a study on overall quality assurance in just in time manufacturing process in ahlada engineers pvt....
TRANSCRIPT
PROJECT REPORT
Submitted by
SATHISKUMAR M
Register No: 710511631048
In partial fulfillment for the award of the degree
of
COIMBATORE INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY
of
MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION
IN
PRODUCTION
July 2013
A STUDY ON OVERALL QUALITY ASSURANCE IN
JUST IN TIME MANUFACTURING PROCESS IN
AHLADA ENGINEERS PVT. LTD, HYDERABAD
COIMBATORE INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY
COIMBATORE - 641109.
Department of Management and Research Studies
PROJECT WORK
July 2013
This is to certify that the project entitled
A STUDY ON OVERALL QUALITY ASSURANCE IN JUST IN TIME
MANUFACTURING PROCESS IN AHLADA ENGINEERS PVT LTD, HYDERABAD
Is the bonafide record of project work done by
M.SATHISKUMAR
Register No: 710511631048
Of MBA Production during the year 2013.
_____________________ ____________________
Project Guide Head of the Department
Submitted for the Project Viva-Voice examination held on______________
________________ ________________
Internal Examiner External Examiner
DECLARATION
I affirm that the project work titled A Study on overall Quality Assurance in Just In Time
Manufacturing Process in Ahlada Engineers, Hyderabad. Being submitted in partial
fulfillment for the award of MBA is the original work carried out by me. It has not formed the
part of any other project work submitted for award of any degree or diploma, either in this or any
other University.
M.SATHISKUMAR
Reg No: 710511631048
I certify that the declaration made above by the candidate is true
Y.BABU VINOTHKUMAR
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to present my heartiest gratitude in the footsteps of my parents who
have taken intense burden for my successful education career.
I wish to place our profound sense of gratitude to our respected Director
Dr.K.A.Chinnaraju and our beloved Principal Dr.N.Nagarajan for providing us
with excellent facilities without which the project would never has been successful.
The respect we shower would really be no match to describe in these words,
for we can really never forget the faith asserted in us by our esteemed Head of the
Department Dr.T.Raju. I am very thankful for his incredible counseling and
encouragement.
I would fail miserably in my duties if I do not maintain the service of her
guidance Mr.Y.Babu Vinothkumar for the support and valuable suggestions in
completing this project without which this project would not have become true.
Place : Sathiskumar M
Date : (710511631048)
Abstract
Abstract
JIT manufacturing is a philosophy by which an organization seeks continually to improve
its products and processes by eliminating waste. Organizations wanting to use the JIT approach
to manufacturing must have several building blocks in place. The building blocks include:
company-wide commitment, proper materials at the right time, supplier relationships, quality,
and personnel. The present work will analyze what have been the results throughout the supply
chain, in terms of inventory management, of those companies who do business with OEMs that
utilize JIT systems. The results of this study should enable managers that have or are considering
implementing or participating in a JIT inventory management system to become more effective.
The JIT system runs smoothly with no peaks or valleys. The typical inventory system, on the
other hand, is fraught with peaks and valleys that represent costs to the organization in the form
of inventory holding costs, back order and stock-out costs, overtime and idle time labor costs,
and waste of materials and space.
List of Contents
List of contents
S.NO CONTENTS PG.NO
1 INTRODUCTION 1 - 16
1.1 Company Profile 2
1.2 Introduction to the Topic 5
1.3 Objectives of the Study 11
1.4 Statement of Problem 13
1.5 Limitations of Study 15
2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 17 - 22
3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 23 - 26
3.1 Research Design 24
3.2 Data Collection 24
3.3 Sampling 25
3.4 Statistical tools 26
4 DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION 27 - 46
4.1 Chi-square test 28
5 FINDINGS AND SUGGESTIONS 47 - 53
5.1 Findings 48
5.2 Suggestions 50
5.3 Conclusion 52
6 APPENDIXES 54 - 59
7 REFFERENCES 60 - 61
List of Tables
Sl. No CONTENTS PG.NO
4.1.1 This table shows the association between the age and color
availability objectives of the customer expectations.
29
4.1.2 This table shows the association between education and good
quality perceived by the consumer.
31
4.1.3 This table shows the association between Income level and
Durability by the assurance the manufacturer to the consumer.
33
4.1.4 This table shows the association between satisfaction and
locality by the assurance the manufacturer to the consumer.
35
4.1.5 This table shows the association between training programs and
quality maintenance in geometric dimensioning and tolerance.
37
4.1.6 This table shows the association between on time delivery and
on time logistics scheduling.
39
4.1.7 This table shows the association between on professional attire
and knowledge of representative.
41
4.1.8 This table shows the association between geographical area and
the establishment of the company.
43
4.1.9 This table shows the association between grading aggregates and
profitability of the company.
45
List of Charts
Sl. No CONTENTS PG.NO
4.1.1 This chart shows the association between the age and color
availability objectives of the customer expectations.
30
4.1.2 This chart shows the association between education and good
quality perceived by the consumer.
32
4.1.3 This chart shows the association between Income level and
Durability by the assurance the manufacturer to the consumer.
34
4.1.4 This chart shows the association between satisfaction and
locality by the assurance the manufacturer to the consumer.
36
4.1.5 This chart shows the association between training programs and
quality maintenance in geometric dimensioning and tolerance.
38
4.1.6 This chart shows the association between on time delivery and
on time logistics scheduling.
40
4.1.7 This chart shows the association between on professional attire
and knowledge of representative.
42
4.1.8 This chart shows the association between geographical area and
the establishment of the company.
44
4.1.9 This chart shows the association between grading aggregates and
profitability of the company.
