a novel approach on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl
DESCRIPTION
PVATRANSCRIPT
ww.sciencedirect.com
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h yd r o g e n e n e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 2
Available online at w
journal homepage: www.elsevier .com/locate/he
A novel approach on ionic liquid-based poly(vinylalcohol) proton conductive polymer electrolytes forfuel cell applications
Chiam-Wen Liew, S. Ramesh*, A.K. Arof
Centre for Ionics of University of Malaya, Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, University of Malaya,
Lembah Pantai, 50603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 8 December 2012
Received in revised form
4 July 2013
Accepted 23 July 2013
Available online xxx
Keywords:
PVA
Ionic liquid
Proton conductivity
Fuel cell
Power density
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ60 3 7967 439E-mail addresses: liewchiamwen85@gma
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-polymer electrolytes for fuel cell applicj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
0360-3199/$ e see front matter Copyright ªhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2013.07.0
a b s t r a c t
The preparation of proton conducting-polymer electrolytes based on poly(vinyl alcohol)
(PVA)/ammonium acetate (CH3COONH4)/1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride (BmImCl)
was done by solution casting technique. The ionic conductivity increased with ionic liquid
mass loadings. The highest ionic conductivity of (5.74 � 0.01) mS cm�1 was achieved upon
addition of 50 wt% of BmImCl. The thermal characteristic of proton conducting-polymer
electrolytes is enhanced with doping of ionic liquid by showing higher initial decomposi-
tion temperature. The most conducting polymer electrolyte is stable up to 250 �C. Atten-
uated total reflectance-Fourier Transform Infrared (ATR-FTIR) confirmed the complexation
between PVA, CH3COONH4 and BmImCl. Polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC)
was fabricated. This electrochemical cell achieved the maximum power density of
18 mW cm�2 at room temperature.
Copyright ª 2013, Hydrogen Energy Publications, LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights
reserved.
1. Introduction component in PEMFCs is the proton exchange membrane
Depletion of non-renewable fossil fuel catalyzes the devel-
opment of environmentally friendly alternative energy sour-
ces. Fuel cells are promising candidates as power sources for a
wide range of applications, ranging from portable devices to
electric vehicles [1,2]. Fuel cells are of great interest in the
recent research due to their attractive properties. They offer
many advantages, such as environmentally benign, high en-
ergy efficiency and lower emission of pollutants [3,4]. Fuel
cells also do not require the need for rapid recharging process
in the presence of electricity compared to the lithium
rechargeable batteries [5]. Apart from that, fuel cells exhibit
higher energy density than the batteries [6]. The main
1; fax: þ60 3 7967 4146.il.com (C.-W. Liew), rame
W, et al., A novel approaations, International Jo
2013, Hydrogen Energy P92
(PEM) which is used as proton (or charge carriers) provider
from anode to cathode. The basic requirement of PEM is the
membrane must be proton conductive with some satisfactory
properties like excellent mechanical strength and chemically
stable. Perfluorosulfonated membrane, Nafion produced by
Dupont has widely been used as host polymer in PEMFCs.
However, high methanol transfer is the main shortcoming of
using Nafion as primary polymer membrane in fuel cells [6,7].
High methanol crossover may cause the loss of fuel, slow
methanol oxidation kinetics and formation of carbon mon-
oxide (CO) intermediate on the platinum catalyst layer at the
cathode as well as cell polarization. As a consequence, the
performance of this electrochemical cell could be decreased
[email protected] (S. Ramesh), [email protected] (A.K. Arof).
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
ublications, LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n en e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 22
[6e8]. It also possesses some drawbacks such as expensive,
high water swelling characteristic which reduces the lifespan
of the membrane and decrease in conductivity at elevated
temperature [9]. So, the utilization of Nafionmembrane in fuel
cell is limited. Therefore, many attempts have been done to
overcome the weakness of Nafion.
Non-perfluorosulfonated polymer membrane was
employed to replace Nafion in DMFC. Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA)
is a potential material because of its cheaper price [2]. PVA is a
biodegradable semi-crystalline synthetic polymer bearing
with hydroxyl functional group [7,10,11]. Superior chemical
stability, non- toxic, high hydrophilicity, ease of preparation
and biocompatibility are advantages of PVA [10e13]. Further-
more, PVA exhibits excellent thermal and chemical stabilities
and high abrasion resistance as well as high flexibility [13,14].
PVA also possesses high dielectric permittivity and excellent
capacity for charge storagewhich is an important feature for a
supercapacitor, as reported by Hirankumar et al. [15]. In order
to prepare proton-conducting polymer electrolytes, ammo-
nium salt must be embedded to provide the charge carriers as
it is well-known as proton donor. Ammonium acetate
(CH3COONH4) was chosen in this project due to its plasticizing
effect. However, the ionic conductivity is relatively low.
Therefore, much effort has been devoted to enhance the ionic
conductivity, for instance polymer blending, addition of
plasticizer, incorporation of filler, mixed salt system and
doping of ionic liquid. Among all these approaches, impreg-
nation of ionic liquid can be considered as the most feasible
method because it is well known as environmentally friendly
compound. Ionic liquid brings multiple advantages such as
wider electrochemical stability, relatively high conductivity,
negligible vapor pressure, high resistance to chemical sub-
stances and excellent thermo-stability, as reported in our
previous works [16e18].
Several PVA-based fuel cells had been fabricated and
analyzed by researchers. Higa and his co-workers fabricated a
direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) with a polymer electrolyte
membrane where PVA is cross-linked 2 mol% of 2-methyl-1-
propanesulfonic acid (AMPS). Themaximumpower density of
2.4mWcm�2 was delivered by this DMFC [7]. In addition, PVA-
based nanocomposite polymer electrolytes were frequently
used as separator in direct methanol alkaline fuel cell
(DMAFC) and studied by Yang CC research group. The
maximum power density of 15.3 mW cm�2 was achieved
using PVA/potassium hydroxide (KOH) with doping of 20% of
fumed silica [6]. However, lower maximum power density of
7.54mW cm�2 was obtained in PVA/titania (TiO2)-based DMFC
[4]. Sekhon et al. synthesized polymer electrolyte containing
poly(vinylidene fluoride-co-hexafluoropropylene (PVdF-co-
HFP), triflic acid (HCF3SO3) and 2,3-dimethyl-1-octylimidazo-
lium triflate (DmOImTf) for a PEMFC. Power density of
0.5 mW cm�2 was obtained. This result is quite low compared
to the Nafion membrane. However, it is comparable with the
literature [19]. The objective of the current project is to prepare
environmentally friendly polymer electrolytes with high
electrical properties and excellent thermal stability. Polymer
electrolyte membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs) are thus fabricated
using prepared polymer films. The electrochemical perfor-
mances of PEMFCs such as power density are eventually
studied in the present work. Another aim of this current
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
project is to explore the effect of ionic liquid onto the elec-
trochemical properties of polymer electrolytes and fuel cells.
2. Experimental
2.1. Materials
Proton conducting polymer electrolytes comprising of PVA,
CH3COONH4 and BmImCl were prepared in this present work.
PVA (Sigma-Aldrich, USA, 99% hydrolyzed with molecular
weight of 130000 g mol�1), CH3COONH4 (Sigma, Japan) and
BmImCl (Acros organic, USA) were used as polymer, salt and
ionic liquid, respectively. All the materials were used as
received.
