a chelsea original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
... A Chelsea Original
EXPRESSION OF INTEREST
![Page 2: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
![Page 3: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Contents Foreword page 5 Introduction 6 Key Themes 8 Competition Process 10 Background and Context 13 Project Essentials 16 Prospective Teams 17 Site Information 19 Budget 20 Anticipated Programme 21 Submission Form 23 Submission Requirements 24 Selection Criteria 27 Competition Requirements 28 PQQ 31
Declaration Form 43
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
16.
![Page 4: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
4
Aerial photograph of the Duke of York development taken from the west. The existing café is to the
left of the running track.
Image by Adam Parker Photographer
![Page 5: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
5
From the Chief Executive of the Cadogan Estate
It is now ten years since the re-development of the Duke of York Square from a closed
military barracks to a mixed-use scheme including shops, restaurants, flats, offices, a
school, a gallery of modern art and a public space. The Duke of York Square has become
an established and a much-loved quarter within Chelsea and the King’s Road.
Our management of the scheme reflects our extensive property holdings in the area and
our long-term business approach, which is to ensure, wherever possible, that we contribute
to the attraction and success of the wider area, both for visitors and the local community.
It has become increasingly clear that the extremely popular café, positioned in the heart
of the scheme, has the potential to make a further contribution to the success of the area.
To achieve this, we need an exceptional and innovative design, infusing the space with
excitement whilst also connecting with, and relating to, the surrounding environment and
community.
The competition provides us with the opportunity of presenting the challenges of the
redevelopment of the cafe to a wide group of architects which will, hopefully, result in a
range of design solutions from which we will identify the best approach. This is a novel
approach for us and one we are very excited about.
Hugh Seaborn, Chief Executive of the Cadogan Estate
1. Foreword
![Page 6: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
6
The Duke of York development, focused on its new square, was completed in the early
millennium to much acclaim. It embodied many of the ideals identified by the recently
published Urban Taskforce Report ‘Towards an Urban Renaissance’ and was described, at
the time, by Lord Rogers as ‘the first successful square in London designed specifically for
public use’.
Pioneering in many respects, the development opened up to the public, a former military
site located just off the famously-vibrant King’s Road. It was also the first new public
square created in London’s West End for over a century.
With a skillful blend of retail, residential and commercial uses combined with a successful
integration of historic and contemporary buildings, The Duke of York Square created a new
urban quarter. It was further enhanced through the relocation of the Saatchi Gallery to the
former Royal Military Asylum on the site not long after completion; this cultural addition
strengthening the development’s credentials as an integrated mixed-use campus.
The project was intended to be elegantly recessive, a development which melds seamlessly
into its surrounding urban fabric rather than flaunting its contemporary qualities. Its
architecture is intentionally a deliberate backdrop or a stage for the actors in the play of
public and civic life that occupy it.
The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the project. The
existing building, described by The Architects’ Journal as, ‘a transparent temple to the
cappuccino’ sits, sentinel-like, by the main thoroughfare to the Saatchi Gallery. A neat essay
in proportion and rhythm, it reflects the rest of the Duke of York Square buildings, without
establishing any very definite identity.
Despite this issue, it has become extraordinarily popular and overwhelmed with visitors,
creating a practical problem of how it can be developed to meet this demand and raising
the question of what should replace it.
2. Introduction
![Page 7: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
7
It is the client’s intention that while the proposed building should fit within the architectural
setting, it should bring new qualities and energy to the ensemble, both during the day and
at night, refreshing and influencing the Square and the buildings around it.
The site, in a prime position in one of London’s most sophisticated districts, deserves a
world-class design, innovative and striking, which enhances the public’s experience of the
space, lifting spirits and creating a lively sense of atmosphere.
In this sense it should be a Chelsea original.
![Page 8: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
8
The Cadogan Estate is not seeking the already well-established architect, rather it is keen
to identify and support emerging talent and in doing so act as a client patron in the classic
sense.
It is looking for a team with a fascination for innovative construction techniques and
logistics, an interest in the art of place-making and an eye to keeping disruption to a
minimum.
A creative exploration of the project is strongly encouraged and teams should outline
ideas on an additional programme of use(s) and user(s) that will give the café a unique
identity that raises it above that of an everyday coffee shop. This should help to foster
community engagement and connection. We encourage competitors to form interest-
ing collaborations from a wide array of disciplines, including artists. Designers should be
aware of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea’s recently-announced cultural
place-making strategy (see page 17).
