a study on the effectivenes of ta improving organizational performance tez master 76
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
1/156
A STUDY ON THE EFFECTIVENESSOF TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSIS FOR
IMPROVING ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE
Daniel W. Buckner
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
2/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
3/156
AVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOLMonterey, California
THESISA STUDY ON THE EFFECTIVENESSOF TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSIS FOR .IMPROVING ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCEby
Daniel W. BucknerSeptember, 1976
Advisors J. W. CreightonJ. C. Kiley
Approved for public release; distribution unlimited.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
4/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
5/156
UNCLASSIFIEDCLASSIFICATION OF THIS RACE (Whan Dmm Sntorod)
REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGErIporT NuCTf*
READ INSTRUCTIONSBEFORE COMPLETING FORM2. OOVT ACCESSION NO. S. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBER
TITLE (ond Subtlll*)STUDY ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF
TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSIS FOR IMPROVINGRGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE
i. TYPE OF REPORT * PERIOO COVEREOMaster's Thesis:September, 1976
S. RERFORMINO ORO. RERORT NUMBERAUTMOdflJ
Daniel W. Buckner. CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBERfaJ
PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME ANO AOORESSPostgraduate SchoolCA 93940
10. PROGRAM ELEMENT. PROJECT, TASKAREA * WORK UNIT NUMBERS
CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME ANO AOORESSPostgraduate SchoolCA 93940
12. REPORT DATESftpfpmhft
IS. NUMBER OF PAr r 1976AGES75
MONITORING AGENCY NAME * AOORESSflf dlltotont horn Controlling Oltlco)
Postgraduate SchoolCA 93940
IS.. SECURITY CLASS, (ot thf riocrt)
UNCLASSIFIEDIS*. OECLASSIFICATION/OOWNGRAOINGSCHEDULE
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (ot thi Hopott)
for public release; distribution unlimited
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (ot tho mmotrmet ontorod In Block 20, II dltttmnt Report)
SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES
KEY WORDS (Conttmio on roworoo olmo If nocooomrr mn4 lomntllr r olock numtAnalysisImproving Organizational PerformanceTrainingupervisory TrainingBasic Human NeedsABSTRACT (Conltnuo on rororoo too It nocmooorr ond identity *T otooM ntmmmt)
study investigates the effectiveness of Transactionalused in personnel training by surveying two populations,one that had taken Transactional Analysis training, and one thattaken conventional training. Questionnaires were administeredto the two populations. Responses were compared to determine ifransactional Analysis training resulted in greater awareness ofhuman needs than did conventional training. Results
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
6/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
7/156
UNCLASSIFIEDftCuWlTY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS BtGEfWiiw,
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
8/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
9/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
10/156
c./
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
11/156
JUULEY KNOX LIBRNAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHI
TEREY, CALIFORNIA 23S4Q
ABSTRACT
This study investigates the effectiveness of TransactionalAnalysis used in personnel training by surveying two popula-tions, one that had taken Transactional Analysis training,and one that had taken conventional training. Questionnaireswere administered to the two populations. Responses werecompared to determine if Transactional Analysis trainingresulted in greater awareness of basic human needs than didconventional training. Results indicate no significantdifference between the two.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
12/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
13/156
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I . INTRODUCTION 6OBJECTIVE AND SCOPE OF THIS STUDY 7
II. A DESCRIPTION OF TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSIS ANDTHE COMPARED TRAINING PROGRAMS 9DESCRIPTION OF CONVENTIONAL TRAINING USEDAT NAVAL AIR TEST CENTER 11DESCRIPTION OF PROGRAM USED AT PACIFICMISSILE TEST CENTER 13
III . THE QUESTIONS AND THEIR RESULTS. 15DESCRIPTION OF THE QUESTIONNAIRE 15RESPONSES TO ATTITUDINAL QUESTIONS 17RESPONSES TO DEMOGRAPHIC QUESTIONS 24ANALYSIS OF DATA 28
APPENDIX A - QUESTIONNAIRE 3 2APPENDIX B - CHI -SQUARE CALCULATIONS 36APPENDIX C - POPULATION HISTOGRAMS 37APPENDIX D - HISTORICAL DATA BANK 69BIBLIOGRAPHY 73INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST 74
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
14/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
15/156
I. INTRODUCTION
Organizations are concerned with improving performance(Drucker, 1973). Empirical evidence supports the theory thatawareness of basic human needs by management can improveperformance of the organization (Maslow, 1970)
Further highlighting the importance of an understandingof the basic human needs for improved performance is astatement by Maslow, "When we talk about the needs of humanbeings we talk about the essence of their lives". Managers,then, must be concerned with basic human needs in order toimprove performance.
Much work has been done on the study of basic human needsand the relationships of people working together, but no onesystem of describing and analyzing human behavior has provencompletely successful. Management cannot wait untilscientists and scholars have completed their work in thisarea. Management must try to make the organization performtoday (Drucker, 1973).
A new system for understanding basic human behavior hasbeen developed in recent years . This new system for explain-ing human behavior is called "Transactional Analysis" and wasdeveloped by the late Dr. Eric Berne.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
16/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
17/156
OBJECTIVE AND SCOPE OF THIS STUDYSupervisory and personnel training utilizing both
conventional human needs concepts and Transactional analysistechniques have been given to employees in the Department ofDefense. The purpose of this study is to compare therelative effectiveness of conventional training and Trans-actional Analysis for improving performance.
This study is based on the assumption that a greaterawareness of basic human needs will lead to improved perfor-mance (Maslow, 1970) . The study was conducted by use of asurvey to determine whether Transactional Analysis, as usedat the Pacific Missile Test Center, Point Mugu, California,contributed to a greater awareness of basic human needs thandid conventional training, as used at the Naval Air TestCenter, Patuxent River, Maryland.
To conduct this study, two populations suitable for thepurpose of this investigation were first identified. Aquestionnaire was then developed and administered to the twopopulations. The responses were then compared usingstatistical analysis to determine if Transactional Analysistraining resulted in a greater awareness of basic humanneeds than did conventional training.
The populations considered for use in this study werelimited to employees at two Naval Air Systems Command fieldactivities
With .the assistance of the Civilian Personnel Office atthe Naval Air Test Center, Patuxent River, Maryland, a group
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
18/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
19/156
of personnel was identified who had received human needstraining using conventional theories. At the Pacific MissileTest Center, Point Mugu, California, the Civilian PersonnelOffice helped identify a group of personnel who had receivedtraining using Transactional Analysis.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
20/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
21/156
II. A DESCRIPTION OF TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSISAND THE COMPARED TRAINING PROGRAMS
Transactional Analysis is based on the observations ofDr. Eric Berne, during his work as a psycotherapist inSan Francisco, that each person demonstrates three verydifferent forms of behavior. At times a person acts andfeels like his parent or parent figure. When a persongestures, sounds, and carries himself very nearly as hisparent figure did, Berne said that the person was in hisParent ego-state. At other times a person reasons objec-tively, processes data, solves problems, asks questions, andgives information essentially without feelings, rather likea computer. A person behaving in this manner is. in his adultego-state. At other times a person may think and feel as hedid when he was a child, in this case he is in his Childego-state. Berne used these three ego states to describe hisanalysis of human behavior. In this paper Parent, Adult, andChild when capitalized will refer to ego states and not toactual parents, adults, or children.
Berne observed that a person in the Parent mode directshimself at another Parent or at a Child. The Child directshimself at another Child or at a Parent. An Adult looks foranother Adult. If the Parent is being critical then probablya rebellious or compliant Child will respond. If the Parentis being huturing then probably a grateful, appreciative
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
22/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
23/156
a rebellious Child usually stimulating a critical Parent.The Adult, like a computer, must be turned on to activate.Internally, the Adult is a good mediator between Parent andChild. Externally, the Adult is a good problem solver, butlacks spontaneity (Berne, 1964).
