a critical assessment of don marquis' anti-abortionistargument · a critical assessment of don...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-Abortionist Argument
Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi
Abstract:After briefly reviewing the philosophical controversy on abortion. I will introduce Don Marquis' "fu
ture-like-ours" argument and its various critiques. Marquis insists that (J) it is seriously immoral to kill
us because killing deprives us of our valuable futures, and (2) a human fetus has a future like ours, there
fore (3) it is seriously immoral to kill a human fetus. His argument is very simple but plausible. and not
easy to rebut. Possible objections to his argument are (J) an objection from negligence of the women's
viewpoint. (2) a rududio ad absurdum objection from contraception. (3) an objection from metaethical
analysis of "loss" and "deprivation", (4) an objection from personal identity and non-similarity of a fetus
and us, and (5) a metaethical objection from relation of value and desire. I argue that objection (5),
which relies on the desire account of value. is most powerful, if we are to account for modifications and
qualifications of "desire". such that desire should be interpreted as "dispositional desire" and desires
should be "rational and well-informed". But these objections also have a significant burden of philosophi
cal justification.
~~'*'ti'Jt::. t 0bQ;g~~rD9J1!jK.0t"'(It, IEr"'.!
L'lt, ~ A 'J '/(f) r~~'*'ti'J(f)m~j (Thomson.
1971), ~? - Y-(f) r~~tpti'Jc~~l:JI'.f&Lj
(Tooley, 1972), :!O.t 0:'./ '/ ji-(f) r~~.l1(f)1tflJlillJ
(Singer, 1979, 1993) L'(f)~~iJ;3F'ffit::.1'i~L'iI;
Q. LiJ'L, IE~L'~•• t~~(iJ·~~~tpti'J~
-S-i!-jt~.nJ1;:(~~~.n-n'Qt.:.lJ:>iJ·, ~.nJ;J.~~(f)
m~~~~(*~~~tp~~~~~QU~(f)b(f)
iJ·.-t:5H::.tIllM~.n-n't.ct'.t?t::',~,b.n7.> ". *ili'i
L'ltL~L~rQW(f).*.~~~~tpti'J~j
(Strong, 2008) c ~.nQ 7-'\>.A(f) rtJ:-tf~f~tp
ti'J1;l:.'l'iElfRjtJ:(f)iJ.j (Marquis, 1989) ~m1f L t.:.J:
L', ~.nt::.~~QJlt*II~tIlINLt.:.t'.
.t ( ~fJ~.n -C t, Q .t ? t::., ~*L'11~~tp~(f)1:'9
tmft~1'flI16alill~(f)tJ:iJ'L'~ ~., c ~.t (~~~.n,
~ L t 'i'ai«'(f)~t::. tJ:" -C t, Q '7 - 7 (f)-0L'iI; Q.
~f~r.p~t::.~~Q~~lff«(f)~il1Ii(f)~( It~*~tUii
ilt!L'iI;Q. ~.n~-A\l:t::'~(f).t?tJ:Jf~~c Q.
I. AI:JI~f&~'::c 11'l'lEL';f.,7.>.
2. IJaYi'.11Ara9L';f.,Q.
3. ~.n.p*-, IJa~I'.~f&~~f~9'~I;l:.'l'lEL'iI;Q.
.t (~J~.nt.:.r,iJlWc L -C, rJJ€l~I'.I;l:.t'0iJ·~Ardl
t.c(f)tJ.j c t'? r~iJl ~1~9J.!!jj iJ;;f.,7.>. ~ «(f)~~
• 19 •
![Page 2: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
~M~••~. M~t~~~~MKlt~.~-.~
51 < .: UJ;-C'!!<t.. ~·~t:.tJ,,:;. MYclt:l'l:fi'i~~~I~}!i:
tJ' ':; AJ~~ -e i!; ;;, t ~. ? !~IJl' ~ t ;;, 0
.: ? U-: f!?:';j:.~ f.&iMli It - JI.~ t .: .c:d)· t.. 'J fJl.j.<f
tJtJ;i!;;;,t-:lb. ~fWi<~M~~l~K.J:..,-C (i!;;;'Ht..;. 1''''';,- f
c0~tJ;i!;;h.li~·-::>-e~) r.ti&:"';h.;;' t~:~T;;' y"." <t ..... { ;..
7/L--?~tR$it~~Rlt'"i ""i t..:iE~11::~;1;\;;"HTt ..
b"";;,~,z.t.. ~·o -'t~~i~~*5.lIJT;;' t. (I) I· 1>.-;
:/~J:? K.• :i<i'l~m'fIJt'Jill'C~m'fIJU:;)fffi.T;;' ~
~t;;"~L. :i<i'l~m~~.~T;;,.:t~~~LJ:
? t T;;' ~~. (2) I- ? - Y - -? 7 ... v:/ (Warren,
197:3) ii> ~ J: ? IC rV- U ~~~~5t:lfrT;;'': tiC
J:.., -C. IJill'CItrRAll c~il\!~J'J':Jj1!l{lLIH..,n·t..
~< t H~IDE L J: ? tT;;' ~~. (3);0 11-~J: ?
P;lJ'fIJ~il'iiJ'J':Jt.. j!bffl~~U!il"I~;-:!ITICJ:;;' ~ ~ (Singer,
1993) ;;;). ~.=: :f1[ilc t.. ;;, 0
1-1>.-;:/K~."';h.;;'~i'l~m5t~~~K.T;;'
m'fIJlcii!F,z. ;;'ilff1:lil~iiil:*~iltt\';\lt. v -( 7'IC J: ;;'~f
Wi<-? m~~~7EIU)'fJ'b;;,ItEWi<~J:? t.. ffiYii6t..~l
~~~l1li. m~~,l1J'~IC)tfT ;;,m'fIJtJ;'Jill'C~~E1fI;
IC)tfT ;;, m'fU J: 'J ,'i'; IC.~T;;' t ±5~T ;;, ~ Iti!ft L
~< t. it-:. IJill'Clcltm~~,l1J'1*~m~·;;, CiHfAl
J'J':J) tffi'fUtJ;i!;;;' t ~~T;;' .: t It (c}' t.. < t ~ -1l1\~V-Uct ..,-Clt) T5tfiJ{jgIC,,;!;,,b;h.;;';: t -ei!;;;'o
m~-?IJill'C~tffi'fIJf/'c~ J: "> t.. ~ ~fNtm I]fJ t~· ">
bl1-elt t.. ~· ~t:' f)' ,:;, ';f.·ICm~~m'fI]tJ".~T Q
~t:'U)'. i!;;;'Ht. IJil~lc~m~o)%i*~iil!,,>tffi
'fUIHJ:~·~t:'t jllJjj~ L -C L i ? .: t l,tiMli}A\~J&lct..
..,-CLi ?:to-'t;h.tJ;i!;;;'o Lt.:.tJ;..,-C, J:ic~J:?
t.. ffiYii6t..~~~~~·t-:~fWi<~Mlct-:~· L -CIt I- 1>.-;
:/ ':; ~ilff1iMliltT7}i'illtJt .. ~ ~-eIH.. ~·o
-1L 7 ... v :/ {' I- ? - Y- ':; IC J: .., -CfJHll t<;h.
t~M~r.t$T;;'~iMliKJ:;h.li. M~lti~fV-t
(I' - -; :/) J -ei!;;;' t-:Ib~<I6,~~iLI:-ei!; ;;'M:~{' EI
c%!:~~~ ..,n·t.. ~·~t:'tJ'':;it:' fv-tJ -ei!;Q
t IH' ,z. f. -'t;h. t9' ,z./iltA t 15] L: J: ? t..il\!~(I'JJtIlilL
{'tffi'fIJlt ~.., -C~.;;, t IH·,z. tJ:~' t t< ;h.;;, 0 .: ~1lI!
~j',&f,~~m-( '/ I-~. 1!t~<;j:.~~~~lcML-C. fA
fal (:to J: V' -'t ~ JJill'c) ~!Jt 5.lIWh· T ;;, :U.E EI3 IH.. IC
tJ'J f!Jtlc[YJ¥J.J t ~illl~'ltRf)'J t~· "> r.~I~·~-::>!!<
-::>11;;,.:tKi!;;;'o ~M~M.~••~a4~. ~
-l.f~~:f1[i t L -C ~Aralt:'11 tJ;!JtJ)IJ tJ::ilHAHI'Jl1!l!J'L~ ~
-::> ~tJ, ~TI:IDET;;' ;: t tJ"i!ft U <. t ICi!;;;' 0 ArhliJ;
il\!~!(fJlc!JtJ)11 tdcll'D.~<16'~ t T;;' l'dlE13 tJ\ iiilcArJ]
ItAlhlt:'iJ·':;J t~·?.: t -ei!;;h.li. -'t;h.ltijU.. ;;,
11\:5)IJ {,ifaJl. t 15Jffl:~ ~ ~ -e L tJ' t.. ~.:to -'t;h. tJ;i!; ;;, 0
AltJJltAINlt:.tJ,,:;!JtJ)IJt:.. t~·.., t-:llliEl3lt. t-: t,z.
lilUl~~{,A1ill~ J: ? t..il\!f!.1J'J':JK_m:~-et..~·!Jt~~
JfI ~. -C!Jt:@~ :/ IL- - 7'~A ,< t:'I1~!JtJ)IJ1Jl. U-: 'J ilk
5)IJ U-: 'J T;;' .: t t 7<:!!< t..illlHH.. ~·o U-:tJ;.., -C.
b;h.b;h.ltiji t.. Q~~1lI!~illl~ ·t-:11-e~ t.. <. AfJj
t it!! ~!lYJ¥J.J~IHJlci!; Qil\!~J'J':JICm:~ tJ:illl~' ~ JI. ~ ·t:.