46
List of Abbreviations
SERIAL NO SHORT FORM ABBREVIATIONS
1 JIT Just In Time
2 EDI Electronic Data Exchange
3 MRP - I Material Requirements Planning
4 MRP - II Manufacturing Resource Planning
Introduction
Company Profile
Chapter - 1
1.2 Company Profile
Ahlada engineers private limited is one of the leading manufacturers of Machinery,
Storage Racking Systems. Our products are well accepted within the industry by the leading
Companies requiring the product.
They are an ISO 9001:2008 certified company and was established in the year 2005 with
its team/promoters having a collective experience of over 15 years. AEPL is located in
Hyderabad and has branch offices at New Delhi, Kolkata, Mumbai, Pune, Bangalore, Chandigarh
and Chennai with a strong sales and service network.
They earned a reputation in amongst the best product manufacturers with an equally
efficient service oriented team. The teams result oriented policies of hard work with class
workmanship, and precision have enabled it to win frontline clientele of repute in the shortest
possible time.
They are dedicated to planning, designing, and manufacturing of its products for Clean
room applications, Equipment and Machinery, Storage Racking Systems for Pharmaceuticals,
Bio-technology, Micro Electronics and Other industries. The production technology and range of
products have been continuously enhanced / improved and refined to suit customer needs and
requirements, keeping in view the international standards. And they has a manufacturing unit
which is equipped with world class infrastructure, highly advanced and sophisticated CNC
controlled machinery.
They have a factory building and plant to an extent of 2,70,000 Sq.ft land with 2,00,000
sq.ft production area with adequate power and water connection. As ours is a complete
fabrication work unit, we have evolved, developed and installed in-house facilities for all the
operations.
And they grow rapidly along with technological developments to provide the world class
quality.
Mission
To achieve excellence in manufacturing and a leading market share, globally
Vision
"Our vision is simple. We build lifelong relationships through our interactive designs,
attention to detail, adherence to strict schedules and project completion to predetermined budgets
and quality standards".
Core Principle Values
Professionalism, Transparency, Integrity, Total Customer Focus & Zero PPM.
Quality Policies:
They follow stringent quality norms by maintaining high quality raw material, periodic in-process
inspections and itemized reporting. Due to the strong and continuous effort of the company, we have
successfully achieved the trust of elite companies, and are proud to be among very few vendors to be
given the green channel route of supply.
We are also flexible with 3rd party quality inspection which allows our customers to have quality
inspected here at our manufacturing site itself. They are well equipped with machines for testing and
inspection and follows a stringent time based inspection relating to inward, in-process and final
movement of its products.
Advanced quality measures taken at Ahlada ensure that focus is on Quality, not only of our
products but also of our processes and our people. This has enabled us to stand tall amongst our
competitors in market across the world. We are a customer driven organization focused on achieving
and exceeding customer expectations.
Structure of the Efforts Towards Quality
Quality Policy, Quality Objectives
1. Control of Documents & records
2. Control of non - conforming product and service
3. Quality Policy, Quality Objectives
4. Control of Documents & records
5. Control of non - conforming product and service
Introduction to the Topic
1.3 Introduction:
It is an inventory strategy implemented to improve the return on investment of a business by
reducing in-process inventory and its associated costs. The process is driven by a series of signals, or
Kanban are usually tickets but can be simple visual signals, such as the presence or absence of a part on
a shelf. When implemented correctly, JIT can lead to dramatic improvements in a manufacturing
organization's return on investment, quality, and efficiency.
New stock is ordered when stock drops to the re-order level. This saves warehouse space and
costs. However, one drawback of the JIT system is that the re-order level is determined by historical
demand. If demand rises above the historical average demand, the firm will deplete inventory faster
than usual and cause customer service issues. To meet a 95% service rate a firm must carry about 2
standard deviations of demand in safety stock. Forecasted shifts in demand should be planned for
around the Kanban until trends can be established to reset the appropriate Kanban level. Others have
suggested that recycling Kanban faster can also help flex the system by as much as 10-30%. In recent
years manufacturers have touted a trailing 13 week average as a better predictor than most forecasters
could provide the details.
A related term is Kaizen which is an approach to productivity improvement literally meaning
"continuous improvement" of process.
History:
The technique was first used by the Ford Motor Company This describes the concept of "dock to
factory floor" in which incoming materials are not even stored or warehoused before going into
production. The concept needed an effective freight management system (FMS) Ford's Today and
Tomorrow (1926) describes the technique was subsequently adopted and publicised by Toyota Motor
Corporation of Japan as part of its Toyota Production System (TPS).
Japanese corporations cannot afford large amounts of land to warehouse finished products and
parts. Before the 1950s, this was thought to be a disadvantage because it forced the production lot size
below the economic lot size. (An economic lot size is the number of identical products that should be
produced, given the cost of changing the production process over to another product.) The undesirable
result was poor return on investment for a factory.
The chief engineer at Toyota in the 1950s, Taiichi Ohno, examined accounting assumptions and
realized that another method was possible. The factory could implement JIT which would require it to
be made more flexible and reduce the overhead costs of retooling and thereby reduce the economic lot
size to fit the available warehouse space. JIT is now regarded by Ohno as one of the two 'pillars' of the
Toyota Production System.
Therefore over a period of several years, Toyota engineers redesigned car models for
commonality of tooling for such production processes as paint-spraying and welding. Toyota was one of
the first to apply flexible robotic systems for these tasks. Some of the changes were as simple as
standardizing the whole sizes used to hang parts on hooks.The number and types of fasteners were
reduced in order to standardize assembly steps and tools. In some cases, identical subassemblies could
be used in several models.