An exchange of recognition between two persons is saidto constitute a transaction. All transactions can beclassified as either complementary, crossed or ulterior(James and Jongeward, 19 71)
A complementary transaction occurs when a message sentfrom a specific ego state, gets the predicted response froma specific ego state in the other person. The following isan example of a complementary transaction:
Stimulus: Adult to Adult - Where are my cuff links?Response: Adult to Adult - On the desk.In this case the lines of communication are open, and the
people can continue transacting with one another.A crossed transaction occurs when an unexpected response
is made to the stimulus. The following is an example of acrossed transaction:
Stimulus: Adult to Adult - Where are my cuff links?Response: Parent to Child - Why don't you keep track of
your cuff links?In this case communications are broken off and the people
will tend to withdraw from one another.An ulterior transaction occurs when a stimulus is directed
to one ego state, but is intended to hook another ego state.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
24/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
25/156
The following is an example of an ulterior transaction:Stimulus: Open - Adult to Adult - This car is our
finest, but it may be too expensive for you.Hidden - Adult to Child - You probably can'tafford it.
Response: Adult to Adult - Yes, it is too expensive forme .Child to Adult -I'll take it.
In this example the hidden message is rejected if theAdult responds, and it is accepted if the Child is hooked.
Berne also observed that people early in life very oftenmade decisions about their life position when there was muchconfusion and insufficient data. These decisions such as"I'm O.K. - You're Not O.K.", "I'm Not O.K. - You're O.K.",which made sense to a very young child, provide the basis fora life script. The person lives his life according to hisscript in order to reinforce the life position he adoptedduring childhood. Berne believed that in the proper atmos-phere unfortunate early decisions could be redecided in amore favorable manner (Holloway and Holloway, 1973).
DESCRIPTION OF CONVENTIONAL TRAINING USED AT NAVAL AIR TESTCENTER
At the Naval Air Test Center each person queried hadattended at least one of the following courses:
- Basic Supervisory DevelopmentThe objectives of this course was to acquaint new
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
26/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
27/156
supervisors with the rudimentary skills of super-vision. The instruction was principally by lectureand stressed leadership, communications, cooperation,and personnel functions.
- Supervision and Group PerformanceThis course was given to explain the human behaviorinvolved in accomplishing a group project. After anintroduction to human relations, the course wastaught using a participative style where the studentsconducted group projects in order to experience firsthand the interactions involved in a group effort.
- Supervision of the Low Skilled and Culturally DifferentThis course was intended to provide supervisors anawareness of other cultures besides their own. Thecourse involved participation in which participantshad to perform task from a disadvantaged position inorder to get a feeling of what it was like to bedisadvantaged.
These courses were classified as conventional trainingbecause they were based on the traditional theories of work,organizational design, and human needs. Frederick Taylor'sstudy of work and Henri Fayol's organization design modelprovided part of the bases for the traditional training(Drucker, 1973). Mas low's "hierarchy of basic needs" wasused to explain basic human needs in traditional training(Maslow, 1970) .
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
28/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
29/156
DESCRIPTION OF PROGRAM USED AT PACIFIC MISSILE TEST CENTER
The Pacific Missile Test Center employees had each takenat least one of the following courses:
- Transactional Analysis CommunicationsThe objective of this course was to provide anunderstanding of and an improvement in personalcommunications . The dynamics of communications wereexplained in terms of Transactional Analysis egostates. Exercises were conducted to enable thestudents to feel their various ego states, and toexperience the use of the ego states in problemsolving.
- Career Women SeminarThis seminar was intended to enable the participantsto realize job satisfaction, and to make more effec-tive contributions to their respective agencies . Thisseminar addressed questions such as "Who am I atwork?", and "Do I want changes in my job or career?".
- Transactional Analysis and Your CareerThis course was intended to assist the participantsin applying Transactional Analysis to their currentjobs and to expand their goals. The course providedthe students an introduction to Transactional Analysisas it might be applied to unblocking their potentialpower to get their careers moving.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
30/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
31/156
- Communication for WomenThe objective of this course was to increase theparticipants' ability to communicate more effectivelyThe course included group discussions, films, andexercises to provide an opportunity for understandingand practicing effective communication skills
These courses used Transactional Analysis as their base.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
32/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
33/156
III. THE QUESTIONS AND THEIR RESULTS
An instrument was developed for use in measuring theemployees' awareness and understanding of basic human needs.Demographic questions were also included in order to evaluateother factors that might influence the responses of theemployees. The questionnaire was carefully worded to avoidthe use of Transactional Analysis terminology which mightcause a conditioned or triggered response on the part of theemployees who had taken the Transactional Analysis training.The questionnaire was pretested by administering it tomembers of the Naval Aviation Executive Institute ManagementProgram, Point Mugu, California. After pretesting andincorporating corrections, a total of 561 questionnaires weredistributed at the Naval Air Test Center and the PacificMissile Test Center. Appendix A contains a copy of thequestionnaire and the cover letter.
Table 1 gives a breakdown of the number of returnedquestionnaires from the two bases.
DESCRIPTION OF THE QUESTIONNAIRETwelve questions contained in the questionnaire were
designed to be answered by selection of one of five responseswith numeric values as given on the following page.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
34/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
35/156
wJCON ^h 4J r~~+-> ^H cd+J 5-. ^ CHt/1 03 -3CJ +-> CDCD C CCJ 03 CD JhH U 3 oM C M +J c^.t/> J-i CD CDo> o Oh OSe- mH T3 ,-vCD t CD CDii o3 in CHH CJ CD fn JO *d-C/> JO 3 03 00(/) N S 4-> VI 11H 3 3 CD 33S GO Zci^'3U 2 iH U -Hm +j CD Jh t3H C JO +-> CDU -H (/)+-> tnaJ O 3 -h 3 \oOh Oh 2 G JO rg
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
36/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
37/156
Response Numeric ValueStrongly Agree 1Agree 2No Opinion 3Disagree 4Strongly Disagree 5
To prevent the respondents from perceiving a pattern ofdesired answers, five of the questions were worded negatively(inverted) so that positive responses would be disagree orstrongly disagree. To aid in analysis of the data, theresponses for the inverted questions were recoded prior tothe computer analysis so that disagree and strongly disagreewere equated to agree and strongly agree. This recodingallowed all of the attitudinal data to be looked at with auniform ranking scheme. Under this scheme, strongly agreeand agree were taken as an indication of awareness andacceptance of the life position or human need addressed bythe question.
RESPONSES TO ATTITUDINAL QUESTIONSQuestions 3, 9, and 11 were designed to measure the
respondents' own perception of his personal O.K.-ness. Noneof these questions were inverted and respondents who felt apersonal sense of O.K.-ness would tend to respond with anagree or strongly agree.Question .3 - "Qiviz.Ka.lly, I i up
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
38/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
39/156
This question is based on the premise that a personholding an I'm O.K. life-position has faith in himself(Harris, 1967).
The frequency of response for each population is givenbelow:
PMTC NATCStrongly Agree 26 42Agree 124 115No Opinion 18 10Disagree 10 4Strongly Disagree 1 1Missing 5
Question 9 - "When In a. AULpzivlAoiy fiolz, I can adjust myatt-itu.dm towasid* tmpi.otjQ.z6 && -teqtuAed fion.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
40/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
41/156
Question 11 - "I {eel confident o{ my abtltty to kandleZntel-pelAOnal Kelatto tt4 OYl tke job."
This question is based on the idea that a person with anI'm O.K. life-position feels capable of handling personalrelationships
The responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 47 32Agree 127 125No Opinion 7 11Disagree 3 4Strongly DisagreeQuestions 1, 8, and 10 were designed to measure the
respondents' feelings about the O.K.-ness of others.Question 1 - "V/iom my peiAonal expeKten.ce I kave. {oand that
the conce.pt taught tn textbooks Mhtch Ata.te.6'mo&t employee* axe competent, capable pei^on*'li> tncoxtiect. "
This question is inverted and respondents who felt thatothers are O.K. selected a disagree or strongly disagreeanswer
The raw responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 6 10Agree 47 64No Opinion 13 10Disagree 98 71
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
42/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
43/156
Question 8 - "In my zxpe.sUe.ncz, I kavz &ound moi>t zmployzz*ah.z not za.pa.blz ol zkangtng tkztn. wonk atti.tu.dzt>and habtt& to tmpnovz tkzth. woik pzK^ofimanzz."
