a test - new york universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valugspr17/... · 2017-02-22 ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
159
ATest
¨ YouaretryingtoestimatethegrowthrateinearningspershareatTimeWarnerfrom1996to1997.In1996,theearningspersharewasadeficitof$0.05.In1997,theexpectedearningspershareis$0.25.Whatisthegrowthrate?
a. -600%b. +600%c. +120%d. Cannotbeestimated
Aswath Damodaran
159
![Page 2: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
160
DealingwithNegativeEarnings
¨ Whentheearningsinthestartingperiodarenegative,thegrowthratecannotbeestimated.(0.30/-0.05=-600%)
¨ Therearethreesolutions:¤ Usethehigherofthetwonumbersasthedenominator(0.30/0.25=120%)
¤ Usetheabsolutevalueofearningsinthestartingperiodasthedenominator(0.30/0.05=600%)
¤ Usealinearregressionmodelanddividethecoefficientbytheaverageearnings.
¨ Whenearningsarenegative,thegrowthrateismeaningless.Thus,whilethegrowthratecanbeestimated,itdoesnottellyoumuchaboutthefuture.
Aswath Damodaran
160
![Page 3: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
161
TheEffectofSizeonGrowth:CallawayGolf
Year NetProfit GrowthRate1990 1.801991 6.40 255.56%1992 19.30 201.56%1993 41.20 113.47%1994 78.00 89.32%1995 97.70 25.26%1996 122.30 25.18%¨ GeometricAverageGrowthRate=102%
Aswath Damodaran
161
![Page 4: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
162
ExtrapolationanditsDangers
Year NetProfit1996 $122.301997 $247.051998 $499.031999 $1,008.052000 $2,036.252001 $4,113.23¨ Ifnetprofitcontinuestogrowatthesamerateasithasinthepast6years,theexpectednetincomein5yearswillbe$4.113billion.
Aswath Damodaran
162
![Page 5: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
AnalystEstimates
GrowthII163
Aswath Damodaran
![Page 6: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
164
AnalystForecastsofGrowth
¨ Whilethejobofananalystistofindunderandovervaluedstocksinthesectorsthattheyfollow,asignificantproportionofananalyst’stime(outsideofselling)isspentforecastingearningspershare.¤ Mostofthistime,inturn,isspentforecastingearningspershareinthenextearningsreport
¤ Whilemanyanalystsforecastexpectedgrowthinearningspershareoverthenext5years,theanalysisandinformation(generally)thatgoesintothisestimateisfarmorelimited.
¨ AnalystforecastsofearningspershareandexpectedgrowtharewidelydisseminatedbyservicessuchasZacksandIBES,atleastforU.Scompanies.
Aswath Damodaran
164
![Page 7: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
165
Howgoodareanalystsatforecastinggrowth?
¨ AnalystsforecastsofEPStendtobeclosertotheactualEPSthansimpletimeseriesmodels,butthedifferencestendtobesmall
Study Grouptested Analyst TimeSeriesError ModelError
Collins&HopwoodValueLineForecasts 31.7% 34.1%Brown&Rozeff ValueLineForecasts 28.4% 32.2%Fried&Givoly EarningsForecaster 16.4% 19.8%¨ Theadvantagethatanalystshaveovertimeseriesmodels
¤ tendstodecreasewiththeforecastperiod(nextquarterversus5years)¤ tendstobegreaterforlargerfirmsthanforsmallerfirms¤ tendstobegreaterattheindustrylevelthanatthecompanylevel
¨ Forecastsofgrowth(andrevisionsthereof)tendtobehighlycorrelatedacrossanalysts.
Aswath Damodaran
165
![Page 8: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
166
Aresomeanalystsmoreequalthanothers?