Toyota engineers then determined that the remaining critical bottleneck in the retooling process
was the time required to change the stamping dies used for body parts. These were adjusted by hand,
using crowbars and wrenches. It sometimes took as long as several days to install a large (multiton) die
set and adjust it for acceptable quality. Further, these were usually installed one at a time by a team of
experts, so that the line was down for several weeks. So Toyota implemented a strategy called Single
Minute Exchange of Die (SMED), developed by Shigeo Shingo. With very simple fixtures, measurements
were substituted for adjustments. Almost immediately, die change times fell to hours instead of days. At
the same time, quality of the stampings became controlled by a written recipe, reducing the skill level
required for the change. Further analysis showed that a lot of the remaining time was used to search for
hand tools and move dies. Procedural changes (such as moving the new die in place with the line in
operation) and dedicated tool-racks reduced the die-change times to as little as 40 seconds. Today dies
are changed in a ripple through the factory as a new product begins flowing.
After SMED (single minute exchange of die), economic lot sizes fell to as little as one vehicle in
some Toyota plants. Carrying the process into parts-storage made it possible to store as little as one part
in each assembly station. When a part disappeared, that was used as a signal (Kanban) to produce or
order a replacement.
Just-in-time (JIT) inventory systems are not a simple method that a company can adopt; it has a
whole philosophy that the company must follow in order to avoid its downsides. The ideas in this
philosophy come from many different disciplines including; statistics, industrial engineering, production
management and behavioural science. In the JIT inventory philosophy there are views with respect to
how inventory is looked upon, what it says about the management within the company, and the main
principle behind JIT. Inventory is seen as incurring costs, or waste, instead of adding value, contrary to
traditional thinking. This does not mean to say that JIT is unaware that removing inventory exposes
manufacturing issues. Under the philosophy, businesses are encouraged to eliminate inventory that
doesn’t compensate for manufacturing issues, and to constantly improve processes so that inventory
can be removed. Secondly, allowing any stock habituates the management to stock and it can then be a
bit like a narcotic. Management are then tempted to keep stock there to hide problems within the
production system. These problems include backups at work centres, machine reliability, process
variability, lack of flexibility of employees and equipment, and inadequate capacity among other things.
In short, the just-in-time inventory system is all about having “the right material, at the right time, at the
right place, and in the exact amount” but its implications are broad for the implementers.
Four Basic Conditions:
There are different points of view about the elements that led the approach to productivity. E.
Hay (1988) understands that there are six internal factors and one externally focused element, the
purchasing activity. On the other hand Harrison (1992) explains the "core techniques" of waste
elimination, total quality and people preparation; however I will follow Cheng and Podolsky's (1993)
structure to present the necessary conditions for the JIT implementation.
People Involvement:
Whoever is related to the company that intends the implementation, shall be committed
to the project. Starting with the machine operators and ending on the high level management,
everybody has not only to be aware of the implications but to support the implementation as well.
Implementation is a critic phase of JIT, and is advisable to avoid problems, to reduce the amount of
time and efforts throughout this stage.
Plants:
Numerous changes take place in the layout of the "new" plant. Some changes are easy to
achieve as the so called productions cells, in which the machinery is located in a way that helps
reducing the time it takes to move materials from one process to another. Nevertheless the
introduction of Kanban (Japanese name of the cards that confirm material requirements), self-
inspection, Material Requirement Planning ("MRP") and MRP II (in case they were not already in
use) and job enrichment within plant workers, involve structural change thus they are far from being
simple to implement. MRP I involves a computer system for building inventory, scheduling the
production and to administrate inputs; on the other side MRP II, that stands for Manufacturing
Resource Planning, includes the MRP I’s activities plus marketing and purchasing operations and the
financing function.
Systems:
Existent systems may remain within the company, however the MRP and MRP II systems should
be implemented. Further investments can take place, as the use of luminous Kanbans or the
implementation of the Electronic Data Interchange ("EDI") to link inventory existence with suppliers
Purchasing:
Relationships with suppliers become a key factor not only in a JIT environment but in other
production systems that intend to reach efficiency and to shorten production time.
Quality in JIT:
According to Hay (1998) states that JIT brings a number of unique elements to a total
quality environment. From an interesting point of view he presents the counterpart of Just in
Time benefits. These are "Immediate Feedback", "Slower Run Speeds" and "Stopping the Process".
The under demand pull system gives immediate information about the situation, now defects
can be detected within two hours, or two minutes or even while they are still happening rather than
ten days or two weeks later. The production schedule, under JIT is not pressing any more to work as
fast as possible, instead frequency is set by the demand, the machinery is not forced and the process
becomes predictable. (as the traditional theory teaches) but to take advantage of it detecting a
defective part and not letting another problem to happen again.
Steps for Achieving Quality Assurance in JIT:
Always follow standard operations.
Establish “one-piece flow” whenever possible to Mini-Mize manufacturing
Lead-time.
Stop the line whenever a defective item is produced.
Act immediately to make an improvement that goes right to the source of the problem.
“Quality is built into products at each process.”
Objectives of Study
1.4 Objectives of the study
Primary Objective:
To analyse the factors influencing the "Overall Quality Assurance in just in Time"
production process.
Secondary Objectives:
To know the Customer Expectations
To know the values of the quality perceived by the consumer
To know the durability of the manufacturer to the consumer
Statement of the Problem
1.5 Statement of Problem:
Traditionally, a manufacturing business competes on price, quality, variety, after service, etc.
Now, these conditions are merely prerequisites. Few businesses exist today without offering this
requirement, and the key competitive factor has become speed. Major businesses have been trying to
adopt new business initiatives in order to stay alive in the new competitive market place. Just in time
production system is one of these initiatives that focus on cost reduction by eliminating non-value
added activities. These tools and techniques of JIT have been widely used in both discrete and process
industry starting with the introduction of the original Toyota production system.
