462 analysis of sharia compliance element in the film
TRANSCRIPT
462
ANALYSIS OF SHARIA COMPLIANCE ELEMENT IN THE FILM THE SONG OF
SPARROWS (2008)
Rosmawati Mohamad Rasit (Ph.D.)
Department of Da'wah & Leadership Studies, Faculty of Islamic Studies,
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Bangi
ABSTRACT
The production of films that elevate the sharia compliance is very much needed in the film
industry to achieve varieties of targeted da’wah. The films produced must adhere to the sharia
compliance criteria for upholding the da’wah amar ma’ruf nahi mungkar (enjoin good forbid
evil). Nonetheless, the sharia compliance element needs to be paralleled with the Film Theory
known as ar-Risalah. This study is to examine the plot of the story, and the characters in the
film to see the exsistence of the spirituality value. The study also aims to examine to what
extent does this sharia compliance elements in the film meets the ar-Risalah Theory of Film.
The study employs the qualitative content analysis and the Iranian film The Song of Sparrows
(2008) by Majid Majidi has been chosen as the sample. The assessment for the meaning of the
film and coding and category forms are used as the instruments. Whereas, as for the data
analysis, narrative and thematic analysis are used. The findings of the study shows that the film
The Song of Sparrows (2008) has a high spirituality value. Same goes to the elements of
morality, worship, belief and sharia also know as the basic elements that balance the perfection
of Islam. These elements have become the issues discussed in the film. These elements also
meet what has been discussed in the Theory of Film (ar-Risalah). Other than that, the approach
to the Islamiah da’wah has also become the important theme debated in the film The Song of
Sparrows (2008).
Keywords: Sharia Compliance, Element, Film, Approach of Islamiah Da’wah, Spirituality
INTRODUCTION
The role of films should be seen as the important contribution in bringing the community to a
more directed value of life through the ideas and messages from the films. Film carries a role
in highlighting responsibility values driven by the main objective on the issues discussed in
the film including how some matters are resolved so that audience can gain benefits from the
film (Hasliza, 2009). Thus, the discussion on the role of films has proven that films could
influence and give effects to the audience especially community from the message spread
through the films.
Take for example masterpieces of the most influential director from Iran Majid Majidi who
has produced films like Children of Heaven (1998), The Color of Paradise (2000) and The
Song of Sparrows (2008). Iranian cinema has gone far to talk about changes and evolution of
spiritual touch and religion in the films. These changes are felt by the audience around the
world especially after the Islamic Revolution (Sadr, 2006; Bahar, 2010; Soltani-Gordfaramarzi
463
& Kazemi, 2010) that has contributed a lot to the basic changes in the film production. This
adds to the production of more religion based of the Iranian films.
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
Films should be one of the main media resources for teenagers to learn about themselves.
Therefore, the content in the films needs some restructuring from the aspects of storyline,
theme, the use of Malay language (consistently), behavior and values, culture and more (Zalila,
2007). Hence, the production of films that elevate the sharia compliance is very much needed
in the film industry to achieve varieties of the targeted da’wah. The films produced must adhere
to the sharia compliance criteria for upholding the da’wah amar ma’ruf nahi mungkar (enjoin
good forbid evil). Referring to Naim (2010) the production of films is an obligation in Islam.
Nonetheless, this obliged job can be wrong (haram) when the contents are against the code of
ethics in Islam. On the other hand, if what we obliged to do are good and we comply, the job
will be categorized in the good works that we have done. These good works will continue to
receive rewards from Allah SWT as long as the films produced benefited others (Naim, 2010).
The study on sharia compliance in the films is still new especially in Malaysia compared to the
study on films from the social and cultural point of view. Thus this study is looking at the new
perspective that sees the needs of the sharia compliance to be connected directly to the aspects
of films.
Sharia Compliance
The influence of films could be seen either from the positive or the negative aspects towards
the audience. This statement is in line with what has been said by Abd. Aziz (2007):
“It’s time for us to produce more films that bring to the centre elements of Islam and
humanity so that we can balance up our life with the films that ‘have no soul’ shown to
the audience lately.”
