"#!#'!67!57!#7$4!5'"+#%&!"!$A$53#!;$+!&")!

*&B$!#7$*!&55'3"#&1($!#'!'#7$%!-'(!#!5&(!&5#'%+?!/+!/%$")!Z!-7&%#!&")!'#7$%+!7&;$!&%93$).!$($5#'%&(!

+4+#$*+!#7&#!)!;!)$!-'(!#!5&(!-'6$%!&*'"9!*3(#!-($!9%'3-+.!+357!&+!5'3%#+!&")!($9!+(&#!;$!1')!$+.!&%$!

*357 !EZ!2-7&%#!=>eGI?!S"!'%)$%!#'!*$&+3%$!#7!+!5'"5$-#!6$!3+$!3O#4A(0=#!

"=H!/%57!9'+!'"(4!*$&+3%$+!#7$!($"9#7!'8!#$"3%$!'8!#7$!-%!*&%4!-'(!#!5&(!($&)$%?!M7$%$8'%$.!#7$!#$"3%$!

*')$(+!!"5(3)$!'"(4!$($5#!'"+!!"!67!57!!"53*1$"#!%&".!*$&+3%$)!14![XZ@/!F=?!!

Page 16: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !&

P5%6(.-0%(6!8%'*!#7$!O'(!#4!S^!-%'2$5#!Ed&%+7&((!&")!g&99$%+!FGGFI?!M7!+!!")$A!%&"9$+!8%'*!'"$!#'!+$;$"!

&")!*$&+3%$+!#7$!$A#$"#!'8!!"+#!#3#!'"&(!0$)!5'"+#%&!"#+!'"!#7$!)$5!+!'""*&B!"9!-'6$%!'8!57!$8!

$A$53#!;$+.!&")!!"5(3)$+!+357!5'*-'"$"#+!&+!#7$!!")$-$")$"5$!'8!#7$!23)!5!&%4!&")!#7$!)$9%$$!'8!

($9!+(&#!;$!'--'+!#!'"!#'!$A$53#!;$!&5#!'"?!!

[$A#.!6$!8'53+!'"!#7$!23)!5!&%4?!Z$9&(!+4+#$*+!67!57!&%$!&1($!#'!';$%%3($!)$5!+!'"+!'8!#7$!

$A$53#!;$!'%!($9!+(&#3%$!-%';!)$!+'*$!57$5B!'"!&!($&)$%\+!$A5$++?!S"!+'*$!5&+$+.!#7$4!*&4!&(+'!1$!&1($!#'!

-%';!)$!&!#&"9!1($!-$"&(#4!!"!#7$!8'%*!'8!!*-%!+'"*$"#!'%!'#7$%!($9&(!5'"+$`3$"5$+?!M7$!S"+#!#3#!'"+!&")!

X($5#!'"+!O%'2$5#!ES/XOI!-%';!)$+!&!*$&+3%$!'8!23)!5!&(!!")$-$")$"5$!EU$9&".!J%&"B.!&")!Y(&%B!FGG>I?!V$!

5'"+#%35#!&!1!"&%4!;&%!&1($.!$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(6.!1&+$)!3-'"!#7$!%!)&#&.!67!57!*$&+3%$+!67$#7$%!&!5'3%#!

5&"!%3($!'"!$A$53#!;$!'%!($9!+(&#!;$!&5#!'"+?!!

/"'#7$%!+'3%5$!'8!-'#$"#!&(!&55'3"#&1!(!#4!+#$*+!8%'*!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!&5#'%+?!L';$%"*$"#+!#7&#!

3+$!%$-%$++!'"!#'!*&"!-3(&#$!$($5#!'"+!'8#$"!8!")!#7$*+$(;$+!'1+$%;$).!5%!#!5!0$)!'%!+&"5#!'"$)!14!'#7$%!

)$*'5%&5!$+.!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!'%9&"!0&#!'"+.!&")![L,+?!:357!5%!#!5!+*!*&4!($&)!#'!#&"9!1($!5'"+$`3$"5$+!!"!

#7$!8'%*!'8!$5'"'*!5!+&"5#!'"+.!('6$%!($;$(+!'8!8'%$!9"!&!).!&")!%$)35$)!!";$+#*$"#?!d$*1$%+7!-!!"!

!"#$%"&#!'"&(!#%$&#!$+!*&4!!"5%$&+$!5'+#+!'"!%$-%$++!;$!($&)$%+?!/(#7'397!#%$&#!$+!&(*'+#!"$;$%!7&;$!

5%$)!1($!$"8'%5$*$"#!*$57&"!+*+!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+!;!'(&#!'"+.!#7$4!'8#$"!$*-'6$%!"'"+#&#$!&5#'%+!6!#7!

#''(+!#'!-%$++3%$!%$-%$++!;$!9';$%"*$"#+!E&3#7'%I!&")!*&4!#7$%$8'%$!!*-'+$!!")!%$5#!5'+#+!'"!%$-%$++!;$!

($&)$%+?!M%$&#!$+!*&4!&(+'!+7&-$!$(!#$"!"!#!&#$)!&9$")&+!&")!+3--'%#!)'*$+#!5!73*&"!%!97#+!(!#!9&#!'"!

#7&#!5&"!73%#!!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#+!E:!**'"+!FGG>I?!V$!5%$&#$!&!;&%!&1($.!!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&.!67!57!!+!&!

5'3"#!'8!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!#%$&#!$+!#7&#!&!5'3"#%4!7&+!%&#!8!$)!14!&!-&%#!53(&%!4$&%?!M7$+$!)&#&!&%$!8%'*!#7$!

<"!#$)![&#!'"+.!#7$!/8%!5&"!<"!'".!#7$!X3%'-$&"!<"!'"!&")!#7$!,%9&"!0&#!'"!'8!/*$%!5&"!:#&#$+?!

:!*!(&%(4.!6$!$A&*!"$!#7$!HA19#.!5?!HDQ6.!&!('99$)!5'3"#!'8!#7$!"3*1$%!'8![L,+!#7&#!&!5'3"#%4\+!

5!#!0$"+!7&;$!*$*1$%+7!-!!"!$&57!4$&%?!M7$+$!)&#&!6$%$!53(($)!8%'*!#7$!<"!'"!'8!S"#$%"&#!'"&(!

/++'5!&#!'"+!E&3#7'%I?!Z!B$!#%$&#!$+.!*'%$![L,+!+7'3()!!"5%$&+$!#7$!(!B$(4!5'"+$`3$"5$+.!&")!#7$%$14!

Page 17: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !'

"'#!&))%$++!"9!3"'1+$%;$)!7$#$

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

)$5%$&+$!#7$!3+$!'8!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"?!!

J'(('6!"9!'#7$%!+#3)!$+!'"!%$-%$++!'".!&")!1$5&3+$!#7%$&#+!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!-&%#!&((4!

)$#$%*!"$)!14!'#7$%!8&5#'%+!67!57!+7'3()!!"8(3$"5$!%$-%$++!'".!6$!!"5(3)$!+$;$%&(!5'"#%'(!;&%!&1($+!!"!&((!

*')$(+?!!:!"5$!6$!$A-$5#!#7&#!!"53*1$"#+!6!((!1$!*'%$!5&-&1($!'8!)!%$5#!"9!#7$!+#&#$!&--&%&#3+!#'!3+$!

$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'".!&")!*&4!&(+'!;&(3$!#7$!1$"$8!#+!'8!7'()!"9!'88!5$!*'%$!#7&"!"'""!"53*1$"#+.!6$!

!"5(3)$!&!1!"&%4!*$&+3%$!'8!67$#7$%!#7$!!"53*1$"#!5'"#$+#$)!#7$!$($5#!'".!$%4A19#%(!BA%?=T!!V$!

!"5(3)$!&!*$&+3%$!'8!P0=0/!R-.!!"#$"+!#4!8%'*!#7$!d&2'%!X-!+')$+!'8!O'(!#!5&(!^!'($"5$!@&#&+$#!EdXO^I!

Ed&%+7&((!FGGTI!1$5&3+$!6&%!#$")+!#'!1$!5'%%$(&#$)!6!#7!&!+-!B$!!"!73*&"!%!97#+!;!'(&#!'"+!EO'$.!M&#$.!

&")!Y&*-!=>>>I?!W$5&3+$!&!9';$%"*$"#\+!3+$!'8!%$-%$++!'"!*&4!1$!!"8(3$"5$)!14!6$&(#7.!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!

$5'"'*!5!$A-'+3%$.!'%!#7$!5'3"#%4\+!+!0$!6$!&(+'!!"5(3)$!D>,!E('9I.!!.-&#!E('9I!&")!,5'A/-(05%!E('9I!8%'*!

#7$!V'%()!@$;$('-*$"#!S")!5&#'%+!EV'%()!W&"B!FGGHI?!!!!

V$!$+#!*&#$!#7$!*')$(!&1';$!3+!"9!'%)!"&%4!($&+#!+`3&%$+.!8'%!+$;$%&(!%$&+'"+?!J!%+#.!1$+!)$+!

#7$!8($A!1!(!#4!'8!,Z:.!&(#$%"&#!;$+!+357!&+!'%)$%$)!-%'1!#!-%';!)$!$+#!*&#$+!#7&#!&%$!!"5'"+!+#$"#!&")!

)!88!53(#!#'!$+#!*&#$!!"!8!A$)!$88$5#+!&")!)4"&*!5!+-$5!8!5&#!'"+!EL%$$"$!&")!]$"+7$%!FGG>I?=e!/(#7'397!

3+!"9!,Z:!!"!&"!'%)$%$)!5'"#$A#!!+!"'#!5'*-($#$(4!8%$$!'8!#7$+$!57&(($"9$+.!#7$!1!&+$+!!"#%')35$)!14!

%'9$"$!#4!&")!#!*$!)4"&*!5+!&%$!*'%$!+$%!'3+!-%'1($*+.!-&%#!53(&%(4!

"=T!M7!+!;&%!&1($!!+!5')$)!8%'*![XZ@/F=!E@!)!#7$!!"53*1$"#!%3"lI?!V7$"!6$!(!*!#!#7$!+&*-($!1&+$)!'"!

!"53*1$"54!!"!#7$!*')$(+!!"5(3)!"9!<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2!&")!<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6.!6$!3+$![XZ@/FG!EV&+!#7$!

'88!5$!'8!#7$!!"53*1$"#!5'"#$+#$)lI?!!

=e!/+!6!#7!1!"&%4!*')$(+.!#7$!3+$!'8!8!A$)!$88$5#+!5%$&#$+!&"!!"5!)$"#&(!-&%&*$#$%+!-%'1($*!67!57!5&"!

%$+3(#!!"!!"5'"+!+#$"#!$+#!*&#$+!E+$$!L%$$"$!&")!]$"+7$%!FGG>!8'%!&!)!+53++!'"I?!/!8$6!+57'(&%+!7&;$!

3+$)!dYdY!*$#7')+!#'!$+#!*&#$!'%)$%$)!*')$(+!6!#7!)4"&*!5!+-$5!8!5&#!'"+!Edm(($%!&")!Y0&)'!FGGK.!

L!%&%)!&")!O&%$"#!FGG=I.!7'6$;$%!#7$+$!*$#7')+!7&;$!"'#!1$$"!3#!(!0$)!#'")&#$!#'!&))%$++!73*&"!

%!97#+!)&#&?!!

Page 18: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !(

67$"!(''B!"9!&#!$($5#!'"!#!*!"9.!67!57!$A7!1!#+!5'"+!)$%&1($!5%'++""&#!'"&(!7$#$%'9$"$!#4!EW$5B!&")!

b&#0!=>>KI?!]'6$;$%.!#'!)$*'"+#%&#$!#7&#!'3%!%$+3(#+!7'()!3")$%!&(#$%"&#!;$!+-$5!8!5&#!'"+.!6$!

%$-(!5&#$!#7$!&"&(4+!+!3+!"9!'%)$%$)!-%'1!#?=>!!

,3%!5$"#%&(!$*-!%!5&(!%$+3(#+!!"5(3)$!!"#$%&5#!'"+!1$#6$$"!J#-.6(53/#4(05%!&")!+31+#&"#!;$!

;&%!&1($+?!M'!-%$+$"#!'3%!%$+3(#+!!"!&!*&""$%!#7&#!&!)+!+31+#&"#!;$!!"#$%-%$#&#!'".!6$!-%$+$"#!-%$)!5#$)!

($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!8'%!$&57!'8!#7$!#%$&#*$"#!;&%!&1($+!EM&1($!FI?FG!J'%!!"#$%&5#!'"!#$%*+!!";'(;!"9!

5'"#!"3'3+!;&%!&1($+.!#7$!5'$88!5!$"#+!&")!+#&")&%)!$%%'%+!5&""'#!1$!!"#$%-%$#$)!6!#7'3#!(''B!"9!&#!#7$!

5'*1!"$)!$88$5#!'8!$&57!!"#$%&5#!'"!EW%&*1'%!$#!&(?!FGGHI?!!M7$%$8'%$.!#7$!-%$)!5#$)!($;$(+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!

%$-%$++!'"!!"!M&1($!F!&%$!$+#!*&#$+!'8!#7$!$88$5#!'8!$&57!+31+#&"#!;$!;&%!&1($!67$"!$($5#!'"+!&%$!"$&%.!

67$"!$($5#!'"+!&%$!)!+#&"#.!&")!67$"!#7$!+31+#&"#!;$!;&%!&1($!!+!&#!!#+!*&A!*3*!&")!*!"!*3*?!!W4!

$A&*!"!"9!7'6!#7$!$+#!*&#$)!3+$!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!57&"9$+!6!#7!#!*$!#'!&"!$($5#!'".!&")!&#!

)!88$%$"#!;&(3$+!'8!#7$!+31+#&"#!;$!;&%!&1($+.!M&1($!F!*&B$+!#7$!+#&#!+#!5&(!+!9"!8!5&"5$!&")!+31+#&"#!;$!

!"#$%-%$#&#!'"!'8!74-'#7$+$+!5($&%$%!#7&"!#7$!3"#%&"+8'%*$)!5'$88!5!$"#+!&")!+#&")&%)!$%%'%+!&('"$?!!

iM&1($!F!/1'3#!]$%$j!

M7$!%$+3(#+!!"!M&1($!F!&%$!(&%9$(4!5'"+!+#$"#!6!#7!'3%!74-'#7$+$+?!V7$"!&"!!"53*1$"#!!+!8&5!"9!

<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6!'%!<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2!!"!#7$!-%$"$($5#!'"!-$%!').!#7$!&;$%&9$!($;$(!'8!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!

$($5#!'"!!+!"$&%(4!)'31($!#7$!&;$%&9$!($;$(!'8!%$-%$++!'"!67$"!$($5#!'"+!&%$!83%#7$%!&6&4?!V7$"!-'((+!&%$!

8&;'%&1($!#'!#7$!!"53*1$"#!($&)$%.!$($5#!'"+!&5#3&((4!7&;$!&!)$-%$++!"9.!#7'397!!"+!9"!8!5&"#.!$88$5#!'"!

;!'($"5$?!/+!6$!74-'#7$+!0$).!#7$+$!%$+3(#+!&%$!5'"+!+#$"#!6!#7!#7$!&%93*$"#!#7&#!!"53*1$"#+!3+$!

%$-%$++!'"!&+!&!+#%&#$9!5!$($5#'%&(!#&5#!5!#'!`3$((!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%!-'6$%?!V7$"!#7$!-%'1&1!(!#4!'8!('+!"9!&"!

$($5#!'"!!+!('6.!$($5#!'""%$(&#$)!!"5%$&+$+!!"!%$-%$++!'"!&%$!3"(!B$(4?!V7$"!#7$!-%'1&1!(!#4!!+!7!97.!#7$!3+$!

'8!%$-%$++!'"!&#!$($5#!'""#!*$!!"5%$&+$+!+7&%-(4?!!!

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!*"KLM"NOPMO"QONRST"OMUVWTU"XOM"QOMUMYTMP"SY"KXRWM"&Z""

FG!M7$!3"#%&"+8'%*$)!5'$88!5!$"#+!&%$!!"5(3)$)!!"!M&1($!P?!!

Page 19: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !)

!('6$%!-%$)!5#$)!($;$(!'8!%$-%

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

V$!&(+'!8!")!+3--'%#!8'%!#7$!$88$5#!'8!5!#!0$"!3"%$+#!&+!&!8'%*!'8!#7%$&#?!X($5#!'"+!!"!67!57!