This question reflects the view of persons who believethat others are not O.K. Respondents who felt that othersare O.K. selected a strongly disagree or disagree answer tothis question (Holloway and Holloway, 1973) .
The raw responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 5 3Agree 33 27No Opinion 7 8Disagree 109 112Strongly Disagree 30 22
Question 10 - nMo& zmptoyzzb can bz th.u.&tzd to pzn.^on.m anddo a zon&ztznttou.* job wkzn tz{t on tkz-in. own."
This question is based on the theory that most peoplewant to perform to the best of their abilities (James andJongeward, 1967). Respondents who believed this theoryselected an agree or strongly agree answer.
The responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 20 17Agree 138 123No Opinion 3 3Disagree 20 26Strongly Disagree 2 2
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
44/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
45/156
Question 2 - "I nave faund that fax mott employee.* the bougie4 a.tA.&l action o doling tfnZA.fi woxk well nlA.mlYia.tzt>the need fax any additional xecognition."
This question is based on the theory that people have abasic need for recognition (Berne, 1964). Respondents whowere aware of this need selected a disagree or stronglydisagree response to this question.
The raw responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 6 3Agree 17 20No Opinion 3 2Disagree 85 82Strongly Disagree 73 64Missing - 1
Question 4 - "Employee.* have a definite need fan. emotionaland physical 6t-lmu.la.tton to continue to bepA.odac.ttve in the vtonk situation."
Question 4 is based on the fact that people have abiological, phychological , and social need for stimulation(Berne, 1964). An agree or strongly agree response wasselected by respondents who were aware of this need.
The responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 81 65Agree 88 89No Opinion 7 6Disagree 4 8
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
46/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
47/156
PMTC NATCStrongly Disagree 3 4Missing 1
Question 5 - "I dt* agn.ee ivttk the concept that employ ee* vtJULZ.*eek dtt2.YitX.OYi on the job, even t tt beYie.ga.ttvz, n.athen. than accept no fiecognttton atall."
This question is intended to measure the respondents'awareness of the fact that the need for recognition is sostrong that people will even seek adverse recognition in theabsence of positive recognition (Berne, 1964). Respondentswho were aware of this fact selected a disagree or stronglydisagree response to this question.
The raw responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 12 11Agree 63 69No Opinion 18 14Disagree 58 63Strongly Disagree 30 15Missing 3
Question 6 - "Mo*t employee* nave had tkeln. ba*tc wolkattitude* and pen.*onalttte* e* tabIt* Wed pfiton.to entering the wotik ion.ee."
Question 6 was included to test the respondents' aware-ness of childhood scripting. This theory is based on thehypothesis that most people live their lives according to
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
48/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
49/156
decisions that they made in early childhood (Holloway andHolloway, 1973)
The responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 29 27Agree 105 86No Opinion 7 6Disagree 38 46Strongly Disagree 5 7
Question 7 - "Most &mploye.zA nave, a dz&tnZtz nzzd ^oh. a.4 tn.u.ctu.n.2.d datty wonh. 4c/iedu.e. "
This question is based on the observation that peoplehave a definite need to avoid boredom which results in a timestructure-hunger (James and Jongeward, 1971) . Awareness oftime structure-hunger was reflected by selection of an agreeor strongly agree response.
The responses to this question are given below:PMTC NATC
Strongly Agree 9 29Agree 109 95No Opinion 10 8Disagree 45 37Strongly Disagree 11 2Missing - 1
Question 12 - "In my axpeA-tewce I have, not ound tkz needIon opin and comptttz communtcatZon* on tkt jobto be oui> tmpon.ta.nt cu> btatad tn tzx.tbook.6- ."
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
50/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
51/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
52/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
53/156
CUCUU
CO1)CO
003COo m ON O m 00 00 vr NO VI- CO f 00co CO CN r nO o CN r^ CO NO CN 3ex CUo CUPL, U00 oo m CN 00 vr vr m NO m o NO ON -H
COCO CO oo CN no CO CO O O vr CN 1 O 4-l H ^-4 no - 00 ON 00 vr 00 m NO 00 r^
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
54/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
55/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
56/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
57/156
Question 15 - "Wkat I* you/i Rank on. Gxadd lzve.1?"The responses to this question were ranked in interval
order. The responses to this question are given below:Group PMTC NATCGS 2$3 5GS 4$5 72 46GS 67 26 28GS 89 10 17
GS 1011 23 30GS 1213 34 40GS 1415 6 6Missing 8 5
Question 16 - "What 16 you.fi ago.?"1. Twenty-four or under2. Twenty-five to twenty-nine3. Thirty to thirty-nine4. Forty to forty-nine5. Over forty-nine
The responses to this question are given below:Group PMTC NATC
1 9 112 31 413 47 594 44 325 48 29
Missing 5
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
58/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
59/156
ANALYSIS OF DATAThe statistical Chi-square test was used to compare the
responses of the two populations. Application of this testdetermined if the responses from the two populations differedat the 0.05 level of statistical significance (951 confidencelevel) . For each question where the populations differed atthe 0.05 level of statistical significance, the results werethen checked to see if the responses showed a meaningfuldifference
Table 3 contains the results of the Chi-square test forthe two populations' response to each question. At the 0.05level of statistical significance the two populations differedon only two of the attitudinal questions, 3 and 7, and two ofthe demographic questions, 15 and 16.
The findings of the data from the attitudinal questionsshow that the two populations were statistically alike 83%of the time. It is interesting to note the similarity of theaverage responses of the two populations as shown in Table 2.PMTC had an average percentage of 80.3 agree responses, andNATC had an average percentage of 79.9 agree responses.On the disagree responses PMTC had an average percentage of14.1, and NATC had an average percentage of 15.8. Theseresults show that both populations had a good awareness andacceptance of the concepts of basic human needs.
Table 3 indicates that the two populations differed at the0.05 level of statistical significance on grade level and age.Because the two populations showed essentially the same over
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
60/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
61/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
62/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
63/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
64/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
65/156
all response to the attitudinal questions, the differencesbetween the two populations in these two demographic areaswere not meaningful to this study.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
66/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
67/156
APPENDIX AQUESTIONNAIRE
This appendix contains an exact copy of the letter ofintroduction and questionnaire that was sent to 561 individualsat the Pacific Missile Test Center, Point Mugu, California andthe Naval Air Test Center, Patuxent River, Maryland
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
68/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
69/156
NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOLMONTEREY, CALIFORNIA - 93940 in reply refer to
Code 550001-2
To Questionnaire Recipient:This questionnaire has been sent to you in order togather research data for a study on attitudes of employees
located at a NAVAIR SYSCOM Field Activity. This study is part ofa project being conducted through the Naval Postgraduate School,Monterey, California. The data is being analyzed by a member ofthe Naval Aviation Executive Institute Program located at PointMugu, California.
Your answers will provide valuable and unique data forestablishing a baseline on employee attitudes. Your personalidentity and individual response will not be divulged. Thequestionnaires do not have to be signed. The success or failureof this research project will depend upon your response.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
70/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
71/156
v 000) cdu CO00 Hco co T3>s H >iH e aj H60 H u 00c u a 00 co 0) o aj o1-1 u en u-J 00 o H uC/3
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
72/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
73/156
enter the most appropriate answer in the box at the right
indicate the level of your formal education.High school / /Associate of A~rts degree or equivalent /_/More than two years college /_/Undergraduate degree /_/Graduate degree /_/ Please state whether graduate degreeis at the masters or Ph.D. levellong have you been in government service?One year or less /_/Two or three years /_/Four or Five years /_/Six to ten years /_/More than ten years /_/is your Rank or Grade level?
is your age?. Twenty- four or under /_/. Twenty- five to twenty-nine /_/. Thirty to thirty-nine /_/. Forty to forty-nine /_/. Over Forty-nine / /
35
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
74/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
75/156
APPENDIX BCHI-SQUARE CALCULATIONS
The Chi-square values shown in table 3 were calculated as follows
* 2 - C C coi.i- Ei-i )i=l j=l E.where
0. . = observed number of responses assigned to the i row of the jcolumn.