3. Key Themes
![Page 9: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
9
The project’s key themes encompass:
• Exemplary design: innovative and striking
• Sustainable design which relates to the high-quality, historic setting
• Cultural place-making
• The needs of both locals and visitors
If selected the team’s proposal for the building should include:
• A configuration to provide for circa 100 covers (60 outside and 40 inside)
• A dynamic covering for the outside users
• Strong indoor and outdoor connection
• Back of house facilities located underground to maximise activity and transparency
The intention behind the EOI stage is to identify a team with which Cadogan can work
constructively, and engage with, throughout the creative and construction process and
who can deliver an innovative and exciting project to both time and budget.
The following document sets out the requirements of this two-stage competition process.
At this stage, the Expression of Interest, we are not seeking a design but an explanation
behind the proposed composition of your team, an approach to the issues at hand and a
reaction to the emerging brief.
![Page 10: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
10
The Cadogan Estate wishes to appoint an expert design team to reinterpret the current
café offer at the heart of the unique Duke of York Square setting. The Estate is determined
to develop the site in a sustainable way, in keeping with the ethos of the rest of the Square.
It seeks a design team capable of realising this project in ways that combine imagination
and verve with economy and sustainability.
Malcolm Reading Consultants (MRC), an independent expert organiser of design
competitions, will lead and administer a two-stage competition on behalf of the Estate.
This will result in the selection of a winning team and design, who will be appointed to
develop their design and to deliver the project.
The two-stage design contest is comprised of:
Stage 1:
An international call for participation—an Expression of Interest (EOI)—that is aimed at
attracting technically competent and professional teams to register their interest in the
project, as described in this document. A shortlist of five to seven of the best teams will be
selected to move to Stage 2. Successful and unsuccessful teams will be contacted by MRC
prior to the commencement of Stage 2.
Stage 2:
The shortlisted teams will be asked to produce a concept design. A comprehensive brief
will be issued to these teams, as well as detailed information about the site. This stage
may also require visits to projects completed by each of the shortlisted teams. A technical
panel will review the entries and a final jury will conduct interviews prior to a winner
being announced. A public exhibition of the shortlisted teams will be held prior to the jury
meeting.
4. Competition Process
![Page 11: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
11
An honorarium of £5,000 will be awarded to each of the unsuccessful shortlisted teams
following the selection of the winner.
MRC is running this competition for the Cadogan Estate. Any questions should be
directed to MRC and not to the Cadogan Estate. Contact details can be found later in this
document.
![Page 12: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
12
1
2
1 & 2 The site in use as the
Territorial Army headquarters
in the 1990’s as seen from the
King’s Road
Images by Paul Davis + Partners
![Page 13: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
13
5.
History...
The Duke of York Square site, amounting to 2.5 Hectares in total, is the former home of the
Duke of York’s regimental barracks and other supporting facilities. As a military installation
it presented a hard, unanimated façade to the predominantly lively King’s Road.
Unlike many military estates the Duke of York’s site contained a great many quality, and
historically important, buildings and structures. The main buildings on site were in the
Palladian tradition by the architect John Sanders (1768-1826), a one-time pupil of Sir John
Soane. These include the Royal Military Asylum (1801-03), now the Saatchi Gallery, and
the former Chapel (1824). Also noteworthy is the running track, overlooked by the central
portico of Sanders’s Asylum building and laid out during the Second World War, where
Chris Chataway and Roger Bannister trained for the first sub-four-minute mile. Towards the
end of its military existence the site was home to the Territorial Army Headquarters.
At the end of the last millennium, following a strategic review by the Ministry of Defence,
the site became available for redevelopment. The Cadogan Estate emerged as the
preferred purchaser because of its long-term residential and commercial property interests
in the area, its experience in mixed-use development and the re-purposing of existing
buildings and its financial strength.
The resultant development, carried out between 2001 and 2006, was for a phased, £120
million mixed-use scheme of cultural, residential, retail and commercial facilities.
