a clifford geertz’s perspectiverevistalatinacs.org/18slcs/2018_libro/056_borges.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1032
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
The use of netnography in design research:
a Clifford Geertz’s perspective
La utilisation de la netnographie dans la recherche en design: la perspective de Clifford Geertz
El uso de la netnografía en la investigación del diseño: una perspectiva de Clifford Geertz
Virginia Borges Kistmann – Universidade Federal do Paraná – [email protected]
Abstract: Recently, designers researchers and professionals have introduced
new methods to gather consumer behavior, following the expansion of the
mediascape (Appadurai 1996). Among these, digital/virtual empirical research
based on visual anthropology has been used frequently because it is faster,
costs less, facilitates access to distant users/consumers and decreases
interpersonal contact, not always desired (Lucca 2016). In spite of these
advantages, this approach may also reduce the complexity of ethnographic
studies, since this new method is mediated by the Internet, rather than filming or
using photography, recording or deepening the description and discussion of
context in the field. This turned field research, full of rich elements, into a desk
research. Thus, it profoundly modifies the way researchers search for and
understand demands of consumers to define product concepts. It brings a new
configuration in which experience and interpretation of another reality involve
two or more individuals who may not always be even real subjects in mediation.
Considering this, this paper discusses the implications of this new method in
relation to the concepts of Geertz (1983, 1988, 1989). It seeks to consider how
netnography (Kozinets 2017) interweaves images, texts, social media sites, as
well as questionnaires and interviews, as sources of information to define
demands and product concepts (Santos et al 2018). Considering this pragmatic
tool to make evaluations on the sensitive field, this paper sheds light on the
implications associated with the integration of web-based technologies in design
ethnographic research. It explores these issues through an interpretative
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1033
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
approach in the form of an essay, highlighting the results to be considered in
the adoption of netnography as a methodological resource in the field of design.
Keys words: design methods; netnography; digital ethnography; design
management; design research; interpretative cultural study.
Resumo: Recentemente, designers e pesquisadores introduziram novos
métodos para reunir o comportamento do consumidor, seguindo a expansão do
mediascape (Appadurai1996). Dentre esses, o uso da pesquisa empírica
digital/virtual baseada na antropologia visual vem sendo usado com frequência,
pois ela é mais rápida, custa menos, facilita o acesso a usuários/consumidores
distantes e diminui o contato interpessoal, nem sempre desejado (Lucca 2016).
Apesar dessas vantagens, essa abordagem pode também reduzir a
complexidade dos estudos etnográficos, pois o novo método é mediado pela
Internet, ao invés de filmar ou usar fotografia e registrar e aprofundar a
descrição e discussão sobre o contexto no campo. Isso transformou a pesquisa
de campo, repleta de ricos elementos, em uma pesquisa documental. Assim,
de fato, modifica profundamente a maneira como os pesquisadores buscam e
compreendem as demandas dos consumidores para definir conceitos de
produtos. Traz uma nova configuração em que a experiência e a interpretação
de outra realidade envolvem dois ou mais indivíduos, os quais nem sempre
podem ser sujeitos reais na mediação. Considerando isso, este trabalho
discute as implicações desse novo método em relação aos conceitos de Geertz
(1983; 1988; 1989). Busca-se considerar como a netnografia (Kozinets 2017)
entrelaça imagens, textos, sites de midias sociais, além de questionários e
entrevistas, como fontes de informação para definição de demandas e
conceitos de produtos (Santos et al 2018). Considerando esta ferramenta
pragmática para fazer avaliações sobre o campo sensível, este trabalho lança
luz sobre as implicações ligadas à integração de tecnologias baseadas na web
na pesquisa etnográfica em design. Explora essas questões por uma
abordagem interpretativa em forma de ensaio, trazendo como destaques dos
resultados a serem considerados na adoção da netnografia como recurso
metodológico no campo do design.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1034
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Palavras-chave: métodos de design; netnografia; gestão de design; pesquisa
em design; estudos interpretativos.
1 Introduction
Design management is aims at the insertion of design in the institutions from
the managerial point of view. In this respect, the design of new products and/or
services considers the conscious or unconscious demands of consumers/users
as a starting point. The first studies towards this were developed under the
Produkt-Semantik (Steffen 2014), developed by Krippendorff (1984). From then
on, design has established design methodologies in which the central point is
the consumer/end user to help the formulation of companies’ strategies and
actions.
For Krippendorff (1984), designers need to be responsible specially for the
communicative aspects of product forms. The communication model from his
perspective would act on two levels: one, prescriptive, in which the designer
should configure a meaning reflecting potentialities of products; and another
where it should consider how the user/consumer appropriate the product, from
the cognitive point of view and this reflects in their social use.