2.2. Preparation of ionic liquid based-poly(vinyl alcohol)proton conducting polymer electrolytes
Ionic liquid based-poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conducting
polymer electrolytes were prepared by solution casting tech-
nique. PVA was initially dissolved in distilled water. Appro-
priate amount of CH3COONH4was subsequentlymixed in PVA
solution. The weight ratio of PVA:CH3COONH4 was kept at
70:30. Different mass fraction of BmImCl was thus embedded
into the PVA-CH3COONH4 mixture to prepare ionic liquid-
based proton conducting polymer electrolyte. CL 2, CL 5 and
CL 6 were the designations of polymer electrolytes with
respect to addition of 20 wt%, 50 wt% and 60 wt% of BmImCl,
whereas CL 0 was for the polymer electrolyte without incor-
poration of BmImCl. The resulting solution was stirred thor-
oughly and heated at 70 �C for few hours until a homogenous
colorless solution is obtained. The solution was eventually
casted on glass Petri dish and dried in an oven at 60 �C to
obtain a free-standing proton conducting polymer electrolyte
film.
2.3. Characterization of ionic liquid based-PVA protonconducting polymer electrolytes
2.3.1. Ambient temperature-ionic conductivity studiesFreshly prepared samples were subjected to ac-impedance
spectroscopy for ionic conductivity determination. The
thickness of the film was measured by digital micrometer
screw gauge. The ionic conductivity of the polymer electro-
lytes was measured by HIOKI 3532-50 LCR HiTESTER imped-
ance analyzer over a frequency regime between 50 Hz and
5 MHz at ambient temperature. The data acquisition was
recorded at a signal level of 10mV. Proton conducting polymer
electrolytes were sandwiched on the sample holder under
spring pressure in the configuration of stainless steel (SS)
blocking electrode/polymer electrolyte/SS electrode.
2.3.2. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA)TGA was accomplished by thermogravimetric analyzer, TA
Instrument Universal Analyzer 2000 with Universal V4.7A
software. Sample weighing 2e3 mg placed into 150 ml of silica
crucible. The sampleswere then heated from 25 �C to 600 �C at
a heating rate of 50 �C min�1 in a nitrogen atmosphere with a
flow rate of 60 ml min�1.
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Rs+Rb
Rs
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h yd r o g e n e n e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 2 3
2.3.3. Attenuated total reflectance-Fourier TransformInfrared (ATR-FTIR)Themoscientific Nicolet iS10 FTIR Spectrometer (from USA)
was employed to perform ATR-FTIR study. This spectrometer
is equipped with an ATR internal reflection system. The FTIR
spectra were recorded with a resolution of 4 cm�1 in trans-
mittance mode over the wavenumber range from 4000 to
650 cm�1. The FTIR spectra and peak deconvolution were
scrutinized by OMNIC 8 softwarewhich is provided by Thermo
Fischer Scientific Inc. The transmittance mode of FTIR spectra
was initially converted into absorbance mode for peak
deconvolution process. In order to deconvolute the FTIR
spectra, baseline correction and curve fitting must be imple-
mented. The FTIR curve was fitted with gaussian-lorentzian
mixed mode.
2.4. Fuel cell fabrication
The most conducting polymer electrolyte was used for PEMFC
fabrication. The polymer membrane was soaked in distilled
water for 5 min prior the fabrication. The surface area of
electrodes is 16 cm2. The polymer electrolyte was then placed
in the PEMFC kit which is purchased from H-tec, Germany.
The assembled kit was eventually subjected to the Electro-
lyzer 10 (from H-tec, Germany) for electrochemical analysis
with hydrogen flow rate of 10 cm3 min�1 and oxygen flow rate
of 5 cm3 min�1.
2.4.1. Cell performancesThe performance of PEMFC was done by fuel cell measure-
ment setup which is comprised of Programmable DC power
supply (Model no: 3644A, Array Electronics Co. Ltd. from
Taiwan), rheostat (Model no: ZX97E, Tinsley from United
Kingdom) and Digital Bench Type True RMS multimeter
(UT803, Uni-Trend from Guangdong, Zhina). DC power supply
is employed to provide the current flow through the cell,
whereas the rheostat is used to adjust the current flow. The
measurements of voltage and current flow were probed using
multimeter. The cell potential in every 10 mA of current was
noted down, starting from 10 mA. The current density was
determined by dividing the operational current into surface
area of electrodes (16 cm�2). On the other hand, the power
densitywas calculatedusing the fundamental equationbelow:
P ¼ IV (1)
where P is power (W), I is operational current (A) and V is cell
potential (V). Again, the power density was eventually
computed by dividing the power into surface area of
electrodes.
00 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
Fig. 1 e ColeeCole impedance plot of CL 0 at room
temperature.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Ambient temperature-ionic conductivity studies
The ionic conductivity of polymer electrolytes is determined
using the following equation:
s ¼ lRbA
(2)
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
where l is the thickness of polymer electrolytes (cm); Rb is bulk
resistance (U) of polymer electrolytes and A is the known
surface area (cm2) of blocking electrodes. Fig. 1 shows a typical
impedance plot of CL 0 at ambient temperature. The Rb is
determined as shown in Fig. 1. Since the impedance plot is not
starting from origin, so the series resistance (Rs) is appeared in
the figure. The total resistance (combination of Rb and Rs) is
calculated from the intercept of the spike with the extrapo-
lation of the semicircular region on Z real axis. The Rb is
computed from the deduction of the total resistance with the
initial Rs. On the other hand, the spike of the plot indicates the
charge accumulation at the electrolyteeelectrode interface.
Fig. 2 depicts the ionic conductivity of proton-conducting
polymer electrolytes at different mass fraction of BmImCl.
Upon inclusion of ionic liquid, the ionic conductivity is
increased. As expected, the ionic conductivity increases with
mass loadings of ionic liquid, up to an optimum level. The
ionic conductivity increases gradually when 10 wt% of
BmImCl is added into the polymer electrolyte. However, the
ionic conductivity is found to be increased rapidlywith doping
of 20 wt% of BmImCl. The highest ionic conductivity of
(5.74 � 0.01) mS cm�1 corresponding to addition of 50 wt% of
BmImCl is observed. This conductivity has been increased by
two orders of magnitude in comparison to the polymer elec-
trolyte without impregnation of ionic liquid. The abrupt in-
crease in ionic conductivity is due to strong plasticizing effect
of ionic liquid [16,18]. Strong plasticizing effect of ionic liquid
aids to soften the polymer backbone and hence increases the
flexibility of polymer chain. The proton can be transported
easily within the polymer matrix with highly flexible polymer
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
-5.50
-5.00
-4.50
-4.00
-3.50
-3.00
-2.50
-2.00
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90Weight percent of BmImCl (wt %)
Fig. 2 e The ionic conductivity of proton conducting
polymer electrolytes at different mass ratio of BmImCl.
NN+
H
NN H+
Deprotonation+
..
CH2 CH CH2 CH
O OH
n
H
CH2 CH CH CH
O OH OH
n
H
NC
+
N
NN..
