9th circuit ca proposition 8 decision perry v brown

133
      Case : 10-1 669 6 02/0 7/20 12 ID: 8059 031 DktEn try: 398- 1 Page : 1 of 128 (1 of 133 )

Upload: shane-vander-hart

Post on 06-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 1/133

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 1 of 128 (1 of 1

Page 2: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 2/133

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 2 of 128 (2 of 1

Page 3: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 3/133

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 3 of 128 (3 of 1

Page 4: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 4/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 4 of 128 (4 of 1

Page 5: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 5/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 5 of 128 (5 of 1

Page 6: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 6/133

  

 

  

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 6 of 128 (6 of 1

Page 7: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 7/133

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 7 of 128 (7 of 1

Page 8: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 8/133

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 8 of 128 (8 of 1

Page 9: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 9/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 9 of 128 (9 of 1

Page 10: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 10/133

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 10 of 128 (10 of 1

Page 11: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 11/133

 

  

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 11 of 128 (11 of 1

Page 12: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 12/133

 

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 12 of 128 (12 of 1

Page 13: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 13/133

 

 

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 13 of 128 (13 of 1

Page 14: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 14/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 14 of 128 (14 of 1

Page 15: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 15/133

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 15 of 128 (15 of 1

Page 16: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 16/133

 

   

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 16 of 128 (16 of 1

Page 17: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 17/133

   

 

 

       

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 17 of 128 (17 of 1

Page 18: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 18/133

   

    

 

 

 

 

    

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 18 of 128 (18 of 1

Page 19: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 19/133

 

 

     

 

 

   

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 19 of 128 (19 of 1

Page 20: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 20/133

  

 

    

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 20 of 128 (20 of 1

Page 21: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 21/133

 

 

 

   

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 21 of 128 (21 of 1

Page 22: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 22/133

 

 

 

    

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 22 of 128 (22 of 1

Page 23: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 23/133

   

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 23 of 128 (23 of 1

Page 24: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 24/133

  

 

   

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 24 of 128 (24 of 1

Page 25: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 25/133

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 25 of 128 (25 of 1

Page 26: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 26/133

 

 

 

 

 

   

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 26 of 128 (26 of 1

Page 27: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 27/133

 

  

   

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 27 of 128 (27 of 1

Page 28: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 28/133

 

  

   

    

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 28 of 128 (28 of 1

Page 29: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 29/133

 

   

  

 

 

 

   

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 29 of 128 (29 of 1

Page 30: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 30/133

 

 

 

 

   

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 30 of 128 (30 of 1

Page 31: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 31/133

 

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 31 of 128 (31 of 1

Page 32: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 32/133

  

  

 

  

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 32 of 128 (32 of 1

Page 33: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 33/133

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 33 of 128 (33 of 1

Page 34: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 34/133

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 34 of 128 (34 of 1

Page 35: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 35/133

 

  

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 35 of 128 (35 of 1

Page 36: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 36/133

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 36 of 128 (36 of 1

Page 37: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 37/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 37 of 128 (37 of 1

Page 38: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 38/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 38 of 128 (38 of 1

Page 39: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 39/133

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 39 of 128 (39 of 1

Page 40: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 40/133

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 40 of 128 (40 of 1

Page 41: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 41/133

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 41 of 128 (41 of 1

Page 42: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 42/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 42 of 128 (42 of 1

Page 43: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 43/133

 

 

 

   

  

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 43 of 128 (43 of 1

Page 44: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 44/133

  

  

  

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 44 of 128 (44 of 1

Page 45: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 45/133

  

    

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 45 of 128 (45 of 1

Page 46: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 46/133

  

 

 

   

   

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 46 of 128 (46 of 1

Page 47: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 47/133

   

 

  

 

   

 

  

 

 

 

   

     

   

    

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 47 of 128 (47 of 1

Page 48: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 48/133

 

  

   

   

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 48 of 128 (48 of 1

Page 49: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 49/133

    

   

 

  

 

  

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 49 of 128 (49 of 1

Page 50: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 50/133

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 50 of 128 (50 of 1

Page 51: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 51/133

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 51 of 128 (51 of 1

Page 52: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 52/133

 

 

 

 

  

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 52 of 128 (52 of 1

Page 53: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 53/133

  

  

  

   

  