Under the design management strategies, communication process is
considered by institutions, from human physiological, psychological aspects and
cultural characteristics. In this sense, if practical aspects related to the use of
the products were mainly related to the physiological and anthropomorphic
approaches, on the other hand, the semantics of the product led to the ones
favoring the aesthetic-formal, symbolic and symbolic aspects, related to culture.
Thus, sign issues are related to the performance of a product or systems
towards specific functions. They convert into meanings and imaginations results
from design process. With different implications from cultural aspects and
circumstances in which they are inserted, products and services are treated in
its symbolic content (Steffen 2014).
Considering these communicative aspects highlighted by Krippendorff, Steffen
(2000) states that products act as vehicles of social interaction, offering
possibilities of connection of several orders, in which details can't be determined
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1035
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
in advance. In this way, communicative processes that are established between
products and users are important for companies’ market performance.
The ideal condition from the design management point of view is the
equivalence between the emission and reception, that has as consequence the
conversion of consumer into user. Therefore, the communicative process
between products/services offered by companies and consumers/users is of
great importance for the design activity.
Produkt-Semantik, in its origin, had three main objectives: a) to know the model
of ideas and cognitive objects and the universe that circulates them from the
point of view of values; b) to verify how the forms of the products are valued,
how their need communicates with the users and what social behaviors they
provoke; c) and in which sense these products provide a material basis for new
symbolic systems (Steffen 2014). But also, in the opposite direction, the result
of the investigation of product semantics brings new influences, from a
cognitive, interpersonal and social aesthetic point of view, as new cultures are
founded, from which designers can't be disconnected. Melissa sandals in
Illustration 1, for non-gender consume, represent a kind of strategy using these
aspects.
Illustration 1. Melissa nogender sandals. Source: Estadão, 2018
With this, interest in ethnographic-based research to understand the
interactions between services and products with users/consumers has grown
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1036
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
along with this discipline. This generated new fields of research such as User
Experience Design and Human Centered Design, defined as an approach
focusing on the needs and requirements of users, enhancing effectiveness and
efficiency, improving well-being and satisfaction (Norman 2005).
But the emergence of virtual communities, their specific culture in the digital
media in the late 1980’s and the growing interest in marketing and
communication phenomena in cyberspace brought the adoption of
methodologies. Intrinsically related to this new scenario, a space in which
diverse cultures are manifested, netnography emerges as a new research
methodology, to give understanding of the cyberculture communicative process
(Kozinets et al 2018).
Broadly speaking, netnography is a type of ethnography that uses computer
mediated communications as a source of data to arrive at the understanding
and ethnographic representation of a cultural phenomenon, to understand the
behavior of consumers/users in relation to a product or service as well as to
some type of communication content (Santos et al 2018). This new approach
has been considered positive from the point of view of the companies that have
been adopting it. They highlight the fact that this new method considerably
reduces the cost of research, shortens the research time and avoids personal
contact between researcher/designer and users/consumers (ibid).
However, questions emerge considering the true contribution of this method,
since it departs from the traditional ethnography and inserts new elements in its
delineation, realization and analysis of the investigations that it produces. Thus,
this article seeks to discuss netnography from the point of view of Geertz 's
interpretive theory, who states that anthropology focusing communities or
groups of people engaged with one another turns a mere collection of
heterogeneous material into a mutually reinforcing network of social
understandings” (Geertz 1983).
Following his principles, the text leads a vision in an equally interpretative
approach, using the essayistic way.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1037
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
2. Between a pilgrim and a cartographer
Geertz (1988) expresses the etnographer as a double character: a pilgrim and a
cartographer, highlighting the challenge to interpret the complexities of
self/other negotiations. And this seems to represent also the contradictions one
should consider the netnography associated to design. Operating to understand
social behavior, actually it has the aim at a new set up, attending companies in
order to obtain profit.
Recently, the use of netnography became a frequently method in design field
(Santos et al 2018) following the first netnography propositions from market and
communication fields. As an anthropology for design, netnography has its
foundations in researches that intensify in the 1990s with the work of design
company IDEO, which turns ethnography as a design tool (Brown 2009).
As a positive result in business associated with strategic design, the example of
the Lego company is classic. Almost bankrupt in 2003, the company was able
to recover using virtual surveys to identify new markets looking for existing
digital communities. Today, from ten contracted designers, two came and
belong to virtual fan communities (Época 2018), using a collaborative
netnography. The Illustration 2 presents one of the products developed with
these communities.