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n en e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 24
chains. Besides, higher flexibility of polymer chains improves
the mobility of polymer segments and assists the ionic
transportation within polymer complexes. Consequently, the
ionic conductivity is higher compared to the polymer elec-
trolyte without doping of ionic liquid. Moreover, ionic liquid
increases the amorphousness of the polymer matrix. Ionic
liquid could weaken the transient coordinative bonds among
the molecules in the crystalline region and thus turn the
polymer chains into flexible characteristic leading to higher
amorphous degree of polymer complexes. Ionic liquid also
promotes the ionic conduction process by providing more
conducting sites. This can be done by interacting BmImþ with
hydrogen of the side chain in the polymer backbone. This
interaction not only provides more conducting sites, but it
also provides more mobile proton upon the deprotonation.
In order to understand the principle in the proton-con-
ducting polymer electrolytes, the proton hopping mechanism
must be well studied. We propose a mechanism pertaining to
transport of conducting ions for proton-conducting polymer
electrolytes illustrated as follows. The ionic liquid: imidazo-
lium cation (BmImþ) and chloride (Cl�) can be easily detached
from the transient partial bonding due to the bulky size of the
cation. Thus, the hydrogen at C2-position of the mobile
BmImþ is initially de-protonated to form a stabilized carbene
[21,22].
CH2 CH CH2 CH
O OH
n
H
NC
+
N
Cl OCH3CO
CH2
or / and
3
3-butyl-1-methyl-4,5-di
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
This carbene could then interact with the hydrogen in
hydroxyl group of PVA and result carbocation in the imida-
zolium ring.
This interaction leads to the partial hydrogen bonding
between oxygen and hydrogen. In addition, the de-proton-
ated hydrogen in this step can help in accelerating the proton
conduction as it is in mobile state. When the hydrogen
bonding is partially bonded, the dissociated chloride and
acetate anions from ionic liquid and salt will prefer to
interact with the carbocation and thus break the hydrogen
bond between the imidazolium cations and side chain of
PVA. After the disintegration of hydrogen bonding, the oxy-
gen atom in the hydroxyl group of PVA turns into negatively
charged or forms anions. Therefore, these electron deficient
oxygen anions would accept the electron from proton from
the loosely bounded ammonium cations or from imidazo-
lium cations. Two possible side products could be formed in
this segment, viz. 3-butyl-2-chloro-1-methyl-4,5-dihydro-1H-
imidazole and 3-butyl-1-methyl-4,5-dihydro-1H-imidazole-2-
carboxylic acid methyl ester, as shown in the mechanism
below.
CH CH2 CH
O OH
n NN
Cl
NN
OOCCH3
: :..
+
or / and
-butyl-2-chloro-1-methyl-4,5-dihydro-1H-imidazole
hydro-1H-imidazole-2-carboxylic acid methyl ester
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h yd r o g e n e n e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 2 5
Beyond this step, there are two possibilities of proton
conduction process. The proton transportation can be gener-
ated from the hydrogen in ammonium cations or the
hydrogen in BmIm cations. The dissociated proton from
loosely bounded ammonium cations of doping salt would
then interact with this negatively charged oxygen and result
the formation of hydroxyl group through hydrogen bonding.
This partial hydrogen bonding would result the CONH coor-
dination bond. On the other hand, the detached chloride or/
and acetate anions will abstract an electron from hydrogen.
This hydrogen will thus leave the hydroxyl group and hence
turn into anions. The adjacent hydrogen could interact with
this oxygen and hence generate the proton transportation
from site to another adjacent site.
CH2
CH CH2
CH
O O
n
H+
Cl OCH3CO
H
CH2
CH CH2
CH
O
n
OH: : ..
or / and
: : ..
Apart from that, we suggest that proton conduction can
also take place at the BmIm cations. For this proton transport,
BmIm cations could interact with the oxygen in PVA and form
NeO bond temporarily. Similarly, the detached chloride or/
and acetate anions will abstract an electron from hydrogen of
another branched site and produce oxygen which is appeared
as anions. As next step, the electron from the hydrogen from
C2-position in BmIm cations could be donated to this electron-
deficient oxygen. In order to form a stable compound, the NeO
bond must be broken down. Hence, this bond detachment
could lead to the formation of carbene, which is an important
chemical compound in weakening the transient coordination
bond within the macromolecules. Eventually, the proton
conduction mechanism is repeated again with the formation
of carbene. These two possible mechanisms will cause
continuous ionic hopping mechanism in the polymer matrix.
CH2
CH CH2
CH
O O
n
Cl OCH3CO
H
NN+
CH2
CH CH2
CHn
OO
NN
H
NN
: : ..
or / and
: :
..
+
..
Beyond adulteration of 50 wt% of BmImCl, the ionic con-
ductivity is found to be lower in value. This is ascribed to the
agglomeration of ions. Excessive ions in the polymer electro-
lyte could form ion pairs and ion aggregates. These ion pairs
and ion aggregates might block the conducting pathway and
hinder the proton from transportation, leading to lower ionic
conductivity. The amount of proton for conduction is also
decreased in the presence of ion pairs and ion aggregates. At
high concentration of ionic liquid, NH4þ cations could rather
form ion pairs with other anions than provide proton for
transportation. Similar observation goes to BmImþ cations.
These cations help in providing the conducting site as afore-
mentioned above. However, at highmass loadings, the cations
could form ion neutral pairs with anions and thus turn the
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
cations into immobile state. As a consequence, the conducting
sites could be lesser and ultimately reduce the ionic conduc-
tivity. These neutral ion pairs and ion aggregates could
impede the conducting pathway and reduce the flexibility of
polymer chains. This phenomenon can be proven by deter-
mining the activation energy of the proton transportation. The
activation energies of polymer electrolytes containing 20 wt%,
50 wt% and 60 wt% of BmImCl are 7.54, 7.11 and 7.74 meV,
respectively (not shown in this manuscript). Higher activation
energy of the polymer electrolytes infers higher energy that
the proton requires to overcome the barriers for the trans-
portation. Therefore, we can conclude that the lower ionic
conductivity of the polymer electrolytes containing highmass
fraction of BmImCl is attributed to the formation of ion pairs
and ion aggregates as the ion pairs can block the transport
pathway within the polymer chains.
3.2. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA)
Fig. 3 portrays thermogravimetric analysis for pure PVA, CL
0 and ionic liquid-based polymer electrolytes. Pure PVA shows
three major weight losses, as described in Yang et al. [14].
However, four thermal degradation steps are observed for salt
and/or ionic liquid-doped polymer electrolytes. The initial
thermal degradation in the region of 25 �Ce125 �C is due to the
dehydration of water or moisture as polymer is a hydroscopic
compound [23]. The insignificant weight loss in this stage is
also due to the elimination of impurities in the polymer
electrolytes. Small weight losses of 5%, 5% and 6% are
observed for pure PVA, CL 0 and CL 6, respectively in this re-
gion. However, higher mass losses of 9% have been observed
for CL 2 and CL 5. Beyond this stage, the weight of all the
samples remains the same until 200 �C. Upon the dehydration,
ammonium acetate could be decomposed easily into acet-
amide, CH3C(O)NH2.
On the contrary, two PVA polymer chains might be cross-
linked as a result of water removal. This elimination could
lead to the formation of ether cross-linkages [11]. Above
200 �C, an abrupt decrease in weight is observed for all the
samples. Among all the samples, pristine PVA portrays the
highest mass loss from 210 �C to 235 �C in this segment.
Elimination of side chain in polymer backbone of PVA is the
main attributor to this thermal degradation for pure PVA [14].