¨ AstudyofAll-AmericaAnalysts(chosenbyInstitutionalInvestor)foundthat¤ ThereisnoevidencethatanalystswhoarechosenfortheAll-America
Analystteamwerechosenbecausetheywerebetterforecastersofearnings.(Theirmedianforecasterrorinthequarterpriortobeingchosenwas30%;themedianforecasterrorofotheranalystswas28%)
¤ However,inthecalendaryearfollowingbeingchosenasAll-Americaanalysts,theseanalystsbecomeslightlybetterforecastersthantheirlessfortunatebrethren.(ThemedianforecasterrorforAll-Americaanalystsis2%lowerthanthemedianforecasterrorforotheranalysts)
¤ EarningsrevisionsmadebyAll-Americaanalyststendtohaveamuchgreaterimpactonthestockpricethanrevisionsfromotheranalysts
¤ TherecommendationsmadebytheAllAmericaanalystshaveagreaterimpactonstockprices(3%onbuys;4.7%onsells).Fortheserecommendationsthepricechangesaresustained,andtheycontinuetoriseinthefollowingperiod(2.4%forbuys;13.8%forthesells).
Aswath Damodaran
166
![Page 9: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
167
TheFiveDeadlySinsofanAnalyst
¨ TunnelVision:Becomingsofocusedonthesectorandvaluationswithinthesectorthatyoulosesightofthebiggerpicture.
¨ Lemmingitis:Strongurgefelttochangerecommendations&reviseearningsestimateswhenotheranalystsdothesame.
¨ StockholmSyndrome:Referstoanalystswhostartidentifyingwiththemanagersofthefirmsthattheyaresupposedtofollow.
¨ Factophobia (generallyiscoupledwithdelusionsofbeingafamousstoryteller):Tendencytobasearecommendationona“story” coupledwitharefusaltofacethefacts.
¨ Dr.Jekyll/Mr.Hyde:Analystwhothinkshisprimaryjobistobringininvestmentbankingbusinesstothefirm.
Aswath Damodaran
167
![Page 10: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
168
PropositionsaboutAnalystGrowthRates
¨ Proposition1:Thereiffarlessprivateinformationandfarmorepublicinformationinmostanalystforecaststhanisgenerallyclaimed.
¨ Proposition2:Thebiggestsourceofprivateinformationforanalystsremainsthecompanyitselfwhichmightexplain¤ whytherearemorebuyrecommendationsthansellrecommendations
(informationbiasandtheneedtopreservesources)¤ whythereissuchahighcorrelationacrossanalystsforecastsandrevisions¤ whyAll-Americaanalystsbecomebetterforecastersthanotheranalysts
aftertheyarechosentobepartoftheteam.¨ Proposition3:Thereisvaluetoknowingwhatanalystsare
forecastingasearningsgrowthforafirm.Thereis,however,dangerwhentheyagreetoomuch(lemmingitis)andwhentheyagreetolittle(inwhichcasetheinformationthattheyhaveissonoisyastobeuseless).
Aswath Damodaran
168
![Page 11: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
It’sallinthefundamentals
GrowthIII169
Aswath Damodaran
![Page 12: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
170
FundamentalGrowthRates
Investmentin ExistingProjects$ 1000
Current Return onInvestment on Projects12%
X = CurrentEarnings$120
Investmentin ExistingProjects$1000
Next Periodʼs Return onInvestment12%
XInvestmentin NewProjects$100
Return onInvestment onNew Projects12%
X+ = Next PeriodʼsEarnings132
Investmentin ExistingProjects$1000
Change inROI from current to nextperiod: 0%
XInvestmentin NewProjects$100
Return onInvestment onNew Projects12%
X+ Change in Earnings$ 12=
Aswath Damodaran
170
![Page 13: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
171
GrowthRateDerivations
In the special case where ROI on existing projects remains unchanged and is equal to the ROI on new projects
Investment in New ProjectsCurrent Earnings
Return on Investment Change in EarningsCurrent Earnings=X
Reinvestment Rate X Return on Investment = Growth Rate in Earnings
in the more general case where ROI can change from period to period, this can be expanded as follows:
Investment in Existing Projects*(Change in ROI) + New Projects (ROI)Investment in Existing Projects* Current ROI
Change in EarningsCurrent Earnings=