Illustration 2. Lego brand product designed collaboratively with users identified in existent forums. Source: Schlosser, Kurt, 2018. Available from: https://www.geekwire.com/2018/artist-builds-lego-scene-modern-day-seattle-iconic-buildings-tents-streets/
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1038
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Branding and netnography are also interconnected elements in the equation of
design communication with their consumers (Alasse 2012). As an example, the
company Fleischman in Brazil used the combined netnography to other tools to
ascertain how the brand was being perceived by the young public regarding
their desserts. For this, it set up an Orkut community to make observation and
invited people to participate and consume the products. Based on the study,
they modified brand's positioning with new packaging and visual communication
by design.
In the same way, as in Illustration 3 below shows, Johnson and Johnson used
netnography to develop a new product. In this case, it used different
communication channels to obtain more information about their consumer (ibid).
Illustration 3. Collaborative application of Johnson and Johnson with the use of digital media of communication. Source: Mall no divã, 2018 http://mallnodiva.blogspot.com/2012/02/
In the launch of new products, through netnographic research, companies
follow the profile of defined audiences, noting their favorite hobbies and
consumption habits, identifying opportunities. With this, Coca-Cola Life, a new
design could be developed as Illustration 4 shows.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1039
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Illustration 4. Website of Coca-Cola Life, Argentina, developed from a netnography study. Source: Felizola, Matheus Pereira Mattos, 2014.
The language of the site, the predominant colors, the logo of the brand were
redesigned from the results of the online search with consumers.
Assuming that design is a communication agent in the cyber culture, its core
aspect plays an important role in relation to disciplines as the product
semantics, the netnography and the interpretative theory, since they all in
general terms rely on a semiotic approach. As such, design is inserted in a
communicational process, in which products bring in their form a history,
consumption circles, function logic and system of economic values as much as
interfere in the cultural context, creating history and affecting technology and
economy.
From these examples, the designers as pilgrims search and offer sensitive
content as much as register and limit space. As interpreters and proponents of
new realities in the face of history, traditions, human nature and worldviews,
they must be concerned with the study of their interference in the contemporary
world, relying on methods of design and stimulating reflective role.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1040
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
3. The communication space of netnography
Following Geertz (1988) when he says that anthropology is some form of
participation in the world of the other, Kozinets (2017) points out that
netnography practice:
“(...) includes participation. It includes being fully present in the data
stream, as well as being fully considered a member of a particular
cultural configuration. (…) The other is being present socially, in that
public data stream, as a voice, as social scientist who interacts with
the world, as an academic micro-celebrity, a relevant and publicly
engaged psychological researcher.” (Kozinets 2017 p. 380)
Netnography seeks to identify the behaviors in the contemporary world, through
established performances and people's ways of being, in Web-mediated
relationships. It consists of an approach that happens partially or integrally in
the virtual environment. The Web is the space from where comes most of
relations stablished between designers/companies and consumer/users, but not
the only one. It expands towards other spaces, physical or virtual.
In virtual ethnography or digital ethnography, other ways of naming this
ethnography, the conventional notion of space can be altered, due to the
distance between key informants and the researcher (Santos et al 2018). Most
of the studies are done largely without the presence of the physical locus.
To explore the extension of the field, they mention that impacts of the digital
environment gives to the physical one can be evaluate using online
questionnaires, obtaining face-to-face data from the target audience, making it
possible to contrast the real and the declared (ibid).
One can notice that, from the point of view of design, marketing or
communication, frequently a unilateral character of the use of netnography is
taken, as by producers, companies or processes. However, for Sá (2014)
cyberculture means more than the use of digital technology as just a one side
tool. It acts as a matrix of the meanings of our times, in which spaces are fluid,
deterritorialized, in which oppositions online/virtual and off-line/"real" are
questioned. She also states that, unlike the anthropological approach, where
the past consisted the research space, netnography research focuses on the
relational aspect, on what we are becoming in the future.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1041
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
In this sense, the concept of supermodernity as a producer of non-places, helps
to understand the fact that, contrary to modernity, place and non-place are
rather fleeting polarities: "the former is never completely erased, and the latter is
never fully realized palimpsests in which the shuffled play of identity and relation
is re-established without ceasing" (Augé 1994 p.74).
In this way, more than cultural description, the interpretive proposal needs to be
revised, from the point of view that in this context interpretation becomes
impermanent. Thus, for the designer, the central point in the use of netnography
could be seen as the identification of the possibilities that open up, both from
the point of view of the company, the user and the consumer, putting in check
the central point of traditional ethnographic studies, the alterity: non-place is the
space of others without the presence of others, the space constituted in
spectacle (Augé 1994). Then, an interpretive theory based upon netnography
becomes a quasi-theory. Its subject isn’t a subject but a relation.