5'"5$%"+!&1'3#!3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&!&%$!6!)$+-%$&)!&%$!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!*'%$!#7&"!QGR!7!97$%!($;$(+!'8!

%$-%$++!'"!#7&"!$($5#!'"+!6!#7'3#!#7!+!8'%*!'8!3"%$+#?!M7$!%$+3(#+!8'%!3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(!&%$!&(+'!&++'5!&#$)!

6!#7!&"!$($5#!'""4$&%!!"5%$&+$!!"!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'".!&(#7'397!#7$!$+#!*&#$)!)!88$%$"5$!1$#6$$"!

$($5#!'"+!6!#7!-%'#$+#!&")!#7'+$!6!#7'3#!-%'#$+#!!+!-'+!#!;$.!13#!"'#!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#?!M7$+$!%$+3(#+!

+399$+#!#7&#!9';$%"*$"#!;!'($"5$!!+!&!5'**'"!%$+-'"+$!#'!#7$!#7%$&#!-'+$)!14!-'-3(&%!*';$*$"#+?!!

S"53*1$"#+!6!#7!&!+7'%#$%!!#%A.#!&%$!&(+'!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!3+$!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!

$($5#!'"?!V$!8!")!#7&#!67$"!!"53*1$"#+!7&;$!1$$"!!"!-'6$%!8'%!($++!#7&"!&!4$&%.!#7$4!3+$!&"!$+#!*&#$)!

TTR!15.#!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!$($5#!'"!#7&"!67$"!$($5#!'"+!&%$!)!+#&"#?!S"!5'*-&%!+'".!*'%$!$+#&1(!+7$)!

($&)$%+!3+$!&"!$+#!*&#$)!PFR!/#66!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!$($5#!'"?!Y'"#%&%4!#'!#7$!5'**'"!&++3*-#!'"!#7&#!

$"#%$"57$)!&3#'5%&#!5!!"53*1$"#+!&%$!#7$!*'+#!5&-&1($!&")!6!((!"9!#'!3+$!;!'($"5$.!#7$+$!%$+3(#+!

+399$+#!#7&#!$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$!!+!!"+#$&)!&!#''(!'8!#7$!6$&B!&")!!"$A-$%!$"5$)?!M7!+!*&4!1$!)3$!#'!&!

"3*1$%!'8!8&5#'%+?!V$!7&;$!&%93$)!#7&#!"$6!!"53*1$"#+!*&4!(&5B!!"8'%*&#!'"!&1'3#!#7$!%!&1!(!#4!#'!6!"!

&"!$($5#!'".!)3$!#'!#7$!%!!"$A-$%!$"5$!6!#7!*'1!(!0!"9!+3--'%#?!]'6$;$%.!"$6$%!!"53*1$"#+!'8#$"!7&;$!&!

9%$&#$%!"3*1$%!'8!;!&1($!57&(($"9$+!#'!#7$!%!%3($!#7&"!$+#&1(!+7$)!!"53*1$"#+.!&").!&+!&!%$+3(#.!"$6!

($&)$%+!*&4!&(+'!8$$(!*'%$!#7%$&#$"$)!&")!1$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!%$+'%#!#'!;!'($"5$!&+!&!*$&"+!#'!$"+3%$!

#7$!%!5'"#!"3$)!%3($?!!

V$!&(+'!8!")!#7&#!#7$!($;$(!'8!9';$%"*$"#"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"!!+!5'")!#!'"&(!'"!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!

5'"+#%&!"#+!8&5$)!14!#7$!!"53*1$"#?!X($5#!'"+!6!#7!&!*&A!*3*!"3*1$%!'8!3O#4A(0=#!P5%6(.-0%(6!7&;$!&!

FQR $++!'"!#7&"!$($5#!'"+!6!#7!'"(4!&!*!"!*3*!"3*1$%!'8!5'"+#%&!"#+?F=!

"F=!S#!!+!)!88!53(#!#'!%$2$5#!#7$!74-'#7$+!+!#7&#!7!97!XA$53#!;$!Y'"+#%&!"#+!&(6&4+!($&)!#'!('6$%!($;$(+!'8!

%$-%$++!'"!)3$!#'!#7$!8&5#!#7&#!#7$%$!!+!"'#!&!+!9"!8!5&"#!)!88$%$"5$!!"!"$&%!&")!)!+#&"#!$($5#!'"+?!M7$!

5'"+#%&!"!"9!$88$5#!'8!XA$53#!;$!Y'"+#%&!"#+!'"!+-$5!8!5&((4!$($5#!'""%$(&#$)!;!'($"5$!1$5'*$+!*'%$!

&--&%$"#!67$"!6$!&))%$++!#7$!5'*1!"$)!$88$5#+!1$('6?!!

Page 20: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" !*

:!"5$!#7!+!*')$(!!"5(3)$+

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

:!*!(&%(4.!67$"!#7$!P5A.(!+4+#$*!7&+!';$%+!97#!';$%!#7$!&5#!'"+!'8!#7$!9';$%"*$"#.!#7$%$!!+!&"!$+#!*&#$)!

QFR!($++!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!$($5#!'"!#7&"!)!+#&"#!8%'*!&"!$($5#!'"?!M7$+$!%$+3(#+!+399$+#!#7&#!

!"53*1$"#+!&%$!+$"+!#!;$!#'!#7$!!"+#!#3#!'"&(!5'+#+!'8!3+!"9!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!$($5#!'"?!

S"#$%"&#!'"&(!&5#'%+!*&4!&(+'!-(&4!&!%'($!!"!#7$!)$5!+!'"!#'!3+$!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"?!J'%!5'3"#%!$+!

#7&#!7&;$!+!9"$)!#7$!*&A!*3*!"3*1$%!'8!!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&.!6$!'1+$%;$!+!9"!8!5&"#(4!($++!%$-%$++!'"!!"!

#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'"!#7&"!)!+#&"#!8%'*!&"!$($5#!'".!&!)$5%$&+$!'8!';$%!QFR?!V$!$+#!*&#$!($++!'8!&!

)$5%$&+$!E=QRI!67$"!6$!(''B!&#!+#&#$+!6!#7!#7$!*&A!*3*!HA19#.!5?!HDQ6!E/5CG.!7'6$;$%!6$!+#!((!8!")!&!

+!9"!8!5&"#!%$)35#!'"!!"!9';$%"*$"#"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'"?FF!!

,3%!#7!%)!74-'#7$+!+!E!((3+#%&#$)!!"!J!93%$!=I!-%$)!5#+!#7&#!#7$!9%$&#$+#!($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!+7'3()!

'553%!67$"!#7%$&#+!&%$!7!97!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'"!&%$!8$6?!S"!'%)$%!#'!#$+#!#7!+!74-'#7$+!+.!

6$!$+#!*&#$!'3%!*')$(!14!!"5(3)!"9!#7$!83((!+$#!'8!!"#$%&5#!'"+!1$#6$$"!#7%$&#+.!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&")!

J#-.6(53/#4(05%;)S!M7!+!&--%'&57!&(('6+!3+!#'!$+#!*&#$!67$#7$%!#7$!$88$5#!'8!#7%$&#+!!+!5'")!#!'"&(!'"!#7$!

+$;$%!#4!'8!5'"+$`3$"5$+?FP!!

!*3(#!-($!!"#$%&5#!'"+.!6$!-%$+$"#!#7$!%$+3(#+!14!-%$)!5#!"9!5'")!#!'"&(!

"FF!V$!&(+'!$+#!*&#$!#7&#!+#&#$+!6!#7!#7$!*&A!*3*!"3*1$%!'8![L,+!3+$!*'%$!%$-%$++!'".!!"!9$"$%&(.!

#7&"!+#&#$+!6!#7!8$6![L,+?!M7!+!*&4!1$!)3$!#'!&!+$($5#!'"!$88$5#f!*&"4![L,+!#&%9$#!+#&#$+!6!#7!+$;$%$!

73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+?!:!"5$!#7!+!$88$5#!!+!3"(!B$(4!#'!1$!5&3+&(.!6$!)'!"'#!1$(!$;$!!#!57&(($"9$+!'3%!

+31+#&"#!;$!8!")!"9!#7&#![L,+!%$)35$!#7$!($;$(!'8!;!'($"5$!)3%!"9!&"!$($5#!'"?!!

FQ!M7!+!%$+3(#+!!"!#7$!8'(('6!"9!*')$(.!67$%$!0!!")$A$+!5'3"#%4!&")!(!!")$A$+!4$&%f!/012033456-." 7

9:;,[20@D-. 9 :<=,[20@D-. > ?0@23,5AB0CD456-.E 9 :\=]5630^_06C03-. > ?0@23,5AB0CD456-.E 9

":̀ =,[20@D-. > ]5630^_06C03-.E 9":a=,[20@D-. > ]5630^_06C03 > "?0@23,5AB0CD456-.E 9 "FG-. 9

H- 9 /012033456-.I; "9 J-.?!

FP!/+!"'#$)!14!b!"9!&")!c$"9!EFGGHI.!!#!!+!!*-'%#&"#!#'!#&B$!!"#'!&55'3"#!#7$!(!*!#+!'8!&"&(40!"9!'3%!)&#&!

&#!#7$!$A#%$*$!(!*!#+!'8!'3%!*')$(?!

Page 21: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #+

$&#+!&%$!&#!#7$!%!*&A!*3*?!!

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

$88$5#+?!V$!&%$!-%!*&%!(4!!"#$%$+#$)!!"!7'6!#7$!5'")!#!'"&(!$88$5#!'8!#7%$&#+!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!!"8(3$"5$+!

#7$!(!B$(!7'')!#7&#!%$-%$++!'"!6!((!!"5%$&+$!!"!#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'"?!M&1($!Q!-%';!)$+!#7$!$+#!*&#$)!

57&"9$!!"!%$-%$++!'"!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!&!57&"9$!8%'*!*&A!*3*!#'!*!"!*3*!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!&#!;&%!'3+!

($;$(+!'8!#7%$&#+!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+?!/!-'+!#!;$!E&")!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#I!;&(3$!!"!#7!+!#&1($!!")!5&#$+!

#7&#!#7$!&++'5!&#$)!$($5#!'"+!7&;$!!"5%$&+$)!($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!5'*-&%$)!#'!4$&%+!83%#7$%!8%'*!#7&#!

$($5#!'"?!/!"$9&#!;$!E&")!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#I!;&(3$!!")!5&#$+!#7&#!#7$!&++'5!&#$)!$($5#!'"+!&%$!

$+#!*&#$)!#'!7&;$!('6$%!($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!#7&"!"'""$($5#!'"!4$&%+?!L$"$%&((4.!!"!$&57!9%'3-!'8!8'3%!

5$((+.!6$!$A-$5#!#7&#!#7$!7!97$+#!($;$(!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!+7'3()!'553%!67$"!#7%$&#+!&%$!7!97!&")!

5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!('6?!M7$+$!5$((+!&%$!7!97(!97#$)!!"!9%&4?!/((!'#7$%!5'")!#!'"+.!$+-$5!&((4!#7$!'--'+!#$!

5'")!#!'"+!!"!67!57!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!7!97!&")!#7%$&#+!&%$!('6.!+7'3()!1$!('6$%!#7&"!#7$!$+#!*&#$+!'8!

-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!!"!#7$!&++'5!&#$)!9%&4!5$((!E13#!"'#!"$5$++&%!(4!"$9&#!;$!'%!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#I?!!!!

iM&1($!Q!&1'3#!7$%$j!

M7$!%$+3(#+!!"!M&1($!Q!(&%9$(4!+3--'%#!'3%!#7!%)!74-'#7$+!+?!V$!8!")!#7&#!#7$!(&%9$+#!!"5%$&+$+!!"!

%$-%$++!'"!&%$!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!5&+$+!!"!67!57!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!*!"!*&(!&")!-'(!#!5&(!#7%$&#!!+!7!97?!J'%!

$A&*-($.!67$"!+#&#$+!(&5B!&"!$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(.!#7$"!<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2.!<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6!&")!3/#4(5.-/!

M.-A&!&%$!&((!+!9"!8!5&"#(4!-'+!#!;$!&")!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!&!+31+#&"#!&(!EF!#'!P!-'!"#I!!"5%$&+$!!"!9';$%"*$"#!

%$-%$++!'"!)3%!"9!&"!$($5#!'"?!S"!5'"#%&+#.!67$"!9';$%"*$"#+!7&;$!#7$!';$%+!97#!'8!&"!$%&#'#%&#%(!

P5A.(N!-'(!#!5&(!#7%$&#+!&%$!"'#!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!&!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#!!"5%$&+$!!"!%$-%$++!'"?!V$!+$$!

+!*!(&%!%$+3(#+!67$"!6$!(''B!&#!3O#4A(0=#!P5%6(.-0%(6!&")!!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&?!S"!"'!5&+$+!&%$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!

&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!&!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#!!"5%$&+$!!"!%$-%$++!'"!&").!6!#7!+'*$!!"#$%$+#!"9!$A5$-#!'"+.FK!

6$!+$$!&!+!9"!8!5&"#!!"5%$&+$!!"!%$-%$++!'"!67$"$;$%!3O#4A(0=#!P5%6(.-0%(6!&")!!.#-(0#6!&%$!*!"!*&(!&")!

#7%

"FK!S"!M&1($!Q.!#7$!!"#$%&5#$)!%$+3(#+!67$"!3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&!$A!+#+!E*&AI!&")!67$"!5'"+#%&!"#+!&%$!('6!)'!

"'#!8!#!'3%!$A-$5#&#!'"a!#7$4!&%$!"'#!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#?!!

Page 22: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #!

57''+$!67$#7$%!#'!7'()!$($5#!'"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

M7$+$!$+#!*&#$+!5'3()!1$!3+$)!#'!+399$+#!&!)!%$!83#3%$!8'%!5'3"#%!$+!6!#7!6$&B!!"+#!#3#!'"+!&")!

5'*-$#!#!;$!$";!%'"*$"#+?!/(#7'397!$($5#!'"+!*&4!-%';'B$!!"5%$&+$)!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'".!'3%!%$+3(#+!

&(+'!'88$%!+'*$!%$5'**$")&#!'"+!8'%!5'3"#$%!"9!#7$+$!#%$")+?!V7!($!5'*-$#!#!'"!*&4!!"5%$&+$!

!"5$"#!;$+!#'!$"9&9$!!"!%$-%$++!'".!#7'+$!!"5$"#!;$+!5&"!1$!+3--%$++$)!14!+#%'"9!!"+#!#3#!'"+!#7&#!

!"5%$&+$!#7$!(!B$(4!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!($&)$%+!67'!$"9&9$!!"!%$-%$++!'"?!S"!5'3"#%!$+!#7&#!$A-$%!$"5$!

-%'1($*+!6!#7!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'".!!"5%$&+!"9!#7$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!%$-%$++!'"!+7'3()!%$)35$!#7$!3+$!'8!

%$-%$++!'"!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!#&5#!5?!

<+,"&.',-@"!*>;+'.',-$./!'.0!2$6=/,."//!?1"%9/!

,3%!-%!*&%4!%$+3(#!!+!#7&#!67$"!($&)$%+!8&5$!+#%'"9!&")!5%$)!1($!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%!-'6$%.!&")!

8$6!5'"+$`3$"5$+.!#7$4!&%$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!!"5%$&+$!%$-%$++!'"!!"!'%)$%!#'!*&"!-3(&#$!$($5#!'"+?!M7$+$!

%$+3(#+!-%';!)$!+#%'"9!$;!)$"5$!!"!+3--'%#!'8!'3%!74-'#7$+$+.!&")!&%$!%'13+#!#'!*3(#!-($!&(#$%"&#!;$!

+-$5!8!5&#!'"+!&")!#7$'%!$+?!S"!#7$!+3--($*$"#&%4!'"(!"$!&--$")!A.!6$!%$(&A!&!"3*1$%!'8!'3%!*')$(!"9!

&++3*-#!'"+!14!%$-(!5&#!"9!'3%!%$+3(#+!14!3+!"9!%&")'*!%&#7$%!#7&"!8!A$)"$88$5#+.!!5(3+#$%!"9!'3%!

+#&")&%)!$%%'%+.!$A5(3)!"9!'3#(!$%+.!3+!"9!8!%+#!'%)$%!&3#'%$9%$++!;$!E/U=I!+-$5!8!5&#!'"+.!-%';!)!"9!