E. . = number of resposes expected to be assigned to the i row of the.th ,J column.
The expected values for each cell (E. .) were found by multiplying thecolumn total times the row total, for each cell in the contingency tableand dividing this product by the total number of responses.
2The values of OC resulting from the formula are distributed approximatelyas chi-square with df= (r-l)(k-l), where r = the number of rows and k = thenumber of columns in the contingency table.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
76/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
77/156
APPENDIX C
Population Histograms
mUJ
CC irirccicWNOOfVoj ~- o r{\i ? K* c\i
i-i O* o* * UJ #* *_' 1-* 2 ;z* * a: COa. * ocu. +tr> **CO *c ** o o co * f^ ac x tri o v un nju *3. * tou ** > u.to1 **
**
***** *-* c ora:CO> tO
U. UJX
aUo4C-^^ * * UJ ^r UJ C 2 X e- t
C_J c * * Uj 3T - s/; f\J * * a o C Uj > IT '/:X UJ * ^* + o t t- * C 0- Ujex.
** P*"> ** - * -( * U. > - o^ *- * __ * ^^ 2 u. t fViu. C * tr * a o >- - c c H- =3* 2 * U* a. * e 2 _j r- C X c t*^ alu * C * u. * C * o u-r- UJc.
mHI
=3
IT. tO t-
toa ^** - 2 CJ CJuj Vrt
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
78/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
79/156
Uit2
3 IViCCI* _J* IS* ~Z* c* cr* t**Co
5C
********
********* UJ tu* or* 12m c
u- >- Uj _i* u: 12* tr ^* -a C* to w ct* - fr-it o * t/3 X -> C2cr UJ UJ 2-k. r^ X i U
J? oaC c u. X iP c/: t- 2C
acrc u
coru
oo o coXI
rv c u-> c c: ^C c >c o 3 aC" c * c 3
rv.IT-
UiIC *- ^< X C" uto 3 a.^^ Z c*
X X 3t T - _}
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
80/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
81/156
Mire o o - o o 2 1 toCCUiX LT wO1- t- ^ -0 cr
Cfl CO tO 2. z
u.C U-
3 c ax c roc c ^j CJcr
cc oAJ
cc co coto to
to
toUjto
tr 1- 4~ r C t;to ~ ac z cz U. - -
_UJ c =3 - Z z ^ 3" u >
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
82/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
83/156
r-
a.Uscnccc
a:o
**
ai
UJ
2"
**
**
*ft**ft*ft** jjft a* o* -x *ft >- *ft _ ** e ** z. *
OCec
2 U.*- a.c cr
tr > *~
ao
XIC
cc-cor
Cft Ctft -ft 1/5*ft
-ft ct cr, a:ftir c w *- -ft -ft 2 C j/j %_* *
oo
t> ru o c ; rvi o o o>C vO o c CO
c
CJ2 2< 4 Uit - t3c at z xu.1 ct
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
84/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
85/156
C >C O C r*\K! ^ O O >c it c c er\j ^ ru r^
IT
Xc
UJa:
a.
isUJX>
UJ
isc_>
a.
o
* U-.* Q-* B* >-* _* is* z* c* cc* t-* tr**
00IT
********
****-r u_* u.* or* cs
z~ c* z* *-- a* c* c* z*
K1XI
***-*
***
*+**
e
UJu.ctC5
*-%
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
86/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
87/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
88/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
89/156
ID
a.COCCc
a:
o.
x.
a.Hicr
aUJ
a:*-_a-*-CO
UJcccor
IT
*********UJ 2T *e; *a *
-> *c >- *_1 *ir *^ * u.c * Ulac * cc *- * tocc -r * x * c* * * *
c CX * UJ*- * a:a * Hic *
UiUla.C3-trzc
* to
p- \J c c ->o f^ c o k a: CO
>o
OMXO.O(T C f\l C -o o r^ o tr;
COCOJc_
o ct > CO 2* t*>a u Id **n Xuj Q z .*. l_ 3 COc C UJ X ir to if o IT M tr CO 3T X
cu
Ula:
cc ccru r*
c ocIT
^ C wm C mr C OL C. OL>c c t- c: =j
to I~ X uCO 3 Q.C* XZ liih M c or x >
iij o T X 3T X o
to
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
90/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
91/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
92/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
93/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
94/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
95/156
UJ
a
I' O O C IT~* ^r o o p-o x o c rv.'rvi =j in re
aUJenXccUion
5.a.IUi
u:Ui*- aC U
**************
cu.cr
c>
H> *e *- 2 * U.C + U!* i * a:* *~ * us
o*- Uj ^>Z Ui ft- aa -' tic * CO
* to* -* 2 * C *^
UJli-ar
xi-ic>ocor*-X
2 2" x x H- crc or Ui u. r 2X UJ O 2 X XC C Ui >. j~. X1- 1- >C 2Uj
UJa:
X C IT c fji o r^ c x a.- c po c c rvj ru fu r
c u. \r.coaX Co uo
or
corvi
cc cc oX 2XX
X03 I- _Ui 3 w -
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
96/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
97/156
rv
a.
=3 - C O CCi/> ru o c crco f c c co- K> 5f -
toecoOUJUJ(-1
uQ.I
1^
***************
* ** >- ** _i ** C3 ** z * u-* C * Ll.* cr * or
r-
w ctz*- C
r- -t *~ u.z ki u,- a:a. itc ->to* tok * w c
c
c
Uiuz z<
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
98/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
99/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
100/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
101/156
UJC3
i ir o c ^rec r*> o c >- rv: ^r ^ rvj
Ui(O
ccUJ
UJcr
-2:a.c >
UJ
X
*******
***
*
*
*
_)
I
f
rvj
11tca:
*** _?* XL. tf;* LP O
LP
>c
&
IT
J)
cr > 09 X 1a: Ju U 3 dC
^3" UJ c 2li
_'03C c 111 X iT tof * * d CT 10 ir. a; 2 y
Uj
ac a.
a c c r- uj C 3 - x 3: *. X l_>
tr
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
102/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
103/156
IV.
UJ
r- ^r o ot^. in o o ocm o >^r -* K\ i- =i
IT*
a.Li-teXcC
a.
tu
QUJa-
* O* * *ac * *u. * *CO
f\J* *+ #- c1 f\. * *
'21 * *u-' * *i." ^~ * *2 f\. * *a > - * *Uj, * c ^.> * * * 1 ir>c I 1 + * 1 co * K> If' * * u. Oj* * 1 * I + Ua >-LL * ac a r -k v~ _;c * r~ * c * - *
UjU< < UiO T 2 XSU * 3r >a3
n w ire rc c - c cin
Iu~ Z3
m
Uj
ac :> co X l- cra. u. Uj .Za- c A ^r CJ w.S ooe c Uj x If tcK- 1- X. -3 e tr. BQ WO ZL- X,
cr c nC c. >cf\ c r- c r*~
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
104/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
105/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
106/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
107/156
K r^ cv o c -4}1/1 =J o o cc^^ co ir =r o O >Cu_ r- 5u o- Kl ^T
*ft
ftft
ftft -> o * :> a 5a -ft -ft a-
li- K1 ft -ft ften ft* -ft -ftft(C * * -ftC.