In this respect, it seems that what is at stake in the construction of spaces and
in their own experience, which allows the acceleration of time and the
virtualization of space, is the transformation of ourselves into others, something
that we intend, but of which we do not realize it (Sá 2014). Time is no longer the
same and it is included in the design use of netnography perspective.
Space suggests action at the same time as it limits it. It is the people who
ultimately interact in the middle of this game of possibilities (Sá 2014). Non-
places are places to consume, and to create "new needs" (advertising,
information). They are the ones that characterize the supermodernity (ibid.)
If physical spaces and time are measurable, like a room or the field, one week
or one month, in virtual space, such statements are no more the focus. What is
privileged is the relationship. All layers receive, whatever they are, information.
In non-places, information is made available and often individualized (Augé
1994), creating the shared identity of individuals, consumers/users. Thus,
semiotic interpreting cybernetic culture also demands a non-research place. In
it, object and subject are blended. Company, designer, consumer, user, product
become multiple faces of a single coin. It stresses the ambivalence of traditional
ethnography (Geertz 1983).
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1042
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
On the other hand, this is linked to the concept of network that Castells
proposes, in which space organizes time and its 'spaces of flows' as a set of
advanced services, including finance, insurance, real estate, projects,
marketing, research and development, scientific innovation, etc (Castells 1999).
This reasoning is based on an interpretation of the use of netnography as a
mechanism to sustain these spaces of capital, information, technology,
organizational interaction, images, sounds and symbols. This is the opposite of
an organization rooted in time. Castells's "space of flows" (1999) would be a
place whose form, function and meaning can be considered independent within
the frontiers of physical contiguity. Therefore, to a semiotic interpretation a
cyberculture means to give meaningful structure to a space that does not rely
on a single space, or in a single time.
Sá (2014) explains that by this mechanism the existence of a "lifestyle" that is
similar throughout the whole world, what can be manifested in a design
proposes by the use of certain objects, clothes, worries, symbols of an
international culture. Unconnected to a specific society, its members, with their
different economic, social and cultural situations have great difficulty in
identifying themselves with the space they inhabit. There is a kind of
disconnection from the physical and social space where one lives. Even
cosmopolitan, the individuals remain local.
Marc Augé's "non-places" are exactly the means that allow the circulation of
everything and everyone, "are non-places, insofar as their first vocation is not
territorial, it is not to create singular identities, symbolic relations and patrimony
but rather to facilitate circulation (and thus consumption) in a world with the
dimensions of the planet "(Augé 1994 p.85), like in Illustration 5.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1043
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Illustration 5. Non-places, design subject. Source: Mercado e consumo, 2018.
Thus, one can say that the non-spaces of Augé or the spaces flows appear as a
result of the design activity, in terms of physical spaces. However, the design of
spaces of consumption, circulation and communication (Castells 1999), can
also be extend to the networked community.
But one can see also some kind of reinforcement of cultural and individual
meanings. Some studies and companies have been using the web as a co-
design space, bringing the consumer/user needs to their core competences, as
Natura company (Illustration 6).
Illustration 6. Virtual store of the company Natura in the Pintarest, a non-space where
space flows occur. Source: Cosmetic Innovation, 2018.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1044
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
In this space researcher and consumer/user communicate in a continuous
interactive process, in which the semiotic interpretation of one becomes the
semiotic interpretation of the other.
The reflexive question that derives from it is the meaningful appropriation that
each one elaborates. The pilgrim and the cartographer meet each other here
again.
4. The construction of meaning in netnography
An important question as to the ethnographer's place in virtual space is related
to the limits occupied by his members. So how to interpretate communication in
virtual media where impermanence is constant?
The geographic and spatial notions, fundamental in everyday interactional
experiences that contextualize relations differ in the netnographic approach,
since interactions are mediated by virtual environments, as a symbolic
presence, devoid of physical barriers (Herrera and Passerino 2008). In them,
the researcher leaves traces, entering and leaving community, but his words
maintain present and can be read and commented on, just as other members.
To understand this new set, one can take Geertz says:
“We need not accept hermetic views of écriture as so many signs
signing signs, (…), to see that there has come into our view of what
we read and want we write a distinctly democratical temper. (…)”
(Geertz 1983 p 20)
Thus, researcher integration between designers/researchers and
consumer/users should be considered as an open view of netnography, that
can led even to a poetic construction, as in Geertz’s Works and Lives (1988).
This network communication is constituted by a series of signs, from all parties.
