a combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for...

18
A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT AND REUSE IN COLD CLIMATE CONDITIONS C. Kinsley, K. Kennedy, A. Crolla 1

Upload: phunghanh

Post on 06-Sep-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED

FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT AND

REUSE IN COLD CLIMATE CONDITIONS

C. Kinsley, K. Kennedy, A. Crolla

1

Page 2: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Introduction

• Septage - accumulated sludge in septic tanks

• ~1.2x106 septic systems in Ontario (860 000

m3/yr) • 60% applied directly to agricultural land

• 40% co-treatment at WWTP

• Ontario Ministry of Environment is committed to

phasing out the land application of untreated

septage

2

Page 3: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Reed Beds• Variation on drying bed

design

• Sludge is dewatered and composted in one step

• Plants provide many benefits: • roots create drainage pathways

• plant movement and growth breaks sludge cake

• plants absorb water from sludge

• oxygen transfer to the plant roots assist in the stabilization and mineralization of the sludge.

3

Page 4: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Combined Reed Bed-Freezing Bed Field Study

4

Reed Bed Filters Unplanted Filter

Experimental Variables• Solids Loading Rate (42-144 kg TS/year)

• Hydraulic Loading Rate (1.9-5.9 m/year)

• Planted vs unplanted

• Season (T, Precip)

Page 5: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT
Page 6: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT
Page 7: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

7

Page 8: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Treated Effluent Irrigation

8

Page 9: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Plant Development

Page 10: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Experiment 1: Effect of SLR on Drainage

10

Page 11: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Experiment 1: Effect of SLR on Drainage

11

Page 12: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Experiment 2: Effect of Plant Growth on Drainage

12

Page 13: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Design Loading Rate

• Subtract ponded water from May-Nov from hydraulic

loading.

13

Year Design Hydraulic Loading Rate (mm/d)

SF RB1 RB2

2007 8.4 8.5 9.5

2008 8.4 8.2 8.8

2009 10.8 7.1 8.1

Avg. ± SD 9.2±1.4 7.9±0.7 8.8±0.7

Design Hydraulic Loading Rate = 8.6±0.7 mm/d or 2.9 m/y or 75 kg/m2/y

Page 14: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Experiment 3: Effect of Hydraulic Load on Drainage

14

Page 15: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Filtrate Quality

15

Significant effect of Period for COD, TSS, TN and TP was observed

(P<0.05), while no effect for Year (P>0.05) was observed.

Page 16: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Dewatered Sludge Quality

• Similar nutrient and solids content to solid dairy manure

• Metals and E.coli meet biosolids standards

16

Page 17: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Acknowledgements

• Ontario Ministry of Environment

• Canadian Water Network

• René Goulet Septic Tank Pumping

• Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation

• Eastern Ontario Water Resources Committee

17

Page 18: A combined reed bed and freezing bed filter for …uest.ntua.gr/swws/proceedings/presentation/02.C.Kinsley.pdf · A COMBINED REED BED AND FREEZING BED FILTER FOR SEPTAGE TREATMENT

Thank you!www.orwc.uoguelph.ca