a tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · unité de recherche inria sophia...

32
HAL Id: inria-00070781 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070781 Submitted on 19 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, Tatiana Kozubskaya To cite this version: Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, Tatiana Kozubskaya. A tetrahedral- based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics. [Research Report] RR-5212, INRIA. 2004, pp.28. inria-00070781

Upload: others

Post on 26-Oct-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

HAL Id: inria-00070781https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070781

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme foraeroacoustics

Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, TatianaKozubskaya

To cite this version:Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, Tatiana Kozubskaya. A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics. [Research Report] RR-5212, INRIA. 2004, pp.28.�inria-00070781�

Page 2: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--52

12--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

Thème NUM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme foraeroacoustics

N. Gourvitch, G. Rogé, I. Abalakin, A. Dervieux, T. Kozubskaya

N° 5212

May 26, 2004

Page 3: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone
Page 4: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65

� ������������� ��������������������������������������� ��!���"�� #$�&%'����������������(�")*���

+-,/.1032"465�798;:'<"=?>@.A,"BC03DFE?G'>"H',JI K"LFMNLPOQ7SRJT'>JIU,"V WX465�7SWX2QYJZ[>J\1,@]03^_2"K"`aOPL?b3L3c

dfehg6ikj�lnmporqts?uwvyxzg6ikjav�{?|hik}a~����X|hjav�J~z�[�yj*xns?i��_v�e

� �[�h�F��~�x �wj�~zja��ehja~z��ehj�{3�J���h����qto1�;u���h�������[��q��[��������j�v

����a 6¡'¢h£� �¤ ¥ j �wjavz�*~z�§¦Fj�¨{X|�i�ja~����6��©�vz��ehj6ikj�ª9�_~e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«���6v�¬�j6©«©��_�h�[�hx�ja�Uxz��¦F�[xze­�[ja~���®�huX{P�[ik�«�av��[{P�U��j6~z�_�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�av6¯Cdfe�j°v���ehjaikj��«v±�j6~�x�j6²U�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��(�Q³´x����h�h©«�§j�v�¬��§x�eAv�ja�*�_{��U��~��wj6~�_�6�6|h~z�_�*uUx��U|h{�v�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja�­x�j6x�~��[ehj��w~��«µa�[x��«��{�v��[{P�Aj*²?xzj6{��hv�xz�¶eh�§�_ehj6~k�_~z�wja~ ·S|h�¸x��¶v��§²?x�eP¹��_{���*j6~�xz���§{¶xyu?�FjC��ªn�6�[~�x�j�v����[{¶ikjav�ehj�v6¯-swj6±�ja~z��©@¦��_v����C��j6~z�_���6��|�v�x�����{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©/j6²w�Pja~��«ikj6{Xxzv��[~zj��~�j�v�ja{_xzja�(¯º1»X¼3½z¾¿ ¡'À���¤ÂÁ ja~��X���*�_|�v�x����6va�_{?|hikj6~z���6�[©(vz��ehj6ikj�v6�?e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«�«�Ãik�w�wj6©�v6�w©«�«{hja��~���v�j��CÄJ|�©§ja~�ja�X|��'®xz�§�_{�va�w|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j�� i�j�v�e�jav

Æ�ÇFÈ�ÉFÊ�Ë'ÌzÍSÎ�ÏyÐ*ÑyÒaÓ;Ñ/Ô�Õ;É�Ï�ÖØ×�Ï�Ù�Ë�ÎÅÎzÚ*ÛÅÛ�Ê3Ü'Ï�Ý�Þ;ÖSÍßÖNÓ;à9Í9á�Ï�àSÒ;ÑÅË;â'àØÏ�Ò;×yÑãJä Ï�ÖNÖNÏ�Ó;Ù åØÍ�æ?Ð�çèÏzåØçêéÅÒXË�Î�ë�ì�Ó;Ï�ç?á�Ï�àS×�ÑyÙ ä Ï�ÖØÖ´Ï�Ó;Ù å�Ë'íÅîÅî�ïyÚnðaÏ�çêÒ6åSÍSÊ3ÙêéÅÓ;ñXË�â'àNÏ�Ò;×yÑò"ó á�á�Ë'áôçêÓ;ÖØõ�Ï�ö6Ï�ÖN÷[ÕêË;Ú*Ï�Ë'áôéÅÖØ×yé�øùï�îÅÛÅú�Ú6ÎaË�ûüÓ;ÖNÖØçèÏý ó È�û ó æ�Ë[îÅúÅú�Ú�ûüéÅÓ�åØÑ@ñ;ÑyÖ�þ?Ó�×�çêéÅÙêÑyÖ�Ë'Ô(ÉwÕ[íÅÿ�Ë'úÅÌÅíÅúÅî ðaéÅÞ�Ü;çèÏzÍßæ�Ò*åØçêÞ�éÅÙêçêÖ�Ë;â'àØÏ�Ò;×yÑ� ó á�á�Ë'áôçêÓ;ÖØõ�Ï�ö6Ï�ÖN÷[ÕêË;Ú*Ï�Ë'áôéÅÖØ×yé�øùï�îÅÛÅú�Ú6ÎaË�ûüÓ;ÖNÖØçèÏ

Page 5: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ���J��� #$� � �������������������� ����������������������� ��!�-���������������������C�ü��)����

�� �� �� � ¤ � j ~��[�h�F��~�xk�h}a�*~z�§xk|�{¸vz��eh}6i��U{?|hik}6~z�«�X|hj ¦h�«j6{ �����[�wxz}��U©�� ��}6~z�?�huX{P�[ik�«�X|hj j*x�A©�� �[}a~��X���*�_|�v�x����_|�j�¯ � j-v���eh}ai��ùjav�x�*ja{Xx�~z}�v��_iki�j6xCj*x�h~�}��*��vC��| v�j��*��{P� �_~z�h~�j¨v�|h~�hjav�xzj*®xz~z��}a�w~z��v��[x��«��{�v�{���{w® vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�}ajav�j6xp��� |h{��_~z�h~�j���©§|�vÃ}6©«j6±_}C·ê�y|Pv��X|�� �Cv�� ²�¹nv�|h~p|h{��6j6~�xz���§{1xyu?�Fj��wjxz}*xz~z��}a�w~z�«vz�'xz�§�_{�6��~�xz}av��§ja{h{hj_¯��Ã|hja©«�X|hj�v�j*²w�P}a~�ja{��*j�v"{?|hik}6~z�«�X|hj�v��hj�¦���v�j�ja{��[}6~z�_�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�X|hj�v��_{Xx��~�}�v�ja{_xz}6j�v6¯� ¿  �� ½ £�� � ��¤ Á }6~z�_�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�X|hj_��v���e�}6i���vJ{?|hik}a~����X|hjava�_ik�w�wga©§j�v/e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«���_|�java�_ÄJ|h©«j6~�©«�§{h}��[~z�«v�}��i����§©«©«����j�v�{���{w® vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�}�v

Page 6: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� '

( ) �������� �C�/��)*���

dfe��«vÃ���[�Fj6~px���*�j�v �h©����6j��«{Xx�� �C~zjav�ja��~z��e �h~z���_~z��i�ikj���§ik�«{h��[xp��~��_�P�Xv��«{h�°{?|hikj6~z���6�[©"vz��ehj6ikjavja{h��|���e ���h���wx�j��°xz��¦F�[xze1���*�_|�v�x����Ãik�w�wja©«v���{�� �*��ik�Fj6~�v�v��«¦h©§j,+�|h��� ik�?�hj6©�v6¯³´x��«v�§{­�6��{h{�ja�Åxz�§�_{Ux����¨v�j6~z�«jav���ªf¬���~*wvôª9�w�*|�v��«{h�1��{¶xzehjC{?|hikj6~z���6�[©�v��«i|h©��'xz�§�_{ù�[ªfx�|�~�¦h|�©§ja{_x+P�'¬ v�¬��§x�e�v�ja�6��{��?®´��~��wja~�vz��ehj6ikj�vJ�[�h�h©«u?�§{��Ã�_{�|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja��ikjav�ehj�v6�[j��X|h�§���Pj���¬��§x�ek�p±�ja~�u�©«�'¬�h�«vzv��«���[x��«±�jÃx�j6~zi ��v�j6j.- �_�0/´�1-ê�[��/´�2- �h��/´¯dfe�j{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©"v��«i|�©«�[x��«��{¨��ª@x�ehj��h~z�������_�[x��«��{ �[ª��_�*�_|�vyxz�«�¬��;±_jav�¬��§x�e43�~�vyx�®N�_~z�wja~n����~�xz�«��©��h� ªß®ª9ja~�ja{Xx����[©3ja�X|��[x��«��{�v��[ª�e?uX�Fj6~z¦F��©«�«�Ãxyu?�Pjôe��_v��[{ �§ik�F��~�xz��{_xf�«i��P���Åx��_{ ���§~��*~��'ªßx��wjav��«��{ü�5-«�76�/´�h�[{P��«{?±��_©§±_javp� �h�98°�*|�© x���h�h~z�;²?�«i��'xz�§�_{¨�h~z��¦h©«j6i ¯�� �'xzehj6~�v��«i���©§j�v�ja�*�_{��?®´��~��wj6~ô���a�*|h~��'xzj�ikj6x�eh�w�hveP�;±�j�¦Fj6j6{-i|���e1|Pv�j��¨�[{����[�h�h~zja�6�«�[x�j��Cª9�_~Ãja©§©«�«�wx������h~z��¦�©§jaikva¯ ³ {��6��{Xx�~���v�xa��ª9��~:3�~zv�x�®´��~��wja~ e?u_®�Fj6~z¦F��©«�«�av6�@{��[xk��{h©«u¶x�ehj1�wja~��«±'�'xz�§�_{A�[ªp��j6{?|h�«{hja©§uùv�ja�*�_{��A�_~z�hj6~�i�j6x�eh�w�hv�e��_vk�*�_v�x�j��­�-©§��x���ªj�;F�_~�x�v6��¦h|wxp��©«v����§xÃv�jaj6i�v�xze��'xÃi��Xvyx ��ª@v�j��*��{P�?®N�_~z�hj6~�ikj*xzeh�w�hv·Ø�[{�� ja±�j6{ ik�_v�xn��ª�xzeh�«~z�?®´��~��wja~�_{hjav�¹��[~zj�x��?���w�«vzv��§���[x��«±�j�x�����©§©«�'¬Aj�8°�6�§ja{_x@ja{h��|���ek���6�6|h~��'x�jf�*�_ik�h|wxz�[x��«��{�v"��ª3�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�av�ª9��~J~zja�[©©«�§ª9j��h~��_¦h©«j6i�v6¯swj6±�ja~z��©w���?�w��eh�§�_e���~��wj6~@vz��ehjai�j�v@�[~zj�{h�'¬ �;±'�[�«©«��¦h©§jfª9�_~@~zj6��|�©«��~Ji�j�v�e�jav ·Øv�jaj��_ª9��~@j6²w��ik�h©§j_�<-«��/9¹Å¯dfe�j6u°�[~zjô�wj6~z�§±_ja�°ª9~��_i v���ehjaikjav�¬�� xze ©§�'¬ �h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ü�w�'x�©«ja�_vyx�ª9��|h~�x�eh®N�_~z�wja~��_�6�6|h~z�[x�j_�X�_~�¬��§x�e�k�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{{��[x�©«��~��_j6~�x�eP�[{ x�ehj��h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ �[�h�h©«�«ja��§{ ª9��|�~�xzew®N�_~z�hj6~����a�*|h~��'xzjpvz��ehj6ikj�v6¯dfe�jô�a��v�jn��ª�~zj6��|�©«��~�ikjav�ehj�v���v���~�ja©«�[x��«±�j6©«ukja�_v��«j6~f��{�j�¯ ¥ j��a�[{C|�{��wj6~�v�xz�[{P�°xzeh�«vf�§ª�¬�jô�*��{Pv����wj6~xzehjfv��«ik�h©§�13�j����a��v�j/�[ªF���w±_ja�Åxz�§�_{�¬��§x�e��6��{�v�xz��{Xx�±�ja©§�w�6� xyu_¯Q³ {�xze��'x@�a��v�j��03�{��w�«{h�ô�n�_�?�?����w±_ja�Åxz�§�_{vz��ehjai�jf��vJjavzv�j6{Xx����[©«©§u=3P{��w�«{h���[{��§{Xxzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{kv���ehjaikj�¯�³ {�xzehj �6�_v�jf��ªF� � ��|�~z��{_x"{?|hi¦Fj6~Jj��X|��[©xz�?>A@«��v���ikj�v���ehjaikjav �a�[{ j6±_j6{ ¦Pj�j6²h���Åx�¯CBh|�~�xzehj6~��h~zj6��|�©«��~�ikj�v�ehj�v �[~zjô���[~�x����*|�©«��~�©«u�ªS�;±��_|h~��[¦h©«jxz�kx�ehj��wj6~z�§±'�[x��«��{ �[ªJeh�«��ew®´��~��wja~ ���6�6|h~��'x�j�vz��ehj6ikj�vfx�e��[xÃ�*�Xvyxn�k~��'xzehj6~Ãv�i��[©«©ü{?|hi�¦Pja~n�[ª"���Fj6~��'®xz�§�_{�v�ª9��~fxzehj6�«~n�_v�v�j6i�¦h©§u_¯dfe�jô�a��v�jô�[ª"|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��Cikj�v�ehj�v�~zj6�h~zjav�j6{Xxzv�xzehj�i��'²w�§i���©ü�w�98°�6|h© xyu_¯$B��§~�vyx��hikjav�e�«~z~�ja��|h©��[~z� xyu��ik�h©§�13�j�vp�h�«v��Pja~zv��«��{���ehj6{h�_ikj6{���¯�s?j��*��{P�w©§u_�üi��[{?u1|�v�j*ª9|h©J{?|hikja~����6��©�ikj6x�eh�w�hv��w� {h��xôj6²?x�j6{P�j���v��§©«u ·ßxz~z�_�w� xz�§�_{��[©��6��ik�����*xkvz��ehjai�j�v6�/ª9��~kj*²h��i���©§j;¹�xz��xzehj�Dy|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja��E �6�_v�j_¯­dQ�w�h�;uùj�vy®v�j6{Xxz�«��©§©«uCxy¬��°ªS��ik�§©«�§j�vn��ª�vz��ehj6ikjavnj6{'�y�'u eh�«��eh®N�_~z�wja~ �[ª����6�6|h~����*u_�P�6��{�v�j6~z±'�'x��«��{1��~��_�Pja~�xz�§j�vn�[{P��h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{A�_{hjava�Jx�e�j �_�h�[�wx��'xz�§�_{A�[ªÃÄ/lGFn®NxyuX�Fj v���ehjaikjavx��U|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��Aikjav�ehj�v ·H- ��/ß¹*�/�[{P�xzehjJIÃ�«vz�*�_{Xx��«{X|���|�v�®LKô��©§ja~�*?�«{-ikj6x�eh�w� ·H- ' /9¹Å¯NM�|wx�x�ehj�v�j°xy¬�� ªS��i��«©«�§j�v��[ª vz��ehj6ikj�v��[~zj°���a�*|h~��'xzjja{h��|���e ��{h©«uC�§ªJx�e�j6u �[~zj��[ª"ª9��|h~�x�e �_~z�wja~a¯�³ { x�eP�'xn©���v�xn�6�_v�j_�hx�e�j6u �*��{Pv�|hikj���©��[~z��j��6��ik�h|wxz�§{h�j�;F�_~�x�ª9��~�ja�_��e°|h{O*?{h�'¬�{ü�w��{���xzehj6u��[~zjnj�8°�*�«j6{Xx��_{h©«u�¬�e�j6{Cja{h��|���e°{h�w�wj�vf�[~zjn|�v�ja�°��{��C�±�ja~�uv�i��[©«©(j6~z~��_~f�«v��wjai��[{��wj��(¯B�~��_i x�ehj�v�jp~�jai��[~*?v�¬�jÃ�6��{�wja~��«±�jnx�ehjpª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{��~zja�*�_ikik��{��h�[x��«��{�v@ª9��~�|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��°ikjav�ehj�v�P®n·S��¹�¦�|h�§©��1v�ja�*�_{��?®´��~��wj6~fvz��ehj6ikjav�xze��'x �«{?±���©«±�jô��v�ª9ja¬ �h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ ��v��w�keh�«��ew®´��~��wja~fvz��ehjai�j�v6�®�·9�«��¹@ja�X|h�«�kx�ehjnv�ja�6��{��w®N�_~z�wja~Jv���ehjaikj��[ªüv�|��Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6j��h~z���Fj6~�x��«jav@��{��6��~�xzjav��«��{�ikj�v�ehj�v@�[{P�|Pv�j���vf��ªßx�ja{ �_vf�P�Xv�v��«¦h©§j��a�[~�x�jav����[{Cikj�v�eh�«{h�k�[ªJv�|h¦h~zj6���«��{Pv���ªQxzehj��*�_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���©ü�w��i��[�«{ü¯M�u�v�|h�Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6j��h~z���Fj6~�x��«jav�¬�jpikja�[{°x�e��[x�xzehjôv���ehjaikjÃ�[���h©§�«jav�xz���[~z¦h�§x�~��[~zu�|�{�vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j��ikj�v�ehj�v�¦h|wx �«{~zj6�_�§�_{C¬�ehja~�jÃx�ehjôikjav�e �«v��a�[~�x�jav����[{ü�Xx�e�jÃxz~�|�{��6�[x��«��{Cja~�~z��~���v�v�i��[©«©«j6~f¦?uCv�ja±�ja~z��©�_~z�hj6~�v��[ª i�����{h�§x�|��hj�¯ Á v�ªS�[~���v ·9�ß¹���vk�*��{P�*j6~z{hj��(�"¬�jj6ik�he��_v��«µ6jCx�e��[xx�e�jCx���v�*U��v��*��ik�h©«j*²(¯³ {P�wj6j��(�ü�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{-v�eh�_|h©��¨��;3j6~ô� �*��ik�Fj6{�vz�'xz�§�_{1x�� �w��v��Fj6~�v��§�_{¨�§{-x�e�j�v�j6{�v�j�xze��'x�j6²w�6javzv��«±�ja©§u�h�«v��Pja~zv�ja�Ceh�«��e°ª9~zja�X|hja{��*�«javfv�eh��|�©«�C¦Pj��h��i��Fja��«{�_~z�wja~/xz���;±��������Xv��6�§©«©«�[x��«��{�v��[{P�°©��[~z��jnja~�~z��~�va¯dfe�jp¦P�[©��[{��6jÃ��v���j6{�j6~��[©«©§u��_¦wxz���§{hj��°¦?uC��eh�?�Xv��«{h�e��§�_ew®N�_~z�hj6~f���6�6|h~����*u_¯RQn�'¬�ja±�ja~a�X�§{x�e�jô�hj6~z�§±'�'®