Apart from formation of ether cross-linkages, the polymer
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Wei
ght (
%)
Pure PVA CL 0 CL 2 CL 5 CL 6
Fig. 3 e Thermogravimetric analysis of pure PVA, CL 0, CL
2, CL 5 and CL 6.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n en e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 26
backbone of PVA could start a rapid chain stripping on the
polymer backbone upon heating and hence turn into conju-
gated double bonds, giving rise to formation of polyene, as
illustrated as below [11]:
Upon addition of salt and ionic liquid, the mass loss in this
stage is significantly decreased. Besides, the starting decom-
position temperature in this stage is improved. These obser-
vations deduct the contribution from the complexation
between salt and/or ionic liquid and PVA. This is because
higher energy would be required to break the transient coor-
dination bond in the complexation process. Weight losses of
32%, 43%, 33% and 44% corresponding to the temperature
range of 240 �Ce245 �C, 245 �Ce285 �C, 250 �Ce305 �C,235 �Ce245 �C are attained for CL 0, CL 2, CL 5 and CL 6,
respectively. The contributor of this thermal decomposition
stage is suggestive of the degradation of acetamide where its
decomposition temperature is around 222 �C. The chain
stripping mechanism is less favorable in CL 0 when the salt is
complexed with PVA. In contrast, the carbene produced from
ionic liquid interacts with the hydrogen from hydroxyl group
in PVA and forms the coordination bond. Therefore, the chain
stripping process might also be absent in the polymer
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
electrolytes containing ionic liquid. Moreover, BmImCl starts
to be degraded at 237 �C as reported in Lee et al. [25]. As a
result, decomposition of BmImCl also causes the mass loss in
this region. Hence, the weight loss of ionic liquid-based
polymer electrolytes is found to be higher than CL 0 with this
additional attributor. This is in good agreementwith the result
obtained where higher weight loss is obtained for those ionic
liquid-plasticized polymer electrolytes. As can be seen, CL 5
depicts the highest decomposition temperature. This implies
that the most conducting polymer electrolytes exhibit better
thermal properties than other polymer complexes.
A consecutive enormous loss in weight is observed
thereafter for all polymer electrolytes. However, pure PVA
exemplifies insignificant mass loss of 8% from 235 �C until
410 �C. The weight loss of all polymer electrolytes remains in
the regime of 20e30%. CL 0 has weight loss of 20%, starting
from 245 �C until 375 �C, whereas CL 2 exhibits mass loss of
21%, from 285 �C to 365 �C. Similarly, CL 6 also shows around
21% of weight loss in the temperature range of 245 �C and
350 �C. On the contrary, the weight loss of CL 5 is increased
by 5%, which is around 26% whereby the degradation tem-
perature starts from 305 �C to 355 �C. The thermal degra-
dation in this phase arises from the chemical degradation
processes. These chemical decomposition processes include
the breakdown of ether cross-linkages and random chain
scissoring between carbonecarbon bonds [11]. Random bond
scission yields two intermediate products and thus
forms methyl-terminated allylic polyene in cis and trans
isomerisms via elimination process, as demonstrated as
below [24].
Final weight loss is attained at elevated temperature. Pure
PVA and CL 0 show 20% and 26.8% of weight losses, along with
12% and 11% of mass residues at 575 �C, respectively. Ionicliquid-based polymer electrolytes display lower mass loss in
comparison to CL 0. CL 2 exhibits 21% of weight loss from
365 �C to 570 �Cwith residualmass of 3%, whereas CL 5 reveals
higher mass loss, which is around 25% with 6% of residue in
the temperature range of 355 �C-565 �C. CL 6 starts to loss its
weight around 22% with 9% of residue from 350 �C to 575 �C.This final weight loss is connected to the breakdown of the
polymer backbone as reported in Yang et al. [14]. Upon further
heating, the double bond of polyene would be broken down
into single bond and eventually converted into aliphatic
polymer chains at this stage [24]. Beyond this stage, theweight
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h yd r o g e n e n e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 2 7
of samples remains unchanged. This observation infers the
fully decomposition of the polymer matrix. Although the re-
sidual mass of ionic liquid-based polymer electrolytes is
lesser, however, CL 5 is still a promising candidate as polymer
electrolyte due to its higher first decomposition temperature.
3.3. Attenuated total reflectance-Fourier TransformInfrared (ATR-FTIR)
The PVAeCH3COONH4 polymer electrolyte systems have been
prepared and investigated. The FTIR results and the
complexation between PVA and CH3COONH4 have been
elucidated in the literature [15,20,26e32]. Therefore, the
interaction between PVA and CH3COONH4 is not discussed in
this present work. The interactions between ionic liquid and
ammonium acetate-doped polymer electrolyte are also
analyzed and discussed in details. Fig. 4 depicts the ATR-FTIR
spectra of CL 0, BmImCl, CL 2, CL 5 and CL 6. On the other
hand, the band assignment of the spectra is summarized in
Table 1. The ATR-FTIR spectrum of CL 5 is investigated as it
achieves the maximum ionic conducting as aforementioned
in section 3.1. Upon adulteration of BmImCl, sixteen new
peaks have been formed by comparing Fig. 4(a) with Fig. 3(d).
These peaks are CeH vibrational mode for cyclic BmImþ at
655 cm�1, 693 cm�1, 3109 cm�1 and 3159 cm�1 [33], CeH
bendingmode for cyclic BmImþ at 752 cm�1 [33], in-plane CeH
bending mode of imidazolium ring at 890 cm�1 [34], in-plane
CeNeC bending mode at 951 cm�1 [35], out-of-plane CeH
wagging mode in alkyl chain at 1019 cm�1 [34], CH3eN
stretching mode at 1168 cm�1 [36], CH2 symmetric bending
mode at 1335 cm�1 [33], CH3 asymmetric stretching mode at
1378 cm�1 [33], CH3 asymmetric bending mode at 1428 cm�1
and 1456 cm�1 [36], C]N stretching mode at 1540 cm�1 [37]
and CeC and CeN bending modes of imidazolium ring at
1696 cm�1 [33]. Some characteristic peaks of CL 0 are dis-
appeared with doping of BmImCl. Examples of these charac-
teristic peaks are the combinations of CHOH bending mode,
CH3 in-plane deformation and CeH wagging mode at
Fig. 4 e ATReFTIR spectra of (a) CL 0, (b) BmImCl, (c) Cl 2, (d)
CL 5 and (e) CL 6.
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
1329 cm�1 cm�1, CeH deformationmode at 1414 cm�1 and C]
O stretching mode at 1701 cm�1.
Apart from that, the CeCl stretching mode of BmImCl at
791 cm�1 is disappeared. This entails the chloride dissociation
from BmIm cations. Therefore, the dissociated BmIm cations
could form the carbene compound after the deprotonation
process, as suggested in section 3.1. This idea is supported by
the absences of out-of-plane CeH bending mode of imidazo-
lium ring at 730 cm�1 [35], CeH bendingmode inmethyl group
at 1132 cm�1 [38], CeN stretchingmode of imidazolium ring at
1289 cm�1 [35] and ¼ CeH stretching mode at 3091 cm�1 [35].