Hence, this should become the interest to the film makers to take a look again at the issues
discussed in the film so that in the future films should be talking about maintaining the good
values of Malaysian community (Asiah, 2003). Asiah (2003) also was debating the factors that
influenced all these good and bad values in local films and the audience perceptions towards
it. According to Syed Zulkifli (2010), the films which are narrated in the way of sharia
compliance is making sense and can be very interesting for it to be the niche. Therefore, the
production of films with the sharia compliance based is seen as the important mechanism in
producing the real da’wah films.
Abu Hassan (2006) came up with the film theory known as ar-Risalah (Figure 1). ‘Risalah’ is
a tool or medium that spreads justice, humanity, honesty, holiness, piety and faith (Abu Hassan,
2006; Abu Hassan, 2000; Abu Hassan, 2011). In discussing films as ar-Risalah, Abu Hassan
(2006) relates theory with the plots in the Malay films.
Figure 1. Theoretical Framework of ar-Risalah
464
Adapted from Abu Hassan (2006)
This can be understood that films are some important pieces that carry along images and
civilization of the community. Therefore, the production of films does not only to fulfill the
entertainment objectives to the human beings but also to fulfill the responsiblity when they
watch it. Films and media need to come back to the basic creation of human beings. This is
because the media content is somehow acted as mobile infromation that possesses receiver and
sender functions. It also carries the responsiblity in placing the streghth in the world and
hereafter (Abu Hassan, 2011). This has been explained in details by Abu Hassan (2009) by
saying that Malay films cannot only act as a bunch of entertainment or some business
commodity because films also have roles to spread good messages (Hasliza, 2009).
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
The objectives of the research are as follows;
1. To study the story, plot and characters in elevating the spirituality
element in the film.
2. To study how far is the sharia compliance element in the film meet the
Theory of Film as-Risalah.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Design
This research employs the qualitative content analysis as its research design. Qualitative
content analysis is seen from the basis assumption of the traditional interpretive that seeks the
importance of what underlies the text and approach the texts as the meaning interpretation
subjectively. Kracauer (1952) compares this qualitative content analsysis as a method that
looks at the epistemology subjectively. To him the world out there can only be undertsood
from the perspective of a person who communicates with what is being researched.
Research Instruments
The content analysis form that includes film meaning evaluation form and theme and category
coding form are used as the instruments for this study. Researcher has developed the theme
and category based on the literature review as well as reading and some researcher’s
experiences about films reviews and critiques. The ideas in developing the theme and category
Films as ar-Risalah
Morality Worship Belief Sharia
To spread
the religion and good
moral values
465
have started earlier for the researcher to undertsand the whole journey of this research.
Researcher has referred to Merriam (2001) that talks about content analysis research design in
the form of sequence which begins from the developing theme and category, sampling,
collecting and data analysis and interpretation.
As for the film meaning evaluation form, researcher has listed eight important meanings to
obtain the basic picture about the researched film like title, director, producer, subject and plot,
characters, story telling (relevance, intensity effects and originality). Other than that, the
structure of the film (introduction, first point plot, conflict parts, second point plot and the final
part), dailogues and sub-texts. Morevoer, in the theme and category coding form, researcher
has put five important themes in each sample; displaying of morality, worhip, belief and sharia
as well as Islamic da’wah approach.
Qualitative Data Collection Method and Recording Procedure
The second phase of the research involves the data collection through the qualitative content
analysis. Othman (2009) said that data collection and analysis for the qualitative research are
normally moved together to develop coherent data interpretation. The data collection process
in the qualitative research could give opportunity to the researcher in obtaining data with these
characteristics (Barker 2003):
1. Data that are meaningful and important to the research subject
2. Unexpected and unplanned data
3. Deep data that can explain the researched issue
Mcnamara (2006) said that the qualitative content analysis is depending on the ‘reading’ of the
researcher himself in interpreting media texts. Nonetheless, intensive research and limited time
focus are among the factors that qualitative content analysis can only involve small samples
from the media content.
To run the qualitative content analysis in details, researcher referred to the process suggested
by Zhang & Wildemuth (2009) and Elo & Kyngas (2007). In this study, researcher is
depending on the collection of text data from the sample of the film as the main source of the
data. To obtain the data, all samples of films are watched and analysed by inserting the facts
into the content analysis forms- film meaning evaluation form and theme/category coding
form. The researched film was viewed at least twice to obtain text meaning data as stipulated
in the meaning coding form. The first viewing was done to get pictures and effects about the
whole film wherease the second phase of viewing and the rest was for the recording purposes.