The production system of Ethiopian industries in today's global market including the
industries in focus has been suffering from a lot of challenges. Most of the problems are internal, but
some external problems also exist. In general the problems like:
High production cost.
High concentration of waste.
Inflexibility of the process and workforce.
High inventory costs.
Lower employee involvement for the overall improvement of the factory, and
High defects and reworks are few due mentioned.
While it seems that some JIT tools are difficult to adapt in our industries, it is possible to implement
most of JIT techniques at first and implement the difficult tools gradually.
Therefore, in order to compete in today's global competitive market our industry, The researcher
believed that JIT implementation in this factory would lead them on the competitive and leading line of
the country.
Limitations of Study
1.5 Limitations of Study:
There were certain limitations in undertaking this research work. As it is understood that the limitations
are a part of the project, they have been overshadowed by the benefits of the study.
Culture Differences The organizational cultures vary from firm to firm. There are some
cultures that tie to JIT success but it is difficult for an organization to change its cultures
within a short time.
Traditional Approach The traditional approach in manufacturing is to store up a large
amount of inventory in the means of backing up during bad time. Those companies rely
on safety stocks may have a problem with the use of JIT.
Difference in implementation of JIT Because JIT was originally established in Japanese,
it is somehow different for implementing in western countries. The benefits may vary.
The survey conducted may not be considered as comprehensive as only limited
respondents could be contacted because of the time constraint.
Objectives and the purposes of the study and the questions had to be explained to the
respondents and their responses may be biased.
Some of the respondents were reluctant to give their responses.
Only limited sample size had been considered for the study and therefore, the conclusions
drawn based on this may not be a reflection of the entire population.
Review of Literature
Chapter-2
Review of literature
Juran’s definition of quality is simultaneous attempts to be a level one and level two definition.
He defines quality based on a multiple meaning, namely
“Quality consists of those product features which meet the needs of customers and
thereby provide product satisfaction.
“Quality consists of freedom from deficiencies."
A practical definition of quality is probably not possible, and
Quality is apparently associated with customers’ requirements, and fitness suggests
conformance to measurable product characteristics (Juran 1988).
Goodman, O‘Brein & Segal (2000) support the aforementioned viewpoints by defining quality as
consistently producing what the customer wants, while reducing errors before and after delivery to the
customer. The quality definition of fulfilling or exceeding customers‘ needs has become an ideological
trailblazer driving the pursuit of customer satisfaction. In the embedding of quality thinking this
ideological core plays an important role. More importantly, however, quality is not so much an outcome
as a ever-ending process of continually improving the quality of what an institution produces. There is
no doubt that many institutions have so well ordered their capability to meet their customers’
requirements, time and time again, that this has created a reputation for “excellence”. Institutions must
“delight” the customer by consistently meeting customer requirements, and then achieve a reputation
of “excellence”. Quality should be viewed from the perspective of the customers and potential
customers. The aim of institutions should be to satisfy existing needs of customers with quality products
or services, and to identify, anticipate and create new needs. This requires the cultivation of a close
relationship between the institution and its customers.
(Garg et al., 1995) have found 'work culture' a critical element if a company wants to implement JIT.
Adopting JIT culture in India is not an impossible task. According to them, dimensions of work culture in JIT
include multifunctional workers, long term employment, motivation and trust, top management attitude and
commitment, support from union leaders, effective communication, poka yoke inspection method, and
incentive scheme. It is felt that JIT could be a great opportunity for India in the context of recent reforms in
economy and trade towards opening of economy and globalization. Some benefits attained in quantified
form were also presented when some elements (quality circles, suggestion schemes, kaizan etc.) were
applied in an Indian automobile company.
(Garg et al., 1996] examined critically JIT purchasing in Indian context. An analysis of a questionnaire
supplied to various industries is carried out with the help of statistical tests. A test of significance (t-test) was
applied for the importance of JIT attributes, problems in implementing JIT attributes, and expected
percentage benefits of JIT purchasing implementation. There was an indication that Indian industries were
giving importance to JIT attributes, facing some problems in implementing JIT, and expecting an overall
benefit on an average 59.8% if JIT purchasing is fully implemented. Tests confirmed that the scope of JIT
implementation in India was fair and it was independent of the type of industries, layout, and number of
employees. Small industries were more optimistic than large and medium scale industries about JIT
implementation.
(Kumar and Garg, 2002] took a closer look on JIT implementation problems and benefits in Indian
context. A survey of Indian industries was conducted to identify those JIT elements which are highly difficult
to implement, those which are easy to implement in Indian context and to identify the most expected JIT
benefits in Indian context. It was found perfect JIT implementation may not be feasible in most Indian
industries due to lack of resources, lack of technology, non availability of multifunctional workers etc.
However, some elements such as continuous improvement, layout improvement, quality circles, small lot
size etc. are easy to implement as reported by Indian industries. Therefore maximum weight age must be
given to these elements to reap maximum benefits. The elements which found to be difficult to implement
included zero defects, automation and autorotation, JIT purchasing, kanban system, set up time reduction
etc. Reduced work in process, reduced purchase lot size reduced production lead time, improved
competitive position etc. were found some of the high ranked expected benefits as a result of JIT
implementation.