T <16'~ tJ;i!; ;;, 0 '" ~ t.. 11;h.1;! i!; ':; tJ' C-Ib AfJJJ;)J'l-~
!lYJ~~~1fI;~Alhl J: 'J ~ fiIfiif!!iJ" t.. ~· t ;tNjIM.. < fJ1)fJ~
L-CLi?4~~~mL-C:to'J. f1ll!iIk~J K:to
't:> ~ • .., -C ~. Q .: t/U.. ;;, 0 -'t L -C :to -'t ':; < !lYJ~ t A
I~~t ~*!!< < 5tI1Q:iEi~J'J':Jlc:!fI~t..illlHt. %!:~{'
~~~tJ. -'tL-C~c%!:~~c-ei!;;;,t~b;h.Qo
TQtM~~~~.~.tl5J••tJ·-'t;h.~~~.~
{',';!'.~~tJ Lf)'~'"n·t..~·~-e. Illi:At I5J L: J: ?
t..mWt ~.., n·t.. ~· t~,z. ':;;h.Qo
;:~Y-(~~.iMli~i!ft4~--::>lt.M~~~-e~
<~~y~ ~ i Ut!! ~lIiH~L. t IffJ./Jl' iJ·-'t ;h.J;),~~M:
~1il{',';!;',01&·til§JJ LtJ·~.., n·t..~.~-e. ~-?'t-t.. c~
lI~i~Ll:WHJl:T ~ t tJ;f;!r-~ "';h.;;' ~ t.. ':; Ii. -'t;h.J;),~
~~:~{'!;!!,~fjgtJ LiJ'~ t-:t"~'~~l'CHJl:T': t ~
ii'!'$ "';h. -C L i "> t ~. ? fJjllj'j-C' i!; Q ;,) 0 ~.., t llli~~
B';JlcmiJiU t.. nfJJij'jlt. b;h.b;h.lt%!:~~9<.., t-: 'J. fill
!lYJ(J"Jlcill\1;L L -C ~ ·t-: 'J L -C. M:~{' mc.~~9<..,
-C ~ ·t-: ') EI 'l}tJ;~tr«!!< ~ ~~!i'! i t.. ~.,: t tJ;i!; Q
~, -'t~~~~il\!~J'J':J~.~M.-ei!;'J-::>~I1.il\!
fl!1(rJJ1!lilL{'tffi'fIJ~9<bt"~·~IH..-l.fiJ·t~·? .: tiC
~,z. tJ: 11;h.lit.. ':; t.. ~· t ~. ? ;: t -e i!; Qo t-: t ,z.li
I-? - Y -It, fi!;QA~XIC)c:tTQm'fUtJ;i3(~",
;h. "> ;;, ~It. -'t~A¥J.JtJ', X~1iX;j( Ln· Q .i:j;J~t:' ~j
-et.. <. ~-FO)5k{*tJ;t..~;h.(i-'t~AltlJl.tEX ~iiX
;j( L n ·t-: -e i!; 6 "> t ~.,z. Q ij;l~ ~ ~tr 0 -'t~5ki~:
t l;t. (i)-'t~ A~iJ;jm1llJB':Jt..~&ij~9<..,t-=lX!~lci!;
Q. (ii)-'t~A~iJ;lJl.tE~:~~9<..,-C~.;;,. (iii)-'t~A
¥J.Jlt XO)!J.:!lo ~iiX;j(T Q J: ? ~i'l'~ 11 ':;;h.n· Q.
t~·? ~~-ei!;QJ (Tooley. 197L. p.4S) t~·..,t-:
~~~~m:@~W<Kei~. ~-l.f':~J:?~m:@
t;;!hLiJ·;h.;;, ~ fJ' ~-r5tlcitlI.~T;;' .: t Ita L c": t
~~Ib-C~'Qo ~ L. ~·ilJl.IC%!:~~~..,-Cc·t.. c·
• 20 •
![Page 3: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
O',l: {>lI\1gt vn, ,<"J-,l: b l&:K.@'W: C 'ClJ:~z- (,-:>
,t ? K.t.l: :<, 1J' iC> ill*"Ali¥JK.lli~ t.l: I<) t.: t L' ':>t.:illt IjfJ >d:'
1JII k.:<' t.l: iC> 1;1:- IIf'i 'JC. b jib' iC>fft~{> 13 C:t!.~Z- b
0,t?~~:<'I<)~b·iC>.A,l:~C,t?~.?«~~
,l: L'? 13UiUb,nrfJl§b'b Utt.l:L'.
.: ? U~Jl(I,<i:i >d:'13'.7t-t.l:b\ iC> b, ~1'*f!£f~:Jt.l:'m~-f:TVI
r.:~I<)il';I"t':C'It, ':? U~ fO',l:J ~~I<)5ttrrb'
iC>*~>d:'.e~:<'~~:<'~.fl~.~~M.>d:'~{>
Cc~k.~~*~>d:'T-~C'il';:<',l:~k.:<'.~k~
~~,l: --:> C l<)illHIIiII, t: I<),t ? ~~ C c f:fill~5JIJJ z-@
~C~ffiiC>~'JC.~b~A,l:~~l<)m~i¥J~&Z-e~
7.>~.H'\HH~ 7.> b', C'il'; 7.> ,l:~ k. iC> n 7.> •
2 ?-~A~ rpnpnc~~~*J ~
~~ijij
':?Ck~.I<)~b·C'~~·7-~~ffilOO9.
b"'J1\l!±l U~mfU)(fl, ~~*f!£fI9t.l:il6trJ!Q.\b'iC>, -Jil.~7.>
U~'ffi I~ illt~\Hf) t.(~~ * ~R:tt l<)1lNmfU z-J1\l!±l C c t:l:§ >d:'fG V't~o -t l<)~il6l;1<)11H1HI~~'ffiI~ '-" ~ 7' I~ c" il';
7.>. ijij;1!fl:~-hli~l<),t ? ~~tJ::<'.
I. f:>!:Ab\T-~C'il';7.>l<)fl, fI!i~~b'iC>bnbn
t~C~~il';7.>~*z-~?k~C'il';7.>o
2 (~'Ij~ t.() JIf'i l'Cf:l:bnbn,l: ~ CfiUi(i!iil'; 7.>:t;1
*Z-b --:>cl,'7.>.
3 -tn~k., ~'JC.>d:'.~':,l:ltbnbn>d:'.~
':,l:,l:t--:>k<~C~t:.*~T-~C'il';7.>.
.: l<)~mfUl:I:, bnbnl<)!? < l<)illffi.i¥JOOlfll!,l: ~it
ff.JC'il';:<,o iiIrh';. 7tI:l:bnbn~~,l: --:>cM,I,'bl<)C'
il';~, t1AI:l:T-~C'il';:<'. Cb,UHf-t?t.(l<)t':6
? b',l: 7-~:A f:l:F"'? 7tb"'M,c"il'; ~, .Ab"'T-~
t.( I<) 1:1:, ii' ~~ -tntM'i'fJi'j z- lj- k. 7.> b' iC> C'11tJ: 1,'. b
C-t? t.( iC> Ii. 'i!fji'i'i t.( < .~t.( iC> IH9:AIF1'.lE c"l:I:
tJ:I,·,l: 1,' ? .: ,l: I~ tJ: ~ b·b t.(1, 'b' iC> C'il'; 7.>. 7 - ~
:A11~1<),t? ~~-g?
hhhhf:l:. hhhh t3 tn::. 0L' L IDl'l,' ID t.l:" nij
jIU"c,!lillt <>.: t n'--r:i! 0 0 'thliTt.eh~, <hh
hh ~;litT': t li'FJE --r: <60) g,? jo'lIh'<60 0
&ID~••~_.IDRre'tht3.~ &~;Iit~
h 0': t ~'FJE~::'To hft--r:lit.e "0 &1,-,<t."",B',
1of.i>~*9<T o!iliJll, &Ii, ;Iit~ ht.efthli:fi1*1D
t',IDD-t!:: V(ID~Ii5~tlllJi11:L."n'1~tJ'>(,l-ht.e"
1i5!IiJJ~Hiilli~iQ<l-.l;. t.e!::" IDT'" -C ~9<., -C l- "H'.
l-k~"L, &~7th~ &ID:fi1*K~To~.~
T"'L••~h-Cl-!?.:tK~oo 0i!~ltot•
':5l-k*9<~&~1(,kGT.:t~,&~;litT.:t
~'FJEI::'TolD--r:<6oo 't5,'5hft--r:, <ft!!I::'~f.\!:
IDllli iJJ n' t.e ft h Ii. ,'n' t.e 0 Ji11:A l-1~ Are1 ~ i, ;lit T
':!::f:l:i!hlt-C'FJE--r:<6<» !:Toi,IDf:l:, 'tIDA
IDH-* ID i~9< --r: <60 .J: 5 ~::. .\!;(hh 0 0 (Marquis,
1989. pp.189-190 'iiliil!\lliJil(Xo)
7tb'M,C';J;~, ~J!:Ab'T-~C'il';7.>l<)f:l:, DC6,
-tntM?nbnb' iC> (ilij(Hlil'; 7.>i'l-*Z-~? b' iC> C'il'; 7.>.