Background and Context
![Page 14: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
14
Views of the existing café in the Duke of York Square
Images by Adam Parker Photographer
![Page 15: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
15
…Present Day
Now a popular haunt of fashionistas, visitors and locals, the Duke of York Square, located
opposite the John Lewis Department Store Peter Jones, provides a relaxed atmosphere,
as well as terrific shopping; with more than 30 retail units and a choice of six cafes/
restaurants all with external seating. Its fusion of original historic buildings mixed with
new classical design creates a beautiful mini-district, offering opportunities for social
stimulation and relaxation. The Saatchi Gallery, a must-see on the London circuit, draws
international and culturally-minded visitors to the area.
For more information on the Square, visit www.dukeofyorksquare.com
The Cadogan Estate
Originally established more than three hundred years ago, the Cadogan Estate today
controls 93 acres of one of the capital’s most exclusive neighbourhoods, spanning Chelsea
and stretching deep into Knightsbridge. The Estate comprises over 3,100 flats, nearly 200
houses, more than 330 shops and stores and 500,000 sq ft of office space. It takes a long-
term interest in the quality of the environment, seeking to maintain the vibrant culture and
quality of life in Chelsea as exemplified by the recent developments of the new concert hall
at Cadogan Hall, and the public realm aspects of the Duke of York Square development.
To find out more about the Estate and its history, please visit www.cadogan.co.uk
![Page 16: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
16
The project should deliver:
• A new café to provide for circa 100 covers (60 outside + 40 inside).
• Strong indoor/outdoor connection to add life year-round.
• A dynamic covering for outside users.
• A basement area to house prep area, storage, toilets, staff wash/change area, rubbish,
stair and hoist in order to maximise ground level seating/activity and transparency.
• Visible location and great place to watch the world go by.
6. Project Essentials
![Page 17: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
17
The Cadogan Estate encourages EOIs from multi-disciplinary teams which should include,
but are not limited to, architects, a structural engineer, a building services engineer and a
cost consultant. The team must be led by an architect who will act as the lead consultant.
Additional skills may be proposed in your submission if you feel they are necessary.
Competitors should note within their response any other specialist team members they
would like to include in their team and who they believe will be necessary to complete
the commission, for example, artists or landscape architects or product suppliers. Teams
responding to this EOI must have the necessary expertise to complete the project within
the project constraints, which include: design, budget, programme and site constraints.
A creative and artistic exploration of the project is strongly encouraged and teams should
be aware of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea’s recently-announced cultural
place-making strategy. 1 It is likely that the building/structures may require innovative
approaches to offsite, prefabrication and component techniques. The Cadogan Estate
would be keen to see this reflected in the teams’ relevant expertise in this area.
The form of construction procurement for the café is yet to be determined. It is currently
anticipated that the selected team will be required to provide full design services for the
building from RIBA stages B-L. It should be noted that the Cadogan Estate may choose
to transfer responsibility for the development of the design to a contractor, at RIBA
stage D or E, and the team may work for the Estate or the contractor, depending on the
circumstances. The Cadogan Estate intends to call on the expertise of the selected team to
determine the most sensible procurement method.
The Cadogan Estate reserves the right to determine the final composition of the design
team appointed as the winner and this may include the appointment of consultants that
are not suggested within the competitor’s bid. For the avoidance of doubt, this is to ensure
the correct mix of skills and expertise and will not be imposed unreasonably.
1 Please refer to the following link to access the document: http://www.rbkc.gov.uk/leisureandlibraries/culture/artsservicenetworkingandtrainingevents.aspx Once on the above page please click on ‘Cultural Placemaking Proposals’, subscribe and then the document can be accessed.
7. Prospective Teams
![Page 18: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
18
Constraints diagram by Paul Davis + Partners
![Page 19: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
19
The site is located on the south side of the King’s Road in Chelsea, in the heart of Duke of
York Square adjacent to the Saatchi Gallery.
The site at present consists of a café building now occupied by a Gelateria Valerie with out-
door seating to the west. The occupier of the future café is yet to be determined.
Please see the diagrams on the previous page and the photo on the page 4.
A full site information pack, together with survey information and the brief will be made
available to the shortlisted practices at the next stage.
8. Site Information
![Page 20: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
20
9.
The total project costs are estimated to be £2,000,000 (including construction, fit-out,
fees, VAT and associated costs).
Further information on the budget will be given at the next stage of the competition.