Here the content of the film was analysed to tackle the problem statement and answer the
research questions of the study.
Furthermore, to make sure the meaning of the data was being recorded clearly, the data
collection process was done exactly after the watching ended. To obtain the most correct
meaning, the film needs to be viewed over and over again. The sample of the film is being
viewed and read for many times. The analysis of the data could only begin after all the
466
processes of data collection settled. In other words, researcher is held responsible to get good
creation of analysis via the processing and interpretation of the narrative data.
This study is depending on the text data analysis (audio and visual film) for the data entree.
The analsyis was done based on the chosen scene to examine the value aspect of religion and
moral. In using the narrative and thematic analysis, researcher did not only look at the
manifested elements (countable ones) but also the concealed elements sent by the film.
Data Analysis
In the researcher’s view, to analyse a film by using qualitative content analysis in studying the
element of meaning in the film is very much suitable. The narrative and thematic analysis are
used to analyse the text data from the film. The film narrative structure like the content of the
story and how the story is told and the plot are used to analyse the film. Other than that,
characteristics of the characters are also apart of the analysis.
FINDINGS
Story and Plot in The Song of Sparrows (2008)
The Song of Sparrows is about self conflicts and clashing of traditional values and religion to
the values of materialism and individualism. This film elevates the spirituality of life. It is all
about a father (Karim) who faced challenges in his work in order for him to raise his family (a
wife and three kids). The challenge happened when he was fired from his job after losing a
valuable ostrich. He also faced a difficulty when his daughter Hanieh’s earphone was faulty
and needs to be replaced as she is sitting for an exam. In searching for a job in Tehran City,
Karim has transformed himself to become someone who is materialistic. The incident of him
fell into a pile of used stuff has made him realized of himself and come back to Allah. This
film has given a very convincing effect to the audience when it tried to elevate the relationship
of the symbol of environment with humanity. The Songs of Sparrows is an easy narrative to
be digested and undertsood even though it has a very high spiritual value in each of its scene.
This film is very original. Animal symbols like gold fish and ostrich have become the moving
factors of the plot.
Characters and Characteristics in The Song of Sparrows (2008)
The main character Karim is the husband to Narjes and father to Hanieh, Hussien and Zahra.
He is a loving husband and responsibility father to the family. However, he is also someone
who is bad temper, egoistic, calculative and unwilling to accept people’s opinions. On the other
hand, Narjes is a loyal wife and caring mother. When Karim is ill, Narjes takes the
responsibility to go find food for the family. She is very dedicative in finding the money for
the family by selling vegetables with the help of Abbas, Karim’s cousin. All the three of their
children are having hearing problem. Hossein the only son is very ambitious and he wants to
be a millionaire by having a business of rearing fish with his friends. Zahra is Karim’s
youngest, soft and cute.
467
Category and Theme of the Film
Five categories were determined and they were the approach to Islamic da’wah (missionary),
display of morality, worship and solah, belief and sharia.
Approach to Islamic Da’wah
Dakwah bil-Hal
- The Song of Sparrows uplifts the approach to dakwah bil-Hal.
- Majid Majidi did not preach about da’wah and goodness in the film but he
portrayed it through modeling the action and behaviour from Karim’s charater.
Displaying of Islamic Morality
Giving out Salam (greetings)
- Karim likes to give out salam and greets his neighbour that he meets.
Respecting each other
- Narjes respects Karim so much as her husband even though at times Karim is
being calculative and stingy towards her.
- As children Hanieh, Hossein and Zahra also respect Karim.
- Karim respects all his neighbours. Everytime they meet each other Karim gives
salam and will have a small talk.
- Neighbours visit Karim when they know Karim is wounded.
Honesty
- Karim is honest when he manages to return the fridge which he was supposed
to send (although at first he wanted to have it for himself as he is need of using the
money)
- The motorcyclist returns Karim’s money to him.