.: nb'7 - ~:A 1<)7t I<)M,~ ~~01,' cj;jUIJ~7.> f~uq:
illtJ (deprivation account) C'il';7.> "'o 7t1<)M,~ 1':-:>
"cl:l:/I!H~~:lL(f;;Jillb\il'; l) k.7.>0 -01:1: f7tb~')/gI,'
b I<) C' il'; 7.> I<) a, -tn b"'~A I<)!t ~Mti'tt.: , ' ,l: 1,' ?
iik;J<I::'R~ 7.> b' iC> c"il'; 7.> J ,l: ~:<, fiik;J<illtJ (desire
account) C';J;~, b?-01:1: f7tb\M,I,'bl<)C'il';
7.> 1<)11, -tnb\~AI<) -tn :l' C'1<)li'£~HJr~m --:> c
C t ? b'iC> C'il'; 7.> J ,l:~ 7.> f;a;~illtJ (discontinua
tion account) C'il';:<, oil 0
7 - ~ :A f:l:, /Ui'; --:> c 1,' :<, A, -1~fJ':JI~1\):II!lH!Ui!i~~
;J; :<, A {>, -lli¥ff-Jt.(I!i;/j(Ii!\I~jl(hc rE >d:' i\ A., C'I,' 7.>
W.li!t~7.>':,l: >d:'i\A.,c"IH't.(I,'t;\ -tnC'b7t
I:I:-t? Ct~A'H':,l:--:>cM,I,'bl<)C';J;7.>,l:I,'?oC
t~b' --:> c iik;J<illtfiilltt1li¥Jc"fHJ:h -15, ;a;~illt~~
01,'cl:l:(kI<),t ? t.(.~,~~~I~IDFk. 7.>. il'; 7.>m3<\.1<)
.i!:!.:jt,-1M~·il'; ~~ilf{ U·'i!f C .7t-1~mi A., C':to l), -tn~k.
-t1<)••I<)~~I<)li'£.I:I:-tn~~*~~.~~b~
t.l: I, '. Cb' C, -t I<)I~.<ii.C'I<) rE z-il!t11nl;(,\!:!.:jt,-I:I:-t
1<).@mcc•• il';7.>!tm~~7.>':,l:ffiC'~:<'I<)C'
il';nli, {>11~ 7tI:l:!I!.(I,'bl<)C'il';7.>o U~b;.,c,
7t1<»)/g~ 1:I:~~I<)li'£.,l: 1:l:iJ<liH*If;f-fH t.:f, ;a;~
illt b illtf--'lll)C'fH.(1, '0 -t.: C'~7.>~1~q:illtb'7tI<)M,~
~~01,' c 1<)~~*f!£i¥JtJ:illtljJj t C c fin c 1,' 7.> .: t I~
t,r; 7.> 0
~iC>~, ~'ffi~~'JC.btkhnbn,l:~C,t?~
-t ? C t.: filfi(i!iil'; 7.> i'l-* z- b --:> c 1,' :<, .: ,l: 1:1:~ 1:< 13 UJj
C'il';7.>,l: 7-of-:Alt~·k.7.>0
• 21 •
![Page 4: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
<.~~~~-.~~~~~n.•-.~~n. ~
~lIHg~tMj7t~H*~filljf[(~i\19<~0 iJ'G -r:;J; 0>
~ " 5 :t\IW:. kf/(1i(,*,~~j(,ol1ln::.;ttl-llt 5 >f<jt!!~t.e
Hjl1lili~ ~ t-: G~o 1\\'!i\!!~t.e1ll1 ''1.~1'1*I::'f:l:. rP.1\
~Y;tll'l.~:j;1* ~ fOJ--c';J; o.l: 5 t.e-iili~ft!fR. ~-rii!iJ.
~.~E~~ihoo.~.~A~~.~~~~~
t.e~ f:l:t.e.g' iJ' ~i\l1!!IJ ~ 0 ~ I::. i-7)- t.el1l1 EiJ 1:1:. 1lI1,'I. r::.
~ik~-cnioo ~~k~. <.~W.~l1I1EiJ~~
fthff. 'p~f:l:illflJ(t:H::';!b~-C~~-C';J;o>~ "
5 li8~f::' t.e 0 0 (Marquis. 1989. p.192)
~/(1i(,*,el:l:.A~i~k<~~C~E~K-e~
0''''0 ~hfi'//7/J..-eil;1) t.eiJ;Gt.eiJ,t.etJ'/~ '7 7
1\.0 t.eJX!lf/(1i(,*,etOi.1l!i>Jt-e il; 0 0
7-~~tO••~li'/:-'7~~tO~~~.~<tO
:lHJrtJ"il;oo 'ttO,· < -:>t),~il;Irf-C';;"J: 5, 1iBI~. -:.tOi~.li r(A,fl,1tO) !t1'ititO*,II!M!~J tOJ: 5
t.e*r!dt-Jt.d§~1::.1Rfr:-t 0 ~ to-eI:tl" "0 il; < i-e
rbhbh~.-t ~ ~ fi~K-eil; oj ~ ,. 5*~.
(J) A!? I::'~~~ ~ h -C,' 0 ~1'7t<;yj{EI9ts:1§ ~t)' G~q; ~ t':
~ho~tO-eil;oo it-:. rmflJJ tOJ:5ts:rti'l'~'
A1.l,i¥Jjlj'{~I::.m;t 0 ~ to -e ~ t", .,ii'0liB=x. ~ tOf,il!~(.fi rfi1!i(f!liJ 1::.-:>,·-Ct01!f$i¥JK.
;l(ILHL1J1lj~if@] L n·ot':l>? 'thl::.~;to46,J,g
tJ;ts:,< ~-eil;oo bhbhtOA!t~"lH·~(J)I::.-t
o ~ tOtr,f"j-e il; 0 tJ'fi1!f$:jlj(J)IN]-e ~ ~JVM.b'J·h
0 0 t:J<~ijji,~ ~ o1!f$:jljat:J<~t.:lttJ··fi1Ii(f!li-eil;o ~
±3R L. ~fiIl.i¥J y ~ r ijji,~ ~ o1!f$:jljfiffi~~Rtj~
~~.~~.'ttO_. ~fiIl.~~hkfillj.~fr:~-to
~~iJR-tot':~ 5;"0 UJ·L':': -efi't(J)J: 5 tdil
L H,}]JI£j I::'~ ~ l.l:l-t46,J,gI:tfs:'·, ~ fiIl.EI9j;!£JI;',l-e il;
h. 1t!!tO~fiIl.i'I'~Ij]:!il1tOrvtj'[-c'il;h. ~ lUI' <. bt-:
LtO~*~bkL~.~~~-Cfi1li.~il;o,:~~~
lii!i':iE-e~tS:"J:51::.bt-:U::'lilj!!,bhoo ~L-C.
bkLtJ·G. 't5Lkfi1li.il;0~*~••~h-CL
i5':~~bkLtO~tO.~tO.J,g~.7t~•• L
-C"o': ~tJ"~l>?ots:Gli. ~ I) il;;tf'th -e7
~~tO.H;jiil::'li-H}-eil;o~ ,. 5.: ~IUs:oo
m=:I::'. j;)ljijiJ'Gjltf.IJ~h -C"o rJ!Ii'Jeli~~i¥J
ts:rH -eil;o. 'th,,!>;t. lJ'~ ~ IftJ L:ii\'i:c@i¥J11ilfIJ~
~ -:> (ii\'i:C@(~JI1!l(:!L ~ ~ -:» J ~ -t 0 r~~tt tOi.1l!~f(jJ
~tOi&H::'I'HI L-C~': 50 ~tO,9 4 7·tOi.1l!~;itili~
< tO~;iti:jlj I::' J: ~ -C 1Ii'diIi¥J1::'i!i':iE ~ h -C ,. 0 0 r J" 'J
:-'~W5J:5~~/'Y~'·fh.tO#~ ••-to
ti' G ~ ,. ~ -C. -t-eI::..tO#-eil; 0 ~ I1'·;t ts:,·o
IftJCJ:5~. ~~ffi~*.A~~o~L-C~••A
~ IftJ C11ilfIJ~ ~ -:> ~ 11'·;t ts:h il; :OU'j,o,'U -e!J"ftt
p ~ ~ -:>b· E 5 t1'li. 'tht), G. to IR¥A\l , -e!J"ftt p
~~-:>t)·E 5 tJ'I::'li1Rfr:Lts:,·tO-C·il;oo ~ 5 Lt-:
~~i1tOi.il!~I:t. ~ ~ L -C. l!liY'GtOU'jA-e'thli!t
~ 0 rmm ~ ~ -:>b·i!i'tJ·. it.:. MYeli rlJ' ~ J
-e il; 0 tJ·i!i'tJ·l::' tJ'b'b 0 f,i!!~;itit': ~ t..: t-:/lb I::'. 1:to J:
5~JX~~';;"ibhoo ~':~ffi. rbhbh~1ftJ
C1'f*J ~~-:>b'E5tJ'~'·5.~X-C'li. 1!Ii~~ 5ilJ(
ge~::.t-:'·L-C*~ts:;m;H:tIH·0 E~G~~'tG<
(7'f;:iI§ffij-e. j)J!tJ;J: Ithl:O 70ijO~~-tbhbh~
IftJ Cfi1Ii(f!liil;o~*~ ~ ~ -C,' 0 ~ ,·;too .: to J: 5
I::' 7 - ~ ~ to.~;itifi. r r' :-' (/ Y1:1: i t':.tO# -el:l:
ts:H ~,'5)x~(;U~j@It-C,'00
~gg~::., "7'-~AQ)~ii6UI'1~ f""-:J /~i1UJ O)J:
5 1::.~~~:ill:1ll.-t 0 i.1l!~tJ;..-;-:>tJ, 0 *IliI!:I*!il1~ ~ ~ll:
Wfi!it:jlj ts: E tOl~1J1lj~@]j@ Ln· 0 0 il; 0 V' CiJ;A!t
tOil;onlf ....... -e*IliI!L n·J: 5~. f,'j*,lli¥JI::.~'ti::iE-C'
il;~5~. iJtJl&l~hn·J:5~. ~L'ttOAI::'bh
bh ~ IftJ C J: 5 l::'fiJfi(i~iil; 0 1'f*b·'t.Jl~ h n· 0 b·
;totO-eil;h~ 'ttOA~~~~o':~fibhbh
~~~~otO~IftJCJ:5~~K-eil;00~L~~~
.1ll.-to.:jlj~ r*IliI!:I*!il1tO.:jlj~m"~~b~
,. (J)li. ~*~~~ ~ I) ~ E Lt-: ~ ~ to't (J).I!:.:jljtO
.*~.~ffi••~tJ·G-eil;oJ ~~;to~GIL
~~ b :p1*.*~#.!:~ ~ ~ -:> -:. ~ I::' ts: 0 tOt':tJ'G.
lftJil'lH::.j)k 5 ..-.: ~ -e il; 0 ~ ,. 5 .: ~ IUs: 0 0~~1L~. ~ tOi.1l!~li:f[!7::§:5]iJtOllfJIIJ'j~@]j@ L -C ,.