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 53 of 128 (53 of 1

Page 54: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 54/133

 

 

 

 

   

  

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 54 of 128 (54 of 1

Page 55: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 55/133

  

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 55 of 128 (55 of 1

Page 56: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 56/133

 

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 56 of 128 (56 of 1

Page 57: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 57/133

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 57 of 128 (57 of 1

Page 58: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 58/133

Page 59: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 59/133

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

  

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 59 of 128 (59 of 1

Page 60: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 60/133

  

  

 

 

 

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 60 of 128 (60 of 1

Page 61: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 61/133

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 61 of 128 (61 of 1

Page 62: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 62/133

 

  

  

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 62 of 128 (62 of 1

Page 63: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 63/133

 

 

 

    

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 63 of 128 (63 of 1

Page 64: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 64/133

 

  

 

 

   

   

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 64 of 128 (64 of 1

Page 65: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 65/133

 

  

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 65 of 128 (65 of 1

Page 66: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 66/133

Page 67: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 67/133

 

  

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 67 of 128 (67 of 1

Page 68: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 68/133

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 68 of 128 (68 of 1

Page 69: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 69/133

Page 70: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 70/133

  

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 70 of 128 (70 of 1

Page 71: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 71/133

  

 

 

  

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 71 of 128 (71 of 1

Page 72: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 72/133

  

   

 

    

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 72 of 128 (72 of 1

Page 73: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 73/133

  

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 73 of 128 (73 of 1

Page 74: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 74/133

  

   

 

 

 

   

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 74 of 128 (74 of 1

Page 75: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 75/133

    

 

 

  

   

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 75 of 128 (75 of 1

Page 76: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 76/133

Page 77: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 77/133

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 77 of 128 (77 of 1

Page 78: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 78/133

 

 

  

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 78 of 128 (78 of 1

Page 79: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 79/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 79 of 128 (79 of 1

Page 80: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 80/133

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 80 of 128 (80 of 1

Page 81: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 81/133

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 81 of 128 (81 of 1

Page 82: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 82/133

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 82 of 128 (82 of 1

Page 83: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 83/133

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 83 of 128 (83 of 1

Page 84: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 84/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 84 of 128 (84 of 1

Page 85: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 85/133

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 85 of 128 (85 of 1

Page 86: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 86/133

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 86 of 128 (86 of 1

Page 87: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 87/133

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 87 of 128 (87 of 1

Page 88: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 88/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 88 of 128 (88 of 1

Page 89: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 89/133

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 89 of 128 (89 of 1

Page 90: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 90/133

 

 

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 90 of 128 (90 of 1

Page 91: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 91/133

 

  

  

  

 

   

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 91 of 128 (91 of 1

Page 92: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 92/133

 

 

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 92 of 128 (92 of 1

Page 93: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 93/133

   

 

 

  

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 93 of 128 (93 of 1

Page 94: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 94/133

 

 

  

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 94 of 128 (94 of 1

Page 95: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 95/133

 

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 95 of 128 (95 of 1

Page 96: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 96/133

 

  

 

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 96 of 128 (96 of 1

Page 97: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 97/133

 

 

  

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 97 of 128 (97 of 1

Page 98: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 98/133

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 98 of 128 (98 of 1

Page 99: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 99/133

 

 

 

   

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 99 of 128 (99 of 1

Page 100: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 100/133

  

  

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 100 of 128(100 of 1

Page 101: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 101/133

  

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 101 of 128(101 of 1

Page 102: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 102/133

 

  

 

   

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 102 of 128(102 of 1

Page 103: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 103/133

  

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 103 of 128(103 of 1

Page 104: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 104/133

  

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 104 of 128(104 of 1

Page 105: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 105/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 105 of 128(105 of 1

Page 106: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 106/133

 

  

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 106 of 128(106 of 1

Page 107: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 107/133

 

  

 

 

  

  

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 107 of 128(107 of 1

Page 108: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 108/133

 

 

 

  

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 108 of 128(108 of 1

Page 109: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 109/133

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 109 of 128(109 of 1

Page 110: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 110/133

 

 

  

  

 

  

   

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 110 of 128(110 of 1

Page 111: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 111/133

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 111 of 128(111 of 1

Page 112: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 112/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 112 of 128(112 of 1

