9-10-2008 21:12 (00) below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei a. staszczak...

47
9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear energy-density-functional methods on nuclear energy-density-functional methods, Jyväskylä, 9-11 Oct. 2008 Jyväskylä, 9-11 Oct. 2008

Post on 15-Jan-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Below-barrier paths:Below-barrier paths:multimodal fission & multimodal fission & doughnut nucleidoughnut nuclei

A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin)A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin)

FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meetingFIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear energy-density-functional methodson nuclear energy-density-functional methods,, Jyväskylä, 9-11 Oct. 2008Jyväskylä, 9-11 Oct. 2008

Page 2: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

MModelodel

The self-consistent HF+BCS equations are solved using the code HFODD v.2.35 that uses the basis expansion method in a 3D Cartesian-deformed HO basis.http://www.fuw.edu.pl/~dobaczew/hfodd/hfodd.html

The s.p. basis consists of the lowest 1140/1771 stretched HO states originating from the 31 major oscillator shells.

The Skyrme functional SkM* is used in the particle-hole channel and a seniority pairing force is taken in the particle-particle channel.

Page 3: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

The symmetry reflection planesThe symmetry reflection planes

P

T

zyxkJiR kk ,,,ˆexpˆ

PRS kkˆˆˆ

The The self-consistentself-consistent symmetries: symmetries:

parity

signature

simplex

time-reversal

ySxS

xS

zS

ySmass symmetric fissionmass symmetric fission

mass asymmetric fissionmass asymmetric fission

Page 4: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Multimodal fissionMultimodal fission

LORW*LORW*)) group group

**) ) LORW group:LORW group:

A. Baran, A. S. (A. Baran, A. S. (LLublin)ublin)W. Nazarewicz (W. Nazarewicz (OOak ak RRidge)idge)J. DobaczewskiJ. Dobaczewski ((WWarszawaarszawa))

Page 5: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 6: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 7: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 8: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

asymmetricasymmetric fissionfission(aEF)(aEF)

bimodalbimodal fissionfission((sCF & ssCF & sEF)EF)

compact-symmetriccompact-symmetric fissionfission((sCsCF)F)

Page 9: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

154 156 158 160

98

100

102

104

106

N

Z

Page 10: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 11: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Doughnut nucleiDoughnut nuclei

C. Y. Wong, A. S.C. Y. Wong, A. S.

Page 12: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Boltzmann-Nordheim-Vlasov (BNV), Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck (BUU) kinetic transport models and Monte Carlo simulations…A. Sochocka, R. Płaneta, N.G. Nicolis, Acta Phys. Pol. B 39, 405 (2008).A. Sochocka et al., Int. J. Mod. Phys. E17,190 (2008).

Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) theory with the Gogny D1S force

M. Warda, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E16, 452 (2007).

Semiclassical extended Thomas-Fermi (ETF) model with the Skyrme SkM* force

X. Viñas, M. Centelles, M. Warda, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E17,177 (2008).

Liquid drop model (LDM) with Strutinsky shell corrections

J.A. Wheeler (unpublished).C.Y. Wong, Phys. Lett. 41B, 446 (1972).C.Y. Wong, Ann. of Phys. (NY) 77, 279 (1973).C.Y. Wong, Proc. Inter. Symp., Lubbock, 1978, (Pergamon Press, 1979), p. 524.

Page 13: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 14: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

dd

Potential energy curves for toroidal nuclei

Page 15: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

1coshsinh,cosh

,8

1cosh15sinhcosh10sinh

cosh3

245

02

02

0

02

0002

0

202

32

dR

RAQ

Page 16: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 17: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

50 MeV

Page 18: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

25 MeV

Page 19: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

12 MeV

Page 20: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 21: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 22: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 23: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 24: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

KONIEC

Page 25: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 26: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 27: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 28: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 29: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 30: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 31: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 32: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 33: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 34: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 35: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 36: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 37: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 38: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 39: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 40: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 41: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 42: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 43: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 44: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

Page 45: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

The constrained HF procedureThe constrained HF procedure::

The constraints act as the external fields capable to deform the nucleus in different ways

The collective coordinates can be defined in a natural way by measuring the deformations generated by the various constraints

The constrained mean field theory defines the deformed states(BCS- or HFB-type) that solve the variational equation:

with the constraint conditions

ˆˆ ˆ{ } { } , { } { } , { } { } .j jq N q N q Z q Z q Q q q

{ }q

212

ˆˆ ˆ ˆ{ } { } 0N Z j j jjq H N Z c Q q

quadratic multipole constraintsquadratic multipole constraints

The multipole constraints prescribe different kinds of deformation characterized by the set of parameters

1 2{ } { , ,..., }.Nq q q q

Page 46: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

is the many-body nuclear (non-relativistic) Hamiltonian H

2

2( )

1

ˆˆ 1ˆ ˆ2 2 2

A Aii effiij

i i j

ppH V

m Am

center-of-mass “projection” termcenter-of-mass “projection” term(in the VAP technique),(in the VAP technique),

to eliminate spurious mode associatedto eliminate spurious mode associated with the broken translational symmetrywith the broken translational symmetry

nuclear effective interaction termnuclear effective interaction term(Skyrme, Gogne type forces)(Skyrme, Gogne type forces)

To describe the fission process most “important” are the low-multipolarity mass moments, i.e.,

2 *20 20

3 *30 30

4 *40 40

ˆ ( ) 16 5 ( , ),

ˆ ( ) 4 7 ( , ),

ˆ ( ) 4 9 ( , ).

i i ii

i i ii

i i ii

Q r r Y

Q r r Y

Q r r Y

““nuclear stretching”nuclear stretching”

““reflection-asymmetry”reflection-asymmetry”

““necking”necking”

Page 47: 9-10-2008 21:12 (00) Below-barrier paths: multimodal fission & doughnut nuclei A. Staszczak (UMCS, Lublin) FIDIPRO-UNEDF collaboration meeting on nuclear

9-10-2008 21:12 (00)

J. Dudek, et al., J. Phys. G6(1980)447.

Seniority pairing:Seniority pairing:

/ //

18.95 0.078 , 88

19.3 0.084 , 88

17.90 0.176 , 88

13.3 0.217 , 88

n p

n

p

n p n p

N Z ZG A

N Z Z

N Z ZG A

N Z Z

G f G

fn= 1.28, fp= 1.11 (for SkM* Skyrme force)

In pairing (BCS) window N (or Z) s.p. states are taken,fn/p parameters are chosen to reproduce pairing gaps ∆n/p for 252Fm.

J. Bartel, et al., Nucl. Phys. A386(1982)79.