-*ft
ftft
-ft-ft o r^ C inc * ft -ft a c & O !*>
u_ * * ft ft o 1X f\i O Kl- * -ft k ft - c * * * ft K> 1 if Klu- * * ft fta. * ft ft ft jru ** -ft ftft ftft U:t **
ftftftft
***-ft*
ftft*ftft*
-ftftftftftft
-* o aaUJ
V)> WJa. UJa 2
3" -
>
_: " ft ft -ft ft 3 -^ u; a ft ft r^ O u- X iT* tor -ft * ft ft fr- - * r ?"^ *ft ** & ** -ftft IT
Lu a. ru ft I * I 1 ft o*t 3 -ft i ft I ft 1 -ft 5T - c
- C * ft C * i ft t -ft 1 -.Li. Q- * a -ft i- * C ft c ft >- ec c >c c a o*
tr * j_ ft ft i- n ft a w t_> c c en C t*> r^* c ft I -ft Ui i. ir c a- c rvi V4> * 2. IT o ft c- * > ft UJIE * 3 ft fV * f> ft 5X ft c ft 3 K IT- 1 3
* -ft k l ft 1 ft ft e r^[fcj * ft * ft ft ft U*O * ft * ft ft aO u. w
>c UJr^ u o c c c c c rf-^ O)C c c c o c O > 3 lO * _^o > X uu3: O 33" ^ *> 3: o 4.>
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
108/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
109/156
f\J
HI(5
Q.u.toC
a:
2i
c
**********
*-* *r *- uj *UJ *or + *->cr * c- ** _s ** IS * i: * uj w* C * U.* oc * or ** i- * tr *
-* CO * COc -*>
t\J vC o o Or- c o o IT*9 q o o cfU w< ^ IT*a3-
rO
oo-4 -> Oo a z zllL < 3SE > flt lO
O
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
110/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
111/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
112/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
113/156
C5
uGOCOo
;n
zI
txl
5CC
-* _J* tr-K Z* c* or* H-* 'Jl*
****It*
**** -^ Z* o C* "" - 2* t* j- a* Ui c* a c* * * 2: w* ** * *
a eIT
c>as
r*> IT o c r*ao ft c C l-ao ^r o o a-^ ^
co\1Z z
O4 < uut-f -HI CJc ct z zUl n. ct to tO z CDa. u. U, 3 zUl c z x _r. *-
j - CDe c UJ X IT tO*~ - It
>-
UJ
0L' C IT C Kl fVJr. c k> c t*i r-ec c. r- c ~- ~
uctc u
aUito
c: oco cc co
r*>
cc ooin
ca:
ru K" ITtoto
to *- a*-> 2 _' C_>to ae X cZ. Ul c cr ^ > _JUJ o _j i
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
114/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
115/156
its12a-cc
-o o o o r^m co o o inr- ?- o o c
a.u,toGO
a:cj
cj*-C2
2c
in
**k*****k**** bu* uJ+ or* tSt* -* _** cr* 2* C* or* h- (A
aUito
toUJcc
ca:
cc
***It
************-k
******* u.* W* * X' COi- - 5C
oc ccin
c C cc C cc rvirv C CT O- f r^CO C o C ir M f * cc3
toluCO
O - ij c 3 -< 47 3" 5cT X CJ >
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
116/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
117/156
ID3
~* c c o inK000 O C -Kl I-* 3T 5T ro
ir>
t-t c
~c
a.
vi-
llia.
-aZI
2
o
I*-
aUjcr-
oco
CCJIX
Ccif\ CJccor
*********- *
IT UJ * OJ *or *o * i-i
a:i-
UJuo < (U#- t-i tactr ziui < < z:x :> a - >c o m-c: \t o o XIT
ec 3: *-. isa Ll. u_ _ 4EUJ c z X U >-^2 V (C oo 2 5"
CJ c o o o
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
118/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
119/156
IS
a.COCCocHior
cr
orco
CXc
ru
US-r a.
* -a* >-* _)* IT* 2* c* a:* t-* co
x
*********************
***** a.* u.* o:* IT* - ftcrZc o c c oCO in o o w* ki c c ^
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
120/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
121/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
122/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
123/156
oa
w* K1 c o X-~ 00 o o OJO CO c o ^fVi =3
trai
a.UJto50c
r\
Uj2-
itC
**k****-k**Mt *(VO **>- *
-(S *Z * U_ C * Lk-* or * a* f- * c* CO * * *
f\i
-, Q.a * oo * ** CO
UJu.Orc*^ CJ in c ^C O* c c --*
in OJtoUJto CO s cror UJ UJ ^tiu C n X c; a toc e UJ X in to- - X. d O" ir tc CO X X
c>-LIZUiu>OTc u_
a.o cou*CO ecu coor .
oo!\J
cc co ocIT-
Wi c 3 c r\jCC C >C O K>A; C 5T C Mf\J - -
CO -- X t_!to 3 a.C T2UJI-H oj a o -
A*
COCO4u
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
124/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
125/156
f\J o c o ur- ru o o otr 5 c c -- 5T - fVI
a.toXoOUJ
UJa:
UJ
UJ
OJ
**********
itc
ir orrv, cr *- *
_J *wo *i. * u.* C * Uj* at * a. -* - * kT* to * * ** * ** * *
UJu:ortratr>*>c
Ui -> >r u* a: cc
0(0900JT* U -JO c cO C Jt O s
ru
oru an -*
CO
cou.COrCJ
a > to i > tsc a. li u. 2cc \Mi C -z. X LJ CCC: c wl. X m cct - V
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
126/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
127/156
oUJ12
r^ o- o oc r c o r*r\i a- -U.cco cj
o
********
U Ui *a *^ c *f- -a * *>- *I *t3 * -z * u. a- C * Ui c
ft * ^* - * tr C* CO -tt *-' ~z* ** * *
>o
U
2c* C9*
c-
Oj
c-o
Uiux Zm w UC (* X XUi -< 3
r-^ r^ nj O UI n>o I*- -o c ru X - H sc i a CO
*-*
IT(C
r^- o =? c ^ j^ o f* o 53 1^AJ c
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
128/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
129/156
ruru
ISa
fU O" O O Kl o o *C K! C C K> fU
a.U.CO
O
UJa:
_J>--azI
C
IT*ru
******
*-> -. *Oilu *Kl CjJ *
Jt *ir **
* is ** 2 Uj* C * Uj* Or * t ** t~ * tr* CO * ** * *
UJ
en
ooruUJCI
I *S. UJ- -* oc or z xul *- r>x > or en
^r ru o o r^ O^r CO * c: K>o IT ^ o ccorvi ^T 4*
CO
COto
a: > CO - trc or U. EftJ 2CO Uu c 3 (J tOc c u X x lO - x-
at
cr c ccf\. c d c >CC CN C I\,~- ru rv c
CO k-- 3 jj C 3 - X X 3t X CJ
ru
toCO
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
130/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
131/156
UJ
>0 > o c f*1?T P- O O l/>r- t\i c o ^3 O- nj
cc
UjtoCOc
u.
tus
tozz.cto
ctoCat
cu.UJ
%- *** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** * ** ** ** ** ** ** ** u. ** Uj ** Ct ** ZS * *i ** ** >- *-It j ** IS ** z * u_
LP tr
c^ * a: a: to
43 O N O (Vec r* ec c o - fVj o oc
-. ~ io toto
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
132/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
133/156
rvi
ujis
>o o o ~*t> o o o trro K) o f M O f\I ft I c* _i f\-ft C ft C Ift X to -v* u crft tO w fcft I -* I -ft Ift I -ft t* -ft CJft 1 -ft c - -HI-*-, *
-U
-vjt
C
ftft ft fft t-ft I-ft ft CO-ft ft Xft I-ft Iftft
urUJft Qft* u_ft I-* 3-ft Cft or to
oX l ru o =3- o r*> o r*i in to xi tra: UJ Uj X 2LkJ c 2 y (J t^ COl c Lk. X X tot - A 4 cr w to CO jr X
X>cO U_
c o cKl
o oIP
K- c a c 5X rvio: c cr c f r^" c a c rvj w~^ i c
1^-
toUl
to -
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
134/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
135/156
COCVJ
I?a.
4) o o c t*>O O O O Ogff CCftl5 Kl f" 53
03
Oor
CJ
t
a-
>to
cu.cto:
* I* a.* c* i* i* t*
crvj
* * r* a* a* c* i* *
KlIf!