Page 113: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 113/133

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 113 of 128(113 of 1

Page 114: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 114/133

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 114 of 128(114 of 1

Page 115: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 115/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 115 of 128(115 of 1

Page 116: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 116/133

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 116 of 128(116 of 1

Page 117: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 117/133

  

 

  

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 117 of 128(117 of 1

Page 118: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 118/133

 

  

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 118 of 128(118 of 1

Page 119: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 119/133

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 119 of 128(119 of 1

Page 120: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 120/133

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 120 of 128(120 of 1

Page 121: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 121/133

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 121 of 128(121 of 1

Page 122: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 122/133

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 122 of 128(122 of 1

Page 123: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 123/133

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 123 of 128(123 of 1

Page 124: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 124/133

 

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 124 of 128(124 of 1

Page 125: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 125/133

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 125 of 128(125 of 1

Page 126: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 126/133

  

  

 

 

 

 

 

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 126 of 128(126 of 1

Page 127: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 127/133

 

 

  

 

 

  

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 127 of 128(127 of 1

Page 128: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 128/133

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-1 Page: 128 of 128(128 of 1

Page 129: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 129/133

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Office of the Clerk

95 Seventh StreetSan Francisco, CA 94103

Information Regarding Judgment and Post-Judgment Proceedings

(December 2009)

Judgment

• This Court has filed and entered the attached judgment in your case.Fed. R. App. P. 36. Please note the filed date on the attacheddecision because all of the dates described below run from that date,not from the date you receive this notice.

Mandate (Fed. R. App. P. 41; 9th Cir. R. 41-1 & -2)

• The mandate will issue 7 days after the expiration of the time forfiling a petition for rehearing or 7 days from the denial of a petitionfor rehearing, unless the Court directs otherwise. To file a motion tostay the mandate, file it electronically via the appellate ECF systemor, if you are a pro se litigant or an attorney with an exemption fromusing appellate ECF, file one original motion on paper.

Petition for Panel Rehearing (Fed. R. App. P. 40; 9th Cir. R. 40-1)

Petition for Rehearing En Banc (Fed. R. App. P. 35; 9th Cir. R. 35-1 to -3)

(1) A. Purpose (Panel Rehearing):

• A party should seek panel rehearing only if one or more of the followinggrounds exist:

  A material point of fact or law was overlooked in the decision;   A change in the law occurred after the case was submitted which

appears to have been overlooked by the panel; or 

  An apparent conflict with another decision of the Court was not

addressed in the opinion. • Do not file a petition for panel rehearing merely to reargue the case. 

B. Purpose (Rehearing En Banc)

• A party should seek en banc rehearing only if one or more of the followinggrounds exist:

Post Judgment Form - Rev. 12/2009 1

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-2 Page: 1 of 5 (129 of 1

Page 130: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 130/133

  Consideration by the full Court is necessary to secure or maintainuniformity of the Court’s decisions; or 

  The proceeding involves a question of exceptional importance; or 

  The opinion directly conflicts with an existing opinion by anothercourt of appeals or the Supreme Court and substantially affects arule of national application in which there is an overriding need fornational uniformity. 

(2) Deadlines for Filing:

• A petition for rehearing may be filed within 14 days after entry of 

 judgment. Fed. R. App. P. 40(a)(1).

• If the United States or an agency or officer thereof is a party in a civil case,

the time for filing a petition for rehearing is 45 days after entry of 

 judgment. Fed. R. App. P. 40(a)(1). 

• If the mandate has issued, the petition for rehearing should be

accompanied by a motion to recall the mandate. 

• See Advisory Note to 9th Cir. R. 40-1 (petitions must be received on the

due date). 

• An order to publish a previously unpublished memorandum disposition

extends the time to file a petition for rehearing to 14 days after the date of 

the order of publication or, in all civil cases in which the United States or

an agency or officer thereof is a party, 45 days after the date of the order of 

publication. 9th Cir. R. 40-2. 

(3) Statement of Counsel• A petition should contain an introduction stating that, in counsel’s

 judgment, one or more of the situations described in the “purpose” section

above exist. The points to be raised must be stated clearly.

(4) Form & Number of Copies (9th Cir. R. 40-1; Fed. R. App. P. 32(c)(2))

• The petition shall not exceed 15 pages unless it complies with the

alternative length limitations of 4,200 words or 390 lines of text.

