5g for personalized health and ambient assisted living › en › eemcs › bss › documents ›...
TRANSCRIPT
5Gforpersonalizedhealthandambientassistedliving
prof.drir.HermieJ.HermensUniversityofTwenteEnschedetheNetherlandsRoessinghResearchandDevelopment,Enschede,theNetherlands
IntroductionThereisanincreasingawarenessthathealthcareinthewesterncountriescannotbecontinuedinthewayithasdevelopedinthepast;Itisjustnotsustainableduetotheincreasingdemandforvolumeofcare,limitstotheamountofqualifiedpeopletoworkincareandlimitstotheamountofmoneywecanspendonhealthcare.Amaintrendthatiscontributingtothisneedforchange,istheincreasedlifeexpectancyofourwesternsociety.Astheyearsthatareadded,comewithlongerperiodoftimeinwhichwehavetocopewithchronicconditions,thevolumeofrequiredhealthcareservicesisrapidlyrising.Thisincreaseinvolumeofcareneededcannotbemetwithaproportionalincreaseinprofessionalpersonnelandmoney.Thereisastrongbeliefthattechnology,especiallyinformationandcommunicationtechnologycanmakeasignificantcontributiontomakecaremoresustainable,bysupportingpeopleintheirwishforindependentlivingandincreaseofselfmanagementcapabilities.Areasthatareespeciallyrelevantinthiscontextare:
- Unobtrusivemonitoringofhealthrelatedconditionsandbehavior- Homebasedinterventions.Enablingpeopletodotherapylikephysical
andcognitivetrainingathome,remotelysupervised- PersonalisedHealthSystemsthatprovidepeopleinreal-time
personalizedadvicesabouttheirhealth,basedonmultimodalsensing- Caringhomes,supportiveenvironmentthatintuitivelyfeelstheneedsof
itsuserandisabletoreactproperlyTheseareasarecomingupfastduetorapiddevelopmentsinsensingtechnology,artificialintelligenceandimprovedcommunicationinfrastructures[7].Inthischapter,Iwouldliketodescribesomerecentdevelopmentsintheseareasofhealthcaresupportingtechnology,bothfromatechnicalandfunctionalpointofviewandthen,basedonthepresentdevelopmentstrytoimaginehow5Gwillsupportand/oracceleratethese.
Technologytosupportpersonalizedhealthandambientassistedliving
2.1exercisingathomeWhenpatientsareabletodotheirtrainingathome,thiswouldhavegreatbenefitsforallstakeholders.Patientscandotheirtrainingwhereandwhattimetheywant,notbeingobligedtogoe.g.threetimesaweektoaphysicaltherapy
practiceorarehabilitationcentre[8].Ifitispartlyreplacingtheintramuraltherapysessions,itisalsobecomingmorecosteffectiveandenlargingthecapacityofintramuralcare.Ifitisusedasanextensionofintramuralrehabilitation,itwillhelpindecreasingthefallbackofcapacitiesinthehomesituation.
Figure1.Exampleofapatientplatform,supportingwebbasedexercising,videoteleconsultation,selfmanagementandactivitycoaching(ContinuousCareandCoachingPlatform,RRD)IntheECprojectClear,intheperiod2011-2013,1000patientsin4Europeancountrieswereusingasystemthatwasabletodelivervideosofexercises,anexercisescheme,remotesupervisionandteleconsultationservices.Intheextensivehealthtechnologyassessmentitwasshownthatthisremotelysupervisedtreatmentwascosteffectiveandefficientwhenappliedaspartialreplacementoftheregularintramuraltherapy.Moreover,itwasshownthatthepatients,whoexercisedmore,improvedmore.Thisunderlinesthatthepatientisinthedriverseatandisabletotakecontrol.Theadvantageofthisapproachisthatitisfullywebbased,makingitindependentofplaceandtimeandrelativelylow-tech,meaningthatyouonlyneedapcorasimilardevicetogettheserviceworking.Assuch,itisagoodfirststeptointroducethiskindoftechnologyindailyhealthcare.Anextstepinthetrainingathomeinvolvesmuchmorecomplexsystemsinvolvinggamestomaketheexercisesmoreenjoyableandpersuasive,combinedwithpassiveoractiveroboticsupportsystemstocorrectthemovementand/orsupportthepatientsincarryingoutthedesiredmovementwhenmuscleforceisstillnotsufficient.Anexampleofsuchacombinedsystem,istheScriptsystem[1],developedintheEuropeanScriptproject,targetingupperextremitytrainingforstrokepatients.Itinvolvesanarm/handsupportsystemthatallowspersonaladjustmentoftheamountofsupport,sensorstocontrolthegameandanumber
Selfmanagement
Webbasedexercising
Self-management Ac5vitycoaching
WebbasedexercisingTele-consulta5on
ofgamesthatvaryindifficultyandadecisionsupportsystemthatrecommendsindividualgamesettingandachoiceofthegames.
