• introduction •aim • methods • results...catherine j. m., sharon m. n. 2016. effects of...

27
Tengku Fatimatul TH 1 , Rohaida I 1 , Wan Rosli WI 2* , Noor Fadzlina H 2 , Wan Suriati WN 2 , Hamid Jan JM 2 , Nor-Haslina M 3 , Arifin WN 4 , Wan Mohd Izani WM 5 , Rohana AJ 6 , Tengku Alina TI 6 , Mohd Ismail I 6 , Tahir A 7 , Wan Abdul Manan WM 2 1 Kelantan State Health Department, Ministry of Health Malaysia, 2 Program of Nutrition and Dietetics, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia 3 Program of Environmental and Occupational Safety and Health, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 4 Unit of Biostatistics and Research Methodology, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 5 Department of Medicine, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 6 Department of Community Medicine, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 7 Institute for Public Health, Ministry of Health Malaysia,

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

Tengku Fatimatul TH1, Rohaida I1, Wan Rosli WI2*, Noor Fadzlina H2, Wan Suriati WN2, Hamid Jan JM2, Nor-Haslina M3, Arifin WN4, Wan Mohd Izani WM5, Rohana AJ6, Tengku

Alina TI6, Mohd Ismail I6, Tahir A7, Wan Abdul Manan WM2

1Kelantan State Health Department, Ministry of Health Malaysia, 2Program of Nutrition and Dietetics, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia 3Program of Environmental and Occupational Safety and Health, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 4Unit of Biostatistics and Research Methodology, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 5Department of Medicine, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 6Department of Community Medicine, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 7Institute for Public Health, Ministry of Health Malaysia,

Page 2: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Introduction

• Aim

• Methods

• Results

• Conclusion

Page 3: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Obesity is an alarming public health issues

• Various reports in the 1990s have pointed out prevalenceof overweight of over 20% and obesity of over 5%amongst urban population groups of the more developingcountries in Asian (Tee 2002)

• The trend of overweight and obesity in Malaysia wereincreasing with prevalence 47.7% (NHMS 2015)

Page 4: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• The change in overweight and obesity prevalence in some Asian countriesin comparison to the United States, 1980-2013

• Overweight and obesity prevalence 2013

Source: Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation, 2014

Source: Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation, 2014

Page 5: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Obesity is associated with increase risk of cardiovascularand metabolic disease (Thorndike 2015, Cheong 2014)

• Diabetes Mellitus• Hypertension• Dyslipidaemia• Stroke• Nephropathy

• Asians are more likely to develop central obesity, which isassociated with higher risk of developing those diseases

(Cheong 2014)

Source: https://cenegenics-boca.com

Page 6: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Obesity among workers• Prevalence of obesity among government and semi government

employees in Malaysia were 40.3% compare to 26.6% amongprivate employees (NHMS 2015)

• Obesity generates indirect costs for employers byincreasing workers’ compensation claims, related lostwork days, absenteeism and presenteeism

(Heinen & Darling 2009)

• Need to focus on workplace environment and propose forworkplace program

• Education, modification and self-monitoring of dietary intake andphysical activity (French et. al. 2010)

Page 7: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• The economic and health impacts of employer-sponsoredhealth promotion and wellness is growing

(Heinen & Darling 2009)

• Worksite interventions have been found to be effective incontrolling overweight and obesity

• Combine nutrition and physical activity(Thorndike 2011, MOH 2015)

Page 8: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

Research Grant from Ministry of Health Malaysia (304/PPSK/6150130/I103)

My Body is Fit and Fabulous (MyBFF@work): An Intervention Project to Combat Obesity Among Malaysian Civil Servants in Kelantan

Conducted in Kota Bharu, Kelantan, Malaysia. Researchers from Universiti Sains Malaysia, Health Campus and Kelantan

State Health Department Principal Investigator: Prof. Wan Abdul Manan Wan Muda

Page 9: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Phase 1 – Qualitative and baseline survey• A cross sectional study was implemented through surveys of

worksite administrators and employees, and/or an assessment ofthe worksite and surrounding community environments todetermine areas conducive to environmental interventions.