The proton conduction in ammonium salt-doped polymer
electrolyte is based on the formation of CONH bond, as
explained in section 3.1. However, the proton is migrated in a
different way for polymer electrolytes containing BmImCl, as
suggested in section 3.1. The CONH bonding mode of CL 0 is
absent in all the ionic liquid-based polymer electrolytes and
further verifies the proposed mechanism.
The CeH bending mode of CL 0 is shifted to lower wave-
number from 662 cm�1 to 655 cm�1 due to the overlapping of
CeH vibration mode for cyclic BmImþ. The CeH vibration
mode for cyclic BmImþ at 698 cm�1 also exhibit downward
shift to 693 cm�1 by comparing Fig. 4(a) with Fig. 3(d). The
sharp peak at 844 cm�1 in Fig. 4(a) is designated as skeletal
CeH rockingmode of PVA and shifted to 846 cm�1 with doping
of ionic liquid. This peak not only exhibits the change in shift,
but it also undergoes the change in peak intensity. The in-
tensity of peak is gradually reduced from 11.28% to 8.66%, in
transmittance mode, as demonstrated in Fig. 5. This phe-
nomenon indicates the interaction between ionic liquid and
polymer matrix. Another apparent proof to show the inter-
action between CeH bonding in imidazolium ring and CL 0 is
also attained at the wavenumber of 890 cm�1. A sharp peak
with its intensity of 19.12% is observed in ionic liquid spectra;
however it has been turned into a weak peakwith its intensity
of 0.14% in transmittance mode. Fig. 4(b) depicts a sharp peak
at 900 cm�1 with a shoulder peak at 940 cm�1. Upon addition
of PVA and ammonium acetate, this band becomes two new
peaks with an extremely low intensity at 918 cm�1 and
951 cm�1. These twoweak peaks are assigned as OeH bending
mode and in-plane CeNeC bending mode at 918 cm�1 and
951 cm�1, respectively, reflecting the formation of NO bond as
aforementioned in section 3.1 [28]. The intensity of first peak
is also reduced from 3.35% to 1.06% in transmittance mode. A
sharp peak is observed at 1089 cm�1 in the wavenumber range
of 1100 cm�1e1000 cm�1 for CL 0 and assigned as CeO
stretching mode. But, it has been changed to a medium sharp
peak at 1092 cm�1 with a shoulder peak at 1021 cm�1 when
BmImCl is embedded into the polymer complex. This in-
dicates the overlapping of out-of-plane CeH wagging mode in
alkyl chain with polymer matrix and further deduces the
interaction between CeO bond from polymer matrix and CeH
functional group from ionic liquid. This result agreeswell with
our proposed mechanism in section 3.1 where the hydrogen
from ionic liquid will be abstracted to the adjacent electron-
deficient oxygen for the proton hopping mechanism. Even
though the CeO stretching mode still remains unchanged at
1236 cm�1, however, the intensity of the peak is relatively
reduced upon impregnation of ionic liquid. The peak reduc-
tion entails that the proton conduction could be taken place at
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Table 1 e The assignments of the vibration modes of BmImCl, CL 0, CL 2, CL 5 and CL 6.
Descriptions of vibration modes Wavenumber (cm�1)
BmImCl CL 0 CL 2 CL 5 CL 6
CeH bending mode e 662 655 655 657
CeH vibration mode for cyclic BmImþ 662, 698,
3113, 3152
e 655, 698,
3103, 3159
655, 693,
3109, 3159
657, 703,
e, e
Outeofeplane CeH bending mode of
imidazolium ring
730 e e e e
CeH bending mode for cyclic BmImþ 746 e 753 752 751
CeCl stretching mode 791 e e e e
Skeletal CeH rocking mode e 844 846 846 848
Ineplane CeH bending mode of imidazolium
ring
900 e 885 890 e
OeH bending mode e 918 918 918 918
Ineplane CeNeC bending mode 940 e 951 951 e
Outeofeplane CeH wagging mode in alkyl
chain
1018 e 1019 1021 1019
CeO stretching mode e 1089 1092 1092 1089
CeH bending mode in methyl group 1132 e e e e
CeC and CeO stretching modes of doubly H
ebonded OH in crystalline region
e 1140 1143 1140 1142
CH3eN stretching mode 1163 e 1169 1168 e
CeO stretching mode e 1236 1236 1236 1236
CeN stretching mode of imidazolium ring 1289 e e e e
CHOH bending mode, CH3 ineplane
deformation and CeH wagging mode
e 1329 e e e
CH2 symmetric bending mode 1337 e 1335 1335 1332
CH3 asymmetric stretching mode 1388 e 1378 1378 1375
CeH deformation mode 1413 1414 1409 e 1410
CH3 asymmetric bending mode 1434 e e 1428 e
CH3 symmetric bending mode 1465 e 1453 1456 e
C¼C stretching mode 1517 e 1504 e 1504
C¼N stretching mode 1560 e e 1540 e
NeH bending mode e 1561 1567 1571 1559
CeH stretching mode e 1648 1648 1647 1652
eCONHe bonding mode e 1669 e e e
CeC and CeN bending mode of imidazolium
ring
1675 e 1696 1696 1699
C¼O stretching mode e 1701 e e e
CeH symmetric stretching mode in methyl
group of alkyl chain
2872, 2950,
2966
2850, 2906,
2937
2876, 2911,
2940
2870, 2939 2850, 2911,
2938
OeH stretching mode of OH group e 3259 3332 3347 3260
¼CeH stretching mode 3091 e e e e
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n en e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 28
the CeO coordination bond when the ionic liquid is com-
plexed with polymer backbone.
The sharp peak at 1163 cm�1 is designated as CH3eN
stretching mode, whereas the weak peak at 1388 cm�1 is
associated with CH3 asymmetric stretching mode. The first
peak exhibits upward shift to 1168 cm�1 with reduced peak
intensity of 31.11%, from 44.11% to 13% in transmittance
mode. On the contrary, the latter peak shifts to lower wave-
number to 1378 where its intensity is gradually reduced from
3.17% to 0.73% in transmittance mode. The peak at 1414 cm�1
is designated as CeH deformation mode. However, the in-
clusion of 50 wt% of ionic liquid induces to the formation
double peaks at 1456 cm�1 and 1428 cm�1, as shown in Fig. 6.
The change in shape is suggestive of the overlap of CeH
deformation mode at 1413 cm�1, CH3 asymmetric bending
mode at 1434 cm�1 and CH3 symmetric bending mode at
1465 cm�1. This can be proven using the deconvolution
method. The peaks are fitted and deconvoluted as illustrated
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
in Fig. 7. Three deconvoluted peaks are obtained in this
wavenumber range. This result is in good agreement with our
suggestion. Again, this signifies the interaction of hydrogen
from CeH bond with polymer membrane where the proton
conduction can take place at. A medium sharp peak at
1561 cm�1 corresponding to NeH bending mode is attained in
CL 0 spectra. Nevertheless, the peak has been developed into a
sharp peak at 1571 with a shoulder peak at 1540 cm�1. The
intensity of the sharp peak is increased from 6.56% to 10.01%
in transmittance mode. The overlapping of C]N stretching
mode at 1560 cm�1 andC]C stretchingmode from ionic liquid
at 1517 cm�1 contributes to this changes of peak intensity,
peak location and shape. This can be a sign of interaction
between ionic liquid and CL 0. The weak peak analogous to
CeH stretching mode at 1648 cm�1 is changed to a medium
sharp peak at 1647 cm�1. The intensity of this peak is
increased from 0.43% to 5.63% in transmittance mode as
observed in Fig. 4(a and d). This finding reveals the
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Fig. 5 e The change in peak intensity of skeletal CeH
rocking mode of (a) CL 0 and (b) CL 5 in the wavenumber
region of 850 cmL1e800 cmL1.