Taking Augé (1994), it constitutes a "rhetorical territory, with all those who are
able to enter into their reasons, all those whose aphorisms, vocabulary and
types of argumentation compose a cosmology" (Augé 1994 p. 73). The
netnography as a participatory research, demanding deep immersion, results
“pretty much entirely on the side of ‘literary’ discourses rather than ‘scientific’
ones” (Geertz 1983 p. 8).
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1045
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Illustration 7, below, shows a prothesis cover customized by its user. Coming
from a netnographic approach, the final product offers to the users a possibility
to transform it.
Illustration 7. Three different customizations of Confeti prothesis. Source: Archtrends,
2018.
Netnography more and more includes the collaborative perspective. As seen,
netnography consists of an empirical research technique conducted on the
Internet, in which the researcher is allowed and encouraged to gradually join the
group in order to acquire knowledge and transform and improve personally and
socially (Kozinets et al 2018).
But, the distance between company and user/consumer as the distance
between researcher/research operates in a being and not being condition.
Relying on interpretative ethnography (Geertz, 1989), netnography seeks to
interpret observed facts by looking for motives and meanings. In this sense,
netnography, like ethnography, it gives importance to the commitment and
involvement of the researcher with his object of study.
While in traditional ethnographic research the technological artifact stands in
symmetry with human actors and occupies a limited and secondary role in
netnography, technology as a primary factor, as an intrinsic part of the research
process and becomes fundamental, reducing, in some cases, the importance of
visual aspects of the face-to-face approach. Moreover, the non-visualization of
all members of the group makes perceptions of everyday life less valuable,
such as clothes, gestures, personal peculiarities, which in some cases can be
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1046
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
perceived through audio and video (Abelha et al 2012). From this, derives the
instrumental character of the netnographic research used in the field of design.
In this way, both the semantics of the product and the netnography approach
are based on Geertz's (1989) interpretive theory, a semiotic approach, that
considers a multicultural world, of multiple epistemology, demands a specialist
who is able to articulate contextual relations, considering them parts against
each other, associated to culture or history, the relation of those who in some
sense builds it and its relation to the realities conceived around it (Geertz 1989).
On the other hand, it is possible to affirm that the netnography does not differ
much of the traditional ethnography, except for the way in which the immersion
and engagement of the researcher takes place. In some cases, it is said that
the researcher's look at netnography would be less invasive, causing less
interference in the process, since the ethnographer takes into account the
beliefs, ethical identity, sexual orientation etc (Abelha et al 2012). Although an
ethical dimension is considered by most designers/companies, its use is linked
to the research objective itself and does not necessarily advance an ideological
or ecological question.
With respect to the future development of this ethnographic approach, Kozinets
(2017) says that when moving from:
small data to big data, of mass to niche data, of commercial to
scholarly focused, and of the visual to textual, leads us to
conceptualize a range of different relationships to collected and
created data which depend upon assuming different participative and
empiricist perspectives. (Kozinets 2017 p.380)
Other advantages observed in the use of netnography are the ease of
searching and collecting data, the breadth of collection and storage (in time and
space) that can be done through blog posts, for example, and the possibility of
unfolding the research, quickly. We can also consider the fact that interviews
are transcribed (Abelha et al, 2012) According to Primo (2015), social platforms
that operate from custom algorithms and other data mining techniques are built
to obtain information that has monetary value because they represent concepts
and values of users that leave digital traces "and talk about our interests, our
tastes, our relationships, our life stories" (Primo 2015 p. 69). In netnography, the
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1047
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
data are easily extracted, in great proportions, at reduced cost and diminishing
time, through a communication mediated by computers, with richness for the
analysis.
In the case of messages written in forums, emails, mailing lists and blogs, for
example, because they are written texts, there is the possibility of constructing a
narrative or elaborating an opinion without being interrupted by breaking the line
of reasoning. In addition, the text can be better elaborated (Herrera and
Passerino 2008).
It is also worth noting that even with closed environments, messages from
forums and blogs can be accessed, creating a new notion of time and presence
(Mozo, 2005), since the netnographer does not have to be present online the
participants of your research. In addition, the use of emoticons, from upper case
to "loud talk", and onomatopoeia indicating humor, playfulness, such as
hahahaha, kakakakaka, kkkk, and punctuation marks such as exclamation,
questioning and ellipsis, contribute to the manifestation of values, and should be
part of the netnographic interpretative process. As “(…) ‘life is a text’ proponents
incline toward the examination of imaginative forms: jokes, proverbs, popular
arts. (…) (Geertz 1983 p. 33).