Figure2.Upperextremityexercisesystemincludingroboticsupportforthehandfunctioning,gravitycompensationandindividuallytailoredvideogames(Scriptproject.eu)Withrespecttorequiredbandwidth,andtechnicalcomplexity,systemslikeScriptaremuchmoredemanding.Optimally,onewouldallowexperiencedclinicianstolookattheperformanceofthepatientexercisingremotely,butalsohavereal-timecontroloftheroboticdeviceaswellasthevirtualworldwherethepatientisexperiencing.TheevaluationstudiesoftheScriptsystemshowthatsuchsystemsarepromisingwithrespecttoindependentandmotivatingexercisingathome,butstillratherfragile.
2.2MovementanalysisandmonitoringMovementanalysisisanimportantstepinthefunctionaldiagnosisinrehabilitation.Itfocusesonquantificationofthemovementpatternandtoinvestigatetheunderlyingdeviationsinneuromuscularcontrolandthecompensationmechanismsthatoccur.Gaitanalysishasbeenrestrictedtolaboratories,wheregaitwasquantifiedusingoptical,markerbasedsystems.Reflectingmarkersareplacedatspecificplacesonthebodyandassessedusingvideocamerasplacedaroundthesubjectthatpulsewithinfraredlightstoobtainathreedimensionalimage.Off-linetheseimagesarethencombinedwithathree-dimensionalmodelandforceplatesto
6
calculatejointforces.Inthepastyears,thisisbeingseenmoreandmoreasaso-calledcapacitymeasurementasthelaboratorysituationisaratherperfectenvironmentwithaverycleancontext,wherethepatientcanbetotallyfocusedonthetaskathand.Aneedhasarisentobeabletohavequantitativemovementdatafromrealisticsituations,likeathome.Inthepastyearsthishasbeenenabledbyrapiddevelopmentofinertialsensortechnologyandprocessingalgorithmstogeneratethemovementsfromthedata.ArecentexampleofprogressmadeinthisareaconcernstheInteractionproject.
Figure3.ThedifferentcomponentsoftheInteractionmonitoringsystem(https://www.xsens.com/news/interaction-project/)Hereacompletemovementrecordingandanalysissystemhasbeendevelopedwithmotionsensorsembeddedinsmarttextiles,abletomonitortheactivitiesofapersoninhisownenvironment.Itinvolvesdifferentmodalitiesofsensinglikeinertialsensorstodetectpostureandmovements,surfaceEMGsensorstomeasuremuscleactivationpatternsand3Dforcemeasurementunderthefoot.Thesystemispresentlybeingappliedinstrokepatientstomonitorhowtheyusetheirmovementcapacitiesindailylife,afteraperiodofrehabilitation.Theresponsesfrombothpatientsandcliniciansareingeneralverypositive,underliningthatthesekindofunobtrusivemonitoringsystemshavegreatpromiseforfutureintegratedcare.