0 0 t-: ~ ;t ff*!J!iilll'iAJRtO-f,jII:l:bnbn ~ J: < jj;),
-C~I). ~tOkl>?bhbh~~~~CJ:5~fi1Ii.~
01'f*~~ ~-c'·QtJ·~ l-htJ:"o b l-'t 5 ts:Gff.
*!J!iilll'iA3ffHll:-t.: ~ fibhbh Hll:-t to ~ IftJ C <G'·~K-eil;0~'·5': ~1::.ts:otJ'~ Lhts:\,·o
1i. J'lmts:EI:t1-:LtJ·l::' r!t~-C"oJ tJ;~'tG <
,'i!'.'.~~~c~i.1tt~j:.:,·n·o ~~;tGnot-:l>? b
hbh ~ IftJ C J: 5 ts:~*~ ~ ~ -c,. oblt-C'I:tIs:'·o
Lk~~-c'thG~.-t':~fibhbh~.-t.:~
• 22 •
![Page 5: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
hl:.cl:l:'1'JE1:I;J:t.n't-:650 ;: <OJ: 5 ~c L'c7-'\'
A <OiID!~ifUli.f*:<;1'±~*<O-IlltIi'Jtdili~6D<O J: 5 ~::.:(ffi~
5J1j1i'J1:f;J:t,c: I, '0
~ G ~C, flIi <oi'.N~Ii.ID:!Jl'II1,'1~H'c ~*Wl.~.*<Oi'tfff.
~~~~.·JE~1t~~~.~h~0 ~~~L~
',W.K.~~*~~~~b~b~~~~J:5~
filJi(lfih~H*fi.~ ..,"(l"t,c:l"tl,~ L~t,c:I,'o ;:<OJ:
; t,c:~~~c-t<O.\!i.*~~!I;HC"f tHt ~ ;: ~ Ii., "f t-:~~A~~<Oh~~~~~~K"ftl~~~c'1'JE1:
Itt,c:I,'tl,~ L~t,c:I,'o ~1'1f;~cID:I,'ffili'J' fHI;Ii'JII1,'1i!l'
~~1,', ~1f<o A~~tl;~~1f;~::.:J,· t,c: I, ':ifr~~H Ji'Ji'*1:h ~ 0 ,: <0 Au::. -::> I, , -C 1i. 7 - '\'- A <o@' 1Il1 ~C Ji'l1l: L
t,c:I,'~*~~I,'t-:6 5 tl\ flIi~::'Ifi]m~~.A~:J,·t,c:<t,c:I,'t-:6 ; 0
~~:7Hc ~ tl,t,c:' ft Lh 1-\:~IY"t,(jjt,¥IJ~I,'<-::>tl,
A -C~ ~ ,: ~ ~c L J: ; 0 Wfr¥l <0 tJl.,\'i: <0 ~:lJL (2)1l!
u<or"~fIIj, (3) r1li!9<J r~IJ'l\tJ <OXt,*~cl>!J~ ~ '" fJ
••$Ii'J~W, ~r~~J rb~b~J <O~-~~
b~b~~ lJ1iW'.<O~\I;J.~~::.tl,tl'b~~,¥II,(5)(iIIi([( ~
.*<OOO.Ktl,tl~~~W~ft~li'J1:h~o.KA
-c~tcl,'o
4.1 'tl:11(l)fl.\'1:
"fT, ,:; LtC7-'\'-A<oiID!~~Uol,'-Cft,~f~
~ ~ fr~ 13 ,!ltl::' -::>1" -C"f .., tc <A!h~ G~ -C 1,' t,c:1, '.<2.~~W~~~«t~650 ~~~~~,~~7-,\,
A~~~<o••Ii'J.&Ka~L, ~~<o~~~M~
tJl.~~ -:ti1:, fr~ 13 ,!It<o:fIj'jf;~m:fIJK "f -:>1c <a
~: ~ tL. .., -C 1,' t,c: 1,'.<2. ~ ~ fll L -C 1" ~ (Cudd,
1990) 0 ;: ~It~1:IC1970:¥j-\:tl' G~f~'Ni!:~cl>!J~
~7~i:A~~~<O.~KJ:..,-C~K±.~~-C
t~ID:~~~B1:h9, 7-'\'-A<oiID!~<oA~~;:
~ <l)1:t t,c:HK.\'i:1:h~~ ,~.b~~o
Lb'L, ~~<O••Ii'J.&<o~fIIj~.~~TK,
:t('¥l<om:fIj<O~~±.~~ bltlc ~ I, 'tl,t,c:1, '0 J:1:
~ A, 'J /<o);i\i~I::'-::>\,''"(tlil1li LtcJ: 51c, IJliYc<o:fIJ
i!i'~m:flj J: 9 fr¥l <o:fIji!i'~;gtRt,c: c tl;~J't:~ 0 <0 tl'
c5tl'~"f~K~flIj1:ho<O~fr~<otJl.B~~.
ICA~-C\',t,c:\"tl'G ~ \"'" '"( 7-'\'- A <o);i\ir.6D~-1f,t
4.2 9;Hm,*,~f!!l:: ;~UI
.=<O.Ii., 7-'\'-A<O~.1:lt~:(ffi<01l!U~"f
~'1'JE1:ho;:~K~~;:~~~-t5~~~~<01:
hoo tc~~li, /-"oAIi., ~WT~m'f~, Iii;
~~~~J:5Kb~b~~~~filJi.h~H*~~..,
-C \" 0 ~ j§i ~ t,c: 1,' <0 tl' t. r"~ 5 (Norcross, 1990)0
~ L~~J:; t.dlli([(h~H*~~ ..,'"(l"o Uj~o
<0 t,c: GIi, 7 - '\'- A <Oi\!l!!Jj -C'Ii., 1l!kf ~ f&.A ~ ~ ~
;fli1!Jl'lc'1'JE1:ho;: ~ I::.t,c:oo Ltl' Lb~b~lt1l!