Budget
![Page 21: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
21
10. Anticipated Programme
JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV
1. COMPETITION LAUNCHED
2. EOI PERIOD
2. SUBMISSION OF EOIs
3. SHORTLIST AND ISSUE OF COMPETITION INFORMATION
4. TENDER PERIOD
5. SITE VISIT
6. FINAL SUBMISSION BY SHORTLISTED TEAMS
7. ASSESSMENT, INCLUDING INTERVIEWS
8. WINNER ANNOUNCED
5 JULY
30 NOV
20 AUG
20 SEP
27 SEP
12 NOV
![Page 22: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
22
KEY DATES
Competition launched 5th July 2012
Submission of EOIs 20th August 2012
Shortlist and issue of competition information 20th September 2012
Site visit to Duke of York Square site 27th September 2012
Final submissions by shortlisted teams 12th November 2012
Assessment, including interviews 27th–29th November 2012
Winner announced 30th November 2012
Planning application Summer 2013
Earliest anticipated date of Commencement of Construction Spring 2014
Earliest anticipated date for Project Completion Spring 2015
![Page 23: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
23
11.
Competitors MUST complete the following form and attach it to the FRONT of all copies of
their submission:
Cadogan Café Competition
Registration number:
(Competitors will have received this by registering for the competition on the website)
www.malcolmreading.co.uk/architecturalcompetitions/cadogancafe
Name of Team Lead:
Names of all Collaborators:
Company Name Role (e.g. architect, landscape architect)
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Submission Form
![Page 24: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
24
12.
Competitors are asked to produce the responses to Parts 1 - 4 as a bound A4 document.
All responses must be in the order shown below.
1) PQQ questions
Questions should be submitted electronically and in hard copy. Please see Section 15.
Teams may change the layout if they wish, but the format and order must remain the same.
There is a Word version of the PQQ available for download online, should competitors
prefer to use this.
www.malcolmreading.co.uk/architecturalcompetitions/cadogancafe
Format: A4, hard and electronic copy in PDF format (to be completed by lead consultant
only).
2) Team composition
We are looking for interesting team collaborations to undertake this project. Please tell us
why you have brought together the disciplines you have and why you think the team will
deliver a successful project.
Please provide a one-page summary of details for each of the principal consultant firms
who will form part of your team. The team, as a minimum, must include an architect, a
structural engineer, a building services engineer and a cost consultant. Please provide
details of any other consultants who are vital to your design approach and state who will
be the lead for the team. Please note that teams composed of both emerging architects
and established consultancies will be looked upon favourably.
Format: One side of A4 for each discipline, hard and electronic copy in PDF format.
Submission Requirements
![Page 25: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
25
3) Relevant projects
Please provide a précis of your approach to similar challenges on previous projects and
how you have worked to maximise value for the client. This should include analysis of
programme, budget and buildability.
The lead consultant should demonstrate the practice’s approach and expertise to similar/
relevant projects and why the company is appropriate for this commission. Please describe
your approach to the site problems and design solutions for one past project, either built
or otherwise.
The other team members should provide no more than one side of A4 outlining projects
they have completed.
Both the lead consultant and other team members should identify:
• Client name, email address and contact number.
• Date of project completion.
• Previous experience of working as a team, where possible with the team members
proposed in this EOI.
• Anticipated and final budget.
• Anticipated and final duration of the project.
• Aspects of the design or design approach that are relevant or showcase equivalent
challenges to the Cadogan café project.
Illustrations and sketches should be used where appropriate. Client references may be
taken up.
Format: A4, hard and electronic copy in PDF format.
![Page 26: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
26
4) Press
Each competitor should also provide a 150-word snapshot of the practice or collaboration
that can be used for press in the event of the team being shortlisted. In addition, up to
three high-resolution images of representative projects should be provided for the same
reason. These will only be used in any press announcements, and should be submitted with
the EOI submission.
Submission Details
Please return seven hard copies and one electronic copy (either on a memory stick or CD)
of your submission to:
Malcolm Reading Consultants
Fourth Floor
10 Ely Place
London EC1N 6RY
Submissions must be sent securely in a single package, clearly marked:
Cadogan Café Competition
Submissions must be received by 14.00 on Monday 20th August 2012.
All copies of the submission MUST display the form (page 23) on the front and be clearly
marked with your registration number.
![Page 27: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
27
The following criteria will be used to select a shortlist:
1. Ability to meet essential financial and business standards for the commission, based
on Part 1 of the Submission Requirements (10%).
2. Technical and professional capability of the proposed team, including the
communication of ideas and composition of team, based on Part 2 of the Submission
Requirements (45%).