(Prem Vrat et al., 1993) have identified problems in JIT implementation in Indian context. These
included poor quality of incoming material, non-receipt of delivery by buyer of exact quantity on exact
time, little workers' motivation, unreliable transportation system etc. The Delphi study carried out by
(Prem Vart et al., 1993) indicated the JIT index to be 23.38 on a 40 point (0-40) scale, implying that
though quite difficult, JIT implementation in India is possible. It may take 10-20 years for JIT to be fully
implemented in Indian industries. It further stated that in order to become competitive, the Indian
industry can't ignore the idea of JIT. The study also indicated that attention must be focused on poka
yoke inspection methods, reduced setup times, 100 % quality of incoming material, kanban system,
delivery by the vendor of exact quantity on exact time to achieve the results. Worker motivation and
literacy need to be increased.
(Kolay, 1993)] suggested an approach to assess a vendor on an overall performance index, which
was certainly useful in the area of supplier management in Indian context. (Kumar et al. 2002) reported
that several Indian industries were implementing basic principles of just-in-time (JIT) in a fragmentary
framework of Total Quality Management (TQM) with the belief that it would be helpful in facing global
competition. The present status of JIT/TQM quality techniques in India had been analyzed through a
survey of 46 Indian industries. The survey indicated that techniques such as quality circle, total
preventive maintenance, cause and effect diagram, kaizen, JIT purchasing etc. require more attention
since their implementation may be helpful to improve present position of Indian industries in the areas
of quality, cost and flexibility.
Mahadevan [1997] through survey investigated how far the Indian companies they are ready for
Just-in-Time. Findings suggest TQM and vendor development efforts precede the launch of major JIT
programmes. Automobile Industry in the country has made significant improvements in areas such as
multi-skilling of work force, setup time reduction and small lot sizes. TQM, TPM, and JIT purchasing
constitute the basic requirements for successful JIT implementation. It has also been suggested that JIT
and TQM must go together. JIT provides an organizational frame work for the exposure of waste and
problems, TQM provide and organizational framework to solve these problems. The author is of the
view that Indian companies are slow in exploiting the far reaching effects of JIT implementation.
(Garg & Deshmukh, 1999] reviewed and classified the literature on JIT purchasing. The literature
was reviewed and classified as conceptual articles, survey, case studies, and empirical/modelling work.
The relative importance of JIT purchasing attributes had been identified. A survey of the attributes was
carried out in Indian context. Attributes of high quality, mutual trust and cooperative relationship,
reliable delivery, increased customer and supplier's support was among the attributes that were given a
very high importance by Indian industries. This study had also predicted a better scope of JIT
implementation in India compared to an earlier study. The results of a case study in JIT implementation
of an Indian tractor assembly were presented in this paper. Significant benefits were achieved by
reductions in inventory, material movement, space, manpower, work-in-process and lead-time and an
increase in productivity and quality as a result of JIT purchasing implementation. The key steps in
implementation were: extensive training of employees on pull concept, identification of key
performance parameters; new layouts based on U-shaped cells, standardization of operations, a
maintenance plan for each machine, housekeeping, visual control and multi skill training. It has also
been found that most of the identified JIT purchasing attributes were given strong emphasis.
(Gupta et al. 2003) investigated the role of JIT in service sector through case study of an
educational institute. The study was focused on admission process of the students. Existing process was
characterized by: long waiting time for students and their parents, long duty hours for staff, poor
information system leading to unrest and confusion etc. To encounter the difficulties in the existing
system, a new process was proposed in JIT context. Key JIT element of successful JIT installation in this
environment involved GT type cell layout, Kanban, multi skill workforce. It will reduce significantly the
number of days to complete the whole process and will make everybody satisfied with the service
provided. A survey (Gupta et al. 2004) of Indian service sector has been conducted to determine the
relevance of JIT in service sector in Indian context. A questionnaire was developed and administered to
80 service industries. Responses from 43 industries (Response rate 54%) were obtained. Data is
compiled and analyzed. Firstly, it is done by factor analysis on a scale (0-100) .The mean score for the
importance of JIT elements taken together as perceived by the respondents was found to be 75.75
(Maximum importance=100) which can be interpreted as fairly good . The mean score for problems in
implementation taken together was found to be 73 (Maximum for no problem in implementation=100)
which can be interpreted as little problems in implementation. Similarly mean score for expected
benefits taken together as a result of JIT implementation was found to be 75.75(Maximum benefit=100)
which can be interpreted as high benefits as a result of JIT implementation. Some JIT elements, which
are comparatively easy to implement, are also identified in the survey. These are quality improvement
techniques, standardization, process simplification, lay out improvement, quality circles etc. Attention
must be focused on these elements so that maximum benefits can be obtained
Research Methodology
Chapter-3
Research Methodology
Research methodology is the way to systematically solve a problem. A research methodology
consists of various steps. A researcher should have detailed knowledge before implementing all the
steps of the research methodology. The researcher must design the steps of research methodology
focusing on the research objectives and the logic behind it. Thus when we talk of research methodology,
we not only talk about the research methods, but also consider the logic behind the methods. Keeping
the concept in mind, the study designs the following research methodology.
3.1 Research Design:
When designing research, one is faced with a continual series of trade-offs. Since there
are tropically numerous design alternatives that will work, the goal is to find the design that
enhances the value of the information obtained, while reducing the cost of obtaining
it.”(Malhotra.N.K, 2005).
Research design is the plan, structure to answer whom, when, where and how the subject is
under investigation. Here plan is an outline of the research scheme & which the researcher has to
work. The structure of the research is a more specific outline and the strategy out, specifying the
methods to be used in the connection & analysis of the data.
3.2 Data Collection
The main source of information for this study is based on the data collection. Data collected are
both primary and secondary in nature.
Primary Data:
Primary data have been directly collected from the rural customers in the Coimbatore district by
survey method through undisguised structured questionnaire.
