5. role of deposit insurance in bank failures...entries in this section focus on bank failures and...

24
5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES 5. Role of Deposit Insurance in Bank Failures Enties in this section focus on bank failues and the ole deposit insuance played in those failues: the undelying causes of bank cises, failed-bank esolution methods, bank closue ules, the costs of failed-bank esolutions, and histoical pespectives on the U.S. savings and loan debacle and the commecial bank cisis of the 1980s and ealy 1990s. *$/3&'( W++ S4( a"A'+ *4 -2&L+( "', 8"L%, D4 a@++$&:N4 566J4 a@A 8& !"'N/ >"%$c XL%,+':+ =2&< 3@+ 56Y`/4 @ID'2)%,#2$- #$ @&2$2<#& A#-,2)B 75( '&4 J;J`6H754 ?@%/ 0"0+2 +O"<%'+/ 3@+ :"./+/ &= 2.2"$ B"'N ="%$.2+/ ,.2%'# 3@+ 56Y`/ ./%'# " '+P$A :2+"3+, /3"3+[$+L+$ ,"3" /+2%+/4 !A =&:./%'# &' 2.2"$ B"'N/( 3@+ ".3@&2/ "2+ "B$+ 3& %'L+/3%#"3+ 3@+ %<0":3/ &= "#2%:.$3.2"$ ,%/32+// "', #&L+2'<+'3 0&$%:%+/ &' 3@+ :$"// &= B"'N/ "::&.'3%'# =&2 T` 0+2:+'3 &= 3@+ ="%$.2+/ %' 3@+ ,+:",+4 >"%$.2+ 2"3+/ P+2+ @%#@+/3 P@+2+ ="2< ":2+"#+ "', $"', L"$.+/ @", %':2+"/+, 3@+ <&/3 B+=&2+ 56Y` B+:"./+ 3@+/+ 2+#%&'/ /.==+2+, 3@+ P&2/3 "#2%:.$3.2"$ ,%/32+// /.B/+_.+'3$A4 *#2%:.$3.2"$ ,%/32+// :"./+, <&2+ B"'N ="%$.2+/ %' /3"3+/ P%3@ ,+0&/%3 %'/.2"':+ /A/3+</( /.##+/3%'# 3@"3 %'/.2"':+ +':&.2"#+, B"'N/ 3& %':2+"/+ 2%/N "/ 3@+%2 '+3 P&23@ ,+:$%'+,4 ]5666 X:&'W%3^ !"+2( F+2B+23( "', 8"'%+$" d$%'#+B%+$4 566V4 QA/3+<%: E%/N a@+' 8+0&/%3&2/ !+"2 W&//+/4 9' 5+-+%)&4 #$ "#$%$&#%' J+)E#&+-F C)#E%,+ %$3 C:0'#& C2'#&B( L&$4 G( +,%3+, BA -+&2#+ -4 d".=<"'( 56VH7`Y4 S*9 M2+//4 ?@+2+ %/ /.202%/%'#$A $%33$+ +L%,+':+ &' 3@+ <":2&+:&'&<%: +==+:3 &= %<0&/%'# $&//+/ &' ,+0&/%3&2/4 ?@%/ "23%:$+( ./%'# :"/+ /3.,%+/( 02+/+'3/ /&<+ +<0%2%:"$ +L%,+':+ &' 3@+ $%'N/ B+3P++' 3@+ 32+"3<+'3 &= ,+0&/%3&2/ &= %'/&$L+'3 %'/3%3.3%&'/ "', /.B/+_.+'3 <":2&+:&'&<%: 0+2=&2<"':+4 ?@+ =%L+ +0%/&,+/ /3.,%+, "2+ X/3&'%"( 566Yi *2#+'3%'"( 56T6i 1"$"A/%"( 56TIi S"0"'( 56JIi "', 3@+ K'%3+, Q3"3+/( 56774 !"23@( S"<+/ E4 56654 94+ K)+%, J%E#$=- %$3 /2%$ G+0%&'+O *<+2%:"' X'3+202%/+ 9'/3%3.3+4 8+/:2%B+/ 3@+ =":3/ %' 3@+ :"/+ &= 3@+ P%,+/02+", ="%$.2+ &= /"L%'#/ "', $&"' %'/3%3.3%&'/ ,.2%'# 3@+ 56T`/( "2#.%'# 3@"3 3@+ <"Z&2 B$"<+ 2+/3/ P%3@ #&L+2'<+'3\/ ="%$.2+ 3& 2+=&2< 3@+ P"A %' P@%:@ ,%/:%0$%'+ %/ %<0&/+, &' K4Q4 ,+0&/%3&2A %'/3%3.3%&'/4 D@2&'%:$+/ 3@+ #2&P3@ "', ,+L+$&0<+'3 &= /"L%'#/ "', $&"'/ =2&< 3@+%2 &2%#%' %' 5T75 3& 3@+ <&,+2' :2%/%/ A+"2/ B+#%''%'# %' 56T`4 8%/:.//+/ 3@+ +L+'3/ &= 3@+ 56T`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ivision of Research and Statistics 57