-&"$(!5'%%$5#$)!+#&")&%)!$%%'%+.!8!%+#!)!88$%$"5!"9.!&")!!"5(3)!"9!#!*$!#%$")+?!M7$+$!%'13+#"$++!57$5B+!

&((!5'"8!%*!'3%!%$+3(#+.!&")!#7$!5'$88!5!$"#+!'"!'3%!-%!*&%4!*')$(+!%$*&!"!+#%'"9!&")!+!9"!8!5&"#?FH!!

:$5'").!&+!&!57$5B!'"!67$#7$%!'3%!%$+3(#+!&%$!+$"+!#!;$!#'!#7$!5')!"9!'8!'3%!)$-$")$"#!;&%!&1($.!

6$!%$"$+#!*&#$!'3%!*')$(+!3+!"9!#7$!O'(!#!5&(!M$%%'%!:5&($!EOM:I!EL!1"$4.!Y'%"$##.!&")!V'')!FG=GI?!V$!

5'"8!%*!'3%!$+#!*&#$+!3+!"9!1'#7!5'*-'"$"#+!'8!#7$!OM:.!!"5(3)!"9!#7$!/*"$+#4!S"#$%"&#!'"&(!&")!:#&#$!

@$-&%#*$"#!)&#&?FT!!

M7!%).!6$!&))%$++!#7$!-'++!1!(!#4!'8!$")'9$"'3+!$($5#!'"!#!*!"9?!S8!!"53*1$"#+!%$93(&%(4!

+!!"!%$+-'"+$!#'!+#%$"9#7$"!"9!-'(!#!5&(!'--'+!#!'".!!#!!+!5'"5$!;&1($!

"FH!/--$")!A!M&1($+!="P!-%$+$"#!#7$+$!%$+3(#+?!M7$!'"(!"$!&--$")!A!!+!&;&!(&1($!&#!7##-fkknnnnnnnn?!!!

FT!/--$")!A!M&1($+!="F!-%$+$"#!#7$+$!%$+3(#+?!

Page 23: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" ##

M7$!5%'++""&#!'"&(!$*-!%

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#7&#!#7$!%$(&#!'"+7!-!1$#6$$"!#7%$&#+!&")!%$-%$++!'"!!+!+-3%!'3+?!V$!8!")!#7!+!'12$5#!'"!3"(!B$(4?!,3#!

'8!&((!$($5#!'"+!!"!'3%!+&*-($.!($++!#7&"!=GR!6$%$!7$()!&55'%)!"9!#'!&"!C!%%$93(&%D!$($5#'%&(!+57$)3($.!

&55'%)!"9!#'!#7$![XZ@/!)&#&?!]'6$;$%.!#'!83%#7$%!&55'3"#!8'%!#7$!-'++!1!(!#4!#7&#!$($5#!'"!#!*!"9!

5'"8'3")+!'3%!$+#!*&#$+.!6$!%$"$+#!*&#$!'3%!*')$(+!$A5(3)!"9!$($5#!'"+!67!57!&%$!7$()!$&%(!$%!'%!(&#$%!

#7&"!#7$!%!+57$)3($)!)&#$?!V$!8!")!;$%4!(!##($!)!88$%$"5$!1$#6$$"!#7!+!%$+#%!5#$)!+&*-($!&")!#7$!

5'*-($#$!)&#&+$#?Fe!!

J!"&((4.!6$!%$(&A!'3%!&++3*-#!'"!#7&#!#7$!!"53*1$"#!%$+-'")+!+!*!(&%(4!#'!1'#7!$A$53#!;$!&")!

($9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+?F>!V$!&++3*$!#7&#!1'#7!#4-$+!'8!$($5#!'"+!5&"!-'+$!&!#7%$&#!#'!#7$!!"53*1$"#!

($&)$%+7!-.!&")!+!*!(&%!)4"&*!5+!!"!$&57!5&"!($&)!#7$!!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#!#'!!"5%$&+$!73*&"!%!97#+!

&13+$+!!"!%$+-'"+$?!!]'6$;$%.!$A$53#!;$!&")!($9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+!5'3()!1$!+31+#&"#!;$(4!)!88$%$"#!!"!

#$%*+!'8!67$"!($&)$%+!&%$!*'+#!(!B$(4!#'!3+$!%$-%$++!'"!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!#&5#!5?!M'!#$+#!'3%!&++3*-#!'"!

#7&#!#7$!)4"&*!5+!&%$!+!*!(&%!1$#6$$"!)!88$%$"#!#4-$+!'8!$($5#!'"+.!6$!%$"$+#!*&#$!'3%!*')$(+!6!#7!

'"(4!$A$53#!;$!$($5#!'"+!&")!6!#7!'"(4!($9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+?!,3%!%$+3(#+!%$*&!"!+#%'"9$+#!8'%!$A$53#!;$!

$($5#!'"+.!&(#7'397!*&"4!'8!#7$!$+#!*&#$+!&%$!&(+'!+!9"!8!5&"#!8'%!($9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+?QG!!S"!-&%#!53(&%.!

6$!'1+$%;$!&!+!*!(&%!!"5%$&+$!!"!;!'($"5$!67$"!$($5#!'"+!&%$!57&%&5#$%!0$)!14!$($5#!'"!8%&3)!'%!-'+#"

$($5#!'"!-%'#$+#.!&")!&!+!*!(&%!%$)35#!'"!!"!;!'($"5$!67$"!5'3"#%!$+!7&;$!+#%'"9!5'"+#%&!"#+!'"!#7$!

$A$53#!;$!&")!7&;$!!")$-$")$"#!5'3%#+?!

?'/"!A,=0-"/Q=!!

!5&(!&"&(4+!+!($")+!+3--'%#!#'!'3%!#7$'%4.!&")!#7$!%$+3(#+!&%$!%'13+#!#'!

"Fe!/--$")!A!M&1($+!Q!o!P!-%$+$"#!#7$+$!%$+3(#+?!

F>!Z$9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+!!"5(3)$!1'#7!($9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+!!"!-%$+!)$"#!&(!'%!*!A$)!+4+#$*+!&")!

-&%(!&*$"#&%4!$($5#!'"+?!!

QG!/--$")!A!M&1($+!K!o!H!-%$+$"#!#7$+$!%$+3(#+?!!

Q=!V$!#7&"B!nnnnnnn!8'%!!";&(3&1($!%$+$&%57!&++!+#&"5$!'"!#7$!c!*1&16$!&")!S%&"!5&+$+?!!

Page 24: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #$

!#7$!FGGG!-&%(!&*$"#&%

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

&(#$%"&#!;$!+-$5!8!5&#!'"+.!4$#!6!#7!""4$&%!;&%!&#!'"!!"!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!!+!&%#!8!5!&((4!5'")$"+$)!!"#'!

&""3&(!'1+$%;&#!'"+?!@$#&!($)!5&+$!+#3)!$+!5&"!7$(-!#'!$;&(3&#$!'3%!74-'#7$+$+!6!#7!*'%$!8!"$"9%&!"$)!

!"8'%*&#!'"!EZ!$1$%*&"!FGG>I?!!,8#$".!$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$!+-!B$+!!"!#7$!*'"#7+!-%!'%!#'!&")!&8#$%!&"!

$($5#!'".!&")!'3%!+#&#!+#!5&(!*')$(+!)'!"'#!83((4!!)$"#!84!#7$+$!+-!B$+!1$5&3+$!'3%!73*&"!%!97#+!)&#&!&%$!

(!*!#$)!#'!&""3&(!!"8'%*&#!'"?!]$%$.!6$!5'"8!%*!'3%!%$+3(#+!3+!"9!)$#&!($)!!"8'%*&#!'".!!"5(3)!"9!

*'"#7(4!)&#&!'"!&13+$+.!67!57!6$!7&;$!5'(($5#$)!&5%'++!+$;$%&(!$($5#!'"+!!"!c!*1&16$!&")!S%&"?!V$!

3+$)!$A!+#!"9!%$-'%#+!'"!73*&"!%!97#+.!!"5(3)!"9!#7'+$!8%'*!#7$!<?:?!:#&#$!@$-&%#*$"#!&")!/*"$+#4!

S"#$%"&#!'"&(.!67!57!&%$!3+$)!#'!5%$&#$!#7$!,5/0(04-/!B#'.#6605%!;&%!&1($.!&+!6$((!&+!%$-'%#+!!"!#7$!

!"#$%"&#!'"&(!"$6+!*$)!&.!#'!5')$!$&57!+-$5!8!5!!"+#&"5$!'8!$($5#!'""%$(&#$)!+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!%$-%$++!'".!

!"5(3)!"9!#7$!)&#$.!-$%-$#%&#'%+.!;!5#!*+.!&")!"3*1$%!'8!!")!;!)3&(+!&88$5#$)?!!

!"#$%$&'!

U'1$%#!d39&1$!!+!'"$!'8!6'%()\+!('"9$+#!%3(!"9!)!5#&#'%+?!]$!7&+!1$$"!-%$+!)$"#!'8!c!*1&16$!_!&!

"'*!"&(!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!)$*'5%&54!_!+!"5$!#7$!5'3"#%4!9&!"$)!!")$-$")$"5$!!"!=>eG?!:!"5$!FGGG.!

d39&1$!&")!7!+!-'(!#!5&(!-&%#4!&++'5!&#$+!!"!#7$!c!*1&16$!/8%!5&"![&#!'"&(!<"!'""O&#%!'#!5!J%'"#!Ec/[<"

OJI!7&;$!8&5$)!+!9"!8!5&"#!'--'+!#!'"!8%'*!#7$!d';$*$"#!8'%!@$*'5%&#!5!Y7&"9$!Ed@YI!&")!#7$!%!($&)$%.!

d'%9&"!M+;&"9!%&!.!67'!7&;$!9&!"$)!!"!-'-3(&%!#4!&")!-%$+$"#!&!%$&(!#7%$&#!#'!d39&1$!&")!7!+!-&%#4?!S"!

&))!#!'"!#'!3+!"9!)!%$5#!8'%*+!'8!$($5#'%&(!8%&3)!#'!+#&4!!"!-'6$%.!c/[<"OJ!7&+!%$93(&%(4!%!99$)!$($5#!'"+!

!"!#7$!%!8&;'%!14!#$%%'%!0!"9!-'(!#!5&(!'--'+!#!'"!*$*1$%+!&")!+3--'%#$%+?!S"!d39&1$\+!6'%)+.!CV$!&%$!

"'#!9'!"9!#'!9!;$!3-!'3%!5'3"#%4!8'%!&!*$%$!p!'"!&!1&(('#?!]'6!5&"!&!1&((-'!"#!8!97#!6!#7!&!93"lDQF!!

M'!!((3+#%&#$!#7$!-&##$%"!'8!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"!!"!)$#&!(.!J!93%$!F!*&-+!'3%!*'"#7(4!)&#&!'"!

+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!;!'($"5$!1$8'%$!&")!&8#$%!$($5#!'"+!!"!c!*1&16$!&")!+7'6+!#7$!!"5%$&+$!!"!-'(!#!5&((4!

*'#!;&#$)!;!'($"5$.!1'#7!!"!#$%*+!'8!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!$;$"#+!&")!"3*1$%!'8!-$'-($!&88$5#$).!&5%'++!8'3%!

$($5#!'"+f 4!$($5#!'"+.!#7$!FGGF!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'"+.!#7$!FGGK!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!

"QF!O%$+!)$"#!U'1$%#!d39&1$.!5!#$)!!"!#!*$?5'*k`3'#$+.!&")!!"!L&")7!!&")!O%0$6'%+B!!EFGG>.!FI?!!

Page 25: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #%

"OJ!%&"!#'%#3%$!5&*-+!&5%'

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

$($5#!'"+.!&")!5'"53%%$"#!-%$+!)$"#!&(!&")!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!$($5#!'"+!!"!FGGe.!67!57!!"5(3)$)!#6'!%'3")+?!!!

iJ!93%$!F!7$%$j!

O%!'%!#'!#7$!FGGG!$($5#!'"+.!d39&1$\+!7'()!'"!-'6$%!6&+!3"`3$+#!'"$)?!]$!%$-'%#$)(4!6'"!#7$!

=>>H!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'"+!6!#7!*'%$!#7&"!>GR!'8!#7$!;'#$?!M7$!'--'+!#!'"!6&+!"'#!-$%5$!;$)!#'!1$!

-&%#!53(&%(4!+#%'"9.!&")!&55'%)!"9!#'!'1+$%;$%+.!#7$!FGGG!$($5#!'"+!6$%$!#7$!8!%+#!!"!67!57!&"4!'--'+!#!'"!

-&%#4!-'+$)!&!%$&(!57&(($"9$!#'!#7$!)'*!"&"5$!'8!#7$!c/[<"OJ?!@3%!"9!#7$!FGGG!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!$($5#!'".!

-'(!5$.!!"#$((!9$"5$!'88!5!&(+.!6&%!;$#$%&"+.!&")!c/[<"OJ!+3--'%#$%+!*3%)$%$).!#'%#3%$)!&")!!"#!*!)&#$)!

d@Y!+3--'%#$%+f!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!%$-'%#$)(4!B!(($)!*'%$!#7&"!QG!-$'-($!8'%!-'(!#!5&(!%$&+'"+!E<?:?!:#&#$!

@$-&%#*$"#!FGG=a!/*"$+#4!S"#$%"&#!'"&(!FGG=I?!J!93%$!F!+7'6+!#7&#!#7$!;!'($"5$!1$9&"!+$;$%&(!*'"#7+!

-%!'%!#'.!&")!+-!B$)!)3%!"9.!#7$!$($5#!'"?!!:$;$%&(!*'"#7+!1$8'%$!#7$!$($5#!'".!;'#$%+!+355$++83((4!

)$8$&#$)!&"!&##$*-#$)!%$8$%$")3*!'"!5'"+#!#3#!'"&(!57&"9$.!67!57!6&+!+$$"!&+!&!-$%+'"&(!1('6!#'!

d39&1$?!!d39&1$!&(+'!$*1&%B$)!'"!&!5&*-&!9"!#'!%$+#%!5#!&")!)!+5%$)!#!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!$($5#!'"!

'1+$%;$%+.!&")!%$83+$)!#'!5%$)$"#!&(!*'%$!#7&"!FG.GGG!)'*$+#!5!$($5#!'"!*'"!#'%+.!'+#$"+!1(4!!"!'%)$%!#'!

%$)35$!#7$!-%'1&1!(!#4!#7&#!7$!6'3()!1$!5&397#!&")!5'")$*"$)!8'%!$($5#!'"!*&"!-3(&#!'"?!]$!)!)!&((!'8!

#7!+!6!#7!9%$&#!5$%#&!"#4!#7&#!"'!)'*$+#!5!'%!!"#$%"&#!'"&(!9%'3-!'%!!"+#!#3#!'"!6'3()!1$!&1($!#'!7'()!7!*!

&55'3"#&1($!&")!8'%5$!7!*!'3#!'8!-'6$%.!-3#!7!*!!"!2&!(.!'%!'#7$%6!+$!-3"!+7!7!*?!M7$!5'3%#!!"!c!*1&16$!

6&+.!&")!+#!((!!+.!6$&B?!XA$53#!;$!5'"+#%&!"#+!6$%$.!&")!%$*&!".!8$6?!M'!#7!+!)&4.!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!7&+!"'#!

+!9"$)!#7$!#%$&#4!-%'7!1!#!"9!#'%#3%$!&")!-(&5$+!*&"4!%$+#%!5#!'"+!'"!#7$!&5#!;!#!$+!'8![L,+?!

S"!$;$%4!$($5#!'"!+!"5$!FGGG.!#7$!d@Y!7&+!#7%$&#$"$)!d39&1$\+!%3($?!S"!%$+-'"+$.!7!+!

9';$%"*$"#!7&+!$"9&9$)!!"!&!5&*-&!9"!'8!%$-%$++!'"!*$&"#!#'!6$&B$"!#7$!d@Y!&")!B$$-!#7$!%!'6"!

7'()!'"!-'6$%!14!C6!""!"9D!#7$!*&2'%!#4!'8!;'#$+?!S"!FGGF.!-%!'%!#'!&")!)3%!"9!#7$!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'".!

c/[< ++!c!*1&16$!#'!C%$$)35&#$D!'--'+!#!'"!+3--'%#$%+?QQ!!M7$!!01#6!5?!