Fig. 7 e The original and fitted curves with the
deconvoluted peaks in the wavenumber region of
1495 cmL1e1390 cmL1.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h yd r o g e n e n e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 2 9
complexation between ionic liquid and macromolecules and
verifies the proton conduction.
Another proof to show the proton conduction is also
detected in the range of 3000 cm�1e2800 cm�1. Double peaks
with a shoulder peak are appeared as a broad bandwithin this
region. This band is designated as CeH symmetric stretching
mode in methyl group of alkyl chain. However, only a peak
with a shoulder peak is observed at their respective wave-
number of 2939 cm�1 and 2870 cm�1 upon inclusion of
BmImCl. Similar phenomenon is attained for the band within
the range of 3400 cm�1e3000 cm�1. CL 0 illustrates a broad
peak at 3259 which is related to OeH stretching vibration
mode of OH group in PVA. Two additional shoulder peaks are
scrutinized at 3109 cm�1 and 3159 cm�1 in which the OeH
-0.01
0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
1380 1400 1420 1440 1460 1480 1500
Abs
orba
nce
Wavenumber (cm-1)
Original curve Fitted curve Deconvoluted peaks
1465 cm-1
1434 cm-1
1413 cm-1
Fig. 6 e The change in shape of vibration modes of (a) CL
0 and (b) CL 5 in the wavenumber region of
1500 cmL1e1400 cmL1.
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
stretching mode is shifted to 3347 cm�1 with doping of
BmImCl. These newly formed shoulder peaks are known as
CeH vibration mode for cyclic BmImþ of ionic liquid. There-
fore, these changes in shift and peak position can be indicative
of interaction between CeH vibrationmode of ionic liquid and
OeH stretching mode of PVA which aids in the proton
conduction.
Among all the samples, we found out that the highest ionic
conductivity is achieved by adding 50 wt% of BmImCl as
shown in Fig. 2. One of the attributors in enhancing the ionic
conductivity is correlated to lower crystalline region (or higher
amorphous degree) in the polymer electrolytes. The vital
feature can be proven in the ATR-FTIR spectra. CeC and CeO
stretchingmodes of doubly H-bonded OH in crystalline region
is located at 1140 cm�1 with its intensity of 5.57% in Fig. 4(a).
The intensity of this peak is gradually reduced to 3.97% cor-
responding to CL 2 at 1143 cm�1 and 1.61% at 1140 cm�1 for CL
5. Therefore, it can be concluded that CL 5 has the lowest
crystalline region compared to CL 0 and CL 2. It is in good
agreement with the suggestion that we proposed in section
3.1. The intensity of this characteristic peak of CL 6 is
increased to 6.42% in comparison to CL 0, CL 2 and CL 5, as
shown in Fig. 4(e). When the ionic liquid is added further, the
crystalline phase of CL 6 becomes higher due to the ion pairing
and ion aggregation as a result of excessive ion. The formation
of ion pairs and ion aggregates can be further proven by the
disappearance of some characteristic peaks in Fig. 4(e). These
peaks are: in-plane CeH bending mode of imidazolium ring at
900 cm�1, in-plane CeNeC bending mode at 940 cm�1, CH3eN
stretchingmode at 1163 cm�1, CH3 asymmetric bendingmode
at 1434 cm�1, CH3 symmetric bending mode at 1465 cm�1, C]
N stretching mode 1560 cm�1, and CeH vibration modes for
cyclic BmImþ at 3113 cm�1 and 3152 cm�1. The changes in
peak intensity, peak position and shape establish the
complexation between ionic liquid and polymer matrix.
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Fig. 9 e The power density of the fabricated PEMFC
containing CL0, CL 2, CL 5 and CL 6 polymer electrolytes at
different current density with inset of figure.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n en e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 210
3.4. Cell performances
In order to study the effect of ionic liquid onto the electro-
chemical performances of fuel cell, four fuel cells are assem-
bled by sandwiching CL0, CL 2, CL 5 or CL 6 between anode and
cathode and further analyzed. Electrolyzer is used to generate
hydrogen and oxygen gases. The hydrogen gas is connected to
anode, whereas the oxygen is channeled to cathode. Below are
the general reactions in both electrodes.
Anode : 2H2/4Hþ þ 4e�
Cathode : 4Hþ þO2/2H2O
Complete reaction : 2H2 þO2/2H2O
Hydrogen gas which acts as fuel will be split into positively
charged hydrogen (or known as proton) and negatively
charged electrons in the presence of catalyst layer at anode.
For next step, the polymer electrolyte membrane allows the
protons to travel from anode to cathode. In contrast, the
electrons are transported along the external circuit to cathode
and hence create electrical current. Eventually, the combina-
tions between proton and oxygen with the help of electrons
will formwater as by-product at cathode side. This by-product
will be flowed out from the system.
The open-circuit voltage (Voc) is determined when no cur-
rent flows into the fuel cell. This is known as the initial voltage
prior to the cell voltage measurement. Figs. 8 and 9 depict the
cell potential and power density of the electrochemical cells
with different current density at room temperature, respec-
tively. The Voc of CL 0, CL 2, CL 5 and CL 6 are 0.27 V, 0.37 V,
0.66 V and 0.56 V, respectively as illustrated in Fig. 8. As can
been seen in current density-potential curves, the cell po-
tential of ionic liquid-based polymer electrolytes are higher
than that of polymer electrolytes without inclusion of ionic
liquid. This is mainly attributed to the strong plasticizing ef-
fect of ionic liquid. The plasticizing effect of ionic liquid not
only helps in promoting the proton conduction by weakening
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Cel
l pot
enti
al (
V)
Current density (mAcm-2)
CL 0 CL 2 CL 5 CL 6
Fig. 8 e The cell potential of the fabricated PEMFC
containing CL0, CL 2, CL 5 and CL 6 polymer electrolytes at
different current density.
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
the transient bonds, but it also produces sticky samples. The
sticky feature of the sample can improve the contact between
the cathode and anode. Therefore, the proton can be traveled
easily. All the curves manifest the same pattern with respect
to current density. The cell potential of fuel cell decreases
with increasing the current density. The result is same as the
findings that other researchers have reported previously
[3e6]. Ionic liquid-based polymer electrolytes possess better
electrochemical performance than CL 0 by showing higher
current density at the end of the curve. This occurrence in-
dicates that fuel cell comprising of ionic liquid-based polymer
electrolytes can withstand higher current before the complete
degradation process. CL 0 has been fully decomposed when
620 mA of current (or equivalent with current density of
38.75mA cm�2) is applied into the cell. Upon inclusion of 20wt
% of ionic liquid into the polymer electrolyte, themembrane is
degraded at the current of 660 mA (or corresponding to
41.25 mA cm�2). On the other hand, the fuel cell consisting CL
5 stops the function at the current 950 mA or current density
of 59.34 mA cm�2. However, the electrochemical properties of
fuel cell are decreased when BmImCl is further added into the
polymermatrix. Comparing CL 5 and CL 6, CL 6 is decomposed
at lower current that is 700 mA with current density of
43.75 mA cm�2.