Upload: others

Post on 24-Feb-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    5. Role of Deposit Insurance in Bank Failures

    Ent ies in this section focus on bank failu es and the ole deposit insu ance played in those failu es: the unde lying causes of bank c ises, failed-bank esolution methods, bank closu e ules, the costs of failed-bank esolutions, and histo ical pe spectives on the U.S. savings and loan debacle and the comme cial bank c isis of the 1980s and ea ly 1990s.

    *$/3&'()W++)S4()a"A'+)*4)-2&L+()"',)8"L%,)D4)a@++$&:N4)566J4) )a@A)8&)!"'N/)>"%$c XL%,+':+)=2&"%$.2mailto:B$+)3&)%'L+/3%#"3+)3@+)%

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    @"R"2,) "2%/+/4) ) Q.##+/3/) $+//&'/) 3@"3) "00$A) 3&) "$$) =+,+2"$$A) %'/.2+,) ,+0&/%3&2A %'/3%3.3%&'/4))]�5666)X:&'W%3^

    !"23@()S"4)!"23@&$&

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    !"23@() S""%$.2+/) %') 3@+) K'%3+,) Q3"3+/4) ) 9'! C)+E+$,#$=! 7%$*! >)#-+-F! /+--2$-! 6)2

    !$"$&:N() S&/+0@)!4()?%+,+2"$) Q"L%'#/) "',) W&"') 9'/.2"':+) D&20&2"3%&') ]>QW9D^) =2&

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    !2&P'()E%:@"2,)*4()"',)Q+3@)X0/3+%'4) )566Y4) )E+/&$.3%&')D&/3/)"',)!"'N)>"%$.2+/;) )*' K0,"3+)&=)3@+)>89D)F%/3&2%:"$)W&//)1&,+$4))"GH>!7%$*#$=!5+E#+S)V()'&4)5;5H5I4

    ?@+)".3@&2/):&'/32.:3)")=%'"':%"$)+,+2"$)Q"L%'#/ "',) W&"') 9'/.2"':+) D&20&2"3%&'4) ) 8+/:2%B+/) 3@+) /.B/+_.+'3) ,+L+$&0+B2."2A)56TI4))]�5666)X:&'W%3^

    !.:N()D&,A4) )566Y4) )94+!;7>.-!26!"GH>F! !A2S!,2!J%E+![2:)!;--+,-! 6)2

    ?@+) ".3@&2() P@&) &':+) P&2N+,) "3) 3@+) >89D() +O0$"%'/) /&+B2."2A)56TI4))]�5666)X:&'W%3mailto:L&$L%'#)=+,+2"$$A)%'/.2+,),+0&/%3&2%+/)"',),+0&/%3)%'/.2"':+)3@"3)2+02+/+'3)3mailto:56T5)3@2&.#@)56TJ)"',)3@+):"./+/)&=)3@+)$&//+/)%

