a case for custom silicon in enabling low-cost information technology for developing regions z. foo,...
TRANSCRIPT
The University of Michigan 1
A Case for Custom Silicon in Enabling Low-Cost Information
Technology for Developing Regions
Z. Foo, David Devecsery, T. Schmid, N. Clark, R. Frank, M. Ghaed, Y. Kuo,
Lee, Y. Park, Z. Renner, N. Slottow, V. Vinay, M. Wieckowski, D. Yoon,
C. Schmidt , D. Blaauw, P. Chen, and P. Dutta
The University of Michigan
The University of Michigan 2
Motivation
• Recent studies show benefits of information in developing regions
• Avaaj Otalo– Mobile-phone-based interactive voice forum– Users found value listening to questions and answers
• Digital Green Project– Disseminate agricultural information through video– Large increase in adoption of agricultural practices
The University of Michigan 3
Motivation
• Talking Book Project– Provide on-demand access to information from local experts– Information pre-loaded onto devices, and re-programmed in field– Farmers showed a significant increase in crop production
• Question: Why aren’t these devices more popular in developing regions?
The University of Michigan 4
Commodity Devices Not Sufficient• Radio
– No replay capability– No indexing– No on-demand information
• Voice Recorder– No indexing– Information distribution difficult
• Cell Phone– Too expensive - $20-$40– Running cost too high - $.10-$.30/min. in rural Africa– High power draw– Connection unreliable
The University of Michigan 5
Custom Devices Still Not Sufficient• Lifeplayer
– Provides data recording, playback, indexing, communication
– Costs around $100– Very large
• Talking Book– Similar functionality to Lifeplayer– Scaled way down
• Hand-held• Costs between $20 and $35• 2 - 3 day lifetime on AA batteries
Source: lifelineenergy.org
The University of Michigan 6
Our Goal
• Design a custom device:– Provide recording, playback, communication, data
indexing– < $10– Reduce upkeep cost to user
• Case Study: Redesign Talking Book
The University of Michigan 7
Improving The Talking Book
• Reduce costs with– Custom silicon integration– Flatter memory hierarchy – Unconventional communication
• Will reduce cost to $10 and power by 6x
The University of Michigan 8
Use Custom Silicon
• Aggressively integrate into custom silicon• Eliminate discrete components
The University of Michigan 9
Integrate to Chip
• Speaker amp• Voltage regulators• Oscillators
– One off chip crystal– Inexpensive, and slow
The University of Michigan 10
Memory Hierarchy• Old Memory Hierarchy
• Goals of new system:– Minimize Costs– Allow for large code bases– Easy for programmers
Core
ExternalNOR Flash
Internal Flash
ExternalSD Card
Internal RAM
The University of Michigan 11
Minimizing Memories
• Use only one NAND Flash– Lower power– Less expensive
• NAND Flash– Chips wear out– Not fault tolerant– Slower– Requires software FTL– Uses cache
– Improve performance– Reduces flash wear
Software FTL
NAND Flash
Cache
Microcontroller
Core
The University of Michigan 12
Custom Cache• 4-way set associative• 128 KB memory• Cache must use core
– Interrupts fetch data– Similar to MMU
• Pinned region– Stops critical code from missing– Allows real-time guarantees
Software FTL
NAND Flash
Cache
Microcontroller
Core
The University of Michigan 13
Move Interfaces On-Chip• Push button interface
– Expensive - $1– Requires membrane switch-pad– Mechanical failure
• Replace with Capacitive Sensors:– Low chip area – Nearly no cost– Built into PCB– No physical system
The University of Michigan 14
Communications
The University of Michigan 15
Communications
FM Radio
• Long range voice distribution
• Digital data through RDS sub-band
• Download information over night
The University of Michigan 16
Communications
FM Radio
Inductive Link
• Replaces USB• Wireless peer to peer• 500Kb/s• Integrated into PCB• Minimal hardware cost
The University of Michigan 17
Communications
FM Radio
Inductive Link
Cell Phone
• On-demand information download
• Directly download voice
• Digital data with FSK modulation– Firmware Updates
The University of Michigan 18
Bill of Materials - ComponentsComponent Name Cost Speaker Inductor $0.0245 Speaker Capacitor $0.0090 Linear Regulator Cap $0.0107 Step-Up Converter Cap (Type 1) 4
$0.0027
Step-Up Converter Cap (Type 2) 2
$0.0246
Chip Area $0.7600 Total Chip Cost $0.8315
The University of Michigan 19
Bill of Materials - BoardComponent Name Cost Chip $0.8315 Speaker $0.7783 Headphone Jack $0.0232 Microphone $0.0935 PCB $1.0050 NAND Flash $2.0000 Radio $1.0395 Total Board Cost $5.7711
The University of Michigan 20
Bill of Materials - System
Component Name Cost Board $5.7711 Casing $1.0000 Test & Assemble $1.0000 Total System Cost $7.7711
The University of Michigan 21
NRE Costs
• Custom silicon equal COTS 70k units• Custom silicon < $10 at 400k units
The University of Michigan 22
Power Costs
• 2 Week battery lifetime on 2 AA Batteries• Overall 6x power reduction
The University of Michigan 23
Summary
• Current devices are not sufficient• Custom silicon:
– Gives similar functionality to old Talking Book– Allows entire system on three chips– Reduces all costs to within goals
• Custom silicon presents a viable option for large-quantity developing world products
The University of Michigan 24
Low-Power Core
• Use ARM Cortex-M0 processor– 50MHz core clock– ARM v6m ISA
• 32-bit performance • 16-bit instruction size
– <10% of total chip energy in active mode– Decodes, timescales, & plays audio real time
The University of Michigan 25
Cell Phone Issues
• Use More Power• Stuff about why not good