8. are there moral truths? thinking about ethics

The Philosopher's WayThe Philosopher's WayA Text with ReadingsA Text with Readings

CHAPTER

FIFTH EDITION

Copyright © 2016, 2013, 2011 by Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

are there moral truths?Thinking about Ethics

8


Peter Horree/Alamy

What Is Our Duty to Others? Vincent Van Gogh’s painting depicts the story of the Good Samaritan, who stops to help a stranger who has been robbed and beaten. The importance of helping those in need is a moral teaching common to religions. In this chapter, we will consider whether it is possible to decide on universal moral values.


Learning ObjectivesLearning Objectives

8.1 Explain the idea of an internal moral compass and it's application to your experience.

8.2 Analyze and discuss arguments for and against ethical relativism.



8.3 Explain and discuss ethical absolutism, the idea that at least some moral values are universal and apply to all individuals and cultures.

8.4 Describe and critically evaluate egoism as a universal principle.



8.5 Explain and critically evaluate the connection between religion and universal values.


Chapter OverviewChapter Overview

Click on the screenshot in presentation mode to view a video on thinking about ethics.

https://mediaplayer.pearsoncmg.com/assets/mythinkinglab-intro_philosophy-thinking_about_ethics


8.1 Your Moral Compass8.1 Your Moral Compass

• The role of philosophy• Ethics and values

Ethical and moral are essentially equivalent terms that can be used interchangeably.

Moral values


David Joel/Getty Images

Should We Prolong Life at all Costs? Ethical dilemmas are an unavoidable part of life. What is your reaction this photograph of a comatose patient on life support equipment? Do you believe that medical technology should be used to extend people’s lives in all cases? Why or why not?



• How does one become a "philosopher of values?" Thinking deeply about profound moral

issues Studying efforts of great thinkers Discussing these concepts with others Constructing a coherent ethical

approach



• Thinking critically about ethics Most people's values are not "systems"

at all.• General principles• Practical conclusions• Emotional pronouncements


8.2 Ethical Relativism8.2 Ethical Relativism

• Ethical relativism• Ethical subjectivism

Fatal flaw• Does not entail tolerance for views of

others Live and let live? Mohandas Gandhi• The golden rule of conduct


Bettmann/Corbis

Mohandas Gandhi (1869–1948). As leader of India’s struggles for independence from Britain, Gandhi’s method of nonviolent resistance served as a model for twentieth-century civil rights leaders, including Martin Luther King, Jr. A political and spiritual leader, Gandhi helped India achieve independence through nonviolent civil protest and disobedience. What were the factors in his background that influenced his decisions? Were these choices free?



• What are the roots of ethical subjectivism?

• Why does it seem to be particularly popular on college campuses and in our culture?

• Descriptive ethics• Normative ethics

• John Searle



• Developing informed beliefs We should ask ourselves two important

questions.• What is my opinion about this issue?• Is my opinion informed by evidence and

reasons?



• Isn't everyone "entitled to his or her opinion?"

• Ethical subjectivism can lead to moral apathy. Refer to the case of Deletha Word in the

student text.• Our moral beliefs have real-world

consequences.


Steven R. Nickerson/Detroit Free Press/AP Images

What Are the Consequences of “Not Getting Involved”? Deletha Word’s family and friends gathered to mourn a loss that might have been prevented had onlookers intervened. Do you think that a belief in ethical subjectivism results in a lack of caring for others?



• Cultural Relativism: Each Culture Determines What Is Morally Right Cultural relativism is ethical

subjectivism on a societal level.• Ruth Benedict, from Anthropology and

the Abnormal Analyzing Benedict on culture and

values


Ruth Benedict (1887–1948). This American anthropologist was one of the first women to become prominent in the social sciences. In Patterns of Culture (1945) Benedict advocated cultural relativism and attempted to apply individual psychological concepts to whole groups.

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division[LC-USZ62-114649]


8.3 Ethical Absolutism: Some 8.3 Ethical Absolutism: Some Moral Values Are UniversalMoral Values Are Universal

• Ethical absolutism• W. T. Stace, The Concept of Morals

Two main arguments in favor of relativism

• William James• Analyzing Stace's critique of ethical

relativism


AP Images

Is Genocide Morally Evil? According to Stace, our belief in absolute moral standards allows us to make moral judgments about genocide. Most of us would have no difficulty in judging Hitler’s actions as morally wrong. What about the actions of those who followed his orders? Or those who supported Hitler but did not literally participate in killing Jews and other prisoners?


8.4 Egoism as a Universal Principle8.4 Egoism as a Universal Principle

• Ethical egoism• Arguments for egoism

Plato, The Republic, "The Myth of Gyges"

Social contract theory Analyzing the "Myth of Gyges" Psychological egoism



• Ayn Rand, from The Virtue of Selfishness Analyzing Rand


Ayn Rand (1905–1982). Rand was an American writer who advocated “the virtue of selfishness” in her novels, plays, and short stories. Her most famous works are The Fountainhead (1943) and Atlas Shrugged (1957).

Bettmann/Corbis


Everett Collection

Is it ethical to break the law to defend our personal integrity? Gary Cooper in The Fountainhead. The protagonist of this film and novel is Howard Roark, a gifted and original architect who refuses to compromise his artistic vision to please others. Roark personifies Rand’s moral ideal. When his designs for a huge public works project are modified—and in his mind adulterated—without his permission, he undertakes to destroy the completed structures. How would you evaluate the morality of his decision? Why?



• Arguments against egoism James Rachels, from Egoism and Moral

Skepticism• Analyzing Rachels's critique of egoism


Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division[LC-DIG-ppmsca-19241]

Are good deeds selfish? Lincoln claimed that in doing good he was acting selfishly because not doing good would make him suffer. Do you agree that it is selfish to want to help others?


8.5 Religion and Universal Values8.5 Religion and Universal Values

• One of the traditional roles of most religions is to provide moral guidelines for believers in that religion.

• The relationship between religion and morality is a natural one for many reasons.



• Divine Command Theory The story of Abraham and Isaac, from

The Bible



• Natural Law Theory St. Thomas Aquinas Martin Luther King Jr., from Letter from a

Birmingham Jail Analyzing King on universal values


Bettmann/Corbis

Martin Luther King Jr. (1929–1968). King was an American minister and civil rights leader and winner of the Nobel Peace Prize. In the tradition of natural law ethics, Dr. King believed that “one had a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws,” a position that led to his arrest on several occasions. Do you agree with Dr. King’s reasoning?


Making Connections: On Becoming Making Connections: On Becoming an Ethical Personan Ethical Person

• Can you make connection between theory and choices you make on a daily basis? Robert Coles, The Disparity Between

Intellect and Character

8. are there moral truths? thinking about ethics

Documents