3. Overall experience and examples of previous work, including the ability to deliver to
specification, budget and programme, based on Part 3 of the Submission Requirements
(45%).
Selection Criteria13.
![Page 28: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
28
Only candidates who respond in accordance with the submission requirements may
be considered. During the Expression of Interest stage, the Cadogan Estate staff, its
consultants and project team members should not be contacted, as this may lead to
disqualification from the competition.
Receipt of Expressions of Interest
Expressions of Interest will be received up to 14.00 hours (BST) on Monday 20th August
2012.
Please ensure that your submission is delivered no later than the appointed time. The
Cadogan Estate may not consider your submission if it is received after the deadline.
Questions
All enquiries relating to the competition should be addressed to Malcolm Reading
Consultants, the independent competition organisers appointed to manage the process.
Do not contact the Cadogan Estate or any member of staff directly.
Questions should be emailed to: [email protected]
A question and answer log will be compiled and uploaded to the website on a regular basis:
www.malcolmreading.co.uk/architecturalcompetitions/cadogancafe/downloads
14. Competition Requirements
![Page 29: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
29
Permissions
The Cadogan Estate reserves the right to make use of all presentation materials submitted
in any future publication about the competition, exhibition or website. Any use will
be properly credited to the competitor and the competitor warrants that the material
submitted comprises solely their own work or that of any member of a consortium
submitting a PQQ response. This non-exclusive licence is irrevocable, shall survive the
competitor’s exit from the tendering process and is royalty-free.
Language
The official language of the competition is English. All entries must be in English, including
all additional information.
Financial data
Any financial data provided must be submitted in, or converted into, pounds sterling.
Where official documents include financial data in a foreign currency, a sterling equivalent
must be provided.
Insurance
The Cadogan Estate and Malcolm Reading Consultants will take reasonable steps to
protect and care for entries but neither organisation will insure the proposals at any time.
Competitors are urged to maintain a complete record of their full entries and be able to
make this available at any time should adverse circumstances require this.
Deviations
Only submissions that meet the basic criteria of entry will be considered. Information or
supplementary material, unless specifically called for in subsequent communication, will
not be considered by the assessors.
![Page 30: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
30
Amendments to the Expression of Interest
The Cadogan Estate may, at any time prior to the submission date, amend the Expression
of Interest (EOI), and Malcolm Reading Consultants (MRC) shall notify all competitors of
any such amendments. If MRC issues any circular letters to competitors during the EOI
period to clarify the interpretation to be placed on part of the documents or to make any
changes to them, such circular letters will form part of the EOI. Accordingly, all competitors
will have been deemed to take account of these in preparing their submission.
Overseas competitors
Overseas competitors should note that, for Customs purposes, no commercial value should
be assigned to any postal or courier documentation for the EOI. This may cause your
submission to be delayed and returned to you unopened.
Site visits, photos and drawings
Competitors are welcome to visit the site, but at this stage of the competition there will be
no formal site visits.
Competition materials
All material which is submitted as part of your response to the EOI will be retained by the
Cadogan Estate and will not be returned to participants.
![Page 31: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
31
15. PQQ
Submission requirements
The Cadogan Estate has authorised Malcolm Reading Consultants to issue the following
pre-qualification questionnaire (PQQ) on their behalf as part of the tendering process for
the Cadogan Café Competition.
The PQQ should be completed for the lead consultant only.
Please answer all of the following questions. Failure to answer the questions may result
in disqualification from the process. Please ensure that your submitted answers are in the
order given, with clear indications of any appendices/supplementary information.
![Page 32: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
32
1 Organisation’s Name
2 Trading Name (if different)
3 Address of registered office
Address
Telephone
Fax
4 i. Company Number or alternative EU
registration number (if applicable)
ii. Date of registration
5 Contact name for queries in connection
with this questionnaire
Name
Position in organisation
Address
Telephone
Fax
6 Emergency Contact
Name/Number
7 Location of office likely to administer the
contract
(if different from above)
8 Status of organisation
e.g. Public limited / Private limited / Private
Sole Trader / Part of Corporate Group /
Joint Venture / Partnership / Consortium /
Other (please specify)
Organisation Details
![Page 33: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
33
9 Provide full details of any parent,
subsidiary or affiliated companies
including name and registered office
address
10 VAT Registration No.
11 Please provide a copy of your certificate
of enrolment on the professional or trade
register under the conditions laid down
by the laws of the Member State in which
you are established (for example the UK
Register of Companies) and the number
of years in business, or declaration of
oath, or solemn declaration
12 If your organisation is a company,
please list the names of your majority
stakeholders
13 Does any employee or officer of your
organisation currently have any personal
or professional connection with the
Client, or had any prior involvement with
the Client which might preclude their
eligibility for performing this contract?