In netnography, it is said that the same action is practiced, although there
remains doubt as to the identity of the informant (KONIZETS, 2002). But it does
not differ much from traditional ethnography, where “(…) People use
experience-near concepts spontaneously, un-self-consciously, as it were
colloquially; they do not, except fleetingly and on occasion, recognize that there
are any ‘concepts’ involved at all” (Geertz 1983 p. 58).
As for the question of the identity of the respondents, it is suggested that
traditional triangulation of data with data collection with photos, video and audio
would be necessary, since accurate observation, prolonged engagement, good
interview techniques and the introspection of the researcher themselves
contribute for data validation.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1048
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
6. From entrée to conclusion: a subtle movement
Linked to the world of the nineteenth century, confronted with distant cultures,
ethnography still retains today its sight to the other, the stranger, seeking, by
means of immersion in the group, to understand cultural meanings. Classically,
it comes from a process of estrangement of the researcher when confronted
with new cultural aspects and behaviors of distant societies. But, in the case of
netnography applied to design, designer and/or company seek to understand
how a certain group considers certain values, either to reinforce them or to
introduce new ones. In some cases, the strangeness is very subtle.
According to Abelha et al (2012), netnography can be used in three main ways:
1) as a methodology for studying cybernetic cultures and virtual communities; 2)
as a methodological tool to study cybernetic cultures and derived virtual
communities; and 3) as an exploratory tool to study topics in general. It is also
associated with 4.0 business netnography, leading to the strengthening of
startups, providing innovation. So, intrinsically the use of social networking
became a daily attitude in companies to stimulate internal and external
collaboration at low cost, making these tools accessible even to the smallest
companies in the market. In addition, they can increase the effectiveness of
organizational strategies, improve the area of R & D, knowledge management
and viral marketing.
Acting as a platform for the dissemination of values, approaching its consumers,
it causes the initial diminishing of difference, including the users/consumers as
members of company’s culture. Thus, unlike ethnographic studies, that can help
preservation of differences, in netnography the quest for the reduction of
difference is its ultimate goal. It thus becomes an approach not only interpretive,
but collaborative and, beyond, persuasive.
As an example of this double function can be observed in user forums, as well
as online research with consumers. In them, the distance is ubiquitous. It is
present and at the same time distant. In some case culture is pasteurized,
insofar as in offering new products the distance is reduced, the intention is
equated with the proposition.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1049
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
In its origin, ethnography starts from a private, detailed and deeply explored
observation, established in a direct, participant and critical way, in which it
constructs, from the phenomenological data, the conception of the world of its
members. In netnography, by shortening time due to market needs. Some time,
results are treated in an intuitive way, coming closer to the driven innovation
(Verganti, 2012), in which the perception of vague behavioral signals can help
in proposing innovations that will be adopted by future users/consumers.
So, as Geertz points out, “(…) the various disciplines and quasi-disciplines that
make up the arts and sciences are, for those caught up in them, far more than a
set of technical tasks and vocational obligations; they are cultural frames in
terms of which attitudes are formed an lives conducted. (…)” (Geertz 1983 p.
14). In this sense, by simplifying the structure of tasks, it allows intuition in
action, makes things visible, keeps pace with activities, and embraces and
exploits the limitations of the system. The “(…) move toward conceiving of
social life as organized in terms of symbols (…) whose meaning (…) we must
grasp if we are to understand that organization and formulate its principles, has
grown by now to formidable proportions” (Geertz 1983 p. 21), following the
mediascape expansion (Appadurai, 1996).
The use of anthropology as a mode of investigation of these non-places (Augé
1994), which configure the constantly changing virtual spaces, has been
questioned in its capacity to apprehend complex societies. Thus, unlike the
traditional ethnographic approach, in which the object of study could almost be
lived by the researcher, in netnography this does not seem to happen. The
romantic view, often present in the field of design, having the designer a role to
fulfill the gaps of consumer/user desires becomes critical in this approach.
For the future, with the possibilities that the big date and that artificial
intelligence, more emphatically, the prospects of using netnography as a tool for
design becomes even more critical, as Kozinets points out. But, by the data and
the way to appropriate it, by the commercial use, by the consumer/user gratuity
data supply (Primo 2015), as well as by the possibility of establishing speeches
not feasible, not always clear interests, as Illustration 8, shows.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1050
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Illustration 8: Fake news e real news in 2018 Brazilian election campaign Source:
Metro 1, 2018.
It is thus part of the future perspective netnography, for design as perhaps for
many other fields, to observe more the relations than to focus on technical
knowledge. Now to solve its subtle ethical dimension may be the most important
issue.