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 7: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

xz�§�_{A�[ª�xzehj In��v��Fj6~�v��§�_{­��j6©��'xz�§�_{A�J~zjav�j6~z±X�«{h�­·�IÃ�n�/¹�v���ehjaikj��@d��[i �[{��­�*�[®´¬���~*�j6~�vp�h~zj*ª9j6~�x���_�wx��«ik�§µajpx�ehj�vz��ehj6ikjpª9��~�©«�'¬ ��e���v�jôj6~z~��_~�¦Fj*x�x�ja~�x�e���{ *_j6ja�h�§{��k�_�6�6|h~z�_�*u¨·H-§��/ß¹*¯

³ {�-«����/N�'��ªS��ik�§©«uÃ��ªh±�ja~�xzj*²?®´�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��n|��X¬��«{�����j6~z�_�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�"vz��ehj6ikjavQ�[�h�h©«u?�§{���x��nx�j*xz~z��ehja�h~��«µa�[®xz�§�_{�v��[{P���~�j�v�ja{_xz�§{��kv�|h�Fj6~��*�_{X±_j6~z��ja{��*jÃ�h~��_�Pja~�xz�§j�vf¬��_vf�§{Xxz~��w�w|��6ja�(¯@dfe��«v vz��ehjai�jô��v �[©�v���|Pv�j���«{1v�ja±�ja~z��©P¬���~*wvp·H-§����/�-§���7/�-§�a��/ -«����/ß¹fdfehj���~�j�v�ja{_xf~zj6�F��~�xf��~��_�P�Xv�j�v�� ' I�j*²?x�ja{�v��§�_{��ª��§xa¯

³´x ¬��«©§©Qe��;±�jÃx�ehjôª9�_©§©«�'¬��«{h�k�h~��_�Pja~�xz�§j�v�P·S��¹�xzehj�vz��ehj6ikjô�«vn�*��{Pv�ja~�±'�'xz�§±_j��·S�§�ß¹�x�e�j��w�«vzv��§���[x��«��{ü�w¬�e�j6{ |�v�ja�(�w��v �wja~��«±�j��°ª9~z��i v��§²Xxzew®´��~��wj6~��wja~��«±'�'x��«±�j�v6�·S�§�«�ß¹fx�e�j�vz��ehj6ikj���v 3�ªßx�ew®´��~��wj6~n¬�� xze��w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{¨��{��¨v�� ²?xzew®N�_~z�hj6~ ���a�*|h~��'xzj�¬��§x�eh�_|wxp�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{¬�e�j6{ � xn��v��[���h©§�«ja�Cx��°������~�xz�«�6|h©��[~��6��~�xzjav��«��{Cikjav�eü¯

� � ��� � )6�Q��)*� �ô��)*�������C�����/��)6�� ���"�� #$����� (��mn�?¬��§{�� vz��ehj6ikj�vk�[ª Kp�?�h|h{h�'±Axyu?�Fj1j6{'�y�'u �¶©§��x°�[ªô�§{Xx�ja~�j�vyxz�§{��¶�X|���©§�§x��«jav��h|hj x��¶xzehj¨�Fj6~�ª9ja�Åx�_�wja�X|��[x��«��{ �[ª"x�e�j�|h�?¬��§{��h�§{h�Ci�j���e��[{��«v�i xzehj6u�§{?±��_©§±_jô¬�� xze1|h{�v�x�ja�_�wuC¬f�;±�j�v6¯�m {wª9�_~�xz|h{��'xzj6©«u��xzehj°�[ik�_|h{Xx��[ª��w�«vzv��§���[x��«��{-x�ehjau-�6��{Xxz���§{¶v�jaj6i�v�i�|���e¶©«��~��_j6~px�e���{¶{hja�6javzv���~�u ª9�_~�[{¶���a�*|h~��'xzj{���{w®´�_vz�*�«©§©��'xz��~zu {X|�i�ja~����6��©@�[{�v�¬�j6~�¯ Á v�� �*�_{�v�ja�X|hj6{P�*j��Qx�ehj°�h��ik�§{P�[{Xx�x�ja~�i �[ª�x�ehj�{?|hikj6~z���6�[©ja~�~z��~���v �6��~�~z�§j��°¦?u�xzehj��w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{Q¯

¥ jv�|h���_jav�x�x���ª9��~z��j6x��[¦F��|wx�vyxz~����Åx�i��_{h�[xz��{?u¶�[{��Uxz����j6x�«{�v����§~zja�ù¦?u In�«~zja�Åx�s?�«i|h©��'xz�§�_{xzja��eh{��«�X|hj�v �«{1¬�eh�«��e1{���{w® �w��v�v��§�P�'x��«±�j�e��§�_e1��~��wj6~n���h�h~z�;²w�§i��'xz�§�_{�v��[~zj�v�xz�[¦��§©«�«v�ja� �«{1���?�w�1���a�*|w®~����6up�6��{��h� xz�§�_{�vüxze��[{<*?v�xz� 3�©§x�ja~zv�¬�eh����e�~zj6©«u���{�±_j6~zu_®´eh�«��e�ja±�j6{��~��wj6~��wj6~z�§±'�[x��«±�java¯ ¥ jfv�e���©§© 3�~�vyxv�eh�'¬ e��'¬ x�e��«v �a�[{ ¦Pj��h��{hj�¬��§x�e1����{hj6®´�h�§ikj6{Pv��«��{���©3eh�§�_ew®´��~��wj6~ o1mps � � ikj*x�e��?� ik�w�w�13�ja� �«{v�|���e �ki��[{h{hja~fx�e��[x�x�ehj��h��ik�§{P�[{Xxn�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{x�ja~�i!�«v���v��§²Xxzew®´��~��wj6~��wja~��«±'�'x��«±�j_¯J³ { x�ehj�©«�§{�ja�[~�a��v�j��?xzeh�«vf��v�j6²w�_�Åxz©§u�xzehj��*�_{�v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{C�[ª - ��/��[©�v���|Pv�j��C�«{ - ��/N¯

!�"$# %'&)(+*�,-(/.�#103254�%)687:9<;>=@?BA).$(+*C,$;>D� j*x�|�v 3P~zv�x �*��{Pv����wj6~fxzehjôx�e�j���{hj6®´�w�«ikj6{�v��«��{���©3�6��{?±�j��Åxz�§�_{Cja�X|��[x��«��{

EGFIHKJLELM8NPO ·y��¹

dfe�j,3P{h� xzj*®´±��_©§|hikjpikj*x�e��?���vf|�v�j��°ª9�_~�x�ehj�v����'xz�«��©3���h�h~z�;²w�§i��'xz�§�_{ü¯+QCR��5>TS�UVSXW �hj6{h��x�jpx�ehj�h�«vz�*~zj*xz�§µ��'x��«��{ �F���«{_x�v��[ª�x�e�j�ikjav�eü¯ B���~�ja�_��e1�w�«vz�*~zj*xz�§µ��'xz�§�_{�F���«{Xxa�h¬�j�vyx��'xzj&P E RZY E+[ Q R�\ �[{P�¬�j��wj�3P{hjôx�ehj��6��{Xx�~z��©3±_��©«|hikjT]^R���v�xzehj��§{Xxzj6~z±;��©>_ Q Ra`cbd�e Q R<fgbdih ¬�ehj6~zjIQ R<fIbd N

QCR H QCR<fkjl ¯

� j*xnm Npo�E R�q x�ehjk|h{<*X{��'¬�{-±_ja�Åxz��~p¬�eh�_v�jk�*��ik�F��{hja{Xxzvô�[~zj����h�h~z�;²w�§i��'xz�§{���x�ehj�ª9|h{P�Åx��«��{E+[ Q \ �«{°j�����e�{h�w�wj�U��[ª(x�e�jnikjav�eü¯ ¥ jn¦h|h�«©���x�e�jn±�j��Åxz��~'r [ m \ �_�6�6��~��w�§{���x���v����[x����[©F�[�h�h~z�;²w�§i��[®xz�§�_{��ª [ts+[uE \$\ M �h¬�eh����e �6�[{ ¦Fj�¬�~��§x�xzj6{1��v=P

rcR [ m \ N >v Q [xw R<f bdzy w Ra` bd \�{ w R<f bd N|wg[uE R<f bdi} e E R<f bd�~ \ ·Ø��¹

ó È�û ó æ

Page 8: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �

sh��ehj6ikjav � � ��� ��� � ¡;À » ¡� � ��� ' � � '� � ��� ' ®n��'� � �' � ��� ' � ®n��'� �� � ��� ' ®n���w�a� ®n��?��� �� � ��� ' ®n���w�a� ®n��?��� �

d��[¦h©«jk�AP Á �a�*|h~����6u��[ªJ�w�9;3j6~zj6{Xx�±�ja~zv��«��{�v��[ª�x�ehj�{�j6¬ v���ehjaikjp�«{¶�7I��a��v�j

¬�ehja~�j E R� bd�� �hj6{h��x�jôx�e�j�±;��©§|�jav���ª E �[x ¦P�_|h{��h��~��«javf��ª"�6��{Xx�~z��©(±_��©«|hikjT]^R�¬��§x�e wg[uE e� \ N�� _ [ > y ��������� [ J \$\ EKH [ > y ��������� [ J \ \ >h ¯Á �a�*��~��w�«{h�ôx��x�ehjôo1mÃs � � ikj*xzeh�w�w��©«���_u· - ��/9¹Å�_x�e�jn©«j*ªßx��[{��k~z�§�_eXx��*�_{_xz~��_©h±��_©§|�i�jn¦P�_|h{��h��~�uv�xz�[x�j�v E R� bd � ��v�¦h|��§©§x |�v��§{h�k©«�§{�ja�[~��«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{Cª9�_~�i�|h©«�_vGP

E R<f bd } N E R H j� v E R<f bd } { E R<f bd ~ N E R<f j y

j� v E R<f bd ~E Ra` bdi} N E Ra` j H j

� v E Ra` bd�} { E Ra` bd�~ N E R yj� v E Ra` bd�~

· ' ¹

¬�ehj6~zj v E R�zbd � �[~zjôv�©«���Fjava�w�د j�¯@���h�h~z�;²?�«i��'xz�§�_{�v/��ª��wja~��«±'�'xz�§±_jÃxzj6~zi�� E� Q¯

v E R<fzbd } N [ > y � \ [ E R<fkj y E R \ H � [ E R y E Ra`1j \ ·9�X¹v E R<f bd�~ N [ > y � \ [ E R<fkj y E R�\ H � [ E R<f � y E R<f j�\

·Ø��¹¬�e�j6~zj��@� �«v/|h�?¬��§{��h�§{h����[~��[ikj*xzj6~Jxze��'xf�*�_{_xz~��_©«vJx�ehjn�6��i�¦h�§{P�'x��«��{���ª3ª9|h©§©«uk|h�?¬��§{P���[{��°�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��v�©«���Fjava¯ B���~�� N >����xzehj�v���e�j6ikjô�«v�xzehj�vyx��[{����[~��°xzeh�§~����~��wj6~����a�*|h~��'xzj�v���ehjaikj�¯³ {­x�ehj �h~zjav�j6{Xxk±�ja~�xzj*²?®´�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��ù�*�_{_xzj*²?xa�/eh�§�_e­�_~z�wja~��_�6�6|h~z�_�*u¶��v�{��[xk��¦wx��[�«{hja�­¦XuA�-eh�«��ehja~�®�_~z�hj6~��§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{­¦h|hx°¦Xu �[{¸�§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{Axze��'x°�*�_ik�Pja{�v��[x�j�vxzehj1j6~z~z��~k�*��ik�«{h�-ª9~��_i x�ehj3P{��[©ü�6j6{Xx�~��[©ü�w�1;3j6~zj6{��6�§{h�k�«{ù·Ø��¹*¯@dfeh��vf¬�~��§x�j�v���v�ª9��©«©«�'¬ v�P

v E R<f bd } N [ > y � \ [uE R<f j y E R \ H � [uE R y E Ra` j \H � � [ y E Ra`1j H � E R y � E R<f j H E R<f � \ ·S�_¹H � � [ y E Ra` � H � E Ra` j y � E R H E R<f jk\v E R<f bd�~ N [ > y � \ [uE R<f j y E R\ H � [uE R<f � y E R<fkj\H � � [ y E Ra`1j H � E R y � E R<f j H E R<f � \ · �[¹H � � [ y E R H � E R<f j y � E R<f � H E R<f � \

¬�ehja~�j!�@�"�����{��#���U��~�j¨|��X¬��«{��w�«{h� ���[~��[ikj*xzj6~�v�xze��'x �*��{Xxz~��_© x�e�j-�*�_i¦h�«{��[x��«��{ �[ª�ª9|�©§©«u|��X¬��«{�� �[{P��6j6{Xx�ja~�j��v�©§�_�Pj�v6¯

¥ j���¦�v�j6~z±�jÃx�eP�'xnvz��ehj6ikjavf�wj�v��6~��«¦Fja� �§{¶·Ø�_¹f�[~zjô�§{ ��ja{hj6~��[©(v�ja�*�_{��?®´��~��wj6~f���a�*|h~��'xzjô¦h|wx�x�e�j6u¦Fja�6��ikj eh�«��eh®N�_~z�wja~@���a�*|h~��'xzjfª9��~�v���ikj�±'�[©«|hj�v@�[ª3xzehjn����~z��ikj*x�ja~zv$�/�%�?��� � �[{��&� � ¯ ¥ jn{h��x�j�xze��'xª9�_~'��� N O e � � N y >�(¬�jki��'²w�«ik�«v�j�x�ehj°�wja��~zj6jk�[ªf|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h��¯ Á ©«v���� 3hªßx�e¶��~��wja~����6�6|h~����*u

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 9: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

� ��� ��� ]�������� M�� ' � � �w¯ ' ����� ' ®n��'� � �h¯ê�[� '�� ' � ®n��'� ��¯ 'A' ��� ' ® ���w�a� ® ��?��� ��¯ ��� �

d��[¦�©§j¨��P1o1�[²?�«i��[© � ��|�~z��{_xk{?|hi¦Fj6~�v1·9j6²w�h©§���*�§x°����¶v���e�j6ikj�¹ª9��~�xzehj ª9��|h~��w�1;3j6~zj6{XxCv��P�'x����[©vz��ehjai�j�v�·y�0I��[{���©§uwv��«v�¹

��v��_¦wxz���§{hj��U¬�� xze¶��{ù���wj��_|P�'x�j���eh�_�«�6j��[ª�x�ehjkxzeh~zj6j°�*�?j�8��6�§ja{Xxzva¯JBh�_~�x�eh��v�©���v�x�6�_v�j_�Q¦h|wx�¬��§x�e� N O �?x�e�j6{ ¬�jô�_j*x ���*ja{_xz~z��© ® �w�1;Fja~�ja{��*j��Cv�� ²?xzew®N�_~z�hj6~f���6�6|h~��'x�j�vz��ehj6ikj_¯!�" ! ,$?�� (� �+(/D�� ,$D����*C(��g,$. ,x*��¥ j��6��{ �6��i�¦h�§{�jÃxzehj��[¦F�'±�jôvz��ehj6ikjô¬�� xze x�ehj�v�xz��{��h�[~�� ��|h{h�_j*®��ô|wx�x���xz�§ikj�_�w±'�[{��6�§{h�P¯

s?�«{��6j@x�e�j@�h|h~z�P�Xv�j/�«vüx��n�6��ik�h|wxzj@©§�«{hj��[~��_�*�_|�vyxz�«�av6�a¬�j��6�[{�v��«i���©§�§ª9upx�ehj/� |h{h��j6®��ô|hx�xz��vz��ehjai�jxz��x�ehj�©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j����_�[ikjav���{±'�[~z�«��{_x�·H- �7/9¹�¬�eh����e ¬�~��§x�j�v���v�ª9��©«©«�'¬ v�P

m����! N m�"m �$#% N m ���! H v'&

W y)( H > �+*tm �$# `1j -, e ( N >$@7@�@$Wm " f j N m �/.0

·S�_¹

¥ j�~zja�a�[©«©Q�«{�d��[¦h©«j���v���ikj�xyu?�h���6��©�i��[²?�«i��[© � B � {?|hi¦Fj6~�v ª9�_~ xzehj�v�� ²?® vyx��[�_j�� v���e�j6ikj��¬�e��«��e�ja{�v�|�~�jn����©«��¦���©P���a�*|h~����6u��[ª53P±�j�ª9�_~@x�e�j xy¬���¦Pj�vyx�v���ehjaikjav@��ª(x�ehjÃ�h~z���F�_v�ja��ªS�[ik�«©§u_¯"dfe��«vx��[¦h©«j�«©«©§|�v�x�~��'xzjav x�e��[xnx�e�j��[¦F�'±�j�v���ehjaikjavn�a�[{1¦Fj|�v�ja�¨¬�� xze � B � {?|hi�¦Pja~n�[ªJxzehj�_~z�hj6~n��ªJx�ehj|�{h� xyu_¯