Questions like open ended, close ended and multiple choice have been used for the purpose of data
collection.
Secondary Data:
Secondary data have been collected from official website of manufacturing company and also
from other official websites related to production industry.
Types Of Questions
Open ended question:
Open ended question are the type of question used to get suggestion from the respondent in
order to give feed back to the organization.
Close ended question:
Close ended question are the type of questions with a clear declined set of alternatives that
confine the respondents to choose one of them.
Multiple choice question:
It consists of multiple choices in which the respondents can choose more than one
Likert scale:
It uses 4 point scale to elicit respondent’s favor or unfavor towards an object.
3.3 Sampling:
The present study is empirical and analytical in nature, and it is based on primary data
collected from the customers with the help of a well-structured comprehensive questionnaire.
The sample size was 50 respondents (Consumers)
And the another sample size was 100 (Company Employers)
Totally 150 respondents, And the manufacturing industry were identified from Hyderabad
by proportionate stratified sampling method.
Hypothesis:
Knowledge of the service existence by the customers influences the users level of
satisfaction.
3.4 Statistical Tools and Analysis:
Tools used for analysis are:
1. Chi-square test
2. Graph
1. Chi-square test:
There may be situation in which it is not possible to make any rigid assumption about
distribution of the population from which samples being drawn. This limitation has led to the
development of a group of alternative techniques known as non-parametric tests. Chi-square describes
the magnitude of the discrepancy between theory and observation. In order to achieve the objectives
taken up in the study, chi-square test have been used to test the level of significance.
χ² = ∑ [(Oi – Ei) 2] with n-1 degrees of freedom
i =1 Ei
2. Graphs:
Graphical method was used in order to represent the factor in various graphical methods
like pie-chart, bar diagram and cylinder.
Data Analysis & Interpretation
Chi - square
Chapter - 4
4.1 Chi -Square Test
Table - 4.1.1
This table shows the association between the age and colour availability objectives of the customer
expectations.
Age Colour texture Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-Agree
below 20 1 0 1 0 2
20-30 8 17 7 1 33
30-40 2 5 4 0 11
40-50 1 1 1 0 3
Above 50 1 0 0 0 1
Total 13 23 13 1 50
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-
sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 6.638a 12 .881
Likelihood Ratio 7.505 12 .823
Linear-by-Linear
Association .176 1 .675
N of Valid Cases 50
AH: There is an association between the age and colour texture in the objectives of the customer
expectations.
NH: There is no association between the age and colour texture in the objectives of the customer
expectations.
Chart - 4.1.1
This chart shows the association between the age and colour availability objectives of the customer
expectations.
Chi-Square value = .881
Inference: There is no association between the age and colour texture in the objectives of the customer
expectations.
Age/color
below 20
20-30
30-40
40-50
Above 50
Table - 4.1.2
This table shows the association between education and good quality perceived by the consumer:
Education Good Quality Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-Agree
school level 4 5 0 0 9
Diploma 4 4 1 0 9
Ug 5 13 1 1 20
Pg 2 5 2 1 10
Others 2 0 0 0 2
Total 17 27 4 2 50
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 10.671a 12 .557
Likelihood Ratio 11.842 12 .458
Linear-by-Linear
Association 1.331 1 .249
N of Valid Cases 50
AH: There is an association between the education and good quality in the objectives of quality
perceived by the consumer.
NH: There is no association between the education and good quality in the objectives of quality
perceived by the consumer.
Chart - 4.1.2
This chart shows the association between education and good quality perceived by the consumer:
Chi-Square value = .557
Inference: There is no association between the education and good quality in the objectives of quality
perceived by the consumer.
Education/ Good quality
school level
Diploma
Ug
Pg
Others
Table - 4.1.3
This table shows the association between Income level and Durability by the assurance the
manufacturer to the consumer:
Income Level Durability Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-Agree Strongly
Disagree
below 10k 2 12 2 1 0 17
10-20k 2 7 3 0 0 12
20-30k 2 6 3 1 0 12
30-40k 1 3 2 0 0 6
Above 40k 0 1 0 1 1 3
Total 17 27 4 2 50
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 24.212 16 .085
Likelihood Ratio 14.335 16 .574
Linear-by-Linear
Association 3.736 1 .053
N of Valid Cases 50
AH: There is an association between the income level and durability by the assurance the manufacturer
to the consumer
NH: There is no association between the income level and durability by the assurance the manufacturer
to the consumer
Chart - 4.1.3
This chart shows the association between Income level and Durability by the
assurance the manufacturer to the consumer
Chi-Square value = .085
Inference: There is no association between the income level and durability by the assurance the
manufacturer to the consumer
Table - 4.1.4
Income level/Durability
1st Qtr
2nd Qtr
3rd Qtr
4th Qtr
This table shows the association between satisfaction and locality by the assurance the manufacturer
to the consumer:
Satisfaction Locality
Total Rural Urban
Strongly Agree 8 1 9
Agree 6 5 11
Neutral 20 6 26
Dis-Agree 0 3 3
Strongly Disagree 1 0 1
Total 35 15 50
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 10.802a 4 .029
Likelihood Ratio 11.559 4 .021
Linear-by-Linear
Association 1.125 1 .289
N of Valid Cases 50
AH: There is an association between satisfaction and locality by the assurance the manufacturer to the
consumer.
NH: There is no association between satisfaction and locality by the assurance the manufacturer to the
consumer.
Chart - 4.1.4
This chart shows the association between satisfaction and locality by the assurance the manufacturer
to the consumer:
Chi-Square value = .029
Inference: There is an association between satisfaction and locality by the assurance the manufacturer
to the consumer.