*********K* O* * I* C* t-* I ,* f*-ft
IS
*****
*****K*** o I* ac* U.'* I-* uU* a*
oo
oCO
'aU
-i *- CDC C Z Xx > a. to
X LP -C O -CO O" JJ O CTo
-o 1 Eft Kl
Ui to jr -* cra LkJ u_ zii_ C 2 X (J) i 10c c uJ X IT to- 1- * c CO C CO rvi=3- c 3 c c r^- c rv. c c *^ tr l rv. 3
tOUito t~
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
136/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
137/156
K1
UJt2
a: toa. * **a: ru *c * * C N N C tr tflc * ' w * Mtr^oaa- * * ~* >o O O P^- * * * c< * * ft K> * r- k>Uj * * * *Q: * * * * U3Li -k* ** ** * UJ1 ******
*****
***
****** or u. a_ zr uj c z 2: c
-a
_> * * * * 2 -* tc- * * * * * C C oj X IT to o. k k * + * x C t2 3 * * * ~* * !0 * m (OtCK I xC * * * * m-* * M -c v * C * C * c * * * * k 1 * -k 1 k f k tUbu * ce * CC * CO * cc *
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
138/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
139/156
a.
IXIX.COOCc
c_
cr
>-a?Ul.C2
fV
^ 0.* c:* 2* ZJ-<
* -
*-K**** rvj * l* O* t-** fVJ* l
crin
m********* cr* i i* c* t-* t* c* r*> l*
*** o* o* I* I** C* i-* i+ c* f-IT*
**
i* i* at* u_* :>* c* f*
>C Kl O c ften ** ^
incc
2a.'
2c
a: r.
IT. ^- < crtt X X 3 2XI * 2 X U >
-3 COC a UJ X iT> tnf- *- it
co crIT-
r- o Kl O f- Oiir c V C K* r^- c a C >C K-- *n 1
COX:o
IO - Z (J UCO ! ac T c*2 u- ^~ H^- C a; 2 > .JoJ C Z3 i
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
140/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
141/156
APPENDIX D
Historical Data Bank
Statistical data bank is contained in this appendix forboth populations. Populations are identified by the lastinteger of each line. The integer i, corresponds with PacificMissile Test Center, and the integer 2, corresponds withNaval Air Test Center.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
142/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
143/156
in in 5i(viunrin 3 in-* ru in .n sire ru ruru ~* ruru ru ru53 53 53ru m ruru ru ruft.! rv 53P. Pi PJru rv ru53 53 Pi
(VI M 3in ru 5T53 m lpin lp inru ru ruru ru reru ru ru53 IP 53rv to ru53 in ruru ru rutvi (\j rus* in 53 IT Kl
53 rux rulp inin 53 533- ruru ru53 5353 ru -IP =3--. ruru toip ipru cr
tOLPrvjir.53 LP 5353 IPre ruru "re *v51 ipru=*ru-ip IPa* min ip ru- ru toIP iPru jrru to53 sr toIP 53S3 IP
53 5i ruin rp ruLP LP toru ru to5i ru ipru ru -ru ru ruru ru rua- ru IPru ru ?ru 53 5353 53 53 OJ ~ru ru ruIP 53 5353 53 ru
IP 53x toIP tp53 IP IP ruru reru ru53 ruru ruru ru53 fV>ru rv53 IP53 53
ru ipre ipto IP tO53 ru ruru 53ru to53 ruip ru53 ru53 ruru ruru rv53 5353 53
ru s\53 CIP IPPi 53IP 53ru ru ruru 53 53re reru *ru tssw- ruru ~-ip ip53 5T
53 (Pr- 5jiP 51ir to53 IP ruru ru=3 C53 ru53 53ru ~+re toru -*ru ip ipIP K>
3 M 31P1*1 rv ru rutp =t ip mru 5jru ruru ruru ruru toru 553 ruru rp* to53 ru*4 IP53 53
ru 53-5i rum ~*ru reru 53ru ruru ruru 53ru ruru ruru 53ru ip
to lp -C -C f\iIP in ruin 53 53 5T IP~ rv ruru ru 5jru ru to53 53 53S3 ru ruru ru ru53 ip ruru ru ru ru 5353" 53 53IP ru ru
IP iP K*k> ro ruip ru k*K> 53 ru in ipru ru ruru 5j ru ru to53 53 53ru ru ruru ru rurv 53 53ru ru ruru ru ru53 IP 5T(VI 53 5T
IP 5T f*3 fVIKIIP IP IT-* ru 3 3 Jlru ru ruru ru ru to ruPJ tO 53ru ru ip53 53 ruIP IP 53- ru ~* ru ruIP s\ IP53 m 53
53 to ruru ip ru53 53 ru* ip -iIP 53 IPru ruru ruip ruru ip53 PIru 53 tore IP piru rvto v rvin 53 in53 ru ru
to r*>rv pru 53 5ip ip
~. ru ru53p. IP
5353 ruip inru ~ru ~53 IP53 53
ru f toru to xito 53 IP-^ .* toru 5i tPru ru ruru ru rurv ru 53 5i mrv 53 mru 53 53 53 53ru ru -+re to 53 53 ip53 to 53
to ST tO in m5j in m-- to m53 in inru ru ruru ru -- ^ ru- S3- 53ra ru ruru to rurv ip ip *-* ruK V* M53 IP 5353 IP 53
53 IPrv rPin m-. rv5j mru ruru rurv ruru ruin inrv rv~ rurv rv;p ip53 53
ru mru >c5 IP^ 5Tru ruru rvru 53ru 53ru 5i53 ru 1ru rurv rvru ruru rvru mP. 53
in inrv ruin in -iru ruS3 5Jru rv53 ru- p.- rut** tn-- orv rv53 IPru 53
53 tPIP 53IT. tPS3 LP rvru ruru tPru 5353 53ru S3ru tn mru rvru 53ru 53
ru3 53LP LP ruru in 5353 tP 53rv re ~rv =3 ru 53 rusj ru tpru rv toru ru ru53 53 53ru ru ru 5j ru53 tO P53 S3 LP
tO S3ru to53 IPru IPto rvru rut* ru53 53S3 ruS3 -*P' rvS3 ru rvin rvito =3-
f rv>o tP53 5353 ~*LP S3~ ruru toe\i rv53 LPto rvru ru 53ru sjrv rvS3 -*t** ru
ip ipx> ruip mP sjip ipru -S3 t\lre rvS3 sarre rv53 535? OIP 53 -53 5353 53
C 53O K>O LPC -^53 re ruru rurv ru
LP 53
LP OLP Oin cru ct\i ^ru roru toto rv inrv ruto rurv to ru 53ru 5353
- toru cru 53m lpru -ru ru toru 53rv re53 5353 IPru c53 LP53 53
in cto oLP cLT P 53ru toru ruru reZl 53rv kS3 ruLP 53ru rere reIP 53K> IP
53 f* ru to 5} ru 53" .n ip ru SJ ru LP 53 LP to to LT to LP M rv m S3 IT rv ^ rv si 1*1 (O S3 t" wP J~in ru ru ru ip ru s X rv ru X S3 ro 53 re X X X ru - rv in IP S3 S3 rv m X LT re LT. r- re rem ru 5T ip m ru X ^~ ro f" in CJ vn LP IP LO 53 LP s> m ro S3 m in LT rv S3 ru lp S3 S3 IP ST -P s- Klto . 4 53 tO S3 rv ^. in ._ to f* in 4 53 iP. 53 K* *- - f< H rv ir to iP S3 w~ S3 LP *" "~S3 tO 5X S3 53 IP IT ru ji 51 57 iP LP 53 LP IP LP 52 LP S3 S3 m-^ lp in S3 ST in 53 5J LP S3 Kl LP S3 J^ rvre ru ru 5t ru ru re ce rv ru _ P. rv ru rv rv re rv' m rv ru ru ru re ~- rv Pj re rv re rv rv re reru ru fV 5T ru re re sr rv ru rv P.f 53 rv ru ru ru ru rv rv ru re re rv re ru ru rv p_ rv re rv rv rvru o Pi p. ru ru rv K> rv to rv to rv ru ru to p. re ru r^1 Pi rvi ru p p. rv ru m* rv m /* re 3 c rvS3 re tp m 53 S3 rv 5T SJ in LT, 53 5? IP ru sj LP S3 LP PJ 53 IP S3 ru S3 r*> 51 re IT *n re S3 S3 rvre re rc rv ru ru P. t^ LT- P so rv 53 rv rv rv re re S3 rv re 53 rv re rv 53 ru 5T 5? s* 53 s? rv rvre ru cr ru ru 53 ru ru ru Pi 4 ^ 5J 53 ru ru ru -i S3 < rv ru rv rv w rv rv in re S3 re: rv rvj -", rvt*i 53 5T K" ru LP 5^- P' m 53 rv m P' 53 53 l*t IP 53 53 rv rvi s? re LP rv rv r*> rv in ^ "" SJ rv (\ cr STrv rure to rv