~fHJ!:.A t. ~ ~ J: ; 1::''1'JE'"('h~ t. Ii.~~ t,c: \, '0 L
tc7'1;.., -C 7-'\'- A <o);i\i~ltnX::J;jj L -C\',t,c:\" ~ ~ 0 0
,: <o1l!~f~ f&.A7'1"~ ~ -C' h 0 7'1' ~ \" ; 1J,~fIIj~c -::> 1,'
-C, 7-'\'-A l3,!ltltlk<OJ: 5 ~::.i1S«-c\"00
.H~fihh~.~~~. A.,~mTt. (••3
hk)-0~.T~~&~~~~~?~. ::'hG~
~~eh3~~.~~A.~9'~~0 ••~~~eh-ltlt;l'?tc<~1£Lt.t\"0-tht.'. ~'BlE~~J
hh~~.t.~~'~lt.•~~~~eh-lt~~.~t.tO)t~0? tJ" L.tJ' L. i:'~~~1l-h-ltO)~IJl:j~t~
0;?~0)~~';l'k~~~~~o.~~~±~~
1'.~t~3 t.tl,', (Marquis 1989, pp.201-202)
7-'\'-A~1l!U<O&.1:ltC<offi'ft.c<o.'f~
fa.g.~ 0 ;: ~ I::' t,c: 0 tJ'v.t:lE ~ ~ -C \,' t,c: \, 'tclib IC. "f
t-:b~b~t. ~ ~~~*It ~.., -C\',t,c:\" t.~~ ~b~
1:hoo L7'1'L, ':':1:, ,~.~~!\tl)~L-C~oo ~~
'f-OO t. *J'H-OO~;gfR L, '/ ,. - v <0 t,c:7'1'~CA~
ot,c:Gli, (-t~G7'1"~ L$1l:ffi~o ~~~Ii) $1l:*J'i
J:),lJfrK. ~1:I::' c <o!J~'f t. c <Ofi'H7'1"fii.g.~ 0 7'1'ltY<
:lE~~ -C "~;: ~ Ict,c: 0 0 L t.:.tJ;.., -C, ,: <O!J~T ~
;: <o*JH 7'1"fa.g.~ 0 ,: t. H;lji!l'~ 0 t,c: GIi, ,:~G
<O~H t. ffi'H' G;b~b~~ ~ ~H*~'l\t..,'"(l,'o
,: ~ l::.t,c:~7'1'~ L~t,c:\"o
'b L;: <o.'i!.',~~!\tl)<Ofa:!lW'JELlthfi, m~eb
~ 7'1"Y<:lE ~ ~ -C \, , t,c: \,' tclib IC iJiGflll'f t. $1l:f,'i!J~ <orHlIc
11* ~ t,c:••Ii'JJ1hfli.<Ojfi[\, '7'1;6'> 0 ~ ~07 - "" A <0
Aflilit-: 1t1:1i.-j-~1:fi. t,c:1, '0
tct-:L'l1A1:lt. ;:,: 1:7-'\'-Alt):),Jlfr7'1'G9'M
lZJc:IVF< IC J: .., '"(til! IiI '" ~ '"( 1,' 0 jl'j~f'l<ojfi[ 1,' <or.ili~
• 23 •
![Page 6: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
K.:lJH.6': ctr'-C~6iJ'{, I...-ntJ:I,', -t-C~'::;<-:l
:/ v>1970:¥fl:::fJJjiJH.:, ffli-'N~i- c :Jtf,'W~ c -Cli,
jq.*Ii'ZA~.:tJ:6i.\Y.i«\t'lv;"*~< ili!1", ':nv>lM~Al'I~J
il'fr~.:~!&~Jj-*. -(\,'6': c HifiJi*i1...- '(\,'6 (Noonan,
1970, p.56), :;< -:;I- :/~':J:nl:(. -'t{'-'t{,lM~~PI'iI
il'frli;;$:1'lB9 ~':Jm:!,!,\f'1~': v> v>b 6 ~:ljlJ'fr -C h 6, t:. IJ' G
.:-'tl~~~I~Jm:i«\tt-cA~~~~6,:cK~6
fi~c, 2 7j-~ 1 ~JlA\'i«\tt-C~tJ:~6': c ~.:tJ:6fi
~liim:~\(fJtJ:;r:IE ~ ~,¢.', -c;t ·cd.:. <"* ~ tJ:ili!I,' v>h
6, ~ilJji- c :Jtf,~!J~-Cf;J:-1't*rti:A~.: tJ: 6i.\Y.?/.WltJ""*
~<ili!51...-,:Jtffi.c~.5~~~M~~~K{,"*
~tJ:ili!I,'v>h6, ':~ili!I,'li, bnbncl'ilL::J;-l*
~ {,--:> J: 5 ~.: tJ: 6 JlA\'i«\t'l ~ili!I,' -C {, h 6, {, 1...-': 5
I...- t.:.:;< -:1- :/ ~~illilliliv>llj(b-Ch 6 c -tnl:(. / - !J
" 7- G~11'f~~I}JjJ¥j~ Jjh 't.:.m:illilili"7 - """ 7- O)~:lliti
~m:!£1-t6~':li~""n'tJ:I,'J: 5 ~':,'i!:\bn6,
4.3 i/<IJW C~;Ic
~ / -y I- 7 - A 7- I- " :/ !J'li, "7 - """ 7- ~1'.illillili-C'
ffll,'Gn6 r'lli!9i:J (loss) ~ r9i:5J (loose), r~J
~~J (deprivation) c 1,'''' t.:.iilfl/'4i-~B9-Ch6': c
~jifiJi*i I...- -c 1,' 6 (Sinnott-Armstrong, 1997), bn
bnli r'lli!;lcJ ~ r~J'!\tJ c \" 5 :m~.:;\'-n -C '" "'-T1 7'tJ:I'IH51.~:Ifi!~v>"G-CiV'), -'tnli!lf\l,< c-CiV
6c~*.v>"G-CiV6, t.:c*.I:(. AV>B~ll:t;{jj~
'!\t..,t.:~-Chnl:(. t.: I...-v'~.:-'tnli;r:IEtJ:': c-CiV
6,BffiM~~.I...--C9i:",~c-tnlf-'tnliBK
c..,-C;r:¥tJ:,:c-C'iV6, Lv'L, t.:t.*.lfA t.
Bffi~-V-7-~L-C, Affi."L~.~, -'tnli
B ~.: t. .., -C .fIJ~ I, tJ 7 1 - ~'Ili!9i: (loss) t:' t.13
*. 6 v\ A IttJ:~': iJ,;r:IE tJ:': c f;J: L t.:.b VT -ClttJ:1,',
{, I...- B v',,,. ~ :/ I! -y !J -C';r:IEtJ:'f-~:ll:~ffll,'-Cse ~
jf Iv ~j~1~ L t.:.': t. v>~Jt L t.:. t. -t 6 tJ: G If, B v>
G -" jf Iv~~J'!\t-t6': t.IHs LiSIE U< U:'iS 5,
-?;t ~ r'lli!9i:J ~ r)fIJ'ti'J ~':lii1!i~(flluj'j'[tJ:ilG;zn
(flffli* C, 3~i!I!~il'¥fiIfi~t';trim:~@.(19ffl~tJ>iV6, b
nbnli': 5 L t.:.ffl~~ili!H':fiiXF~-C iV 6,Q:,:ID!t;>h
6,
"7-",,"7-~ rIi'ZA~of&-t.: t.t;>;r:IEtJ:~li, mfiiiii
iV 6 j'i*~~J'!\t-t 6t;, Gt:'J c 1,'''' t.:.3!<:gH.: M'-C
Ii, r~J~i<J liJ1!i~@'(fJtJ:M.,*-C'ffll,'Gnn'6 J: 5
~':Ji!,*.6, L1J'L, t.:LtJ'I':iV6D-ct;q.,t. {'t.im:
f~\(:I'~tJ:t1tfIJ~ {, .., n, 6 {, ~ ~)f.IJ'W-t 6 .: t. li;r:IE
-CiV6tJ\ -'t 5 Lt':'#lm~ {,.., -n'tJ:I,'{, ~~~I~i'
~n~~9i:..,~~-t6.:t.f;J:im:~B9K~n-CiV6Ii
f-CiV6, "7-",,"7-~~illili-C~r~.~~KJ:..,-C
lJilYclibnbnt.liiJL:J: 5tJ:-1't*~'i!i!9i:-t6J ~ r'l~
9i:J lii1!if@.(j'~tJ:m'*-ClttJ:I,', t. 1,' 5 ~f;J:, Ml'CiJ',
-'t 5 Lt.:.i1!if~\B9mfIJ~ {, .., on, 6t;''i§'v'li;t t:'li..,
~ ~ Ln'tJ:I,'iJ'G-ciV6, l!Ill'Cliilli:f@'(flmflj~{,
.., -n, 6 c -t 6 .: t. liillili,?\geJliU': tJ: 6, -'tn'1> *. y
/ -y I- 7 - A 7- I- " :/ !J'li, "7 - """ 7-li;t fJJil~'Ct;,
J1!i~lI¥Jmfl]~{, .., -C 1,' 6 iJ' C 5 v,~n;UE-t 6~ ~-c
iV6t.-t6,
.: 5 I...- t.: y / -y ,- 7 - A 7- I- tJ :/ !J' ~jjt~:lHi, I1I~~;zn~6X~ffl:m c, filfiiMllltfr~;zn~6X~ffliili
c ~1K7J11 c1,' 5 -" ;; jl1ill1lt~~jLJ~'t~':Ill!g,;L t.:iJl.l"j;JJ
I) 1:J~{,"?-C1,'6, LtJ'I...-.:~m:!£1O)ii'l'infili;:fEU',
t.:. LtJ'I': "7 - """ 7- ~~~(;Uli r)fII~i<J ~ r'i!i!9i:J c 1,'
.., t.:.IT!ViiJ ~'i§'IE(i'-JI'IJZI. ~;r:~ l.:flJffll...- -C 1,' 6 J: 5 I':
,1[',bn6, I...-tJ'l...-, ;tf.:.: -C"7-",,"7-~{,c {, t.
~~illilili, rmflJj t. 1,' 511.I'tt:~':lim*. -C l"tJ:I,',:
cK~m-t6~~~iS5, rIi'ZAA~of&-t.:t.ffi;r:
IE-c iV 6 ~Ii At;, GmfiiiiiiV 6i'i*~'!\t 5 tJ> G t:'J
c 1,' 5 X iJ4~ ~.:illfA\B9 r#iffIJJ ~.: f'JF *. t.:. {, ~ -C iV
6 ~IJ> C 5 t;>liUI':IM'lllffriJ>;:fE L 1,', {, L"7 - """ 7
~f.illillilitJ\ r#iffl]J t.1,'5~Jtt:~.:f;Jf*.6,:ctJ:<fitJ:
bn-n'6~-ciVnlf, y/ -y 1-7-A7-I-":/!J'
~m:!£11i~r:T~iJ'{,I...-ntJ:I,',
;t t.:. "7 - """ 7- iJ"tHl:i I...- -C 1,' 6 ~f,(;U -Cli, im:~B9I':
m::ID!t.~*.Gn-CI,'6':cli rfJlfiiiiih6j'i*~{'..,
n'6J t. 1,' 5-,?\-C'h6, Ii'ZAt.JJil~'C~re1~-'t~
jt!!~ili!1,'Ii. ("7 - """ 7-1': J: .., -C Ii) im:~A\B9I':Jl!:ID!tJ:
,f-1:/ I- cli~*.Gn-CI,'tJ:I,', I...-t.:.t;>"?-C, y/
-y I- 7 - A 7- I- tJ :/ !J'~ J: 5 ~':liltA t.IJill'C~ iV 1,' t:.~':lim~(t~tJ:#ifflj~;m~, t;\iV 6 lift:. t. -t 61'.Nillili.:
-'tillili}!.',geJf~ ~rr tJ: .., -C 1,' 6 !f!:nv',iV 6, L t.:.tJ>"? -C ,
.: ~:N!~jjt~'11t i'I<lE(fre iV 6 ,l: 1i.13 I, 'I;>t.:. 1" J: 5 ~.:
mbn6,trL~~.li,ill~B9KJl!:ID!-CiV6,l:~
n6 ~*~{'-?J clic~J:5~.:t.tJ>~f;J:"?~
~~~6.:t.-ciV6J:5Kmbn6,
4.4 D-cO)I'iI-11 , tJntJnc~ill'CO)~IHJ;.l11
"7 - """ 7- (i, llilYclihnbn t.I"J L:i'l-*~ {, -? t.