"QQ!Z$'!:57(!"B.!Cd3%)$%+!!"!d39&1$!#'%#3%$!5&*-+.!-&-$%!%$-'%#+?D!!T#.4A.2!E]'1&%#N!/3+#%&(!&I.!d&%57!

P.!FGGF?!

Page 26: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #&

!6$!)!)!"'#!5')$!&+!&!8'%*

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

F5%&5%!%$-'%#$)!#7&#!#7$!;!'($"5$!5&*-&!9"!($)!#'!)'0$"+!'8!)$&#7+!&")!)!+&--$&%&"5$+!&")!73")%$)+!

'8!&1)35#!'"+.!&++&3(#+!&")!#'%#3%$!;!5#!*+?QP!J!93%$!F!+7'6+!#7&#!#7$!;!'($"5$!1$9&"!+$;$%&(!*'"#7+!

-%!'%!#'!#7$!$($5#!'".!&")!&(+'!#7&#!73")%$)+!'8!-$'-($!6$%$!;!5#!*!0$)!!"!#7$!*'"#7+!!**$)!&#$(4!

8'(('6!"9.!!"5(3)!"9!QPP!*$*1$%+!'8!#7$!N'3"9!V'*$"\+!Y7%!+#!&"!/++'5!&#!'"!67'!6$%$!&%%$+#$)!)3%!"9!

&!-$&5$83(!*&%57!#'!-%'#$+#!#7$!$($5#!'"!%$+3(#+?!['#!!"5(3)$)!!"!#7$+$!8!93%$+!&%$!#7$!#7'3+&")+!'8!

-$'-($!67'!8($)!c!*1&16$!&8#$%!#7$!$($5#!'".!8$&%!"9!-$%+$53#!'"!8'%!#7$!%!+3--'%#!'8!#7$!d@Y?!!

M7$!<:!:#&#$!@$-&%#*$"#!&553+$)!c/[<"OJ!'8!*&"!-3(&#!"9!#7$!$($5#'%&(!-%'5$++!!"!#7$!FGGK!

$($5#!'"+!#7%'397!5'%%3-#!'"!&")!!"#!*!)&#!'".!!"5(3)!"9!3"(&683(!B!((!"9+.!-'(!#!5&((4!*'#!;&#$)!

B!)"&--!"9+.!&")!+#&#$!+&"5#!'"$)!&5#!'"+!14!#7$!+$53%!#4!8'%5$+!#'!#'%#3%$!*$*1$%+!'8!#7$!'--'+!#!'".!

3"!'"!($&)$%+.!&")!5!;!(!+'5!$#4!&5#!;!+#+!EFGGHI?!,;$%&((.!#7$!($;$(!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!6!#"$++$)!!"!

($9!+(&#!;$!$($5#!'"+!!+!('6$%!#7&"!!"!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'"+.!'+#$"+!1(4!67$"!d39&1$!8&5$)!&!9%$&#$%!

#7%$&#?!!Z!B$!#7$!-%$;!'3+!$($5#!'"+.!d39&1$!+'397#!#'!(!*!#!!")$-$")$"#!'1+$%;&#!'".!)$"4!"9!$"#%4!#'!

$($5#!'"!'1+$%;$%+!8%'*!#7$!<"!#$)!:#&#$+.!#7$!Y'**'"6$&(#7.!/3+#%&(!&.!g&-&".!#7$!X3%'-$&"!<"!'".!

W%!#&!"!&")!'#7$%!X3%'-$&"!5'3"#%!$+!67'!6$%$!!"#$"+$(4!5%!#!5&(!'8!c!*1&16$q+!-%$;!'3+!$($5#!'"+?QK!!

d39&1$\+!3+$!'8!;!'($"5$!&")!%$-%$++!'"!6&+!+'*$67&#!('6$%!#7&"!!"!#7$!'#7$%!$($5#!'"+!+7'6"!!"!

J!93%$!F.!!"!-&%#!1$5&3+$!#7$!c/[<"OJ!$*-('4$)!&!+#%&#$94!'8!*&"!-3(&#!'"!#7&#!!";'(;$)!#7$!

-'(!#!5!0&#!'"!'8!8'')"&!).!!"5(3)!"9!#7$!)$"!&(!'8!8'')!&++!+#&"5$!#'!+3+-$5#$)!+3--'%#$%+!'8!#7$!d@Y.!

67!57 !'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"?QH!@3$!#'!#7$!%&-!)!)$5(!"$!'8!#7$!$5'"'*4.!

"QP!!01#6!EZ'")'"I.!CY7&'+!J$&%+!&+!d39&1$!1('5B+!-'((!'1+$%;$%+D.!d&%57!T.!FGGF?!

QK!S"+#!#3#$!8'%!V&%!o!O$&5$!U$-'%#!"9.!Cc!*1&16$a!M7$!U!97#!:'%#!'8!,1+$%;$%+.D!7?.04-!H#I6.!d&%57!FK.!

FGGK?!

QH!:#$-7&"!$!['($"?!C@'!+7!"4!1'A$+!*&B$!8'%!&!8&!%!;'#$!!"!c!*1&16$la!W$7!")!#7$!&--$&%&"5$!'8!&"!

'%)$%(4!$($5#!'"!#7$%$!6&+!$;!)$"5$!'8!'()"+#4($!!"#!*!)&#!'".D!D/59#!-%&!T-0/!EM'%'"#'I.!/-%!(!=.!FGGK?!

cM^=.!]&%&%$!FGGK?!!Cc!*1&16$\+!%3(!"9!-&%#4!)$"!$+!3+!"9!8'')!&+!5&*-&!9"!6$&-'"?D!!WWY!d'"!#'%!"9!

Page 27: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #'

!!"23%$).!M+;&"9!%&!!57'+$!#'!1'45'##!#7$!%3"'88!!"!&"!$88'%#!#'!&;'!)!%!+B!"9!#7$!(!;$+!'8!*'%$!'8!

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

*!((!'"+!'8!c!*1&16$&"+!6$%$!!"!)$+-$%&#$!"$$)!'8!8'')!&++!+#&"5$?!!d@Y!+3--'%#$%+!6$%$!#3%"$)!&6&4!

&")!#'()!#'!%$#3%"!&8#$%!#7$!$($5#!'"?QT!M7$!-&%#4!&(+'!$*-('4$)!#7$!+3--'%#!'8!#%&)!#!'"&(!($&)$%+.!67'!

#7%$&#$"$)!#7$!%!+312$5#+!6!#7!$;!5#!'"!!8!#7$4!8&!($)!#'!;'#$!5'%%$5#(4?Qe!

M7$!FGGe!$($5#!'"+!*&%B$)!#7$!8!%+#!5'"53%%$"#!-%$+!)$"#!&(!&")!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!$($5#!'"+.!&!

57&"9$!&);'5&#$)!14!d39&1$?!W$8'%$!#7$!FGGe!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'".!d39&1$.!8&5!"9!9%'6!"9!

3"-'-3(&%!#4.!1&""$)!&((!-'(!#!5&(!%&((!$+!&")!&%%$+#$)!7!+!5'*-$#!#'%!_!-%$+!)$"#!&(!5&")!)&#$!d'%9&"!

M+;&"9!%&!!_!'+#$"+!1(4!8'%!;!'(&#!"9!#7$!1&"!67!($!&##$")!"9!&!-%&4$%!*$$#!"9?!M+;&"9!%&!!6&+!+$;$%$(4!

1$&#$".!+3+#&!"$)!&!*&++!;$!7$&)!!"23%4.!&")!6&+!)$"!$)!&55$++!#'!"$5$++&%4!*$)!5&(!#%$&#*$"#?Q>!

[$;$%#7$($++.!#7$!57&(($"9$!-'+$)!14!M+;&"9!%&!!&")!#7$!d@Y!6&+!9%$&#$%!#7&"!!"!&"4!-%$;!'3+!$($5#!'".!

&")!#7$!d@Y!6'"!&!-&%(!&*$"#&%4!*&2'%!#4!8'%!#7$!8!%+#!#!*$.!6!#7!>>!'8!FGG!+$&#+?!M7$!9';$%"*$"#!

)$(&4$)!#7$!%$($&+$!'8!#7$!%$+3(#+!'8!#7$!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'"!8'%!*'%$!#7&"!&!*'"#7.!&!*';$!-$%5$!;$)!

14!*&"4!#'!1$!&"!$88'%#!#'!%$*$)4!d39&1$\+!6'%+$"#7&""&"#!5!-&#$)!-$%8'%*&"5$?!V7$"!'88!5!&(!

$($5#!'"!%$+3(#+!6$%$!8!"&((4!&""'3"5$).!c/[<"OJ!%$5$!;$)!PQR!'8!#7$!;'#$!&")!d@Y!%$5$!;$)!PTR.!23+#!

+74!'8!#7$!KGR!*&2'%!#4!"$$)$)!#'!6!"!#7$!8!%+#!%'3")!'3#%!97#?!!/!%3"'88!6&+!"$9'#!&#$)!&#!#7$!+&*$!

#!*$!#7&#!d39&1$\+!&9$"#+!!"+#!9&#$)!&!)$&)(4!6&;$!'8!;!'($"5$!&9&!"+#!d@Y!+3--'%#$%+?!!@3$!#'!#7$!

)$9%$$!'8!;!'($"5$!)!%$5#$)!#'6&%)!7!+!+3--'%#$%+.!6!#7!*'%$!#7&"!eK!5'"8!%*$)!*3%)$%$)!&")!

#7'3+&")+

"/8%!5&.!d&%57!F>.!FGGK?!!O$#&!M7'%"45%'8#.!Cc!*1&16$!;'#$%+!r6$%$!9%!--$)!14!#$%%'%\!X($5#!'"!'1+$%;$%+!

5'")$*"!d39&1$!;!5#'%4.D!>-0/2!!#/#C.-'"!EZ'")'"I.!/-%!(!P.!FGGK?!

QT![$!(!M6$$)!$.!FGGK?!!C/!73"9%4!83#3%$!8'%!-''%!;'#$%+!67'!'--'+$!d39&1$?D!!>-0/2!!#/#C.-'"!

EZ'")'"I.!d&%57!FH.!FGGK?!

Qe!O$#&!M7'%"45%'8#.!Cc!*1&16$!;'#$%+!r6$%$!9%!--$)!14!#$%%'%\D!>-0/2!!#/#C.-'"!EZ'")'"I.!/-%!(!P.!FGGK?!

Q>!O$#&!M7'%"45%'8#.!CM+;&"9!%&!!q)$"!$)!(&64$%!'%!*$)!5&(!#%$&#*$"#q.D!>-0/2!!#/#C.-'"!EZ'")'"I.!d&%57!

=Q.!FGGT?!!

Page 28: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #(

!g3"$!=F.!FGG>!$($5#!'"!!"!S%&"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

7!+!+3--'%#$%+!!"!#7!+!C;!'($"#.!!(($9!#!*&#$.!+7&*!'8!&"!$($5#!'"!-%'5$++?D!d39&1$!%$+-'")$)f!!C,"(4!L').!

67'!&--'!"#$)!*$.!6!((!%$*';$!*$.!"'#!#7$!d?@?Y?.!"'#!#7$!W%!#!+7?DPG!J!93%$!F!!+!&!5($&%!!((3+#%&#!'"!'8!

#7$!*&++!;$!+-!B$!!"!;!'($"5$!)3%!"9!#7$!*'"#7!'8!#7$!$($5#!'"?!

Y'"+!+#$"#!6!#7!'3%!74-'#7$+$+.!&")!&+!!"!&!"3*1$%!'8!'#7$%!$($5#!'"+!!"!'3%!+#3)4.!d39&1$!

&(('6$)!5'*-$#!#!;$!$($5#!'"+.!&")!67$"!8&5!"9!&!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#.!#3%"$)!#'!;!'($"#!&")!%$-%$++!'"!&")!

8%&3).!67!($!6'%B!"9!#'!*!"!*!0$!#7$!(!B$(!7'')!#7&#!7$!6'3()!1$!5&397#!&")!-3"!+7$)?!!!

()%*!

S"!c!*1&16$.!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!7&+!%$-$&#$)(4!$"9&9$)!!"!%$-%$++!'"!5&*-&!9"+!-%!'%!#'!$($5#!'"+!

!"!&"!$88'%#!#'!6$&B$"!#7$!%!-'(!#!5&(!'--'+!#!'"?!M7$!FGG>!$($5#!'"!!"!S%&".!14!5'"#%&+#.!-%$+$"#!&!5&+$!!"!

67!57!#7$!7!97$+#!($;$(+!'8!%$-%$++!'"!'553%%$)!&8#$%!#7$!$($5#!'".!&+!&!%$+-'"+$!#'!-31(!5!-%'#$+#!&9&!"+#!

8%&3)3($"#!%$+3(#+?!

M7$!FGGK!S%&"!&"!-%$+!)$"#!&(!$($5#!'"+!6$%$!7$()!6!#7'3#!6!)$+-%$&)!-31(!5!-%'#$+#!'%!!"5%$&+$+!

!"!+#&#$!+-'"+'%$)!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"?!!O%$+!)$"#!d'7&**&)!b7&#&*!!+#$--$)!)'6"!!"!FGGK!&8#$%!

+$%;!"9!#7$!*&A!*3*!#6'!#$%*+?!/((!5&")!)&#$+!8'%!#7$!-%$+!)$"54!*3+#!1$!&--%';$)!14!#7$!L3&%)!&"!

Y'3"5!(.!(!*!#!"9!#7$!-''(!#'!%$9!*$"+&"5#!'"$)!5&")!)&#$+.!&")!#7$!*&4'%!'8!M$7%&".!d&7*'3)!

/7*&)!"$2&).!6'"!&8#$%!#6'!%'3")+!'8!1&(('#!"9?!!!!

M4-!5&((4.!#7$!S%&"!&"!-%'5$++!'8!5&")!)&#$!+5%$$"!"9!14!#7$!L3&%)!&"!Y'3"5!(!93&%&"#$$+!#7&#!

*'+#!&+-!%!"9!5&")!)&#$+!&%$!-%'7!1!#$)!8%'*!%3""!"9.!!"5(3)!"9!*&"4!6'3()"1$!'--'+!#!'"!5&")!)&#$+?!

N$#!!"!FGG>.!-'-3(&%!+$"#!*$"#!#3%"$)!&9&!"+#!!"53*1$"#!-%$+!)$"#!/7*&)!"$2&).!&")!-31(!5!'-!"!'"!

-'((+!5'")35#$)!-%!'%!#'!#7$!$($5#!'"!+399$+#$)!#7&#!'"$!'8!#7$!5&")!)&#$+.!d!%"]'++$!"!d'3+&;!.!6'3()!

8'%5$!&!%3"'88!$($5#!'"?!!J!93%$!Q!*&-+!'3%!*'"#7(4!)&#&!'"!+#&#$"+-'"+'%$)!;!'($"5$!1$8'%$!&")!&8#$%!

#7$ !&")!+7'6+!#7$!!"5%$&+$!!"!-'(!#!5&((4!*'#!;&#$)!;!'($"5$.!1'#7!!"!#$%*+!

"PG!W'#7!`3'#$+!8%'*!Y$(!&!V?!@399$%!&")!W&%%4!W$&%&B.!Cd39&1$!U!;&(!s3!#+!c!*1&16$!U3"'88.!Y!#!"9!

/##&5B+.D!H#I!J5.K!!01#6.!g3"$!FQ.!FGGe?!!!

Page 29: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #)

&#7?P=!/#!#7$!#!*$!'8!6%!#!"9.!+

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

'8!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!$;$"#+!&")!"3*1$%!'8!-$'-($!&88$5#$)?!

iJ!93%$!Q!7$%$j!

J'(('6!"9!#7$!$($5#!'".!1'#7!5&")!)&#$+!)$5(&%$)!;!5#'%4?!S"!&"!&1"'%*&((4!%&-!)!;'#$!C5'3"#.D!

&3#7'%!#!$+!)$5(&%$)!#7$!!"53*1$"#!-%$+!)$"#!#7$!6!""$%?!O%'#$+#+!$%3-#$)!&")!*!((!'"+!'8!-$'-($!#''B!#'!