Power density of fuel cell is also determined. The power
density of fuel cell increases with current density, up to a
maximum level, as depicted in Fig. 9. The inset of figure por-
trays the peak obtained for fuel cell based on CL 0, CL 2 and CL
5 in a smaller scale. Beyond the highest value, the power
density of fuel cell is found to be decreased gradually. This
decrement of power density is correlated to the degradation of
polymer electrolytes at higher current supply. The doping of
ionic liquid can enhance the electrochemical properties of fuel
cell as explained above. The same conclusion can also be
drawn using the power density result. Fuel cell based on CL 2
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h yd r o g e n e n e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 2 11
polymermembrane exemplifies higher power density than CL
0. The maximum power density of 0.73 mW cm�2 is observed
at 0.05 V with a peak current density of 15.63 mA cm�2. This
peak is shifted to higher current with a higher power density
with addition of 20 wt% of BmImCl. Fuel cell comprising of CL
2 displays a maximum power density of 1.13 mW cm�2 at a
maximum potential of 0.06 V with a peak current density of
18.13 mA cm�2. Among all the ionic liquid-based polymer
electrolytes, the fabricated fuel cell using CL 5 offers excellent
electrochemical characteristics, where the power density of
18mWcm�2 at a peak current density of 46.88mA cm�2 with a
maximum operational potential of 0.38 V is observed in Fig. 9.
The increase in power density of fuel cell as increases the
mass loading of ionic liquid into the polymer matrix is
strongly due to the higher ionic conductivity of ionic liquid-
based polymer electrolytes. Numerous protons with higher
mobility are allowed to be transported from anode to cathode
if the polymer electrolyte is conductive. Therefore, higher
conductive characteristic of polymer electrolyte promotes the
conversion of the fuel into electricity through a redox process
in a fuel cell system and thereby increases the power density
of the electrochemical cell. Nevertheless, the further inclusion
of ionic liquid alters the electrochemical properties of fuel cell.
Fuel cell based on CL 6 exhibits the maximum power density
of 2.96mWcm�2 at amaximumpotential of 0.25 Vwith a peak
current density of 11.88 mA cm�2 is observed in Fig. 9. Upon
addition of 60 wt% of BmImCl not only decreases the power
density of cell, but it also reduces the peak current density, as
depicted in the inset of Fig. 9. In other words, excessive ionic
liquid concentration in the polymer electrolytes could pro-
duce the ion aggregation which inhibits the conducting routes
within the polymer chains. As a result, this proton con-
ducting-polymer electrolyte possesses lower ionic conduc-
tivity and hence leads to lower electrochemical performance
of fuel cell.
Composite polymer electrolytes-based direct methanol
fuel cells (DMFCs) were also prepared by Yang group. The
maximumpower density of 6.77mWcm�2 was reported in the
literature. Another type of DMAFC using crosslinked PVA/SSA
was also prepared by Yang. This DMAFC generates the highest
power density of 4.13 mW cm�2 at 60 �C and 1 atm [39,40]. The
power density of PEMFC obtained in this present work is
higher than these two literature and the literature that we
mentioned in the introduction. So, this implies that the pre-
pared ionic liquid-based proton conducting polymer electro-
lytes exhibit excellent electrochemical performance in fuel
cell. It can be concluded that CL 5 is the promising candidate
as polymer electrolyte in a fuel cell as it can achieves the
highest cell power density of 18 mW cm�2 with improved
electrochemical properties.
4. Conclusion
Ionic liquid-based proton conducting polymer electrolytes
were prepared by solution casting method. The ionic con-
ductivity of these polymer electrolytes is greatly increased
with doping of ionic liquid due to the strong plasticizing effect.
The ionic conductivity also increased with mass fraction of
ionic liquid, up to a maximum level, which corresponds to
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
inclusion of 50 wt% of BmImCl. Upon addition of 50 wt% of
BmImCl, the highest ionic conductivity of (5.74 � 0.01)
mS cm�1 is achieved at ambient temperature. This most
conductive polymer membrane exhibited better thermal
properties than other polymer electrolytes as it is stable up to
250 �C. The temperature of first thermal degradation stage is
shifted to higher temperature with doping of salt and ionic
liquid due to the complexation. ATR-FTIR showed the in-
teractions between PVA, ammonium acetate and BmImCl and
further proved the complexation within the polymer electro-
lytes. Fuel cells were eventually fabricated using the electro-
lyzer and fuel cell membrane kit. Ionic liquid also helped in
enhancing the electrochemical properties of fuel cells. The
open-circuit voltage and power density of fuel cell have been
greatly improved with doping of ionic liquid. The maximum
power density of 18 mW cm�2 was achieved in the fuel cell
containing the most conducting polymer electrolyte at room
temperature, along with operational current of 750 mA.
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by the High Impact Research Grant
(J-21002-73851) from University of Malaya and eScienceFund
(16e02e03e6031) from Ministry of Science, Technology and
Innovation (MOSTI), Malaysia. Gratitude also goes to “Perun-
tukan Penyelidikan Pascasiswazah (PPP), Universiti Malaysia”.
One of the authors, ChiameWen Liew gratefully acknowl-
edges the “Skim Bright Sparks Universiti Malaya” (SBSUM) for
scholarship award.
r e f e r e n c e s
[1] Kim DS, Park HB, Rhim JW, Lee YM. Preparation andcharacterization of crosslinked PVA/SiO2 hybrid membranescontaining sulfonic acid groups for direct methanol fuel cellapplications. J Membrane Sci 2004;240:37e48.
[2] Qiao J, Okada T, Ono H. High molecular weightPVAemodified PVA/PAMPS protone conducting membraneswith increased stability and their application in DMFCs. SolidState Ionics 2009;180:1318e23.
[3] HasanieSadrabadi MM, Dashtimoghadam E, Ghaffarian SR,HasanieSadrabadi MH, Heidari M, Moaddel H. Novelhigheperformance nanocomposite proton exchangemembranes based on poly(ether sulfone). Renewable Energy2010;35:226e31.
[4] Yang CC. Synthesis and characterization of the crosselinkedPVA/TiO2 composite polymer membrane for alkaline DMFC. JMembrane Sci 2007;288:51e60.
[5] Surampudi S, Narayanan SR, Vamos E, Frank H, Halpert G,Laconti A, et al. Advances in direct oxidation methanol fuelcells. J Power Sources 1994;47:377e85.
[6] Lue SJ, Mahesh KPO, Wang WT, Chen JY, Yang CC. Permeanttransport properties and cell performance of potassiumhydroxide doped poly(vinyl alcohol)/fumed silicananocomposites. J Membrane Sci 2010;367:256e64.
[7] Higa M, Hatemura K, Sugita M, Maesowa S, Nishimura M,Endo N. Performance of passive direct methanol fuel cellwith poly(vinyl alcohol)ebased polymer electrolytemembranes. International J Hydrogen Energy2011;37:6292e301.
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n en e r g y x x x ( 2 0 1 3 ) 1e1 212
[8] Bhat SD, Sahu AK, George C, Pitchumani S, Sridhar P,Chandrakumar N, et al. Mordeniteeincorporated PVAePSSAmembranes as electrolytes for DMFCs. J Membrane Sci2009;340:73e83.