• Also identify barriers to implementing the intervention includingfactors that could enhance participation of employees in theintervention through qualitative study.

• Screening for baseline (pre-intervention) for intervention andcontrol groups will include 4 measures, namely:

• Socio demography and health problems• Pain score• Weight, height, and waist circumference• Physical activity history• Dietary intake/binge eating/night eating behavior

Page 10: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Phase 2 – Intervention and Qualitative Study (embedded)

Aim:• To assess the dietary intake changes among overweight

and obese government employees in Kota Bharu,Kelantan

Page 11: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• This intervention study focused on healthy lifestyleapproach through nutrition education and dietarymodification

• It involved 16 Government Agencies (Federal and State) inKota Bharu, Kelantan

• The post intervention result was obtained after 6 months completing the intervention program

Page 12: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• BMI > 27.0 kg/m²• Age 18 to 59 years old• Fit and healthy• Agree to abide the study procedures and

protocol, signed the informed consent forms

Inclusion criteria

• Involvement in any commercial weight reducing program

• Taking any medication/ food/herb products for weight reduction

• Pregnancy or planning to conceive during the study duration

Exclusion criteria

Page 13: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• 24 hrs diet recall is used to measure energy andmacronutrients intake were measured using.

• Record the details of food and beverages in standard householdmeasurements using food diary.

• Portion standard measurements were converted into grams andthen calculated using the Nutritionist Pro Software.

Page 14: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• The respondents were randomly selected and groupedinto 3 main groups:

• Meal Replacement (MR)• Portion Size (PS)• Control (CON)

Page 15: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education
Page 16: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Provide lunch delivery for 5 working days• Replace one meal of white rice-based with non-white

rice based• Only brown rice will be provided

Page 17: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• 50 recipes were compiled bynutritionist team

• Nutritional values were calculated• Energy values of the meals ranged

from 427.7 kcal to 575.8 kcal

Page 18: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

Examples Menu for MR group during 6 months interventionMushroom burger Grill chicken salad with spicy baked potato

Grill chicken with oat rice Grill Thai chicken with brown rice and vegetables

Spaghetti aglio olio BBQ grill chicken with brown rice

Sandwich meatball Dory fish casserole

Chicken in Thai mayo with pita bread Spaghetti pizza with chicken cake

Yong chow fried brown rice Asam pedas

BBQ mince beef brown rice Steam dory with brown rice

Pan fried dory with little shell pasta Chicken kerutuk and oat rice

Baked Pattaya brown rice Vinegar fish with oat rice

Beef steak whole meal sandwich Spaghetti soto

Roasted paprika chicken with corn on cob and assorted vegetables

Beef brown rice

Chicken enchiladas wrap with whole meal tortillas Pizza rendang

Page 19: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Reduce portion size of regularfood intakes/meals by using“Portion Plate”

• Lunch taken following the portionplate

Page 20: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• No intervention• Basic health and nutrition education – Monthly

Page 21: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

Variable Group Mean (SD) F statistic (df) P-value

Energy intake differences (kcal/d)

MR (n=70) -94.0 (510.28)0.07 (2,168) 0.932PS (n=56) -99.1 (490.57)

CON (n=49) -130.5 (621.16)

Total carbohydrate differences (g/d)

MR (n=70) -20.2 (74.68)1.17 (2,168) 0.313PS (n=56) -0.5 (68.0)

CON (n=49) -22.1 (101.07)

Total protein differences (g/d)

MR (n=70) 0.3 (31.66)1.40 (2,158) 0.249PS (n=56) -6.3 (25.24)

CON (n=49) -8.7 (33.12)

Total fat differences (g/d)

MR (n=70) 2.0 (29.12)1.91 (2,168) 0.152PS (n=56) -7.8 (27.48)

CON (n=49) -3.7 (26.45)One-way ANOVA was applied. Assumptions (normality, homogeneity of variance) were checked and found fulfil

A total of 283 participants were recruited with 38.2% of dropouts.