~ ip ru -h ru ^, ru ru -i -^ ~* ru ru rv ru rv rv * - ~~ rv * ^* ru rv ^ rv S3 *~" *""rv 53 tP ru ru 5T pi ru rv S3 P ru t^ p ru P rv rv re re rv - rv K* LP rv rv r^* rv Pi c Kl
ru ru C3 53 53 53 in 51 in j"> S3 m in S3 53 LP LP 53 53 S3 ro in LP LP S3 S3 LP 51 IP lP S3 LP S3 rv S3 sr5r rv S3 rv to rv rv ru 53 S3 53 t^ S3 P sj rv in 53 rv rv: S3 ru =3 rv ST 53 5T ST r*t s? ST LP S3 S3
to ruru rurv sj~ ruS3rvprvs?S3
LPruS3LPS3ru toin rv> ru-* ruLP 5353 53
ru inru ruS3 S3K* 53
p t^LP s?53 53LP - 53~- rure' ioLP ru ru
ru ru roru ru xru 53 in53 ru inin 53 in rv53 ru rvrv to rv-* 53 53rv re 5353 ~* ruP' LP K"a'K< -53 -^ 5353 53 ru
ro toru ru53 rure -LP LP-ru -"ru rure o5T 5353 S3ru s? 51t\! in IPrv
53 tOrv x51 53ru injn lprv -~- rviP syLP 51ru ru rvLP -- 51in lpLP LP
ru ruru ro51 S3~+ -*LP 53t*^ ru-i rure. reS3 LP53 rv53 51!" 53ru ru P'LP 5353 S3
to ru =3p" rv xm 53 tnm- IP(T! Ifl 3^- reru rv ru to ru53 ru =3ru re rv53 ruruLP 53 S3rv ru ru^ 53 5353 53 ru
LPre ru 5i53 iSi 53 ruru -vc ru51 S35? rvsi ru f*ru ruc ruLP 51ru f
in rurp rur/i 575? 53ru re rvrv ru5T ruru resi ruru P'ru rvi pi51 LPp rv
tO S3 fOX X toIP LP LPLP LP tOS3 LP 5353 rv H*53 53rv 53S3 rvP' rv~* ru -re re -
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
144/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
145/156
a a rv \j rv a A A' A A A A A AAA A A A A A A AJ A A A A A A A A A A A A Aairif 1*1 57 -< r*l rA K in K K< K> 53 K* K Kl ET n K A in d A A 5J Kl A 3 M", wP v* A 5T 3 r*ix rv kt rv A ru m A X X X x m WIT .O A r- =i X A 53 X K X x x A X K in A A 3 m. Atr tr< 53 x 51 Ki 51 ai in IT Ki K> A53 r*i53 inA' 5T
Ai rvrv r*>X c53 in53 Aiin inA A.A AJrv rv53 K" 53AI rv=T Arv Arv rv53 in53 A
A rv Arv 53 53aj a inf> f*> in A 53 in 53rv rv arv rvAAA53 in rvAAArv 53 -*53 53 A'A Arv -- 53 53 5353 rv rv
rv a-< *iA CA 53 53m 53A A A 53 m53 m53 ^ rvrv-~*s*i in 5353 in
a rv Ain ai inA 53 >CJ1 3 ITA ~+ m 53 A A AiAJ At AA A 53 53 53A' A rv rv Arv A' s? AJ AA i Arv 53 inin A' si
A) ru A i mftidiKIf m 3 A A53 m AAA5i fi mA -- AA r** A'k ?*> 53 -* rv53 a in rvA rv 53 53 53in 53 m
rv A Ajyi po a
A53in
53 m5s m53 53U*l CM 53 rv -^A: A 5j ai inf 53 A53 AJ 5353 53 AMVliT53 A' in 53 rvf*> 53 A
AAAA* rv KA rv A53 53 53- 53 Aa i*> rvAAA A A53 53 53A 53 AA AI 53A AAAA53 A 5353 A 53
A AA 51vC >C53 5353 -~53 51A 53rv rvA 53A 53A AA 53A 53AJ rvA A53 53A
A. AKl ~x mm ain 5im mA A53 ruA A53 51Ar"AJ AA' AJrv -*A A'53 inh!3
A' A' AKl -* 51>C A A53 po inin a 53 in tnrv A' pnrv rv AK* A 53 53A A' I"> 53A A A AA A' 53 53 tn53 A A'
A53
A Apn 5:m i*ia in53 JlA ~c intn 53 53k*> inA AAi AAi A53 AA 53A AA' 5353 * A53 in53 53
AAA3(\Jin m 5iA IT. 53Kl H -.53 in a A f*>AAAAAA53 in 535T A Am 53 53A Aru a rv A rv53 53 5353 Ai A
1/1>C Ain a53 AX 53A AA AA K.53 53A A53 AA A~ AA K53 -^A A
53 inin inK Kt53 in53 53 AA KtA 53in 5353 AA AJC AAi -A A53 5353 AJ
ru AA 53 AAI 5351 KlA Ai A A53 AA 53A -*A' A'rv 53 A53 rv
A' A**> A'A AiA Kl tnA' AA -*A Kl53 53 Arv A53 53* (\iA 53in 53A AJ
A AA KtA X*53 53. tf53 53A AA 53K A53 AA A'53 53A AA AA A'53 AA A
AAAK K Kla k m53 in k 53k ru 53A Kl Ain Kt 53A 53 AA K A53 A A A AAJ K 53Kt Al AJA K AAJ Kt 53K Ai 53
A AA KK AKi mm 53rv aA A'A Ain 5353 AKi A53 53K Ain in53 53
A AK Kk< in53 inA *-5i inA rv AA Ain 5353 5353 mrv - AA A53 51fU A
A AA 53Ki A53 onK 5J53 51A A 53A A.A 53A 53A 53A 5Tin aA ~in 53rv aj
AAA53 53 53m r -cin 5? trin in a in mAAA53 A AA A Aa 5i in 53 AA 51 AlIT 53 --. ru AAAm in in53 A 53
A AA 53A 53in in53 inAI KiA Aa m53 53A A AA. mA A Atn inki tn
A A Aa in ax in ki53 X 5351 in ~ xAAAA AJ AA a in53 A A53 53A A -* A'x in in53 a in
A53A5357
A AK KiA Xtn mA 51tr xA A53 AA A53 53A' AA 353 mA A53 5353 53
A A53 irA Kin in53 5JA 53 A A53 KiA 53A 53(V 53A -"A *rv ina in
AAA-* tn kA X Ka ir x A 53 53 53 A A A AK A A51 53 51K 53 AA A 53 53 AAAAK A AA 53 53a 53 ir
A Aa tra tra ri5i min 5iA AA AX 53 53A 53A 3in 5353 A
m 53 A IT K. 53 o 3 53 Kt O 5X 353 a in 53 Kl 53 in , in K r*> 3 X K Ki K 5J m 1*1 A A r*>A A A X X Kl o X f>0 53 O r*> C A A' A A X ir a; A" A A Kl A X t*~ X X A X A A A A Atr tr 53 tn a ir c T> d in c in in ai a a tn XI 3 5T m 3 XT \T 53 X X X X A LT X* 3 3" A ? (Vl o A -~ Kl c - ~* A *1 IT r^ - 53 ^ A ^7 51 3 K ^,ir 53 in 53 53 in 3 in 53 in m tn in 53 3 53 m A 3 53 IT IT 3 53 A 3 57 X 3 A 3 X 5? X A A AAA A A - A A A A A A CM A A A A > A M A A A K A A A A Ax m 53 AAA AJ A 3 - A A A X A A A 53 A A A A IH CM A A A A r^ A 53 A A A Aru a A AAA A A K A' A K AAA A K A o A' f> A A rv A A A K K rv A 1*1 1*1 A53 K> lT 53 53 53 53 3 3 A 53 53 5353 in 53 A 53 A IT 3 A 3 53 53 51 57 53 X 3 X 51 3 53A 53 IT 53 A A A* 53 A K A 53 AT 53 A rv A A ir A A V4 A A K r\ K 57 ^_ 5T K A .._ A A A A A A' A * A' 53 A AJ A 53 A A A tr 53 A V* X 53 A A A A A A Ai Al A AA' 51 53 K A A A 53 3 K A 53 53 A in 53 A IT 53 K- 53 X IT A f m A' pi A 3 LT K rv A A 53 A A AJ A A A Kl A rv A ^^ _ Ki A A A A AA A A rv ru a A A A' A A K A A A CM A' A A rv 53 - A V4 A A A A ^_ A A' K Kl A53 53 51 5i tr in m 53 < 53 r in 53 a in in a J-l in A in A X ir 53 53 57 X 53 m 3 53 51 X X 5353 53 A A 51 53 53 A 5T 53 3 53 53 A' 5T 53 Ki 53 r*l 53 53 53 A 5: 57 53 3 3 53 A X 57 K" 57 53