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    "//&:%"3+,) P%3@) P%,+/02+",) ,+0&/%3&2) 2.'/) "',) B"'N) /3&:N) 02%:+) ,+:$%'+/() 3@+ 0"'%:),%,)'&3)02&,.:+)/%#'%=%:"'3)/&:%"$):&/3/) %')3+22+,+2%:N)Q4()"',)WA'')*4)b+Z+R:@$+B4))566Y4))!"'N)>"%$.2+)E+/&$.3%&'()3@+)D&/3

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    "/) 3@+) 0+2:+'3"#+) &=) ,+0&/%3/) "3) =+,+2"$$A) %'/.2+,) B"'N/) 3@"3) P"/) :&L+2+,) BA =+,+2"$),+0&/%3)%'/.2"':+4))?@+)%'/32.

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    P%$$)B+)"L"%$"B$+) %') 3@+)'+"2) =.3.2+4) )!A) 2+,.:%'#) 3@+)0"A&==)+O3+2'"$%3A(),+0&/%3 %'/.2"':+):"')%',.:+),+0&/%3&2/)3&)./+)3@+%2)%'=&2"%$.2+/) ?@"') E+#.$"3+, !"'N%'#c))>%,2!?2:)$%')5I()'&4)5;JGHIY4

    ?@%/)"23%:$+)+%'"':+ "',)X:&'&

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    D&$+()E+B+$)*4()"',)E&B+23)*4)X%/+'B+%/4))566I4))?@+)E&$+)&=)M2%':%0"$H*#+'3)D&'=$%:3/ %')3@+)56T`/)?@2%=3)D2%/%/4))5+%'!@-,%,+!@&2$2+,+2"$) E+/+2L+) W+',%'#) 3& !"'N/) ?@"3) >"%$+,;) ) 94)D&332+$$()1%:@"+$)Q4)W"P$&2()"',)S&@')F4)a&&,4

    D&P"'() D@"2$+/) 84) ) 566G4) ) Q3"3%/3%:"$) Q"

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    ":@%+L+/) /%#'%=%:"'3):&/3) /"L%'#/)P@%$+)+'/.2%'#) 3@+) "::.2":A)"',)_."$%3A)&=) 3@+ 2+/.$3/4

    8+0&/%3)9'/.2"':+)"',)K4Q4)!"'N)>"%$.2+/4))566J4))H$,+)$%,#2$%'!>:))+$&B!5+E#+S)Y5()'& 5HY;7`HJG()VJ4

    ?@%/)"23%:$+),2"P/)=2&

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    >+,+2"$)8+0&/%3)9'/.2"':+)D&20&2"3%&')]>89D^4))566T"4))?@+)!"'N%'#)D2%/+/)&=)3@+)56T`/ "',)X"2$A)566`/;))Q.89D)%')*02%$)566T()P@%:@) =+"3.2+,),%/:.//%&'/)&=) 3@+) /32"3+#%+/)./+,) 3& $%_.%,"3+)3@+)5(I5G)B"'N/)"',)5(Y6V)3@2%=3/)3@"3)="%$+,),.2%'#)3@+)0+2%&,4))]�5666 X:&'W%3^

    >+,+2"$) 8+0&/%3) 9'/.2"':+) D&20&2"3%&') ]>89D^4) ) 566T:4) ) 5+-2':,#2$-! A%$3022*F (+,423-!62)!5+-2'E#$=!9)2:0'+3!"#$%$%'!H$-,#,:,#2$-!#$!,4+!V$#,+3!J,%,+-4))>89D4

    ?@%/)@"',B&&N),+3"%$/)3@+)02&:+//+/)"L"%$"B$+)3&)3@+)>89D)=&2)2+/&$L%'#)02&B$+< B"'N/)"',)/"L%'#/)%'/3%3.3%&'/4

    -"2:%"() -%$$%"'4) ) 566V4) ) 989D9*^():$&/.2+)%/)