[9] Clochard MC, Berthelot T, Baudin C, Betz N, Balanzat E,Gebel G, et al. Ion track grafting: a way of producing lowecostand highly proton membranes for fuel cell applications.J Power Sources 2010;195:223e31.
[10] Maiti J, Kakati N, Lee SH, Jee SH, Yoon YS. PVA nanocomposite membrane for DMFC application. Solid StateIonics 2011;201:21e6.
[11] Guirguis OW, Moselhey MTH. Thermal and structural studiesof poly(vinyl alcohol) and hydroxypropyl cellulose blends.Natural Sci 2012;4:57e67.
[12] Yang CC, Wu GM. Study of microporous PVA/PVC compositepolymer membrane and it application to MnO2 capacitors.Mat Chem Phy 2009;114:948e55.
[13] Buraidah MH, Arof AK. Characterization of chitosan/PVAblended electrolyte doped with NH4I. J NoneCryst Solids2011;357:3261e6.
[14] Yang JM, Chiang CY, Wang HZ, Yang CC. Two stepmodification of poly(vinyl alcohol) by UV radiation with2ehydroxyl ethyl methacrylate and solegel process for theapplication of polymer electrolyte membrane. J MembraneSci 2009;341:186e94.
[15] Hirankumar G, Selvasekarapandian S, Kuwata N,Kawamura J, Hattori T. Thermal, electrical and opticalstudies on the poly(vinyl alcohol) based polymer electrolytes.J Power Sources 2005;144:262e7.
[16] Ramesh S, Liew CW, Ramesh K. Evaluation andinvestigation on the effect of ionic liquid onto PMMAePVCgel polymer blend electrolytes. J NoneCryst Solids2011;357:2132e8.
[17] Ramesh S, Liew CW. Tailoremade fumed silicaebasednanoecomposite polymer electrolytes consisting ofBmImTFSI ionic liquid. Iranian Polym J 2012;21:273e81.
[18] Ramesh S, Liew CW, Arof AK. Ion conducting corn starchbiopolymer electrolytes doped with ionic liquid1ebutyle3emethylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate.J NoneCryst Solids 2011;357:3654e60.
[19] Sekhon SS, Lalia BS, Park JS, Kim CS, Yamada K.Physicochemical properties of proton conductingmembranes based on ionic liquid impregnated polymer forfuel cells. J Mater Chem 2006;16:2256e65.
[20] Hirankumar G, Selvasekarapandian S, Bhuvaneswari MS,Baskaran R, Vijayakumar M. AC impedance studies onproton conducting polymer electrolyte complexes(PVA þ CH3COONH4). Ionics 2004;10:135e8.
[21] Zhang Z, Liu W, Xie H, Zhao ZK. An Unexpected reactionbetween 5-hydroxymethylfurfural and imidazoliumebasedionic liquids at high temperatures. Mol 2011;16:8463e74.
[22] Canal JP, Ramnial T, Dickie DA, Clyburne JAC. From thereactivity of Neheterocyclic carbenes to new chemistry inionic liquids. Chem Commun 2006;17:1809e18.
[23] Sriupayo J, Supaphol P, Blackwell J, Rujiravanit R. Preparationand characterization of aechitin whiskerereinforcedpoly(vinyl alcohol) nanocomposite films with or without heattreatment. Polym 2005;46:5637e44.
[24] Gilman JW, VanderHart DL, Kashiwagi T. Thermaldecomposition chemistry of poly(vinyl alcohol). In:
Please cite this article in press as: Liew C-W, et al., A novel approapolymer electrolytes for fuel cell applications, International Joj.ijhydene.2013.07.092
Nelson GL, editor. Fire and polymers II: materials and test forhazard prevention. , Washington: American ChemicalSociety; 1995. p. 161e84. ACS Symposium Series 599.
[25] Lee KY, Kim CS, Kim H, Cheong M, Mukherjee DK, Jung KeD.Effects of halide anions to absorb SO2 in ionic liquids. BullKorean Chem Soc 2010;31:1937e40.
[26] Awadhia A, Agrawal SL. Structural, thermal and electricalcharacterizations of PVA: DMSO:NH4SCN gel electrolytes.Solid State Ionics 2007;178:951e8.
[27] Hema M, Selvasekarapandian S, Arunkumar D,Sakunthala A, Nithya HFTIR. XRD and ac impedancespectroscopic study on PVA based polymer electrolytedoped with NH4X (X ¼ Cl, Br, I). J NoneCryst Solids2009;355:84e90.
[28] Lu Y, Wang D, Li T, Zhao X, Cao Y, Yang H, et al. Poly(vinylalcohol)/poly(acrylic acid) hydrogel coatings for improvingelectrodeeneural tissue interface. Biomater 2009;30:4143e51.
[29] Pahune Bharadwaj S. Synthesis and characterization ofproton exchange membrane for fuel cell technology. ArchAppl Sci Res 2011;3:78e82.
[30] Gedam SK, Bhoga SS. Preparation and characterization ofproton conducting polymer electrolyte. Integr Ferroelectr2010;119:74e81.
[31] Bhargav PB, Mohan VM, Sharma AK, Rao VVRN. Structuraland electrical properties of pure and NaBr doped poly(vinylalcohol) (PVA) polymer electrolyte films for solid statebattery applications. Ionics 2007;13:441e6.
[32] Abdelrazek EM, Elashmawi IS, Elekhodary A, Yassin A.Structural, optical, thermal and electrical studies on PVA/PVP blends filled with lithium bromide. Curr Appl Phys2010;10:607e13.
[33] Jiang J, Gao D, Li Z, Su G. Gel polymer electrolytes prepared byin situ polymerization of vinyl monomers inroometemperature ionic liquids. React Fuct Polym2006;66:1141e8.
[34] Shi F, Deng Y. Abnormal FTeIR and FTRaman spectra of ionicliquids confined in nanoeporous silica gel. SpectrochimiActa Part A 2005;62:239e44.
[35] Chowdhury A, Thynell ST. Confined rapid thermolysis/FTIR/ToF studies of imidazoliumebased ionic liquids.Thermochimi Acta 2006;443:159e72.
[36] Singh PK, Bhattacharya B, Nagarale RK, Kim KW, Rhee HW.Synthesis, characterization and application ofbiopolymereionic liquid composite membranes. Synth Met2010;160:139e42.
[37] Akai N, Kawai A, Shibuya K. Ionepair structure of vaporizedionic liquid studied by matrixeisolation FTIR spectroscopywith DFT calculations: a case of1eEthyle3emethylimidazolium Trifluoromethanesulfonate.J Phys Chem A 2010;114:12662e6.
[38] Bazito FFC, Silveira LT, Torresi RM, Torresi SIC.Spectroelectrochemical study of a soluble derivative ofpoly(aniline) in a room temperature ionic liquid. ElectrochimActa 2007;53:1217e24.
[39] Yang CC, Lee YJ, Yang JM. Direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC)based on PVA/MMT composite polymer membranes. J PowerSources 2009;188:30e7.
[40] Yang CC, Chiu SJ, Chien WC. Development of alkaline directmethanol fuel cells based on crosslinked PVA polymermembranes. J Power Sources 2006;162:21e9.
ch on ionic liquid-based poly(vinyl alcohol) proton conductiveurnal of Hydrogen Energy (2013), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/