4 aug 04 ietf 60rfc editor1 4 aug 2004 60th ietf meeting san diego, california rfc editor report
TRANSCRIPT
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 1
4 Aug 2004
60th IETF MeetingSan Diego, California
RFC Editor Report
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 2
Justifiable Pride
April 7, 2004: 35th anniversary of RFC 1.
RFCs were earliest online publication series.
Series currently contains over 80,000 pages.
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 3
Procedure Changes
New copyright/IPR rules put into practice.o In: draft-rfc-editor-rfc2223bis-08.txto See:
http://www.rfc-editor.org/copyright.htmlo We think we have it right, now…
New IESG rules for approving independent submissionso In: draft-iesg-rfced-documents-03.txto New disclaimer boilerplate.
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 4
Procedure Changes
Require that citations & references match.
Using automated checkers when feasible -o MIBs, abnf, XML, XML schema.
WG chairs included in msgs to author, ADs
Public discussion list:[email protected]
“Office hours” at this IETF.
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 5
Procedure Changes
Advisory group for RFC Editor “Editorial Board”
Chosen by RFC Editor, to provide a set of wise heads with deep Internet and/or publication experience.
To help us to serve the community better.
Provide broader competence for review of independent submissions.
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 6
Current Ed Board membership (expected to grow):
Scott Bradner, Vint Cerf, Bruce Davie, Sue Hares,Bob Hinden, John Klensin, Craig Partridge, Jim
Schaad.
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 7
New Services
Errata pages linked from RFC search engine.
Internet Draft names in master index file rfc-index.xml.
File of RFC bibliographic entries.
Queue page now contains hyperlinks.
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 8
Monthly Stats (1)
Since Last IETF: March 2004 – July 2004
Processed Docs~Pages
DNPs/Withdrawals: 2 64
Total Published: 132 3899
Submissions DocsIETF Submissions: 123 Independent Submissions 18
Total Submissions: 141
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 9
Monthly Stats (2)
RFC Editor Queue as of June 30 , 2004 Status Docs PagesPending RFC Editor Action:(EDIT) Editing/Nroffing/Proofing 50 1340(EDIT) + IANA 27 767(EDIT) + REF 30 1170(EDIT) + REF + IANA 5 298Final Review (RFC-EDITOR) 10 596Independent Submis. Review (ISR) 25 782Pending External Action:Author Revisions (AUTH & AUTH48 20 529 &ISR-AUTH)IESG action needed (IESG & TO) 18 524IANA action needed (IANA) 0 0Docs with Norm Ref. Issues (REF) 28 1000
Total Drafts in Queue 213 7006
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 10
If your RFC was created with xml2rfc: please send us the xml file with the .txt file.
URLs
ftp://ftp.rfc-editor.org/in-notes/IETFreports
ftp://ftp.rfc-editor.org/in-notes/rfc-index.txt, .xml
ftp://ftp.rfc-editor.org/in-notes/rfc-ref.txt
http://www.rfc-editor.org/news.html
Reminders
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 11
Work in Progress
Adding working group names into the RFC index.
oObstacle: getting valid historic data. Improving spam-robustness of email
retrieval service (rfc-info)
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 12
0
50
100
150
200
March April May June July
Submitted PublishedNot Published RFC Editor Queue StatesExternal Queue States
Stats by Month
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 13
Queue – all states
RFC Editor Queue
0
50
100
150
200
250
8/1
/20
02
9/1
/20
02
10
/1/2
00
2
11
/1/2
00
2
12
/1/2
00
2
1/1
/20
03
2/1
/20
03
3/1
/20
03
4/1
/20
03
5/1
/20
03
6/1
/20
03
7/1
/20
03
8/1
/20
03
9/1
/20
03
10
/1/2
00
3
11
/1/2
00
3
12
/1/2
00
3
1/1
/20
04
2/1
/20
04
3/1
/20
04
4/1
/20
04
5/1
/20
04
6/1
/20
04
7/1
/20
04
Queue Length
Date
EDIT ISR RFC-EDITOR TO AUTH48 AUTH IESG REF IANA OTHER
4 Aug 04 IETF 60 RFC Editor 14
RFC Editor Queue
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
8/1
/20
02
9/1
/20
02
10
/1/2
00
2
11
/1/2
00
2
12
/1/2
00
2
1/1
/20
03
2/1
/20
03
3/1
/20
03
4/1
/20
03
5/1
/20
03
6/1
/20
03
7/1
/20
03
8/1
/20
03
9/1
/20
03
10
/1/2
00
3
11
/1/2
00
3
12
/1/2
00
3
1/1
/20
04
2/1
/20
04
3/1
/20
04
4/1
/20
04
5/1
/20
04
6/1
/20
04
7/1
/20
04
Queue Length
Date
EDIT-no-mod EDIT*A RFC-EDITOR ISR
Queue – only RFCEd states