#7$!+#%$$#+!#'!)!+-3#$!#7$!8%&3)3($"#!%$+3(#+?!M7$!-%'#$+#+!#7%$&#$"$)!#7$!($9!#!*&54!'8!#7$!%$9!*$!&")!

#7$!9';$%"*$"#!%$+-'")$)!6!#7!+6$$-!"9!73*&"!%!97#+!;!'(&#!'"+?!,"!g3"$!=P#7.!-(&!"5('#7$+!8'%5$+!

&##&5B$)!&!M$7%&"!<"!;$%+!#4!)'%*!#'%4!&")!%$-'%#$)(4!B!(($)!8!;$!+#3)$"#!-%'#$+#$%+?!,"!g3"$!=H#7.!#7$!

9';$%"*$"#!1&""$)!8'%$!9"!2'3%"&(!+#+!8%'*!#7$!+#%$$#+a!&")!&%%$+#$)!&(*'+#!=GG!-$'-($.!!"5(3)!"9!

8'%*$%!9';$%"*$"#!*!"!+#$%+!&")!+$"!'%!-'(!#!5&(!8!93%$+?!U!'#!-'(!5$!)!+-$%+$)!-%'#$+#+!!"!M$7%&"!&")!

6$%$!;!)$'#&-$)!B!((!"9![$)&!/97&.!&!4'3"9!14+#&")$%!67'!1$5&*$!&"!!5'"!8'%!#7$!&"#!"9';$%"*$"#!

*';$*$"#?!O%'#$+#+!5'"#!"3$)!&")!#7$!9';$%"*$"#!%$+-'")$)!6!#7!*'%$!;!'($"5$?!,;$%!#7$!"$A#!8$6!

*'"#7+!P.GGG!-%'#$+#$%+!6'3()!1$!&%%$+#$).!&")!'#7$%+!6'3()!1$!B!(($)!&+!&!)!%$5#!5'"+$`3$"5$!'8!

$($5#'%&((4"!")35$)!%$-%$++!'"?!

<")$#$%%$).!O%$+!)$"#!/7*&)!"$2&)!6&+!+6'%"!!"#'!'88!5$!!"!/393+#?!d$&"67!($.!9';$%"*$"#!

5'"#%'(($)!5'3%#+!1$9&"!+7'6!#%!&(+!&9&!"+#!)$#&!"$$+.!*&"4!&(($9$)(4!5'$%5$)!!"#'!*&B!"9!8&(+$!

5'"8$++!'"+!'8!-&%#!5!-&#!"9!!"!&!8'%$!9""1&5B$)!&##$*-#!#'!';$%#7%'6!#7$!9';$%"*$"#?!:$53%!#4!'88!5!&(+!

+73#!)'6"!#7$!'88!5$+!'8!&!5'**!##$$!5'(($5#!"9!!"8'%*&#!'"!&1'3#!#'%#3%$!&")!'#7$%!&13+$+!&9&!"+#!

-%'#$+#'%+!&")!)$#&!"$$+?!g'3%"&(!+#!/(!!U$0&!X+7%&"97!!6&+!+$"#!#'!-%!+'".!8'(('6$)!14!&5&)$*!5!b!&"!

M&21&B7+7!&")!'#7$%!-%'*!"$"#!!"#$(($5#3&(+.!-'(!#!5&(!8!93%$+!&")!2'3%"&(!+#+?!d&"4!6$%$!+$"#$"5$)!#'!

)$ '*$!7&)!&(%$&)4!1$$"!$A$53#$)?PF!

"P=!/*"$+#4!S"#$%"&#!'"&(.!CS%&"f!X($5#!'"!Y'"#$+#$).!U$-%$++!'"!Y'*-'3")$)?D!/;&!(&1($!&#!

7##-fkk666?&*"$+#4?'%9k$"k(!1%&%4k!"8'kd@X=Qk=FQkFGG>k$"!E&55$++$)!J$1%3&%4!=>.!FG=GI?!

PF!/*"$+#4!S"#$%"&#!'"&(.!C[!"$!&#!U!+B!'8!XA$53#!'"!';$%!S%&"!O%'#$+#+.D!J$1%3&%4!F.!FG=G?!/;&!(&1($!&#!

7##-fkk666?&*"$+#43+&?'%9k)'53*$"#?-7-l!)tX[L[/<FG=GGFGF=KFQe!E&55$++$)!J$1%3&%4!=>.!FG=GI?!

Page 30: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" #*

M7$!($&)$%+!'8!S%&"!%$+-'"+!1($!8'%!#7$!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'".!(!B$!#7$!($&)$%+!'8!c!*1&16$.!7&)!8$6!

%$&+'"+!#'!8$&%!-3"!+7*$"#!8'%!#7$!%!-'(!5!$+!'8!&13+$?!M7$%$!&%$!;$%4!8$6!-31(!5!5'"+#%&!"#+!'"!#7$!

$A$53#!;$\+!&3#7'%!#4.!#7$!5'3%#+!&%$!"'#!!")$-$")$"#.!&")!!")$$).!6$%$!5'*-(!5!#!!"!#7$!-'+#"$($5#!'"!

%$-%$++!'"?!S%&"!1$('"9+!#'!;$%4!8$6!73*&"!#%$&#!$+!&")!&(('6+![L,+!;$%4!(!##($!!")$-$")$"5$!'%!&55$++?!

:$5%$54!+3%%'3")!"9!#7$!#&((4!"9!'8!#7$!;'#$+!*$&"+!#7&#!67&#!&5#3&((4!3"8'()$)!!+!"'#!B"'6".!

13#!'1+$%;$%+!+-$53(&#$!#7&#!#7$!S%&"!&"!($&)$%+7!-.!7&;!"9!&(%$&)4!+5%$$"$)!#7$!-%$+!)$"#!&(!5&")!)&#$+.!

6&+!3"5'*8'%#&1($!6!#7!&"4!%$+3(#+!#7&#!6'3()!7&;$!+399$+#$)!&!5('+$!$($5#!'"?!J&5!"9!&!6'%+$"#7&""

$A-$5#$)!-$%8'%*&"5$!14!#7$!!"53*1$"#.!#7$4!$"9&9$)!!"!&!%&-!)!E&")!"'#!-&%#!53(&%(4!+B!(($)I!

8&(+!8!5&#!'"!'8!#7$!$($5#!'"!%$+3(#+?!S"!+7'%#.!#7$!$($5#!'"+!%$;$&($)!#7&#!#7$!'--'+!#!'"!5&")!)&#$+!-'+$)!

&!9%$&#$%!#7%$&#!#'!/7*&)!"$2&)!#7&"!&"#!5!-&#$).!-%';'B!"9!&!-'+#"$($5#!'"!-%'#$+#!*';$*$"#!#7&#!

83%#7$%!#7%$&#$"$)!#7$!%$9!*$\+!($9!#!*&54?!!U&#7$%!#7&"!%!+B!+357!&"!$($5#!'""!")35$)!#7%$&#.!#7$!

9';$%"*$"#!)!883+$)!-%'#$+#+!14!5'**!##!"9!6!)$+-%$&)!;!'($"5$!&9&!"+#!#7$!-%'#$+#$%+.!)$#&!"!"9!&")!

B!((!"9!($&)$%+!'8!#7$!'--'+!#!'"!*';$*$"#.!&")!5%$&#!"9!&!5(!*&#$!'8!8$&%?!!!!!

,;$%&((.!$($5#!'"+!!"!S%&"!&")!c!*1&16$.!&+!6$((!&+!+!*!(&%!5&+$!+#3)!$+!6$!7&;$!5'")35#$)!'8!

$($5#!'"+!!"!'#7$%!5'3"#%!$+.!5'"8!%*!#7&#!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!!+!&!#&5#!5!3+$)!14!9';$%"*$"#+!#'!

*&"!-3(&#$!$($5#!'"+!!"!#7$!-%$"$($5#!'"!-$%!')!&")!+3--%$++!)!++$"#!!"!#7$!-'+#"$($5#!'"!-$%!').!&")!

#7$+$!!"5%$&+$+!!"!%$-%$++!'"!&%$!*'+#!(!B$(4!67$"!#7%$&#+!#'!#7$!%$9!*$!&%$!7!97!&")!&"#!5!-&#$)!

5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!('6?!!!

?$.%+=/-$.!

<+!"9!&!"$6!)&#&+$#!'"!$($5#!'"+!#'!3"-&5B!#7$!&++3*-#!'"!#7&#!$($5#!'"!;!'($"5$!'"(4!'553%+!!"!

#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'".!6$!9$"$%&#$!+'*$!'8!#7$!8!%+#!9('1&(!$;!)$"5$!'8!#7$!5'")!#!'"+!3")$%!67!57!

9';$%"*$"#+!&%$!*'+#!(!B$(4!#'!3+$!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!&+!&"!$($5#'%&(!+#%&#$94?!M7%'397'3#!#7$!

)$;$('-!"9!6'%().!6$!8!")!#7&#!($&)$%+!&%$!*'%$!(!B$(4!#'!!"5%$&+$!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!!"!#7$!-$%!')!

+3%%'3")!"9!$($5#!'"+!67$"!#7$4!8&5$!+$%!'3+!$($5#'%&(!5'*-$#!#!'"!&")!8$6!5'"+$`3$"5$+!8'%!$"9&9!"9!

Page 31: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $+

'*-$#!#!'"!!+!"$5$++&%4!8'%!)$*

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

!"!%$-%$++!'"?!<+!"9!*'"#7(4!)&#&!&")!)$#&!($)!5&+$!+#3)!$+!'"!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!!"!c!*1&16$!&")!

S%&".!6$!-%';!)$!83%#7$%!+3--'%#!8'%!#7$+$!%$+3(#+?!

V$!!"#$%-%$#!#7!+!&+!$;!)$"5$!#7&#!+'*$!!"53*1$"#+_!!"5(3)!"9!#7'+$!!"!5'3"#%!$+!(!B$!

/0$%1&!2&".!Y&*1')!&.!S%&".!'%!c!*1&16$!_!7&;$!3+$)!&!+#%&#$94!'8!%$-%$++!'"!!"!&"!$88'%#!#'!%!9!$($5#!'"!

'3#5'*$+.!&")!)'53*$"#!#7$!5'")!#!'"+!3")$%!67!57!+357!$($5#'%&((4!*'#!;&#$)!&13+$+!&%$!(!B$(4?!S"!

$88$5#.!$($5#!'"+!*&4!$A&5$%1&#$!73*&"!%!97#+!;!'(&#!'"+!!"!#7$+$!-(&5$+!!"!#7$!+7'%#!#$%*a!6!#7'3#!

$($5#!'"+.!#7$!;!'(&#!'"+!6'3()!1$!8$6$%!E#7'397!;!'(&#!'"+!*&4!+#!((!'553%!8'%!'#7$%!%$&+'"+I?!!

,3%!%$+3(#+!)'!"'#!+-$&B!#'!67$#7$%!'%!"'#!($&)$%+!67'!3+$!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!#'!8!A!$($5#!'"+!

&5#3&((4!+355$$)!!"!+#&4!"9!!"!-'6$%.PQ!'%!67$#7$%!-$%!')+!'8!$($5#'%&((4!!")35$)!-'(!#!5&(!;!'($"5$!&%$!&"!

!"$;!#&1($!-&%#!'8!-'(!#!5&(!(!1$%&(!0&#!'"?!d&"4!'8!#7$!6'%()\+!('"9$+#"+#&")!"9!5'"+'(!)&#$)!)$*'5%&5!$+.!

!"5(3)!"9!J%&"5$.!#7$!<"!#$)!b!"9)'*.!&")!#7$!<"!#$)!:#&#$+.!$A-$%!$"5$)!-$%!')+!'8!!"5%$&+$)!-'(!#!5&(!

%$-%$++!'"!+3%%'3")!"9!$($5#!'"+?PP!!M7!+!7!+#'%4!%&!+$+!83")&*$"#&(!`3$+#!'"+!&1'3#!#7$!('"9"#$%*!

%$(&#!'"+7!-!1$#6$$"!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'".!$($5#!'"+.!&")!)$*'5%&#!0&#!'"?!:'*$!+57'(&%+!&")!-3")!#+!

*&4!1$!#$*-#$)!#'!!"#$%-%$#!#7$!8&5#!#7&#!($&)$%+!+'*$#!*$+!3+$!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!#'!*&"!-3(&#$!

$($5#!'"+!&+!5'"8!%*&#!'"!#7&#!$($5#!'"+!&%$!"$5$++&%!(4!C1&)D!8'%!5'3"#%!$+!6!#7'3#!&!7!+#'%4!'8!$($5#!'"+!

&")!)$*'5%&54?!,"!#7$!5'"#%&%4.!'3%!&"&(4+!+!)'$+!"'#!+3--'%#!#7!+!5'"5(3+!'"?!!!

U&#7$%.!+$;$%&(!!*-'%#&"#!!*-(!5&#!'"+!8'(('6!8%'*!#7$!$;!)$"5$!-%';!)$)!!"!#7!+!-&-$%.!+'*$!'8!

67!57!&%$!%$($;&"#!#'!'"9'!"9!5'"5$%"+!!"!-'(!54!5'**3"!#!$+!&1'3#!$($5#!'""!")35$)!;!'($"5$?!!J!%+#.!

#7$!5'3"#%!$+!*'+#!(!B$(4!#'!$A-$%!$"5$!!"5%$&+$+!!"!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"!+3%%'3")!"9!$($5#!'"+!&%$!

-%$5!+$(4!#7'+$!-(&5$+!!"!67!57!#7$!!"53*1$"#!9';$%"*$"#!!+!#7%$&#$"$)!14!&"!'%9&"!0$)!&")!-'#$"#!&((4!

-'6$%83(!'--'+!#!'"?!/(#7'397!%$-%$++!'"!!+!5($&%(4!)$#%!*$"#&(!#'!)$*'5%&54!!"!#7$!+7'%#!#$%*.!

5 '5%&54!!"!1'#7!#7$!+7'%#!&")!#7$!('"9!#$%*?!S8!'3%!&"&(4+!+!!+!5'%%$5#.!

"PQ!M7$!&3#7'%+!&%$!53%%$"#(4!3")$%#&B!"9!#7!+!&"&(4+!+?!

PP!:$$.!8'%!$A&*-($.!/($A&")$%!b$4++&%!EFGG>I!!

Page 32: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $!

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

#7$"!*'%$!'8#$"!#7&"!"'#.!$($5#'%&((4"*'#!;&#$)!%$-%$++!'"!!+!&!+4*-#'*!'8!&!#7%$&#$"$)!&")!-'#$"#!&((4!

6$&B$"!"9!&3#'5%&#!%&#7$%!#7&"!&!+!9"!#7&#!)$*'5%&#!0&#!'"!_!&")!83#3%$!-%'#$5#!'"!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+!_!!+!

)''*$)?!/+!6$!7&;$!&%93$).!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"!*&4!(&%9$(4!1$!&!6$&-'"!'8!#7$!6$&B?!!

/"'#7$%!!*-(!5&#!'"!'8!'3%!&"&(4+!+!!+!-$%7&-+!$;$"!*'%$!!*-'%#&"#!8'%!-'(!54"*&B$%+?PK!/+!

*$"#!'"$)!!"!#7$!!"#%')35#!'".!+57'(&%+!7&;$!)$-('%$)!#7$!+-%$&)!'8!$($5#!'"+!#'!5'3"#%!$+!6!#7'3#!&!

7!+#'%4!'8!C5'"+#!#3#!'"&(!(!1$%&(!+*D!Ec&B&%!&!=>>TI?!!,3%!&"&(4+!+!+3--'%#+!#7!+!5'*-(&!"#!#'!+'*$!

$A#$"#.!13#!-%';!)$+!&!-'#$"#!&(!+$5'")"1$+#!'-#!'"!8'%!5'3"#%!$+!#7&#!)'!"'#!&(%$&)4!-'++$++!&!7!+#'%4!'8!

5'"+#!#3#!'"&(!(!1$%&(!+*?!V$!7&;$!+7'6"!#7&#!&(#7'397!$($5#'%&(!#7%$&#+!!"5%$&+$!#7$!-%'1&1!(!#4!#7&#!&!

9';$%"*$"#!6!((!!"5%$&+$!%$-%$++!'"!&%'3")!$($5#!'"+.!!"53*1$"#+!&%$!+$"+!#!;$!#'!#7$!5'"+$`3$"5$+!'8!