1 � ��(���"�C�/�������� �@� �p��� )a#$� �C��)*����-����Q�

dfe�j ªS�[ik�«©§uk��ª���I v���ehjaikjavJxze��'x��«v��*�_{�v��«�wja~�j��k�«v�� % � ��� 02C�@� �L���L �������%&��2$�G� �����H���1��%&���<�C��� �!������� �%&��� � ��� ���[���h©§u?�«{h�p��{�xz~����[{���|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6�[��{�����ª ������L�<�A�H�����<�L���� xyu?�Pj_¯ ¥ jf~�j6ª9j6~�x�� - ��/wª9��~J�p�wj*x��[�«©§j���hjavz�*~z�§�wxz�§�_{��ªQxzeh�«v�ªS�[ik�§©«uC��ª�vz��ehj6ikj_¯

Á ~��_|h{�� ja�_��eC±�ja~�xzj*²C��vf¦h|h�«©§xÃ�k�*j6©«©3ª9��©«©«�'¬��§{h��xz��i����§{ ���hx��«��{�v7P®@ja� xzehj6~ x�ehj��*ja©§©Q�«vf©«�§ik�§x�j�� ¦XuC���[~�x��[ª�x�ehj�ikja�h�«��{�vf�[ª"v�|h~z~z��|h{��h�§{h��x�~z���[{h�_©§j�v6�®���~nx�ehj��*j6©«©��«væh|h�«© xô���a�*��~��w�«{h�kx�� �[{1���wja�C�[ª$Mf�[~�x�eA·H- 6�/ß¹ ¦Xu��y�_�§{h�«{h��xzehjk�*j6{Xxzj6~n��ªJja�w�_jav ¬��§x�exzehj��*ja{Xx�j6~���ª�v�i��[©«©§j�vyx �*�«~��*©«jô�6��{Xxz���§{��§{h��xzehj��*�_{�v����wja~�j���x�~z���[{h�_©§j_¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 10: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �

I

J

B��«��|h~zjk�AP/o j��w���[{ �*j6©«©Q�6��{�v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{

I

J

B��«��|h~zj¸�OP � �§~��*|hi��6j6{Xx�ja~ D�Mf�[~�x�e�E­�*ja©§©��6��{w®v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{

B��«��|h~zj ' P�d�~z�_�*jk�[ª�x�ehj�ikja�h�«��{�v��w�«±X��v��§�_{U�_{xy¬��&Bh~z�§j��w~z�«��e�v�®��ôj6©«©§ja~�ja©§jai�ja{Xxzv

B��«��|h~zj��!P¸d�~z�_�*j-�[ª Mf�[~�x�e �w�«±X��v��§�_{ ��{ xy¬��B�~��«ja�w~z����e�vy®��ôj6©«©«j6~�j6©«j6ikj6{Xxzv

dfehj�+�|w²wjav���~�j°�_v�v�j6i�¦h©«ja�-��{ù�[{¶ja�h��j*®´¦��_v�j����h~z�w�*j�v�va�Q�N¯ j_¯Cª9�_~�ja�_��e-j��w��j � U¨¦Pj6xy¬�jaj6{¶xy¬��{��?�hjav �/��{��VU��h��{��x�ehja{1v�|hikikja�ª9�_~�ja����e {h�w�wj �/�_v�ª9��©«©§�'¬ v7P

������������� F � H� w�� R N O · 6_¹¬�e�j6~zj w � R��[~zjÃja©§jai�ja{Xxz�[~zu&+�|h²?j�v��*�_i���|wx�j��¬��§x�e1���«j6i���{h{1v��_©§±_j6~�v6¯¥ j,3�~zv�x�~zja�a�[©«©�xzehjê9ja�'xz|h~zjav@��ª��[{Cj*²?x�ja{��wja�C±�ja~zv��§�_{��h~z���F�_v�ja�k�«{4- ��/´� -ê��/Fª9��~fÄJ|h©«j6~��a�[©��*|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6¯

dfehj�{X|�i�ja~����6��©��§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{ ¬��§x�e ��{ |h�?¬��§{�� vz��ehj6ikj1�_j6{hja~z��©§©«uù©§j����hv�x��A�[���h~��;²w�«i��'x��«��{Pv¬�e��«��e���~�j@�_{h©«u,3P~zv�x�®´��~��wj6~ü�_�6�6|h~z�[x�j_¯Qdfehj�o¨mÃs � � i�j6x�eh�w�w�_©§�_��up�[ªh±'�[{ � j6ja~Qe��_vQ¦Fj6ja{�j*²?x�ja{��wj��xz� ±�j6~�x�j6²?®´�6j6{Xx�ja~�j�� |h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��¨ª9�_~�i�|h©��'x��«��{Pvn�«{¶��~��wj6~Ãx�� ~zja����e-v�j��*��{P���_~z�wja~p�_�6�6|h~z�_�*uù·Sv�j6jª9�_~Jj*²h�[ik�h©«jG- ��/ß¹*¯�dfeh��vJj6²Xxzj6{�v��«��{~zj6©«�«jav"��{�x�e�j�j6±'�[©«|��'xz�§�_{ +�|h²?j�v"¬�� xzekj*²?x�~��[�F��©��'xzja��±'��©§|hj�v �� R �� R � �[x�x�ehj��«{Xx�j6~�ªS���6jô�[ªQxzehj��*ja©§©�v�· B��«��|h~zj��¹�P"¬�� xze P

� � � R N � � H O @ � [��� � \ � R @ �� U� R � N � R y O @ � [��� � \ R � @ �� U ·��a�_¹

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 11: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

- +S Sji

W WWWi ij ji j

Iij

B��«��|h~zj���PJ���_v�� xz�§�_{��ª � � R���{�� � R � �_{ -�� � ���GR�/¬�e�j6~zj�x�ehj.Dyj6²?x�~��[�F��©��'x��«��{¶v�©§�_�Pj�vLE [ �� � \ � R � R � ��~�j°�_¦wxz���§{�ja�¶|�v��§{����¨�*�_i¦h�«{��[x��«��{ù�[ªn�6j6{Xx�ja~�j����{��|h�?¬��§{�� �_~z�_�w�§ja{Xxzva¯

³ {��_~z�wja~Jx����«{��6~�j���v�jfx�ehjn�_�6�6|h~z�_�*u���ª3x�ehj ¦P��v��«� o1mps � � �6��{�v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{ü��¬�j��h~z���F�_v�jfx���hj�3�{hjxzehjav�j�v�©«���Fjav��_v�ª9��©«©§�'¬ v=Pdfe�jô�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��C�_~z�_�w�«j6{Xx [ �� � \ �� R ��v �wj�3�{hj�� �_v [��� � \ �� R @ �� U N � R y � � ¯dfe�jn{h�w�h��©P�_~z�_�w�§ja{Xx [��� � \ � ��v��a�[©��*|h©��'xzja�k�_{�x�ehjô�*ja©§© ] � �_v@xzehjô�;±�j6~��[�_jf�[ª(x�e�jÃ�_~z�_�w�§ja{XxzvJ��ªüx�ehjxz~����[{���©«jav�¬�eh����e �«{��6©§|��hjÃxzehj��*�_{�v��«�wja~�j��C{��?�hj P

[ �� � \ � N >� � ��� [ ] � \ �

������� � ��� [� \

��# ��� � # �

� w � # ·�����¹

dfe�j°|h�?¬��§{P�¶��~����w�«j6{Xx��«v��*�_i���|wx�j��ù���6�6��~��w�«{h� x��1xzehjC�wj�3�{h�§x��«��{A��ª�xzehjC�w�'¬�{Pvyxz~�j��[i ��{��¶|h�w®v�x�~zja��i xz~����[{h�_©§j�vf¬�eh����e¨�6�[{ ¦Fj��_v�v��w�*���'x�j��C¬��§x�e¨��{1ja�w�_j _ � � � R h · B��§�_|h~zj��_¹Å¯�dfehj��h�'¬�{�vyxz~�j��[i��{��|h��v�x�~zja�[i x�~z�«��{h��©«javf�[~zjô~�j�v��Fja�*x��«±�ja©§u°{��[x�j�� � R ��{�� R � ¯ FÃ{hjôe��_v�v�� P[��� � \ �� R N �� �� ����� �[{�� [��� � \��� R N �� �� ����� ¬�ehja~�j �� �� � N �

# ��� � # �� w # � ��~�j�xzehj����*®

Kô��©§ja~�*?�«{°��~����h�§ja{_x�v/�_{°xz~����[{h�_©§j ¯"dfeh�«vf�_�wx��«��{�[©«©§�'¬ v�j*²?x�ja{�v��§�_{�v�x�� � �w�6��©FÄ"²?xz~�jai|hi IÃ�§ik�«{w®��v�eh�§{�� · � Ä$Iô¹�vz��ehj6ikj�v���v�v�eh�'¬�{C�«{ - ��/N¯

¥ j@{h�'¬¶v��Fja�6� ª9uÃ��|h~Qi�j6x�eh�w�pª9�_~Q�*�_i���|wx��«{h�fx�e�jJj*²?x�~��[�F��©��'xz�§�_{pv�©§�_�Pj�v [��� � \ � R �[{P� [��� � \uR � P[ �� � \ � R @ �� U N [ > y � \ [ �� � \ �� R @ �� U H � [ �� � \��� R @ �� U

H�� ��� [��� � \��� R @ �� U y l [��� � \ �� R @ �� U H [��� � \ �� R @ �� U��H�� � � [��� � \�� ��!� @ �� U y l [��� � \ � @ �� U H [��� � \ R @ �� U � e

·�����¹

ó È�û ó æ

Page 12: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� 6

dfehj��6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��ª � R � ��v �[{���©§�_���_|�v�P[��� � \ R � @ �� U N [ > y � \ [��� � \ �R � @ �� U H � [��� � \��R � @ �� U

H�� � � [��� � \��R � @ �� U y l [��� � \ �R � @ �� U H [��� � \ �R � @ �� U��H�� � � [��� � \ � ���� @ �� U y l [��� � \ RA@ �� U H [��� � \ � @ �� U � e

·�� ' ¹

dfehjpxzj6~zi � �� ��� � ��!� ��v�x�ehjô�_~z�_�w�§ja{Xxf�[x�xzehj��P�_�§{Xx����� R ¯Jdfeh��vf©���v�xf�_~z�_�w�«j6{Xx���v��*�_i���|wx�j��C¦?u�«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{¨�[ª@xzehjk{h�w�h�[©���~����h�§ja{_xp±'�[©«|hjavô�'xpx�e�j�{h�w�wj�vô�*��{Xx��[�«{hja���§{�x�ehj�ªS���6j��_�h�F�_v�� xzj�x�� ��«{ x�ehj�|��X¬��«{��Cx�~z�«��{h��©«j � R�¯

D*ij D*ji

S

Tij Tji

S

m

i j

n r

s

B��«��|�~�jô�OP � �?�a�[©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{C��ªQx�e�j�j*²?x�~����§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{�F���«{Xxzv����� R ��{�����R � ��ª�{��?���[©(��~����h�§ja{_x�v

B��§�_|h~�j ��P"Ä/�w��j6®N|h�?¬��«{��Cx�j*xz~z��ehja�h~z�dfehj��6�?j�8°�*�«j6{Xxzv��@� � � �[{�� � � ��~�jô|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h������~z��i�j6x�ja~zv�x�eP�'xÃ�6��{Xx�~z��©Fx�e�j�*�_i¦h�«{��'xz�§�_{��ª

ª9|�©§©«uC|h�?¬��«{�� �[{�� �*ja{Xx�j6~zja� v�©§�_�Pj�v6¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 13: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

� � � � � � FÃ~��wj6~

�(® vz��ehj6ikj ��� ' � � � '

�(® vz��ehj6ikj ��� ' � � � �

�J~�j�v�ja{Xx o1j*x�e��?� ��� ' ®���� ' � ®y���w��� � �

�J~�j�v�ja{Xx o1j*x�e��?� ��� ' ®���� ' � ®y���w��� � �

d��[¦h©«j ' P Á �6�6|h~����*u���ª"�h�9;3j6~zj6{Xx�±�ja~zv��§�_{�v��[ª�x�ehj�{�j6¬ vz��ehjai�jô�«{¨��I�~zj6�_|h©«��~��a��v�j

d�� v�|hir|��ü�3x�ehj�v�j�vz��ehj6ikj�vne��;±_j�_{h©§u¨v��§²Xxzew®´��~��wj6~ô�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{-�[{��-�[~zj��«{��_j6{hja~z��©�v�ja�6��{��?®�_~z�hj6~n�_�6�*|�~z�[x�jô¦h|wxÃx�ehjau ¦Fja�6��ikj�eh�«��e�j6~�®N�_~z�wja~����6�6|h~��'x�j��«{1xzehj�©«�§{hj��[~p�6��v�jôª9��~pv��_ikj�±;��©§|�jav ��ªxzehj�����~z��i�j6x�ja~zv � ·Sv�j6j&-«�a��/9¹ � � ��{�� � �_��v�j6j.-«���0/��[{�� d���¦h©«j ' ¯� � )6�������)6�Q�ô�")*��dfe�j°{��'xz|h~��[©@ik�w�wj6©/ª9��~�xzehjC��~��_���[�X�'x��«��{U�[ª����6��|�v�x����6v��§{­� +P|h�«�A�«vôxzehj�6��ik�h~zjavzv��«¦h©«j�ln�;±?�§ja~�®s?x��A*_javJj��X|��'xz�§�_{�v6¯ Q �'¬�j6±_j6~�x�e�j6�«~/|�v�j�ª9��~@x�eh��v/��|h~��F�_v�j���v/�w�18°�*|h©§x�v�ik��©§©F�[ik�h©«� xz|��wj ��ª(±;��~����'xz�§�_{xze��'xn�6��~z~�j�v��F��{P�hv@xz�°���6��|�v�x����6v��hehja{h��ikja{��h¯

³ {x�e��[x"�a��v�j@x�e�j�©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j���ÄJ|h©«j6~"ik�?�hj6©?�«v���ja{hj6~��[©«©«uô�n~�j���v���{���¦h©«jJ��{hj_¯�dfehjfÄJ|h©«j6~"ja�X|��[x��«��{�v��~�jô�wja{h�[xzja� ¦?u P � F H � [ � \ M)H�� [ � \�� N O ·��6�X¹��{��Cx�ehja�§~ ©«�«{hja��~���v��[x��«��{{hja��~f��v�x�j����wu�+��'¬ � � ¬�~��§x�j�v�P

� F H [ ��� [ � � \ � \ M H [�� � [ � � \ � \ � N O @ ·�����¹

³ {A��{ù�«�wj��[©/v��§x�|��[x��«��{ü��¬�j�¬���v�eA�[{ù�[�h��~��;²w�«ik�[x��«��{U�[ªfx�e�j°©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja�¶v�u?v�x�jairxze��'x¦Fj �����!������� ���� � �� �[{P� � ��� i� ����� �O��� � �� ¯A³ { �h~����Åxz�«�6j��J¬�j{�j6ja�ùx��U�§{Xx�~z�w�w|��6jv���ikj�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{A¬��§x�e �� �§jaik��{h{ v��_©§±_j6~�¯

�)"$# 7n,$D �1( =@, � (+*�,-;>D ;^9 (� ,-� ? (/D)D � ;>.�� � =dfe�j��«{Xx�j6~zjav�xô�[ª�����?�w�1|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h���vô�C~��'xzehj6~p~��'x��«��{P�[©�¬��;u �«{��«{_xz~��w�w|P�*�«{h� �h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ü¯�dfehj+P|w²�w�1;Fja~�ja{��*j�v��h©«� x�x��«{h���h~z���F�_v�ja�C¦Xu���?j�¬�~��§x�j�v�P

[ � [ m� \ H � [ m�� \$\ � l y [��m \ [ m�� y m� \ � l ·��a�_¹¬�e�j6~zj �m e���©��hv@ª9�_~�x�ehjô���?jp�;±_j6~��[�_j��[ª m��U�[{�� m��¯Jdfeh�«vf�;±_j6~��[��j�ja{�v�|h~�j�v@xze��'x����?j�� vfv���©§�§x�xz�§{h���v@|��X¬��«{��k�«{°v�|��Pja~zv���{h�����6�_v�j_��¦h|hx/x�e��«v/eh��©��hvJ�_{h©§u��«{�{h��{h©«�«{hja��~/�6�_v�j_¯ Á {��[x/���wj6{Xxz�«�a�[©N�_¦h|hx/±�ja~�u

ó È�û ó æ

Page 14: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �_�

�6©§�Xv�j_�?ª9��~zi|h©��'xz�§�_{C��vfx�e�jôª9��©«©§�'¬��«{h�<P

[ � [ m \ H � [ m �>\ \ � l y ������� [ [ �m \$\ [ � [ m �>\ y � [ m 1\$\ � l ·���[¹�«{ ¬�eh����e ������� [ \ ª9�_~n���w���[�_��{���©§��v���¦h©«jÃi��'xz~��§² N `1j � �h¬��§x�e � N � � � � [�� j e � � e � ��\ eh��©��hvª9�_~fx�ehj�j6²w�h~�j�v�v��«��{ P