• The petition must be accompanied by a copy of the panel’s decision being

challenged.• An answer, when ordered by the Court, shall comply with the same length

limitations as the petition.

• If a pro se litigant elects to file a form brief pursuant to Circuit Rule 28-1, a

petition for panel rehearing or for rehearing en banc need not comply with

Fed. R. App. P. 32.

Post Judgment Form - Rev. 12/2009 2

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-2 Page: 2 of 5 (130 of 1

Page 131: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 131/133

• The petition or answer must be accompanied by a Certificate of 

Compliance found at Form 11, available on our website at under Forms. 

• You may file a petition electronically via the appellate ECF system. No

paper copies are required unless the Court orders otherwise. If you are a

pro se litigant or an attorney exempted from using the appellate ECF

system, file one original petition on paper. No additional paper copies are

required unless the Court orders otherwise. 

Bill of Costs (Fed. R. App. P. 39, 9th Cir. R. 39-1)

• The Bill of Costs must be filed within 14 days after entry of judgment.

• See Form 10 for additional information, available on our website at under

Forms. 

Attorneys Fees

• Ninth Circuit Rule 39-1 describes the content and due dates for attorneys

fees applications.

• All relevant forms are available on our website at under Forms or by

telephoning (415) 355-7806.

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari

• Please refer to the Rules of the United States Supreme Court at

Counsel Listing in Published Opinions

• Please check counsel listing on the attached decision.

• If there are any errors in a published opinion, please send a letter in

writing within 10 days to: 

  West Publishing Company; 610 Opperman Drive; PO Box 64526;St. Paul, MN 55164-0526 (Attn: Kathy Blesener, Senior Editor);

  and electronically file a copy of the letter via the appellate ECF

system by using “File Correspondence to Court,” or if you are an

attorney exempted from using the appellate ECF system, mail the

Court one copy of the letter.

Post Judgment Form - Rev. 12/2009 3

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-2 Page: 3 of 5 (131 of 1

Page 132: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 132/133

Form 10. Bill of Costs ................................................................................................................................ (Rev. 12-1-

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

BILL OF COSTS

Note: If you wish to file a bill of costs, it MUST be submitted on this form and filed, with the clerk, with proof o

service, within 14 days of the date of entry of judgment, and in accordance with 9th Circuit Rule 39-1. Alate bill of costs must be accompanied by a motion showing good cause. Please refer to FRAP 39, 28

U.S.C. § 1920, and 9th Circuit Rule 39-1 when preparing your bill of costs.

v. 9th Cir. No.

The Clerk is requested to tax the following costs against:

Cost Taxable

under FRAP 39,

28 U.S.C. § 1920,

9th Cir. R. 39-1

REQUESTED

Each Column Must Be Completed

ALLOWED

To Be Completed by the Clerk 

No. of 

Docs.

Pages per

Doc.

Cost per

Page*TOTAL

COST

TOTAL

COST

Pages per

Doc.

No. of 

Docs.

Excerpt of Record

Opening Brief 

Reply Brief 

$

$

$

$

$

$

$ $

Other**

Answering Brief 

$ $

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$ $TOTAL: TOTAL:

* Costs per page may not exceed .10 or actual cost, whichever is less. 9th Circuit Rule 39-1. 

Cost per

Page*

Any other requests must be accompanied by a statement explaining why the item(s) should be taxed

pursuant to 9th Circuit Rule 39-1. Additional items without such supporting statements will not be

considered. 

Attorneys' fees cannot be requested on this form.

** Other:

Continue to next pa

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-2 Page: 4 of 5 (132 of 1

Page 133: 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

8/3/2019 9th Circuit CA Proposition 8 Decision Perry v Brown

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9th-circuit-ca-proposition-8-decision-perry-v-brown 133/133

Form 10. Bill of Costs - Continued 

I, , swear under penalty of perjury that the services for which costs are taxe

were actually and necessarily performed, and that the requested costs were actually expended as listed.

Signature

Date

Name of Counsel:

Attorney for:

Date Costs are taxed in the amount of $

Clerk of Court

By: , Deputy Clerk 

(To Be Completed by the Clerk)

("s/" plus attorney's name if submitted electronically)

Case: 10-16696 02/07/2012 ID: 8059031 DktEntry: 398-2 Page: 5 of 5 (133 of 1