3+!"9!$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"?!/55'3"#&1!(!#4!6'%B+!1$+#!67$"!!#!5'*$+!8%'*!+#%'"9!)'*$+#!5!-'(!#!5&(!

!"+#!#3#!'"+.!(!B$!5'3%#+?!V7$"!!"53*1$"#+!8&5$!&"!!")$-$")$"#!23)!5!&(!+4+#$*!6!#7!';$%+!97#!';$%!#7$!%!

&5#!'"+.!($&)$%+!3+$!($++!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!&"!$($5#!'"?!]'6$;$%.!6$!8!")!+'*$!+399$+#!;$!$;!)$"5$!#7&#!

!"#$%"&#!'"&(!&55'3"#&1!(!#4!*$&+3%$+.!+357!&+!#%$&#!$+!&")![L,+.!*&4!&(+'!-%';!)$!+'*$!5'"+#%&!"#+!'"!

($&)$%+?!X;$"!!8!#7$+$!&55'3"#&1!(!#4!*$&+3%$+!&%$!%$(&#!;$(4!6$&B.!#7$4!5&"!+#!((!+$%;$!&+!&!5'"+#%&!"#!'"!

$($5#'%&(!%$-%$++!'"?!!S8!$($5#!'"+!5'"#!"3$!#'!#&B$!-(&5$!!"!"$&%(4!&((!5'3"#%!$+!!"!#7$!6'%().!&!8'53+!'"!

&55'3"#&1!(!#4!8'%!73*&"!%!97#+!&13+$+!!+!$+-$5!&((4!!*-'%#&"#.!&")!*&4!7$(-!%$)35$!#7$!3+$!'8!$($5#'%&(!

%$-%$++!'"!!"!!"+#!#3#!'"&((4!741%!)!%$9!*$+?!d'%$!'-#!*!+#!5&((4.!8'%!5'3"#%!$+!6!#7'3#!+#%'"9!)'*$+#!5!

-'(!#!5&(!!"+#!#3#!'"+!'%!&!7!+#'%4!'8!5'"+#!#3#!'"&(!(!1$%&(!+*.!&"!!"5%$&+$!!"!5%$)!1($!*$57&"!+*+!'8!

&55'3"#&1!(!#4!*&4!1$!&1($!#'!+$%;$!&+!&!+7'%#"#$%*!57$5B!'"!($&)$%+!3"#!(!%$&(!)$*'5%&54!5&"!)$;$('-?!!!

"PK!/!"3*1$%!'8![L,+!&")!S,+!7&;$!8'53+$)!&##$"#!'"!!"!%$5$"#!4$&%+!#'!$($5#!'""%$(&#$)!;!'($"5$?!!J'%!

$A&*-($.!+$$!#7$!CX($5#!'"!^!'($"5$!X)35&#!'"!&")!U$+'(3#!'"D!-%'2$5#!+-'"+'%$)!14!#7$!S"#$%"&#!'"&(!

J'3")&#!'"!8'%!X($5#'%&(!:4+#$*+.!7##-fkk$;$%?))?!8$+?'%9k?!!

Page 33: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $#

B'6+"!CD!A=##'&(!A,',-/,-%/!

!! d$&"! :@! d!"! d&A!

d$&"!!

!8!EN$&%+!u!d$&"I!

d$&"!!

!8!EN$&%+!#!d$&"I!

,5/0(04-/!B#'.#6605%! Q?HQ! F?FQ! G?GG! e?GG! Q?TH! Q?KG!

J#-.6!53/#4(05%-! G?>H! =?KG! G?GG! >?GG! "k&1! "k&1!

<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2! G?Q>! G?P>! G?GG! =?GG! G?QH! G?P=!

<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6! G?TT! G?PF! G?GG! =?GG! G?Te! G?TK!

3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&! G?PK! G?P>! G?GG! =?GG! G?PT! G?PQ!

3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(6! =?H>! G?QT! G! =?GG! G?=T! G?=H!

F#-&#.!!#%A.#! T?eH! H?eF! G?GT! QH?TP! e?PQ! T?HH!

3O#4A(0=#!P5%6(.-0%(6! P?GP! F?FG! =?GG! T?GG! Q?TQ! P?QQ!

$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(! G?HT! G?PT! G?GG! =?GG! G?P>! G?PP!

!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&! Q?QH! F?>H! G?GG! =F?GG! K?Ge! K?HP!

HA19#.!5?!HDQ6!E/5CG! K?>K! G?>Q! G?GG! e?FQ! K?ee! H?GF!

!-['#$f!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!#7$!&1+'(3#$!)!+#&"5$!8%'*!&"!$($5#!'".!$A5$-#!67$"!'#7$%6!+$!"'#$)!!"!#7$!

5&+$+!'8!!<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2.!<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6.!&")!3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(;!!

1!:!"5$!#7!+!!+!"'#!&!*$&"!"983(!+#&#!+#!5.!6$!'*!#!!#!8%'*!#7$!+3**&%4!

!

!

!

Page 34: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $$

B'6+"!ED!F&"0-%,"0!8"@"+!$3!F$+-,-%'+!2";&"//-$.)!CGHC"EIIJ'!

!! !! K'>! K-.! $!K-.!,$!K'>!

B1&"',/! !! !! !!

+*,%-.)%$/'!0.//1$! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! P?e=EG?QPIvv! Q?Q=EG?QQIvv! =?PeEG?HIvv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! F?G!EG?QeIvv! P?QTEG?QeIvv! "F?QQEG?HIvv!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! F?eEG?T=Ivv! "=?GPEG?T=I! !!

+*2')3%"*!4"23.)5$! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! P?TFEG?QPIvv! Q?P=EG?QFIvv! =?QQEG?KHIv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! F?K=EG?QTIvv! Q?TPEG?Q>Ivv! "=?=>EG?HTIw!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! F?FHEG?TIvv! "G?QFEG?H>I! G?>HEG?PIv!

6/'23".*!0).3'1312! !! !! !!

! [$&%!X($5#!'"! Q?QTEG?PQIvv! F?T>EG?Q>Ivv! G?KTEG?TTI!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! P?=HEG?PPIvv! P?=eEG?P=Ivv! "G?HFEG?T>I!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! "G?TeEG?eKI! "=?=EG?eI! !!

6/'23.)%/!7)%89! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! Q?>eEG?=eIvv! F?HQEG?=HIvv! =?QHEG?Q=Ivv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! Q?PEG?FeIvv! P?Q>EG?FHIvv! "G?>QEG?P>Iw!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! G?KeEG?PPI! "=?TKEG?Q>Ivv! !!

:'%9')!;'*8)'! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! F?KQEG?PHIvv! P?KFEG?P=Ivv! "F?GFEG?T>Ivv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! P?QeEG?KHIvv! F?KHEG?KPIvv! =?e>E=?GHIw!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! "=?eKEG?>>Iw! =?>HEG?>FIv! !!

?$./"L=".%"/! !! !! !!

6<'283"-'!=.*13)%"*31! ! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! F?>FEG?FFIvv! Q?eEG?F=Ivv! "G?e>EG?PQIv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! Q?=FEG?QPIvv! P?H=EG?F>Ivv! "=?PeEG?KeIvv!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! "G?F=EG?KFI! "G?e=EG?PQIw! !!

(*9'>'*9'*3!=.8)3! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! F?eeEG?FFIvv! Q?TFEG?=eIvv! "G?eKEG?QeIv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! P?FeEG?QQIvv! Q?HEG?FQIvv! G?HTEG?PeI!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! "=?QeEG?KFIvv! G?==EG?QTI! !!

;)'%3"'1!?%3","'9! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! Q?=>EG?FHIvv! Q?QKEG?F=Ivv! "G?=eEG?PKI!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! P?TFEG?PFIvv! Q?FKEG?Q=Ivv! =?PQEG?HHIv!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! "=?KPEG?KTIvv! G?=EG?PPI! !!

@8#$')!.,!@AB1! !! !! !!

!! [$&%!X($5#!'"! Q?H=EG?=QIvv! F?FTEG?QeIvv! =?QTEG?PeIvv!

!! @!+#&"#!X($5#!'"! P?=HEG?FIvv! F?eHEG?PTIvv! =?F>EG?KeIv!

!! $!@!+#&"#!#'![$&%! "G?KHEG?FTIv! "G?HQEG?KI! !!

w!+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=GR!v+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!KR!!vv+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=R!-!Y'*-($#$!%$+3(#+!8%'*!#7$!,Z:!*')$(+!&%$!!"!M&1($!P?!/((!$+#!*&#$+!+!*3(&#$)!3+!"9!c$(!9!ES*&!.!

b!"9!&")!Z&3!FGGTI!6!#7!%'13+#!+#&")&%)!$%%'%+?!9!J#-.6(53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!4$&%+!-%!'%!#'!&"!$($5#!'"?!!

5!J#-.6(53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!#7$!"3*1$%!'8!4$&%+!+!"5$!&"!$($5#!'"?!

Page 35: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $%

B'6+"!MD!?$#6-."0!*33"%,!$3!B1&"',/!'.0!?$./"L=".%"/!$.!F$+-,-%'+!2";&"//-$.)!CGHC"EIIJ-!

! ! ! B1&"',/!

! !! !! <%4#.(-0%!L04(5.29! <%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6

9! 3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&!

! !! !! d!"! d&A! d!"! d&A! d!"! d&A!

?$./"L=".%"/!

3O#4A(0=#!

P5%6(.-0%(6!

d!"! "Q?KK!

E=?HPIv!

H?TH!

E=?HPIvv

"G?=T!

E=?PTI!

F?TP!

E=?ePI!

"F?Ge!

EG?eeIv!

"G?QK!

E=?GTI!

d&A! Q?GK!

EF?Q=I!

"=?QF!

E=?e=I!

"=?e!

EF?FQI!

F?QP!

EF?F=I!

"=?Pe!

E=?G>I!

F?Q=!

E=?TTI!

$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(! d!"! "G?TQ!

E=?FeI!

P?Fe!

E=?=eIvv

"G?e>!

E=?=TI!

P?FK!

E=?PeIvv!

"=?>H!

EG?TQIvv!

=?eK!

EG?T>Iv!

d&A! =?KK!

E=?QKI!

"F?QK!

E=?PeI!

"G?>K!

E=?TI!

G?GQ!

E=?K=I!

"=?P!

E=?GPI!

"=?=K!

E=?=>I!

!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&! d!"! "G?T>!

EF?Q>I!

H?K!

E=?QQIvv

F?PQ!

EF?eTI!

Q?H=!

EF?=PIw!

"=?T>!

EG?eIv!

=?K!

EG?>TI!

d&A! "=?=Q!

EF?QeI!

"F?T!

E=?TTI!

"P?Q>!

EF?PIw!

G?QQ!

EF?F=I!

"=?TT!

E=?=>I!

"G?e>!

E=?KQI!

!

w!+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=GR!v+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!KR!!vv+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=R!

-!['#$+f!J'%!$&57!'8!#7$!"!"$!1'A$+!5'"#&!"!"9!8'3%!5$((+!$&57.!#7$!9%$4!5$((!!")!5&#$+!#7$!5'")!#!'"+!*'+#!

(!B$(4!#'!-%$)!5#!&!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#!!"5%$&+$!!"!%$-%$++!'"!!"!#7$!4$&%!'8!&"!$($5#!'".!67$"!#7%$&#+!

&%$!7!97!&")!5'"+$`3$"5$+!&%$!('6?!S"!5'*-&%!+'"!#'!#7$!9%$4!5$((.!#7$!;&(3$+!!"!#7$!'#7$%!#7%$$!5$((+!E!"!

67!#$I!+7'3()!1$!+*&(($%.!13#!"'#!"$5$++&%!(4!"$9&#!;$!'%!+#&#!+#!5&((4!+!9"!8!5&"#?!!Y$((!;&(3$+!%$-%$+$"#!

#7$!-%$)!5#$)!57&"9$!!"!%$-%$++!'"!&++'5!&#$)!6!#7!&!57&"9$!8%'*!*&A!*3*!#'!*!"!*3*!

J#-.6!53/#4(05%;!O'+!#!;$!"3*1$%+!!")!5&#$!&!+-!B$!!"!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!$($5#!'"+.!&")!"$9&#!;$!"3*1$%+!

!")!5&#$!&!)!-!!"!%$-%$++!'"!"$&%!$($5#!'"+?!d')$(+!$+#!*&#$)!3+!"9!,Z:!&")!c$(!9.!6!#7!%'13+#!+#&")&%)!

$%%'%+!!"!-&%$"#7$+$+?!V$!!"5(3)$!#7$!83((!+$#!'8!!"#$%&5#!'"+!!"!#7$!1&+$!*')$(!EW%&*1'%!$#!&(?!FGGHI?!

1!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!4$&%+!-%!'%!#'!&"!$($5#!'"?!

Page 36: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

B'6+"!ND!8"'/,!AL='&"/!*/,-#',"/!$3!O$@"&.#".,"A;$./$&"0!F$+-,-%'+!2";&"//-$.!

w!+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=GR!v+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!KR!!vv+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=R!

!! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! Y'"+$`3$"5$+! Y'"+$`3$"5$+! Y'"+$`3$"5$+! Y'"+$`3$"5$+!

!! d')$(!=! d')$(!F! d')$(!Q! d')$(!P! d')$(!K! d')$(!=! d')$(!F! d')$(!Q! d')$(!P!

P8A!*/,-#',"/! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6!1! G?GHEG?==I! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

,5//6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! "G?GevvEG?GQI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2!1! !! G?FFvEG?=GI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

<%4#.(-0%UJ#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! "G?GKvEG?GQI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(6!5! !! !! G?FKvEG?==I! !! !! !! !! !! !!

,.5(#6(6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! "G?G=EG?GQI! !! !! !! !! !! !!

3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&! !! !! !! G?FKvvEG?GeI! !! !! !! !! !!

M.-A&UJ#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! "G?GTEG?GKI! !! !! !! !! !!

F#-&#.!!#%A.#! !! !! !! !! "G?GFvEG?G=I! !! !! !! !!

!#%A.#U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! G?GGvEG?GGI! !! !! !! !!

3O#4!P5%6(.-0%(6! !! !! !! !! !! "G?=GvvEG?GQI! !! !! !!

P5%6(.-0%(6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! "G?G=EG?G=I! !! !! !!

$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(6! !! !! !! !! !! !! "G?FFvEG?==I! !! !!

P5A.(U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?G>wEG?GKI! !! !!

!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?GFEG?GFI! !!

!.#-(0#6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?G=wEG?G=I! !!

HA19#.!HDQ6! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?P=vvEG?=QI!

HDQ6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! "G?GGEG?GFI!

J#-.6(53/#4(05%! G?GQEG?GFI! "G?GFEG?GFI! G?GQvvEG?G=I! G?GevvEG?GQI! "G?GPwEG?GFI! G?GevEG?GPI! G?G=EG?GQI! G?G=EG?GPI! G?GTEG?=QI!

$%4A19#%(BA%! "G?GeEG?G>I! "G?GQEG?G>I! G?G=EG?GHI! G?GHEG?GHI! "k&! G?GHEG?GHI! G?GQEG?GHI! G?GHEG?GHI! G?GHEG?GHI!

P0=0/!R-.! G?F>vvEG?GPI! G?F>vvEG?GPI! G?FevvEG?GPI! G?FevvEG?GPI! G?FevvEG?GHI! G?F>vvEG?GPI! G?FevvEG?GPI! G?F>vvEG?GPI! G?F>vvEG?GPI!

3O#4!P5%6(.-0%(6! "G?=QvvEG?GQI! "G?=QvvEG?GQI! "G?G>vvEG?GFI! "G?=GvvEG?GFI! "G?G>vEG?GPI! "k&! "k&&! "G?==vvEG?GFI! "G?=FvvEG?GFI!

!.-&#!E/5CG! "G?Q=vEG?=FI! "G?QQvvEG?=FI! "G?QGvvEG?=GI! "G?F>vvEG?=GI! "G?=PEG?=PI! "G?QGvvEG?=GI! "G?QPvvEG?==I! "G?QFvvEG?=GI! "G?QGvvEG?=GI!

,5'A/-(05%!E/5CG! G?eHvEG?QKI! G?>PvvEG?QKI! G?eKvvEG?FTI! G?TTvvEG?FTI! =?FevvEG?Q>I! G?eGvvEG?FTI! G?PFEG?F>I! G?KKwEG?F>I! G?KevEG?FTI!