[YES/NO]
If ‘YES’, please give details.
14 Please disclose any potential conflicts of
interest
e.g. contracting services or partners
associated property/construction
companies, contracts/agreements or
interest in systems or material suppliers.
![Page 34: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
34
15 If you are applying on behalf of a
consortium, please:
a. provide names, addresses and
organisation details for each consortium
member;
b. identify roughly which part(s) of the
contract each consortium member will
deliver
16 Submit a brief history of your organisation
(max. 300 words).
17 The Cadogan Estate will disqualify any
supplier at this stage who
a. is bankrupt or is being wound up, where
his/her affairs are being administered by
the court, where he/she has entered into
an arrangement with creditors, where he/
she has suspended business activities or is
in any analogous situation arising from a
similar procedure under national laws and
regulations;
b. Is the subject of proceedings for a
declaration of bankruptcy, for an order for
compulsory winding up or administration
by the court or of an arrangement
with creditors or of any other similar
proceedings under national laws and
regulations;
c. has been convicted by a judgment
which has the force of res judicata in
accordance with the legal provisions of the
country of any offence concerning his/her
professional conduct;
![Page 35: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
35
d. has committed any act of grave
professional misconduct;
e. has not fulfilled obligations relating
to the payment of social security
contributions in accordance with the legal
provisions of the UK;
f. has not fulfilled obligations relating to
the payment of taxes in accordance with
the legal provisions of the UK;
g. is guilty of serious misrepresentation in
supplying the information required under
this Section or has not supplied such
information;
h. has been the subject of a conviction for
participation in a criminal organisation;
i. has been the subject of a conviction for
corruption;
j. has been the subject of a conviction for
fraud;
k. has been the subject of a conviction for
money laundering.
Please confirm whether any of the above
applies to your organisation or its directors
or any other person who has powers of
representation, decision or control of the
Organisation.
[YES/NO]
Where the answer is ‘YES’, please provide
details.
![Page 36: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
36
Financial Details
18 Please state the name(s) and
address(es) of your banker(s). This is
only required from the lead consultant.
19 Who is the person in your organisation
to whom any financial enquiries should
be addressed?
Name
Position in organisation
Address
Telephone
Fax
20 Division Actual and Anticipated annual
turnover
Last Year 2011
Current Year 2012
Next Year 2013
21 Division Actual and Anticipated
operating profit
Last Year 2011
Current Year 2012
Next Year 2013
22 If applicable, Group Financial Annual
Turnover
2010
Last Year 2011
Current Year 2012
23 Has your organisation met the terms
of its banking facilities and loan
repayments (if any) during the past
year?
[YES/NO]
If ‘NO’ what were the reasons and what has been
done to put things right?
![Page 37: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
37
24 Has your organisation met all its
obligations to pay its creditors and staff
during the past year?
[YES/NO]
If ‘NO’ please explain why not.
25 Please provide one of the following:
a. A copy of your most recent audited
accounts (for the last 3 years if this
applies)
b. A statement of turnover, profit and
loss account and cash flow for the most
recent year of trading
Please note the Cadogan Estate will seek independent financial advice from an internet
business and consumer credit information provider to assist in its evaluation. Organisations
that are new to the market or are less than two years old are required to submit other
adequate information to demonstrate their economic and financial standing.
![Page 38: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
38
26 Detail the number of personnel currently
directly employed in your organisation which
will be directly responsible for performing this
Contract
Partners/Director
Professional Staff
[Inc. Contract Mgrs]
Company Structure
Staff Capability
27 Generally what professional qualifications and
technical experience do staff hold for the type
of work now contemplated by the Cadogan
Estate?
28 Does your organisation operate a training
policy?
[YES/NO]
If ‘YES’, please provide a copy of the
policy including the name(s) and qualifica-
tions of nominated Training Officer(s).
![Page 39: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
39
Company Policies
29 Please provide details of your
organisation’s approach to risk
assessment, a copy of your organisation’s
health and safety policy and details
of any declaration, information or
instruction issued by your organisation to
protect the health and safety of staff at
work.