7. References
ALASSE, Letícia, 2012. Netnografia se consolida como ferramenta estratégica.
Mundo do Marketing. [Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://www.mundodomarketing.com.br/reportagens/digital/22990/netnografia-
se-consolida-como-ferramenta-estrategica.html
APPADURAI, Arjun, 1996. Modernity at large : cultural dimensions of
globalization. Mineapolis: Universtiy of Minnesota Press, 1996. ISBN 0-8166-
2792-4
ARCHTRENDS, 2018. Democratizar a autoestima. [Acessed 10 November
2018] Avaiable from: https://archtrends.com/blog/en/democratizar-a-autoestima/
AUGÉ, Marc, 1994. Nao-lugares: introducao a uma antropologia da
supermodernidade. [Acessed 10 November 2018] Campinas: Papirus. ISBN
85-306-0291-8 pp. 70-105
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1051
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
ABELHA, Daniel et al, 2012. A Netnografia e a Analise de Comunidades
Virtuais: um Estudo de Caso Aplicado Aos Discentes da Ufrrj. Proceedings.
Simpósio de Excelência em Gestão e Tecnologia. [on line] [Acessed 10
November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://www.aedb.br/seget/arquivos/artigos12/45616486.pdf
BROWN, Tim, 2009. Change by design: how design thinking transforms
organizations and inspires innovation. 2009. New York, Harper Collins, 2009.
ISBN 978-0-06-176608-4.
CASTELLS, Manuel, 1999. A sociedade em rede. Vol. 1. São Paulo: Paz e
Terra, 1999. ISBN 85-219-0329-4
COSMETIC INNOVATIONS, 2018. Pintrest e Natura se juntam no mundo
digital. [Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from :
https://www.cosmeticinnovation.com.br/pinterest-e-natura-se-juntam-no-mundo-
digital.
ÉPOCA, 2018. Após quase falir, Lego se reinventa e conquista o maior lucro de
sua história. [Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://epocanegocios.globo.com/Informacao/Acao/noticia/2015/07/apos-quase-
falir-lego-se-reinventa-e-conquista-o-maior-lucro-de-sua-historia.html.
ESTADÃO, 2018. Como a moda sem gênero vai afetar o guarda-roupas
masculino. [Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://emais.estadao.com.br/blogs/a-moda-deles/como-a-moda-sem-genero-
vai-afetar-o-guarda-roupas-masculino/
GEERTZ, 1983. Local Knowledge: further essays in interpretative anthropology.
New York: Basic Books, 1983. ISBN 0-465-04162-0
_______, 1988. Works and lives: the anthropologist as author. Satanford:
Stanford University Press. ISBN 0-8047-1747-8
_______, 1989. A interpretacao das culturas. Rio de Janeiro: LTC, 1989. ISBN
978-85-216-1333-6
Felizola, Matheus Pereira Mattos, 2014. Estudo netnográfico do lançamento da
Coca-Cola na Argentina e sua relação com o debate ambiental. Tríade. Revista
de Comunicação, Cultura e Mídia. [on. Line] v.2 n. 4. Narrativas midiáticas.
Uniso. p. 185-199. [Acessed 10 November 2018].
HERRERA, Miguel Hexel; PASSERINO, Liliana Maria, 2008. Estigma e
ciberespaco: desafios da netnografia como metodologia para pesquisa de
redes tematicas na blogosfera. RENOTE - Revista Novas Tecnologias na
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1052
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
Educacao [on line] July v. 6 n. 1, 2008. Acessed 10 November 2018] ISSN
1679-1916 Avaiable from: http://seer.ufrgs.br/renote/article/view/14396.
KOZINETS, Robert, 2017. Netnography: Radical participative understanding for
a networked communications society. In: Willig, Sara and Rogers, Wendy
Stainton. [on line] The Sage handbuch of qualitative research in psychology.
[Acessed 10 November 2018] ISBN 978-1-4739-2521-2. pp 374-380. Sage,
2017. Avaiable from: https://books.google.com.br/books?hl=pt-
BR&lr=&id=AAniDgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA374&dq=KOZINETS,+Robert.+Net
nography:+Radical+participative+understanding+for+a+networked+communicat
ions+society.&ots=dnk1joycG2&sig=wtPTcsdnHb7_LvcDO5cGRfPtTNs#v=one
page&q=KOZINETS%2C%20Robert.%20Netnography%3A%20Radical%20part
icipative%20understanding%20for%20a%20networked%20communications%2
0society.&f=false
KOZINETS, Robert et al, 2018. Evolving netnography: how brand auto-
netnography, a netnographic sensibility, and more-than-human netnography can
transform your research. Journal of Marketing Management. 2018. [Acessed
on line] v. 34 n. 3-4, p. 231-242. Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0267257X.2018.1446488.