D>,!E/5CG! G?FQEG?FTI! G?FHEG?FTI! G?K=vvEG?F=I! G?KKvvEG?F=I! G?PQEG?F>I! G?KTvvEG?F=I! G?KevEG?FQI! G?KQvEG?F=I! G?QHEG?FFI!

,"260%(("V! G?Q>vvEG?GFI! G?PGvvEG?GFI! G?PFvvEG?GFI! G?PQvvEG?GFI! G?QevvEG?GQI! G?PQvvEG?GFI! G?PPvvEG?GFI! G?PQvvEG?GFI! G?PFvvEG?GFI!

Q=#!P6/R! =.eeQ! =.eeQ! F.Q>>! F.PQK! =.QPQ! F.PQK! F.QQH! F.PQP! F.PQ=!

2!AL! G?Fe! G?Fe! G?QG! G?QG! G?FP! G?QG! G?Fe! G?QG! G?QG!

&!V$!$A5(3)$!3O#4A(0=#!P5%6(.-0%(6!8%'*!#7$!$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(!*')$(!+!"5$!#7$!$A!+#$"5$!'8!&"!!")$-$")$"#!5'3%#!+4+#$*!!+!3+$)!#'!)$#$%*!"$!#7$!($;$(!'8!3O#4A(0=#!

P5%6(.-0%(6;!1!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!4$&%+!-%!'%!#'!&"!$($5#!'"?!

$&"

"

5!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!4$&%+!&8#$%!&"!$($5#!'"?

Page 37: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

" $'"

B'6+"!SD!F&$6-,!*/,-#',"/!$3!O$@"&.#".,"A;$./$&"0!F$+-,-%'+!2";&"//-$.!

!! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! M7%$&#! Y'"+$`3$"5$+! Y'"+$`3$"5$+! Y'"+$`3$"5$+! Y'"+$`3$"5$+!

!! d')$(!=&! d')$(!F! d')$(!Q! d')$(!P! d')$(!K! d')$(!=! d')$(!F! d')$(!Q! d')$(!P!

P&0"&"0!F&$6-,!*/,-#',"/! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

<%?-=5.-9/#!,5//6!1! G?GeEG?GeI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

,5//6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! "G?GPvEG?GFI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

<%4#.(-0%!L04(5.2!1! !! G?=FEG?GeI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

<%4#.(-0%UJ#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! "G?GPvEG?GFI! !! !! !! !! !! !! !!

3/#4(05%!,.5(#6(6!5! !! !! G?=PwEG?GeI! !! !! !! !! !! !!

,.5(#6(6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! "G?GFEG?GFI! !! !! !! !! !! !!

3/#4(5.-/!M.-A&! !! !! !! G?FFvvEG?GHI! !! !! !! !! !!

M.-A&UJ#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! "G?GevEG?GQI! !! !! !! !! !!

F#-&#.!!#%A.#! !! !! !! !! "G?GGEG?G=I! !! !! !! !!

!#%A.#U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! G?GGEG?GGI! !! !! !! !!

3O#4!P5%6(.-0%(6! !! !! !! !! !! "G?GTvvEG?G=I! !! !! !!

P5%6(.-0%(6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! G?G=EG?G=I! !! !! !!

$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(6! !! !! !! !! !! !! "G?=GwEG?GHI! !! !!

P5A.(U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?G>vEG?GQI! !! !!

!.#-(0#6!B-(0?0#&! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?GFEG?G=I! !!

!.#-(0#6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?G=vEG?GGI! !!

HA19#.!HDQ6!E/5CG! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! "G?G=EG?GHI!

HDQ6U!J#-.6(53/#4(05%! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! !! G?G=EG?GFI!

J#-.6(53/#4(05%! G?G=EG?GFI! G?GGEG?G=I! G?GFvEG?G=I! G?GKvEG?GFI! "G?G=EG?G=I! "G?GFEG?GQI! "G?G=EG?GFI! "G?GQEG?GQI! "G?GFEG?==I!

$%4A19#%(BA%! "G?G=EG?GHI! "G?GFEG?GHI! G?GQEG?GKI! G?GFEG?GPI! "k&! G?GQEG?GPI! G?G=EG?GKI! G?GQEG?GPI! G?GQEG?GPI!

P0=0/!R-.! G?=FvvEG?GQI! G?=QvvEG?GQI! G?==vEG?GKI! G?==vvEG?GQI! G?=QvvEG?GQI! G?==vvEG?GQI! G?==vvEG?GFI! G?=FvvEG?GQI! G?==vvEG?GQI!

3O#4!P5%6(.-0%(6! "G?GTvvEG?G=I! "G?GHvvEG?G=I! "G?GHvvEG?G=I! "G?GKvvEG?G=I! "G?GHvvEG?GFI! "k&! "k&&! "G?==vvEG?GFI! "G?GHvvEG?G=I!

!.-&#!E/5CG! "G?=evvEG?GKI! "G?=TvvEG?GKI! "G?=KvvEG?GPI! "G?=HvvEG?GPI! "G?FGvvEG?GHI! "G?=HvvEG?GPI! "G?=TvvEG?GKI! "G?=HvvEG?GPI! "G?=HvvEG?GKI!

,5'A/-(05%!E/5CG! G?FFvvEG?GQI! G?FQvvEG?GQI! G?FFvvEG?GQI! G?FFvvEG?GQI! G?=>vvEG?GPI! G?FQvvEG?GQI! G?FPvvEG?GQI! G?FQvvEG?GQI! G?FQvvEG?GQI!

D>,!E/5CG! G?=QvEG?GHI! G?=QvEG?GHI! G?==vEG?GKI! G?==vEG?GKI! G?=evEG?GTI! G?=GvEG?GKI! G?GeEG?GKI! G?=GwEG?GKI! G?=GvEG?GKI!

,"260%(("V! G?K=vvEG?GFI! G?KGvvEG?GFI! G?KQvvEG?GFI! G?KQvvEG?GFI! G?KFvvEG?GFI! G?KPvvEG?GFI! G?KQvvEG?GFI! G?KQvvEG?GFI! G?KPvvEG?GFI!

Q=#!P6/R! =.eeQ! =.eeQ! F.Q>>! F.PQK! =.QPQ! F.PQK! F.QQH! F.PQP! F.PQ=!

2!AL! G?FPF! G?FPQ! G?FKP! G?FKH! G?FPK! G?FKK! G?FKG! G?FKH! G?FKK!

w!+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=GR!v+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!KR!!vv+!9"!8!5&"#!&#!=R!!

&!V$!$A5(3)$!3O#4A(0=#!P5%6(.-0%(6!8%'*!#7$!$%&#'#%&#%(!P5A.(!*')$(!+!"5$!#7$!$A!+#$"5$!'8!&"!!")$-$")$"#!5'3%#!+4+#$*!!+!3+$)!#'!)$#$%*!"$!#7$!($;$(!'8!3O#4A(0=#!

P5%6(.-0%(6;!1!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!4$&%+!-%!'%!#'!&"!$($5#!'"?!

5!J#-.6!53/#4(05%!!+!5')$)!&+!4$&%+!&8#$%!&"!$($5#!'"!

Page 38: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" $(

T-:=&"!CD!*>;"%,"0!2";&"//-$.!U1".!*+"%,-$./!'&"!Q"'&!V'6$@"W!'.0!!-/,'.,!V6"+$XW!

!

Page 39: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" $)

!

T-:=&"!ED!Y'&-',-$.!-.!F$+-,-%'+!2";&"//-$.!6(!*+"%,-$.!-.!Z-#6'6X"!

!!

!

Page 40: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" $*

T-:=&"!MD!Y'&-',-$.!-.!F$+-,-%'+!2";&"//-$.!-.!5&'.)!EIIG!F&"/-0".,-'+!*+"%,-$.!

!

!

!

Page 41: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" %+

2"3"&".%"/!

!

/*"$+#4!S"#$%"&#!'"&(?!FGG=?!W019-9I#"71%#6(2!$%(#.%-(05%-/!B#'5.(!)**V?!!!

W$5B.![&#7&"!$(?!FGG=?!CM!*$":$%!$+""Y%'++":$5#!'"!@&#&f!V7&#!]&;$!V$!Z$&%"$)!!"!#7$!O&+#!J$6!N$&%+l?D!

7%%A-/!B#=0#I!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!PE=If!FT="F>Q?!!!

W$5B.![&#7&"!$(.!&")!g'"&#7&"![?!b&#0?!=>>K?!CV7&#!#'!)'!E&")!"'#!#'!)'I!6!#7!M!*$":$%!$+!Y%'++":$5#!'"!

@&#&?D!!"#!71#.04-%!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!B#=0#I!e>EQIf!HQP"HPT?!!!

W$5B.![&#7&"!$(.!&")!g'"&#7&"![?!b&#0?!FGGP?!CM!*$":$%!$+"Y%'++":$5#!'"!S++3$+f!@4"&*!5+.!FGGP?D!O%$+$"#$)!

&#!#7$!7%%A-/!T##(0%C!5?!("#!X540#(2!?5.!,5/0(04-/!T#("5&5/5C2.!:#&"8'%)!<"!;$%+!#4?!

!W$5B.![&#7&"!$(.!g'"&#7&"![?!b&#0.!&")!U!57&%)!M35B$%?!=>>e?!CM&B!"9!M!*$!:$%!'3+(4f!M!*$":$%!$+"Y%'++"

:$5#!'"!/"&(4+!+!6!#7!&!W!"&%4!@$-$")$"#!^&%!&1($?D!71#.04-%!Y5A.%-/!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!PFEPIf!=FHG"

=Fee?!!!

W$5B.!M7'%+#$"!$#!&(?!FGG=?!C[$6!#''(+!!"!5'*-&%&#!;$!-'(!#!5&(!$5'"'*4f!M7$!@&#&1&+$!'8!O'(!#!5&(!

S"+#!#3#!'"+?D!!"#!R5./&!Z-%K!345%5104!B#=0#I!=KE=If!=HK?!!!

W%&*1'%.!M7'*&+.!V!((!&*!U'1$%#+!Y(&%B.!&")!d&##!L'()$%?!FGGH?!C<")$%+#&")!"9!S"#$%&5#!'"!d')$(+f!

S*-%';!"9!X*-!%!5&(!/"&(4+$+?D!,5/0(04-/!7%-/2606!=PE=If!HQ"eF?!!!

W%'6"($$.!g&+'"?!FGG>?!CO'%#$"#+!'8!O(3%&(!+*f!]'6!]41%!)!U$9!*$+!/88$5#!@$*'5%&#!5!M%&"+!#!'"+?D!71#.04-%!

Y5A.%-/!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!KQEQIf!K=K"KQF?!!!

Y&%$4.!:&1!"$!Y?!FGGH?!CM7$!@4"&*!5!U$(&#!'"+7!-!W$#6$$"!O%'#$+#!&")!U$-%$++!'"?D!,5/0(04-/!B#6#-.4"!

[A-.(#./2!K>E=If!=!"==?!!!

Y!"9%&"$((!.!@&;!).!&")!d!B7&!(!J!(!--';?!FG=G?!CX($5#'%&(!U3($+!&")!S"5$"#!;$+!#'!O%'#$5#!]3*&"!U!97#+?D!!"#!

Y5A.%-/!5?!,5/0(046!TFEG=If!FPQ"FKT?!!!

Y!"9%&"$((!.!@&;!)!Z?.!&")!@&;!)!Z?!U!57&%)+?!FG=G?!!"#!P0%C.-%#//0"B04"-.&6!EP$B$G!@A1-%!B0C"(6!>-(-6#(?!

/;&!(&1($!&#f!7##-fkk666?73*&"%!97#+)&#&?'%9?!

Y'((!$%.!O&3(?!FGG>?!R-.6N!DA%6N!-%&!L5(#6?![$6!N'%Bf!]&%-$%?!!!

Page 42: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" %!

Y'A.!L&%4?!FGGe?!C/3#7'%!#&%!&"!X($5#!'"+!&")!Z$&)$%+7!-!:355$++!'".!=>TK"!FGGG?D!T6;!<%0=#.60(2!5?!

P-/0?5.%0-N!X-%!>0#C5?!!!

@&7(.!U'1$%#!/(&"?!=>T=?!,5/2-.4"2\!,-.(040'-(05%!-%&!Q''560(05%?![$6!]&;$"f!N&($!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

@&;$"-'%#.!Y7%!+#!&"?!=>>T?!CJ%'*!1&(('#+!#'!13(($#+f!&"!$*-!%!5&(!&++$++*$"#!'8!7'6!"&#!'"&(!$($5#!'"+!

!"8(3$"5$!+#&#$!3+$+!'8!-'(!#!5&(!%$-%$++!'"?D!3/#4(5.-/!X(A&0#6!=HEPIf!K=T"KPG?!!!

@&;$"-'%#.!Y7%!+#!&"?!=>>K?!Cd3(#!"@!*$"+!'"&(!M7%$&#!O$%5$-#!'"!&")!:#&#$!U$-%$++!'"f!/"!S"`3!%4!!"#'!V74!

:#&#$+!/--(4![$9&#!;$!:&"5#!'"+?D!71#.04-%!Y5A.%-/!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!Q>EQIf!HeQ"T=Q?!!!

@&;$"-'%#.!Y7%!+#!&"?!FGGT?!C:#&#$!U$-%$++!'"!&")!O'(!#!5&(!,%)$%?D!7%%A-/!B#=0#I!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!=GE=I?!!!

@&;$"-'%#.!Y7%!+#!&"?!=>>H?!CM7$!V$!97#!'8!#7$!O&+#f!XA-('%!"9!Z&99$)!@$#$%*!"&"#+!'8!O'(!#!5&(!U$-%$++!'"?D!

,5/0(04-/!B#6#-.4"![A-.(#./2!P>EFIf!QTT"PGQ?!!!

@&;$"-'%#.!Y7%!+#!&".!&")!@&;!)!/?!/%*+#%'"9?!FGGP?!C@$*'5%&54!&")!#7$!^!'(&#!'"!'8!]3*&"!U!97#+f!/!

:#&#!+#!5&(!/"&(4+!+!8%'*!=>TH!#'!=>>H?D!71#.04-%!Y5A.%-/!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!PeEQIf!KQe"KKP?!!!

@!&*'").!Z&%%4!g&4?!FGGF?!CM7!"B!"9!/1'3#!]41%!)!U$9!*$+?D!Y5A.%-/!5?!>#154.-42!=QEFIf!F="QK?!!!

L&")7!.!g$""!8$%.!&")!X(($"!Z3+#",B&%?!FGG>?!CX($5#!'"+!<")$%!/3#7'%!#&%!&"!+*?D!7%%A-/!B#=0#I!5?!,5/0(04-/!

X40#%4#!=F?!!!

L&")7!.!g$""!8$%.!&")!/)&*!O%0$6'%+B!?!FGG>?!C]'()!"9!'"#'!O'6$%!14!/"4!d$&"+l!M7$!,%!9!"+!'8!

Y'*-$#!#!;$!X($5#!'"+?D!T6;!315.2!<%0=#.60(2?!!!

L!1"$4.!d&%B.!Z!")&!Y'%"$##.!&")!U$$)!V'')?!FG=G?!CO'(!#!5&(!M$%%'%!:5&($!=>TH"FGGH?D!/;&!(&1($!&#f!

7##-fkk666?-'(!#!5&(#$%%'%+5&($?'%9k?!

L!%&%).!O7!(!--$.!&")!X%!5!O&%$"#?!FGG=?!CW&4$+!&"!/"&(4+!+!'8!/3#'5'%%$(&#$)!,%)$%$)!Y&#$9'%!5&(!@&#&!8'%!

S")3+#%!&(!s3&(!#4!d'"!#'%!"9?D!!#4"%51#(.046!PQEFIf!=eG"=>=?!!!

L'$*&"+.!]$!"!X?.!b%!+#!&"!:?!L($)!#+57.!&")!L!&5'*'!Y7!'00&?!FGG>?!CS"#%')35!"9!/%57!9'+f!/!)&#&+$#!'8!

-'(!#!5&(!($&)$%+?D!Y5A.%-/!5?!,#-4#!.#6#-.4"!PHEFIf!FH>?!!!

Page 43: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" %#

L%$$"$.!V!((!&*!]?.!&")!@&;!)!/?!]$"+7$%?!FGGe?!Cd')$(!"9!,%)$%$)!Y7'!5$+f!/!O%!*$%!&")!U$5$"#!