������� [ \ N `1j � � � � [ ��� ��� [�� j \ e ������� [�� � \ e ������� [�� � \$\ @ ·��a�_¹¥ jô�6�[{ja�_v��«©§u���ehj���*�x�e��[x�xzeh�«v�ª9�_~�i ��©§©«�'¬ v@ª9|�©§©(|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h��§ª���©§© � � �[~zjn�[ª�v���i�jpv��«��{Q�_xzeh��v/xz�§ikj¬��§x�e���|wxn�_v�v�|hik�§{��xze��'x �m ��v�x�ehj����?j��;±�ja~z����j_¯ Á vn��©«�«{hja��~���v�j��C±_j6~�v��«��{Q�X¬�j�v�|�����j�vyx0P

[ � � [ m� \ � H � � [ m�� \ � � \ � l y ����� ��� [ [ �m \ \ [ � [ � � \ y � [ � \ \ ·��76_¹¥ ehja~�j �m �6�[{¶¦FjC�h~z�w�w|��6ja�U¦?uU��{XuUv�u?ikikj*xz~����°�;±�ja~z�����«{h��¯ � �Xj�8°�*�«j6{Xx � �«v�x��¨¦FjC��eh�Xv�ja{

v�i��[©«©Ø�w�«{ ��~��wj6~�xz���X�[�«{¦Fj6{�j�3hxn��ªQxzehj�j*²?x�~��kvyx��[¦h�«©«� xyu°��ª"��©«�§{�ja�[~fª9�_~�i�|h©��'x��«��{Q¯

�)" ! 7n,$D �1( =@, � (+*�,-;>D (/D �>.$; �)(/.n( &)&)=@;��c,$? (+*�,-;>D¥ j/{��'¬Uj6²?x�j6{P�ôx�ehj�eh�«��ew®´��~��wja~Q���a�*|h~��'xzj@�*��{Pvyxz~�|��*x��«��{���ªwx�ehjC3�~zv�x�v�ja�*x��«��{ôxz� x�e�j��6�_v�j/�[ªh±'�[~z�«��¦h©«j�6�?j�8°�*�«j6{Xxzva¯ ¥ j=3P~zv�x vyx��[~�x�ª9~z��i � �7I�vz�6�[©��[~��a��v�jAP

� F H [ J�[ Q \ E+[ Q \$\ M N O @ ·N�[�_¹

FÃ{hjÃ{h�'±�ja© xyuk¬��§x�e~�j�v��Fja�*x/x�� - �A/ü�[{��?-ê�0/´�w�«v/x�eP�'xf¬�jì���{_x�x���v��;±_j�x�ehjp��~��wja~/�[ª����6�6|h~����*uª9��~��{h�_{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi ¦�����*?��~z��|�{��.+��'¬��w~zj6�h~zjav�j6{Xxzja�°e�j6~zjp¦?u Ji[ Q \ ¯ FÃ|h~f�h~z���F�_v�� xz�§�_{°ª9�_~fx�eh��v��h|h~z�F�_v�j��v�x��°���h�h©«u�x�e�j�eh�§�_e�_~z�hj6~ �wja~��«±'�'x��«��{���Fj6~��'xz��~�v/xz��x�ehj�� ������� J�[ Q \ E+[ Q \ ¯

dfeh��v��«vk�w�_{hj ¦Xuù�«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§{h�-±'�[~z�«��¦h©§j J E+[ Q \ �@ª9~z��i �§xzv�±'�[©«|hjav [ JaE \ � �_{­j�����eA{h�w�wj_�/�[{P�ª9~z��iÂ�§xzvô{��?���[©J��~����h�§ja{_x�v [ � E \ � ¯ ¥ jk��¦hxz�[�«{¶�*j6©«©J�«{_xzj6~�ªS���6j�±'�[©«|hj�v [ J E \ f� f j � ��{�� [ J E \ `� fkj � �'x��¦�vz�*��v�vz�[j Q � f j� � ¯dfehj�~zjav�|h©§x��«{h��v��P�'x����[©«©«uCv�jaik� ® �w��v��6~�j6x��«µ6ja�v���e�j6ikjô¬�~��§x�j�v�P

������� [ � \ � � � F HXw � fkj � y w � `1j � N O ·N�w��¹¬��§x�e

w � f j� � N O @ � [$[ J E \ f� fkj � H [ J E \ `� f j� � \ ·N����¹dfe�j¨�[¦F�'±�j �;±�j6~��[�_�§{����[ªô�h©«|�v°��{��¸i��«{?|�v�±'�[©«|hj�v°�*�_~�~zjav��P�_{��hv�x��A�¶�6j6{Xx�~��[© �w�1;3j6~zj6{��6�§{h�¶ª9�_~�®i�|h©��'x��«��{¸·1D�{h� ���§jai��[{h{Uv��_©§±_j6~HEy¹*¯ Á �a�*�_~z�w�«{h�Cx�� x�ehjk��eh�_�«�6j���i��_{h�°xzehj��[¦F�'±�j,D��«{_xzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{�v�P�[~��[ikj*xzj6~�vLEÅ�h�§xp�6��{1¦Pj��[ª@v�ja�*�_{�� x�� v��§²?x�e1�_~z�wja~Ã�_�6�*|�~z�_�*u�¯ ¥ j{h��x�j��«{¨���_v�v��«{h��x�eP�'x xzehj���wja���ª@��eh�?�_v��§{h� +�|h² �«{Xx�j6~z�F��©��'x��«��{1��©§©«�'¬ v�x��°j�v��a�[�Fjôx��kxzehj�v�ja�6��{��?®´��~��wja~�©«�«i��§xz�[x��«��{¨�_�w±��w�6�[x�j��C¦?u¥ |1�[{�� ¥ �[{h�¨·H-§� ' /ß¹�ª9�_~no1mÃs � � v���ehjaikjava¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 15: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�;� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

�)"�� % *C( �z,$. , � (+*C,$;>D³´x��a�[{U¦Pjk{hj��*javzvz�[~zuxz�1vyx��[¦h�«©§��v�j�xzehj�v���e�j6ikj��wj�3�{�j��«{-x�ehj��h~zj6±?�«��|�vôv�ja�*x��«��{ü�(j�v��Fja�6�«��©§©«u¨¬�ehja{{���{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi ikjav�ehjav���~�jp|�v�ja�(¯

Á v��6~��§x�ja~������[ªQ�hjav��§�_{kª9��~f�wjav��§�_{h�«{h��x�e�jÃv�xz�[¦��§©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{kx�ja~�i�va�_¬�jn�h~z���F�_v�jfx�e�jnª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{�����{hj�v�P·S��¹ ®(v�xz��¦h�«©§��v��[x��«��{���v��h�§~zja�*x�©«uÃ�_�'±�j6~z{hj��æ?upx�e�j��w��v��6��{Xx��«{?|h�§x��«jav��h~��w�w|P�*ja�ô¦?upx�e�j/�«{_xzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{�v

��e��_v�j6{C�«{ x�ehj��6j6{Xx�~��[©ü�h�9;3j6~zj6{��6ja�Cx�ja~�i·S�§�ß¹´®/v�xz��¦h�§©«��v��[x��«��{Cv�eh��|�©«�°��©§©«�'¬ ª9|h©«©3|h�?¬��§{��h�§{h� ·S�_v�ªS�[~f��v��[©«©3��eP�[~����Åxzj6~z� xz�«�av@�[~zjn�«{°xzehj�v���ikj

�h�§~zja�*x��«��{ü�h��{��°xzehj��«{_xzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{ �«v���©«v���ª9|h©«©ü|h�?¬��§{P��¹·S�§�«��¹ ®Fv��§{P�*jJxzehj@©«ja���h�§{h��ja~�~z��~(¬��«©«©[¦Pj��w�§~zja�*x�©«uÃ�_�'±�ja~�{hj�� ¦?uÃx�ehj 3P~zv�xQ�wj6~z�«±;�[x��«±�j�v(�[ª?j6�«��ja{X±'��©§|hj�v6�

¬�j��w�k{h�[x {�j6ja�Cx����«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xzjÃxzehj6i!�§{1�k�*�Xvyxz©§uC¬��;u_¯

w ����� � " �� f j � N w � f j� � y � � f j� � ·N� ' ¹¬��§x�e � � f j� � N O @ � � ������� [ J � f j� � \ [ [ J E \ f� f j� � y [ J E \ `� f j� � \ ·N�'�X¹¬�e�j6~zj J � f j� � ��v�x�ehjôv��«ik�h©«jp�;±_j6~��[��j [ J � H J � f j \ � l ¯Jdfehjô�*�?j�8°�6�§ja{_x ��¬��«©§©ü��©§©«�'¬ � 3�{�jnxz|h{h�«{h����ªxzehj ������� � ��� �w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{ �[ª�x�ehj�vz��ehjai�j���{��v�eh�_|h©«� ¦Fj�©§j�v�vf�_~fja�X|��[©üx�� >�¯�)" � # 0 . ,$D� (+=G, � � ���Ag.-�1=��;^=@? A).-(+*�,-; Ddfe�j��§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{���vJ{h�'¬¸�[�h��©§�«ja��x��ôxzehj�±'�[©«|hjav@�[ªFx�ehj�©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j�� +�|h²?j�v � � [ m \ � ¯Js?xz�[¦��§©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{��vf�«{�v����§~zja�¦?u°x�e�j����§jai��[{h{ v��_©§±_j6~f�h~z���F�_v�ja�¦Pja©§�'¬�¯Jdfeh��v�~zjav�|h©§xzvf�«{ P

w ����� � " �� f j � N w � f j� � y � � f j� � ·N����¹

¬��§x�e Pw � f j � N O @ � [ [ � � [ m \ � \ f� f j� � H [ � � [ m \ � \ `� fkj � \ ·N�[�_¹

��{��5P � � fkj � N O @ � �&������� [ � f j � \ [$[ � � [ m \ � \ f� f j� � y [ � � [ m \ � \ `� fkj � \ ·N���[¹�)"� !^0 . ,$D� (+=G, � � ���Ag.-�1=��;^=@? A).-(+*�,-; Ddfe�jôÄ@|h©§ja~ ja�X|��[x��«��{�v���~�jp¬�~z� x�x�j6{ �«{1v�eh�_~�x0P

�'F H � [ � \ MBH � [ � \ � N O ·N�[�_¹�_~7P

�'F H � � �� N O ·N��6_¹� j*x�|�v�wj6{h��x�j � � R�xzehj��«{_xzj6�_~z��©J�[ª�x�ehj�{h�_~�i���©J±�ja�*x��_~��[©«��{h� x�e�j��§{Xx�ja~�ªS�_�*jk¦Fj*xy¬�j6j6{Uxy¬��1�*j6©«©�v6�] ����� � ��{�� ] ����� R ¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 16: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� � '

dfe�j��«{Xx�j6~z�F��©��'x��«��{-�«vp{h�'¬ �[�h�h©«�«ja�1xz� x�ehj�±'�[©«|hjavp�[ª�x�ehjk©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j�� +�|w²�±_ja�*x���~�v �«{-x�ehjk{h�_~�i��[©�h�§~zja�*x��«��{

�� [ m \ � @ � � R�¯@dfeh��vf���«±�j�v�P

w � ��� � " �� R N w�� R y � � R · ' �_¹¬��§x�e P

w � f j� � N O @ � [ [ � � [ m \ � \ � R�@ � � R H [ � � [ m \ � \ R � @ � � R \ · ' ��¹��{��5P

� � f j � N O @ � � ������� [�� � Ri\ [ [ � � [ m \ � \ � R @ � � R y [ � � [ m \ � \ R � @ � � Ri\ · ' ��¹¬�e�j6~zj � � R��«vn�wj�3�{�ja� ¦?u P

� � R N �� [ [ m � H m+R \ � l \ @ � � RA@ · 'A' ¹

�)"�� %�A)? ? ( = � ;^9 *�� � � &g(k*�,$( . � ��� � ?��dfe�jp�_©§�_¦��[©ü��©§�_��~z� xzehi ª9��~ �6��ik�h|wxz�§{��kx�ehj=+�|h²?j�v��6��{¦Fj�v�|�i�ikj�� �_v�ª9��©«©§�'¬ va¯

��¯ Á ¦�����*?��~z��|�{��.+��'¬ m N [� e � E e � Ge� \ �[{�� ���Pja~�xz|h~z¦��'xz�§�_{� N [ � � e � [� E \ e � [�� \ e � \ �P��{ ja�_��e±_j6~�x�j*²°��ª�xzehj�ikjav�e ��~�jô�_�§±_j6{ü¯�_¯ � ��ik�h|wxzj�xzehj©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j��J+P|w²wjav �� N � � [ m \ @ � e �� N � � [ m \ @ � ��{¨j�����e ±�ja~�xzj*²ù·9±�ja~�®

xzj*²w¬���v�jô©«�X�_�P¹Å¯

�h¯ � ��ik�h|wxzjkx�ehj�{h�w�h��©J��~����w�«j6{Xx�v ���� e ���� �[ª/xzehj�©«�§{hj��[~z�«v�ja�4+�|w²wj�vô��{¶ja�_��e�±�ja~�xzj*² ·Sj6©«j*®ikja{_xy¬���v�jp©«�?���P¹*¯@dfeh��vf�«v �h��{hjô¦?uC�[���h©§u?�«{h��x�ehj�{��?���[©(��~����h�§ja{_xfª9�_~�i�|h©«�<P

[������ \ � N >� � ��� [ ] � \ �

����� �� � ��� [� \

��# � � [

�� \ # �� w � # · ' �X¹

' ¯/sXxz��~�x �� �"#���/� ���.��������%&��� ���1�0��� P�6��ik�h|wxzjpx�ehj�j6²Xxz~z���P�_©«�[x�j��v�©§�_�Pj�v=P

[������ \ � R @ �� U N [ > y � \ [������ \$\ �� R @ �� U H � [������ \ \��� R @ �� UH�� � � [������ \$\�� � R @ �� U y l [������ \ \ �� R @ �� U H [������ \ \ �� R @ �� U �H�� � � [������ \$\ � ��!� @ �� U y l [ ����� \$\ � @ �� U H [ ����� \$\ RA@ �� U�� e

· ' ��¹

·Ø�[{�� �[{P�[©«����ª9��~ �� [ �� [ m e�� \$\ \ � RX¯dfe�jô�6j6{Xx�~��[©ü�h�9;3j6~zj6{��6ja� +�|w²�«v �hja�w|��6ja�5P

w�� R N O @ � [ �� �GH ���� � R H �

�R y ���

�R � \ @ � � R · ' �_¹

�«{ ¬�eh����e P�� N [ �� e �� \ · ' �[¹

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 17: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�a� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

�P¯@ÄJ±'�[©«|��'xzjÃxzehj�v�xz�[¦��§©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{Cxzj6~zi P

� � fkj � N O @ � � ������� [ � � R \ [$[ �� � R&@ � � R y [ �� R � @ � � R \ · ' �_¹¬�e�j6~zj � � R �«vn�wj�3�{�ja� ¦?u P

� � R N [ � � e � � \ [$[ m � H m+R \ � l \ @ � � RA@ · ' 6_¹�h¯ � ��ik�h|wxzjÃxzehj=3�{���©üja�h��jG+�|w² ��v7P

w ����� � " �� R N w � R y � � R ·S�_�_¹

��{�� ���h�¶·Sv�|h¦�v�x�~����*x�¹��§x�x�� +�|w² ��vzv�jai¦h©«u°�'x ±_j6~�x�j*² �p· U?¹Å¯�)" � � ; A)D )( = � �L;>D� ),-*C,$;>D �M��_|h{��h��~�u��*�_{��w�§x��«��{�v�e��;±_j��p�*~z|��*���[©?�«{�+�|hja{��*jf�_{�x�e�jf�X|���©§�§xyu��[ªF�h~����Åxz�«�a�[©?���6��|�v�x�����v��«i|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6¯ln��{w®´~zj�+�j��Åx��«{h��¦F��|h{P�h�[~zu��6��{��w�§x��«��{Pv/�[~zj�{hj��*javzvz�[~zu��§{��_~z�hj6~Jxz��;±��_�«��v���|h~��«��|PvJ~�j�+�ja�*x��«{h��¬f�;±�j�vxz��xz~z�;±_j6©f�«{­xzehj1�*��ik�h|hxz�'xz�§�_{��[©��w�_i��[�«{ü¯­³ { x�eh��vk�h~zj6©«�§ik�«{��[~zuAv�x�|��wu_�/¬�j1v�e���©§©f{h��x°�*��{Pv����wj6~��~��_¦h©§jai�v�¬�� xzeA�F�_vzv��«¦h©«j°~�j�+�ja�*x��«��{�va�J�[{��¶¬�jCv�e��[©«©/|Pv�j°�«{ùxzehjC�h~zjav�j6{Xxzja�¶�6��©«�6|h©«�[x��«��{�v|h�?¬��§{P�ªS��~H3Pj6©��ù�*��{P�w� xz�§�_{�v�~zj6©«u?�§{��¨��{¶xzehj s?x�j6�_j6~�® ¥ �[~zik�§{�� +P|w²Av��h©«�§x�x��«{h�P¯�³ {­v�eh��~�xa�R+�|h²?j�v�¦Fj*xy¬�j6ja{¦F��|�{��h�[~zuC�6j6©«©ü�[{��j*²?x�ja~�{P�[©(ikja�w�«|hi �[~zjô�6��ik�h|wxzja� ��v�ª9�_©§©«�'¬ v7P

w�� M�F ��� " ���� N f [ m � \ � � H

` [ m \ �

¬�e�j6~zj N � ����@ �J� � ¦Fj6�«{h�¸x�e�j-{h�_~�i���©nxz�¸¦F��|�{��h�[~zu��Tm ��{�� � ~zjav��Fja�Åxz�§±_j6©«u x�ehj