KRIPPENDORFF, Klaus, 1984. Die Produkt-Semantik öffent die Turen. Form:
Zeitschrift fur Gestaltung. [on line] 2018. 108/109 p. 14-16. [Acessed 10
November 2018] Avaiable from: http://repository.upenn.edu/asc_papers/236.
LUCCA, André de Souza, 2016. A etnografia rápida no metaprojeto de design
para o território. Florianópolis, e-Revista LOGO. [on line] [on line] Florianópolis,
v. 5 n. 1, 2016, p- 23-36. Acessed 10 November 2018] ISSN 2238-2542
MALL NO DIVÃ, 2018. Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
http://mallnodiva.blogspot.com/2012/02/
MERCADO E CONSUMO, 2018. Os novos playeres dos shopping centers.
Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://www.mercadoeconsumo.com.br/2015/12/11/os-novos-players-dos-
shopping-centers/
METRO 1, 2018. Agora foi longe demais: PT nega que Pabllo Vittar seja vice
de Lula. [Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from :
https://www.metro1.com.br/noticias/politica/59316,agora-foi-longe-demais-pt-
nega-que-pabllo-vittar-seja-vice-de-lula.html.
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1053
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
MOZO, Ana Maria Galvez, 2005. Sociabilidad in Pantalla. Um estudio de la
interacion em los entornos virtuales. AIBR- Revista de Antropologia
Iberoamericana. [on line] Madrid, n. especial, nov./ dic. 2005. Acessed 10
November 2018] Avaiable from:
http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=62309916
Cosmetic Innovation, 2018. Pintrest e Natura se juntam no mundo digital.
[Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https://www.cosmeticinnovation.com.br/pinterest-e-natura-se-juntam-no-mundo-
digital/
NORMAN, Donald, 2005. Human-centered design considered harmful.
Interactions. [on line] Jul-Aug 2005. p. 14. [Acessed 10 November 2018]
Avaiable from:
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Donald_Norman/publication/200086092_H
umancentered_design_considered_harmful/links/0c9605208fca197c2e000000.
pdf.
PRIMO, Alex, 2015. A grande controversia: trabalho gratuito na Web 2.0.
[Acessed 10 November 2018] Avaiable from:
https//s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/38005249/Capítulo_Alex_
Primo_-__performances-interacionais-
miolo.pdf?AWSAccessKeyld=AKIAIWOYYGZ2Y53UL#A&Expires=1539963255
&Signature=du6813vM6NkSyPYqzZRMr0CuUiY%3D&response-content-
disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DA_grande_controversida_trabalho_grat
uito.pdf.
SÁ, Tereza, 2014. Lugares e não lugares em Marc Augée. Tempo social. [on
line] v.26, n.2, pp.209-229. [Acessed 10 November 2018] ISSN 0103-
2070Avaiable from: http://www.scielo.br/pdf/ts/v26n2/v26n2a12.pdf
SANTOS, Aguinaldo dos et al, 2018. Etnografia. In: Seleção do método de
pesquisa: guia para pós-graduandos em design e áreas afins. Insight. p. 110-
117. ISBN 978-85-62241-46-8
SCHLOSSER, Kurt, 2018. Lego brand product designed collaboratively with
users identified in existent forums. [Acessed 0 November 2018] Available from:
https://www.geekwire.com/2018/artist-builds-lego-scene-modern-day-seattle-
iconic-buildings-tents-streets/
STEFFEN, Dagmar, 2000. Design als Produktsprache : der ‘Öffenbacher
Ansatz’ in Theorie und Praxis. Verlag Form. ISBN 3-931317-34-X
Comunicación y música: mensajes, manifestaciones y negocios Universidad de La Laguna, diciembre de 2018
SBN-13: 978-84-16458-93-6/ D.L.: TF-799-2018 / DOI del libro: 10.4185/cac144 Página | 1054
Libro colectivo enlínea: http://www.revistalatinacs.org/18SLCS/libro-colectivo-2018.html
STEFFEN, Dagmar, 2014. Design als Produktsprache: Einfuhrung. [Acessed
10 November 2018,
Lucern University of Applied Arts. [on line] PDF. [Acessed 10 November 2018]
Avaiable from: https://blog.hslu.ch/product/files/2014/03/Psp_MA1_2014.pdf
VERGANTI, Roberto, 2012. Design driven Innovation: mudando as regras da
competição. São Paulo: Canal Certo, 2012.