2.3PersonalcoachingsystemsTheamountofpeoplewithchronicconditionsisrapidlygrowingespeciallybecausewelivesubstantiallylongerbutthisextensionofourlivesisunfortunatelygoinghandinhandwithdealingwithchronicconditionsthataffectourqualityoflife.Chronicconditionscannotbecuredbutithasbeenshowninmanystudiesthatqualityoflifeandtheoccurrenceofco-morbiditiesisstronglyrelatedtotheextendwebehavehealthy,intermsofphysicalactivity,
Legenda:
EMGsensor
CEstrain
CEGoniometer
Xsens/Xsens+UDP Interface/
Xsens+EMG interface
healthyfoodandavoidanceofstress.We,humanarenotgoodinchangingourbehavior,properandintensivecoachingisessential.Aswedonothavetheabilitytodothiswithpersons,theideawasborntodothiswithtechnicalsystemsusingonbodyandcontextsensing,smartcontextawarereasoninganduser-friendly,persuasiveinteraction[6].TheconceptofsuchPersonalCoachingSystem(PCS)isshowninfigure4.
Figure4.SchematicpresentationofanartificialPersonalcoachingSystem,involvingon-bodysensing,contextawarereasoningandpersuasivefeedback.SeveralPCShavebeenrealizedinthepastyears.Figure5showssomeexamplesofpastandon-goingwork.ProbablythefirstPCSwasasystemtotreatneck/shoulderpainduringactivitiesofdailyliving[13,14].ItinvolvedmeasurementofthemuscleactivityintheTrapeziusmuscles,wellknowntobesensitiveforstressandpain,processingthesignalintermsofamountofrelaxationandgivingpersonalfeedbackviavibrationtowarnthesubjectwhenthereisnotsufficientrelaxation.ThissystemwassuccessfullyevaluatedinaEuropeantrial,showingthesystemcanbeappliedinneck/shoulderpainpatients,withoutaffectingtheiractivitiesofdailyliving[9,12].Asecondsystemisasmartactivitycoach,developedtocoachpeoplewithchronicconditionstowardsamorehealthyactivitypatternthroughtheday.Thisoftenconcernsahigherlevelofactivitybutalsoinmanycasesbetterbalancingtheamountofactivityovertheday,toavoidatooearlyexhaustion.Itmeasurestheamountofactivityduringtheday,usinga3Dinertialsensor.Thismeasurementiscontinuouslycomparedwithadesiredactivitypatternandbasedontheresultitprovidesencouraging,discouragingorneutralmessages.Boththecontentandtimingofthemessagesaredynamicallypersonalized,usingamodelwhichtakesintoaccountmanyactivityvariablesandcontextinformation[2,3].Thesystemisundercontinuousdevelopmentbutinparallel,ithasbeensuccessfullyappliedinover100patientswithdifferentchronicconditions,likechronicpainandCOPD[10,11].Thethirdexampleisastressmanagementsystem[15,16].Stressappearstobeacomplex,notwell-definedphenomenon.Peoplealsorespondindifferentwaysto
The future coach
Model based reasoning & Interactive learning
Context aware Feedback via various devices
Context information
Self learning from responses
Wearable sensors
stress,whichmakesthatforaPCSapersonalsetofsensorsarerequiredandapersonalizedmodelthatisabletoweightthedifferentinputsintooneestimateofstress.Experimentalstudiesinthelabshowthatthisapproachisfeasible.Experimentsinfree-livingconditionsshowthatagreatamountofcontextinformationhastobetakenintoaccounttoprovideagoodreal-timestressestimateandtoenableaproperinterpretation.
Figure5.ThreeexamplesofPersonalCoachingsystems,thatusesensorandcontextinformationtoreasonaboutahealthconditioninordertoprovidepersonalizedandpersuasivefeedback.