30 Have any formal notices been issued
or legal proceeding been taken against
your company by the Health and Safety
Executive or the local authority enforcing
body in the last 3 years?
31 Does your organisation have a written
equal opportunities policy to avoid
discrimination?
[YES/NO]
If ‘YES’, please enclose a copy of the policy
document.
32 Does your Company have an
Environmental policy?
[YES/NO]
If ‘YES’, please enclose a copy of the policy
document.
33 Is your Company registered under ISO
14001 or equivalent?
[YES/NO]
34 Please provide details of any quality
assurance accreditation held by the
office that would be responsible for
the contract (e.g. ISO, BS, IIP etc.).
Please enclose certificates. If no formal
accreditation is held, please describe
relevant quality assurance policy and
procedures.
![Page 40: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
40
35 Please submit details of your
memberships of any other relevant
industry/trade associations, bodies etc.
36 Give details of any court cases or
legal disputes involving the company
during the last 3 years and any current
and known future court cases or legal
disputes.
37 Have you had any contracts terminated
(in whole or in part) for poor
performance in the last 3 years, or any
contracts where damages have been
claimed by the relevant client?
[YES/NO]
If ‘YES’ please give details
38 Do you have a complaints procedure? [YES/NO]
If ‘YES’ please enclose a copy. If no, please en-
close a statement detailing how your organisa-
tion deals with complaints.
39 Where applicable, would the consortium
or the ultimate holding company be
prepared to guarantee your contract
performance as its subsidiary?
[YES/NO/NOT APPLICABLE]
![Page 41: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
41
40 Please provide details of your organisation’s insurance protection.
The insurance policy should be appropriate for the services required by the Cadogan Estate
(for example public liability, employer’s liability, professional indemnity).
The selected lead consultant will be required to hold Professional Indemnity, Employers’
Liability and Public Liability cover of no less than £2 million, in order to be appointed.
Applicants without this level of insurance will, however, not be penalised at this stage
providing they are able to procure the required level of insurance if necessary. Where
details are not available, please confirm you are able to provide a broker’s confirmation in
relation to insurance cover.
There is no need to include insurance certificates at this stage.
Public Liability
Insurer
Indemnity Value
Employers Liability
Insurer
Indemnity Value
Professional Indemnity
Insurer
Indemnity Value
41 Give details of insurance claims involving
the company during the last 3 years and
any current and known future claims.
Insurance
![Page 42: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
42
Use of Information
42 Candidates must adhere to the
requirements of the Data Protection Act
1998 (the 1998 Act).
a. Does your organisation have a Data
Protection policy?
[YES/NO]
b. Is your organisation registered with the
Information Commissioner in accordance
with the 1998 Act?
[YES/NO]
If ‘YES’, what is your DPA registration number?
NB Where responding on behalf of a
consortium these details should be
provided for each consortium member.
Declaration
43 Please print off and complete Section 16, the Declaration on page 43 of this document and
enclose an electronic and hard copy with your submission.
![Page 43: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Expression of Interest Expression of InterestThe Cadogan Café Competition
43
16. Declaration
The following declaration should be completed by each team’s lead for the project. A
declaration form for each team member organisation should be provided and attached.
I / we certify that the information supplied in the questionnaire and any supporting
documents is accurate and valid to the best of my / our knowledge. I / we will
immediately bring to the attention of the Cadogan Estate any change in company
circumstances which would alter the responses given to the questions on this form. I / we
accept that my / our response is a bona fide expression of interest and that the Cadogan
Estate and its Selection Committee may rely on the information provided in my / our
response. I / we understand that false information could result in my / our exclusion from
the selection process at any stage.
I / we have no objection to the information given on this form being held in the Estate
database and being circulated to staff.
I / we confirm (please tick) that our submission includes:
1. Completed Parts 1-4 of Section 12 Submission Requirements
2. CD Rom or memory stick with PDF files (obligatory)
Signed _______________________________________________
Name ________________________________________________
Position in firm ________________________________________
For and on behalf of ____________________________________
Date _________________________________________________
![Page 44: A Chelsea Original › upload › downloads › 128xx › ... · public and civic life that occupy it. The café, the subject of this competition, is sited at the very heart of the](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042400/5f0ecd317e708231d44101bc/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)