@$;$('-*$"#+?D!XXBH!#F09.-.2?!/;&!(&1($!&#f!7##-fkk++%"?5'*k&1+#%&5#t=F=QG>Q?!!!

]&8"$%"W3%#'".!X*!(!$!d?.!&")!b!4'#$%3!M+3#+3!?!FGGK?!C]3*&"!U!97#+!!"!&!L('1&(!0!"9!V'%()f!M7$!O&%&)'A!'8!

X*-#4!O%'*!+$+?D!71#.04-%!Y5A.%-/!5?!X5405/5C2!==GEKIf!=QTQ"=P==?!!!

]'6&%).!d&%5!d?.!&")!O7!(!-!L?!U'$++($%?!FGGH?!CZ!1$%&(!0!"9!X($5#'%&(!,3#5'*$+!!"!Y'*-$#!#!;$!/3#7'%!#&%!&"!

U$9!*$+?D!71#.04-%!Y5A.%-/!5?!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!KGEFIf!QHK"Qe=?!!!

]3*&"!U!97#+!V&#57?!FG=G?!CY&*1')!&f!M%!13"&(\+!J!%+#!:#$-!!"!:$&%57!8'%!g3+#!5$?D!/;&!(&1($!&#f!

7##-fkk666?7%6?'%9k$"k"$6+kFG=GkGTkFHk5&*1')!&"#%!13"&("+"8!%+#"+#$-"+$&%57"23+#!5$!i/55$++$)!

/393+#!Q.!FG=Gj?!

]3"#!"9#'".!:&*3$(!O?!=>>=?!!"#!!"0.&!R-=#\!>#154.-(08-(05%!0%!("#!F-(#!!I#%(0#("!P#%(A.2?!['%*&".!,bf!

<"!;$%+!#4!'8!,B(&7'*&!O%$++?!!!

]4)$.!:3+&"!@?.!&")![!B'(&4!d&%!"';?!FGG>?!C[&#!'"&(!X($5#!'"+!&5%'++!@$*'5%&54!&")!/3#'5%&54f!V7!57!

X($5#!'"+!Y&"!1$!Z'+#l?D!T6;!J-/#!<%0=#.60(2?!/;&!(&1($!&#f!7##-fkk74)$?%$+$&%57?4&($?$)3k"$()&k!

i/55$++$)!g&"3&%4!FQ.!FG=Gj?!!!

S*&!.!b'+3B$.!L&%4!b!"9.!&")!,(!;!&!Z&3?!FGGe?!CM'6&%)!&!Y'**'"!J%&*$6'%B!8'%!:#&#!+#!5&(!/"&(4+!+!&")!

@$;$('-*$"#?D!Y5A.%-/!5?!P51'A(-(05%!-%&!D.-'"04-/!X(-(06(046!=TEPIf!e>F">=Q?!!!

S*&!.!b'+3B$.!L&%4!b!"9.!&")!,(!;!&!Z&3?!FGGT?!W#/0C\!3=#.25%#]6!X(-(06(04-/!X5?(I-.#?!/;&!(&1($!&#f!

7##-fkkLb!"9?7&%;&%)?$)3k0$(!9?!

S"#$%"O&%(!&*$"#&%4!<"!'"?!=>>Q?!P-195&0-\!'-./0-1#%(-.2!#/#4(05%6!P5%6(0(A#%(!766#19/2N!V^^S?!/;&!(&1($!

&#f!7##-fkk666?!-3?'%9k-&%(!"$"$k%$-'%#+k&%5kFGK=n>Q?7#*!i/55$++$)!g3(4!F=.!FG=Gj?!

b$!#7.!Z!")&!Y&*-.!&")!:#$;$"!Y!O'$?!FGGP?!C/%$!Y'"+#!#3#!'"&(!:#&#$!'8!X*$%9$"54!Y(&3+$+!X88$5#!;$!"!/"!

X*-!%!5&(!XA-('%&#!'"?D!@A1-%!B0C"(6![A-.(#./2!FHf!=GT=?!!!

b$4++&%.!/($A&")$%?!FGG>?!!"#!B0C"(!(5!L5(#\!!"#!P5%(#6(#&!@06(5.2!5?!>#154.-42!0%!("#!<%0(#&!X(-(#6?!

U$;!+$)!X)!#!'"?!W&+!5!W''B+?!!!

Page 44: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" %$

b!"9.!L&%4.!&")!Z&"957$!c$"9?!FGGH?!CM7$!@&"9$%+!'8!XA#%$*$!Y'3"#$%8&5#3&(+?D!,5/0(04-/!7%-/2606!=PEFIf!=Q="

=K>?!!!

Z$;!#+B4.!:#$;$"?.!&")!Z35&"!V&4?!FG=G?!P51'#(0(0=#!7A("5.0(-.0-%061\!!"#!Q.0C0%6!-%&!3=5/A(05%[email protected]&!

B#C01#6!0%!("#!,56("P5/&!R-.!3.-?![$6!N'%Bf!Y&*1%!)9$!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

Z$;!#+B4.!:#$;$"?.!&")!Z35&"!V&4?!FGGF?!CM7$!U!+$!'8!Y'*-$#!#!;$!/3#7'%!#&%!&"!+*?D!Y5A.%-/!5?!>#154.-42!

=QEFIf!K="HK?!!!

Z$6!+"W$5B.!d!57&$(!:?!=>>G?!345%51046!-%&!3/#4(05%6\!!"#!T-:5.!R#6(#.%!>#154.-40#6?!<"!;$%+!#4!'8!

d!57!9&"!O%$++?!!!

Z!$1$%*&".!X;&"!:?!FGGK?!C[$+#$)!/"&(4+!+!&+!&!d!A$)"d$#7')!:#%&#$94!8'%!Y'*-&%&#!;$!U$+$&%57?D!71#.04-%!

,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!B#=0#I!>>EGQIf!PQK"PKF?!!!

Z!2-7&%#.!/%$")?!=>eG?!>#154.-42!0%!,/A.-/!X540#(0#6\!7!P51'-.-(0=#!3O'/5.-(05%?![$6!]&;$"f!N&($!<"!;$%+!#4!

O%$++?!!!

Z!")1$%9.!:#&88&"!S?!FGGH?!>#154.-42!-%&!3/#4(05%6!0%!7?.04-?!W&(#!*'%$f!g'7"+!]'-B!"+!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

Z!-+$#.!O%'8$++'%!:$4*'3%!d&%#!"?!=>e=?!,5/0(04-/!T-%\!!"#!X540-/!Z-6#6!5?!,5/0(046?!XA-&")$)?!M7$!g'7"+!

]'-B!"+!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

Z3+#",B&%.!X(($"?!FGGH?!CX($5#!'"+!<")$%!/3#7'%!#&%!&"!+*f!O%$(!*!"&%4!Z$++'"+!8%'*!g'%)&"?D!

>#154.-(08-(05%!=QEQIf!PKH"PT=?!!!

d&9&('"!.!W$&#%!0?!FGGH?!L5(0%C!?5.!7A(54.-42\!@#C#15%04!,-.(2!XA.=0=-/!-%&!$(6!>#106#!0%!T#O045?!

Y&*1%!)9$f!Y&*1%!)9$!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

d&!"6&%!"9.!:5'##.!@&"!$(!W%!"B+.!&")!/"!1&(!O$%$0"Z!"&"?!FGG=?!CY(&++!84!"9!O'(!#!5&(!U$9!*$+!!"!Z&#!"!

/*$%!5&.!=>PK"=>>>?D!X(A&0#6!0%!P51'-.-(0=#!$%(#.%-(05%-/!>#=#/5'1#%(!QHE=If!QT?!!!

d&%+7&((.!d'"#4!L?!FGGT?!Cd&2'%!X-!+')$+!'8!O'(!#!5&(!^!'($"5$.!=>PH"FGGH?D!P#%(#.!?5.!X26(#104!,#-4#N!R#9!

'-C#N!/-6(!A'&-(#&!5%!X#'(#19#.!=e?!!!

Page 45: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" %%

d&%+7&((.!d'"#4!L?.!&")!b$!#7!g&99$%+?!FGGF?!CO'(!#4!S^!O%'2$5#f!O'(!#!5&(!U$9!*$!Y7&%&5#$%!+#!5+!&")!

M%&"+!#!'"+.!=eGG"FGGF?D!>-(-6#(!<6#.6_!T-%A-/N!P#%(#.!?5.!$%(#.%-(05%-/!>#=#/5'1#%(!-%&!P5%?/04(!

T-%-C#1#%(N!<%0=#.60(2!5?!T-.2/-%&?!!!

dm(($%.!L$%"'#.!&")!Y(&3)!&!Y0&)'?!FGGK?!C/"!/3#'%$9%$++!;$!,%)$%$)!O%'1!#!d')$(!V!#7!/--(!5&#!'"!#'!]!97"

J%$`3$"54!J!"&"5!&(!@&#&?D!Y5A.%-/!5?!P51'A(-(05%-/!-%&!D.-'"04-/!X(-(06(046!=PEFIf!QFG"QQe?!!!

O'$.!:#$;$"!Y?.!&")!Y?![$&(!M&#$?!=>>P?!CU$-%$++!'"!'8!]3*&"!U!97#+!#'!O$%+'"&(!S"#$9%!#4!!"!#7$!=>eG+f!/!

L('1&(!/"&(4+!+?D!!"#!71#.04-%!,5/0(04-/!X40#%4#!B#=0#I!eeEPIf!eKQ"eTF?!!!

O'$.!:#$;$"!Y?.!Y?![$&(!M&#$.!&")!Z!")&!Y&*-!b$!#7?!=>>>?!CU$-%$++!'"!'8!#7$!]3*&"!U!97#!#'!O$%+'"&(!

S"#$9%!#4!U$;!+!#$)f!/!L('1&(!Y%'++"[&#!'"&(!:#3)4!Y';$%!"9!#7$!N$&%+!=>TH"=>>Q?D!$%(#.%-(05%-/!X(A&0#6!

[A-.(#./2!PQEFIf!F>="Q=Q?!!!

O'$.!:#$;$"!Y?!$#!&(?!FGGG?!CM7$!Y'"#!"3!#4!'8!:388$%!"9f!@'*$+#!5!M7%$&#!&")!]3*&"!U!97#+!/13+$!/5%'++!

M!*$?D!S"!,-("6!(5!X(-(#!B#'.#6605%\!@A1-%!B0C"(6!-%&!P5%(#%(05A6!,5/0(046!0%!P51'-.-(0=#!,#.6'#4(0=#.!

$)?!Y7%!+#!&"!/?!@&;$"-'%#?!W'3()$%f!U'*&"!Z!##($8!$()?!!!

O%0$6'%+B!.!/)&*?!=>>=?!>#154.-42!-%&!("#!T-.K#(\!,5/0(04-/!-%&!345%5104!B#?5.16!0%!3-6(#.%!3A.5'#!-%&!

F-(0%!71#.04-?!Y&*1%!)9$f!Y&*1%!)9$!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

O%0$6'%+B!.!/)&*?!FGG>?!CJ'%5$.!V$&(#7.!&")!X($5#!'"+?D!T6;!H#I!J5.K!<%0=#.60(2?!!!

U$9&".!O&#%!5B!d?.!U!57&%)!V?!J%&"B.!&")!@&;!)!]?!Y(&%B?!FGG>?!C[$6!@&#&+$#+!'"!O'(!#!5&(!S"+#!#3#!'"+!&")!

X($5#!'"+.!=>TF_FGGK?D!P5%?/04(!T-%-C#1#%(!-%&!,#-4#!X40#%4#!FHEQIf!FeH?!!!

U!57&%)+.!@&;!)!Z?!=>>>?!CO$%!('3+!O%'A4f!]3*&"!U!97#+!&")!#7$!O%$+$"5$!'8![&#!'"&(!X($5#!'"+?D!X540-/!

X40#%4#![A-.(#./2!eGEPIf!HPe"HHK?!!!

U!B$%.!V!((!&*!]?!=>HK?!>#154.-42!0%!("#!<%0(#&!X(-(#6?![$6!N'%Bf!d&5*!((&"?!!!

U'1!"+'".!g&*$+!/.!&")!U&9"&%!M'%;!B?!FGG>?!CM7$!U$&(!:6!"9!^'#$%q+!Y3%+$?D!71#.04-%!345%5104!B#=0#I!

>>EFIf!Q=G"Q=K?!!!

Page 46: 32 45#22%$' 1$ 67'%58971 :9;1%$'2!!pages.ucsd.edu › ~ehafner › pdfs › Hafner-Burton_Terrorizing... · 2015-04-18 · 7$!(! .(#! % $&" " 5 !%" $'"

"

" %&

U'$++($%.!O7!(!-!L?.!&")!d&%5!d?!]'6&%)?!FGG>?!CO'+#"Y'()!V&%!O'(!#!5&(!U$9!*$+f!V7$"!@'!X($5#!'"+!

d&##$%l?D!S"!>#154.-(08-(05%!92!3/#4(05%6.!$)?!:#&88&"!S?!Z!")1$%9?!W&(#!*'%$f!g'7"+!]'-B!"+!<"!;$%+!#4!

O%$++.!-?!PQF?!!!

:57$)($%.!/")%$&+?!FGGF?!CM7$!d$"3!'8!d&"!-3(&#!'"?D!Y5A.%-/!5?!>#154.-42!=QEFIf!QH"KG?!!!

:$(!9+'".!d!#57$((!/?.!&")!g'7"!/?!W''#7?!=>>K?!3/#4(05%6!-%&!>#154.-42!0%!P#%(.-/!71#.04-N!B#=060(#&?!

XA-&")$)?!Y7&-$(!]!((.![Yf!M7$!<"!;$%+!#4!'8!['%#7!Y&%'(!"&!O%$++?!!!

:!**'"+.!W$#7!/?!FGG>?!T590/080%C!?5.!@A1-%!B0C"(6\!$%(#.%-(05%-/!F-I!0%!>51#6(04!,5/0(046?![$6!N'%Bf!

Y&*1%!)9$!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

:!*-+$%.!/(1$%#'?!FGGK?!Cd&B!"9!^'#$+!['#!Y'3"#f!:#%&#$9!5!S"5$"#!;$+!8'%!X($5#'%&(!Y'%%3-#!'"?D!O7@!

@!++$%#&#!'"f!:#&"8'%)!<"!;$%+!#4?!

:!+B.!M!*'#74!@?!=>>K?!>#154.-(08-(05%!0%!X5A("!7?.04-\!!"#!3/A60=#!X540-/!P5%(.-4(?!O%!"5$#'"f!O%!"5$#'"!

<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

:"4)$%.!g&5B!Z?!FGGG?!M.51!L5(0%C!(5!L05/#%4#\!>#154.-(08-(05%!-%&!H-(05%-/06(!P5%?/04(?![$6!N'%Bf!['%#'"?!!!

<?:?!@$-&%#*$"#!'8!:#&#$?!=>>P?!P-195&0-!@A1-%!B0C"(6!,.-4(04#6N!V^^S?!!

<?:?!@$-&%#*$"#!'8!:#&#$?!FGG=?!W019-9I#!@A1-%!B0C"(6!,.-4(04#6N!)***?!!

<?:?!@$-&%#*$"#!'8!:#&#$?!FGGH?!C/0$%1&!2&"!]3*&"!U!97#+!O%&5#!5$+.!FGGK?D!!

^&(!4$;.!/"&%!d?!FGGH?!CO&%(!&*$"#&%4!X($5#!'"+!!"!/0$%1&!2&"f!/!J&!($)!U$;'(3#!'"?D!,.59/#16!5?!,56("

P511A%061!KQEQIf!=T"QK?!!!

V!(B!"+'".!:#$;$"!S?!FGGH?!L5(#6!-%&!L05/#%4#?![$6!N'%Bf!Y&*1%!)9$!<"!;$%+!#4!O%$++?!!!

V'%()!W&"B?!FGGH?!CV'%()!@$;$('-*$"#!S")!5&#'%+?D!P>"BQTN!R5./&!Z-%K?!!!

c&B&%!&.!J&%$$)?!=>>T?!CM7$!U!+$!'8!S((!1$%&(!@$*'5%&54?D!M5.#0C%!7??-0.6!THEHIf!FF"PQ?!!!

!!