2.4Thecaringhome;supportivehomeenvironmentsInordertoenablepeopletoliveaslongaspossibleintheirownenvironment,thereisaneedforintelligentsupportsystems.Ideally,thesystemshould“feel”theneedsoftheuserintuitivelyandabletoreactwhenrequired.Inadditionitisimportantthatthesystemispersonalizedandabletoofferawiderangeofservicesintheareaofhealth,well-beingandcomfort.Presently,manyprojectsaregoingoninthisareadealingwithseveralsubgoalsinthecontextofthecaringhome.ForexampleProjectsthataimtodeterminethebehaviorofthepersonusingdifferentmodalitiesofsensing.KeytargetpopulationhereispeoplewithMCIordementiaasthereisagreatandrapidlygrowingneedtosupervisethemaslongastheyliveintheirownhouses.AgoodexampleofanoverallapproachtothischallengeistheeWallproject.TheconceptofeWallistoofferservicesinauser-friendlywayusingalargeinteractivescreen,runinabrowserandsupportedbyanextensivecloudserviceinfrastructure.Thewaytheservicesarepresentedisinnovativebyusinga50’shomeroomenvironment.Itoffersapersonalizedsetofservicesincludinghealthserviceslikeanactivitycoach,videobasedexercising,asleepqualificationsystemandapersonalizedguidancethroughtheday.
Personalcoachingsystems
Flickr-Kaptain Kobold
Rest Rest Rest Rest RestStress Stress Stress
Time (s)
Estim
ated
st
ress
leve
l
0 500 1000 1500 20000
5
10
Rest Rest Rest Rest RestStress Stress Stress
Prob
abilit
y of
bein
g st
ress
ed
0
0.5
1
Neck/shoulder pain Coach
Physical activity Coach
Stress management Coach
Figure6.Anintegratedcaringhomeenvironment,offeringhealth,wellnessandsafetyservicestopeoplewithchronicconditions(http://ewallproject.eu/)Integratedapproaches,likeeWall,requireconsiderablebandwidthfortheseservicesasthereislotofsensing,real-timedataprocessingandhumancomputerinteractionwithanimations.Itisgenerallyexpectedthatsuchapproachwithanintegrationofservicesandusingacloud-basedinfrastructurewillbecomecommonsoon.
Opportunitiesdueto5GOverlookingthedescribedupcomingareasthatwillhaveimpactonthehealthcare,especiallythecareforpeoplewithchronicconditions,ontheonhandandtryingtounderstandandforecastthecontribution5Gcanhavetotheseareas,onecouldmakethefollowingpredictions.
MovementanalysisandmonitoringFormonitoringpurposes,especiallyintheareaoftheanalysisoffunctionalmovements,moreandmorerathercomplexmultimodalsensorsareused,likecombinationsofgyroscopes,accelerometers,magnetometersandultrasoundtogetacomplete3Dpictureofthesubjectandhismovements.WhenthesearecombinedwithEMGmeasurementsofseveralmuscles,aconsiderablebandwidthisrequired.5Gwouldallowsuchsimultaneousmeasurementsinafreeconditionoutsidethelab.Andprobablyalsobeyondthepresentsetofmeasurements,likeadditionofEEGtoassessmotorcontrolandmoodinreal-timewouldbecomepossible,makingaholisticmonitoringofallrelevanthealthandbehaviouraspectspossible.Attheotherside,theviewingofallthesesensordatainanunderstandableandcomprehensiveway,isaconsiderablechallenge,especiallywhenthedatasetisexpandedextensively.Anupcomingtechnicalopportunityistheuseof
holographicprojections.Thiswouldallowthepresentationofthedatatothecareprofessionalinawayhe/sheisusedto,likeinhisdailypractice.Seeingthesubjectmove,whileinformationisaddedlikeinenhancedreality.The5Gbandwidthwouldhaveabigimpactinmakingthisfeasible.
PersonalcoachingsystemsPersonalcoachingsystemsareattractingmoreandmoreattentionasthewayforwardtosupportpeopleinchangingtheirbehaviour.Anearreal-timeresponseofthePCSisessential,astheuserhastobeabletolinkhisbehaviourtotherecommendationsthesystemisproviding,soheisabletobeawareofhisbehaviorandabletochangeitdirectly.MorecomplexPCSlikeoneforstressdorequireanindividuallymodeledcombinationofseveralsensorstogetanestimateofstressforfeedback.Thecapacitiesof5Gwouldsupportreal-timedatacollectionandprocessingcentrally,enablingtheuseofcomplexbehaviormodeling.