¦P����*?��~z��|h{P�.+��'¬ ��{�� �Pja~�xz|h~z¦��'xz�§�_{ v��Pj��*�13�ja� �'x�ªS��~H3Pj6©��(¯

�)"�� ,$?�� (� �+(/D�� ,$D�dfe�j�xz�§ikj°�_�w±'�[{h�_�§{h� ��v���vpª9�_~ôx�ehj1�0I v���e�j6ikj�� � |h{h��j6®��ô|hx�xz� �_{hj��(xze��'x�a�[{U¦Pj�|Pv�j��-�«{Ux�ehj©«�«{hja��~���v�j��°±_j6~�v��«��{ �wj�3�{�ja� �§{ù·Ø�_¹Å¯

� ) ���������� � )6#$� ���)6��C�

�"$# 2 � ),$( D�� � � . . �ÄJ²Xxzj6{�v��«��{°xz� ' ®LI ��ª�ikja�h�«��{�*ja©§©�v��«vf{��[x��*��ik�h©«���6�'xzja�(¯ FÃ{�j/�y|�v�x�e��;±�jnx���xz�A*�jô��v�x�e�jÃj6²w��eP�[{h�_jv�|h~�ªS���6jæFj*xy¬�j6ja{xy¬��k±�ja~�xz�«�6jav��[ªJ�[{ j6©«j6ikj6{Xx��wx�ehjôxz~����[{���©«javf�*�_{h{hja�*x��«{h�<P

� x�ehj�ik���h�w©«j��[ª�x�ehj�¦P�[~�©«�§{O*?�«{h��x�ehj��6��{�v����wj6~zja��[�h���*j�v6�

� x�ehj��6j6{Xx�ja~��[ª"��~��;±?� xyuk�[ª�x�e�jôªS���*j�vf�[ª�x�ehj�ja©§jai�ja{Xx e��;±?�§{h��x�e��«v�¦P�[~ ��v���{j��w��j_�

� x�ehj��6j6{Xx�ja~��[ª"��~��;±?� xyuk�[ª�x�e�j�j6©«j6ikj6{Xxa¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 18: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �;�

M�u1�[{���©§�_��u¬�� xze-�;®LI�F��{�j�v�eh��|h©�� ~��'x�e�j6~Ã�6��{�v�x�~z|��*xp�*ja©§©�vn�_v ~zj6�_|h©«��~Ã�_v �F�_vzv��«¦h©«j�¬�ehj6{�x�ehjikj�v�e��«v"{h�_{w® vyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja�ü¯Qdfehj6{Q�[��{hj�¬���|h©���¬���v�e�x�e�jf�6j6©«©«v�¦Fjf~�j��Åxz��{h��©«j/�P�[~��[©«©§ja©§ja�h�§�Fja��v��6j6{Xx�ja~�j����~��_|h{��x�e�j��[���«�6jav ¬�e�j6{ x�e�jikjav�e¨��v�x�e�j ' ®LI j��X|h�§±'��©§ja{_xnx��JB�~��«ja�w~z����e�vy®��ôj6©«©«j6~�ikjav�eü¯:B��«~zv�xa�F� x��vf�«i��F��~�xz��{Xx�xz�°�wj�3P{h� xzjôx�ehj�v�e����Pjô�[ª�x�e�j�±���©«|hikj*xz~����Ãj6©«j6ikj6{Xxzva¯

�" ! � D��� * � *C=�( �� c=@,�� (k*�,$;>D³ { ' ®�I��hv��P���*jô��v 3�~�vyx �w�«±?�«�hja� �§{Xxz��ehj*²h�[e�ja�w~��h¯ Bh�_~ v��A*�jô�[ª"v��«ik�h©«�«�6� xyu_�wx�ehj��a��v�jô�[ªJ� � ��~�xzjav��«��{ikj�v�e ��vn�*�_{�v��«�wja~�j��(¯�dfe?|�va��¬�j��*�_{�v��«�wja~�~�j��Åx��[{h�_©§j�vf���[~��[©«©§ja©§ja�h�«�Pj��hv�·ßxzehj6~zja�[ªßx�ja~n�6��©§©«ja��� ����J ( �;¹Å�¬�e��_v�j ±��_©§|hikj�v/�[~zj � � N v Q v�� v� ¯�³´x��«v��wj�v��«~z��¦h©«j x���j6{��°|h�C¬��§x�e�xzj*xz~z��ehja�w~��[©Pj6©«j6ikj6{Xx�v {xze?|�v6�?�_{hjÃi�|�v�xfv��h©«� xfx�e�jav�jæh©«�w��*wv6¯ � j6x�|�v�ª9�w�*|Pvf��{�xy¬����h�§±?��v��«��{�v��*�_{�v��«�wja~�j���¦Fj*ª9��~zj�¯Jdfehj,3�~�vyx·����w¹pik�§{��§ik�«µ6jav�x�ehj�{?|hi�¦Pja~��[ª�v�|h¦h®Øxzj*x�~��[e�ja�w~��h�(¦h|hx��ja{hj6~��'xzjavô� ¦h�§�¨�6��~zj�ja©§jaikj6{Xxa��·9±��_©§|�i�j� � � ���_¹*�Q�[{��-ª9�_|h~��Pja~��«�hehja~z��©Jj6©«j6ikj6{Xx�v�·��J��©«|hikj � � � �(X¹Å¯�dfehj°v�ja�*�_{��U�w�§±?��v��«��{ ·����P¹puX�«j6©��hvxy¬������wja{_xz�«�a�[©��h~z�«v�i�v6�Jj�����eA¦Fj6�«{h�-v�|h¦3�w�«±X���wj��A�«{_xz��xzeh~zj6j°xzj*xz~z��ehja�w~��h¯ M�|wxa�@�«{­�_~z�hj6~�xz��x���*_j�«{Xx��C�_�6�6��|h{Xx�x�e�j{hja¬ �6j6©«©«v x�e��[xì��«©§©�¦Pj��wj�3P{hja�(�3�[{P� ��|h~n��i¦h�§x��«��{ xz�C�*�_ikj�¦�����*Cx��C�JB��«{h�§x�jIÃ�1;Fja~�ja{��*j�vnvz��ehj6ikj��P� ' ®LI x�~z���[{h�_|h©«�[x��«��{ ���wj6{Xx����6��©üxz�kx�ehj Bh~z�§j��w~�����e�v�®��ôja©§©«j6~�xyu?�Fj�ikjav�e1�§{��'®�I��vf�h~z���F�_v�ja�(¯

dfehj���~��_�P�Xv�j����w�«±?�«v��§�_{¸·����1»X¾�� »���» ¡'¢w ! ¿"� In�«±?�«v��«��{ü�ü�_~#���$� ¹pv��h©«� x�vôx�ehj%� ����J ( �§{¶v��§²���wja{_xz�«�a�[©wxzj*xz~z��ehja�w~z��{Pv6�'¬��§x�e�±_��©«|hikjav � � ��(h�[j�����e�¦Pja�§{h�ôxzehj �«i��[��jf��ªF�§xzv/{hj6�«��e?¦F��~�v��«{°�ôik�§~z~z��~�¯Á ©§©"xzehjav�j�j6©«j6ikj6{Xxzvpe��;±_j�«{U�6��ikik��{U�C�w���[�_��{���©���ª/x�e�j�� ����J ( ¯dfe�j��6�X�_~z�h�§{��[x�j�vn��ª@x�ehj�xzj*x�~��'®e�ja�w~z��{�v�~zjav�|h©§x��«{h��ª9~��_i x�ehjpxzeh~�jaj��w�§±?��v��«��{Pv��[~zjpv�eh�'¬�{C�«{?B��§�_|h~�j�vp�a�k�[{��-���_�w�wj6�Fj6{��h�§{h��|��P�_{xzehj�©«�?�a�[©({?|hi�¦Pja~zvf��ªQx�e�j�¦h©§�w��*°±_j6~�x����*j�v6¯ B��§�_|h~zjav��k�[{�� 6kv�e��'¬ x�e�j#���°��{��&���$�r�w�«±X��v��§�_{�v6¯

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z

0

2

4

6

X0

2

4

6

Y

Y

X

Z

B��§�_|h~zjô�<P'���C�h�§±?��v��«��{

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z

0

2

4

6

X0

2

4

6

Y

Y

X

Z

B��«��|�~�j 6OP'���$�r�h�§±?��v��«��{

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 19: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

1 2

8

34

5 6

7

������������ �������������������� ���!�����"$#%��'&'�(�)�*+���,�.-0/!132)4

56����7��8& #���9&�����*:<; :>= ?<@A:

� BDC�E F�EHG8EJI�K BL�%E C�E M�E F8K BNC�E!�%E OPE F8KC BDC�E M�E O�EHGQK BL�%E I�E F�ERG�K BSM�E C�E OPE F8KM BDI�E T�EHG8E O8K BSF�E!�%ERG�E M8K BUG�E M�E OPE F8KO B9��EJC�E O�EJI�K BL�%E I�ERG�E T8K BST�ERG�E OPE F8KI BDC�EJI�EHG8E O8K BL�%ERG�E M�E T8K BNI�E T�E OPE F8KF BL�%E M�E OPE T8K BL�%E I�E OPE F8K

���!�%���V���%�$W�����XN&)&'�0��Y��Z��0��#���9&�����*[��Z���8&'�!\��Z"]����^�����������������0_`������� ���!���V"]�%�$&Y�a&'Y����Z��!"bX"]����8&V*'c����H&�!���8*

d+eDf gihkj�lnmoj[p'p9qsrtj[hVj�u�v�w�xLyzh{ ��|*'Y������ �����7~}�?,�8��@A���[�8�Q�����S� �������]�]��}ABS����?<@,��K6&Y���������c���"[c ������Y��Z�����P*�*'���0Y�&Y��Q&&Y�`)���0Y��������*'���9"S�%�)|�P�&L������&L�a���������Y��P�%�'������#���9&�����*$�L������*�E�"]���k������#���A��!��7��8&��

� &'Y�`�7�(Z�Z���`��"�&'Y�`3Z���`��������3��&�!����&Y��*'|&L���7#���9&�����*�E

� &'Y��}%�����Q�U�����<����� ���8��}7��"[&'Y��"S���)3*+��"�&'Y�`��!��7��8&�Y���#��!����&Y���*k�Z��%|���,�)�%���7�%��E

� &'Y���)#��%�!���7`�)��8&'��Q�V��"�&'Y�`��!�����8&�E

��Y���

� &'Y��}%�3�[�Q�D����������� ���8��}<��"k�>�%�!#%�� "S�%�)��(*��!&*���¡ ��¡ ��¡<�H"k�!&������7c����*'�*�������� ���)��&'A���������*��&Y�������*'�E��!&k�(*a&'Y�¢���!�8*93*L&�c �����%&k��"[&Y��&'������������E��D¡ �¡£&'Y�`���(Z�Z���`��"��H&0*��������%�*9&+3Z���%E

� &'Y� }�¤ �P�N�$¥ �¦����� ���8��}.��"k��� �����7��%&���*¢�H&0*���¡ ��¡ *�¡§�H"+&'Y��"]����7��¢�(*¢��������&'�Zs����*'��Z��&'Y������7��8&3¨6��&'Y�������*'�E$�H&��(*`&Y�����!�8*93*L&`c �����%&3E£�N¡ �¡A&'Y�s}������Q�U���%�©�%��� �3�8��}>��"a&'Y�������'�%�*9&*9���9"S�%�)�¡

{ �� ����������&'�(�)>&Y��Q&§��Y����&'�&'�0��Y�3Z��0���'3*9���H&�"]�'�%�ª?<@A:«&Y���¬�����V&Y�s�����7��8&*�"S�����*���'A�'3��&0�����%�!�&'������������*�¡�­®�¯&Y���*~����*'�E6&Y�§�)����£�L������*�&'Y�A�7�(Z�Z������"k&'Y�����������*9&7�Z��%���"°&'Y�&)&���Y��Z�����§&��&Y�����(Z�Z����*|��"t&'Y����&Y���|�Z����*�¡`±+Y�7�)����(*°�%�������&'3Z§�!�.&'Y��(*|�a���,�������!���0_�*�E����8&'��'3Z§���������Z�&'Y�¢#���9&�����*���"$&Y�¢�7�*'Y�¡����!�%���'3*��3C7����Z ��M7*'Y��Q�²&Y�`&��%�)`��"�&'Y��Z���#8�(*'�!�%���"�������!��7��8&��!�8&'���������*�E������)�%�Z�������&'��&'Y�`���(ZA����Z�����³���&'Y���Z�*�E���*'cP3��&�!#%�����¡

­®�<\��0*L&��!�P*L&0�������E������*'Y�������Z.cP�%�!�8&�����&|&'Y���&�&'Y���������0�Q&�Z>�������*|�7�!���!�7��´��&'Y�7�����7���(�����Z���**9��c���&'�����7���'�%�6Z����&��&'Y�V���������*£� )&L�a����&'Y�kc ��c ���Z��(�)�������6&'��&Y�V�)��!�(*t����Z�&'Y�k3Z���3*£&'Y������'�8*'*�¡ { ��&'Y�°��&'Y���zYP����Z�E��!&a�����~� °*'Y��Q���7&'Y���&a���~?<@A:µ&')&���Y��Z��'��´���&'���������PZ�&'Y�°������������*Z�)\����!&'�����P*�E��!&V�(*�c �%**9�������&'�~�����)���%*9°&'Y�����0Z������"$&Y�¢*9cP���)¢*�0Y����%¡t­®��Z���Z�E���*9������¶¸·¢¹6º�»���!&'Y>�7����Z�������c�������Z§���0��Z��!��%&3E�Z��\����Z§���§&'Y��*'���7`�a�����%*����.C�X®¼½�!��¾ OQ¿UE��%����)�%�7�*+���%�0_�&'�

À]Á�Â�ÀbÃ

Page 20: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� ���

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z0

2

4

6

X

0

2

4

6

Y

XY

Z

B��«��|h~zjô���OP�d�~z�_�*j��[ª3ikja�w���[{Pv@�*ja©§©�vJ��{��pxzj*x�~��'®e�ja�w~z��{ ~�j�v�|�© xz�§{h��ª9~z��i ���$�

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z

0

2

4

6

X

0

2

4

6

Y

XY

Z

B��«��|h~zj�� ' PJd�~z�_�*jp�[ª ����� ��{ �x�j*xz~z��ehja�h~��_{~zjav�|h©§x��«{h��ª9~��_i ���$�

B��«{h�§x�j IÃ�9;3j6~zj6{��6java¯CFÃ{hj��6�[{x�e�j6~zj*ª9��~zjpj*²w�Pj��Åxfx��k{h��x����*j��[{ ��~��wja~���¦P�'±_jô� ·Svz��ehjai�jô�_~z�wja~�¬��§x�exzehj��h~zj6±?�«��|�vf�w�«±?�«v��§�_{P¹Å¯

� � � #$���")*����U���°�����")6#$� ���� )6� �z�¥ j�v�eP�[©«©ü�*��{P�*j6{Xxz~z�[x�jp��{ |h{h�§ª9��~zi ¦�����*?�_~��_|h{��&+P�'¬�¯ Á {j6²h�[ik�h©«jp��ª�{h�_{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi ¦�����*?�_~��_|h{��+P�'¬��«vp���«±�ja{¨�«{ -«�6��/@�[{P� -«���0/´¯dfehj�{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©�j*²w�Pja~��«ikj6{XxzvÃ�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��1ehja~�jk�[~zj��ª@xy¬��Cxyu?�Pj�v6¯B��«~zv�x�©«u���¬�j���ehj���*1x�e�j°���6�6|h~����*u1�_~z�hj6~ô�[ªf��|h~�vz��ehjai�j�v6¯°s?j��*�_{��w©«u��Q¬�j��*�_i���|wx�j°� ¬�j6©«©$*?{h�'¬�{xzjav�xn�6�_v�jp�§{ �_~z�wja~�x���j6±'��©§|��[x�jpx�e�j6�«~ ���6�6|h~����*u��«{1��i��_~�jô�h~����*x����6��©3�6��{Xx�j6²?xa¯

��"$# � � � Ac=�( � � � (/.$, c(+*�,-;>D³ {C��~��wj6~/x���e��;±_jn�[{�[{���©§uXx����6��©P�6��{Xx�j6²Xx/ª9��~f���6�6|h~����*u�±'�[©«�«�h�[x��«��{ü�X¬�jn��eh�?�_v�jn�v���©«|wxz�§�_{�¬�eh�«��eC�«v±_j6~zu�v�i��[©«©�{hj��[~@xzehjn¦F��|�{��h�[~z�«jav@��ª3x�ehjô�*�_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���©��w��i����§{ü¯ B���~/~zja��©§�«µ6�«{h�ôxzeh�«v��h~z���_~z��i�ikj_�¬�jôe��;±�jÃx����«{Xx�~z�w�w|��*j�v���|h~��*j�v�x�j6~zi�vf�§{ �_|h~fª9��~zi|h©��'xz�§�_{ü¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 21: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

��� � � � ��» �a k£_¢h� » À » ��£[¡ ���  ¿"�¥ j��wj�3�{hjôx�e�jp¦P����*?��~z��|h{P�&+��'¬ �m �_v�P

m N����

> @ O M �>���

�� � @

dfe�jv�u?v�x�jai ��ª ©§�«{hj��[~z�§µaja�ùÄJ|h©«j6~�ja�X|��[x��«��{�v¬�� xzeùx��«ikj ��{��ùv������6jC�wj6�Fj6{P�wj6{Xx�v��_|h~z�6j�x�ja~�i�v�«v��~�j�v��6~��«¦Pj���_v