Love
- Although Karim is a bad tempered person, he is loving and caring to his wife
and children.
o Karim is working so hard to repair Hanieh’s hearing aid and later he is
struggling to find money to replace the hearing aid.
o Karim ties Hanieh’s shoes laces when he is sending her to school.
o Karim likes to entertain his wife Narjes at they are at home.
o Karim washes his bike with his children.
o Karim allows the children to draw on his bandage when he was sick.
Generous
- Karim has good relationship with his friend Mash Rameezon - Mash Rameezon
gives him an ostrich egg after Karim lost his job.
468
- Karim is also generous in sharing the omelette of the ostrich egg with his
neighbours.
- Karim gives Mash Rameezon some money when he wants to go to Mecca and
returns to Afghanistan.
- When Karim is still wounded, Mash Rameezon visits him and brings him gift.
Displaying of Worship in Islam
Performing a solat (praying)
- A scene showing Karim is praying in fromt of a big house.
Donating
- Even only by having an intention of donating you have already been rewarded
– a scene where Karim is in the Tehran City during the red light, there is a girl
approaches him and asks him for some money. He wants to give the girl but he doesn’t
have small change. He asks around and later fails to give the money to the girl as the
light turn green. He has the intention and effort to give even he fails at the end.
Raising the Family Sincerely
- Karim is trying his best to raise his family in a halal way.
Duty of Charity
- The scene that portrays a fruit falls down from the motorcylce show that Karim
needs to pay his zakat (pays to the charity) to cleanse his assets.
Parenting Responsibility
- As a father, Karim is very responsible towards his family. He is struggling
looking for something to be eaten by his family.
Displaying of Belief in Islam
Believe in Allah
Performing a solah (praying) is a symbol of a Muslim in believing in Allah. This film portrays
praying as the key to the gain confidence and a belief of a Muslim to the creator, Allah SWT.
The Song of Sparrows (2008) shows the importance of praying to all Muslims.
- When Karim is praying in front of the big house, he could not concentrate and
focus to his praying because the owner of the house is in the car and cannot got into the
house because of Karim. They have to wait for Karim to finish praying. They do not
scold Karim instead they give Karim a glass of water.
Displaying of Sharia
Importance of Praying
- The scene where Karim is praying in front of the big house in the Tehran City.
469
Covering the Aurah (parts of body)
- Every character is portrayed as covering their aurah even if they are in the house
at night.
Intercommunication between Boys and Girls (with no relationship)
- This film takes care of the limitations in relationship between boys and girls.
There is no scenes of unnecessary touching and freedom of relationship although it is
the scene of husband and wife.
DISCUSSION
The findings of this study reveal that the film The Song of Sparrows (2008) contains high
spirituality value. The existence of humans and their relation with the environment brings
humans nearer to the Creator, Allah SWT. The effects of spiritual in this film have shown the
greatness of believing in Allah. Humans should always go back to Allah, the Almighty.
Same goes to the element of morality, worship, belief and sharia have become the main content
in the film. These four elements were also being debated as basic elements to complete the
perfection of Islam and have become the topic of discussion in the compliance sharia film.
This compliance sharia element has met what has been discussed in the Theory of Film known
as ar-Risalah. Other than that, the approach to Islamic da’wah is also the main main deliberated
in The Song of Sparrows (2008).
The religion value like performing solah (praying) has become the centre topic of discussion
in the film. The importance of solah (praying) is shown in many scenes. One of them is when
Karim is praying in front of a big house. It can also be seen that, from praying one person’s
character can be transformed to a better one. Furthermore, the aqidah (belief) concept portrayed
in the film has become the interpretation of faith and tawheed towards Allah. This is also shown
through Karim’s character who believes everything that happens to him is by Allah’s will.
Allah says in the Qu’ran;
“For a known extent. And We determined [it], and excellent [are We] to determine.”
(al-Mursalat: 22-23)
The study also found that Islamic morality portrayed through he language and image from the
film has put forward good examples of good moral which is in line with al-Ghazali’s (2000)
patience, honest,and forgiving. The film The Song of Sparrows (2008) is strong in its da’wah
concept that elevates the approach of da’wah bil-Hal. This means that Majid Majidi as the
director has managed to direct the concept through the action not only utterances of the
dialogue. This aspect is in line with what is being discussed through behaviourist model
(Bandura, 1969) and qudwah hasanah (Hasyimi, 2010). Moreover, the strength of the film lies
in its narrative sub-texts (what is being manifested in the film). The Song of Sparrows is rich
with its sub-texts and metaphors that used certain symbols to move the plot. For example the
dirty detention pond that has snake in it symbolises how dirty human’s soul can be the snake
is the devil in the humans. Hossein and his friends were trying their best to clean the pond to
470
have some fish in it. Which at the end of the story, the pond is clean and there is fish inside.