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    "',) 3@+) ",

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    >+$,)%'! 7%$*! %$3! ,4+! "#$%$%'! JB-,+%)E+3!#$!J%$3F!!;!5+D2),!2$!,4+!>2''%D-+!26!,4+!5423+!H-'%$3 J4%)+!%$3!G+D2-#,!H$3+2)D2)%,#2$4))Y)L&$/4))Q3"3+)&=)E@&,+)9/$"',4

    ?@%/)2+0&23)+$"B&2"3+/)&')3@+)=&$$&P%'#)2+"/&'/)=&2)3@+)="%$.2+)&=)3@+)E@&,+)9/$"', Q@"2+)"',)8+0&/%3)9',+"%$.2+) E+/&$.3%&') %') 3@+) K4Q4 ?@2%=3)"',)!"'N%'#)9',./32%+/O!!"#$%$%'!(%$%=+

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    2+#.$"3&2A) /3.,%+/) &') 3@+) :"./+/) &=) 3@+) :2%/%/() 3@+) :&/3/) &=) ,%==+2+'3) 2+#.$"3&2A /32"3+#%+/)./+,)3&):&%'"$$A() 3@+)".3@&2)#%L+/)@%/) 3@&.#@3/)&') 3@+)02&/0+:3/)&=) 3@+)B"'N%'#)"',) 3@2%=3 %',./32%+/4

    F&$$"',()8"L%,)Q4) )566T4) )T4+$!5+=:'%,#2$!T%-!922!J:&&+--6:'^94+!J#I,4!G+&%3+!26 G+D2-#,!H$-:)%$&+F!!;!A#-,2)B!26!,4+!9)2:0'+-!26!,4+!VOJO!7%$*#$=!H$3:-,)B!#$!,4+!_M`N-%$3!@%)'B!_MMN-O))M2"+#+24

    ?@%/)B&&N)+O"

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    0+2:+'3)&=)3@+)="%$+,)B"'N\/)"//+3/4))*')"'"$A/%/)&=)3@+),+3+2QW9D)"',)"'"$AR+/)/&:%"$$A)0+2L+2/+)%':+'3%L+/ :&'=2&'3%'#) 3@2%=3) 2+#.$"3&2/4) ) ) M2+/+'3/) 3P&) :"/+) /3.,%+/) &=) 3@+) QW9D) =&2B+"2"':+) ,.2%'#) 56TV[56T64) ) *$3@&.#@) 3@+ &00&23.'%3A):&/3)&=),+$"A),%,)'&3)%':2+"/+)+L+2A)A+"2()%3),%,)%':2+"/+)&')"L+2"#+4 F",) &00&23.'%3A[:&/3) /3"',"2,/) &=) :"0%3"$) ",+_.":A) B++') 2&.3%'+$A) +'=&2:+,( >QW9D)#."2"'3++/)P&.$,)'&3)@"L+),%/0$":+,)02%L"3+):"0%3"$)&')")&2B+"2"':+)*,,)3mailto:0&$%3%:%"'/)"$$&P+,)"::&.'3%'#)#%89D

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    d"'+() X,P"2,) S4() "',) 1%') ?+@) m.4) ) 566V4) ) 1+"/.2%'#) 3@+) ?2.+) M2&=%$+) &=) ?"O0"A+2 W&//+/)%')3@+)QkW)9'/.2"':+)1+//4))?2:)$%'!26!7%$*#$=!%$3!"#$%$&+!56()'&4)T;5JV6HGG4

    ?@%/)2+/+"2:@)/@&P/)3@"3):&'/+2L"3%L+)

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    3%"%$+,[!"'Nmailto:D&20&2"3%&')]E?D^)%')32A%'#)3&)/+$$)"//+3/)P%3@&.3)Eka/4))?@+A)"$/&)"'"$AR+)3mailto:2+)

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    b+.B+2#+2()S&'"3@"')*4))566`4))F&P)3&)D$&/+)?2&.B$+,)!"'N/4))>+,+2"$)E+/+2L+)!"'N)&= Q"')>2"':%/:&!T++*'B!/+,,+))]8+:+!7%$*#$=!5+E#+S)7()'&4)Y;5H7J4