� �� &H � [ M �zH E \

� Q H � [ � �zH \� �

N����������a[�� & \ � [ `�� [ M d f � d \ \ N� E� &

H � [ M�E H�� \� Q H � � E

� �N

� * y M�������� [�� & \ H l �M Q �! #" [�� & \ y l �! $" [�� & \ Q H l � M%�! #"1[�� & \ � , � [ `�� � M d f � d \� � &H � M E f

� Q� [ � H&� \

� �N

� * y � �'������[�� & \ H l M � �( $" [�� & \ Q H l �� �( $"L[�� & \ � y l �! $" [�� & \ � , � [ `)� � M d f � d \� �� &H � [ M �nH�E \

� Q H � [ � �nH \� �

N*�+������� [�� & \ � [ `)� [ M d f � d \<\·S����¹

dfehj��«{h�§x����[©Q���'xz����v�xz�A*�j6{ ja�X|���©3x���µaj6~z�xze��'x ��v

� [ O e Q e � \ N O e E+[ O e Q e � \ N O e [ O e Q e � \ N O e �1[ O e Q e � \ N O ·S�X��¹dfehjp~zjav�|h© xz�§{����§{�� xz�«��©F¦F��|�{��h�[~zuk±'�[©«|hjn�h~z��¦�©§jai ·S���;¹´®Å·9�X�_¹"e��_v@xzehj ª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{����[{P�[©«u_xz�«�a�[©Fv��_©§|w®

xz�§�_{� [ Q e � e & \ N,�-�! #" [�� & \ � [ `�� [ M d f � d \ \E+[ Q e � e & \ N y M �-�! #" [�� & \ � [ `�� [ M d f � d \ \ [ Q e � e & \ N y � �-�( $" [�� & \ � [ `)� [ M d f � d \$\� [ Q e � e & \ N �G[ Q e � e & \ @

·S� ' ¹

dfehjC���[~�x����*|h©��[~z�§xyu��[ª�x�e��«v�v��_©§|hx��«��{¶�«v�x�e��[x�§x�«v�� ª9|h{��*x��«��{ù��ª 3P{h� xzjCv������6j°v�|h���P�_~�x�¯ dfe��«v��~��_�Pja~�xyu���v�j*²w�Fja�*x�ja�Cx�����~�ja±�j6{Xxfª9~z��i xz~��_|h¦h©«jav��*�_{h{hj��Åx�j��C¬��§x�e ª9~zj6jô¦F��|h{����[~zuC�*�_{��w�§x��«��{�va¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 22: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �06

��� � � � � ¿ À ���£_¢w  ¿ � ¿��  ! � » �   »�� ¡'¢w  ¿"� ��¡ ¿ £ » À ü¡ »� j*x�|�v�v�x�|��hu°x�e�jÃxz�§ikj��«{Xx�j6�_~z�[x��«��{�[ªQxzehjôja�X|��[x��«��{�v�v�uwvyxzj6ir·9�P��¹*¯J³´xf��vfja�_v�u°x��k±�ja~��§ª9ukx�e��[x�x�ehj|Pv�|���© �_�[ikj�v��_{°�h~z�?�6ja�w|�~�j�·S�_¹/�h~z�'±?�«�wj�v��eh�«��eC�_~z�hj6~��[ªüxz�§ikj��[�h��~��;²w�«ik�[x��«��{��_{h©§u�ª9�_~��_~z�h�§{���~�u©«�«{hja��~��w�1;Fja~�ja{Xx����[©Fja�X|��'xz�§�_{�v@��ª(ª9��~zi � � � � & N � � H� & ·S¬�ehj6~zj � �[{P� � ��~�jÃ�*��{Pvyx��[{Xxzv�¹@��{��k��{h©«uxzehj�v�ja�*�_{����~��wj6~�ª9��~ ��{?u°�[xzehj6~�~z�§�_eXx�e���{�� v����wjô�[ª�x�e�j FGIÃÄ�¯

³ {U����ja{hj6~��[©��6��v�j��«{��*©«|��w�«{h�Cx�ehj�±'�[©«�«�h�[x��«��{ xzjav�xô�a��v�j���¬�jeP�;±�j�xzehj�ª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{��°��~��w�«{��[~zu �h� ªß®ª9ja~�ja{Xx����[©(ja�X|��[x��«��{�v

� m� & N � [ m \ H s+[ & \ ·S���X¹

¬�e�j6~zj��¨��v �� ��» ¢w¡ �w�1;Fja~�ja{Xx����[©?���Fj6~��'xz��~���{�� s+[ & \ ��v�x�ehjfv��_|h~��*j@xzj6~zi �Q¿"�(½ �� ��» ¢w¡ � ¼ À » � » � À » �  ¿"�   � » & ��{�� � À » � »�� À »��   ¿"�  �� » � ¿ � Q  ¿ � m�¯

³ {°�_~z�hj6~@xz��h~z�'±?�«�hj eh�«��eC�_�6�*|�~z�_�*u�_~z�hj6~���¬�jÃv�eh��|h©��kik�w�w� ª9ukxzehj �_�[ikj�v��_{kx��«i�jÃ�§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{ª9�_~"x�ehj �a��v�jf�[ªP{���{h©«�§{�ja�[~J�_{ & v���|h~��*j�x�ja~�i�va¯Q³ {��w�_�§{h��v�����v"|�v�|��[©«©«u���©«j*x@|PvJ�[�h�h©«u�xzehj d��;uX©«��~�j*²?®�P�[{�v��§�_{k�[ª3ª9|h{��*x��«��{ � �wj�3�{�ja�k¦?u�xzehjnj��_|P�'x��«��{1·S���X¹*��~zj6�h©����6jfx�ehjÃ�*��~z~zjav��P�_{��w�«{h�px��«i�jn��~����w�«j6{Xxzv¦?ux�ehja�§~p±'�[©«|hjav xz�A*�j6{¨ª9~��_i&·S���X¹n�[{�� ~zja��~�~��[{���jpx�ehjx�ja~�i�va¯ Á vp�°~zjav�|h©§xa�Px�ehjx��«i�j��§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{xzja��eh{��«�X|hj��6��{¦Fjôª9��~zi|�©«�[x�ja� ��v�xzehjôª9��©«©«�'¬��§{h�k©«�'¬ v�x���~��[�_jÃi�|h©§x��§®´v�xz����j�·Sl ®´v�xz����j�¹���©§�_��~z� xzehi

m ��� N m "m �$#% N m �$� H v &

W y ( H > � * m �$# ` j , H [ W y ( \� #� �� j v'& �[ W y ( H � \�� �

� `1j s� & � ` j e ( N >C@�@�@ W

m " f j N m �/.0 ·S�X��¹

��� � �� � �� » ¡ 9£�¢ ��¡ » � �ß ��dfe�j°x�j�vyx��*�_{��w�§x��«��{�v��[~zj�ª9|h~�x�ehja~�v��Fja�6�93�j��ù¦?uù��eh�?�_v��§{h� M N � N�O @ � ��� � [�� ��� \ ��{�� �NO @ O�O l � � N O @1>_¯@dQ¬���±'�[~z�«��{Xxzvf�[~zj��*��{Pv����wj6~zja�ü¯/dfehj6u�w�9;3j6~Ã��{h©«u°¦?u°xzehj���eh�_�«�6j��[ª�ª9~�j��_|�j6{��6u ��«{ù·9� ' ¹��[{�� �w�1;Fja~�ja{Xx 3�{��[©3xz�§ikj�v �� � " ��� P

� d�Ä/swd �AP � N l � O @ O > l �h� N l � � � N���O @§� � � " ��� N l O @� d�Ä/swd ��P � N l � O @2>�� N l � � � N > O @«� � � " ��� N � O @

dfe�j��§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{ e���vn¦Pjaj6{¨�w�_{hj�¦F�[x�e-���6�6��~��w�«{h��x���xzehj�xzja��eh{h���X|hjC·S�X��¹ �[{����6�*©���vzv����6��©��nª9��|�~�xze�_~z�hj6~���|h{h�_j*®��ô|wx�x���i�j6x�eh�w� ¬��§x�e x�ehj�|�{h�«�X|hj � �_|h~��[{Xx�{?|hi�¦Pja~�ja�X|���©3x�� O @ l �h¯Á ©§©�xzehj��6��ik�h|wx��'x��«��{Pvne��;±_j�¦Fj6j6{U�w��{�j��{-~�ja��|h©��[~ni�j�v�e�jav�·S�*�X�[~�v�j_� v Q N v�� N l @F��{��?3P{hj��v Q N v�� N >A@ê¹/¬��§x�e xzehj�|�v�j��[ªRMf��~�xze �6j6©«©«va¯Á v�x�|P�wu°�[ª�x�e�j��*��ik�h|hxz�'xz�§�_{��[©ü�_�6�6|h~z�_�*uk��v��h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��C¬��§x�e x�e�j�|�v�jô��ª�xzeh~�jaj��w�9;3j6~zj6{Xx {h�_~�i�va�

� E � � N���� �j"! � ! . � y � � M � � F e� E � b N .#� j � y � � M � � F %$ ��� � [ ] � \ e� E � d N'& .#� j � y � � M � � F � $ ��� � [ ] � \)(j � ·S�_�_¹

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 23: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

¬�e�j6~zj $ ��� � [ ] � \ ��v �*�_ik�h|wx�j�� ¬�� xze x�ehj Mf�[~�x�e1�6j6©«©ü���wxz�§�_{ü¯ Á { {?|hikja~����6��©ü���6�6|h~����*u��_~z�hj6~��U�«v�a�[©��*|h©��'xzja�¦?u�x�ehjôª9�_©§©«�'¬��«{h�ª9�_~�i�|h©���v

� N y��" � � y � � M � � F ���������� � y �

" � � y � � M � � F �������� � �������" [ �VQ \��������� � y �

" [ � Q \������� � ���� � ·S� �[¹¥ j��*�_i��P�[~zj:3�~�v�x�x�ehjôxy¬���x�jav�x �6�_v�j�vf¬�� xzexzehj�¦Fjav�xnv���ehjaikj��h�*�_~�~zjav��F��{��w�«{h�x�� � N O ¯

³ {Ud���¦h©«javÃ��[{P�-�w�3¬�j�_j*x��*��{O3�~�i��[x��«��{ x�eP�'xpx�eh��vôv���ehjaikj���vn��ª�v�� ²?x�e-��~��wj6~p���a�*|h~����6u ��{��¨�§xzv�«ik�h©«j6ikj6{Xxz�[x��«��{ �«v ±;��©§���h�[x�ja�ü¯

� ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~�~z��~� �_��~zv�j �h¯ 6���� I ® � � ��¯ ���[� In® � ' �h¯ê���[�AIn®´�X�B��«{hj �h¯«�����AI ® ��� ��¯ �_�[�AIn® �_� �h¯ �X� ��In®´� �

l |hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~ �w¯ � ��� �w¯ ���?� �h¯ 6X���d��[¦h©«jô�<P IÃj6{Pv��§xyuCja~�~z��~�v@ª9�_~�� N O P � N O @ O > l � l � � N ��O @

� ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~�~z��~� �_��~zv�j �h¯ê�[� ��I ® � � ��¯ � ' ��In® �[� �h¯ ' �X��In®´�_�

B��«{hj �h¯ ' �[� I ® �A6 ��¯ �_� ��In® ��� �h¯ �_� ' In®´�_�

l |hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~ �w¯ �_�[� �w¯ê���[� �h¯ �C�?�d��[¦�©§j���P Inja{�v�� xyuj6~z~��_~zv/ª9��~�� N O P � N O @1> l � � N > O @

¥ j°���h�hja�-x�ehj°�6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{U��ª�d�Ä/shd!�k¬��§x�e¶xzehj°�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«±�jk±_j6~�v��«��{ü�(�N¯ j�¯°¬��§x�e � N >�¯d��[¦�©§j��k�w��v��h©��;uwv�x�ehj�~zjav�|h©§xzv�xze��'x�±'�[©«�«���'x�jôxzehjôx�e�j6��~zj*xz�«�a�[©(�[{P�[©«u?v���vp· 3hªßx�e1�_~z�hj6~Źů

s?�_ikjô�6��ikikj6{Xxzv��a�[{¦Pj�i����hj�¯Jdfehjôi��[�«{�F���«{Xxf��v�x�eP�'xfx�ehjôj6²?�Fja�*x�j�� �_�6�6|h~z�_�*uk��vf±�j6~z�13�ja�(¯¥ jôj6ik�he��_v��«µ6jpxze��'xfx�e��«vf±'�[©«���h�'xz�§�_{ �w�?j�vf{h�[x��«{��*©«|��wjpx�e�jp¦F��|�{��h�[~zu°~zj6�_�§�_{ü�Xv��«{��*jô��|�~ v��_©§|wxz�§�_{��vf±�ja~�u°v�i��[©«©3{hja��~�xzehj�¦F��|h{����[~zu�¯ Q �'¬�j6±_j6~���xzehjôx�~zja�[x�ikj6{Xxf�[ª�~zj�+Pja�Åxz�§{���¬f�[©«©(�*�_|h©«�¬��§x�e1v��_ikjvz��ehjai�j�v/¦Fj��*�_i���|wx�j��C¬��§x�e eh�«��ew®´��~��wj6~����a�*|h~����6u�¯�³ {C��|�~��_�wx��«��{Pv6�Xx�e�jp��~��_�P�Xv�j��°v���e�j6ikjÃ��v�{h�[x��¦h©«jxz� �h�Cxzeh�«va�Qja±�ja{�¬��§x�e¶� �a�[~�x�j�v����[{¨ikj�v�eü¯�dfeh��v��w�«vz���h±;��{Xxz�[�_j��vpx�ehjk~zjav�|h©§xô��ª/��|�~ô�hjav��§�_{

ó È�û ó æ

Page 24: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �h�

� ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~�~z��~� �_��~zv�j �h¯ � ' � I ® ��� ��¯ ���A6AIn® �_� �h¯ê���w�7In®´���B��«{hj �h¯ê�[�[�#I ® � � ��¯ ���_�AIn® �[� �h¯ �_�[� In®´�_�

l |hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~ ��¯ 6��_� �w¯ ���h� �P¯ 6_���

d��[¦h©«j��OP IÃj6{Pv��§xyuCja~�~z��~�v@ª9�_~�� N >.P � N O @ O > l � l � � N ��O @�_�wx��«��{Pv6��¦h|wx�¬�j°~zja�a�[©«©Jx�eP�'x�_|h~�x��[~z��j*x�6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{ù�«v����*�_|�v�x����6v��«{­�*�_ik�h©§j6²-�_j6��ikj6x�~zu-�[{P��«{U��j6{�j6~��[©�x�ehj�ikj�v�e¶¬��«©§©J{h��x�¦Pj°�a�[~�x�j�v����[{-�§{-x�ehj°�h�§~zja�*xô±?���*�«{h�§xyu��[ª�x�ehj�¬f�[©«©�v6�ü¦�|wx�� x�a�[{U¦Pj�a�[~�x�j�v����[{�§{ x�e�j�~�j�vyx��[ª�x�ehj��6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��[©ü�w�_i��[�«{ü¯

��" ! (/? * � ��* �L( � �Á v�ja�*�_{��kxzjav�xf�a��v�jn��v/{h�'¬ �*��{Pv����wj6~zja�k�«{C�_~z�hj6~�x���v�x�|P�wukx�ehjô���a�*|h~����6u���ªüx�e�jÃ�h~z���F�_v�ja��vz��ehjai�j�_{1�ki��_~�jôxyu?�h���6��©Q���6��|�v�x����p�h~z��¦h©«j6i ¯fdfehj��h~z��¦h©«j6i x��Cv���©«±�jô��vfxz�A*�j6{ ª9~z��i x�ehj���� ������� � � �� ����0������ ��� �:��� �� %&������ ���#���1��% �n� � � ��%,�!���L��� � ��� ��� �:�����0�A��������� � ����� � �,��� ehja©«�1�«{ QÃ�[ik�w®xz��{ü���Ã�§~z���«{h�����§{4Fp�Åxz��¦Fj6~n�[�[®y�[�h�F�76 6[� · -«�a��/9¹Å¯

��� � � � ��» �a k£_¢h� » �´¿ ¡ � ��9¢w ! ¿"�¥ j��h|wxn���_���§{

m N����

>A@ O M �>���

�� �

��{��Cx�ehj�±_ja�Åxz��~��*�_ik�P�_{hj6{Xxzvf��ª��«{h�§x����[©Q�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�p�w��vyxz|h~z¦��[{��6jav���~�j��wj�v��6~��«¦Pj���_v

� [ Q e � e O \ N�� ��� [ y �" l� [ Q � H � � \$\ H O @2> � ���L[ y �

" ll � [ [ Q y (�� \ � H � � \<\E+[ Q e � e O \ N O @ O � � � ��� [ y �

" ll � [ [ Q y (�� \ � H � � \<\ [ Q e � e O \ N y O @ O � [ Q y (�� \ � ��� [ y �

" ll � [$[ Q y (�� \ � H � � \$\� [ Q e � e O \ N�� ��� [ y �

" l� [ Q � H � � \ \ @

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 25: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�_� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

dfe��«vf�«{h�§x����[©ü¦F��|h{P�h�[~zu°±'�[©«|hjô�h~z��¦h©«j6i eP��v�x�e�jôª9��©«©§�'¬��«{h���[{���©§uXxz�«�a�[©(v��_©§|hx��«��{