• 24 •
![Page 7: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
~.~~b~~~. rbhbhJ ~M*~t0=t
t. /li;)'CV;M*~t0=to);5~·t':K_i:t:k~tJ:;n>;~·
V;;5~o)'1.'i:ttJ:~·v·t~·">litftf);;5~o 1f. lJil9c.
f:t ;J: t.: r v- U '1.' i:tfJ: <. 1 t.:.. TVt:lll: L- t.:. O)"b 0)
rV-u tl:tjjlJ-'1.'I:tfJ:~·t~~Jlt'I'IJv;;5~ot.:.t
;tit. 7'1"Tco-I:t. lJil)V:t;J:t':{.'I'fJf.5illb~rrtJ:'"
-C:io Gf. -thry;t V- t 0) jjlJ-i'l (personal identi
ty) 0)~f\l1~7liJt.:. L- n·tJ:~' ttliiWli L- -C~.~ (McIn
erney,1990)0 L-t.:.v;..,-C. lJil)'Cv',t ..,-C~.~ t t>
h~M*I:t. -to)/li;~~~:Ill:L-kM.~C~v-to)
M* t jjlJ C t o)-C'(.:ttJ:~' t ~~o ;J: t.:. 7" 7" :/ l:t.
rbhbhJ ~ r bt.:. L-J t i:t{,·~ t .., t':'f?tE~
(minded being) '1.';5.., -C. -to);$:'!'ti:t#f*-C-i:tfJ:
< %!:I,I,X'1.';5 I). U.:.v;.., -C rbt.:. L-J O)f:t C 1 'J i:t
rbt.:. L-J v;~· ~ 1ifj!\H*v'·%!:I,I,X~ t "bi:t CObt.:.II!t,\'i.
'1.';5~t:t.~~ (McMahan,2002)0 L-t.:.f);..,-C.
j,'tJ: < t t fJJJ!IlO)2fM<<f'ti'li:t;1l):A J: 'J IHs L- -':>~2f
I;:/!;(-C~'~o "k1;:;5Vft.:.'.//", c 7-A? C o:/f/
t. bhbho)J:">~-~O)~:Ill:~~~~L-.-~
O)%!:I,I,X••~-t~;tk~~*I:t••;5~M*~t..,
n·~ t~..,-CH'J:? I;:.'~,bh~v\ fJJWIO)IJil)'C
iiH.:IitI,l,X••~t ..,n·tJ:~·o ;J:t':-m't t ..,t.:.
= to)tJ:~·tO)~9i:? =tl:t'1.'~tJ:~·t':-':> "> t~~o
7 - '1"? 0) illllr,fi1; I;: t.:. ~.~ ~ = h G O)J.R!li!tt:ii*I:t1i$
1JrtJt':v\ rbhbhJ U:tcA,tJ:r-f~'1.';5~v't
~ • "> 'fg'jtrtJl;:~F11'; l;:rnlliE tJ: PJJlIH~.g Iv '1.' ~. ~ = t v;
'f'tR t> h ~ t.: -':> "> 0 0"," 0) rAIMJ9;1J1g:ifni~ ~ to ~
-A 0) rAIMJ;$:l1ifniJ I;:l!ll~ t"b. mf-l::-C'I:t/, - 7
~ "' r (Parfit, 1971) I;:P:r,~ge~ ~ V- t 0) Jj1J-11O)Pn911H 1;:1*1 L- -C 1:t'fg'jtrtJl;:j','j\ It tJ:.lLJtJ v',iiJilli-C';5 ..,
-C. =='1.'I:tt-51I;:m?=tl:t'1.'~tJ:~'o
L- v' L- 7 - '1"?' 0)~r,(iU"0)~!1'J!1;: 0~' -C ~. < 0 v'
:J;l:/ c L--C:io< = tl;:~Qo 1flli:'Jl!tJ:0)1:t. 7
-'1"?O)~ifni-tO)tO)f:t~fL-t rv-tJ~-tO)jjlJ
-110)1IJ'tftl;:m;tv'~-CIH·tJ:~< t'1.';5Qo 7-
'1"?O)~ifni~~'Jl!~o)i:trV-tJ~:t~<~L--':> r.
(i!iO);5Qj;r-*J -C';5Qo L-t.:.I/'",-C. tIU),< tJ:1v
GV·O)~~*v;:bh:bh t /i'iJ C J: "> t"tJ:/v G1)·0).
(i!i;5QM*~ t .., n· ~ t :t'lK-C' ~ hlt~ifnil:tllli:.lL
~Qo
;J:k. 7-'1"?O)illllifnil:t. /li;~~O)~O)rv-tJ
t jjlJ-O)~~'1.';5 Q =t t liljr~ L- -C ~. t",'o /1( 0) J:
? tJ:,~.~:'Ji!.~ L- -C;l,o. J: "> 0 ;5QAfF'j1=jllo;:J:..,-C
jjGte:~;J: .., t.:. < 9i:.., -C L- 1 ~', -t O)M.. 7" 7 /.
:/~ './ / "' r 7 - A ? r 0 :/ f/ V;:tP.~ L- -C ~. Q J: ">
~%!:~'1.'O)v-tO)jjlJ-I1~9i:..,-CL-;J:..,kt~Qo
GtJ· L- -t 0) V- t f/·-t O)U!f,.2, '1.'. Ei 51O)j;r-*O)~f.5I;:.(OCiV;;5 Q t !&.IO Q 0)'1.';5hlt. ~I:t 'J -to)~f.51;:
l:tfilliIOCif);;5QJ: ?1;:,~l:bhQ"o L-t.:.I;;..,-C. v-t
0) rjjlJ-I1J t7-'1"?0)~ifniKf:t~fL-t~.'1.'
i:tt,,~·I;'t L-ht,,~·o
=O)J:?~. rv-tJ t-tO)jjlJ-I1~IO~~illllifni
f:t 'fg'*"(J91;:i1iE U'o r;5 Q ¥.f~ 0) V- t 'J 0) V- t J '1.'
;5 ~ = t i:t cO) J: ? tJ: = t 1;' t ~. "> i1iE1~9~fii7lrJ<~ ~
<!Z•• v";5 Qo 1980if.f1:0) /, - 7 ~ "' r O):kln! rJ![
~tA.JU•• ~<O)'fg'jt*~J:~-CM.~~~
~••~=t~~t>h-C:io'J. 7-'1"?K~~L--C
UM<'Ni'lI:tJriWrtJl;:f.'f~'1.'~ Q t:t. L- J: "> t ~Q
y "'7 IviJj'cO)'fg'jt:j\;-I:t. j,·t" < t t. = 0) j!(Wa O)m
~~ J![fii7I-;- Q <!Z,'Jl! 1;;;5 Q0
4.5 *¥*O)ft!ljfili
jjlJ:f!fil;:11I'jt(tJ tJ:rnlliE~.g Iv '1.'IH' Q 1;\ 7 - '1"?
O)~ifni~J.R.~Q~'1.'J:'J'./:/~~~o)l:tr••;5
Qj;r-*J v'·tJ:-lffillifiilv";5Qo)f)'1;:0~'-C. 7-'1"?
O)~.ti:t~o).'1.'.;t. -t=I;'GA~;1l):~;:t~
tJ:-lf/fIE '1.';5 Q 0) v'l;:"n· -C lJl] 0)~JWI~l*ffl~ Q ;:
t'1.';5~t,~.bhQo =~GfH?j,'L-jj$L-<~-C
:io~t.:.~·o
7' - co:/ (Boonin, 2003) l:t. /V.: * ~ t t.:. tJ: ~·fJJ
lllIO)IJil)'CI;;H*~ t -::> t L- -C t. H':1'ok* IH ..,-C
~.t,,~,O)'1.'. -to)H*f:t-tO)IJil)'CI;:t ..,-C;J:t.:. r.
fi!i;5~J to)-C'I:ttJ:~·tJ.R.LJ:?t L--C\"Qo ;:
=~;5Qo)f:t. :bh:bhf:t••~;5Qto)~/V.:*~
Q 0) f)'. /V.:*~Q 1;' G -t O)/V.:;]( O»)(aU;: (iffi(ffi[I;;;5 Q
0) v'b' "> i1iEr~9-C';5 Qo 7 - '1"? v":io -t G < bh:b
hf:t••~;5~I;'G~~/V.:*~Qo)'1.';5Qt~;tQ
o)l;:~L-';). ~-co :/f;t:bh:bhl;"~~/V.:*~QI;'
G;: -t~I;:(ilfi(i!if/';57.> O)t.: t"T Qo
rfmilOCi;5 QH*J t ~·bh Q ~1.g.O)j;r-*O)filfifi1if:t.