    ?@%/) "'"$A/%/) /++N/) 3&) +O0$"%') 3@+) @%#@) ="%$.2+) 2"3+/) ""%$.2+)&=)>%'"':%"$)9'/3%3.3%&'/)3@2&.#@)E+=&2%'"':%"$)9'/3%3.3%&'/)3@2&.#@)E+=&2mailto:2+2/)&=)'&'="%$+,)B"'N/4))!&3@)#2&.0/)&=)":_.%2+2/)P+2+)"B$+)3&)%

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    /%R+) +==+:3/4) ) K'$%N+) S"

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    Q"$3R() 92"4) ) 566GB4) ) >+,+2"$) 8+0&/%3) 9'/.2"':+) D&L+2"#+) "',) !"'N) >"%$.2+/;) ) * D&%'3+#2"3%&') *'"$A/%/) P%3@) Q+89DUC^() 3@+) 3"'#%B$+) :"0%3"$l"//+3 2"3%&() 3@+) :&

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    D&20) "',) 3@+) +L+'3/) $+",%'#) .0) 3&) 3@+) 1"2:@) :$&/%'#) "2+) $%N+$A) 3&) @"L+) " /%#'%=%:"'3) +==+:3) &') @&P) =.3.2+) ="%$.2+/) "2+)

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    K4Q4)D&'#2+//%&'"$)!.,#+3)U==%:+)]D!U^4))566J4))?@+)D@"'#%'#)!./%'+//)&=)!"'N%'#;))* Q3.,A)&=)>"%$+,)!"'N/)=2&89D)3&):"$:.$"3+ "',),&:.89D) %'"':+)"',)K2B"')*=="%2/4) )94+!7%$*!26 R+S!@$='%$3!"%#':)+!%$3!5+-2':,#2$F!!A+%)#$=4))5`Y,)D&'#4()5/3)/+//4()1"A)YJ)"',)YV4

    ?@%/)/3.,A)&=) 3@+)="%$.2+)&=) 3@+)!"'N)&=)b+P)X'#$"',)%')S"'."2A)5665)%',%:"3+/ 3@"3) B"'N) ./"2&()?+22"':+)1:d+''"()*'3@&'A)S4)Q&$&4)d+22A() S&@')S&/+0@)1&"N$+A()!2.:+)!&$$%'#()E"A$Amailto:2")E4)>./"2&()?+22"':+)1:d+''"()*'3@&'A)S4)Q&$&89D9*)P%$$)@+$0):&'32&$)=.3.2+)="%$.2+/)&=)3@%/)3A0+()/%':+)3@+)":3mailto:3.,A)&=)3@+)="%$.2+)&=)3@+)!"'N)&=)b+P)X'#$"',)%')S"'."2A)5665)%',%:"3mailto:2+_.%2+89D9*4))Q+:3%&')57]:^]J^)2+_.%2+/)3@+)>89D)3&):"$:.$"3mailto:2+0&23)02+/+'3/)3@+)2+/.$3/)&=)3mailto:2+_.+':A)P%3@)P@%:@)3@+)+/3%

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    K4Q4)F&./+4))5665:4))D&$&2") >./"2&() ?+22"':+ 1:d+''"() *'3@&'A)Q&$&"%$.2+/;))b+P)XL%,+':+)=2mailto:a%$$%"

  • 5. ROLE OF DEPOSIT INSURANCE IN BANK FAILURES

    a@++$&:N() 8"L%,) D4() "',) Q.B"$) D4) d.

  • DEPOSIT INSURANCE: AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY, 1989–1999

    &=) 3@+)!&"2,) %'),%/0&/%'#)&=) %'/&$L+'3) 3@2%=3/()+/0+:%"$$A) %')56TT4) )8%/:.//+/) 3@+ :$+"'.0) $+#%/$"3%&') &=) 56T6() "',) +O"%2/3[3%+,+2"$)8+0&/%3)9'/.2"':+)D&20&2"3mailto:2+"/+,):&