Ek[ Q e � e & \ NQ y M &l �

" ll ����!> H O @ O � [ � y � & \ � Q � [ y �

" ll � [ [ Q y (�� y M & \ � H [ � y � & \ � \$\

[ Q e � e & \ N�

l �" l� �

� > H O @ O � [ � y � & \ � Q � [ y �" ll � [$[ Q y (�� y M & \ � H [ � y � & \ � \$\

�1[ Q e � e & \ N >l �" l�

� l

�G[ Q e � e & \ N-� H O @2> � ���L[ y �" ll � [$[ Q y ( � y M & \ � H � � \ \

·S�_�_¹

¬�e�j6~zj

� > [ Q e � e & \ N�

� � ��� [ y y � ���" l \�� j [�� � \ � �( $" � & ���

� l [ Q e � e & \ N�

� � ��� [ y y � ���" l \�� � [�� � \ � ����� � & � �

� � �[{P� � jp�[~zjnxzehj��*�_~�~zjav��P�_{��w�«{h�.M�j�v�v�j6©3ª9|�{��Åxz�§�_{�v6¯��� � � � C» �� ��ß ��dfe�j�ª9��©«©«�'¬��§{h�°x�jav�xp�a��v�javÃ�[~zj�*�_{�v����wja~�j��(¯ ³ {1xzehj 3P~zv�xnxzjav�xÃ�h~z��¦h©«j6i ·Ød�Ä/swd ' ¹�x�ehj�ikja��{?+��'¬±_j6©«�w�*�§x��«jav��[~zj M N O @ �w� � N�O @ O ¬�eh����e �6��~z~�j�v��F��{���v�xz��xzehj1�6��v�jC��ªp� � e���~z�§µa��{Xxz��©�¬��«{����ª9~z��i x�ehj�©§j6ªßxa¯�³ { xzehj�v�ja�6��{��x�j�vyxp�h~z��¦h©«j6i&·Sd�Ä/swd �?¹�x�e�jav�j�±�ja©§�w�*�§x��«javn�[~zj M N�O @ � ����� � � � � � M N O @ � ��� � � � � � ¬�e��«��eù�*�_~�~zjav��F��{��hvpxz�¨� � �h�«������{P�[©J¬��«{����üª9~z��i x�ehj�©«j*ªßx�¦P��x�x��_i&�6��~z{hj6~���ª�¶�6��ik�h|wx��'x��«��{P�[© �w�_ik���§{Q¯ M��[x�e �h~z��¦�©§jaikv���~�j1v���©«±�j��A�«{ �Uvz�X|��[~zj�QLj N y > O�O �^Q � N > O�O �� j N y > O�O � � � N > O�O ¯

Á xyu?�h���6��©ü{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©3~�j�v�|�© x ��vf~�ja�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��°ª9�_~fx�ehj��wja{�v�� xyu �w�«v�x�|�~�¦���{��*j�v��§{?B��§�_|h~zj��6��¯Jdfehjv���©«|wxz�§�_{ �6|wxzv���~�jô���«±�ja{ �[xfx�ehj�vz�[ikjG3h²wja�x��«ikj�ik��ikj6{Xx & N � O ¯��� � �� � ¿ � » £ ¿ � � »��  a� ¿ � ¡ » � �ß ��dfe�jô��¦P�'±_jô~�j�v�|h©§xzvf©«ja�_�°xz��x�ehjôª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{��k�6��ikikj6{Xxzva¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 26: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� � '

� �[~�x�jav����[{ i�j�v�e mn{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j�� i�j�v�ed�jav�x�� dQj�vyx '

� �_�[~�v�jÃikjav�e B��«{hj�ikjav�e � �_��~zv�jpi�j�v�e B��«{hj�ikjav�e���_�[���Ã{��?�hjav �_���_�h�Ã{h�w�wjav 6�� 6 ' {h�w�wjav ' 6_�_����{h�w�wjav

o � ��� N > � @ � > O > O ` j >A@ � � (� > O `1j >A@ O > � > O � > @ � O ( > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �h¯ ' 6 ' ��¯ 6A6o � ��� N O > @ l O l > O � >A@ � O (� > O `1j >A@ l ���# > O � � @ � � � > O ` �l |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ ' ¯ ���_� �w¯ê�'�M � �� N > ��@ ��l � > O ` j >A@ O � � > O `1j >A@ O�O � > O � > @ � l O > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �h¯ 6X��� ��¯ 6 �M � �� N O � @ ( � � > O ` j ��@ l > �# > O ` � >A@ l�� � > O � > @ � � � > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �P¯ �X� ' ��¯ 6��

� �_i��P���Åx�®´� ��· � �_¹ O @ ��>�� > O � O @ � � �# > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ ' ¯ �X� 'Ip� � · � ��¹ O @ ���� > O � O @ � � > > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �h¯ � �?�

d��[¦�©§j ��PGInja{�v��§xyu � �Cj6~z~z��~�v�ª9��~pª9�_|h~ô±�j6~�v��§�_{�v ��ª@x�ehjk�h~zjav�j6{Xxzja��vz��ehjai�j_�(�د j�¯¬�� xzeU�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{�P�[~��[ikj*xzj6~��v�j*x j��_|P�[©Fx��?>��[{P�°xz� O �h�[{��¬��§x�e1�*ja©§©Qv�e����Pj�vf�[ª�ikj��w�«��{Cxyu?�Fj°·Øo � ¹��_~f�[ª M���~�xzexyu?�Fj1· M � ¹Å¯üdfehjk~zjav�|h©§xzvô�[~zj��6��ik����~�j��1¬�� xze�xzehj���{�javp�[ª��a�[~�x�j�v����[{U�6�[©��*|�©«�[x��«��{�v -§���7/@¬��§x�eUx�ehj|Pv�jô�[ª�ª9��|�~�xzew®N�_~z�hj6~f�*��ik���_�Åx 3�{h�§x�j6®´�h�9;3j6~zj6{��6j��[{�� Ip� � v���e�j6ikjava¯

� l |hikja~����6��©h���6�6|h~����*uô�_~z�wja~"±;��~��«jav�ª9~z��i l @ �Ãx�� �<@«�[¦h|hx@i��XvyxJ��ªPikja�_v�|h~zj6ikja{_x�v���~�j�{h��x�ª9|�©§©«u�wj6ik�_{�vyxz~z�[x��«±�j�v��§{��6jpx�ehj�~zjav�|h©§xzvf��{x�e�j��*�_��~zv�jpi�j�v�e�javf�«{X±_��©«±�jp�_vz�*�«©§©��'xz�§�_{�va¯

� dfehj�Mf�[~�x�e¶�*ja©§©J�_�wx��«��{U¦Pjae��;±�j�vp¦Pj6x�x�ja~��«{-xzehj°�6��~�xzjav��«��{-�a��v�j���{��-v�©«�§�_e_xz©§u�¬��_~zv�j��«{Ux�ehj|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja� �6�_v�j_¯

� l |hikja~����6��©P�w��v�v��«���'xz�§�_{��«ik�h~z�'±�javJx�ehjnv���©«|wxz�§�_{k�X|���©§�§xyu���{�v��_ikjn�*�X�[~�v�jfikjav�ehjav/¦h|wx/{��[x/�_{�[©«©ü�[ª�x�ehjai ¯

� dfehj��6��ik����~���v��_{ô¦Pj6xy¬�jaj6{�|h{�v�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja�ôikjav�ehj�v���{���vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j��ô��{hj�vü��vü�F�_vzv��«¦h©«j/v��«{��6j@x�j�vyx�6�_v�j�v ' �[{��C���[~zjn��ªQja�X|h�«±'�[©«j6{Xx��h�98°�*|�© xyu_¯J³´x���v�{h�[x�v����wj*ªS�;±_��|h~��[¦�©§jfxz�xzehjÃ|�{�vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j���6�_v�j_¯ dfehj�ja~�~z��~��_{ù�*�_��~zv�jkikjav�ehjav��h�9;3j6~�v��_j6{hja~z��©§©«u¨�[ªf��{�©§u¶� ª9j6¬ �F��|h~��*ja{_x�v6¯?FÃ{¶x�ehj3�{hj1ikjav�ehj�v6�/x�ehj1v�ik��©§©«jav�x�|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja� j6~z~��_~ · � @ � > O ` � ¹���vk{h�[xkxy¬����*j ©��[~z��j6~�x�eP�[{¸x�ehj¦Pj�vyxnv�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja���{hj°· ��@ l > O ` � ¹*¯J³ { i��Xvyxn�6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{�_{Cxzehj�|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja�i�j�v�e�java�wx�ehj�_vz�*�«©§©��'xz�§�_{�vk�[~zj�_¦�v�j6~z±�ja�­�'x�©§j���v�x���{ x�ehj1�*�X�[~�v�jikjav�ehjava�/¦h|hx�x�ehj {?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©f��~��wja~���ª���a�*|h~����6u°vyx��;u?vf{��[xz��¦h©«u°©«��~��_j6~�x�e���{ l ¯

� dfehj�xzjav�x��6�_v�j���vJ~��'x�e�j6~@¬�j6©«©��*�_ik�h|wx�j��k¬�� xzekx�ehjÃ�6�[~�x�j�v����[{ 3�{hjni�j�v�eQ¯$FÃ|�~/v���e�j6ikj��«v@¬�ja©§©�*�_i��P�[~zja��¬�� xze�x�e�jÃv�xz�[{P�h�[~��kv���ehjaikjavJª9�_~�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja����~��6�[~�x�j�v����[{kikjav�ehj�vn· Ip� �Avz��ehjai�j-§��/N�Ã�*��ik���_�ÅxC��|�{h��j6®��ô|wx�xz�ùikj6x�eh�w� -«��7/9¹Å¯ ¥ j-j6ik�he��_v��«µ6j1xze��'x{h��{hj-�[ªôx�e�j-vz��ehj6ikjavx�e��[x�¬��_v�x�~z�«ja�¨�_{¨xzeh�«vô�a��v�j��*�_|h©��¨�h~z�w�w|��*j��C{?|hikja~����6��©��_~z�wja~Ã��ª����a�*|h~����6u �6©§�Xv�jx��x�ehj

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 27: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�[� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

-0.06

-0.04

-0.02

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

-100 -50 0 50 100

Den

sity

per

turb

atio

n

x

Calculation

Exact

B��«��|h~zj��a�<P ��� � ��� � �k£ ¿ Q�a  9£ ¾ ¢�� » � � À 9¢ �F¿"� ¢ � ¾ � À �s?x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��Cikj�v�eü� � N O �wikja�h�«��{ �6j6©«©«v�·S�_���_�h�Ã{h�w�wjav�¹

x�ehja��~zj*xz�«�a�[©���{hj_¯ôdfe��«vp��vÃj6²w�h©«���§{�ja�1¦?u x�ehj���~���v��«{h�°��ª��wj6xz�[�«©�vn�«{¨xzehj�j6²h���Åxôv��_©§|hx��«��{¨xze��'x�[~zj�v�i��[©«©«j6~�x�e���{ x�ehj�ikjav�e1v��«µ6j_�h�'x�©«ja��v�x�ª9��~fxzehj��*�X�[~�v�jÃikjav�eü¯

� ³´x/v�e���|h©���¦Pj�{h��x�j���xze��'xJxzehj�j*²h���*x@v��_©§|wxz�§�_{���vJ�_�§±_j6{�_{h©«u��vJ��v���©«|wx��«��{��[ªF©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja��ÄJ|h©«j6~ja�X|��[x��«��{�vp�[{����6�[{�{h�[xp¦Pjk�*�_{�v����wja~�j��¨��vÃ�°�he?uwv����6��©��_{hj�¯ôdfeh��v ªS�_�Åxô�«vp�wjai��_{�v�x�~��'x�j��1�«{B��§�_|h~�jC����¬�ehja~�jôxzehj�~zjav�|h© xÃ�[ªJ|�v��§{h��{���{h©«�§{�ja�[~ÃÄJ|h©«j6~nik�w�wja©Q��v ~zj6�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��(¯fdfehj��eh�_�«�6j�[ªüi��'xzehj6i��[x����6�[©Pik�?�hj6©Pª9��~@xzehjÃ�_�*�_|�vyxz�«� ¬��;±_jav@�wj�v��6~��«�wxz�§�_{��«v/±�j6~zu��§ik�F��~�xz�[{Xx�v��«{��*j ja±�ja{�§{°x�ehjô�6�_v�j ��ª(~z�[x�ehja~�v�ik��©§©3�w��vyxz|h~z¦��[{��6jav@x�ehjé§�«{hja��~/ik�w�wj6©�v��6�[{���~��w�w|��6j ±�ja~�u��«{����a�*|h~��'xzj~�j�v�|�© x�v�·Sv�j6j&-«�6��/´� -«���0/9¹Å¯

� � � #$���")*����U���°�����")6#$� ���� )6� 1T�dfe�j/xzjav�xJ�a��v�j���v�x�e�jf�h�§~zja�*x"�_�h�[�wx��'xz�§�_{�[ª�x�ehj��6�_v�j��h~zjav�j6{Xx�j����«{���¯§�_¯ ¥ jf|�v�j��Ã|h{h���X|hj��*��ik�h|hxz�'®xz�§�_{��[©F�w��i����§{kª9�_~@x�e�~�jajn�*�_i���|wxz�[x��«��{�va¯"³´x/�«v/x�e�jn����~z��©§©«j6©«���h�«�Fja� _ y > O�O e > O�O h �_ y l e l h �_ y l e l h ¯o1jav�ehjav��_� �h� ' ��~�j �wj�3�{hj���ª9~��_i ikjav�e°v��«µ6j�v�� � ���X�h¯ê�ô�[{��k�h¯ê���h¯�³ { ���ô¬�j �wja�h���Åx@xzehj � � {X|�i�ja~�®���6��©"��~��wj6~���vô�ª9|h{��*x��«��{U�[ª�x��«i�jkª9�_~px�ehj��*�_i¦h�«{��[x��«��{���ª�{hja¬ �6|h¦Pj°v��h©«� x�x��«{h�����$� �[{P��{hja¬

ó È�û ó æ

Page 28: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �_�

-0.06

-0.04

-0.02

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

-150 -100 -50 0 50 100 150

Den

sity

per

turb

atio

n

x

Nonlin. (calc.)

linear’d (anal.)

B��«��|h~zj­�;��P ��� � � � � ��¿ � ��¢w¡ 9� ¿ � � »   ¾»?»�� �� ��» ¢w¡ 9� » À � ¢ � ¢ � ¼  ! 9£�� � ¿ � Q  ¿ � ¢ � À��¿"� �� �Q» ¢w¡ � ¢ � �Q¡ ¿�� �¶¢h  » � ¿ ��»�6j6©«©«v �����C¯ Á ªßx�ja~nv��_ikjô�_�h�[�hx��«��{ �w|hjôx���v��§{���|h©��[~ v�xz��~�xz�§{h�P�?x�ehj�{?|hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~f��v �*�_{�3�~zi�j���_v��*©«�_v�jnxz�C�w¯

� � �����a�C��)*��

¥ jCeP�;±�j��h~z���F�_v�ja�¶�¨{�j6¬ ªS�[ik�«©§u¶�[ª vz��ehj6ikj�v�ª9��~x�ehj©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja�ùÄJ|�©§ja~ja�X|��[x��«��{�v¬�� xzeh��|hx���~¬��§x�e1v���|h~��*j�v6¯

dfehj���~��_�P�Xv�j��vz��ehj6ikj�v��6�[{ ¦Fj��[�h��©§�«ja�x���|�{�vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j��Cxz~����[{���|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6¯@dfe�j6u��~�j��[xf©«ja�_vyxv�ja�6��{��w®N�_~z�wja~����a�*|h~��'xzj��J�[{��¶�«{?±��_©§±_jC� x�|�{��[¦h©«jv�i��[©«©�v�xz��¦h�«©§��v��[x��«��{¶xzj6~zi&i��_�wj°¬��§x�e ��v��§²?x�ew®�_~z�hj6~��wj6~z�«±;�[x��«±�j_¯"dfe�j����6�6|h~����*uk��v�i|P��e¦Fj*x�x�j6~ x�e��[x�ª9��~�|�v�|��[©üv�ja�6��{��w®N�_~z�wja~�vz��ehjai�j�v6¯dfe�j�v���e�j6ikjav���©«v��ùj6{'�y�'u¸v�|��Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6j�h~z���Fj6~�x��«jav°��{ �6��~�xzjav��«��{ ikjav�ehj�v6�f|h� xz�­�ùv�i���©§©±?���*�«{h�§xyu°�[ª�x�ehj�¦F��|�{��h�[~zu�¯@s?|��Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6jn��~��wja~���ª"�_�6�6|h~z�_�*u��6��{ ¦Pj���vfe��§�_e �_v ����~�(h¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 29: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

3.6

3.8

4

4.2

4.4

4.6

4.8

5

5.2

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

dx=4,2dx=2,1

B��§�_|h~�jk���OP ' I vz��ehjai�j.PJ{?|hikj6~z���6�[©3�_~z�wja~���v�ª9|h{��*x��«��{ �[ª�x��«ikj

dfeh��vp��~��wj6~Ã�[ª��_�6�6|h~z�_�*u �«vÃ��¦Pv�ja~�±_ja� ª9��~��_�weh�w��xzjav�xô�a��v�java¯GB���~ô�°¦��_v�����_�*��|Pvyxz�«�av xzjav�xô�a��v�j·H-§����/9¹Å��x�ehj����6�6|h~����*un�«vQ���?�w�Ã�_{��6�[~�x�j�v����[{ôikjav�ehj�vü�[{���v�x��«©«©�~��'x�e�j6~(���?�w�p��{�|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja�pikjav�ehj�v6¯

