4 e vietnam war practice
TRANSCRIPT
SBCSQ PracticeSelf-marking and evaluation
Qns 1 (a)
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
What the source said:
A lot of Vietnamese died because
of the Americans
Children too
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
Source's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
What makes up yourexpectation
determines whichlevel you have
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectationSource's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation
Base on general knowledge:Americans are suppose to get Americans to supportAmerica's involvement
Source's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation
Base on general knowledge:Americans are suppose to get Americans to supportAmerica's involvement
Source's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
does not support
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation
Base on general knowledge:Americans are suppose to get Americans to supportAmerica's involvement
Source's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
does not support
I'm surprised!
What if you base your expectationsfrom what you've
found out from other sources too?
What if you base your expectationsfrom what you've
found out from other sources too?
Doesn't that make it a higher level than just general knowledge
because you considered more things?
Example: Sources E and F
Example: Sources E and F
Death of Peace and progress
Send your sons to die
Example: Sources E and F
Death of Peace and progress
Send your sons to die
American public to not support the war
American public to not support the war
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectationSource's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectationSource's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectationSource's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectationSource's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Supports
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectationSource's purpose:Garner
support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Supports
I'm NOT surprised!
Let's write it out
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation Source's purpose:
Garner support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Supports
I'm NOT surprised!
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation Source's purpose:
Garner support of Americans to
go against American's
involvement in the Vietnam
War
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Supports
I'm not surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War.
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Supports
I'm not surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War. The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince the American public that the American's involvement in the Vietnam War is not moral. This is because the source shows a lot of Vietnamese killed in the war, including a child. This source was published when the Vietnam War started on an American newspaper. Therefore, the cartoonist is trying to garner the support of Americans to not support the American's involvement in the Vietnam War.
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
Supports
I'm not surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War. The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince the American public that the American's involvement in the Vietnam War is not moral. This is because the source shows a lot of Vietnamese killed in the war, including a child. This source was published when the Vietnam War started on an American newspaper. Therefore, the cartoonist is trying to garner the support of Americans to not support the American's involvement in the Vietnam War.
TypicalStar Approach
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
My expectation
From Source D and E:War is not viewed favourably by Americans
Garner support of Americans go against America's involvement in Vietnam War
I'm not surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War. The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince the American public that the American's involvement in the Vietnam War is not moral. This is because the source shows a lot of Vietnamese killed in the war, including a child. This source was published when the Vietnam War started on an American newspaper. Therefore, the cartoonist is trying to garner the support of Americans to not support the American's involvement in the Vietnam War. This is supported by
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
I'm not surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War. The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince the American public that the American's involvement in the Vietnam War is not moral. This is because the source shows a lot of Vietnamese killed in the war, including a child. This source was published when the Vietnam War started on an American newspaper. Therefore, the cartoonist is trying to garner the support of Americans to not support the American's involvement in the Vietnam War. This is supported by Source D and E, which is also trying to garner the support of the Americans to go against the American's invovlement in the Vietnam War.
Are you surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War? EYA.
I'm not surprised by what this source says about the Vietnam War. The cartoonist in Source A is trying to convince the American public that the American's involvement in the Vietnam War is not moral. This is because the source shows a lot of Vietnamese killed in the war, including a child. This source was published when the Vietnam War started on an American newspaper. Therefore, the cartoonist is trying to garner the support of Americans to not support the American's involvement in the Vietnam War. This is supported by Source D and E, which is also trying to garner the support of the Americans to go against the American's invovlement in the Vietnam War.
You can alsoreplace thiswith a star approach
for one of the sources.
It is better supported this way
Qns 1 (c)
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
What is the logic for this?
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Just show that one of them is wrong!
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Just show that one of them is wrong!
wrong!
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Just show that one of them is wrong!
wrong!
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
How do you show if something is wrong?
wrong!
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
How do you show if something is wrong?
wrong!
= cannot believe
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
How do you show if something is wrong?
wrong!
= cannot believe
So what skill does it require then?
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
How do you show if something is wrong?
wrong!
= cannot believe
So what skill does it require then?
Reliability!
How about other possible combinations?
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?
wrong!correct
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?
wrong!correct
No need cause the question asked if ONE OF THEM IS WRONG
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?
wrong!
This will sufficiently show that ONE OF THEM is wrong isn't it?
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Do I need to show that one is correct and the other is wrong?
wrong!
This will sufficiently show that ONE OF THEM is wrong isn't it?
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Is there a need to do this?
wrong! wrong!
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Is there a need to do this?
wrong!
No. Cause showing that both are wrong still shows that ONE OF THEM is wrong .
wrong!
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Can this answer the question?
Right! Right!
No, none of them is wrong
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Can this answer the question?
Right! Right!
No, none of them is wrong
Yes you can. But you must explain why both are right even though the views are different.
Source D Source E
The two sources give differing views on how President Johnson hopes to achieve his objectives in Vietnam. Does this mean that one of them is wrong? Explain your answer.
Can this answer the question?
Right! Right!
No, none of them is wrong
Yes you can. But you must explain why both are right even though the views are different.
Disclaimer: This rarely occurs.