Sales
1st Qtr
2nd Qtr
3rd Qtr
4th Qtr
Table - 4.1.5
This table shows the association between training programs and quality maintenance in geometric
dimensioning and tolerance:
Training programs
Quality maintenance
Total Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Strongly
Disagree
Strongly Agree 20 14 3 0 20
Agree 22 14 5 0 22
Neutral 6 7 3 1 5
Dis-Agree 2 0 0 0 2
Strongly Disagree 1 0 1 1 1
Total 51 35 12 2 50
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 24.007a 12 .020
Likelihood Ratio 15.705 12 .205
Linear-by-Linear
Association 6.185 1 .013
N of Valid Cases 100
AH: There is an association between training programs and quality maintenance
NH: There is no association between training programs and quality maintenance
Chart - 4.1.5
This chart shows the association between training programs and quality maintenance in geometric
dimensioning and tolerance:
Chi-Square value = .020
Inference: There is an association between training programs and quality maintenance.
Training/Quality maintainence
1st Qtr
2nd Qtr
3rd Qtr
4th Qtr
Table - 4.1.6
This table shows the association between on time delivery and on time logistics scheduling:
On time
Delivery
On time logistics Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-
Agree
Strongly
Disagree
Strongly Agree 16 20 8 2 0 46
Agree 16 21 5 3 1 46
Neutral 2 1 0 0 1 4
Dis-Agree 1 0 1 0 0 2
Strongly
Disagree 0 1 0 0 1 2
Total 35 43 14 5 3 100
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 29.117a 16 .023
Likelihood Ratio 17.658 16 .344
Linear-by-Linear
Association 2.800 1 .094
N of Valid Cases 100
AH: There is an association between on time delivery and on time logistics scheduling.
NH: There is no association between on time delivery and on time logistics scheduling.
Chart - 4.1.6
This chart shows the association between on time delivery and on time logistics scheduling:
Chi-Square value = .023
Inference: There is an association between on time delivery and on time logistics scheduling.
On time delivery/On time logistics
Strongly Agree
Agree
Neutral
Dis-Agree
Strongly Disagree
Table - 4.1.7
This table shows the association between on professional attire and knowledge of representative:
Professional
attire
Knowledge of representative Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-Agree Strongly
Disagree
Strongly Agree 16 17 8 3 1 46
Agree 17 12 7 0 0 46
Neutral 9 3 3 3 0 4
Dis-Agree 1 0 0 0 0 2
Total 43 32 18 6 1 100
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 10.951a 12 .533
Likelihood Ratio 12.993 12 .370
Linear-by-Linear
Association .530 1 .467
N of Valid Cases 100
AH: There is an association between on professional attire and knowledge of representative.
NH: There is no association between on professional attire and knowledge of representative.
Chart - 4.1.7
This chart shows the association between on professional attire and knowledge of representative:
Chi-Square value = .533
Inference: There is no association between on professional attire and knowledge of representative.
Sales
1st Qtr
2nd Qtr
3rd Qtr
4th Qtr
Table 4.1.8
This table shows the association between geographical area and the establishment of the company:
Geographic
area
Well established Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-Agree Strongly
Disagree
Strongly Agree 9 15 11 4 1 40
Agree 20 22 7 1 2 52
Neutral 1 5 0 1 0 7
Dis-Agree 1 0 0 0 0 1
Total 31 42 18 6 3 100
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 13.896a 12 .307
Likelihood Ratio 15.314 12 .225
Linear-by-Linear
Association 3.195 1 .074
N of Valid Cases 100
AH: There is an association between geographical area and the establishment of the company.
NH: There is no association between geographical area and the establishment of the company.
Chart - 4.1.8
This chart shows the association between geographical area and the establishment of the company:
Chi-Square value = .307
Inference: There is an association between geographical area and the establishment of the company
Sales
1st Qtr
2nd Qtr
3rd Qtr
4th Qtr
Table - 4.1.9
This table shows the association between grading aggregates and profitability of the company:
Grading
aggregates
Profitability Total
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Dis-Agree Strongly
Disagree
Strongly Agree 19 14 2 3 2 40
Agree 11 8 6 2 1 28
Neutral 12 9 4 1 0 26
Dis-Agree 0 1 3 0 0 4
Total 1 0 0 0 1 2
Chi- Square Test
Chi-Square Tests Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 29.059a 16 .024
Likelihood Ratio 22.020 16 .143
Linear-by-Linear
Association 1.017 1 .313
N of Valid Cases 100
AH: There is an association between grading aggregates and profitability of the company.
NH: There is no association between grading aggregates and profitability of the company.
Chart - 4.1.9
This chart shows the association between grading aggregates and profitability of the company:
Chi-Square value = .024
Inference: There is an association between grading aggregates and profitability of the company.
Grading aggregates/Profitability
1st Qtr
2nd Qtr
3rd Qtr
4th Qtr
Findings and Suggestions
Findings
Chapter - 5
5.1 Findings
There is no association between the age and colour texture in the objectives of the
customer expectations.
There is no association between the education and good quality in the objectives of
quality perceived by the consumer.
There is no association between the income level and durability by the assurance the
manufacturer to the consumer.
There is an association between satisfaction and locality by the assurance the
manufacturer to the consumer.
There is an association between training programs and quality maintenance.
There is an association between on time delivery and on time logistics scheduling.
There is no association between on professional attire and knowledge of representative.
There is an association between geographical area and the establishment of the company.
There is an association between grading aggregates and profitability of the company.
Suggestions
5.2 Suggestions
The implementation model of JIT developed for the companies are made with the
consideration of where the companies are at the moment. Their readiness is rated at their infancy stage
to implement JIT. Therefore, the line implementation model should be followed sequentially without
shortcutting or jumping any of the steps.