ThecaringhomeThecaringhomeisjustatthebeginningofitstime.TheupcomingInternetofthings(IoT)willextendthesensingandinteractioncapabilitiesofthehomeenvironmentconsiderablyand5Gwillenablereal-timedatacollectionofalltheon-bodyandcontextualIoTdata,enablingabetterintuitiveidentificationoftheuserneedsandrequiredresponsesofthehomeenvironment.Itwillalsoenabletheincorporationofnewsensingmethodsthatinvolvemoredata;likemooddetectionusingreal-timevideoprocessing.
DiscussionHealthcareisslowlybecomingawareofboththeneedtochangeandthepotentialbenefitsofe-healthandtelemedicineservices.Thereisalsoanincreasingawarenessofthedeterminantsofsuccessfulimplementation[4,5],basedonthemanyexperiencesgainedinthepastdecade.Presenthealthcareisnotyetfullyexploitingthecapacityofthepresent3Gand4Gnetworks.Electronicpatientrecordsdousealimitedamountoftrafficand,apartfromtheimagingdata,involvesmallamountsofdata.Onlyrehabilitationexercisingathomewherevideosareusedtoenableindependentexercisingdoesrequiresomesubstantialbandwidth.Nevertheless,itisexpectedthatthiswillchangetheupcomingyears,nowthatmanyhealthcareinstituteshavetheirEPDreadyandarenowlookingfortechnologysupportedinnovationsoftheircareservices.Andthiswillmeanthatthedescribedareaswillreceiveincreasingattention.Itisexpectedthat5Gwillenablesignificantstepsforwardintheareas.Theexpectedlargebandwidthcombinedwithhighreliabilityandavailability,willenablereal-timedatacollectionfromlargeamountofsensors(onbody,IoT),theuseofcomplexusermodelingandnewwaysofuserinteraction.Itwillalsoincreasetrustintheseareasbothbytheend-usersandcareprofessionalcommunity,speedingupthelargescaledeploymentofthesecaresupportingsolutions.
References1. Amirabdollahian,FandAtes,S.andBasteris,A.andCesario,A.andBuurke,J.H.
andHermens,H.J.andHofs,D.andJohansson,E.andMountain,G.andNasr,N.andNijenhuis,S.M.andPrange,G.B.andRahman,N.andSale,P.andSchätzlein,F.andSchooten,B.vanandStienen,A.H.A.(2014)Design,developmentanddeploymentofahand/wristexoskeletonforhome-basedrehabilitationafterstroke-SCRIPTproject.Robotica,32(8).1331-1346.ISSN0263-5747
2. Akker,H.opden,Tabak,M.,Marin-Perianu,M.,Huisin'tVeld,R.,Jones,V.M.,Hofs,D.,Tönis,T.M.,Schooten,B.W.van,Vollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.andHermens,H.J.(2012)Developmentandevaluationofasensor-basedsystemforremotemonitoringandtreatmentofchronicdiseases-thecontinuouscare&coachingplatform.In:6thInternationalSymposiumoneHealthServicesandTechnologies,EHST2012,3-4July2012,Geneva,Switzerland(pp.pp.19-27).