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
146/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
147/156
P ru rv. rv rv rv. ru rv rv f\! rv rv rv rv rv. rv rv rv p. rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rvi~r> LP KI r\j rv K< k> ru IT. ki in rv p cr k* n cr ir cr i*i ^- it t*s (l cr f ip m -i n vn K1C n x LP =i K< r- k Ki >c x rv r^. in =3 in 3 in CJ K4. rv rv ^c >c c t\ K1 - ^c x crZ3 m * cr cr CJ in CT IT n m Ki cr m Jl cr in n LP IT rv 1ft CT cr LT r^ C3 >n C LT in cran rvi IP CI rv ID rv. m- cr H w in rv - ~^ - K- V* 9-* cr cr ro LT w* -- cr cr cr crJT IT =3 LP un CT IT vn CT cr in CI J"' k 3 CJ a n (*1 =1 CI in Cf IT IT CJ cr cr LP cr K-J P rv." ru M rv rv rv rv - rv rv x rv rvi rv rv ~~ rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rvru CV rv w* rvi 3 M rv 5j p*\ rv rv rv ci rvi rv cr rv rv rv rv rv c rv c? rv rv rv rv rv ru a'ru h IV rv ru rv. rv rv K rv rv. rv rv rv * rv rv rv- rv cr rv r^i rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rvCT LP cr cr 3 ci cr m rv K> CJ K cr cr vr cr cr cr rv n cr cr cr c cr cr CJ CI CJ Cf ct CfK P rv f. (V m- A. rv rv rv ^ =7 rv rv =3 . rv rv M cr rv rv rv c rv rv rv rv rv rvCJ rv ci CT > rvj rv. w* rvi 3 rv ru rv cr rv ru =i rv CJ rv :\1 CT cr - cr Cf rv r\ rv rv rvCI rv cj K1 rv rv rv rv rv cr K cr rv ST cr cr K cr m rv sy d -- rv rv fH rv cr rv in r\ - rv rv. rvi - *4 rv ru ^T rv h rv rv rv rv CI ~ rv ru rv -* i-^ rv w- rv rv ru rv rvPS H CT w- rv rv m- rv p rv rv H rv k< rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv: rv rv rv rv rvm 3 cr CT in in in in CJ cr ru r- CT CT in ci rv ru m ru ru cr m in Cf m in cr cr cr in ruru m rv K-< P.' CT -> rv cr K> CT cr rv rv rvi rv cr ru cr rv rv c; cr in cr cr f\s cr cr cr ru ru
rv ru rv. rv rv cv rv rv ru rv rv rv rv rv rv rv P r\. rv rv rv rv rv rv rv rv r\ rv rv rv rv rv rv rv ru ruru LP ** fVI K> ru cr tr cr cr - ru ru ru f** Cf rv rv LP Cf Cf K1 CJ r*> Ki rv K* K< LP LP P)f*^ r* ^ fi r^ m r*- o Ki K1 rv cr cr rv rv LP i IT C >c rv ^c rv rv CJ .P IP Ki ^ cr P nC >o LP LP c cr Ct IP IP. rv LP cr J~ p" LP LP J- n LP cr m P K IP LP LP Cf""" - p*" .- "^* r*-,
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
148/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
149/156
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Berne, E., The Structure and Dynamics of Organizations andGroups , J. IT Lippincott Company, New York, 1963
Berne, E., Games People Play , p. 13-15, 29-30, and 58, GrovePress, Inc., New York, 1964.Berne, E., What Do You Do After You Say Hello ?, p. 11-21,Grove Press , Inc. , New York, 1972Drucker, P. F., Management: Tasks, Responsibilities,Practices , p. 24^ 181, 200-202, 456, and 520-523, Harper
Row, Publishers, New York, 1973.Harris, T.A. , I'm O.K. - You're O.K. , p. 33-37, 74-77, Harper
Row Publishers , Inc. , New York , 1967.Holloway, H. W. and Holloway, M. M. , Change Now! , p. 16-22,Midwest Institute For Human Understanding, Medina, Ohio,1973.Isacc, S., and Michael, W. B., Handbook in Research andEvaluation , p. 58, Edits Publishers , San Diego, 1971James, M. and Jongeward, D., Born To Win , p. 1-3, 56-59, and265, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Menlo Park,California, 1971.Kress, G., The Business Research Process , I Candid Publica-tions, Fort Collins, Colorado, 1974.Maslow, A. H. , Motivation and Personality , 2nd Ed., p. xii,35-58, Harper $ Rox, Publishers, Inc., New York, 1970.Nie, N. H., Statistical Package For The Social Sciences ,2nd Ed., McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1970.
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
150/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
151/156
INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST
No. Copies1. Defense Documentation Center 2Cameron StationAlexandria, Virginia 223142. Library, Code 0212 2Naval Postgraduate SchoolMonterey, California 939403. Chairman, Department of 2Administrative SciencesCode 54Naval Postgraduate SchoolMonterey, California 939404. Naval Air Systems Command 4Naval Aviation Executive InstituteWashington, D.C. 203615. Professor J. W. Creighton 1Code 540fDepartment of Administrative SciencesNaval Postgraduate SchoolMonterey, California 939406. Professor J. C. Kiley 11026 Bronco Rd.Pebble Beach, California 939537. Ms. S. M. Coray 1Code 0222Career Development Division
Pacific Missile Test CenterPoint Mugu, California 930428. Mr. E. Stokel lEmployee Development DivisionCivilian Personnel DivisionNaval Air Test CenterPatuxent River, Maryland 206709. Mr. K. L. Wilkinson 1AT0 2
Naval Air Test CenterPatuxent River, Maryland 20670
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
152/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
153/156
10. Mr. D. W. BucknerP. 0. Box 328Lexington Park, Maryland 20653
11. Mr. L. Trettin1293 Buena VistaVentura, California 93001
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
154/156
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
155/156
B83e
?5 Kb
6-;e; 1666S3feci-- udy Oft
?'''#8
of'"a'VsOrc0ce . *at;
forOft^
ThesisB832 Bucknerc.l A study on the ef-
fectiveness of trans-actional analysis forimproving organization-al performance.
1SSS53
-
7/28/2019 A STUDY on the EFFECTIVENES of TA Improving Organizational Performance Tez Master 76
156/156
"iesB832
ess of transact
3 2768 002 0788ft -3