document

1
928 Book reviews inoculation of himself to study Bartonella orga- nisms is another chapter of special interest to dermatologists. Other chapters deal with such topics as cardiac catherization, anesthesia, dietary manipulation, rabies vaccination, and many equal- ly interesting problems. All are well written and heavily documented, and aid to those who seek further details. My only disagreement with Dr. Altman is a minor one. At every turn, he seems vitally con- cerned about the ethics of self-experimentation. Although there certainly have been physicians who did great harm to themselves in the interest of research, think what the alternatives might have been. To me, the moral issue is simpler: if a researcher is determined to try something new in a human subject, who can be a more appropriate subject than the researcher? In any event, no one can accuse Dr. Altman of endorsing self-experi- mentation, because he cautiously presents both sides of every story. If you have a chance, read this book You'll find it a welcome change from most daily medical reading. Walter H C. Burgdorf, MD., Albuquerque, NM The tradition of excellence. Dermatology at the University of Pennsylvania 1870-1985 Herman Beerman, M.D., and Gerald Sylvan Laz- arus, M.D. Philadelphia, 1986, University of Penn- sylvania. 274 pages. $49. This encyclopedic review details the founding and development of the department of dermatology Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology at the University of Pennsylvania and presents an account of the accomplishments of the persons associated with it. The accomplishments are mani- fold, as anyone with the slightest acquaintance with the specialty will readily acknowledge. Beginning with Louis Duhring and continuing through Ste1- wagon, Hartzell, John Stokes, Herman Beerman, Donald Pillsbury, and Walter Shelley and right up to the present day, faculty and graduates of the University of Pennsylvania department have been prominent participants in every scientific and edu- cational advance in the world of skin diseases. Organizational problems are inseparable from works of this literary genre, in which historical, biographic, statistical, and philosophic frames of reference compete with one another. The result here, as always, is a reference work, a source book for fact hunters that cannot easily be read straight through. And yet at the same time this example is a browser's delight. The often witty, candid, and amusing reminiscences featured here and submit- ted by dozens of alumni, many of whom have become influential figures on the dermatologic scene in their own right, are particularly reward- ing. Those of us who trained at Penn will scarcely need any urging to acquire a copy, but the book is better than that. Because of the significance of the contributions and the caliber of the men described in its pages, the work belongs in the library of anyone interested in the history of the specialty. John Thorne Crissey, MD., Pasadena, CA

Upload: john-thorne

Post on 28-Dec-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: document

928 Book reviews

inoculation of himself to study Bartonella orga­nisms is another chapter of special interest todermatologists. Other chapters deal with suchtopics as cardiac catherization, anesthesia, dietarymanipulation, rabies vaccination, and many equal­ly interesting problems. All are well written andheavily documented, and aid to those who seekfurther details.

My only disagreement with Dr. Altman is aminor one. At every turn, he seems vitally con­cerned about the ethics of self-experimentation.Although there certainly have been physicians whodid great harm to themselves in the interest ofresearch, think what the alternatives might havebeen. To me, the moral issue is simpler: if aresearcher is determined to try something new in ahuman subject, who can be a more appropriatesubject than the researcher? In any event, no onecan accuse Dr. Altman of endorsing self-experi­mentation, because he cautiously presents bothsides of every story. If you have a chance, read thisbook You'll find it a welcome change from mostdaily medical reading.

Walter H C. Burgdorf, MD., Albuquerque, NM

The tradition of excellence. Dermatology atthe University of Pennsylvania 1870-1985Herman Beerman, M.D., and Gerald Sylvan Laz­arus, M.D. Philadelphia, 1986, University of Penn­sylvania. 274 pages. $49.

This encyclopedic review details the foundingand development of the department of dermatology

Journal of theAmerican Academy of

Dermatology

at the University of Pennsylvania and presents anaccount of the accomplishments of the personsassociated with it. The accomplishments are mani­fold, as anyonewith the slightestacquaintance withthe specialty will readily acknowledge. Beginningwith Louis Duhring and continuing through Ste1­wagon, Hartzell, John Stokes, Herman Beerman,Donald Pillsbury, and Walter Shelley and right upto the present day, faculty and graduates of theUniversity of Pennsylvania department have beenprominent participants in every scientific and edu­cational advance in the world of skin diseases.

Organizational problems are inseparable fromworks of this literary genre, in which historical,biographic, statistical, and philosophic frames ofreference compete with one another. The resulthere, as always, is a reference work, a source bookfor fact hunters that cannot easily be read straightthrough.And yet at the same time this example is abrowser's delight. The often witty, candid, andamusing reminiscences featured here and submit­ted by dozens of alumni, many of whom havebecome influential figures on the dermatologicscene in their own right, are particularly reward­ing.

Those of us who trained at Penn will scarcelyneed any urging to acquire a copy, but the book isbetter than that. Because of the significance of thecontributions and the caliber of the men describedin its pages, the work belongs in the library ofanyone interested in the history of the specialty.

John Thorne Crissey, MD., Pasadena, CA