3. Akker,H.opden,Cabrita,M.,Akker,R.,Jones,V.M.andHermens,H.J.(2015)Tailoredmotivationalmessagegeneration:amodelandpracticalframeworkforreal-timephysicalactivitycoaching.Journalofbiomedicalinformatics,55.pp.104-115.ISSN1532-0464
4. Broens,T.H.F.andHuisin'tVeld,R.M.H.A.andVollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.andHermens,H.J.andHalteren,AvanandNieuwenhuis,L.J.M.(2007)Determinantsofsuccessfultelemedicineimplementations:aliteraturestudy.JournalofTelemedicineandTelecare,13(6).pp.303-309.ISSN1357-633X
5. Car,JosipandHuckvale,KitandHermens,Hermie(2012)Telehealthforlongtermconditions.BMJ:BritishMedicalJournal,344.E4201.ISSN0959-8138
6. Hermens,H.andAkker,H.opdenandTabak,M.andWijsman,J.andVollenbroek,M.(2014)PersonalizedCoachingSystemstosupporthealthybehaviorinpeoplewithchronicconditions.Journalofelectromyographyandkinesiology,24(6).pp.815-826.ISSN1050-6411
7. Hermens,H.J.andVollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.(2008)Towardsremotemonitoringandremotelysupervisedtraining.JournalofElectromyographyandKinesiology,18(6).pp.908-919.ISSN1050-6411
8. HuijgenB.C.H.,Vollenbroek-HuttenMM.R.,ZampoliniM,OpissoE,BernabeuM,NieuwenhovenJ.,IlsbroukxS.,MagniR,GiacomozziC,MarcellariV.,ScattareggiaMarcheseSHermensH.J.(2008)Feasibilityofahome-basedtelerehabilitationsystemcomparedtousualcare:arm/handfunctioninpatientswithstroke,traumaticbraininjuryandmultiplesclerosis.JournalofTelemedicineandTelecare,14(5).pp.249-256.ISSN1357-633X
9. Huisin'tVeld,RM.H.A.andHuijgen,B.C.H.andSchaake,L.andHermens,H.J.andVollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.(2008)Astagedapproachevaluationofremotelysupervisedmyofeedbacktreatment(RSMT)inwomenwithneck-shoulderpainduetocomputerwork.TelemedicineandE-health,14(6).pp.545-551.ISSN1530-5627
10. Tabak,M.andVollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.andValk,P.D.vanderandPalen,J.A.M.vanderandTonis,T.M.andHermens,H.J.(2012)TelemonitoringofdailyactivityandsymptombehaviorinpatientswithCOPD.Internationaljournaloftelemedicineandapplications,2012(438736).ISSN1687-6415
11. Tabak,M.andFlierman,I.andSchooten,B.vanandHermens,H.J.(2013)Developmentofatrustedhealthcareservicetosupportself-managementandaphysicallyactivelifestyleinCOPDpatients.In:Telemedicine&eHealth2013:Agingwell-howcantechnologyhelp?,25-26November2013,London,UK.
12. Voerman,GerlienkeE.andSandsjö,LeifandVollenbroek-Hutten,MiriamM.R.andLarsman,PernillaandKadefors,RolandandHermens,HermieJ.(2007)EffectsofAmbulantMyofeedbackTrainingandErgonomicCounsellinginFemaleComputerWorkerswithWork-RelatedNeck-ShoulderComplaints:A
RandomizedControlledTrial.JournalofOccupationalRehabilitation,17(1).pp.137-152.ISSN1573-3688
13. Vollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.andHuisin'tVeld,M.H.A.andHermens,H.J.(2008)Myotel:adressingmotorbehaviorinneckshoulderpainbyassessingandfeedbacksemginthedaily(work)environment.In:Internationalconferenceonambulatorymonitoringofphysicalactivityandmovement,conferencebook,21-24may2008,Rotterdam,Netherlands(pp.p.86).
14. Vollenbroek-Hutten,M.M.R.andHermens,H.J.andKadefors,R.andDanneels,L.andNieuwenhuis,L.J.M.andHasenbring,M.(2010)Telemedicineservices:fromideatoimplementation.JournalofTelemedicineandTelecare,16(6).pp.291-293.ISSN1357-633X
15. Wijsman,J.andGrundlehner,B.andPenders,J.andHermens,H.J.(2010)TrapeziusMuscleEMGasPredictorofMentalStress.In:WirelessHealth,WH2010,5-7October2010,SanDiego,California(pp.pp.155-163).
16. Wijsman,J.,Grundlehner,B.andLiu,HaoandHermens,H.J.andPenders,J.(2011)TowardsMentalStressDetectionUsingWearablePhysiologicalSensors.In:33rdAnnualInternationalConferenceoftheIEEEEngineeringinMedicineandBiologySociety,EMBC2011,30Aug-3Sept2011,Boston,USA(pp.pp.1798-1801).