B�|h~�xzehj6~�j6²w�Pja~��«ikj6{Xxzvô��ª/x�e�j°v���ehjaikjav��[~zj��§{U�h~z����~zjavzva¯³ {U���[~�x����*|h©��[~��3x�e�j°�*��ik�h|hxz�'xz�§�_{-��ªxzjav�xn�6�_v�jp��{1���6��|�v�x����ì��;±_jav��§{ {h�_{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi +��'¬ v 3�j6©��hv���vf�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��C�«{ -§�a��/´� -§�;�0/´¯

dfehjn�h~��_�P�Xv�j���vz��ehjai�j�v@�[���Pj��[~/v�|h�§xz�[¦�©§jfª9�_~@x�e�jn���w±_ja�*x��«��{����[~�xzv@��©«v��ô¬�� xze°{h�_{h©§�«{hj��[~ +�|w²wj�v6¯dfe�j/v���ikj@���[�Fj6~�v@·H-§�a��/N��-«���0/9¹ü�6��{�v����wj6~(xzehj�vz��ehjai�jJik�w�w�13P�6�[x��«��{��_�6�*�_|h{Xx��«{h�fª9��~�{h��{�©§�«{hja��~üj�;3ja�*xzv�«{C�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�n¬��;±_jav@�wu?{���ik�«�av6¯ Á v��Fja�*���[©«©«u�ja©«��¦P�_~z�[x�j���x�jav�x��a��v�jn��v��6��ik�h|wxzja�(¯JdfehjÃ~�j�v�|�© x�v�v�eh�'¬xzehj��w�1;Fja~�ja{��*j��«{1©«�§{hj��[~ ��{�� {h��{�©§�«{hja��~�ik�?�hj6©�v ��vf¬�j6©«©Q��v�x�ehj��F�_vzv��§¦h�«©«� xyu°��ªJ{hj6�X�'x��«±�jô�«{�+�|hja{��*j��ª�~z��|h{P�C�A;�j6~z~��_~zva¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 30: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� � �

� ��%'����� �C�����

-«��/ � ¯ �k¯ ¥ ¯üd���i � ��¯ � ¯ ¥ ja¦h¦ü� IÃ��v��Fj6~�v��«��{h®´��ja©«�[x��«��{w® �J~zjav�j6~z±?�§{h��B��«{h�§x�j&In�1;3j6~zj6{��6jksw��e�j6ikjavª9��~ � �_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���© Á �*��|Pvyxz�«�av6¯�� ������� ��� ��� � ��%:� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� ��� � �����(�����h�*®y�[�����P�76A6 ' ¯

-ê��/���¯ Á ¦h��~��[©«©N¯ Á { j�v�v�j6{Xx����[©«©«uù{h��{w®´�_vz�*�«©«©«�[x���~zu¶~�j��*�_{�vyxz~�|P�Åx��«��{­�h~��w�6ja�w|h~zj ��{ 3�{h�§x�j1j6©«j6ikja{_xxyu?�Pjôikjav�ehjava�?�[�h�h©«���6�'xz�§�_{°xz���*�_ik�h~�j�v�v��«¦h©§j:+��'¬ va¯ � ��%,�!���L���4������0 ��I� � � � �!� � �� �N��������@� ������ � ��"i� � ����� � ��" � � � � �(�06A6[�P��6_�;®��a����¯

- ' / B�¯�Mf��vzv��w�[{P��s3¯'��ja¦��;u�¯ Á eh�«��ew®´��~��wj6~����a�*|h~��'xzj��w��v��6��{Xx��«{?|h��|Pv 3�{�� xzj�ja©§jaikj6{Xx�ikj6x�eh�w�ª9��~�x�ehj{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©wv��_©§|hx��«��{���ªhx�ehj��6��ik�h~zjavzv��«¦h©«j/ln�;±?�«j6~�® sXxz�A*_javüj��X|��'xz�§�_{�v6¯�� ������� ���<� � � ��%,�!���L��� � ��� ���� ���� � ��� � � �F�(�76 6 �w�?��� ��®y����6h¯

- ��/ � ¯ Inja¦h�«j6µ�� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±?�§ja|w²(¯po �§²wja�¨ÄJ©«j6ikja{_x �J��©«|hikj�o1mps � � i�j6x�eh�w�hvì��§x�e¨¬�ja�A*±?��v��6�_v�� xyuª9��~ v�x�j����wuC��{�� |h{�v�x�j����wu&+P�'¬ �6��©«�6|h©��'x��«��{Q¯�� ��%:� ������� ��� ��C���C� �� ���76A6 6h� ���Q�?�A6'®������

-ê��/ � ¯ Inja¦h�§jaµ�� Á ¯ Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(� �k¯3o j6~��P��{��?Mp¯Pl��n�_{h�_��¯ � �_i���|wxz�[x��«��{1�[ªJ|h{Pvyxzja���hu�+��'¬ v�¬��§x�eik� ²wja� 3�{h�§x�j���3�{h�§x�j�j6©«j6ikj6{Xx�|h�?¬��§{���i�j6x�eh�w�hva¯�� �<�L����� ��� � ��� ��� � ������� ����������� ��%&��� � ������4��� ��7 ��� ���C���C� �� ���76 6��h� ���(�ü�06 ' ® �����h¯

- ��/ Mp¯J±'�[{ � jaj6~�¯¸d��'¬f�[~��hv�xzehj¨m ©§x��«i��'xzj � ��{�v�j6~z±'�'x��«±�j IÃ�9;3j6~zj6{��6j�sw��ehjai�j ³Å¯@dfehj �Ã|�jav�xk��ªo ��{��[x��_{h���*�§xyu�� ������������=� �������z� � � ���� � ��� �Q�76 �[�h� ���Q�w�ü¯§��� '

- �0/ Á ¯ �_�[ikjav���{ü¯ Á ~�x��13P�*���[©/�h�9;3|�v��§�_{ü��|��X¬��«{��¶¦h����v��«{h����©§�«ik� xzj6~�v�[{P��xzehj6�«~j�;Fj��Åx�_{ù���6�6|h~����*u�[{���i�|h© xz�§�_~������*��{?±_j6~z��j6{P�*j/�«{�x�~��[{�v���{h���f�[{���e?u?�Pja~zv���{h���C+��'¬ v6¯ � � �,� �O���O��������� ������� ¯ Á ³ ÁnÁ���6x�e � ��ik�h|wx��'x��«��{P�[© B�©§|��«� IÃuX{P�[ik�«�av � ��{hª9j6~zj6{��6j��!FÃ~z©«��{��w����B � �«�76 6 ' ¯

- ��/ Á ¯OInja~�±?�«j6|w²(¯JsXx�j����wu°ÄJ|�©§ja~ns?�§i�|h©��'x��«��{Pv�mÃv��«{h�km {�v�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja� o jav�ehj�v6¯ �J��{ ���[~zi��[{°³ {Pvyxz� ®x�|wxzj�ª9��~,B�©«|h���?Inu?{���ik�«�av6� � ja�*x�|h~zj�v�j6~z�§j�vô�76��X�;® �[�P� � �_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���© B�©§|h���?IÃuX{P�[ik�«�av�·y�06��X��¹Å¯��j6±?��v�j��C±_j6~�v��«��{���|h¦h©«�«v�ehja� ��vf����e��[�hx�j6~f��ª �*�"�[~�x����[© IÃ�9;3j6~zj6{Xx����[©üÄ/�_|P�'x��«��{Pv���ª�e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«���_|�jxyu?�Pj���{�� Á �h�h©«���6�'xz�§�_{�v �'�OKpj6u?ik��{��[x Ä@�(¯«� ¥ ��~z©«� sw�*�«j6{Xxz�93P���Ps?�«{h�_���P�_~�j_�3�76�� �?¯

- 6�/�dô¯5Mf�[~�x�eü¯ Á v��Pj��Åx�vÃ��ª�m {Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja� Kp~����hvp�[{�� B��«{h�§x�j6® �J�_©§|hikj�s?��©«±�ja~zv ª9��~Ãx�ehj�ÄJ|h©«j6~��[{P�ln�;±?�«j6~�® sXxz�A*_jav�Ä@�X|��'xz�§�_{�v6�?�«{ � ����� � ��� � ��������� ��� �R�O��� ���<��� ������ � � � !4������0 ��������,�, � ������ � ���� ��%n� � ���L�� "�C�1� � �$# � � �)�c����� �O�����%'&(% ���ü¯P�'®��nxz�k�[®´�����3�76 6_�h¯

-«�a��/��[® Á ¯AIÃjav��«�hj6~z�Ø� Á ¯ Kp��|P�;�y���X�[{����¯_swj6©«i��«{ü¯Fdfeh�§~��?®´��~��wj6~"{?|hikj6~z���6�[©hvz��ehjai�j�v�ª9��~@e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«����h~z��¦h©«j6i�va¯ �,����������� ���L�O����� � �g� � �)#*� ��+�,�-�% �Q�76_� �w¯

-«����/p³Å¯ Á ¦��[©���*?�«{ü� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±?�§ja|w²(�ü�[{��Udô¯ �Ã��µ6|�¦�vH*'�;uX�h� Á ±�j6~�x�j6²��*ja{_xzj6~zja��eh�§�_e��_~z�wja~�o1mÃs � �v���e�j6ikj��[�h�h©«u?�§{���xz��©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja�ÄJ|h©«j6~n�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�av6¯ �:������������ ��� �O����� � �)� � �#*� ��+/.�.���� �F�[�_�_�h¯

-«����/ô��¯ � ��~��Fj6{Xxz�§ja~a¯ � � �!������� %.��� � ��� 10 ���������1��%&���!� � � �O������� � ���<� ��� �����2+R� �A�!� � ���� � ���43? ��� � �O�������� � � � �t��� �������7� � � �2���<� ��� ����� ¯/dfehj�v���v6�hmn{h�«±�j6~�v�� xyu°��ª"ln�«�6j*®ys?����eh�«� Á {Xxz�§�F��©«�«va�ü�06A6_�h¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 31: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

-«� ' /=Q¯ ¥ | �[{�� � ¯ ¥ �[{h�P¯Ql �_{w®Nj6²w�«v�x�ja{��*jÃ�[ªüxzeh�§~��°�_~z�hj6~��_�6�6|h~z�[x�jpv�jai��§® �w�«vz�*~zj*xzjpo1mps � � ®Nxyu?�Pjv���e�j6ikjavê9��~�{���{h©«�§{�ja�[~��6��{�v�j6~z±'�'x��«��{�©«�;¬ vô�[{P�¨|h{h�13�j��U�6��{�v�x�~z|��*x��«��{���ª/eh�«��e¶���a�*|h~��'xzj�Ä@l=Fv���e�j6ikjava¯ � � � � � �<�L����� ��� � ��� ��� � ��%:�O��� � ��% ��� � ��%,�!���L��� � ��� ��� �C���C� V� ��� ��% � ��� �Qs?ja�wx�jai¦Fj6~�[® �h�(�06A6_�h� � ��*_jpd��[e��Xj_�hl ��¯

-«�6�A/p³Å¯ Á ¦���©«�A*?�§{ü� Á ¯#Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(�_dô¯ �n�_µ6|h¦PvH*'�;u_��¯ � ��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��[©Ps?x�|��wuk��ª(o1�[x�ehjai��'x����6��©Po �w�?®j6©�vfª9��~ ln����v�j IplÃs3� � � �,� ��������� �[�_�_�;®y�����_�

-«����/p³Å¯ Á ¦P�[©���*?�§{Q� Á ¯7IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h²3�'dô¯ �n�_µ6|h¦�v�*'�;u_��¯0Qn�§�_e Á �6�*|�~z�_�*uÃsXxz|��wuô�[ª�o1�[x�ehjai��'x����6��©_o �w�wja©«vª9��~ IÃlps��[ªül �_�«v�jn�[~z��|�{���s?x�ja�_�wu�o ja��{.B�©«�'¬��3�§{°�J~z�w�[¯_�[ª � ����� � ����� � �9"� � ������ )�$�2� � �>� ���1 � ���'��������� ������-�-�� � I�¯ Ä ¯��Fja� xz��|h{ü����¯/��j6~z�«��|w²(� ��¯ Á ¯$Inj�v����wja~��N�foù¯�o1�[~z�«{h�·SÄ/�hv6¯ê¹Å� � ³�o1lÃÄ��Mf�[~��*j6©«��{P�·N�[���X��¹

-«�a��/ �*³ ��Á swÄ � � �_� �$¥ ��~*wv�eh�_� ��{ M�j6{���ehi���~�* �J~��_¦h©«j6i�v �«{ � ��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��[© Á ja~��X���6��|�v�®x����6v�· ��ÁÃÁ ¹ �[�Pl Á s Á � �_{wª9j6~zj6{��6j��J|h¦h©«�«�a�'xz�§�_{ü�<Qn��ik�wx��_{ü���n�«~��_�§{��«���!Fp�Åx��_¦Pja~n�'��® ���h�F�76A6���¯

-«���/p³Å¯ Á ¦���©«�A*X�«{ü� �¯:M��_¦O*��'±3� Á ¯:IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h²3��dô¯�Ã��µa|h¦�v�*;�;uX�h� ��¯Ãs?eh�«~zu_�[ja±3�ôsXxz|��wu �[ª�e��§�_e���a�*|h~����6u �_~z�wja~ vz��ehjai�j�v��{�� {���{w®´~�j�+�ja�*x��«{h�A¦F��|h{P�h�[~zu �*��{P�w� xz�§�_{�vª9��~ {h����v�j��h~z�������_�[x��«��{�h~z��¦h©«j6i�va� � �«���h|h{h�'±­³ {�vyxz� xz|wx�j-~�ja�P�_~�x�����~����yja�ÅxJ6 6'® �_�h���[�_�h�_���;±'�[�«©��[¦h©«j ��{ P�eXx�xz� P � �;¬�¬�¬f®v��_�ü¯ �§{h~z���h¯ ª9~ �;x�~z���h���6v � Á ©«���§{ü¯ IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h² �'©§���[��|h{h�'±3¯ eXxzi�©

-«�a��/°³Å¯ Á ¦P�[©���*?�§{Q� Á ¯ Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(�_dô¯ �n�_µ6|h¦PvH*'�;u_��¯�FÃ{��_�6�*|�~z�_�*u��[ª({h�_�«v�j��w�«~�j��Åx/�6��©«�6|h©��'x��«��{k¦��_v�j����{1ÄJ|h©«j6~�ik�w�wja©Ø� � �<� + � +5�,��������� � ��� ·ßxz�°�[�h�Fja��~�¹*¯

-«�76�/�s?x�}6��e��[{hj � j6i��[�«~zj��AKp�«©§¦Fj6~�x@�����_}�¯ Á }6~z�_�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�X|hj��[�h��©§���X|h}6j��[|h²�;±X�«��{Pv���� ��;3���§~zjav7PQ�J~z��¦w®©§}ai��'x����X|hj��Xik}*xzeh�w�w��©«���_�§j�j6x���|hx��«©«v/j6{?±?�«vz�[�_}avJ��ehjaµ:IÃ�_v�vz�[|�© x Á ±?�«�[x��«��{¨·9�«{�ª9~zj6{���eF¹ ��&���%.� ��������1���<� *0 �������0 ���� ��%n����<� ���A� � ����@���G�)�����0�A��������� ����<� ���: ����� �����1��� ��������� ����� ����<���=��� ��������������������#�:�,� � � Á ~��6�_��eh��{ ��®L6�w�*x���¦�~�j��[�_�_�h�

-ê�[��/�s(¯ � �[i���~�~z�Ø�Xo¶¯ ��¯Xsw��©§±_j*x�x��N� Mp¯ �Ã�?��¦h|�va� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h²3¯3l |�i�ja~����6��©��w�1;F|Pv��«��{�¦��_v�j�����{keh�«��ew®��~��wj6~p�wj6~z�«±;�[x��«±�j�v �«{-o1mÃs � � vz��ehj6ikjavnª9��~ � Ä/s¨��{1|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja�¨��~z�«�hva�n�«{1xzehj�h~z�w�*jaja�w�«{h�_v�[ª �� � �!� .(#k� � ����� ��� ����" ��� � ���� � % ���2��� � ���<� � �Q� ��|h©«u¨�a�[® ���h�ê�[�������XdQ¬�j6{Xx�j�·�Q ��©«©��[{���¹

-ê�w��/�s(¯ � ��i��[~z~��N�Po¶¯ ® ��¯üsw�[©«±�j6x�x��N� Á ¯ Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(� Mï �Ã�X�_¦h|�va¯ Á ©«�'¬��w�1;F|�v��«��{-o1mps � � vz��ehjai�jª9��~ � Ä/s ��{ |h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja���~z�«�hva� �:����������� ��� ������� � �)� � �#*� ��+�.�.���� � �[|�©§u �[���X�

-ê����/�s(¯ � �[i��[~z~z�Ø�5Mp¯ �n�?�_¦h|�va�Qo¶¯ ��¯�sw��©§±_j*x�xz�Ø� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±?�§ja|w²(¯ Á ©«�'¬f®´�w�1;3|�v��«��{¶o1mÃs � � vz��ehjai�jª9��~ � Ä/s ��{ |h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja���~z�«�hva¯ � ��%,�!���L����� ��� ��C���C� �� ·9x����[�h�Fja��~�¹

ó È�û ó æ

Page 32: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Futurs : Parc Club Orsay Université - ZAC des Vignes4, rue Jacques Monod - 91893 ORSAY Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38334 Montbonnot Saint-Ismier (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399