This change relates to how Karim’s life has changed to become someone who understands of
himself and others more.
The scene where Karim is searching for the lost ostrich can also be translated into how Karim
is searching for his real life that has lost which at the end he found it. The same thing happens
to the ostrich, it came back. The water in the film symbolises purifying. Water as one of the
nature elements acts as a tool to cleanse and purify human’s soul. When Karim is paid by the
pillion extra, he uses the money to buy two kilos of fruits. There is also a scene that shows the
fruits fell off from the plastic bag and went straight into the river. This scene is said to show
the purifying part. Allah has cleansed the fortune and luck that Karim brings home to the
family.
Therefore, other local film makers must take the initiative to elevate religious the film industry
in Malaysia by focusing more on the content of the film that portrays more of the real Islam.
This statement is being supported by Naim (2011: 70):
The narrative aspect brightens up the sleaze, exalts the Western philosophy and value,
secularism and hedonism which do not at all encourage the expansion, school of
thought of people’s mind. This does not suit the meaning of ‘Our Film is Our Face’,
‘Cultural Image of the Nation’ and ‘Religion Image of the Nation’ and anything that is
against the norms and culture. If his happens, the religion can be abandoned as the films
do not meet the real standard of Islam.
CONCLUSION
The findings of this study were derived from the narrative and thematic analysis that discussed
the concept of Islamic da’wah and sharia compliance element based on the Theory of Film
known as ar-Risalah. Thus, all local film makers must take the initiative to uplift the production
of religious films and pay more attention to the content of the film as such the film can portray
the real of Islam.
In conclusion, da’wah can be expanded in the form of story telling, drama and film by using
the media as the main communication to send out the message. Hence, if the people in the
community can maximise the chances through film as the medium of spreading the da’wah, it
can be shared with the audience. The production of da’wah films is highly needed in the local
film industry to meet the target of having varieties of da’wah films. These films must adhere
to the sharia compliance criteria to uphold the amar ma’ruf nahi mungkar (enjoin good forbid
evil).
Due to all of the above, there is a need to research on the films from the aspect of developing
Islam especially in buidling up sharia compliance films. The criteria in making the films can
act as the guidelines for the film makers and producers to move together to produce more
quality da’wah films in Malaysia.
References
471
Al-Quran al-Kareem.
Ab. Aziz Mohd Zain, Nor Raudah Siren, Yusmini Md Yusoff, Faridah Mohd Sairi dan Mohd
Anwarulhaq Sulaiman. (2006). Dakwah Islam di Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Penerbit
Universiti Malaya.
Ab. Aziz Mohd Zin. (1997). Metodologi dakwah. Kuala Lumpur: Penerbit Universiti Malaya.
Ab. Aziz Mohd Zin. (2005). Metodologi dakwah. Kuala Lumpur: Penerbit Universiti Malaya.
Abd. Aziz Itar. (2007). Perbanyakkan Filem Berunsur Keislaman. Utusan Malaysia, December
12.
Abu Hassan Hasbullah. (2006). Filem sebagai ar-Risalah-menemukan keimanan dan kebijakan
dramaturgi wayang gambar Melayu. Dramatic Writing Seminar, December 2-3.
Adam Salleh. (2008). Tandus Filem Agama. Harian Metro.April 20.
Al – Ghazali Abi Hamid Muhammed (2002). Ihya’ ulum al-din. [Revival the religion science].
Bayrut: Dar al-kutob al-c Iamiyah, (Vol. 3).
Al- Ghazali, Abi Hamid Muhammed. (2002). Ihya’ ulum al- din. [Revival the religion science].
Bayrut: Dar al-Hadith, (3 rd ed.), (Vol.2).