100120 X 12% = $12
$120
For instance, if the ROI increases from 12% to 13%, the expected growth rate can be written as follows:
83.33% X 12% = 10%
$1,000 * (.13 - .12) + 100 (13%)$ 1000 * .12
$23$120= = 19.17%
Aswath Damodaran
171
![Page 14: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
172
EstimatingFundamentalGrowthfromnewinvestments:Threevariations
EarningsMeasure ReinvestmentMeasure ReturnMeasureEarningspershare RetentionRatio=%ofnet
incomeretainedbythecompany=1– Payoutratio
ReturnonEquity=NetIncome/BookValueofEquity
NetIncomefromnon-cashassets
EquityreinvestmentRate=(NetCapEx+Changeinnon-cashWC– ChangeinDebt)/(NetIncome)
Non-cashROE=NetIncomefromnon-cashassets/(Bookvalueofequity– Cash)
OperatingIncome ReinvestmentRate=(NetCapEx+Changeinnon-cashWC)/After-taxOperatingIncome
ReturnonCapitalorROIC=After-taxOperatingIncome/(Bookvalueofequity+Bookvalueofdebt– Cash)
Aswath Damodaran
172
![Page 15: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
173
I.ExpectedLongTermGrowthinEPS
¨ Whenlookingatgrowthinearningspershare,theseinputscanbecastasfollows:¤ ReinvestmentRate=RetainedEarnings/CurrentEarnings=Retention
Ratio¤ ReturnonInvestment=ROE=NetIncome/BookValueofEquity
¨ InthespecialcasewherethecurrentROEisexpectedtoremainunchanged
gEPS =RetainedEarningst-1/NIt-1 *ROE=RetentionRatio*ROE=b*ROE
¨ Proposition1:Theexpectedgrowthrateinearningsforacompanycannotexceeditsreturnonequityinthelongterm.
Aswath Damodaran
173
![Page 16: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
174
EstimatingExpectedGrowthinEPS:WellsFargoin2008
¨ Returnonequity(basedon2008earnings)=17.56%¨ RetentionRatio(basedon2008earningsanddividends)=45.37%
¨ ExpectedgrowthrateinearningspershareforWellsFargo,ifitcanmaintainthesenumbers.ExpectedGrowthRate=0.4537(17.56%)=7.97%
Aswath Damodaran
174
![Page 17: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
175
RegulatoryEffectsonExpectedEPSgrowth
¨ Assumenowthatthebankingcrisisof2008willhaveanimpactonthecapitalratiosandprofitabilityofbanks.Inparticular,youcanexpectthatthebookcapital(equity)neededbybankstodobusinesswillincrease30%,startingnow.
¨ AssumingthatWellscontinueswithitsexistingbusinesses,estimatetheexpectedgrowthrateinearningspershareforthefuture.
NewReturnonEquity=Expectedgrowthrate=
Aswath Damodaran
175
![Page 18: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
176
OnewaytopumpupROE:Usemoredebt
ROE=ROC+D/E(ROC- i (1-t))where,
ROC=EBITt (1- taxrate)/BookvalueofCapitalt-1D/E=BVofDebt/BVofEquityi =InterestExpenseonDebt/BVofDebtt=Taxrateonordinaryincome
¨ NotethatBookvalueofcapital=BookValueofDebt+BookvalueofEquity- Cash.
Aswath Damodaran
176
![Page 19: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
177
DecomposingROE:Brahmain1998
¨ Brahma(nowAmbev)hadanextremelyhighreturnonequity,partlybecauseitborrowedmoneyataratewellbelowitsreturnoncapital¤ ReturnonCapital=19.91%¤ Debt/EquityRatio=77%¤ After-taxCostofDebt=5.61%¤ ReturnonEquity=ROC+D/E(ROC- i(1-t))
=19.91%+0.77(19.91%- 5.61%)=30.92%
¨ Thisseemslikeaneasywaytodeliverhighergrowthinearningspershare.What(ifany)isthedownside?
Aswath Damodaran
177
![Page 20: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
178
DecomposingROE:TitanWatches(India)in2000
¨ ReturnonCapital=9.54%¨ Debt/EquityRatio=191%(bookvalueterms)¨ After-taxCostofDebt=10.125%¨ ReturnonEquity=ROC+D/E(ROC- i(1-t))
=9.54%+1.91(9.54%- 10.125%)=8.42%
Aswath Damodaran
178
![Page 21: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
179
II.ExpectedGrowthinNetIncomefromnon-cashassets
¨ ThelimitationoftheEPSfundamentalgrowthequationisthatitfocusesonpershareearningsandassumesthatreinvestedearningsareinvestedinprojectsearningthereturnonequity.Totheextentthatcompaniesretainmoneyincashbalances,theeffectonnetincomecanbemuted.