~;$:I¥JI;:-tO)~A (;5~ H:t~O)1'fmlf*) I;: t ..,-C
0) (ilfi(i!i'1.';5 Q0 t = -':> '1.'. filfi(OCi l:t~tmrtJjl1:?r-I;::'Ji!1E
~Qto)'1.'f:t~<. :bh:bh~%!:I,I,X~J:..,-C~.~
lll:W L -C ~. Q b 0) -C';5 Q (;: 0) J: ? tJ:.lL~'if:t;l }l iIfu
• 25 •
![Page 8: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
llli~1:(J)~H:\±i1J(~W€W.~:tEilliii c P¥litL. ;<" ifilIllli
~(J)±lifEz-7r%Ii:L"(I,'Q)0 U-:b'..,-c, ~_Me:c
..,~(J)~*(J)••lt. ~A(J)B.~.~'17~O
:; '" !7 l- c 1,' .., t-: lj, (J) fe:WfJl ~ tL Q -: c fUJ: Q0 't
n.g,;t, ;l' t.:&,\Y!:Z- lj, t-: tJ:1, 'KlIIJlli! ~IJa}I'.Ie:ltbtLb
M'il L. .{iirih Q~*lttJ:I,'c ~:t GtL Q0 -: (J)jjt'i'lj
~. 7-~~(J)~illiii't(J)~(J)c~.~"~r~cJ
(J)\JJI;~IUtrJf:t ~ 1,' tJ:l,< <!:Ie: lj, tt~ L ~.:I: L 1,'0
~~. j;J1:(J):lL~z-ctL.i. 7-~Afe:jjZL~,
(2 't'hVft-:) 7E(J)ilf.~~1JI:A(J)~jf~Ie:01,·~(J)
~*~Z-CQCC~~Q00;l'9.1JI:A~~jf't'h
Q(J)lt, f1Iii!l~(J)1=. e- ~lTt-: 1,' c 1,' ; ~;Jae:jjZTQ
b·G't'hQo~lt-:(J)~.(J)~~7-~~(J)~.1
9 lj, ~ :/ 7' I~'t';l' t-: ~ l- 1/ - l- 't':i/!;;l' L 1,' lj, (J) fe:,'B
btLQ o
)'f;fe:~t-:l; Ie:, 7-~~b'~*~z-1*Jfl LtJ:I,'
(J)lt, 'ttL 't'lt(I)ttllifj~1il\(J),\!).~"~, (2); 0Wl't'7E
z-:i/!;A.,'t'I,'Q'i1f$z-7EtJ:-ltQ C c b,~jf't'hQ -: c
z-~IJJJ C' e- tJ:I,' c ~-;t GtL t-:b' GC'h Q0 t-: U'Ie:
E-~ G (J)?" - ~ 't' lj" 't (J)~Alt~e- ~lTt-: 1,' c 1,'
; ~*z-9<:.., ~ 1,' Qb\ 't tL ~'lj, ~ft 9 7EtJ:-lt Q -:
c ft~jfle:,'!I.btL Qo
'ttLC'ft~*~'t'~*~~1:(J)?"-~z-~IJJJC'e
tJ:I,'t':6; b·o ;G'=r-f."(' L <~~ ;;,;.t-:I,'o ~*~IU"
1,'~ It. i1!!fAlB'JIe:1ll:~C'h Q C;;,;. tJ: ~ tL QbtLhh
(J)~*(J)I:I:c A., Eft. ,!jHe:~.~h ~I,' Q~*'t'lt
tJ: <, (IjI1cJ c L ~(J)~* (dispositional desire) C'
h Q C 1,' ; ..ii. C' h Q (Boon;n, 2(03) 0 t-: c ;tli,
btLbhlt B'ii';1=.f.5 IU" I, ,~ jUri¥.- r1=. e- ~lTt-: I,.J
c ~.TQ -: C Itlt>.., t-: Ie: tJ: I, '0 r1=. e- ,wllTt-:1,' b.J
C~lb~~tLt-: 9 I3r"~ L ~;;,;.t-: IJ U-: c e-Ie:. hM'
It1=.{,lf(J)fG;mHe:~U-: c e-Ie:~. ~ tL Gt':ITC'h..,
~, il!!(J)liiliYfiC'lt~.~tLtJ:I,·(ljlIoJC L~ 't ; 1,. ;
~*z- lj, .., ~I,' Q fe:T e--tJ:1, '0 Lb- U':b-G c 1"..,
~bhbtLb'~e-~lTt-:1,' c 1,. ; ~;j(z- lj, .., ~ 1" tJ:
l,'blTC'lttJ:I,'o (IjIlcJc L~(J)i'J,:;j(cltC(J).t "lIe:
't\t1~lJ~tLt-:c e-(J) (llJl:t':!B'JtJ:) :)§:c tJ:Q lj,(J)~'hQo
lj,L-:"lLk(ljllcJcL~(J)~*-:'t~1ll:~~(J)C'
h Q c TtL Ii. IliI!lrm~t}lliI!(J)tb~lI1!ltlX(J) 1 ; 1e:~1JJJ
~tLQo ttllil!~W.Ie:hQ~C lj" lj, L~.;/)\hMJ:
G~r1~~J t:)§::tQC'h6;t ••C'e-Q(J)C'
htL~, (IjIlcJcL~(J)~*tL~~e-~ITQ~*z-
lj, .., n, Q t I,':t Q0 't tL.g,:t ttllil! L~ 1,' QA z-1&
T -: c lj, 't (J) A (J)~;j( le:jjZ L~ 1,' Q;/)\.g,:t fe:~jf C'
hQtTQ-: t;/)\C'e-Q o U-:;/)''''~' ~*m~'lj,
ttllil!~W.(J)~cZ-7E~-ltQct(J)~jf~~~IJJJC'e
tJ:\, 'b 1TC'lttJ:I, '0
'ttL't'lt, ;0~W.(J)W$(J)?"-~ltE;~6;
;/)'0 ~r.ili (J)1: ~'lj, ; -0<i6,igi tJ: (J) It. i1!!f@B'J~ID:~
c~tLQ«e-~*lt.m~~illiiillli~jjZLk~~llli~
lj, (J)'t'h.., ~ IttJ: G tJ:I,' t 1,'; ~i4'C'hQo 4l+~Ie:
;l' ..,t-: < lj, t-:5\,'~I"tJ:I,,~;j(~illiiillliEt',jIe:ilMLLt-:
~*~ilif@B'J~m~~~~t.;tQ(J)~~'tG<~
~llli't'hQo~llliB'J~m~i1!!f@B'J~m~.TQ(J)
It. 't; U-:~~J'dli1H)F~U-:~*(J)ltfC'hQ
(Brandt, 1979)0 i1!!fAlfI91e:1ll:~tJ:(J)ft, ; 0~11!\C'
7Ez-:i/!;A., ~'I,. Ql~r~p z-7E tJ:-lt Q (J)tJ\~jf tJ: (J)ft, 't
; U-: (7Ez-:i/!;tst I"..,t-:) ~*ft-AlHe:-I1!ji¥JtJ:
~*hQ Ht~'t<:;EtJ:ti'I!JYJle: lj, c -:51,'k~~lllitJ:~
*C'h9, 't;Lk~*z-.kTCt~ft-.~.
{f[[b·-tJ:l"tJ·i?~·hQo ~ Gle:. I3ff'J-'H3l:I*lffile:lj,
tt 13 T Q« ~ C'h Qo mfi;/)';/)\ 13 7t(J)1Ez-:i/!;A., C'I,' Q
t L~ lj" t-:l"n'(J)j~1~ftl3;,)-(J)7E't(J) lj, (J) lj, (J)
~'lttJ: < 'is'1i\'i ~lIftli!i;/)· G (J)!9'IWcz-:i/!;A., 't'1,' Q Ie:T e-
tJ: 1,'7E It~'t<:;E tJ:1j'I!JYJle: .t .., ~~lt> GtL~ L ;l' .., t-:
tlJ.!Iffl0'i1.:t t-: =H3l:Ie:T e--tJ:I,' (J) C'lt tJ:I,';/). t ,'!I,btL
Qo U.:;/)'..,~~'tG <. 'f!&c L~7Ez-~*TQ
C t It~~j!JltJ:Jj;j~;/)\*~eC'h6; 0
.{iiric~*(J)llIl{;f,Ie:01,'~ -:; U-:i\F!r,~;/)\jf1..-\"
~lcJfe:hQ c TtLli, ttllifj~11!\(J),\!).~~;0Wl(J)'Ff
$(J)?" - ~ Z-JlJl, ·t-: 7 - ~ ~ (J)7E(J)~ ~ Ie:01,'~ (J)
~*mz-iJ!IT.t; cTQr,!lif,;lt'ttLl:l:E2liI,·lj,(J)C'
IttJ:1, '0 {I!! Ie: lj, ~r.ili LtJ:lTtLlttJ: i? tJ:I,' ,<!i.ltf,(3'- <
tJt~ tLn, Qb\ ~*mftfilliiiiric ~*(J)r':l(J)WjJ'UJ:
.ffiz-~IJJJC'~QA't'tsL67-~~(J)M.m.t9
lj,:i/!;;l' L 1,' lj, me: ,'!I.btl Qo
~:/~~'t'2li~~7-~~(J)jjZU.~M(J)~if,;~
'<t L ~, ~ -< 7 Iv (J)~~Ie:~ "t-: 1,' t ~:t QliJf:1t~
~7-~~(J)~:/~~~i\F!if,;z-~A.,G;/)·(J)B't'~.