Impatient and lack of preparation of proper foundation on which to make changes.
Skipping the small, preliminary projects and jumping directly to the large projects
such as pull production system.
Implementing one or two JIT techniques and expecting the benefits associated with
implementing a complete JIT production system.
Under estimating the difficult of changing their production system to JIT.
Setting insufficient resources aside for ongoing training and development of
employees.
Champions are promoted out of implementation projects before the projects are
completed.
The companies are not prepared to loosen their control over inventories, production
planning and control, shop floor activities, etc, enough to let JIT work.
Conclusion
5.3 Conclusion
Hence we can see that to have a Total JIT manufacturing system, a company-wide commitment,
proper materials, quality, people and equipments must always be made available when needed. In
addition; the policies and procedures developed for an internal JIT structure should also be extended
into the company's supplier and customer base to establish the identification of duplication of effort and
performance feedback review to continuously reduced wastage and improve quality. By integrating the
production process; the supplier, manufacturers and customers become an extension of the
manufacturing production process instead of independently isolated processes where in fact in clear
sense these three sets of manufacturing stages are inter-related and dependent on one another. Once
functioning as individual stages and operating accordingly in isolated perspective; the suppliers,
manufacturers and customers can no longer choose to operate in ignorance. The rules of productivity
standards have changed to shape the economy and the markets today; every company must be
receptive to changes and be dynamically responsive to demand. In general, it can be said that there is no
such thing as a KEY in achieving a JIT success; only a LADDER; where a series of continuous steps of
dedication in doing the job right every time is all it takes.
Appendixes
Chapter - 6
Appendixes
Questionnaire: Customer:
Name: __________________________________
Age
A) Below 20yrs B)20 - 30yrs C)30 - 40yrs D)40 - 50yrs E) Above 60yrs
Education
A) School level B) Diploma C) UG D) PG E) Others
Income Level
A) Below 10k B) 10 - 20k C) 20-30k D) 30 - 40k E) Above 40
Locality
A) Rural B) Urban
1 - Strongly Agree 4 - Dis Agree
2 - Agree 5 - Strongly Dis Agree
3 - Neutral
A) To know the Customer Expectations
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 The door has perfect size & dimensions
2 Variety of colors and textures are wide
3 The door designs can be customizable
4 The door has posh look & finish
5 Availability is wide
B) To know the values of the quality perceived by the consumer:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
6 The door has good quality
7 Cost of this door is affordable
8 Raw materials used in the door is superior quality
9 This door is strong
10 Locks can be easily mounted and it is heavily built
C) To know the assurance of the manufacturer to the consumer:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
11 The door's durability is high
12 The doors are eco - friendly
13 Quality of the doors are 100% satisfactory
14 Warranty/Guarantee coverage are easily by the wide
manufacturers
15 Service provided by the manufacturer is satisfactory
Questionnaire: Company
Please rate the following questions:
1 - Strongly Agree 4 - Dis Agree
2 - Agree 5 - Strongly Dis Agree
3 – Neutral
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 The company delivers the product on time
2 They balance Lead Time perfectly
3 Monitoring downtime is good
4 Quality related training programs are good
A) Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerance:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Drawing Interpretation is well organized
2 LEAN Manufacturing is perfectly planned
3 Statistical Process Control is need by the time of
production
4 SPC is regularly implemented, only through customer
requirements
5 Willingness of sharing the cost information to the
team is satisfactory
6 Reduction in product manufacturing cost due to
market conditions are acceptable
7 Dock-to-Stock with any customers is acceptable
8 On-time scheduling of logistics is perfect
9 Quality of maintenance program of the equipments
are regularly monitored
B) Documentation of reporting system in track metrics are good:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Scrap
2 Rework
3 Delivery
4 Productivity
5 Frequency in Distribution of internal non-
conformance reports are acceptable
6 Level of corrective action internally is advisable
7 Industry/marketplace have a wider knowledge on
product manufacturing
8 The company is well established
9 Capable in consulting the team and consumers
balanced
10 Wage, technology and tools are perfect
11 Personal Referral is acceptable
12 Lowest rate of raw material produced at this time of
production
13 Responsiveness to requests is on time
14 Value-added services provided by the company is
satisfactory
15 The responses from the team are put in action
immediately
16 The response of QC department in customer need is
good
17 The knowledge level of your Representative is high
18 Overall, how do you rank our services to you
C) Factors
1) Periodic in-process inspections:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Geographic Area
2 Environment
3 Life of Structure
4 Independent Assessment
5 Precautionary Measures
2) Professionalism:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Training
2 Significance
3 Professional Attire
4 Time at Work
5 Identification
3) Integrities:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Protect
2 Promote
3 Anchor
4 Preserve
5 Guide
4) Workability:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Proportions
2 Size Aggregate
3 Shape of Aggregate
4 Ratio & Course of Aggregates
5 Grading Aggregates
5) Performance:
Sl.No 1 2 3 4 5
1 Income Generation
2 Cost Management
3 Customer Performance
4 Profitability
5 Growth
7 - References
Chapter - 7
References
Mortimer J. ( ed ) 1986 Just In Time An Executive Briefing IFS Publication Ltd, Bedford, UK
Jansen R. & Warnecke ( ed ) 1988 Just In Time Manufacturing IFS Publications Ltd, Bedford, UK
O'Grady, J. (ed) 1988 Putting the Just-In-Time Philosophy into Practice Nichols Publishing Company, New
York
Schonberger J. (ed) 1987 World Class Manufacturing Casebook Macmillan Inc, New York
Raju.T, Prabhu. R (ed) 1947 Business Research Methods, Chennai, India.