Page 22: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Previous studies demonstrated that workers/ healthcareworkers lost significant weight following interventionbehavioural, dietary and physical intervention

(Thorndike 2011, Tee 2012, Hemysfield 2003)

• Dietary self-reporting is a commonly used for populationsurveillance of dietary intake. However, reporting errorsand daily variations in dietary intakes may be barriers toachieving reliable results with estimated under reporting25-68%

• (Black and Cole 2001, Lauren S. F, 2014)

Page 23: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Despite the reduction of dietary intake in groups, therewere no significant difference in between groups.

• The 6 months intervention was focussing on behaviouralmodification approach through modification of dietary,physical activity and behavioural

• Further assessment in MyBFF• Weight loss, BMI & WC• Changes of Blood Parameters• Cost benefit analysis of MR and PS• Changes in Physical Activity Level• QOL and pain score• Acceptance and compliance to MR

Page 24: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

Meal Replacement Educational module Mydumbell workout

More research should be carried out in the futurewith cultural appropriateness, feasibility ofreplication and also cost effectiveness

Page 25: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

1. Black A. E. & Cole T. J. 2001. Biased over or under reporting is characteristic of Individuals whether over time orby different assessment methods. J Am Diet Assoc. 101 -(1):70-80.

2. Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomizedcontrolled trial. Nutrition Journal, 15:31.

3. Cheong W.S. 2014. Overweight and Obesity in Asia. Underwriting Focus. Edition 2/20144. Cohen, J. 1988. Statistical power analysis for behavioural sciences. Hillsdale, NY: Lawrence Erlbaum

Associates.5. Green K. L.1988. Issues of control and responsibility in workers' health. Health Education Quarterly, 15:473-486.6. Heinen, L & Darling, H. 2009. Addressing Obesity in the Workplace: The Role of Employers. The Milbank

Quarterly, Vol. 87, No. 1. 101–1227. Heymsfield, S.B.; Van Mierlo, C.A.J.; Van der Knaap, H.C.M.; et al. 2003. Weight management using a meal

replacement strategy: Meta and pooling analysis from six studies. International Journal of Obesity, 27:537–549.8. Laurence S. F., John M. C., James E. M., et al. 2014. Pooled Results From 5 Validation Studies of Dietary Self-

Report Instruments Using Recovery Biomarkers for Energy and Protein Intake. American Journal ofEpidemiology, doi: 10.1093/aje/kwu116.

9. Mirnalini K., Zalilah M. S., Safiah M. Y., et al. 2008. Energy and nutrient intakes: Findings from the MalaysianAdult Nutrition Survey (MANS). Malaysian Journal of Nutrition, 14(1):1-24.

10. MOH. 2015. National Health Morbidity Survey 2015. Institute for Public Health, National Institutes of Health,Ministry of Health Malaysia

11. Norimah A.K., Safiah M. Y., Jamal K., et al. 2008. Food consumption pattern: findings from the Malaysian adultnutrition survey. Malaysian Journal of Nutrition, 14:25-39.

12. Tee, E-Siong. 2002. Obesity in Asia: prevalence and issues in assessment methodologies. Asia Pacific Journalof Clinical Nutrition 11(3): S694–S701

13. Thorndike A.N. 2011. Workplace Interventions to Reduce Obesity and Cardiometabolic Risk. Curr CardiovascRisk Rep. 5(1): 79–85

Page 26: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education

• Participants• States and Federal Government Agencies• Grant from Ministry of Health

• USM Grant No. 304/PPSK/6150130/103

Page 27: • Introduction •Aim • Methods • Results...Catherine J. M., Sharon M. N. 2016. Effects of nutrition education on weight gain prevention : a randomized Effects of nutrition education