TQ~~~hQo~~~7-~~(J)r.iliX (t'tnz
~ 71 l- Lt-:lj,(J) It1990$5fUJ'Glt1=.{,lf{filIllli~·
lGmiifuJ1dl~(J)7 :/ '/ 0 ;,'-Ie:liffi\;;,;.i2;;l' tLQ C t ;/)\-
• 26 •
![Page 9: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
·~K~0d).••~.K~~k~~~~K~.~
<O)~~~fFBXtJ;t±ft.}ln -CV'Qo
~ni~~k15K7-~A~~~K~L~~R
~f;t\,' < ":)b'iiJfjg~h;;'o I:: < K.4.41::4.5~h~t-.:
.~~.~~~k~~I~b'~0~m~R~K~05
;;, I::.'i!:.:bn;;,o LiJ'L~nGIH"'I::~~iIi~IITJ-t't
K.!>llT ;;, Tf[OJ.:J:~ltfEr"~~, 1iIIi([i I:: li!oJ<~ !>lli,%IC":) l '
~ ~:' }l ffitlJmOJ.:J:~ltfEll,~~1J;Iv ~l' ~m.tJ(~·f~i*:iE
~t,t: ~ ~ I:: I~ ~ l 'b:t-.: <, flljijj.lca~~iiib:tJ:j~-'t 5
ICt,t:l'o i t-':3~~'P;IC ,-,,:/ 7'I"t,t:7-~ A~~~~R
Rt";;, t-.:It.JIC. j,jEfb' ~ ~'m*t,t:Jm~iii~t,t:tJ:tlM"IZ,
Jt}! fC t,t: ;;, .¢.', ~ ~WB ~h ;;, 0
~ t,~A, 7 - ~.A ~W!~iiib:l' i t':-~ L ~~::tJt':
b'G I:: l''J~. t-.:t.:t,lckf~rN;{'lICl ~ Jii!iLl'~~
tdl1.1!iljHl!lT'" ~ t.: I:: l' 5 ~ I:: ICltf,t: 10, t,t:l '0 m.~
~KaU~~M~Jii!iL<.~T;;'~I::I~§*~aQ
~~m~~kGT~~50.~~a~~·~R~~
W!~I::~.~~W!~~.IITJ#n;;,a~~h;;,~~tt
mT;;''''~~h;;'o LiJ'L. ~·t,t:< I:: ~~ft1E,,"lckf
~~M~~BT;;'klt.J~Tf[OJ.:~.~I~i~i~~Jt}!
I:: #nn,;;,o H-.:. kH",~M~r"~Ji'lj1~. {t!J~~ffl
~.~~kGT.Jm~M.~~~Gf. ~.~.*
a~~oo~~.Jm~M.I::~~.T;;'~~~1J;~~
iIi.JmOJ.:~~*~M.~h;;'o .~~~W!~~Jm~
~kIt.JK~~~~kIt.JK~7~77-c#n. ik
~~#n;;''''~~h~51::~:bn;;,0
(;1)--------------
1lilf'J "ltiE L. <P1Wl '" tt _C,. tH':t; 'ttttl·'" ;; .:. I: ,.:....",_c
'tiI <:l (2007) ,,~lft L.tc.
ii) 1lilf'J,,'tT5ti1 Il '" tt_c,. t<e 'fJ\ !iE!l!<9'1i'!1.:.1l'...,h;; r("
I:J~.*~~MI:L._C,t~-U-~~~19~~.~~~
~ ~ ~1J fJ;J1;. <11: H"Att I?tt~.i'li!t.JfJ·'''';;,
iii) OO~~~1LfiLlf~'iff-llr~~-y'i~~J K~~~~
.",tt;;':'I:~.;;~, iE~K~.~~~ft~ltrDI:J ~
.*,~,t ""~ c fRl!I\ L. t. H;!Jf'J3'.!1l1"'" o. i tcll1M\"'Ii'!~
%.,,~"3'..,t8~.t.J~~~".01:.htto~, *~
,,~j;IliN U.'·,iv) 1<~ll?tt_c'·;;15'~. ~ >-U-'t.:.~I~JIill~. lIiot
~.L.~j£.re"'tto~.~.,,0.:.1:~.~_CL.1l'5.:.I:K
1?_cWle~L.15I:T;;fJ\ 11:H"Attl?ilt.'·I:~x.o'"'o\\;·
,t~", ~. ~~~'t~-A"t'''';;o
v) •••'t~~~~~-~~v.~1?r~~."'J ~•• I:
L. _c 't3'.iilt~ 'Itx.;j ~-...,"t'''';;. ~~. '" ,~...". _c ~-¥I~
A 9 -'(>THil", t L. _C Nagel (1979) :t; 1 V' Singer (993) til
4 f,l:~1$J¥.l.-lt 1.
vi) r!l'J~~.J r/i!(;lliiiI.J :t;lU' rillli'!.J ~{,lli',~7-~~'~
1 ;; ~ ~"t'.O. Marquis (1989). p.195.
I'ii) ~-"'~,t.;r-8'J'~f1;;t....,_C'·t.,·fJ\ t L.fJ'L.tcl? 1
9*"H*~~ ?_C,.;;~"t'. 'f.~,·td~A~*'tT':'1: 19
~'fiEl: ",x.efx.ofj·~L.ttt.h
,iii) r~Mt1liJ ItA1.MI~t.l!il*,,'H.'·t "''';;fJ\ ~~t1lifJ;iiIi:
iL L. _C";;':'I: ~c~ 1 5'~ "jf;;H'!<B-'j'~) ftOiETo~tJ·1:
" ? ~IJ ~lllJlillfJ;!t t.: ;;
ix) A!t~{ilij{i"'~..."._c ~l\!~~ft~I':' ...". _C hfJ. 9 ~"T"1ll
irl: ~?jf,t Parli' (1984) ~W-1 0
x) ~~L., ~~.2~...,t...,~01:.~~ill.8'JK'fj£~.:.
I: "t'''' 0 .:. I: ~T5l",~.[lJJ"t' t t. < t.;; fJ' ~ L.tt t.,·
xi) ~?I:t, ~-"'~~!1',t.:.~,o!i,'~...,,·_CI»Jl?fJ.td!1!I£~
~{.T0':' t ~il!!H"_C ,.;;.
xii) Kuhse and Singer (]999). Bonnin (2005), Timmons (2007)
(*Jffi%il!)-------------
Bunnin, David (ZOO;{) A Defellse of Abortion. Cambridge Univer
sity Press.
Boonin. David and Graham Odie (eds.) (2005) What's Wrong?:
Ap/J!ied Ethicists and Their Critics, Oxford University Press.
Brandt. R.B. (1979) A Theory vf the Good and the Right, Claren-
dOll Press.
Cudd. Ann E. (1990) "Sensationalized Philosophy: A Reply to
Marquis's "Why Abortion is Immoral" ," Thejvltmal oj Philoso
phy. Vo1.87. No.5. pp.26Z-264.
Kuhsc. Helga and Peter Singer (I 999) . Bive/hies: A11 Anthology,
Blackwell.
Marquis. Don (989) "Why Abortion 15 Immoral." Thejo/lmal of
PJlilosophy, Vo1.86, No.4.
Mcinerney, Peter K. (1990) "Does a Fetus Already Have a Fu
ture-Like-Ours?" journal of Philosophy. Vat87.
McMahan. Jeff (2002) The Ethics of Killi1lg: Problems at the Mar
gi1ls of Life, Oxford University Press.
Nagel, Thomas (1979) "Death," in Mortal (Juesli01ls, Cambridge
University Press. (to "7.7. • .;(. - 7' II.- r:J '/ --l;- I) -C' tV;:' cIt c.'
• 27 •
![Page 10: A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument · A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-AbortionistArgument Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi Abstract:](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042213/5eb8cc6c9151253f0f5a2fc9/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
UH? t,,,- i:b'J, 7k!FJ!llR, IYJ1,'il'JlJI, 1989)0
Noonan. John T .• Jr. (1970) "An Almost Absolute Value in His
tory," in The Morality ofAbortion: Legal aud Historical Perspec
tives, Harvard University Press.
Norcross. Alastair (1990) "Killing. Abortion. and Contraception:
A Reply to Marquis." jOltmal of Pizilosophy, Val.S?, No.5.
Parfit. Derek (1971) "Personal Identity," The Philosophical Re·
view, Vo1.80. No.1.
-- (19&0 "What Makes Someone's Life Go Best." in Reosot's
alld Persons. Oxford Universit)' Press. ('7 t,.;? • r~ - 7 .f '7
" rJillEb i:AIlI ; .~AIlIM;U)!fIJ!Il""J, l!littiffilR, !YJl,~ TlJ,
1998)0
Singer. Peter (I979) Practical Ethics. Cambridge University Press.
( ,,- !I - , '''' 1/-, rjl!~J<U)!fIJ!IlJ (l!l 11'.fD, UJ1"!1i:=flIl '
Jli!iltl'1'lR, II'lfOR;, 1991)0
-- (l99:·n Practical Ethics, Cambridge University Press, 2nd
edition. (e'-!l-' '''':!l-, r~~U)f$~JU frrli!i, IlJr'J1i:=
Jlil' J1j;/til'1'll<lR. 1I'l'fl1R;, 1999)0
Sinnou·Armstrong. Waller (997) "You Can't Lose What You
Ain't 'ever Had: A Reply to Marquis on Abortion." Phi/osop/II-.
col Studies, Vo1.96_
Strong, C (2008) "A critique of 'the best secular argument
against abortion'" ,joun/al ofMedical Ethics, Vo/.34. 2009.
Thomson. Judith Jarvis (1971) "A Defense of Abortion," Philoso·
phy & Pllblic Affairs. Vol.!. No.1.
Timmons. Mark ed_ (2007) Disputed Moral Issues: A Reader. Ox·
ford Universit)' Press.
Tooley. Michael (I972) "Abortion and Infanticide." Philosophy &
Public Affairs. Vo1.2, No, I.
Warren, Mary Anne (1973) "The Moral and Legal Status of
Abortion," The Monist. Vol.57.
i:IClIlll (~IJ07) rfjl I"! U)1'.1fIi !fIJ!Il'l"IU.It '" r,<- ~ "'illiJ U)'Ji:
~J, W!fUl:it?ilf~J, mlO'Fr, )iCml:!r'T#f:o
• 28 •