Al -Ghazali, M. (1994). Khulq al-Muslim [Muslim’s character] (11th ed.). Bayrut: Dar al-
Qalm li tibayah wa alNashir wa tawizyc . Al-Ghazali, M. (n.d.). Muslim’s character.
Sauddi Arabia: Dar al- Naduah al –Ac alamiyah li tibac ah wa alNashir wa tawizya.
Al-Sadr, M. B. (1982). Risalatu-na. Tehran: Maktaba al-Najah, 3rd ed.
Asiah Sarji. (2009). Malaysian Film Industry Development in the Context of Islam Hadhari.
In Komunikasi di Malaysia Suatu Penelitian Awal Pendekatan Islam Hadhari. edited
by Mohd Safar Hasim & Zulkiple Abd. Ghani. Bangi: Islam Hadhari Institute,
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. 193-218.
Bahar, Mehri. (2010). Religious identity and mass media: the situation of women in Iranian
cinema following the Islamic revolution. Journal Media and Communication Studies,
Baker, J. (2003). Early specialization in youth sport: A requirement for adult expertise? High
Ability Studies, 14, 18-94.
Bambang SM Said. 2005. Judicial criticism of comedy value. Screen Journal, 2(2), 83-91.
Barker, John & Weller, Susie (2003) "Is it fun?" Developing children centred research
methods. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 23(1/2), 33-58.
Elo, S. & Kyngas, H. (2008). The qualitative content analysis process. Journal of Advanced
Nursing, 62(1), pp. 107-115.
FINAS (The National Film Development Corporation Malaysia). 2011. Tayangan filem cereka
tempatan. http://www.finas.gov.my/index. php?mod=industry&sub=cereka (30 Mac
2011)
Flesher, V.M. Paul dan Torry, Robert. (1998). Teaching religion and film. The Journal of
Religion and Film. 2(3). http://www.unomaha.edu/jrf/Fleshart.htm (2 November 2010)
Fuziah Kartini Hassan Basri, Faridah Ibrahim and Mohd. Safar Hasim. 2009. Viewing Feature
Films in Malaysia: Behavior, tastes, perceptions and expectations. Ampang: FINAS.
Howell, Julia. (2008). Sufism on the silver screen Indonesia innovations in Islamic
televangelism. Journal of Indonesian Islam. 2(2): 225-239.
Ibn Hamid, Soleh bin Abdullah. (1999). Ma’alim fii Manhaj al-Dakwah. Jeddah: Dar
al-Andalus.
Idris, N. (2010). Reseacrh in Education. Malaysia: McGraw-Hill.
472
Javed Mohammed. (2010). Muslim cinema: an introduction. My Favorite Review.
http://www.myfavoritereview.com (1 September 2011).
Khatijah Mohamed Yatim. (2002). Malay da’wah film: the most extensive analysis of rhetoric.
Unpublished Project Paper. Universiti Malaya: Academy of Malay Studies.
Kozlovic, Anton Karl. (2005). Hollywood hermeneutics: a religion and film genre for the 21st
century. The Film Journal http://www.thefilmjournal.com/issue11/religion.html. (3
Mac 2011).Lindvall,
Kracauer, S. (1952). The challenge of qualitative content analysis. Public Opinion Quarterly,
16, 631-642.
Macnamara, J. (2003). Mass media effects: a review of 50 years of media effects research.
Retrieved July 30, 2004, from http://www.archipelagopress.com/jimmacnamara
Macnamara, J. (2005). Media content analysis: Its uses, benefits and Best Practice
Methodology. Asia Pacific Public Relations Journal, 6(1), 1– 34.
Matties, Gordon. (1998). Religion and Film: Capturing the Imagination. The Journal of
Religion and Film. 2(3). http://www.unomaha.edu/jrf/imagine.htm (2 November
2010).
Mehdi Soltani-Gordfaramarzi & Abbas Varidj Kazemi. (2010). Iranian Movies and Gender
display: a Study in Post Revolution Cinema. International Journal of Innovation,
Management and Technology, Vol. 1, No. 2, June 2010 ISSN: 2010-0248.
Merriam, S.B, & Simpson, E.L. (2000). Aguide to research for educators and trainers of adults.
(2nd ed.) Malabar, FL: Kreiger Publishing company.