¨ Amoregeneralversionofexpectedgrowthinearningscanbeobtainedbysubstitutingintheequityreinvestmentintorealinvestments(netcapitalexpendituresandworkingcapital)andmodifyingthereturnonequitydefinitiontoexcludecash:¤ NetIncomefromnon-cashassets=Netincome– Interestincomefrom
cash(1- t)¤ EquityReinvestmentRate=(NetCapitalExpenditures+ChangeinWorking
Capital)(1- DebtRatio)/NetIncomefromnon-cashassets¤ Non-cashROE=NetIncomefromnon-cashassets/(BVofEquity– Cash)¤ ExpectedGrowthNetIncome =EquityReinvestmentRate*Non-cashROE
Aswath Damodaran
179
![Page 22: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
180
Estimatingexpectedgrowthinnetincomefromnon-cashassets:CocaColain2010
¨ In2010,CocaColareportednetincomeof$11,809million.Ithadatotalbookvalueofequityof$25,346millionattheendof2009.
¨ CocaColahadacashbalanceof$7,021millionattheendof2009,onwhichitearnedincomeof$105millionin2010.
¨ CocaColahadcapitalexpendituresof$2,215million,depreciationof$1,443millionandreportedanincreaseinworkingcapitalof$335million.CocaCola’stotaldebtincreasedby$150millionduring2010.¤ EquityReinvestment=2215- 1443+335-150=$957million¤ Non-cashNetIncome=$11,809- $105=$11,704million¤ Non-cashbookequity=$25,346- $7021=$18,325million¤ ReinvestmentRate=$957million/$11,704million=8.18%¤ Non-cashROE=$11,704million/$18,325million=63.87%¤ Expectedgrowthrate=8.18%*63.87%=5.22%
Aswath Damodaran
180
![Page 23: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
181
III.ExpectedGrowthinEBITAndFundamentals:StableROCandReinvestmentRate
¨ Whenlookingatgrowthinoperatingincome,thedefinitionsare¤ ReinvestmentRate=(NetCapitalExpenditures+ChangeinWC)/EBIT(1-t)
¤ ReturnonInvestment=ROC=EBIT(1-t)/(BVofDebt+BVofEquity-Cash)
¨ ReinvestmentRateandReturnonCapitalExpectedGrowthrateinOperatingIncome=(NetCapitalExpenditures+ChangeinWC)/EBIT(1-t)*ROC=ReinvestmentRate*ROC
¨ Proposition:Thenetcapitalexpenditureneedsofafirm,foragivengrowthrate,shouldbeinverselyproportionaltothequalityofitsinvestments.
Aswath Damodaran
181
![Page 24: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
182
EstimatingGrowthinOperatingIncome,iffundamentalsstayunchanged¨ Cisco’sFundamentals
¤ ReinvestmentRate=106.81%¤ ReturnonCapital=34.07%¤ ExpectedGrowthinEBIT=(1.0681)(.3407)=36.39%
¨ Motorola’sFundamentals¤ ReinvestmentRate=52.99%¤ ReturnonCapital=12.18%¤ ExpectedGrowthinEBIT=(.5299)(.1218)=6.45%
¨ Cisco’sexpectedgrowthrateisclearlymuchhigherthanMotorola’ssustainablegrowthrate.AsapotentialinvestorinCisco,whatwouldworryyouthemostaboutthisforecast?a. ThatCisco’sreturnoncapitalmaybeoverstated(why?)b. ThatCisco’sreinvestmentcomesmostlyfromacquisitions(why?)c. ThatCiscoisgettingbiggerasafirm(why?)d. ThatCiscoisviewedasastar(why?)e. Alloftheabove
Aswath Damodaran
182
![Page 25: A Test - New York Universitypeople.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/podcasts/valUGspr17/... · 2017-02-22 · ¨ A study of All-America Analysts (chosen by Institutional ... In the special](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042210/5eaed4c89794aa74d7206f5a/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
183
TheMagicalNumber:ROIC(oranyaccountingreturn)anditslimits
Aswath Damodaran
183