Merriam, S.B. (1998). Qualitative research and case study applications in education. (2nd ed.)
San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
Mohd Hilmi Abdullah. (2010). Kenapa festival filem Islam menyepi? Utusan Online Bicara
Agama, January 17.http://www.utusan.com.my/utusan/info.
asp?y=2010&dt=0117&pub=Utusan_Malaysia&sec=Bicara_ Agama&pg=ba_01.htm
(4 April 2011).
Muhammad, R., Zahari, M.S.M., Othman, Z., Jamaluddin, M.R & Rashdi, M.O. (2009).
Modernization and ethnic Festival Food Paper presented at the international
Conference of Business and Economic, Kuching, Sarawak.
Naim Ahmad. (2010). Islamic film: a trial. Broadcasting Fiqh Workshop paper. Organized by
JAKIM, TV al-Hijrah & FDAM. ILIM, Bangi 20 June.
Najib al-Kilani. (2006). Drama about Islami. Mokhtar Hussain. (Terj.). Shah Alam: UPENA.
Nayar,
Neuman, W.L. (2006). Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantiative Approaches.
Toronto: Pearson.
Noraini Idris. (2010). Penyelidikan dalam pendidikan. Kuala Lumpur: McGraw Hill
(Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd.
Plate, S. Brent. (1998). Religion/, literature, film: toward a religious visuality of film.
Sadr, Hamid Reza. (2006). Iranian cinema a political history. London: I.B.Tauris & Co.Ltd.
Santana, Richard W. dan Erickson, Gregory. (2008). The gods of film:representing god and
Jesus at the movies. In Religion and popularculture rescripting the sacred. Santana,
Richard W. dan Erickson,Gregory. (eds). USA: McFarland and Company, Inc.
Sarji, A. (2003). The film and its impact on society in ensuring the preservation and enrichment
values of malaysian society. Malaysian Journal of Communication, 19, 1-21.
473
Sarji, A. (2009). The development of Malaysian film industry in context of Islam Hadhari
approach. In M. S. Hasim, & Z. Abd. Ghani (Eds.), Communication In Malaysia A
Preliminary Research on Islam Hadhari Approach (pp. 193-218). Bangi: Institut Islam
Hadhari, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.
Sheila J. (2010). Reconfiguring the ‘genuinely’ religious film: the oral contours of the
overabundant epic. Journal of the American Academy of Religion, Vol78, No.1: 100-
128. doi:10.1093/jaarel/lfp086Okuyade, Ogaga. 2011. Woman and evangelical
merchandising in the Nigerian filmic enterprise. Kemanusiaan, 18(1): 1-14.
Sohirin M. Solihin. (2008). Islamic Da’wah Theory And Practice. KualaLumpur: International
Islamic University Malaysia.
Soltani-Gordfaramarzi, Mehdi dan Kazemi, Abbas Varidj. (2010). Iranianmovies and gender
display: a study in post evolution cinema. International Journal of innovation,
Management and Technology, 1(2): 110-115.
Suhaina Hj. Mat Ludin. (2006). The effectiveness of preaching throughart entertainment music
and drama: a survey of psychological perspectives.Proceedings of the Regional
Seminar on Da'wah and Islamic Art , 35-47.
Terry. (2004). Religion and film part 1: History and criticism. A Quaterly Review of
Communication Research 23(4):1-44.
Teusner, Paul. (2002). Horror film and the construction of religious identityin contemporary
media culture. http://paulteusner.org/docs/paper. pdf (2 November 2010).
Zalila, I. (2007, December 5). Film and Malaysian Youth. Retrived from
http://www.yadim.com.my/
Zaydan, ‘Abd. Al-Karim. (1976). Usul al-Da’wah. t.tp.: Maktabah al-Manaral-Islamiyah.
Zhang, Y., & Wildemuth, B. (2009). Thematic content analysis. In B. Wildemuth (Ed.),
Applications of Social Research Methods to Questions in Information and Library
Science (pp.308-319). Westport, CT: Libraries Unlimited.
Zhang, Y., & Wildemuth, B. (2009). Unstructured interview. In B. Wildemuth (Ed.),
Applications of Social Research Methods to Questions in Information and Library
Science (pp.222-231). Westport, CT: Libraries Unlimited.